Everton set to sign Darron Gibson

, 12 January, 202comments  |  Jump to most recent
Man Utd midfielder fits limited Moyes budget
Manchester United midfielder Darron Gibson reportedly had a medical at Finch Farm this evening and is expected to officially sign tomorrow. The 24-year-old midfielder is surplus to requirements at Old Trafford, where he has made just two appearances this season, despite their injury crisis. At a fee of believed to be £500k, potentially rising to £2M (to be confirmed), he clearly falls just within Moyes's limited budget for new players.

Liverpool Echo journalist Greg O´Keefe broke the news on his Twitter account this evening, and believes that the deal will be concluded tomorrow.

Gibson is out of favour at Old Trafford and has recently saw Sir Alex Ferguson opt to recall retired legend Paul Scholes to his first team squad ahead of him, effectively calling time on Gibsons career at the English Premier League champions.

Quotes or other material sourced from Sky Sports News



Reader Comments (202)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Nick Smith
1 Posted 12/01/2012 at 14:54:32
No, Let's just call it a down-payment on Jack Rodwell or Ross Barkley for Mr Ferguson...
James Stewart
2 Posted 12/01/2012 at 14:56:32
What a waste of money. Another Utd cast off. If we have a little money it would be insane to waste it on Gibson! Not what we need at all.
Dave Lynch
3 Posted 12/01/2012 at 15:00:20
Another Moyes utillity buy.
Limted ability, defensive minded and has got to be worth at least a goal a decade.
Paul Gladwell
4 Posted 12/01/2012 at 14:59:54
I would have anyone at present, but surely any pennies they do get must go on a forward, sadly if Gibson is coming it will surely come with no cash going to UTD just as Nick said as a down payment. at least the lad shoots, I cannot remember when we had a shot nevermind a goal.
Danny Broderick
5 Posted 12/01/2012 at 15:07:21
It has been reported elsewhere as £1 million. If it saves us from seeing Heitinga and Neville being paired together in midfield, I will happily take him. Our priorities are a winger and a forward, but he is not a bad player I suppose. not the best, but not bad...
Chez Hutton
6 Posted 12/01/2012 at 15:11:26
I'm not going to claim he's the Messiah, but he can pass and shoot......gotta be better than what we got!
Paul O'Grady
7 Posted 12/01/2012 at 15:18:03
He is horse shit. End of story.
Ste Hawkins
8 Posted 12/01/2012 at 15:18:16
Does he actually improve our team? Would you put him in before Fellaini, Rodwell, Osman, Barkley even Bily or Cahill? Waste of time, I agree it could well be a nod towards a future transfer!
Jack Wilkinson
9 Posted 12/01/2012 at 15:20:16
He's alright, not really what we need now. I wouldn't mind getting him on a free in the summer seeing as he's out of contract. Would be a waste of £2m if we bought him now though.
Howard Don
10 Posted 12/01/2012 at 15:18:07
Seems to have lost his way a bit but a former United youth player of the year, and scored 10 goals from midfield in 60 appearences, not bad for a midfielder although a lot of them not in PL games. Obviously a gamble, but sounds like a typical get him back on the right track Moyes signing. Also Moyes will have been well briefed by his mate SAF. Anywhere around £1-2 million at 24, he has to be worth a punt in our potless state.
Andrew Fair
11 Posted 12/01/2012 at 15:23:47
I would imagine Moyes will get him on loan or cheap as he is out of contract in Summer. Will not be the 2m people are touting. If it keeps Pip or Jonny out of midfield then we can all rejoice.
Brian Waring
12 Posted 12/01/2012 at 15:22:19
Says it all really, when Carrick and Anderson are way ahead of him in the pecking order.
Colin O'Keeffe
13 Posted 12/01/2012 at 15:19:33
What this guy might bring is a bit of goal threat in the centre of midfield. From what I've seen of him his natural position is a forward playing centre midfielder who knows where the goal is (whereas Rodwell and Fellaini are both defensive minded).

His goal record is decent ? 10 goals in 60 appearances for United ? with presumably a few of those as a substitute as well. If he only worry would be his wage demands ? which is why his move to Sunderland broke down. However overall potentially a decent addition to the squad in my opinion.

We all want a winger and a striker who are going to improve us ? but where can you pick them up for the sort of money been talked about for Gibson?
Jimmy Sørheim
14 Posted 12/01/2012 at 15:28:32
NO MONEY
Robbie Riddal
15 Posted 12/01/2012 at 15:31:04
The Echo reports Gibson would be temped by the lure of 'regular first team football' at Everton.

Seriously, what would this guy bring to our midfield that we don't already have?

At £1M he'd represent decent value in terms of a transfer fee and if we were looking to fill out the squad, but he will not be worth the exorbitant wages he'll no doubt command.

Probably about as pointless a signing as we could make at the moment.
Mark Murphy
16 Posted 12/01/2012 at 15:37:20
Yeah, that's right... We're too good for him!!!

Pffftt
Anthony Flack
17 Posted 12/01/2012 at 15:49:18
He has to be better than Bily Bollockov ? who last night disgraced the blue shirt...
James Morgan
19 Posted 12/01/2012 at 15:50:08
Hope it's a loan. Fellaini, Rodwell, Osman and Barkley ahead of him for me. Plus, a striker and a winger are the real priorities.
Jeremy Benson
20 Posted 12/01/2012 at 16:01:09
I would guess at a loan, if he's off at the end of the season anyway, Man Utd may as well get him off the wage bill.

Still, not a striker or a replacement for Jags or a backup for Baines, is it?
Chris Wright
21 Posted 12/01/2012 at 15:58:42
The fact that Utd brought Scholes out of retirement rather than play him says all you need to know. Shit player, totally useless, a couple of my mates who are Utd season ticket holders lash him every week. One described him as a poor mans Phil Neville in midfield. Don't get fooled that he scored a couple of great goals. So has Bily. Wrong player, filling the wrong position. What a joke. Typical Moyes. I honestly think we could go down this year.
Stephen Leary
22 Posted 12/01/2012 at 15:47:31
He's fucking crap ? plain and simple.
Brian Waring
23 Posted 12/01/2012 at 15:59:19
My other half and her family are Man U fans. My other half said, the main reason he never made it wirth the Mancs, is not that he hasn't got the ability, because he has, its because he has a twat of an attitude. She also said he would do a job for us. She nearly got the back of the hand!
James Flynn
24 Posted 12/01/2012 at 16:08:40
Leave this fellow where he is. Play our own kids.
Chris Fisher
25 Posted 12/01/2012 at 16:15:15
I fucking hope not.
Tony Watson
26 Posted 12/01/2012 at 16:11:48
I think he will be an OK signing for us. He is not a top 4 player, but will do a decent job at a mid table club (which is what we are now).

As for him being a down payment on Rodwell.....good!!

We need to sell Rodwell and use that money to improve the squad - exactly the same as when we sold Rooney all those years ago and built up the squad then.

What would you rather have - Rodwell, or £20m of other players??
Sam Hoare
27 Posted 12/01/2012 at 16:22:55
The only reason i'm not sure about this is because it might limit Barkley's chances.

@1-2m this guy has to be worth it. He can pass and shoot and at 24 if the worse comes to the worse we can surely sell him to another prem team or top championship side.

At best he could be someone like Arteta or pienaar, who has ability but has not had the chance to realise it.

Frankly i'd be excited to see us bring anyone in!!
Brian Harrison
28 Posted 12/01/2012 at 16:28:15
I think the fact Ferguson asked Paul Scholes to come out of retirement to play ahead of Gibson says a lot.

Seeing we have our highest paid player and a current England International already occupying these positions when fit, Not to mention a highly rated young midfield player who no doubt will halt his progress still further, is a central midfield player our priority I think not.
Chris Wright
29 Posted 12/01/2012 at 16:32:47
Tony @14 if we sell Rodwell for around £20 million how much do you honestly think Moyes would get? I reckon not much maybe £5 million at a push but equally see it as 1 or 2 million or even none. I'd rather Rodwell than Gibson and no money to spend.
Jeremy Benson
30 Posted 12/01/2012 at 16:32:40
The way I see it, even if he is a decent player, and we're getting him "cheap" at the end of his current contract, he must be asking for decent wages - he couldnt agree personal terms with sunderland, and the daily mail reports it was around £40k per week.

We need that money to pay for a striker...
Sandra Bowen
31 Posted 12/01/2012 at 16:22:01
Ticks all the Moyes boxes really.

Man U reject ? check
Not creative ? check
Slow ? check
High wages ? check
2/3 goals a season ? check
No improvement to squad ? check
Steve Woods
32 Posted 12/01/2012 at 16:46:00
LOL Sandra spot on.
Robbie Riddal
34 Posted 12/01/2012 at 17:03:22
Tony Watson #014, we got £24M for Lescott and hardly improved the squad. I remember £6M of the initial £10M we got for Rooney went on James Beattie and Simon Davies. I don't think they 'improved the squad' !!
Anthony Jaras
36 Posted 12/01/2012 at 17:34:23
UNBELIEVEABLE!!!

LISTEN PEOPLE, We are in trouble. We have very little money. We have few players and we have played several games this season without a single shot on goal.

This lad, although not the most skilful, is a solid midfielder who likes to shoot on sight, from range and has a good record from such shots. He is accurate and even if he scores three goals this season from midfield, it's better than what we have got as a goal return from most of our players.

We NEED players who want to shoot and this lad does exactly that.

He IS better than Bilyaletdinov, Heitinga, Cahill and Neville as a central midfielder, which leaves us with only Barkley (who is young and inexperienced, but I would start him), Osman (Who for some reason is a boo boy for some) Fellaini, Rodwell, McEleny, Forshaw and Wallace.

The majority are too young or are playing out of position.

GET REAL FOLKS, THIS IS WHAT WE HAVE TO GET USED TO AND IF IT IS A CHEAP DEAL, WHAT'S THE PROBLEM????
Jeremy Benson
37 Posted 12/01/2012 at 17:42:55
Anthony, using caps really doesn't help your argument.
Chris Verghoden
38 Posted 12/01/2012 at 17:42:53
SSN Sources claim we're in talks.
Anthony Jaras
39 Posted 12/01/2012 at 17:46:12
It doesn't hinder it either so what's the difference?
Brian Waring
40 Posted 12/01/2012 at 17:47:25
Using caps Anthony makes you sound angry. Also, it doesn't matter how skint we are, or how much trouble we're in, Gibson is still shite!
Gavin Ramejkis
41 Posted 12/01/2012 at 17:51:18
If he did he'd be better flushing it down the shitter than giving it to Man U for Gibson
Anthony Jaras
42 Posted 12/01/2012 at 17:46:50
Sandra, in all fairness;

Man U reject ? check
Not creative ? check
He is more creative than most of our current central midfield roster.

Slow ? check
Again, of which of our central midfielders is he slower than? Neville? Heitinga? Osman? He is quicker than all three.

High wages ? check
How do we know what his wages are?

2/3 goals a season ? check
His goal record is 84 apps, 12 goals. Compare that with our other central midfielders.
No improvement to squad ? check
Agin, would people rather have Neville or Heitinga there?
Anthony Jaras
43 Posted 12/01/2012 at 17:53:06
I agree, Gibson is not very good, but beggers cannot be choosers and he is a better option in central midfield than Bilyaletdinov, Neville or Heitinga.
Anthony Jaras
44 Posted 12/01/2012 at 17:54:31
Brian, of course it matters how much trouble we are in and how skint we are as that determines the calibre of player we can sign.
Barry Rathbone
45 Posted 12/01/2012 at 17:54:02
More sense getting the Yak back.
Jeremy Benson
46 Posted 12/01/2012 at 17:55:48
Anthony, it does hinder your argument. As it appears you can't comprehend other peoples views, and your post(s) come across as only you seem to know best.

And believe me, you don't. Caps not required, there's a lot of intelligent posters on here who can think for themselves.
Brian Waring
47 Posted 12/01/2012 at 17:55:06
The problem is Anthony, we will be spending money on him, money we can't afford to waste. Also, it was over wages why his move to Sunderland fell through, so if they weren't willing to pay him what he was after, then you could imagine he was after a fair wack.

Another thing you know, it would have been a lot easier to have just paid Pienaar what he was asking for.
Anthony Jaras
48 Posted 12/01/2012 at 18:03:10
Brian, I fully agree on the last part, however we can't afford to look back and say what she should have done, we need to concentrate on what we are going to do.

As for the money, I also agree that we need to put every penny towards a position we are extremely weak in and that is up front.

However, it's clear Moyes wants Gibson, so instead of looking at the negatives, I prefer to view the positives of the move and if it means we don't see Neville, Bily or Heitinga in the middle, coupled with the willingness to shoot that Gibson possesses, then I see that as a good thing.
Gavin Ramejkis
49 Posted 12/01/2012 at 18:06:43
To be brutally honest we'd be wasting money we barely have on an average player to gain 2 or 3 goals if we are lucky, it wont keep us in the league and thats what we need until Kenshite fucks off or the administrators come
Steve Woods
50 Posted 12/01/2012 at 16:46:00
LOL Sandra spot on.
Shane Corcoran
51 Posted 12/01/2012 at 18:17:25
He has a good pass and shot and would add to our midfield. As long as we don't mind him only playing for 5-10 minutes per game then we're sorted. Unless of course Moyes can mould him into a better player.
Nick Smith
52 Posted 12/01/2012 at 18:24:03
Tenner says we sign Gibbo then Moyes slots him in at right-back so Pip can continue to glue the team together in the middle.

Hold on, here comes Danny Simpson.
Paul Gladwell
53 Posted 12/01/2012 at 18:47:38
When I have seen him he is attack minded and shoots, something I have yet to see from any centre midfielder for us in the past 15 months, beggars cannot be chooses and if it keeps two defenders out of our centre mid then great.
Howard Don
54 Posted 12/01/2012 at 18:44:08
Sandra (20) So I take it Moyes had a blind spot and failed to check his tick boxes when he signed Arteta, Piennar, Baines and Jagielka then?
James Stewart
55 Posted 12/01/2012 at 18:54:50
Agree with sandra @20

What planet are some people on! There is no way in hell Gibson can be describe as a creative player! He is another defensive midfielder! He is considered a joke among the Utd fans I know. The guy is not fit to lace Barkley's boots let alone take his place. Stupidity. Then again Moyes's logic is if you have played for Utd you must be good. Cretin.
Barry Rathbone
56 Posted 12/01/2012 at 18:20:15
Lifted these quotes from a Utd forum debating Gibson - all very similar.

"Well that's the thing. He is ok on the ball when he has space but he is extremely slow. He is not great at winning it and in my opinion, does not have too much to offer. I think he's a Championship player to be honest."

"No, not for us, IMO. He'll get a Premier League team, but he strikes me as the sort who will slide when he leaves United. I'm not yet convinced about his attitude and/or desire."

Got Moyes and EFC stamped all over him.

Wonder if fergie uses a "Moyes" tray instead of an "out" tray.
Paul Gladwell
57 Posted 12/01/2012 at 19:01:55
James you are so right in ways especially the Barkley shout, but what can we do? he is better than what Moyes is playing now put it that way and 10 goals in 60 games is not bad for a defensive minded player, its better than any of our players ratios who play in centre mid.........and up front.
James Martin
58 Posted 12/01/2012 at 19:19:59
If he can muster the basics like shooting passing and tackling then he'll be walking into our midfield. No one else seems to have managed to do that this season. Bilyaletdinov is atrocious in any position and the Rodwell and Fellaini partnership yielded us how many points exactly? All those goals they scored and clean sheets they kept as well.....
Andrew Fair
59 Posted 12/01/2012 at 19:32:22
Alot of sources on the web saying it will be a done deal as of tommorow. I have faith In Moyes and if we can get an extra body in to the squad then thats only a gd thing. People slagging him off b4 we have seen him in a blue shirt. Lets give the lad a chance. I ask all the people slagging him off who else can we get in? For cheaper? Not going to be able to.
Gavin Ramejkis
60 Posted 12/01/2012 at 19:35:06
He's supposedly having a medical now, hope he realises when Moyes puts him up against a tortoise in the multi stage fitness test aka bleep test he has to lose to gain a contract, Moyes genius pack the squad with slow shite
Andrew Fair
61 Posted 12/01/2012 at 19:35:34
Brian! Pienaar didn't want extra money. He wanted to leave, he said he was getting stale, so we had no option but to get rid.
Andrew Fair
62 Posted 12/01/2012 at 19:41:24
Gavin, Slow Shite? Gueye,Drenthe,Baines, Distin,Jags, all relatively quick players.
Gavin Ramejkis
63 Posted 12/01/2012 at 19:43:30
Really sums up the season getting shut of Yakubu for £1.5m now scoring for fun and sratching around the bins at Man U for a reject for £2m, genius
Andrew Fair
64 Posted 12/01/2012 at 19:44:59
Gavin, I wouldnt imagine it to be 2 million. There will be a small fee if not a loan involved then sign up at end of season as his contract is up. Also Yakubu was shite for us in his last 1 and a half years, except a quality shoulder barge against the shite so it was a no brainer to get rid of him.
Stephen Kenny
65 Posted 12/01/2012 at 19:51:57
I'm no fan of Moyes except where his judgment of players(nb. not handling) is concerned.

from the little I've seen he's at least as good as Rodwell. Though he's got a few years on him and Jack has still got a lot of potential.

I can see this fella slotting in beside Mo and Rodders playing the Cahill role.

IMO when money is this tight and we are as poor as we are up top then this is a waste of money badly needed elsewhere.
Gavin Ramejkis
66 Posted 12/01/2012 at 19:45:00
Andrew, look at those names Jags crocked, Distin crocked, Drenthe just back from an injury but technically not ours just on loan, Gueye still cant guarantee a game from the misery even with our small squad and Baines an ever present - I stand by slow and shite. WBA signing Maynard and we sign dross - which of the two should we be signing?
Colin Ryan
67 Posted 12/01/2012 at 19:58:45
Glenn Whelan and Keith Andrews keep him out of the Ireland team. That says it all. Cant believe we are buying this guy. A half decent shot is all he has going for him.
Gavin Ramejkis
68 Posted 12/01/2012 at 20:01:03
Andrew you've a fairly poor memory of last season, Yak overweight but hardly got a game, decent game against the shite and good goal against Stoke then dropped to rot on the bench whilst we watched Saha for months fanny about without goals. This season we've gtot Saha barely breaking a sweat and getting fuck all goals, two other strikers off the books for the sake of the banks a loan striker who fucking Leicester rejected and watching him you see why to replace the three strikers we sold. The only players scoring aren't our strikers, our fucking keeper has more goals to his name than Saha this season so yeah I guess I stand by my multiple posts saying we dont need another average brings fuck all with him midfielder when its plain to a three year old the team who scores the most goals wins the game.
Al Reddish
69 Posted 12/01/2012 at 20:04:36
A half-decent shot is better than the current 'no shot at all' option...
Andrew Fair
70 Posted 12/01/2012 at 20:02:29
Maynard is going to cost 3 million plus. Swansea yesterday were willing to offer 2 players plus cash (according to the papers) We cant afford to risk that on a player who may or may not do the business in Prem. We do know however that Gibson can pass, shoot and tackle and will add a bit of bite into the middle. Hopefully as DM with Rodwell and Fellaini infront. He is a CM so doesnt need pace, look at Spurs CM Parker and Sandro, even Modric they dont have pace. (Yes they have better attributes than Gibson) but pace is very rare in CM and for the little price we will get him its great to get another body in.
Karl Jones
71 Posted 12/01/2012 at 20:13:44
Waste of money. Miles away from the type of player we need in MF.
Robbie Riddal
72 Posted 12/01/2012 at 20:10:02
All this 'at least he shoots' business; our problem is getting midfielders into a position to shoot. It's all well and good having players who like to have a pop but it's futile if the midfielders don't get into attacking situations. I can't recall too many times this season when I've thought 'why didn't he just fucking shoot then?' about an Everton midfielder. A striker maybe, but rarely can I recall thinking Fellaini, Rodwell, Osman, whoever, should have shot. Because they don't get into advanced enough positions to be a threat, and I would suggest that is down to the setup of the team.
Sandra Bowen
73 Posted 12/01/2012 at 20:10:18
Good luck to him if he does indeed sign. I really hope he does well and proves me wrong but I can only see this going one way. The way being that we won't get relegated, we'll finish in the lower-middle somewhere and Moyes will be off one way or another in the summer, probably to Villa or Spurs and we'll be stuck with another dull-bog standard player in an area where we don't need another average Joe. For the remainder of this season I would be much happier for a midfield of Rodwell, Fellaini, Osman, Drenthe and Barkley(barring injuries of course) to be given the confidence just to go out and play. It can't get any worse so lets just go for it. Oh and for gods sake, get a Striker of some sort in, not another carthorse!!!!!
Sam Hoare
74 Posted 12/01/2012 at 20:16:27
Whatever it is it's not a waste of money because at 24 and at a knock down price we will be able to sell him on for at least the same if not some profit...
Peter Laing
75 Posted 12/01/2012 at 20:22:33
Scraping the bottom off the barrel. I agree that this deal has all the hallmarks of a down payment or sweetener by Manchester United for Rodwell or Barkley. It sickens me what Everton have become, this looks like a Walter Smith type desperation buy. We also have to read shite on here like 'the Rooney money improved the team', the best player in his generation playing elsewhere (obviously).
Jimmy Sørheim
76 Posted 12/01/2012 at 20:25:51
Hello people, Did Moyes not say he had NO money to spend????????????????????
Still you believe Gibson is coming here for 2 million?
Jon Ferguson
77 Posted 12/01/2012 at 20:38:57
It doesn't matter if it's Gibson (who I don't rate) or a centre mid of undoubted quality, the fact remains the same; we have two good centre midfielders in Rodwell and Felli and an exciting prospect in Barkley. The fact we are even considering another centre mid (when it is plain to see to anybody with even a mediocre footballing brain that we desperately need someone upfront and / or pace out wide) is farcical.
Phil Martin
79 Posted 12/01/2012 at 20:51:57
Big thanks to the worlds greatest Evertonian for permitting this "great club" to spend some cash on transfers.
Mark Riding
80 Posted 12/01/2012 at 20:52:14
Boro about to sign Jutkiewitz.. they are pushing for the Prem..
Paul Gladwell
81 Posted 12/01/2012 at 20:51:51
Jimmy our Echo man O'Keefe has tweeted he is having a medical and will sign tomorrow.
Mark Riding
82 Posted 12/01/2012 at 20:54:16
Gibson? Even Bily has got a good shot on him...
Stan Sheppard
83 Posted 12/01/2012 at 20:58:54
SSN saying he's having a medical subject to a move.....
Jamie Sweet
85 Posted 12/01/2012 at 21:00:13
While I can't slate Moyes for signing a player he hasn't yet signed... all I can say is that if we do sign this lad, but do not bring in a striker during this transfer window, then our manager and our chairman will have seriously let us down.

I do remember us being linked with "another Utd reject" a couple of seasons back in the shape of Darren Fletcher. I remember the outcry on here, much like the above. Turns out he's not such a bad player. We could have done a lot worse. Let's hope Gibson, if he signs, isn't quite as bad as some are suggesting. A 35 yeard screamer at Anfield in Feb could change a few minds!
Kevin Hudson
86 Posted 12/01/2012 at 21:19:33
Jamie,

I'm hearing that a striker is also being pursued.
Brian Waring
87 Posted 12/01/2012 at 21:23:03
Any names cropping up Kevin?
Mark Riding
88 Posted 12/01/2012 at 21:25:32
Let me guess the names.. Maynard ? Sharp ? - Beckfords better than both... Moyes does well with his bargain basement buys though ( cough )

Andy Johnson ?
Yakubu ?
And just for good measure.. Michael Owen no doubts..
Rob Hollis
89 Posted 12/01/2012 at 21:19:00
He may like to shoot but I will never forget Lee Carsley scoring a blinder against Birmingham and pointing out later that the boss does not like us to shoot from that distance. We will soon knock that habit out of him.
Dan Schweizer
90 Posted 12/01/2012 at 21:28:17
I feel sorry for this kid; he has been slated by so many people at Man Utd and now slated by Evertonians ? and he hasn't even signed yet!

Rodwell has taken Saha's sicknote and at the moment any fresh blood at all would be an improvement on what we have seen. Plus I will be delighted to finally see us sign someone, even if it isn't a striker we most definitely need.
Dean Adams
91 Posted 12/01/2012 at 21:11:06
If he can shoot and score three goals a season then he will go straight in instead of Saha, well it is Moyes who puts square pegs in Rounds holes!!!
Nick Entwistle
92 Posted 12/01/2012 at 21:38:42
I've a feeling some players have been kept and are coming in so we have affordable options for when the players of value leave.

Gibson. Jesus. Four Utd cast offs.
Ben Jones
93 Posted 12/01/2012 at 21:39:57
For god sake, we're actually spending money on a senior player, first time in 2 years!!!!

That's an acheivement in itself.

I don't see what the problem is. Young, hungry, point to prove, would be our most creative central midfielder. Not buying him for much.

Please can we get rid of all the negativity!
Mark Riding
94 Posted 12/01/2012 at 21:48:41
Stop the press...

Its actually Terry Gibson..

Replacing Round...

Now thats more like it !!
Brian Waring
95 Posted 12/01/2012 at 21:47:52
" Young, hungry, point to prove " If we only had someone in the side like that now.
Mark Riding
96 Posted 12/01/2012 at 21:50:47
Brian.. Ross's face dont fit anymore...
Nick Entwistle
97 Posted 12/01/2012 at 21:47:31
I know what you're saying Ben, but I can't help but remember the scene in Enemy at the Gates where the Russians are being nailed in the battle for Stalingrad and Bob Hoskins has all the officers lined up. After getting the officer in charge to shoot himself, he asks if any of the others have new ideas. Joseph Fiennes steps forward and says 'I have an idea, we need a hero'. And after two years without a signing we get Darron Gibson?
Jack Wilkinson
98 Posted 12/01/2012 at 21:49:25
I pray that the reported £2m is false, what a waste!! He's out of contract in the summer, if Moyes is that desperate I'd rather he got him on a free then...
Michael Kenrick
99 Posted 12/01/2012 at 21:52:33
Nick (#163):

"Four United cast-offs" ? Wow... that kinda drives it home... like a good kick in the man-tackle.
Tony Twist
100 Posted 12/01/2012 at 21:51:02
What is Moyes thinking? Does this mean a deal for a striker has already been agreed? Utter madness really as he is not even a playmaker midfielder that we desperately need. I dispair.
Shaun Brennan
101 Posted 12/01/2012 at 21:55:50
Dean 156 - I don't want to know what Moyes puts into Round's hole!!
James Stewart
102 Posted 12/01/2012 at 21:58:10
Joke signing. One of the slowest players you are likely to see in the league.
Was shite at Wolves when on loan and even they didn't want him. A good example of why Moyes would be dangerous with money. Crap player in a position we don't need. Follows on well from the last money he had and wasted on Bily and heitinga.

Very disappointed.
James Stewart
103 Posted 12/01/2012 at 22:04:25
Could have signed Drenthe up for the money wasted on tortoise
James Stewart
104 Posted 12/01/2012 at 22:07:05
The guy had to close his twitter account within 2 hours of opening it after abuse from his own fans.

He has the touch of Phil Neville and the pace of dead dog.
Steve Higham
105 Posted 12/01/2012 at 22:00:34
Ross Barkley must of really pissed Moyes off. Trust me Gibson is not fit to lace his boots.
Why are we buying another cast off from Utd ?
What a joke of a club we have become first McFadden now Gibson - how the once mighty have fallen.
Ciarán McGlone
106 Posted 12/01/2012 at 21:55:06
Happy days. Moyes can play an entire midfield of defensive players. Anyone who thinks he's creative has never watched him. Bewildering signing.
Sam Hoare
107 Posted 12/01/2012 at 22:07:38
Can only sign drenthe if he wants to come. Gibson has hardly had 5 games in a row for years so noone really knows how good he might be.

How about we try to be positive about a new player rather than knocking him before he's even kicked a ball!
James Stewart
108 Posted 12/01/2012 at 22:17:41
True there would be no way in hell I would sign for us were I drenthe.

Gibson played a lot for wolves and was terrible. He is a slug and is awful at passing so he should fit right in with Moyes.
David Booth
109 Posted 12/01/2012 at 22:15:05
A left back, a winger, a striker, a second striker?

Oh no...

We've only got Fellaini, Neville, Coleman, Bilyaletdinov, Rodwell, Cahill, Barkley, Osman, McFadden, Drenthe, Donovan and Gueye in midfield - so clearly with only those 12 to choose from it's obvious we desperately need a reject to bolster the team.

Were he just one of half a dozen to come in during this window, then all well and good. A reliable squad player should never be underrated.

But I get the impression this is our 'big' signing?

What the hell is happening?
Kevin Hudson
110 Posted 12/01/2012 at 22:12:47
The majority need to get a grip and reserve judgement here.

* Bitching about 4-5-1, then slaughtering the "wrong type," of 4-4-2.

* Complaining about the lack of signings, and then slaughtering the "wrong type," of signing.

* Clinging to a certainty about a 17 year old kid as the saviour but slaughtering the "wrong type," of a one goal in six strike rate, a Champions League Semi-Final goal, and an education at the country's top club.

Let's just see how it pans out, shall we..?
John Malone
111 Posted 12/01/2012 at 22:32:39
So Fergie thinks a retired Paul Scholes who's lost all the pace he never had is better than this lad in his prime? So we take him when we need creativity and a striker... that tells me Rodwell is off to raise more cash.
Ray Robinson
112 Posted 12/01/2012 at 22:44:10
Kevin, yes, Neville and Heitinga in midfield is the wrong type of 4-4-2. Not a stupid statement at all. Just as playing Howard as a forward in a 4-5-1 formation would be wrong - oh, come to think of it, he's scored as many as Saha ....
James Stewart
113 Posted 12/01/2012 at 22:46:03
442 with Saha and Anichebe up front is not 442.
Mike Elbey
114 Posted 12/01/2012 at 22:39:57
Kevin I agree with you.

For Christ sake after over 2 years it's a signing whichever way you want to look at it and that has to be better than nothing. And you can bet the fee is nowhere near 2.5m, probably nearer 1m as he is a free agent in the summer.

To put it in perspective, assuming he signs in time, who would most people want in central midfield on Saturday given the choice of Neville, Heitinga, Billy or Cahill ?

Let's at least give the blokes go before we slag him off, after all it's normally the low expectation signings that Moyes makes that end up being the better ones...
Alex Mullan
115 Posted 12/01/2012 at 22:35:07
I think I am going to stay off interweb forums from now on because no matter what the article, or club situation, there is always a landslide negative wave of opinion - lots of keyboard warriors about and all that. This headline could have been 'Everton sign Messi', and the first comment would have a high chance of being 'fuck me, hes too short, sort it out Davy'

We are crying out for more players - we are about to sign one who I think will do fine at Everton. Hes got a good shot and will attack more than out centre back midfield.

Cast off at United? Name one fucking player in our entire squad who would make the united squad? If we signed a QPR cast off, I would give you that. Don't slate a young man for wanting to achieve something in his career instead of sitting on his arse at a 'top 4 side'.

I hope any prospective signing that is deemed good enough by the masses around here doesn't by chance have a glance at this forum, because it would certainly turn me off. Nothing but sarcasm and negativity from many, many people. No wonder people call us the bitter blues.
Mike Elbey
116 Posted 12/01/2012 at 22:49:07
Kevin I agree with you.

For Christ sake after over 2 years it's a signing whichever way you want to look at it and that has to be better than nothing. And you can bet the fee is nowhere near 2.5m, probably nearer 1m as he is a free agent in the summer.

To put it in perspective, assuming he signs in time, who would most people want in central midfield on Saturday given the choice of Gibson or Neville, Heitinga, Billy or Cahill ?

Let's at least give the bloke go before we slag him off, after all it's normally the low expectation signings that Moyes makes that end up being the better ones...
Mark Riding
117 Posted 12/01/2012 at 22:50:18
Alex.. I reckon.. Baines.. Barkley and at a push Rodwell.. all possible in the next 2 years...
Paddy Howlin
118 Posted 12/01/2012 at 22:40:53
To slag the lad off before he has actually kicked a ball is over the top.

Granted, it's not a signing the sets the pulse racing and I do have my reservations on if it is what we need currently, however; I left White Hart Lane fearing the worst last night i.e. no new signings and players in terminal decline like Cahill, Saha and Neville playing week in/week out until the inevitable relegation either this season or next.

The one thing we need is fresh blood and players who are not kids or totally past it, until players like Barkley are ready to step up.

Whilst Gibson is limited, he is 24, an international and will give us some different options at a time we need them. Hopefully there are others going to join him, however with the current board I doubt it.

Rather than have a go at a player who has yet to kick a ball or pull on a shirt for us, perhaps vent your anger and frustrations at a Board that has invested £0 for over 12 years and paitently lies to its fans at any opportunity it see's fit to protect its own positon.
Alex Mullan
119 Posted 12/01/2012 at 22:53:31
Mark,

Wake up mate, they going to drop their captain to include Bainsey? Barkley?? He has only played for us a couple of times and your putting him in the United team? Rodwell doesnt even always start for us!


Give the guy a fuckin' go at least. Some of the vitriolic bollacks here about Gibson is just ridiculous. Do you guys think we should be chasing Wesley fuckin' Sneijder?
Mark Riding
120 Posted 12/01/2012 at 22:59:29
Alex.. you asked what players would get in the Utd squad ? Baines wouldnt get into the squad ???
Rodwell is an England international.. would get into most squads..
Barkley could be anything ? Piss head.. genius ? who knows.. but a defo for the squad..
Utd do have some average players as well you know !
I would love Gibson to come off.. who does he replace in the Moyes first team though ?
Fellani ? Rodwell ?

Alex, I dont even know what 'vitriolic' means.. so I cant answer that one Im afraid..
Tom Las
122 Posted 12/01/2012 at 23:26:07
Is he a better midfielder than Neville? Shit yeah!!!!
Matt Garen
124 Posted 12/01/2012 at 23:31:44
Apparently the price is 500k rising to 2m based on various things. Which if true is a fucking good deal. . . . ONLY as long as he is the first of 3 signings and nobody is sold against moyes wishes. Doubt it though.
Col Noon
125 Posted 12/01/2012 at 23:24:40
Neville, Heitinga, Gibson - Moyes's holy trinity? All joking aside good luck to him if he does sign. Not a player I would like personally but I am open-minded and hoping he can come in to the club determined to make an impact. I remember him scoring against Bayern at Old Trafford in a champions league game and he played well. Apart from that, not much. Heres hoping.
Edward Kenny
126 Posted 12/01/2012 at 23:34:29
i think people are forgetting that up to a couple of weeks ago,before gibson fell foul of the ayotolla ferguson,he was considered a regular in the man u team,so im of the opinion that if he was deemed good enough for man u ,well im going to give him a chance at efc,im sick of all the negativity that these forums generate at times,who did u expect to come here? a top english or foriegn star,lets get real,not a pot to p*** in,this to me is a very sensible signing considering our situation with lack of funds,sir alex to our rescue again!
Denis Richardson
127 Posted 12/01/2012 at 23:37:34
I for one would be glad if he comes. As stated above many times, whatever people think of him he is definitely better than either Neville or Heitinga in CM! Breaking that son of satan pairing in the midfield is worth it!

On a slight concern, hope we dont end up paying a transfer fee for him given hes out of contract in the summer anyway. Then again 1m is good value - he is not that bad.

When the fook are we going to sell Billy - what happened to Wolfsburg and the Ashik whatever they're called in Russia??

Welcome Mr Gibson - lets see if you can get our shots on target tally per game up to say 3 or 4!
Christopher Kelly
128 Posted 12/01/2012 at 23:39:54
I believe I called this on another post. You had to think Moyes and Kenwright would have to spend SOMETHING. it would be a complete pr nightmare otherwise. I also think it's a poor attempt at trying to appear more financially sound than they actually are. Any potential buyer will see right through this.

At least there's a tiny bit of life around the club. Another option at least

Glen Anderson
129 Posted 12/01/2012 at 23:31:25
This is our long-term Phil Neville replacement, but with a modest goal scoring record.

I actually think we should give him a chance rather than slate the lad unfairly.

Remember when Carsley signed? I recall many a Blue moaning that he wasn't good enough and what an important player he turned out to be.

You never know, Gibson could turn out well, hold the midfield, shoot from distance now and then, and free up other players to get forward more often.
Sam Hoare
130 Posted 12/01/2012 at 23:34:46
To be fair the other man u 'rejects' have been pretty solid.

Howard- arguably one of our best players this season

Neville- a dependable if not inspirational utility player and professional club captain.

Saha- probably our best striker for the last few seasons when fit- not that there's been much competition!
Roman Sidey
131 Posted 12/01/2012 at 23:41:01
First thought was, "Fucking hell, another one of Moyes' pointless signings."

Then, that developed into, "Well, the midfield aren't really doing anything right at the moment anyway so fuck it." At least Moyes didn't sign a defender.

Sad thing for Gibson is though, if he can't prove himself on the left wing in the next month, we'll never see him again.
Christopher Kelly
132 Posted 12/01/2012 at 23:45:47
Having a few winners around doesn't hurt either
Denis Richardson
133 Posted 12/01/2012 at 23:49:25
Any chance he'll be available for Villa so we dont have to play Billy or Cahill in CM?
Nick Entwistle
134 Posted 12/01/2012 at 23:48:34
At least we're Utd B, a few seasons ago Fulham were Everton B with Pembridge, Radzinski, Davies, AJ, John Collins.

Yikes!
Paul Lally
135 Posted 12/01/2012 at 23:38:04
I have a bad feeling this deal also involves Rodwell somewhere down the line.
A close member of Rodwell's family,in general conversation re his injury etc,added that Rodwell is happy at Everton but that Jack believes it's a real possiblity he will be sold,sooner rather than later,as EFC 'need' the money.
COYB
No Status No optimism
Oppose stagnation


Tommy Coleman
136 Posted 13/01/2012 at 00:01:48
Great, another Man Utd reject, my mates will be taking the piss again.

I hate Man Utd but they really do see us coming.
Dan Doran
137 Posted 13/01/2012 at 00:07:28
MAN! I almost can't read Toffee Web any more. I've never seen such pessimism and negativity, its depressing. Granted, it is warranted but FFS we're getting a new signing, why complain so much about it?! Worst case scenario he's performs no better than what we have but at least there's the CHANCE he will make us a better team. This has been the worst season I've ever watched, we've had little to hope for. I'd be happy with any signing at this point.
Nick Millington
138 Posted 13/01/2012 at 00:31:45
At least, for the first time in 2 years it's a signing we have actually paid for. We should be rejoicing.
Rob Teo
139 Posted 13/01/2012 at 00:27:45
Dan#229, I think many punters here (myself included, to tell you the truth) see the signing of Gibson as being on the same level as the signing of McFadden - simply there to shore up the numbers without necessarily improving the squad.

Fair enough that there's a chance he's make us a better team, but there's also a chance I'll win the lottery, and considering our dire financial state, it's a big risk Moyes is taking with a player whom many Utd fans have regularly slagged off as not good enough.

So, no, it's not a case that worst-case scenario, he performs no better than what we already have. Rather, it's that, on the basis of his performances at Man Utd, the most-likely outcome is that he performs no better than what we already have, while sucking up some of the limited funds we have for his wages.
Clive Lewis
140 Posted 13/01/2012 at 00:37:46
I dont want to be a doom mongerer but anyone realised we have 2 weeks left in the transfer window Rodwell or Barklay to Man U?
Mick Davies
142 Posted 13/01/2012 at 01:25:57
Why does Moyes go down the East Lancs every time he has a few bob? We must have the worst scouting system around. How do other clubs find the Ben Arfa's, the Demba Ba's, MacLeans, Odemwingies etc?
Moyes is either putting this 'Fergie reject in front of players he's spent lots of money on or he's going to be on the bench. Proves how good he is, we're the only ones interested and if Man U fans don't want him and the manager sees him in training every day and he doesn't want him, then what kind of endorsement is that?
Alex Mullan
144 Posted 13/01/2012 at 02:54:22
Mick Davies, 239,

"if Man U fans don't want him and the manager sees him in training every day and he doesn't want him, then what kind of endorsement is that? "

Do you really think we are in the same league of 'wanting' as Man Utd? Do you really think if Everton were linked with the likes of midfielders United are, like Sneijder, we would 'want' Gibson?



"We must have the worst scouting system around. How do other clubs find the Ben Arfa's, the Demba Ba's, MacLeans, Odemwingies etc?
"

This the same scouting system that uncovered Rooney, Rodwell and Barkley? The same guys who scouted Lescott who was sold on for stupid money? I wonder did they scout Baines, or Cahill, when he was a nobody at Millwall or Jags. Or helped take Arteta from the back arse of nowhere. Pienaar a name that means anything to you? Your right! Our scouts and management have never found a gem, or made a decent buy - all we do is buy from Man Utd....Have a think mate.
Sagar Palikhey
145 Posted 13/01/2012 at 03:55:11
bloody hell ... fcuk i can't believe to see so many negative comments when we are about to sign a decent midfielder .. I think this site has been infiltrated by the anti blues so they are just trying to bring this negativity in this site.. Darron Gibson is a very good player, he never got chance at united but he's really good.Both fellani & rodwell are defensively good but they don't pose attacking threat. Gibson can pass,shoot and tackle. i think he'll be a great addition to the squad..
Jason Lam
146 Posted 13/01/2012 at 04:18:51
I can't believe how low we've become. And that's not just coming from the old folk. What have we become? Fucking dump site for used tampons by manure. How you no shame? Oh, he's a winner for sitting on the manure bench. We've only got a penny we should be so grateful. Begging for fucking scraps off the fat bastards who stamp on our faces. FFS this is the last straw. Why should I raise my children to beg for fucking scraps, have their noses pushed into the dirt by other equal children? Sad sad sad end to a once great footballing institute, and all the past greats that toiled for this club.
Peter Barry
147 Posted 13/01/2012 at 05:20:23
All those complaining about the Yaks condition and motivation last season are just confirming that Dour Daveys man management and motivational skills are crap.
Derek Thomas
148 Posted 13/01/2012 at 05:43:44
Sagar #244; Just coz we're negative, pessimistic, bitter and paranoid, doesn't mean we're not right.
Breandan Clarke
149 Posted 13/01/2012 at 05:48:24
In no way shape or form understand the total shite some people are coming out with regards Gibson, then again might be my Irish pride... but the price tag says it all: great deal.

Let's look at it on the face of things: young player, international and Champions League experience plus playing with some of the best players in the world daily ? for £2 mill?

I asked my friend who is a Man Utd supporter who had this to say:

"A decent player. Regardless of what he ever did, him, Evans and Carrick get blamed for everything that goes wrong at United. Suffered from never getting a run of games and not costing £30 million. Scored some great goals, played in big European games against Bayern Munich and such like. Ignore most of the shite talked about him."

He still hasnt signed... he might not, but I'll reserve my judgement for when he has actually played a game for us.
Breandan Clarke
150 Posted 13/01/2012 at 05:58:07
It actually reminds me of a few years ago when we were linked with Darren Fletcher for something like £2-3 million and there was an uproar at the time... look at the player he became.
Gavin Ramejkis
151 Posted 13/01/2012 at 06:40:04
This has got to be a downpayment on an outbound. Another question, wasn't he out of contract this summer? If so why is the fee rising to a figure - unless its part of the money Everton are expecting from a player going the other way and Billy Bullshitter's business acumen has seen us fucked over by Man U again.

We need goals, we end up with a player who couldn't get a game over a 37 year old retired player - fuck off Everton.

Brendan - even Howard has mpore clean sheets this season than Fletcher - subtle but I'll let you work that one out.
Andrew Fair
154 Posted 13/01/2012 at 08:24:26
Brain 170 and Mark 171! Why does Barkleys face not fit anymore? Just an excuse to slag Moyes off. He is still getting back to fitness after career threatening injuries and he now has a knee injury. He himself has said Moyes is the man to move his career forward. He has only just 1 month ago turned 18, there are not many other 18 year olds who are regulars in ANY prem team even Championship teams. Now we are out of the Youth cup I am sure Moyes will give him more chances.

Why does signing Gibson affect Barkley? One is a DM and Barkley will be an attacking player either right or behind the striker.

To all the people complaining about the fee, it will be nominal and we have probably got that money from the sell-on fee we had for jutkiewicz.
Paul Olsen
155 Posted 13/01/2012 at 08:35:50
On our budget a good signing.

Some people ae just so into the negativity they`ll remain negative anyway.

He`s not a world-beater,but

- He shoots
- He adds numbers
- He costs next to nothing and has premier league experience.
- He plays in midfield, meaning that maybe Neville and Heitinga could play in defence for once.
- He`s not quality, but adds some much needed depth.
- He`s still relatively young, in an ageing squad. If he fails, not much is lost really. If he does well he could be a saleable asset in the future.

Most things going on at Goodison is gloomy agreed, but adding numbers are good. M`kay?
Paul Olsen
156 Posted 13/01/2012 at 08:44:16
As for Scholes.

at 37 and retired, he would still have been heads and shoulders above our current midfield.
Lee Gray
157 Posted 13/01/2012 at 09:06:54
Paul...you have not got a clue, he is rubbish, we could have signed Robbie Keane in August for less money. I would NOT give Moyes a tenner to spend....Billy need I say more!
Karl Meighan
158 Posted 13/01/2012 at 09:01:39
Gibson may not be the best but can easily give us what Rodwell and Felliani give us and his shooting is way ahead of either of those two.

I would now be tempted to move either Felliani or Rodwell on for a decent fee which will allow Moyes to strengthen the forward areas. Moyes has to wheel and deal as the present first team are simply to close to the relegation threatened teams. Maybe the penny has dropped and Moyes can see that we are currently a very poor team who are so easy to defend against its untrue.
Dave Lynch
159 Posted 13/01/2012 at 09:12:10
This may be a down payment or part of the Rooney backpay.
I will bet this though, no way willBarclay, Baines or Rodwell leave in this window.
BK may be a twat, but he is no idiot (?)
Imagine the uproar if one of them went this window, expect it all to go off in the summer though.
Andrew Fair
160 Posted 13/01/2012 at 09:26:13
Lee - You havent got a clue. Robbie Keane wanted to go to pastures new, i.e. America. He is also a washed up prem striker who struggled to score any goals for West Ham last year.
Jason Chew
161 Posted 13/01/2012 at 09:45:49
Stop complaining about us getting the Man Utd rejects, Rooney is working very hard to fall into this category and come home!
Ciarán McGlone
162 Posted 13/01/2012 at 09:38:47
Why does signing Gibson affect Barkley? One is a DM and Barkley will be an attacking player either right or behind the striker.

-----------------------

The rather humourous assumption being that Moyes actually plays people in their most suited position.

The fact is we are oversubscribed for players of Gibson's position and quality. Moyes should know this.

The argument that he's a good squad player doesn't stack up either. You don't spend money on bench positions when you've glaring holes in the first 11. Especially when money is as tight as it is at Everton.

There's also the argument that our bench is well and truly full at the moment... this will no doubt affect our young players' progression.
Paul Thompson
163 Posted 13/01/2012 at 09:39:19
On this site there seems now to be no issue which is not filtered through the anti-Moyes, anti current regime lens.

I would NOT give Moyes a tenner to spend....' Lee Gray @ 286.

He literally cannot win nomatter what he does.

We've hardly got any money, This is the pool we are compelled to fish in and, on the face of it, this looks like a bargain. But let's see Gibson perform over a period of time before we decide whether it was a good investment.
Mark Fitzgerald
164 Posted 13/01/2012 at 09:21:14
Wow, do some people here actually have a default negative comments setting? We've been crying out for new signings since..... its been so long I can't even remember the last one, and finally when one is announced, it's slammed before it's even been confirmed.

Sure, Gibson isn't our ideal choice, but lets get real people, what were we expecting? The reality is, in our current financial debacle, this is the level at which we have to work. Like you, I wish the situation was different, but it isn't!

Gibson is no star but he has enough going for him to warrant a opportunity to impress. After watching the Spurs game I'm all for bringing in a new midfield face who just might test the keeper or make an actual creative pass.

Let's give the lad a chance first and if he stinks then I'll happily agree with the 'warranted' criticism. Maybe, just maybe, he might prove a few doubters wrong.
Paul Gladwell
165 Posted 13/01/2012 at 09:51:19
I am just glad that we will have someone in our squad whose confidence is not shot to bits, he can only be better than what we are seeing in our midfield at present and I don't understand the uproar, what do we expect the club is run by gobshites? I am just happy we have got someone, that's how bad the situation is.
Paul Olsen
166 Posted 13/01/2012 at 09:55:28
#286 thanks for pointing out yourself that you obviously have no clue whatsoever
Glen Anderson
167 Posted 13/01/2012 at 10:04:43
I agree with Paul Olsen on both of his last two comments. Decent player, let's see whether he signs and how well he does. I see a Lee Carsley MkII.
Sam Hoare
168 Posted 13/01/2012 at 10:01:43
This thread proves one thing, some people are DETERMINED to find fault in everything.

This really is a no lose situation. A transfer fee next to nothing and probably no more than average wages for a young player with premiership experience and the ability to score on occasion from long range.

If he flops we could probably still move him on for a profit.

What's the problem here?!!
Andrew Laird
169 Posted 13/01/2012 at 10:11:25
One word which sums up this transfer and the player himself: Underwhelming..

Sam, some people are DETERMINED not to find fault in anything.
Thomas Windsor
170 Posted 13/01/2012 at 10:08:25
Why cant we try and get rid of Bily who never gets picked and with the cash buy a forward?

I suppose Gibson might be better than Neville and Hietinga in midfield... but only just ? I missed Tamworth game in protest but going again against Blackburn.
Dave Wilson
171 Posted 13/01/2012 at 10:18:47
You`re right of course Andrew.

Dont know why we didnt go out and buy Messi, Ronaldo and silva.

Now they would have been PROPER signings.

Err . . . .Moyes out !
Andrew Laird
172 Posted 13/01/2012 at 10:24:00
Here comes Dave... obviously had a lifeboat left on his sinking ship of hypocrisy.

How about you tell us what you think of this transfer speculation, maybe even try and sum it up in a word?

Remenber that "Bill Kenwright" will count as 2 words.
Gareth Fieldstead
173 Posted 13/01/2012 at 10:18:35
I am not slagging the player, what I have seen of him he is decent enoug, my only concern is that we are desperate for a striker and after Wednesday another centre back yet Moyes has parted with what little we have on another midfielder. What happened with the Arteta transfer fee would leave me weary to sell a player, even Bily! If I was not going to see a penny of it but something has to be done, whether it's someone like Zamore or Johnson for a few million or he takes a risk on one of the lower league strikers via a player exchange and cash. Kenwright and his cronies need to realize that they will get nowhere near a 100 million for a relegated club.
Kevin Hudson
174 Posted 13/01/2012 at 10:30:53
Andrew (312)

It's blatant to anyone reading the thread that plenty are DETERMINED to reserve judgement upon the player, to see if he proves to be a good acquisition for us.

Naturally, this will take some time to assess..

As opposed to a sizeable chunk who have immediately sprung to a negative conclusion - before either a ball has been kicked, or, the contract itself has been inked-out.

That shows a knee-jerk determination TO find fault, before a situation has even begun to play-out.
Andrew Ellams
175 Posted 13/01/2012 at 10:48:47
Surely the issue here isb't who we might be signing, but more what we might be signing.

Apparently the priority at the beginning of this transfer window was a striker, so we bring in Donovan, a wide midfield player. Then due to unforeseen circumstances, the priority becomes the centre of defence so we line up Darren Gibson and box to box central midfielder. Am I the only that that is a little bit confused here?
Alastair Bates
176 Posted 13/01/2012 at 10:55:42
I just wonder why a central midfield player and not a striker or a centre half, a right back, cover for a left back, a winger, anoter forward.....

I thought we were quite covered in central midfield, Fallaini, Rodwell, Barkley, Osman, Cahill, Heitiger, Neville.

Yes the last two are only cover, and Neville, Cahill and Osman are getting on a bit in football terms but still the first three are our best hope unless one or all are to be sold!!! cheers BK keep ruining our club!
Ray Roche
177 Posted 13/01/2012 at 10:56:23
Andrew Ellams,

No, amte, you're not he omly one. What on earth is Moyes thinking about? A stiker should be top of the list by a mile. I'd be a bit naffed off if he spent what little bit of money Bill found down the back of his sofa on a defender who could play left back at a push, but a midfielder? Does this mean that Barkley is now on the shelf, Rodwell's on his way, Fellaini's out the door carrying Bily or all four aren't going to be seen again?
Paul Joy
178 Posted 13/01/2012 at 10:46:39
What a typical thread on TW - dull negative people leaping in to slag off the player and the deal.

He can pick a pass and he carries a real goal threat - we have neither of those attributes this season. I have paid good money yet again this season to watch Neville & Heitinga play centre midfield plus the consistently useless Bily.
In my opinion Gibson would play as 1st choice. I do not accept that he is a defensive midfielder at all - the lad can play.

The deal looks very good too from our perspective and he is only 24.

Give him a chance to at least pull on the shirt FFS before slaughtering him.
Andrew Fair
179 Posted 13/01/2012 at 11:05:02
Signed him 4 and a half year deal. If he doesnt do the business we can sell him on. Good luck to him and welcome to Goodison, hope the REAL fans will get behind him.
Ian Bennett
180 Posted 13/01/2012 at 10:57:08
If it means that we can sell billy, and use his proceeds for a striker it might be okay. Gibson is still rubbish though.
Andrew Fair
181 Posted 13/01/2012 at 11:05:57
Ray - yes thats right all four are never to be seen again. We are not going to play any midfielders. Get real!!! Fellaini, Rodders and Barkley on long term deals. Which would look like 2 of the 3 would be staying at least. If one goes then it will be to try and improve squad similar to Rooney.
Steavey Buckley
182 Posted 13/01/2012 at 11:07:44
There is something that Gibson can do, which is lacking at the moment in the Everton team, he knows where the goal is, to have a shot.
Danny Broderick
183 Posted 13/01/2012 at 10:48:24
What's the worst that can happen? If he ends up being shite, we can probably sell him on for a similar fee in a few years time. Not being a regular at United is nothing to be ashamed of. In the position we are in, most of their back up would walk into our starting line up.
We have finally bought a player. At 24, he's a good age, an international with an eye for goal. Hopefully this will save Moyes buying another centre half - he will now stop playing Heitinga in midfield (I hope!)
Another striker now please. Beggars can't be choosers. The players we will be bringing in will be from the bargain basement because we haven't got a pot to piss in due to our incompetent board. We might as well get used to it and give any new lads a chance - it's not their fault after all. Remember Marcus Bent and Tim Cahill? Didn't cost mega bucks but served us well...
Sam Hoare
184 Posted 13/01/2012 at 11:04:53
Andrew laird....be so kind as to point out the fault here? Is he worse than Neville heitinga? Are we overpaying? Is he past it? Are we unlikely to get resale value if it doesn't work out?

Go on. Invent some negatives.
Amit Vithlani
185 Posted 13/01/2012 at 10:59:00
A few knee jerk reactions on here. Let the deal complete first , lets see how much we paid, and give the lad 10 games in the shirt.

Give him a warm welcom to Goodison and thank our fucking lucky stars that if he plays, Neville wont be asked to play Centre Mid.

Moyes could sign Ronaldo but because in the eyes of many he is a useless manager, any new signing is not worth it.

Judge Gibson on his own merits. Maybe he was shite at United but its not unheard of for a player to change clubs and improve themselves.

FFS, give the lad a break.
Sam Hoare
186 Posted 13/01/2012 at 11:15:00
Done deal!!! Just announced on OS. First transfer fee proper in 2 years!
Amit Vithlani
187 Posted 13/01/2012 at 11:14:40
That said, one swallow does not make a summer, so the pressure on BK should not subside after Gibson's arrival.

We are still treading water and I hope the BU keeps up its campaign for more transparency, more answers and most important of all, the introduction of an independent board to seek outside investment and draw up a long term busines splan for sustainability.
James Morgan
188 Posted 13/01/2012 at 11:09:10
An underwhelming signing for me, however, he will at least bring the winning mentality United players get instilled with and should prevent Heitinga and Neville playing there. Would still prefer Barkley given a run in MF instead and put the cash towards a striker.
Brian Waring
189 Posted 13/01/2012 at 11:15:15
Alex (#243) the thing is though, Man u are crying out for a defensive midfielder, but they are still willing to let the lad go, if he's that good, then why are they willing to let him go? Also, the Man u fans think he's shite, Wolves rated him that much when he was on loan, they let him go back to Man u. Sunderland fucked him off because of his wage demands, are we going to be able to meet his wages?
Sam Morrison
190 Posted 13/01/2012 at 11:16:36
What did people expect with the pennies we have? Gibson is a decent player who's lost his way. So Utd fans slag him off. Plenty of Evertonians do the same with most of our team right now, and let's be honest the standard is not the same as Utd's.

I'll reserve judgement until he's actually played a few games.
Ray Roche
191 Posted 13/01/2012 at 11:17:42
Andrew Fair
Listen Andrew,I think it's you who needs to get real, signing a player on a long term deal is,in Everton's case, for one reason only. To make sure we get a better deal than if they had only 1-2 years left. We are a selling club. End of story.
I actually quite liked the look of Gibson on the occasions when I've seen him play, but a midfielder is NOT the priority. Unless, of course, one or more of the players I've mentioned are due to leave. I tell you what, I'll bet you £25 that one of those four will have left this club by the start of season 2015-2016 if we have the present board/manager. Which is only two season away.And the money will got o the bank.
Jim Knightley
192 Posted 13/01/2012 at 11:12:47
Woah guys calm down...If the fee is actually only 500,000 - 1million, then it is hardly the end of the world is it? a Manchester United reject does not then qualify him as no good... they are a far better team than us, so why not get their rejects? to get first choice players to come to Everton, we would have to buy from teams worse than us, which would led to the usual vitriol.

Gibson is a decent player, with a goal threat. To buy him signals a declaration to improve our central midfield, which too often has seen Neville and Heitinga playing together. Whilst as some have rightly pointed out, we do have central midfielders in Rodwell, Fellaini, Osman etc, it is not correct to say we have enough. Barkley will not be ready for a couple of years at least, he should go on loan to league 1/lower champ team now. Our squad is the smallest in division, and we need to add to it, and are adding to a position where alot of criticism has been directed at.

Buying Gibson does not mean we will not get a striker in. And what Striker could be bring in for 500,000-1,000,000 anyway? Even the good championship guys are going for 3-4million (Would love Jordan Rhodes though)

Calm down, and take perspective. He is a good player, brought for cheaper than his real value because of his contract position. If he fails, we will sell him on, losing only his wages which may be covered in a bigger fee.
Andrew Laird
193 Posted 13/01/2012 at 11:18:28
Kevin #321

There are plenty on this thread who have already wrote him off, fair enough. I never said there wasn't.

I stand by my summary, underwhelmed. I have seen the lad play a few times myself. How about you tell us what you think about the transfer?
Amit Vithlani
194 Posted 13/01/2012 at 11:23:56
Brian Waring I think United need central defenders more than anything else. They have an injury crisis right now, but once all are fit will have an overloaded squad. My guess is Fergie needs to make room to bring in a Centre back, and Gibson fit the bill.

Give the boy a break. Even if he was not good enough for Fergie he might be a decent player for us.

Fergie has flogged players who have gone on to do decent jobs elsewhere - Kanchelskis, Stam, Diego Forlan. A few have gone on to become no-marks. Lets see what happens in Gibson's case.
Andrew Laird
195 Posted 13/01/2012 at 11:31:28
Sam #333 No fault with what you say, if we sell him for a profit it's a good piece of business. Purely for balance I counter that there are plenty who are blind to anything but positives, that was the point Sam.
Jim Knightley
196 Posted 13/01/2012 at 11:27:59
Ray 2015/2016 is three seasons away...(3 and a half)
And if you took 4 midfielders from any premiership team, some of which cover similar positions, I bet at least one of them would move on over the course of three and a half years. Pointless argument.

We have too few midfielders, not to many. Look at our squad and compare. We need a striker, but why does the arrival of a cheap midfielder suggest we wont bring one in? Given our sales over the summer, I expect we had about 3-4million to play with over this window. 13 days in and Gibson and Donovan have arrived. Surely better already than many of us would have expected a month ago?
Brian Waring
197 Posted 13/01/2012 at 11:32:17
At the end of the day Amit, if he becomes an Everton player, I'll back him because he'll be one of us, and I hope he turns out to be able to do the bizz. But everyone is entitled to have an opinion on whay they think of him.
Simon Harris
198 Posted 13/01/2012 at 11:32:13
I'm sure Moyes is after a striker, but finding and securing one for 1m or less is going to be difficult. Does make you wonder why we accepted Blackburns bid for the Yak, without a replacement waiting in the wings.

As for Gibson, i'll reserve judgement until after a few game. If he signs, good luck to him.
Sam Morrison
199 Posted 13/01/2012 at 11:32:10
If people don't rate him, fine. He may be shite, of course. What is so tedious is that so many seem to be willing him to fail. You can be against Kenwright, and/or Moyes, but still want the team to do well.

Loathing each and every action of the club is not absolutely necessary in order to show your disdain.
Chris Rudd
200 Posted 13/01/2012 at 11:41:09
To me this is neither good nor bad, just baffling. If we have little or no money, why are we spending it on the one area of the team that is well catered for?

Will it limit Barkley's progression? I hope not. I can't help but suspect though, that this signing means that one of our more saleable assets will be on their way in the next two weeks. Rodwell or Fellaini? Again I hope not.

If we sign another striker in this window as well then fair enough, I see him as premiership experienced, reasonable quality with hopefully a winning mentality, having been schooled by United. If we don't, then it's crazy.

In the meantime I'll cheer the guy on while he's wearing the Blue shirt, pray he lives up to his early promise and that when he left Old Trafford he packed his shooting boots.

Because we could really do with some goals from somewhere...anywhere for god's sake.
Ray Roche
201 Posted 13/01/2012 at 11:50:35
Jim Knightley

Of course, you're right, it IS 3.5 seasons away. (I was using several fingers to type with which meant the inevitable confusion that age has brought...apologies)
Not such a pointless argument because I was attempting to indicate that our better midfielders will be lined up to be sold to the likes of Man Utd, because we are a selling club. Gibson, whatever he turns out to be like, is a replacement for someone who, I believe, will leave this,or the next,window and would you be surprised if more than one went? I wouldn't..
Furthermore, after Kenwright had promised that the Arteta money would be available..the Arteta money was about £10m, right?...not £3-£4m, and Donovan HAS turned up along with Gibson. Donovan will also have gone pretty soon and I have said on these pages before that a lot of fans were expecting too much from him. He's not the Messiah. He's not even a very naughty boy. At best he is a stop gap player who Kenwright knew would be welcomed by the fans. I am, though, glad that he's here.
Dan Brierley
202 Posted 13/01/2012 at 11:43:24
Howard - Man U 'reject'
Arteta - Rangers 'reject'
Pienaar - Dortmund 'reject'
Drenthe - Madrid 'reject'

It quite harsh using the term 'reject' isn't it? You could even apply it to your own beloved, who only married you as the fella she really wanted wasn't interested.

I don't see this as a bad signing at all, a few years ago he was in the starting 11 for the League Cup final. He has lost his wat at United, but then again how many of our players would even get into the United first team? Probably only Baines in my eyes. And I would suggest that it signals that the curtain is coming down on our captains career, which will be of delight to many on here. What bothers me most, is that we have so many 'fans' that are just so negative towards our team. I can understand the frustrations with the board, and to some degree with the manager, but slating a lad before he has even kicked a ball in training? Its fucking ridiculous. I for one will never stop supporting the lads on the pitch, regardless of what happens off it.
Gareth Fieldstead
203 Posted 13/01/2012 at 12:21:14
I think even more importantly is Prentices article, about time, but better late than never, do you think he will be banned now?
Amit Vithlani
204 Posted 13/01/2012 at 12:13:33
Donovan and Drenthe out wide, Gibson and Felli in the middle. On paper, does not sound too shabby. A shame that we do not have a in-form striker to speak of.

Perhaps Donovan to take on the mantle like he does at Galaxy?

Would allow Barkley (when fit) a chance to play.

If we can offload Bily and get a winger on loan (what's happened to McGeady?), the side will start taking shape...

OK FM mode off now.
Robbie Muldoon
205 Posted 13/01/2012 at 12:41:52
Number 4? Is he guna be a bench warmer like Drenthe though? Does this mean no Neville in midfield ever again? Does it also mean Barkley is further down the pecking order? Tells me nothing this signing.
Adam Luszniak
206 Posted 13/01/2012 at 12:55:36
Let's face it, you could call Pienaar a Spurs reject if you want to as he hardly gets a game. Doesn't stop him being a decent player.
Chris Keightley
207 Posted 13/01/2012 at 12:53:17
Wow, 200 posts all pretty much split down the middle on opinion - not a big fan of the reject tag does that mean if we had signed Charlie Adams for example he would have been a blackpool reject?

Give the lad a chance, people, he's now signed let's back him 100%, stay off his back and give him a chance to settle ? hopefully we are clearing the decks for a few fresher hungrier players.

Good luck Darron and welcome to EFC.
Robbie Muldoon
208 Posted 13/01/2012 at 13:02:48
Fellaini
Rodwell
Cahill
Osman
Barkley

Gibson

Neville
Heitenga

Surely one of the top group are going to be sold... QPR are after Cahill... I wonder if he fancies a move to London to be closer to his bezzie Arteta? I'd watch that one.
Kevin Hudson
209 Posted 13/01/2012 at 12:58:12
Andrew (349)

I'm a little more "whelmed," than you..
Chris Jones [NZ]
210 Posted 13/01/2012 at 13:20:15
Sometimes, the people on this website just 'do my head in'.

COYBB!
Tony J Williams
211 Posted 13/01/2012 at 13:31:15
"I wonder if he fancies a move to London to be closer to his bezzie Arteta?" - Robbie, there may be something in that way of thinking.
Tommy Coleman
213 Posted 13/01/2012 at 13:47:44
Sign Gary Neville on a free !
Tim Locke
214 Posted 13/01/2012 at 12:24:47
Dan - 369 Spot on.

I don't understand this whole reject thing. If a club is willing to sell a player does that make him a reject? If a player is not in the first 11 or warming the bench does that make him crap?

You have two choices as a football club buy players who are in the first team from a good club or those on the fringe of a club. The first group cost millions, even those the club wants to sell, and no player comes with a warranty or guarantee attached when they fail or get injured. So as we don't have millions like Man City to waste we have to buy carefully. If he does not work out then we are not in the crap and if he does it's another bit of good transfer work by Moyes.

The other thing to remember is a player not in the first team at one club can do very well at another; Arteta and Howard are good examples. It is shocking how negative people are on this site, we are not setting the world on fire but we are doing ok, do you sit and think Ars or Liverpool are really doing that much better? Go back a few years and Leeds were the dogs nuts and where are they now???? I like everyone want to see flowing attacking football built off a solid defence, but we are, where we are and Moyes is doing a good job and the player are working for him. It's not the best but it's a lot lot better than it could be.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads