Vellios presses claims with Reserves treble

, 16 January, 108comments  |  Jump to most recent
First-half hat-trick will hopefully catch Moyes's eye
Apostolos Vellios, seemingly frozen out of first-team action since early December has done his claims for greater involvement a power of good with a first-half hat-trick against Blackburn for the Reserves this evening. The Blues' second string ran out 4-2 winners after Jose Baxter tacked on a fourth after Vellios had had another disallowed.

Despite not seeing any action beyond a six-minute cameo at Sunderland on Boxing Day the Greek teenager remains Everton's highest-scoring striker with three goals — and only Leighton Baines has more goals in the team with four.

It is Denis Stracqualursi who has still to find the net despite increasing playing time, who has been getting the nod as a starter or the go-to attacking substitute in recent weeks, though, leaving Vellios either out of the squad altogether or forced to watch as an unused sub.

Quotes or other material sourced from Everton FC



Reader Comments (108)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Marc Williams
1 Posted 16/01/2012 at 20:19:38
Nah...not enough tracking back for the gaffers liking !
Al Reddish
2 Posted 16/01/2012 at 20:32:31
Maybe dropping him has done the trick!
Dave Richman
3 Posted 16/01/2012 at 20:30:51
Well that's him buggered!!!! His punishment for scoring in the first team was banishment to the reserves, so Christ knows what will happen to him now?
Gavin Ramejkis
4 Posted 16/01/2012 at 20:36:50
The third one was a great lob over the keeper
Stephen Kenny
5 Posted 16/01/2012 at 20:38:16
He knows where the goal is!!!

What he can't do is lead the line alone. Moyes has got a frustrating habit of bringing people down a peg or two and IThink he was (unintentionally) set up to fail when he started.

Pace, movement and an eye for goal are what were missing badly, put Victor up with him and you can add power.

Perhaps neither of them are top quality but both are better than what were being offered at the moment.
Martin Graves
6 Posted 16/01/2012 at 20:48:14
i heard he was dropped for his attitude in training, just not doing as much as he should. so moyes played strac over him.

i also heard that moyes believes saha will come good, so on the other hand.....
Gavin Ramejkis
7 Posted 16/01/2012 at 20:49:58
He cant be any worse than playing Saha on his own but like Stephen says he needs a strike partner and not Cahill
Gavin Ramejkis
8 Posted 16/01/2012 at 21:00:49
Martin apparently Beckford was sold because Moyes didn't like his attitude but thanks to that decision we lost a decent goal scorer with a good goal return, I hope Moyes isn't fucking us over with his PE Teacher mentality
Jon Cox
9 Posted 16/01/2012 at 21:05:09
Gav, I know it could be construde as conspiricy but I still think Moyes is after the boot.

It makes complete financial sense.

Do the punditary gig until Celtic or the National side come a calling.

If I'm right then I only wish he'd had that sense on a team management level.
Russ Quinlan
10 Posted 16/01/2012 at 21:09:13
I always thought these EPL Managers on stupid wages knew better than us !!

My god it doesn't take a brain surgeon to see who's scoring and who isn't !

Saha OUT

Vellios IN

Never mind your stupid rules we need a goalscorer, in fact we have one but he never fucking plays !
Bobby Thomas
11 Posted 16/01/2012 at 21:19:34
What the fuck does Vellios think he's doing?

Fine him 2 weeks wages. Its just not on.
Jamie Sweet
12 Posted 16/01/2012 at 20:55:20
I will never understand Moyes' handling of strikers or young players. So if you're a young striker, you're probably completely doomed!

Vellios got a start against Fulham having netted at Stamford Bridge, and admittedly didn't have the best game for the 50 minutes he was on the pitch (although I'm pretty sure he got the assist for Drenthe's wonder strike), but then immediately Moyes says he clearly isn't ready to be starting games etc, and drops him to the bench.

He then sits on the bench and watches Saha stink the place out game after game after game, yet is there any sign of Moyes dropping our aging Frenchman who would struggle to hit a cows arse with a banjo on current form? No.

Must be infuriating. Barkley seems to be getting the same kind of treatment ever since he made one error against Blackburn.

Moyes has no trust what-so-ever in youth. I sometimes wish he would take a leaf out of SAF's book and throw a few more in at the deep end and give them a decent chance to prove their worth.

If and when Vellios gets another start, he'll be thinking that he better score a hatrick in the first half or he'll be dropped to the bench for another half a season.

Young players need to be sent out to play with as little pressure on their shoulders as possible. Moyes loads them up with the weight of the world and then drops them like a brick as soon as they show any small sign of weakness.

Fair enough limiting the young guns to cameo appearances if your seasoned pro's are playing so well it would be impossible to drop them. But Saha in particular, and Cahill to a certain extent have been so bad lately that it has really exposed the shite Moyes is willing to accept from experienced players before he is willing to turn to the younger lads.
Denis Richardson
13 Posted 16/01/2012 at 21:19:41
Dont worry, we've given Vellios a massive confidence boost by bringing in a 30 something player on trial, who is barely cutting it in the German 2nd division. Reverse psycology and all that from the manager...
Derek Thomas
14 Posted 16/01/2012 at 21:25:49
Big Dunc, Yak, Beckford, Vellios, according to Moyes they ALL have or had attitude problems( aka bustups...adds up)I make that 1 pot and 4 kettles
James Stewart
15 Posted 16/01/2012 at 21:46:01
Saha cannot even be called a striker anymore. He is barely a shadow of his former self and needs to be moved on. Insanity to keep starting him
Jamie Barlow
16 Posted 16/01/2012 at 21:54:40
To be fair Derek, the first three have or had attitude problems.
Sam Hoare
17 Posted 16/01/2012 at 22:27:46
Apparently Baxter was very good too, calm on the ball and playmaking. Scored a good goal.

I would very, very much like to see Baxter and Vellios given a chance over Cahill and Saha. There really isn't any way that they could be worse i don't think.

Jon Cox
18 Posted 16/01/2012 at 22:31:25
Jamie, (357)

Accurate to a "T"

So what are the reasons for Dourvey to be on this course of negativity?
Seamus Murphy
19 Posted 16/01/2012 at 22:48:56
Jamie Sweet - Excellent assessment. That's exactly what I see. It's infuriating. But you will still have the usual heads coming on saying Vellios done nothing in the two games he started! It makes no sense. I despair every week when I see the team sheet and Cahill and Saha are up front again.
Don't get me wrong, I love Cahill, he has been a hero but he's just not contributing at the moment, and hasn't been for a while. And as for Saha, he just can't even shoot anymore for whatever reason. But as you say, they continue to get unlimited games up front despite delivering absolutely nothing. One goal between the two of them in over half a season is a damning statistic, one completely lost on Moyes it seems.
Ste Lewis
20 Posted 16/01/2012 at 23:18:11
Velios has lots to learn. He looked like a lost boy upfront when he started against Stoke. He has time on his side and will surely come to the fore in the future. Nothing wrong with making him go back and work on bits of his game out of the spotlight.
Kevin Hudson
21 Posted 16/01/2012 at 23:06:12
Got to take some issue with Jamie Sweet's assessment of Moyes's handling of young players.

Jamie, you state that Moyes "has no trust whatsoever in youth." This I have to disagree with, and would cite Moyes's willingness to deploy Rooney, Osman, Hibbert,Vaughan, Anichebe, Rodwell, Chadwick, Baxter, Mcaleney, Barkley, Vellios, and now Duffy, as evidence to the contrary.

Naturally, I accept that injuries to senior members have forced his hand on occasion, and a number of those players have only made fleeting appearances.

But I do know that Moyes has repeatedly stated that Everton is a club that prides itself on it's youth development, admittedly has to work this way, but that he will continue to give the kids a chance.

I would also take issue with the rather sweeping, and factless, statement that: "Moyes loads them up with the weight of the world."

I would argue that the fans repeatedly screaming for a central role being handed to a 17 year old Barkley, as the ones placing excessive hopes on such callow shoulders. My opinion is that Moyes is responsibly developing the player, precisely to develop a pressure-free environment for him to make it & ultimately thrive in the game.

Moyes sees the players every single day; we see them for two hours per week. I would suggest that his youth record warrants our trust.
Jimmy Sørheim
22 Posted 16/01/2012 at 23:13:48
What about the 20 games Cahill and Saha has started and done nothing with. Vellios gets only 2 starts and he is off to the reserves.
Yet Vellios ALONE has more goals than Cahill and Saha has combined.
David Moyes is a real stand up, fair guy, huh?

You really have got your priorities straight mr. Moyes or should I say Moose.

Tunnel vision or something, he only sees what he wants to.
And that crap about Saha coming good, wait and see, bla bla bla.

David Moyes really knows how to irritate a football fan, I want goals damn it.
Is that too much to ask?
I am not saying Vellios is the answer to all our problems but still, sometimes I think Moyes is a school teacher and not a football manager.
He really seems to be out of it.
Give Vellios the same chance to play 20 games and then you can judge who is the better or worse of them.
It is not exactly rocket science is it?
IQ below 80 mr.Moyes?
Roman Sidey
23 Posted 16/01/2012 at 23:29:36
Kevin, take some context out of your own assessment. Most of those players you mentioned got their start in Moyes first "5 year plan". The rest of those players read as follows:
Rodwell - accepted. Has been given a bloody good shot.
McAleny - has played 20-odd minutes, in games that we were down a goal.
Barkley - Enough said.
Vellios - As soon as he became our top scorer Moyes lost his shit.

People have to stop lauding over Moyes' "achievements" from years ago. So, he brought Rooney through and sold him for a record. What has he done for us lately?
Andrew James
24 Posted 16/01/2012 at 23:42:35
The two games I have seen in which Velios started he was found wanting. He has done alright but he is very young.

Next, Anichebe being chosen ahead of him has been justified because Big Vic now has just as many goals having been on the pitch less time.

Finally, now the Straq has clearly got up to speed fitness wise, why shouldn't he be played first? He's got a lot more experience than Velios because he's older.

And it makes me laugh that people are questioning Moyes and his record with youth when Shane Duffy looks like he could be a regular for years to come.
Roman Sidey
25 Posted 16/01/2012 at 23:59:21
Oh, Kevin, I forgot to mention Duffy.
Duffy - played due to no other options, amidst Moyes moans of not having cover.
Yep, does really well by the youth.
Kevin Hudson
26 Posted 17/01/2012 at 00:01:04
Roman,

If you want to see the un-proven Barkley, Vellios & McAleney frequently deployed, then that's your bag. With Saha & Cahill misfiring it's the seductive, and 'obviously apparent answer,' to many.
,
However, the context that matters to me, is that we have an experienced, professional staff and a manager who spend 30-40 hours a week working with these kids; in context to their readiness, and relative to the resources he has at his disposal, Moyes gives them a shot, albeit at a seemingly geological pace for some.

Make no mistake, I'm eager to see them given plenty more game time too. But I tend to think that Moyes knows what he's doing..
Kevin Hudson
27 Posted 17/01/2012 at 00:16:44
..I already referenced Duffy before you Roman, and acknowledged the reason for his rapid promotion..
Paul Ferry
28 Posted 17/01/2012 at 00:17:09
Kevin Hudson - Duffy is hardly a 'youth'
Paul Ferry
29 Posted 17/01/2012 at 00:18:46
and isn't Ross 18 now???? I just add this as you put a great deal of emphasis on what you know
Paul Ferry
30 Posted 17/01/2012 at 00:20:13
People have to stop lauding over Moyes' "achievements" from years ago. So, he brought Rooney through and sold him for a record. What has he done for us lately?

Spot on Roman Mate; I can't bear the Robbie Savage/Alan Green you can't say something critical of DM because of the first six or seven years

Kevin Hudson
31 Posted 17/01/2012 at 00:19:29
He's still not old enough to drink in this summer's pre-season tour to the US, Paul.

He's also managed just 24 competitive career appearances to date - so he's as 'green,' as they come.
Mark Riding
32 Posted 17/01/2012 at 00:24:06
Paul, your forgetting that keeping Everton FC in the league is a major achievement and Moyes is a miracle worker to anyone who does not have to watch Everton play...
Paul Ferry
33 Posted 17/01/2012 at 00:25:57
Great shout Mark, mate! Like you, Savvy and Greeny have endured and weighed up each minute of each game (without spending sponds), and, therefore, know as much about our current situation on and off the pitch as you do. God bless well paid pundits with a conflict of interest!!!
Kevin Hudson
34 Posted 17/01/2012 at 00:24:23
Re Barkley's age:

So..he's18 years and one month old. What's your point..Is he a veteran now..?

(The fans WERE bombarding ToffeeWeb when he was Seventeen, and I made the same point at that time also..)
Mark Riding
35 Posted 17/01/2012 at 00:33:09
Paul, I was chatting with a bbc pundit today, and I had my Everton shirt on.. even the mention of any anti- moyes talk is laughed off....
Paul Ferry
36 Posted 17/01/2012 at 00:30:12
Drinking age is 21 over here Kev mate: I'm exiled in Chicago. I always enjoy reading what you say on these boards: IMO you're less a Moyessiah apologist and much more a 'let's try and keep a realistic and pragmatic' interpretation in the mix.

Sam Hoare - another one who will defend Moyes but also criticize when appropriate - spot on about Velios and Baxter #376 - and, by the way, why have all the numbers gone weird!!!!!
Adrian Seal
37 Posted 17/01/2012 at 00:24:53
Forgive the positivity here but I think Moyes has realised this season is a frustrating write off and is looking to next season now (barring a morale boosting FA cup adventure of course...we can still dream!).

I think he has a lot of time for Barkley, Vellios, Duffy, etc but doesn't want to 'blood them too early' (Copyright John Motson 1832).



I can't really argue with Moyes' tenure at the club given the circumstances we are/have been in; we have had some recent close shaves with success but we can't consolidate because of our financial situation at present and it's as frustrating for the manager as it is for us!

I await your vitriol but remain firm in my beliefs!
Mark Riding
38 Posted 17/01/2012 at 00:42:37
Adrian, I actually agree.. get to 40-45 points.. and see what happens. I also think its a sad state of affairs if thats all we can go for, but Im a realist too. Why drop Howard in the Chelsea league cup game if thats our best hope of gettiing to Wembley ?
Change is now coming..
Jamie Sweet
39 Posted 16/01/2012 at 23:59:22
Kevin Hudson #388 - you make some fair points, but some of the examples you've had to call upon to support Moyes don't really help with your arguement.

Osman, started his first game for us a few days short of his 23rd birthday. Hardly what I would consider a youth player at that point.

Walter Smith had already given Hibbert his debut before Moyes came along.



You are really clutching at straws if you think Nick Chadwick is a good example of how Moyes develops youth players.

Jose Baxter made his first team debut in 2008 and has hardly been given a fair crack since with only 6 senior appearances.

Conor McAleny given fifteen minutes of football doesn't really add much weight to your assertion that Moyes has a "willingness to deploy" young players.

Shane Duffy made his debut two years ago and hasn't had a sniff of first team football since. If it hadn't been for a number of injuries forcing Moyes' hand, he would still be playing for Scunthorpe United!

Vellios, a couple of starts. Dropped.

Barkley, one mistake. Dropped.

Rooney. Sold far too cheaply before we ever got to see the best of him.

Vaughan - admittedly never fit enough for long enough to be given a fair crack. Sold.

So from your list, we have Rodwell and Anichebe left:

Has Rodwell really fulfilled his potential yet under Moyes? That is debatable.

Moyes, much to the annoyance of many Evertonians, has persisted with Vic and that persistance may pay off, but that remains to be seen. Big Vic could yet become Moyes' greatest success!

I personally think at a club that is increasingly going to have to rely on youth development for the sake of it's future... the above indicates a worryingly poor record from our manager over a ten year period.
Jamie Sweet
40 Posted 16/01/2012 at 23:59:22
Kevin Hudson #388 - you make some fair points, but some of the examples you've had to call upon to support Moyes don't really help with your arguement.

Osman, started his first game for us a few days short of his 23rd birthday. Hardly what I would consider a youth player at that point.

Walter Smith had already given Hibbert his debut before Moyes came along.



You are really clutching at straws if you think Nick Chadwick is a good example of how Moyes develops youth players.

Jose Baxter made his first team debut in 2008 and has hardly been given a fair crack since with only 6 senior appearances.

Conor McAleny given fifteen minutes of football doesn't really add much weight to your assertion that Moyes has a "willingness to deploy" young players.

Shane Duffy made his debut two years ago and hasn't had a sniff of first team football since. If it hadn't been for a number of injuries forcing Moyes' hand, he would still be playing for Scunthorpe United!

Vellios, a couple of starts. Dropped.

Barkley, one mistake. Dropped.

Rooney. Sold far too cheaply before we ever got to see the best of him.

Vaughan - admittedly never fit enough for long enough to be given a fair crack. Sold.

So from your list, we have Rodwell and Anichebe left:

Has Rodwell really fulfilled his potential yet under Moyes? That is debatable.

Moyes, much to the annoyance of many Evertonians, has persisted with Vic and that persistance may pay off, but that remains to be seen. Big Vic could yet become Moyes' greatest success!

I personally think at a club that is increasingly going to have to rely on youth development for the sake of it's future... the above indicates a worryingly poor record from our manager over a ten year period.
Gareth Lucy
41 Posted 17/01/2012 at 01:50:33
How as he given the chance to score three? Surely after he netted the first he should have been replaced by a defender so we could concentrate on holding out for a 1-0 win. Moyes needs to get a grip on these attack-happy reserves!
Paul Ward
42 Posted 17/01/2012 at 01:10:58
I find reading comments on this great site, the same old debates about the same old players and the many poor decissions that David Moyes has been responsible for. One of his most rediculous errors is surely Yakuba.
Moyes buys Yakubu for the over inflated price of over 11 million pounds because he is a proven goal scorer.
All Evertonians know how lazy the Yak is and how his goals came in bursts but how could Moyes justify wanting him out of the club so badly to drop his price by nine million. The Yak is playing in a very poor team yet he may score more goals this season than the entire Everton team.
To see some of Moyes quotes about his team lacking fire power and his need for a striker are unbeleivable.
Roman Sidey
43 Posted 17/01/2012 at 02:50:06
Kevin, never once have I mentioned on here that Barkley, Vellios, etc are the answer. Your at-all-costs defence of TD4 is becoming very flawed. Once again, I have never said that they are the answer. Just because I don't think that Moyes is doing as well with the youth as some do does not mean that I think he has world beaters coming through the ranks.

Look at the youth of the last few years though. How many young players have we either sold to lowly clubs for bugger all, or simply let go after their apprenticeship? As a 20-year-old signing, Fellaini was a promising midfielder, so promising that we spent far too much money on him. Now, as a 24-year-old, he is in football terms, nearing middle age, and has gone sideways, if not backwards since his first season.

What I really don't understand is this "he's too young" bollocks. It's a semi-contact sport, that is more about brains than it is about brawn. In my eyes, if the player can trap, find a pass, make the pass, run, shoot, and/or tackle, they are old enough.
Matthew Svatos
44 Posted 17/01/2012 at 02:13:50
Well if we look at our entire first team at the moment, pretty much all of them are 30+. Howard, Hibbert, Neville, Distin, Osman, Saha and Cahill all are over 30. Jagielka is 29 and the youngest of the starters are all in their mid to early 20's with baines coleman and fellaini. Unless we start blooding these youngsters soon, the average age of the team is going to be to high and it's going to be to hard to replace all the ageing players!!!!
Roman Sidey
45 Posted 17/01/2012 at 03:18:14
Sadly, Matthew, even Baines is the wrong side of 25. He's 27 now, and if he continues to play every single game for Everton, that 27 is going to feel like 30, especially if he goes to Polkraine in the summer.
Russell Buckley
46 Posted 17/01/2012 at 04:24:34
Vellios deserves at least a good 30 minutes in a match if we are needing a goal. At the moment I'd like to see him start up front along with Vic.

Can't believe I want Vic to start but credit to him he hasn't looked to bad since coming back. I don't think they will run the trip but Saha or Straq can still serve as back up.
Gavin Ramejkis
47 Posted 17/01/2012 at 06:36:01
Kevin the stubborn reliance on packing the midfield with defenders and watching it like a car crash in slow motion or even thinking about trying alternatives such as Barkley are plain idiotic, repeating the same mistake week after week isnt a sign of some managerial genius.

Velios needs a strike partner, very few strikers including Saha in his own words can act as a lone striker without either an attacking midfielder or as a two man strike force with their partner helping them out, Saha said as much when he was partnered with Beckford and similarly Velios stranded on his own such as the Fulham game is another example of waste by the manager. 4-5-1 or 4-4-2 or whatever pattern you like but with the players with the right skillset in the correct positions, not sticking with a tired gameplan which isnt working.
Peter Barry
48 Posted 17/01/2012 at 06:37:07
How much more evidence do we need that Dire Dour Daveys man management and motivational ability is in the gutter. But hey we have a 30 y.o. ,MLS reject ,Bundesliga Div 2 surplus to requirements, "Striker" on trial who must be the answer to Dire Daveys prayers.
Peter Barry
49 Posted 17/01/2012 at 06:49:55
I have to laugh at all the balloons on here saying the youngsters have no experience then defending Dire Dour Davey when he does not give them any.
Jason Lam
50 Posted 17/01/2012 at 06:35:44
The problem with the lads are they're too nice. If Moyes wants to emulate the success of the 80s he's got realize that team contained some real hard bastards who turned the air blue and intimidate the ref and opposition. I'm afraid you can't have one and not the other, and field a team of choir boys that won't challenge the ref. Leaders on the field inevitably have that edge in them, Big Dunc, Yak, Beckford, which is essential in strikers having the confidence to shoot even when there's another player on. I think Moyes just doesn't understand the strikers' setup. These players deserves certain perks and if they don't/can't track back, float to the wings, be a complete arsehole, so be it.
Sam Hoare
51 Posted 17/01/2012 at 08:26:36
One way or another more youngsters are going to get chances as we simply don't have the funds to buy new squad players. I personally think Moyes has a prety decent record with youngsters. He doesn't throw them in the deep end if he can help it but brings them through gradually.

Too often youngsters given alot of starts (and pressure) at an early age go the Cadamarteri route. Having said that i do think Vellios clearly desreves some more game time.

From what i hear it seems their loan moves have really benefitted Duffy and Baxter and both Bidwell and Garbutt are doing well too. I think getting first team league expereince really brings these players forward and is something i would be looking to do as much as possible.

I also think if Barkley were not injured over Christmas/New Year he would have definitely got some game time.

Andrew Fair
52 Posted 17/01/2012 at 08:34:03
Moyes said he was resting Vellios, because he had seen a drop in training from him. As with any team at any level if you dont perform in training then you wont be in the 16 come match day. Its obviously having the desired effect and I am sure he will be in the 16 this week. Good management Davie well done. Shame most people on here see it as a negative against Moyes!
Ciarán McGlone
53 Posted 17/01/2012 at 08:55:06
He also 'pressed his claim' by being our top scorer for most of the season.

He, like Barkley, is simply another victim of our manager failing to put his best and in form XI on the field.

But then again..'we don't see him in training'... blah, blah, blah.
Kevin Hudson
54 Posted 17/01/2012 at 08:50:14
Jamie,

McAleney, Barkley & Vellios haven't, in my book, 'earned,' a starting place yet, so to suggest that they've been dropped, is a glass half-full mentality.

Moyes develops the youth - at the pace he sees fit. Not all of them work out, some get farmed-out, some suffer debilitating injuries & some get found-out; but this isn't a phenomenon unique to Everton.

But I take on board your points about Hibbert & Osman, and admire your optimism over Vic!

Roman,

To suggest that my defence of Moyes comes "at all costs," is frankly, artistic licence on your part, as I've panned him on several occasions.

I concede YOU may not have been banging the drum for increased youth inclusion, but you're surely aware of the shrill castigation of Moyes for not giving them more game time?

My point remains that we only see their ability for a fraction of the time the gaffer does.
James Martin
55 Posted 17/01/2012 at 09:26:58
Its very easy to go trhough each of Moyes' youth players and criticise them individually for not yet nailing down a regular starting spot in the first team but how does Moyes' record compare to other clubs?

Liverpool have arguably only got Spearing and Kelly anywhere near their first team, and Spearing is 22 (?) whilst Kelly is definitely not 18. How many people on here would have been happy if Moyes had waited another 5 years with Rodwell before he got a regular spot or waits another 4 now with Barkley?

Man U would rather turn to Paul Scholes than Ravel Morrison. Admittedly Wenger gave Wilshere a chance because he was exceptional but even he did a loan at Bolton. Barkley hasn't played out on loan and hasn't even played that much football at all. How many teenage strikers are there playing regularly every week in the league? Not many, even talents like Welbeck have had to wait their turn (albeit in a better team)

In my opinion Moyes has relied on youth more than any manager in the league over the past few years but that doesn't mean that the moment they get a sniff of the first team they have to be in it every week. Its very different scoring goals from the bench than playing 90 minutes.
Thomas Windsor
56 Posted 17/01/2012 at 10:02:46
The lad should be played from the off against Blackburn with Anichebe ? if it does not work, put Stracq on. What's the point of playing Cahill and Saha? ... it just does not work anymore.

If we line up 4-5-1 against Blackburn we will stink the place out again and the gates will drop lower. Go for a win, you negative boring manager.
Dave Wilson
57 Posted 17/01/2012 at 09:56:12
Mark #411

You make a very good point Mate.

I think a lot of valid criticism of Moyes is dismissed becuase its usually buried under a mountain of absolute drivel.

Moyes`s critics do themselves no favours when they try to insult fellow Evertonians by telling them that he said "He`s satified with a defeat" or "He`s a liar" because he told us he wasnt getting the Arteta money.

I find it impossible to take claims that "he never changes his plan" seriously, particularly when I have witnessed he has played with four different formations in the past four matches.

Who do people think they are kidding when they scream "we played with EIGHT defenders"? do they not realise we watch the game too ? and why do they always count the goalie ?

Claims like "he doesnt want to win", "He`s trying to get the boot" and "he doesnt like goalscorers" are always going to draw riidicule.

We know the Totenham team cost a lot more than ours, why do people try to convince us it didnt ? and why do they think we dont know Barkley is injured and cant play at the moment ?

I dont get why people think they can pursuade others the are right by using every D in their vocabulary to describe our Manager. I dont get why they would stay up until 1am to watch a game . .only to go to bed at half time because - as they suspected - it was dour and "predictable" . . . HELLO.
I laugh when these people later refer to those who dont buy into this drivel as "ballons".

By all means tell us our manager is deliberately holding back top class youngsters, that he tries to "coach their ability out of them".
Call for every promoted manger who wins two games on the bounce to replace Moyes.
Cancel and reinstate Chrimbo so many times the turkey jumps in the fucken oven itself.

BUT, please dont complain when it falls upon deaf ears.
Andrew Ellams
58 Posted 17/01/2012 at 11:07:49
Jason @ 444, imagine what would happen if our players started behaving like the primadonnas at Man U, or the cheating scum at Klanfield. There would be red cards flying around all over the place. Unfortunately those days are gone unless you are one of the approved elite,
Andrew Fair
59 Posted 17/01/2012 at 11:00:25
Dave #481 great post. Completely agree with you on all your points. A couple of weeks back there were quite a few people writing about the merits of Martinez being our manager and how he should replace and would do a far better job than him. Then I see a team with 3 wins and only 18 goals all season, from an ATTACKING manager. Well i would rather have Moyes than Martinez anyday. In fact I would only replace Moyes with Fergie out of any prem manager currently available.
Roman Sidey
61 Posted 17/01/2012 at 11:31:53
Andrew, that is the problem. Some people only think that our next manager can come from the Premier League. There is more to life.

Dave, that was a good post. It went against most of the things I think about our manager, but you have some sense, unlike some of his other supporters.

The one question that I would love to have an idea of an answer to regards how "Moyes hates goal scorers". While that quote is sensationalist, can you not see that Moyes seems to handle goal scorers in a peculiar way? Going back to Yak, he scored against Stoke and had a cracker against the Shite, then we never saw him again. Saha and Cahill haven't scored in years, but they keep their places. Vellios becomes our top scorer in a year where goals are hard to come by, and we never see him again.

I'm not trying to restart a debate here. I just want to know if those of you that are in Moyes' corner see that trend, and if you have a more optimistic answer than most of us in the MOB.
James Stewart
62 Posted 17/01/2012 at 12:07:46
Exactly Roman. Moyes does not handle strikers well at all.
Andrew Fair
63 Posted 17/01/2012 at 12:13:34
Roman, I could spread the net wider! I would only have Fergie from any country Mourinho, Ancelloti and Guardiola would be top class but wouldnt understand what its like to manage Everton. Moyes is up there with the best managers we have ever had, because of what he does for this team on such a shoestring compared to the others. If he went we would be in big trouble.
Stephen Kenny
64 Posted 17/01/2012 at 12:23:17
Very, very simply, could Barkley and and Vellios have done less than Saha and Cahill have this half a season??? We all know the answer if were being honest.

Then, what about the second half of the season?

If you do what you've always done you will get what you always got.
Peter Cummings
65 Posted 17/01/2012 at 12:23:21
Need the lad say more, a treble and one disallowed speaks for itself, GIVE HIM A GO!!
Tom Rowe
66 Posted 17/01/2012 at 12:36:38
All this moaning after a reserves game.... must be a slow news day
Tom Rowe
67 Posted 17/01/2012 at 12:37:43
http://www.goal.com/en/news/12/spain/2012/01/17/2851102/evertons-royston-drenthe-hits-out-at-real-madrid-for
Andy Callen
68 Posted 17/01/2012 at 13:09:22
Maybe the reason why Vellios, or anyone else for that matter, doesn?t start is because they simply aren?t doing enough in training to warrant it? Or is this too simple an idea?

Scoring a hat trick for the reserves will have got the attention of the gaffa, and I?m sure he will be monitored closely over the coming days to see if he is putting in the required effort and warrants a start/ playing time.

People blame Moyes for putting too much pressure on our players ? Christ the lad scored 3 for the reserves and all of a sudden he is our saviour? NSNO
Graham Mockford
69 Posted 17/01/2012 at 13:04:11
Dave Wilson #481

I would give up with Predictable Pointless Pete and his one line of argument in every thread he joins. Your points are far too balanced and measured for him.

As for Vellios, the lad appears to have some potential but can anyone who saw the Stoke game really claim he looked like a player currently capable of leading the line on a consistent basis? That would normally mean he could be brought on gradually; however, the current lack of form of Cahill and Saha means many are seeing him as the answer, when he quite patently is not... yet.

For me, Anichebe is probably the best start at the moment, and believe me it is with a very heavy heart I say that. We desperately need a forward in the window but that is only likely to be achieved by a sale of one or more to fund it.
Joe McMahon
70 Posted 17/01/2012 at 13:36:52
Jamie Sweet ? you make some very good points. If we can all suss out Moyes other managers certainly can and have done. Who else would stick with a pairing that has scored 1 goal in over 20 games! Would SAF play Cahill if he was goaless for 14 months?
Brian Waring
71 Posted 17/01/2012 at 14:25:04
Andrew (#453) On Vellios, you say
" As with any team at this level if you don't perform in training then you won't be in the 16 come match day "

Obviously then Andrew, Cahill and Saha must be performing miracles in training, because what they are doing in the actual games, doesn't warrant a starting place.

Also, do you agree with Moyes's philoosophy, that if your not performing in training, then you shouldn't be in the 16?
Andrew Fair
72 Posted 17/01/2012 at 14:40:04
I agree they are not having a good time at all and if it were down to me I would get rid of Cahill or use him for 20 mins at end of games. But they must be either, finishing well in training or putting in maximum effort. Remember these are previously high performing individuals so they have earned Moyes faith. I agree yes, if the effort isnt there then they should be made to stew in the stands until they get the message
Dave Wilson
73 Posted 17/01/2012 at 14:52:24
Roman

there is a bit of a myth surrounding Yakubu. He did not have a cracker against the Shite, he got the crowd going by barging a few of them about but that was it, he had no part in our goals.

For two seasons Yakubu`s performances had been very poor, Evertonians were giving him dogs abuse, any sympathy for his terrible injury soon vanished because he didnt seem to be trying too hard to regain full sharpness.
Moyes was slaughtered for picking him - ring any bells ?.
Liecester ran a mile from signing him, in fact nobody wanted to know.

One more thing Roman.

If, as we are constantly told, Moyes never changes his style of play, how come Yakubu got 20 odd goals playing that way one season, but when his form fell off a cliff - as it has done with every club he`s been with -it still got to be Moyes`s fault ?

And where were all these people who are screaming about Moyes selling him at the time ?
Stephen Kenny
74 Posted 17/01/2012 at 15:58:13
Peddling a few myths yourself there Dave.

Yakubu had an excellent game against the R/S. He pretty much occupied their two CB's alone and gave us a platform to get at them, linking play up and getting in dangerous positions all game. I came out buzzing wih his performance and thinking he was back. After that he scored one and made one in his next two games, then got dropped.

For two seasons his performance weren't poor. He scored on his first game back and was then dropped and got 5 mins here and there and an odd start, for the best part of two years. Proven goalscorers need game time to get sharpness back. He never got it from Moyes. Moyes clearly preferred Saha. God knows why?

Leicester never ran a mile from signing him. They couldn't afford him and he was reluctant to drop a level on a permanent basis. The deal was going to be permanent if they came up, Moyes said so himself.

The above post is full of nonsense, go back and see any posts about the time he left to see he still had a lot of support.
Dave Wilson
75 Posted 17/01/2012 at 16:06:30
Sorry Stephen lad your grasping at straws.

I watched that game recently for another reason and found myself chuckling at the Yak, he looked as if he`d been eating cushions. I invite you to take another look. Its still widely available.

With the exception of Anichebe I dont think anyone got close to the sort of abuse the Yak got, I dont have to go back and check posts I witnessed it with my own eyes and ears. He got the same from Liecester fans - they hated his "laziness" as well.

Your post smacks of somebody trying to rewrite history How can you say Liecester could`nt afford the Yak, they paid twice as much for Beckford FFS.

Saha or the Yak ? If you`d have posed that question a year ago you`d have got a very different answer to the one all these people with perfect Hindsight would give you now.

Oh BTW Stephen the Yak had been poor for two seasons and his form had fell off a cliff long before his injury.
Stephen Kenny
77 Posted 17/01/2012 at 18:43:31
Dave,

considering your a home and away bluenose where did you get the time to go and watch leicester? Did any of them mention his goals that had them climbing the table? 11 in 20 I believe.

Convenient that you watched the game recently but I've got no need to. He was widely regarded as having a good game. I remember it because he was my favourite player and I was telling my mates he was back in business all week. Cushions are nice with blackbean sauce and a chianti, I don't blame him.

While he did get a bit of abuse on his odd cameo's most that had a clue saw a player desperate for a run in the side. He never got it. But I think we can all agree that when he gets a run he scores, even for Blackburn.

I can say Leicester couldn't afford him beacuse we wanted £4m as per the loan deal. He also gets £50k a week. The only reason he wen't cheap is because we had a last minute fire sale.

Feel free to point out the run of games he had that I missed. Say 5 or 6 on the bounce?
Andrew Gilbert
78 Posted 17/01/2012 at 19:21:22
Dave-481,

Nice one. Boring barry bollox has been doing my head in for a while. Don't be suprised though if he gets his thesauraus out and finds another D for the Blackburn game.

I do hope though that Vellios gets some game time soon.
Dave Wilson
79 Posted 17/01/2012 at 19:03:51
Stephen

I didn't see him play a single game for Leicester. The reason I said they didn't like him was the guys in our Leicester branch would often send me emails saying things like when are you going to take this lazy fat bastard back, they told me he often took stick from their fans?

Perhaps that's why Sven would drop him.- even in the Championship.

I`m not sure why you think the Yak was in a fire sale and Beckford wasnt, if memory serves me right, I think they went on the same day.

Log on to the players stats at the top of the page, You`ll find Yakubu played 8 times last season, 21 times the season before and 16 times the season before that. In that time he notched 12 times (around 1 in 4). During the same time Saha played 80 times scoring 33 goals (around 1 in 2.5).

That's probably why Moyes favoured Saha.

Like I say, hindsight doesn't half come in handy when you're deciding which of your ageing crocks is finished and which one will have a bit of swan song.
Brian Donnelly
80 Posted 17/01/2012 at 21:31:18
Dave Wilson

I agree with Stephen Kenny that the Yak had an excellent game against the red Shite. He didn?t have many good games in the last 2 years that he was with us, but that was definitely one of the good ones.

If you look at column articles for 2010-11 (Oct) you will see what Paul Trail said about the Yak in that Liverpool match.

?Yakubu: Was brilliant for an hour before fading though he was living off scraps for most of the second half. He worked hard, was strong on the ball and linked up well with the midfield. Just needs a goal I reckon and he?ll be flying again. 8?

The above hardly matches your comments, such as ?He did not have a cracker against the Shite, he got the crowd going by barging a few of them about but that was it?
Stephen Kenny
81 Posted 17/01/2012 at 21:38:49
Dave

we both know who got the minutes on the pitch and who never out of Louis and the yak. Seeing as though your up on the stats care to let us know about starts etc?

I would have thought Sven rested him once or twice because he'd barely played since a career threatening injury!

What's done is done and I can't see us agreeing for the simple reason everybody looks for different things in a player. My only prerequisite for a striker is that they score regularly, which is why I think Vellios deserves a chance.
Mark Stone
82 Posted 17/01/2012 at 22:11:04
There were a hell of a lot of people posting on here in the summer that we needed to get rid of Yak,, some of those people are now bemoaning Moyes for letting him go.

My opinion at the time was that he should have been kept. He always looked like our most effective striker. I'm loathe to criticise a manager who has consistently achieved more than his finances would dictate, but I just can't understand the decision to sell the Yak. I truly thought the loan last season was to get him up to full fitness, then we'd get him back.
Gavin Ramejkis
83 Posted 17/01/2012 at 23:02:52
Mark you should also qualify that those bemoaning Moyes to get shut never had an inkling that he'd get shut of three strikers off the books and replace them with a single loan replacement who Leicester turned down and looks lost on the pitch when he has played in Strac.

Players come and go and for all intents and purposes it looked like Yak had to go as Moyes flatly refused to play him. I thought Yak had a good game against the RS and Stoke but was dropped after that for fleeting cameo appearances which just highlighted how out of form he was which was no surprise getting no game time.
Mark Stone
84 Posted 17/01/2012 at 23:39:56
But thinking he had to go as he wasn't getting a look in is different to 'fat lazy shit who is going to be 48 next week and has fuck all to offer'.
Denis Richardson
85 Posted 17/01/2012 at 23:46:03
Maybe those 'lazy'performnces were due to him only getting the odd cameo appearance and no real backing from the manager, hence leading to a not very happy player?

Moyes obviously had a falling out with Yakubu and when that happens the player always ends up being the one leaving. Personally I was sad to see him go at the time but if the manager was not going to give him a look in, there was not much else to be donet.

I also remember that game agains the RS and thought he did well - favourite moment was him sending mereles flying.

He obviously does/did still have something to offer looking at his goals for Blackburn.
Kevin Hudson
86 Posted 17/01/2012 at 23:44:50
Gotta agree with Dave Wilson.

Both selective hindsight & rose-tinted specatacles are on show here..

Right or wrong, the decision was made to cut our losses. I fail to see the virtue of poring over it again.

(Having said that..there is yet another Rooney-related thread for those who can't let go).
Peter Barry
87 Posted 18/01/2012 at 08:46:52
I have to laugh at some of the fools who post on here and 'attack the messenger' when really they should be either criticising or defending Dire Dour Davey instead.
Dave Wilson
88 Posted 18/01/2012 at 08:58:42
Dear me theres a few people turning Gwladys Knight here.

Yakubu took the piss out of Evertonians everywhere. Whats all this garbage about a "few camios" ? he had chance after chance after chance, he couldnt even be arsed getting fit.

Yes Goodison loved it when he played skittles with the RS defenders, but skill ? you really are having a laff. perhaps if he put a similar effort into one or two other games he would still be here.

The guy would come back days late from piss ups with his Nigerian team mates and you guys wanna blame the manager ?

Stephen #586

I dont have stats, just the knowledge that even the away support was sick to death of spending fortunes to see Yakubu stroll around the park without a care in the world
Dave Wilson
89 Posted 18/01/2012 at 09:13:34
I just checked the TW stats on Yakubu since his injury. He played in 51 games, started 22.

I think that just about nails this Myth that Moyes restricted him to a few "camio appearances"

Moyes and Everton were desperate for a striker.

Whats that term T Williams uses ?

Oh yeah, Player apologist
Stephen Kenny
90 Posted 18/01/2012 at 10:18:37
22 starts in over two years.

Wow, I was well out there, he was practically a regular.

Thats about a quarter of the total games played in that period.

Not once did he get even 5 games on the bounce to get his sharpness and touch back, never mind match fitness.

The rest, as I said, cameo's.

I was also going the aways at that point Dave. I mostly remember people screaming at Moyes to give him a go as we were badly in need of a proper striker.

What's the term MK uses?

Oh yeah, apologist
Dave Wilson
91 Posted 18/01/2012 at 10:42:36
51 chances in a season and a half - He was at Liecester for the second half of last season - And you still cling to this pathetic excuse that he wasnt given enough chances . . hard working players have reached burn out in fewer games.

Not sure whats the most mystifying Stephen, your claim that he was`nt given enough chances by Moyes or your claim that Sven "rested him once or twice because he hadnt played" Perhaps Sven couldnt find a pair of shorts big enough ?

Your argument has been blown away mate, ironically by stats you asked me to find.

As for the Apologist Jibe. You can say what you want, but I tell you this; If it was up to me, Moyes would have been out on his arse for allowing this guy to take the piss for so long out of Evertonians who were spending their hard earned so this joker could stroll around the park without even breaking sweat.

All the hindsight in the world wont change that
Stephen Kenny
92 Posted 18/01/2012 at 12:14:26
Dave

you haven't blown anything out the water.

Seemingly everybody in the world except you accepts that a player coming off the back of serious injury needs game time to get back to thier best or even just match fit. Yak never got it, simple as.

You can blow my argument out the water when you show me 5-10 consecutive games played. You won't because you can't.

5-10mins here and there doesn't count and you know it.

The joker you mention is still strolling round the park without breaking sweat, scoring more than all our forwards combined.

Your "Sven dropped him for being lazy" was nonsense and I offered a different take on it, as you know.

Or, are you now claiming to have the inside line on Sven's managerial decisions as well as a hotline to all the Leicester fans that go the match?

It was you who started with the jibes when you realised you were talking crap about the Derby and didn't like getting called out on it.
Brian Harrison
93 Posted 18/01/2012 at 12:31:40
So reading most of the posts on here, am I to conclude that Moyes has a wonderful array of young talent, but refuses to play them as they would produce winning football.
Dave Wilson
94 Posted 18/01/2012 at 12:28:20
1) "Seemingly everybody in the world except you accepts a player coming back from injury needs game time" ... Stephen, he played in 51 games in a season and a half ? how much game time can he get???

You and others have been claiming for ages that he was ignored and left to rot. FIFTY ONE GAMES?

Dance around the issue as much as you want, Sven DROPPED him, when he was playing in a Championship team. Don't blame me, blame Sven and blame the Leicester fans for giving him the same stick as the Everton fans did.

Yakubu may well have scored in five games for Blackburn, but he has cost them too, I have also seen him let his team mates down in games like the SOL and Anfield... and if they go down, he will be every bit as responsible as any other player.

Let's see where he ends up.
John Daley
95 Posted 18/01/2012 at 12:46:51
I was probably one of the Yak's harshest critics during the last year of his Everton career. I couldn't comprehend how a professional athlete could consistently appear to have the dynamism, energy and fight of a plastic bag stuffed full of horse shit. He was hopelessly out of shape and seemed to be making no progress whatsoever in inching his way back to match fitness.

It wasn't all to do with his injury either. His form was on the wane well before he was crocked. He went through a barren spell in front of goal (only broken by one bouncing in off his back against Middlesborough I think) and looked totally disinterested. Coincidentally, about this time there were rumours circulating that he was on his way to Spurs.

The only issue I had with him being shown the door was the piss poor fee we ended up getting for him. However, the fact that Blackburn were prepared to go no higher, Leicester decided against it and no other club even sniffed his knickers showed how far his stock had fallen.

True, with hindsight, Blackburn appear to have bagged a bargain but would he really have rediscovered his form here under Moyes? Steve Kean recently stated that he doesn't want Yakubu running around and tracking back, he has 9 other players to do that, he just wants him there ready to finish when the chance arises.

Rightly or wrongly, forwards aren't utilised like that at Everton. They're expected to defend from the front, pressure the centre halves, challenge in the air, hold the ball up, bring others into play and run the channels. I bet the Yak was fucking gasping for breath just thinking about it.
Sam Hoare
96 Posted 18/01/2012 at 13:13:20
All this Yakubu stuff is kind of desperate.

If you're going to have a go at Moyes then you have to have a go at all the other managers who didn't want to buy him for £5m or £4m or even £2m. Are they all idiots too? Everyone thought he was washed up. Its not like Moyes was going against popular belief!!

Blackburn took a punt. He proved people wrong and fair play.
Stephen Kenny
97 Posted 18/01/2012 at 16:09:37
Dave way to skew the facts. Very, very desparate.
Stephen Kenny
98 Posted 18/01/2012 at 16:11:55
Sam,

I didn't have a go at Moyes. I rarely give my opinion on his transfer dealings because only a divie would fail to see how good he's been for us in that respect.

Moyes clearly didn't fancy the Yak for whatever reason, that's looking to be a bad decision but about the time he was leaving I personally saw him going to a nando's at about 11am. That convinced me him going weren't a terrible decision. due to his professionalism, or lack of.

What I object to is people who solely blame Yak for a lack of fitness or try and tell me I never saw him have a great game against the shite, or talk bollocks like Leicester fans didn't like him. The only instance I've ever heard of when a team gets a new player, player scores like fuck and the fans still don't like him.
Dave Wilson
99 Posted 18/01/2012 at 16:17:05
Stephen

You and several others were and have been for sometime trying to claim Moyes had frozen Yakubu out. I desputed it because I`d witnessed different.I knew the Yak had been given plenty of time to get himself sharp

I`m not a statto, I base my opinion on what I`ve seen, so I was going to leave it when you challenged me to prove it with stats.

Then I stumbled across an absolute mine of imformation on these very pages, If I`m honest I was shocked at just how many chances the Yak had been given.

I wont take credit for blowing your argument out of the water, because the person who`d complied the sats did that.

the simple fact is, if you take the Yaks International games into consideration you have to accept he had even more opportunity`s than the TW pages revealed. and I think its safe to say if he didnt play for Nigeria he would have been involved in even more games than the 51 games highlighted. he was involved in nearly every game he was available for.

I didnt create the facts/stats, I merely presented them.

Let it go lad, I`m not claiming any victory here.The fact that they make such a a complete mockery of the claim Moyes froze the Yak out is nearly as big a surprise to me as it obviously is for you
Stephen Kenny
100 Posted 18/01/2012 at 16:48:40
Dave

some would say sending a player on loan to a mid table club a division below, when he is right up there with the very best in terms of goals scored, is freezing him out. Likewise playing with no strikers when he's fit.

Like you I go off what I've seen. I know it takes games to get back to fitness. 22 starts spread over a couple of years isn't enough. I don't agree the stats support your argument, i think they support mine. I also think the reasons he may not have got the starts is because he's a lazy fucker.

I'll let it go when you stop peddling shite!!!
Sam Hoare
101 Posted 18/01/2012 at 16:57:21
Stephen, wasn't claiming you specifically were having a go at Moyes but lots of people have. As you say he's got a strong transfer record and very few people predicted this sort of goal glut from the Yak.
Brian Waring
102 Posted 18/01/2012 at 20:05:24
12 goals already for the Yak, and he could easily get into double figures, if he does, he will be the bargain of the season!

Also, the money we got for him, you would be hard pressed to get a decent 1st division striker for that.
Dave Wilson
103 Posted 18/01/2012 at 20:00:00
Stephen

Thats up to you, you asked for the stats/facts, you got em, now you call it peddling shite

As far as I`m concerned , when Moyes gave Yakubu 51 chances in 18 months he gave him about 30 too many..

for me, Your claim has been nailed to the wall. If you want to continue this debate, then I suggest you find somebody who still thinks it`s contestable - I dont, I`m done
Gavin Ramejkis
104 Posted 18/01/2012 at 21:07:34
Andrew #453 using your own logic about what Moyes does or doesn't see in training or on the actual pitch as the basis to drop players for a drop in form, please do explain what exactly Saha and Cahill have to do to express a bigger drop in form than they have both done for over a year a piece before they are dropped?

If the logic were true its pretty much proved to be a hypocrisy right there.
Drew O'Neall
105 Posted 18/01/2012 at 23:38:37
Getting back to the topic of the OP, does anyone suspect the mysterious disappearance of Vellios has anything to do with his impending contract renewal? They don't want to pay him as a first team regular so they can't play hin as one or his agent will get the flickers.
Jamie Sweet
106 Posted 19/01/2012 at 03:54:15
Just to try and stop the ongoing feud between Mr Wilson and Mr Kenny ? I think it will help for you to realise that you are both right, and you are both wrong, so it?s a draw. Take a point each and move on.

Around the start of the 2010/11 season, Yak started in 6 consecutive games. We won three (Birmingham, Liverpool & Stoke), and we drew three (Fulham, Spurs, Blackpool).

I think this backs up Mr Wilson?s point of view that the Yak had an opportunity to show his worth, and slays Mr Kenny's claim that he was never given five games in a row.

Now, much of your take on what happened to the Yak, I guess, depends on whether you think that in those six games, putting the good results to one side for the moment, the Yak did enough to warrant a starting spot in the team moving forward or not.

Now it?s purely down to personal interpretation as to how well you think the Yak performed against Liverpool. I personally thought he did a great centre forwards job. He occupied Skrtel and Kyrgiakos all afternoon with a powerful display. He was still looking like he could do with shedding a few pounds, but he charged around for a good hour and used his large frame to bully the Liverpool centre halves into submission. It wasn?t the classiest of displays, but it was certainly more effective than anything I?ve seen from any of our front men in any game this season.

He then notched a typical Yak type goal with an instinctive strike against Stoke, and many of us thought that we might just be getting back the striker that our team so desperately needed. Sure he still wasn?t looking 100% fit, but he was at least making telling contributions and leading the line pretty well.

It is what happened next therefore which somewhat backs up the theory that he was ?frozen out? by Moyes.

Despite the fact that during those six games we were undefeated, gaining 12 points out of a possible 18, including a magnificent victory against our bitter rivals, the Yak then sat on the bench for 8 out of the next 10 games, making 5 sub appearances, mostly on the 80+ minute mark, and being an unused sub in three. During these ten games, our form dipped dramatically and we won just two games. But rather than re-instate The Yak, he was loaned out to Leicester City without ever being given another chance to build on his previous encouraging displays.

So in summary, I think he was given a decent chance in the side after his injury, but then, just as he was starting to show signs that he could still do a good job for us after leading the line through a series of decent results, he was dropped like the proverbial brick.

Let?s face it, his style doesn?t fit the Moyes mould and I understand why Moyes decided to move him on. I just wish he had lined up a decent replacement before he left us so woefully short on numbers and quality in that department.
Seamus Murphy
107 Posted 19/01/2012 at 23:02:25
Jamie ? nail on the head again.
Dave Wilson
108 Posted 20/01/2012 at 07:07:47
Jamie #802

"feud" ? Not really, just two Passionate Evertonians debating a point. I`m flattered that you awarded us a point, but I didnt warrant mine. I merely took facts from the TW archives.

I thought I was done with this thred, by trying to act as the guy who decided who was right and who was wrong, you merely brought another perspective to the argument. However, you have raised other issues.

It doesnt matter if either myself or Stephen were right /wrong, The question is, was Davey Moyes right ?

You claim Yakubu was "dropped like the proverbial brick" after a run of decent games ? what you are overlooking is the fact that the Yak had been given as many opportunities as our other forwards.
They had all been misfiring.
Just before Christmas last year Davey Moyes dropped all three of his forwards, it went largely unoticed at Eastlands - probably because we won - but when we failed to win at the Boleyn all hell broke loose. Moyes was slaughtered. But he stuck by his decision. Was it right ?

Moyes will argue that it had the desired effect on Saha and Beckford, both upped their game. The yak didnt. Six weeks later
He was still vastly overweight and was farmed out.

Everton had scored 18 goals before the City game.

Moyes will feel his decision to let the Yak go was vindicated by the fact that we scored far more goals without him than we did with him and surged up the table gaining another 30 points from the remaining games.

The second question is : Is Stve Kean right to indulge the Yak by relieving him of "team duties" ?
Well that remains to be seen, If Blackburn stay up, it will be viewed as a brave decision, but a succcess ? Were Blackburn expecting to be in a a dogfight ?

If Blackburn go down, their fans will not look at the goals the Yak has scored, they will look at the 30 games he didnt score in and therefore contributed little or nothing.
Keans decision to risk playing with 10 men will be viewed as catastrophic.

Interesting times ahead

Jamie Sweet
109 Posted 20/01/2012 at 20:47:39
Some very valid points there Dave, and you're right that our form after letting the Yak go does help to vindicate that decision. I think you deserve an extra point!

We did still have Beckford at the time we sent the Yak on loan though. The only reason I call into question the sale of either Yak or Beckford, is because we are so woefully short on numbers and quality in that position this season.

Yes perhaps the Yak is past his best or doesn't offer enough to the team, and yes perhaps Beckford isn't quite "Premier League quality", but I do think that still having one or the other on our books today would just give us better options up front than are currently available to our manager. They both offer at least one attribute each which we are severely lacking up front. Electric pace (Beckford), and a natural ability to stick it in the onion bag (The Yak).
Dave Wilson
110 Posted 21/01/2012 at 09:41:07
Indeed Jamie

I suspect, with the benefit of hindsight, DM would snatch your hand off if you were to offer either player for the remainder of the season

Last season Moyes lost patience with his strikers and as you will recall he was slaughtered for it.
This season he is getting slaughtered for being too patient - both periods being roughly the same lenghth

Without investment, Moyes will be faced with similar predicaments in various positions. Every wrong call will be used as a stick to beat him.

Guess thats why he gets paid the big bucks

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads