Destination Kirkby, 2 years on...

, 30 November, 28comments  |  Jump to most recent
?There was no Plan B?
Friday 25 November marked the second anniversary of the Government's decision to reject Everton Football Club's proposed plan to relocate from Goodison Park to a new stadium and retail complex in Kirkby. Since that day, Evertonians have been feeling the full weight of ex-CEO Keith Wyness's now prophetic statement that ?There is no Plan B?. This article from the Blue Union reviews the subsequent progress on getting Everton a new stadium and provides some hope for the future.

Some excerpts from the BU article:

Earlier in the year, members of The Blue Union met Everton Chairman Bill Kenwright. The agenda was long and varied, but unsurprisingly the future of Goodison Park was a topic that was up for discussion. Mr Kenwright assured our representatives that he believed that the state of the ground was not impacting on the inability to find a buyer or investor to take the Club onto the next level.

Much to our confusion, this was contradicted in an interview that Mr Kenwright gave to Christian Purslow a couple of weeks ago. Whether you believe story A or story B is irrelevant, what is important is that for Everton to compete at the top end of the league, on a consistent basis, the regeneration of Goodison Park, or the relocation to a suitable and deliverable site within the Liverpool boundaries is essential to the future survival of Everton FC.

The Football Quarter represents that light at the end of the tunnel; that opportunity that Everton missed with the Kings Dock project to give something back to the City that we can all be proud of. An opportunity to kick on to the next level, to give the manager a fighting chance to bridge the gap, to compete at the top end of the table, to fully comply with UEFA regulations and dare I say it, deliver some much needed silverware.

One thing is for sure, throughout our glorious history, Evertonians have been pivotal to the continued and future greatness of our Club. From the days of creating the very first Shareholders Association, to the Everton Former Players Foundation a foundation envied the world over, to the Everton Collection the most comprehensive collection of Football memorabilia in the world, to the sterling work carried out by Everton in the Community and yes to KEIOC and their achievements during the ?Destination Kirkby? Public Inquiry and their ingenuity in developing the Football Quarter proposal, Evertonians have influenced and will continue to influence the future of our great Club, the Famous Everton Football Club.

Quotes or other material sourced from The Blue Union



Reader Comments (28)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Nick Armitage
1 Posted 30/11/2011 at 21:51:42
Plan A was the Kings Dock. Kenwright missed the boat and we will never have another opportunity like that.

Destination Kirby was a half-baked Plan B, a common garden slug had more legs than that white elephant.

We are stuck where we are. Who in their right mind is going to front the building of a state of the art stadium in one of the most deprived areas of Western Europe. Factor in that the UK is about to go through a decade of austerity and discontent.

Face it, we are mid-table stragglers until the game of football changes.
Robbie Shields
2 Posted 30/11/2011 at 21:56:03
Why can't the City Council build a Super Stadium for the City and then rent it out to the clubs as per the Milan model? Might even get around the new UEFA rules. Both clubs instantly back were they belong and an asset to be proud of for the whole City.
Matt Traynor
3 Posted 30/11/2011 at 22:13:03
Robbie #2, that is a joke question right?
James Flynn
4 Posted 30/11/2011 at 22:52:02
I still say, no reason to leave Goodison. Unless I've read wrong everything about EFC history, Goodison remains the most storied stadium in the country. Why leave it?

Fixing the Old Girl up is the best solution; financially and historically.

Besides, we've seen new (pick the sport) sports stadiums over here for decades. It's not the be-all end-all it's cracked up to be. If the team doesn't win, people stop going. New stadium or old.
Mike Keating
5 Posted 01/12/2011 at 10:52:00
Nick ? spot on.

Every time I pass the dreadful Echo Arena I am reminded of the club's failure to put Everton at the very heart of our city ? hospitality, conferencing & concerts would have recouped the outlay and the club could have been sold to someone who has the dosh to invest in players. Even BK admits the need for a new stadium has been the biggest stumbling block to offloading the club.
David S Shaw
6 Posted 01/12/2011 at 11:24:02
Re mourning for the Kings Dock.

Do you think that Kenwright learnt to deceive after the Kings Dock, or do you suspect that the world class Kings Dock, may have not have been as World Class as you were sold?

Steavey Buckley
7 Posted 01/12/2011 at 11:41:28
Everton will still have to increase revenue streams, whether they stay at Goodison or not. Stagnation is not an option. At the moment, Everton are trapped by their finances.
Gavin Ramejkis
8 Posted 01/12/2011 at 14:54:36
Steavey sadly some of those finances are self imposed; merchandising being a major one, add lack of corporate facilities through no ground improvement, piss poor sponsorship below par with our peers and no seating increases for years and you get a sharper image of the failings of the current incumbents.
Mike Dolan
9 Posted 01/12/2011 at 16:32:04
I have lived in the States for years so forgive me if I am missing something. If Everton do need a new ground or even a massive rebuilding of the old one, surely the City of Liverpool should be funding it?

As KEIOC has pointed out, it is the City of Liverpool that benefits from having a great and historic team within its boundaries, the benefits would be tenfold if a world class facility with world class amenities could be built to house both clubs near the city center.
Mike Allison
10 Posted 01/12/2011 at 16:45:08
There's no real precedent for that in the UK Mike. Add to that the fact that sports teams don't just up and leave like they do in America and you start to stumble upon the fact that sport in the two countries operates on an entirely different model, making comparisons awkward at best.
Kevin Gillen
11 Posted 01/12/2011 at 16:43:56
Totally agree with Mike Dolan - it's a no-brainer. State-of-the-art shared stadium built by the City of Liverpool with 60,000 capacity would be a licence to print money and objectors would take ten minutes to get used to it.
Mike Keating
12 Posted 01/12/2011 at 16:57:15
As the City Council was forced to make £90M cuts in services last year and another £50M this, I don't think they are likely to be building state-of-the-art footy stadiums any time soon.
Ray Roche
13 Posted 01/12/2011 at 17:42:25
Gavin,
You are so right about the merchandising. I remember the stats a few seasons ago which said that Man Utd made more money from selling just Ryan Giggs shirts than Everton did in the whole of their merchandising scheme. Tragic.
Ian McDowell
14 Posted 01/12/2011 at 17:48:50
As Nick @ post 1 says .

Plan A was the Kings Dock. Kenwright missed the boat and we will never have another opportunity like that.

We will regret that for many years to come.
Dennis Stevens
15 Posted 01/12/2011 at 18:02:42
Ray, that's hardly surprising, one of the reasons we've signed up for the much-criticised Kitbag deal is the total inability of the club to successfully merchandise ? to the extent that the whole operation was actually losing the club money instead of boosting our coffers to support squad development. At least with Kitbag we're guaranteed some income.
Gavin Ramejkis
16 Posted 01/12/2011 at 18:07:02
Dennis ? the kitbag deal is a dead loss, no visible merchandise anywhere besides the web or the city centre. I could walk into any sports shop anywhere in the country and find other teams' merchandising at the drop of a hat besides ours.

If you want to push more product it needs to be available and visible. The former merchandising team internally could have been bladdered and replaced with more capable staff, surely the whole concept of 'perform or P45' isn't an alien concept to the current board or maybe it is.
Dennis Stevens
17 Posted 01/12/2011 at 19:19:18
Wow! Gavin, I've never come across any of those points before!

My post wasn't making a case for the Kitbag deal, merely pointing out that, when run in-house, things were far worse. That doesn't mean that our inept club administration farming the job out, as a tacit admission of their own incompetence, is to be commended. Apart from their uncharacteristic bout of self-awareness, I suppose...

It still beggars belief that Everton Football Club could have ever been running at a loss ? an operation that's practically a license to print money.
Gavin Ramejkis
18 Posted 01/12/2011 at 19:35:12
Dennis ? amazing you quote the Kitbag deal makes the club some money and I point out it's a poor deal which, with an iota of planning, could have been avoided or improved... and you go on the defence, wow indeed.

A very simplisitic case of reviewing the business on a line-by-line basis with cash-flow reporting on a daily/weekly basis is used by companies to name and shame failing sections and teams into an exit or action ? the club don't do Plan A and B. The justification to outsource, if not quantified against alternatives, is yet another punt that failed.

I picture the board meetings of days gone by with shysters like the monorail bloke from the Simpsons episode selling BK some mumbo jumbo ideas and waltzing off with a suitcase stuffed with unmarked bills.
Elaine Riding
19 Posted 01/12/2011 at 19:59:10
#18 Gavin, Monorail was a funny line..

Please dont shoot me down here, but a would we sell out / fill sufficiently, a 'new, state-of-the-art mega stadium'??

We struggle to sell out home games as it is, due to bad ticketing policies... I mean to send out text messages to season ticket holders the day before Liverpool at home, offering extra tickets on top of the extra ones already purchased, is totally bloody amateurish.
Robbie Shields
20 Posted 01/12/2011 at 21:25:32
Mike (#12), whilst I appreciate that LCC have had to cut costs they still do have far more capacity to deliver on a joint stadium for the benefit of the City and the two clubs, for example.

1) They have guaranteed tenants they can 'lock in' for x many years.
2) They will have far greater access to funds and credit lines than the clubs have.
3) The clubs themselves would be able to borrow money to contribute to the scheme, in return for lower rent
4) The construction costs would be spread over a number of years, 3 minimum.
5) The city itself would benefit from increased revenue from increased tourism. Liverpool would easily get 60,000 week in week out, we COULD get 40,000 plus (If we started to play half-decent footy mind). Plus, the big games, United, Liverpool, City etc. we'd get closer to 60,000.
6) A common model used to build a new stadium for city is to establish a temporary levy for all rate payers with all monies from the levy contributing to the scheme.
7) LCC could look to other National and European goverment institutions to assist in construction costs
8) The naming rights for an iconic stadium shared by the the two most successful teams from any one city in the highest profile league in the world would be huge. The stadium would be on TV up to twice a week.

All in all, the City has a much higher capacity to deliver on a stadium than either Everton or Liverpool have individually or together. It resolves a number of issues, such as stadium ownership, increases the cities profile, increases the cities appeal to tourists and puts the city back on the map as the home of Football ? not Manchester.
Dennis Stevens
21 Posted 01/12/2011 at 21:41:33
Nothing amazing, Gavin. Just that you were repeating oft-quoted points that we all know as if I had proclaimed the deal as a smart piece of business, rather than a reflection of the inept management of the operation in-house.

I'm not sure what you think I need to defend, but you seem to be intent on rebutting a point I'm not endeavouring to make. However, in your second pass I feel you give Kenwright far too much credit: holding Board meetings? Listening to ideas? Packing a suitcase? [If only!]
Dan Brierley
22 Posted 01/12/2011 at 22:02:08
Gav, you are aware that EVERY major European football side has a deal with kitbag? Why do you think that is, if there is so much more money to be made by doing it in-house?
Mike Dolan
23 Posted 02/12/2011 at 01:59:54
There is no reason for Everton FC to own the stadium that it plays in. The only way that we will ever be able to compete consistently at the highest levels on the pitch is by being allowed compete at the same levels as our rivals at the box office.

Liverpool should be thinking of a massive private and public redevelopment of its waterfront and a world class shared stadium should be the anchor.
Ste Traverse
24 Posted 02/12/2011 at 07:29:46
I can't believe some people are still banging about the non-starter of a joint stadium.

This was ruled out years ago, never going to happen.

Why should others bail out our useless board?
Anthony Hughes
25 Posted 02/12/2011 at 07:50:04
The Liverpool Waters scheme which Peel Holdings are proposing, starting from Princes Dock and spreading northwards across the disused dockland area, would be an attractive location for a football stadium.
Trevor Skempton
26 Posted 02/12/2011 at 08:17:35
The joint stadium has been researched and dismissed, partly because a section of fans would never be reconciled to it and partly because it would diminish each club's unique selling points - not a smart idea in business terms.

The opportunity for a dockside development in conjunction with the public sector came, was missed, went and will probably always be regretted, in the form of the Kings Dock.

However, looking forward, the big hope now is for the Football Quarter, promoted by supporters, in which the two clubs, the public sector [land and influence] and the private sector [finance and development] work together on a joint infrastructure for the Stanley Park area, around two expanded historic stadia. This is the way forward to create a unique world-class facility, and benefitting North Liverpool communities.
Dennis Stevens
27 Posted 02/12/2011 at 14:08:38
Surely a pre-requisite for EFC's involvement in any new scheme must be the replacement of the current Board. It's hard to believe anybody would be willing to work with them given their history of failure.
Mike Dolan
28 Posted 02/12/2011 at 17:42:52
The Princess Dock area is precisely the area that should be considered for redevelopment. The almost mind numbing perfect common sense idea of a joint stadium funded totally by the City of Liverpool has not been discussed. It would make perfect business sense for both Everton and Liverpool to not only to unburden themselves of hundreds of millions of pounds of future mortgage payments but to also benefit from halving the costs of running a massive and underused facility.

If a scheme like this is seen as a hand out or a bail out then I agree it cannot work. I believe though that the City of Liverpool will benefit massively by partnering the two entities that along with the Beatles have so helped to define it.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads