Season › 2011-12 › News
Blue Union hits back at Kenwright accusation
Part of their response is as follows:
As fans who have put a lot of money, time and devotion into following our club through good times and bad, we find Mr Kenwright's comments to be incredibly disrespectful, deliberately divisive and without any substance whatsoever. Not only are his words offensive to the officers of the group, but to the many thousands of Evertonians who have shown their direct support for our campaign.The fans who questioned Mr Kenwright did so of their own volition, and independently of the members of The Blue Union that were present.
With regard to the specific allegation of betrayal, was it The Blue Union who informed the fans, the shareholders and the Council that the money was ringfenced for the then proposed iconic stadium on the Kings Dock? Was it The Blue Union who attempted to pass off a Walter Mitty character, Chris Samuelson, as an Evertonian investor at a shareholders meeting?
Was it The Blue Union who attempted to move this great club to a former council refuse dump and in the process mislead the fans into believing that a supermarket chain were contributing £52m towards the construction cost of the stadium which turned out to be a bare faced lie?
Was it the Blue Union who handed over a legacy from Sir John Moores to the bank? Was it The Blue Union who attempted to mislead the fanbase by informing them that the abortive Everton Place development was delayed due to an insurance problem? Nothing but the best is good enough? The sheer effrontery to attempt the deflection of responsibility for the many acts of betrayal against our famous motto by the chairman of the board is disgraceful.
Quotes or other material sourced from SOS1978
Reader Comments (119)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 09/01/2012 at 14:39:23
IMO a mistake to implore other fans to ask the questions of Bill outside the ground. It would only take one pissed up gobshite shouting the odd's and the club would jump all over it and saint Bill would milk it for all it's worth PR wise.
3 Posted 09/01/2012 at 14:47:14
4 Posted 09/01/2012 at 14:49:52
5 Posted 09/01/2012 at 14:56:19
"Did not take much for the divide in the ranks did it."
They will be blaming each faction next, watch KEIOC.
6 Posted 09/01/2012 at 15:01:41
Does anyone know what they are referring to here? Bellefield?
7 Posted 09/01/2012 at 15:00:06
Although to be fair to Bill, I don't expect him to have Sly Stallone's whereabouts to hand.
8 Posted 09/01/2012 at 15:05:16
9 Posted 09/01/2012 at 15:09:02
Their whole reaction has been hysterical to watch, including during the incident itself. Don't dish it out unless you can take it.
10 Posted 09/01/2012 at 14:57:15
There has to be a way to get this man to at least hand the running of the club over to someone more capable.
At the moment he is lapping it up portraying BU as the pantomine villain.
We have to reverse that and show him to be the villain that he is.
I would like the BU to ask for subs and use that to fund a media campaign to hound this idiot out of his "I am the best Evertonian" complex..
11 Posted 09/01/2012 at 15:18:01
If he turns the whole club into a pantomime we might start making a few quid, he knows what he's doing with them!!!
12 Posted 09/01/2012 at 15:20:35
13 Posted 09/01/2012 at 15:33:45
You were probably one of those who clapped Kenwright at the Villa game. We need to protect the future of Everton FC from fans like you, who simply don't know better. Thank goodness there are thousands of the rest of us (and it is growing every week that passes) who are prepared to hold this board to account for a terrible lack of progress and under-investment these last 12 years.
14 Posted 09/01/2012 at 15:39:49
Another one who can't see the wood for the trees.
15 Posted 09/01/2012 at 15:41:04
It takes a while to list all his betrayals.
16 Posted 09/01/2012 at 15:38:52
No excuce for scandalous failure to invest in 80s in general infrastructure and specifically in Goodison. That's when clubs like Villa and Man U started to gradually upgrade their facilities. We've done the Park End Stand and seated the Lower Gladwys (because of Taylor). Still hardly any unobstructed views in Main Stand, Bullens Rd and most of Lower Gladwys, given they maintained original structure of Upper Gladwys stand.
Absolutely criminal, but not really TBH's fault for the start of the rot, continued under the brief regime of that clown Marsh and then Johnson. Johnson made money from the club but did invest in net terms during his tenure, something that TBH have singularly failed to do.
17 Posted 09/01/2012 at 15:46:11
18 Posted 09/01/2012 at 16:09:54
Maybe they are the "certain fans" refered to in Emailgate ?
19 Posted 09/01/2012 at 17:05:16
20 Posted 09/01/2012 at 17:45:05
Do you think that Kenwright and his cohorts have anything to answer for??
Do you think that this club has actually been mismanaged??
Do you think that the Club in any way have misled or lied to the support??
I ask these questions of you as you appear steadfast in the belief that the Management have done nothing wrong and that concerns of genuine supporters are not relevant.
21 Posted 09/01/2012 at 18:20:33
22 Posted 09/01/2012 at 18:48:01
You sound like the Blue Union, demanding things you're not entitled too.
I never do anything on demand therefore anything I have to say on the subject (and I have said it before on this site many times) will be when I want to, not because people can't handle anyone with an opposing view.
23 Posted 09/01/2012 at 19:02:59
24 Posted 09/01/2012 at 19:11:55
25 Posted 09/01/2012 at 19:11:22
Now, I implore you to look at the facts. I have done so and, frankly, you are defending the indefensible. Our club is in peril and Mr Bill Kenwright is responsible.
There are flaws in the Blue Union, of course there are. However, what is the alternative? They care and, in my view, Bill Kenwright has been treated by them with more respect than he deserves. There are few clubs in the land who have fans who would take what Evertonians have from this disgrace for a chairman.
He is a self-serving freeloading luvvy who is beyond contempt. Paul ? stop this foolishness.
26 Posted 09/01/2012 at 19:19:31
I put them to you because you dance around direct questions with generalisations.
You are extremely quick to take umbrage at anyone who questions you.
I have no problem if you have an opposite view to myself but this forum is for debate and therefore my questions to you.
There are many people on here who can give chapter and verse on the boards actions over the years so I just want to see where you are coming from.
It certainly appears that you are quick to condemn others but not very quick to refute with facts.
I await to be proven wrong.
27 Posted 09/01/2012 at 19:30:13
28 Posted 09/01/2012 at 19:36:14
29 Posted 09/01/2012 at 19:48:31
I am counting the days - 22 left - where a monumental shift will occur. I am talking about one Mr Richard Dodd. No stauncher defender of Kenwright has ever graced this site - by his own testimony he's wavering, but wanted the window to close before confirming his verdict. We respect that and look forward to hearing back from you Doddy.
We have to accept that as a forum where people are pre-disposed to write and be active - then we are doing no more than (in the main on this issue) preaching to the already converted. The shift has to occur in Goodison.
If the likes of Doddy shifts - then there's no more accurate a barometer - the rest will follow suit - just watch.
30 Posted 09/01/2012 at 19:59:08
31 Posted 09/01/2012 at 20:21:49
BK hasn't put a bean of his own money into the club, and on his watch we are saddled with huge debt, and in a right mess, but because he's a ' True blue' he's defended to the hilt... doesn't figure.
32 Posted 09/01/2012 at 20:23:02
"If the likes of Doddy shifts, then there's no more accurate a barometer ? the rest will follow suit... just watch."
That is rather optimistic!! Not used to such unbridled hope from a fellow toffee. We can all dream of better days and things improving cos, to be honest, they really can't get much worse, can they?
33 Posted 09/01/2012 at 20:40:53
He's like one of those straw exit polls, or if you have a yen for American politics, a New Hampshire voter - once they swing to a view, they are strong indicators of a changing mood.
No disrespect to Michael or Lyndon, the Toffeeweb population, or at least those that contribute, is only a fraction of the support that attends Goodison.
34 Posted 09/01/2012 at 21:17:09
36 Posted 09/01/2012 at 21:39:20
Just watch Kenwright pluck 3 million (begged,borrowed or stolen) out of his Rabbit's hat at the end of January for his marquee signing and then go "Wow".
People seem to forget that as soon as the BU announced a planned protest Billy L was on telling us he was talking to at least 4 interested parties. That has dried up now so on to his next audience tweek and all the gullible seem to lap it up.
37 Posted 09/01/2012 at 21:56:40
That is more succinct and although I agree with you in the main, I still think that the posters on this site are far more anti-establishment than the majority of Evertonians. Perhaps it is because the strength of feeling is less diluted here.
38 Posted 09/01/2012 at 22:03:44
They also naively blamed the falling gates on Kenwright. WRONG. The gates are falling due to Moyes tactics. I am one of them.
39 Posted 09/01/2012 at 22:06:22
Are you saying you are a gate!!!!
Only kidding, could not agree more. Shit displays do not encourage the disillusioned to waste more of their precious time.
40 Posted 09/01/2012 at 22:09:19
Ian (011), the BU are all about getting new owners / investment for EFC. That's their unifying objective. If they start widening this for a change in manager, then they'll lose credibility.
Two things I firmly believe - it should be up to any new owner whether Moyes stays, and how long he's given. That said, I think as soon as BK goes, he'll be right behind him.
Sadly I think BK will hang on until the club is sold from underneath him, which will leave us in deeper shit than at any stage in our history.
41 Posted 09/01/2012 at 22:13:05
It's sad that it's come to that but that's how shallow some people are. If the manager can paper over the cracks, they are happy to bury their heads. Thankfully, it seems that he has run out of answers.
42 Posted 09/01/2012 at 22:15:13
" Bill is not responsible for the direction of the club" was one particular humdinger.
They should stick to photo's of dogs & tatoos.
43 Posted 09/01/2012 at 21:56:54
Anyway, Kenwright out!
44 Posted 09/01/2012 at 22:22:38
45 Posted 09/01/2012 at 22:49:35
I'm no defender of Moyes but he now reminds me of a dead man walking, He, to me, has lost any enthusiasm he brought to the club and now has no money to anything but get loan, oer over the hill players in. As i said, I'm not defending Moyes, I think that as a manager he has had his chance. But to dream that if Moyes goes, all will be well is, in my humble opinion, barking mad. He is a symptom of the disease. The cause of the demise of Everton Football Club, is the smarmy bugger who calls ordinary fans as the betrayers of Evrton Football Club.
Unless we get a board in who will generate a vision, give this club back its respect and treats its fans as a valued part of the whole essence of being an Evertonian, then we are fucked. Move Moyes out, maybe but that isn't going to happen unless kenwright think it weill save his skin. But what has he got to offer a new manager coming in. Sweet fuck all except perhaps a season ticket to one of his theatres.
We need to see this man out of Goodison Park
46 Posted 10/01/2012 at 00:03:43
Speaking of Bluekipper, I have just made my last post to them, after coming to the following conclusion that they are too 'blue tinted', and imo becoming more biased with the posts they publish, toeing the heirachical line.
I said this:
"There are two stereotypical types of butler (manservants etc),...
1. The type that brings order out of chaos.
2. The type that ensures order to the last.
I fear that this site (Bluekipper) errs to the latter type.
The 'Grand old ship' is sinking, yet on this day 45 years ago, Fred Pickering scored a hat-trick against Sheffield Wednesday (you catch my drift)! etc.
Well I'm off to ToffeeWeb, where most members want to keep on bailing."
And so back to reality, I thought the comment about the Echo apologising over being cynical about the availability of the Arteta money for players,and not 14 days later, we find ourselves more than likely looking at buckwheat (so to speak) the pits. I so hope and dream its a fuckin ruse.
47 Posted 10/01/2012 at 01:07:49
Having started out as a sympathetic body, they've predictably self-destructed via today's tactically ill-concieved tirade.
Any aspirations BU once had about working with the Board, liasing with potential International investors, availing itself of a new stadium project etc...have vanished into thin air.
Sullying their veneer of credibility, their surly, foot-stamping attack on Kenwright smacks of a desperation that can only come from knowing that they've become an irrelevance to the club, and the realisation that they're an impotent, angry talking-shop.
My opinion..? Wrong move. I've repeatedly agreed with their premise that Kenwright should step down.
I also think it is right to ask pertinent questions & raise issues of concern, concerning the Chairman.
BUT...my issue sits at odds with their credentials, and here, strategy.
They previously said nice things about Kenwright's tenure, and acknowledged some of the positive aspects relating to his involvement with the club.
(Nb: When they were trying to court him).
Now that their '15 minutes,' has turned sour, and they didn't get their way, they've now reduced themselves to carping & mud-slinging
This is Amateur-Hour..
Publicly slaughtering a Chairman, whilst maintaining a desire to pursue a relationship with the club is professional Kamikaze...a cyanide pill...practically a 'Dear John,' letter - written in blood..
48 Posted 10/01/2012 at 02:25:54
49 Posted 10/01/2012 at 03:29:24
Among the fan base overall (not just TW), is the general consensus that Kenwright is a good guy with no money, a fool with no money or a lying scumbag with no money?
Did he have just enough money to buy the club but not enough to maintain it? Was there criticism at the time he bought the club that he was underfunded?
Would Kenwright be a better owner if he had more money?
I take it that King?s Dock was a good opportunity for a new stadium, and Kenwright screwed it up somehow, but that?s all I can figure out. Can someone explain what the deal was, and how he failed?
I see lots of posts about his lying to the fans... what were some of those?
What is the board of directors supposed to do, and what have they done wrong?
I see lots of calls for Kenwright and the board to be ?forced out?... can the fans really do that? Has it happened before at other clubs? (I ask because it couldn?t happen in a US sports franchise, some of which have truly horrible owners.)
If somehow the Blue Union or the fans were to force Kenwright and the board to leave, what would happen next?
I posted these questions previously to the proprietors of TW, but they were ignored. So guys, please enlighten me.
50 Posted 10/01/2012 at 03:44:27
You keep saying that you, too, want the Chairman and Board out. But throughout it all, the tone of your posts conveys more of a sense of anti-BU invective than any pro-Everton suggestions. Your latest post being the prime example of this.
While I understand that we each have different views on whether the Blue Union's approach is effective and/or correct, it's another thing altogether to publicly gloat (yes, that's how your post sounds!) at the BU's perceived "downfall". I mean, does that actually make your day? Do you actually derive happiness from the perception that the BU is now "persona non grata" in the club hierarchy's eyes? Most importantly, how does gloating over the BU's perceived "demise" actually benefit our great club?
Come on, come up with some positive ideas instead of this armchair-sniping.
51 Posted 10/01/2012 at 04:25:33
http://www.toffeeweb.com/season/10-11/comment/fan/16215.html
http://www.toffeeweb.com/season/10-11/comment/fan/16228.html
52 Posted 10/01/2012 at 04:36:07
http://www.toffeeweb.com/season/09-10/comment/fan/article.asp?submissionID=12846
http://www.toffeeweb.com/season/09-10/comment/fan/article.asp?submissionID=13125
53 Posted 10/01/2012 at 07:15:53
One track is the running of this club and allowing wages to spiral out of control, whilst selling and borrowing till we are bled dry.
The other track is the job he does for his "friends" in the boardroom , He is put into place as a string puppet where he takes out what he can from the club before selling it with major profits to himself and all his friends.
He plays a double role, like an ambassador for the club "the biggest Evertonian", and the puppet master for his friends who along with him own this club.
It goes without saying that Kenwright is a profit maker for these people, the price for which the club is for sale is said to be
around 150 million, and that is without the debt, so you can add that into the price as well.
How on earth can he or any of his friends expect the fans to believe that Kenwright is the best salesperson for this club when the price is the nr.1 problem.
The whole reason why there never will be a sale as long as they demand this price.
I do not know who Kenwright belives he is preaching to and charming but it seems he is using the media against the BU and Everton fans, by putting them into a bad light.
54 Posted 10/01/2012 at 07:43:37
If I had mega bucks I would not buy into EFC because I would feel that as soon as something starts to go wrong (and it does in Football) Blue Union et al will be on my back and to be honest l can do better things with my money.
As for the whinging that Kenwright has basically handed over the club to the banks - well where do you think he got the money from to buy players? Don't delude yourselves that it was from TV/gate money or the sale of players because it was from the banks - which is why we have the debt. If Kenwright didn't get money from the banks to buy players then the fans would have been on his back for failing to buy players - he cannot win. Being chairman/owner of a football club is the most idiotic position in the world - who on earth would put themselves, their family and their money in that position? I wouldn't and I have been supporting the Blues since the 1960s and EFC dominates my life.
I suspect the transfer money from Arteta, Pienaar etc has been to reduce the debt in order to make EFC more financially attractive to potential buyers. We can't reduce debt and also buy players. We can't have it both ways.
55 Posted 10/01/2012 at 08:30:53
You said you find the bile from BOTH BK and BU damaging then you set about to only have a go at the BU.
Kenwright has lied about the money and so many other things, those are the facts. He is not communicating with the fans. It really isn't difficult for someone who is only too willing to show his face when things are going right to also talk to us when things are going wrong.
The problem is, he has no defence.
56 Posted 10/01/2012 at 08:50:23
You are absolutely right. Communication is the key - and truthful communication at that. However, we have to accept that he cannot tell us about the discussions to sell that may or may not be ongoing and sadly we all have to cross our fingers and hope for that a mega rich idiot or megalomaniac (yes another one) comes along.
57 Posted 10/01/2012 at 09:06:21
Just the latest in a line of untruths stretching back many years, which idicate a severe lack of integrity.
58 Posted 10/01/2012 at 09:30:57
59 Posted 10/01/2012 at 09:17:33
"Genuine talks" were taking place according to Robert Elstone & Bill Kenwright.
It amazes me that no journo ever enquires where these mysterious buyers disappear to.
The fact is though, we have not purchased a player in over two years, the only PL club with this dubious record.
You can argue the toss all day of who holds the moral high ground ? Everton are dying before our eyes, and certain individuals want credentials.
They remind me of a dying man refusing CPR from a tramp.
60 Posted 10/01/2012 at 09:38:07
No matter how much you attempt to assassinate the character of its members, you will not succeed; it is you that with each post comes across as more bitter.
Do you have any credible opinions other than your pathetic and continual assault on fellow Evertonians who are trying to save the Club from the abyss that we are staring into?
61 Posted 10/01/2012 at 09:57:43
He doesn't agree with the Blue Union manifesto and they way they went about it. It's not a crime to have a differing view.
The worst problem, is that everyone (well almost everyone....Doddy) ant him gone and even on a point that we all agree with, we are still bickering amongst ourselves.
It would have been better, in my eyes to have grace under fire and perhaps ask for a clear the air talks (without any notes...!) and to try and get the releationship back on solid ground again, not start the tit for tat this has now turned into.
We are all emotional creatures but it would have been more advisable than to create such a statement after a daft, probably, druken man has blurted something out to what he would have perceived as "scallies" abusing him.
62 Posted 10/01/2012 at 10:31:24
Bill Kenwright is responsible for setting Evertonians against each other, its a very sad and sorry state of affairs with the division, splits and animosity that he has created and presided over during his tenure. I recall Robert Elstone coming out in the wake of the disaster that was DK suggesting that the Club would actively work to heal divisions. I have seen absolutely no evidence to date of these words being transferred into actions.
63 Posted 10/01/2012 at 10:47:25
On the recent BU thread, my entire contribution was predicated by a perfectly rational questioning of the Blue Union's credentials.
(Workable ideas, industry acumen etc..)
After all, we've got a motley crew of disparate groups wishing to participate in the dealings, process & re-development of a multi-million pound company.
Right....?
So, rather than blindly 'getting behind the boys..after all, they're proper Evertonians,' is it not prudent, or fair to make an observation about them, based on their behaviour & minus any definitive industry history?
Hence, yesterday's hit-piece, which was the professional equivalent of egging Kenwright's car.
I'm simply saying, it was a bad move..
64 Posted 10/01/2012 at 11:05:47
65 Posted 10/01/2012 at 10:51:29
Various groups have had several meetings with the club over the years....the result invariably being lip-service (with a few exceptions). Even shareholders cannot adequately voice concerns anymore, which tells you all you need to know about the prospects of transparency with our current custodians. The point is, the club cannot answer these questions honestly, as there would be open revolt..... hence the mock effrontery we're served every time the questions are asked.... it's the only remaining diversionary tactic: feign disgust and never answer a single question, blaming others, especially the accusers at every opportunity......
The club should be engaging with these fan groups, and shareholders who have generated ideas for stadium redevelopment and ambitious football quarter and trust schemes.....but they have made such a hash of everything, there is such a littany of mistakes and lies that they know they cannot easily save face and retain credibility. It's a total mess that has been engineered to conceal the truth from the fans, and against that backdrop communication will always be difficult (at best).... and possibly pointless/impossible at worst. It is the end-game for this lot.... but not for us. We will have to live with the consequences of years of mismanagement and missed opportunities.
66 Posted 10/01/2012 at 11:41:08
?On the recent BU thread, my entire contribution was predicated by a perfectly rational questioning of the Blue Union's credentials.?
Indeed you did ask these questions on the other thread and when Tom Hughes answered you, post #297, even providing you with links to make it easier for you to digest, you strangely disappeared from the thread never to be heard of again until you pop up on here with exactly the same questions which, if I?m honest, you should direct at the board as they have admirably demonstrated over the years that they haven?t the credentials you seek so diligently.
I think that the majority know that The Blue Union aren?t the problem, you appear to have a major problem with them for some reason.
It was a pity you disappeared from that thread; your style of writing was intriguing and entertaining.....
?Fine..(sigh)...the Blue Union have "gained," some national press coverage, and kudos to them for it. Happy..??
?(Re, Everton, see 'fish,' and 'price of.')?
?Hmmm......?
I?m sure you?ll keep seeking answers on here....(sigh)....we all look forward to it...
Stay Cool..............................
67 Posted 10/01/2012 at 11:54:29
68 Posted 10/01/2012 at 12:11:40
At the Kirkby inquiry did KEIOC not prove their credentials?
69 Posted 10/01/2012 at 12:05:09
I'd already left the thread, and strangely dissapeared, (to bed,) by the time Tom's, presumably helpful information surfaced.
I have re-visited the thread, and tried to access his link, but currently having no joy at the moment; suffice to say, I'll attempt to try again later, and fair-play to him for providing some substance.
Now, if I may pick a bone with YOUR writing style:
You state: "Some feel (EFC) is a business such as Waitrose, and as such, owners are entitled to do what they wish, and don't need to offer any explanations."
If this is aimed at me, then at no point do I elicit such an idiotic stance. The point was simple, I'm no more qualified to (in a business sense) instruct Waitrose's CEO about policy, than the BU are (without evidence to the contrary) to do likewise with EFC plc.
The emotional bond we all have with our club goes without saying, but as BU supporters continue to remind us (and I agree,) simply "loving the club," isn't enough..
70 Posted 10/01/2012 at 12:08:27
I answered your question.
Feel free to contact the group to arrange to attend one of their regular meetings. They are open to any discussion and/or advice.
Conversely, try the same with the club. You wont need to dissect the issues before the drawbridge goes up.....read the minutes for any AGM from 1999 onwards for examples (remember them).... unless perhaps you have an inside line you can exploit.
71 Posted 10/01/2012 at 12:20:45
Very different with a football club and, while I understand where you are coming from, things are a lot more transparent within the football world.
The fact that we have no money for transfers and have sold off all our assets speaks volumes. If Waitrose ran out of beans you would just go and buy 'em elsewhere.
72 Posted 10/01/2012 at 12:33:22
I agree with plenty there, but regarding "emotional ties," the BU are obliged to provide a whole lot more than mere allegiance to a cause if they wish to actively participate in the process.
...Which I believe Tom Hughes has provided us with, in the form of some background.
Thanks for the link, Tom
73 Posted 10/01/2012 at 12:31:46
Precisely right.... the club is not a transferrable franchise and the fans are not transferrable customers. We come as part of the package........the players, the ground and the fanbase are the only remaining assets..... all intrinically linked. The comparsion with any other business/product or service provider is disingenuous and intentionally derisory to belittle our stance. Without the fanbase there is no club..... end of story.
74 Posted 10/01/2012 at 12:57:29
You may have gone to bed Kevin, but I answered you much earlier, #279, which you also ignored, as you did others, but you continued to post until Tom answered you.
You appear to be conducting a one man tirade against Evertonians in the Blue Union; you?ll be accusing them of being drunken knobheads next.
What have they done to you to instil you with such fortitude in your campaign to discredit a bunch of lads who have woken the world up to what?s going on at Goodison?
The Waitrose analogy wasn?t aimed at you Kevin, it was a generalisation to explain football clubs aren?t simply businesses in the normal sense of the word; but if they were, then I think you?ll agree with me, the owner, or group of owners, that fail to invest and develop their business, essentially leaving it to go to wrack and ruin, aren?t entitled to see a ROI.
My belief, and I?m not forcing anyone to agree, is that because football clubs aren?t businesses their supporters have every right to ask questions and, in the absence of a viable solution to the problem, the ownership, they?re perfectly entitled to offer a solution; particularly when those supporters provide 25% of the turnover.
That's what I think and interestingly UEFA also agree.
75 Posted 10/01/2012 at 12:53:33
"Disengenuous and intentionally derisory to belittle our stance."
...Not buying that.
Whatever YOUR stance is, (and I'm prompted to directly ask if you're a member of the Blue Union) it is perfectly reasonable to ask if:
The BU know how best to operate, maintain & develop a football club?
If they have a verifiable track-record, or even some experience in doing this..?
Since they wish to actively participate in the process, one would assume that they would, right..?
Otherwise...their mission statement is mere hypothesis.
76 Posted 10/01/2012 at 13:07:05
Do you agree with that line of thinking? You seem to...
77 Posted 10/01/2012 at 13:03:07
My comments recieved about 50 responses the other night. Short of endlessly repeating myself, or hiring a secretary, I answered as many as I could.
For the record, as I explicitly stated very early-on in Sunday's thread, I salute the BU's passion for their club, and I hope Kenwright sells to someone better-equipped.
BUT...as engaging as this particular debate is, it is also now redundant:
Their horse has bolted the stable, the club won't have anything to do with them now. They've blown it.
(And I'm done).
78 Posted 10/01/2012 at 13:21:33
If you're not responsible for the Waitrose comparison how can you comment on its intended meaning....
The club has been approached for these answers for years. This isn't a sudden and recent occurance. The BU has come about because the answers have never been forthcoming...... and because the issues are glaring and so numerous. They really do not have to be former club owners to see this.... and certainly not to ask them again.
What isn't Hypothetical is the failings of the current incumbents and the need for change..... and thankfully we're all in agreement with that.
79 Posted 10/01/2012 at 13:10:41
I'll give you the benefit of the doubt, Kevin, and that I may have missed a key part of your reasoning (or your debates with Tom, Colin, etc), but what sort of credentials are you expecting from the BU in their promotion of the idea to find a group of professionals to expedite the sale of the club?
Going back to what you've written at #043 ("Any aspirations BU once had about working with the Board, liasing with potential International investors, availing itself of a new stadium project etc") and #117 ("we've got a motley crew of disparate groups wishing to participate in the dealings, process & re-development of a multi-million pound company") - It's one thing to suggest that the BU want to take over the running of the club (which I agree would need serious credentials), but surely it's another altogether to want to "promote the idea" of getting "a group of professionals" to "identify new owners", which is quite a few steps removed from wanting to run the club themselves (and also, in my view, require less stringent credentials).
Again, I may be missing some background info, and if so, please feel free to enlighten me. But from what I can gather (here on this thread, at least), it sounds as if you've misrepresented the BU's aims and, as such, are questioning their credentials over something which they've not stated is part of their objective?
80 Posted 10/01/2012 at 13:19:22
I think you're WELL done Kevin......(sigh).....
Have you ever stopped to think that those guys are well aware that there's no chance of any meaningful relationship with anyone at Everton? There are, after all, several well publicised precedents which I think most are aware of; none more so than the shareholders relationship.
Their whole raison d'être is to attract publicity to their cause, which given over 30,000 views of their latest video and coverage on the national news, I would say has been achieved.
I would have thought anyone having a background in PR would agree.
81 Posted 10/01/2012 at 13:11:22
The BU are doing nicely. They are an itch that Kenwright can't quite scratch but finds increasingly irritating. His "performance" on Saturday was risible.
BlueKipper's mailbag on the BU statement and the questioning of Kenwright on Saturday, contains the type of bullying and intolerance that they are so quick to accuse the BU of. It's a Beano comic for those who prefer pictures to reading and I won't be visiting it again.
82 Posted 10/01/2012 at 13:48:22
You are one of the 'converted' in the anti-BK crusade but you need to bring the rest of us (circa 30,000 on a match day) with you rather than turning us off. Focus on converting people to your argument as some of the initiatives being driven through the change agenda are good.
So to heap ten tons of shit on BK because he got out of his car (admittedly a chauffered limo) and responded when BU starting giving him verbals is ridiculous. It's called HUMAN NATURE to respond to something like that.
The difference in our views that I think he has done a bad job over the last ten year but I don't feel the need to treat him like he is something I'd trodden in.
Let's have the debate in a respectful manner worthy of the dignity of the club...after all we're not the Redshite over at KKKville.
83 Posted 10/01/2012 at 13:49:09
The group is in it's infancy and the only near coherent focus for protest - they're taking on a multi million pound outfit with 130yrs plus standing with the media.
Thinking they're not going to fuck up or be rough round the edges is wishful thinking.
Those not going having anything constructive to say avoid the temptation to be a smart arse putting the boot in.
Alternatively nail your colours to the mast and say you support Bill or get off your fat lazy arse and do something better than these lads.
84 Posted 10/01/2012 at 13:41:30
Exactly, and very well put! A total misrepresentation of what the BU is about. Why, I wonder?
KEIOC were regularly afforded the same treatment to detract from the real issues, to belittle their argument and to try to influence the fanbase, and we all know the source of that misinformation campaign...... eventually undone by misuse of the tools of his trade.
85 Posted 10/01/2012 at 14:12:29
Get real or you have no chance of persuading the majority to listen to the arguments the BU is putting.
86 Posted 10/01/2012 at 14:19:16
And frankly the argument that 1) KEIOC/BU is hard done by 2) not listened to 3) everyone else is wrong 4) BK is the anti-christ just makes you sound stupid.
87 Posted 10/01/2012 at 14:03:54
I accept that this was not an organised Blue Union protest but I suspect that those taking part are sympathetic to their cause.
This statement seems an hysterical reaction to a non-event by a group with an inflated sense of its own importance.
Before I am shot down in flames consider this: I am an Evertonian and have been for nearly 40 years; I am a season ticket holder; I am not defending Kenwright or Moyes; I feel the same frustrations of, probably, most supporters; I simply don?t support the Blue Union.
88 Posted 10/01/2012 at 14:20:30
We all want the same end result and that is Everton in financially secure hands with a buisness plan.
The one bone of contention is that some want us to go about it in different ways.
I have crossed swords with Kevin before on other threads but what does come across is that he is an intelligent individual who doesn't post and run but stands his corner and fights for what HE thinks is right for the club, as do the rest of us who applaud the BU.
If we as fans could harness that passion and put our differences aside then BK wouldn't stand a chance and would have no choice but to walk.
89 Posted 10/01/2012 at 14:36:58
90 Posted 10/01/2012 at 15:05:31
The fact is we have been finishing in the top 8 regularly in the last 10 years (in the richest league in the world), been to a Cup Final and played in Europe on various occasions. And yet we have only made a profit once if I am right in my thinking... and that was when we sold Rooney.
91 Posted 10/01/2012 at 15:35:04
Just been reading what Colin and Tom have been saying to you. To me they appear to be hinting that you are somebody else? I was looking at NSNO and I noticed that someone has just posted one of the email by Ian Ross that were leaked recently. Here?s part of it.
?Just quickly on the Blue Union firestorm.....I spent three months telling RE he MUST keep the militants out of the Club.....then, two weeks ago, he went behind my back and met them...but he didn't even have the courtesy/balls to tell me....he then ( astonishingly ) recommends that Bill
meets them....again, all behind my back...Bill meets them...they secretly tape the meeting ( as I would have told him they would had someone kept me in the loop )....the result? A 3000 word verbatim piece on the Blue Union website which makes Bill ( and, indeed, all of us ) look VERY
stupid....Bill is mortified.....it's a joke.......delete and ring later "
Are you on a wind up KEVIN?????
92 Posted 10/01/2012 at 16:14:24
93 Posted 10/01/2012 at 15:58:09
Unfortunately, however, neither Colin's work nor the links you provided to Roger's articles really answer my questions. Colin addressed Kenwright's inaccuracy and lack of forthrightness, but didn't cite specific lies. And Roger's only mention of King's Dock was a reference to "ring-fenced" money, which I didn't understand, so I'm still mired in my ignorance about that failed deal..
As to the other questions I posed before bed last night (my time) regarding Kenwright's finances when he purchased the club, the overall fan view, and the practicality/result of any fan/BU effort to force him or the board out, I don't think anyone else responded. But thanks again for your reply, Eric.
94 Posted 10/01/2012 at 16:36:53
Just want to clarify something, are you actually suggesting that Kevin Hudson is in fact Ian Ross? Outrageous if you are correct. Also mildly humorous to say the least...
95 Posted 10/01/2012 at 17:30:46
Where are YOUR credentials to be in a postition to be able to judge the BU regarding their manifesto on how to take the club forward?
96 Posted 10/01/2012 at 17:40:20
So you stand exactly where?
On one hand you saying the BU have valid points but then throw in a disguised defence of Kenwright (not the anti christ.....).
This is the wishy washy stuff that gets us exactly nowhere except more of the same.
Nail your colours to Billys mast if thats your want or do something.
But don't sit there sucking lemons preening away saying "oooh those boys aren't playing fair, the mistakes they're making are simply shocking"
Do one or the other.
97 Posted 10/01/2012 at 18:10:59
In both threads Kevin Hudson has deliberately misrepresented the Blue Union's aim and actions.
98 Posted 10/01/2012 at 18:45:49
99 Posted 10/01/2012 at 18:21:43
100 Posted 10/01/2012 at 18:41:51
As stated at the start, I am certainly no fan of bk but I find the blue union to be quite laughable, well intentioned but as badly run, as arrogant, as devious and just generally as similar to the people currently running the club that its frightening !! Im not saying I'm right or wrong, this is my opinion based on what I know.
I will now get my tin hat and retire to my air raid shelter
101 Posted 10/01/2012 at 19:30:42
Seriously some people on here are sensitive souls! Get a grip!
102 Posted 10/01/2012 at 19:34:52
You speak of mis-representation, but fail to acknowledge that it was me who quoted the Blue Union's mission statements verbatim:
"That we would assist the Owner, the Chairman, the Board and the Executive Officers in their endeavours to attract investment and/or a take over of the Club."
"That we would work with all interested parties to resolve the longstanding Stadium issue."
Cue my appropriate question as to how they would pursue these goals.
Fair enough..?
I also indicated that if I marched into Waitrose wanting to involve myself in their business affairs, without adequate credentials, or a workable plan, armed only with frothy words, I would be laughed out of the room...
They can critique the regime to their hearts content; but if they're eager to play a significant role in the long-term direction of the club, then he burden of credibility lies with them.
But their amateurish behaviour has put paid to that notion.
103 Posted 10/01/2012 at 19:47:51
104 Posted 10/01/2012 at 20:26:21
105 Posted 10/01/2012 at 20:22:39
106 Posted 10/01/2012 at 21:00:49
You?re bleating on about this mission statement thinking you?re getting one over on the Blue Union but let me stop you there. One of the constituent parts of the Blue Union is KEIOC. They?ve published, to critical acclaim, a prospectus which the city council, the MP?s, major public and private stakeholders and even the clubs themselves have embraced.
After an extensive search of over 35 sites in Liverpool and the surrounding areas, Everton produced a report that confirmed there were no suitable sites for a new stadium and now KEIOC has managed to do what the club couldn?t.
They?ve managed to get the council to support, through providing land, the redevelopment of Goodison as part of the Football Quarter. The masterstroke being that they?ve also managed to involve LFC and devise a plan that complies with local and regional development plans including the regenerational strategy which will attract funding ? something the club spectacularly failed to do with their multi-million pound cock-up, Destination Kirkby.
So when a potential buyer comes along, spots the herd of elephants in the room that is the stadium problem, instead of saying ?No, we haven?t got a clue? they can point to the council supported prospectus. Now don?t you think that mission statement is being complied with?
You?re just looking to post any old rubbish because you have an illogical problem with them, carry on doing so and leave it to people who have some real passion about the club and do something more than posting on an internet forum.
107 Posted 10/01/2012 at 20:56:21
They don't claim to be businessmen or international investors but the current incumbent for all intents and purposes hasn't really shown any acumen or ability despite 12 years to do so. What the BU is about has been done to death already on the other thread.
108 Posted 10/01/2012 at 21:19:38
109 Posted 10/01/2012 at 21:53:58
* They released details of a confidential meeting
* Being a motley group
* Being a bunch of scallies
* Gerrymandering/coralling the national media
* Secretly taping the meeting with Bill Kenwright
* Publishing a report of the meeting with Bill Kenwright that was inaccurate & skewed
* Stating that the Blue Union agreed in advance of the meeting that they wouldn't take notes despite an email from Everton stating this was only asked at the actual meeting
* That they have zero footballing or business credentials
* Claiming that they want to operate, maintain & develop a football club
Finally you have completely ignored the fact that the main aim of the Blue Union is the appointment of an independent group made up of professionals to sell the club.
Fair enough?
110 Posted 10/01/2012 at 22:39:50
To sell the club? How are they going to go that by the way?
That will be some achievement. I would like to meet the team of lawyers they appoint to sell someone else's business... that would change the business world overnight.
I am off to speak to my lawyers, I have decided I want to sell Marks and Spencer's I spend a few quid a year there also so that gives me the right, does it not?
111 Posted 10/01/2012 at 22:29:02
With regard to the rest of your comments I think you are missing the point of what the Blue Union are attempting to do. Firstly they want the club to be sold via an independent board of professionals. Secondly they are attempting to get the media to focus on what is actually going on with the running of the club. KEIOC who are part of the Blue Union have done some excellent work on the Football Quarter which I highly recommend you have a look at. They worked with Liverpool University, the city council and also LFC fans (See http://www.keioc.net/index.php?page=football-quarter & also http://thefootballquarter.com/)
112 Posted 10/01/2012 at 22:33:48
"Motley group," refers to the BU being made up of variegated organisations.
"Being a bunch of Scallie's..?" This refers to the folks shouting through the railings at the Chairman, filming it, then publishing it.
Okay, just for you, I'll re-phrase their definition to astute, non-invasive, well-disciplined, grass-roots lobbyists. Happy..?
"Gerrymandering / coralling." Another puerile attack on the simple usage of verbs - already clarified TWICE by me; then softened due to poster sensitivity.
"Recording the meeting. Publishing a word-for-word, skewed, mis-representative account." Absolutely.
(But feel free to take the word of an organisation fronted by a creepy-looking clown carrying a cake if you must).
Regarding the chronology of the request for no notes: "Advance of the meeting," still means BEFORE the meeting. (Ie: "commenced.") What did you think I meant...3 months before it.?!
Re: "Footballing and business credentials." As Barry (the conspiracy-theorist) trumpets, antsy, divisive pressure groups like KEIOC have drawn-up various plans in the past.
Barry re-hashed their background, despite the glaring flaw that NONE of their plans came to ANY fruition.
BUT..They've re-attempted the football quarter idea for the second time - and despite my scepticism, (I think it's pie-in-the-sky) one can only wish them luck in their endeavours.
Barry "real passion," Jones:
I'm overly familiar with the KEIOC rhetoric, and doubtless they'll keep trying, and butting heads with those who have the gumption to question or disagree with them. If they ever produce ANYTHING that sees the practical light of day, feel free to come back and say "I told you so!"
Meanwhile, I'd lay off the paranoia if I were you, and stick to printing some more tee-shirts (for the cause..)
113 Posted 10/01/2012 at 23:36:41
His point scoring exercise with the BU is, frankly, pathetic.
Troll?
114 Posted 10/01/2012 at 23:42:13
Apparently I'm "Kevin," according to Barry Jones.
...And even more imaginatively: "Kevin Hudson..." according to Ste Traverse.
I sense they're also itching to call me a Kopite infiltrator.
Later...Whackjobs.
116 Posted 11/01/2012 at 00:31:10
117 Posted 11/01/2012 at 00:42:50
In both scenarios the person being asked the questions being filmed has the opportunity to walk away, make no statement or simply say no comment.. Its also interesting that the baiting and swallowing of the bait is still ongoing, an interesting response.
118 Posted 11/01/2012 at 00:54:13
119 Posted 11/01/2012 at 02:36:33
If they have a verifiable track-record, or even some experience in doing this..?
Since they wish to actively participate in the process, one would assume that they would, right..?
Otherwise...their mission statement is mere hypothesis."
Operating, maintaining and developing a football club is not the aim of the Blue Union.
I suggest you read their mission statement before you comment on it.
120 Posted 11/01/2012 at 07:05:11
If I became too extemporaneous for your taste, then I can easily address that....but not before it gets pointed out to you that selectively truncating a quote to supoort a theme is as misleading as it gets.
I concede that they haven't actually stated that they wish to take over the running of the club. But nor did I suggest (literally) that they want to..
Yet...(And here's what you deliberately omitted..) it is 'reasonable to ASK,' if they know best how to operate, maintain & develop a football club, it is 'reasonable to ASK,' if their track record is verifiable, and again to 'ASK if they EVEN have some experience of doing this.'
These are known in the trade as 'questions,' Eric. A simple answer would have sufficed.
Otherwise, why did they ask for a seat at the table?
Surely they must have based their pitch upon some significant ideas about the many wide-ranging practicalities, Offered some know-how in assisting the club in attracting new investment: How..? (Schmoozing doesn't cut it).
Working with all interested parties to resolve the stadium issue. Why don't I approach the Waitrose CEO with a PowerPoint presentation and discuss realistic & workable sites for new store openings..?
(There is some track record HERE, however, but I maintain that the words: 'workable,' and 'realistic,' are of some relevance).
Setting up a fans parliament. What for..? No one has codified what this forum's mandate would be, or what it could achieve. I've recieved no significant explanation about this, despite referencing it several times on both threads.
...What I definitely DID do, and which you inexplicably & inconveniently omitted to mention, is that I was the FIRST one to quote, (word-for-word,) sections of the mission statement you refer to.
My subsequent questions were tailored around them.
121 Posted 11/01/2012 at 18:14:51
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 09/01/2012 at 13:11:42
Bill@Kenwight.com
This is his theatre company in London.