Everton left in the shade

, 10 January, 190comments  |  Jump to most recent
As David Moyes laments the widening gulf between Tottenham and Everton, the manager confirmed that the £10m raised from selling Mikel Arteta to Arsenal last August will not be made available to spend in this month's transfer window — that despite the club wringing an apology from the Liverpool Echo for suggesting just that and Bill Kenwright himself assuring fans that funds would be available.

Until last season, Everton and Spurs regularly competed for European qualification in recent years, but Harry Redknapp has been able to invest and improve over to such an extent over the past two seasons that they are now viewed as credible contenders for the title.

Moyes, of course, has not bought a senior player for two and a half years and has seen his ability to challenge for European contention fall away as a result.

"It is a little bit sad they are starting to pull away from us a little bit more than I would like," Moyes admits.

"It is frustrating because all managers will tell you when you are close and competing with teams you never like to see them go away from you, but we are looking at them going away from us at this present time.

"They have continued to kick on and over the years they have got in some really good players. Rafael van der Vaart is one and Scott Parker another recently."

Members of the Blue Union challenged Bill Kenwright, on a range of financial issues as he arrived at Goodison Park for the Cup tie against Tamworth, including whether the proceeds of Arteta's sale on transfer deadline day last summer would be reinvested in Moyes' squad.

Moyes insisted that the decision to sell Arteta was taken for "football reasons" but was forced to concede that he will not be given the proceeds to spend on new players.

"I think everybody knows that the bank wanted the money. I think you all knew that," said Moyes.

Everton demanded and received an apology from the Echo last year when the paper reported that the Arteta money would not be given to Moyes in January.

"I would guess that [Tottenham] have been one of the biggest spenders in the Premier League over the last 10 years. Certainly since I came in they have always supported whatever manager they've had, whether that be Juande Ramos, Martin Jol or Harry Redknapp. They have always backed their managers.

"We know that we have to [invest] if we are going to hang on but it's hard. I see one or two other clubs that could say they were competing with Everton and Tottenham not too long ago who are in a similar situation. That's the way it is. A big part for us will be to make sure we develop our own players and bring our own players through and pick up one or two from the lower leagues who we can hopefully turn into Premier League players."

Asked if he could pursue that policy in this transfer window, Moyes replied: "I would be surprised if we did. I don't think that is going to be the case."

Quotes or other material sourced from The Guardian



Reader Comments (190)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Robby Daniels
1 Posted 10/01/2012 at 23:08:03
I blame Uncle Bill just as much, the overpaid PE Teacher, Moyes, is getting off scott free from most blues. Even today, he said Spurs are one of the biggest spenders if not the biggest in the Prem....

What the fuck, last close season Harry couldn't sign anyone for a decent amount of money.

He spent £5 mill on Parker, good business, and got Ade in on loan, while Utd spent £50mill, Chelsea spent £50 mill on a forward (I can't remember his name now) and City spent a couple of Billion (I think), and The Shite spent £100 million! Because Harry's out-performed him, he's making out that Harry's been the biggest spender.

I read somewhere he has a lower net spend than Moyes... if that is true, it would dispel the Moyes Myth....

Either way, £5mill and a loan signing, doesn't make them the biggest spenders, just to make the MYTH look good.

He isn't starting to tell lies now, is he?

Kenwright disease.... it's catching....

Shagged Demi Moore last night, she was hanging around outside the off licence on our estate, had nothing else to do, monday night,.........

Oh sorry, I made that bit up... ffs.
Mick Davies
2 Posted 11/01/2012 at 03:54:33
Moyes gushed over 'Arrys side on SSN and actually said "Spurs play attractive football. They're a side I would pay to watch"!!!!

Well fucking hell Davey boy, if it helps you to learn how to actually play football then I'll help with the train fare. That has to be the nail in his coffin... totally out of touch.
Rob Teo
3 Posted 11/01/2012 at 03:46:34
Well, I for one am glad that the Guardian is taking notice of what's happening at Everton.

Interesting, too, that the Guardian has seen fit to mention the Blue Union incident with Kenwright. Whether that's an indication that the BU's tactic of "challenging the club's chairman" is reaping dividends (i.e. in regard to raising awareness of the various financial issues among the major media outlets) or if it's meant only as a side-note, it's really hard to tell.

Also interesting is how, reading between the lines, Moyes and the Guardian seem to indicate that the club's hierarchy has failed to deliver on supporting (possibly even reneged on promises to support) Moyes with funds for new players, particularly from the Arteta sale.

Are the media finally wising up to all the double-talk that constantly emanates from the club's hierarchy? In any case, I sincerely hope this is the start of greater scrutiny of the club's finances and transparency (or lack thereof) by the major media outlets on a regular basis.
Richard Styles
4 Posted 11/01/2012 at 03:57:07
Everton officials demanded and received an apology from the Liverpool Echo last year when the newspaper reported that the Arteta money would not be given to Moyes in January......

Now I think The Echo should do the same... Because we all knew that money was going partly to the bank and the rest to the owners...

Wanna Apology from me? The second word is off! You figure out the first...

Lies, Lies, and more lies every year! Half-season tickets, ha ha, buy your season ticket early and save £150.... No thanks ? not renewing mine anytime in the near future, UNLESS it's deadline day and we have already signed at least 3 good quality players, not loaners like the last 3 years.

When Landon, Drenthe, and Stracq all go home, Everton will be thread bare... and either Kenwright will be forced out or Moyes will....

This is my last season but that wont stop me from protesting against boredom in the stands because of the tripe that is being served up to us on the pitch...

One or both of them must go....

Nils Satus Nisi Optimum...
Eric Myles
5 Posted 11/01/2012 at 04:23:59
I don't think anyone except Doddy will be surprised to hear that the Arteta money has gone to the banks.

It was all more bullshit from Billy Liar.

Kenwright OUT

Michael Kenrick
6 Posted 11/01/2012 at 04:31:38
Is this what you recall:


http://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/everton-fc/everton-fc-news/2011/09/06/everton-fc-s-joseph-yobo-seals-loan-return-to-fenerbahce-100252-29369300/3/


IN Saturday?s Echo we stated that Everton FC?s financial plight made the sale of Mikel Arteta necessary.


We understand from Everton this is not the case and Arteta was reluctantly allowed to leave because he expressly stated a desire to do so ? not because of any financial pressure upon the club, which would have been happy and able to keep him.


We apologise for giving the wrong impression on the matter.


Peter Barry
7 Posted 11/01/2012 at 04:31:10
What a shock Billy Liar is well.................. a LIAR.
Russell Buckley
8 Posted 11/01/2012 at 04:35:42
Moyes has let slip in his last interview that the Arteta money has already gone to the bank. When pushed further about the possibility of signing someone from a lower league he explained that he didn't see that has being likely.

So its a no to your Samba wish. Straight from the manager's lips an established Premier League player is out of our reach. Plus we have two solid centre-backs already in the squad with enough players who can cover that for 6 weeks. What we don't have is anyone who can set up a goal or finish.

Thanks again, Mr Kenwright. Sigh... FFS.
Shaun Brennan
9 Posted 11/01/2012 at 05:22:00
Last one at Goodson Doddy turn the lights off will you...

Zack Yusof
10 Posted 11/01/2012 at 05:41:05
Jesus wept.. can this season get any worst? How long can we keep treading water before we drown? So sad to see us sinking like this..

Zack Yusof
11 Posted 11/01/2012 at 05:53:12
Like somebody posted on another thread recently: Fool me once, shame on you.. fool me twice, or three times, or four, five etc etc...

Here's one more sucker that actually believed (more out of sheer desperation more than anything in my own defence..)that the Arteta money was going to be put to good use this January. How does Bill do it? He's so obviously full of shit and yet I keep falling for it..never again.

I'm off to complete that survey for Trust Everton. Something has to be done to stop the rot NOW!!!
Jem Traynor
12 Posted 11/01/2012 at 05:47:42
I really do feel for season ticket holders propping this club up and having to listen to this rubbish from alleged devotees of The Club who are all drawing a generous wage and having the gall to put this crap out into the public domain.

They are nothing short of parasitic and I pity their sad outlook and Morality of life and 'sport'. Everton fans are the best fans in the league by far because of the club's history, that is fading fast thanks to the Greed rotting it from the inside.
Eric Myles
13 Posted 11/01/2012 at 06:15:54
Zack, at least you have had the wool removed from over your eyes and can be a 'born again Evertonian'.

You are in a much better situation than those that are so blind because they refuse to see like Kevin Hudson, Martin Mason and Ken Dodd.
Zack Yusof
14 Posted 11/01/2012 at 06:22:35
Cheers Eric! Yes i suppose i am "born again".. finally liberated from all the bullshit, lies and double talk coming from the folk that seem content to run this great club of ours into the ground.

But the truth, that we are hopelessly skint and havent got a pot to piss in and cant afford any much-needed reinforcements this January to save our collective arses... well, that's a mighty bitter pill to swollow. i knew we were in deep shit but naively choose to believe that the custodians of our club would eventually do the right thing by us..boy, do i feel stupid!

Gavin Ramejkis
15 Posted 11/01/2012 at 06:42:21
RIP Everton, the cancer that is Kenshite looks to have finally tipped the club. It's no just a case of watching the clock tick away.

The prosecution rests its case, we demand the culprit is brought to justice and hounded not just from the club but from the city never to show his two faced smug lying bastard arse ever again.
Kunal Desai
16 Posted 11/01/2012 at 06:51:32
The only way forward is for people not too renew season tickets, and thousands now must realise and wake up that the situation will only deteriorate. I know people will say I support the team and not Moyes and Kenwright but if your giving your money in support then your giving your hard earned money to Kenwright as far as i'm concerned. It would not surprise me if there is another big name to go at the end of this window with no players coming in next summer let alone this window. It's going to get a lot lot worse. Start voting with your feet people. Enough really is enough now.
Zack Yusof
17 Posted 11/01/2012 at 07:02:58
Oh and nice sidebar there Toffeeweb.. just to remind all the doubters and fence sitters among us just what kind of people we have running the club at present.
Christopher Kelly
18 Posted 11/01/2012 at 07:04:07
I hate the guy but wait til the window closes to make your decision.

It probably won't but things could shake out.
Gavin Ramejkis
19 Posted 11/01/2012 at 07:23:40
Christopher what part of the "there's no money" is hard to understand? Do you think someone is going to roll up before the end of January and say "Hi, I'm a 30 a season striker and do you know what I'll play for fuck all" together with a creative midfielder who says the same again.

The other thing bearing in mind is those loan blokes - we can't afford to keep them either, enjoy them while they last as the holes in the team are just going to get bigger.
Paul Gladwell
20 Posted 11/01/2012 at 07:28:30
Well Niklas and co, defend this one and carry on slating lads who are at least doing something to get shut of this loser.
And as for Moyes, he's as bad I bet he could not wait for this game to get back to moaning about excuses and praising other managers after four games against teams he could not use excuses on.
Ian McDowell
21 Posted 11/01/2012 at 07:31:30
Kunal is right, the only way to go now is to boycott games unfortunately, Enough is enough.
Derek Thomas
22 Posted 11/01/2012 at 07:31:45
I've said it before and I'll say it again. 'All we are is Leeds in slow motion'. Not IF but WHEN.
Michael Brien
23 Posted 11/01/2012 at 07:34:39
I am not wanting to defend Kenwright but it seems to me that Dithering Davey is hiding behind the lack of funds excuse just a bit too much.
1. He refers to Tottenham spending - well during the summer most of the talk was dominated by players leaving e.g. would they be able to hang on to Bale.
2. Yes they signed Parker - but they also sold Crouch.
3. Moyes picks the team and decides the tactics - and lack of money or not at times we have had as many as 3 strikers on the bench and 1 on the pitch. What's all that about? I don't know if Vellios is the answer - but he has scored as many goals as Carroll and cost about £34.8M less !! Come to think of it he has probabaly scored as many as Torres and he cost over £49M more.
4. The goalscoring of people such as Ba, Fletcher and Holt and some bloke called Yakubu shows that you don't have to pay £10M+ to sign good players.
Sam Hoare
24 Posted 11/01/2012 at 07:35:53
Why the uproar? This was clearly always going to happen.

Stupid of Bill to have lied last time round but it's in his blood.

Our last accounts said we had how much debt? Around £40m. Well with any luck that should be now sitting closer to £20m with a reduced wage budget to match. Painful to not bring in any new players but it means we are closer to clearing our debt after which we will no longer be forced to sell any more players.

If the board are assuming no mystery investor is going to step forward then this is really the best way to move forward. So long as we can stay in the Premier League with the players we have... which may be where the plan falls apart!
Sean Allinson
25 Posted 11/01/2012 at 07:32:00
Robbie #1. Congratulations. Possibly the most remarkably stupid and ill-informed post ever, and there have been some contenders. For the record:

Harry Redknapp has a net spend of £61,339,000. at Spurs. £58mill net since we last signed a player.

David Moyes in that time has spent... well nothing. In fact his net spend since Redknapp came to Spurs is about minus £20million.

So Rednapp has had £80million more than Moyes since 2009.

And Rednapp is now saying he wants to spend 'Big'.

Dream on David.
Rob Teo
26 Posted 11/01/2012 at 07:43:49
Hahaha...Michael#440 - spot on with point no 3!

More broadly, you're right: The incompetence of the chairman and board affects the ability of the manager to compete on the field. However, it doesn't completely exonerate nor excuse some of the failings we've seen this (and in parts of the last) season.

As another poster on another thread on this site has stated (http://www.toffeeweb.com/season/11-12/comment/fan/20150.html), Moyes has to either "change the attitude or walk away". Using the "lack of funds" as a reason to justify poor tactics, team selection and a defeatist attitude can only take him so far before it starts to sound like a desperate excuse.
Ray Roche
27 Posted 11/01/2012 at 07:47:13
Michael Brien.

At West Ham (a) last season we didn't have forward on the pitch when we kicked off. Not one! Against West Ham. FFS, a team that were propping up the league. Although I do have some sympathy for Moyes at the way the team has been sold from beneath him he doesn't help himself by his negative tactics,coupled with the fact that he is now Kenwrights puppet and is prepared to toe the party line by making excusus for Billy Liar instead of hanging him out to dry.
Christopher Kelly
28 Posted 11/01/2012 at 07:49:30
Gavin,

I didn't read "There is no money" in the article. If I missed it, my apologies.

I knew this day was coming so it isn't a shock but I think before we jump off a collective cliff, we should take a look and see what the team does in the entirety of the window.

Should any of us be surprised if we close the wallets? No.. But i have a hopeful feeling that Billy the Bullshitter has no choice BUT TO spend something this window.

Maybe he'll get a handout from one of the old rich stiffs on the board?? Maybe he'll go out and splurge on a 1m striker??

But the fact is the noose is tightening around his neck and in order for him a) not to continue taking broadsides from the BU and now the media and b) to retain whatever little bargaining power he has with a future buyer, he'll need to stump up some cabbage.

Complaining is boring and the fuckin horse has been well dead for some time now with this lot. Why not hope just a little. It can't do these losers any more harm... In case no one noticed, our fuckin' goalkeeper has more goals than Cahill this season! Wait, did I just write that???
Sam Hoare
29 Posted 11/01/2012 at 08:02:27
Michael brien

1&2, I don't think he was referring to just this summer but tottenham over the last few years, during which they have outspent us hugely

3. One swallow does not a summer make. The lad is fresh and looked very poor when starting vs Fulham. May not be ready yet.

4. It's not that we don't have 10m it's that we havent spent even 1m on any player for 2.5 years. Fletcher, Ba etc therefore out of price range.
Dave Wilson
30 Posted 11/01/2012 at 08:05:23
Sean #443

Careful there son. Thats perilously close to common sense you are talking.

Its difficult to understand why people have so much trouble grasping the difference that 80m quid makes.

Moyes has battered Redknap down the years, absolutely battered him and now the "enlightened" are telling us Arry is the better coach . ."money has nothing to do with it".

I despair that people STILL blame the manager for this, they complain that he sides with the Chairman and criticise him for not slagging him off and admitting we are skint . .but when he spells it out for them . . They act all amazed ! WTF ?

If you guys are surprised there is no money, I dont think anything is going to prepare you for the shock you are in for when Moyes does go.
Guess what ? The New manager - whoever he may be - is going to struggle like fuck to keep up with the big boys too.

Maybe thats what its going to take for you to smell the coffee and realise where our problems really lie
Steve Foster
31 Posted 11/01/2012 at 06:54:34
Massive apologies for this lad's.

I have been reading all these threads over the last few months, all about the Blue Union, and all the lies from the club. But this has really, really got me.

Let me get this right........BK promises money in Jan. The Echo prints that there is no cash and it has gone to the banks. BK forces an apology over this statement. Then DM just passes it off to be true in a pre-match press confrence!

Seriously, I have kept quiet on this. But this (amongst others) is a bared face lie. No squirming, a lie we have been told.

I am just dumbfounded by it all, simple as that. An Evertonian for 39 years, and now this is the final straw.

Can life as an Evertonain get any lower? Surely not. Not like we take an injury ravaged side to an in-form Spurs any time soon......oh wait..........
James McPherson
32 Posted 11/01/2012 at 08:26:19
The greatest sadness is the lack of any kind of surprise with this article/statement. I'm numb from the now torrent of lies that has come form the club. With Moyes now changing his story, final definitive proof that he is complicit in all that is happening. Yet, he still conducts his now ritualistic pre match gripe and raising of his white flag.

Numb yes, but still absolutely sickened.

Messrs Dodd, Hudson, Hoare, Niklas, Tunstead and Entwistle, this is no longer about nuances, interpretation, grey area, shades of opinion - its a simple matter of facts around the club telling continual bare-faced lies in a pernicious and manipulative way - well I say manipulative, but chances are even those that have turned a blind eye will perhaps finally see the sham for what it is.

Not sure whether you gentlemen will. But one thing I am clear on is that for you to continue your counter argument, then, I'm sorry, it's nothing more than sheer bloody mindedness and a bizarre joy in acting in a contrary manner. It sure as hell has nothing to do with the facts of the matter.

James Martin
33 Posted 11/01/2012 at 08:42:29
The apology by the Echo only talks about the motive behind Arteta leaving i.e he wanted to leave for footballing reasons, he wasn't forced out just to satisfy the banks. This is all true and therefore the Echo to report otherwise was improper journalism and an apology was needed. The fact that Kenwright then saw fit to take than 10 million and give it to the bank rather than to Moyes is the bit that obviously hacks off all Evertonians including me. Just because he chose too after Arteta's sale however doesn't mean the sale was motivated by it. Not that this is meant to be a defense of Kenwright in any way. It would be nice to get some official communication from the club detailing whether or not the debt is being reduced by all these player sales. Surely there has to come a point where your operating profits due to player sales outweigh your interest payments and you can start to reduce that debt down, or ar ethese player sales merely containing the debt at aorund the 40 million mark?
Sam Hoare
34 Posted 11/01/2012 at 08:52:29
James, I can't argue with the fact that Kenwright has been manipulating and lying to us since day 1. I would happily see him leave tomorrow. To borrow a parlance I would drive him myself.

But I do think to drag Moyes down by association is a tad unfair and dare I say naïve. I'm sure he doesn't like it but to ask him to leave as a result is unrealistic. If every employee who disagreed with some of the morals and ethics of their bosses left then its likely this country would have very few workers indeed!!

I think Moyes has conducted himself pretty well in what must be an extremely difficult and frustrating situation. He has tried to show loyalty to his employer in order to keep as much harmony as possible at a club that is clearly being run by amateurs.

His job is very simple, to try and keep us in the Premier League by accruing as many points as possible. He does that to the best of his ability and in the best way he knows how (sadly for us, to keep it tight and pinch a goal when possible). Of course with no new players things have gone stale. How you can blame Moyes for this is beyond my understanding.
Eric Myles
35 Posted 11/01/2012 at 09:14:05
Sam #442 "Our last accounts said we had how much debt? Around 40m. Well with any luck that should be now sitting closer to 20m with a reduced wage budget to match."

BUT Sam, we are losing £14 million a year so assuming your reduced figure is near enough then the debt at the end of this year will be £34 million.

So you see, we're not really making much of a dent in the debt unless we sell another player this transfer window (Baines on the last day if anyone's doing a pool)
Rob Dolby
36 Posted 11/01/2012 at 08:41:40
This is a consequence of not having a pot to pee in. We all know that Kenwright initially steadied the ship when he took over the club and without doubt employing Moyes is his best and probably only good decision whilst in charge. The problem now is that Moyes has had both hands tied behind his back and is still expected to deliver. Its not happening and as everyone knows in football you cannot concede more than you score and whilst we arent scoring we arent conceding many either thanks to the defence minded team. When I look at the squad we are relying on a leftback as our main supplier of quality if he gets injured then I cant see where the next goal is comming from in open play with this current crop of players. Unless we have a handful of top notch kids in the reserves I dont expect anything to change unless Kenwright goes and we secure some investment. The comparison with Spurs is way off the mark they have always backed their managers. No idea where their money comes from but they have it and we dont. There is only Norwich,Swansea,Wigan,Bolton and Blackburn who we can compare ourselves to. Not having money to spend for 2 seasons is taking its toll on us all. Time for Bill's final curtain call I reckon.
Thomas Windsor
37 Posted 11/01/2012 at 09:21:43
You have lied and cheated us for the last time it is time for action --- protests on a larger scale starting against Blackburn.
James McPherson
38 Posted 11/01/2012 at 09:07:28
Sam, sorry, but with Moyes changing his story to fit the now clear facts and sugar coating his new version with "we all knew the Arteta sale was going to the banks", he is complicit.

If that were not the case then Moyes too each and every time (let's not forget that Kenwright has now been proved to be a serial liar over many years) has been massively mislead.For him to stay and accept this really points to a man without backbone, principle and integrity. Let's not firget that up an till a few years back, he could have walked into a fairly reasonable job. I just do not get that Moyes would be so naive and accepting - he is involved.

I get your comment on the correlation on workplace/employers - that's a fair shout. However, football does not overlay the ordinary workplace - look no further than the salaries/work hours etc etc...

My problem with Moyes Sam is that in accepting the situation, which by his actions he implicity is, he now has a duty to earn that salary. I do not think he is doing that presently. His continual downplaying of our chances before each and every game at best belittles us further, must diminish the players' already fragile confidence, at worst prolongs this nice little each way bet he has - win nothing, well told you so - win something, what a miracle.

It's extremely manipulative in its own way.

He signed a new contract when the tide had already turned (Kenwright's fabrications you admit run to the whole 10 year term) he's now taking the money, time to get on with the job which does not include endless negativity or simply go.
Al Reddish
39 Posted 11/01/2012 at 09:18:19
Kenwright is once again proven to be a liar, whether it's his own doing or he is covering for the grey men behind the scenes, he is still lying. Get this useless buffoon out of our club now. People say who will come in to replace him, at this moment in time I would take the jobless bloke from a run down flat in Manchester!
Martin Mason
40 Posted 11/01/2012 at 08:22:19
Sam at 442 has got it. The rest of you will when you are less hot under the collar. What has happened needs no malfeasance and no bleeding of the club dry by insider greed (I'd be interested to see evidence of this btw). All that is happening now is that we are finding our natural level of spending based on income and until we get debt down to the required level we will be cutting wages and selling players. From that point we will operate at our natural level and that could be mid table in the Championship. That is unless some very generous sugar daddy comes along and saves us. We are where we are because of the amount of resources we have and a new board with no magic "investment" money, Alan Sugar as chairman and Alex Ferguson as manager would be very unlikely to do better. I believe that the last couple of years has seen us go down against all clubs because we have had to sell good players and because the players that we took a flyer on like Straq, Velios, Gueye, etc., are not going to make the EPL grade. For those who believe that everything is OK structurally and all we have to do is get Kenwright and Moyes out you could be in for a very rude awakening. EFC is in real trouble and praying would be more effective than some of the "solutions" I see spouted. If the salvation of the club is in the hands of the neo-Neanderthals who were berating Kenwright then we are in desperate trouble. BK and the current management are neither the major problem or the solution just here at the wrong time. I see more a club that is in its death throes and which has been in decline since 1970.
Derek Thomas
41 Posted 11/01/2012 at 09:27:22
Apart from the banks actually wanting their money, another reason is; debt reduced = more profit accrueing from the eventual sale price.
Eugene Ruane
42 Posted 11/01/2012 at 09:31:36
Just as depressing to me is the gullibility of many supporters. Seems BK and Moyes could be filmed in Liverpool shirts having a slash on a picture of Alex Young and there'd still be those saying "Yeah but those lads shouting at Moyes did the BU no favours..." etc blah.
Ed Staunton
43 Posted 11/01/2012 at 09:44:24
In my opinion Moyes has a lot to answer for, but this latest statement if anything is playing into the hands of his & Billy liar?s critics. He like the supporters is frustrated by the lack of funds that have helped / enabled Spurs to race ahead of us, when just a few seasons back we were winning this race, along with being ahead of Villa our other main rival for the best of the rest.

Moyes has let the supporters down by his negativity & is lack of understanding that the supporters want us to have a go, not just sit back & hope. But & it could be a big BUT, he could also be a victim of Billy liar, he may have been told all sorts of things that led him to believe that funds / players would be made available, but is now like us, has had enough. If he has had enough he should walk, a lot would say, but maybe he thinks that it would be better to stay & keep us up before walking!

Only time will tell, but in the meantime I would like to see more & more pressure put on Kenwrong because even though I believe Moyes needs to move on, I still believe that whoever the new manager is, he will struggle under this regime.
Robbie Shields
44 Posted 11/01/2012 at 09:51:21
Sam #454, here is an extract from the Blue Union transcript where Kenwright was asked why he hadn't told the fans what the financial situation was at Goodison......

Bill describes an article he sent to David Moyes, a two page article that Moyes told him he didn?t need to release, that he was Bill Kenwright.
Mark, ?Who said you shouldn?t do that?
Bill ?On my mother?s life, David Moyes?

Sounds like Moyes is bloody complicit to me!!!!!
James McPherson
45 Posted 11/01/2012 at 09:51:03
Ok then Martin, is it not reasonable to request that Kenwright now falls on his sword and replace him with a figurehead that does not have to be charged with waving a magic wand, but merely act with integrity and honesty?

I mean, what does Kenwright do? In reality?

A man of the calibre of Terry Leahy, a realsit, pragmatist and a business person who would say it as it is, manage the dire sitaution as best it can be and be honest with the manager, fans and shareholders alike.

If we do find our natural place and it's done transparently, credibly and inclusively then I for one would still be massively disappointed but considerably more accepting.

Alun Jones
46 Posted 11/01/2012 at 09:57:38
Well DM is correct. Spurs have a nett spend of 76million over the last five years and Everton have a nett spend of 1million so whatever you think about Moyes versus Redknapp he is spot on about the huge difference in investment. Harry?s figures at Tottenham are better because as well as buying alot of players he has also sold alot so has been able to recoup alot of the investment in the last couple of years buy selling Crouch, Palacios, O?Hara, Keane to name but a few just very recently. But just three years ago thet did spend over 60million pounds on new players so for once DM?s remarks are correct and i am not surprised they are now doing so well.
Robbie Shields
47 Posted 11/01/2012 at 10:04:27
James mate, you talk a lot of sense, some see it, some, for whatever reason, appear blind to it.
James McPherson
48 Posted 11/01/2012 at 10:00:45
Elstone's mantra is every £0.85p in the £1 generated goes into the team, Finch Farm and player development

Given we have sold the capital assets that we have, redcuced the wage bill to the extent we have and ongoing inbound revenue (TV) has escalated - this statement is now factually not correct.

Can we agree on that?
Peter Laing
49 Posted 11/01/2012 at 10:05:35
To force change we need a mass boycott at the next home game, I decided that enough was enough and have not been to Goodison since Wolves at home and ditched my season ticket for the first time in 12 years. Since then I have had snide comments on here like 'your not a proper blue', 'fair-weather' supporter etc etc, how much more are we supposed to suffer before people wake up and smell the coffee. The board have got to be replaced there is no alternative.
Chris Matheson
50 Posted 11/01/2012 at 09:54:36
The problem we have is that although the Arteta money will pay off some debt, the REASON for the debt is still there - ie gross mismanagement and visionless financial incompetence.

All we are doing when selling players is staving off the day of reckoning.

Until we get someone in who knows what they are doing, this problem will continue.
Robbie Shields
51 Posted 11/01/2012 at 10:09:34
Peter #475, I completely understand your position 100% and think it is disgraceful for any blue to slate you for making that decision.

I posted on here 6 months ago stating that if we stopped going the game, and hence supporting the current doomed regime, we could accelerate the sale by forcing the value of the club down. At the same time if we put that money aside, or ideally into Trust Everton, then we could be involved in any consortium to buy the club back when it inevitably goes into administration.

My fear is that the Trust Everton vehicle MAY be too late. We need it up and running ASAP because it might not be Finch Farm we end up buying, but as part of a wider consortium, the club off the administrators for a hugely knocked down price, I.e. a realistic price based on it's true worth as a basket case in its current state.

I've been saving my pennies, others could do the same.
Martin Mason
52 Posted 11/01/2012 at 09:57:48
James, that is very fair comment and I agree. I'd say that if we really are in the trouble that I see us in then yes, Kenwright and the board should sell up and go as quickly as possible. The game has changed and clubs needs far better more professional management; being a True Blues isn't enough. I'd like to see this board sell up and a new board come in with fresh ideas and more openness. I'd also be glad if this meant a new, younger, possibly English, manager who'd give us some pride in seeing our team playing with enthusiasm and skill.

The only difference I have is that I recognise that BK and his board own and control the club and it isn't the place of us fans to make demands on what he has to do. If we want change then we need to buy him out. There is also the possibility that what is happening inside Everton is nothing like what is being bandied about, it may be that Moyes genuinely is keeping us way above where we should be. I don't know and neither does anybody else posting on here.

I'm an Evertonian of nearly 60 years and I hate to see where we have fallen to but I have to give my support to the existing club and hope that with our support they can turn the club around, hopefully by selling quickly to a new ownership. Support and dialogue though not confrontation and demands.

I'd be very happy if initially the board were open with the fans, I'm sure that would get even the most demanding on board. Why be so secretive and dishonest with what they tell the fans. Whilst they have no legal obligations to do take us into account they have a moral obligation because without its wonderful fans the club is nothing.
Barry Rathbone
53 Posted 11/01/2012 at 09:53:51
What a surprise - Bill lies.

What a surprise - Moyes joins in.

What a surprise - same Evertonians won't see/criticise.

What a surprise - fuck all changes.



Tony J Williams
54 Posted 11/01/2012 at 10:19:47
"To force change we need a mass boycott at the next home game" - How is that going to force change? All it does is offer less money, that week, to Everton FC Ltd and the soft shites like me have already paid for the game via season tickets.

He knows we want him out, the respectable media know we want him out but I'll be fucked if I am going to miss a match for that prick.
Lee Preston
55 Posted 11/01/2012 at 10:27:51
Think I'm part of a growing number of fans who wont be renewing my season ticket at the end of the season.

I wont be returning until Bulls**t Bill has left OUR club!

29,500 against Bolton, 27,000 (5,000 away fans) against Tamworth....I think everyone feels the same way now!

It is completely beyond me how there are still supporters of Kenwright, how many more lies, how much deceit before people will open there eyes to what is happening? Our club is in severe danger with this idiot in charge, selling assets, not replacing players, securing debt on the back of 'potential' future earnings, one false move and we're in administration.

Kenwright out!!
Roman Sidey
56 Posted 11/01/2012 at 10:36:27
I could not give a fuck about how much money Redknapp has spent. He's got a lot of players at Spurs that he either inherited or that he has brought up from mediocre to be decent players. Net spend is a fucking joke anyway.

After this revelation, I wonder if the club will apologise to The Echo?

Moyes has publicly deceived the fans on this one, and for that, he is as bad as Kenwright, and needs to fuck off.

I used to like the guy, but hated his management. Now I hate him personally.
Steve Guy
57 Posted 11/01/2012 at 10:31:39
Martin, "our natural level"? I'd agree that under BK, the way things are going, our natural level may not be in the Premier League, which is why he needs to get out and let someone with more business acumen come in; which quite frankly shouldn't be difficult.

This has always been about commercial and financial management and shouldn't have been about egos. Unfortunately it has become increasingly transparent that with BK it's all about ego and holding onto power. Both he and his team have shown a spectacular lack of business nouse. I can't believe that new owners couldn't do better and then maybe our "natural level" would still be the EPL and maybe (say it quietly) as a top four side ?
Sam Hoare
58 Posted 11/01/2012 at 10:35:25
Robbie@477...don't think this is the right thread to use a quote from Kenwright as an indication to the true matter of things!

James, i accept that to some degree that Moyes is complicit, he clearly knows what is going on. But what do you expect him to do. He can't come out and say his boss is a liar and lambast him and he doesn't want to walk away from a job he feels he has worked hard to keep. As i said he has tried to keep doing his job under very circumstances without rocking the boat, which would surely not help matters on the pitch.

His job, as i said, is simply to accrue points, the things he says before and after matches are irrelevant to be honest so long as he does what he has always done which is to get us more points than our spending on playing staff would suggest we are entitled to. Whatever your gripes with Moyes, his league finishes have always been higher than evertons position in any net spend, spend on wages, or player valuation table. Its not been pretty but he has kept us further up the league than we might have been.
James McPherson
59 Posted 11/01/2012 at 10:37:38
Martin, agree with what you say in the main. For the life of me, I cannot understand why Kenwright just does not say enough is enough. Even allowing for his narcissistic tendencies and bravado, surely he too can take no more? Just how many lies can HE utter without looking at himself and thinking as I say, enough is enough? Make no mistake, (in the context of all that's gone on) in many fans eyes this Arteta lie will be his biggest and most heinous.

I am left thinking, what on earth compels him to keep hold? I'm not talking about the sale of the club here - I am talking of stepping aside and letting a new figurehead come in and take the club forward. Just a figurehead.

My conclusion, which of cause can only be alleged and due to the fog Kenwright has created, is that something/someone behind Kenwright is involved here, Someone who needs Kenwright to stay/sell and generate their return that Kenwright has promised as part of their "backing" (Underwriting the debt). Sir Philip Green and Robert Earl are foremost in my mind. The last thing they would need is their puppet going and a fresh face coming in to reveal exactly why we are in the mess we are in.

Amit Vithlani
60 Posted 11/01/2012 at 10:29:01
1. Kunal et al - on the non-renewal of season tickets: its kind of happening already given our falling attendances. However that doesn't mean a mass non-renewal or attendance is a good idea. Season ticket sales service the club's securitised debt (previously with Bear Sterns, can't remember with who now). All that happens is we increase the likelihood of defaulting on our loans. Going into administration would be a disaster. It doesn't guarantee we will be rid of Kenwright & Co, because if they have lent the club money they will be in the queue of creditors. I am not a season ticket holder but have signed up to ETV, bought a shirt, got the credit card and done as much from South Africa as I can. The reason is that it still gives us a voice. I would rather achieve change without the club going into administration. With the efforts of BU and the new Trust we may be able to accomplish that.

2. On the Arteta money, Moyes has always had a tendency to play things down, so probably best to wait until the Window and see. That said, no one should be surprised if we make no signings, given how dire our operating performance is.

3. The priority for the club has to be a clear direction and a clear plan for sustainability. What happens on the pitch is becoming increasingly secondary. Matters on the pitch (whether with Moyes in charge or not) will not improve unless we have a clear plan. After DK, there is no clear evidence of where we are heading. As I see it, our options are currently limited to a search for outside investment, tapping the fan base, or selling players. Despite the limited options, a well structured, clear and organised approach could yield fruits: for example, the fans may be willing to contribute if we have confidence in a new board; or we could follow the Ajax model and sell players, provided the funds received are well managed and put to good use, such as paying off expensive loans and investing in the academy; the search for outside investment must be done in a more organised professional manner to avoid future instances of discussions with people living in 1-bedroom apartments.

We have known we are in a mess for a long time, and I dont think Moyes' statements change that. The pressure from BU et al must continue.
Dave Wilson
61 Posted 11/01/2012 at 10:47:29
Roman

"hatred" ? you whipping yourself into a frenzy lad.

Show me where Moyes has lied to you, Show me two contradictory statements from him.
And please dont give me the old "I remember him saying something like . . " nonsense. Concrete evidence please.

if Moyes has led me up the garden path I want to know about it.

So come on, If you - or anybody else - is going to lable the guy a "liar" put up or shut up
Kiern Moran
62 Posted 11/01/2012 at 11:00:22
I do not think we have 10 million to spend or indeed any or much money. However, if we did have a pot of money to spend and had players in mind we might for virtue of haggling not announce in the media exactly how much monmey the club has to spens.
Kevin Tully
63 Posted 11/01/2012 at 10:51:44
If anyone on here thinks the Arteta sale wasn't engineered to happen as late as possible, then think again. That deal was complete days before the window closed.

The guy never even had time for a medical, after a serious injury. Funny eh?

The Arteta sale was only announced as late as it was, so that lying cunt could hide the real reasons for the sale.

Where are the wankers who want credentials now?
Tony J Williams
64 Posted 11/01/2012 at 11:10:24
"Where are the wankers who want credentials now? " - Who's that aimed at?

Just because one party is useless, doesn't mean there shouldn't be due dilligence for the next one.
Tom Winek
65 Posted 11/01/2012 at 11:14:42
2011/2012 will be instantly forgettable but i'll continue to support Moyes. He's made some strange decisions this season, which have infuriated me at times, but unlike a lot of fickle, memory-loss suffering supporters on here, I appreciate what he's done for us.
Neil Pickering
66 Posted 11/01/2012 at 11:14:37
I happen to love our dear old chairman, and technically he hasnt lied. There has been investment; we signed Donovan for 2 months havent we?

What more do we want? We still have moyes, he is an amazing manager so everyone other than knowledgable Everton fans say. We will be fine this season. Once the injured lads come back they will be like new signings, and we will push on up the league like we always do in the second half of the season.

Nothing for us to worry about!
Paul Gladwell
67 Posted 11/01/2012 at 11:16:38
Dave, to be fair mate, he came out and said we never had to sell Arteta but he wanted to leave and he did not want to begrudge him that and it was too late for us to spend the money.
Well how come he never had those same feelings when Lescott wanted to leave for a far bigger and better challenge than Arteta?
Also why did he not give Jags that chance too when Arsenal made a bid for him?
Moyes surely knew that Arteta money was going to the bank and yet he basically said we could have spent that money if the deal was not done so late, lets be honest he could have said no to Arteta and i believe he would of if he could.
Kevin Tully
68 Posted 11/01/2012 at 11:18:58
Tony, that comment is aimed at any idiot who suggests the Blue Union are somehow ruining the club, or are at fault for pointing out the we have con-men running Everton.

They should be fucking knighted.
Barry Rathbone
69 Posted 11/01/2012 at 11:24:41
Dave Wilson

"Moyes insisted that the decision to sell Arteta was taken for "football reasons" but was forced to concede that he will not be given the proceeds to spend on new players.

"I think everybody knows that the bank wanted the money. I think you all knew that," said Moyes."

Extracted from the OP.

2 contradictory reasons - it's either one or the other.

Most people would call that lieing
Denis Richardson
70 Posted 11/01/2012 at 11:03:53
Sam @487 - one question. Kenwrights lies aside and lack of funds aside, would you be happy to see Moyes remain Everton manager for another 5-10 years?

If we had some cash, would you rather Moyes be given the money so we can continue with another decade of defend first football (which was also our style before players stopped coming through the door) or would you rather bring in a new manager with fresh ideas?
Martin Mason
71 Posted 11/01/2012 at 11:26:23
Kevin, evidence of con-tricks please also evidence that the late sale of Arteta was engineered to hide the reasons for the sale. Please don't state opinion as fact.
James Morgan
72 Posted 11/01/2012 at 11:26:58
Just now on talkSPORT they are talking about Everton, a guy told Quinn and Saggers that he was a supporter of Billy liar until he saw the video from the other day, hopefully many more have turned against the fiend!
Roman Sidey
73 Posted 11/01/2012 at 11:23:07
Dave, Paul said it and I'll say it again.

Moyes said in the press after the August transfer window that the only reason he let Arteta go was because Arsenal came in with a bid, Moyes told Arteta he wanted to keep him, but looked him in the eye and said "You want to go don't you?"

If today's revelations, and Moyes' quote of "I think everybody knows that the bank wanted the money. I think you all knew that," is a true quote, then he has lied to us. Directly. Fuck him! He's as bad as Kenwright.
Henry Weindling
74 Posted 11/01/2012 at 11:00:09
I?ve defended David Moyes on this site before, and having read a lot of the above, feel the need to do so again.

I agree that sometimes his tactics and team selections can be frustrating, however we should judge him on his results and past league finishes. Everton are a club that have massively punched above their weight over the past seasons and the sole reason for this is David Moyes. With the size of our squad, and the money constraints of the last few years, it?s amazing that we?re still a top half club. A lot of other clubs (Leeds, Middlesbrough, West Ham to name a few) have been relegated with far greater resources than Everton

A lot of people seem to forget very quickly that this is the man who delivered a 4th place finish, an FA Cup Final, and a couple of very good European adventures. I didn?t hear anyone complaining about his style of management back then.

In comparison to Harry Redknapp, I agree with Dave Wilson @ 449, there is no comparison. Moyes has bettered Harry in almost every area and £ for £ is by far the better manager. We must also remember that for every Gareth Bale that Harry Signs, there are three or four flops that signed for vast amounts of money...Crouch, Bent, Zokora, Bassong, Pavyluchenko, Palacios, Jenas, Gomes (about £60 in total there!). If Moyes had half the cash that Harry had at his disposal, we would be a top four club, not just challenging for the top four as Spurs are.

The worry for Evertonians should be not how can we replace Moyes, but whether Moyes himself starts to wonder if it?s all worth it.
Dave Wilson
75 Posted 11/01/2012 at 11:25:55
You see Paul thats my problem.

He "BASICALLY said we could have spent that money " . .no he didnt. He didnt say anything of the sort.

If you guys want to convince yourselves that`s what he said, then fine, but it dosent make Moyes a liar . .it just makes you wrong.

Moyes initially turned down the offer for Arteta, just as he turned down their offer for Jags,
He PROVED didnt have to sell, simply by turning down BOTH offers. The difference being Arteta - by his own admission - said he wanted to go.

There is a very clear difference between HAVING to sell and knowing that if you do, the money will go straight to the banks.
Moyes was accutely aware of that difference
Sam Hoare
76 Posted 11/01/2012 at 11:34:37
Denis@503

Good question. As much as i think Moyes gets far too much unfair criticism on here i would not be adverse to a change. There's no doubt an air of staleness. I also would not be necessarily adverse to him staying.

I think two years ago we were actually playing pretty good football. As now we lacked a good striker but i think we looked good. Aresnal lite!

I guess it depends how much money we have and what we are aiming for. If we were to be getting small amounts say £10m to spend a year then i would back Moyes to build competitive sides able to mix it up. If we were getting £40m or more then i would think we could afford someone with European experience and used to top players.

Does that make sense?
Tim Marchant
77 Posted 11/01/2012 at 11:36:20
I have supported Kenwright in the past, to the hilt and been abused for it on here, but now even my eternal optimism is wearing out.

I don't blame him for having a pop at the Blue Union though, after the abuse posted on here on other sites, what he said is fairly mild in comparison, and from one point of view, true. They did betray HIM in order to get the information out to the fans, and he views himself as the embodiment of the club.

He'll wriggle himself out of it, by saying something like he failed to stipulate how much money would be available, or the situation has changed since then, or the banks have refused to saction the funds he wanted to provide, leaving DM to do the best he can with the hand he has been dealt.
Paul Gladwell
78 Posted 11/01/2012 at 11:42:29
Dave, lescott wanted to go and lets be honest had better reasons than Arteta and Moyes did everything possible to turn him into a villain and although we all agreed with him to an extent, he went way over the top in the end making himself look like a bitter fool which even had our own players coming out sticking up for lescott.
Dave Wilson
79 Posted 11/01/2012 at 11:42:13
Roman

If this was a court of law, you`d have been laughed out of it.

You and Paul cant even agree with each other on what actually happened
Roman Sidey
80 Posted 11/01/2012 at 11:42:37
Gee, Dave, you really can twist things into your own corner can't you.

If you read one post above you, there's that old "pound for pound" quote coming out again.

Henry, the last time Moyes HAD half that amount to spend he apparently fucked it up royally.

To be fair, I began to doubt Moyes' as a man-manager around the Lescott Saga time. I still thought he had a bit of football quality left, despite having and FA Cup in one hand and auctioning it off with the other. Now, I wouldn't care if he wins every game for the rest of the season. I want rid, and I don't think he deserves to see the next board of this club. Fuck, I don't think he deserves to see the next transfer window.
Kevin Tully
81 Posted 11/01/2012 at 11:41:05
Martin #504

What do you want? The actual paperwork, telephone conversations I have recorded between Arteta and his agent? A transcript of Moyes & Kenwright in the boardroom that evening?

IF someone has lied to me on numerous occasions, on numerous subjects, I will take that into consideration they are PROBABLY telling me lies again.

Apologies if i can't convince you the club is run by fraudsters & liars, that is my personal opinion.

Oh, and have you read the e-mails between the club employees?

They would put Kim Jong ill and his regime to shame.
Roman Sidey
82 Posted 11/01/2012 at 11:50:42
Dave, with comments like that #513, you're slipping again.
Tony J Williams
83 Posted 11/01/2012 at 11:49:14
Roman, what's that?

The sale of Arteta, who put in a transfer request after the offer from Arsenal was rejected and then an admission that teh money made from teh deal ended up with the banks.

How is that lying?

Arteta went for footballing reasons, to play for a better side in the Champions League, nothign to do with the money we got for him ending up....predictably....with the banks.
Dave Wilson
84 Posted 11/01/2012 at 11:48:37
Paul

Moyes made no secret of the fact that he wanted to keep Lescot. Man City had acted shamefully. Unfortunately money talked, They got their way, but how in this world do you come to the conclusion Moyes lied ?

Anyway Guys

I`m ignoring all calls for a boycott, I`m off down to Spurs
Paul Gladwell
85 Posted 11/01/2012 at 11:56:19
Dave I am not debating with Roman and that's alls it is a debate, chill out will you.
David Minahan
86 Posted 11/01/2012 at 11:55:32
Ok so the £10m Arteta money has gone!
What about the money from Pinnear,Yakubu and Beckford, and the loan deal for Joseph Yobo.?
Oh and wasn't there supposed to be £40m "ringfenced" for Project Kirkby??
Henry Weindling
87 Posted 11/01/2012 at 12:00:16
Roman @ 514 - With regards to Moyes' record in the transfer market, I agree some signings have not been great. Billy has been a poor signing. And as highly as I rate Felliani, the amount of money we paid was huge by Evertons standards. He still has a lot to prove.

However again in Moyes' defence, he has made some unbelievable signings which speak for themselves - Howard, Jags, Lescott, Cahill, Arteta. Even Saha was a very shrewd bit of business.
Roman Sidey
88 Posted 11/01/2012 at 12:01:45
Dave, I wish I could be on my way to Spurs too. If I lived in Britain I would be. I don't think I'd be able to boycott. I would, however, hold a placard of some description.

Tony, the way I read Moyes' above quote about the bank wanting the money, leads me to believe that the sale was forced, or that A sale was forced, and that was the bid we received. There's plenty of ways it can be interpreted, that is how I, and many others, read it.

As I've said, Moyes goes along with the lies of Bill Kenwright, therefore he is part of the problem.

I find it extremely hard to believe that such staunch Moyes supporters, whilst understanding why he does this, aren't irate when he pats "the best chairman I could ask for" on the shoulder all the fucking time.

Kevin Tully, that was a funny little analogy, and from now on I will be referring to Bill Kenwright as Our Dear Leader.
Roman Sidey
89 Posted 11/01/2012 at 12:09:01
Henry, for how long can a man rest on those laurels?
Roberto Birquet
90 Posted 11/01/2012 at 12:14:06
Robby No 1
Moyes, is getting off scott free from most blues. Even today, he said Spurs are one of the biggest spenders if not the biggest in the Prem....

What the fuck, last close season Harry couldn't sign anyone for a decent amount of money.
--------------------
For Heaven's Sake. Spurs have spent shit loads over the past few years. Any Club is not merely what it spent in one summer, but what it has accumulated over a few years. Spurs have spent very big - more than Liverpool, and behind only Chelsea, and perhaps United before City hit the jackpot in finding the best buyers around.
Jem Traynor
92 Posted 11/01/2012 at 12:07:31
James McPherson
460, Sadly this post hit's the nail on the head for me I couldn't agree more.
Liam Reilly
93 Posted 11/01/2012 at 12:04:33
Arsenal came in with a significant bid at the 11th hour. Arteta told Moyes he wanted to go and because Moyes turned him down the previous year, he agreed to the transfer request.

As the club is heavily in debt to the banks, who honestly believes that they would just sit idly by and let 10 Million sit in the Everton accounts until such a time that it could be spent in January? Of course they wanted the cash and rightly got it.

Gross mismanagement from the board has put the club in a perilous position, but it is what it is, so reducing the debt whilst staying in the division has to be the priority at the moment otherwise administration and a firesale awaits.
Martin Mason
94 Posted 11/01/2012 at 12:11:20
Henry #508 What you have said here is a very valid defence of Moyes. Same with the board in general, it just may be that the club is not dragging the club into oblivion but are doing well in very difficult circumstances.
Roman Sidey
95 Posted 11/01/2012 at 12:22:17
Liam, it goes further than reducing debt. They have to completely turn around the business model. Simply reducing debt is like getting a job, earning enough to pay rent for a month, then quitting your job.
Paul Carr
96 Posted 11/01/2012 at 12:21:48

Preumably Barclays are more relaxed having received over 10 million 6 months ago, so any funds now raised should be available- unlessof course we get them on 31st January at midnight again! It is also in Barclay's interest for the club to remain in the Premier League.
On a more positive note why isn't Billy going back to Russia so we can buy a decent striker like Jordan Rhodes.
Ciarán McGlone
97 Posted 11/01/2012 at 12:24:26
"Show me where Moyes has lied to you, Show me two contradictory statements from him. "
__________________________

Moyes; "I have the best chariman in the world"

Moyes; "I have had no money to spend for two years"

An obvious contradiction.

Paraphrased .....but even you might get the point Dave. Or maybe not.
Daniel A Johnson
98 Posted 11/01/2012 at 12:09:41
I was stood at the metro this morning and opp me was a poster with "BIll Kenwright" presents "Dreamcoats and Petticoats" the stage show.

So thats where the Arteta money went............on his latest show
Sam Hoare
99 Posted 11/01/2012 at 12:24:59
I still don't see how Moyes has lied? Because he let Arteta go, even though he knew the money would probably go to the bank?
Liam Reilly
100 Posted 11/01/2012 at 12:26:36
Roman
I'm not saying it doesn't, but the Debt Management and Wages to Turnover ratio are presently at critical levels, hence the banks not unexpected stance.

So servicing the debt is a must at this time, whilst buying over priced players in the Jan window on vast salaries would not be permitted by the Banks.
Robbie Muldoon
101 Posted 11/01/2012 at 12:11:06
The Guardian is the best newspaper around, it's the only one I read, and the only one I trust to publish researched articles with an unbiased agenda.

I actually feel quite depressed that it seems many Evertonians were expecting the Arteta money to be made available in January. These people need to switch their brains on and wake up. It's shameful to keep falling for the lies Kenwright expels.

What's more depressing is that I can expect absolutely nothing from White Hart Lane tonight, not a sniff. The last I looked I saw Spurs had odds of 8/15 to win. That is an easy way to make money.

Good to hear Moyes say "A big part for us will be to make sure we develop our own players and bring our own players through and pick up one or two from the lower leagues who we can hopefully turn into Premier League players."

So even more worrying to see Barkley languishing in the reserves behind Neville and McFadden. I think this is a genuine cause for concern now. I'm sure an £8-10m sale of the lad will keep the banks happy and give Kenwright some spare changes to hand to Davey.



Phil Rodgers
102 Posted 11/01/2012 at 12:37:28
I have 2 young children and I am not bringing them up to support Everton.
Robbie Muldoon
103 Posted 11/01/2012 at 12:39:50
If Moyes and Barkley have had a falling out as Tony Marsh has claimed on another thread, then I'd want to see Moyes go before Barkley.
Denis Richardson
104 Posted 11/01/2012 at 12:25:13
Sam@503 - fair enough. We're not too far apart. To be honest I was never that big a Moyes fan from the off - didn't know anything about him so gave him the benefit of the doubt. Thought he did a great job in stabilising the ship but was not good enough to take us further. We should have parted company 2-3 years ago so that a better manager could take the club forward - playing better football at the same time. (Think it would also have been better for him in hindsight as well (salary aside)).

Right now, I think the whole club needs to be turned upside down from owner to manager to players - complete spring cleaning.

For those posters having a go at people voting with their feet - this is probably the best form of protest that will result in BK leaving the fastest. As the empty seats increase in number the banks and other creditors will start putting more pressure on BK and the board to sort the situation out. Carrying on selling the family silver will just increase the snowball effect getting us to the same conclusion faster.

I really feel that the tide that started with a slow turn in August is gaining momentum now and this summer/year will see a significant change. If Moyes really cares about his integrity and he is again given no cash in Jan or the summer, then by staying he will really be telling the world he is just there for the cash - after moaning about it ad nauseam.

Keep watching and keep the faith, the end of the tunnel is getting closer.
Neil Humphreys
105 Posted 11/01/2012 at 12:54:29
Doddy, I think you can come out of your self appointed exile now. The games up. You can now join the rest of us who have seen the light. Doddy is dead, Long Live the Fres(field) Prince!!!

Have to laugh - otherwise you'd cry. As Moyes said, did any of us seriously think that Kenwright would stand by his word? He is the ultimate Walter Mitty.
Mike McIlroy
106 Posted 11/01/2012 at 12:56:46
does anyone know how to send a personal email to BK - think we should lobby the lying twat until he leaves!
Michael Brooks
107 Posted 11/01/2012 at 12:56:41
I think we all need to remember old Bill is Everton?s number one fan and he told us that! Thankfully he hasn?t lied to us on a constant basis!
Paul Carr
108 Posted 11/01/2012 at 12:34:30
Any honest manager with integrity ( like Martin O'Neil) would have resigned by now,on the basis of lack of support from a discredited and disingenuous Board, whose mismanagemnt has left him with diminishing resources for the last 3 years.
I suspect DM is merely sitting tight, waiting for the call from Spurs just as soon as Harry either gets the England job or goes to jail for tax fraud.
Robbie Shields
109 Posted 11/01/2012 at 12:46:40
Agreed Denis #548, the end game is fast approaching. Normal procedure is for everybody to abandon ship looking for life rafts to save their own sorry arses first. Who will be first though, Kenwright, Moyes or Elstone??????????????
Phil Rodgers
110 Posted 11/01/2012 at 13:01:08
I am guessing fellaini was told this before he signed a new contract. I can see another leaving this month
Peter Warren
111 Posted 11/01/2012 at 13:03:18
Moyes has not lied. He let Arteta go cos he wanted to, he didn't have to as he showed turning down bid for Jags. Obviously, the bank do need the money , they are owed £50m or whatever with a min of £5m accuring each season, that's when we're finishing between 5th and 8th place - unlikely this season.

The debt is my biggest concern rather than the manager. I believe board took a massive risk, hoping for Champions League (1) but secondly, all their eggs being in the basket of DK and they would then sell for a big tidy profit. Since then, everything has collapsed and we're in fre fall.

Hopefully, wages are under control now they have let several high earners leave. I would be interested to know if this means the debt will not increase which would be a start.

They also need to reduce debt level from £50m or whatever to a realistic level, under £10m I would say. To do this, sadly, they need to try and sell players as these are only assets we have.

Moyes likes Kenwright because he's never forced him to sell anybody - that's my belief anyway. However, for good of club, we need to reduce debt and I actually think Moyes is doing this, choosing to let Arteta go instead of Jags etc. We need to look forward not back and unfortunately, short term future is bleak and more players need to be moved on. I suspect Heitinga and Billy at minimum will be moved on next either this window or next and probably Fellani too.
Colin O'Keeffe
112 Posted 11/01/2012 at 13:16:50
Not an apologist for BK by any means - but I don't believe we had to sell Arteta to keep the banks off our backs - as the Echo said. Therfore the club were right to ask for an apology.

Re. Arteta, I think the guy heard of Arsenal's late bid and decided he wanted out - and Moyses wasn't going to keep an unhappy player. I don't believe Moyes was told to sell the player.

However once a sale has been made then obviously the banks take notice and will start making demands. Everyone knew that that 10 million was never going to made available - the banks wouldn't allow that.

All that BK said was that 'some money' would be available in January - now that's pretty vague and if you get some players in on loan then that's akin to spending some money. So as far as claiming the club / BK a liar on this i'm not sure where people are coming from.
Ste Traverse
113 Posted 11/01/2012 at 13:24:47
It's now obvious that BK's 'there will be cash to spend in January' was yet another of his bare faced lies to get fans off his back after the sales of Arteta,Beckford and Yakubu.

And to think some dickheads were applauding him just a few days later when we played Villa and his smug smarmy grid appeaered on the big screen.

Can this disgrace of a man sink any lower?

Well,yes, is probably the answer to that.
Sam Hoare
114 Posted 11/01/2012 at 13:40:00
By the way, people who said Spurs did not spend much money this summer.... Could you imagine if we would have had the wages to have brought in Adebayor and Scott Parker? We'd have a pretty decent team:
John Ford
115 Posted 11/01/2012 at 13:40:38
Ive no problem with Moyes speaking like this as it places pressure firmly on Kenwright.

Over the past eight years Everton have the best record of any non money club (sky four...now six with City and Spurs) in terms of premier challenge/position. Even when Spurs started spending we were better than then. Unfortunately that has now caught up with us and arry has spent big over the past three seasons which has allowed them to break the glass ceiling. Meantime we have moved from a modest spend to virtual paupers. Twats!

Peter Laing
116 Posted 11/01/2012 at 13:42:10
Colin O'Keefe #560 and Dave Wilson in this thread before, in answer to your assertions that "I don't believe we had to sell Arteta to keep the banks off our backs", do you not believe then the contents of the leaked e.mails from the master of spin Ian Ross when he quite clearly states that at least one if not two marque player's would need to be sold to prevent the apparent foreclosure that was imminent.

Kenwright pleading with the banks, the subsequent PR spin from Ian Ross and his cronies in the media, apologies from the Echo and there are still people willing to offer Kenwright credibility, I really do question why we bother.
John Ford
117 Posted 11/01/2012 at 13:50:10
Agreed Sam. Fellaini and Parker in the centre with Drenthe Osman and Donovan/Gueye supporting Adebayor in attack.

Spurs spend last summer was nowhere near the hugfe wads they'd spent in the previous two/three seasons, so it went virtually unnoticed. It still made us look like the poor relations though!
Anto Byrne
118 Posted 11/01/2012 at 13:32:44
Its a pity Moyes didn't come out and say he was dismantling this aging team and would introduce young and up-coming players throughout the season, such as Wallace, Baxter, Duffy, McAleny and Vellios, and put out to pasture some of the aging players such as Neville, Saha and Cahill.

He could have got money for Jags and Saha and even Sunderland wanted Cahill. With Sales from these players and Arteta (and he should have offloaded Bily) he could have raised a good £40m, he could have then gone shopping for another Lescott, Cahill or Yobo another up-and-coming Spaniard from somewhere.

We would have appreciated that we were in transition and rebuilding with youngsters who at least would have a fucking go. But alas no... we play with 9 defensively minded players plus the keeper and play keep-ball crabby dross and play for the 1-0 WBA style wins get massive strokes of luck at Blackburn and Fulham ? six points we were gifted.

We should be able to eek out another 16 points from the next 18 games otherwise we slip into oblivion and can look forward to the likes of Birmingham, Coventry and whoever.
Sam Hoare
119 Posted 11/01/2012 at 13:58:55
Agreed John. The sad simple fact is that money, be it transfer fees or wages buys better players. We have none, hence swimming against the current.
Mark Murphy
120 Posted 11/01/2012 at 13:54:08
Whilst I do not think Moyes is all of a sudden a poor manager I think he has given up and is resigned to mediocrity.

I am convinced that come May he will leave of his own volition to go to a more ambitious club. IF Bill thought as much of Moyes as he claims to, he would realise that he is holding back a once-promising manager who is dying a slow death.

What that will mean for our club remains to be seen but if we do not add to this squad this window I cannot see any other scenario.

Everton and David Moyes are a busted flush.

ps: I don't blame Moyes ? I blame Kenwright ? just to make that clear.
Tony J Williams
121 Posted 11/01/2012 at 14:00:00
Without taking into conseration players sold and "net spend"

'Arry, since coming in 2008 has spent £174m at Spurs, Moyes has spent £35m or one Andy Carroll
Kunal Desai
122 Posted 11/01/2012 at 13:58:10
Just my personal opinion and that is I fear it will take something disasterous like administration or relegation which will benefit the club in the longer term. Though this will trigger a mass clearout at the club from top to bottom. Perhaps in 3-5 years time we can come back a more thorough and effective business with the entertainment industry. We need people at the club runnning EFC as a business and not as a joke shop. There has to be processes and procedure in place within all forms of the business. People brought in for specific expertise.
Sean Stevenson
123 Posted 11/01/2012 at 14:00:50
Any business which looses £13 million a year, with no hope of an improvement to this figure, is going into administration. The slow selling of assets (property as well as players) only delays the process.

Kenwright has no business sense, that's clear from from the recorded interview. The only thing BU have betrayed is his gross incompetence.

If we go into administration, the points penalty will mean relegation. Even worse, if we ge relegated first, administration would be inevitable and a further points penalty in the Championship.

I don't think any of our previous owners allowed the club to get into a situation where we are losing £13 million a year.
Mike Manchester
124 Posted 11/01/2012 at 13:50:19
IMWT............But Bill is testing my patience.
Steve Sweeney
125 Posted 11/01/2012 at 14:16:33
I posted this on another thread but it is still relevent I think.

The very sad an realistic scenario is that we could be in Administration by the Summer.
Gates will continue to decline.
With the continued Dire Football being served up and Billy Liars continued mis- truths can anyone envisage the Early Bird Season Ticket offer being taken up by the Fans.
I would think that Season Ticket sales for Next season will be at an all time Low.
This in itself will put even more pressure on our Uselss Board. (The Season Ticket Revenue has already Been Securitised along with the TV Money)
They have nothing left to sell except players. The Chicken is surely coming home to roost.
This reminds me of that comedy film where the boat runs out of fuel mid ocean and they burn it to keep on sailing.
Come on Doddy Lets hear the possitive!!
I know you said you would wait till after the Deadline but Moyes has announced that contrary to your belief, Bill was only joking when he told everyone in September that Arteta's Transfer Fee was "RINGFENCED"
for Moyes to spend in January
Mark Boulle
126 Posted 11/01/2012 at 13:56:29
I was up from London for the Norwich game in late December. One of the people I went to the game with, who is from Liverpool, knows Elstone.

He told me (and this is conjecture that I cannot prove) that one of Kenwrong's problems is that he borrowed money from Philip Green to pay for his 30% shareholding but, buffoon that he is, he agreed that he would pay back double the amount that he borrowed!

I'm not sure what figures are involved but, if the rumour is true (and it would explain the shadow of Green hanging over the club), BK is stuck because selling for the club's true value would not allow him to meet his repayment obligations. Hence, perhaps, the wildly unrealistic £150m sale figure that has been quoted...
Joe Bibb
127 Posted 11/01/2012 at 14:29:01
Just heard Moyes on Radio Merseyside telling us how good Bale is and Adebayor and others, well I think now our lads should all wear nappies and not shorts Moyes has them crapping themselves .

Get the clown out of Everton Football Club now, the man is a joke. He said he would pay to watch an entertaining Spurs team, lol. Well he wouldn't pay to watch the crap he serves up as Everton manager.

Why didn't he say "Gareth Bale? We have Baines so we are not worried." Sorry that would have been positive and promoting Everton, not Moyes job is it?
Joe Bibb
128 Posted 11/01/2012 at 14:35:18
Here is an idea: get a manager, give him ten years, let him produce a young attacking team with shots from outside the box, have a go in Cup competitions with two up front at home, don't play injured players, pass the ball through the middle to the record signing centre forward, take your choice Beattie, Johnson the Yak etc. Maybe the ground will fill up, maybe they will spend money maybe we would be financially safe...

I know I live in a dream world it never happened under Catterick did it? When the Moores money dried up, Harvey, Royle, Husband , Hurst, Whittle, Wright, etc we won the League but Youngsters will win you nothing, I am always being told... lol.

Moyes's latest loan deal: Weir... and maybe Stubbs to do a Scholes and come out of retirement.

The Ground should be renamed Titanic, we are sinking fast.
Steve Cotton
129 Posted 11/01/2012 at 13:57:55
1. Arteta was allowed to go because he was on high wages for the next 4 years and playing crap and 29. wheras Jags was only on 35k a week and playing ok (not great but ok) if Jags was sold we would have had to spend the money on a replacement and Bill wanted the money for the bank not just to juggle the team around.
2. Fellaine has been offered a good contract in order to sell him and not let him leave for nothing, nothing more than that
3. Drenthe and Count Straqula were desperate loans and both will go back no matter how well they play
4. Steve Round is useless
5.The club now realise that playing in a city that has the financial clout of LFC is futile and we will end up mid table in the championship (as someone has already said)
6. Bily is currently playing too shit to sell
7. McFadden must have something on Moysie how else could he get a contract
8. Bill wants the debt down to maximise the profit when he sells the club in the summer

none of this is rocket science so just accept we are in serious decline and go and worry about something else.. it is too late to turn this ship.....
Dave Lynch
130 Posted 11/01/2012 at 15:28:04
Agree with Steve Cotton.
The iceberg is imminent.
Ray Roche
131 Posted 11/01/2012 at 15:37:39
Steve Cotton.

I'm sure Mc Fadden must have a photo pf Moyes shaggin' a goat.
Jimmi James
132 Posted 11/01/2012 at 15:34:32
Just got in from another day at the coal face and tuned in to Sky sports only to hear Mark Hughes will be given subsantial funds to guide QPR towards challenging for Europe next season, QPR for fucks sake, yes I know when a club hire a new manager the expectations may be spouted as unrealistic but for QPR to even think of Europe never mind say it just twats me right in the head when I think of how we have become a laughing stock, and on the same note as being a laughing stock they reminded us on Sky sports that if spurs beat us by 13 goals they will be second in the table. We are a fucking joke, welcome to Leeds in royal blue. Fucking management.
Denis Richardson
133 Posted 11/01/2012 at 15:22:51
Tony @578 - sorry but you do need to take into account players sold as well.

Spurs in the last 3 years have spend about £140m on player transfer fees. In that same time they have also received about £122m in transfer sales fees so the manager has generated most of the funds through player sales. It's not as if the board has had to raise £140m in fresh capital for him. Net spend of £18m approx.

In the same time Everton have spent about £39m on players and received about £52m in transfer fees so net spend about -£13m.

So in total a £31m difference between the two clubs in transfer fees.

Figures from http://www.transferleague.co.uk/premiership-transfers/tottenham-hotspur-transfers.html

Not taking any side but this paints a slightly different picture......yes Moyes has had less money but most of Spurs' transfer kitty has come from player trading....
Denis Richardson
134 Posted 11/01/2012 at 15:49:05
Make that last 4 years not 3...
Brian Lea
135 Posted 11/01/2012 at 15:53:28
come on guys, it's now time to join as one to get rid of kenwright.......he simply has to go....up to now it is just a couple of marches, but we now have to be heard at the match....so come on make ourselves heard......or it is dour times ahead...........this is EVERTON F.F.S......
Danny Jones
136 Posted 11/01/2012 at 15:58:14
What's the story here?

I haven't read anywhere that the Arteta money was available to Moyes to spend. In fact, the Sky page says, "There will be not a lot of money in terms of what other clubs are spending on centre-forwards but there will be money."
Also, nobody denied that the money from the Arteta sale went to the bank. They only said that Arteta wasn't sold at the behest of the bank.

If you cry 'liar' you need to be especially accurate or may you become one, inadvertently or otherwise.
Steve Pugh
137 Posted 11/01/2012 at 15:51:31
There seems to be an opinion amongst some people that Moyes saying the sale of Arteta was for footballing reasons and then saying that everyone knew that the banks wanted the money is contradictory. What a load of balls.

Arteta was sold for footballing reasons, ie he wanted a crack at the Champions League, fine. At that point the banks were not involved. As soon as Everton recieved the money the bank wanted it to help reduce our debts. It really is a simple concept to understand. If you owed me money and at the same time someone made you an offer too good to refuse for your car, I am not making you sell your car, but as soon as I find out that you have I will be knocking on your door for the money that you owe me.

Whether or not you like Moyes should be put second until we can sort out the problems of the board. No matter how good the next manager is, if they have to continue with the budgetary restraints that Moyes have they will struggle to achieve anything more than he does. It may be a more attractive form of defeat, but it will still be defeat. So I implore you, support moves to get rid of the board and leave the manger until later. You never know new owners may get rid of him anyway, they normally do.
Amit Vithlani
138 Posted 11/01/2012 at 16:14:05
Is anyone seriously contemplating that administration will be a good thing for the club?

I don't think so. A generation of players will be lost and if we are relegated I can't see anyone wanting to invest. If we can't make money on gates on 30,000 how will we on 20,000?

These days good championship players are also on hefty wages, and we would need to hit bottom before we hit sustainability. Where is the bottom? It could be League one.

The way out of this mess lies in staying in the Premier League, which continues to provide a profile to the club and atleast some publicity to the BK out campaign. More pressure has to be put on Kenwright to relinquish control of the sale / investment process to an independent board, which should also be given responsibility for formulating a business plan to reduce the club's debt whilst maintaining Premier League status.

A very difficult task yes but one which we must aim for before such a drastic event as administration and, inevitably, the relegation which will follow.
Frank Key
139 Posted 11/01/2012 at 16:30:03
'Billshit' is a form of purposefully deceitful language used by those directly involved in the running of Everton Football Club.

As soon as Moyes sold Arteta and claimed it was for 'football reasons' he to became a 'billshitter' in my eyes and I now hold him in no higher regard than the rest of the twats who are destroying the club I love.
Andy Parsons
140 Posted 11/01/2012 at 16:48:02
Anyone blaming Moyes for the decline is way off the mark. Some of us have sat through recent deadline days, speculating and hoping without any joy and the writing has been on the wall - decline is inevitable. You can't let the likes of Pienaar and Arteta go without replacing them and expect otherwise. To suggest otherwise is absolutely ludicrous.

Moyes took over a team that was constantly fighting relegation. The chairman at that time was Bill Kenwright. He turned us into a team that took us into Europe several times and finished in 4th place. He did this in spite of Kenwright, not because. The progress that Moyes made with the team over the last 10 years is literally the ONLY progress made during the Kenwright regime. Moyes has, to be honest, worked miracles - if it wasn't for him, we would have been relegated long ago.

It's inevitable that when his current contract ends, Moyse will walk. Let's see what calibre of manager we attract then - given the resources that will be available at his disposal and the leadership taking the club backwards. Even now he is being very careful with what he says publically - picking his words in such a way as not to permanently damage the club and escalate the downward spiral.

At the end of this season we will lose Drenthe and Straq back to their own clubs and the writing is on the wall when it comes to selling at least another of the established members of the squad. Quite how anyone can think the situation at Everton is anything other than dire I don't know what else to say.
Mark Stone
141 Posted 11/01/2012 at 16:51:09
Robbia between 2006-2011 Spurs have the 4th highest average, annualntransfer outlay (net) of all the clubs in the premier league (~£15.5m)... Behind Citteh, Chelsea and Liverpool (actually very similar to Liverpool but light years behind Citteh and Chelsea. Go back a bit further and you see that between 2003-2011 and they are still the 4th biggest spenders on transfer fees (~14.5m per year). So what that tells you is Spurs have consistently been in the top four spenders in the league consistently for at least 8 years (behind the same teams). In terms of salary, in 2009 and 2010 Spurs had the 6th biggest wage bill (just over £90m per year) below Citteh and Chelsea (~£200m), Liverpool and Man Utd (~£145m) and Arsenal (~£110m). Evertons annual salary at the same time was ~£50m p.a
Mark Stone
142 Posted 11/01/2012 at 17:04:12
But Dennis #603 as I've pointed out above Spurs have been spending big consistently for years! They also pay nearly twice what we do in wages. Also, I don't think it paints that much of a different. Two teams on the edge of European qualification, one has to sell their best players and make a £13m profit, the other is given £15m to strengthen. What do you think is going to happen (p.s they already had a better and bigger squad than us - we were overachieving by competing with them - from a financial point of view)
Colin Wainwright
143 Posted 11/01/2012 at 16:56:27
Go back to sleep Danny Jones, everythings ok. Uncle Bill will read you a nice story. Ssssshhhhh.
Mark Stone
144 Posted 11/01/2012 at 17:13:31
Andy Parsons, I don't know what website you think you are contributing too - writing stuff that is reasonable and justified! Don't you know we're the fourth most successful club in the history of English football, and that as such we have a God given right to be challenging for Europe every season regardless of the fact we have had to sell all of best players?
Nick Waters
145 Posted 11/01/2012 at 16:38:00
Steve Pugh - 'the simple concept' is the opposite of your stance - that if we weren't forced by the banks to sell Arteta then they have no right to claim the proceeds. And if it was for 'footballing reasons' then the money stays in the club and logically is re-invested in 'footballing' also.
Denis Richardson
146 Posted 11/01/2012 at 17:16:18
Mark @626, my post was for the last 4 years as the post I was replying to was also for the same time period.

I am not saying that spurs did not spend more than us nor spend a lot. Was just making it clear that the majority of the cash they were spending was generated through player sales. Saying a club spent 100m on players and another only 10m looks very different if the first club generated say 85m in player sales to fund most of the 100m.

Yes spurs have spent big (and have the billionaire backing from Lewis behind them) but most of the transfer money they have spent has been self generated and not fresh capital. They are actually a very well run business and don't just give free money to the manager to spunk on players - the manager has to generate cash as well through sales.

To sum up, my point is that if you are going to compare transfer spend between two clubs for any period of time you cannot ignore funds from player sales that were reinvested in the squad. E.g. people go on about the RS blowing 35m on Carrol and so were huge spenders, do you really think they would have done that had Chelsea not stupidly given them 50m for Torres?

To be fair to Moyes, a manager would be reluctant to generate cash from sales if he is not sure the money is going to be given to him for new players. This is the only reason I am will into forgive him for not biting Arsenals hand off for the Jags offer.
Sam Hoare
147 Posted 11/01/2012 at 17:16:30
The way I see it, Kenwright has ballsed the whole thing up and Moyes is doing his best to act with dignity, get us points whilst not dragging the owner/club through the dirt.

The only hope is to reduce outgoings by trimming the wage budget and sell off one or two more players till our debt is gone.

If we could sell Bily and heitinga and maybe one big player (Rodwell, Barkley or Fellaini) as well as lose top earners like Cahill, Saha and Neville. Then club may just be profitable again and with no debt. But can we do that and stay in the Premier League? A lot will depend on the young crop coming through.
Nick Waters
148 Posted 11/01/2012 at 17:23:51
And we're missing the point about whether Moyes has lied or not. The issue is whether his relationship with BK is damaging the club either directly or through alienating supporters with all that brings.
Equally this manager who was a fighter and a winner (potentially it seemed years ago) is now a lacklustre, tired, defeatist and safety-first also-ran. It's only this season that I have lost support for Moyes, but like a balloon it suddenly burst rather than deflated. He has to leave soon and I would never have believed I'd have said that if asked 12-18 months ago.
As for Kenwright - what credibility remains? What are the grounds on which anybody can defend this traitor?
Vinny Garstrokes
149 Posted 11/01/2012 at 17:33:12
I don't know what I think - I know I am probably naive and not as aggressive in my protestations as most contributors on here when they voice their disappointment in their own inimitable styles but for my twopenneth - Everton are not a 'virtual' team and the money that comes in goes out four fold. I had every intention of getting my kids what they wanted on their christmas list last year but you know the reality was that other things needed doing and while they had a good time, they didn't get eveything they wanted. I don't think BK is a liar and I don't think DM is a PE teacher - I think that they are up against it like they never have been before and are fighting on a daily basis to keep the club afloat. Mistakes have been made and had the Kings Dock project gone ahead then I think we would have the spending power that Man City have now go. Nobody else is going to come in and sort it out so its down to BK, the board and everybody else at the club to do their infinite best to ensure that we don't find ourselves with 10 point penalty dooming us to the championship
Wayne Smyth
150 Posted 11/01/2012 at 17:41:09
Sam(633), agree completely with you. I've been saying the same thing for a long time. Its the only way forward given that Kenwright is not really up for selling the club so we can expect zero investment.

One thing which narks me is the short-termism that seems to be emanating from the club. Getting people like McFadden in, when I'd much rather see players brought in with youth and potential on their side.

If we can remain in the Premier League, clear down our debts, lower the wage bill, sell off any players on massive salaries, such as Fellaini, Heitinga (and a few others no-doubt), then rebuild with youth and potential then we might succeed.

Doesn't excuse the mis-management of Kenwright(for borrowing too much) or the white-flag-waving and ineptitude of Moyes....but that's the only route forward I can see for us as a club.
Steve Pugh
151 Posted 11/01/2012 at 17:33:28
Nick 630, please don't be so naive; if we are not fulfilling the criteria of sustainability that the bank requires they can lay claim to any money that comes into the club in order to meet our obligations on the overdraft. Generally banks like to see overgrafts disappear at least once a month, if a business is constantly in the red, and isn't showing a level of income that tells the bank that they will get their money back then the business is not meeting their side of the overdraft agreement. If they want to they can either reduce or remove the overdraft completely and demand that the club clears it. Right now our survival is largely dependent on the whims of Barclays bank.
Gavin Ramejkis
152 Posted 11/01/2012 at 17:49:33
Sam if only we could sell .... chose any player you like the money would be swallowed by the banks and make up the shortfall which is already on its way through people voting with their feet, those holes in the first team squad would become even larger, more of the fanbase would say why the fuck should they pay their hard earned whilst some millionaire carpet bagging lying bastards sit back waiting for a payday, oh and who do we play in the roles now vacated by the sales? The paucity and inability to compete at this level drops and the club drops out of the league, its more a case now of what will kill it first - administration and ten point deduction or Billy Lying Bastard selling whatever's left for a stay of execution because thats all it is and has been for the last two years nd counting; players out nothing back in. Roll that to more drops in footfall and less income of the 25% the fans bring in now and less money to service the debt and need to sell more, only trouble is the tipping point already passed and fuck all left to sell.
James McPherson
153 Posted 11/01/2012 at 18:01:52
Just looked at the Official Site. It's headline? "Everton sale continues" (talking about merchandise offers). On this of all days...you could not make it up....only at Everton.

Brought a momentary smile...on a pretty crap day.
Nick Waters
154 Posted 11/01/2012 at 18:03:27
Steve you're still missing the point. The club says we didn't have to sell Arteta - yes? In which case following YOUR logic we voluntarily sold him knowing that the banks would take the cash, even after selling Yak, Beckford and Vaughan. What I'm saying is that the club have deceived Everton fans by claiming a 'footballing' sale when - any way you look at it, using your logic or mine - it was a sale deliberately sanctioned and approved to reduce debt and not to be re-invested in the 'footballing' sense.
Jimmy Digney
155 Posted 11/01/2012 at 18:14:19
Kenwright and Moyes out, and now.

Why? Well let's look at some of the recent comments from Moyes: "People are not coming to Goodison anymore because they are not getting entertained..." "Our Chairman is trying his utmost to supply funds for transfers" ... "Bill loves Everton" Blah, Blah, Blah.

Well whose fucking job is it to entertain those fans??? How much is Moyes on? 65/75 Grand a week...

How much is St Bilco taking out of the club?

Smells like "I will throw the smoke screen up this month, Bill, and we will alternate the excuses until we have confused the fuck out out them fans..."

So what are we gonna do about it? Well, the Shite across the road got rid of their Yanks... We cannot accept anymore excuses ? Kenwright, Moyes
? the two of you... get to fuck now!!!
Brian Keoghan
156 Posted 11/01/2012 at 18:14:54
So no "Mikel money" for Moyes to spend this month? No surprise there then!

My understanding of the ten million was that it is being paid over the length of Arteta's contract (4 years), so does that mean we are still waiting for £7½ million? I think we should be told.

A few weeks back, Moyes said that that the Arteta deal was "good business"; now, with all due respect to "business", I think Evertonians put entertainment and exitement above "business" and Arteta in my view was and is, entertaining and exiting. Mikel has gone and so has the money; has that really been good business?? Really???

Bill Kenwright indicated at the time of the transfer that some of the cash would be available to Moyes but once again has failed to deliver and is sounding more and more like the band leader on the Titanic. I do have sympathy for Bill, he is a staunch Blue, but he is presiding over the slow demise of his beloved club. However, he does not do himself any favours with his ill-advised meeting with the Blue Union tape recorders and his trading of insults through the car park railings to supporters along Goodison Road.

It is time for Bill to be professional and issue a statement telling us how it really is, warts and all; his current posturing is causing division and disunity at a time when we need it in "shedloads".
Ryan Holroyd
157 Posted 11/01/2012 at 18:15:47
Gavin

You're right. It's death by a thousand cunts.

Ray Roche
158 Posted 11/01/2012 at 18:20:37
Brian Keoghan

Brian, if Kenwright had been that honest from the start he'd not be taking as much flak as he is. However, after the complete and utter cock up that WAS the Kings Dock he has just gone from bad to worse. KD was the chance for this club to leap forward, but all his money is "ringenced" lies have led us into the situation we now find ourselves in. The paltry, by todays standards, sum of £30m , I believe, was all that the club needed to find but when the crunch came the ringfenced money didn't exist. Add to that debacle the Kirby episode, Samuelson, Sports Foundation, and some prick in a bedsit in Manchester and we are now so far up shit creek a container full of paddles wouldn't help. Kenwright will go down in sporting history as the lying cheat who destroyed a football club he professed to love,and ruined the dreams of thousands of Everton fans around the world.
James Ennis
159 Posted 11/01/2012 at 18:35:12
The fish rots from the head down - even Moyes is rotten now
John Salmon
160 Posted 11/01/2012 at 18:47:38
Why O Why another friggin lie why o why do,s he lie. We all knew that some money was going to the bank, but for frigs sake, not even a penny. DM if you get anything we need a striker, we can manage without a defender for 6 weeks.
Clive Lewis
162 Posted 11/01/2012 at 18:55:52
OK time for demonstrations I take it everyone is on board now!
Ian Bennett
164 Posted 11/01/2012 at 19:09:30
Ask yourself could Everton have afforded to have kept Pienaar on £60k plus. Who would have been sold if he had signed the 'new' deal. Could be another player hung out to dry by Everton - £3m fee and £3m saved in wages, bank happy.

Brian - add the other £3.3m saved in wages, then yes it looks like a good deal for a club that was in a fire sale. Frankly we might have had to have given him away for nothing
Stephen Kenny
165 Posted 11/01/2012 at 19:34:39
I wonder if the penny's only just dropped with Moyes too???
Ray Said
166 Posted 11/01/2012 at 19:31:20
Used to be 'Nil Satis Nis Optimum' now its 'Cash Converters R Us'
Dean Adams
167 Posted 11/01/2012 at 20:37:59
Clearly Moyes is interested in the Spurs job when he has finnished telling the press how good Arry is. Nice to know he is planning to save us £3.5 million a year by heading to WHL.
Jan Kowsky
168 Posted 11/01/2012 at 22:01:01
Maybe at the next home game those opposed to the Kenwright regime should hold aloft an A4 piece of paper with the word 'BETRAYED' printed on it..



Colin Wainwright
169 Posted 11/01/2012 at 22:16:42
Crackin' idea Jan BTW. Fit in your pocket. No one needs to know.
Paul Melarange
170 Posted 11/01/2012 at 22:18:35
Well there's a shock! The Arteta money went to the bank...

What I would like to know is where the Pienaar, Vaughan, Yakubu and Beckford money went?? The sooner this board sell up, the better!

No wonder fans are voting with their feet, going to have a struggle selling those season tickets for next season!
Joe McMahon
171 Posted 11/01/2012 at 22:36:43
Not what what to say anymore, this is the lowets point in Everton, since 77 when I (sadly) started supporting. No Hope at all, Goodison is a wooden shit heap, and we have the worst Chairman in our history with the most negative manager I've ever known. You can see it now can't you, the tosser reds will wina trophy and we will go down. Cheers Bill, Cheers Moyes. Oh I forgot "Becareful what you wish for, If not Moyes Who" Where are you now Richard Dodd & Ian Tunstead- anything to say?
Joe McMahon
172 Posted 11/01/2012 at 22:40:44
Sorry for typos guys, just too piseed off, like all of us
Joe McMahon
173 Posted 11/01/2012 at 22:41:40
Dean (687) not sure Spurs fans would want 6-7 defenders on the pitch, and hoping to nick a goal. They like attacking football, and get it, We have forgoten what the word attacking means, total Dross since 1996.
Russell Buckley
174 Posted 11/01/2012 at 23:03:15
The sad thing is that I now watch us play and buy the jerseys out of obligation and duty. I don't enjoy watching us play as anyone with a bit of football knowledge knows we are either going to get flogged or play ugly in the hope of sneaking some points.

The club is a complete mess, Moyes seems like a lost man and our senior players are in poor form. Reading the press or fan sites just makes it even more depressing.

So I'll continue to watch the matches but other than that I'm taking a break...just can't see the fucking point at the moment. I'm 26 and only started following in my teens so I've never seen a successful Everton
David Hallwood
175 Posted 12/01/2012 at 00:10:18
Sometimes you've got to ignore what is coming out of someone's mouth and see the actions behind it. Arteta was sold for footballing reasons however when we got the £10 mill it was only then that someone thought it was a good idea to give it all to the banks-does anybody really believe that.

I've posted this on a number of occasions, but there was a fire sale at GP in the summer and all the players were up for sale, but like used car salesmen, they were after top dollar, and it was only when they realised that the Arse wouldn't give them an improved offer for jags etc, they panicked and took any offers on the table; that's why yak, Becks & Arteta was sold to reduce the wage bill and get a few bob in to throw at the debt, if that isn'rt the case where are the replacements?

I can't make out what's going through Bill's head because if it's bad now, how about in two years time; Saha, Distin, Neville, Osman, Hibbert, Jags, Cahill will all be gone or retired with little or no resale value. He must know that instead of treading water we are heading toward the iceberg. How does that increase the value of the club?
Mark Riding
176 Posted 12/01/2012 at 00:47:29
David #779

The last paragraph of your post is so true.. is should scare the shit out of any complacent Everton fans.. we may say that we couldnt do any worse without the players you mention.. but, I can honestly see us going tits up..
Eric Myles
177 Posted 12/01/2012 at 01:20:14
Dave #509, Moyes turned down the first offer for Arteta becuase it was only £5 million, the second offer was only accepted because it was double.

If arsenal had not have upped the offer Arteta would have still been playing for us whether he wanted to go or not.
Mick Davies
178 Posted 12/01/2012 at 01:41:21
"Lie with the dogs and you'll catch their fleas". Lie being a Freudian slip, but Moyes knows what's happening at EFC and if he's been keeping his mouth shut for 10 years while earning obscene amounts of money from our debt ridden club, then besides him being a clueless coach, he's also a charlatan with no thought for the fans or Everton and it's glorious history. Is this the sort of man you want running our club? Is Kenwright the sort of person you'd trust with your pet goldfish? I reckon the answer to both is NO
Eric Myles
179 Posted 12/01/2012 at 01:45:02
Paul #535 "Preumably Barclays are more relaxed having received over £10 million 6 months ago, so any funds now raised should be available"

The problem is as I pointed out before that by the end of the financial year we shall be an additional £14 million in debt on top of what the current level is.

So any player sales will have to go to the bank.
Eric Myles
180 Posted 12/01/2012 at 02:02:06
Mark #585, I think it's on record that the Greggs, specifically Anita Gregg, loaned Kenwright the money to buy his initial shares.

But when the Greggs sold their shares they would surely have asked that the loan be repaid immediately.

And maybe the same person that paid Gregg for his shares also took over BKs debt?
Tom Dodds
181 Posted 12/01/2012 at 05:40:17
The overview of Kenwright's plan for his ownership/success at Everton from the start,was a gamble that one/more of his theatrical productions would hit the jackpot,ie (a la mousetrap etc).
A combination of the events,pre 2007 of the pounds high rise against the dollar and the post 07 london bombings,kept the Yanks/tourists at bay,so any and every production had a tough time.
I have two neighbours who worked for him,and they both claim that staff where getting paid infrequently,and producers where often lied too,regarding famous names he promised them would be onboard.
Back to recent times,he has not let up on this
scenario,and there have been a raft of productions in the last few years,ie' spamalot 'etc.Of course you well may wonder what/where funds came from to fund them.!
It has been published recently that his 'company' has finally started making a profit,albeit only 2 million this year.
The point of my mail therefore is this;all the clubs in the leagues are owned by 'businessmen',which is fair goes and par for the situ ..BUT surely there should of been an independent body at Efc to vet any new owner(s) ????????? (note just like kenwright's claiming to do now !)
Kenwright was a gambler from the start,no one vetted him,no one's contradicted his business plan,
of strike gold with a blockbuster hit play that wiould feed him forever.
Simple as.

John Bourne
182 Posted 12/01/2012 at 06:29:36
I lay the blame firmly at the door of the current board of Directors, they are only too content to continue with the status quo, have they no shame?

They seemingly contribute nothing to the future of this great club, yet are only too happy to enjoy their fine dining and fine wines before every home game, shame on each and every one of them. I voted with my feet some time ago, even turning down free tickets to a home game.

Heavens knows what Harry Catterick would make of this shambles. And as for the clown who is supposedly running the club, words fail me.

Hail to the Thief!
Ian Bennett
183 Posted 12/01/2012 at 07:12:57
Eric 794 - it tells you a lot that wegner had offered just £5m for Arteta, 6 months after Spurs had offered £250k for Neville. Everton were desparate to dump wages and or bring in transfer fees.

The club is a distressed firesale, all reasonable offers accepted. No wonder Moyes is unhappy.
Eric Myles
184 Posted 12/01/2012 at 07:59:58
Tom, Kenwright was up to those tricks a long time before 2007, my contacts with his theatre productions go back pre-2000.
Steve Pugh
185 Posted 12/01/2012 at 11:26:40
Nick, as you have now said The Club, not Moyes. If you reread my original post I am talking about Moyes. He sold Arteta because Arteta wanted to go. That is a footballing reason. After the Lescott affair I think it is fair to say that Moyes learned his lesson about keeping players that want to leave. This thread is saying that Moyes is a liar for saying that from his point of view the Arteta sale was for footballing reasons.
Dave Rice
186 Posted 12/01/2012 at 12:19:55
Whilst it's difficult to defend the running of the club, the demand that Kenwright sells up is a bit pointless.

Everton have been available for sale for years - no-one's buying, and it would appear that without additional funding running a football club is a loss-making exercise.

Difficult to sell anything if no-one wants to buy it.

John Keating
187 Posted 12/01/2012 at 13:23:16
Dave. You are way off base. Kenwright has told us that there have been numerous interested buyers. Are you suggesting that he's lying ??
Just before the next protest he will announce at least another 75 interested parties.
Tim Locke
188 Posted 12/01/2012 at 13:49:38
Robbie, Moyes didn't say last year, he said the last ten years and he said I guess, not I know and too be honest he is not wrong, below a table from 2006 to 2011 so only the last 5 years but gives a picture.

Manchester City lead followed by Chelsea, Liverpool and Tottenham, when looking at net spend. Out of the teams in the Prem at the moment Everton sit at 15 with a net spend of £1m, Tottenham is £76m.

Full table at http://www.transferleague.co.uk/league-tables/2006-2011.html.

If you look at the lifetime of the Prem then we still sit near the bottom http://www.transferleague.co.uk/ compare Tottenham's £178m with our £52m.
Dave Rice
189 Posted 12/01/2012 at 14:01:08
The general rule of thumb on here is that BK lies constantly - are we to take his word as law when it comes to interested parties, but infer he's a liar in everything else?

I have no idea of the truth, and perhaps there have been a number of interested parties - but none have progressed to a sale. And, perhaps quite importantly, I've never heard any party comment publicly that it was interested in buying Everton but the price was too high.

Maybe there are interested parties but they want the club for a ridiculously low amount? Maybe BK has an unreasonable expectation of the value of the club? Maybe BK legitimately wants to sell but only to a buyer that can offer Everton a propserous future? I don't know, but the point is, no-one on here knows and yet most are telling him to sell - who to?


Dave Rice
190 Posted 12/01/2012 at 14:13:52
Tim Locke - 949

It's interesting that our net spend at £52M since the inception of the PL yet for the last 5 years has been £1M.

Remember the days when we bought big - chasing Collymoore, got Kanchelskis, then Nick Barmby, linked with Trevor Sinclair, then the Beattie, Johnson, Yak and Fellaini.

Since then we've fell off the edge.

But the facts are that most clubs are where they are on the merit of the amount of money they have to spend, with some variations for skilled management and good fortune.

Tom Dodds
191 Posted 12/01/2012 at 14:40:59
Re 831# John
A scenarioic shot in the dark here,Green or Granchester,or both of them in cahoots may be hanging/circling round waiting for kenwright to implode,then step in with firesale bids ?
Would sound a plan to me.What say others ?
John Bourne
192 Posted 12/01/2012 at 17:14:02
Re #963 Tom

Indeed Tom, there will be no shortage of vultures circling as Nero fiddles.

The Green involvement troubles me greatly, he has a single agenda, namely a return on any investment he has made being his priority,

Worrying times indeed.
Nick Waters
193 Posted 12/01/2012 at 19:40:49
Hi again Steve Pugh - I think our positions on this are converging a bit and we are both speculating in any case. However if you read the article leading this thread Moyes says

"I think everybody knows that the bank wanted the money'.

I would assume that he includes himself in 'everybody' and following your argument that it would be obvious to all that the bank would call the money in, then it must have been just as obvious to Moyes, being closer to the club than you or I, that approving the Arteta deal would be synonymous with raising money for the bank. That basically means that there are no footballing reasons whatsoever that tally with the sale - long term stability perhaps but footballing reasons? -hardly.



Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads