Football Quarter Prospectus Launched

, 28 December, 94comments  |  Jump to most recent
New stadiums for Everton & Liverpool
Today, Everton and Liverpool fans launched their prospectus for The Football Quarter [4.7MB PDF], a conceptual development plan that includes ideas for redeveloped stadiums at the historic locations of Goodison and Anfield on either side of Stanley Park. The prospectus outlines a joint vision for the area surrounding both Everton and Liverpool Football Clubs.

It is the collaborative effort of two fan groups who joined forces to develop a deliverable solution to their clubs' long quest to solve their respective stadium problems. Based around individual stadia, The Football Quarter is designed to attract educational, community, recreational, leisure and retail facilities to an area which will have modern stadiums at Anfield and Goodison as its hub — all serviced by a sustainable transport infrastructure.

The prospectus is aimed at attracting developers to over 40 acres of land that has the potential to not only provide a better environment in which the football clubs can flourish but to make a significant contribution to the sustainable regeneration in North Liverpool.

Quotes or other material sourced from Keeping Everton In Our City



Reader Comments (94)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Gavin Ramejkis
1 Posted 28/12/2011 at 15:04:14
An admirable piece of work several years in the making, makes the failed ground moves look even more amateurish.
John Keating
2 Posted 28/12/2011 at 15:03:39
Well done to both KEIOC and SOS. No doubt there will be many posts slagging off the idea of the football quarter. The guys at KEIOC and SOS together with other parties have given up their time and efforts to at least put forward ideas which will stimulate discussion and other ideas and move the debate of both stadia and regeneration forward.

I was born and brought up in Everton and God knows the area could still do with some help. Never mind the club!!

Again, well done to all.
Joel Durkin
3 Posted 28/12/2011 at 15:09:41
An interesting concept which allows the club to retain individuality whilst remaining in the city.

However, it appears the prospect relies on commercial investments. It will be interesting to see what sort of businesses want to join.
Callum Wilson
4 Posted 28/12/2011 at 15:15:13
Bill is the luckiest chairman in the world, he fucks up two ground moves and the fans eventually do the work for him! Fair play to the guys who've put the effort in to create this.
Eric Myles
5 Posted 28/12/2011 at 15:30:57
Why do you have to pay to sign the petition?

Self defeating I would have thought?
John Malone
6 Posted 28/12/2011 at 15:27:11
Fingers crossed major investors take interset and see a future involving both football clubs, it would be great for the city!
Denis Richardson
7 Posted 28/12/2011 at 16:14:23
Interesting idea but the end solution IMO should be a shared stadium. Reduces the costs for both sides and ensures it is used every week and not every other week, so in relative terms earns double the money. Double the revenue and half the costs of a normal stadium for each club.

I know many fans on both sides are dead against the idea but I really dont see what the fuss is about. If redevelopment of GP is too costly or not viable due to land ownership issues, (same for the RS), then why not build one fuck off fantastic stadium for both clubs, which can also be used for European finals, internationals and concerts in the summer?

Can then add the usual commercial stuff around and inside the stadium, with revenue shared between the clubs for matchdays. Advertising revenues for the stadium would be higher as its used twice as much.

Just my naive opinion anyway, works for Munich, Milan, Genoa, Turin, Rome....
Jamie Saddler
8 Posted 28/12/2011 at 16:25:23
@ Eric Myles - You don't have to pay. Once you've submitted your information it asks you whether you'd be prepared to make a donation to the upkeep of the site, but records your signature anyway. I checked, and mine is on their list even though I didn't donate anything.

The proposals themselves are very impressive. But people need to get behind it if it's going to go anywhere.
Roberto Birquet
9 Posted 28/12/2011 at 16:39:13
Dennis

Interesting idea but the end solution IMO should be a shared stadium. Reduces the costs for both sides.
------------------
Hate to say but I reckon that's all down to Liverpool FC. We can't afford to be choosy, and maybe they can. And if that's so, they won't share. If it turns out they can't be choosy either, then it's a goer.

But quite frankly, we can't be choosy; unless the choice is: stay poor, and stagnate at best; or groundshare.
Tony I'Anson
10 Posted 28/12/2011 at 16:54:52
The prospectus says "Football Stadia. Our Prospectus does not attempt to resolve the stadium plans for either club. However, it is our understanding that the vast majority of the Supporters would, if given the choice, prefer their clubs to remain in their spiritual homes, famously either side of Stanley Park, if they could be expanded and modernised. The All Together Now Group call on both clubs to consult with their most important stakeholder, the Supporters on any future proposals."

It's not about stadia development, but the infrastructure around Anfield and Goodison. It will be up to the Clubs to decide whether or not to develop each of their respective grounds. No doubt there would have to be commitment from the clubs to stay where they are for the Football Quarter concept to work, and we would hope this would ultimately lead to ground improvements.
Ed Fitzgerald
11 Posted 28/12/2011 at 17:06:03
The idea of a football quarter is a very good idea and should have some form of commercial appeal to both clubs and potential investors. However the stumbling block is still the ground issue everybody needs to be both realistic and and recognise that a ground share on Stanley Park is really the only way forward given both clubs finances and the prevailing economic climate. The fans of both clubs deserve a state of the art stadium that reflects the cities tradition and place in English football otherwise our rival city at the other end of the M62 will surely become the dominant force on and off the field for many years. Everton (and Liverpool) for once need to show some foresight otherwise the future is looking rather bleak. We can still bloody dislike each other but it will be to both clubs and the cities mutual benefit that a solution is found and quickly.
Steve Brown
12 Posted 28/12/2011 at 17:16:37
"Working with the City Council, Dr. Alan Southern from the University of Liverpool and the private sector"..can one of the authors of the prospectus tell us 1) which private sector companies were involved 2) what financial commitments in principle these companies (or any other private sector investors) have discussed in principle with the authors? Thanks
Steve Brown
13 Posted 28/12/2011 at 17:21:42
Just want to know how serious this really is.
Steve Brown
14 Posted 28/12/2011 at 17:23:48
Because regeneration funding would only come from a ground share as Ed indicates, therefore it would need to be private investment.
James Morgan
15 Posted 28/12/2011 at 17:26:04
I'm up for a shared stadium if it's a world class facility. What would annoy me is however, that it would probably always be referred to as 'Liverpools stadium.'
Both clubs need a new ground, anyway. Hopefully this is a step in the right direction.
Danny O'Neill
16 Posted 28/12/2011 at 17:27:44
Haven't read the prospectus yet but initial thoughts are positive about the concept of a football quarter based around both grounds. In an ideal world it would involve both clubs keeping their stadium but in the current climate I too feel a shared stadium is a no brainer if private investment is required whilst it may not even be our shout (Denis @7, Ed @11 and Steve@14). Is that my preferred option? No. Could I live with it? Yes. Its not just that it works in other cities for some of Europe's biggest and most successful clubs (as highlighted above). Ultimately should both clubs have to make a decision that they have to leave their current grounds, the location rather than the nature of the stadium appears to be on the forefront of most supporters' thoughts (certainly Evertonians). It will be interesting to see how seriously this proposal gets taken. On a lighter note, would a shared stadium on Stanley Park not give us slight bragging rights given we are going back to our original playing field whereas they are moving to where it all began from a ground we vacated?!!!!
Sean McCarthy
17 Posted 28/12/2011 at 18:33:23
Nice idea but in the midst of the worst financial crisis in living memory (if not ever) I really cant see where the amount of investment, both public and private, is going to come from.

The L4 area is not a place where I can imagine major hoteliers investing especially with the glut of both affordable and premium rate hotels already in the city.
Its depressing that a city which prides itself in its football hertitage has 2 of the worst stadiums in the premiership and I for one cant see that changing anytime soon
Davie Turner
18 Posted 28/12/2011 at 18:38:07
" The fans of both clubs deserve a state of the art stadium that reflects the cities tradition and place in English football otherwise our rival city at the other end of the M62 will surely become the dominant force on and off the field for many years"

I been worried about Hull City FC for years too.

In seriousness though, this is a fantastic idea but needs more support from local government and business, i hope that support comes.
Martin Mason
19 Posted 28/12/2011 at 18:52:35
This is good thinking and for me even better with a shared stadium. I haven't read the proposal but surely if it means EFC contributing then it isn't going to happen. How about Council, Government or EU contribution. In Crawley the Council built a really nice new stadium for CTFC.
Richard Dodd
20 Posted 28/12/2011 at 19:40:07
I`m all for a shared stadium but that just ain`t gonna happen.Leaving that aside,I love this idea and were I advising BB,I would tell him to throw Everton behind the concept as well as making a PERSONAL DONATION to kick start it!
Phil Walling
21 Posted 28/12/2011 at 19:54:36
I suspect you`ll be waiting a fecking long time for that to happen,Doddy Lad!
Jay Harris
22 Posted 28/12/2011 at 19:51:08
Any initiative aimed at getting LCC and EFC execs off their respectives arses has to be good.

I wonder if state of the art training facilities could be incorporated and we get a reduced cost lease option instead of Finch Farm.

As it would be in the Liverpool 4 area I wonder if we could also propose an Everton 5 store as part of the development.

Continue to watch this space and go Wow when Billy liar finally backs something!!
Al Reddish
23 Posted 28/12/2011 at 19:59:34
...........THE MONEY FOR IT IS RINGFENCED
Mick Wrende
24 Posted 28/12/2011 at 20:29:54
Shared stadia do not work - show me a single example anywhere in the world which has worked to both teams satisfaction. But please do your research first before posting stuff like Milan etc
Tom Hughes
25 Posted 28/12/2011 at 19:37:03
This concept is for a framework that is intended to build on the assets we have, to maximise their potential....

Importantly, their combined potential via a "sum of the parts"-type logic that exploits the whole inter-relationship! It's intention is to attract investment and finance of all kinds, for development of the stadia and their surrounding residential areas and infrastructure. All within the extended context of the larger North Liverpool development programme, including Liverpool Waters, and of course linked to the on going North city-centre developments.

The proposals need not necessitate a shared stadium scenario... for several reasons. The main one being (as with the residential element) because so much useful capacity is already in place. Just as the intention would never be to knock down the entire housing stock of both areas, nor need it be the case for either club to completely start afresh.

Both clubs could possibly get up to their required capacity (and quality) by adding just 1 or 2 new stands. Thus preserving their separate identities within stadia that respond to their individual needs, and importantly reflect their histories. This is a key consideration that has to be taken into account when considering the sharing option....

Firstly, both clubs have completely different needs. Everton probably require a 45-55k stadium, whereas LFC may be looking for 75k+. Then there is the design: we have a tradition of double-deckers whereas they favoured large single tiered stands until recently... and I cannot see how you can rationalise the two identities into one structure.

The oft-mentioned sharing comparison with the Italian clubs will become a thing of the past in years to come (all the sharing clubs are looking for pastures new, and some have split already), indicating that all is not harmonious and indeed profitable with the supposed "no-brainer" model. Also, enabling or partnering developments might be more readily achieved and profitable at the separate sites, rather than at the one shared location. These could help towards the build costs of adjacent individual stands.

The Bullens Road side of Goodison Park has massive potential as only 2 roads abutt it, and the school is prime for redevelopment into a greater community-based school/education establishment.

The Park End also has great potential for almost any kind of development sitting on a main arterial road on a high profile corner over-looking the park.... just 2 miles from town, and only one mile from the extents of the Liverpool Waters scheme. Hotel/exhibition/conference centre would sit quite comfortably here.... perhaps attached to a new/extended park end stand with boxes convertible into hotel rooms (as at several other clubs).

These two developments alone would completely transform Goodison Park in terms of both capacity and quality. I think the project can help yield viable individual development packages, even if the whole scheme wasn't delivered in its outline form.

It's important to also remember that, if packaged attractively, it could also help attract the calibre of owners who could make the most of all the opportunities to give us what we need on and off the pitch (indeed it has helped already with regards to some of the interested parties mentioned recently). Therefore, it could preclude concerns for the inabilities of the current impotent owners. All in all, something to be backed and promoted to see what can be achieved.
Mark Wild
26 Posted 28/12/2011 at 19:56:33
Tough Love (A Different View) - The business we are in is entertainment, the market is leisure and tourism. Given the choice, do you go to Blackpool or the Bahamas? To get the City back up and running, Everton and Liverpool need to move, sorry but take the heart out of the argument and you'll see the harsh truth. We need a more attractive location on the Mersey nearer the City Centre.

I know this will provoke criticism but you only have to look a little down the M61 at Bolton, set in a more green setting with good transport links and part of a successful retail park and done on a budget. Yes, I appreciate the stadium is not great but it illustrates what could be done.

Plus look at the commerciality of the Arsenal ?solution?, they have pulled together a solution to ensure they will still be around for another 100 years. Will we still be around in 10? What is the appeal of an investor with £500m of Stanley Park?

When will the people of Liverpool, let alone Everton fans, focus their frustrations on the people who have slowly sucked the life and prosperity out of the city... the City Council? You don't need me to remind you that Liverpool was once a focus of industry and commerce, a mighty City with character and charisma.

Travel through Liverpool today and compare it to parts of Manchester, Birmingham and many other cities and it looks drained and tired. Drive around the city through the eyes of a stranger. How difficult is it for the council to tear down derelict buildings and return them to green spaces? There is so much more small and large that could be done.

All great empires have gone hand in hand with creativity and innovation. Please let's not forget our history was made through bold decisions. Dwelling on past achievements only makes us stale. If we are to open a new chapter, we now need bold decisions or we disappear into lower league obscurity. I love Goodison but how much income will the local community receive in two or three years if we do a Leeds and go down to the Championship or League One?

Coming back to where I started, we need a commercial decision ? one based on leisure and tourism ? providing that ?Premier League experience?. Businesses invest billions each year to advertise and associate themselves with powerful brands. You can see down the East Lancs Road, Manchester City are becoming a world brand. Brands take time but you can guarantee in 10 years time Man City will still be a Premier League team and probably a Champions League regular. Probably not the best examples because of the rare injection of mass investment but it highlights the point: we need to make ourselves attractive to investment.

If we are to attract people back to the City, projects like Liverpool One need to be generated and embraced. If we attract enough tourism and develop the City brand, business will follow. Liverpool as a city has so much to offer but it needs a hell of a lot more than the Council's superficial lick of paint! If tourism increases and businesses are attracted to the area, the prosperity will spread to all parts of the city through employment and taxes. There is no quick fix, the solution is at least 20 years of innovation, development and hard work lead by a dedicated, intelligent and innovative council.

This debate is actually bigger than Everton and Liverpool Football Clubs. Ultimately, the sooner we recognise the need to move, the sooner the club and city can attract new people and investment and begin the process of regeneration towards becoming a leading edge UK ? if not world ? city. This is about the prosperity of the City as a whole and the need for serious action taken by those who lead the city. The council are the catalysts of regeneration; let's remind them of their responsibilities!
Eugene Ruane
27 Posted 28/12/2011 at 21:11:02
Well done to all involved.
Mick Davies
28 Posted 28/12/2011 at 22:18:34
Mark Wild, you can't blame the city council for Britain's entry into the EEC, therefore leaving our city facing the wrong direction commercially. Or the extreme right wing governments that the rest of the country have elected to destroy public ownership and infrastructure to enrich greedy, usually foreign, individuals. The obscene cuts to local govt. and equally obscene payments to already super rich management has left areas like Merseyside feeding off European Social Fund handouts. The rise and rise of Manchester as the north's leading economic and football power has further fuelled the enmity between our two regions. So if is left to the two great clubs in our city to progress and not fall even further behind, we can't expect the council to foot the bill for what are, after all, businesses in the entertainment world. LFC fans will have to realise soon that their intransigence over sharing a stadium is holding them back as much as it is us. They haven't won the league for 20 years and aren't even guaranteed Europa league let alone CL qualification. The sale of our two grounds, maybe even the sale of Melwood and a shared training centre would bring much needed investment towards a state of the art football 'centre' in Stanley Park, with a historic theme to rival the Beatles industry in the city. So I would advise reds fans, stop being conned by yankee venture capitalists who have no interest in soccer, and to those on both sides who are reluctant to share a modern arena, remember, we work, drink with and even share our own homes with the 'enemy' so how hard would it be to sit in a seat that is occupied half the time by a rednose?
David Thomas
29 Posted 28/12/2011 at 23:17:16
Have any private investors stated they are willing to invest in this project. It all sounds nice but without anyone willing to invest the capital its never going to materialise.
Clive Lewis
30 Posted 28/12/2011 at 23:34:20
How does a shared stadium work in terms of financing, is it likely if we cannot pay the mortgage lease then will the banks turn to Liverpool and ask them to buy our half out. Leaving us with no ground eventually. Quite likely to happen considering we have no money.
Danny O'Neill
31 Posted 29/12/2011 at 00:02:22
Some posts in danger of getting political, but good to see all having their say - this subject is bound to generate different opinions. Mick @24: I am always one to consider (and accept) both sides of the debate, so do you have examples to back up your claim they do not work? Also, I suppose it depends on what you call satisfaction. Here are some initial (scratching the surface) findings:

Milan. Both clubs have shared since 1947. In that time, AC have won the following:

Italian League x 15
Coppa Italia x 5
Euro Cup/Champion's League x 7
UEFA Cup x 7
ECWC x 2
Euro Super Cup x 5

Meanwhile, during the period of ground sharing, Inter have recorded the following:

League x 13
Coppa Italia x 6
Euro Cup/Champion's League x 3
UEFA Cup x 3
Euro Super Cup x 1

In terms of working to both clubs satisfaction I would suggest that in terms of measurable success (which keeps fans satisfied), that ticks a lot of boxes.

Munich presents an interesting insight. Both clubs (Bayern & 1860) have shared 3 grounds since 1925. In that time the mighty Bayern have achieved the following:

Bundesliga/German Champions x 22
Deutsche Pokal (FA Cup) x 15
Leauge Cup x 6
Euro Cup/Champion's League x 4
ECWC x 1
UEFA/Europa Cup x 1

1860 meanwhile have won 1 x league title and 2 x German FA Cups in addition to being runners up in the ECWC. Interestingly they co-owned the new Allianz Arena with Bayern but in 2006 were forced to sell their 50% share to avoid bankruptcy.

Although I wouldn't compare us to 1860 it certainly presents a different outlook, although they continue to play there and have always shared with Bayern. More debate needed; inevitably there will be good and bad examples.

Moving away from the football quarter / L4 option, what are everyone's thoughts on Speke? I always thought it was something overlooked. Plenty of land available for development, great transport links (Airport, Motorway network, mainline rail) and within the city boundaries (which seems to matter to many).
Tony Waring
32 Posted 29/12/2011 at 09:43:12
Mark #26 and Mick @ #28. Interesting comments but Man City are hardly the team to quote. They "inherited" a brand new stadium which in turn made them ripe for an Arab takeover that has given them zillions to spend on whicheber player they desire. Mick you go back to the days when Blues & Reds walked side by side to each others' matches, something whuch rarely occurs these days. But it is nevertheless true to say that our families are made up of "opposite sides" and we get on with our lives. Time for a little more sanity all round and I sincerely hope this idea gets off the ground for all our sakes. A shared stadium is surely the best way forward though I'm not too sure about training facilities if both teams want to use them at the same time !
Mark Wild
33 Posted 29/12/2011 at 11:45:49
Hi Danny@31, unfortunately however you cut it, it is a political debate, lest we forget Liverpool City Council's block on the move to Kirkby. Unfortunately we are at risk of trading places with the likes of Southampton. What state will the local community be in when attendances are down to under 20,000 and no Sky TV money? More unemployment at best.

The reality is Kirkby has been the closest we have come to a 'solution'. Something that could attract new investment, provide extra income for the long term. We need a Kirkby solution near the city centre; Stanley Park is not the answer. I do agree though we are all on the same team and ultimately just want the best for the club. Happy to listen to all arguments to get to the right plan.
Tom Hughes
34 Posted 29/12/2011 at 12:22:16
Tony, the fellas who took over at Man City spent an absolute fortune just getting their team past ours. That money could've built us a whole new stadium..... therefore, I've always felt the stadium issue was bordering on irrelevant as regards that particular group. They could've built eastlands and/or a new Goodison many times over and still put together the most expensive squad in the world just using their small change.... they are literally that wealthy. They have even chosen a team with the biggest football club in the world over the road..... LFC are massive but they're not compared to Man Utd..... so, I don't think our stadium problems would've overly deterred them.
Tom Hughes
35 Posted 29/12/2011 at 12:34:08
Danny,
You are right to try to present a balanced argument as regards sharing.... it should perhaps also be noted that both Milan clubs won a few trophies pre-sharing, . The other thing to remember is that they had relative parity when the sharing arrangement started.... in that one wasn't the poor lodger (although Inter were the tenants), and both had roughly equally sized fanbases and honours.... meaning they both needed the same capacity. EFC and LFC do not match this criteria.

Another issue is that several foreign examples essentially share a municipally owned stadium which is probably not what would be on offer in Stanley Park.

Turin also paints a completely different picture to Milan.... whereby Torino never prospered after they started to share with Juventus at the comunale, then the del alpi. They had the greatest side in Italy in the 1940's (lost through a tragic aircrash).... and never rose to those heights again.... both Turin clubs now have their own stadia. Similarly with the rival teams in Rome who between them have won less domestic titles than Everton despite having a practical freeby for generations, and are both currently looking to relocate.... so for every Milan (where Inter still want to relocate too) there are several others for whom the arrangement has not really delivered success (and could be argued contributed to decline of one or both parties).... and there is certainly no example in the UK.

It could be argued that our city is different, and that perhaps there is more scope, but I'm not so sure. The Turin clubs have similar shared origins to our two in that Torino formed out of an historic split..... yet one has prospered, the other fallen!

The Munich example is even more pronounced in this respect. Therefore I'm a bit wary of this concept being seen as a natural pathway to sharing per se. For a start I think that it is not necessaily the case, and I also believe that ALL options should be considered/explored at this initial stage... and a rush to the sharing "no-brainer" might become divisive and stifle that process before it has had a chance to grow.

I am honestly open to persuasion otherwise, but at this point believe that there is a lot of hidden value in the separate identities (literally the sum of the parts etc), that I feel is watered down in any shared arrangement. I have always believed that your stadium is the biggest single manifestation of what your club is about, and as such is more than a structure to view footy from. There is a whole sense of ownership, and history that can help attract and keep fans who experience it and buy into it. Tribalism is very territorial after all. Vive la Difference?
Tommy Coleman
36 Posted 29/12/2011 at 14:23:38
I love the idea and effort that's gone into this. My only problem is funding this massive job. London 2012 Olympics will cost around £10B, what will the Football Quater cost if you include development of the stadiums ? £5B ? That's a big gamble for alot of investors.

At least it's got people talking though.
Tom Hughes
37 Posted 29/12/2011 at 14:46:02
Mark #33,
The Kings Dock should've been the real thing..... but for boardroom politics, and our complex ownership conundrum that has stifled real progress.

Destination Kirkby was never comparable nor viable in any respect...... all long since fully discussed, and filed under "failure".

The FQ concept is seen as a mechanism for generating interest and finance....by harnessing the two premier clubs as major anchors in such close proximity, and with pending regeneration programmes of surrounding districts...... all in conjunction with something new that feeds off all the parties involved, and others further afield. If you go on their website you will see it has the backing of several influential bodies and individuals already involved in redevelopment schemes of this scale. With others already showing a keen interest. Two of the groups mentioned as being in talks with EFC recently, also stated that the FQ idea was what gained their initial attention.
Carl Arnold
38 Posted 29/12/2011 at 15:04:32
This is the same idea which has been spouted and overlooked a million times before. Reason? MONEY!!!

Having a good idea is all well and good but having the money to bring it to reality is another matter. Rotherham, Anderson and the BU can all offer their 'support' over and over but without the required hundreds of millions, the couple of hundred pound spent on the blueprints and other 'research material' has been washed away.

As Mark @33 points out, Kirkby has been the only viable option and, but for the KEIOC crew pointing out the importance of Kirkby being in Knowsley, we would be readying ourselves for a brand new, state-of-the-art stadium with all of the facilities allowing EFC to enter the 21st Century EPL.

Instead, we are left with a decaying stadium, ageing team with no money, no chance of a takeover and with a fanbase more at odds with each other than even the disastrously poor team performances.

Oh, but wait; we'll draw up plans for an utter pie-in-the-sky idea for a 'Football Quarter'. Behave yourselves.

You reap what you sew people!!!
Michael Evans
39 Posted 29/12/2011 at 15:17:12
Carl@38 "... state of the art stadium" ? With all due respect, surely you are not putting forward the argument that DK was a panacea and that those nasty people at KEIOC ruined everything ?

Who's to blame for the dire, soulless "entertainment" served up on the pitch - the BU ?!

Tom Hughes
40 Posted 29/12/2011 at 15:28:10
Carl,
Bitter and twisted because you backed a non-starter perhaps?

Don't let your unnatural dislike for those who called it right years ago affect your judgement.

They called DK for what it was, and were fully vindicated by the endless lies and falsehoods that were exposed. Even the club accepted the outcome (otherwise they would have built it regardless), and the mistakes they had made, yet you still attempt to blame KEIOC?

You need to get a few facts straight before you comment..... the "state of the art stadium" is especially laughable.
Danny O'Neill
41 Posted 29/12/2011 at 15:26:57
Tom,

Yep, a real scratch the surface look last night. At face value a share option seemingly offers the benefits of a stadium worthy of the modern era and in most examples, it would be fair to assume this is has been the case. Then again so would our own.

I appreciate however there are draw-backs and hidden dangers, pros and cons as with any venture. Therefore as you suggest all options need to be investigated in detail and considered.

Okay, I apologies for the "no-brainer"; I was simply suggesting that from a business and investment perspective in the current climate it would seem logical. Then again, I'm no businessman!!! I also concur (as I did above), it is not my preferred option, I just suggested I could live with it should it happen (which I doubt anyway).

Mark - wasn't strongly against Kirkby actually and certainly not on the basis it wasn't in Liverpool (Carl @38). I hated that argument at the time as I think of large parts of Knowsley and South Sefton to be "Liverpool". Bootle, Kirkby, Huyton and Halewood all as Scouse to me as Dingle, Speke, West Derby or Wavertree to me. If we can't physically re-draw the boundaries (which are political not cultural), we can at least think like a city region rather than a city. Most successful cities now follow this model....funnily enough look no further than 35 miles down the M62!

John Keating
42 Posted 29/12/2011 at 15:42:19
Carl. What planet have you been on ??
The discussion is about the FQ and you are talking absolute shite about DK !!
I thought most right minded people by now knew the reasons DK was knocked back. Obviously you weren't on the planet during the inquiry.
Colin Wainwright
43 Posted 29/12/2011 at 15:46:54
''Kirby'', ''viable'' and ''state of the art stadium'', all in the same sentence!

Jesus wept!
Tom Hughes
44 Posted 29/12/2011 at 15:54:22
Danny,
The keep Everton in our city name wasn't really aimed at the "border" issue as such...... (although there was some concern about the future perceptions of the club as something peripheral, out of sight, out of mind etc). The membership would've been equally opposed to Speke (within the border) since the feeling was that it would be too far removed from the centre of the city and the higher capacity public-transport focus. I can walk to Speke, and would be opposed.... simply because the transport infrastructure can never match that of a more central site. Anyone who has had to go to the retail park recently will know what I mean..... almost permanent grid lock, and that's without a stadium! One dual carriageway in and out, and only a few bus services could not support it.
Danny O'Neill
45 Posted 29/12/2011 at 16:13:13
Hey Tom, not aimed at KEIOC - everyone entitled to their opinion and position on any issue. I just didn't like that as a reason for not going to Kirkby (thanks for clearing up by the way). The reason should have been because it wasn't a viable plan (which it proved not to be).

I still think Speke would be viable; appreciate what you highlight but those problems would exist in a central location. In fact if my thoughts are correct, less Scotland Road to the north, aren't most of the arteries into/out of the city pretty dire until a few miles away from the city centre (Edge Lane, Smithdown Road/Menlove Ave and Park Road/Aigburth Rd)> Yes, been past the retail park and ignored it because of grid-lock! Problem is, won't a new development attract commercial activity in the vicinity anyway? In Liverpool South Parkway and Hunts Cross, it does however have mainline and local rail links close by to ease the burden. That said, I am open-minded and Kings Dock for me was a tragically missed opportunity. For the setting alone where better in the city could we have gone?

Central or out-of-town, I have no preference as long as it's best for the club and fans, bearing in mind we'll never satisfy everyone.

Good debate, nice to agree & disagree with people on here without getting slated for having a difference of opinion(for a change) !!
Steavey Buckley
46 Posted 29/12/2011 at 16:29:38
I doubt very much that Liverpool FC will agree to a shared stadium. But 2 stadiums in Stanley Park? Possible. 2 could be built more cheaply, side by side, if someone can give Everton the cash they need to meet their obligations. If not, just Liverpool FC.
Tom Hughes
47 Posted 29/12/2011 at 16:31:56
Dan,
yes debate is good..... the FQ is a concept that needs discussion and engagement.

As regards sites.....The transport is key..... the nearer to the centre the capacity and service density increases dramatically. In Walton for instance there are multiple dual carriageways serving the area from all directions. There is also the convergence of Northern rail services also operating in both directions and not the end of line service of Hunts Cross..... ie 1 train every 2-4 mins at both Kirkdale and Sandhills as opposed to 1 every 15 mins at Hunts cross/S.Park way. Plus there is no comparison in terms of bus routes serving the areas. The city centre has services from every part of the city and metropolitan area.... and would be ideal in this respect. Capacity drops almost exponentially with distance from town.... and a stadium needs high public transport capacity (preferably rapid transit) more than any other amenity/venue as people arrive and more so leave en masse. Walton/Anfield has proven infrastructure that can be improved substantially and are easily fed from the city-centre.
Colin Fitzpatrick
48 Posted 29/12/2011 at 16:55:42
Mark #33 and Carl #38

If you?re going to comment on Kirkby I think the pair of you need to seriously read up on the facts surrounding what was a complete waste of time, five years, effort ,by the management team, and money by a club that has precious little. That?s not me saying that, that was the conclusion of the government inquiry which reported that the whole development contravened planning regulations and guidelines at a local, regional and national level and that Everton were unable to demonstrate how they could finance the £78m cost of the stadium which, even if 95% occupied on every single matchday, would only have generated £6m per annum. The development was undeliverable and this should have been identified at a very early stage.

All development proposals need to be deliverable and to do so you need several components in place the first of which is civic leadership. Here?s what the Council Leader, Joe Anderson, told the press and those assembled at the launch of the prospectus yesterday,

?The Football Quarter concept is something I strongly support. It is ambitious and should be, given the standing of both Clubs in the world of football. It is something that could provide an economic boost to the City and in particular to North Liverpool. I believe that all parties, the Football Clubs and the Council, have never had a better relationship; one that is based on trust and understanding. I feel that the Football Quarter offers real benefits for all and could be deliverable if we can continue to work together and certain things happen. The Council will continue to respect our relationship with both clubs and won't add much else other than to say if we can make it happen we will. Best wishes to you all and to both clubs for 2012.?

The next component needed is land. For the FQ the council has no money, they have to accommodate £50m of cuts in order to deliver their budget, which to set is a legal requirement; what the Council does have is land and over 40 acres in and around Stanley Park has been identified that could act as an enabler for the FQ to deliver a regenerative scheme that meets with redevelopment and commercial targets found within the North Liverpool Strategic Regeneration Framework document and the ?Rebalancing Britain? a policy document produced by Sir Terry Leahy and Lord Heseltine which explains how the Liverpool City Region should build on its strengths, one of which is identified as its two premiership clubs.

The final component is Partnership, this is where the funding, both public and private, equity and debt, gets provided along with the design, consultation, construction and delivery. Of course there needs to be a will between the partners to deliver the concept and yesterday it was encouraging to see the room full of people who included academics, representatives from the council, the clubs, the Liverpool Business community and yes, even some developers!

The components are being assembled, it?s a challenge but it?s coming together. The next step is to deliver a comprehensive feasibility study which builds on the earlier pre-feasibility study conducted by Dr. Alan Southern of Liverpool University who said yesterday,

?There would be clear economic, social and cultural impacts. One of the key issues is the level of leadership required to deliver this. There are small group who are crucial. The city council, the two football clubs who are private investors and the community, with other stakeholders including schools, business and the NHS. These people have to drive a shared vision. Of importance for the clubs is to be sustainable in the Premier League ? and both have had their financial problems. There are undoubted benefits of a Football Quarter. The fans would accept it and spend money there. If you go to Arsenal and walk down Islington High Street, it shows a real gentrification of that area. The challenge for Liverpool is to convince the private sector to invest in this area.?

There will always be well meaning distractions; I classify the shared stadium solution as one of these. It?s often accompanied by the suggestion that it makes sense, that it?s the logical answer to both clubs problems; is it? Let me see the empirical evidence, show me the report that proves this contention, show me the will. The reality is there isn?t a will amongst the owners of the clubs as both have vastly different target markets and require a tailored business strategy to exploit this, which therefore means that both clubs will have vastly different requirements, not to mention the UEFA financial fair play regulations which will place greater importance on non-matchday income; do you think either club wants to share their ability to raise revenue with a competitor?

No, proposing the shared stadium solution is the same as proposing that Moyes? names in his starting eleven for the weekend Messi, Iniesta and Ronaldo; neither is going to happen so let?s get behind something that might happen particularly when it has political support.

Other sites are continually mentioned, Speke has a major ownership problem and the owners can't move their business. Stonebridge Cross is a non-starter as it's dependent on a retail development and Knowsley will successfully object to any significant development and let's not forget, both Everton and Liverpool spent years evaluating all available sites in and around Liverpool and concluded that none were suitable.
Tom Hughes
49 Posted 29/12/2011 at 16:48:02
Steavey,
I agree, I don't think sharing is more than a theoretical option, mainly for the reason you gave.

The prospectus covers the options of Liverpool rebuilding Anfield in phases or relocating into the actual park.... whereas Goodison can be built in situ with remodelling of the areas behind the Bullens, for expansion on that side.... there is a natural impetus to redevelop this location that can aid the club's expansion.
Murdo Lang
50 Posted 29/12/2011 at 17:55:38
Great concept and lively debate, showing a lot of insight ? in particular, Tom (#47) hits the nail on the head: whichever stadium option is worked out, the success of any major sporting project of this sort hinges upon the quality of transport from major transport hubs like railway stations and bus terminals. Take a good look at how the Germans work it out, they can get 80,000 or so in an out of the Dortmund stadium in less than an hour.

As someone born on Everton Brow and in his mid-50s, having lived away from the city for many years, I am struck by just how little Everton/Breckfield areas have changed ? despite housing and leisure regeneration projects, the area otherwise remains much as it was when I was around in the 60s. Radical thinking needed, and the unbridled support of the City Council to make it happen? We have world class football clubs and radical thinking is needed to help the clubs develop their (still ) huge potential.

Again, credit to you all for the hard work and for keeping the debate alive. I am for a shared stadium, by the way, sat in Stanley park... I'm not precious; I can just see EFC's chances of redeveloping GP fast going down the toilet as our torpor drags on...
Anthony Jones
51 Posted 29/12/2011 at 18:46:50
I very much respect those that have contributed to this innovative document.

Forgive my ignorrance but I cannot help but see this as a nice idea that simply wont attract investment.

In the movie Field of Dreams, you build it and they come. It's not so simple in real life! Liverpool has shops and hotels in excess as it is. Would any of you invest in this concept to make money?
Tom Hughes
52 Posted 29/12/2011 at 19:02:52
Anthony, Liverpool's hotels have the highest occupancy rates in the country with several more being built as we speak, and more planned. Several existing chains wanting to build more, such has been their success (and not all in the city-centre)..... and all during a recession! Liverpool has bucked the trend in this regard.

Try getting a hotel room when Liverpool are at home for instance, or during several other major events. Give them another 25k seats and see that demand go through the roof..... similarly if we add more quality capacity, and/or exhibition/conference facilities.

Plus, you should also remember to not judge the area on its current state. The proposals are for several anciliary developments with year round appeal... and residential elements to build on the high density population and potentially adding further footfall, with the proximity to the city-centre also being a factor.
Tommy Hesketh
53 Posted 29/12/2011 at 19:20:02
Carl 38#,

You seem to have got lost mate, it's BlueKipper you should be posting on. As it's normally the idiots on there that still bleat on about having a "World Class" stadium for free!

http://www.bluekipper.com/news/13-misc__news/3712-keioc_issue_prospectus_on_football_quarter.html

No wonder we are in the shit with fans as stupid or ignorant as those posting on Kipper,

On a side note, outbid for Donnelly by the mighty Swansea, Jesus Wept..
Richard Tarleton
54 Posted 29/12/2011 at 19:28:11
The words "butter no parsnips" spring to mind, We'd all love this, but in practical terms , will this lead to buttered parsnips?
Colin Wainwright
55 Posted 29/12/2011 at 19:36:34
You've lost me Richard.
Mark Wild
56 Posted 29/12/2011 at 19:16:42
I am sorry to keep harking on with this point but the City Council are the lynch pin in this debate. May I highlight Man City would not be Sheik owned and have the vast wealth but for it not the work of Manchester City Council who competed and won the right to host the Commonwealth games. From which City inherited a world class stadium in an area ripe for redevelopment and within spitting distance of the city centre. This opportunity attracted international interest and investment. West Ham are on the verge of also benefitting from a similar scenario. Have people forgotten what a powerful City Liverpool once was. Have people lost the appetite to returning it to what it could be.


As for politics, it was Councillor Brady and co who spun the 'Liverpool City can not afford to lose another employer' line. The Kirkby decision was influenced by a lot of rhetoric. Why would the Government disagree when there are numerous other developments of this type including Bolton, Swansea and Coventry?

Councils have powers, they decide the moratoriums of where and when and how business and buildings can be built. I would like to see they same council get their fingers out use their powers to make a difference. Look at Cities like Valencia who have gone through vast transformation to ensure they maintain both their culture but are geared to be a city for the future.


The football quarter idea is a great idea but Stanley Park is the wrong location and a solution will not succeed without the support from a creative and entrepreneurial Council.
Keith Glazzard
57 Posted 29/12/2011 at 19:50:02
Tom Hughes says

"Capacity drops almost exponentially with distance from town.... and a stadium needs high public transport capacity (preferably rapid transit) more than any other amenity/venue as people arrive and more so leave en masse."

How odd. I thought that the objectors were complaining that you you couldn't walk to Kirkby, or to Speke, at 2.30, from the local.

As one of the many, many thousands who travel more than 30 miles to Goodison, and who get grid-locked leaving Walton I was always dismayed by the 'our city' mentality.

Good luck to them, but I see this proposal as having as much chance of success as LFC ever doing us a favour on or off the field.
Tom Hughes
58 Posted 29/12/2011 at 20:47:55
Keith,
Goodison Park has one of the best dispersal rates in the UK according Merseyside police and the football research unit. If you need a good route out of the city, just give me your address and favoured parking area. We always get away quite quickly.... if we don't stop for a pint in one of the many pubs available in the locality. After which the roads are usually clear. If you read about the public inquiry you will know that the transport strategy, even after multiple revisions was the laughing stock of the whole submission.... to the point that Knowsley covered their backside with a last-minute capacity reduction clause. They knew that stadium dispersal criteria could never be accommodated at that site, and would've reduced the capacity to 40k or less to reduce the nuisance factor for its residents. There is no need for capacity reduction or crush-loading trains at GP, and it hasn't even got a park and ride facility in place yet. Kirkby would've needed the biggest system in the UK, and still wouldn't have met its public transport quota........ nothing to do with walking from our locals. Mine is far nearer to Speke than Walton, and I still wouldn't want it there for the same reason I wouldn't want it in Kirkby. Out of town stadia are old hat, and contradict all modern stadium planning policy..... simple as that really!
Tom Hughes
59 Posted 29/12/2011 at 21:07:42
Mark,
The out of town retail shed park would've needed to be several times the size of the Trafford centre to have got anywhere near giving the enabling finance to fund the stadium (as was claimed in the ballot literature). As it was, the proposals violated all planning legislation and would've threatened the viability of several surrounding developments that were already in place and not illegal. Liverpool didn't spend billions regenerating the city centre to then set up a competitor within its catchment area..... as was the case for Sefton, West Lancs and St Helens who all had their own fully compliant schemes in place. This scheme had no chance right from the start.... and KEIOC were telling everyone, including the club that they were wasting valuable time and resources.

The stadium was a basic off the shelf barr design of little merit or quality.... and was perched on a site that could not support it. The club lost something like just £12m enabling by loss of the retail.... yet mysteriously still decided to not follow up on it. Is it any wonder after the exposure of all the defficiencies at the public inquiry? Il-conceived and fundamentally flawed at every stage..... and it really shouldn't have got beyond the initial idea phase.
Colin Fitzpatrick
60 Posted 29/12/2011 at 21:46:23
Keith #57,

?How odd. I thought that the objectors were complaining that you couldn't walk to Kirkby, or to Speke, at 2.30, from the local. As one of the many, many thousands who travel more than 30 miles to Goodison, and who get grid-locked leaving Walton I was always dismayed by the 'our city' mentality.?

Dear me; how any matchgoing Evertonian could believe and write such an opinion after all these years is beyond me.

The co-authors of the Football Quarter prospectus are KEIOC; here?s their closing submission to the government inquiry into Kirkby; take a read of it, let me know which paragraph includes the objection you highlight above. http://www.scribd.com/doc/11778132/KEIOC-Closing-Document-3rd-February-2009

During the inquiry I remember the day that the inquiry staff showed me a letter of complaint they?d received from some supercilious twat from Huddersfield; he was an Evertonian and it turned out that he was a Labour Councillor and a planning professional. He was claiming that he was being discriminated against by KEIOC using the phrase ?our city? and wanted KEIOC and their evidence removing from the inquiry. All of the inquiry staff were laughing at the letter, they regarded it as a joke, but it saddened me that an Evertonian could be so thick and so embarrassing. How could anyone go to the match, associate with fellow Evertonians yet believe such unadulterated bollocks I thought.

It?s still all about education, getting people to understand is a never ending process. Sadly some, like that letter writer, are beyond help.
Mark Stone
61 Posted 29/12/2011 at 22:32:06
Gavin #1, how does it make the 2 (3 including theirs) failed projects look amateur? I'm impressed with sentiment, but is it deliverable? Where is the funding coming from? Is planning permission possible? Etc etc etc

If it comes off, brilliant. Until then it's a pipe dream.
Peter Mills
62 Posted 29/12/2011 at 23:20:35
The proposal is very thought-provoking, and well presented. However, it is totally dependent upon both clubs staying where they are, and I can't see how Everton could make any kind of commitment to stay at Goodison.

One of the Club's main hopes must be that a developer would see Everton FC as a brand around which other businesses would group, it is just possible that this could happen at Liverpool Waters, with a new stadium in the dockland area acting as a catalyst for wider regeneration.

Tom Hughes, you have posted some very eloquent responses here ? do you or anyone else have any thoughts on this?

Whatever the merits of the FQ, it is good to see some intelligent discussion about potential ways ahead for the future of football in our city.
Mark Riding
63 Posted 29/12/2011 at 23:57:30
Could anyone please explain #54.. Butter Parsnips before I have to go to bed, as it will keep me awake all night thinking of what it means ?
Eugene Ruane
64 Posted 30/12/2011 at 00:09:49
Mark 63, my (late) father used to use the expression "Fine words butter no parsnips" in response to me saying things like "SIGHHH...I'm just ABOUT to do me homework" or "SIGHH..I'll tidy me room IN A MINUTE".
Karl Masters
65 Posted 30/12/2011 at 00:13:26
Colin 60.

Evertonian residing in Huddersfield? Where is Robert Elstne from? And, no, I Don't think he wrote it himself, but he might know the person who did....

It's too late for this stuff after midnight, probably just me adding 2 and 2 together and making 6. I wish Evertonians and the Club could all unite behind one vision and just get on with it. How nice that would be!

Good Night.
Mark Riding
66 Posted 30/12/2011 at 00:18:18
Eugene.. I now understand.. cheers !!
I will make an effort to use the phrase in work tomorrow..
COYB !
Mark Wild
67 Posted 30/12/2011 at 00:17:25
Tom #59,

I don't disagree with your post regarding Kirkby. Going back to my original post a Kirkby type commercial retail/business park on the Mersey close to the City centre is what is required. Stanley Park is not the future. It would take something special with regards to planning permission and the bringing together of complimentary businesses etc by the Council to start to make it feasible.
Steve Smith
68 Posted 30/12/2011 at 00:29:57
Tom @ 52
"Try getting a hotel room when Liverpool are at home for instance" Nice one !

Just had a read through the prospectus for the FQ and it's an exciting concept, I'm not really sure how it helps either club attract extra funding, or would pay for stadium redevelopment of either club.

As a regeneration project for the area in general, it sounds great, although it seems to me that the only involvement for the clubs is to stay where they are in order for it to work.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but when this idea was first mooted, it was an idea that was put forward as a way for both clubs to gain investment for redevelopment of their respective stadia, it now looks like a plan for private businesses to make a living from the success and history of both clubs by having them on their doorsteps.
Mark Wild
69 Posted 30/12/2011 at 00:17:25
Tom #59,

I don't disagree with your post regarding Kirkby. Going back to my original post a Kirkby type commercial retail/business park on the Mersey close to the City centre is what is required. Stanley Park is not the future. It would take something special with regards to planning permission and the bringing together of complimentary businesses etc by the Council to start to make it feasible.
Mick Davies
70 Posted 30/12/2011 at 03:14:16
Mark Wild, will you stop sniping at LCC. They have been hammered with the most draconian cost-cutting measures in history and if you remember, they bent over backwards for Everton over the KD site. It was the clubs lack of funding and direction which scuppered that historic opportunity.

The massive container terminal at Felixstowe left Merseyside high and dry as regards our traditional industries, and the accessibility of Manchester, Birmingham, London etc attracts investment on a scale we can only dream about. The only positive outcome of our two clubs' worst combined position since the 50s is the Blitz spirit which seems to have drawn us closer together and finally being prepared to work as a team for the first time since 1892.

So let's give all parties a chance and get behind any scheme which aims to progress this once great footballing city back amongst the elite, as it was in the 80s.
Danny O'Neill
71 Posted 30/12/2011 at 08:46:13
Murdo #50 (I think!),

Mass transport links are crucial to any site, be that exploiting existing (i.e. choose somewhere already well served) or ensuring a new site is adequately linked on match days.

The German example is one to learn from. World class stadia and affordable tickets. The outcome? Whilst they may not be as highly regarded as the self-proclaimed "best league in the world", I see (and correct me if wrong) a competitive league, healthy attendances and one that is still amongst the top in Europe in which genuinely top young talent flourishes (compare them to England in 2010). I acknowledge I am 2 years out of date, but a Bundesliga ticket costing approximately £15 also included free travel on all modes of public transport for the day. Incentive to reduce the level of cars on the road thus avoiding gridlock? Imagine that in this country or the Premier League? No, me neither!

Sorry to side track from the ground debate, it's just you highlight a very good point. The Germans have set the conditions (ground, facilities and fan-friendly initiatives) for their league to remain competitive. Ours is boring. Forget football; have incredibly rich owner = win (Man Utd being the exception having at least builty their success over a period and attracted the investment). The rest pick up the scraps playing "avoid losing" tactics (and we / Moyes aren't the only ones in that position).
Trevor Skempton
72 Posted 30/12/2011 at 08:47:05
Steve 68 and Mark 69

LCC cannot put large amounts of public money into the Football Quarter, certainly not in the foreseeable future. However, the practical value of the FQ for the clubs is that, through civic leadership and control of planning and development, the Council could deal with all the difficult and expensive issues of planning, transport and infrastructure, including the long-term stadium footprints. The scenario could be similar to Liverpool One, which was a partnership between a private developer and LCC, the former having the finance and the latter having a vision and the means to create the conditions for the development to take place.

Over the last few years, a wide range of stadium opportunities has been investigated, some in considerable detail, including shared stadia and dockland developments. It is clear that a shared stadium would upset many supporters [ask Fulham and Charlton fans about their efforts to get away from their previous ground-sharing and back to their 'spiritual homes'], and it would also run the risk of damaging the 'unique selling points' of each club as a business - there is considerable 'brand value' in both Anfield and Goodison [although closely identified with the respective clubs and so difficult to convert into a naming-rights deal].

The Football Quarter needs both clubs to stay in Stanley Park. The City Council could start the ball rolling with a detailed feasibility study, even if the clubs don't join in at the outset - they will join in when they see their opportunity to influence events to their advantage. The lack of decisive activity from both clubs in terms of stadium development over recent years is shocking, but there is a great deal that the public authorities can do to clear the route ahead, with a significant advantage of the Football Quarter concept being that the Council can be even-handed in dealing with these two competing businesses.
Alan Williams
73 Posted 30/12/2011 at 09:17:50
Mick Davies, I?m sorry Felixstowe did no damage to Liverpool at all. Liverpool?s old problems are down to several issues the main ones being the tide, the lock system and the militant work force.

The latter was addressed in the 90?s the tide obviously can?t change so they have invested hundreds of millions in to making Liverpool the only Port North of London that will be able to offload the large mother vessels from the Far East and the Indian Sub Continent along with enhancing the connections with the Atlantic trade. See attached. http://www.peelports.co.uk/port-news/mersey-docks/2011/06.htm.

Once these upgrades are complete this will bring massive amounts of investment and jobs to the area and Liverpool will be the gateway so the future for our City is excellent. Only last year the world?s largest shipping line Maersk closed its head office in the city of London and moved it to Liverpool, it has a turnover of $58 billion per year and the holding company can smash that, to date it puts no direct vessels in to the port yet it has chosen the City as its UK HQ along with other lines in the industry.

The City of Liverpool in my opinion is totally underachieving and it needs to realise that the potential it has can be fulfilled ? it just needs a more innovative approach and look forward not back.

The FQ is a start, but my personal opinion is both clubs will privately never do business with each other. Peel Ports have a lot of land that may be of use to either club, I would love EFC to take some land off Waterloo Rd.
Gavin Ramejkis
74 Posted 30/12/2011 at 09:47:53
Mark #61 at no point does the prospectus claim any falsehoods or lies or is underpinned by a power struggle for control as such QED pisses all over two failed ground moves by the so called professionals at the club. Not sure just what logic you use to include a third failure if by any chance you are suggesting the loop proposal which the club gave scant regard to despite not having spent a penny of their own money on it with laughable lies like DK would have a larger capacity and be more accessible. Stick to the two the club has fucked up and you'll be on the right lines.
Gavin Ramejkis
75 Posted 30/12/2011 at 10:05:07
Alan #73 it saddens me to see how slow Liverpool has been to rebuild and rebrand itself having watched Manchester completely transform and that wasn't just down to the Arndale bombing it has gone on for years, Liverpool got fits and starts with the Albert Dock and virtually nothing else of note and then Liverpool 1. I'm currently program managing a takeover in one of the graces and can testify to Tom's statement about hotel occupancy as I have several colleaguies from Scotland struggle to get accomodation whilst working for me.

Liverpool needs regeneration and to drop the infighting and look at the longer term prosperity it brings. Developments very often reciprocate more developments as an area become the "location" to be at.

Keith, I've travelled to GP from outside the city for decades and found it much better than so called retail sites right next to a bloody motorway like Bolton or Reading to get away from.
Richard Tarleton
76 Posted 30/12/2011 at 11:06:36
I've signed the petition and voted for world peace and an end to poverty in the Third World.
Colin Fitzpatrick
77 Posted 30/12/2011 at 12:19:03
Alan #73,

I?m wise enough not to challenge anyone when they?re on their ?home turf? so to speak but answer me this; yes admittedly there was a history of militancy amongst the dock workers, not just in Liverpool, and the history and reasons behind that is another debate, but wasn?t the catastrophic decline in the workforce inevitable whether they were militant or compliant? Wasn?t the introduction of new handling technology in the 50s and 60s the death knell for all docks as mass employers?

I understand that the port today handles more than 30m tonnes of cargo every year with very few dock workers due to those advances in technology that, like in many industries, banking, printing to name just two, would have happened irrespective of workers fighting for their rights or not.

As with everything the world moves on and so must Everton; the current board are unable to move the club forward so their plan now is simply to sell the club. The stadium situation will still need to be addressed and it won?t be addressed without the full cooperation of the council and the development of a plan that conforms to local and regional plans ? unless we find a money no object owner but don?t hold your breath, I?m not!
Mark Stone
78 Posted 30/12/2011 at 12:55:29
Gavin #74 this is a proposal for a joint venture between Everton and Liverpool. Now, unless I've missed something and Liverpool are playing in a shiny new state of the art stadium on Stanley Park, there is a third failed ground move (hence 'theirs').

And the fact remains, this proposal is only as good as it is deliverable. Is it affordable? Will planning be possible? If not it's just a pipe dream. Don't get me wrong, I'm 100% behind this idea, I've nothing but positives to say about the people responsible for driving it and I truly hope that it becomes a reality. But to say it makes Kirkby and the Docks look amateur is plain daft. Hopefully we'll look back in 10 years and see that it has done just that, but at this early stage with no details of who is going to pay for it etc ... it's not even in the same ball park.
Tommy Hesketh
79 Posted 30/12/2011 at 13:11:52
Gavin 74#,

Program Manager???, gizza Job mate.....
John Keating
80 Posted 30/12/2011 at 13:19:41
Alan 73. Yes I've always wondered why Peel never got more involved utilising their land for stadia and associated amenities. Certainly anything around the Dock Rd area could utilise a Ferry terminal to dispurse supporters from the Wirral/North Wales/South.

One point of issue: I have to agree with Colin, Technology was the main death knell for the Port Of Liverpool.

I've been calling in to Rotterdam since 1970. Europort is 10 times bigger than Seaforth and to all intents and purposes apart from the actual container cranes, is totally mechanised and manpower free. Containerisation was the end of Liverpool.
Alan Williams
81 Posted 30/12/2011 at 13:53:37
Colin, what you say is correct in part and the ?militant? are not exclusive to the city, in fact you can add every UK and EU port to the same issues as we had but, rather than change with the times, they chose to take on the MDHC and fight for their working rights which is nothing to be ashamed of at all. The problem was they wanted to keep rules such as nepotism on new vacancies which is just madness in today?s HR world.

The company stood its ground and won to the changes as they had people queuing up for the jobs which is very sad for the old workers but sometimes its better to sit around the table rather than allow your testosterone to takeover.

Liverpool has and still has some of the quickest vessel offload times in the country and that just shows what good workers they are and they are part of the reason why the port will again be one of the assets to the region.

In hindsight, the word 'militant' to describe all is probably a bit too provocative; don?t wish to sound like a southern Tory! LOL. I worked in Manchester for 15 years and Liverpool is 10 times the city they ever will be ? we just need to realise it, and at last I think we do.
Colin Fitzpatrick
82 Posted 30/12/2011 at 14:24:32
Alan, you forgot the chinless fella! lol

What about this post panamax facility in the river, is this still happening and will it have an impact or are we too late?
James Flynn
83 Posted 30/12/2011 at 14:12:21
Great thread. Being American, I learned a lot reading this dicussion. The only thing I can think to add is that LFC's new ownership will likely back the idea.

As a Yankee fan, they own baseball's Red Shite, but no denying they are very good businessmen at running a professional sports Club.

Can't see them letting "tradition" get in the way of an idea that will reap them financial benefits.

EFC ownership, on the other hand . . . . . . .
Alan Williams
84 Posted 30/12/2011 at 15:50:52
Colin, the larger vessels would come under the panamax project as they would berth on the estuary as apposed to entering the dock via the lock system which has size and tide restrictions which stunts growth. The new berth could house two of the large 9000 capacity container vessels which would give the region a direct link to FE, ME and ISC and the benefits to the region are enormous, without sounding like a geek its like Speke Airport overnight becoming Heathrow, the opportunities for the NW and the City of Liverpool are just massive. Liverpool will once again have the ability to handle global cargo direct which hasn?t been seen for a century. We are on the up!! Let?s hope EFC ride the wave too, sorry couldn?t resist the pun. Happy New Year to all.
Mark Stone
85 Posted 30/12/2011 at 14:45:54
Mark, #26 I don't disagree with your sentiment but one thing you said (a bit off topic) really bugged me.

''Travel through Liverpool today and compare it to parts of Manchester, Birmingham and many other cities and it looks drained and tired.''

There certainly are some run down parts of Liverpool, but there are equally grim parts of Birmingham and Manchester. Huge parts of Liverpool are actually some of the most beautiful parts of the country (as far as suburban residential areas go).
Peter Laing
86 Posted 30/12/2011 at 16:08:25
All the best Alan, I've read your last couple of posts and although there is a lot that we do not agree on your aspirations for Everton and the wider Liverpool region as a whole are very much welcome.
Carl Arnold
87 Posted 30/12/2011 at 15:59:45
I thought my earlier post would incite allkinds of reaction from the ToffeeWeb / KEIOC / BU lot in a way that has been proven but, in all honesty, it's like posting racist vitriol on a black power website ? only I'm not looking to cause offence.

Even so, I still feel my points are not only valid but are shared by the MAJORITY of blues fans. The same MAJORITY that voted in favour of the proposed DK move - which, may I add did not go ahead on the principle that the retail park would be "too large" not because the stadium was unsafe or unsuitable (for that see GP), not because the management, players and everybody at EFC did not want it, and certainly not because of any brainwashed fools from within a 3-mile vicinity of GP walked down a street holding flags and banners.

We all know DK would have been a much better option than any other on offer and most definitely better than the incumbent, decaying and ridiculous death trap we play at now.

The budget had been allocated and was achievable. The required £78m would be offset by the sale of GP, naming rights and various sales of the numerous executive boxes, etc the new stadium would have provided. But hey, don't worry, we are still at GP (see above for the adjectives used to describe it) and we have no money, no chance of a new stadium, and are in danger of falling behind 70% of the EPL.

As long as we didn't move to Kirkby though eh?
Colin Fitzpatrick
88 Posted 30/12/2011 at 16:08:28
Alan #84,

Sounds positive, had heard about it on many occasions just wasn't sure, even after government approval, that it was going to happen.

Heard about the Maersk relocation, assumed that was tied into the development at the port and I?m aware of the common ownership of the port, airport and ship canal which will see a coordinated approach to freight movement; great to see things are looking up and it?s not all doom and gloom.

Yeah, you have a good one and hopefully meet up in the New Year.
Colin Fitzpatrick
89 Posted 30/12/2011 at 16:25:27
Oh and Alan, to ride the wave you need a decent board! I'll get my coat lol
Eugene Ruane
91 Posted 31/12/2011 at 00:44:31
Carl (87) - this might sound like a frivolous question but I assure you, having read your posts, I'm ABSOLUTELY serious. Ok, my question is this. Do you have hooves?
Phil Bellis
92 Posted 31/12/2011 at 01:00:08
Carl
There are 2 Ls in bollocks
Colin Fitzpatrick
93 Posted 31/12/2011 at 01:07:43
Carl #87

Let?s not forget the £52m contribution from Tesco, you forgot to mention that and I notice you also left out the contribution from the sale proceeds of Bellefield which was on the wish list but your income from the sale of the new boxed wasn't.

Let?s also not forget what the government inspector really said about Everton?s ability to finance the move in the report into Destination Kirkby by the Secretary of State:

?Furthermore, the financial structure of EFC and its ability to fund the remainder of the cost of the stadium is far from clear. No financial evidence was submitted by the club to demonstrate how the remaining £78m would be raised, apart from a breakdown of the potential sources of funding for the stadium.?

Let?s also forget that even with the stadium filled to 95% capacity, using this failed finance package which you so willingly believe in, which clearly would have been greatly more reliant on debt finance than admitted, the stadium in Kirkby would only have generated an additional £6m contribution; clearly this would have been significantly less if nothing at all.

You keep on keeping on with the nonsense you post and you?ll keep getting shot down in flames; I personally find it quite embarrassing when an unfortunate on here starts telling posters why DK failed. Like I said to another, read this http://www.scribd.com/doc/11778132/KEIOC-Closing-Document-3rd-February-2009 and try not to revel in your own ignorance.
Tom Hughes
94 Posted 31/12/2011 at 12:10:34
Carl..... Everything you've said was conclusively answered or disproven several years ago on multiple threads and more importantly at the public inquiry. Destination Kirkby was never a viable option in any respect. Even if a new cash-rich owner came along, it would be the least desirable of all the options that would then present themselves. As outlined numerous times, the transport issues are not readily resolved. Kirkby will always be an end of line location, and a once a fortnight event venue will never have the desination status to merit the level of infrastructure investment to change that. Stadia need mass public transport, Kirkby will NEVER have the same transport capacity and flexibility of Walton, and certainly nothing approaching that of the city-centre. By far the greatest proportion of our match-day attendance comes from the city-region conurbation.... and to push the venue to the periphery of that catchment is logistical nonsense. Hence the reason why most new stadia are being located as close to downtown areas as possible. The stadium design itself was also weak..... there wasn't a great amount of exec/corporate provision as you've stated.... less than all of our competitors, even less than the likes of Coventry, Sheff Utd etc and far less than Spurs have already. DK was a square peg in a round hole.... and a marriage of convenience that only ever suited third parties and not EFC. It should be, and is thankfully consigned to history. FQ has far more about it.... with focus on all the parties in equal measure.
Tom Hughes
95 Posted 31/12/2011 at 12:33:54
Peter #62,
I would love us to have a stadium near to the proposed Liverpool waters developments..... as there are several similar examples world wide that have been great catalysts for these types of development.

However, I think KEIOC have had talks with Peel to that effect, and little has been forthcoming as yet.

The whole issue is a moving target of course and things can change, but there are several constants and already solid foundations regarding the FQ that can be built upon: Both areas are going to be development hotspots regardless, because of the issues affecting them and their importance to North Liverpool and the inner city generally; Liverpool FC are going to stay in the viscinity whatever happens; The Park exists and is a quality focal point in terms of the space available and the historic value, and is already being refurbished to a high standard; The council and local universities are on board and can be major players in the FQ's future; The Bullens Rd/Gwlady St school site and the Park end are also prime sites for major landmark developments on a main arterial city-route.... with much redeemable from the existing structures at both stadia. There is a lot in place, and a lot that isn't already harnessed....... all of which when added together means opportunity.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads