Season › 2011-12 › News
Agents' Fees in the Premier League
The “table” is shown below, and you’ll be not at all surprised to see Manchester City sitting top of the table (as they are in the Premier League table, and the Indebtedness Table).
|
Club |
Amount (£M) |
| 1 | Man City | 9.664 |
| 2 | Tottenham | 7.572 |
| 3 | Liverpool | 7.001 |
| 4 | Chelsea | 6.458 |
| 5 | Newcastle | 6.380 |
| 6 | Arsenal | 4.649 |
| 7 | Man Utd | 4.457 |
| 8 | Blackburn | 4.227 |
| 9 | Sunderland | 3.735 |
| 10 | Aston Villa | 3.163 |
| 11 | EVERTON | 2.931 |
| 12 | QPR | 2.499 |
| 13 | Stoke | 2.208 |
| 14 | Bolton | 1.942 |
| 15 | West Brom | 1.306 |
| 16 | Wolves | 1.110 |
| 17 | Fulham | 0.951 |
| 18 | Norwich | 0.710 |
| 19 | Wigan | 0.660 |
| 20 | Swansea | 0.249 |
The total of £71.8m is a slight increase over the previous period total of £70.7m and is dominated by three teams that significantly reshaped their squad in that period – Liverpool, Tottenham and of course Man City. Not surprisingly, the promoted teams fall near the bottom, with the exception of QPR – who not only spent more than their fellow arrivals from the Championship, but also had the biggest “freebie” of the close season, Joey Barton arriving from Newcastle with a £1.3m agents fee taking up more than half of their agent spend.
The Premier League states that “The amounts shown include payments made by clubs on behalf of players” which is not clearly explained, but could relate to clubs moving players on. Not stated, but I am 100% sure it will be the case, is that this would also include payments on new/extended contracts.
Therefore when analysing Everton’s spend of almost £3m on agents fees (down from almost £3.6m the previous period), given that we didn’t sign a player for money in the period covered, as well as the loans in and transfers out, we did renew a few contracts. The major one, Fellaini, should fall outside of this period, and therefore will be included for next year’s accounts. I can’t find any reference to Agents Fees in the clubs accounts after a cursory glance, so perhaps these form part of the much vaunted “Other Operating Costs”, if they are not included as part of player trading.
Just a general viewpoint, it is often cited that agent fees represent money going out of the game, but I think that argument is weak, as you can also argue that players wages is also money going out of the game. Some agents were quick to capitalise on the opportunities presented by the influx of money into the game, and engineer ways and means of making a fantastic living off the game. The test as part of the process to become FIFA Licensed is very basic – multiple choice, simple maths (calculating commissions etc) which is why there are so many out there. Some players now have a team managing their career, with all of the opportunities for image rights etc, hence they are represented by a company more so than an actual individual.
But most agents aren’t in this exalted position. Most will do this as sideline work, hoping to score the next “big” player, whilst risking the possibility of being shafted by others in their profession.
I’ve said before, if I could see one change, it would be for players to pay their own agents fees, rather than clubs. This would need to be worked in some way that it was players earning a certain amount, but would include pretty much all Premier and Championship players at least. If nothing else, it would make players think a bit more about who’s acting in whose best interests. Clubs aren’t always whiter than white of course – many will force a player out for non-football related reasons, but financial reasons – something Evertonians of any age should be familiar with.
Matt Traynor
Quotes or other material sourced from The Premier League
Reader Comments (16)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 01/12/2011 at 14:42:44
This however, has not prevented EFC from spending nearly £3m knicker on Agents fees in the last 12 months. According to my calculations, incoming players to EFC in the last 12 months have been:
Drenthe (Loan)
Stracqualursi (Loan)
Haneman and
Green
So how the [insert inflammatory vernacular of your choice here] can EFC have spent £3m on Agent's Fees? What do these Agents do in order to justify such fees? And more importantly, why are EFC paying them?
Furthermore, how is it that clubs like Wolves (bought 3 players for £12m) and Fulham (bought 7 players for £11.5m) have paid vastly less than EFC? (Both less than half what EFC shelled out!!)
Is this yet another example of poor management? Is there anyone at EFC capable of negotiating such Deals? Why aren't the players paying their own sodding Agents?
3 Posted 01/12/2011 at 14:44:36
I'm in bewilderment yet again.
4 Posted 01/12/2011 at 14:51:21
5 Posted 01/12/2011 at 15:15:47
Drenthe (Loan) - agent fee for a loan??
Stracqualursi (Loan) - agent fee for a loan??
Hahneman - free so did we pay any agent?
Green - an agent fee for a kid?
grassy knoll - Fellaini really signed back then?
6 Posted 01/12/2011 at 15:34:54
7 Posted 01/12/2011 at 15:20:43
Player From Club Transfer Type Date
Royston Drenthe Real Madrid Season Long Loan 31/08/2011
Denis Stracqualursi Tigre Season Long Loan 31/08/2011
Eric Dier Sporting Lisbon Season Long Loan 05/07/2011
Apostolos Vellios Iraklis Thessaloniki Nominal 01/07/2001
EFC Agents Fees for Period (Oct 2010 - Sep 2011) Total £2,931,127.10
Jan Mucha Legia Warsaw Free 01/07/2010
Magaye Gueye Strasbourg Undisclosed 30/06/2010
Joao Silva Desportivo Das Aves Undisclosed 09/06/2010
Jermaine Beckford Free ?Leeds? Free 31/05/2010
Philippe Senderos Arsenal Loan 23/01/2010
Landon Donovan LA Galaxy Loan 02/01/2010
EFC Agents Fees for Period (Oct 2009 - Sep 2010) Total £3,599,040.51
Lucas Neill Free ?WHU? Free 17/09/2009
John Heitinga Athletico Madrid 6m raising to 7m 01/09/2009
Sylvain Distain Pompey Undisclosed 28/08/2009
Diniyar Bilyaletdinov Lokomotive Moscow Undisclosed 25/08/2009
Cody Arnoux Carolina Dynamo Undisclosed 04/08/2009
Shkodran Mustafi Hamburg Free + Compensation 06/07/2009
Seamus Coleman Silgo Rovers Undisclosed 02/02/2009
Jo Man City Loan 02/02/2009
EFC Agents Fees for Period (Oct 2008 - Sep 2009) Total £2,008,407.00
Total EFC Agents Fees Since Oct '08 - £8,538,574.61
8 Posted 01/12/2011 at 15:42:04
Player To Club Transfer Type Date
Joseph Yobo Fenerbahce Season Long Loan 05/09/2011
Jermaine Beckford Leicester City £2.5m 31/08/2011
Aiyegbeni Yakubu Blackburn £1.5m 31/08/2011
Mikel Arteta Arsenal £10m 31/08/2011
Shane Duffy Scunthorpe United Loan 31/08/2011
Joao Silva Vitora FC Season Long Loan 12/08/2011
James Vaughan Norwich City Undisclosed 28/05/2011
James Wallace Stockport County Loan 18/02/2011
Iain Turner Preston North End Loan 11/02/2011
Joao Silva Uniao Desportiva Loan 31/01/2011
Kieran Agard Kilmarnock Loan 31/01/2011
James Vaughan Crystal Palace Loan 26/01/2011
Steven Pienaar Tottenham Hotspur Undisclosed 18/01/2011
Aiyegbeni Yakubu Leicester City Loan 13/01/2011
Kieran Agard Peterborough United Loan 06/01/2011
Aristote Nsiala Macclesfield Town Loan 08/10/2010
James Vaughan Crystal Palace Loan 08/09/2010
Joseph Yobo Fenerbahce Season-long loan 01/09/2010
Lukas Jutkiewicz Coventry City Undisclosed 26/07/2010
John Ruddy Norwich City Undisclosed 05/07/2010
Seamus Coleman Blackpool Loan 19/03/2010
James Vaughan Leicester City Loan 11/03/2010
Lucas Neill Galatasaray Undisclosed 17/01/2010
Joleon Lescott Manchester City Undisclosed 25/08/2009
9 Posted 01/12/2011 at 15:58:21
"The major one, Fellaini, should fall outside of this period".
Yes but we renewed more than one players contract which seems to have evaded the notice of some of the posters on this thread. We as a club have more "big names" than those clubs below us.
All this conspiracy theory stuff is getting a bit boring. No proof is brought forward, yet people seem to feed of previous posters creating a frenzy that borders on paranoia.
10 Posted 01/12/2011 at 17:00:04
11 Posted 01/12/2011 at 20:25:33
Now given that City were signing everybody during that period and our neighbours doing their best to imitate them whilst we were failing totally to add to our playing strength, what the hell was the money paying for?
In this mad, mad, world of football finance are we to believe that Everton actually had to pay a middleman to dispose of the likes of Pienaar and Arteta or does the club pay players` agents to negotiate AGAINST them in wage matters?
12 Posted 01/12/2011 at 22:51:15
As in any 'profession', I'm sure there are some that do much better and are much worse than others, but for my (comparatively little) money the current role of football agent can be seen in its best light as that of a benign parasite. At worst they are a vigorous cancer in the game that are draining the life out of the clubs we love and that will continue to greedily gorge till their hosts fall down dead.
Yes, the agents themselves may 'only' take their 10-15% (a 'paltry' £3M in the table above - that's around 4% of Everton's turnover or 1.5 Steven Pienaars), but like that other group of charming (and equally socially useless) professionals, the investment bankers, you have to realise that their effect is leveraged many fold. In order to get rich themselves they have to make footballers considerably richer and so it's these agents boundless greed that I believe is a (if not the) primary factor in driving up player wages to the entirely unjustifiable and totally unsustainable levels we are currently enduring.
On top of that there's the inherent instability they cause by encouraging their charges to move clubs, (again entirely in their own self-interest - player movement = payday!) and that's not to touch upon the even seedier world of 'commercial rights' we're seeing with Tevez et al.
That it's the clubs picking up the bill for all this is of course total insanity ? as RIchard Dodd says, the clubs are effectively paying someone to negotiate against their interests ? and quite why this hasn't been redressed is totally beyond me.
I stress this isn't to say that I think football club boards are packed with honest hard-working, salt-of-the-earth types or that players should do it for the love of the game or enter negotiations unprotected or assisted. They are after all simple souls with precious few years to make their mark and earn their multi-million fortunes (unlike the rest of us who are smug in our overpaid, underworked, 100% secure jobs... oh hang on!!).
What I do definitely think however is, like so many other elements of neo-liberal hyper-capitalism that we're seeing unravel right now, the model for paying footballers and the role played by football agents is broken, wrong and quite self-evidently not in the long term interests of the sport, the community, or even I suspect the players and agents themselves.
Having recently bought a house and being engaged in a business that deals with ad-buying agencies I have had numerous reasons to question the role of middle-men or 'agents' recently and have found in virtually all instances that the role adds unnecessary confusion, cost and stress, whilst quite often actively working against the interests it is supposedly serving.
Football agents however command a special place on the shit-list, sat snugly and smugly alongside investment bankers, conservative politicians and the board of First Great Western in being first against the wall when the revolution comes.
13 Posted 01/12/2011 at 23:42:33
Simon Jordan refused to pay for Timmy Cahill's agent's fee so that worked out for us, but there's little fans hate more than this.
14 Posted 02/12/2011 at 01:38:34
I?ve said before, if I could see one change, it would be for players to pay their own agents fees, rather than clubs.
I think you probably have your explanation in the second sentence, the clubs pay the agents fees on behalf of the players.
15 Posted 02/12/2011 at 13:01:12
The vast majority of Agents are honest, hard-working, and have the best interests of their clients (who can be clubs as well as players) at heart.
As with most things, there are a few bad examples who, often in legion with officials at clubs, give the rest a bad name.
In the ludicrous money world that is the Premier League now, they are arguably more necessary than ever to protect their clients interests ? a role that the PFA could reasonably have filled years ago.
Generally, I dislike anyone with Agent in their job title (estate, sports, Fed)
16 Posted 02/12/2011 at 19:32:49
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 01/12/2011 at 14:40:32