Trust Everton goes live

, 10 January, 91comments  |  Jump to most recent
All Evertonians are invited to complete online survey
Trust Everton is a bold initiative to put ownership of Everton Football Club into the hands of the fans, starting with some of the real estate: Goodison Park and Finch Farm.

After many months of planning and negotiations, a website has been set up based on a scheme under the umbrella of Supporters Direct, under the slogan: "Securing the Future of Everton FC for the current and future generations of Evertonians."

The initial rationale for Trust Everton is to explore thoroughly the feasibility of a supporters' vehicle providing sustainable long-term funding for the real-estate assets of the football club. The two that spring to mind are the training ground and the stadium.

To progress beyond this first phase, Trust Everton will need to raise and manage safely a considerable sum of money, and then run and maintain valuable property assets. Its infrastructure and management will need to be of ?industrial strength? in order to do this.

Trust Everton is now in a position to ask all Evertonians if they would be interested in participating in the purchase of Everton's state of the art training ground, Finch Farm. To help begin this process, all Evertonians are invited by Trust Everton to complete the first in a series of surveys.

If you are interested in helping with the Trust Everton project you will also find details on the Register page of the particular areas of expertise that Trust Everton is currently seeking. These requirements will change over time and updates will be announced in the Trust Everton newsletter.

If you would like to be kept informed about developments at Trust Everton please go to the Register page and register for the Trust Everton newsletter mailing list. You can also say you like Trust Everton on Facebook and follow the Twitter account.

Quotes or other material sourced from TrustEverton.com



Reader Comments (91)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Ronan Mathews
1 Posted 10/01/2012 at 04:01:02
Nice idea but nothing can be achieved from this. Sounds faulty
Eric Myles
2 Posted 10/01/2012 at 04:10:30
Another one who thinks we should sit idly by and see Kenwright and his 'friends' destroy the Club.
Mark Rankin
3 Posted 10/01/2012 at 07:42:44
Have to make something like this work
Richard Styles
4 Posted 10/01/2012 at 08:20:51
Isn`t this what Chelsea did 15 years ago with Stamford Bridge...10 years later and after the Russians arrived, they get offered the same money that they bought them for from the club. And to reinforce it threatened that the club will just move to a new development and fans with be left with the empty lot...if they didn`t agree?

I wouldn't mind supporters and investors alike buying the club from Kenwright.... but then we go back to the same question: How much does Kenwright want for it?
Colin Wainwright
5 Posted 10/01/2012 at 09:02:01
Well done Tony and all the other lads involved. I know you have all worked feckin' hard to get to this stage.

A little bit of light at the end of a dark tunnel.

Nice one!
Martin Mason
6 Posted 10/01/2012 at 09:08:10
This, unlike other movements such as the BU is actually doing something and asking fans to put their money where their mouth is. I will definitely sign up.
Chris Matheson
7 Posted 10/01/2012 at 09:11:43
Tony I'Anson is, I believe a regular contributor to this site. I have no doubt that he and the other lads have worked their socks off on this for which thank you.

I have no idea if it will work, but we have to try something so I will give it a go.
Colin Wainwright
8 Posted 10/01/2012 at 09:15:46
Ronan (051). Sounds faulty? WTF?
Chris Barnes
9 Posted 10/01/2012 at 09:15:58
I'm not up on the ins and outs of the details, but isn't Finch Farm available for £15m? If Everton are tied into the lease on this for 25 years at £1m or something per year, it would make great business sense to purchase this. I may be wrong on these figures.

My credit rating wouldn't allow for me getting a loan but surely there are Blues who may see this as an opportunity?? Better for it to be in the hands of a genuine supporter/group of supporters than some faceless property developer?
Tony I'Anson
10 Posted 10/01/2012 at 09:48:16
Michael, Lyndon

Many thanks for the write up on Trust Everton.

Just to clarify one point, the aim of Trust Everton is the financing or ownership of property assets (and in effect becoming the club's landlord), as explained in the FAQ section of the website.

The Crystal Palace Supporters' Trust has a similar initiative underway. Further detail can be found at http://palacetrust.org.uk/training-ground/
Vijay Nair
12 Posted 10/01/2012 at 10:12:15
Tony et al.. thanks for all the hard work you have put in. I for one have registered and filled up the survey. As Chris says above, there is no guarantee of this working, but lets give it a red hot go!
Tom Hughes
13 Posted 10/01/2012 at 10:04:56
Well done Tony..... I know this has taken over your life (and Mike's) in recent months (yrs). All the best and thanks for what's been an incredible effort, and lets hope all Evertonians worldwide engage with it. I think the potential could be massive..... and could go a long way towards resolving some of the major issues affecting our club.

So, come on all you Evertonians...... back this project, and ask all your blue friends to do the same.... make us the real "people's club".
Declan Burke
14 Posted 10/01/2012 at 10:40:02
Sorry for the blank guys.
Agree with you 100% Tom. Thank you Tony and friends for all the effort.
Tony J Williams
15 Posted 10/01/2012 at 12:02:12
I applaud you Tony but I fear you are facing an uphill battle in these tight financial times.

Well done for doing something for our beloved club.
John Crawley
16 Posted 10/01/2012 at 12:00:13
Well done guys on getting this if off the ground. It must have taken a lot of hard work. This is a really positive step and I for one will be signing up.

I would like to see the ultimate aim of such a trust to take on ownership of the whole club but I think we need to walk before we can run and I see ownership of finch farm/Goodison as being achievable.
Tom Owen
17 Posted 10/01/2012 at 12:20:46
Looks a very interesting idea. Something all Evertonians should consider.
Ian Black
18 Posted 10/01/2012 at 12:14:09
I think this is a great idea and would like to reiterate previous comments of well done! Like others though I'm sceptical over whether or not it's achievable.

As Finch Farm isn't owned by Everton this may be realistic, though as tenants would Everton have some say? With engagement between fans and the club at a particularly low ebb at the moment, would it be realistic to assume that, even if the cash was there, we could walk up to Goodison Park and say 'Hand over the keys, Bill'?

I personally believe BK has no real control anyway, he's just a figurehead for the board and his guarantors. The people with the money who stand to lose/gain from any sale of the assets... and I don't believe they give two hoots about preserving supporters participation in the clubs affairs, which is partly why we're in this financial mess in the first place.

So, although Bill is a blue and might be for the idea, I suspect if others aren't keen as it dilutes their control over the club, he might get a tap on the shoulder and a shake of the head.
Dennis Stevens
19 Posted 10/01/2012 at 12:48:40
A hearty well done for all your efforts so far - even though there still so very far to go. I think you're starting in exactly the right place with Finch Farm, & hopefully the next step wil be the freehold of Goodison Park. This should ultimately prove to be a healthier arrangement for the club as well.
Danny Broderick
20 Posted 10/01/2012 at 13:09:08
I really hope these lads succeed. It is a massively ambitious project though, akin to climbing Everest. Finch Farm has been put on the market for offers in excess of £15,356,000. I just can't see them ever finding this sort of money.

To raise £1 million would be phenomenal. Would it be more realistic to start off by looking to pay off one of the clubs dozen or so mortgages?

Just a thought. Best of luck anyway, I'm in...
Christine Foster
21 Posted 10/01/2012 at 13:16:40
Tony & Mike, well done, every journey starts with a small step and a place to go. It's a positive response that l have no doubt will be well supported.

It's been a worthwhile task and it shows the club we want to be involved in a positive manner, brilliant.
Andrew Laird
22 Posted 10/01/2012 at 13:34:28
Thanks and well done to all involved, I really hope you can achieve something worthwhile.
Colin Malone
23 Posted 10/01/2012 at 13:48:38
Sorry, I've never heard of Trust Everton. We seem to be branching off into different avenues. Are Blue Union and KEIOC behind this venture? Again sorry for my ignorance.
Tom Brown
24 Posted 10/01/2012 at 13:38:37
Nice to see someone trying to come up with ideas rather than simply being negative about the current situation.

I hope you have some success, even if it is only in provoking others to think constructively about ideas and options.

Is there any history of football clubs being run as charities?

When you go into London Zoo you make a 'charitable donation' rather than paying the ticket price. This means the zoo can reclaim your income tax from HMRC as well as getting the money you paid for your ticket. This could add more than 20% to the clubs income (some fans are higher rate tax payers).

Money donated to set up the entity (or shares in EFC gifted to the entity) would also be tax-deductible for those making the gifts.

In an extreme example, let's assume Everton has a market value of £30m (no reason for this value, just plucked out of the air to illustrate the point). Everton's owners could gift EFC into a charitable entity so the entity then owns EFC. The current owners would be able to reclaim income tax on the £30m donation. Assuming they were all 40% tax payers and had enough income to make the reclaim, the amount of tax they would be able to reclaim would be £20m.

Result: Charity now owns EFC and the owners have walked away with 2/3 of the market value cash in hand. (nb: Despite the old owners making a loss here, they might like to do it anyway, even if their interest in Everton is only a business interest, as it means getting definite cash now rather than hoping for cash from some unknown purchaser someway down the line.)

So Everton is now owned by a charity run in the interests of the fans and the wider community. Club income is up more than 20%.

There must be a reason why this can't be done as I know of no club that has done it. Maybe Tony's group is the group to comment ? they seem to know what they are talking about....
Steve Brown
25 Posted 10/01/2012 at 14:03:56
Consider the socios model that operates in Spain. Clubs are run as members? associations are owned by their socios (paid-up members) and their non-profit nature forces the club to re-invest any profits or revenues gained to commercial activity back into the club. Furthermore, the board of directors is constantly held to account by the members, being required to receive authorisation from the club?s general assembly upon any sale or acquisition of property or economic rights with a value equal to or greater than 20% of the budget, and for any commercial agreement with a length that exceeds five years.

Members are also able to vote for the club presidents in elections held every five years, incumbents not being able to serve more than two terms. Any member over the age of eighteen with at least one year?s membership already completed is able to vote in the elections, the directorship of the teams being decided in a more democratic manner than the UK model.
Steavey Buckley
26 Posted 10/01/2012 at 14:08:23
Everton is owned by the shareholders, so, legally, nothing can be done to change ownership by popular demand. Also, the club is for sale at £140 millions, so change of ownership (legally) won't come cheaply. The best thing for all Evertonians is to get behind the team, and hope.
Tom Hughes
27 Posted 10/01/2012 at 14:16:16
Steve,
Many clubs do not own their stadia and other facilities...... even in this country there are noteable examples. Including ourselves as regards training facilities etc. This is a vehicle to attract funds to invest into such infrastructure..... a simple idea that has worked elsewhere. There are issues to be resolved, but the potential is there.
Howard Don
28 Posted 10/01/2012 at 14:55:21
Thanks to all the guys who've put the work in on this. Whether it proves viable or not it's a hugely admirable attempt, in this time of doom and gloom, to do something positive.
Martin Faulkner
29 Posted 10/01/2012 at 15:27:46
Tom @ 172

Not sure you figures add up there, mate.

A £30M charitable donation by a current owner (however fanciful the idea) would then come off their top line of taxable income for the year. Assuming they paid 40% tax rate then their tax liability would be reduced by £12M not £20M.
Denis Richardson
30 Posted 10/01/2012 at 16:24:17
Done the survey, need to start somewhere and Rome wasn't built in a day etc.

Good work..keep it up.

Steve Smith
31 Posted 10/01/2012 at 16:20:25
Just completed the survey and received 36 identical e-mails welcoming me to the "survey me" website.

Anyway, I absolutely believe this initial proposal is achievable, we are looking at a commitment from a hard core of about 30,000 supporters of £500 each and probably payable over a period of two or three years, obviously a lot less the more that sign up.

This is an opportunity for supporters to show just how much we care about the long term future of the club for what amounts to quite a small initial outlay. This scheme needs widespread publicity on a global scale to get as many people making a financial commitment as possible.

For me it represents a massive step forward in going some way to secure the long term future of our beloved club. A massive well done to all those involved in the hard work it's taken just to get to this early stage, I wish you every success in the future and will state here and now, that I am prepared to contribute at least the current price of a season ticket to the scheme.
Tony Cheek
32 Posted 10/01/2012 at 17:09:22
Beat me there Steve, I only got 27!!
Jamie Carroll
34 Posted 10/01/2012 at 18:32:05
This is a great idea and I will be letting as many blues over here (Ireland) know about this.
David Denby
35 Posted 10/01/2012 at 19:18:08
Feel left out here, I only got three!

As Steve has put it needs huge publicity to get as many on board as possible. I guess the guys organising it are on the ball but it must be difficult, go to say Sky Sports News now to get it out there or wait a while to see the initial interest levels so we actually have figures we (they) can quote. Overall I'm just made up to see something positive about the club.

I made the effort to get back up from Devon on Saturday and it all just felt so flat. Let's get the momentum built on this lads, we could all do with something to smile about.
Guy Rogers
36 Posted 10/01/2012 at 19:54:57
Okay, you actually need a smart phone to fill in the questionaire? No one made this clear, argh!!!!
Rob Hughes
37 Posted 10/01/2012 at 20:17:46
All, we apologise if you've been emailed multiple times from SurveyMe today. I own SurveyMe and I have supported Everton for 40 years. We are 100% behind the Trust Everton guys in their constructive attempts to help the club.

Over 500 people have registered and given their feedback via SurveyMe today which was more than anyone anticipated on day 1. We hope you take time to register and make a difference. By taking the time to register now as the Trust Everton project continues your opinions can be sought quickly by the Trust Everton people and you can give real time feedback via the free SurveyMe smart phone App and/or the links on the Trust Everton website.
Ian Bennett
38 Posted 10/01/2012 at 20:54:21
Anyone thought about asking the 11 millionaires that run around on the pitch on the saturday inbetween being on twitter.
Jon Cox
40 Posted 10/01/2012 at 21:16:58
Tony, sorry mate but all day every day I have to log in, do my passwords and then if i'm not at my computer for 15 mins cos i'm out and about, i have to log in do my password again and again all day every day it goes on and on and on till i've lost the will to live.

Please mate just give me a box to tick and i'll happily do your survey. Also well done it really sounds like you're making a difference.

Whatever your survey asks the man from Delmote says yes!
Drew O'Neall
41 Posted 10/01/2012 at 21:20:09
I would suggest that if you were to get eg 1000 supporters to chip in £100 you would be well on the way to getting a story on Football Focus or Soccer am etc

Have you thought about what the larger agenda could be once you have the forum to speak?

A thousand people marching up Goodison rd is one thing but a thousand fans putting their hard earned on the line is another.

The media would have to listen and it's important that the message isn't 'cakes and clowns' as well meaning as it may have been.
Mark Riding
42 Posted 10/01/2012 at 21:37:03
Drew, the figures you mention, I would imagine, would be obtained within a few hours...
Drew O'Neall
43 Posted 10/01/2012 at 21:39:02
I can't see it but I hpe you're right.
Michael Winstanley
44 Posted 10/01/2012 at 21:35:39
@ Ian
Now there's a thought!
Bob Parrington
46 Posted 10/01/2012 at 21:50:09
Tony et al well done for putting the time and energy in to this positive move. One question ref strategy. First - ok ref the modern Finch Farm facility. But, being owner 'landlord' of GP -- which needs big $$$$ spent on an upgrade -- how do you see the financing of this fit in with Trust's capacity?
Robbie Shields
47 Posted 10/01/2012 at 21:42:01
Jon Cox #292, if that is your level of apathy towards this venture then don't bother. The survey was set up to gauge the interest and likelihood of Evertonians putting their money where their mouth is and actually doing something to safeguard the future of the club through acquiring some of the assets that Kenwright and the board have either mortgaged off or sold in their entirety. If you can't be arsed logging in to complete the survey then it looks like you are one of those blues who will not contribute to the scheme anyway.

I have, and I personally will pledge 50GBP per month into this scheme, but that is my birthday and Christmas presents.

Well done Tony and all, superb effort, if Barcelona can do it we bloody well can......... But not the style of football that is ;)

Before doing the survey you should go to the trusteverton.com website and read what it is all about first!!!!!!!!!!
Peter Laing
48 Posted 10/01/2012 at 21:47:36
Cheers Tony and others for all your hard work in establishing Trust Everton and I wish you every success and whatever financial support that I am able to offer. I would love to believe that such an initiative will appeal to the likes of Lord Grantchester and the many other Evertonians with serious wealth.
Drew O'Neall
49 Posted 10/01/2012 at 22:05:00
Also, if you asked for a grand you could say 'Oh it's a grand ol scheme to pay for...."

I'll get me coat.
Robbie Shields
50 Posted 10/01/2012 at 22:11:46
Drew, that's a fantastic shout, I love it.
GJ Butler
51 Posted 10/01/2012 at 22:12:01
Don't apologise Drew, I'm still laughin
Robbie Shields
53 Posted 10/01/2012 at 22:12:46
Oh it's a grand old scheme to pay for
Oh it's a grand old scheme to support
And if, you know, your history
It's enough to make your heart go whoooooa
We don't care what Kenwright says
What the fuck do we care?
Because we only know, that there's going to be a show
And the Everton fans will be there

See TrustEverton.com
Tony I'Anson
54 Posted 10/01/2012 at 22:09:49
Thank you to over 500 Evertonians from around the world who completed the survey today. Very encouraging.

It really is a case of everyone spreading the word to those fans yet to complete the survey. All comments are taken on board and we'll come back to you with ongoing updates.
Dean Adams
55 Posted 10/01/2012 at 22:14:05
Drew 313

That is classic.
Stephen Kenny
56 Posted 10/01/2012 at 22:16:19
I think asking family and friends to make donations in your name at birthdays and Xmas is a brilliant Idea. I'll probably do that myself and chip a few quid extra too.

Whether this come off or not I think you deserve a medal (or a pint). The best of our fans really are better than most.
GJ Butler
57 Posted 10/01/2012 at 22:12:01
Don't apologise Drew, I'm still laughin
Tom Owen
59 Posted 10/01/2012 at 22:39:29
I have completed the survey. Took a few seconds to sign up and a minute or so to complete the form. No problems for me.
Seamus Murphy
60 Posted 10/01/2012 at 23:31:18
Good stuff. I'm in
Roberto Birquet
61 Posted 11/01/2012 at 00:22:28
I'd prefer if a fans' consortium just bought a share of the Club. Use the funds raised to pay off whatever debt is still being demanded. If we raised £16 m in sales in the summer, and the banks were demanding £25 m over two years, that would still leave £9 m (assuming we are not operating at a loss).

That way we'd also get the asking price of the Club.

Banks all over Europe are calling in debts for everything but real estate, especially since Merkozy ordered them to. Were they to do to force real estate sales, they know prices would plummet, and their balance sheet would be covered red, forcing them to call in even more loans. So all other loans are being called in.

Get out of debt, I say.

Btw, there must be some land in Liverpool where you could build a cheapish ground. I've lived in London for years, and have to say was amazed to see Arsenal find a place nearby in a city that never stops building. Whereas we cannot find a place in Liverpool that's seen half its population go in the past 50 years.

Something's wrong. Get on the council's back. Imagine the jobs it would create.
Jamie Sweet
62 Posted 11/01/2012 at 00:28:29
Great concept and good luck to all involved.

Couldn't Uncle Bill throw in the Arteta money and Trust Everton make up the shortfall?

If I have read things right - we pay £1.2m a year in rent for Finch Farm. Surely any owner with a long-term vision would see that it makes far better economic sense to own this facility?
Drew O'Neall
63 Posted 11/01/2012 at 00:48:56
Jamie 387

THE OWNERS HAVE NOT A POT IN WHICH TO PISS.
Drew O'Neall
64 Posted 11/01/2012 at 00:52:14
..Having said that, there is an option for the tenant (Everton) to buy it back at c£15m this summer - after that they have to wait another 5 years... Could be what Uncle Vill's been saving up his pocket money for...
Jamie Sweet
65 Posted 11/01/2012 at 01:13:53
Drew, my comment on Bill putting his hand in his pocket was somewhat tongue in cheek.

However, maybe I'm looking at this far too simplistically as I don't have an economics degree, but if we didn't have to sell Arteta as is reported, then the £10m fee plus £3.5m for one years wages could have pretty much bought us back Finch Farm which would consequently save us £1.2m per year in rent, which in 12 years time would have effectively paid for itself. Plus FF will probably be worth £17m in a few years time where as Arteta would have been worth not a lot.

Another example... would the club be in a better position today if we had bought Finch Farm back instead of buying Bily and Johnny? Financially yes - quality of our squad-wise, we wouldn't be much worse off.
Eric Myles
66 Posted 11/01/2012 at 01:53:05
Ian #148, the Club don't 'own' Goodison, it's mortgaged out so TrustEverton could buy the debt from the mortgager if they were willing to sell it.
Eric Myles
67 Posted 11/01/2012 at 02:01:19
Jamie #387 "If I have read things right - we pay £1.2m a year in rent for Finch Farm. Surely any owner with a long-term vision would see that it makes far better economic sense to own this facility? "

It was the current Board that built Finch Farm and then sold it on a lease back scheme in which they would pay 5X the amount it cost.

So no, they do not have the sense to see that economically it would be better to own the facility as they could have saved themselves £40 million.
Thomas Williams
68 Posted 11/01/2012 at 02:50:57
Jamie #400, good response but here is the more sensible one the club should have done:

Land was £2M we should have paid that out of the Bellefield money, Builder cost: £7.5M, we could have mortaged that over 10 years at the current rate of £1.2M we are paying, then in 10 years we own it, not sit back and let the builder make £6-7M on our project or saddle EFC paying £1.2M for 50 years for something they will not own!!

Whoever allowed this scheme to run as it has done needs firing now, the most stupid business decision I have ever seen in my life.
Thomas Williams
69 Posted 11/01/2012 at 02:57:05
I agree with the idea and want to get involved but cannot understand why it is limited to people with iPhone and Android. This will limit the amount of people who want to help. I don't have one of them phones so now I cant help; organisers will need to address this issue asap.
Mick Davies
70 Posted 11/01/2012 at 02:57:26
Bob Parrington @ 307. Not sure about this but if GP were owned by a charitable organisation, it may be eligible for funding, possibly from the ESF and other agencies for any development work. Just a thought, does anyone know for sure?
Eric Myles
71 Posted 11/01/2012 at 03:22:42
Thomas #406, I don't see anything on the TrustEverton website that refers to smartphones?

You can contact them by email and recceive news by email and by looking at their website, all on your computer.
Richard Styles
72 Posted 11/01/2012 at 04:15:41
Danny regarding your post, I really hope these lads succeed. It is a massively ambitious project though, akin to climbing Everest. Finch Farm has been put on the market for offers in excess of £15,356,000. I just can't see them ever finding this sort of money.....

Well let's say 35,000 Evertonians want to buy a share in the whole project, Thats £438.00 each which comes to £15,330,000 I think the bank would take £15 million if you offered it... One lump sum or 7 installments of £50.00 and one for £88.00. There will be a lot of others who would want in on this and would want more than one share.... If you are doing this, count me in....
Lee Jamieson
73 Posted 11/01/2012 at 09:41:02
Your not telling me that the landed gentry that are in the boardroom at Everton have not got enough money to arrange a loan to buy Finch farm, more like they just don't care. Signed the petition and happy to support whatever the guys can achieve. Stop the rot!
Danny Broderick
74 Posted 11/01/2012 at 12:08:03
Lee,

I don't think the banks would lend to them. They were already spooked in the summer and demanded we reduce our overdraft/debt to around £25 million reportedly.

Also, most of our loans now seem to be from private lenders ? is this because the High Street banks won't lend to them?
Danny Broderick
75 Posted 11/01/2012 at 12:17:59
Richard,

I sincerely hope you are right. But a part of me wonders if 35,000 Evertonians could ever agree on something! To get them all to then cough up almost £500 might be stretching it. But I hope it can be done.

The cause would be helped if some of the more wealthy Evertonians could make a significant contribution. Maybe the Everton Former Players Foundation could help to raise funds somehow? After all, the well being of the club is in their interests also.

Maybe fund raising functions could also help ? between all the members of a scheme like this we must all have a load of memorabilia that could be auctioned off and the proceeds given to the charity.

Again, just a couple of ideas off the top of my head...
David S Shaw
76 Posted 11/01/2012 at 12:18:25
If we did raise £15m, wouldn't it be better for this to go on a new stand?

How would the club benefit from whether they pay their rent for Finch Farm to person a or person b?

Or is the club to be rent free, or have a reduced rent?

If it takes 11 yrs to get the £15m paid back then what do we do with that £15m and whatever we were to do with that £15m, why not do it now with it pre 11 yrs inflation?



Michael Hegarty
77 Posted 11/01/2012 at 13:13:20
Great idea lads. It's nice to see a group doing something pro-active instead of walking round with banners and demanding things happen.

I will definitely sign up to this.

Blue Union, time to step aside and let the adults take over.
John Taylor
78 Posted 11/01/2012 at 13:30:47
Fantastic initiative! Well done to all involved in making this happen.

I have a couple of questions regarding objectives etc. Firstly, If we as a supporters trust purchase Finch Farm, what is the plan? Allow Everton to use it rent free?

I personally would be against that as I do not feel the current board are deserving of such generosity. I would much prefer their own stupidity in signing such a lease to be used against them... ie, Any monies paid for the lease etc to be used to A) Aquire shares in Everton B) Purchase debt from existing lenders. I believe both options would strengthen the trust's position with the final objective being to fully own & control the club. Also, who is responsible for maintenance & repair of Finch Farm? The landlord or the tennant?

It may take years to happen but small progress is better than no progress... Once again, a big Well Done to all involved.
Mark Boulle
79 Posted 11/01/2012 at 13:49:16
Eric #409. I had the same problem as Thomas in that I've been able to register for Trust Everton e-mail news but the survey link doesn't work unless you download a smartphone app of some kind.

Tony L'Anson: I also do not have a smartphone and therefore cannot complete the survey. Perhaps when the Trust Everton organisers have a moment they could try to address this to make the survey available to everybody please?
Mike Hayes
80 Posted 11/01/2012 at 16:27:09
Just opened an account with Trust Everton survey and got a big thank you...which is nice. Hope this all works, anything is better than the shite kenwright is bringing down on the club. Everything about Everton stinks at the moment, Moyes is depressing with his negativity, instilling no hope to the fans let alone players, the rot has got to stop sooner rather than later, like many, if I had the money I would glady hand it over. Good luck with this.
Tony I'Anson
81 Posted 11/01/2012 at 17:16:05
Thanks for all comments to date. Keep them coming as all are being collated to prepare the next update.

We cannot stress enough about the importance of getting everyone you know to complete the survey, even if you think it's a pipe dream.

The survey can be completed without a smart phone by clicking on the link on www.trusteverton.com Another few hundred were completed today.

If you have a smart phone, you will need the code at the end of the URL http://www.survey-me.co.uk/take-a-survey/UK-1878-2012

The survey code is 1878-2012 if you are accessing from a smart phone.
Nick Waters
82 Posted 11/01/2012 at 17:49:06
Michael - 558. This thread does not require any criticism of other ordinary Evertonians' efforts to stop the rot. The BU may not be to everyone's liking but they are genuine and devoted and are stepping up to the plate,not simply moaning about the deterioration of the club.
Robbie Shields
84 Posted 11/01/2012 at 22:37:26
Well said Nick.
Dennis Stevens
85 Posted 12/01/2012 at 00:01:40
Some very good points there John [566]. Certainly food for thought if we can get to the stage of making the first acquisition.
Mark Riding
86 Posted 12/01/2012 at 00:34:00
I registered ( uk ) using my laptop, not smartphone.. created account, then signed out, then clicked the link on toffeeweb page, signed in, completed survey.
Money, and I mean decent money, could become available to these guys quite quickly if they show that they are reputable.
Shame the Chang deal is so long !
Eric Myles
87 Posted 12/01/2012 at 08:05:57
Danny #525,

Barclays demanded that the Club reduce the overdraft as they were afraid that it would go over £25 million this year.

The overdraft reported in the last accounts is £9million, our losses each year are £14 million so their fear was well founded.

And yes, finance cannot be obtained from the High St. banks as the Club are operating on a 'cash only' basis as they are considerd a high risk.
Danny Broderick
88 Posted 12/01/2012 at 10:25:19
Eric,

I saw someone on other thread quote the figure of £14 million annual losses. I am not too sure if that is accurate. Where did you get that figure from? I thought it was £5 million based on the 2010 accounts, but is it only £5 million because we sold Bellefield? (i.e. 5+9=14).
I haven't paid too much attention to the loss amount because it is different every year. For instance, our figures will be different again next time round because we have sold £20 million of players this year.
Or am I missing something?
Liam Reilly
89 Posted 12/01/2012 at 10:20:44
Lyndon, Michael, WTF is up with the numbering in these threads?

The Trust is a great idea (survey completed), however it needs to be more realistic in its initial expectations, at least until it's established.

Buying FF or the mortgage for Goodison is just not going to happen in the short term, because in these times of austerity, people will not hand over significant sums of money without a clear of definition of where its going. This is not yet clear and so with the best will in the world, isn't going to happen.

For me, the better option would be to use the Trust (subscription and voluntary contribution based) and use its presence to strike up a relationship with the current custodians. Work with them (yes WITH them, because they aren't going away) in an attempt to establish where the issues are regarding investment and the sale of the club. A controlled channel of communication should then be opened up to the Trust Members, something which is seriously lacking under the current regime.
The trust would gradually establish itself over time, become a club partner (not an adversary) and increase its presence in the Media. It would only then and become more viable to the average supporter in which to invest.
Eric Myles
90 Posted 12/01/2012 at 10:47:42
Danny, yes the £14 million is excluding Bellefield sale as we don't have one of them to sell every year but in the last accounts it DOES include player sales for 2010/2011 accounts.

So to reduce that £14 million loss we have to sell players in 2011/2012 accounts. Maybe the players already sold will be enough as the wages will also be reduced?

It would be much better if we could reduce the 'other operating costs' which make up 25% of our expenditure.
Eric Myles
91 Posted 12/01/2012 at 14:15:15
On the other hand, falling income due to falling attendances lower league placings will negate any reductions from player sales.
Eric Myles
92 Posted 12/01/2012 at 14:21:54
^Danny, we've only had £13 million in player sales since the close of the last accounts as of 31 May 2011.
Michael Kenrick
Editorial Team
94 Posted 12/01/2012 at 20:47:02
Chill, Liam

Think of it as a reference number for each comment. They are not in sequence, but are tied irrevocably to the comment and won't change.

This way, if there is a dupe that needs deleting, or if other comments or mailbag items get moved to this thread from elsewhere, they won't screw up the sequential numbering like what they were.

I hope you can get used to it.
Eric Myles
96 Posted 13/01/2012 at 04:30:51
Having overnight to think about this debt figure further I now realise that we are in deeper shit than I previously feared.

The Club made a loss of £5 million in the last financial year according to the accounts to 31 May 2011. During that same period we sold £22 million of assets (£9 million fixed assets being Bellefield and £13 million other assets being players.)

This to me means (and I'm not an accountant) that the Club operated at a loss of £27 million in the year purely in terms of trading as a business.

In other words if this year we don't sell any assets we can expect the accounts to show a loss of £27 million and considering that attendances are down and league placing money will be less then it could well be more (less any savings on sold player wages)

So what players do we have that we could raise £27 million on before the next accounts are due, which is before the next transfer window opens.
Tony I'Anson
97 Posted 13/01/2012 at 13:20:08
ý3 Trust Everton representatives have just had a constructive progress meeting with Supporters Direct in London to keep things moving forward. They also agreed about the importance of encouraging the wider fan base to complete the survey. So come on lads n lasses, lets reach the 1,000 marker before the weekend is out.
John Keating
98 Posted 13/01/2012 at 17:48:40
Tony. Now that Prentice at the Echo has finally realised he's got a pair, and mentioned something detrimental against the Management do you think he might run a piece on the Trust ??
This would certainly increase exposure in the City. Obviously overseas is another matter.
Tony I'Anson
99 Posted 15/01/2012 at 09:01:35
Nearly 900 responses in 6 days since the site went live with only 3% thinking the idea is a complete pipe dream.
Tony I'Anson
100 Posted 17/01/2012 at 14:20:40
Another constructive 2 hour meeting with Supporters Direct in London. Jim Brown from Baker Brown Associates was on a conference call and tweeted about it afterwards, which has been retweeted by Trust Everton. See www.twitter.com/trusteverton

An update report is currently being prepared for everyone who has completed the survey.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads