ToffeeWeb’s content may include affiliate links, which means we could earn a commission if you choose to register or make a purchase through one of our featured partners. This compensation does not influence our editorial integrity; all recommendations are made independently. However, it may impact the positioning and visibility of certain operators within our articles.
Clattenburg only saw fit to show Kuyt a yellow card for this dangerous challenge
Controversial referee Mark Clattenburg, who hasn't refereed an Everton match for over four years after the infamous "Clattenburg derby" has been named as the match official for Aston Villa vs Everton on the 14th.
Clattenburg sent off Tony Hibbert following a 50-50 challenge with Steven Gerrard in the Goodison derby in October 2007 where replays suggested any contact was probably outside the area. It was a decision clearly influenced by a word by Steven Gerrard as the official was clearly going to only book the Everton man.
Clattenburg then compounded the that decision by failing to give a red card for a two-footed airborne assault by Dirk Kuyt on Neville or two very strong claims for a penalty for the Blues, the second of which in stoppage time would have given Everton the chance to claim a point.
Liverpool won the match 2-1 and though Clattenburg retired from the game briefly amid a financial scandal, he returned to the Premier League's refereeing line-up a couple of seasons ago (with a new hair system in place!) but this will be the first time the FA have dared appoint him to officiate a game involving Everton.
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
Tommy Coleman 1Posted
09/01/2012 at
16:44:42
Great.
Robert Johnson 2Posted
09/01/2012 at
16:48:39
Ill never forgive that corrupt cunt, and there are no fucking words strong enough to describe that bent bastard, I hope he die's a very fucking painful death.
Tony J Williams 3Posted
09/01/2012 at
16:52:59
Hopefully he may feel bad and give us all the decision, God knows we need them, as the Villa always get them against us. (Petrov going down like he was shot when Lescott cleared a ball and kicked his shoulder slightly...)
More likely the fucker will award 3 pens against us and send off Baines and Howard to further fuck up our season.
Chris Brown 4Posted
09/01/2012 at
17:03:18
Wow, I thought that there was some "agreement" to never let him ref us again. Maybe it was that he never ref a derby again. Not looking forward to seeing that waste on the pitch with our boys.
John Keating 5Posted
09/01/2012 at
17:05:46
Robert very succinctly put with an excellent grasp of the English language. Could not have put it better.
Nick Entwistle 6Posted
09/01/2012 at
17:08:17
It'll put 10,000 on the gate.
Eugene Ruane 7Posted
09/01/2012 at
17:08:14
We all moan about refs, but I believe I have only seen three who were ACTUALLY corrupt in some way.
Clive Thomas, Collina and this shifty bent twat.
Hope he breaks both legs.
Paul Joy 8Posted
09/01/2012 at
17:22:50
Thats just the lift we needed. We are bad enough when its against 11 men and now we have got that bent bastard to cope with. I trust our brilliant away support will treat him with the reception he deserves. I wonder if he wears his Stevie G shirt underneath his refs kit still? Problem we have got is that we hate all the refs and just boo the lot - or are we just crap?
Danny Lizars 9Posted
09/01/2012 at
17:34:37
Think this has just about convinced me to get a ticket for the game now to give this dodgy bastard the abuse that he deserves
Kevin Sparke 10Posted
09/01/2012 at
17:32:58
I thought Stevie G laa refereed that derby and Clot-an-burk was his little friend?
Brian Hill 11Posted
09/01/2012 at
17:29:36
I reckon that this is the FA "testing the water". It is not a live TV game, nor a game that anyone outside of the two clubs support bases will care about. Therefore Clattenburg's performance will get no publicity unless he is worse than usual. Remember "The Clattenburg Derby" matters only to we Blues, so it is up to the attending Blues to let it be known to Clattenburg that his cheating that day will never be forgotten. I wish I could be there be there to cheer our every corner, throw-in, free kick, penalty (!!!!) etc.
Rob McFawn 12Posted
09/01/2012 at
17:52:27
After 4½ years, I thought we'd seen the last of him... it's going to be an interesting game to go to now though, for good or bad reasons.
Who knows, it might even help us out, something to unite the fans, players, manager and even chairman after months of dour games; the fans will be extra noisy, you can guarantee that!
To be honest, though, I wouldn't want a dodgy penalty or red card etc to go in our favour, I just want a fair match and a deserved three points on Saturday ? something he robbed from us in 2007.
Liam Reilly 13Posted
09/01/2012 at
18:00:38
This game has just got very interesting, as I too believed that he would never be given another Everton game, probably for his own safety. No surprise its not a Goodison though.
Be interesting to see if he gives a dodgy decision against us, I would suspect not, might be worth a score on an away win.
Stephen Kenny 14Posted
09/01/2012 at
18:05:49
He had to ref us again again before the rest of the league started demanding the same deals when a ref fucked them over, probably to the shires or Man utd's benefit. Ironically the two sides who moan the most about refs!!!
Matt Traynor 15Posted
09/01/2012 at
18:11:26
Stephen, at the rate Queen Kenny and Taggart complain, there'd be no-one left to referee them. Taggart particularly has been doing this for years, publicly demanding immediately post-match that the ref doesn't get the job again.
As others have said, it had to happen eventually, and it would inevitably be an away game.
Brian, I wouldn't worry about Blues letting him know. I mean, we still remember Clive Thomas and his exploits (though he did us a favour in a game v Ipswich, one dodgy decision against Satans XI and he's forever tarnished!)
Jem Traynor 16Posted
09/01/2012 at
18:16:39
We're not looking for favour's off that twat! Just what is right we ONLY want to win fair and square. Fuck the pissing down the leg's win at any cost (chiefly our name) We are not like those crying Bastards from across the Park! Hollow Victories ARE WORSE THAN A LOSS! WORSE THAN A HIDING!!!!
Peter Cummings 17Posted
09/01/2012 at
18:26:15
Bottom line: he should NEVER ref an Everton game again and the club should demand another ref. Neither he nor Atkinson should be anywhere near us. Ironic that these two arseholes ruined two derbies with outrageous decisions in favour of Stevie's mob.
Adam Bennett 18Posted
09/01/2012 at
18:48:53
I thought there was an agreement in place whereby Clattenburg won?t referee any more Everton games if Moyes doesn?t say what went on inside the tunnel?
It will be interesting to hear David Moyes? views on this now.
Clattenburg was said to have said a few things to him and the some of the players, in front of an LMA chief, that caused all kinds of murder. One I?m led to believe was ?You don?t give penalties against Liverpool in the last minute?. Also, the fact that Moyes was set for a disrepute charge for his comments after the game, and then the charge was subsequently dropped with no explanation as to why.
The Finch Farm press conference could be lively on Friday! As will the 2,500 or so Evertonains at Villa Park!!
James McPherson 19Posted
09/01/2012 at
19:35:42
Browsing the grand old team link (via this site) and there is a you tube clip of that infamous Clattenberg derby match.
Looking at it, I noticed something that had no relevance then...but sure does now.
The 4th official is none other than Martin Atkinson!
Just a coincedence I'm sure.
James McPherson 20Posted
09/01/2012 at
19:38:16
Sorry, should have said: for those of you who cannot stomach seeing this again..then skip to the end as the players leave the pitch.
Richard Farrington 21Posted
09/01/2012 at
19:49:54
Going to both so would love to be giving them as much abuse as I can but fear that may be counter productive ? we need some points and some good decisions from them. They are a vein bunch, so is it worth it?
Also going the youth cup game on Thursday at Loftus Road (I live darn sarf), perhaps Dave Thomas could come and do that one!!! COYB
James Stewart 22Posted
09/01/2012 at
19:59:55
The guy is a complete embarrassment to his peers.
He is as bent as they come. He has been involved in some shocking decisions and not just involving us. Surely he daren't give anything against us again though!
Simon Harris 23Posted
09/01/2012 at
20:20:47
He'll be on best behaviour, and will be overtly generous and award us a dubious pen (if we manage to venture that far forward) to try and mend some bridges. Here's hoping anyway..
Derek Williams 24Posted
09/01/2012 at
21:06:32
Ha ha, I just Googled him to remind myself where he comes from (County Durham). Up pops Wikipedia which states in the first paragraph 'He is a devoted Liverpool supporter'. Well we all suspected that obviously but if it's on Wiki it's obviously factual! It doesn't say he's a complete twat however so they are only 99% accurate
Kevin Day 25Posted
09/01/2012 at
21:15:57
Maybe... just maybe he will be conscious of what happened 4 years ago. but then again billy boy may sell to a no 1 russain everton fan who has a few billion burning awhole in his pocket. Which one is more likely??????
David Hallwood 26Posted
09/01/2012 at
23:51:12
The worst of it is that he's a highly competant ref, which makes his performance against us (and it was a performance) so obviously bent, one of the worst most blatant corrupt refs I've seen, should never have been allowed to referee again. Twat.
Colin Gee 27Posted
10/01/2012 at
00:12:22
It could be the best £34 I've ever spent. Add to that the, TV, vat... some abuse, only problem is those stewards at Villa can be a bit 'lively'. There won't be any blues left at full-time if he doesn't give us a blatant penalty!
Lee Mandaracas 28Posted
10/01/2012 at
10:18:50
Still to this day makes me sick to the pit of my stomach. He was so blatant it was like watching a masterclass in how Mr Bean would disguise having been bought.
No words could match my utter disgust for this despicable oxygen thief!
Nick Millington 29Posted
10/01/2012 at
10:37:53
Will never forgive this thief, just hope the FA realise Everton supporters will never forgive him.
Andrew Laird 30Posted
10/01/2012 at
11:36:36
David #032, agree he is a competent ref. Probably one of the best which is, as you allude to, a travesty. Maybe we can bung him a few quid?
John Crawley 31Posted
10/01/2012 at
12:10:26
Once you are shown to have no integrity as Clattenburg did both during the match and particularly his comments to Moyes after the game then you are simply not fit to referee ANY game.
At the time of the derby the FA should have immediately launched a full investigation into Clattenburg's comments to Moyes and his conduct in the game. Instead they did nothing apart from threaten Moyes and then subsequently dropped the charges against him.
I think Everton should protest the decision to appoint Clattenburg as the match official and if it is not reviewed then they should publish a statement stating exactly what Clattenburg comments to Moyes were.
Steve King 32Posted
10/01/2012 at
12:37:45
I have never been as angry about football as I was that day!! I started to watch the attached You Tube video but had to stop after a minute as I was in danger of throwing my monitor across the office!!
He should NEVER have been allowed to referee another game at any level again! Stevie G should have been investigated for influencing his decisions, and the shite should have been relegated.....just because I never hated them so much as that weekend!!
OK maybe a little unrealistic but this man should not have been allowed back into the game....he's like one of those Banker assholes who keeps fucking up everybody's lives and yet keep coming back!
I hope Moyes has the balls to say what he really thinks before the game
Nick Entwistle 33Posted
10/01/2012 at
13:06:28
Couldn't watch the clip either. Once I saw DJ Steve run through I closed it down. Time and time again football is being decided on outside influences, be that players yelling at refs and refs being capital Cs of the highest order. Love Everton hate football.
(Though the Manchester derby was riveting!)
James Morgan 34Posted
10/01/2012 at
13:43:23
How about 'the referees a wanker, the referees a wanker' from the off?
I hope as he chases the play he does a Djibril Cisse, the bent bastard!
Howard Don 35Posted
10/01/2012 at
15:28:42
I'd forgotton how outrageous the foul on Lescott was at the end, Kopenburg had a perfect view, how could he not give it?
Gerry Quinn 36Posted
10/01/2012 at
22:06:07
That video brought it all home to me again (even though I didn't view it all!) - I have never, ever hated a referee that much - unbelievably smug bastard - and of course, I didn't think I could have detested the RS much more, but that video has doubled, nee tripled, nee quadrupled my utter resentment of who and what they represent. TWATS. GOBSHITES. DEVIL'S SPAWN. Oh for the day that we get some sickly lucky decisions that go against them and tawt them 6-0 - at ANALfield
Gerry Quinn 37Posted
10/01/2012 at
22:11:35
tawt?
Gerry Quinn 38Posted
10/01/2012 at
22:16:30
Just chants of "cheat, cheat, cheat" every time he gives a decision against us...I think that after a few mistakes, then he might realise we have not forgotten
Nick Armitage 39Posted
11/01/2012 at
00:05:08
The worst single refereeing display I have ever witnessed, but I wish more referees would send Phil Neville off.
Mick Davies 40Posted
11/01/2012 at
03:30:15
David Hallwood @ 32. I agree, since his first ever PL match which was actually our 3-1 win at Palace, I thought of him as one of the most competent MIB around. So that plane journey to the Far East with Stevie and the boys and his obvious allegiance to LFC should have ruled him out of a M/side derby. His ability as a referee proves that he was not acting objectively.
Mike Dean lives on Wirral and so is barred from reffing us or the reds: why? Does this mean he may be biased? Surely that's admitting that some of them are not as fair as they're supposed to be. That derby match should have been his last game ever and the decision to allow him to be in charge at Villa is shocking. Like Robert Johnson @ 937, I wish him all the worst and hope his hair transplant falls out, he gets nicked again for fraud and this time goes down for 10 years ... oh yeah, and he's banged up with Purple Aki.
Andrew Ellams 41Posted
11/01/2012 at
12:15:42
I forgot we scored first. How far was Hibbo's challenge on knobhead actually outside the box, forgot about the first pen that wasn't given for a foul on Lescott when it was still 1-1 and the tackle by Kuyt on Neville was a disgrace.
Mick Davies 42Posted
12/01/2012 at
02:59:53
Stop Press. . he's just been promoted to the FIFA elite list of referees, where he joins such other notable professionals as Atkinson and Webb. Makes the mind boggle. Rose West has been elected as Minister for Child Welfare and Timmy Mallet is to take over as presenter of Mastermind
Callum Wilson 43Posted
12/01/2012 at
04:57:31
Hopefully Big Dunc will run onto the pitch if he has any dodgy decisions and give him a signature head butt, fuck it not just if there's a dodgy decision just for revenge for the derby that horrible little corrupt fucker Clattenburg he should have been banned from refereeing altogether and NEVER allowed back in the game. The fact he is still around shows what a bent little corrupt shithouse of an organisation the FA are, i wonder if he had put this sort of performance in against Man Utd and Fergie mouthed off about it whether he would still have a career, call me cynical but i think the odds of him returning to football would have been slimmer!
Steve Smith 44Posted
12/01/2012 at
19:49:08
I guarantee he will award us a penalty on Saturday and probably send off a Villa player just for good measure, get ya mortgages on it !
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 09/01/2012 at 16:44:42