“What wins games is goals”

, 4 December, 86comments  |  Jump to most recent
David Moyes rues the poor performance of the referee, the players' inability to make or take chances, giving away a goal and not getting one back. Here are the thoughts of the Everton manager on today's performance:

"I thought the referee had a poor game.

"It is not the reason for our loss - far from it because that was down to our inability to make and take chances.

"But there was a lot going on in the box and we got very little of it.

"We hadn't done an awful lot wrong and we found ourselves a goal down.

"I don't think we deserved to be behind in the game but we had to go chasing it.

"What wins games is goals and they got the goal and we didn't."  



Reader Comments (86)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Paul Ferry
1 Posted 04/12/2011 at 19:35:22
Can someone, anyone, please speak up to support this utter abrogation of responsibility on the part of blame-anyone-but-me Moyes? The last line is priceless, almost worth £60k a week.

Can someone please show me a word or two where Moyes actually says that some of this might be down to me, my selections, my set-ups, my substitutions, my playing people week-in and week-out out of position, my sticking with dead wood, my defensive mentality, my formations, my Osman, my Cahill, my Neville, my downright pig-headedness and self-righteous stubborn as a mule tunnel vision.

Kenwright is worse; but Moyes is catching up, and quickly
Mark Freese
2 Posted 04/12/2011 at 20:57:46
Its really hard being a Everton fan these days, my son who's 5 next year is coming up fast to a point were he need to start to understand the world of football and more important EFC, however I hate to say it but iam really torn in two minds to introduce him the pain we all suffer in being a evertonian. Ok he's 5 next year and I have taken him to 2 games, and for both he was board shitless, so was I!!! Does my son need to support this sinking ship that was once the millionaire club and maybe enjoy the football somwere else?? We live in Norfolk, Norwich are the team down here, they play great football and have very big ideas to take there club to the next level, we Everton have so many problems. I love this club, I have blue blood and yes ive been there and got the t-shirt in the late 70's, 80's and 90's, but when i see our team at home against a really shit fooball side like Stoke who cant make the goalkeeper earn his wages do i introduce my son to THIS??
Joe McMahon
3 Posted 04/12/2011 at 21:14:01
Speechless, I'm stunned. into year 11 of his masterplan, £65,000 a week, and his words of wisdom are "What wins games is goals and they got the goal and we didn't". I have never felt so angry and low in 34 years of supporting Everton. Maybe i'm being dramatic, but we supporters have been well and truely fucked by this board and manger.
Ciarán McGlone
4 Posted 04/12/2011 at 21:17:21
Typical arse-covering words from Moyes.
James McPherson
5 Posted 04/12/2011 at 21:19:26
Mark #2,

Your challenge will not be your son becoming an Evertonian ? but him remaining one.

Good luck!
Steve Barr
6 Posted 04/12/2011 at 21:12:48
I know that if you go through the evertonfc.com archives section that contains the manager's "post match review" you will find scores of similar negative summaries.

Totally unacceptable. Over time this kind of negativity will (and has) permeate throughout the club.

I've never been one for knee jerk reactions and believe everyone must be given a fair chance and run, whether it be a manager or player.

Moyes has had more than a fair chance at this great club and has come up well short of what is needed. It's time for him to move on, gracefully I hope, and allow new blood to be given a chance.

Oh and please don't tell me there is no one else out there.
Paul Knox
7 Posted 04/12/2011 at 21:20:56
Why has it taken so long for people to see that Moyes has always been inept? Same style of play for 10 years now... everyone knows our gameplan: preserve the point we kick off with.

Get Him out now!
Tony Christian
8 Posted 04/12/2011 at 21:28:25
Dear Santa,

Can I have a new manager for Christmas, I've been a good boy and the one you brought me eleven years ago doesn't seem to work anymore.

Love

Tony aged 41 and a half.
Luke Dunn
9 Posted 04/12/2011 at 21:41:43
Stop picking Cahill, then you might increase your chances of scoring.
Dennis Stevens
10 Posted 04/12/2011 at 21:39:01
Has Moyes lost the plot - or the will? He just seems totally bereft. I do wonder whther he'll seek to keep us up this season & then decide he's done all he can & quit. Although I'm no great fan I wouldn't blame him.
Stephen Kenny
12 Posted 04/12/2011 at 21:59:26
If that's the case probably not the best idea in the world to sell all your strikers bar two sick-notes who your lucky to get 10 games out of each, eh Dave???
Kunal Desai
13 Posted 04/12/2011 at 22:08:48
Boring and stale comments just like he serves his team up to play football.
Wayne McNee
14 Posted 04/12/2011 at 21:57:56
At least Wally showed remorse & looked ashamed!

My daughter lives in Newcastle & at the age of nine & after taking her to a couple of games, I've told her to just support the Barcodes if she wants. Rather than the poor kid put on a shit Le Cock kit, sponsored by Chang shit beer, supporting a dire footballing side, with a gutless manager... I'm not setting her up to get bullied!

From top to bottom, kit, sponsor, business plan, back room, board, toffee girls.... We're the shits!

It's Boro on a grander scale, waiting to happen! At least they had Gibson with half a brain & more of a heart IMO. Although they had less history & bragging rights at stake.

BK, Mr No1 Evertonian! Is that the legacy that you want to be remembered for? Bringing THE club you care so much for to it's knees? Take DM with you... I'm in management & it's great to have a "yes" man, but my job doesn't affect people's lives, pride, history & income.

"You had me at Kings Dock" X
Alan Feehely
15 Posted 04/12/2011 at 22:11:21
How can Moyes complain about lack of goals when he has sold Beckford and Yakubu?

I'm not saying that they are top quality, but Beckford got 10 goals for us last year, and the Yak seemed rejuvenated after his his loan spell at Leicester, and sharp in pre-season.

The only orthodox strikers we have at the moment is Saha (always injured), Vellios (young and raw), and Anichebe (7 goals in 93 games)

You can only assume Moyes shafted them due to personal differences, but unlike Sir Alex Ferguson, he does not have the resources to replace them.

So instead of having the Yakubu or Beckford as backups, he has Tim Cahill operating at the top of a painfully negative 4-6-0.

He then bemoans the lack of attacking flair!
Andy Hegan
16 Posted 04/12/2011 at 22:22:23
The mind boggling naivety in our play is what gets me. Almost every attack came from the flanks, usually Baines against a side who are far better equipped to deal with balls into the box than any of our so called attackers. I think only once did we attempt to feed the ball through the centre and turn the centre halves.

It's the exact same story every single week. This manager has no idea about how to set a team up to score goals and will never learn. This is the reason he has ruined every striker we have had.

The points we could have had over the years and games we should have won is frightening. It's not the finances, it's the manager.
Dick Fearon
17 Posted 04/12/2011 at 21:29:51
Having proffered these astonishing insights and brilliant analysis, perhaps the Messaiagh could further enlighten us as to how and why we conceded Stoke's winning goal. I recall it resulted from a defensive corner that saw our entire team crowded around our penalty spot while completely unmarked opponents hovered on the edge of the area.

When facing corners or free kicks this ultra defensive set up is so predictable, managers the length and breadth of the country can plan to exploit it.
Wayne McNee
18 Posted 04/12/2011 at 22:40:04
When BBC pundits praise his management style over the years, you know there's a conspiracy to keep DM at the helm for their own sick enjoyment ;)
Steve Guy
19 Posted 04/12/2011 at 22:31:20
Today was an embarassment.

I sat freezing my nuts off having driven across the Pennines to watch that rubbish.and taken my son with me as a "treat" break from exam studies. I reckon the match in total cost me £125 just to watch football by numbers. No invention, no guile, no guts, no clue. Graham Sharp on the radio defending the indefensible (and even he was struggling). Then adding insult to injury, Moyes coming out with his "honest" and "frank" assessment.

We continually get the mantra of who would you have instead ? Quite frankly I could do a better job than Moyes; I regularly predict his tactics and substitutions (and increasingly it's clear his opposite numbers have too) so I reckon with a few tweaks and a lot more positivity I could do better. So if I could I'm sure there's a few actual managers out there who could too..

The whole structure at Everton now needs root and branch change. Unfortunately Moyes going won't change anything instrinsically unless the owner changes first. KENWRIGHT OUT
George McKane
20 Posted 04/12/2011 at 22:51:32
Bored. Totally. Have been for the past few years overall. Sitting in my seat not even getting angry ? because then you are told you're not a real Evertonian – after 52 years of watching the Blues.

Just bored with Moyes and everything to to do with him. I guess the real Evertonians are those who just say this is OK and things will get better. Will they? Time for change.
George McKane
21 Posted 04/12/2011 at 22:58:57
Who would I have - which seems to en the only argument. My Aunty Mary. Or her cat. Or budgie,
Michael Winstanley
22 Posted 04/12/2011 at 22:57:54
"What wins games is goals..."

Finally the penny has dropped.

Jamie Sweet
23 Posted 04/12/2011 at 23:07:04
Shame that penny didn't drop before he left us with NO fit, recognised strikers. What a joke our so called manager is.
Paul Ward
24 Posted 04/12/2011 at 22:56:26
For once I can't think of anything different to say that does not appear in the comments here. Only to ask, is there any Evertonian that can defend this destruction of a once great club?

If there is they should take responsibility as well. Kenwright and Moyes will not go until fans stop attending and buying season tickets.
Dick Fearon
25 Posted 04/12/2011 at 23:35:32
Wayne # 14, You echoed my own thoughts about outsiders who rave on about the brilliance of Moyes.
Andy Crooks
26 Posted 04/12/2011 at 23:58:59
Dick and Wayne. Like the 'one good season' Yak myth, dealt with by Paul Olsen on another thread, the 'Moyes punching above his weight' myth has been repeated often enough to have become a fact.

Most pundits provide cliches rather than analysis and "Moyes has done a great job against all odds" is now a given. It's a little closed shop where all are mates and no highly paid coach ever deserves the sack.

"Brucie will walk into another job" ? Why?
Andy Hegan
27 Posted 04/12/2011 at 22:22:23
The mind boggling naivety in our play is what gets me. Almost every attack came from the flanks, usually Baines against a side who are far better equipped to deal with balls into the box than any of our so called attackers. I think only once did we attempt to feed the ball through the centre and turn the centre halves.

It's the exact same story every single week. This manager has no idea about how to set a team up to score goals and will never learn. This is the reason he has ruined every striker we have had.


The points we could have had over the years and games we should have won is frightening. It's not the finances, it's the manager.
Paul Conatzer
28 Posted 05/12/2011 at 00:06:42
I beginning to believe the question isn't "who would do a better job than Moyes?" It's "Who couldn't do a better job than Moyes?" I'm getting to the stage where I don't want to bother watching and that's just on TV over here in the states, I can't imagine getting excited to spend all that bloody money to actually go to a game....Makes me miss Gordon Lee...
Domino Darkley
29 Posted 05/12/2011 at 00:13:06
The Gordon Lee era was a dream compared to this crap.
Gareth Fieldstead
30 Posted 05/12/2011 at 00:14:00
At last! Nearly everybody in complete unison. Moyes is shite, end of. He has morphed into Smith and once again the same old tired excuses may well be copy-&-paste jobs from 2000 onwards. As stated above, everybody deserves a chance but surely 10 years is enough?

That performance today is one of the worst I have seen from an Everton team, they simply didn't have a clue, how many high balls were played into the Stoke box? I stated on this site eleven months ago my disgust with Cahill pissing off to Asia to play in some two-bit competition, sadly I was proved right, he has hardly had a decent game since, yet Moyes sticks with him... ditto Osman, Hibbert etc.

Can anyone offer an argument for Hibbert that he is such a better player than Barrett? Yet Earl was pilloried on a weekly basis. I cannot believe the support Moyes gets from the press and within the game serving that rubbish yet Royle was pushed out after one poor run of results, despite an injury list that would have provided the likes of Ferguson with problems! and the fact he put trophies in the cabinet.

As for well who would you get? Well, sorry... the Smith apologists used that excuse every week as well. What about Lambert? Or Reid with a promoted Sheedy? Players who won things as players, capped by their countries and would at least show some enthusiasm and maybe even attacking football. Sadly, whilst Kenwright is there, nothing will change, it almost makes me wish for the return of Johnson!
Marcus Kendall
31 Posted 05/12/2011 at 00:40:44
Peter Reid??? Come on ? don't be daft now.
Mark Riding
32 Posted 05/12/2011 at 01:01:21
Gareth above, Smith actually had won trophies as a manager, even though not credible ones to most Everton fans.

Did you see Martin O'Neil's face in the stand today watching his soon to be team play ? You will laugh when I say he had the 'eye of the tiger'... by that, I mean he looked, keen and interested.

Moyes used to have that look.. he lost it when Lescott went. He is getting advice on the touchline from Round and Woods... Swap them two no-marks for Reid and Southall and you may have a squeak?
Domino Darkley
33 Posted 05/12/2011 at 01:02:43
Graeth....I agree with practically evereything you have written there.

One exception is the idea that Joe was "pushed out" due to poo results.

If I recall correctly, Joe resigned of his own free will when the board wouldn't fund a move for Torre Andre Flo.
Jamie Sweet
34 Posted 05/12/2011 at 00:47:05
"Sadly while Kenwright is here, nothing will change".

That is the really depressing thing about this whole scenario. Bill will NEVER sack Moyes. Why would he risk bringing in another manager that might actually demand transfer funds or start rocking the boat and asking questions about why the club stinks from top to bottom. He knows that Moyes will never expose him to be the fraud that he is.

Moyes will never walk and why would he want to? Get paid millions of pounds a year for a job where it's ok if you underperform. He's so cosy that he knows even relegation wouldn't see him get the chop (Bill said so himslef!)

So our only hope is for Moyes to change. And that is what is so frustrating.... he appears incapable of change. He is so stubborn. So habitually negative. So incapable of seeing the glaringly fucking obvious. So incapable of learning from his mistakes.

So assuming Black Bill and Boring Dave aren't going anywhere... our only hope is for Davey to change his ways. Unfortunately there's a large number of fans who continue to support his actions, despite the absolute dross they see on the park every week. They are as stubborn and as blind to the obvious as he is.

We should unite to send a clear message that things have got to change on the pitch. No hiding behind the farce that is going on off it.
Alex Mullan
35 Posted 05/12/2011 at 01:35:14
Jamie #30

I really echo your remarks that the fans have to unite to get rid of the parasites dragging Everton down, but will that ever happen?

Credit to the Red Shite, they dont fuck about when they have a problem with a manager or owner, look at Hicks and Gillet and Hodgeson. Could you ever see Evertonians doing that? The board, the manager and yes, even the fans are just utterly lethargic.

You dont even hear of any 'issue' at Everton in the media or on Sky, just the usual shite about how great Moyes is doing with no cash. Frankly, its obvious Moyes is not doing a good job. Most of our points this year have been lucky last min poke ins or penalties. Were shite, but the media think its down to no money. No one outside this club questions Moyes's quality, and the vast majority of people who support it can only be bothered to come on here and rant, but when it comes down to it, nothing is done. It will be the same next week when we lose to the Arse. We'll cry here and then move on bitterly.

A boycott of Goodison is needed. Never going to happen though.
Jason Lam
36 Posted 05/12/2011 at 01:57:41
I recall many of us asking for Vellios to start instead of crap Saha. Well Vellios was pretty crap too. I have to say the ref was anti-Everton the whole game but in all honesty we were trying to play a flair game without the flair players.

I know for certain our ONLY offensive outlet is Baines, his crosses and runs down the byline. Followed by bloody good crosses under pressure and no room at all. Lose him we are truly fucked. There is no imagination down the middle to break through the centerbacks. On the right Coleman does his running but neither he nor Hibbert has the telling final ball, they piss around long enough only to swing the ball back left for Baines. Hoof down the middle and Stoke or any good side will defend with ease. Bily's confidence is shot. It is looking very bleak and bloody awful football.
James Flynn
37 Posted 05/12/2011 at 03:30:24
Wow! It's still Moyes' fault?

The only "fault" with Moyes is that he's kept our head above water.

Top predators cost money. I don't have any. Any of you?

Are we really going on about Yak? The only manager who gave Yak his best chance to prove himself was Moyes.

Yak's "best" was to find a manager to let him hang around the off-side line game in and out. Seems like he's finally found that manager. On a team destined to go down. God bless him.

We need investment. No surprise there. Money. That's what we need.

For those thinking the problem is Moyes, put SAF etal in his place these last 9 years and explain how we'd be in a better place.

C'mon, how would we be better off? SAF and the rest of em. How would we be better off?

We wouldn't. Money, that's what we need.
Jamie Sweet
38 Posted 05/12/2011 at 03:51:55
James Flynn... what is this mystical "off-side line" that you speak of? I assume it's an Americanism?

Do you mean that he's actually in an advanced position, playing off the shoulder of the last defender and trying to score goals as his number one priority?

Wow. What a concept. Could never work at Everton as we need all eleven men to be concerned about defending all the time.

If you think that there is nobody in the world that could do better with our current squad or get us to play a more attractive brand of football than the dross that is currently served up week in week out then that is your opinion. If you are happy to settle for worse than mediocre then good for you - way to go!

I personally think that we can do much better - even with our current squad. Call me crazy, but I personally think that we should be capable of registering a shot on target against Stoke City at Goodison Park. The fact we failed to do so can be blamed on a lack of money if you wish to hide behind that excuse. But if you look at the attitude and tactics of our great manager, you will realise that therein lies the real problem.
Rob Teo
39 Posted 05/12/2011 at 04:41:09
James #35: We sold the Yak for 1.5 million pounds. For that, Blackburn are reaping the benefits. Yes, top predators cost money, but they still don't cost as much as top managers.

Not saying Steve Kean is a top manager, but to let the Yak go for that kind of money - esp when he's been in the kind of form he's been lately (i.e. that of a "top predator") - you have to really wonder what our dear manager was thinking (more so in the context of this post's title).
Suresh Gill
40 Posted 05/12/2011 at 04:54:25
All I saw from the game was frustration from a few players so Stoke succeded in their gameplan. We lacked someone with desire and drive today.

Nevermind the ref not giving anything our way but Stoke had 33% possession and still won. I don't think I will be able to watch the Arsenal game after this.
Anto Byrne
41 Posted 05/12/2011 at 07:56:47
I am on $65000 a week with no chance of getting the bullit. I dont have to perform or put out a footballing side that plays anything approaching decent football. I dont have to play strikers which is good as they are always sick anyway. I dont have to justify myself to any one. We are broke and its not my fault my best players have left to play in the champions league. We have no interest in playing there anyway.
My job is to keep EFC in the premiership gravy train.Fuck me who is going to give me $65k a week for the next 2 years of my nice little contract. I had a little chuckle to mayself when 30,000 turned up to watch us lose to Stoke are these people fucking morons? Well next best thing is a fucking evertonian as they put up with the shit i serve up everyweek. At least if i take them down to the chumpionship we may win a few games and finish top four and with my record of knock out competitions we wont get past the play offs. Yes 65,000 quid a week what do you fucking earn you fucking morons? 200-300 pounds a week if your lucky and you spend it here watching this shit i serve up to you. whatever you do dont park your old bomb next my ferrari that wont do. Remember this I am the manager and i take no fucking responsibilty for the shit of a fucking mess you morons have put me in. Your fucking obsessed with winning trophies. Get fucking real while i am in charge you wont win a fucking argument. Do i give a shit well why would i with 65k in my arse pocket everyweek. Fuck off you losers im here for the next 10 yrs so get used to it.
Chad Schofield
42 Posted 05/12/2011 at 08:49:32
Completely agree Jamie.

Yes the football was woeful, but having played some of the Champions League darlings and sitting 8th before kick off is what the "experts" focus on. Of course once they're there watching the turgid offering served up then they rarely praise Moyes.

Whoever it was who mentioned the calls for Vellios to start, yes, you are right but then if you're actively trying to ease a young player in, is Stoke and their bruising defence the best game?

Moyes has had to battle with little money and terrible injuries to a thread bare squad... But he's actually struggled more at times when he's had a bit of cash and had to keep a squad happy. It's difficult to see how he'll breeze in as athe next Celtic manager given those faults. Everyone though need a breath of fresh air. Unfortunately until Bill releases the club from the Dutch Oven he's held us down with, Everton will be as rank as a trapped old fart.
Thomas Windsor
43 Posted 05/12/2011 at 10:17:11
We go to the match to be entertained to see players do things we can't do ourselves. I never sawanything from the 20 outfield players that has been worth the entrance fee .

Stoke must be the worst team I've seen in years, it time for supporters to boycott the game because that shite I saw today from both teams is the end of football.

I might go and watch the under 15s play... at least they win something, before they get all there football ability coached out of them .
Daniel A Johnson
44 Posted 05/12/2011 at 12:03:04
Moyes has been giving his team a massive confidence boost all week by telling the world and his wife we're shite and, shock horror, they didn't let him down on Sunday.

Plus to compund the agony of our inability to score in a brothel with a £50 note and a bag of Viagra, the "lazy" Yakubu hits four for that fantastic footballing side Blackburn.

Happy days... what's our club motto again....?
Ciarán McGlone
45 Posted 05/12/2011 at 11:59:20
"Yak's "best" was to find a manager to let him hang around the off-side line game in and out."
-----------------

Amazingly, that's what he does best... What I say to the oft quoted and tired line that the Yak was lazy... so feckin what!

The guy had a very serious injury... was a proven 20-goal-a-season striker... second only to Thierry Henry over the seasons that Henry was here..

And we let him go for peanuts while having sod all experienced strikers (Saha aside)..

As for the suggestion that Vellios was crap yesterday..Abolsute nonsense. He'd have actually had to have had some service for that to be true. He got sod all.

While Moyes is to blame for raising expectations..he's also to blame for not being able to fulfill them.

If you want a manager to gve you middle of the table stability (while still making piles of schoolboy mistakes), then Moyes is your man.

Unfortunately, I think we're beyond Moyes's professional nadir now.
Lol McNally
46 Posted 05/12/2011 at 12:25:13
I'm 60 years old and I've seen the good times and the bad... but this shit I'm watching tops the lot.

Time for the supporters to shout Moyes Out!
Peter Cummings
47 Posted 05/12/2011 at 12:31:00
I can't disagree with any of the comments posted on the site. I've been an Evertonian now for over 60 years and seen the best players of past, Matthews, Finney, Swift, Carter, Sagar, Jones ?not forgetting Labone, Young, Ball... the list is endless.

After another boring, futile and truly depressing excuse for a game of football at Goodison, I'm beginning to wonder if I made the wrong choice as a 6-year-old watching my first game from the Boys Pen in Gwladys Street.
James Stewart
48 Posted 05/12/2011 at 13:19:15
@43

Exactly!
Gavin Ramejkis
49 Posted 05/12/2011 at 13:24:49
Well Gollum, you sold the creativity to the banks, sold our goal scorers to the banks and brought in a donkey you won't play that a Championship side knocked back, and you play a kid who isn't a lone striker. (you know, Gollum, that trick you destroy every striker you've ever had with...) ? and you wonder why your team don't score goals?

Do one Gollum, go now, go anywhere.
Peter Warren
50 Posted 05/12/2011 at 13:45:32
Alan, #14 ? I echo our sentiments re: Moyes. I believe he let Beckford go, because he didn't rate him and thought it was good money and perhaps, his hand was forced by the banks.

With Yak, clearly, it wasn't down to the Banks ? he didn't play him hardly at all last season and not at all pre-season. Moyes chose to let him go. Like you, I think he just fell out with him and he's not in position of Ferguson or Redknapp and should cut his cloth accordingly ? that said, it must be very hard for him owing to his values (which mirror his virtues).
Robbie Muldoon
51 Posted 05/12/2011 at 13:50:19
Who actually is keeping this man in a job? I think if you are happy with this manager, you must be wrong in the membrane.
Robbie Muldoon
52 Posted 05/12/2011 at 13:53:40
It's obvious why Moyes fell out with Yakubu. It's all to do with the handling of Joesph Yobo!
Peter Laing
53 Posted 05/12/2011 at 13:52:02
Bored with Everton from the top to the bottom, swerved yesterday's game and even found putting the Christmas decorations up with the wife and kids more interesting. Thanks Mr Kenwright and David Moyes ? we are dull, boring and soulless.
Sean Patton
54 Posted 05/12/2011 at 15:44:18
And who score goals David?

Strikers yes that is strikers with an s not one but wait for it now two thats right two on the pitch at the same time.
Gareth Fieldstead
55 Posted 05/12/2011 at 15:55:42
Sorry Domino I am only going off Royles own auto biography but he did state that he went to that final meeting with Johnson with no intention of resigning and when he arrived Johnson informed him that Desmond Pritcher had said to him that Royle had told him (Pritcher) that he was going to resign, despite not even having a conversation with the man. Furthermore Johnson had asked Royle if he felt he had improved the team since his arrival. Royle felt he wasn't recieving the support or reassurance that Johnson actually wanted him there. It could be called a mutual decision but in reality he was pushed with a lot of help from the national and local press particularly Phil McNulty. As for Reid, why not? I thought he did a good job at City and Sunderland and against the odds managed to keep Leeds up in 03 when the players were leaving quicker than rats deserting a sinking ship. If you look at Moyes credentials prior to managing Everton, even Kendalls at Blackburn they dont stand up to even the likes of David Jones who did a good job at Southampton, Wolves and Cardiff. there are options out there. Either way if things dont change we could be in a lot of trouble, this season is already resembling the 01 02 season.
Chris Matheson
57 Posted 05/12/2011 at 16:35:25
I am not sure where to begin, to say anything that hasn't already been said by everyone else in this thread.
The football we play is lifeless, predictable dross, sideways passes then pushed up the line, then a high ball lumped in. Never any invention, never anything on the ground and through the middle, an over reliance on set pieces and an overly defensive set up even though we can't keep clean sheets.

I am clear in my mind that Kenwright is responsible for this mess. The buck stops with him as he sells all our best, creative players to stave off the banks and so maintain the vanity of his position for which he is so obviously unsuited and unqualified.

That said, the fight seems to have gone out of Moyes, the imagination and the drive and the desire to win. I can almost hear stock phrases such as "get your crosses in", "Keep it tight and nick one", "hold the ball up". etc etc which depict such little tactical imagination. Maybe I am doing him a disservice. I don't blame him, being forced to sell all his best players. I just wish that for once he would come out and say as much.

How does this end? Either with Kenwright finally selling up, which I don't think is likely, or with the inevitable decline of Everton and, yes, relegation, cos I don't see how we are going to improve any time soon. If it doesn't come this season, it will come next. Something has to give. Kenwright's vanity, Moyes's stubborness, or the club?
Tony J Williams
58 Posted 05/12/2011 at 17:23:16
"I'm 60 years old and I've seen the good times and the bad... but this shit I'm watching tops the lot"

You must have slept through a couple of seasons if you think this is the worst we have ever been.
Joseph Fong
59 Posted 05/12/2011 at 17:59:12
Chris @55 : Are you for real? As much as I want a change in the management, when was it BK's fault in all those out transfers? Pienaar and Arteta wanted to play in CL and our current manager couldn't deliver that. Yak, Beckford, Silva, Yobo etc etc were either sold cheaply or loaned out and only one person can do that and he is DM.
Joseph Fong
60 Posted 05/12/2011 at 18:06:09
The most jaw dropping moment in the game was Vellios substitution. We were losing by a goal, toothless upfront with crosses coming in left and right, stats were showing zero attempts on goal with more than ten off targets and what did our great manager did? He brought on Stracqualursi to replace Vellios. One striker for another with less than 15mins to play on a goal down. What a brilliant tactic that was! I wouldn't keep this clown as our manager if I am the new owner. DM reminds me of The Gollum in The Lord of The Rings and for that we are doomed.
Antony Matthews
61 Posted 05/12/2011 at 18:43:14
Moyes: "What wins games is goals and they got the goal and we didn't." NO SHIT SHERLOCK!

Managers win trophies.... well some of them do.
Jimmy Sørheim
62 Posted 05/12/2011 at 19:18:42
Moyes must take responsibility and resign, the fans must start a protest against him, staying away from Goodison is not going to do it. Start screaming "Moyes Out".

Moyes is never to blame, he is God, he is Jesus, Kenwright's lovechild... I am disgusted by all this. Dumb and Dumber, Bill and Moyes.

If you want a change than start a protest; if not, just do what you currently are doing, simple as that.

I bet we will not see a protest until there are 5 games left of the season and we lie in the bottom 3. By then it will be too late, mark my words. Get him out NOW.
Ian Tunstead
63 Posted 05/12/2011 at 20:03:16
Heard it all before jimmy for about 10 years. The doom mongers need to stop getting so dramatic and realise we couldnt get a better manager. Even if we could afford to sack Moyes and bring in the best manager available he would struggle with this team and no money to improve the side in future seasons. Without huge investment we will not break into the top 6. Its not rocket science.
Phil Martin
64 Posted 05/12/2011 at 20:12:13
Totally agree Ian. Who better* would we attract as a new manager? I'm awaiting the inevitable long line of "fashionable" managers who've got less than 2 years experience and never managed a big club.

Sacking Moyes is just papering over the cracks...

*as in proven track record of high finishes and gets teams to play quality football.
Sean Patton
65 Posted 05/12/2011 at 20:17:32
Yep you are both right it has just dawned on me with your comprehensive analysis that David Moyes is the ONLY manager in the world.
Will Firstbrook
66 Posted 05/12/2011 at 20:18:06
If I hear one more soundbite from Moyes about needing money to compete, I'm going to snap like a carrot! Stating the bloody obvious is tired and pathetic. Stop sulking and come up with a plan (and not the Plan A that we see every week). Hell, for £60k/wk or whatever he get's paid, it's the least anyone can expect!

While it would be nice to have a consistent goal-scoring hitman leading the line, I don't see that as the #1 issue facing this team at the moment. As others have noted in this thread (and was painfully on display Sunday), it matters not who you have as a striker if you can't provide service!! Our midfield is incapable of getting the ball through the opposition. No control, no creativity ? just aimless crosses into the box. Is this what they are being drilled on every week?!? God help us all if that is true.
Phil Martin
67 Posted 05/12/2011 at 20:39:56
@63 - well name a suitable candidate then Sean!!!

@64 - yes no creativity in midfield. But that's what you get when you sell your two most creative midfielders and dont replace them.

Fuck me.
Ian Tunstead
68 Posted 05/12/2011 at 20:47:24
I have named him Phil, on the "Make up; we need a manager remover" thread. It's the obvious choice.
Jay Harris
69 Posted 05/12/2011 at 20:27:45
Ian and Phil.

At one time I would have agreed with you because Moyes is a man of integrity and principle.

The only problem now is that he has become one of us.

Totally disillusioned and demotivated and that for a manager is no good at all.

Instead of allowing Kenwright to cry on his shirtsleves about having no money, he should have threatened to resign.
Dennis Stevens
70 Posted 05/12/2011 at 20:57:40
It'll be a sad day for some of you when Moyes leaves ? whoever replaces him isn't going to be good enough for you. Imagine the confusion if Moyes's successor were, against expectation, to avoid relegation & maybe even get the team playing better football?
Gavin Ramejkis
71 Posted 05/12/2011 at 21:08:45
Or Dennis, we'd get someone who doesn't make the same stubborn bastard mistakes, week-in & week-out, after ten fucking years.
Ryan Holroyd
72 Posted 05/12/2011 at 21:08:45
Jimmy Sørheim

Why don't you shout "Moyes Out" at Goodison instead of asking everyone else to say it?
John Ford
73 Posted 05/12/2011 at 20:27:25
Nobody has to deal with the restrictions which Moyes is under. Many managers have had more resources than Moyes and failed repeatedly, the latest being Steve Bruce.

One of the more recent and more bizzare arguments against Moyes is the 'hes responsible for buying players and picking the team' ....... the idiocy of this is the failure to recognise that he singularly HASN'T been allowed to buy players. It's like theres a hole in the head, as if when the season starts every team is on a level playing, and what happens in the market is duly marginalised. When actually how you deal in market is the single biggest determinant of success.

If Moyes had been given decent funds in the summer and bought say Scott Parker, Pienaar back and a half-decent forward to replace Beckford, I would be screaming for his head if we'd produced the shit we're seeing now. We're crap because Arteta & Pienaar have gone and Cahill and Saha are past it. There's no money for replacements.

To me, it's a question of who does most with not very much? Moyes's record stacks up better than anyone's and I'm convinced we will improve with modest investment. He's a miserable twat lately and needs to recognise his duty to keep everyone's confidence in the club, but all these pointless notions about formation and pissing about Strac, Barkley (previously Coleman, Drenthe) needing to start or use two three forwards, wingers, Bily behind the front two are just flapping in the wind. You are applying regular football logic to a completely irregular position. It's all bollocks. Changes have been made but to little effect, because we just don't have the players.

We'll do enough this season but we're seriously in decline. Shuffling our (very cheap) deckchairs will make little or no difference.

OK that doesn't excuse Moyes's reluctance to change, but the only sustainable position as a fan is to suspend expectations and focus on getting the club leadership changed. Without it, we will never progress, regardless of who is manager.
Sean Patton
74 Posted 05/12/2011 at 20:47:51
Phil

Is this the part where I name some managers and you just go through them one at a time saying they either (a) aren't good enough, or (b) wouldn't come here in a million years.

I fail to see why Everton having a new manager is such a big deal ? it really is not ? and the idea that the team will somehow disintegrate once St David of Moyes leaves is nonsense .

Money talks in this country, I know that, and I accept that finishing in the top 4 or even top 6 is unrealistic but here is the key point for me if money decides a team's league placing and Everton have the 8th highest turnover in the league then why does Moyes get so many plaudits?

He is simply doing what is to be expected nothing more and nothing less. In my mind any half decent manager could get this team and this squad into the top 10 at least and a few of them would do so playing a better standard of football that the current custodian is.

I have compiled a list of possible replacements feel free to pick away

Chris Hughton
Mark Hughes
Marco Van Basten
Steve McLaren
Sven Goran Eriksson
Carlo Ancelotti
Bernd Schuster
Michael Laudrup.
Brian Harrison
75 Posted 05/12/2011 at 21:29:13
I can't believe that there are so many calling for Moyes to be sacked. For God's sake, look at where we have finished in his 10 years and you actually think he has failed.

He is now paying the penalty for us being skint. Does anyone really think that he would sell 2 of his strikers without replacing them, If it wasn't a case of the club via the banks saying we had to sell?

Can anyone tell me a club in the last 10 years who have spent less than Everton and finished higher consistently than us.

Yes, we don't play as much creative football as we have in the previous seasons, but two of his most creative players have left the club in the past 12 months ? that has to have an impact on the style of football played.

Finally, everyone goes on about 4-5-1 being negative, well Spurs play that formation and are the most attractive side in the Premier.
Ian Tunstead
76 Posted 05/12/2011 at 21:45:36
Sean, Moyes does get the team to finish in the top 10 so what is your problem?
Phil Martin
77 Posted 05/12/2011 at 22:08:39
Chris Hughton <- nowhere near proven enough
Mark Hughes <- ok a possiblity
Marco Van Basten <- like we have a chance
Steve McLaren <- you're not serious
Sven Goran Eriksson <- you're just having a laugh now
Carlo Ancelotti <- Why would he give us even a sniff with BK (and his disappearing money trick) at the helm.
Bernd Schuster <- I doubt he's even heard of us.
Michael Laudrup. <- What are his credentials exactly? (aside from being a great player).

...And Sean, Moyes has us finshing top 8 year on year.
Robbie Muldoon
78 Posted 05/12/2011 at 21:59:02
Lionel Messi wouldn't have scored if he was in place of Vellios yesterday. The set up is shite.
Sean Patton
79 Posted 05/12/2011 at 22:35:11
The problem is so would every name on that list and they would do so playing better football without getting £65k a fucking week!

The point I am making is he is not performing miracles getting Everton in the top 8 there are loads of managers who could do the same so why does he get an easy ride.

He wins a match he is hailed as a genius he loses a match and its never his fault.
Denis Richardson
80 Posted 05/12/2011 at 21:20:18
John #73, whilst some of what you say is valid, Moyes has also gone stale and simply does not look up for it anymore. Having no funds is no excuse to exude negativity through every pore. Either like it or lump it but ffs stop moaning about it!

Money does make a difference but a side that has its confidence continually dragged down is not going to be successful, regardless of how much or little they cost. If one of the main jobs of the manager is to motivate the players, then for this total failure alone he should accept he has not achieved and do the noble thing and walk (BK is not going to do anything). Stoke are not exactly Barcelona so to not register a single shot on goal, at home, in the match against them is........am lost for words here!

By the way, there were loads of players available on frees and on loan in the summer transfer window, why did we manage to not get any until the usual panic last minute scramble? Players were known to be out of contract in Jan but no one was lined up at all. How much of this is down to BK or Moyes, I don't know but if you look around the league there were many good midfielders and strikers that were on frees so this 'no money' issue is getting very boring.

Simply put if the manager does not feel that he can motivate the players then he should resign. Constantly coming out with negative statements in not a school of motivation that I'm aware of.
Dennis Stevens
81 Posted 05/12/2011 at 23:41:59
Do you even read posts before you respond to them, Gavin?
Gavin Ramejkis
82 Posted 06/12/2011 at 13:10:18
Yes Dennis I do, I obviously hit a nerve as you haven't, like the other Moyes lickspittles you have this hard on claim that removing Moyes is a guarantee for relegation, prove it, I'd offer that challenge to any of the Moyes fans, give me one cast iron proof that the removal of Moyes would guarantee relegation
Dennis Stevens
83 Posted 06/12/2011 at 15:22:04
I can only assume English is your second language then, if you thought my comments were pro-Moyes, Gavin. Hit a nerve? You couldn't be wider of the mark!
Gareth Fieldstead
84 Posted 06/12/2011 at 16:57:57
Sorry John but I cannot agree. You talk about Bruce like he had a lot of money to spend, yes he did but only from player sales, namely, Bent, Ferdinand and Henderson which raised 50 million. When Moyes has had money to spend namely from the sale of Lescott he blew it on two central defenders who are average and a midfielder that has failed big time. Ditto the Rooney money. With the exception of Arteta who did he buy that improved that team in 05? Beattie? Koldrup? Valente? Van Der Meyde? Yes some of his buys have been good, Arteta, Cahill and Baines particularly, but he has made just as many if not more poor buys. Even if he was to recieve all the funds from the summer sales and additional money from players sold in January, Heitinga/Billy? would you honestly trust him to spend it wisely? He would probably still go out and sign a defender, defensive midfielder and a goalkeeper. By the way Jay, yes I agree but he hasn't got the balls to threaten the board with his resignation as he wouldn't get anywhere near that salary elsewhere.
Phil Martin
85 Posted 06/12/2011 at 17:16:41
Gareth are you having a giggle?

He also bought Yobo with the Rooney money.Who has served us well generally.
He essentially constructed the side which finsihed 4th with the Rooney money.

Now lets forget about Pienaar, Saha, Jags, Lescott, Distin, Johnson, Fellaini and pretend he only signs bad players - yes?
Gareth Fieldstead
86 Posted 06/12/2011 at 17:14:15
So why doesn't he state that he was forced to sell the Yak and Beckford? Hasn't he stated on several occasions that only he makes the decisions on whether a player leaves or not? Wouldn't his position at the club become untenable if the board are interfering to such an extent that the team could be relegated? yet they haven't once come out to the press to explain why players are being sold to appease the banks, thus leaving Moyes desperately short in quality personnel? More like Moyes has fallen out with these players, just like Rooney, Radzinski, Ferguson and Johnson? As for Spurs, they only happen to have Bale, Modric, Lennon, Van der Vaart, Parker etc, etc. None of whom cost a fortune, just the small matter of the last two Spurs managers spending there money wisely.
Robert Daniels
87 Posted 06/12/2011 at 19:06:18
Why do people keep saying we play 4-5-1,

Cos we don't... We play 4-4-1-1...

We're the only team that plays it, and we've played it for years under this inept, tacticless "60 mins then the sub" manager.

The 'bricks' (his stupid words ? not mine), Cahill, Ossie, Hibbo, Neville, keep getting their names on the sheet first... Loyalty or scared manager?

He needs to go, not for his sake, not for ours... But for the sake of Everton Football Club.
Gareth Fieldstead
88 Posted 06/12/2011 at 23:17:03
Memory not what it once was Phil? He signed Yobo initially on loan in 2002 03 season and bought him for 4 million at the end of that season. Yobo has been deemed surplus to requirements for two years and hasnt been consistent for four years, I still cringe when I think of a Charlton equaliser at the valley several years back when Yobo decided it was a good time to tie his boot laces. As for the Rooney money constructing the 04 05 side, really? Rooney was sold to Utd on the final day of the transfer window in August 04, leaving Moyes no opportunity to sign anyone. Don't you remember, it was another reason why so many criticised the lads timing of his request to move? Bent and Cahill were already signed before Rooney left. Arteta was brought in on loan in the January of 05 annd yes he had a few good games but he was hardly instrumental in us finishing fourth, Cahill, Bent, Martin, Weir, Carsley, Ferguson and Graveson would have something to say about that. Finally I am not denying he hasnt bought good players, you would hope he would get some right in ten years! but I would hardly call Johnson (17 goals in two years) Beattie, Koldrup, Davies, Van der Meyde, Neville, Wright, Yobo, Kilbane Billy or heitinga success. That was at a cost of nearly 50 million, all with the exception of Johnson sold at a loss or will be! and lets not get onto Yakubu sold at a loss of nearly 10 million who is now scorinf for fun, well done Dave!!

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads