Moyes happy despite defeat

, 10 December, 66comments  |  Jump to most recent
David Moyes felt Everton competed well with Arsenal before slipping to a 1-0 defeat thanks to Robin van Persie's sensational winner.

"I thought the boys did a great job and worked really hard to stay in the game," he said on Sky Sports.

"We were fortunate to go in at half-time 0-0 but in the second half I thought we were on top when Arsenal scored the goal."

Quotes or other material sourced from BBC Sport



Reader Comments (66)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Peter Barry
1 Posted 11/12/2011 at 04:15:59
"David Moyes happy with Everton display despite defeat"

Says the headline on the Beeb and that is exactly why Dour Davey has to go. I don't want an Everton manger who is SATISFIED with being defeated. If we had played a great game of football strained all the sinews and were beaten by a brilliant piece of skill then he could say that. But to play the dross we have been playing this season week in week out and have the manager SATISFIED is just not good enough.

If it is true that Drenthe decked him then DAVEY has to swallow his Jock PRIDE and play Drenthe for the sake of the TEAM and supporters not quarantine him like he did to Yakubu who has been a revelation since he escaped tactics Devoid Dour Davey's clutches. BTW Round deserves his share of opprobrium too Everton's performances have dipped dramatically since he became coach.
Suresh Gill
2 Posted 11/12/2011 at 06:23:53
There is nothing to be happy about, Moyes! You have gone stale with your tactics and your lack of confidence and negativity is reflected in the way we play.
We have gone in reverse It reminds me of 1994. The club needs to be sold, and we need funds.
Whatever happens we still need to get behind the boys and stay in this league. COYB
Adam Baig
3 Posted 11/12/2011 at 08:42:44
Yes Davey, two full games without a shot on target and you are 'satisfied'. Is there another football manager in the world that could say that.

The idea of the game is to score more goals than your opponent, ie put the round thing in that big netty thing.

Fuckwit.
Steve Guy
4 Posted 11/12/2011 at 10:04:05
what's all this about Royston smacking Moyes ?
Mark Tanton
5 Posted 11/12/2011 at 10:18:09
The club has to be bold enough to fire Moyes and move on. "Better the devil you know" will not work forever and it's time to take a risk... But Kenwright seems happy enough with 14th place and a manager who accepts financial inertia.

Thank you for everything you've done Moyes, you'll never have to buy a drink in the city again, but it's time to leave.
Terry McLavey
6 Posted 11/12/2011 at 10:21:07
When I see our players going into print about winning eg.Cahill , I always know it's a sign of impending doom!! Why can't they keep their mouths shut and just play! It was a "hope for the best" performance yesterday we just waited for them to score and if the near misses had gone in it would have been a rout!! We went one nil down and Davey brought on a defender!! damage limitation? Come on Dave admit your a championship manager and always have been and will be again if we're not careful! A Manc checkout operator in my local supermarket , after their exit from the Champions league, asked me if Moyes is going to be their next manager? I just said that should stop you ever winning anything again! Apparently I heard Drenthe had Moyes by the throat he should have used his other hand to throttle Kenwright! But Moyes' ego won't let him play again despite him being the only penetrating player I've seen for fuck knows how long !!
Wayne Smyth
7 Posted 11/12/2011 at 10:30:17
There is plenty to be happy about when you're picking up £65k / week and have a boss who is not going to sack you regardless of your performance.

Moyes no 1 concern is himself. He couldn't care less if we lose at Arsenal 1-0 or 2-0. That's expected isn't it? Arsenal have spent a lot of money, haven't they? The press will just roll out another headline about how Moyes is hamstrung by a lack of funds, and how we put up a determined defence and were undone by a moment of magic.

However, if we lost 3 or 4 nil, or more, then the press might pay more attention and might actually start to look a bit more closely at some of Moyes decisions. This is what moyes cares about, arse covering, not EFC.

That is the ONLY possible explanation for taking off your only striker and replacing him with a defender, or playing 7 defenders in the same team with 30 minutes of a game still to play where the score is 0-0. Damage limitation.

It also explains his comments to the media about bringing knives to a gunfight, etc. I've lost all respect for him. When he arrived, he had bottle, drive, determination to push us forward. Now he's just trying to ensure that whatever happens, nothing bad reflects on him.
Mark Tanton
8 Posted 11/12/2011 at 11:02:49
When Moyes arrived we bullied our way into the top four; we were uninvited guests and we liked surprising people. We had fewer big name players, but it didn't matter.

Moyes has spent money on players, but not always spent it very well and he has a squad which is entirely his own. After ten years the squad is Moyes, the culture is Moyes and we are going backwards.

We make our apologies before we turn up now, we are whimpering our way through saturday after saturday. Where has it all gone? Moyes must take some responsibility.
Anthony Hanlon
9 Posted 11/12/2011 at 10:59:02
We have taken 1 point from the top 13 teams in the Prem this season, conceded the first goal 9 out of 10 games at home, yet the 3rd best paid manager in the Prem has the safest job in football. No doubt we will get the Phil Neville war cry in tomorrow's Echo.

No other manager would put up with little kitty money, no other chairman would put up with dire football week-in & week-out... A perfect marriage: Bill needs Moyes, Moyes needs Bill.
Mark Jensen
10 Posted 11/12/2011 at 12:14:49
We have two wins on the trot and Moyes comes out all negative with "papering over the cracks" and "if we had lost...".
Now, after two defeats, he is pleased with our perforamce.
Enough said.
By the way, don't wait for Moyes Great (?) skill in the transfer market as Cahill was signed in 2004 and Arteta 2005. Moyes has done bugger all since.


Kenwright Out - Moyes Out
Eddie Cotton
11 Posted 11/12/2011 at 11:55:52
I note the comments on your manager's apparent tactical and motivational indiscretions, but my point is this...why do local journalists always give your manager an easy time in post match interviews? They never seem to question Mr Moyes about fundamental on-field issues, as highlighted many times by many people on Toffeeweb, preferring instead to search desperately for any positives, whilst the majority of fans can see nothing but negativity on the pitch. Their lack of moral fortitude is patronising to you fans, and does nothing for the reputation of the journalists asking such inane and brown nosing questions.

This post isn't meant as an anti-Moyes/Everton jibe...that's none of my business...but is merely a reminder that whenever a local journalist fails to ask relevant questions after yet another poor display, then they're doing a severe disservice to the fans and themselves.

Furthermore, their failure to question fundamental tactics both on and off the pitch is one of the reasons why your more active fans are finding their voices, because these fans realise they cannot rely on the local media to ask questions regarding the current situation at Goodison Park.

The old mushroom adage is certainly apt in these circumstances.
Tom Bowers
12 Posted 11/12/2011 at 13:27:58
It's the sign of a defeatist and rather sad that we have a manager who has so lost the plot which only goes to show that he is only interested in players who run for 90 minutes even if the are not good enough to have any impact on the game.
Cahill gets selected again ahead of a younger,quicker striker in Velios-absolutely pathetic by Moyes.
The game went exactly as I predicted yesterday in this column before the game, even down to the desperate substitutions.
So now we have lost to all the top teams except Spurs who, luckily we did not play yet. What next????
Joe Bibb
13 Posted 11/12/2011 at 14:05:07
Post #10 Eddie Cotton, the reason all journalists treat Moyes and EFC with kid gloves is that if they don't they get banned and get no co-operation from the Club . There are many instances of this from Radio Merseyside to the Liverpool Echo.
Andy Corrie
14 Posted 11/12/2011 at 14:21:27
Moyes should just fuck off now, this has gone way too far!
Paul Ferry
15 Posted 11/12/2011 at 15:39:55
Apparently Steve (and this is supposed to come from someone who was there at the time who passed it on - believe in that what you will) our Royston twatted carrot-head at Finch Farm midweek. If so, he is the only one of our front players to hit the target for a couple of weeks. Drenthe must now join the ranks of Everton legend.
Dominic Virgo
16 Posted 11/12/2011 at 16:06:07
This is sad that our manager is satisfied with another boring display. I am a big Moyes fan too but I think all the hard work he has done is now falling a part very quickly. I'm starting to go with my head now that change is needed.

It's okay asking who will do a better job but I would rather have a manger who will take a risk than one who is trying to play safe every week which isn't working and it's evident. I know we don't have much money but we've got talented youngsters on the bench who would probably give it a better go than the same team he picks every week.
Matthew Lovekin
17 Posted 11/12/2011 at 16:45:16
How can any manager go into any match trying to get a 0-0, lose 1-0 and say they are happy?

I wouldn't be happy if I was Grimsby Town's manager losing 1-0 away to Man Utd. A defeat is a defeat. It's still 0 points. Many more 0 points and we are gonna end up relegated!

Will Moyes still be happy then? Probably.
Ov Collyer
18 Posted 11/12/2011 at 18:05:55
I have to go against the grain a little here and say that I can't see a lot of wrong with Moyes's quotes here, if accurate. I don't think he is saying he is happy we lost, just that the players were working hard and competing well in the second half.

That's not to say I think he's been great this season by any means - certainly yesterday I think taking off Saha and putting on Distin on 70 was premature (though strangely we had our best spell just following the sub IIRC)...it mean't we were left without a recognised striker when we needed a goal and of course sent out the message that we had no interest in winning the game.

I also can't understand the demotion of Barkley and his persistence with Cahill.

I have to ask those suggesting sacking Moyes a couple of questions though:

1) how can we afford to pay off his contract?
2) if we were able to, who do you think we would get that is better than Moyes who would be prepared to work under the same financial constraints?

Bryan Ruiz
19 Posted 11/12/2011 at 18:18:26
Just getting in, Mark Jensen you said that Moyes has done 'bugger all since' in the transfer market since 2005, you obviously have not kept up to date with his dealings after that year.

Just some possible examples:

Seamus Coleman, bought for under £100k, a revelation in his first season, even nominated for the PFA Young Player of the Year Award!

Jermaine Beckford, our top scorer last season, got him for nothing, made a healthy £5 million pound profit.

Steven Pienaar, bought for a minimal £2.5 million, made that easily back with his sale to Spurs.

And just not forgetting Jagielka and Baines, bought for about £10 million combined. This above, was all after 2005, amazing eh.
Wayne Smyth
20 Posted 11/12/2011 at 20:11:14
Ov, I'd be happy with almost anyone. Preferably someone willing to give our young players a chance and give our experienced players some belief that they can compete with anyone. Moyes has always been a fairly negative manager, but the last few seasons he seems to have lost all belief too.

The manager is there to give the players confidence and get them to play at the best of their ability, but who gives the manager confidence when he's at wit's end?

I feel sorry for the guy. He was a breath of fresh air when he arrived 10 years ago, he had energy and a determination to do a job with little to no money. We are back in that situation again, except that our squad still has some good players and we're not quite as screwed as we were when wally left.

I worry that Moyes has no plan B. His tactics of playing players out of position all the time obviously affects their confidence. Cahill hasn't scored in a year, Saha looks bereft of confidence and bily is a shadow of the player he could be if he were played in the hole instead of out on the wing.
James Stewart
21 Posted 11/12/2011 at 22:18:48
0 points

Never looked like scoring and all his defenders on the pitch no wonder he's happy.

Cretin.
Robbie Muldoon
22 Posted 11/12/2011 at 22:21:48
Nil Satis Nisi Optimum should be removed from all club badges.
Ryan Holroyd
23 Posted 11/12/2011 at 22:21:53
#4 It's all rubbish according to all the ITK posters on other sites.

Drenthe was injured in the Wolves game and had a scan on Friday apparently. No lasting damage.

#15 Could you please stop calling people with certain hair colour certain names. It's not big and it's not clever.

What next. Black .... something messed up at a corner.?
Matthew Svatos
24 Posted 12/12/2011 at 03:20:36
I don't like to admit it, but I've finally had enough of Moyes's tactics.

Cahill is useless at the moment. No goals, no assists, not even any touches, but he still gets picked every game. Playing against the speedsters of Gervinho and Walcott, we still played up the wings, getting outrun every single time.

Finally, when they both came off, we started playing up the damn middle. And finally, when we did finally start to play, even look like scoring, he takes off the striker and puts on a defender and of course that's when they scored.

The one revelation that came out of the game was the young McAleny but of course now that he showed what he could do, he'll be stuck on the bench with the other players that show any promise, ie; Barkley, Drenthe, Vellios.
Peter Barry
25 Posted 12/12/2011 at 03:51:21
What we dont need Ryan is a load of mealy mouthed Politically Correct moonbats like YOU.
Anto Byrne
26 Posted 12/12/2011 at 03:05:56
Sorry, I can't support this current team, the manager and the fucking drivel that is served up as football. I wish we would play an up-tempo game but it's so fucking predictable... sideways, backwards and hoofing long balls back to the opposition.

Put the kids on, give them a chance with youthful exuberance and a devil-may-care attitude. It won't happen as these teams reflect Moyes's dour stuborn persona. TAXI!!!
Jason Lam
27 Posted 12/12/2011 at 06:43:07
Well if Moyes is happy about this defeat then I expect 3 points the next game guaranteed. Obviously he gained a lot of insight to be put to good use otherwise what's there to be happy about a defeat?

It's going to be the same boring shite next week. And the next. And the whole sad season. FFS Moyes even if didn't care about the fans sitting through your drivel surely you'll want to liven it up for your own sake how can you sit through this yourself and not bore yourself to madness. Do you enjoy waving the white flag before every game? How many mortgages are you holding? Do you really love that yacht you're saving up for? Unbelievable.
Sam Hoare
29 Posted 12/12/2011 at 09:17:01
Yawn... another Monday and more predictable Moyes bashing. I wonder if McAleny had scored that chance if the posts would be any different.

The Stoke game was awful, but they were the ones playing negative football. They scored with their one chance and piled men behind the ball. They held out due to our lack of invention. We had plenty of half-chances but they put in a lot of blocks hence no shots on target. It's happened to better teams than us.

The Arsenal game we were terrible in the first half but improved after the break and Moyes's 'negative' substitutions actually saw us begin to control the game before RVP scored a quite frankly sublime goal. Gueye and McAleny both had half-chances that fell a foot wide. Plenty of teams will get beat by Arsenal this season and by bigger margins.

This weekend we play an attacking Norwich team. If they play their normal game there should be chances for us. If we win there is every chance we'll be in the top 10 with a game in hand. Hardly doomsday is it!! If you want something to get properly worried about, have a look at the thread concerning our accounts.
Tony J Williams
30 Posted 12/12/2011 at 09:45:48
Usual story against the Arsenal. It's the predictablility of it all that pisses you off. You knew we would be giving then a decent game, then they would score near the end and we would huff and puff and get nothing. The same that happens at Old Trafford too.

Appparently, though, these are the Sky side we should be beating, even though they have won 8 in 9...

"Preferably someone willing to give our young players a chance" ? Eh? McAleny anyone?

Getting back to the te thread, nowhere in that interview does it say he is happy; he is bigging up the players.....you know! what some of you were criticising him for not doing not 3 days ago!!!

We are a poor/middle table side that is having a bad run. Our best players are gone, our forwards are naff and we have no money to buy replacements.

Moyes's tactics are too defensive but the real problems lie with the fact we have no squad and no skillful players anymore. And if anyone belives Moyes was happy with selling Pienaar and Arteta, more fool you.
Shaun Brennan
31 Posted 12/12/2011 at 09:52:35
Sam Hoare (29) - you mean to tell me Stoke's gameplan works? That's all Stoke (no disrespect to them) can aspire too.

And the gameplan Moyes has offered us doesn't. But he'll continue with it week-in & week-out. Regardless of we face. Tameworth must be shitting themselve.

That is the difference.

Anyway, answer a question? Are you happy with the football on show week-in & week-out? Because I'm not and that's one of the reasons why attendances are down surely.

What would be the turning point with you anyway? I'd just like to know?
Sam Hoare
32 Posted 12/12/2011 at 10:17:57
Shaun. Am I happy with the football being played every week? Easy one, of course not. It's fairly predictable dour fare.

Do I think we have much of an alternative given our resources? Possibly. But that is the style that our manager thinks best suits our players and our need to get points.

You say:

'That's all Stoke (no disrespect to them) can aspire too.'

Well that is disrespectful. And somewhat arrogant. It implies that we have some god-given right to expect more. Stoke have spent on par if not more than us over the last 5 seasons so what right do we possibly have to think we are innately superior? None.

"And the gameplan Moyes has offered us doesn't. But he'll continue with it week-in & week-out. Regardless of we face. Tamworth must be shitting themselves."

Well except for the most part Moyes's plan has worked. Not every week of course or else we would be Champions. But for the most part we have been higher in the league table than our net spend suggests. And higher than Stoke. Which kind of negates your argument.

The turning point for me would be I suppose if it really stopped to work. If we got to March and were in the relegation zone then I think it would be fair to say that Moyes's gameplan was failing. At the moment, if we beat Norwich at home on this weekend. We'll be 10th with a game in hand.

What's your turning point? When would you admit that Moyes is doing a reasonable job in almost impossible circumstances?
Tony J Williams
33 Posted 12/12/2011 at 10:19:31
Shaun, I'll answer it.

Of course I am not happy with the football on show week in week out. I wasn't happy with the football when we finished 4th either.

I am not happy with the football in general in the whole league. Arsenal are the only team I like to watch and they have become worse to watch now too.

Entertainment means absolutely nothing to the manager and players, all they care about is getting the 3 points and the win bonus.

The turning point for me is when we have decent players and we can't get them competing.

We don't have any decent attacking players left, hence why someone scores one against us, we generally lose.
Shaun Brennan
34 Posted 12/12/2011 at 10:56:20
Sam,

That's all Stoke can aspire too isn't hardly arrogant and disrespectful, because they have gone out and bought players to suit the type of football their manager wants them to play, some big guys at the front and back. i.e. Crouch. You don't end up with that many giants by pure luck alone.

Well if Moyes game plan is working for the most part what is it? To drag ourselves through the season? Because that is working.

Using Stoke as the example, How does that negate my argument? Anyone can spend money? In that case we have had paid for more costly players than Stoke over the years. So would I fully expect us to be higher up the table over the years? Maybe yes I would.

I'd be interested to know the comparison between wages also. I don't know these, but generally as a rule of thumb, the more you pay the higher up the league you finish. Using stoke, that could negate my argument for that basis and I accept that.

What would be my turning point for me? with the resources available to Moyes I still believe he can field an attacking squad. Perhaps play two strikers. Drop players now and again and actually attempt to win a game from the on-set. I understand why he uses this formation against far more better well equipped teams, but for other teams, like the candidates for relegation each season, he'll pursue the same tactics. With the resources available to Moyes, he can try something new. He won't. It's the same rubbish week in week out regardless of who we finish above or below.
Tony J Williams
35 Posted 12/12/2011 at 11:00:55
Shaun, Stoke have this season spent £10m on Crouch and sold Dickinson for £600k, the season before £8m on Jones and more on other and sold Meattie for £1.5m.

The last two years they have spent over £30m and sold players making back just over £2m

The two tears before that they spent almost £37m whilst taking in just over £4.5m

That's almost £70m, whilst only recouping less than £7m = £63m on players.

"In that case we have had paid for more costly players than Stoke over the years. So would I fully expect us to be higher up the table over the years? Maybe yes I would" - not quite true is it?
Sam Hoare
36 Posted 12/12/2011 at 11:06:28
Shaun, it negates your argument because you said that it was working for Stoke but not for us. However we have finished higher than Stoke for last few seasons. And I hope we will this too.

I understand the frustration at Moyes using same defensive tactics. I really do and feel the same way most of the time. But it's what he believes will best work over the long run of the season. And, looking at our league finishes, I think he is mostly vindicated in this.

Also you never answered your own question. Where would we have to finish in order for you to admit that Moyes's tactics are effective in the long run? Or is it that you care more about the style of football than the results?
Mark Jensen
37 Posted 12/12/2011 at 11:08:10
Brian #19, unfortunately I have kept up over the last 5 years. To answer your question, let's look at the players you mention:

Coleman ? great first season but seems to be a headless chicken this season. I blame the coach.

Beckford ? Moyes never gave him a proper chance, fell out with him and got rid as soon as he could.

Pienaar ? played well with Baines. But should have been sold when it was obvious he would not stay. The £2.5 million we got was a joke.

Baines ? sitting on the bench for his first year and only got a good run when Lescott left.

Jagielka ? Bought to play in midfield!

Yes, I remember all these classics. The common theme is Moyes's Plan A is usually shite and he stumbles upon a Plan B due to suspensions and injuries. That is why, with a fully fit squad, we start the season crap. When the suspensions and injuries kick in, he is FORCED to play football.

Look at when we score most of our goals, in the last 10 minutes. This is because his Plan A goes out the window and he is FORCED to panic and play attacking football.
Shaun Brennan
38 Posted 12/12/2011 at 11:19:04
Sam, it doesn't. Do you think Bily was bought to suit our style of play? What about Fellaini? Going further back, what about Johnson? What about Yakubu (who fell from grace)? There is a trend here.

Sam, I believe there can be a trade-off between attractiveness of the football played and results. I still think we may well end up in the same position in the league

Tony, not sure how many players they (Stoke) have brought in for that £60M. But we brought in 4 for roughly £40 million: Yakubu, Fellaini, Bilyaletdinov, Heitinga. That's two-thirds of their outgoings.
Sam Hoare
39 Posted 12/12/2011 at 11:21:46
Mark. Sorry. But rubbish.

Coleman ? Was a novelty last season and once people realised that he was relatively one-dimensional was snuffed out more easily. How is that the coach's fault?

Beckford ? How do you know Moyes fell out with him?! He made 34 appearances, did ok and was sold for a good profit. Has hardly set the Championship alight this season with 2 goals from 14 appearances!!

Pienaar ? Moyes took a risk that we would do well and that would persuade Pienaar to stay. It didn't work, but not his fault Stevie P wouldn't sign new contract; he may yet return...

Baines ? Is now established as an England International UNDER MOYES COACHING.

Jagielka ? Was bought to play in midfield? What!! Just because he was played there when we were short of numbers does not mean that he was bought to play there. Clutching. At. Straws.
Tony J Williams
40 Posted 12/12/2011 at 11:20:29
Mark, on Coleman, blame the coach for what? Doing exactly what he was doing the season before? He hasn't regressed, he just hasn't progressed.

Beckford was a gamble. Got a few goals and then made a huge profit on him. He had the touch of a rapist and, let's be honest, he was not very good. Nice goals when he didn't have to think, instinctual, but that's not how the game is. You need brains.

Pienaar ? To sell someone, you have to receive offers.

Baines ? Was kept out of the team by a defender playing the best football of his life, getting into double figures in goals and getting his International call up.

Jagielka ? brought in as an utility player, gets his international call-up.

For such a shite manager, it's amazing how so many players seem to play their best football under him.

Panicked into playing attacking football... classic!
Sam Hoare
41 Posted 12/12/2011 at 11:27:59
Shaun, you're evading the point.

You said that Stoke's style worked for them but ours does not for us. I said the fact that we finish better than Stoke despite spending less than them suggests this is not true.

I agree about blending results and attractive football; ultimately, however, a manager must try to get results first and foremost.
Marcus Kendall
42 Posted 12/12/2011 at 11:36:37
Tony

Coleman is a full back, end of. I thought the fans got a little over-excited by him last season as a winger to be honest. He needs to attack from deep with someone ahead of him to give him more space to put in a DECENT ball. His play is rushed when he's got a defender to deal with and less space.

I again await someone to tell me how this team would be any worse than what we're playing now:

Howard;
Coleman Heitinga Distin Baines;
Neville (holding and organizing);
Fellaini and Rodwell (both doing the box to box roles);
Gueye and Drenthe as wide forwards (bring Barkley in also if Gueye isn't up to it; Barkley can float around and be given a licence to create with the security of Rodwell, Neville and Fellaini behind him);
Saha as the lone striker (when fit... when injured, then we're shagged!).
Shaun Brennan
43 Posted 12/12/2011 at 11:40:43
Sam, I never said Stoke's gameplan works; I wrote

"You mean to tell me Stoke's gameplan works? That's all Stoke (no disrespect to them) can aspire too."

I see Stoke in a very similar position to us. Until Pulis moves on, I don't think we'll be seeing Stoke push on.

Ok, the resources point, how would anyone explain our cup exits to less well-equiped teams? We are just really unlucky I guess.

Anyway, Yes ultimately the manager must try and get results, but bringing off a striker and replacing him with a defender (not the first time this has happened) is surely not about trying to get a result but damage limitation?

Mark (37) I can't see why anyone else is to blame for Coleman being a "headless chicken" other than himself. If he didn't learn to run with the ball with his head up as a child, he never will.
Mark Jensen
44 Posted 12/12/2011 at 11:43:42
Tony - My point is that his Plan B always seems better than his Plan A.

I am not being critical of the players mentioned but I find that there is a pattern to our games and seasons recently. When he has options we are poor at best. When his hand is forced, we do seem to do better.

My main point, as above, is that he never seems to go with Plan B first. And on the 'forced to attack' point, look at the difference to our starting eleven versus our finishing eleven. We start every game to draw.
Sam Morrison
45 Posted 12/12/2011 at 12:05:26
There's lots of valid reasons to critique and debate the manager, but interpreting this as him being 'happy' is not one of them.

Nowhere in that interview does he say he's happy. He doesn't look or sound happy either. If anyone is really upset about it they should contact the BBC for misleading them. Next week we'll be furious that someone other isn't literally over the moon.
Tony J Williams
46 Posted 12/12/2011 at 12:05:48
Mark, when he had real options we were getting into Europe and beating teams. We beat the eventual winners of the cup, we beat the Norwegian (?) Champions who had never been beaten at home in Europe, ever. We were playing great football for a change, then the injuries hit and we then started selling players.

"Ok, the resources point, how would anyone explain our cup exits to less well equiped teams? We are just really unlucky I guess." ? How did Man U lose to Palace? How did the redshite get beat by Barnsley? How did Chelski get beat by Barnsley? It's not just us you know?
Mark Jensen
47 Posted 12/12/2011 at 17:18:26
Tony - Do you mean a 1-0 win over 10-man Zenit back in 2007?

That was when we were winning lots of games 1-0 and we all belived that this was only temporary and soon flowing football would follow. It was all part of Moyes 5/10 year plan.

We are nowhere near that level now.
Wayne Smyth
48 Posted 12/12/2011 at 17:10:33
Sam, Moyes is obviously happy at his own performance and his choice of tactics as they've not changed since he arrived.

Its just at the moment the players we have are a particularly bad fit into the system he wants to play, hence our performances and results have gone down the toilet.

A decent coach would look at the players available to him and pick a formation and tactics that work for those players, not try to fit square pegs into round holes every bloody week.

Oh, and tony, playing McAleny for 10 minutes with barely any support is not my idea of "giving youth a chance".

How about sitting neville on the bench, giving Barkley some game time with Fellaini, allowing Gueye to play on his favoured left side and playing Saha with either Vellios or McAleny? At least then the young players will be supported by the more experienced ones.

If we did what I suggested, we could well end up losing again, just like we did on saturday, but at least a lot of our younger players will have picked up significant valuable experience, not just 5 minutes chasing shadows when we're already fucked.

At the moment we've got too many dinosaurs in front of our young players like McFadden, Neville. We need a good bloody clear-out to give the youngsters the chance to prove themselves. Only a significant investment in youth on and off the pitch is going to make our club survive without investment. We simply don't have the funds to buy established players.

Bryan Ruiz
49 Posted 12/12/2011 at 17:02:19
Not forgetting Joleon Lescott, Mark! A risk worth taking I believe, a championship player who - yes you guessed it- David Moyes, bought for a tiny amount and sold for the second highest fee ever received by this football club, not too bad.

But of course you could do a better job, because you have won the Johnstone's Paint Trophy on Football Manager! Sorry about that!
David Browne
50 Posted 12/12/2011 at 17:48:46
Let's be realistic: Arsenal are a better team than us at the moment. Compare the squad value and now tell me you think Everton should have drawn (away from home). He is doing the best that anyone could do with funds he has. I know it's same old same old but watch us plummet if Moyesie goes.
Sam Morrison
51 Posted 12/12/2011 at 20:22:56
Wayne, I don't disagree with most of what you say. I think he has stagnated and I miss the old Moyes.

What I was referring to is people frothing at the mouth over something he hasn't actually said - your post was a reasoned critique of our present status, whereas others are just OUTRAGED about a non-event.
Richard Harris
52 Posted 13/12/2011 at 01:04:37
Contrast Moyes's lacklustre comments and praise for mediocre perfomances with Paolo di Canio's recent comments from the BBC site:-

"With this team, and this mentality, I can't win the league." "After two minutes I said to Fabrizio [Piccareta, assistant manager] 'to win this game we are going to have to be lucky' because four or five players had no courage, no heart, no desire. "If we play like today we deserve to be relegated."

Swindon have now gone 14 games unbeaten in all competitions and sit sixth in the League Two table, but Di Canio says despite this run he will consider cancelling the players' scheduled days off if they do not pick up maximum points at home to Morecambe next weekend.

"I have some experience in football. Christmas time is coming and for some of the players it's unusual for them to play over the Christmas period,"
"Maybe they would like a winter break, they're thinking about shopping, organising somewhere to go next weekend for two or three days. That is typical".

"From now on I will not treat them as men, because six or seven don't deserve to be treated as a man".

"We arranged a day off after next weekend. If they don't win against Morecambe we don't have a day off. They are not man enough to have two or three days off to go and celebrate before Torquay".

"I'm sorry for the six or seven who always give their best but when we talk about a group, everybody must pay the price."
Domino Darkley
53 Posted 13/12/2011 at 01:28:48
I am firmly of the belief that this Tony J Williams fellow supports Moyes rather than EFC.

He is totally delusional and unquestioning in his defence of Moyes. It is like he belongs to a cult.

The cult of the Moyesiah.

If and when the happy day arrives that Moyes ships out of our club and takes up employment elsewhere (at a greatly reduced salary you can be sure), Mr. Williams will surely become a fan of that club.
Domino Darkley
54 Posted 13/12/2011 at 01:34:19
"I know it's same old same old but watch us plummet if Moyesie goes"

==========

As opposed to watching us "plummet" with Moyes in charge.
Anto Byrne
55 Posted 13/12/2011 at 01:45:58
Di Canio says despite this run he will consider cancelling the players' scheduled days off if they do not pick up maximum points at home to Morecambe next weekend.

Wasn't this the guy who stopped play in our area when the keeper went down instead of scoring?

I would love this guy and his attitude at Goodison Park. Imagine an attacking free-flowing footballing side at Everton.

Not much chance of that with Moyes in charge.

We also have the players that he didn't have at West Ham

What about it? DiCanio anyone?
Bobby Thomas
56 Posted 13/12/2011 at 01:44:43
Marcus Kendall (44): I fully agree with you on Coleman, he is getting a little found out as a wide midfielder, mainly as he isn't one. He doesn't have the craft, vision or awareness for the position. He's direct, has a great attitude and, to be honest, we would have been fucked without him down that side.

As a fullback, however, he could use his tenacity, pace and running power from deeper and join on the play, playing in less tight situations. I'm hoping this is next season, I don't see it happening this. The fact he is playing where he is at the minute says more about the club than him. I think he's handled it as well as we can expect, he has had an outrageously quick rise, from nowhere, and I admire his spirit and strength of character. It's a massive jump there are gonna be ups and downs.

As for your suggested team, we have been looking brittle at the back for a couple of years now and have been thinking we should go with playing 2 holding players to shore it up, with 3 narrow midfielders ahead. When we had Arteta and Pienaar, I thought they would have flourished in this system.

I like your team; however, I would play Fellaini and Neville holding for protection, especially as the two fullbacks would like to bomb on, with Rodwell playing ahead of the two holding players, freeing him up to get on the ball and influence games going forward. I maintain he has a shitload more about him than we've seen yet...
Jamie Sweet
57 Posted 13/12/2011 at 02:01:16
Domino #52 - We just have to accept that there are those who seem so desperate to defend Moyes that, even after a completely dismal performance like the one against Stoke, they still manage to roll out their list of bullshit excuses for the man, despite the fact that it is plainly obvious that he got it wrong.

I believe that most who sit in the "Moyes out" camp, would still be able to give credit where it was due if the guy pulled off a tactical master-stroke (unlikely though that is given that he just repeats the same shite negative tactics week in week out).

However, the die-hard Moyes fans seem completely unable to admit it when our manager royally fucks up - which sadly is becoming a far more regular occurence these days.

I admit he has done well in the past... but my god we really are hitting new depths of shiteness this season. But for some, Moyes will remain untouchable, no matter how bad it gets.
Ian Tunstead
58 Posted 13/12/2011 at 02:29:57
Jamie i can i admit Moyes fucked up against Stoke but so did Redknapp and so will a few other decent managers, its were we end up at the end of the season that matters though why dwell on one game? Get over it.

Should SAF be sacked as well for getting knocked out of 2 cups by inferior clubs?
Martin Mason
59 Posted 13/12/2011 at 02:32:43
Jamie, it's just as easy to say that those who continuously criticise Moyes wouldn't give him credit whatever he did. We are operating with a very weak squad and what he says about our performance at Arsenal is spot on, do you think we were ever in with a chance of winning down there or do you think it's just a matter of play 4-4-2, attack blindly and we'll win?. I watched Stoke play Spurs Saturday and they are a good side, we were tactically naive against them for aerial bombardment against very big defenders but they are no mugs and will give anybody a good game.

Do you believe that we have any right to be any better than 10th or even to be in the EPL given our resources?
Michael Winstanley
60 Posted 13/12/2011 at 02:26:45
Although I agree with Moyes out sentiments I do feel many are missing the point.
We don't have creativity and intelligence in abundance.
Moyes is sticking with his trusted pros hoping we grind out some results and find some form. It wouldn't surprise me if we don't win some games soon then he will revert to youth in an attempt to pick us up.

Our problem is we don't create chances. I thought we were always in the game against Arsenal, when they scored the relief was tangible as everyone knew we wouldn't score. However, if we had a bit of quality in and around the box then I believe we would create and score. We know we need to score first if we're to have a chance of winning. The football we play isn't that bad...agreed it's far from great but we're not far off producing some good football but sadly we don;t have the players. Unless that is Gueye and Barklay come in and light up the show.

On a slightly different issue I watched Heitinga on Everton TV. To say he didn't look best pleased about being moved into midfield for Distin would be an understatement. I think he's growing in confidence and it would be foolish of Moyes to not play him with Jags next game.
Jamie Sweet
61 Posted 13/12/2011 at 02:38:53
Ian Tunstead in "I admit Moyes fucked up against Stoke" shocker!

Good, we're making progress. Personally I don't give a flying fuck if Redknapp or Ferguson get things wrong... that in no way excuses our abysmal effort.

I fully expect both of those managers to learn from their mistakes and perhaps change a few things in the future to make sure it doesn't happen again. I don't think one dimensional gutless Moyes has it in him to do so. I don't mind seeing people make mistakes, they are human after all. But to show a complete inability to learn from these mistakes is inexcusable in my opinion, and this is what makes Moyes so frustrating.

And Ian, you keep stating that it only matters where we end up at the end of the season as if dropping points against the likes of QPR and Stoke at home won't impact where we finish. What utter nonsense. You talk as if top 10 is the best we can aspire to be, so it doesn't matter how we get there so long as we do. But, hold the phone, imagine if we won games like these, could we not have added those points to the ones which will see us sit in 9th/10th and actually finish higher up the table? Do you not want to see us finish as high as possible? Or are you so utterly content with mediocrity that you really don't care?
Mark Jensen
62 Posted 13/12/2011 at 12:15:41
Bryan #42 - Never played football manager and never said I can do better. Not sure when you got that bit from but never mind missing the point.
We can go on and on about the good things Moyes has done and i will point out the bad.
The past 18 months have been bad.
It is a results business and we are losing. We have lost 8 out of 14 league games.
Something is wrong.
The managers attitude is wrong.
The managers team selections are wrong.
And some of the players attitude is wrong.

I WAS a huge Moyes fan and believed he could take us forward. He did that to a certain extent with finishing fourth etc.
But those days are long gone and I don't see them returning with him in charge, Do you?
Tony J Williams
63 Posted 13/12/2011 at 16:59:38
"I am firmly of the belief that this Tony J Williams fellow supports Moyes rather than EFC.

He is totally delusional and unquestioning in his defence of Moyes. It is like he belongs to a cult.

The cult of the Moyesiah.

If and when the happy day arrives that Moyes ships out of our club and takes up employment elsewhere (at a greatly reduced salary you can be sure), Mr. Williams will surely become a fan of that club"

Nice one. Like most mouth frothing loons, you make up things and state untruths to try and back your feeble arguments.

Take a look at my posts on other threads where I suggest Moyes is part of the problem, I call him too defensive and stubborn.

Doesn't sound too much like I am defending him no matter what does it.

And for you comment about supporting another team because Moyes goes there, just shows what kind of loon you really are.

Maybe you can defend the players or the board, add that to your loon CV.
Ian Tunstead
64 Posted 13/12/2011 at 17:19:35
Jamie you have to except that it is a game of football and anyone can beat anyone on their day because there are so many variables to consider. From time to time we will get beat by teams like stoke so will spurs but over the course of a season Moyes picks up enough points to finish best of the rest. No i dont want to settle for mediocrity but the chances of Everton topping the moeny teams is very slim, but if anyone can do it it is Moyes because he is one of 2 who have done it but he has consitantly came the closest the most.
Nate Allen
65 Posted 14/12/2011 at 17:02:15
Davey is a blessing for the Blues, Haters 'gon Hate
John Ford
66 Posted 14/12/2011 at 20:15:50
Where in this article does it say Moyes is happy? He is trying to encourage the team, but of course he's criticised for not doing that.

If TW is going to invite more Moyes bashing it might at least try not to be so overtly biased about it.
Michael Kenrick
Editorial Team
67 Posted 15/12/2011 at 00:55:50
John,

"David Moyes happy with Everton display despite defeat"

That's the full BBC title of the webpage hosting the interview in question.

"Moyes happy despite defeat"

That's our abbreviated tagline. I think you're barking up the wrong tree here.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads