Moyes acknowledges dwindling crowds

, 3 January, 95comments  |  Jump to most recent
David Moyes cites the lack of entertainment from his team this season as the reason for the slipping attendance levels at Goodison Park this season.

The Everton manager admits that the paucity of home victories has done nothing to entice fans back to the Blues' home games.

"I am a football supporter, first and foremost," Moyes is quoted in the Daily Mail. "I know how it works. If I am winning games, supporters will turn up. I, as manager of Everton, have not won enough games this season for them to come.

"I have not entertained them enough. We have not scored enough goals. I need to do that to get the supporters to fill Goodison."

Of course, while there has been plenty of criticism aimed at Moyes for his lack of adventure and rigid loyalty to certain players and formations, many Evertonians would argue that it's the loss of flair players, the dearth of hope for the club's immediate future in general, plus perhaps broader disillusionment with the unbalanced state of the domestic game in general, that lies behind the falling home crowds.

The home game against Norwich last month saw the lowest gate at Goodison Park for nine years and the average home attendance for the 2011-12 so far is nearly 3,000 off from last season.

Quotes or other material sourced from Daily Mail



Reader Comments (95)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Shaun Brennan
1 Posted 03/01/2012 at 23:17:54
So how is he going to correct it?

Mark Riding
2 Posted 03/01/2012 at 23:25:42
Get 'Sayers' back doing the sausage rolls..
Easy..

Oh, two up front against the likes of Stoke, Norwich may help..
Paul Knox
3 Posted 04/01/2012 at 00:14:52
Moyes has to blame himself, it has taken him all season to find out and the fans have known all season. He is so up himself. WBA Sunday the subs bench told the story and what a difference when he used the subs. Then Moyes, after the game, praised Victor (rightly so) but did not mention Denis, who played a center forward role, allowing movement for others.

But will Moyes learn from this? Hopefully he will as this is the first time he has made changes without being one goal down.
James Flynn
4 Posted 04/01/2012 at 00:10:29
Good he used the word entertainment. However passionate we are about EFC, soccer is entertainment, just like all sports unless you're playing (and even then).

Over here, we've had player strikes in every major sport. None of us liked it. But guess what? Life just went on. If any of us wanted to watch a (pick the sport) game, we could.

Professional leagues are the universal luxury. We cant our budget to affording tickets, traveling, amenities etc. We, everyone one of us, know exactly what the team has to do and where the manager/coach failed in contributing to a defeat. Since most of us have played most sports we support, we absolutely know, beyond question, why XX player fucked up. Even in the disappointment, it's fun.

When things are going well, more folks are present/watch on TV. When things aren't going well on the pitch (or ownership is so egregious), fewer folk spend money on the team.

Nothing new here. What else is Moyes going to say? Professional athletics is entertainment.
Sean McKenna
5 Posted 04/01/2012 at 00:34:36
I think he might play 9 defenders to entertain us tomorrow night..
Alex Kociuba
6 Posted 04/01/2012 at 02:41:45
I think the reality is that people are getting made redundant left, right and centre. People are poorer than they have been for a long time, yet tickets are at an all time high. The economy is fucked, the bankers and governments are robbing the whole nation. The fact were doing shit on the pitch and providing little entertainment only compounds the attendance problem, as evidenced by previous seasons when we've performed even worse yet had consistently higher attendances. 5,000 seats left on the Friday? Then invest in the future and give the tickets away free to kids - or local charities etc.

TL;DR Reduce the ticket prices to fill the ground accordingly! Basic, logical and fair.
Steven Pendleton
7 Posted 04/01/2012 at 04:19:16
The economy and it's current state is a cop out Alex. The approach Moyes employs and the monotonous formation he ALWAYS employs have led to fans to find other ways to entertain themselves. And given our over defensive setup, I can't see any new fans looking to jump on board.

Let's face it, we are as boring as all shit.
Mick Davies
8 Posted 04/01/2012 at 04:44:54
When you think about it, if someone paid to see a play and the actors were awful and the plot very amateurish and boring, they'd demand their money back and never go again. We football fans are a strange lot. Even though the show is unexciting, non-entertaining and expensive to watch in a rickety old stadium while players, managers and agents are earning more in a week than we earn in about 5 years, we still go back, knowing exactly what we're in for. Crazy isn't it?
Andy Codling
9 Posted 04/01/2012 at 06:05:37
Alex it has nothing to do with Finances on my part, I packed my ST up this year because I would rather put my bollocks in a bees nest than watch Moyes dire soul destroying garbage.
Karl Jones
10 Posted 04/01/2012 at 08:52:16
The cynical sale of the much loved Mikel Arteta (who had signed a mega five year contract the previous summer), after all the season tickets had been sold is a major reason. It made it hit home that Everton is a club once again in decline more than anything else that had gone before.

Also, the way Sky/ESPN are handing out the TV money to certain teams (How many times have also-runs Liverpool been shown this season ?), makes me wonder whether there is an agenda to try to form an elite top six as hinted at in the article.
Dave Wilson
11 Posted 04/01/2012 at 09:17:26
The figures I`m looking at would suggest are average gate is just below 34,000 and last season`s average was just below 36,000 - can somebody check this out ? - a fall of just two thousand.

With Spurs, Arsenal, Man City, Newcastle and Chelsea still to come the difference is likely to be even less.

I reckon this is the only thing Kenwright actually gets about our club. Despite the ugly football and the fact that he has given nothing at all back to the fans in terms of new players coming in. He knows he can rely on the almost logic defying loyalty of the Evertonian.So does Moyes
David S Shaw
12 Posted 04/01/2012 at 09:40:25
I think there's more to it than the football we're playing. People want to see a club going somewhere or at least trying to go somewhere, we are not. We'er going backwards, the momentum and promise from a couple of seasons ago has gone.
Dave Roberts
13 Posted 04/01/2012 at 09:36:52
It's all about the money.
I love Everton. I've supoorted them for nearly 50 years and have watched them home and away at much more dire times than this (anyone recall the 1-0 loss to QPR in the mid 70's? I hitched there and went all over to watch a poor team). I've dropped our season tickets because my son's gone to UNI and as a public servant I'm being made to pay for banker's greed by an untruthful government. I've seen 3 home games this season and yes it's poor but I just love being there at Goodison. As for Arteta, it was time for him to go and good luck to him - but DM must be allowed to spend that money when the right player is available - he's not a fan of January window buys so we might have to wait. As one of the posts above suggested - getting Sayers back in might help - Metro serve overpriced rubbish! COYB
Stephen Kenny
15 Posted 04/01/2012 at 09:47:37
I'm glad Moyes recognizes this. I also hope he recognizes actions speaks louder than words, something I'd love to see him pass on to El Capitano next time he feels like dishing out another rallying cry through the rag most blues don't even bother to read.

I think guilt has kept a lot going this year, that's what got me.
Kevin Gillen
16 Posted 04/01/2012 at 09:43:58
I don't think we play ugly football or buy the idea that Moyes is defensive minded. We simply aren't good enough in the opponents' half. The other day we were better than WBA and attacked a lot more than them. We slaughtered Norwich and QPR both of whom parked the bus. We were the more ambitious team in the derby. Most of the teams above us have invested millions in top class midfielders and strikers. It's not rocket science to work out why we are where we are. The Premier League and Sky have shafted football in this country and we have a board that have stood still. We desperately need a new model for football in this country. Affordable ticket prices and wage caps would be a start. Then you might get the government to invest in state of the art stadiums. They're never going to do it whilst the madness of this unregulated market goes on. The Premier League has to act and fast. Football needs a reality check.
Ray Roche
17 Posted 04/01/2012 at 09:41:19
I thought long and hard about renewing my ST this season. If it were not for the Early Bird sweetener I doubt very much if I would have bothered. You can get a seat for just about ANY match, let alone unattractive opposition such as Stoke, Bolton etc. and the Utd, RS, City matches will probably be live on TV anyway. But it wasn't the sheer cost of the ST, it was the liklihood that we will,once again, sell our best players. Arteta leaving at the last minute underlined that. Pienaar was another, no effort made to motivate the Yak, but plenty of effort to get him and others off the wage bill,. No investment of the incoming transfer fees. It was also the prospect of the dour defensive and negative fare that is now the norm under Moyes. I can accept that we are not in the best of financial health but until there is a change at board level that will not improve, and there doesn't appear to be any Cavalry coming over OUR hill right now. If things are just the same as they are now, I shant bother to renew next season, and I doubt if there aren't others who feel as I do. And, by the way, I've supported Everton since the 1950's and had my first ST in 1964 so it's not as if I'm a Johnny Come Lately. Friends who, for different reasons,have had to stop going have now got out of the habit and miss it far less than they thought they would. OK, they'll still look out for the results and argue Evertons corner in the pub but once they've gone it's difficult to get them back. Everton, and Kenwright and Moyes, should be warned.
Kevin Sparke
18 Posted 04/01/2012 at 09:42:59
It's the economy - and if you look at all teams in cities suffering under the current economic woes you'll see attendances down across the board... out of 20 Premier League clubs, the last time I looked attendances were down at 9 of them; out of these 9, 7 of them were from areas hit by the economic debacle inflicted upon us by the friends of the bankers, the politicians (North East, North West, and the Midlands)

Unless the clubs do something proactive to counteract the drift. If you look at Newcastle United they had a 'fire sale' of half season tickets at much reduced prices and made up for a shortfall in attendances of nearly 3% earlier in the season (when they were in the top 3). They're now more or less up to full capacity.

If you look at the last time the politicians fucked up the economy in the 1980s, I think the year we won the league for the first time in the 1980s average attendance was about 28K.

Aslo worth bearing in mind is the average age of punters - in the 1980s it was something like 27 - now days it's late 30s and as these guys lose interest (or more likely, lose income) The amount of young fellas with disposable income to buy season tickets become less and less.

Playing attractive, winning football probably has something to do with the decision whether to go or not - but in an economic recession that decision becomes easier to make if you've not much 'poke' to waste.

Ray Robinson
19 Posted 04/01/2012 at 10:01:23
I think that anyone who refuses to acknowledge that falling entertainment values has not had some effect is a little deluded. However, I think that the general economic climate is also having an equal if not bigger impact.

My take on the matter is that we have lost about 3,000 season ticket holders but that this has been partly offset by some imaginative pricing offers. However, with tickets reduced for several games (rightly so), a buy one get one half price scheme in place over Christmas, plus the fact that most season ticket holders have to miss one or two games a season for various reasons, the club may have to recognise that next year, with an increasingly dire economic outlook, some season ticket holders may well review whether it's worth re-newing.

That's when it's vital to be playing attractive football - so that the lapsed season ticket holders decide to turn up on the day.
Tony J Williams
20 Posted 04/01/2012 at 10:05:26
I support Everton FC, not Moyes/Kenwrong/Baines etc.

I go to watch Everton, yes I would like to be entertained but mostly I just want to walk out of the ground knowing that we have just earned another 3 points.

Unfortuantely I may not be renewing next year but it has nothing to do with Moyes or the wway we play, it is a financial decision.
Ray Roche
21 Posted 04/01/2012 at 10:10:39
Kevin Sparke

Kevin, our average attendance in
83-84,was19,288
84-85, 32,118,
85-86, 32,388,
86-87, 32,977
87-88, 27,782
Interesting and illuminating facts for those
who thought the ground was packed every week,eh?
Kevin Sparke
22 Posted 04/01/2012 at 10:17:33
And you still couldn't get Wembley tickets Ray and in the 1980s Wembley was like a home match - all those ladies with big hats had no bother though...
Phil Bellis
23 Posted 04/01/2012 at 10:07:36
Ray
Lot of sense in all you say
I also left it til near midnight on D-day to renew - it was guilt, thinking about shared memories and the thought of looking across and seeing someone else in "my" seat that swung it
My lad doesn't go to Goodison any more - still Blue in all but home attendance; I go out of "duty" recently, never been so uninspired by an Everton team since Walter - even dear old Gordon Lee had King, Dobson, Thomas, the Latch et al
Barry Rathbone
24 Posted 04/01/2012 at 10:05:00
First off Moyes comes out supporting kenwright contrary to his supporters now he's saying people are staying away because of his football.

HELLO!!! - LMA awards? best of the rest ?

Get with the program Dave - stop being anti Moyes.

I hate it, I hate it, I hate it, I hate it, I hate it, I hate it, I hate it, I hate it, I hate it, I hate it, I hate it, I hate it.
(lies down and sucks thumb as dummy still missing)
Ray Roche
25 Posted 04/01/2012 at 10:34:39
True, Kevin, Wembley days were brilliant. I feel for the younger supporters who've never experienced the joy that success brings, but they still turn up.
Sam Hoare
26 Posted 04/01/2012 at 10:37:55
Moyes has being playing Cahill behind a lone striker pretty much since he arrived so i fail to see why suddenly that is the difference this year.

If anything it is the state of the economy and possibly the act that he was forced to sell two of his most entertaining players (Arteta and Pienaar) without being given funds to replace them.
Ray Robinson
27 Posted 04/01/2012 at 10:37:24
The crowds in the 80's were significantly lower everywhere but don't forget that several thousand were allegedly lost off each gate due to, shall we say, turnstile / VAT anomalies!

If I recall the stands were half empty because most people chose to stand up - cheaper and better atmosphere.
Mick Gallagher
28 Posted 04/01/2012 at 10:42:59
Sam #25 Cahill hasnt looked the same player all season maybe time is catching up with him. He might be better off with a rest and coming off the bench for a few games.
Roman Sidey
29 Posted 04/01/2012 at 10:40:26
Could the lower attendances in the 80s have something to do with the higher amount of games played in those days? I know the league itself was a longer season, and I assume, perhaps wrongly, that we regularly played more cup games as we were a more competitive side. Just a thought. Could be way off the mark, but, as I was barely a twinkle in Dad's eye in the mid-80s whilst he was policing Brisbane, I don't quite know all there is to know about the 80s. What was the capacity then?
Roman Sidey
30 Posted 04/01/2012 at 11:00:09
Sam, it could be the case now, because he is no longer scoring goals like he used to.
Ray Roche
31 Posted 04/01/2012 at 10:55:08
Ray Robinson.

Even if crowds were lower at most clubs an average of 19,288 was a direct reflection to the dross that was being served up. Yes, I know we finished 7th for a couple of consecutive seasons but fans were generally unhappy with the style of play. If you remember, the previous eason we had less than 13,000 turn up for the Coventry game. As I remember, Mike England was sat in the stands and the rumours, repeated on the radio, were that it was Kendalls last match in charge and that England was going to replace him.
Peter Laing
32 Posted 04/01/2012 at 10:51:58
Fair play to David Moyes for acknowledging the elephant in the room regarding the falling attendances, he also appears to want to cop the blame for why fans are staying away. It is more than can be said for Elstone and Kenwright. I am one of the many who did not renew my season ticket and have not been to a game since Wolves at home. The main reason that I am choosing to stay away is the fact that not only have I become disenchanted with the EPL and greed of player's but also the fact that Everton have become boring, stale and predictable. In any business, particularly 'entertainment or leisure' of which I believe football is, there is a need to keep the product fresh, contemporary and vibrant. Putting aside the obvious parochial, tribal and emotive reasons for following the team we are stagnating and without wholesale change the Club will continue on its present course of decline. I havent missed going to the match at all and my stress levels have certainly dropped, you just end up doing something else and spending your hard-earned money on something else !
Ray Roche
33 Posted 04/01/2012 at 11:09:13
David Moyes has got an elephant? Fuck me...


I thought he'd play it at the back. You know, parking the elephant....
Peter Laing
34 Posted 04/01/2012 at 11:11:04
Nah Ray you must be mistaking The Chang mascot for Johnny Heitinga !
Ray Roche
35 Posted 04/01/2012 at 11:13:09
Quality, Peter, quality!
Ray Robinson
36 Posted 04/01/2012 at 11:06:28
Ray Roche - I never mentioned the quality of play in the early to mid eighties - I do indeed admit that some of it was dross. I was really trying to explain why we only had an average of 32,000 in our first championship winning year of the 80's. The recession in the 80's was the worst that I have known but, allied to this, there was perceived fiddling of the gates to avoid VAT payments. Also, spectator violence put a lot of people off.
Alex Kociuba
37 Posted 04/01/2012 at 11:08:18
Steven Pendleton: "The economy and it's current state is a cop out Alex."

Andy Codling: "Alex it has nothing to do with Finances on my part"

I'm guessing you two, and other similar posts haven't had their income stripped from them yet like thousands and millions others have nationwide. Not having a job means spending £40 to watch Stoke at home is an impossibility.
Kevin Hudson
38 Posted 04/01/2012 at 11:10:27
To me this also reads as a scathing attack on the constancy of "support," demonstrated by some Evertonians.

Whilst I completely understand that many have neccesary financial priorities above visiting Goodison, those that CAN still afford to go, but refuse to on account of diminishing entertainment value, are NOT supporting the club through hard times.

(See attendance figures at Elland Road, and Man.City in League One, as evidence of the 'through thick & thin,' argument).

I also imagine that there are those who have dropped-off, and had the nerve to join-in the; "Where were you when you were shit?" chant - aimed at Chelsea supporters post-Abramovich.
Brian Waring
39 Posted 04/01/2012 at 11:17:11
Its not as if the economy being in the shite has just happened now, its been like this for a few years, but attendances weren't down last year, or the season before.
Sam Hoare
40 Posted 04/01/2012 at 11:15:15
I agree that Cahill is not firing on all cylinders (far from it) and probably deserves to be dropped. But i struggle with people who say people are staying away because Moyes refuses to play two strikers. He hasn't done this for some time so it seems odd that that is the main reason.

Incidentally i have been watching Swansea a bit recently and i really think Brendan Rodgers looks like a good manager. Unlike Holloways Blackpool, Swansea look very organised and tight at the back whilst also being very pleasing on the eye when they have possession. All on zero budget. I know he's only got half a season in the Premiership under his belt but if Moyes were to leave, he would be my top choice at the moment to step in.
Alex Kociuba
41 Posted 04/01/2012 at 11:18:39
By the way if you were inferring that I was in some way deflecting blame from Moyes' dire football - I wasn't. I think Moyes is turning into Walter Smith by the week. In fact, I'm beginning to think I'd rather have Walter than Moyes. I've been to most home game this season (luckily I have a job again, and know a couple of people who can't always make the game) and I think its possibly the least entertaining football since I started going the match regularly in 94/95 season.
Alex Kociuba
42 Posted 04/01/2012 at 11:22:25
Brian Waring: another person in a secure job who hasn't yet personally suffered.
Ray Roche
43 Posted 04/01/2012 at 11:22:05
Ray Robinson

I agree with just about everything you say. There were obviously reasons other than the on-pitch performances that would contribute to lower gates but if you are being served up great,exciting, attacking football you would be less likely to ditch your ST and possibly find some other way of cutting your cloth.
However, I'm shocked and disappointed that you should consider our club in any way less than honest in it's VAT accounting. Shocked.
Tom Hughes
44 Posted 04/01/2012 at 10:38:28
Dave Wilson,
I think our average this season is just under 34k (so far) and last season it was just over 36k.... the season before: just under 37k. Our current figure is despite having played both Man Utd and Liverpool, and even after some aggressive ticket sales strategies over the christmas period, when both visiting clubs also brought healthy followings.... otherwise we would have seen our first sub 30k league attendances in years, and a much reduced average IMO.

Considering that in the mid naughties we were regularly posting full house signs (averaging almost 39k, even with 4k obstructed views) it is quite a steady decline, even in an era of relatively steady league-placings. That period was the time to show ambition and push on.... the positive attitude of team and fans was growing, and that momentum should've been built on. Instead we got minimal investment in the team, and nothing in the stadium, with the KD and DK debacles epitomising the current board's ineptitude. Practically all other clubs have been successful in addressing these issues. We simply haven't!

I am seriously concerned about the long-term effects of dropping attendances. As shown in previous eras, the decline can snowball as friends decide en masse to pack it in, and attendances can drop dramatically, seriously affecting the club's well-being and also its general perception........ then getting the fans back and new fans can be a real uphill struggle, especially after they've discovered all the various other modern methods of following the team from afar (for nothing). I think we are seeing this already, and given that we haven't an endless supply of new fans clamouring to get in to Goodison the future could be bleak if not addressed soon. Many other club's have grown their fanbase during the premiership era (and not all due to great success on the pitch), we have practically stood still with no evidence of a strategy to sustain our current fanbase let alone grow it. Personally I think our fans are responding to the serious, and serial lack of ambition/investment by the board, which has in turn reflected in the quality of the team and the stadium. The over-riding current mantra being "why should I put my money in when they haven't? Or, I'm not backing them anymore!". The economic situation doesn't help, but I think our decline predates that even, and is more deeply set in how the club has been poorly run.
Ray Robinson
45 Posted 04/01/2012 at 11:30:14
Tom, I agree with nearly everything you say but I do give credit where it's due and I think that the club have been proactive in trying to gain new fans - in the form of Everton in the Community. I have some first hand experience of their efforts - albeit some years ago- and believe that they are a credit to the club and that their work far exceeds those of other similar clubs.
Phil Walling
46 Posted 04/01/2012 at 11:32:32
The thought of Cahill and Saha starting up front AGAIN tonight will probably put a few off!
Moyes is being eulogised in the media over this holiday period,particularly since his `masterstroke substitutions`on Sunday.
When is he going to realise that games are there to be won from the kick-off-not just in the second half.Bit like his philosophy that only the second half of the season counts.
Tom Hughes
47 Posted 04/01/2012 at 11:43:32
Ray,
I agree that "Everton in the community" is a great scheme, and truly proactive... and has great potential for future growth, with lots to build on.

However, I was talking about us not having taken the opportunity to harness the whole premiership attendance boom, by adding high and medium-quality capacity, and by reducing the ludicrous number of obstructed views. Several clubs have registered their highest ever average attendances in this period, we don't get close, and couldn't even accommodate our record average (or anything like it).

The community stuff is a great start, but only the tip of the iceberg without the rest....
Brian Waring
48 Posted 04/01/2012 at 11:43:37
Alex (#41) As I say, the economy has been in dire straits for a good few years now, but fans were still going the game up to this season. There has been plenty of lads on here, and lads I know personally, who have ditched their season tickets because of the dire football we serve up, and because of the way the club is run.
Obviously the economy has had an effect on the situation, I just don't accept thats the main reason.

I know a couple of Villa fans down here, and they say they have the same spin put on their falling attendances ' Its the economy fault ' But they say the same, they know of loads of fans who are refusing to go because of the shite served up by Mcleish.

Stephen Kenny
49 Posted 04/01/2012 at 12:04:17
My own opinion is that Supporting Everton is second only to feeding and clothing thier children to many.

I know a few who have lost jobs etc who have continued to go and I know plenty who won't go because they wont put money in Bill's pocket or refuse to pay to watch dire football.
Alex Kociuba
50 Posted 04/01/2012 at 12:11:27
Brian, I'm not blaming some mysterious concept called 'the economy', I'm talking about thousands of people losing their jobs, struggling to pay rent and keep up mortgage repayments, keeping a roof over their children's heads etc. There are more people currently unemployed since 1991 with no end in sight to the ongoing redundancies.

On a less extreme level, Moyes' football just doesn't offer value for money. Ticket prices remain high, and continue to rise to counter-balance the increasingly high player wages and spiralling costs of servicing an ancient ground like Goodison. Its always about the money; do you not think we'd sell out if tickets were £15-20?

Some people who refuse to go to a team they've supported through thick and thin in the past are sometimes too embarrassed to admit they can't afford it any longer.
Mike Elbey
51 Posted 04/01/2012 at 11:57:09
The drop in attendances is primarily down to a combination of dire, defensive tactics by Moyes and a complete lack of ambition from the board.

I along with 7 other people have had a season ticket for over 20 years. Last year one of the group jacked it in as he was sick of Moyes defensive tactics. This year is looking like being the last for another 2 due to Moyes tactics and I along with the other 4 are seriously wavering - the reason being Moyes tactics.

It's all very well Moyes saying that the attendances are dropping because of the dire football but does anyone think having identified the problem he is going to change his strategy ? Or will we get Neville and Heitinga in midfield again tonight with one up front and a player supporting the striker who has not scored for over a year - all this against statistically the shittest team in the league.

If Moyes comments are to start convincing people to stay or return then let's see a positive line up tonight, not tactics that are based on us still being in the game with 20 minutes to go so that we can then 'go for it'....

Let's see Donavan, Drenthe, Anichebe start giving some pace and strength up don't or let's see Strach start alongside another striker with a couple of wingers. Let's not see 7 outfield defensive players picked in a home game against shit opposition !

I have said it on previous threads, Evertonians traditionally don't do protests like the RS, hence why the admiral work of the Blue Union goes largely unsupported by many. What Evertonians do historically is vote with their feet, and if the current negative tactics and boardroom stagnation continue within 3 seasons our gates will be down to about 25,000 or less....
Tony J Williams
52 Posted 04/01/2012 at 12:28:03
"The drop in attendances is primarily down to a combination of dire, defensive tactics by Moyes and a complete lack of ambition from the board" ? Why can't it be a combination of all three? (finances)

Two of the lads I used to go with simply can't afford it anymore. I have to do some soul searching next season to see if I can justify the cost.

Moyes's tatctics were the same 3 years ago, yet there wasn't a significant drop in attendences then, it probably went up.

In fact, if we are to believe it, Moyes's tactics haven't changed in 10 years, so why now the drop off?
Tony J Williams
53 Posted 04/01/2012 at 12:32:52
"Let's see Donavan, Drenthe, Anichebe start" With you on the first two, but Donovan hasn't played in the Premier League for two years, Drenthe was injured and Anichebe has played half an hour of footy in months.

We will have used all our subs up at half time to cover them all
Dave Wilson
54 Posted 04/01/2012 at 12:14:53
Tom #43

I`m convinced that the average will have risen slightly by the end of the season, but I`m in complete agreement with you about the steady decline.

I suspect the regular 37k+ crowds will never return on a regular basis if Goodison is left as it is.
Fans can view the whole match from the comfort of their own home and are far less likely to fork out 30-odd quid to sit behind a post.

I believe the decline in numbers are due to many things, but I simply cant accept Brian Warings claim that it's down to the style of play.

Matches being shown live in local alehouses and high quality internet service are relatively new, cheaper alternatives.

The only way to get back the crowds is to improve GP - or find a better alternative within the City - and back the manager sufficiently enough to give him half a chance of achieving success.

The loyalty of the Evertonian has always amazed me, but this board is testing it to the absolute limit.
Robbie Muldoon
55 Posted 04/01/2012 at 12:48:57
The only thing I have had to cheer and enjoying watching was the spraying cross field passes produced by Barkley in the QPR game. Liverpool, Man Utd, and Stoke have all been void of anything impressive. (Nice to see karma bite Suarez on the arse though for the derby antics.)
Dave Wilson
56 Posted 04/01/2012 at 12:52:12
"In fact I dont believe Moyes`s tactic have changed in ten years, so why now drop off"

Anybody ?
Peter Laing
57 Posted 04/01/2012 at 12:50:00
Kevin Hudson your support is admirable, and the 'through thick and thin' mantra will always be valiantly triumphed during lean times. My personal decision not to 'support' the Club during these hard-times is based upon a complete loathing and lack of trust in the board and its lack of vision for Everton. The current policy of developing the youth to be sold on at a profit or the sale of our better player's such as Arteta has the net result of where we are at - stagnation. The only feasible way that I can protest against such policy is to stay away.
Tom Hughes
58 Posted 04/01/2012 at 13:07:57
Peter,
I know a few real diehards who have packed it in precisely for this reason. When I say diehards, I mean fellas who have barely missed a game anywhere in the world over the past 30+yrs. They see it as the ONLY real way to register a protest, and for them to to take this stance demonstrates clearly where we're at as a club.
Phil Bellis
59 Posted 04/01/2012 at 13:30:40
Dave,
"The only way to get back the crowds is to..."
produce a winning team playing attractive, effective football
Trevor Lynes
60 Posted 04/01/2012 at 13:37:35
Years ago when money was scarce (50s and 60s) people came if they were entertained... I played football with southport and Buxton and wanted to see top players who could do better than I could. However, what we see from Everton is very poor entertainment and although the results are important in maintaining our Premier League status, most fans want to be entertained!!

I watched Spurs and the brand of football they play is now the best in the league so even if they dont win the league title they are really entertaining to watch. When I watched our 60s side that was built by Johnny Carey they played the best football I have ever seen from any Everton team since... we truly were the school of science then and that team had gates of over 60,000 every week simply because the team was a joy to watch even when finishing 4th in the league.

We have been totally starved of top class football for so long that nowadays we make so called legends out of players who would not get a game in a decent team.

So long as we stay mid table BK will not spend money... it would take a relegation struggle to get any investment from this present board and this is patently obvious to me if not the rest of you.

We do not have one 'real' star player who can light up Goodison and if we did... BK would sell him to the highest bidder.

I for one have lost interest and so long as EFC survives in the premier then that is all any fan can expect from the bunch who run our once great club.

If we played like Spurs we would fill Goodison twice over. When we played Liverpool years ago in the FA Cup both grounds were filled to capacity and thousands were locked out... that was when BOTH of our city's great sides were the best and Man Utd, Chelsea and Man City were also rans!!

And we did it without foreign players to bolster the sides.
Stephen Kenny
61 Posted 04/01/2012 at 13:43:31
Dave,

ten years ago, even five, the tic-tacs suited the personell perfectly, it was innovative and it was effective. Most knew that was the best side we could put out, playing to the best of thier (limited) ability.

Now it's none of those.

The argument that it has got us finishing fairly high up the league on a consistent basis is a fair one and one I wouldn't knock.

But the unknown is could we have finished just as high or higher playing a different style? Could we repeat the 4th place finish by coming up with a new style that takes the whole league by suprise?

Some of us would like to find out.

We have always been the side were the sum is greater than it's parts. I can see the basis of a really good team with what we've currently got. I think a change in attitude could see us doing well and competing against richer sides, whether we've got a right to or not.
Rob Teo
62 Posted 04/01/2012 at 13:30:02
Tony#51 and Dave#55: "In fact, if we are to believe it, Moyes's tactics haven't changed in 10 years, so why now the drop off? "

My view is that 4-5-1 served us well in years gone by when we had the players who were able to produce attractive football playing that system - e.g. Pienaar and Baines on the left, Arteta in the middle/right, Donovan on the right, Cahill (when he was in his prime) in the hole, etc.

Unfortunately, we have since lost the players who can play well in that system, or that the players who used to perform well in it are no longer able to do so (Saha, Cahill, Neville, etc).

If memory serves me right, the slide to dire football while playing 4-5-1 occurred midway through last season, just after Pienaar was sold.

I don't live in Liverpool (nor the UK, for that matter), so going to GP regularly is out of the question for me. However, I can empathise with some of the local fans who have chosen not see our team live, simply because I, too, have chosen not to watch Everton on some occasions when the cable TV stations here have opted to screen their games, even though I could have done so "in the comfort of my own home" and without having to fork out 30 quid.

Why? Because watching Everton play these days doesn't excite me at all. I feel a sense of frustration whenever I've seen them play this season and last season, coupled with a sense of depressing inevitability - i.e. I can pretty much guess who's in the team, the formation, the times at which Moyes will make his substitutions, the style of football, the "must-not-lose" mentality that pervades our play, etc.

My belief is that finances and the uncertain economic times are also part of the reason for the dwindling crowds at GP. However, to say that the negative style of football that is dished out by Moyes and his team is not an important factor in causing fans to turn away from watching them live (or on TV for that matter) is simply erroneous.
Peter Laing
63 Posted 04/01/2012 at 13:58:16
Rob you reap what you sow, if you lose your creative forces such as Arteta and Pienaar the quality of performances are affected and game of others will suffer, ie, Baines this season. Couple this with the fact that there are no funds available to replace the afformentioned players, the manager is relying upon loan player's and those well and truly passed their sell-by date (Neville, Cahill, Saha), and to a lesser extent Hibbert and Osman, and you end up with the mediocrity that is currently being served up.

I believe that Moyes is also probably running scared of the possibility of losing Rodwell and Barkley, and given the fact that we cannot score in front of goal has concentrating his efforts on shoring up the defence, making us hard to beat and thus producing unimaginative football. Hypothetically speaking, given the £100 million that Daglish has had to spend can you see Everton getting beat 3-0 by Man City and Spurs away ?

Kenwright is killing Everton, the writing should have been on the wall when Rooney was either pushed or walked. I know Moyes is paid handsomely for his efforts but his loyalty to kenwright still amazes me.
Tony J Williams
64 Posted 04/01/2012 at 14:05:14
Rob, I agree with you and that's why I asked Mike why couldn't it be a combination of all three?

The non-change of tactics in 10 years still stands though. They are the same but the problem now faced is that the players have changed, gone are the skilled players and in their stead are the grafters.

Posters will argue that it is Moyes team because he has bought them....yes that's right but as a manager you would expect a replacement if you sell your best ball players, not having to try and unearth another gem from the loan pool or a freebie.
Denis Richardson
65 Posted 04/01/2012 at 13:36:58
Kevin Hudson - appreciate what you are trying to say with the thick 'n' thin arguement but I think we also have a higher chance of seeing change at the top happen faster if crowds go down.

Regardless if pro or anti Moyes, the real problem is the ownership - if attendances start dropping off a cliff, the lenders will start asking some serious questions of the board if they see a big risk in repsect of getting paid their money back.

I for one am happy that people are voting with their feet and think a lot of this is down to the team/tactics on display (as said above, the crisis started in 2007/2008 but attendancies have been falling significantly this season). Whether the team/tactics is Moyes' fault or not, the more empty seats at GP the more Blue Bill will shit it.

Also my view is that football is supposed to provide entertainment and/or hope of improvement in the future. The current situation at GP provides neither. If the management at least appeared competent, trustworthy and had sound plans for the near/mid term future, many fans who have stopped going would probably still be going out of the thick 'n' thin principal. However, if they feel the current management are useless and we are heading up a dark tunnel, then why should they spend their hard earned cash suporting them? It works both ways, fans are not necessarily going to support the club blindly.

I rarely see Everton live these days as I don't live in the UK anymore. However, I have nothing against those fans who have jacked in they ST due to the rubbsh football/no future hope. Also if the stadium is never full, why bother with a ST - you can get tickets for every game anyway.
Dave Wilson
66 Posted 04/01/2012 at 14:00:19
Rob

Sorry that begs the obvious question, if you dont bother to watch Everton even when they are on TV, what do you base your opinion on ?

Phil

Disagree with you too, if we were playing Bolton at a newly renovated GP with top notch facilities, or we were playing them at a new state of the art stadium at say, the bottom of Scottie, I`m convinced we would be playing in front of 40k+

First things first. How long can this crew get away with charging 2012 prices for 1960`s facilities ?
Ray Robinson
67 Posted 04/01/2012 at 14:16:23
Denis, your last sentence is one that resonates. If I add up the minimum possible cost of all home league matches that I have attended this season (some discounted at £20, some at £25, two at £15 using vouchers from fellow season ticket holders, two for the price of 1 and a half at Christmas and then add the two matches that I cannot attend for personal reasons), I'll bet that I could be "out - of-pocket" by actually owning a season ticket.

If the football is dire and money scarce, maybe I should review my season ticket next year and choose those matches that I wish to attend.

Now that's a slippery slope ......
Rob Teo
68 Posted 04/01/2012 at 14:28:16
Dave, I said I don't watch the team "on some occasions". I also said I feel a sense of frustration "whenever I've seen them play this season and last season". (Plus I do read the match reports of all the matches that I've missed.)

Or do I have to watch every minute of every game to be able to form a valid judgement of the attractiveness (or lack thereof) of the team's style of football?
Peter Laing
69 Posted 04/01/2012 at 14:39:11
That was going to be my approach this season Ray but with not having a season ticket I stopped going after the shit served up in the early part of the season. I can get discounted tickets through work and even that incentive has not persuaded me to return whilst Kenwright continues to spin his lies.
Nate Allen
70 Posted 04/01/2012 at 14:48:14
It's no wonder ticket sales are dropping, it's all such a negative experience. Negative football, negative financial situation, it makes sense
Stephen Kenny
71 Posted 04/01/2012 at 14:44:45
Dave, why weren't we playing in front of 40k+ when we were winning titles and Goodison weren't outdated?

I think the numbers will nver drop really low or go really high.
Kevin Tully
72 Posted 04/01/2012 at 14:48:25
From a personal perspective, I will not be renewing 2 season tickets next year.

The match is now my groundhog day. From the team through to the formation, tactics and sustitutions - I know what will happen next.

At least with the likes of Arteta & Pienaar, we had a little bit of improvisation on the ball.

We have regressed to the bad old days of Walter Smith as far as I am concerned.

The team may scratch a few 1-0's here and there, but fuck is it painful to watch. Don't even want to go tonight really with the weather, but we all have our penance to pay.

Ray Robinson
73 Posted 04/01/2012 at 14:58:08
Stephen #70. We did win two titles in 1962/63 and 1969/70 in front of average crowds of 51,000 and 49,000 respectively. Football did not have to compete against other forms of entertainment, it was played on a Saturday afternoon, the football was attractive and there was a reasonable amount of money around.
Ray Roche
74 Posted 04/01/2012 at 14:57:08
Stephen Kenny.@70
As I've pointed out 19,288 is a pretty low gate for a top flight match at Goodison.


Peter Laing @62

"I know Moyes is paid handsomely for his efforts but his loyalty to kenwright still amazes me"
The fact that he's paid handsomely IS the reason for his loyalty.
Tony J Williams
75 Posted 04/01/2012 at 15:10:11
I think there have been some signs of the relationship being strained.

He is constantly talking about money and the need for a striker and that he is going into gun fights with knives etc

It all seems to me to be a plea for dosh.
Greg Lambden
76 Posted 04/01/2012 at 15:08:56
This does not make much sense.

How can you explain a 3000 average crowd deficit from last season by poor early season form and then go on to say we do the same every year? If we do the same every year why would the crowds be down...?

This is a poor piece of PR attempting to deflect attention away from the bigger problem of board room mismanagement.
Tom Hughes
77 Posted 04/01/2012 at 14:54:14
Stephen#70,

We averaged over 51k when we won it '63, and just under 50k when we won it in '70 (infact we only dipped below 40k average once throughout the 60's, and were probably the best supported club at that time). When we won it in 85 we averaged over 32k and it was the 3rd highest average, but this should perhaps be viewed in relation to the fact that LFC averaged less than that only the year before.... despite winning everything, and having done so for over 10yrs! So we need to view things relative to the era and other factors......gates dropped dramatically in the early 80's. The fact that we have averaged higher than '85 in all but 1 of the prem yrs negates the argument. If GP had been big enough in recent times, and we had similar success to the 80's in recent yrs, we would've easily seen 40k+ average attendances IMO.
Dave Wilson
78 Posted 04/01/2012 at 15:04:58
Stephen

Crowds were down everywhere in the late 70`s n 80`s, Football grounds often became battle fields and although I never felt it was quite as bad as the press would have us believe, Many thousands were staying away out of fear.

Simon Harris
79 Posted 04/01/2012 at 15:04:41
Kevin Tully #71 - You've summed up my feelings pretty well.

Losing Pienaar and then Arteta has left us devoid of creativity and attacking purpose. And not having the means to replace them is just demoralising.

I just don't get that same buzz and nervous anticipation going to the match anymore, the football is predictable and the apathy in the stadium speaks volumes as to the clubs stagnation.

I have contemplated my season ticket renewal for next season, but I live in hope BK can finally do something right and find a buyer before we lose anymore players, fans and god forbid top flight football.

Mike Elbey
80 Posted 04/01/2012 at 16:16:07
Tony,

I agree with you re finances and a combination of the three although I couple this with the lack of board ambition.

Whilst I accept that the tactics are the same I do not accept that as an excuse for the negative football we have played this season. It was Moyes choice to sell all flair players and not cash in on defenders if indeed we needed the money. It is Moyes who continues to play Cahill and leave out players like Barkley and Drenthe who could both fit into his 'stale' formations.

We are a boring team to watch now more than any other time under Moyes and that is primarily down to the selections of the manager.

If I do not renew next year it will be because I am tired of watching us play 7 defenders in home games against shit opposition, it will not be because we have not been taken over, although I do accept the board are equally shit.
Shaun Brennan
81 Posted 04/01/2012 at 16:29:53
Kevin Tull #71

You summed up how I feel. I've been thiking of not renewing my season ticket next season also.

I've had it for 17 years on the trot now since I was 14, I've lived in London for the past 6 years and travelled back for nearly every home league game. The journey has become too much mental hardwork. I actually don't look forward to coming home.

On a plus note, i'm going to Canada this Friday for a years secondment with work. If i do renew next season atleast I'll be refreshed for the second half of the 2012-2013 season. Things may have changed by then.
Tony J Williams
82 Posted 04/01/2012 at 16:33:41
Don't hold your breath Shaun!
Shaun Brennan
83 Posted 04/01/2012 at 16:53:25
Cheers Tony.
Jamie Carroll
84 Posted 04/01/2012 at 18:01:55
They will be talking about the dwindling crowds at Goodison on talksport soon.
Joe McMahon
85 Posted 04/01/2012 at 22:06:25
Glad to see he's (Moyes) doing something about it. We are now nearly 11 years into the masterplan! To think there are plenty on here who slag off Swansea & the barcodes.....Jesus H Corbet, where are we after over a decade of Kenwright & Moyes?
Robbie Riddal
86 Posted 04/01/2012 at 23:20:47
Got to say, this is one of the worst footballing Everton teams I've seen. As bad as anything in the last 20 years.
Peter Laing
87 Posted 04/01/2012 at 23:40:19
According to Radio city Bolton brought 250 fans tonight. The weather, midweek fixture, and post Christmas gloom will undoubtedly have contributed to the sub 30,000 attendance, those blues who did attend deserve a medal for braving that insipid performance.
Dick Fearon
88 Posted 05/01/2012 at 05:31:11
On saying that about lack of entertainment Noyes should hang his head in shame. In the last few weeks we have seen City, United, Chelsea and Arsenal knocked over by so called lesser teams. In some cases by two or more goals.

Er' someone remind me how many times a Moyes team has done that. It is time some of you woke up to the giant fraud being perpetrated by him and his pet chairman.
Roman Sidey
89 Posted 05/01/2012 at 05:35:24
Tony,your quote:

"The non-change of tactics in 10 years still stands though. They are the same but the problem now faced is that the players have changed, gone are the skilled players and in their stead are the grafters"

I agree with everything you said in that particular post. However, the job of a football manager is to use the players he has effectively.

Can you seriously say that Moyes is using each and every one of his resources effectively this season? He is too rigid.

For the record, I, and I assume most of the MOB do acknowledge that the board is the biggest issue at Everton, I really do. Sadly though, I really don't think Moyes would do any better under any other board.
Roman Sidey
90 Posted 05/01/2012 at 06:08:08
Shaun, wherever you are going in Canada, be sure to stay away from the MLS! Every few weeks we would forget how shite the side was and go down to watch Toronto FC play. Oh dear god, it made me feel a little better about Everton.
Ste Traverse
91 Posted 05/01/2012 at 07:39:21
I have a season ticket so I'm lumbered at going to watch that load of shite Moyes serves up til May.

The attendance last night was lower than some Mike Walker got---that says it all.

Piss off Moyes,you've outstayed your welcome. And take that prick of a 'Chairman' with you through the Goodison exit door.
Richard Styles
92 Posted 05/01/2012 at 10:26:31
Taxi for Bill the true blue who has lost the plot, he would rather see our club destroyed at his own hands, than a millionaire who knows nothing about football and cares only about business and making money.... Look Bill we know people have enquired about buying Everton Fc, They have offered £100 million when we qualified for the Champions league, remember that? The season you failed to build on the squad because you thought we were good enough to compete with the likes of Barca, Ac Milan, Juventus, etc... I see it like this, If someone wants to sell me his Limousine thats fine, but I don't want to buy the fucker and keep you as the driver and pay you a wage as well...If your selling the club! Sell it! Nobody wants you at the club once its bought out! Please leave or get thrown out!
Tom Hughes
93 Posted 05/01/2012 at 12:37:43
The problem is.... this regime is finished, however, the leeway they have been given by many fans due to the effective propagandist methods over several years means they may well drag our club down with them. On top of that Apathy has also set in..... I'm not really sure the fans even care anymore. It wasn't only quiet last night, it was a funereal atmosphere inside GP that even a freak rarity of a goal couldn't rouse.
Mick Gallagher
94 Posted 05/01/2012 at 13:01:47
Dont worry Tom they will be in talks with new buyers again soon as they will be another Blue Union meeting.

Any blue bill fans know how the talks went with the 3 or was it 4 potential buyers or are they still on going.
Chris Butler
95 Posted 05/01/2012 at 14:36:13
Kevin Sparke. What you say is a load of nonsense really.

Attendances were so low in the 80s due to all the violence that happened at games. With the exception of Liverpool and United who else filled the away end. Also the tens of thousands of scousers who moved down south also caused a drop in attendances.

We've been in a recession for the last 3 years yet our attendances home and away have remained steady. Nowadays there's always visible empty seats in the Park End which were not there last season. I managed to get a ticket for the derby right in the centre of Gwladys Street, despite giving up my season ticket.

The football we play is boring and negative so who would pay £30 to watch it. The moronic idea to raise ticket prices for 7 games and only reduce prices for 2 games and then claim that fans would be getting a great deal.
Peter Knight
96 Posted 05/01/2012 at 20:47:34
I can see why the attendances are bad.
I woke up at 3:30 am to watch the West Brom game... fell asleep shortly after kick-off... woke with a few minutes to go and saw Big Vic score [best game I have seen so far].

I would find it hard to spend money to watch at GP if I lived there.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads