Vic rescues a point from tight affair

, 14 January, 186comments  |  Jump to most recent
Aston Villa 1 - 1 Everton

Aston Villa 1 - 1 Everton

Everton grabbed a point from an untidy encounter between two nervy teams thanks to Anichebe's second-half strike. The substitute latched onto Donovan's defence-splitting pass and slotted past Given to cancel out Bent's earlier goal. Gibson made a quiet but effective debut in a Blues side that had the upper hand in the first half but again lacked bite going forward and in the end neither side seemed all that convinced they could win this low-key affair.

Four years since the kopite Mark Clattenburg had refereed an Everton game... Shane Duffy made his first League start as Sylvain Distin is ruled out, while Darron Gibson made his debut after arriving from Manchester United.

Gibson showed early, giving away a free-kick, and his first possession at the other end was greeted with a chorus of "Shhoooot!" from the travelling Blues.

Heitinga got a stern talking too and was lucky not to be booked for a professional clip on Bent and from the free-kick, Petrov really tested Howard with a pie-driver.

A fantastic forward pass from Gibson was perfect for Cahill but his lack of confidence lost him the chance before it really arrived as he totally failed to master the ball.

The defence was getting tested, mostly by mistakes by Drenthe but Duffy cleared solidly when required and the absence of Jagielka meant that they were playing it forward on the ground, but Donovan was getting little support on the right wing.

A superb free-kick from Baines was met perfectly by a Saha header, forcing a good save from Given but Villa cleared the dangerous rebound.

Great pace from Donovan anda fantastic cross that Saha should surely have converted but he allowed pressure from Hutton to hold his arm, yet no complaint from Saha, who could have got a penalty if he had gone down instead of ending up in the net,

Everton's inability to score from numerous guilt-edged chances was underlined by a fierce header from Warnock of all people forced a brilliant reaction save from Given!

Next with a chance was Baines, but from the free-kick he fired over as the Villians became increasingly concerned with the virtual one-way traffic from their illustrious visitors.

Drenthe redeemed himself with a vital clearance for the first corner, that set up Collins with a free header which he sent well over the bar. Fellaini became the first booking by Clattenburg and he was not happy about it.

Another good run and cross by Donovan won a corner but Drenthe's corner was delivered too hard and low.

Everton faded and Villa recovered a little, Agbonlahor forcing another stretching save from Howard. Everton ahead on points at the break, but frustratingly no goals to show for it.

The game was summed up by turgid stuff at after the break, Villa making 20 passes along the half-way line while Everton stood of them and failed to make a single challenge. Everton did surge forward and Drenthe won a dubious free-kick that Fellaini powered in at the far post only to see it hit Given's upper arm.

At the other end Villa somehow failed to score when Howard failed to deal with a corner and was lucky when the follow up found him in a crowded goalmouth.

After some pressure, Everton seemed tpo gift the first goal to Villa, three defenders unable to clear allowing the cross that enabled Bent to scoop the ball into the net, all-too-familiar story... a poor goal to give away.

Drenthe, who had been mostly very poor, was switched out for Anichebe on the hour. Gibson got unfairly penalized for a none-foul when Ireland's leap convinced the linesman it must have been a foul.

A superb piece of play from Donovan picked out the run of Anichebe through the middle and Nigerian scored cleanly to put the Blues back in it within 8 mins of coming on. But then Anichebe twisted his knee trying to stop a throw-in, and had everyone fearing it was another serious injury as he needed lots of attention on the sideline, eventually clambering to his feet after being persuaded there was no permanent damage.

With everything to play for, both sides seemed to settle for the draw, McLeish finally making a move, bringing on Keane,; Moyes's response was to remove Gibson, who had faded badly, apparently through lack of playing time, bringing on Bilyaletdinov.

Donovan again played in Anichebe but his effort lacked conviction, and no-one could put the ball in from amidst a crazy goalmouth pinball session that followed the corner. With 2 mins left, the Moyes masterstroke was to bring on Stracqualursi for Saha after another useless goalless game.

Stracqualursi won a free-kick some distance out that annoyingly required both Donovan and Baines to execute, with Cahill making a lame shot at the end that was hopelessly off-target as another dismal display in the poptastic Premier League dragged to another desperately dull conclusion. And they wonder why the crowds are dwindling... The only 'sabotage' going on here, Mr Elstone, is to the game of football.

Everton: Howard, Neville, Heitinga, Duffy, Baines, Donovan, Gibson (84' Bilyaletdinov), Fellaini (Y:35'), Drenthe (60' Anichebe), Cahill, Saha (88' Stracqualursi).
Subs: Mucha, McFadden, Gueye, Vellios.

Quotes or other material sourced from ToffeeWeb Match Report Page



Reader Comments (186)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Tony Christian
2 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:01:27
Hard fought draw. Baines had tough time dealing with Allbrighton and Ireland, no support off Drenthe. Donovan had decent game, Gibson faded but to be expected, Saha anonymous, Cahill ditto. Missing Osman more than we care to admit.
Andrew Yates
3 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:01:17
So Gibson offered little? Unfortunately completely missed the game, can anyone provide any positives??

I was at the Bolton game and nothing could have been as bad as that............could it?
Roman Sidey
4 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:08:46
Cannot believe that Fellaini got through that article without a blemish. Honestly, in light of him signing a new contract recently, he should be forced to donate his weekly wage to the away fans for that performance.
Gareth Humphreys
5 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:06:55
Two points dropped by an injury ravaged Everton. Isn't that a contradiction? No wonder this site is deemed as negative when that is the opening gambit from the editor. Get a grip.
Denis Richardson
6 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:08:24
Good debut from Gibson - finally have someone in the middle who looks confortable on the ball, can pass and more importantly looks for the forward pass. Also wasn't hiding, calling for the ball a lot. Stick im the middle and leave him there Moyes - even when Osman and Rodwell come back.

Duffy also looked ok, wonder how many other youngsters would not look out of place if given the chance.

Fellaini was awful, Saha not far behind and Cahill offerred little up top as usual.

Donovan my MOTM.
John Sreet
7 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:07:25
Well I didn't see the match or hear the commentary, but reading your report seems like a pretty interesting game to me.........maybe you have taken a little too much poetic license as your headline does not fit the report.

Two points lost at Villa is a little harsh I think.
James I'Anson
8 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:10:59
No Gareth. Injury ravaged or not, we should have beaten them.
Tony Christian
9 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:10:56
I thought it was fair result. Villa put us under lot of pressure in second half and we worked hard and deserved reward. Wasn't vintage but was improvement on recent performances. Fellaini worked hard as defensive midfielder so any criticism harsh.
Roman Sidey
10 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:12:03
Gareth, did you watch the match? I know we're short on players at the moment, but that Villa side were terrible, and there for the taking.
Michael Kenrick
11 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:15:05
Make no mistake, we should have beaten this lot, we should have won this game.

We didn't for all the usual reasons. Most notably for me the dour dismal manager who patently fails to get the players he has available going for the win ? and who continues to play the utterly useless Cahill and the utterly useless Saha ? our 'strikeforce'... Don't make me cry.

Any feint interest in the match description was nullified by the failure yet again to go for a win in a very winnable game. Moyes is such a dour negative defense dominated twat, he really really gets my goat.
Glen Anderson
12 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:17:11
Just shows how important a good striker is. Villa were awful but Bent was their MOTM and kept them in it.

We weren't much better but accounted well for ourselves given so many injuries.
Tony Christian
13 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:20:37
Why do we seem to think we have the god given right to take all three points if only Davey allowed it? Villa put Everton under pressure and we had to work hard for what we got. In Moyes' defence he realised Baines was being exposed by Drenthe's failure to keep possession and changed it for the good. My only criticism is that we lack any outlet up front and Saha looks disinterested at best, however unless we buy he's our best option and don't say Strac or Velios are an improvement because they aren't.
Dean Adams
14 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:21:24
Michael Kenrick 883

Dont be shy Michael, just say what you mean about Moyes!!!

Hate to be saying it but we will never win with Saha in the team with Timmy and Nev. When players are fit these should not be anywhere the starting 11.
Stephen Kenny
15 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:23:47
Cahill and Saha have scored 1 goal in 30 odd combined appearances.

How they still get a game is beyond me. This has well gone past playing through a bad patch.
Denis Richardson
16 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:23:54
Can we put this injury excuse to bed. If we had no injuries at all how different would our team have been? Not much IMO.

Duffy out for Jags or Distin and maybe Rodwell in. Drenthe was not good today but before the start would still have chosen him ahead of Osman and I would have Neville ahead of Hibbo at RB.

We do have a lot of injuries but they affected the subs bench more that the starting 11 - IMO.
Ian McDowell
17 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:28:34
Thought Gibson did well today, doesn't seem an awful lot of difference between him and Rodwell.
Neil Fereday
18 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:18:37
Didn't see the match but a point at Aston Villa is OK.
Tom Tani
19 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:28:41
Look on the bright side. Everton's old pal Clattenberg was reffing. Felli could have been given a red they way that guy thinks!

Considering that Everton was down, getting a point is a relief and moves them up to #10. Glad to see Landon loan is paying off,, Nice assist today.

But how sad is it when your goalkeeper has a many goals as yoru starting strikers
Jamie Barlow
20 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:25:44
How long is this bullshit strikeforce going to be kept in? I know it's a terrible thing to say but I can't wait for Saha and Cahill to be injured. How come Saha never gets injured when hes playing wank?

Gibson was steady in his first game. Donovan was good. Duffy did alright defending. Neville was his usual slow shite. Felli did nothing and Drenthe can fuck off back to Holland. He does one good thing for every 4 things he fucks up.

I'm not having that it's Moyes not motivating these players because we started of well today and they all look motivated to me. It's when things don't work that they start to panic and no fucker wants the ball.

Same old shite. Too many of the usual suspects letting us down again.
Tony Twist
21 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:29:19
More dropped points which we can ill-afford to do. It's getting tighter at the bottom and we only seem to have one gear, we can't raise our game. What has Vellios done to deserve a seat on the bench? MotM Donovan, that's not good as he won't be with us for long.

Hopefully Moyes can find the best midfield combination maybe it is Fellaini just behind Gibson and Osman with Drenthe on one side and coleman on the other when Donovan has departed. Well done Victor for finding the net, keep the goals coming.
Roman Sidey
22 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:30:18
I think some positives came out of the game in that we have a deeper squad than people think. Duffy was solid, Vic came off the bench and, fuck knows, there just might be a footballer (or at least goal scorer) in there somewhere.

Now the issue will be how Moyes reacts to this. If I were him, I would pick the same side next week, but swap Bily for Cahill, and Vellios for Saha. I think Fellaini needs to be dropped, but only if Rodwell is fit.

What will happen though is this:

Hibbo back in at RB (after Neville has done better there than him).
Osman (if fit) in for Drenthe (Did everyone else notice him tracking back a lot more today?).
Anichebe will start, probably in place of Gibson, even though it is painstakingly obvious that if he is going to be valuable to the squad, it's as a sub.

Quite upset that the Yak won't get his Goodison return next week too.

0-0 my prediction.
Michael Winstanley
23 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:24:48
From the games I've seen I've come to conclusion most teams aren't very good at football.

Villa were awful today and how we didn't score in the first half I don't know.

Fellaini didn't look interested today. I thought Gibson did okay and will do well for us. Drenthe was pretty dire if I'm honest and he gives the ball away far too often.

Duffy & JH played well and although I hate to say it Neville looked not bad at right back.

Donovan is now the main player at Everton and we should play to his strengths. Saha did okay but I don't see what Cahill offers us anymore, yes he tries more than others but we need an end product.

A disappointing draw in the end.
Roberto Birquet
24 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:34:11
We have a bloody fortnight to find a loan striker. And for god's sake, sell Bily and convince Donovan to stay.
Kevin Hudson
25 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:34:38
The two Irish lads put a good shift in I thought, particularly Duffy, who's inexperienced and unlucky with their goal.

Moyes may not agree, but my opinion is that it's at least worth a punt to start with Vellios & Anichebe against Blackburn, as it's impossible not to concur with the Saha / Cahill shouts.

Promising performance, but a decent point under the circumstances.
Danny O'Neill
26 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:37:56
Didn't see the match, swore at the radio (loudly) when we went a goal down and spent last 20 nervous when we equalised! Obviously not qualified to comment on today's performance and obviously you want to win every game but a point away to Villa in the bigger scheme of things ? I'd take that.

Away from the emotion and hormonal nature of being there, independent (non-Evertonian) reports suggest we were unlucky, particularly in the first half.
Kunal Desai
27 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:41:38
Barkley behind Vellios. Now that could be interesting...
Kunal Desai
28 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:45:12
Moyes just said yeah he would have been happy with a point before the match.
Roman Sidey
29 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:43:04
Yes, Danny. How we went into half time scoreless and having had half as many shots as them... quite frankly is confuses the shit outta me. I think Everton of nine months ago would have been 2-0 up at half time against that shite.
Luke Dunn
30 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:42:52
We dominated the first half, Villa were better for 15 mins at the start of the second half.

Gibson did well for his first game, Vic made a diference, not sure what Cahill was doing or where he was supposed to play. Saha should have scored but typical of a player who is not in form.

Not a bad point as once again we came from behind.
Brian Waring
31 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:39:24
Michael (#895): "Villa were awful" ? It shows how bad we must have been, Michael, when the stats were:-

Possesion, Villa 56%, us 44%
Shots on target, Villa 11, us 4
Shots off target Villa 6, us 3
Corners Villa 9, us 3
Brian Waring
32 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:48:07
Luke, we didn't dominate the first half. We had a bit more possesion, but the shots on target count was Villa 7 us 1
Michael Winstanley
33 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:52:48
I watched the game Brian, I didn't think they were any good. They had a spell for about 10 mins after they scored where we looked shell-shocked.

We didn't create enough and looked lost at times as to what we were doing. The first half should have seen us out of sight.
Colin Malone
34 Posted 14/01/2012 at 17:57:04
Ian (#889), there is a difference: Gibson passed the ball forward.
Moyes said we need a centre-half???? Well done, Shane Duffy.
Well done, Darron Gibson.
Brian Waring
35 Posted 14/01/2012 at 18:03:41
Michael, you may say they didn't look very good, but they still mustered 11 shots on target to our 4.
Danny O'Neill
36 Posted 14/01/2012 at 18:02:30
Roman - you being sarcastic?!!
Ray Said
37 Posted 14/01/2012 at 18:02:44
I thought Duffy was good and looks as if he can make it. He headed, tackled and cleared the ball well.

Vic scored a good goal and maybe he can make it as well ? he showed a better attitude today and looked like our best striker (although that's damming him with faint praise).

The experienced (old as the hills) players have let the young lads down and should be fucked off to the bench. Give me youthful energy and effort over experience but slow and lazy anytime.
Michael Kenrick
38 Posted 14/01/2012 at 18:05:35
"We didn't create enough and looked lost at times as to what we were doing."

Could there be a more damning indictment of this manager? What in the name of god does he spend the week doing??? From the body language of the players, their attitude, the entire demeanour of the team...

What was that comment about sabotage???
James Martin
39 Posted 14/01/2012 at 18:04:04
Duffy played well, more dominant in the air than Jagielka's been for a while and had conviction in his clearing, he also has a really good long ball on him that were actually aimed towards people. A bit like Mertersacker though he lacks pace but it would be nice to have a defender with positional defense rather than our usual two 'recovery defenders'.

Gibson was decent and at least looked to pass the ball forward, not that anyone made any runs for him at all. Villa were as bad as us, three strikers up front but the midfield so intent on keeping possession didn't dare pass it forward, exactly like us except we haven't got any quality upfront anyway, something we used to compensate by excellent midfield support.
Roman Sidey
40 Posted 14/01/2012 at 18:10:14
No, Danny. It was a serious answer to your question. I typically don't use sarcasm on here because you can't see tone in text. Sorry for the confusion.
Roman Sidey
41 Posted 14/01/2012 at 18:12:45
Sorry, I mean to say, "yes we were unlucky" or just more deserving.
Ray Said
42 Posted 14/01/2012 at 18:18:24
Michael #911. Couldnt agree more. What do they do all week? I manage a small work team ? if the members performed like that and I told the boss 'they look like they don't know what they are doing', it's MY arse that would be heading out of the door.
Richard Styles
43 Posted 14/01/2012 at 18:11:59
I think you lads were watching a different team from me... We did well for what we had, we both missed chances, certain players didn't turn up again... and should go straight to the kids Cancer ward and donate their wages.

Fellaini can barely run back and when he does, well look at the goal a few times and see what he does for their goal. Other than that, I can't say we didn't deserve a point. Given was fantastic, as are most keepers whenever they meet us. Their team can suck but their goalie has a blinder... Don't take my word for it, see for yourselves...
http://www.eplmatches.com/
Anthony Millington
44 Posted 14/01/2012 at 18:22:55
I thought Gibson did quite well considering all the stick he's been given before he's even played for us. He worked hard and looked a lot more disciplined than Fellaini and wasn't afraid to get stuck in. Maybe he can be the holding midfielder that we never replaced after Carsley, but he's got more to him than Cars going forward too.
Danny O'Neill
45 Posted 14/01/2012 at 18:26:09
No problems Roman - get paranoid on this site when I try to be slightly positive!
Matt Garen
46 Posted 14/01/2012 at 18:33:14
Said it on another thread earlier, Gibson is a decent player and will be a good signing. I notice that 37-year-old keeping him out of the current Champions' midfield scored today for Man Utd. Does that make Gibson shit? Of course it doesn't. It means nothing other than we got a good player for a great price in return for Rodwell's £12m fee in the summer.
Jon Cox
47 Posted 14/01/2012 at 18:30:50
Wow found my way out of the forum at last.

Did anyone else notice that this game started to look good in the 87th min? Like I said then the 22 of them should have been made to play another 90 mins!

Woeful, cowardice, girly football by both teams, on how much a week??!!
Ben Jones
48 Posted 14/01/2012 at 18:36:29
Michael, stop ignoring the fact Villa had more shots than us!

Not a bad point, bit frustrating we didn't capitalise on first-half pressure, but Villa were better in the 2nd.

Must win against Blackburn next week. If we don't win that, then I'll complain.
Sam Hoare
49 Posted 14/01/2012 at 18:40:53
Last time I checked, a point away at Villa, a team around the same level as us was not a terrible result.

Positives in Gibson and Duffy. As ever, we lack a striker.

I really, really struggle to understand why Cahill continues to start as well. I suppose due to lack of better alternatives.
Paul Thompson
50 Posted 14/01/2012 at 18:45:57
Usual problems, but some positives. For someone who may not have even trained with us, Gibson looked very comfortable, Duffy's performance may persuade Moyes that the priority is a striker not a defender in the transfer window. Class goal from open play - what a pass from Donovan.

One negative - I know a lot of people on this site think Drenthe is the messiah, but he's really just a very naughty boy. Never seen anyone give the ball away as much in his own half, including lead up to their goal.
Denis Richardson
51 Posted 14/01/2012 at 18:49:28
Sam - Cahill must be Pele reborn in training or presumably has some compromising photographs of Moyes wirh Subbuteo set!

Seriously though, he did great for the club before and to be fair its not his fault the manager keeps putting him in the starting 11. Anyone of Vellios, Anichebe, Gueye or that youngster who had a good 5-10 mins (McLeny or something) would have been a better shout startin up top.

Two weeks left in the transfer window...not going to hold my breath.
Jon Cox
52 Posted 14/01/2012 at 18:44:13
Anthony M (stardate 917.333 rec)

Spot on about Carsley. We never got to replace this guy and I've been checking this fact out ever since he left. Fellaini has never done it but hopefully "Fender" from Utd will.

We need a fire sale of the deadwood at Goodison and from what I've seen in the Championship and their price tags thereof, we couldn't do any worse than the dark and dismall rubbish we're being served up now.

I can only console myself and think we are in a moment of "transition" but then look at the amount of years the Arse have been in transition and think OH shit. That long to wait.

It's not the managers that come in and do the power motivation shit. It's the managers who do the power motivation shit when things are going wrong after ten years that count.

Steve Yoder
53 Posted 14/01/2012 at 19:08:12
Beautiful pass by Donovan--he is great at passing to space through the middle, something that Everton usually lacks. When he leaves it will be back to working in crosses from the wings solely, a strategy that once worked when Cahill was in form, but that is no longer valid.
Paul Ferry
54 Posted 14/01/2012 at 19:03:57
spot on last paragraph there Coxy
Michael Kenrick
55 Posted 14/01/2012 at 19:03:32
One thing I should have mentioned is the construction of the goal, which started quickly from a Villa attack, thanks to a brilliant quick throw from Howard straight to Donovan on the half-way line. He cut in, creating space brilliantly, and his through-ball to Anichebe was world-class, but it would have counted for nothing without Big Vic's perfectly timed run (I think he was fractionally offside... while the useless Saha was definitely in an offside position but thankfully a long way from the ball).

A goal Made in the USA!

Shows what a difference throwing the ball out can make, rather than the aimless punt from the back. But anyone other than Landon and that would have been a backwards or sideways pass to midfielders ambling forward slowly, making sure they kept the shape, and were ready at the drop of a hat to... Track Back!!!

No worries... a week or two more and Moyes will have Donovan better drilled to the defensive mindset. Such risky forward balls will be eliminated from his game and he'll be toeing the manager's dour dull defeatist line.

Sam Hoare
56 Posted 14/01/2012 at 19:07:06
Denis, i agree, its not Cahill's fault. He is always high on effort but he is essentially a striker who is without a goal in over a year.

Am hoping we might get Sordell from Watford, who are almost as skint as us.

Otherwise i'd say we need to give another combination a run. Trouble is who? Maybe Vellios with Saha behind? Or Anichebe with Barkley behind? God knows but Cahill Saha has been tried to death.
Jamie Tulacz
57 Posted 14/01/2012 at 19:07:25
Thought we played OK today, the bore draw headline slightly harsh. With a better striker we could have got 3 points despite what the stats say, think we had generally had the better of the game today.

Agree completely that the Saha -Cahill combination needs a change but if anyone's thinking that Vellios, Anichebe, Straq etc are going to make that much difference they're kidding themselves.

Encouraged by Duffy's play today, hopefully he can slot in well and mean that Moyes can focus on getting a striker rather than a defender in the window thought Donovan was good, Gibson solid and Anichebe took his goal nicely. Drenthe and Fellaini both pretty poor today though
Colin Malone
58 Posted 14/01/2012 at 19:08:43
We need a right back that will fit the premier league. Sorry Hibbo.
Steve Yoder
59 Posted 14/01/2012 at 19:19:08
Good point Michael about Vic's excellent run and his staying onside. From that goal and from a later combo that I thought Vic should have done better with, it looks like he and Donovan may have a good rapport.

Duffy was good. Reminded me of Distin.
Paul Ferry
60 Posted 14/01/2012 at 19:12:27
Michael-K and Pete Barry should get together to see how many Ds they come up with to describe dreary, dour, defeatist, dull, dim, dark-side, dumb, dickhead, dragon-features, disinterested, dim-wit, dry, dense, dormant, dismal, depressing, drab, dowdy, dingy, disheartening, discouraging, disappointing, deficient, defective, despondent, despairing, damaging, destructive, deleterious,
DAVEY
Steve Mink
61 Posted 14/01/2012 at 18:54:25
Just back from Villa Park.

Leaving aside the tedious debate about shot counts, it was an even game between two poor sides.


Gibson was tidy enough but too similar to Felli
Cahill good first half, Donovan was good throughout
Tom Bowers
62 Posted 14/01/2012 at 19:17:56
A fairly predictable result from 2 mediocre sides with mediocre managers. Donovan was the pick of Everton's players but with the usual suspects achieving very little he didn't have to try very hard. Gibson needs matches under his belt but there is little excuse for Cahill, Saha or Fellaini who just look washed up and achieved little offensively.

Big Vic, apart from a well-taken goal, struggled to make any impact. I have given up expecting much more from this manager and squad certainly for this season.
Jon Cox
63 Posted 14/01/2012 at 19:22:50
Thanks mate, i'm in my 50's. I haven't got the time to wait 30-40 years for something to formulate. I WANT IT NOW.

Oh and by the way what were the 16th-17th century books you were reading?

Myself i'm into "football and can we keep 22 players on the pitch with Bubonica"
Ray Said
64 Posted 14/01/2012 at 19:20:01
Jon (#926).

Spot on about the fire sale but it may be like selling video players in the age of Blu ray-would you buy Saha, Neville, etc?

I would seriously get shut of everyone over 25 except Baines and replace with youth and/or players from the Championship. I would like to see Cahill on the staff but think he will be off to Oz..
Brian Waring
65 Posted 14/01/2012 at 19:17:15
Jamie, how can you can say we had the better of the game, when the stats say we never?

Brian Waring
66 Posted 14/01/2012 at 19:29:52
Steve (#937) best take on the game up to now, and it only took you a few lines.
Paul Ferry
67 Posted 14/01/2012 at 19:29:57
Ha, I'm not much younger Jon; we probably share many memories and experiences mate. If you really want to know, the 17th-century books I was reading Wednesday were:

Robert Jenison - The cities safetie: or, a fruitfull treatise (and usefull for these dangerous times.) on Psal. 127.1. Except the Lord keepe the citie, the watchman waketh but in vaine Manifesting 1. Wherein a cities safetie consisteth. 2. The foregoing signes of a cities destruction. 3. The preventing meanes of a cities ruine. All applyed to our cities in England. Being the effect of divers sermons preached at Newcastle upon Tine, in the lecture there; by R. Ienison, D. of Divinitie (1630)

AND

HT - A looking-glasse for women, or, A spie for pride: shewing the unlawfulnesse of any outward adorning of any attire of haire, either in laying forth the haire, or in crisping of the haire, or in broidered haire in all women, but especially in godly women (1644)

there you go mate - that must be a 1st for toffeeweb!

Thought Gibson did well today, by the way.

Michael Kenrick
68 Posted 14/01/2012 at 19:35:23
Paul (#935) ? Devastatingly direct and deplorably definitive! Sadly all too accurate!!!
Chris Butler
69 Posted 14/01/2012 at 19:29:37
This will always be the difference between us and the top teams. Villa were for the taking really after we equalised we could of put much more pressure on the Villa goal.

Drenthe isn't that good ? he's just the Dutch Bily in many ways capable of producing moments of magic but they are a rare occurence. When we do attack teams at pace, we're a danger, but, when we take our time and then play predictable passes, we struggle.

I believe there is another way to get goals play Felaini behind the striker; in his first season he played behind the striker and scored numerous goals. Now we have cover in central midfield, I believe he would be more efficient behind the striker.
Jon Cox
70 Posted 14/01/2012 at 19:29:04
Paul, Disseminatingly Diceptive.......
Paul Ferry
71 Posted 14/01/2012 at 19:37:30
Nice one Michael ? agree 100 per cent.
Paul Ferry
72 Posted 14/01/2012 at 19:42:11
Shit, I forgot diminutive and disillusioning.
Tim Wilkins
73 Posted 14/01/2012 at 19:37:02
I watched the game today and I thought Duffy and Gibson both played well. I reckon if Gibson gets a run of games under his belt he could turn out to be a very good signing.

Very disappointed with Saha and Cahill ? I think we should cash in on them both this summer while we can still get something for them.

Such a shame to see Cahill (a great servant to the club over the years) become a pale shadow of the player he once was. Saha didn't look interested ? he didn't even appeal when he was fouled in the box in the 1st half.
Jon Cox
74 Posted 14/01/2012 at 19:39:30
Paul, "he that hath shall be giveth, he that hath not shall be taken away" A little bit like the pro footballers to us that toil, for us and our families.

Fender Strat (from Utd) time will tell.
Jon Cox
75 Posted 14/01/2012 at 19:45:46
Saha and Cahill and Moyes, "sell-by date" comng to a ground near you...
Ray Said
76 Posted 14/01/2012 at 19:46:10
Paul 952
Suggest doleful?
Paul Woolf
77 Posted 14/01/2012 at 19:25:41
I too am just back from Villa Park...

Cahill good first half? ? no, he and the total waste of time Saha, have to be dropped! Duffy was okay, as was Gibson, Felli yet again (for me) bloody awful.

Fair scoreline, dour game.
Jon Cox
79 Posted 14/01/2012 at 19:53:42
Ray, Decreptitude!
Ray Said
80 Posted 14/01/2012 at 19:56:36
Jon 960. Dilapidated
John Sreet
81 Posted 14/01/2012 at 19:42:18
It's kind of humorous to read the battering Moyes gets, some here simply play the same old song again and again in fact as soon as you spot their name you know exactly what will be posted. I neither love Moyes nor hate him but ask yourself who the hell do you think would take Everton on right now.

I heard the Sky boys say that without Moyes we would be sunk, now they're only professional footballers and been in the business for aeons, they're not Everton fans with vitriol to shed.........

Maybe we'd like Steve Keane he'll be available soon, or Steve Bruce, or Bruce Lee or.....which manager of quality would come near a club that has no cash and a threadbare squad..........answers on a postcard please!
Bobby Thomas
82 Posted 14/01/2012 at 19:39:07
Loads of injuries and Duffy, Gibson, Drenthe and Donovan wouldn't have played in a first team fixture together before... two of these are loan players and a new signing. And Donovan will be gone as soon as he arrived.

Under the circumstances im happy with a point. The season has been a write off, in the context of this season its a resonable result.

Hopefully the Gibson signing will see us return to the early ethos of Moyes. Young, hungry players on lower wages.

In turn, hopefully we can lose the The Fro off the wage bill in the summer. An astronomical fee for us and now massive wages as well. We run small squads and could have had 2 players for that cash.

Good player, but if we were gonna spend that kind of money it should have been on an impact player and not a stylish holding player. The acid test will be how much we can get for him. In all likleyhood no more than a few more million than we paid for him, if that. Big decisions on who else goes in the summer to, a) finance new signings and b) whos past it/wants out/bids too big to turn down.

If we get an offer its going to be hard to keep Baines for example. Others i would happily cash in on, like Fellaini, poss Rodwell. Saha and Billy i will personally drive them to the airport. Anyone know how long Cahill has left on his deal?
Bobby Thomas
83 Posted 14/01/2012 at 20:01:04
Apologies......meant Duffy, Gibson, Drenthe or Donovan wouldnt have played together before........
Jon Cox
84 Posted 14/01/2012 at 20:03:11
Ray, 961, Deceased!!
Ray Said
85 Posted 14/01/2012 at 20:06:55
Jon, 966. Game,set and match mate!
Bob Willis
86 Posted 14/01/2012 at 19:35:34
Paul 945.

This mumbo-jumbo about the hair bit, sure they were not referring to our Fellini - Drenthe godly pair?
Sam Hoare
87 Posted 14/01/2012 at 20:01:39
Think Tim is contracted till end of 2013-14 season. If we can sell him we should. Great servant but no longer able to produce what we need.

Moyes won't sell Fellaini. He rates him along with Baines and Howard as unsellable.

Rodwell may be another matter.
Graham Duffy
88 Posted 14/01/2012 at 20:07:31
John Street, those Sky boys don't watch Everton week in week out like we do so they don't see what we see; that Moyes doesn't play the best players in their best positions and is soooooooooooooooooooo negative it's turning Evertonians of all ages off our club until there is change.
Jon Cox
89 Posted 14/01/2012 at 20:04:53
Ahh, John Street, "I heard the Sky boys"

FFS think for your self. Sky boys, more like rent boys. And of course they're not saying that Moyes is great because they're told to.

I think you'll find it's called prostitution.
Michael Ward
90 Posted 14/01/2012 at 20:06:46
I think today was the best we have played for a long time and i think the description of the game on the home page is a very negative slant on the team.

My only gripe today was that Saha again started when he has offered nothing in any of the last few games.

The write up also says Drenthe offered no support which I think is completely untrue he made a very good clearance in the first half and in the main played well going forward and attacking.

Donovan was the best player today, Gibson did ok but was not very involved and seemed to be playing as the deepest midfielder and made a few good challenges.

Fellaini was off his game today and had a few stray passes but overall I left feeling happy today more with the performance than the result and moyes actually played an attacking team which was the main reason for this improvement.

Lets hope for more performances like today instead of trying to put a damper on everything.

There's my 10 bobs worth...
Bob Willis
91 Posted 14/01/2012 at 20:08:27
D for damn dozey dodger - Saha.
Bob Willis
92 Posted 14/01/2012 at 20:12:18
Or as we say in Welsh: Diawl Diog.
Jon Cox
93 Posted 14/01/2012 at 20:11:11
Ray, LOL
Jon Cox
94 Posted 14/01/2012 at 20:18:35
Ray, I really think that you're surname is the best on the planet. As in Ray Said, Blah Blah.

I just wish my surname could have been Jon, Moyes is a twat. I'm just looking at my teachers now. "Moyes is a twat come out here and take six of the best"
Lyndon Lloyd
95 Posted 14/01/2012 at 20:23:33
Michael W, I too disagree with the assertion that Drenthe offered no support because he tracked back on a number of occasions and made one excellent interception at the back post as the deepest man back.

He was frustrating going forward, though, and I'm convinced he's better on the right than the left. Seeing as Donovan did his best work on the left flank, I'd switch them against Blackburn if it were up to me.

I don't think we played particularly well today, though. We were OK in the first half and, again, with a bit more attacking support or a rub of the green, we'd have been ahead at half time.

Villa came back into the into the second half though and the goal was a rare moment of vision and inspiration — it gave us a point we probably deserved on balance but we need much more of that. Credit to both players involved.
Tim Wilkins
96 Posted 14/01/2012 at 20:12:14
Agree with Mike #973. We played well today, personally think we should've been 2-0 up at half-time. I have no issues with our defence or midfield, it's our strikers who have let us down this season.

I'm not anti Moyes, I think he's doing the best job he can with the limited resources available to him. If we haven't got any forwards who can consistently find the back of the net then he has to make sure we don't lose instead. Hence the defensive tactics this season.

But, to be fair to Moyes, he's made a few attack-minded substitutions this season (Big Vic has come off the bench and got us 4 points against WBA and Villa). It's not Moyes fault he can't afford a £15m striker to win games. If we had a Bent, Dzeko or Ba then I reckon we could be a top 5 team.
Ray Said
97 Posted 14/01/2012 at 20:29:51
Jon, you should have just changed your middle name to 'Massive'. Imagine the teachers struggling with that one!
Gavin Fennessy
98 Posted 14/01/2012 at 20:34:02
Defensive, Dawdling, Discombobulated, Dopey, Doubtful,Dazed, Deficient, Dense, Dim, Doltish, Dull, Dummy, Discordant, Disordered,Dullard.

Oh and Everton weren't much good either.....
Bobby Thomas
99 Posted 14/01/2012 at 20:11:23
Cheers Sam, 2013/14?

The Cahill conunderum eh? He currently isnt doing it, although he has placed the cause above himself i feel on a few occasions this season, playing injured and out of position etc. He also needs less football not more at his age. Wonder if Moyes would be prepared to lose one of his most loyal and trusted players, who is undoubtedly a big influence around the place? Currently not earning his dolllar though, would possibly benefit from a change of scene himself.

On Fellaini and Baines, you are discounting the player making the decision for the manager. I obviously dont want Baines to leave. But if City/Arsenal came in with a bid its going to make him think. Moyes may or may not view Fellaini as unsellable, but do you think he wants to stay long term? Do you think Fellaini is going to negotiate another deal here after all this shit, most were all amazed he re-signed!!
Jamie Tulacz
100 Posted 14/01/2012 at 20:47:44
Agreed Cahill needs to play less, has been overplayed over the last few years with international fixtures and too much travelling. But seems unfair to criticise him, has always given 100% for the cause and dug us out of many a hole over the last few years. If we did have decent alternatives we should definitely play him less, but unfortunately we don't!
Jon Cox
101 Posted 14/01/2012 at 20:53:39
Ray, so Moyes is a "massive twat"...

How very very dare you, :-)
Paul Ferry
102 Posted 14/01/2012 at 20:44:29
I have no idea where Cahill was playing today: at times behind Louis at other times in front of the centre backs, where he played against the Spuds and had his best game for a while, I think (pressure off there, to score???????). If Timmy is to stay with us then he needs to be moved back; back to where he was on Wednesday, in holding role. He is finished up front, end of - mind you, even though he did not score after Crimbo last season, he still ended up as our top scorer!!!

Saha is a total fucking waste of time and space, no more needs to be said. Ship the lazy fuck (did you see him trying to beat people today and not giving a flying fuck when Hutton pulled him back for a defo pen). Fella stunk today. It's a ritual bleat, I know, but please please please please buy us someone who can score goals and hold the ball in the next two weeks or so.

Saha should never ever start for us again, but he will. He should never again partner Cahill up front or have him tucked up behind him, but he will. There were better options on the bench today. On paper the midfield did not look terrible today. Gibson had a decent start and he looks forwards with ball at feet not backwards. Duffy caught out twice (and was at fault for the goal) but he did well enough for me. Royston: 3/10 mate.

Howard - Hibbbert (if fit) - Duffy - Heitinga - Baines - Drenthe (despite today) - Gibson - Rodwell (if fit) - Donovan - Guye - Velios

next time please, Davey.
Dave Wilson
103 Posted 14/01/2012 at 21:02:30
Where do these stats come from ? We should have won, in fact we should have been home and hosed before they had even had an attack. Cahill missed another sitter, Given made a great save from Saha and an even better one from his own man. we just didnt believe
Jimmy Sørheim
104 Posted 14/01/2012 at 20:36:15
We did play ok in the first half, but it is the sight and bad feeling you get from watching Saha and Cahill that spoils it for me.

No matter how many clear cut chances these two get you know that they will just not score.

For Moyes to keep playing these two knowing full well that they are out of form, it just makes me explode!

I am beginning to hate these two players, but it is not thir fault they are out of form, it is Moyes who keeps picking them to play in front of others who can and would do a much better job than what Cahill and Saha is doing.

This has been my main problem with Moyes in the last couple of years, the fact that he keeps picking players who are out of form just goes to show that he does not know how to find and keep a winning side.

The lack of fresh in-form players are dragging the team and results down.

His adapting in this area is really poor, but this season we do not have many other good strikers to choose from, and I blame Moyes for that, as he has sold 3 strikers only this summer.
Yakubu was the one of the 3 I really miss, and we are now watching what happens when you sell too many strikers at the same time, withoutt bringing in similar quality.
We should have bought a new top striker 3 years ago.

I feel Moyes has done us no good these last few years , and should be leaving as soon as he gets an offer from another club.( Which I think he will.)

Dave Wilson
105 Posted 14/01/2012 at 21:06:17
Oh and BTW

I have`nt had the chance to see a replay yet, but if that wasnt YET ANOTHER nailed on penalty when Saha was bundled into the net then there is no such thing as a penalty.

but Hey. we`re Everton, we dont make a fuss do we ? just accept getting fucken robbed by people like Clattenburg
Paul Ferry
106 Posted 14/01/2012 at 21:14:45
It is absolutely Saha's and Timmy's fault that they are out of form.
Paul Ferry
107 Posted 14/01/2012 at 21:15:57
Dave Wilson - don't tar us all with that don't give a fuss/fuck brush, it was Saha who didn't make a fuss when bundled into the net for a nailed on pen, and that, without any shadow of a doubt, is a sympton and symbol of a lazy fucking past-it piece of crap who should never ever pull on an Everton shirt again, but sadly he will.
Wayne Smyth
108 Posted 14/01/2012 at 21:06:19
I thought we did well for large parts of the game. We had a lot of possession and actually created some stuff.

Gibson was impressive. He reminds me a bit of Joe Parkinson and appears to be a solid all-round midfielder who can pass, tackle, has mobility and appears comfortable on the ball. Its so good to see us have two really solid central midfield players so that we dont have to play 3 central midfielders or expect fellaini to cover 2 positions. A really good signing for what we paid for him I think and I'd like to see how he is after a run of 4 or 5 games to get his sharpness.

Fellaini continues to get stick from some fans, but I honestly dont understand why. As far as I can see he does a cracking job as a defensive central midfielder, breaking up opposition attacks, trapping the ball and passing it along the deck. He played a number of very good forward passes today which I remember.

My patience with Cahill is gone I'm afraid, he always tries, but he provides nothing of note going forward and hasn't done for a long while. He was played supporting Saha today, but on many occasions I watched Saha completely isolated.

Now that we've got 2 solid and proper central midfielders, we need to dispense with cahill and just go with 2 up front and get some goals. I'd like to see Vellios or McAleny get a run, or perhaps even play drenthe up there. I reckon he'd do a job for us with his pace and finishing ability....and if he's not in midfield, he can't be a liability.
Jon Cox
109 Posted 14/01/2012 at 21:07:08
Paul, didn't knowe what Cahills position was also. Did he start in a 4-4-2 or a 4-5-1.

Hey, like we know it's irelevant anyway. We all have to know when certain players are finished and have outlived their sell by date. If not then where's Sheedy?

I feel we're in transition but Moyes cant fathom it out. He cant work out the difference between the yoof or the elders.

Well tough shit Moyes because on £65k a week you should, and this is all at this point have to do.

Over the last couple of seasons we are seeing how good you really are. We are not that enamoured with the way you are working things out.

Forget that wanker Round, and come on here to see where the answer lies. I mean lets face it, we cant do any worse than you. Oh and by the way, we wont have any favourites!
Wayne Smyth
110 Posted 14/01/2012 at 21:19:50
...almost forgot, other positive that came out of today was Duffy who didn't look out of place at all. Nice to see him get some game time and hopefully he'll be like a new signing.
Dave Wilson
112 Posted 14/01/2012 at 21:30:24
Paul #993 I could accept that, if there was murder about it, but there isnt.

Can you imagine if that was the Shite ? Gerrard would have got him sent off as well
Jon Cox
113 Posted 14/01/2012 at 21:34:34
Dave Wilson, the penalty thing was one minute. There are 89 mins left,

And i'm happy at 1000
Paul Ferry
114 Posted 14/01/2012 at 21:38:17
true Dave
Jon Cox
115 Posted 14/01/2012 at 21:38:13
And dont forget 1001 cleans your carpets brilliant!!
Tony Rutherford
116 Posted 14/01/2012 at 21:31:57
Why do people constantly ask for Bily to get another chance? He shouldn't wear the shirt again. I know it's been tough for him but he really doesn't have the capacity to be a player in the Premier League. Don't get me wrong; there's others that need to get their finger out, but Bily needs a fresh start somewhere else. Hopefully we'll get some money him!!!
Jon Cox
117 Posted 14/01/2012 at 21:53:19
Sector one, Bily non compliant, eject.
Adam Payne
118 Posted 14/01/2012 at 21:23:59
All this" who else would want the job" nonsense......I will do it for 65k a week!!!

Come on, no expectations, comfortable mid table position easily achievable. "Threadbare squad".....how many strikers do we have on the books and they are all shit!!! why is that? FFS.
Eddy Bernard
119 Posted 14/01/2012 at 21:26:18
Another point towards safety, not much else you can say really.
Dick Fearon
120 Posted 14/01/2012 at 21:36:09
Saha missed a cert,so did Cahill and Fellaini which was a big improvement over recent games.
If only Vic was not glued to the ground when the ball is in the air he would be a good striker.
From a goal scoring perspective my cat could not be worse than Saha.
Adam Payne
121 Posted 14/01/2012 at 22:10:40
Damn Eddy, I always wanted to be 007
Tony Doran
122 Posted 14/01/2012 at 22:10:50
Show's how some of the players can't be arsed, Saha didn't even appeal for a blatant penalty.
Paul Ferry
123 Posted 14/01/2012 at 21:38:17
true Dave
Chris Wright
124 Posted 14/01/2012 at 23:20:12
Got told at the match today Sol Campbell having medical at Finch Farm signing tomorrow. Anyone heard anything? I really hope it's not true.
Tom Bowers
125 Posted 14/01/2012 at 23:26:36
We have to sell someone soon to get someone else in. I think things will happen before the window closes.
What's happened to Velios and why is idiot Moyes still persisting with Cahill?
Saha is way too slow now and we look awful in the final third. Thank heavens for landin' Landon again.
Steve Abraham
126 Posted 14/01/2012 at 23:15:05
I've heard it said that there is a fine line between success and failure, Saha's header forced a great save from Given and but for a blatent foul Saha surely would have got his head on the cross from Landon. Other good chances weren't converted. I thought eplayed ok today. i don't see all the negative stuff spouted helps at all. Evertonians who slag Fellaini amaze me. Best player we have by far, Baines included.
A decent result today against a team at our level but with a lot less injury problems to first choce players.
Stu Gore
127 Posted 14/01/2012 at 23:36:58
MOTD highlights showed us in a good light to be fair. Should have had a pen. Good saves from Given. Great pass from Donavan for the goal but the run and finish is the bit that makes a pass great so nice one Vic too. We are an average side at the moment and a point away from Home is a good point. Home form needs to improve and we will rise up the league. Lots of dross this year. We should be slightly less drossy then the majority by the end.
Colin Malone
128 Posted 15/01/2012 at 00:07:02
First of all, I see a player with blue blood, who loves EFC. Then I see a player who would run through a brick wall when playing for EFC.

I see a player when in the right position, with the right players around him (ie Arteta, Pienaar Osman and Carsley (not defenders playing in midfield) will ghost in and score goals.

I can see why Mark Hughes is ready to buy him. Timmy, you're up there with the Peter Reids and Joe Royles who would die for the club.

Michael Kenrick
129 Posted 15/01/2012 at 00:07:44
Colin, what's the point? Living the past, living on memories.

There are no brick walls on the field... just gaping goals he can no longer score.

You can't keep justifying a place in the side for guy who gave his all for his country and, as a result, has had little or nothing left in the tank to give us, other than meaningless platitudes.

Over a YEAR since he last scored. What more do you need to know?
Lori Fekete
130 Posted 15/01/2012 at 00:16:57
'the definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over, and expecting different results'
-Albert Einstein

Saha and Cahill to start against Blackburn
Andy Crooks
131 Posted 15/01/2012 at 00:27:17
Colin,I see a player who's best days are behind him. I see a player whom a ruthless manager would have shipped out some time ago. Part of being a great manager is spotting a player very slightly past his best and selling him at an extortionate fee. If our situation was better of the pitch I'd have advocated making Tim Cahill an Evertonian for life and giving him a new role;impact sub and youth team mentor.
Martin Faulkner
132 Posted 15/01/2012 at 00:26:12
Cahill unfortunately put country before club last year and fucked off to the the Mickey mouse Asian cup to be kicked the shit out of by no mark players when he was on form for us. Given the handsome pay he receives from EFC he should have thought twice about playing through 3 different injuries just to play in the final. While he's been a great player and ambassador for the club over the years I just can't forgive him for that, who paid for the fuckin ferrari outside his door? He needs a fresh start either going to QPR if their interest is genuine or back to the A-league (which is about the level his performances have sunk to).
Roman Sidey
133 Posted 15/01/2012 at 00:32:59
Dave Wilson, could not agree more, re: the stats, and actually, most things you've said on this thread.

If ever there was a better example of stats not giving the whole story than this game, I'd love to see it. Ok, they had more shots. Most of those shots were from outside the box. The fact is, anyone who watched this game, on tele or at the stadium, knows that we should have won. Gibson's ball to Cahill in the first half, take not Phil Jagielka, was fantastic, and Cahill would have scored that 12 months ago. Saha probably could have done better with the header that Given saved, but, once again, out of form players do that sort of thing.

Just watched Anichebe's interview on the official site. I am turning on this lad. He is a lot more mature, professional, and wants to win. He had more positivity in that two minute interview than Moyes has had in 18 months.

Additionally, Drenthe's copping a bashing for his performance. Isn't it strange that the game where he actually abides by the manager's rules and tracks back, and actually did well in defence, he has his poorest game going forward? Fucking hell, David Moyes. Let the boy be himself and do what he does best.

If Fellaini plays next week, I think the Moyes favouritism will be at its most prevalent.
Peter Barry
134 Posted 15/01/2012 at 02:46:24
Just a thought a solution to Dour Daveys Dire Dross.

"BOLD BRENDAN RODGERS SHOWS HOW FOOTBALL SHOULD BE PLAYED

Brendan Rodgers has made Swansea an attractive outfit this season

Sunday January 15,2012
By Jim Holden

HE?S a young and bold football manager. He has a direct hotline to his mentor, Jose Mourinho. He speaks fluent Spanish, and his team play some of the most beautiful football in the Premier League."
Stephen Leary
135 Posted 15/01/2012 at 03:58:15
Gibson played okay today... some good passes and a lot better than Screech played. We knew what type of game we would be in for and we did the job well. We tried to win the game and we looked more like doing so in the last 15 mins.
Peter Barry
136 Posted 15/01/2012 at 04:53:53
Lori Fekete you will get very short odds on that bet.
John Bourne
137 Posted 15/01/2012 at 04:52:19
Apologies Gentlemen but I have to get this off my chest.
Tim Cahill is castigated for not having scored for 12 months, a fair point you might say, but he has never in my eyes been classed as a striker, he just happened to produce the goods when our lamentable so called strikers failed to hit the back of the net.

So we propose to sell Cahill and keep Fellaini?
Tell me what has Fellaini done for us since he arrived?, check his movement off the ball, it is truly shocking.
The only reason Fellaini re-signed in my opinion is that there was no other club daft enough to pay for his non existent services.

Hail to the Thief.
Steve Brown
138 Posted 15/01/2012 at 05:21:28
Sell Billy and beg, borrow and steal to get the funds to make an offer for Donavon. Keep Gibson in central midfield as he can actually pass the ball and get a striker on loan, from the Championship if needs be.

We cannot continue for one game more with Cahill and Saha as our "strikeforce". Send them both on their way at the end of the season with our thanks, along with Neville.

By the way, not many people here commenting on what a good goal it was we scored. Brilliant run by LD and well taken by Victor. The centre-halves had good games as well, particularly young Duffy.

Rodwell, Barkley, Velios, Duffy, Duffy (24 years old), Mcaleny..we actually have the some good players here and since the older players haven't done it all season can anyone give me one good reason why the majority of these lads shouldn't play when tey are back from injury.
Tony J Williams
139 Posted 15/01/2012 at 09:26:11
You have to laugh when you read some posts on here.

Villa were there for the taking were they? Why? Based on our form and now injury list, why should our mediocre team be beating them?
Roman Sidey
140 Posted 15/01/2012 at 10:58:02
No, Tony, because they were absolutely shit. Have been shit all year, and even their supporters hate them at the moment. I respect your commitment enough to assume you watched the game. If that's the case, do you really believe that they weren't there to be beaten?
Thomas Windsor
141 Posted 15/01/2012 at 10:55:04
Why play Saha and Cahill when they are not playing well???

Let Vellios and Anichibe start against Blackburn on Saturday... if it's not working, change it, but at least start with them.
James Newcombe
142 Posted 15/01/2012 at 11:06:42
Well in Victor! His goal ratio would make Louis Saha weep. Well it would if he was bothered! If only he could stay fit.
Anto Byrne
143 Posted 15/01/2012 at 00:56:32
We want Tim at the Glory (Perth); he would love it and still be a legend. For EFC, everyday his star grows dim. He needs a new start elsewhere.
Terry McLavey
144 Posted 15/01/2012 at 11:50:13
Martin #23 I doubt the Aussies will even consider Cahill again based on what we have had to put up with! But you're right, the lifestyle they lead is unbelieveable in comparison to the "work" they do. I doubt Saha would be picked in Div 1 judging on his performances for us... when will this farce end, picking him & Cahill EVERY WEEK FFS!!!!!!

On a positive note, Landon did some good work but sticks out like a sore thumb amongst the dross! We shouldn't rely on players coming to rescue us on loan! Did anyone use "drongo" in the Moyes D's?
Terry McLavey
145 Posted 15/01/2012 at 11:59:58
Forgot to mention when I watched to Tamworth "game", the editing was such that several (very short) clips on the trot started with Phil Neville having the ball and were accompanied by booing. (I do presume it was the Tamworth fans?!) It's amazing what I find to entertain myself with when watching a team I have supported since I was 7! Now it's come to this!!!
Lee Baines
146 Posted 15/01/2012 at 12:22:08
Well, just more proof (if ever there was more needed) that we're in desperate need of a striker! Saha could/should have had a brace at least!

Thought Felli had a shocker and Gibson was quiet, though it will take time for him to bed in.

Vic's goal was well taken, and I reckon we created more chances in this game through Donovan, Baines and our Royston, than we have done in the past five or six games put together! If only we had someone to stick those chances away!!
Jack Wilkinson
147 Posted 15/01/2012 at 12:11:54
Couldn't watch the game but caught up on the highlights so I'm not really sure how we played in general, but the goal we scored should get much more credit. It was beautiful! I can't remember the last time we scored a goal of that class.
Bobby Thomas
148 Posted 15/01/2012 at 12:08:21
Roman (063): No, Tony, because they were absolutely shit. Have been shit all year, and even their supporters hate them at the moment.

Sounds quite like us that!!

Many similarities between the two clubs at the minute, attendances down as fans become disillusioned with their club and the Premier League itself, both squads being ran down as costs are squeezed, American loanees to bolster the squad.

Villa are poor, just like ourselves. We will both finish mid-table. You think teams don't turn up at Goodison fancying their chances? Especially as our home form is shocking. We seem more suited to playing away from home at the minute, where the onus isn't on us to attack and the lack of ideas is highlighted.

Perspective needed I think. I thought we were reasonable yesterday. With the level of injuries, loans and a new signing playing you can't just click your fingers and get a side playing with fluency and rythm (if only!).

We have been very poor this season and it will continue to be up and down, the club is in a state of flux. Donovan is only gonna be here for 5 minutes and we will undoubtedly miss him, so I would prepare for more of the same to be honest.

We are average with a capital A. After what's gone on at the club, how can anyone expect us to be anything else? I want this season done, finish mid-table and lets get on with the big task of re-shaping the squad in the summer.
Richard O'Shea
149 Posted 15/01/2012 at 12:56:01
I think the goal yesterday by Vic was very unlike Everton, throw out Howard to Donovan ? not the usual big punt up the field... and Donovan on a dribble, passed to Vic and the ball is then in the net!

It reminded me of Man Utd when they were good at fast counter-attacking football, I think we should do more of it as with Donovan and Royston, we have a bit more pace in the side now.
John Malone
150 Posted 15/01/2012 at 12:53:30
Moyes will not let Cahill go unless the money is too good. Cahill, for all his lack of footballing ability, is the epitome/core of the much talked about 'great team spirit'; if you lose him, you're not just losing a grafter on the pitch, you're losing a big character in the dressing room.

Granted Cahill has not hit the net and has not been holding the ball up, winning header's up front, but let's not forget he is not a centre-forward. Cahill is best when he is not the attacking focus, his game was about arriving late and stealing a yard. He is another Moyes player asked to play out of position. Moyes has got to replace that type of character before he let's him go.

On the other hand, Saha is a different animal altogether: he has so much ability but has totally lost the desire. There was no way Hutton's pull should've stopped him reaching that header and if it did he should've jumped up enraged and appealed to the ref ? there was no reaction! Say no more.
Jim Knightley
151 Posted 15/01/2012 at 13:24:52
We were good today... Again unlucky against Villa and with Anichebe coming back, at least we have a striker with experience to challenge the seemingly semi retired Saha.

Kenrick, are (or were) you not an editor on this site? Your lack of objectivity is hilarious and embarrassing. Well done, we all know you hate Moyes. It's interesting that Moyes brings Donovan in, Dononvan does well, but he only does well in spite of Moyes? If you do not like the manager, at least give credit where credit is due. He is a good signing and Gibson will be a good signing because he is good on the ball. We have all been treated to too much dire football this season, but football nonetheless which sees us positioned 10th in the Premier League, which given our squad size and spending, is imo, beyond expectation.

Too much boring football, but Moyes has with the very little funds available, brought in Drenthe, Donovan, Straq and Gibson in the last two windows (after having to sell creative players). Seems to me like a manager who would like to play better football and buy attacking players, but lacks the money?
Stephen Kenny
152 Posted 15/01/2012 at 13:44:50
That through ball from Donovan was the single best set up I've seen from one of our players in a long, long time.
Andrew Cunningham
153 Posted 15/01/2012 at 13:49:03
Will Anichebe be going to the African Nations Cup?
Sam Hoare
154 Posted 15/01/2012 at 14:11:06
Interesting that we think Villa were there for the taking. This is the first line from a Villa fansite:

Everton with a makeshift defence were there for the taking.

I reckon a point was better for us than for them.
Andrew Cunningham
155 Posted 15/01/2012 at 13:49:03
Will Anichebe be going to the african nations cup?
Alex Willett
156 Posted 15/01/2012 at 14:29:26
Nigeria are not in the African Nations cup, I think they are banned or something.
Michael Summers
157 Posted 15/01/2012 at 14:17:39
It felt like we dropped two points yesterday. Villa are a poor side, they were there for the taking. Saha is just a waste of space, the only good things to come out the game were Gibson (good on the ball), Donovan (a great pass for the goal, also his workrate was outstanding) and young Duffy. As for Drenthe, he just give the ball away all the time. He needs to look up, the rest need to take a look at Donovan's workrate.
Matt Garen
158 Posted 15/01/2012 at 15:22:27
Anyone heard the Sol Campbell to Everton rumour? Fucking Jesus Mary and Joseph
Paul Thompson
159 Posted 15/01/2012 at 16:07:36
Let's not encourage wasted vitriol on this one. Another 'spotted at Finch Farm' rumour. Doing his coaching badge apparently.
Tony Doran
160 Posted 15/01/2012 at 16:56:43
Please keep neville out of midfield. He panicks and gives the ball away and is not very good at togger.
Russ Quinlan
161 Posted 15/01/2012 at 17:31:38
Just watching Swansea, my god they might not have any 'big' name players but their effort is outstanding. Just shows what can be achieved with players who play with pace and no fear. We have supposedly better players but when I watch us, its so fucking slow and predictable.

We HAVE the players, why doesn't the manager believe in them, the only time we showed pace was when Donovan broke forward and played in Vic and look what happened.

Some of our lot look like they are out for a days stroll in Stanley Park FFS
Robbie Muldoon
162 Posted 15/01/2012 at 18:22:59
Brendan Rogers and Total Football would be welcome at Goodison.
Denis Richardson
163 Posted 15/01/2012 at 17:56:55
Andrew - Nigeria didn't qualify, so no, he's not going to the ANC.
Ian Edwards
164 Posted 15/01/2012 at 18:55:22
Robbie

I agree. Watching Swansea (a newly promoted side) playing great football was a joy. Compare that with the dour grinding out, negative sack of shite that Dreary serves up. Oh yes I forgot.... Dear David has no money to spend. The Swansea team must have cost at least the equivalent of Bilyaletdinov.
Steve Barr
165 Posted 15/01/2012 at 19:30:30
I fully agree with posts #126 and #121, and have alluded to these sentiments in a number of previous posts.

We should not be afraid of replacing Moyes. He's had more than enough time at the helm to win something. At the very least, we Evertonians expect a manager to deliver "good football' win or lose.

The likes of Swansea, Norwich and others prove that setting up a side to play good football has nothing to do with finances.

I accept ultimately finances will dictate whether or not you actually win the league though.

However, I'm resigned to the fact that winning the league is beyond us... but I want to watch my team play good, entertaining football. If Moyes can't deliver that then he has to be replaced.
Thomas Windsor
166 Posted 15/01/2012 at 19:41:40
Just watched Swansea against Arsenal; could you see this Everton team beating Arsenal 3-2 at home??? ? No neither could I. It's not all about money, it's about tactics and belief, which the manager gets paid for ? in Moyes's case, very highly.
Barry Rathbone
167 Posted 15/01/2012 at 19:28:33
Hopefully the trend of recent seasons promoted teams playing football and not capitulating before a ball is kicked will see off anti football managers like Moyes.

An absolute blight on football driving fans away from the game, watching Swansea for the second time today made me shudder at the comparison with Everton and all the bogus excuses.

When you saw Donovan instinctively threading that ball for Anichebe you just wonder if Moyes had got his act together and bought him or equivalent when Arteta, Pienaar were here.

Pie in the sky of course, it couldn't happen with Moyes.
James Martin
168 Posted 15/01/2012 at 19:53:03
Weren't Swansea getting laid into on this site the other week for being the most negative team that have come to Goodison this season? Their away record is also atrocious is it not? When they're getting battered, no-one brings them up yet they get one good win and suddenly Moyes should be doing an apprenticeship under Brendan Rodgers.

These Championship managers claiming to be the heir to Guardiola's passing heritage come and go all the time. Mowbray, Di Matteo, Holloway... I'll bet one of Lambert or Rodgers will drop like a stone in the second half of the season whilst the other one will have classic second season syndrome whilst Everton will probably finish above both of them this season (one of our worst in recent times).

The finest example of taking a team up through the divisions and making it stick in the Premier League is Stoke under Tony Pulis and that unfortunately tells you all you need to know about the pragmatic nature of the Premier League from 6th place downwards.
Steve Barr
169 Posted 15/01/2012 at 21:21:27
James @#132.

Swansea may well have been negative when they played at Goodison. Overall they have played good attacking football, like Norwich and others... and are above us in the league at the moment.

I actually remember watching Everton away at Palace, Charlton, Wimbledon and others in our mid eighties glory days, and was dismayed to witness very negative, poor performances. No team can produce week in week out.. but a positive, upward underlying trend is what we must see and judge.

Everton has been dire all season, with not a single game to cite as being anywhere near entertaining and acceptable.

The point is.. we can all point to failed managers (at least they tried) but that is not a reason to bury ones heads in the sand and presume that there is no alternative to Moyes.

Think back to when we appointed Moyes, the same logic could have applied, that we dare not replace Walter as Moyes has no track record, is just a young upstart, and will surely fail!

Come on, how much more time can we afford Moyes to turn things aound? 10 years, no silverware, declining gates, atrocious football.

I reckon I could do better than that, never mind a qualified coach.

Roman Sidey
170 Posted 15/01/2012 at 21:45:04
James, #132. I'll take that bet. I don't think either of Swansea or Norwich will go down this season. You also claim that Everton will finish above these two teams. Well, with our squad, we fucking should, and it would be unacceptable that Everton finish below two, if any, promoted sides. I'm still trying to figure out how Stoke are ahead of us, and now trying to explain to myself how we find sides like Swansea, Norwich and even fucking Newcastle above us in the league.

"One good win"??? Oh how nice that would be.
Eddy Bernard
171 Posted 15/01/2012 at 23:10:33
Sorry Adam @009 you've either got it or you haven't
Jim Knightley
172 Posted 15/01/2012 at 23:03:34
Why shouldn?t Stoke be above us Roman? How much money have they spent? or Newcastle? I would love to hear a valid reason whilst we have a divine right to be above them.

Norwich and Swansea are playing incredible. They are breath of fresh air and deserve the highest of praise. But Norwich will not last in this league playing as they are. They will fall away in the same fashion Reading fell away. They are playing great right now with a superb energy, but teams will realise their weakness', confidence will drop, and so will Norwich(I expect they will be in the bottom 5 next season).

Swansea are more problematic. God knows how they are in this league, let alone playing as they are at the moment. To dominate possession like they do at home, is practically unheard of, save for the very very best of teams. But for them, whilst their philosophy is superb (better's than Norwich imo), I too think they will fall away. (Remember how Reading and Hull dazzled and then dropped off. There are plenty other examples too)

Norwich and Swansea are overachieving. But it is extremely naive to look at those two, and claim they should be our design. The test will come when they lose 4/5 games and confidence goes. Many teams at this point in the season are higher than they will ultimately finish. Sense says Fulham and Stoke, hopefully us alongside Sunderland will form the 3/4 teams outside the top 7. If Norwich and Swansea are in the top 10 this time, next season, then a claim for them as archetypes will be applicable. At the moment it is too early, and stinks of a reaction from watching a fantastic Swansea display against one of the top teams in England(Who btw, gave them two goals from extremely poor defending and with regards to the penalty...well, one of the most ridiculous awards I have seen).
Bobby Thomas
173 Posted 15/01/2012 at 23:32:19
Barry(131), you might not like Moyes but you cant just re-write history.

Donovan was mad keen on coming here, Moyes wanted to make it happen and we, in a break with convention, didnt have the cash. If memory serves me correct £8m would have nailed him? Remember reading an article where Moyes was asked about it and his answer was, "Dont you think ive asked my chairman to make it happen?!"

Absolute kick in the bollocks, that mid: Piennar, Arteta, Fellaini, Donovan, was perfectly balanced. His addition re-invigorated a squad that was just starting to go stale through a lack of necessary additions in key areas if we were to have a real go at the top 4. A wide right midfield player, right back and probably another striker.

The failure to sign him sealed our stagnation and its been downhill since.

Regarding midfielders, you say an equivalent. I have a problem with Moyes signing Billy when he was the polar opposite of what was required. It became pretty obvious soon after he arrived that he was another one paced, ball playing mid, similar to Piennar/Arteta/Ossie, and not the dynamic player required, which is why Donovan did/does work so well.

But lets have it right. If the cash was there Donovan was in.
Roman Sidey
174 Posted 16/01/2012 at 00:09:10
Jim, Stoke have spent a shit load less than us, and they wouldn't have as many players on such high wages as us. I will not cave though, as I've been pretty staunch on my stance that the money is not the only reason teams do well. I accept that Stoke have been improving, but the reaction some fans gave when they beat us at home I can not accept. They do not have a better squad than us, therefore, should not be doing better than us.

Newcastle got relegated three years ago, and now it's like they never left the top half of the table. Again, their squad is not better than ours in any sense of the imagination.

I'm haven't advocated for getting Rodgers or Lambert in as our manager (though I do want to see Moyes fucked off ASAP), but if they can do this now with the players they have, I am going to assume that they could do it for a longer period of time with a squad as decent as ours.

Do not kid yourselves that we don't have a good squad of players. Jaded as they are, they are still a talented bunch of footballers.
Thomas Williams
175 Posted 16/01/2012 at 00:36:02
Roman your comment that Stoke spent a lot less than us is nonsense.
2006-2011 Stoke spent 72.7M on players compared to us 64.7.
SToke outgoings in same period is 16.5M compared to our outgoings of 63.7M
Net outlay Stoke 56.2M ours 1M.
Yes those figures are for Stoke not sky 6 and we have a net spend of 55M less over 5 years on Stoke.
Paul Ferry
176 Posted 16/01/2012 at 01:50:10
Total bullshit, Roman, mate ? Stoke have not spent a shit load less than us ? it's 2012, how much have Stoke spent on incoming in say the last 24 months compared with Everton? Do the counting before you spout crap.
Paul Ward
177 Posted 16/01/2012 at 02:04:02
When is the penny going to drop. Injuries and or small squad does not matter with Moyes he can only play one way, and that is negatively. His mindless defensive tactics dictate whatever personell is available. Moyes plan, at kick off is defence and possession and hope at the 80th minute it is still nil nil. Then chuck someone like Vellios on. Just name one game this season when we have been entertained.
Roman Sidey
178 Posted 16/01/2012 at 10:34:01
That is shocking news to me, and I do withdraw it. I still stand by my argument that our players are better than theirs - almost player for player - and that we should be above them.
Richard Styles
179 Posted 16/01/2012 at 11:24:12
Matt Garen...post 102...Brilliant mate...that has got me off to a good start and brightened up my day... regaring Mr. Streets Post... Maybe we'd like Steve Keane he'll be available soon, or Steve Bruce, or Bruce Lee or.....which manager of quality would come near a club that has no cash and a threadbare squad..........answers on a postcard please!

Well what can I say except that argument is really getting old now.. When Moyes Joined us he came from Preston who at the time where doing well in the Wankership! He wasnt a Premier League Manager but he did well the first 5 years...after that " I have got a 5 year Plan" speech everything has gone down hill, apparently he is the 3rd best paid manager in all divisions 65k a week...

Now what makes you first of all think that based on Moyes`s current form as a manager that anyone other than the Big 5 would pay him anywhere near those wages? and second why any other manager with Premier league experience couldn't do a better job? even if we are broke! we still have players who can do things on the pitch, and my thinking is that Moyes looks tired, pissed off every time he does an interview and cant be bothered because he thinks he is fighting a losing battle....

He can no longer motivate players..That rubs off on your players, if you are negative then they will be the same, one negative person can bring down a whole team... How many times have we seen the change of a manager and suddenly the same team that played shit week after week for months is suddenly winning games 4 or 5 in a row.....You can argue the same about new managers coming in and teams going down, But that for me is usually too little to late...should have been sacked by xmass...

He keeps mentioning its hard to find players in the January window, Yet there are players from other divisions sitting on the bench out of contract and just bursting to prove a point, if we have no funds that fine, go and get as many free players that you think can play your system! Not many can, give them a pay a you play deal for 6 months, I know if I wanted first team football I would take it...

Let me just finish like this Davey Jones, Peter Read, David Wear, Walter Smith,Joe Royal in fact any ex-Everton Player Big Duncan when he gets his badges all could do a better team selection than Moyes based on what he has....And I bet a few would really be motivated after getting a backlash from Big Duncan at half Time.... Can you imagine Saha telling him he didnt score because someone pushed Him! He would new New Undies!!!!!

Stop the who would we get thing its getting really old, There should be a link on the EVERTON site where the fans can pick the team, maybe he would get the massage after the first 3 postings... Drop the shite... and Play anyone but them...
Thomas Windsor
181 Posted 16/01/2012 at 13:56:51
Roman, as you say, almost player for player you say we are better than Stoke, which I agree with... Then why are we not above them?

The answer is simple: Moyes has become a negative manager.

How many good games have we seen this season? I can't think of any.
Paul Ferry
182 Posted 16/01/2012 at 14:36:59
nice reply Roman mate; like it
Bobby Thomas
183 Posted 16/01/2012 at 18:27:04
Roman. Player for player our squad is better than Stokes.

Right, lets take off the blue tinted specs and have a look at it in reality, bearing in mind the previous bollocks you have been spouting.

In reality theres not much, as the table would suggest, between us. We both have quality where the other doesnt.

Our squad is very, very thin, all over the pitch apart from centre back and centre mid. The higher up the pitch we go back to front, theres less depth and less quality.

Nobody on here can agree whos good at Everton or not, never mind Stoke.

In short we are deepish on quality at goalkeeper centre half and in centre mid, although since the best 2 attacking mids went i think the mix is wrong.

We have one quality full back, the one player left who could play for anyone. Stoke are ok for keepers and also deep at centre half. In the main though Stokes full backs and central midfielders are average, hard working, high energy, personified by Palacios(good player) and Whitehead, who to be fair works his bollocks off for them.

In other areas of the pitch im afraid we have, in the main, fuck all. Our left mid has gone. Coleman, a 60k kid thrown in the Prem coping admirably but understandably having ups and downs. He's most likely a full back anyway. Ossie is a hard working, play anywhere, above average squad man. Do we have any players left to name? Neville? Billy? Donovans on loan. Gueye?! Jesus.......

Etherington, for me a very underrated footballer, would stroll in our side and is exactly the kind of dynamic player we need. Fantastic signing by Pulis. He regularly provides the quality that is otherwise lacking. Pennant has been an in and out player his whole career but when on can provide moments. I would take him above Billy as he can actually fucking play in this division.

Up top. After the leathering Cahill and Saha have received on here lately, and im guilty as charged on Saha(finished!!), any of Stokes strikers would walk into our side and i include Cameron Jerome.

Stoke are on the up, have been adding to the squad and have a better balanced side. We probably have more quality in certain areas, but the squad is unbalanced. We also both have our plain average, hard working pro's. And we both have some shite. We can see the difference Donovan makes. Pulis has much more depth and options, especially wide and up top. If we could add Stokes strikers and wide players we would finish comfortably above them. Same for them and our centre mids/poss centre halves and obviously, full back. We will finish around the same positions, but Stoke have depth and firepower.

If you asked any Villa, Stoke or Everton fan whos squad was better, theyd all say their own, and the other was shite. Were all lacking in areas and are the epitome of mid table teams.
Roman Sidey
184 Posted 16/01/2012 at 22:51:31
Bobby, the last paragraph was a good one. Not too sure about the rest. While they're a well balanced squad, they are made up of journeymen and has-beens.

Thomas Windsor applied the thought that I was trying to convey without saying it. The difference is the manager. Pulis plays to his players' strengths, and has done since they were promoted to the Premier League. Moyes makes the players play to his weaknesses, and has done since he got a job in the Premier League.
Bobby Thomas
185 Posted 16/01/2012 at 23:16:04
Roman you are just blatantly ignoring the points ive made. Talk to the hand and all that.......

You claim what i have written is dubious and then immediately concur Stoke are a well balanced side!?!

You make no acknowledgment of the weaknesses in our squad, or the areas of strength in Stokes. You seem to live in some dream world where the smallest squad in the Prem, which is also in the process of being ran down btw, is bursting with options to take us up the league.

So enlighten me. And please do so.

If my assessment is so wrong,, where is it that we are actually strong? What are these options? Allow me to suggest some.

Which of our loanees? The one here for 2 months or the one who is constantly picking up niggling injuries? Is it our right mid playing, 60k converted right back(injured but performs admirably)? Is it our made of glass, past it striker? Our raw, naive Greek kid who to me doesnt look ready to do 90 mins? The raw French kid who looks, at the minute, as if he might not be Prem material? Or the striker who is just back from a shitload of injuries, isnt match fit and virtually everyone on this site hates? Or Cahill, who has been affected by selflessy, and by necessity, playing injured as the squad is so small? As have Osman and The Jag. Fucked. Playing injured as the squad is tiny in modern football terms.

In your dreamworld Stoke are made up exclusively of "journeymen and has beens". They're not. They have some, as, guess what, so do we. They also have some talented players who would strolll in our current team and squad. You appear to not like it cos they play for Stoke, or it doesnt suit your anti Moyes agenda.

Regarding your points on Moyes, I am happy to discuss it. I am on record a few months ago on this site as saying the last 2 years havent been his best, for example. I think he drove the club forward powerfully before that.

But your failure to even acknowledge the laughable lack of options or cover across virtually the entire first team squad, is absurd.
Mark Riding
186 Posted 17/01/2012 at 01:05:58
Bobby... so to sum it up.. Kenwright out then ?
Bobby Thomas
187 Posted 17/01/2012 at 01:09:19
You could say that!!

Asap.

The club really has been destroyed. But theres the problem, its virtually worthless....who is gonna pay for it, and will these pricks pulling Kenwrights strings move on the price? Unanswerable questions i know but.....i struggle to see a way out these days and we are running out of time. Ownership issue, aging players, very little coming through, Goodisons like a ticking bomb on our Prem future, possibly missed the boat on the Prem being attractive to new owners.....oh fuck it im rolling a spliff.....
Roman Sidey
188 Posted 17/01/2012 at 02:34:03
Bobby, if we are so short on cover across the board, it's only because Moyes has constantly selected players out of position rather than giving the "cover" players a chance.

Like you, I've been very critical of both the manager and team. I think some of our players are either past it, or being played out of form. Still, comparing the two lists of players, Moyes has better players to select from than Pulis does. That is my opinion, and probably that of a lot of other Evertonians, and not just ignorance in reading your posts.
Pete Case
189 Posted 17/01/2012 at 07:53:43
About Donovan on the Break:
In Moyes system he wants his wingers to track back on Defense and press the opposing fullback if he's not double teaming the opposing winger. The upshot is that there are very few breakaway plays/counter attacks...which eliminates Donovan's best asset, his ability to press unorganized defenses with speed and passing just like we saw this last week. Everton would do well to give Landon far more latitude.

Here are some examples that parallel the sole score from this last weekend.

1. US v Algeria 2010 WC.
This is the exact play we saw this weekend. Howard is always looking for Donovan in transition and Donovan usually has the space to exploit it (except at Everton) http://is.gd/1yy3pG (Reverse Angle Shows Howard Pass Clearly); http://is.gd/FVq8Zd (The TV angle missed the Howard Pass)


2. AGain in this clip Donovan is lingering a few yards above the top of the Box against Brazil anticipating a Brazilian turnover...and when the turnover comes, Donovan is on his horse shredding Brazil. http://is.gd/7SGs1r

I am convinced that David Moyes has no strategic sense of how to utilize Donovan's speed, something even the dullest US Coaches are able to tap into without a great deal of fuss.
Jim Knightley
190 Posted 17/01/2012 at 12:09:35
Roman...re. your stoke comment, as already remarked by others, is absolutely incorrect. Stoke have consistently outspent us, adding to their squad whilst we have dminished ours, most spectactly with the completely over the top purchase of Crouch (who will be on very high wages fyi).

Newcastle's team, is incorrectly undervalued. They went down, when they should never have gone down, but they had some very decent players and have added many more. Cabaye and Tiote have been brought in, two players of pedigree, esp Cabaye, who could play in most teams in this league. On top of that, they have Ben Arfa, who when back in fitness and in the team, is an extremely valuable player(A player who could replace the Arteta of old for us). Not to mention the inclusion of Demba Ba, who is playing incredibly (and in a world of more everton money, we could have had). On top of that are players like Santon (5mil) who have been brought in, and Gosling stolen from us, who improve their squad. I think the problem here is the constant overating of our players. If we had the team of three seasons ago, we may be better, than the Stoke's and Newcastle's but we don't. Cahill and Saha are older and less effective (and Saha will not be again). We have lost the likes of Pienaar and Arteta, two of our very best players, as well as weakened the bench with players like the Yak sold because of financial difficulties. Try looking at our squad impartially before asserting with assurance that we should finish above the likes of Stoke and Newcastle.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads