Season › 2011-12 › News
Osman to the rescue once more
Everton 1 - 0 Swansea City
Leon Osman scored for the second time in four days and it was just enough to see Everton through against Swansea City. The Blues' lack of cutting edge in attack was again preventing them from turning possession into goals — though Gueye went close twice in the first half — until Osman headed Drenthe's superb corner home with an hour gone.The Blues took a while to get going and it was the visitors who edged the possession in the first quarter of the game, stroking the ball around as has become customary under Brendan Rogers, although it was still Everton looking the more threatening in the final third.
Typically, though, they were lacking sufficient bodies in forward areas under David Moyes's conservative 4-5-1 formation. Osman had been deployed in the Tim Cahill role behind Louis Saha but the lack of the extra striker would be apparent on a number of occasions throughout the afternoon, first in the 6th minute when Seamus Coleman's inviting cross skipped across the Swansea box with no blue shirts in attendance.
Strange then that it would be John Heitinga who started and finished a move with a wayward header off Tony Hibbert's 28th-minute cross before Coleman had to be withdrawn with a reoccurrence of the thigh injury that kept him out against Norwich at the weekend.
His replacement, Magaye Gueye added a bit more attacking presence, though, and the young French forward came so close to opening his account for Everton when he fond himself the recipient of a perfect Leighton Baines centre. Unfortunately, Vorm in the Swansea goal was equal to it, saving well with a low, one-handed stop to keep the scores level.
And the Swansea 'keeper was called into emergency action again on the stroke of half time, closing the angle and denying Gueye for a second time by blocking his shot with his legs.
The second half was a lot more one-sided in Everton's favour but, once again, though they had plenty of the ball and were asserting plenty of pressure but clear-cut chances were few and far between.
As was the case against Stoke and Norwich, the set-piece count was high but very little was being created from them, at least until Drenthe whipped in a peach of a corner from the right and Osman rose to power a header off the back of his head into the far corner.
Swansea responded by upping their tempo a little and finally tested Tim Howard when Graham connected with Routledge's cross but steered it straight into the 'keeper's arms.
Instead, it was back down the other end where the next goal looked most likely to come, Drenthe fizzing a direct free kick just wide and substitute Denis Stracqualursi spurning a chance when put through behind the defense, his lack of pace allowing a defender to nick the ball off his toe at the crucial moment.
Reader Comments (112)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 21/12/2011 at 22:00:15
3 Posted 21/12/2011 at 21:58:38
4 Posted 21/12/2011 at 22:01:00
5 Posted 21/12/2011 at 22:04:24
6 Posted 21/12/2011 at 22:03:50
Neville is fuckin awful
7 Posted 21/12/2011 at 22:13:24
Well done Ossie lad, thank goodness you've done what our impotent 'strikers' cannot.
8 Posted 21/12/2011 at 22:09:38
Unbelievable!
Please, pay me 70k a week, and I'll perform much better!
The guy is lazy (like Saha) and is delaying our play all the time. Hope we sign Drenthe. He played well again!
Great first half, with finally some old fashioned noise from thw crowd. Yes! :-)
COYB!
Tim.
9 Posted 21/12/2011 at 22:12:53
Can't wait for Donovan even for a couple of months to lift the mood cause we are playing some sad football out there.
10 Posted 21/12/2011 at 22:18:13
11 Posted 21/12/2011 at 22:18:33
12 Posted 21/12/2011 at 22:23:06
We just can't finish off the chances we create. Johnny must stay at the back as he is performing well.
13 Posted 21/12/2011 at 22:23:07
14 Posted 21/12/2011 at 22:23:01
15 Posted 21/12/2011 at 22:23:58
16 Posted 21/12/2011 at 22:26:33
17 Posted 21/12/2011 at 22:32:07
18 Posted 21/12/2011 at 22:39:33
19 Posted 21/12/2011 at 22:41:44
"Nothing to be happy about". We just moved up 3 places in the table playing football that according to many on this site is terrible. I would rather win ugly than not win at all.
20 Posted 21/12/2011 at 22:38:23
We've somehow limped to 20 points, and Moyes must now be close to realising his best eleven !
As usual, I see us now kicking on in the second half of the season, with a stronger and fitter squad than the one we started with. The defence now looks settled, with the schoolboy errors lessening.
Drenthe and Gueye (and maybe even Barkley) will surely cement their places as definite starters, and with the arrival of Landon, I see our creativity and movement up front improving considerably.
Of course, injuries will dictate to some degree, but this has often proved a blessing in the past, and forced Moyes' hand in changing formations and blooding youngsters.
Onwards and upwards !
21 Posted 21/12/2011 at 22:45:56
I'll give Ossie MotM ? always trying to create in the pocket and great header!
Johnny Heitinga looks too much of a liability, my heart's in my mouth anytime someone runs at him or past him, he's just too slow and has completely no left foot. Distin back against Sunderland all day!
We look a lot more balanced with Guaye on the left and Drenthe on the right; I'd stick with that until Donovan's available. A good win, what a nice feeling three points is!!
22 Posted 21/12/2011 at 22:50:34
With our usual second half of the season run,we should well pass 50 points by the close.
That will go a long way to taking the pressure off Davey and BK.....for the time being anyway!
23 Posted 21/12/2011 at 22:51:25
Dont be sorry lad.
I thought the same but I did think Felli played well defensively (as usual).
He gave the ball away a few times tonight and didn't offer much going forward imho ;)
24 Posted 21/12/2011 at 22:47:06
I wouldn't miss Arteta and Pienaar too much mate, they've gone now and Pienaar wasn't that great anyway.
Let's put our faith in Ossie, Drenthe and Strac for now and see how we go until our American friend arrives for his strange short spell.
Hopefully in the meantime, we can strike a deal with Asda for a new stadium (only joking), chin up.
25 Posted 21/12/2011 at 22:42:13
Neville simply can't play in the midfield anymore if he is asked to do more than tackle. Some of his passes and touches were scary.
Also I have to mention the Straq's header off the floor. One of the biggest laughs I've had in football but love the effort he shows.
Saha had one or two good touches but he failed big time to lead the line. So many times we got into good positions only to have nobody in the box. On several occassions he looked as though he couldn't be arsed making the run.
It will never happen but I'd love to see Barkley, Drenthe, Landon and Seamus in the side at the same time. All players that will go direct and attack the defender.
26 Posted 21/12/2011 at 23:01:50
27 Posted 21/12/2011 at 23:11:58
I think that's the point Tim was trying to make about Felli not attacking quick enough.
He needs a bit more urgency about him.
28 Posted 21/12/2011 at 23:09:00
Barkley, Drenthe, Landon and Seamus would prove a handful in full flow. Given Saha's terrible injury record (and form!), and The Stracq's obvious limitations, this should be the way to go, and circumstances could well force Moyes's hand to this end.
The way that football is going at the top level, nimble, tricky attackers are the way to go. Having witnessed the likes of Silva, Aguerro, Nasri, and Adam Johnson rip the lumbering thugs of Stoke to pieces on the MOTD highlights just now, I'd like to think that Moyes will now consider this as a strategy, rather than the "one big fella up top" ploy, which clearly hasn't worked for us.
Of course, the slight flaw in this plan is that our attacking players aren't as good as City's, but it does seem the better way to unlock today's tight defences.
29 Posted 21/12/2011 at 23:18:04
If Saha is to continue to drop deep to link the play then we need a striker in front of him.
Swansea were dire but like most of the teams we've played we dominated possession, however unike other games I've watched this season I thought tonight we actually created some chances.
And Neville should never get a game in the centre of our midfield.
30 Posted 21/12/2011 at 23:22:57
31 Posted 21/12/2011 at 23:41:42
32 Posted 21/12/2011 at 23:39:48
Glad Drethe moved to the right. Coleman never ever cuts inside, why?
33 Posted 21/12/2011 at 23:46:27
34 Posted 22/12/2011 at 00:14:34
Which game were you two watching?
If anyone, it was eirther Osman or Drenthe.
35 Posted 22/12/2011 at 00:19:55
Osman ? Not my favourite player but digging in and trying to do the right things. A good goal to boot.
Drenthe ? Full of ability, positivity and drive. Clearly our most creative player, I really enjoy watching him.
Heitinga ? Went about his job quietly and is clearly a very good footballer. Improved as the game went on.
A word for Swansea: Awful. They came for a draw and did not deviate from plan A.
Saha was poor again and I think it's time for a new approach for the trip to Sunderland in terms of attacking options.
All-in-all, it's 3 points, and let's hope we can have our customary run of wins that see us fly up the table. I still have my reservations with Moyes but whilst we win I will keep my mouth shut.
Merry Christmas blues... on the up? Let's hope so.
36 Posted 22/12/2011 at 00:29:41
37 Posted 22/12/2011 at 00:29:29
38 Posted 22/12/2011 at 00:44:43
For me Fella is just top, and I think he was great tonight and as above Drenthe must be a mare to mark. JH is quietly efficient and Tony Tony was reliable and always there at panic stations. Ossie put a great shift in and scored the goal. All in all not really the most convincing tonight but a win and a clean sheet, moving up the table.
Mr Black, above, well done. I thought "King" Louis had been on a management course and was " thinking outside the box" Well thats where he was playing.
Can not wait to see Ken's report and hope that he confirms what I saw which is that, for the last home game of 2011, BB was there.
39 Posted 22/12/2011 at 00:52:46
Moyes doesn't give his midfield enough licence to bomb forward and it is for that reason that it makes us look such a weak attacking force. That and the fact that our one striker isn't on form or really suited to playing the lone striker role when he himself likes to drop deep.
Yes we got the three points and I'm delighted, but 4 points and two goals from our three home games against the promoted teams simply isn't good enough and I believe that it is Moyes's approach to these games with his formation & tactics which are mostly to blame.
40 Posted 22/12/2011 at 01:07:59
41 Posted 22/12/2011 at 01:14:55
Ossie Ossie Ossie ..... Oye Oye Oye!
Ossie Ossie Osie ..... Oye Oye Oye!
Ossie... Oye,
Ossie ..Oye!
Ossie Ossie Ossie ...... Oye Oye Oye.
42 Posted 22/12/2011 at 01:31:51
This is the bloke that gets pushed off every ball that he goes near. Can't run. Can't tackle. Thinks he's Messi.
It's been said so many times here, but it's true. A loss, a draw, and a win against the three promoted sides at home is a disgrace, and I think most people would have to agree that Moyes could have set the side up to win all three games if he had a little bit of vision and a different approach.
I think when I go back to work, instead of teaching the year 8s to their level, I'll give them senior work, then complain that they'e not passing because they aren't going to one of the rich schools across town. Works for Moyes.
43 Posted 22/12/2011 at 03:17:29
Give it a rest, how the heck can Osman win if people like you still knock him when hes earning us points?
How does he think he is Messi? Maybe he should play more like Big Dunc, after all, that would suit his height and size wouldnt it?
Well done tonight Osman. This is a guy who is a true blue, has come from our academy and has, over the years, chipped in with important contributions and goals while other 'stars' like Arteta, Baines and Fellaini take all the plaudits. At least save your blatently undeserved abuse for a night when he actually plays poorly.
44 Posted 22/12/2011 at 04:03:13
Watched SKy and listened to the Radio 5 commentary this morning from sunny Melbourne - good way to finish before Christmas. I'll take an ugly 1-0 win over an ugly 0-0 draw, any day.
45 Posted 22/12/2011 at 06:56:52
46 Posted 22/12/2011 at 07:37:02
Hate hate hate him. We won with 10 men. Cancel his contract or try and get rid in January.
47 Posted 22/12/2011 at 07:23:14
The problems for me...3 right full backs on the pitch from the outset when we need one. We don't need Neville in the middle at all. Fellaini and Osman would be fine.
Saha ? why does he continue to drop deep when we need him in the box? He is a really poor passer.
Vellios is probably our best striker at the moment ? play him.
The jury is also out on Gueye for me. He has time to learn but doesn't seem to be able to cross/shoot particularly well.
48 Posted 22/12/2011 at 08:01:28
50 Posted 22/12/2011 at 08:19:36
Saha should come in for some too, but I refuse to criticise a player who is being played almost completely opposite to his strengths. Moyes playing him on his own would be like playing Cahill at centre half.
51 Posted 22/12/2011 at 08:30:48
52 Posted 22/12/2011 at 08:37:07
53 Posted 22/12/2011 at 08:41:33
Felliani is a decent defensive midfielder but these fans who think he is world class are talking shite imo its based on that stupid turn he does which produces nothing and his hairstyle. I cant remember the last time Felliani played a defensive splitting pass or drove at the opponents back four and got a good shot on target. He does ok keeping it simple but thats the least i expect of Premier Leauge footballers.
If anyone can name the last time Felli had ten good games on the bounce ile take it back but they will be lucky to find ten good performances that influenced a game since he was signed.
54 Posted 22/12/2011 at 09:07:05
In the first half on 2 occasions the ball was put right across the 6 yard box from Baines and Coleman and no one was in there.
I like Saha he has a good touch but comes deep so often to get the ball we need someone else with him who can run beyond the opposition.
Overall important to get the win but were going to have to step it up on Boxing day.
55 Posted 22/12/2011 at 09:19:59
Agree those defending Felli. Yes we all would like to see him futher up the pitch and scoring, but in his defensive role last night he broke up the play dozens of times.
Ossie time and again found space in the "hole" and used the ball well. An honourable mention also for Hibbo who had an excellent game defensively and linked well with Drenthe on the right.
Neville was a nightmare, contributed nothing go forward and looked dodgy going back.
Overall - a win's a win, but if we don't have a striker on the pitch who wants to to score it is always going to be nail-biting stuff.
56 Posted 22/12/2011 at 09:21:42
Fellaini was good
Howard was redundant
Jags was better (!)
Baines was patchy
Neville was determined
Saha was bone idle
others were iffy.
but Drenthe was like the curate's egg - good in parts, brilliant in some and totally frustrating in others.
57 Posted 22/12/2011 at 09:31:24
59 Posted 22/12/2011 at 09:40:39
I don't recall Drenthe ever passing to Hibbert (ok maybe once), either because he tends to go it alone or because he doesn't trust him!
Hibbert, Neville are precisely the reason why we play such tortoise football. Negative sideways or backwards passes nearly all played when stationary. If we need to get the ball forward with more one touch football, these are two of the guys that I would be looking to replace. Fellaini had a good game but he too doesn't shift the ball fast enough.
Last night was a welcome victory but it proved as many negatives as it did positives. For starters, Gueye, is by no means the finished article - he seems to have trouble retaing possession and Strac, quite frankly, looks like the proverbial donkey. With Saha never putting himself where the ball hurts and Cahill totally out of sorts, our attacking options will continue to look minimal and rest on Vellios who is promising but also unproven.
Thank Goodness for a set piece and 3 points against a Swansea team that also pass the ball to death with little or no incision.
This really is a transfer window that we need to be active in - even if it means shifting players out (e.g. Bily) to get players in.
60 Posted 21/12/2011 at 22:18:13
61 Posted 22/12/2011 at 10:00:42
Everyone played well yesterday, even Neville. He got his tackles in when he needed to. Fellaini won a lot of ball and kept it moving wide where we got a lot of joy.
Saha is maybe the only player who didn't cover himself in glory when he shit out of a few 50/50's.
Special mentions must go to the two most maligned players in Everton history, Osman and Hibbert. Hibbert defended like a trojan and his crossing was (again) excellent. Osman ran the show and played as well as any time in his purple patch the second half of last season. His passing through players was excellent.
I didn't see anything to moan about last night bar maybe a lack of presence up top.
One last observation, we looked a lot, lot fitter and stronger than at the start of the season.
62 Posted 22/12/2011 at 10:14:48
Maybe it wasn't a Man City-esque performance but we finally got a deserved 3 points.
I think a lot of it is to do with playig Osman in the hole instead of Cahill. His all-round game is so much more suited to that position with his ability to receive the ball in tight spots and to thread passes through (his one to Baines was a peach). He's also much more of a goal threat these days than Cahill.
Rodwell needs to come back to replace Neville and we desperately need a good striker to come in for Saha. How i wish we could have afforded Demba Ba, he really looks a complete package. I think if we had signed him we would be sat on 25-28 points and breathing down Liverpool's neck. That is why money does make a difference!
63 Posted 22/12/2011 at 10:11:26
' fans who think he is world class are talking shite imo its based on that stupid turn he does which produces nothing and his hairstyle.'
Yeah, nothing to do with him dominating in the air, putting tackles in left, right and centre and taking the ball off people no matter how many are around him.
' the bloke is 30 and has never proven that he is worth 11 seasons in the Premiership'.
I agree that he's maddeningly inconsistent but several times I've seen you post that he only plays well against shit teams(which is bollocks).
Shit teams make up at least half of this league but by you reckoning he's not good enough for this league? Care to explain that one?
64 Posted 22/12/2011 at 10:24:08
In my opinion and in the immortal words of Roy Walker you should "See what you say, say what you see".
Instead of bashing out the comfortable mantra of "Hibbert = Crap", I think you should realise that actually Tony Hibbert is the most improved player in the whole team and has justifiably claimed right back position.
He defends his area as well as any RB in the League, which is clearly the first priority for a defender, and what he has added to his attacking game is the ability to put over quality crosses almost every time. It's not his fault we don't seem to have anyone with the intelligence to get to the back stick because I'm pretty sure we'd score more this way.
Although he is sometimes a little slow off the mark he is actually very rarely caught out for pace, being one of those players who recovers over longer distance. He is probably the best tackler at the club.
Those clamouring for Coleman to take RB should also see that the guy clearly can't defend very well. The thought of him there makes me shudder to be honest.
65 Posted 22/12/2011 at 10:35:35
66 Posted 22/12/2011 at 10:44:44
If you are happy to see crab like football then these players fit the bill but the world of football has moved on. It's slicker and requires players to be comfortable on the ball.
67 Posted 22/12/2011 at 10:55:36
I don't disagree - and please don't project ontp me perceptions that I want to see "crab like football" either.
You agree that he is a solid last ditch defender then, which is his priority.
I'd opine that the kind of free flowing football we both want to see then would be with creative players in the more forward positions first, not right back.
Build solidly from the back first. A world class defending and attacking RB would be much later on in this fantasy plan which has us playing like Barcelona.
Ed Note to Joe: Don't use angle brackets to delineate a quote ? HTML just treats it as a formatting command!
68 Posted 22/12/2011 at 11:18:53
I reckon Leon's overall figures outdo our so called Everton legend
69 Posted 22/12/2011 at 11:27:25
"we need pass and move type players, which Hibbert and Neville are not" That is exactly what Hibbert does. If no one is in front of him, he lays it to the side and heads down the line waiting/supporting. Actually watch the game and see how many time Tony gets the balls, passes it and then moves down the line for the return. If the player is in front, he passes it to him and either stays for the easy pass back or moves inside.
If only Saha could watch him a few times and remember that is what he used to do.
It's so easy to trot out the blame Hibbert line, but this season it is deffinitely not true. Our most consistent player this season by a long strech.
I 100% agree with you about Neville though!
70 Posted 22/12/2011 at 11:30:30
I don't think you can blame Tim for playing though - Moyes has kept selecting him when many of us feel he should be rested/dropped. For me that doesn't make him less of a legend.
71 Posted 22/12/2011 at 11:37:31
72 Posted 22/12/2011 at 11:33:40
Not too sure how accurate Wiki is but according to them, Tim has played 254 games for Everton since 2004 and scored 65 gals and had 37 assists.
Leon's page didn't have assists but since 2004 he has played 278 games and scored 40 goals.
73 Posted 22/12/2011 at 11:52:14
74 Posted 22/12/2011 at 12:10:34
75 Posted 22/12/2011 at 12:25:19
He is class but due to injury hes never showed his true form long enough. He's easily a £25 million midfielder and one day teams will come knocking.
Osman for me is a decent squad player but credit where its due hes really dug deep for the shirt in the last few matches. If ever we had a player who suffers because of the manager its Osman.
76 Posted 22/12/2011 at 12:13:35
77 Posted 22/12/2011 at 13:06:26
I feel Osman plays well when in the middle and not stuck out on the wing, hopefully he?ll stay in that position.
We played quite well last night, although we did lack a real cutting edge and I couldn?t see us scoring in open play. It is so crucial that we bring in a creative midfielder and a striker in January. Do I think it will happen? Nope!
With Drenthe, I liken him to a dodgy firework. Set him off, and watch him fly off in all kinds of mad directions not knowing where the hell he?ll end up, and not knowing if the end product will be a brilliant explosion or a dud! I think he?s boss!
If we set up right, his unpredictability can win us games. I don?t know what he going to do, his team mates are probably unsure what he?s going to do, so you can bet the opposition won?t have a clue!
78 Posted 22/12/2011 at 12:57:31
They've watched Everton for most of their lives, played a bit of Sunday league in their 20s, and might now coach their kids' under 11 team ? and as a result consider themselves sufficiently qualified to identify Moyes' now legendary "tactical niaivety", inability to implement a plan 'B', and failure to implement effective game-changing substitutions.
Honestly, some of you need to get down to Finch Farm and give him some tips.
79 Posted 22/12/2011 at 13:23:55
I tried. Didn't get past security. Obviously took exception to my shell suit.
80 Posted 22/12/2011 at 13:17:27
81 Posted 22/12/2011 at 13:41:02
Just one from last night - one or occasionally two isolated players trying to press the Swansea backline with the rest of the team standing, thirty yards behind on the half way line watching - you must have to have coaching badges to come up with that one.
And I take it you've never in your life commented that a certain piece of music, film, tv programme etc etc or indeed footballer is less than wonderful then?
You must be a saint. Some of us are just very frustrated fans.
82 Posted 22/12/2011 at 14:06:06
Tactically clueless, and up until recently would not make a substitution until 80+ minutes in. Time to move him upstairs to a Director of Football role as, even though we have gone stale under him, there is no doubt he has an eye for buying players at a low cost (mostly).
He has turned us around since his tenure began, but at 42 years old, I am losing the buzz over watching them, as the stuff served up has at times been dross. This season is lost, we might as well blood the youngsters and prepare for next year. We won't go down, so I see no reason in giving Barkley, McAleny, Vellios a regular game instead of Cahill and Saha, who are past their sell-by date and offer little to our play.
It is a cutthroat game, and it is time to move on to building the team with the youngsters that we have and build from there. NSNO
83 Posted 22/12/2011 at 14:29:20
I just mean that people have a view based on limited information and expertise but express it like its cast in stone. It's like walking into a heart operation and telling the surgeon that his incision is 25mm to low and the stents should have been inserted at a sharper angle.
As you say, very frustrating. I don't remember getting this frustrated with Everton years ago, so maybe it is getting worse or maybe it's just me getting older and less tolerant? I find Moyes's demeanour really depressing now ? nothing upbeat about him now.
But I maintain that whilst its easy for us to criticise and comment, the job clearly isn't that straightforward. And the bottom line is money. Maybe he wouldn't spend it well if he had it, but the top six spots are nailed on for the top six big spenders, and the rest of us are fighting for seventh. If we finish seventh (and we're currently seven points off a declining Newcastle) then he'll have performed well, albeit the football is gash.
That's why I prefer porn to Everton ? always a happy ending with porn.
84 Posted 22/12/2011 at 14:54:55
And to be fair I'd guess that fiddling about with someone's innards is a tad trickier than organising a bunch of millionaires to kick a pig's bladder (as it once was) in the same direction... but then again...?
Anyway, it's much much easier to 'criticise and comment' as you say, so I and hopefully you Dave and everyone else in the wonderful world of Toffeeweb will continue to do so whilst eating and drinking too much over the next week or so.
Merry Christmas all!
85 Posted 22/12/2011 at 15:29:05
Yes, you.
86 Posted 22/12/2011 at 16:24:32
Our players are shite but it's the tactics why we lose.
He has served us up Europe but he is tactically clueless
4-5-1 doesn't work but he had to date been consistently up there in the league.
Merry Christmas all
Thanks for another year of colourful debates Michael, Lyndon et al
87 Posted 22/12/2011 at 17:51:27
88 Posted 22/12/2011 at 18:13:07
89 Posted 22/12/2011 at 09:14:46
I only saw the first half last night but there certainly didn't seem a lot of support from midfield. When Gueye came on that made a big difference. I find it a bit depressing that our secret weapon is already coming under criticism for his shooting, as personally I am quite impressed by the progress he seems to have made since I saw him come on last year. Unfortunately he doesn't seem to be the tricky winger that many of us were hoping for. I don't think though it's really fair to criticize a player for not being the type of player you wanted him to be. He seems to be a creative player who operates better in a more central role, with a decent amount of pace.
The midfield seems a lot weaker than last year when we made a lot of chances but couldn't take them. Now we're not even really making a lot of chances. Arteta and Piennar are being missed I would guess. Not enjoying seeing Neville in midfield thougn to be fair to him, it's not really his position and if Rodwell was fit I reckon he'd be playing there.
Anyway enough moaning:) (can there ever be enough?) Here's to a better new year! COYB
90 Posted 22/12/2011 at 20:26:01
Joe Clitherow - Fair enough, Hibbo is the most improved this year. If I was in my 11th season, and I was the "most improved" in my team, I'd retire. The fact is, almost every other player has gone backwards this year, and Hibbo is finally playing somewhat reliably. Does not mean he is now a great right back.
Andrew Ellams - Care to list the teams that Cahill and Osman have both scored against? I think that's where the legend status will be determined.
Tony J Williams - You keep bringing 4-5-1 into this. Most of us in the Moyes Out Brigade have disclosed that it isn't the formation that is killing us, but the way Moyes plays it. It used to work. It doesn't now. He persists in playing central players on the wing, and has too many defensive midfielders (Fellaini is not an attacking midfielder in any sense of the imagination).
91 Posted 21/12/2011 at 23:01:50
92 Posted 22/12/2011 at 20:19:05
Moyes has always just had plan A, which is his cherished 4-5-1 that he has shoe-horned players into over the years. The players come and go, and very occasionally through luck we seem to strike the right balance, such as when landon arrived and we suddenly had pace and a threat down TWO flanks. Not surprising the results started coming.
Its true that Moyes has generally finished best of the rest, but over time Moyes demeanour has changed. He doesn't seem to have the energy and belief that he once had to galvanise a team like ours. We are frail at the back, generally clueless going forward and Moyes doesn't help squad belief by talking about knives and gunfights.
Moyes saving grace is his ability to spot decent players for next to nothing. However for all the talk about giving youth a chance, he still seems overly cautious, especially when it comes to attacking/creative players.
Its taken years for Gueye to get a chance of a decent start, god knows when we'll see Barkley again in the first team and even a seasoned player like Drenthe has had to bide his time while players like Phil Neville keep him out of the squad and journeymen like McFadden take up bench space.
This season we've been losing to the richer teams, which I don't mind too much - except for the complete lack of ambition to TRY to win those games - but we've also not being getting results against teams assembled for far less than our own.
Even in past seasons when we've "punched above our weight", we often used to beat the richer teams and often do really badly against poorer teams.
This completely disproves any notion that finance is the be-all-and-end-all when it comes to getting results. Actually I'd argue that team spirit, desire, workrate and confidence are more important than money, which is why last season Everton got results against: Man City, Man Utd, Chelsea, RS and Spurs despite selling players and buying no-one.
What worries me for our future is Moyes body language and press releases. In the past he has been talking us up, raising expectations. Now he's doing the exact opposite and its not surprising our results have gone down the toilet.
93 Posted 22/12/2011 at 21:00:00
In Fellaini we have one of the premier leagues outstanding defensive midfielders, yet against a swansea team, Moyes felt the need to go with 2 holding midfielders. Ossie and Fellaini would have been more than capable as a pairing and both can actually play good football.
In the event, all I saw from Neville was lots of poor passing and slowing our play down unnecessarily....and he and Fellaini stood on the half-way line afraid to get forward when we did break.
Drethe I thought was magnificent and there was absolutely no excuse for him being on the bench against norwich. That decision cost us 2 pts that day.
I thought Gueye looked great, and it was nice to see him getting in and around the box, creating chances and doing positive stuff that might've ended up with a goal or two on another night.
I feel sorry for saha, stuck largely on his own, without any support and expected to track back for corners, come deep for link-up-play and then be perfectly positioned for the crosses. Thats an almost impossible task for a world-class striker in his prime, never mind a 33 year old.
Our biggest problem is not having enough people in and around the box when we go forward. 1 or 2 everton players vs 6 or 7 swansea players was a regular sight especially when crosses were coming in. Its not surprising we didn't score more....and its not surprising that Cahill hasn't scored either.
94 Posted 22/12/2011 at 21:07:01
If Moyes has us consistently in the top eight with generally only the sky annointed money clubs above us, how on earth is this down to 'very occasional luck', it just doesnt make sense.
I agree with your point regarding Moyes outward persona at the moment. I reckon in part this is him making a point to the board, this is shown in some of his comments this season.
Confidence is indeed important, particularly in individual games, but the facts....that is to say the end of season league table, always but always has money in the top three places.
If it isnt money, and was more about confidence then squillionaire club owners wouldnt invest in players, they'd just routinely hypnotise everyone wearing the team shirt.
95 Posted 22/12/2011 at 23:00:21
This has sucked so far, but we're getting there. Up the Table we go.
Must ask, what did Swansea do yesterday that some find them "attractive"? Once we pressed them, they looked like what they are and will be at the end of the season; a Championship side enjoying an EPL cameo.
96 Posted 22/12/2011 at 23:15:18
He´s not the messiah you know
And how many games do we have him for again?
97 Posted 22/12/2011 at 23:50:06
How can anybody play 11 seasons in the prem and not prove your worth. He has been first choice player in a side that usually finishes in the top eight. Therefore by definition he is a proven top half premiership player.
98 Posted 23/12/2011 at 00:02:16
LD can play anywhere across the middle. He certainly is anything Miki (And I say this with all affection to Miki) ever was, only faster and a dramatically better athlete.
The pieces are in place for us to take it to teams. I'm saying it will coalesce with Landon in front of Fella, nothing more.
By the way, "he`s no playmaker, ball-juggling maestro. He´s not the messiah you know", also describes Arteta.
So we're no worse off for a couple months, are we? Good times coming. Up the Table we go.
99 Posted 23/12/2011 at 00:01:03
The best move of the match was at the start of the second half. It ended with a Superb Defence Splitting Pass from Fellaini to Baines who quared it accross the six yard box only for nobody to get on the end of it. Like many on this site you choose to ignore the evidence rather than admit you are on the wrong side of the argument. Fellaini was superb. Its not his hair or his trick its his ball winning, ball retention (86% pass completion tonight), his strength. He is the strong big match player Arsenal needed. Thank god they got the wrong one.
100 Posted 23/12/2011 at 03:17:35
If they're putting crosses into the box when no one is there to take them, they aren't good crosses. It's akin to a striker guiding a ball into the sideline at halfway. There is not fucking point.
101 Posted 23/12/2011 at 09:53:29
No, he was never up there with Mikel on terms of ability, but his consistency defending has been matched - albeit to a less impressive level - by his consistency going forward.
Give him a winger to link with and he'll bomb forward. I think he suffered with Osman in front of him; Leon would drift inside and the presence on the touchline evaporated.
103 Posted 23/12/2011 at 10:15:30
104 Posted 23/12/2011 at 10:18:55
105 Posted 23/12/2011 at 10:44:09
moyes has bought several players to replace him, he doesn't moan, gets on with it and inevitably gets his position back.
His crossing and forward play has improved dramatically (don't know who is training him because apparantly we don't "do" forward training at Finch Farm) but if we don't win, it's usually "Hibbert's fault" even though most of the goals seem to comr from the left side or the middle.
106 Posted 23/12/2011 at 11:33:18
107 Posted 23/12/2011 at 11:43:40
108 Posted 23/12/2011 at 11:41:35
<"If they're putting crosses into the box when no-one is there to take them, they aren't good crosses."
With all due respect; absolute rubbish.
In high tempo football games a good ball into the box is one which is not necessarily one where the crosser stops, has a look, composes himself and then plonks it on the head of the arriving attacker. If you haven't noticed, that's mostly what we have been trying to do and it ain't working.
My main criticism of Everton this season has been the tendency to take one or two extra touches to make sure ? in all areas of the pitch ? but in reality the split second advantage is then gone. We never break with any pace.
Good teams train and drill because they *know* that when they ping a good cross over into a dangerous area there will be someone around the end of it. Good strikers play percentages in making runs where 9 times out of 10 it is ? or turns out to be ? a waste of effort. We have Louis Saha telling us he is learning to be more "efficient" (aka "lazy") FFS.
So yeah, when Hibbert or Baines ping a cross over which beats the entire defence and bounces (bounces!) in space near the back post with no blue shirt in sight then that is a good cross wasted in my view.
109 Posted 23/12/2011 at 12:06:18
110 Posted 23/12/2011 at 12:16:20
111 Posted 23/12/2011 at 12:55:59
* "gone to ground" ..."scoring for fun"..(is there anyone who scores for misery) who thinks up these crap phrases?
112 Posted 23/12/2011 at 18:05:36
It would be acceptable occasionally, but like some of our assessments of Moyes, doing the same thing over and over again and it not working is insanity.
I'll admit, Hibbo is having a better season than most of the squad, but who in the squad would you say is having a good season. On all their standards, almost everyone is having a major sub-par season, from top to bottom.
113 Posted 24/12/2011 at 09:03:09
114 Posted 25/12/2011 at 10:04:43
Dominating in the air? When did Fellaini last score with his head or use it to stop us conceding at a corner? Fellaini is so great in the air that Cahill regulary picks up the opponents centre-backs and players who are dangerous in the air when defending corners.
I'll stand by my points, when did Fellaini last open up a defence, run the show or have ten good games that he influenced on the bounce? That's what top quality central midfielders have the ability to do.
What's arrogant is that thinking any player who plays for Everton after having no more than fifteen top quality games must be a great player.
115 Posted 26/12/2011 at 03:47:55
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 21/12/2011 at 21:49:20
Don't hold your breath.