Moyes wanted Everton B team

, 20 January, 64comments  |  Jump to most recent
In Spain, top-flight clubs field second-string sides in lower divisions. Several years ago, David Moyes explored a similar option but was frustrated by the sheer depth of the non-league football pyramid.

"Four or five years ago I would have liked to have put an Everton reserve team into the Conference because it would have been better football for them," he said.

"My hope was that we could have used Widnes' stadium as the home ground and that when Everton were playing away the B team would have played in the Conference there.

"That was my long (term) idea because I thought the games would have been better, more competitive and more realistic for the players.

"But we would have had to have gone into Division Nine of the North-West Outer Counties or whatever you want to call it and it would have taken 10 or 11 years to get through.

"I would have been happy just to be in the Conference - no promotion, not involved in cups or anything - just so I could have got a good reserve team and given young players a game against the men.

"If clubs had the right facilities to play on a Saturday I thought it might have helped the Conference as well.

"We have the North and South conferences so it would have been ideal if we had had two or three clubs who had wanted to go into it and it would have maybe boosted the Conference a little bit as well.

"But I think it would be unfair for any team to go into the Championship, the tradition in this country would see that not as the right thing to do."

Moyes said the benefit of playing in a senior competitive league at weekends would extend beyond the experience players would get from the matches.

"Because the games would tend to be on a Saturday or a Sunday the young players would be able to follow the same programme as the senior ones," added the Scot.

"The training week is similar and the players can do similar work.

"When your reserve games are Tuesday or Wednesday night it makes it difficult to follow programmes and your weekends become difficult because they (younger players) may have to come with the first team.

"Before you know it you have young boys missing training sessions and, first and foremost, we have to make sure their development is right."

Quotes or other material sourced from The Independent



Reader Comments (64)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Michael Kenrick
1 Posted 20/01/2012 at 15:20:36
I think he got his wish...

Only his B team is playing in the Premier League.
Shaun Brennan
2 Posted 20/01/2012 at 15:22:04
Micheal, your absolutely right, 10 or 11 years later...
Kristian Boyce
3 Posted 20/01/2012 at 15:49:33
We can't afford one team let alone two. If we actually had some cash, would it possible for the club to buy a team like Darlington, Northwich Vic or Kettering (3 which are in the news about to go bust). Is there any legal issues preventing us from doing something like that. I know that the fans of these 3 teams probably would be against it, as they would be losing years of history and not being able to move into the Football League, but it would give their team a future.
GJ Butler
4 Posted 20/01/2012 at 15:49:07
It seems the man can't make a comment without a snide remark thrown at him. Unbelievable negativity on this site at some times.
Jamie Barlow
5 Posted 20/01/2012 at 16:08:03
Sometimes?
Tony J Williams
7 Posted 20/01/2012 at 16:11:16
It doesn't matter that the Chelsea manager mentioned it too, it's time to have our dialy Moyes attack....
Ben Howard
8 Posted 20/01/2012 at 16:13:39
If he carries on, he can take the existing team down to The Conference (joke). Chill out, Moyes Fluffers!
John Daley
9 Posted 20/01/2012 at 16:10:43
I find snide negativity preferable to false piety any day of the week.
Steve Pugh
10 Posted 20/01/2012 at 16:28:56
Northwich threw away their history the moment they sold the drill field
Gerry Morrison
11 Posted 20/01/2012 at 16:35:50
That is what the reserves used to be for. Why did we ever give up on that?
Andrew Fair
12 Posted 20/01/2012 at 16:40:37
Moyes said he wanted it as it would be more competitive for the reserves. They would also get into a routine of saturday/sunday football rather than tuesday/wednesday nights. What a great and innovative idea but unfortunately red tape put an end to that one. Shame really would have improved our youngsters without having to send them out on loan.
Barry Rathbone
13 Posted 20/01/2012 at 16:46:32
He's only saying this because he read my post about his failure to plan with youth even though he's had 10 years.

Knew he read TW.
Jamie Barlow
14 Posted 20/01/2012 at 17:01:11
In Barry We Trust.
Barry Rathbone
15 Posted 20/01/2012 at 17:03:28
Jamie

you'd be the only one mate, thanks anyway.
Tony J Williams
16 Posted 20/01/2012 at 17:12:27
Barry, get ready to be called, dour, a coward, inept etc

You're not the messiah, you're a very naughty boy!
Barry Rathbone
18 Posted 20/01/2012 at 17:18:15
Tony

Just 10% of the Moyes wages would have smiling like a cheshire cat no matter what the names - I'd sign Weir just to cause more bother.
Gavin Ramejkis
19 Posted 20/01/2012 at 17:26:14
Isn't the B team what we have left that Billy Bullshitter hasn't sold yet?
Gavin Ramejkis
20 Posted 20/01/2012 at 17:27:19
Gerry I dont think anyone gave up on the reserves it was more a case of that league fading into nothing more than an amateur level league and teams lost interest as the quality of the sides in it dropped.
Ray Robinson
21 Posted 20/01/2012 at 17:32:53
If I was being negative, I'd say that we were fast becoming Man Utd's B team!
Ray Robinson
22 Posted 20/01/2012 at 17:35:17
Maybe Moyes does have a Plan B after all?
Steve Guy
23 Posted 20/01/2012 at 17:21:05
GJ Butler: "It seems the man can't make a comment without a snide remark thrown at him. Unbelievable negativity on this site at some times."

If it wasn't for the equally unbelievable negativity on the pitch I think you might find we all adopted a more positive frame of mind too (well most of us).

All I see is Moyes trying to justify why, in the EPL's smallest squad, we have lads like Barkley and our leading scorer Vellios, who can't get a game; when actually it's due to his egotistic stubborness, by insisting on playing Cahill and Saha (to name but two completely out of form players) who have a grand total of 2 (or is it 3 ?) goals to their names this season.

Whilst I'm at it, what lack of understanding and / or arrogance suggests that our reserves would not have to start at the bottom of the pyramid and compete properly, or would want the teams in the Conference to play what would be a meaningless match (for them) just so our Academy lads get a decent run out ?

They'd actually be better players (and people too) if they started out at the bottom and saw just how lucky they are at Everton.

I really have had it with the whole management set up at Everton, talking about this kind of pie in the sky crap when we have a six pointer on our hands tomorrow (can't believe I am writing that but it's true nonetheless) and a relegation battle looming if the A team don't start turning in a shift, never mind a B team. FFS !

Shaun Brennan
24 Posted 20/01/2012 at 17:42:11
I'm with Barry too. Moyes out Barry in.

Anyway chaps, anyone want to explain what happened to the Reserve team league?
Lee Baines
25 Posted 20/01/2012 at 18:06:02
"Whilst I'm at it, what lack of understanding and / or arrogance suggests that our reserves would not have to start at the bottom of the pyramid and compete properly, or would want the teams in the Conference to play what would be a meaningless match (for them) just so our Academy lads get a decent run out ?"

Absolutely spot on, Steve. There are several semi-professional clubs vying desperately to move up the leagues ? and to simply plonk another three or four teams straight into the conference just because they are the second-string of a Premier League side is wholly unfair.

It smacks of complete arrogance ? the same arrogance we see week-in, week-out from so-called 'professional' footballers.
Mike Allison
26 Posted 20/01/2012 at 18:25:16
"his egotistic stubborness"

What utter drivel we read on this site at times. A manager picks two experienced players with a wealth of experience and goals between them ahead of two untried teenagers, one of whom is injured and has had a horrific injury fairly recently, and the other, I'm sorry to say, isn't actually all that good, and this is deemed a major character flaw rather than simply a reasonable footballing decision.

Moyes deserves criticism from time to time but for God's sake, try to maintain at least some credibility.
Steve Guy
27 Posted 20/01/2012 at 18:50:18
Mike, the only one increasingly and worryingly losing credibility is DM: with some of the poorest team selections and performances I have seen in watching Everton for over 35 years.

The deadly duo of Cahill and Saha have been stinking the place out for months. Barkley wasn't played when fit and Velios may not be that good according to you, but he's scored more than Cahill and Saha this season playing a handful of cameos.
Wayne Smyth
28 Posted 20/01/2012 at 18:46:26
Mike, Vellios may or may not be much good, but he has scored more goals than Cahill or Saha (combined) this season:

Cahill :22 apps, 0 goals
Saha: 17 apps, 2 goals
Vellios: 12 apps, 3 goals

Personally I don't give a damn which players have a wealth of experience, or scored a hatful of goals 5 years ago. I care more about what they've done in the last 5 months.

As for Barkley not getting a game because he's injured, Moyes had lots of opportunity to play him before he was injured and didn't. He also came out to say not to expect to see him till the end of the season, after he gave away 1 penalty.

I would say stubbornness certainly is a trait of Moyes which is why we consistently see players like Neville and Cahill played when their performances simply don't justify it.
Nick Entwistle
29 Posted 20/01/2012 at 18:52:22
Once Premier League teams were allowed to loan out to the same division, that was the final nail in the Reserve League.

It gives the big teams so much more power and secures an extra points advantage with their players contributing to the results against their rivals.
Chris Leyland
30 Posted 20/01/2012 at 19:22:32
Steve Guy 276 ? as you have watched Everton for 35 years, I assume you saw Mike Walker's team? I also assume you saw Kendall Mark III? And I assume you saw Walter Smith and his bottom 6 wonders year-in and year-out? Despite this, Moyes has some of the "poorest team selections" you have seen? Despite this, his record is better than all of the above. Discuss.
Stephen Kenny
31 Posted 20/01/2012 at 19:08:43
I find these comments quite odd, a bit worrying too.

If Moyes is talkin about 16/17-year-olds then fair do's. Anybody who's been through our academy and is 18/19 should be looking at higher League One to Championship level for their experience.

One swallow doesn't make a summer but I find it strange that Duffy can play against England internationals and play well but a few weeks before was deemed good enough for League One?
Gavin Ramejkis
32 Posted 20/01/2012 at 19:20:48
Mike, a striker's job is to score goals, Saha isn't doing that and hasn't for so long it's beyond a joke. Cahill used to score goals and his role as an attacking midfielder playing facing the goal and drifting into the area to score bagged him a healthy return and useful goal tally, is it 16 or 17 months now since he scored?

Take those two alone to the bank and ask a simple question: the desired outcome of a game of football is to score more goals than the opposition and win, yes? Scoring fuck all goals and selling your strike force, sticking with an impotent striker (goal wise) and the most you could hope for is a draw.

Last time I checked, that's a single point at most; 38 games equals 38 points if you go through an entire season and draw every match, the regular survival cut in the EPL is 40 points, 38 just doesn't cut the mustard.
Steve Guy
34 Posted 20/01/2012 at 20:11:27
Chris........record smchecord. Argument is not about results it's about the football or lack of it. So yes, in my opinion, it is that bad at the moment. Tragedy is, there have been times when I thought he got it, but not for quite some time. I think that game where both Arteta and Anichebe got injured v The Skunks.... Before that, it wasn't too bad.
Chris Leyland
35 Posted 20/01/2012 at 20:16:14
Steve Ok sorry "it's about the football" I'd forgotten those scintillating Smith years when every week I'd come away from the game thinking "we got beaten again but at least Walter had a real go with 6 central defenders in the side". Or in Walkers second and final year when we didn't win our first 13 games before he got the bullet, I always came away from those games thinking "well we might not have won for 13 games but fuck it this never winning is brilliant as we play some great football"
Steve Guy
36 Posted 20/01/2012 at 21:06:33
Chris, insert Moyes name instead of Walter Smith's in your last post. Notice any difference between then and now ? No, thought not......
Kevin Hudson
38 Posted 20/01/2012 at 22:43:50
Steve,

What are you trying to pull..?

There is a HUGE difference in performance between Smith & Moyes, knock it off.
Steve Guy
39 Posted 20/01/2012 at 22:53:49
Kevin, sorry but if that performance against Tamworth (or Stoke or WBA or half a dozen other teams) had been Smith and not Moyes, Smith would have walked (as he rightly did).

Kenwright has not only mortgaged the Club to the hilt and beyond, he has mortgaged his own future at the Club by committing in absolute terms to Moyes ability to keep us in the EPL. Come what may and regardless of the "entertainment" value .....

11 years ago the only difference between our display at Boro and the display against Tamworth was

1. We won;
2. Kenwright couldn't sack Moyes because he would never find another willing scapegoat / would have to resign too.

A "HUGE" difference? Kevin, what are YOU trying to pull?
Kevin Hudson
40 Posted 20/01/2012 at 23:03:29
"The only difference between the Boro & Tamworth displays was that - we won.." (sic)

...Yeah, love that one.

Here's one or two pertinent reminders of the difference between the two managers:

* The number of times Walter Smith guided Everton to a top ten finish.

* Compared to Moyes.

* The number of times David Moyes flirted with relegation.

* Compared to Smith.

* The number of times Walter Smith reached a final, or even a semi-final, or lead the team into Europe.

* Compared to Moyes.

The statistical record of David Moyes PISSES over Smith's, so again: Knock it off.

BUT..as you already state, this is mere.."Record schmecord," to you, isn't it? Cuts no ice..right?

(There's obviously another, 'equally plausible,' method of comparing managerial tenures that do not involve invoking the respective results, people).

Introducing the cautionary spectre of impending relegation minus ANY credible evidence pointing towards such a scenario is frankly cowardly, fictitious fear-mongering, that doesn't wash. Stop it.

Even more idiotic is your baseless assertion that Moyes, a fully mature, grown man, doesn't select the new flavours of the month due to his apparent "egotistic stubborness."

This is factless, juvenile crap, Steve. Quit it.

Which leads me to your laughable reference of 'credibility.'

Well...dissapointingly, with such sweeping, ale-house talk of that nature, in my eyes, you have...none.
Gavin Ramejkis
41 Posted 20/01/2012 at 23:48:22
Kevin you ignored the statement made, compare the games listed rather than "glossing over" a ten year spin, like your other statement in another thread about Moyes beating more than 50% of Premiership managers, is that he has successes against more than half of them or his overall win rate in the premier league, I'll give you a clue - don't go for the latter.

Moyes has become as stale as Smith became with humdrum dreadful to watch defence at all costs football, so the statement is pointing at that, compare those games listed with the final days of Smith's reign and you could easily transpose the manager name between the two.
Mark Riding
42 Posted 20/01/2012 at 23:50:31
Kevin, dont tend to get involved with you if I can help it, but to say Moyes 'pisses' all over Smith.. I think a trophy count may be in order as a manager ?
Kevin Hudson
43 Posted 20/01/2012 at 23:53:12
You want to adjudicate & compare a hand-full of listed games, and ignore the totality of the data availiable..?

Grow up. One doesn't "gloss over," the fuller picture, unless it doesn't support ones's unswerving antipathy for the most consistent manager in a generation.

(Clue: As the stale, daily rhetoric coming from you would attest).

Better than (at least) 50% of his managerial peers in the Premiership, you ask..?

This is unequivocally on account of 7 top eight finishes in 9 years. This is unimpeachable.

The cosmetic crap...yawn.
Mark Riding
44 Posted 21/01/2012 at 00:03:09
Smith won many trophies in his career.
I think you are the one ignoring the 'data available'.
Moyes has never won fuck all..
Kevin Hudson
45 Posted 21/01/2012 at 00:02:40
Fair point, Mark, but Moyes statistically surpasses Smith's win ratio.

..At Everton.

(Which was the original comparison made here).
Mark Riding
46 Posted 21/01/2012 at 00:09:29
Kevin, im not daft enough to suggest Smith was a top manager for Everton. The facts suggest he knew how to win trophies.. Its a quality few seem to have. When Smith got the job, the opinion I was given from my Rangers pals, was that he was nothing without Archie..
When Moyes took over.. do you remember him out on the pitch warming up with the players ?
He was hungry.. now, in my opinion, a little fight has gone. We all know why.. but its gone.
Kevin Hudson
47 Posted 21/01/2012 at 00:10:18
...By the way, post 345 was fired in Gavin's direction.
Mark Riding
48 Posted 21/01/2012 at 00:27:12
So do you think Moyes may miss Irvine.. like Smith missed Knox when they were not working together ? ( even though Smith & Knox both ended up having spells at man utd.. )
Derek Thomas
49 Posted 20/01/2012 at 23:53:54
Kevin; The only differeence between Smith and Moyes is- Smith was here and now isn't; Moyes is here and now shouldn't be. Both mens football made me sic ( sic )- and yes I am having a go.
Roman Sidey
50 Posted 21/01/2012 at 03:22:58
Mark, I think you've pointed out something quite monumental. Moyes tries to purvey this image of the every-man, one who is down to earth and such. The last few years, he is anything but that, with his press conferences being border-line offensive, to his not warming the players up any more (I know most managers don't do this, but why did Moyes change?).

Kevin, get off your high horse.

Moyes out.

Oh, and regarding the actual story, I guess there's some merit, but I question why Moyes didn't mention this to the fans "four or five years ago" when he was looking in to it. Is someone in need of a bit of spin and smear?
Kevin Hudson
51 Posted 21/01/2012 at 10:09:03
So now wer're reduced to armchair, amateur psychoanalysis, Roman..?

You say; Moyes's press-conferences are "border-line offensive." Factually support this insane statement.

"Moyes trys to purvey this image of the every-man." - No he doesn't, he's not an actor, or a Big Borther contestant; his personality has been fairly consistent from day one.

Far from Moyes using "spin and smear," (again - such an ill-thought out, lazy use of impact language..) he was simply responding to a question prompted by Andre-Villas Boas's comments about the resevrve set-up in the country.

..With the direct opposite of 'spin,' and minus any 'smear,' as you claim.

You're coming out with bollocks, Roman. Again.
Stephen Kenny
52 Posted 21/01/2012 at 10:32:02
If you wan't a moan about Moyes fill your boots there's loads from these past few seasons performances, slow starts, negative comments etc.

But to try and compare their respective Everton records is like comparing Lassie to King Kong.

The football under Smith was good for one season. The football under Moyes was industrial then effective then O.K then good and now poor. It has been nowhere near as bad as Walter's, nor has the league finish.

Moyes has lost his spark and drive IMO and this is costing us big. Walter never really had any to begin with. He started dour and carried on like that.
Steve Guy
53 Posted 21/01/2012 at 10:50:16
Kevin, as you chose to take an offensive line which ignored my point that's your choice. You and Chris Leyland introduced the Moyes is better than Smith argument after my initial post.

Yes I saw Mike Walkers Team and those of Kendall Mk 3 etc. They were all crap and the managers all got sacked. The football we are playing at the moment (and have been for an increasing amount of time) is the equivalent of watching paint dry. If you think differently suit yourself, but I have high standards for Everton as should we all.

The only reason Moyes doesn't get sacked (back to my original comment) is because he manages to keep us in the EPLbut by playing sterile rubbish which sees us outplayed by the most mediocre of teams. He keeps his job because Kenwright knows that sacking Moyes and leaving an aging, disfunctional squad behind would see us relegated.

Moyes knows he's stuck between a rock and a hard place and it shows (did you see the face on him on Sky News last night ?). However, the situation on the pitch is solely down to DM favouring ultra defensive formations and styles and persisiting with out of form players when there are feasible options.

Robbie Muldoon
54 Posted 21/01/2012 at 11:13:11
Can't knock Moyes' on this one, creative thinking and I had never thought of the fact that young players called up for a saturday who don't play just end up having their regular training routines interrupted for nothing.

I think it says it all about Moyes actual tactical abilities and team selections that people like me can still criticise him, even though the total incompetence of the board should be completely shielding him from any blame to Evertons current position. Unfortunately it does not, and I fear defeat against Blackburn today.
Thomas Windsor
55 Posted 21/01/2012 at 11:26:40
I always liked to go and see the reserves play when they used to play at Goodison at 3pm on Saturday. Over the years, saw many a good game ? why not just bring that back?
Kevin Hudson
56 Posted 21/01/2012 at 11:22:19
Steve,

YOU attested that under Moyes, things are as bad as they were under the mocking examples provided to you by Chris.

"So yes, in my opinion, it is that bad at the moment." (297)

"Chris, insert Moyes name instead of Walter Smith's in your last post. Notice any difference between then and now ? No, thought not...... " (311)

That's why I pulled you up.

Now you say that "the only reason that Moyes doesn't get sacked is because he manages to keep us in the EPL."

This is malicious BOLLOCKS.

..As Seven top eight finishes in nine years CLEARLY underscore more than mere survival in the division. Any fool can, and should at the very least acknowledge that, rather than fretting over an imagined relegation.

Steve Guy
57 Posted 21/01/2012 at 12:02:22
Yeah OK Kevin you win....there are none so blind as cannot see.....
Kevin Hudson
59 Posted 21/01/2012 at 12:28:56
...Cannot see what..?

Impending relegation, perhaps.?

You compared oranges & apples and you know it.
Steve Guy
60 Posted 21/01/2012 at 14:02:41
I'm allergic to apples
Mark Riding
61 Posted 22/01/2012 at 00:28:53
We would draw the b team in the cup.. and they would turn us over !!
Bobby Thomas
62 Posted 22/01/2012 at 00:34:51
And the lad up top would be Saha's son, who would bag 3.

Hadnt got round to reading this thread. Just scanned it and have to say Mark agree with you on the Alan Irvine thing. Remember reading an interview with a player from the 70's, cant remember who, he said that in Gordon Lees first 18 months/ 2 years it was brilliant. Then the first team coach left, the players loved him and training wasnt the same etc. The ex- player felt it was one of the main reasons it went downhill.

Moyes and Irvine seemed a really good fit, the working relationship seemed really good and he has a great reputation. Its crossed my mind we miss his input.
Mark Riding
63 Posted 22/01/2012 at 00:56:19
Bobby.. Saha's son.. scary prospect. If he bagged 3, he would get into the first team... and then do his hamstring and be out for months.. having signed a new deal !!

Even if Moyes wanted Irvines input back.. would he be too stubborn to ask for it ?
I think he has had enough anyway.
Bobby Thomas
64 Posted 22/01/2012 at 01:08:52
Its becoming ever more apparent that its actually this season, not 2/3/4 seasons time that we are sleepwalkig into deep shit.

Hypothetically, lets say Moyes is considering walking at the end of this season, I certainly cant see him staying after his contract.....nothing to lose by getting Irvine in. It would be a smack in the face for Round, but, fuck it!!

Im throwing this out as it seems there are big fucking problems. Were not just playing poorly. Were shite. Confidence has gone, as has morale. We badly need a lift, we need something. Different face, voice, new ideas, cos it must be buzzing in training!! It needs a big sort out and the big players have got to start doing something. So the Irvine thing would be one way of lifting it. As would getting a front man in. The Irvine thing is hugely unlikely to happen.

Only just realised today..... I thought it was most likely a bottom half finish, but todays 2nd half and the prospect of the next next 4 home games has got me worried.
Roman Sidey
65 Posted 22/01/2012 at 04:36:12
Kevin, I simply asked a question about Moyes needing some spin and smear. I guess your over the top reaction answers the question.

I happen to find Moyes's press conferences offensive in that he never answers the question that the reporter is asking, which is arrogant, which can be deemed offensive. I also find it offensive that someone who is paid so handsomely by the club that we all support both socially and financially, can be so dismissive and secretive regarding the team.

Get off your high horse, Kevin.
Kevin Hudson
66 Posted 22/01/2012 at 08:14:44
Roman,

Demonstrate (nb: factually) ANY occasion when Moyes has NEVER answered the questions posed of him, rather than 'smearing' him as a petulant, truculent & 'offensive'.

Tell you what, I'll even start you off with one example of my own:

The Anichebe question, prior to the FA Cup Derby with Liverpool, when the journalists were asked NOT to ask questions (about him) and one intrepid sole dared to.

But you stated that Moyes "never answers the question that the reporter is asking".

The word 'never' implies frequency:

Therefore, either you're required to show the evidence to support this claim, or... you're coming out with bollocks, Roman. Again.
Steve Guy
67 Posted 22/01/2012 at 10:13:10
Enjoy the game yesterday, Kevin?
Kevin Hudson
68 Posted 22/01/2012 at 10:55:40
An anxious watch to be honest, Steve. Freezing cold too...
Anthony Millington
69 Posted 22/01/2012 at 22:40:38
He needs to get an A team together first!

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads