Football's Failed Business Model

, 19 December, 149comments  |  Jump to most recent
Everton are the prime example
Anyone who hasn't been following the financial backstory that underlines Everton's current parlous predicament could do no better than read this hard-hitting analysis of last week's Accounts. The "ferociously spun" figures portrayed as "stable" are shown up in a detailed rebuttal of the Annual Report's positive bias, demonstrating how Everton represent English Football's failed business model heading for financial ruin.
If you were after a textbook example of top-flight English football's failed business model, you couldn't go wrong with Everton — consistently decent Premier League performers with consistently high home crowds and a consistently money-generating transfer policy. Yet, without a sharp shift in attitude and fortune, financial ruin awaits.

Quotes or other material sourced from TwoHundredPercent



Reader Comments (149)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Jamie Tulacz
1 Posted 19/12/2011 at 14:15:21
An excellent piece and makes for pretty frightening stuff..

Kenwright out!
Peter Fearon
2 Posted 19/12/2011 at 14:21:08
This is a great analysis of the problems that beset us - but it also shows that our issues are more complex than the simplistic "Kenwright Out" and "If You Love This Club Let Go." Any new owner will have to address these issues, which is probably the main reason why the "Mystical Billionaire" people demand he sell to is proving so elusive.
Ste Boyle
3 Posted 19/12/2011 at 14:33:29
Great article. A big worry is what would a poor finish or relegation do to us. What a fooking state.
Nick Entwistle
4 Posted 19/12/2011 at 14:44:20
We're screwed.

Would we prefer relegation due to playing a team of kids, or due to administration?

At some point this is all going to catch up with the club and become a present day horror show. I'd just like to know how long that is.

(And Drenthe better fall in love with the place because otherwise he won't sign for peanuts)

Colin Fitzpatrick
5 Posted 19/12/2011 at 14:40:49
Peter,

...issues are more complex than the simplistic "Kenwright Out" and "If You Love This Club Let Go."

I comment on this site because of the caliber of the posters; by and large they understand the issues.
Trevor Lynes
6 Posted 19/12/2011 at 14:45:45
The comments raised regarding possible relegation are the same as I have raised many times in the past....DM's job is to keep us in the premier league...if we finish in the top ten then he has succeeded beyond expectations of the board (but not the fans)..He has been the EFC buffer between the board and the disgruntled fans.

What I cannot comprehend is WHY we have no money ??

We have finished in the top third of the league with all the financial gains that means and we have a loyal 30,000 plus support so why are we in a worse situation than clubs who regularly finish lower and who have smaller gates ?

The wage bill cannot be blamed because we have a smaller squad than most and loan out a legion of players every season.

The fans seem to meekly accept that we are broke but my question is WHY ???
Surely a board with a bevy of millionnaire businessmen who have made their money in different ways could between them run a club like ours.

If things continue we will fall quickly and I cannot see our better players staying just out of loyalty...every top footballer wants success and that means cups, medals and caps.

We have a few who I can see moving on if things are not done to remedy this crazy situation.
James Flynn
7 Posted 19/12/2011 at 15:07:56
Good read. Nothing new in it. Just another look at what we already know and have discussed in here many times.

In fact makes it, what's the word? . . . . . simple to say again, "Kenright Out".
Roger Barrett
8 Posted 19/12/2011 at 15:22:02
Bit harsh that, Colin; I think he has a point. If I had the money and was interested in buying the club I would run a mile once I'd had a chance to view the books and was asked to shell out £150 million of my hard earned cash; however, don't get me wrong ? I fully support the Blue Union and admire the work done so far.
Tommy Hesketh
9 Posted 19/12/2011 at 15:22:35
Nothing new??? [just picked my jaw up from the floor...] but Jesus it underlines the fact that we are in the brown stuff and sinking.

How much more can we take before most fans wake up and smell the bullshit that's eminating from the corridors of Goodison???

Is there any news on anymore upcoming BU protests? We need action and action fast; here's me thinking we would sign a half-decent striker in January.

Look forward to seeing any pro-Kenwright responses.

On a side note, the Local Rag in Blackburn has called for both the Venky's & Kean to go... Come on, Prentice & O'Keffe ? grow a fuckin pair and speak out before this club sinks any further.
Gavin Ramejkis
10 Posted 19/12/2011 at 15:41:27
It would be truly mind numbing to hear anyone try to put some positive spin on this, many have been saying this for years and as such it gives me no pleasure in seeing this repeated in black and white for all to see.

To try to belittle or spin the effort of a few to save an establishment for the many and educate the masses is an insult.
Ernie Baywood
11 Posted 19/12/2011 at 15:30:43
I'm pretty sure most supporters know we're skint, Tommy.

I can't and won't defend BK but, let's be fair, what are the options here? Ignore the wealthy benefactor - that's daydream stuff. Costs will continue to increase as clubs follow the earn more-borrow more-spend more strategy and mortgage themselves against the TV incomes and player values that just HAVE to increase - a bit like houses always increase in value.

Maybe it's just not financially viable (in football's bubble) to be the 2nd Premier League team in a northern city that is not particularly affluent.

As horrible a thought as it is, I can't be the only one who has this constantly flashing through my mind?
Tony J Williams
12 Posted 19/12/2011 at 15:48:12
"How much more can we take before most fans wake up and smell the bullshit that's eminating from the corridors of Goodison???" - Too late mate, it's already happened.

Just because they didn't all join the protest, don't judge them as being "for" the board.
Kevin Tully
13 Posted 19/12/2011 at 15:40:39
This board has been in over it's head in both financial & commercial responsibilty for years. They just want a big payday now - while leaving a fucking train wreck behind them.

If these were American or Asian owners, there would be riots.

It's not just Kenwright either, as the article points out.

Does anyone think this board wants what is best for the club? They could prove that by asking for £50 million plus the debt of around £45 million.

They won't, why?

Want to give Bill a round of applause now?
Jimmi James
14 Posted 19/12/2011 at 15:47:18
The local press are compliant in perpetuating the myth that Everton will be okay and are being run for the best by a True Blue... nothing could be further from the truth.

We are going to be the next Leeds Utd with this lot in charge and, if we do go down for whatever reason, can anyone honestly say we will be right back up and better?? A big fat No then.

This is our defining moment and if as fans we can't do anything like Liverpool fans did, then we truly are doomed and could even go out of business permanently. The whole board can just fuck off and take a bored and witless manager with them. For fuck's sake, someone save us.
Roger Barrett
15 Posted 19/12/2011 at 15:54:23
Certain board members do not want to sell, they want to remain on the board and hope some mug comes in with a trolley full of cash and sweeps up around them. Getting that point across to the blind Kenwright supporters is going to have to be done... difficult when they have the media outlets in their pockets.
Chris Matheson
16 Posted 19/12/2011 at 15:56:49
Tony J, I want Kenwright out, but - and I have no evidence for this, just a feeling based on going to the match and talking to other blues - I think he still enjoys majority support. My feeling is that too many out there still allow emotions to rule their heads and like Kenwright as "one of us".
Colin Fitzpatrick
17 Posted 19/12/2011 at 15:44:25
Necessarily harsh Roger, Peter's persistent knocking of the Blue Union, and others opposed to what is little more than the total ineptness of the current board, is fully deserved in my opinion.

He?s been told on numerous occasions that he?s wrong about spreading this type of misinformation but he persists in displaying his ignorance; he's almost proud of it!

Like most, I don't suffer fools gladly and I have no hesitation in calling a spade a spade.
Tommy Hesketh
18 Posted 19/12/2011 at 16:08:07
Tony 11#,

I know mate but certainly on this site we still have indivduals (Doddy) who still back Bill and his Board at any costs.

It's even worse on Kipper, most of them are delusional and don't see what's really happening. As Kevin says#12 if this was overseas owners there would be carnage but somethings gotta give, even after the leaked transcript or the emails they still quote he's a blue etc etc.

Worrying times indeed.

Roger Barrett
19 Posted 19/12/2011 at 16:07:22
Fair enough, Colin. I have read some of his past posts and tended to disagree with him,on this occasion his point of the underlying problems any new investor would have to overcome may be the reason why the sale of the club has not come to fruition I thought were valid IF in fact the club has actually been up for sale.

With regard to the Blue Union I feel it's going to be a very long hard slog to make changes and I hope with all my heart that it happens before we do disappear, keep up the good work.
Matt Traynor
20 Posted 19/12/2011 at 16:10:14
The trickle of information (Keith Harris quote, investment quote in the leaked emails) shows that The Biggest Blue on The Planet wants to make a massive return on his investment, having singularly failed to deliver any improvement in our ground situation, or secondary revenue performance during his tenure.

Still, there'll be plenty who don't see what he's done. No real surprise him and Degsy Hatton are big mates really is it?
Tony I'Anson
21 Posted 19/12/2011 at 16:22:27
Best not to lurk on forums when logged in via iPhone!
Colin Fitzpatrick
22 Posted 19/12/2011 at 16:19:43
Hi Roger that wasn't his point at all. People already know what you've just said because of the efforts of others. Many have even posted articles on how much the club is viably for sale for, Richard Larnder springs to mind, and how much the concerns you've noted will effect the price. Peter simply wishes to launch thinly veiled attacks on concerned Evertonians; concerned that is about their club and not their pockets.
Roger Barrett
23 Posted 19/12/2011 at 16:23:03
Degsy Hatton was also a good friend of Peter Johnson too and agreed with him on his "blend not spend" philosophy.
Tom Hughes
24 Posted 19/12/2011 at 16:15:13
The problem is..... some people will never admit they were wrong. They detest the idea that others showed greater gumption than them. They have invested too much bile in the wrong cause and can't go back on it now. They would rather go down with the ship and our glorious leader. Their pride demands it even!

Normally I just ignore ignorance but they have helped perpetuate the incompetence..... I wonder how many will proudly pronounce that they stood and clapped BK if/when we're consigned to our inevitable fate under his leadership?
Tom Owen
25 Posted 19/12/2011 at 17:04:57
I read the article and basically what I can gather is we are fucked!
Dean Adams
26 Posted 19/12/2011 at 17:19:51
As has been eloquently stated many times during the last six months, the accounts led to the mini fire-sale of players at the end of last season. With that in mind, we can clearly assume that the money raisedand the money saved on player wages has already reduced the debt burden substantially.

Our situation is grim, but painting such a bleak outlook is I believe a little dramatic. We need to be careful granted but we are as we have been just a few years ahead of a number of other clubs who will end up in the same mess. We may be able to do a Houdini act if we are lucky, those other clubs heading our way may not!

As for the selling of players, I would get rid of the highly paid dross that have consistently failed to look half decent this season, in doing so enabling the talented youth to come through.
NSNI
Phil Rodgers
27 Posted 19/12/2011 at 17:33:35
Excellent article. That Martin Samuel piece was the worst piece of journalism I've ever seen.
Dan Brierley
28 Posted 19/12/2011 at 16:43:05
I don't think anybody is under any illusions about whether or not the current business model works.

I think the vast majority of fans do want change at this club, and a new owner that is going to change our fortunes both on and off the field.

My own personal view, is that had Kenwright not taken over and we stayed under Johnson, we would have been relegated from the Premiership a long time ago, and possibly ended up like Coventry or Southampton stuck in the lower tiers. For this, I am grateful of the Chairman.

But now is definitely the time for him to move on, as the club is stagnating. The manager also appears lost now, as he has the lost the means in order to compete for european football this season. This is evident on the pitch, where players have also lost belief. Confidence couldn't be lower, its been a long time since someone from the club has hailed the 'team spirit', which has been the cornerstone of the club's recent improvements.

Have the protests helped the club in any way shape or form? From my point of view, the answer is no. It is has only served to create more unrest at a time when support was truly needed. The fact that the fanbase is unhappy, is clearly underlined by the low gates this season. Protests are simply not required if the only purpose is to show the management the fans are 'unhappy'.

Kenwright is on a hiding to nothing anyway in my eyes. If he doesn't sell the club, he will continue to endure the simply awful death threats levelled at him from some areas. If he does sell just to get out and the new ownership strip the club back further resulting in relegation, Kenwright will be responsible for selling us out to someone without the clubs best interests at heart, which is something even I could NEVER forgive him for. So the only option is seems to have, is to keep treading water, and wait for the right ownership to show the colour of their money.

Will we get relegated this season? I don't think so. Teams with players such as Baines, Rodwell, Fellaini, Jagielka, Barkley, Coleman, Drenthe don't get relegated. But in the absence of a striker anywhere near the level of the names mentioned above, mid-table is the only realistic hope.

All eyes on the winter break, to see if we can get a 20-goal-a-season striker that can give us something to look forward to. Although I am honestly not confident that is going to happen...
Richard Styles
29 Posted 19/12/2011 at 17:35:01
Once again We are embarresed by our so called great leader! Come on Bill Kenright sell the Limosine alone... nobody wants to buy it with the driver!


If you truly love Everton Fc then you really do have to let it go...There are thousands and thousands of Everton Suppoters at home and abroad who are waiting for the news that the club is sold!

We would glady pay more at the gates if we thought that it would help!

But from what we are reading here,no one wants to put any more money into the hands of the Greedy so and so`s who own this club...LEAVE WITH A BIT OF HONOUR MATE, YOU SAVED US ONCE, NOW DO IT AGAIN BY LEAVING US,

If you do that you would be welcome at Goodison anytime, but if this club sinks because of your greed! Then I wouldnt turn up at Goodison ever again mate, Blue or No blue you would get the same reception as Rooney everytime you turned up!

Hugh Walker
30 Posted 19/12/2011 at 17:48:25
The club's accounts and company records clearly show a company that's barely staying afloat. Accompany that with the fact that future TV revenue is already charged to the Barclays, Goodison being charged up to the hilt and the fact that the club appear to be borrowing money from a relatively unknown credit company in order to meet immediate obligations and the situation becomes quite clear: There's no money. Not only is there no money, but there will be no money for the next 5 years. Actually, there's less than no money for the next 5 years as Everton's income is continually exceeded by its outgoings, even with one-off capital sales such as Bellfield being added in.

The future for the club is quite clear: administration. Obtaining loans from a lesser known lender not only brings with it the extra cost of increased interest over and above that of usual financial institutions, but also is a sign that nobody else will lend to Everton. If the funding could have come from another source, no doubt the company would have obtained that funding, but they didn't. The fair conclusion would be that nobody would lend. So, we have the following situation:


1. All existing physical assets already charged;
2. Year on year losses, even when accounting for large capital sales;
3. Increased borrowing rates from unusual lenders;

Given the present circumstances, the club's fall into insolvency isn't a question of 'if?', but 'when?'

This leads to another point: all those stating that we need a quality striker, or right back, or creative midfielder are dreaming. Everton's only way of staving-off insolvency are to buy cheap players and sell them for massive increases, or bring youngsters through the system and sell them on. Rodwell, Barclay, Coleman? Already gone in the board's mind -- the only question concerning them is how much they can be sold for and how many of the debts can be paid from that sale.

Our only hope is for the club to be saved by someone paying-off the debts to put us back on an even keel. Given the fact that Everton's assets are broadly worthless, their international branding being almost non-existent and a team that will for years to come struggle in the Premier League (if they've not been relegated) then the chances of finding such an investor are incredibly slim.

Go back to your homes and prepare yourself for relegation and insolvency; our wonderful team, our beautiful stadium, our football values are for nought.
Gavin Ramejkis
31 Posted 19/12/2011 at 18:19:15
Dan, can't agree with you thinking we would have been relegated under Johnson as he spent more at the club of his own money than Kenshite ever has in over a decade and as for the no to relegation with the assembled players, one you mention isnt even ours; Drenthe. The 20 a season striker I think we all dream of, well who is going to pay for him? The money from player sales last season, wage savings and Bellefield money has all long gone
Tom Hughes
32 Posted 19/12/2011 at 17:53:37
Dan,
Protest is a consequence of our situation, not a cause. KEIOC and now the BU have predicted all of this for several yrs...... and have been fully vindicated once again. Attempting to attach any blame to those who have decided to voice their concern rather than simply follow like the proverbial lemmings is both abhorrent and slightly nauseating! It's no wonder that our feckless leadership has presided over so many calamitous mishaps to the point of terminal decline without recourse!
James Ryan
33 Posted 19/12/2011 at 18:22:30
We are at a crucial tipping point now. if Kenwright is still here in 6-12 months we are doomed both on and off the field, if we are sold we might just be able to hold our heads high again. Even if Kenwright sells to the right buyer he isn't welcome back as far as I'm concerned for the shit he's put the club and its supporters through over the last decade.
Richard Styles
34 Posted 19/12/2011 at 18:41:07
We all know Kenright is a mad Evertonian but I will ask the question

Survey:

Question: Knowing what you now know about how our great club has been run over the last 10 years do you want Bill Kenright to:

A: Go
B: Stay
C: Substain

You can give your vote and your opinion, but let's at least try to keep it nice along with your points view...
Andy Crooks
35 Posted 19/12/2011 at 18:51:12
Phil, the Samuel piece was surely not the worst piece of journalism you have ever seen. It was the worst piece of journalism in the Daily Mail that day but was well short of his usual mind-numbing, self-important, truly awful stuff.
Brian Denton
36 Posted 19/12/2011 at 18:50:03
What's the 'Substain' option about?
Chris Leyland
37 Posted 19/12/2011 at 18:50:01
If only if was as simple as some people in here make out I.e. "sell now" and "Kenwright out"

Erm, sell to who? Who wants to buy us?

Kenwright is a majority shareholder and unless, and until a buyer is found he can't just go "out" as he remains majority shareholder. Yes, he could resign as chairman and director but then anyone coming in has a duty to the shareholders first and foremost.
Gavin Ramejkis
38 Posted 19/12/2011 at 18:58:49
Chis, you cant sell a twatted old banger for Bentley money, if the price was right and it was for sale and not "seeking investment" you'd see a sale.

Could a new owner truly be any worse?
John Ford
39 Posted 19/12/2011 at 19:22:33
Two key points jump out.

Last years 'real' annual NET loss is massive and was 'saved' by selling the training ground combined with the income from Arteta's sale. Given that we aren't going to increase income, and we have no non-player assets left, then the only way to limit the loss is to sell other players.... year after year.

Second, amid the fairly obvious financial problems Kenwright's valuation has priced us out and way beyond the market. I'm ashamed to say that Liverpool did the right thing and reduced their price to allow for the debt. Surely we must do the same? Otherwise we'll limp into oblivion.

Kenwright, please do the only right thing. The board cannot profit from a sale of the club. The club's value cannot be more than it was five or even ten years ago. It doesn't make sense.
Ray Said
40 Posted 19/12/2011 at 19:31:50
Spot on Gavin.

If the price is right they would queue around the block to buy it. Remember the Wolves sale?

"In May 2007, it was announced that he had sold control of the club to businessman Steve Morgan OBE for a nominal £10 fee, in exchange for a conditional £30m of investment in the club. Hayward had originally offered the club for sale in September 2003, but had struggled to find suitable takers. Morgan's takeover was formally completed on 9 August 2007."

That's how its done when you love the club.
Peter Fearon
41 Posted 19/12/2011 at 19:49:02
Colin #5 - I very much admired the work you did defeating Desperation Kirkby and posted here many times that it was a potentially disastrous concept. However, I notice that whenever someone disagrees with you on this site - or elsewhere - you resort to offensive, snide and unnecessarily insulting language, even to the point of openly harassing someone a few days ago. This kind of school yard bullying does you no credit.

The fact is that Everton's financial problems ? I am sure you will agree ? are deep seated and complex and will remain even if and when the club is sold. I watched the Blue Union marchers, and there were many more than have been acknowledged, and understandably. they were trying to crystalise the issues into slogans. But that rarely achieves more than empowering demagoguery.

You appear to believe that Kenwright is dragging his heels on selling for reasons of his own, to whom no-one ever says. I happen to believe he would sell tomorrow if someone with very substantial resources made a serious offer and that in the meantime a new manager would give the team fresh inspiration. I think that's a rational and moderate point of view. The biggest difference is I respect your view and you respect no-one's but your own.
John Talbot
42 Posted 19/12/2011 at 20:05:37
There's always Ebay
Peter Laing
43 Posted 19/12/2011 at 20:07:33
Read the article and thanks to toffeeweb for posting the link. The bottom line is that we need to 'sweat our assets' just to stay alive, which to me adds up to

a) Rodwell
b) Fellaini
c) Barkley

Three assets who we should be planning to build the team around for the next 10 years. The more that comes out regarding the state of Everton's finances the more I am convinced that Rooney was treated as the scapegoat / sacrificial lamb back in 2004.

I have made my decision to boycott Goodison Park until Kenwright is ousted from Everton.
Dan Brierley
44 Posted 19/12/2011 at 20:38:21
Gav, are you joking? Do you not remember the Wimbledon game under Johnsons regime? Could it actually get any closer to relegation than that? OK lets have a look at Johnsons last three seasons which says to me we were going down if he stayed on:

1999-97: 15th position (2 points off relegation)
1997-98: 17th position (stayed up on GD)
1998-99: 14th position (7 points off relegation)

Were you happy with this Gav? Were you honestly happy with the 1999 squad? This is why I am happy Kenwright took over, as we honellty seemed to be going only one way.
Paul Carr
45 Posted 19/12/2011 at 20:32:47
The Wikipedia refererence also shows that Bill is the producer of a new film due out in 2014. Its title: BROKEN. How ironic, wonder if it is about a football club?
I am surprised that his other businesses are doing so well when he states he is working 24/7 on Everton. Somewhat disingenuous.

Also the refererence to Keith Harris was interesting as he was in the news again last week, as the man who introduced Portsmouth to their latest failed investor, recently arrested for fraud. Surely Harris is no longer involved with EFC?
Ste Traverse
46 Posted 19/12/2011 at 21:01:21
Dan.

You need to get your facts right. Johnson didn't gain control of the club until June 1994,a month AFTER the infamous Wimbledon game.
Eugene Ruane
47 Posted 19/12/2011 at 20:22:45
Some (or all) of it MIGHT have been stated before.

But personally, I think it is important that certain things should be repeated and repeated...and repeated.

Let's face it, there are obviously many who (still) simply don't get it (nb: saying' I get it' and getting it - two different things)

For me you DON'T get it if you are applauding Kenwright's stupid smirking mug and you don't get it if you're looking for opportunities to take a pop at The BU/KEIOC (ie: trying to 'kill the messenger').

I make no apologies for repeating from the piece..

"There is no more family silver to sell without diminishing the playing squad, and the accounts include an admission that Everton must continue selling players to survive".

Two things.

1) That sentence is chilling.

2) NONE of it is the fault of KEIOC or The BU.

This is ALL the doing of Bill and his fucking hopeless board and given this, to be looking to have a go at those who PREDICTED it is, quite frankly, fucking staggering.

Whether the BU do things the 'right' way (nb: which is purely subjective anyway) is imo, neither here nor there.

They're trying because they love Everton - simple as that.

"Ah yeah but so does Bill"

Maybe..but can Elstone say the same?

Can Robert Earl?

Green?

Did fatty Wyness want Kirkby coz he loved Everton?

The truth can often be found in the motive and anyone who thinks the majority of those involved with/in our board in recent years have been doing what they've been doing because THEY love Everton is fucking insane.


Dan Brierley
48 Posted 19/12/2011 at 20:58:59
Tom, so what have the protest achieved up to now? Everyone knows we are skint, and everyone knows we are skint due to having and under par stadium that does not generate enough revenue.

The board gambled by putting every penny into the squad and wages to keep the good players, in the hope we would get into the CL. And yes, it didn't come off. The Villareal game was the pivotal moment. Had we got into the group stages, who knows where we would be now?

And the situation now is, that we our gamble did not pay off and we need to pay the banks back before we can borrow again. Its a cycle, that we are now in the bottom part of the frequency. But with the new youth players coming through, and undoubtedly that will continue to come through due to us having access to a top training ground, the future seems more sustainable.

Yes, we will have to sell players in future to appease the banks, but as long as the talent does no dry up, why not use this a business plan until someone comes in capable of taking us to the next level?
Phil Rodgers
49 Posted 19/12/2011 at 21:25:18
Andy, I forgot it was in the mail. Touche. My mate told me to buy it and I could not believe my eyes. It read like Everton fans were the wicked witch and kenwright was Cinderella.
Eddy Bernard
50 Posted 19/12/2011 at 21:37:12
C: Substain
Eugene Ruane
51 Posted 19/12/2011 at 21:11:05
Dan Brierley (47) - You ask Tom "so what have the protests achieved up to now?"

Well I'll let Tom answer that for himself, but I'll ask you what you think absolutely NO protests will achieve?

For me the BU protest might achieve absolutely nothing, but it shows me that a certain amount of Evertonians (not really known for our marching or protests) have decided enough is enough.

The BU took a gamble on getting support from like-minded individuals and the only way to REALLY find out how many of those there would be, was to organise a march (or marches).

To see how many would march with them and/or applaud their efforts.

How it all ends...remains to be seen.

What they achieve (or don't)....remains to be seen

I can give you TWO concrete results though.

1) The unrest many of us felt was often hidden from the press and Bill cetainly used his contacts to keep it that way. Because of the BU's efforts, the cat is now well and truly out of the bag and there is now a pressure on laughing boy that didn't exist before.

2) Not that this was planned, but had it not been for the BU, there wouldn't have been 'that' email from Ross. But...there was and he ended up getting the heave-ho (if that was ALL that was ever achieved, fucking result!)

By the way, these achievements seems even greater when presented next to your own 'plan' which if I'm not mistaken appears to be 'do fuck-all, hope for the best'.
Kevin Tully
52 Posted 19/12/2011 at 21:26:10
Dan, you cannot compare the Johnson regime with Kenwright's tenure.

There has been millions upon millions poured into the coffers of Everton through Sky. During this period we have not added any value to Goodison and the commercial sector of the club has been a disaster, compared to other clubs of our stature. We have been an ever-present in the richest league in the world.

You may be happy selling our talent to larger clubs as a business model, we can keep Kenwright & the board there longer if you want - let's just sell all our young gifted players.

The whole board are culpable of having no long term vision or plan for this club, what more evidence do people want?

We sold Arteta, Pienaar, Yakubu and Beckford. At the same time we have not purchased a player for over two years.

The chairman got a rousing reception for this shambles. You have to ask, are some blues really that gullible?
Dan Brierley
53 Posted 19/12/2011 at 21:44:48
Eugene, I agree there is a pressure on Kenwright, and it has increased since the BU came along. But again, how does this make somebody want to buy the club, which I am sure you are aware is the sticking point?

There has not been a single concrete bid, regardless of the asking price. Even if the price is 200 million for arguments sake, it does not stop people bidding 100 million to test the waters does it? Is this not the best time for a buyer? With all the fans unrest, any bid from a wealthy group would have support from THOUSANDS of fans, not just a few hundred. So why havent we seen a concrete bid? Because nobody has made one! For reasons that have been spelled out a million times on this website, such as it would need hundreds of millions of investment to get close to challenging for the title (a la Manchester City).

I am sure an intelligent gentleman like yourself, would agree that trying to oust the board without anybody there to take over would only result in the destruction of the club. As with any company, when chairman and boards leave, creditors get very twitchy and start clammering to ensure they get their money back before others do.

In order to get me to support any kind of movement, I expect something a bit more substantial than 'let go if you love the club'. Do I know what that something is? I confess, that I don't. The only thing I have seen that I would support is the Trust Everton initiative, which has a bit more structure than wandering around with torches and pitchforks.
Dick Fearon
54 Posted 19/12/2011 at 21:51:46
Just to toss the cat among the pigeons.
Would the death of our club have come quicker at the Kirkby dome?
Dan Brierley
55 Posted 19/12/2011 at 22:00:17
Kevin, I don't blame the board for not being able to compete in this league, that carries more debt than the entire of Europe COMBINED.

Unless we (the fans) are willing to pay double the price of tickets to put us in line with the average price at the Premiership top six, then how can you expect to compete? Putting billboards up in Australia and selling a range of baby clothes in the club shop is not going to change a fucking thing.

But one thing I will ask, what do you believe the current squad value (every football clubs most important set of 'assets') is compared to 1999? Or maybe you enjoyed Pembridge, Gazza, Ginola, Alexandersson, Gerrard, Oster, Ward, Gemmil?
Ste Traverse
56 Posted 19/12/2011 at 22:09:08
Dan.

Are you forgetting that the likes of Gazza,Ginola and Alexandersson were signed on Bill Kenwright's watch?
Kevin Tully
57 Posted 19/12/2011 at 22:12:09
I don't think you are getting the point, Dan.

We got £24M for Lescott, £29M for Rooney, we currently get approx £50M just from 1 season's TV money.

The board have had far more money to spend on players, that's why you cannot compare the last two Chairmen. At least Johnson had a vision to build a new Park End stand.

Sky money & overseas TV rights have transformed every ground in the Premier League.

Except one.

Maybe if we has spent some of that money on new corporate facilities, or removing obstructed views we would be competing, it's called a business plan.
Ian Bennett
58 Posted 19/12/2011 at 22:25:08
Kev, I agree with you.

No business plan over the last 10 years apart from to spend every penny on wages and transfer fees from the broadcasting rise and sale of 'non core assets'. All has been lumped on players in the hope of achieving Champions League. The dream failed like a sad game of poker, with Everton having small pile of chips that can't compete with the high rollers.
Dan Brierley
59 Posted 19/12/2011 at 22:25:25
Kevin, you are right. But if you throw money at your infrastructure, then you cant pay your top stars. So you effectively lose your top playing staff, as you can't afford their wages.

So what do you do? Its catch 22. You can ask Coventry or Southampton fans whether or not its more beneficial in the long run to throw your money at infrastructure instead of your first team.

Ste, I apologise if I have got those players wrong. But my point still stands, does the squad seem healthier now in comparison to 1999? Or did you prefer the football and league finishes on offer at that time?
Tommy Hesketh
60 Posted 19/12/2011 at 22:22:31
Dan,

You say we can't compete because of the Stadium, that's bullshit, who outsourced everything within the ground? We couldn't even build on the ground surounding GP beacuse he mortgaged the fucking land off.

His motto is "if it aint nailed down sell it and if it's nailed down get a mortgage on it"

The man has openly admitted he hasn't got a clue and yet people are still harking on about the days of Johnson, did PJ leave the club in the shit it's in now? I believe Net Assets were worth around £27M no we have liabilities of around £33M so a difference of (?£60M) in ten years this is despite years of supposed record turnover.

Some posters on here could work for the ministry of information for North Korea or Iraq as Bill is a true Blue and won't wake up & smell the constant bullshit that comes from the club on a daily basis.
Eugene Ruane
61 Posted 19/12/2011 at 22:12:25
Dan (54) - you say..

"I am sure an intelligent gentleman like yourself, would agree that trying to oust the board without anybody there to take over would only result in the destruction of the club"

Well I certainly WOULD agree with that..if it wasn't phrased in a way that infers if things stay as they are, the club WON'T be destroyed.

Tell you what, let's agree that the club's destruction would be HASTENED if that happened - I'll go along with that for the sake of debate.

Fair?

Oh but hold on, nobody actually IS suggesting that as an option.

Well...NOT the BU.

Now I'm SURE your're familiar with the FAQ page on their website, but (just in case it slipped your mind), here is the VERY FIRST question again

1. The Blue Union, what?s it all about?

"We?re a collection of Everton fan groups who believe that it?s time for change. We?re just ordinary Evertonians who believe that only a change in ownership can address the serious situation that the club finds itself in. Our focus at the moment is promoting the idea that a group of professionals should be appointed to identify new owners and conduct the sale".

So just to be clear that is NOT "We want Bill to fuck off now and take his useless self-serving board with him"

More along the lines of.. 'we want successful professionals rather than failed ones to find us the right people to take the club on'.

Bit of a difference don't you think?

(and it's an approach that doesn't see to have harmed 'them')
Dan Brierley
62 Posted 19/12/2011 at 22:37:53
Sorry Eugene, I am indeed wrong. I thought I had seen 'one or two' BU supporters asking for BK to leave (put mildly) on this very website, along with some horrendous and childish personal comments that go with it. I thought I had also seen banners saying 'let go if you love the club'. No sign of banners suggesting that the group are trying to find individuals to take the club forward. Is this a different group?

Of course, now you have shown me what is written on a website, I will of course go and have a word in the mirror and correct myself. Thanks for the enlightenment.
Graham Brandwood
63 Posted 19/12/2011 at 22:50:44
Kevin. The park end stand was built before Johnson arrived.
Eugene Ruane
64 Posted 19/12/2011 at 23:04:36
Dan (62) very difficult to read (or indeed produce) a banner that says..

"We?re a collection of Everton fan groups who believe that it?s time for change. We?re just ordinary Evertonians who believe that only a change in ownership can address the serious situation that the club finds itself in. Our focus at the moment is promoting the idea that a group of professionals should be appointed to identify new owners and conduct the sale".

'Let go if you love the club' is more succinct, makes the point and is hardly malicious or offensive (getting Bill and cronies to 'let go' is the ultimate aim, consequently a MORE than legitimate sentiment for a banner).

As for claims of 'horrendous and childish personal comments', I don't dispute they've been made, however to suggest/infer (nb: as your wording does) that these have only come from ONE direction, is imo, disingenuous in the extreme.

Ultimately, we all see what we want to see and I think Tom Hughes was spot on (24) when he said..

"The problem is..... some people will never admit they were wrong. They detest the idea that others showed greater gumption than them. They have invested too much bile in the wrong cause and can't go back on it now. They would rather go down with the ship and our glorious leader. Their pride demands it even!"

I genuinely believe there are those now arguing against the BU, not because they're REALLY against, but simply because that was their starting position and...

Seems many would rather be 'right' than right.

Tom Hughes
65 Posted 19/12/2011 at 22:33:25
Dan,

You seem to continually miss the point.... BU have greatly increased the awareness of EFC's plight, attracting increased scrutiny by the media, and shaming the local papers who have been in the club's pocket for so long. Compare the number of articles outlining the issues pre-BU to recent months. They have increased several fold in both quantity and quality..... as the grim details of all the serial lies and ineptitude unravel. The BU approached all the media and have helped provide that stimulus (they are mentioned in practically every article).

I'm not really sure about the relevance of comparing with Peter Johnson. He was in charge for just 4 yrs or so, in a league with only a fraction of it's current turnover/wealth. He oversaw the building of one stand, and an FA Cup win. He cocked up the managerial issue, sold the club's talisman and paid the price. BK was on his board throughout, and as ever avoided any criticism. Unhappy at not getting ownership he schemed against him at every opportunity (never at AGM's tho).... even helping to fund plans for a redeveloped GP when Kirkby part 1 was unveiled. He then bided his time and got his mates to help buy Johnson's shares when it all got a bit nasty..... Johnson sold for a fraction of the value he was talking about at previous AGM's because he'd had enough, and knew his position was untenable.

BK has built nothing, won nothing, and sold all our best players, and all of our assets.... he has left the club on the verge of administration, and now unable to add any quality to the squad (As any other Everton Chairman done this ever?). During this time he has had the luxury of a manager operating under the tightest budget in the league (consistently outspent by even smaller clubs), yet still managing to fashion "best of the rest" teams, and gaining significant league placing payments. He has done this with zero contribution from the board, despite them and not because of them. Without Moyes, operating the way we have, this club would've been sunk years ago. Well, even that seems to have dried up now that there's nothing left to sell.

Over the years of the premiership many clubs have grown, either in terms of attendances, size and quality of stadia, fanbase or whatever measure of status. During the same period Everton FC in comparitive terms have fallen in status. Several clubs now enjoy their highest ever average attendances.... we are no-where near ours, and the fans are now voting with their feet.

KEIOC highlighted the fundamentally flawed business plan at the public inquiry.... and everything they feared is now playing out. These people have hit the nail on the head time and time again...... Yet, you still believe no-one is interested in Everton FC, when everyone else, and even the club aren't saying that at all? Well one outcome of the inevitable collapse of this club, will be that of this regime too. Then, like Johnson before, when the hounds are at the door the current incumbents will be a lot more receptive to realistic offers, and will have to leave without any ill-gotten gains.
Brian Denton
66 Posted 20/12/2011 at 00:21:47
Eddy (#50) you seem to know what 'Substain' means, as you voted for it. Please tell, as I am genuinely intrigued. I can't even think what it might be aiming for; 'sustain'? 'abstain'? Neither of them make much sense but they're the best I can come up with.
Russell Buckley
67 Posted 20/12/2011 at 01:11:01
I know I?m not talking about a small group here but I simply can?t understand those of us who shout down the Blue Union and believe the best strategy is to wait it out and ?just get behind the team?.

Just waiting it out is the equivalent of being on death row and turning down an opportunity to appeal the verdict. At least the Union are trying to bring this issue to a head and get some action going.

If any Toffee can put aside personal feelings towards Kenwright and simply look at the figures, it's as clear as night and day that we are going backwards with only one outcome in sight. We have no assets left and at present we face at best years of watching the remaining quality stripped from the team and relying on senior loan players and our academy stars.

The worst bit is the board don?t appear to have any ideas as to how to dig themselves out of this hole. I don?t care how ugly it gets or whether the current board come out of this with damage or with pockets of cash... I just want change. Sadly I think the driving force will have to come from us.

His football may be boring at the moment but I think he will keep us in the Premier League. I wish I could say the same for the board.
Derek Thomas
68 Posted 20/12/2011 at 01:03:51
Is it true that Bill ' owns/controls' 85% of the shares?

Is it true that, as I read on here recently 'he paid' £22M (no matter who he got the money off), which means that 100% should total about £26M?

Again, is it true that debts are about £45M?

Total ? £71M... a tad simplistic maybe but...

To my mind, that makes a nice little double your money for a sale at £150M and the more you can get back selling off players the bigger the payoff becomes.

Somebody mentioned Leeds. We are nowt but Leeds in slow motion. It's a good job that we did not qualify in 2005, Bill would have had to put our money where his mouth is a hell of a lot quicker.

We wouldn't have been Leeds in slow motion then... It would have been "hold the (trap)door, mate I'm right behind you."
Russell Buckley
69 Posted 20/12/2011 at 01:17:27
The thing that gets me is are there still some of us who don?t fear administration in the coming years. We might be scraping along now but what happens if the loans are called in (ie. Liverpool).
The idea of sitting up over a weekend with fingers crossed to see if anyone steps in to buy us before the bank?s deadline haunts me.

The sad reality is we don?t have the profile of a Man Utd or Liverpool. The rest of the world won?t blink an eye while this club is breathing its last gasps. We cannot allow it to come to that but thats eventually where we will end up if things remain as they are.
Mike Green
70 Posted 20/12/2011 at 01:37:24
Eugene Ruane : "fatty Wyness"

Correct. What a cock.
Richard Styles
71 Posted 20/12/2011 at 01:46:36
Eddy : It was a bit of a Joke mate, SUB-STAIN never mind...I will fix it for you all:

alternative C:Abstain...

ha ha!
Thomas Williams
72 Posted 20/12/2011 at 01:49:34
Two sets of figures stick out here amidst all the to-ing and fro-ing.

Under Kenwright we have gone from £27M in assets to -£33M, £60M in assets stripped and gone.

Under Kenwright, our net transfer sales is -£18M. £18m more sold than spent.

That is £78M in and nothing out, plus the extra TV money each season and BK tells us he hasn't had a penny out of the club, if that is the case then who has?

Money is sieving out of the club and clowns still clap him!! Wake up!!! We are all being shafted.
Peter Barry
73 Posted 20/12/2011 at 03:00:59
The problem is that any Premier League side nowadays cannot be run on match, TV and competition revenue alone and Everton's financial situation just goes to prove this. Even the top four need a fairy godmother to provide additional funds and they all run at a loss.

So the mythical philanthropic billionaire is in fact the ONLY solution to competing in today's Premier League. No billionaire and we plod along until eventual and inevitable receivership or the Championship.
Christine Foster
74 Posted 20/12/2011 at 05:13:03
Tom, couldn't have said it better myself.

For those who drew our attention to what was being done to the club 3 or 4 years ago were we are today is absolutely no surprise. Yet there are still those who peddle the "do nothing, better what we have, trust Bill" bullshit it's scary. Well get out of the way, if your not part of the solution your part of the problem.

Everton will be sold, the sole reason it hasn't is price. Sole reason. If it was priced to sell then it would.

This bullshit about hanging out for the right buyer is lapped up all the time. If the club was for sale for The debt and a decent return it would still be less than £100M.

Kenwright has overseen the demise of this club. Engineered for sale for greed it back fired. Tough. Stand down, sell for what you can get. Move on and don't make it worse. Give us a chance to salvage our club.

To those who believe he is doing the right thing, go see Santa and play with the fairies at the end of the garden. Smell the roses.
Dave Roberts
75 Posted 20/12/2011 at 07:38:22
There is a little too much emphasis on Everton here which, I suppose, is reasonable to expect on a website dedicated to the club. Surely, though, the underlying message here is that the whole financial structure of the Premiership is unsustainable..... our club just being a very pertinent example to employ in describing the problem.

If we consider football clubs to be 'businesses' then it is safe to assume that if they had to compete in the real commercial world every one of them would be, in a business context, a basket case. Liverpool were a few days away from sinking out of sight last year until their latest kerb-crawler pulled over. Chelsea survive because their owner let them off with vast debts the club owed him. If Manchester United sold holidays or sofas for a living their debts would have overwhelmed them years ago. Manchester City have risen like a Phoenix not because of a successful business model but because one of the richest men in the world is pouring unearned money into the business. That would not happen in the real world.

Revenue streams into clubs are generally too small to sustain the ridiculous player wage levels and player purchases. That is why the game has fallen into the trap of 'needing' billionaire individuals or organisations in order to have a chance of consistent success on the pitch.

Accordingly, while some clubs do have the limited advantage of being 'international brands', generally it is a little unfair to nail Kenwright or any other failing club Chairman or owner to the wall and blame him for a failed business model with respect to a particular club. Show me a successful business model in the Premiership, a model that is self sustaining and which does not involve somebody's deep pockets, panicking at the thought of not getting into the Champions League in order to repay debts and where the balance sheet is consistently just that, balanced, while keeping a club challenging for honours. In the real world of business, real businessmen would not touch a Premiership club with a barge-pole.

In the Premiership there aren't any truly sustainable businesses and Everton is just one example of that stark fact.
Richard Jones
76 Posted 20/12/2011 at 08:45:03
Good try Dave, however we still have a chairman who wont sell for the good of the club.
Richard Larnder
77 Posted 20/12/2011 at 08:57:22
Dave #75 - There are a few clubs in the premiership who operate a sustainable business model. The ones that spring to mind are Arsenal, Tottenham and United. Villa actually live within their means but tried to borrow money to get success and had to sell to pay back the banks when they failed.

One thing that all these clubs have in common is that they used the good times when the cash was rolling in to improve their infrastructure, thereby increasing their local and national footprints and increasing cash flow to the business.

This Board has systematically failed in that respect.

I don't think we need the accusations of Bill taking money out of the club like Thomas has made in #72. We know who's taken the increased revenue out of the club: The players, the managers and the agents. Simple as that.

However, as I have said many times, the Board is currently trying to sell a business that generates no cash, has significant debts and requires massive investment after sale.

Would you pay any more than £1 to buy a house that you wouldn't be able to let, where you had to service the vendor's mortgage and you knew it immediately needed a new roof?
Dave Roberts
78 Posted 20/12/2011 at 08:57:33
Richard Jones

That is what I find so exasperating. So many people in this debate try to put themselves in Kenwright's head and tell us what he is thinking without any evidence whatsoever. Who told you that 'Kenwright won't sell for the good of the club'? Did he tell you? Did somebody with irrefutable insider knowledge tell you?

Let me for a moment try to put myself in Kenwright's head....and in his shoes. What do I see? I see somebody who would sell the club at the drop of a hat even if only because of the grief he was getting. Although I am sure too that a new owner with an earnest wish to make the club successful would be even more welcome.

The problem is, he's finding out, nobody is particularly interested in buying football clubs at the moment and even those who are may be put off buying Everton because of the need for vast investment in the stadium.

Do you believe that? Probably not. But then you shouldn't expect anybody to believe your unevidenced statement either.
Richard Larnder
79 Posted 20/12/2011 at 09:23:57
Dave #78. Do you think the Club would be sold tomorrow if the asking price was £1?
Dave Roberts
80 Posted 20/12/2011 at 09:20:34
Richard Larnder

I agree that Arsenal and Spurs are the nearest you will get to sustainability but both, especially Arsenal, need to be in the Champions League to maintain themselves. Arsenal would be in serious trouble if they missed out for a couple of consecutive years. But while Arsenal and Spurs are the nearest you will get to maintained sustainability at the moment, this does not mean they are examples of well run businesses.

How you consider United to be a well run business is just a little beyond me! They carry more debt than many small countries. It is only the peculiar status of 'football' and its social connotations that keep a club like United going. What do you think the green and yellow scarves were all about?

Their supporters recognise a problem too!
Dave Roberts
81 Posted 20/12/2011 at 09:29:47
Richard

Would you sell your house for a £1 for the good of the street, or the neighbours, or to save it getting run down.

No you wouldn't. You'd want your money back. And so would I.

Don't be ridiculous.
Kevin Tully
82 Posted 20/12/2011 at 09:27:42
Dave, #78,

If no-one is interested in buying football clubs, why is BK "talking to three or four interested parties"???

Or my particular favourite: "We are ALWAYS talking with three or four investors."

Or Elstone's "There are GENUINE talks ongoing."

It's either one or the other ? someone is telling bare-faced lies, or there is loads of interest.

Which is it?
Richard Larnder
83 Posted 20/12/2011 at 09:32:59
Dave #80. The green and yellow scarves are all about United fans moaning that they don't control their club any more, that they're owned by Americans, that the ticket prices have gone up and that the club is a whore to corporate hospitality.

Did they moan when they were listed on the stock exchange? They should have done because that was the moment they were sold down the river.

As someone who doesn't give a flying fuck about United but understands a decent business when he sees it, I see a business that adequately services it's debts, is a money making machine that (despite what the fans think) has picked its price point perfectly, has fantastic infrastructure and, most importantly is worth far more as an enterprise than it was when the Glazers bought it.

I wish I could say the same about Everton. Never mind, we can take comfort that we're still the same club that we were in 1987 when we last did anything good. Unfortunately, that was before a lot of the current players were born.
Chris Leyland
84 Posted 20/12/2011 at 09:19:11
Richard #73 - how do you know Kenwright won't sell for the good of the club?

Have you been part of a consortium that had a bid knocked back?

Maybe we haven't been sold because no one has actually put in a realistic bid?

People have suggested Wolves as a model - but would you rather be them or us right now? What difference has it made to them since Morgan took over? They are still a yo-yo side and they have signed who of any note ?

The facts remain we are the second club in one of the most deprived cities in the country. We have an aged ground with little or no prospect of being developed without substantial investment. We don't sell out that ground regularly and are this about the 9th or 10th best supported club in the country (but one of the cheapest in the Prem to watch). There is little or no scope to increase match day revenues as a result. We aren't a global "brand" so we won't ever have a major kit or shirt sponsor deal. We spend the vast majority of our revenues on wages despite not being big salary payers and having no superstars. We have no real assets aside from a couple of players who, it is counter productive to sell as they would need to be replaced.

Whilst many of these things may indeed be the current board's fault it does show that it isn't as simple as we may think. I very much doubt we would have people "queuing round the block" to buy us if a realistic price was put on us, as some posters suggest.

I'm not pro-Kenwright as the man has a lot to answer for but I am a realist.
Richard Larnder
85 Posted 20/12/2011 at 09:41:14
Dave #81. Who said anything about selling it for the good of the street or the neighbours? I'm not a communist!

That is its fair value.
I'd be interested to hear why you think it would be higher?

When you draft your response consider that 10 years of trying to sell the business 24/7 without success agrees with me.
Graham Atherton
86 Posted 20/12/2011 at 09:32:53
When you have a competitor spending unlimited amounts of money they are achieving a couple of things

1. Buying the best, building the best

2. Pushing up prices and wages to heights that cripple their opponents, forcing them to have smaller, less competitive squads as their supporters demand that they compete

There is a third possibility - Man City and Chelsea before them will force so much debt on their competitors that it forces the established 'business model' to the brink. Throw in a banking loan crisis that will go on for a few years and the game has changed for all but the top two or three. There is no point in spending more to achieve success as that success will not bring in enough money to cover the cost of the success.

Is the average fan going to think it is worth a £500 - £1000 season ticket to watch a team basically doomed to failure? Many will carry on but increasingly many will not, which will further weaken the competition. Many new young fans will support a team that can win something.

It has been said for years that the Premier League is two or three teams that can win plus 'cannon fodder' teams to provide symbolic competition. Now we have moved into an even more extreme era - a virtual football 'ethnic cleansing' strategy. New UEFA rules aside, as someone has already written only billionaires will make the merest dent on our hopes to be more competitive.

Everton can only clear the decks, refocus on building an affordable stadium with the capacity to increase size sometime in the future
Dave Roberts
87 Posted 20/12/2011 at 09:42:05
The Green and Yellow scarves emerged when it was announced United were £800,000,000 in debt. They did not emerge when the Glazers took over although many fans did not like it when they did.

Additionally, don't confuse a successful football club with a well run business. They are not necessarily the same thing.

Kevin

I'm not defending Kenwright or the rest of the club hierarchy here. We've been told lies before and we may well be hearing lies now. That is not the point I'm making.

The point I am making is that when considered within the context of real-world businesses, there is not one Premier League club that could be held up as an example of a well run one.

With less than a third of United's debt (in 2009) Thomas Cook is about to close most of its shops, make thousands redundant and severely restrict its available destinations for the foreseeable future. That is the real business world that the Premier League doesn't live in. It may have to quite soon.
Richard Dodd
88 Posted 20/12/2011 at 09:53:29
A very well written piece although I suspect the same `spin language` is used in most club`s accounts and by not a few companies outside the crazy world of football.

By no means a situation that the £20M sale of the sparingly utilised Jack Rodwell will not ameliorate!
Tom Hughes
89 Posted 20/12/2011 at 08:45:46
Dave.....
There are several clubs that operate profitably and efficiently. Liverpool and Man utd's debts are solely because of the leveredged buyouts whereupon the clubs are actually paying their new owners loans off. Otherwise they would be massively profitable. Even then, they have shown that they can comfortably accommodate those debts and still operate on another financial level than us. We cannot! Everton's problems are multiple, but the inaction of the owners contrasts starkly with achievements elsewhere where even modest clubs have added value and increased revenue streams via prudent stadium development. Very few have required billionaires to do this, just some shrewd planning and a handle on what is required.This board has not demonstrated any of these qualities at any point. They have failed to deliver urgently needed new facilities, and have wasted time and resources either chasing non-starters or criminally rejecting great opportunities just to stay in control in the hope of the big pay day when Moyes delivered success on a shoestring. In the process they have stripped the club to the bone to the point where we are no longer a viable concern. Spurs are a similar sized club to ours.... they redeveloped their stadium gradually and as a consequence their turnover dwarfs ours. Arsenal were no bigger than us at the beginning of the prem. Nor did they have billionaire backers, yet now they live in a futuristic stadium with attendances almost double ours. Villa, Sunderland and Newcastle and many others all gradually improved their facilities maximising their matchday revenue streams, adding value and prestige to their clubs at the same time offering their managers greater buying power. They all had a strategy for the future and they delivered on it. We have not.... and that is by definition negligence and dereliction of duty, regardless of whether or not billionaires have muscled in on the chosen few and skewed the whole equation. After all without their millions for Lescott, our sell to buy policy might have been exposed even sooner...... and no doubt we'll be needing more of their millions soon when we sell more of our assets just to survive. You might be right about the whole health of football...... but if the fever ever strikes weve got all the immunity of a chronically ill gereatric already at death's door. So anyone thinking we'll be sitting pretty when the so called "bubble" bursts should perhaps think again. This board have contributed nothing both financially and in terms of planning for the future.... that is why the club is a shadow of its former self while so many others have progressed either on or off the pitch, or both.
Richard Jones
90 Posted 20/12/2011 at 09:50:54
Dave, There is plenty of evidence that Bill wont sell the club, he says hes been looking since he bought his shares, however at the enquiry it was stated by Elstone that the club wasn't for sale Id say this was proof. a light at the end of the tunnel came when Harris said that Bill was looking at circa £150 million for the club there you have the stumbling block.
This sort of means its up for sale for a riddiclous amount just as if I asked for 3 times the value of my house. I dont think you would be it Dave would you.
Dave Roberts
91 Posted 20/12/2011 at 09:55:56
Richard

I think you are confusing Communism with philanthropy. Even Communists would want their money back.

For good or ill, Kenwright, Earle et al have invested their own money in the club by buying shares. If they sell the club (ie sell their shares) then they would want that money back. They may not get it, or all of it, but they would want it, hence they would value the club to at least that amount. Due diligence would inform any potential buyer as to whether that valuation was reasonable or not. Major shareholders would have a say in that and in any ensuing negotiations.

In buying a business a charge also has to be muted regarding the potential of that business and this may increase the value if the buyer is prepared to consider such business potential. He (or she) may not be willing to do so.

The value of a business is partly governed by how much a buyer wants it and that makes an accurate valuation even more difficult. I would value any business to at least the value of the shares held and the value of disposable assets, in Everton's case, mainly the players. Whatever that amounted to is what I would be asking for if it was up to me.

If you think the club is worth a £1 then ring the club and offer it.

See how far you get.
Richard Dodd
92 Posted 20/12/2011 at 10:07:43
Well, Tom, when you put it like that, I have to agree. On the other hand, I continue to fear sale to a Venkey or Youeng which might well see us in a far worse place than we are now.

With so little faith in BB`s judgement, how can YOU be sure that that won`t happen? After all, Doug Ellis took years to sell his very financially stable Villa `to the right buyer` but even that deal has turned out to be a turkey!
Tom Hughes
93 Posted 20/12/2011 at 10:00:15
Richard.... you will need to find a few Jack Rodwells to plug the gaping holes in this ship's leaking hull....... what happens when we don't have them to sell?

Besides, when they go off to help win things for their new clubs do we bask in that glory, or reflect on what could've been had the owners the wealth, the inclination and/or ability to run a great club effectively? Imagine our squad now if only a few of our outgoings had stayed.
Richard Jones
94 Posted 20/12/2011 at 10:30:34
I'm sorry, Dave, everything will sell at the right price, we are not being sold because we are not being sold at the right price. Simple really!!
Tom Hughes
95 Posted 20/12/2011 at 10:19:47
Richard.... I don't trust him to necessarilly sell to the best candidate. He is beholden to third parties who will want top dollar. He cannot do a wolves.... but that is entirely his own fault. He painted himself and the club into a corner. Now we have to.endure the inevitable stagnation that resulted from the ineffectual leadership. Our only hope is that either Mr right does come knocking or impending financial ruin forces the club's hand and independent agents take over the sale. The ensuing realistic price will generate interest as it has at ALL other club sales.

Villa have a modern stadium and consequently greater turnover. They have substantially more solid foundations. They currently have a crap manager, preceeded by several others... and there lies their problems.
Richard Larnder
96 Posted 20/12/2011 at 10:36:34
Dave #91. There are a few very confused messages in your post.

First of all, I'm sure they do want their money back but that is absolutely no guarantee that they'll get it. Whenever you are an equity provider to a business you know you're risking the lot. If you want some money back then provide senior debt instead.

Also, you're contradicting yourself in your own post. They clearly want a return or at least their invested cash back. However, nobody is willing to give it to them, hence we haven't been sold. Simple as that.

The Board's current valuation is in excess of the market's expectation. There is no liquidity.

Finally, aren't you forgetting something when valuing the business based on the resale value of its assets? A business has liabilities too, which the equity holders are also responsible for. Currently, Everton's outgoings are in excess of its incomings, hence it has net liabilities and makes a loss each year. Why would an acquirer pay money to entitle them to make a loss every year?

Add the cost of capital expenditure required after sale and it's difficult to see how the business is worth anything at all. Maybe a bit of goodwill or the value of obtaining a football licence?

For the record, Chris #84. I have never suggested that Bill should sell the club at a discount 'for the love of the club'. I am genuinely saying that it is worth next to nothing and should be priced as such.
Richard Tarleton
97 Posted 20/12/2011 at 11:32:51
Trevor Lynes#6 makes the most interesting point , just how have we slipped into this situation? Why are we so much worse off than other clubs who have larger squads and smaller crowds. I've been banging on about this for years and no-one offers a credible answer.
Tom Hughes
98 Posted 20/12/2011 at 11:06:57
Chris #84,
Missed your post....

"how do you know Kenwright won't sell for the good of the club?"

I would say there are several examples showing this, some going back almost 10yrs.... not least the failure to secure the Kings Dock. The club had the opportunity to sell with this great prospect in the bag..... and were even offered the life line by a board-member. "The good of the club" was indeed set aside!

"People have suggested Wolves as a model - but would you rather be them or us right now? What difference has it made to them since Morgan took over? They are still a yo-yo side and they have signed who of any note ?"

Firstly, you are confusing on and off-pitch progress. Wolves are a club that had spent most of the previous 3 decades in the lower divisions. From that standing start, and tiny crowds they redeveloped their stadium to give themselves a spring board back to the top flight. They are now trying to consolidate and build further quality infrastructure to increase revenue and hopefully profile. It is an investment in their future. Unfortunately for them, they haven't had a Moyes to maximise the potential of their spend. That said, they can now outspend us, and their new redeveloped stadium will easily outearn ours in years to come if we continue to stand still. This has all been fascilitated by owners willing to pass on to genuine and ambitious new owners for the "good of the club", they took the hit despite their massive previous investment. Our current owners have no such inclination (at present).

"The facts remain we are the second club in one of the most deprived cities in the country."

One of the most deprived cities that has always been one of the most deprived cities (in recent generations)... even more so when we were consistently winning things and outspending everyone. There are many similarly deprived areas.... have you ever took a look around Tottenham's patch? Not to mention parts of Manchester and several other cities. Liverpool's population drop and economy are an issue, but can't cover all the failings. Merseyside's population is relatively stable, and boasts one of the biggest middle classes of all major UK conurbations. According to Liverpool vision we have one of the highest percentage of 2 car families in the UK, and our city centre is in the top 5 for turnover, and is still growing at a faster rate than any other. So yes, while there are serious issues, especially with the inner city, it's hardly the basket case of the mid 80's (when we won everything).

"We have an aged ground with little or no prospect of being developed without substantial investment."

Well who's fault is that? They have been in charge for over 10yrs (and involved longer than that) The opportunities have always existed and the model has been shown to work elsewhere. Incrimental redevelopment could have been implemented and paid for in affordable phases... or they could've simply taken Gregg's offer to deliver the KD.... or sold with planning permission secured. They have had options, but took none of them!! QPR recently found rich owners despite having an antiquated and tiny ground, tiny fanbase, and miniscule turnover..... how many hundreds of millions would it take for them to even get to our current level?

"We don't sell out that ground regularly and are this about the 9th or 10th best supported club in the country (but one of the cheapest in the Prem to watch)."

We sold out quite regularly upto a couple of seasons ago, and our average attendance over the past 10yrs has practically always been greater than the number of unobstructed seats.... People wont pay full wack for an obstructed view anymore when they can watch unobstructed in practically any local pub for nothing.

"There is little or no scope to increase match day revenues as a result."

We have a pitifull number of exec boxes, there are 3rd and 4th tier clubs with many more than us (even conference-league).... and our corporate offer is now practically non-existent. Spurs have 120 boxes and fill them with ease... we have 11. So there are numerous margins to exploit that we currently don't even touch. We have only a limited number of premier standard seats and far too many partially obstructed seats to go along with the 3,500 with obstructions going though goal-views.... so there is massive scope to improve the offer and attract more income.

Personally, despite the obvious issues, I believe there is a lot to sell (although its value in relative and real terms has been allowed to drop dramatically), and even more potential for the right owners, but it's a buyer's market, and no doubt some might be prepared to wait for the fire sale.


Ste Traverse
99 Posted 20/12/2011 at 12:22:50
Ok it's o/t but why do people still call the top flight of English football the 'Premiership' when it's not been called that for years?

It's annoying ? it's called the 'Premier League'.

O/T rant over.
Eric Myles
100 Posted 20/12/2011 at 13:21:51
Peter 2, you've already shown on other topics your ignorance of, or lack of interest in what the Blue Union is all about but now your position is "better this current malignant tumor running the Club than trying to find a solution"?

Are you Elstone in disguise?
Eric Myles
101 Posted 20/12/2011 at 13:31:30
Richard #97, the answer's simple, KENWRIGHT
Richard Tarleton
102 Posted 20/12/2011 at 13:40:48
I agree Eric, he's the main culprit, but it started before Kenwight and he's exacerbated the situation. It's why post Heysel we went backwards so quickly and Liverpool didn't. The way the two Boards dealt with the situation and the reaction of the Grantchester family in their last years in charge and , of course Johnson was no help whatsoever.
James Flynn
103 Posted 20/12/2011 at 13:59:32
TOm (98) - Agree to all. I've mentioned this before. The group who purchased LFC own a baseball stadium in Boston called Fenway Park. Almost everything you posted about Goodison exists there too (including its age and the fact that its land-locked into a long-developed city area).

Over 2-3 seasons, they spruced the place up in every way; more seats, much better food and service, and the immediate surrounding area. From a dump of a place (whatever Jamie Crowley comes in here and denies, he knows the comparison between stadiums is accurate).

Anyway, Fenway turned into a cash cow. No new stadium and certainly no 100s of millions spent fixing the place.
Colin Malone
104 Posted 20/12/2011 at 14:19:52
Pardon my ignorance. Rumours of a takeover, no chang on the shirts against Norwich?. So if a takeover is going to happen and the due dilligence has been done and agreed, rumour of Chelsea are interested in our injured???? youngster Rodwell for £20 mill. Who would benefit?
The new owners or Earl and Green?
Colin Fitzpatrick
105 Posted 20/12/2011 at 14:42:44
Peter #41

No need to admire any work by myself, all I did was point out the bleedin? obvious, nothing more, nothing less, many others did do some amazing stuff which all internet warriors should be thankful.

You?re wrong yet again about people I disagree with, at least you?re consistent I?ll give you that, consistently wrong; I respect anyone?s opinion, I?ll debate with them and they?re entitled to their opinion but if they?re proven to be wrong, and persist with the shite they utter, they?re fair game as far as I?m concerned and as that?s my opinion I?ll know that you?ll respect it.

Plenty of people believed that the world was flat, that was fair enough, but once it was proven to be spherical those persisting in the flat earth theory were pricks; it?s an easy enough concept. Despite being told to the contrary, you have persistently regurgitated false information about the Blue Union and their supporters.

I?m glad you respect my view, I respect plenty on here, but don?t expect me to respect anyone spouting shite like you?ve come out with it this piece and the piece you submitted last week; it?s another easy concept, speak the truth, stop telling lies and stop talking bollocks and you?ll get my respect.

Btw, talking of respect, you do yourself no favours in using a word like ?demagoguery?. Really, do you have to? lol

In all seriousness I cannot understand the logic behind your last point concerning believing Bill Kenwright is simply waiting for of a serious offer from someone with very substantial resources. Are you implying he has the best interests of the club at heart? Because the available evidence indicates the complete opposite, if you discount the gushingly embarrassing rhetoric of being the world?s biggest Evertonian; you just need to look at the balance sheet, the stadium, the failures, the wafer thin squad, selling the club down the river Alt and, straight from the horse?s mouth, pestering a guy in a one bedroom flat to fly over and sign the deal to take the club off his hands; it?s like an illusionist with a pretty girl, it?s all a distraction, it?s all bollocks. If, on the other hand, you?re saying he?d sell it to someone with the resources to buy if for his massive asking price then yeah, I?m with you.

As for removing Moyes and replacing him; with whom? Who in their right mind would come and who would be better under the circumstances, no money and a shit board. Playing 442 or 451 isn't the problem. It would be like changing a pair of shoes that were hurting when the real cause of your pain was gangrene! Changing the manager now would have all the fence sitters saying that you have to give him a year or so, or to put it another way give Kenwright's board another year, it?s simple, enough is enough, it?s time for change and the changes need to start at the top, the time, for temporary fixes, has well past.
Peter Laing
106 Posted 20/12/2011 at 14:43:28
Tom Hughes @65 in a couple of paragraphs you succintly offer a true appraisal of Everton's demise during the 'Kenwright' years. Touching on James Flynn's comments @103 this is also a theme that Tom Hughes has been advocating for a number of years, i.e regenerating Goodison Park.
Peter Fearon
107 Posted 20/12/2011 at 14:08:21
Eric, nowhere have I ever written or implied, "better this current malignant tumor running the Club than trying to find a solution" In fact, I am not ignorant of Blue Union's position, having the documents expressing their policy right in front of me as I write. As usual, however, certain individuals would rather engage in personal animus than in a real discussions on issues. I happen to think the Blue Union policy, well-intentioned and considered as it is, places an undue and unsustainable burden on both the seller and any potential buyer and that as neither is likely to benefit from such a deal, neither is likely to agree to it. That's my crime! Just one of the problems with these fire sale proposals which sets the club's price artificially low is that they that actually offer an incentive to most shareholders NOT to sell but to hold on to their shares in the expectation that a future owner will restore order and drive up the value of their shares. The best solution is always a market solution: a fair price unshackled by artificial restrictions. That's my opinion. is that so very controversial or outrageous? i don't think so. BTW I wish i was Robert Elstone. I could double non-media revenue in a year.
Phil Walling
108 Posted 20/12/2011 at 14:58:44
Virtually every post on this thread -and the original article -indicates that Everton is a basket case which could have little appeal to anyone apart from some meglomaniac with more money than sense.
Certainly,any genuine businessman would have little need to get as far as 'due diligence' to conclude that nothing was to be gained from risking even `Morgan's Pound `on the club.
So, who, in god`s name, does Kenwright and all the `sell now` merchants on here think will relieve him of his burden?
Tom Hughes's take on this question might be interesting!
Kevin Tully
109 Posted 20/12/2011 at 15:40:33
Phil - what about the "three or four interested parties"?

Or are you calling Elstone & Kenwright liars?
Tommy Hesketh
110 Posted 20/12/2011 at 15:47:25
Phil,

If the club was run properly not just outsourced or assets stripped from the club it could become a successfull business that actually makes money. However that won't happen in the near future, the reason why it's not is down to the lack of planning, strategy, a viable business plan and leadership.

If we had any subject matter experts or business professionals on the board or even advising the idiots that run the club it would be a start. Sadly this won't happen as it would be an admisson that things have been royal fucked up.

Tom Hughes
111 Posted 20/12/2011 at 15:49:40
Phil..... because this club has been run into the ground and due to the continued failure to invest and add value, it is now apparently unsustainable. This doesn't mean that future owners with a greater grip of all the issues, and the where-for-all to invest in it couldn't turn it all around. There have been times in the recent past when a minimal injection mightve added the missing quality to push us on. Also, off the field there are several comparisons showing how quite modest investments have transformed stadia in both form and function, at the same time greatly increasing potential revenue. The bottom line is.... if I was a buyer.... I would see the obvious defficiencies of the current regime as a great opportunity.
Richard Larnder
112 Posted 20/12/2011 at 16:37:54
Peter #107

I really don't understand how you can say that all you're interested in is a 'fair market price'?

We are talking about an asset that has been for sale for years. That is from the horses mouth.

If someone has been trynig to sell something for years and had no joy, is it not a fair assumption that said person is asking for too much?

Nobody is asking for an artificially low price, merely fair value. Why not auction the shares if the vendors really wanted to sell. It's been done by private equity firms to great effect in the past.

And if you're convinced that someone 'restoring order' would drive up the price, surely by implication, that means that there is currently such entropy at the club in its current form that value is being destroyed?

There's glaring disingenuousness in everything you write. You claim to be an advocate of the free market, well let it happen. Let's see what the market says the club is worth because one thing is for sure, the market thinks it's worth less than the Board does.
John Keating
113 Posted 20/12/2011 at 16:18:22
Peter I am glad you have the BU policy in front of you as in the past some of your posts suggest you did not.
Actually now that you have finally read and digested the BU statement you may find both your and their position are not a million miles apart.
You advocate a " fair price unshackled by artificial restrictions " I think you might find that that is the BU position.
They would say that by having a group of professionals dedicated to getting a fair price they would bypass the " artificial restriction " of the present board.
Now that you have read the BU statement I would like to think you would be more amenable to their position than it appears you have been in the past.
Spread the word !!
Brian Harrison
114 Posted 20/12/2011 at 17:24:46
I dont think the main stumbling block to Everton being sold is the asking price. I am sure if there was someone out there willing to pump serious money into the club, and thought the asking price was too high then I am sure they would have any number of Journalists willing to print their story.

Everton as a business is losing money year on year, and the only way to turn it around is sell some of your assets, and reduce your overheads. Seeing as our biggest overheads is players wages and seeing quite a few are on 4 year contracts it will be difficult to get round that problem.

Now even if this model was applied it wouldnt make us a better team, in fact because of having to sell to balance the books we would be a worse team. Probably relegation would be inevitable, but you would at least go down being financially solvent and the club would still remain.
Matt Traynor
115 Posted 20/12/2011 at 17:52:30
Brian, #114, I don't think that's true. Firstly, a lot of "interested parties" prefer to conduct their business quietly, hence all the confidentiality requirements on both sides that are par for the course in these transactions. Their reasons are many, but usually because they will be competing with other entities in a lot of their business interests.

Secondly, you miss one glaring issue about Everton's business model - and that is growing revenue streams. Other clubs have done this very successfully, helped by the ever-expanding overseas TV deal. A lot of overseas companies are desperate to be tier 1, 2 or 3 sponsors of teams here, as given the £ has tanked, it represents an almost certain ROI in marketing terms. Again, we lag behind spectacularly in that area.
James Flynn
116 Posted 20/12/2011 at 17:45:06
Tom (111) - Nice way to put it, "I would see the obvious defficiencies of the current regime as a great opportunity".

Which EFC in its current state absolutely is. The simplest revenue-generating means are not being pursued. Is the food and service at Goodison really as bad as posters here say it is? My goodness. We're talking Revenue 101 here. You can count on 30-40 thousand fans 20-30 times a year showing up at Goodison with money they've planned on spending and you don't help them do so? Ugh!

The other point that exasperates me are these 300-500 million figures tossed around freely regarding sprucing up Goodison. Ugh again.

And most importantly regarding, "I would see the obvious defficiencies of the current regime as a great opportunity". We're talking about an EPL Club for sale, for God sakes. The best known and watched soccer league on earth (by far).

Whatever folks may think BK etal lie about, the one thing I believe implicity is that there are constantly interested buyers.

The problem has to be in the asking price. What other reason could there be?
Peter Fearon
117 Posted 20/12/2011 at 19:20:40
Colin et al.- it is almost pointless engaging with someone with the enormous ego and the Napoleon complex you apparently have. One final try: you would never in a million years allow a third party to come into your business, sell it from under you at a fire sale price and at the same time make onerous demands on the resources of a potential buyer, but you expect Kenwright to stand off and do precisely that. You are entitled to hold that view, campaign for it, i wish you luck with it. But of course you have to insult, lash out and harangue anyone who isn't on board. It's childish. Now please, choose another victim.
Peter Fearon
118 Posted 20/12/2011 at 19:33:56
John Keating - that may be the BU position. It isn't what their literature says. What is more disturbing to me than their broad demands, which seem to me to be not Real World, is the offensive and condescending way some of their leadership defend their position. I would hope a day never comes when fans can't express dissent without being shouted down by louts with laptops.
John Keating
119 Posted 20/12/2011 at 19:52:32
Peter, I don't know too much about louts with laptops. I don't know too much about the BU leadership being offensive and condescending.
What I do know is that for a number of years the leadership of my club has treated me offensively and condescendingly. I do know they have treated me with utter contempt and lied to me.
I do know that they have led this club to the situation we presently find ourselves in.
The day long ago arrived when I and other supporters could not express dissent.
It is such a great pity that you and others could not have expressed your concerns to the club hierachy when supporters were treated like shite by the club.
Gavin Ramejkis
120 Posted 20/12/2011 at 19:58:12
Brian #114 and Matt #115, its a fair assumption that any prospective buyer would be asked to sign a non disclosure agreement thus removing the opportunity to "run to the press", any of them getting as far as due dilligence and finding the true clown act behind the scenes and true levels of debt and lack of a business case would walk at that point if the price is outrageous again having no need to go telling tales because of the earlier NDA
Tom Hughes
121 Posted 20/12/2011 at 20:01:49
Peter,
I think you need to put greater vigour into addressing the issues rather than your petty disdain for a group that has arisen because of them. I find those Real World issues: the way in which the club has been mismanaged to the point of collapse, and the way the fanbase have been treated and misled, to be far more offensive to my Evertonian sensitivities. You seem to be far more concerned with something else completely!
Colin Wainwright
122 Posted 20/12/2011 at 20:07:25
Peter(#numerous)

Louts with laptops? Cmon ffs.

The way in which you denigrate the BU, quote ''What is more disturbing to me than their broad demands, which seem to me to be not Real World, is the offensive and condescending way some of their leadership defend their position. I would hope a day never comes when fans can't express dissent without being shouted down by louts with laptops.'' Sounds a bit like Ian Ross.

Not having that?

With that sentence alone, you have nailed your colours to the mast.

BTW. Bet ya could too. (Post 107)
Eddy Bernard
123 Posted 20/12/2011 at 20:47:20
Brian @66 If i told you i'd have to kill you
Eddy Bernard
124 Posted 20/12/2011 at 20:57:53
Richard@71 Tongue was very much in cheek when i replied
Peter Fearon
125 Posted 20/12/2011 at 20:37:30
The issues facing the club are very much Real World. It's the expectation that any major shareholders of a volatile business with a multi-million pound turnover is going to let any third party come in and sell their business from under them at a knock down price - zero in effect. That's what's not Real World. It's also the expectation that a buyer with hundreds of millions of liquidity is going to tie it up in escrow for five years while a new stadium is built to satisfy a fan group.That's also not Real World. What the Blue Union proposes in terms of transfer of ownership is more appropriate to a club actually in administration, or a club in which the shareholders are engaged in irreconcilable conflict in which case a court may order something similar. But that isn't applicable here.
Brian Waring
126 Posted 20/12/2011 at 21:13:44
Peter, you may not notice it, but your distaste for the BU shines through big style.
Gavin Ramejkis
127 Posted 20/12/2011 at 21:09:03
Peter #125 how near enough bar all but name "administration" is a business that has rid itself of six players for multiple millions of pounds, saving multiple millions of pounds in wages and its last owned property for multiple millions of pounds and still posted a loss? With quite literally nothing left but 21 first team players at which point would you personally rate that as insolvent?

Would your stance regarding a change of ownership change if the club went into black and white administration, was docked points, its remaining players sold to be left with insufficient players to actually register a full squad?
Peter Fearon
128 Posted 20/12/2011 at 21:32:53
Gavin, it's like saying "almost pregnant" You are either in administration, in which case certain legal provisions apply, or you are not. Right now we are not. I would be happy to see the club sold. i just don't think it's realistic to ask Kenwright to sell it for the value of the debt. Even if Kenwright, in a moment of sentiment, was willing his two mates probably would not be. And as I say, such a proposal incentivizes shareholders to hold out. The club needs a massive capital injection, and yet the BU proposal ties up 150M maybe 200M in escrow for 5 years! That makes sense to you?
Peter Fearon
129 Posted 20/12/2011 at 21:41:46
Brian Waring: I don't have any distaste for the BU. I'm a frustrated with the situation at Everton as every single marcher and I feel their pain. I do have a distaste for the avalanche of scorn and derision that greets anyone who deviates from their orthodoxy and comes from a small number of bully boys. "You must be Ian Ross!" "You must be Robert Elstone" "You must be a prick!" You aren't an Evertonian!" Really! If I didn't know they were adults I'd bet some of them are 5 years old.
Tommy Hesketh
130 Posted 20/12/2011 at 21:46:52
http://www.talksport.co.uk/radio/richard-keys-and-andy-gray/blog/2011-12-20/adrian-heath-and-peter-reid-join-keys-and-gray

Unfortunately listening to these 3 ex blues I was very disapointed to hear the usual soundbites about Bill being a great chairman, what was very surprising from 35mins Inchy & Reid saying that they have spoken to various Yanks & Asian Businessman about EFC.

It's 40 mins long, however, they speak about the blues in depth between 23-28 mins then 35-40 mins.

Great listening to them about our halcyon days, if only for a time machine....
Stephen Kenny
131 Posted 20/12/2011 at 21:54:44
Peter

One thing you have forgotten with regards to Bill, the major shareholder and spokesman for the group which effectively owns the club, is that he has consistently said he's not looking to make a profit and has the "best interests of the club at heart".

IF he's genuine (no sniggering) then he would be happy to appoint independent professionals to sell the club at a similar price to what he paid.

He won't because his backers, who he consistently lies about won't allow him to.
Gavin Ramejkis
132 Posted 20/12/2011 at 22:25:54
Peter you body swerve the potential for one of those shareholders to actually sell up and move on at a reasonable price and keep reverting to the mythical £150m in escrow for years. If Bill was to sell his shares which would in effect create a new chairman it could well lead to the sale of the remaining two major shareholders but that singular sale alone and a competant business review of failing practices would at the very least steady the ship beyond what is a flawed and fatal downward spiral.

The nearly pregnant comeback was quite humerous but hardly in the same ballpark as being left with fuck all to pay the next set of bills or loan repayment when it comes due, you haven't answered at what point you would turn your colours?

How do you incentivise a shareholder to hold onto a depreciating asset (is it really currently worth anything in the REAL WORLD?) whose shareholding becomes worthless and they become blacklisted as directors of a bankrupt business? As far as Earl's shares go well there in themselves is an entire thread of it's own.
Simon Templeman
133 Posted 20/12/2011 at 23:02:40
It seems that Fulham posted a "profit" of £4.8m. The only reason that could happen is because someone (fayed) is willing to bankroll them to the tune of £200m with no interest payable. The same is true of Aston Villa. We appear not to have anyone willing to offer us an interest free loan. Is that Bill Kenwrights fault?
Tommy Hesketh
134 Posted 20/12/2011 at 23:22:18
Siom,

Yes it is, it's his job as Chairman to ensure the best interests of the club/business are met. This has not happened, he's hapy to keep signing off loans to pay off loans whilst selling everythings, the fucking idiot had even forgot he'd sold the park end car park off and tried to pass it off as a IT problem when they tried to build on it, harldy Donald Trump or Alan Sugar.

can people stop judging him as an "Evertonian" and judge him on what he's done for EFC, marks out of ten 1/10, He's the worst thing that's ever happened to EFC including Johnson & Heysel.
Colin Fitzpatrick
135 Posted 21/12/2011 at 00:29:14
Peter, [all over the shop]

Behave yourself, you?re playing a bigger victim card than Suarez, you?re getting stick from everywhere because you?re talking shite.

Tell you what, I?ll be outside the church at 19:00 tomorrow, I?ll bring a hammer and nails, nail yourself to the cross.

Grow a pair and face this reality; we?ve had enough; Kenwright and his seen and unseen cohorts have brought this club to the brink with their failed and frankly ridiculous strategies; the blue union have offered a solution that will give the club a chance to avoid relegation and or administration. The man said it himself, ?don?t kill us this season? Ross said it in his emails, ?we?re close to financial meltdown? but instead of thinking of what?s best for the club all you?re interested in is the trouser pockets of the guys who could lose us nine points and our status as an elite premiership club.

Look at the press tonight, Moyes is saying we?re not going to let Rodwell go cheaply ? he shouldn?t be going at all.
Hang your head in shame Peter.
Tom Hughes
136 Posted 21/12/2011 at 00:46:48
Anfield cemetery must me a rotavated mess. Will Cuff has probably ploughed the whole place up. Spinning uncontrollably in his grave at the current state of the club he left as the finest the country...... by a country mile! Now at the brink of collapse, and in the era of wealth and plenty for so many others who he would've barely recognised as peers!?

Ok, I over-dramatised..... but have I really? Not if you know your history!!!!!
Eric Myles
137 Posted 21/12/2011 at 05:07:15
Doddy #92 "I continue to fear sale to a Venkey or Youeng which might well see us in a far worse place than we are now.
With so little faith in BB`s judgement, how can YOU be sure that that won`t happen?"

Which is exactly the reason we need someone competant to sell the Club as proposed by the BU.
Eric Myles
138 Posted 21/12/2011 at 05:19:24
Peter #107, if you really are not ignorant of the BUs stated aims then why do you continually misrepresent them in your posts?

I can only asssume you are deliberately trying to mislead readers into thinking you know what you're talking about.

And you have, in several posts on the topic, implied support for the current regime.
Ste Traverse
139 Posted 21/12/2011 at 07:32:38
Spot on,Tommy Hesketh #134.

It was one of the worst days in this clubs modern day history when this utter fucking clown Kenwright first walked into our boardroom.

The sad thing is he's duped too many Blues into thinking he's good for the club on the basis that, er, 'he's an Evertonian'.
Richard Larnder
140 Posted 21/12/2011 at 08:41:28
Peter [various],

Not sure why you're not responding to my points. I'll assume it's that you seem to have a lot to respond to rather than that you don't have an answer. I'll make it more succinct:

- Forget about the BU. This isn't about them, it's about Everton.

- 90% of business sales are aided by professional advisors e.g., Investment Banks or Corporate Finance Boutiques. They can get a better price and have access to larger pools of investors.

- A business that has been for sale for 10 years cannot be a 'fire sale'.

- You might not realise it but by admitting that selling for £1 would bring about a sale you are acknowledging that price is a barrier. Clearly fair value lies somewhere between £1 and the current asking price. Price is the determinant.

- I can tell you (for free) that any potential purchaser would look to get a reduction from the purchase price for a) the value of the net debt and b) the required level of capex needed after purchase. It's difficult to see how these numbers would add up to less than £100m, meaning that even if the club was valued at £120m, the shareholders would only get £20m back.

Food for thought wouldn't you say?
Tom Hughes
141 Posted 21/12/2011 at 09:20:17
Richard..... very succinctly put!

Practically every club in the country has changed hands in the time that BK has supposedly been looking 24/7.......... (some more than once) yet some still insist that no-one is interested in EFC......no doubt as some last vestige for logical support for BK and his regime. Desperation to justify support for the indefensible. The very notion is laughable and contradicted by all the facts, and even by the club's own admission. It's straw clutching at its very worst as it detracts from the onerous issues related to the selling process. Similarly the side swipes at the BU. Its all a bit like arguing with the neighbour who's only trying to tell you your house is on fire......

So I wouldn't expect a similarly succinct response.
Phil Martin
142 Posted 21/12/2011 at 09:59:28
I can't believe that some posters still argue that EFC is on a stable path to financial security and a prosperous future.

I could buy a massive house that I cant afford to run. I can borrow some money from friends to pay the bills and even take out loans just to sustain my residence a little longer. But when the handouts stop and loans are recalled. I have to sell up (to someone more wealthy) and move on.
But what we have in Kenwright is someone who would rather sell the family heirlooms and risk the house go to ruin, rather than sell up.
Phil Walling
143 Posted 21/12/2011 at 12:40:47
Richard`s point is well made although I`d be surprised if Kenwright & Co were able to get even £20M back for relinquishing control. That being the case ? and he knowing it ? probably means that he`s just hanging on in the hope that some looney sheik will ride out of the desert just to polish his ego!

In the meantime........
Peter Fearon
144 Posted 21/12/2011 at 14:04:51
Obergruppensturmbannfuhrer von Patrick: - I tell you what. It's so important to you to be right. You're 100% right. I could not be more hopelessly wrong. Everton should be given away for the value of the debt by an independent third party to a billionaire who should tie up the cost of a stadium in escrow for five years. OK? Now all you need is two people crazy enough to participate, the seller and the buyer.
Eric Myles
145 Posted 21/12/2011 at 14:36:22
^with posts like that Peter you just prove that you have no point to argue and are just making stuff up to sit your own (the Club's?) agenda.
Richard Larnder
146 Posted 21/12/2011 at 14:34:28
Dear Peter,

I'm done.

I like to come on here to debate with intelligent people about the state of our great institution.

However, there is only one thing I find more abhorrent than an idiot blindly following the crowd and that's someone who clearly has intelligence yet chooses to avoid/stifle adult conversation by refusing to discuss those matters that are at the very fabric of everything we hold dear.

When you want to have a proper discussion (without the condescending sarcasm) on any of the points that I've raised, let me know. That is, If you can hear me through all that sand in your ears.

Yours,

Richard
John Keating
147 Posted 21/12/2011 at 15:58:25
Peter. It's a pity you ended the debate the way you did. Just makes you look well...stupid !
Colin Fitzpatrick
148 Posted 21/12/2011 at 16:15:21
Ah, the inevitable appearance of Godwin?s law signals the towel being thrown in by you Peter #144

Yes, I do believe it?s important to be right, you clearly believe otherwise; I now understand why you defend the right of Bill to make a profit on his shares.

My faith in TW as the best Everton site on the web has been reinforced by some of the posts in this thread ? the posts by people who are right obviously Peter ;-)
David Marsden
149 Posted 24/12/2011 at 09:15:14
football is finished as a fans sport, i'm bored of it all.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads