Season › 2011-12 › News
Horne: Asking price is too high
In his role as a regular expert summariser in the commentary box for Premier League games, Horne has often expressed his sympathy for Kenwright but in an article for the Echo this weekend the Welshman spells out the realities of the the Blues' plight.
"Although I always look for the positive about every aspect of the club, there is definitely a sense that we are now caught up in a downward spiral," Horne writes.
"The Blues are still losing £5m a year which is not an attractive proposition for anyone wanting to invest in the club.
"That is the first clue why Everton have not been able to find a buyer and the second is — on the back of Keith Harris recently saying the club would look to sell for around £150m — it must be overpriced.
"In the past I have stuck up for Bill Kenwright and Robert Elstone but the only thing you can do to get someone to buy what you are selling is by dropping your price."
Quotes or other material sourced from Liverpool Echo
Reader Comments (70)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 10/12/2011 at 17:57:16
3 Posted 10/12/2011 at 18:13:12
Keep it up Barry, you may end up saving us twice...
The Echo gives them a dig as well, let's hope the tide is turning.
4 Posted 10/12/2011 at 18:26:51
5 Posted 10/12/2011 at 18:26:10
If someone was prepared to pay him for his shares, what he paid for them plus whatever inflation figure was appropriate, that would be fair. Dont forget, when Kenwright and Gregg took control of EFC, the debt was nothing like what it is now.
I think if he doesn't get out of the club, we're on a one-way ticket to oblivion.
6 Posted 10/12/2011 at 18:32:50
7 Posted 10/12/2011 at 19:03:21
Is that not enough for anyone? Especially if you love the club so much. But then again, the other 75% of shareholders can hold out for more I suppose. So maybe it isn't just BK but all 4 of them..
8 Posted 10/12/2011 at 19:20:03
9 Posted 10/12/2011 at 19:14:38
I understand that he has to negotiate to get the deal required to keep himself, Woods, Earl and Green happy, but something needs to happen NOW ? the club stinks and changes need to be made now!!!!!!
10 Posted 10/12/2011 at 20:04:26
11 Posted 10/12/2011 at 20:09:31
That's what the BU have been asking amongst other things but according to Blue Bill and the other idiots running the club they are the best "sellers" for our club!
12 Posted 10/12/2011 at 20:21:00
I know there are a few correspondents on here who have the nous to value the club realistically, based on its turnover and debts etc... perhaps one of them could come up with a figure along with reasons behind that figure. Barry Horne's article is pointless because it's based on guesswork at best.
13 Posted 10/12/2011 at 20:39:46
14 Posted 10/12/2011 at 20:50:53
It is like Nigel has said at No 1, there is a sense of the tide turning slightly. Furthermore there can only be a few reasons why the club has not been sold: 1 the asking price is too high; 2 - it isn't actually for sale (the "Kirkby Defence"). 3- we are close to financial collapse and the vultures are waiting to get us knock-down.
We need to corner Kenwright and pin him down in order to get at the truth and so make a sale more likely. Comments like this of Barry Horne's set a trend in the media and, yes, make it a little easier for that rag the Echo and other media outlets to "investigate". Let's hope other commentators and pundits now chip in.
15 Posted 10/12/2011 at 21:03:40
16 Posted 10/12/2011 at 21:12:52
Part of the problem is the Echo are shit scared of the Mighty EFC Spin Team, they have on numerous occasions been banned bythe club.
Hopefully like the emails scandal we can only wait in hope that another smoking gun appears and forces BK out. You see part of the problem is that BK still has a significant strong support from the fans even after reading and digesting the BU interview, when you look at the fallout over the interview even though he came across as a bumbling idiot and a full on lying shit all his supporters came out fighting.
17 Posted 10/12/2011 at 21:09:53
Or my particular favourite: "No-one is buying football clubs."
Anyone with half a brain cell knows why the club hasn't been sold. Greed. The contradictions from BK's mouth roll off his tongue.
"There are always three or four people looking at investing in us, and that's the case now, we are talking to three or four interested parties." He should be called "The Riddler".
To think some dull fuckers clapped him at the match... They should be ashamed of themselves.
18 Posted 10/12/2011 at 21:09:22
If you bought £135 worth of British Gas shares in 1986 {if you see Sid tell him!} they would now be worth £1720.00, that's because the "market" says that's what they can sell them for.
I'm not sure that Kenwright wants to make a massive profit on us, neither would I expect him to take a loss, it's all speculation and premature supposition as far as I can see at the moment.
19 Posted 10/12/2011 at 21:21:45
How much do you think would be needed then to buy the club ? bearing in mind that the debt would have to be cleared on top of what is paid for the shares, and you would assume the buyer would want a return on his outlay, so that would mean bringing more money into the club somehow, bigger gates? better players ? how much to achieve this in your opinion ?
20 Posted 10/12/2011 at 21:26:00
A catastrophic fall in gates and or relegation might force their hand.
Perhaps the Moyseahs success in avoiding the drop is condemning us to an overly long drawn out agony.
21 Posted 10/12/2011 at 21:34:28
Brilliant.
If the club went down the IPO route and issued 100m shares to the public, how much would you pay to own 100 shares? Just think about it, if it was your own cash how much would you invest? Different ball game if its your own cash instead of someone elses isnt it.
22 Posted 10/12/2011 at 21:45:48
23 Posted 10/12/2011 at 21:49:01
Shares currently sell on the open market for approximately £1250 each and there are a total of 35,000 so that is a starting figure of £43.75 Million.
Then there are debts to take into account and the fact that it loses money every year, so it isn't worth anywhere near £150m.
24 Posted 10/12/2011 at 21:58:34
25 Posted 10/12/2011 at 21:59:39
26 Posted 10/12/2011 at 22:02:31
Ring Blankstone Sington stockbrokers on 0151-236-8200 on Monday morning and ask them, or better still go on their website now and you will see the EFC logo and information on to how to buy shares in Everton.
I have recently bought shares from them.
27 Posted 10/12/2011 at 22:19:38
28 Posted 10/12/2011 at 22:30:33
29 Posted 10/12/2011 at 22:32:22
30 Posted 10/12/2011 at 22:39:39
the billionaires on the board could underwrite it but they "dont want to dilute their shareholding" which is why it will never happen.
For a sale to take place it will take a massive overvaluation )i.e 150 to 180 million) or a major moneymaking opportunity like DK.
Green and Earl are parasites and will want their pound of flesh unless they are hounded out by the supporters.
Cant see anu of those things happening unfortunately and neither can Moyes.
31 Posted 10/12/2011 at 23:05:09
If he's a businessman and looking to get full market value from it, then fair enough, but at least he should stop all the bollocks about being a blue and wanting whats best for EFC. He wants whats best for BK.
32 Posted 11/12/2011 at 01:56:43
Based on £2,000 share value
Shares market price back in 2006
33 Posted 10/12/2011 at 20:50:53
It is like Nigel has said at No 1, there is a sense of the tide turning slightly. Furthermore there can only be a few reasons why the club has not been sold: 1 the asking price is too high; 2 - it isn't actually for sale (the "Kirkby Defence"). 3- we are close to financial collapse and the vultures are waiting to get us knock-down.
We need to corner Kenwright and pin him down in order to get at the truth and so make a sale more likely. Comments like this of Barry Horne's set a trend in the media and, yes, make it a little easier for that rag the Echo and other media outlets to "investigate". Let's hope other commentators and pundits now chip in.
34 Posted 11/12/2011 at 09:49:49
The club have refused to put a price on the club. Understandable to a point, but the Keith Harris and "email-gate" quotes reveal he is indeed seeking £100m+, for a business with c.£45m debts, off-balance sheet loans, and consequent impacting of revenue streams.
So for a £20m purchase, with debts at the time of around £5m, I'd say a 500%+ return is the least he can ask for?
(For those still not quite awake, that last sentence may be a little sarcastic)
35 Posted 11/12/2011 at 10:00:44
36 Posted 11/12/2011 at 10:50:42
Thanks Matt, i'm aware of that, in those days I used to get to c.30 live games a season. I know I had a few Mahou's watching the game yesterday but I would swear I was the 2nd or 3rd post last night before Roberts post @3, the question marks where just the end of my sentence. Maybe the Mahou is stronger than I thought !!! or I just can't read. COYB
37 Posted 11/12/2011 at 14:54:50
BUT, there's also £47 million net debt. Why should a new buyer pay off the debt of the old owners on top of the purchase price?and the net liabilities are £33 million on top of the debt.
AND the Club is losing money every year it doesn't sell assets, of which all that remains are the players.
38 Posted 11/12/2011 at 15:07:30
Now if it was a typo and you meant KD, that's a different story!
39 Posted 11/12/2011 at 15:06:42
"BK and his mates got their shares for a song.... well below the actual going rate at the time. The share value has dropped dramatically since...."
None of that makes any sense to me, perhaps you could explain the first bit of your statement re; for a song?, and, how can the value of shares drop on a business who's turnover has grown dramatically and will continue to do so while we all carry on paying our Sky subscriptions, and the potential for growth is there for all to see.
40 Posted 11/12/2011 at 15:23:04
41 Posted 11/12/2011 at 15:24:52
Turnover isn't profit but how that turnover is managed can lead to profits if done correctly.
42 Posted 11/12/2011 at 15:45:14
Why, Steve? YOU have made that assumption.
Sheik Mansour will never make a return on his outlay. Nor Abramovich.
I am sure you can find some more excuses for this board if you look hard enough.
43 Posted 11/12/2011 at 15:59:07
Don't wanta be negative, but does Liverpool have a large public sector for jobs? I'm guessing yes, and we know what's gonna happen to them. Govt says private sector (which happens to be in a lot more debt than the govt - little reported fact) will compensate. Yeah, like other jobs popped up in the 80s when Tate&Lyle etc closed. That doesn't spell rising revenues at the ground.
The only hope is a benefactor in the modern game, but the least likely is one willing to plough dosh into a new ground as well as a team.
I get tired of those thinking our income will just grow. I don't see it. It is only the Sky money that keeps us afloat. If that Golden Egg ever disappeared, we'd be screwed. And what is the consequence of the recent victory of a pub landlady to get TV football from elsewhere? Less dosh, perhaps.
I may be proved wrong, but I reckon TV money will become competitive, not a monopoly as it is now. Jeez, we all know we can get live games for free on the Net. So unless we have the ground (and there's no sign as yet) we will do well to stay in the top half without a daft billionaire.
44 Posted 11/12/2011 at 16:10:29
Total= 35,000 100.0% £70,000,000.
Based on £2,000 share value
Shares market price back in 2006
-------------------------
And the stock market is down 10-20% since then, and that is with the Bank of England printing money and giving it to the banks to invest FFS.
45 Posted 11/12/2011 at 16:30:43
46 Posted 11/12/2011 at 17:06:23
I bought a share while PJ was in control.... the going rate was £3-3.5k per share they had been higher previously. BK secured many of his shares at the time of the new issue..... and then when PJ relinquished control it was at a substantially lower price too. All of which contradicts your theory. The current share price is readily available, as already stated.
47 Posted 11/12/2011 at 17:39:40
I think your memory may be playing some tricks....
TBH bought out Johnson for £857 a share, but that was after I think two rights issues under Johnson that increased the number of shares from 2,500 to 35,000. The original price I have listed for those 2,500 shares is £5,000, although this article from 1994 suggests that may have been high:
Prior to the rights issue Everton had 2,500 shares in issue. These are rarely traded but, when they are, change hands for around £2,600. The one-for-one rights issue was priced at £4,000 per share. The price discouraged shareholders from taking up their rights and was calculated to ensure that Johnson pays a price which "places an acceptable value on the company".The memory of Johnson still sparks a lot of flack from Evertonians, and I was as guilty as anyone back then, but his act of doing a Rights Issue, and buying up all of the newly created shares, pumped £10M into the club ? not into the hands of old shareholders (in this case, the Moores family).
There was a subsequent five-for-one rights issue in 1996 that took the total of shares issued to 30,000, based on a share price of £500. So True Blue Holdings (aka Kenwright & Co) paying £857 per share four years later was hardly Going for a Song.
48 Posted 11/12/2011 at 17:58:00
If he is after £150M for a club with no assets, £50M of debt, a team that needs £50M spending it on it, and a stadium that is past its best, he is clearly deluded ? whether Keith Harris tells him or not. Randy Lerner bought a debt-free club, with a decent stadium for £63m, so why would anyone pay much more for the Mighty Blues???
49 Posted 11/12/2011 at 18:30:51
Regardless, much of BK's stock will indeed have come during both rights issues and the subsequent release by PJ. A total that would be substantially less than even the current share value.
50 Posted 11/12/2011 at 18:56:47
I think Blankstones play silly buggers with the price they quote at times, to be honest. But it depends which rights issue. After the first (1994) and £3k is a good price. After the second (1996) and £3k was around five times too much.
£3k * 35,000 = £105M. There is no way Everton were worth anything like that in the 1990s... Do the maths!
£857 * 35,000 = ~£30M, which seems to have been a reasonable price to pay for Everton (with no debt to speak of) in 2000... although I know Johnson had been asking a lot more... and there were no other buyers.
History repeating? Perhaps... we shall see... or not!
51 Posted 11/12/2011 at 21:32:15
Eric 45: Our income from Sky is circa £50M, gate receipts approx £21M, other income approx £9M.
Tom #46: I think Michael's already answered the point I made, my understanding was TBH paid £357 per share over and above the original rights issue price.
52 Posted 11/12/2011 at 22:00:46
To buy a share at that time would've cost you the same as mine..... independently or via blackstones. I did both. The price came down quite dramatically afterwards.....
And Michael, yes PJ did indeed state some ridiculously high estimates of club values and might have stood by it had his position not become untenable.
53 Posted 12/12/2011 at 00:15:33
35000 SHARES £2000 A SHARE BACK IN 2006... COUNT INFLATION and I`d say that on paper we are worth £100 Million... Its not underpriced and its not over priced... The problem is do you build a new team or build a new stadium first.
54 Posted 12/12/2011 at 01:16:53
The Macawber Principle still applies... whatever the figure.
55 Posted 12/12/2011 at 04:04:40
56 Posted 12/12/2011 at 04:16:24
Even if one of those 3 or 4 buyers did come good, the club would be silly to announce before making some signings. They seemed to pay a decent amount for George Green and could sign him outside the window, so did. They've always promised a busy January so I'm waiting until February to judge.
57 Posted 12/12/2011 at 06:34:42
I didn't think we could allow any more players to leave like last January as we're bare bones as it is.
58 Posted 12/12/2011 at 06:10:02
Profit or untangible benefits/goodwill is gained from the exposure of Premier League clubs around the whole world. It would form part of a business portfolio where losses are expected from the Premier League club business unit, but gained in other areas because of the ties/synergy/exposure of the football club. If Premier Leagues clubs permitted there would be sponsors blazing all over the shorts and socks like the French Ligue or F1.
The second is the bragging rights for owning a dildo for the rich, spoilt and/or corrupt.
59 Posted 12/12/2011 at 09:21:58
Kenwright trades on being the biggest Blue there is. I don't have a problem with that, but then he wants to make as much profit as possible from a club he has ruined.
As far as a valuation goes, how could you ask anyone for that figure when they don't have access to any contracts, loans, mortgage details etc. The club didn't even know they could not build on their own ground, because there were issues with mortgages.
60 Posted 12/12/2011 at 22:18:13
61 Posted 13/12/2011 at 00:32:29
"And what is the consequence of the recent victory of a pub landlady to get TV football from elsewhere? Less dosh, perhaps."
I'm sorry but this is going to sound patronising, and forgive me before I start.
That landlady will only get cheap football for as long as Sky allows her too, because within the stadium {pick anyone in the PL it doesn't matter which} the ONLY camera's allowed into that stadium are those belonging to BSKYB, when BSKYB decide that it's detrimental to their income, they will do something about it, the only reason they are not at the moment is, the balance between paying and none paying is acceptable to them, I can wholeheartedly guarantee that within the next three years, you will see a massively different stance from the above mentioned, and it would have been sooner if they could've kept their own scandals in order.
62 Posted 13/12/2011 at 01:02:57
They uplink the feed to a satellite and it is distributed from there to the various companies that have paid for it. So if the Greek satellite company has paid then the Plymouth landlady will get her live matches.
The change would be that they now just might have to sell the European rights at the same price to everyone.
63 Posted 13/12/2011 at 03:56:06
64 Posted 13/12/2011 at 04:35:10
Assets ? what does it actually own, trading stock or inventory (players as they can be bought and sold for a profit or loss); Revenue streams ie ticket sales, tv money sponsors, prize money. EFC reportedly loses £5M each year so it sells off assets or stock to make ends meet: Arteta for £10M props up the accounts.
EFC is not a good buy at £150M ? it's worth a lot less, probably around £35-40M and that is really the value of the squad ? everything else is mortgaged out or financed to keep a team on the park.
The danger here is going into administration and then auto relegation due to points being taken off, eg, Leeds and Pompey. So the only way we get a new owner is when we go into receiveship and then the club can be picked up on the cheap as it will be worthless as most of the players will have to be sold off cheap.
The reality is we end up in the 2nd division playing hoofball with a Moyes clone.
65 Posted 13/12/2011 at 09:30:44
You can only generate an ROI where your total returns are greater than your initial outlay. In the case of Everton, the cash generated by the business is less than when Kenwright bought his shares, the Board has chosen to fund the 'business expansion' through debt and there has been a chronic underinvestment in the club's infrastructure excepting some off-balance sheet finance with regard to the training complex.
You don't need to be an investment banker to realise that all of these things are negative value indicators. Perhaps the Board think differently?
If I were advising somone on the purchase of the club tomorrow, I'd tell them to seek a massive reduction in the cash outlay for the amount of debt on (and off) the balance sheet and I'd also want a deduction for the amount of capex required after sale. Add these things together and you arrive at a very low number for purchase consideration.
I'd struggle to recommend a purchase price of greater than £1.
66 Posted 13/12/2011 at 10:03:41
I think you sum it up perfectly. They've run the old lady into the ground, they can't afford any fuel, let alone to fix all its problems...... and yet they seem to want their original purchase price and more.
Any prospective buyer will be able to see this.... and is probably prepared to wait for this lot to choke on their asking price. Our predicament dictates that it's probably a buyer's market as regards the sale of EFC..... it's all of their own making, but it will be the club (the fans) who will suffer.
67 Posted 13/12/2011 at 11:04:53
?excepting some off-balance sheet finance with regard to the training complex.?
Lol, that?s you off Everton?s Christmas card list!
?I'd struggle to recommend a purchase price of greater than £1.?
And next years!!!!
Spot on btw.
68 Posted 13/12/2011 at 16:23:23
http://www.keioc.net/index.php?mact=News,cntnt01,detail,0&cntnt01articleid=367&cntnt01returnid=15
69 Posted 13/12/2011 at 20:12:58
70 Posted 13/12/2011 at 23:19:15
Well they've now sold the last of the family silver, and the club's true state is there for all to see.
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 10/12/2011 at 17:49:06