Season › 2011-12 › News
The Blue Union respond to Elstone blog
Posted on the SOS1878.co.uk website, the BU response offers some performance analysis of its own, focusing particularly on revenue from commercial activities compared to other Premier League clubs, and from player transactions, as we as tackling the as-yet unresolved issue of the £24m "other operating costs" listed in Everton's 2010-11 accounts.
Quotes or other material sourced from SOS1878
Reader Comments (128)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 20/01/2012 at 23:23:19
3 Posted 20/01/2012 at 23:29:24
I know plenty of businesses that book costs and revenues to different parts to try to mask the under-performance of one aspect of the business, but why would EFC need to do this?
Hang on, re-reading that, talking about under-performance, perhaps all player and manager wages go under Other Operating Costs...
4 Posted 21/01/2012 at 00:25:34
5 Posted 21/01/2012 at 00:36:03
I know Rigobert Song was anonymous as a player, but we didn't sign him did we...??
6 Posted 21/01/2012 at 00:39:15
If you can't take it, don't give it out..
I hate the murdering gobshite reds as much as most... but in the cold light of day Fowlers celebration was very good!!!
7 Posted 21/01/2012 at 00:51:31
I completed a survey on here the other week.. money was even mentioned... not a whisper since ?
Momentum lost..
8 Posted 21/01/2012 at 00:11:15
The £35M net spend is the biggest con trick ever outside of a politician, no mention of the £20M profit on players the season before the figures started, or the £19M in sales last summer, add those two together and we have a net transfer deficit of £3M, £3M profit on player sales over 5 years. £18M player profit on transfers over the duration of Kenwright's term...
In real terms, we haven't spent a bean of the club's money on players since BK took over. When you factor in we got nearly £50M in player sales of our youth players, which is essentially free money as no fees were paid, then how the hell are we in this situation???
I know others don't suggest that pilfering is going on, but my opinion is, if it isn't, why are the club going to such great lengths to avoid the issue of other operating costs?
10 Posted 21/01/2012 at 02:47:18
I don't agree that the Everton Board is doing a great job, but they're also not doing an awful job. However, to suggest that the board members must continue to invest more and more of their own money or sell so that the club can be more successful is just not technically correct.
Any business must make an operating profit, and generate a positive cash flow, otherwise sooner or later it will go bankrupt. In this way, you can clearly see that over the years, Everton FC has needed to cover a negative cash flow with various loans, and not extra investment of the owners. Unless the revenue of the club increases, the negative cash flow will continue to increase.
It is clear to see that Robert Elstone is aware of this and is trying to ensure the stability of the operating business. I do not envy his job.
Let's just be clear: if someone buys the shares of the existing directors, they will pay a cost for the equity/shares, and this will not increase the funds available for the club to spend. If that new owner puts money into the club (for example, for new players), it will likely be put in as some form of loan, with some form of interest to pay.
Now look at the owners' investments shown in the books of the other clubs mentioned in the Blue Union retort and see how bankrupt they would be if the owner removed their support. Some of the clubs pay just about as much to the players as they have revenue... Crazy!
The relative position of Everton in relation to other clubs is seen at http://www.guardian.co.uk/football/2011/may/19/premier-league-finances-black-hole
From the finance position, there is only one long-term position that must be found: that is to increase revenue to cover all outgoing payments. There are of course a number of strategies that can assist this, and the Blue Union mention some.
So let's analyse it from a financial position. If I invest £100M, then I'm probably going to want a return of at least £10M per year, probably much more, to cover the investment risk. That means revenue above expenses must increase at least £10M per year.
But what if that investment doesn't bring the returns that are needed? Well... then you're in an even worse position, and joining Leeds, Portsmouth etc.
It seems Everton are very clearly close to the edge in regards to requiring additional investment, especially as loans are quite difficult to secure nowadays. But sell to completely new owners? Why? In my opinion, they should look to do what other commercial businesses do and that is do a further distribution of shares and sell them to additional investors (similar to an IPO in a way). Using this method, the additional funds can be used for investment in business strategy. Importantly though, the operational running of the club, which the figures suggest is done quite well, remains the same. Perhaps the best idea I've heard of is for fans to buy in, and this would be a good way to keep the best interests of the football club at heart.
I think the Blue Union have the best interests of the club at heart, I just feel the agenda to get the board out is not needed in order to get the club into a better financial position. Perhaps a focus on fans being able to buy a significant new shareholding would be a good positive strategy for the club to stabilise its finances and improve its ability to compete for players, sponsors, tv rights, merchandising etc.
Editorial Team
11 Posted 21/01/2012 at 04:33:45
The hardest thing for these groups is to maintain momentum ? especially in a world we inhabit that is looking for daily news updates.
But stay patient and keep the faith!
12 Posted 21/01/2012 at 03:53:43
"Any business must make an operating profit". Then why doesn't Everton? EPL TV money, good crowds, low wages by EPL standards.
One can approach professional club football finance any way one wants. EFC is right here: the only assets left to sell are the players coming out the tunnel onto the pitch. The only thing between paying the bills and the bailiffs kicking in the door.
This ownership is a failure. You recommend a best path Moyes has masked over the years. Now even he can't.
"In my opinion, they should look to do what other commercial businesses do and that is do a further distribution of shares and sell them to additional investors".
What investors? Financial climate has nothing to do with it. Billionaires have billions. They're not like the rest of us 99%.
The question is what investor would give his or her money to Kenwright, Green et al?
Would you? Yes, you say? God bless you; I wouldn't.
13 Posted 21/01/2012 at 05:02:30
All agree the club needs money.... at least this is something everyone can agree on.
We need to find more common ground. The trick is to find a way to bring in investment that will work for all parties, owners, fans, new investors. Thats not going to be easy unless all will compromise....
Billionaires don't like throwing their money away, and not all billionaires are football fans, and most of them don't have billions in liquid assets.
14 Posted 21/01/2012 at 06:40:23
15 Posted 21/01/2012 at 06:40:23
16 Posted 21/01/2012 at 08:40:06
17 Posted 21/01/2012 at 09:11:28
Correctly or incorrectly, I get the feeling that you?re a nice decent fella, you try to see the good in everyone and you?re always trying to find some common ground so that you can offer a balanced view on things.
But, and it?s a big but, I think deep down you harbour feelings that people who run businesses know what they?re talking about whilst a bunch of ordinary football fans couldn?t possibly understand the intricacies and nuances of the business world, and to reinforce that view you make a series of subtly inaccurate statements that, consciously or subconsciously, are designed to discredit the fans in the Blue Union. Then again I could be talking a load of bollocks!
For example, you say that to suggest that the board must invest more and more of their money is technically incorrect. Your suggestion is incorrect on two fronts; firstly nobody is suggesting that the board invest any money and, secondly, let?s be perfectly clear here, you say more and more? Understand this now, there can?t be any ?more and more? because the members of the board haven?t invested a single penny in the club in the first place. It?s nice that you later explain the rudimentary mechanism of shareholding but to be honest it?s probably more at home on Kipper.
Nobody is suggesting the owners simply put money into the business to cover shortfalls or to pay for players. Investment in the infrastructure would have been nice, investment that would have actually increased revenue and added value to the business would have been welcomed but there was absolutely no chance of that ever happening as since 1999 we?ve had the wrong owners. They?ve sat there, done less than nothing due to their harebrained schemes, added no value to the business whatsoever, in fact the Blue Union article highlights the fact that they?ve actually taken value away in real terms, and now they expect to obtain a profit!
Looking at your claim that other owners of the clubs mentioned would intentionally bankrupt their businesses by removing their support is frankly bizarre, that is never going to happen.
I could go on and on Michael but just about everything you say proves that you are naive; naive when it comes to the people at Everton and the problems at Everton.
There isn?t going to be a rights issue whilst these people are in charge, they don?t want one and no matter how excellent an idea it is it?s never going to happen and they've said so.
Their only plan is to sell and if you believe they?re waiting for somebody to come along who just has the best interests of the club at heart then you?re more naive than I thought. They are not interested in doing anything, investment, rights issues, fan involvement; I can?t believe you don?t understand that.
The Blue Union don?t want the board out as you suggest; they want professionals who can demonstrate a successful track record to handle the sale of the club because if you look at everything the current owners have done all you can see is disaster and Everton can?t afford to get the decision on the new ownership wrong.
You?re right when you say you don?t envy Robert Elstone?s job, neither do I, he?s having to defend the indefensible. Having met him on many occasions I know being untruthful isn?t in his nature. In his blog he has laid out a series of facts, taken from the accounts, which he has interpreted. The Blue Union has just put another interpretation on those facts. It?s up to you which one you choose to believe but a lot of the guys behind the Blue Union have a reasonable record of being right.
18 Posted 21/01/2012 at 09:23:55
It's not a stoic defense of the board that some people have perceived it to be, rather a re-assessment of the all too commonly held view of 'if only the board would sell up to all those billionaires then we'd be fine'. Indeed, he makes some good points that can't be just brushed away with a you're pro-board so don't matter argument. The chances of finding a new owner who is either a blue at heart or who just as so much money that he doesn't care if he's incurring a loss is remotely small. Any billionaire buyer will want a return on his investment, that's how they got to becoming a billionaire first. Unless they're some sort of landed aristocrat, Everton would just be one of a number of investment sin their business portfolio.
Michael has correctly pointed out that the only way they are going to get a return is if they invest so much that the quality of the team improves to a point where you're reaping the benefits of champions league money and sponsorship every year. He's not saying it couldn't happen, he's saying that it's a gamble that Portsmouth and Leeds lost out on
Rather, Michael is looking at the possibility of different financial solutions to Everton's situation including changing the loss-making operational system to a profit-making one. Whoever comes in to buy the club, this system is still going to be in place with everyone hoping that the financial shortfall in it will be masked by the hoped for increase in league/ european prize money or commercial figures.
Colin as for your line that the board are not interested in anything but to sell, that seems doubtful too. Criticism of the board seems to be contradictory, a few months back it was that Bill is only looking for an investor not a buyer, so how can anyone say that they are purposefully putting of investors in the search for a buyer. Others say that Bill doesn't want to sell that he just wants to make money from the club (which he isn't), others claim that he just wants to make money from the sale of the club so is therefore forcing the price too high. There is probably an element of truth in this, but let's face it, if you're the sort of billionaire that is going to buy Everton, wipe out the debt, fund a new stadium, and plough sustained investment into the team in the hope of future profit then what is an extra 100 million on top of the initial acquisition price? If they only sell at the price of the debt then you're only going to get a buyer who can afford that cut down price, who would be the wrong buyer for Everton in terms of long term stability.
This is not a defense of the board, I want a change in Everton's fortunes just as much as everyone else. Criticising other people for bringing up alternative methods for progression, and then calling them 'naive' for not having faith in the board's utter incompetence for not finding the perfect buyer is unwarranted.
One thing the BU argument did illuminate was the spending of our midtable counterparts in the last 5 years compared to Everton's 0. Everyone still want Moyes out?
19 Posted 21/01/2012 at 10:02:06
The board have not invested ANY of their own money, so the words 'continue' and 'more' are completely redundant.
20 Posted 21/01/2012 at 10:01:31
Wouldn't most Evertonians be happy with that?
21 Posted 21/01/2012 at 10:09:09
Just what makes you think that the current board is capable of that? Their past performance in doing so?
22 Posted 21/01/2012 at 10:11:20
Colin (407), Eric (415). I think we all want the same thing, and that's a better performing team where we are exited about beating the top teams and not worrying about being able to compete with the bottom teams.
We don't need to jump on each other as fans because we have different points of view about what the best way forward for the club is.
The absolute fact is whatever the external investment, the modern football club has to have more revenue than accounting expense otherwise it will be unsustainable.
I am not saying I agree with the board in all of their decisions, but I do respect that they have much more to loose than you and I if the club is not successful. Because of this I just don't buy the line that they are trying to destroy the club.
The past methods that we as fans have used to try and 'influence' the decisions of the board and owners of the club, just aren't working. If we want to be listened to then we probably need to work with them instead if against them, and that means gaining their trust.
There are many different business models that Everton could adopt to be successful, but one thing is for sure balancing the books is a fundamental requirement. Just look at the European financial situation for evidence of not regularly balancing the books since the '80s means.
I for one like some of the very positive things the club is doing. The training centre, the youth development etc. This can bring income by selling players, or can build a future successful team, without the risk of a billionaire. Ie its a sustainable business model in its own right. But there are probably some additional methods to get investment today that can buy the players and wages for more immediate success.
Then again I am concerned that a way of obtaining a greater capacity stadium has not been found yet. I'm am sure this is not through the lack of trying on the part of the club owners, and it's very easy to criticize them in retrospect. It needs investment.
Colin & Eric, you might not agree with me but I bet that, like me, you want to watch an Everton side in 10 years that is competing in the Premier League and Champions League, rather than in the Championship or worse?
23 Posted 21/01/2012 at 11:12:07
I'm sure if there were solutions out of this loss making business model, then the current board would have taken them, why would they deliberatley lose their own money? Our commercial reach, maximum matchday attendance, tv rights or sponsorship deals are not going to immediately increase with a new buyer. Some will increase immediately with massive investment in the team (enough investment to break into the top 4), our commercial reach will slowly increase alongside a period of success (sustained by more investment) and our matchday income will only increase with a new stadium. This is a massive amount of investment before any change in the loss making operational structure occurs.
The other way to do it is to not give players high wages, not invest in the academy, and not give any transfer funds at all (the accounts showed that massive borrowing was obviously needed for transfer deals such as Fellaini and Yakubu, a gamble that didn't pay off)
24 Posted 21/01/2012 at 11:21:10
SAVE OUR CLUB!
25 Posted 21/01/2012 at 11:47:21
I?m not jumping on you I?m just telling you that you?re naive. When you say things like, ?I do respect that they have much more to loose [sic] than you and I if the club is not successful. Because of this I just don't buy the line that they are trying to destroy the club.? They?re not intentionally trying to destroy the club they are through incompetence and I can assure you I?m the first in line when it comes to agreeing that people should be rewarded for their endeavours but I?m also the first in line to agree that people who do nothing shouldn?t be rewarded and not making a profit on buying shares, which is a gamble, is a prime example.
Your ideas about working with them I actually agree with, however, you once again show your naivety; have you ever met any of the people you hold in such high regard? You in denial fella, you?ve fallen for the spin completely, it?s embarrassing reading your attempts at teaching some quite serious people on here about business models and perceived successes such as Finch Farm. According to Everton?s own figures Finch Farm has cost an additional £44m over the past four seasons, show me where this has been recouped and the amount of additional profit it has generated.
You?re closing paragraph is frankly unbelievable. Seriously, how old are you?
The main problem I see is that some people like to express views that simply don?t hold water so they ?invent? a perception to support their view. James Martin #411 is a prime example, he says. ?of the all too commonly held view of 'if only the board would sell up to all those billionaires then we'd be fine'. This to my knowledge isn?t a commonly held view whatsoever. Nearly everyone I know simply want a man with a plan, a plan that works. Unless this is achieved the club will continue to decline.
One final point James, I?m not being harsh on Michael because he happens to hold a different view; I?m being ?harsh? as you put it because he?s talking absolute bollocks and because of the content of his posts being completely ignorant of the current situation the only logical assumption I can make is that he is naive.
If anyone disagrees with this then great, get of your arse and actually do something about it, try to negotiate with the board, try to do something, but if you just want to sit behind a keyboard that?s fine to; just don?t criticise the guys in the Blue Union, they?re actually doing something, you?re doing nothing.
I?m off to the game; Peter Fearon? Any Chance? You have a lot to say on here I?d be interested to have the discussion with you at the game, I?ve asked you twice if you?d like to meet but you?ve ignored me; I?m getting the distinct impression.........
26 Posted 21/01/2012 at 12:23:57
27 Posted 21/01/2012 at 12:15:55
Its a classic approach that appeases some but does not stand up to the rigour of review.
Half truths ... misleading but a slanted and manipulated version of selected facts.
But I guess what really gets to me, is the continuing view that the board are doing their best.
The predicament we are in DID NOT JUST HAPPEN YESTERDAY! its been going on for years.
Colin and the BU are quite correct in stating that its the boards responsibility to ensure the financial stability of the club, a fact they have CONSISTANTLY failed to do for over 10 years.
Yet they STILL do nothing. They are NOT interested in diluting their share base for investment, (stated in the inquiry) They have not invested a single penny into the running of the club (stated at the inquiry) and have no intention of doing so!
They have failed the club, the team and the fans.
What is the collective personal wealth of all the board members? Anyone care to guess? Not a penny has dropped in..
Does that not indicate to every Evertonian that they have no confidence in the other directors or how the business is run? Isn't that damming?
This board has been running the exit strategy of selling to get the most return for their shares for the past 4 years. They want a sale but its the biggest shareholders that are dictating the price they want.
This is all about money and getting the most for their shares. Persona greed and wealth at the expense of the club itself.
They are not the club, they are custodians who are without the best interests of the club at heart.
Their stock is falling.. how soon before one of the gang loses their nerve and sells ? Dominoes fall.. so will this board.
Kenwright may be a figurehead for the puppetmasters behind the scenes, but they are out to make a killing at the clubs expense.
Thats the ONLY interpretation that makes sense for the last three years.
Thats WHY we are where we are today.
Incompetance and greed with absolute power and arrogance.
28 Posted 21/01/2012 at 12:47:25
29 Posted 21/01/2012 at 12:55:32
30 Posted 21/01/2012 at 12:58:55
I dont get you, on the Carpe Diem thred, you were claiming Kenwright sold all our assets to support the manager Gambling our future so he could back Moyes!
What gives?
Are you for Kenwright or against him?
31 Posted 21/01/2012 at 13:03:11
Now they are holding out for a buyer to meet their number.. in the meantime we all suffer. Its like a game of chicken.. the club is staring down the headlights of a truck travelling at great speed.
The club has been so badly run by the board and managment that our only survival hope is that they sell at such a price that is realistic and with afford any new owner some chance of funding a revival.
I look forward to that day not just because it means the door closes on a disgraceful chapter of our history. It is up to new owners, the fans and the team to be as one once more.
The pursuit of money has manipulated fans, shareholders alike. Removed shareholders rights through the changing of the Articles of Associate (it maybe legal to do so but it doesn't make it right)
They have split the fanbase at a time whe the club needs solidarity, they continue to do so in their comments and lack of constructive action.
Where is the plan Bill?
Whats your bottom price Mr Earl?
Mr Woods, waiting for the cheque?
Mr Green what advice are you giving?
32 Posted 21/01/2012 at 14:25:27
Who's going to make up a plan to get us a new stadium if they don't have any cash? Multimillionaires are not going to cut it for us anymore. An investor is going to have to wipe out the debt, fund drastic improvements to the team over a sustained period, and then finance a new stadium if we are going to move any further forward than we are now. That's what's needed for real change, giving Moyes 10 million a year through having osme sort of plan would be nice but would not be enough to progress us in the long term. All of the above costs the best part of half a billion pounds. What plan is going to replace that?
Michael suggested an alternative financing plan. Whether or not it owuld work is another matter and if you don't think it would then fine but he is definitely not talking 'absolute bollocks'. Where's your plan Colin? What sort of buyer would you sell to? If you're so quick and easy to disregard someone elses view and intellectually belittle him then you're probably not one of the 'quite serious people' on here.
33 Posted 21/01/2012 at 15:01:00
And that is exactly why we realise that the current owners MUST go.
34 Posted 21/01/2012 at 15:07:22
35 Posted 21/01/2012 at 15:29:07
36 Posted 21/01/2012 at 15:50:25
Estimates for a stadium are at least £350 million, or do you think we can progress to the level everyone on here wants without a new stadium? The Debt is £50 million, that's £400 million in total before a penny has gone on the team.
So it's not too much of a stretch to imagine another £100 million of investment over a certain time period on the playing staff is it? Liverpool spent it in one summer, Man City have probably spent nearly double that. For the long term good of our club, a new stadium is vital for consistent revenue and attracting future investment.
37 Posted 21/01/2012 at 15:56:54
And why do you think we need a new stadium immediately when our current average attendance is 32,000?
Developing Goodison gradually would require only around 20 million for the first stage Park End according to figures I have seen on this website.
Glad that you spread the purchase of new players 'over a certian (sic) time period' though instead of requiring it from day 1.
And as for the debt, why should a new owner pay the debt? It's not theirs it's debt run up by the current owners and is their responsibility to pay off.
38 Posted 21/01/2012 at 17:00:04
39 Posted 21/01/2012 at 16:55:51
The Debt at Everton FC legally belongs to Everton F.C. not Bill kenwright, no matter how much he has contributed towards it. You buy Everton F.C then you buy the debt inherent within it. Bill's not going to sell the club then leave himself a personal debt of 45 million to work off is he, even if he does deserve to.
40 Posted 21/01/2012 at 17:18:37
41 Posted 21/01/2012 at 18:04:58
Or you could continue to pose your views and debate them.
42 Posted 21/01/2012 at 18:10:39
OK so now you're saying a new buyer only needs 10 million for player investment a year. So that's 20 for ground improvements (if done in the first year which isn't necessary considering the attendances) and 10 million for players. 30 million is a far cry from half a billion.
Why must a new buyer purchase "2 quality strikers, a left back, a centre back, a creative midfielder, and two widemen" yet you don't expect the current owners to provide the same?
As for the debt, why would you expect the buyer to pay off the debt? When you sell your house does the purchaser take over your debt? or are you still legally liable for it? The current owners should pay off the debt from the money they recieve for the club, or discount it from the purchase price.
Michael's viewpoint that I rubbished was that the current board members have 'continued to invest more and more of their own money' into the Club. Are you saying that you think they HAVE invested more than £0.01 in the Club?
44 Posted 21/01/2012 at 19:39:47
Any person who understands finance can clearly look at the figures and see the picture of what is required. The strategy to compete against the top clubs requires financing, and the required financing is massive in comparison to current revenues and equity. Regardless of who owns and runs the club.
James notes 1/2 billion, and that's probably a reasonable figure without going into a thorough analysis.
I think Kenright has quite reasonably stated that neither he or the other directors have or are willing to put up that kind of money. There is absolutely no way that a bank will lend the money on current or currently projected revenues.
Finding a buyer who will front up the money to buy out the current owners and also come up with the 1/2 billion on top of that is likely to be almost impossible. Not to mention the return that they would want on this type of investment.
Finding a buyer who can only afford to buy Kenright and co out will only return the status quo, perhaps with a better plan, but again with a lack of funds to deliver.
The long and short is Everton probably has to look at a different business model than the one trodden by Man City, Chelsea, Liverpool, Villa, Portsmouth, Leeds etc. fan investment, corporate investment, other income streams etc
I don't pretend to know exactly what this model might be, only the enormity of the task of getting the funding required to compete at the highest level.
45 Posted 21/01/2012 at 20:28:07
46 Posted 21/01/2012 at 20:35:34
47 Posted 21/01/2012 at 20:16:31
48 Posted 21/01/2012 at 20:43:46
I find your name quite new to our website. Dont recall much said in the way of team tactics, setups injuries lack of purpose etc.
Anyway what I do see is a complete swerve of a fundemental question that has been asked so many times before.
It seems you are defending the board. The words "Thou doust protest to much" come to mind.
The question we all want to know, and you can procrastinate as much as you want is this.
What exactly is the "operating costs" concerning £24,000,000?
Like I said I'm not too good about politics but it does make me think that it's just another way of saying the word (i.e. like the fraudulent banksters of the UK) bonus.
I hear that there's at least two guys with a back pocket value of £100,000,000 each. Well if thats the case then either £50,000,000 each to make our club compete or as far as i'm concerned they can just fade away.
I mean If they've ONLY got £50,000,000 left it's hardly a soup kitchen scenario is it?
49 Posted 21/01/2012 at 21:32:58
50 Posted 21/01/2012 at 21:49:03
51 Posted 21/01/2012 at 21:46:17
52 Posted 21/01/2012 at 22:06:31
I don't disagree that there are some peculiarities in the current books. Obviously not illegal otherwise we would be hearing about the inland revenue investigation, but could be, or might not be hidden bonusses.
I'm just trying to put in perspective the actual size of the investment required to have Everton compete at the highest level, regardless of who is running the club.
We can dissagree on the actual figure, but we could at least all agree it is a significant one.
Groups of fans need to learn to engage effectively with the executives and directors of the club. this can be difficult, but suggesting that they are all hopeless and should be removed will just lead to a continuation of their stonewalling. We need to learn (ourselves) how to communicate with them in order for them to listen to us. If we cant do that then why should we expwct them to change? What we have been doing isnt working.
53 Posted 21/01/2012 at 22:29:28
54 Posted 21/01/2012 at 22:57:12
55 Posted 22/01/2012 at 00:49:44
"but you lose the Bullens Road revenue for however many seasons while you do it."
That is why Peter Laing refers to you as the master of spin. Do you work for The Sun? or for Elstone? It sounds like something Kenwright would say.
Gates are already 5,000 down on average so at this rate Bullens Rd will be empty and there'll be no problem with redevelopment.
As for the sale of Reading, they are probably in a better financial position than us and better run but it's nice to see your valuation of EFC has come down from £150 million to £80 million. Now take the debt off that (£45 million), the loss that the Club will make in the current financial year that is not yet shown in accounts (£17+ million), and the debt that will be incurred next year as a new owner will not be able to turn round the mess he has inherited immediately (another £17+ million), and you have a reasonable value for the club.
56 Posted 22/01/2012 at 01:06:10
If we dropped down a league.. we would be finished. Big debts.. Big contracts.. tired stadium and a chairman who, even by his own admission, hasnt got the funds required.
I thought we would be in trouble next season.. guess what.. we are in trouble now !
57 Posted 22/01/2012 at 03:16:07
Unless you are prepared to watch the game from a building site, you are obviously going to lose the Bullens Road revenue. It not only cuts down the capacity significantly, it does so across the spectrum of ticket prices.
The rest is the usual voodoo economics and beneath refuting except to say that, at your valuation of the club, you and Colin could buy the club tomorrow by leveraging the transfer value of two players. Thank God it's only worth that in your daydreams. I want what you smoke.
58 Posted 22/01/2012 at 03:28:15
Easily counts as being better run than us. PLUS they have an owner that is capable of finding a purchaser in a lot less time than it's taken our board.
You may lose some revenue from redevelopment of Bullens stand but not for 'many seasons' as your scaremongering post stated. And of course you picked the biggest stand for your example, not the Park End which the experts are recommending be developed first and which can be done without any loss of revenue.
Master of spin indeed!
59 Posted 22/01/2012 at 04:46:55
BTW, I chose Bullens Road but the same problem arises wherever you start to redevelop the stadium. It's actually not hard to understand. Stand closes, Nobody there. Lost revenue.
60 Posted 22/01/2012 at 06:30:04
I really can't let that pass. We are where we are because the club lied to the fans, prevented AGMs from taking place because they didn't want the embarrasement of answering concerns and then tried to threaten fans with legal sanctions for raising concerns on websites.
They have ignored requests for meetings, ignored requests for information, ignored genuine concerns of fans. They have blamed fans, (Ian Ross, Elstone, Kenwright et al) split the fan base .... the list goes on..
The answer does lie in communication of truth and honesty by the club, so to turn it around and say we must change is a bit rich, we are in the mess because of the people who won't talk to us and are hardly believeable when they attempt to.
How many sane and genuine requests have been made and ignored? Why don't the club reinstate AGMs as a vehicle?
Michael, I'm sorry but the time for communication with these guys is long gone. THEY DON"T WANT TO COMMUNICATE. THERE IS NOTHING IN IT FOR THEM! They don't have to... that's the problem.
61 Posted 22/01/2012 at 08:01:34
It's clear from what you say that they are stonewalling you, and the current tactics you are trying aren't changing this...
I dont think for 1 minute it will be an easy task to start a positive open dialogue if the board has gone to ground.
Why don't you speak to an expert in dispute resolution and see if they have any ideas, tactics, or even if they can mediate a meeting? Of course you might have already done this. This is what my trade union mates do in difficult negotiations.
62 Posted 22/01/2012 at 08:22:18
It usually works; it certainly did with Mr Johnson, who on reflection wasn't half as bad as Kenwright!!
63 Posted 22/01/2012 at 08:50:08
One of the reasons for this was to be able to attend AGMs and hear reasonable questions asked in a calm manner by other shareholders and generally attempts made for them to be answered in a similar fashion by the Chairman, executives and the manager. It was generally a nice social occasion and on the first one I went to I think there was supper provided.
I think it helped the club to communicate in a reasonable way with the greater fan base as the details of these AGMs were generally reported in the local media. Changing the rules to stop this great form of communication left me with a feeling from that point onwards that something was being hidden and my generally positive viewpoint of Mr Kenwright up to that point started to decline.
That decline has now continued to the point where I now feel that the current majority shareholding does want to sell but are seeking an unrealistic price. I base this on the fact that no information about the price being sought or the reasons leading to that price we are simply asked to accept an announcement from Mr Elstone that price is not the reason why there has been no sale.
I am not looking for any profit on the price I paid for my share and would happily accept what I paid for my share, or even take a small loss if I thought it would move the club onwards. Surely, if Mr. Kenwright is such a committed Evertonian, he should happily do the same?
64 Posted 22/01/2012 at 08:46:22
Your posts are very well thought out and I commend you for remaining civil despite some provocation. However, to a neutral 'regular' Evertonian such as myself, you do come across as rather blinkered in your defence of the club's valuation.
You see, by putting forward the 'fair' value of players as a defence for a heightened value for the business, you are ignoring three things:
1) That you are effectively valuing the club on a break-up basis since a new owner would have to come in and sell our best players to realise the stated value. This isn't going to happen so unless it's a buyers intention then why value the club in this way?
2) Players are depreciating assets and whilst Fellaini might be worth £15m today, as his contract runs down he's going to be worth nothing. This should be reflected in your valuation for people like Baines, Jagielka etc. You can also add in a 'fire sale' discount if you like.
3) If you are valuing us based on our assets ie, players, then you also need to knock off all of our liabilities, not just the debt. It's a pre-requisite of a net asset valuation unfortunately. A short-cut would be to add in the off-balance sheet assets (eg, Ross Barkley) to the reported net assets (or liabilities in our case).
If you can get anywhere near £45m+ on that then let me know.
You see, whilst your disagreement with the posters on here is worth discussing, all I can see is someone who disagrees with a point of view but has no hard evidence to support his conclusions. You seem to be advocating the 'it just is' defence.
Please correct me if I'm wrong.
65 Posted 22/01/2012 at 11:22:05
66 Posted 22/01/2012 at 11:27:25
The Blue Union are doing a marvellous job of opening the wider public's eyes to what some of us have been banging on about for a decade or more. Good luck to them.
67 Posted 22/01/2012 at 13:08:29
Everton are worth less than Reading??!! Are you having a laugh? We might have debt, but they'd have to spend £100 million to get where we are,and even then there'd be no guarantees.
The only assets we've got left are players,but they are still assets. How many £10 million + players have they got? We've got Baines, Jags, Fellaini, Rodwell, Barkley etc.
To say Reading are worth more than Everton is just silly. Even with a crappy old stadium, we are a top Premier League team. They are probably in their rightful place in the English team pecking order, a Championship side, or relegation fodder for the Premier League at best.
68 Posted 22/01/2012 at 13:18:15
For instance, pay off the debt. Not sure how much this currently is, but it was circa £45 million before we sold off £20 million of players last summer. Pay this off, which may cost £50-60 million, the balance sheet would be £4.5 million better off straightaway, as we would be free of those interest payments. With this and a bit of better housekeeping, we would no longer be a club losing money,we would be a club that breaks even. That would change everyone's perception of us. It's hardly rocket science, is it?
Add a tier onto the Park End, circa £10 million, or £20 million with a hotel etc, this would pay for itself within 5 years.
Buy the training ground, another £15 million. That would save us around £45 million in rent over the next 25 years.
Get the catering and kit deals back in house to maximise profits. Manage the wage bill as well,we can't survive with a wage bill which is 70% of turnover.
Give the manger £50 million for players over the next few years. Not massive investment, but it would see us through.
If we did all this, maybe in 5 years time we'd have repaired all the damage done by this current board. This would cost the new owners around £150 million for a 5-year plan. It would increase revenue, make the debt disappear, we'd have invested in the team. We would have a new asset in the training ground. Then we would be in a much healthier position to think about building a new stadium.
Until then, we should banish any talk about leaving Goodison ? we can't afford it and have already wasted enough looking into it ? and cut our cloth accordingly.
69 Posted 22/01/2012 at 15:02:23
70 Posted 22/01/2012 at 15:13:51
Explains why Bill was so pissed off with people asking him questions last week and why he drunkenly told them that their Blue Union had betrayed the club. He must be more interested in money than in Everton.
The mask slips when he?s angry and you see the real Bill Kenwright. Remember when he snapped at the shareholder who asked him the price? Too many people fall for the stories, don?t forget he?s a changeling; he was a red before he was a blue. Can?t trust anyone like that.
So, from what my friend has said, it looks like the Blue Union are starting to have an effect but they have a long way to go as Bill and his mates want £90m for ¾ of the club, then there?s the debt which my friend said, ?If you think £47M will clear it, you?re a balloon.?
Add that lot up and you can see why we are not being sold. Everton can?t possibly be valued at £160-170M can they?
71 Posted 22/01/2012 at 15:29:50
I personally couldn't support anything that helps prop up the current board.
I'm fairly certain they would find a way to take further advantage of well-meaning Evertonians.
This whole 'club for sale' saga has brought it home to me just how important it is for the fans to have eyes, ears and a voice inside the club. We would not be at the impasse we have reached if that was the case, IMO.
I'd hope TrustEverton would look to accrue enough shares for a representative to gain a seat on the board. If new owners came in who appeared to be in for the long haul, an exchange of equity for assets like Finch Farm could happen?
72 Posted 22/01/2012 at 15:44:20
The club are currently paying an annual rent to ROM Capital, where all profits go to shareholders. Is it not better, for these profits to go to Trust Everton (ie, the fans), who will then re-invest these profits into securing more assets (ie, the stadium).
73 Posted 22/01/2012 at 15:52:56
All fair points and ones in an ordinary situation I would agree with.
Say for instance we bought Goodison for x amount. What happens if Bill finds an enabling partner and his chums get it sneaked through parliament. Were left with a dilapidated bit of land which in Monopoly terms is Old Kent Road.
A significant shareholding and a place on the board would still see us in a position to safeguard these assets, maybe more so.
74 Posted 22/01/2012 at 15:58:00
It's a difficult situation because I recognize that by doing these things we help the club. But we also make it easier for him to retain control.
75 Posted 22/01/2012 at 15:59:23
76 Posted 22/01/2012 at 16:04:02
77 Posted 22/01/2012 at 16:00:11
78 Posted 22/01/2012 at 15:27:59
I would prefer the club to own their own asset. The next best thing would be Trust Everton or someone with our interests effectively becoming our landlord and reinvesting the money earned into the club. To be honest, anything would have to be better than renting long-term. The current deal will end up costing the club £50 million over 30 years,and we'll have nothing to show for it at the end.
I can't help thinking that it is a massively optimistic target though. You'd have to get 30,000 Evertonians to invest £500 each for it to succeed (or some other formula ? 15,000 all putting in a grand etc). It's hard enough trying to get a group of Evertonians to agree on anything, without them having to put their hand in their pocket as well!
I sincerely hope it works. It would be nice to think that some of the ex-players like Big Dunc could make a donation, like Benitez has done to the Hillsborough charity in the past. Some of the other wealthy Evertonians could maybe help out also. This might make the target more achievable. I am in, either way; I will put my money where my mouth is.
It may well be that they struggle to raise the £15 million which would be required to buy Finch Farm. I hope they have a back-up plan if this is the case, because it's an excellent initiative and I hope it succeeds in some form.
What do you think, Tony?
79 Posted 22/01/2012 at 16:28:17
If enough fans complete the survey we will be in a position to demonstrate there is a will to buy Finch Farm from the current owners who are selling it. If this can be achieved, the landlord-tenant relationship will remain on an 'arms length' commercial basis.
80 Posted 22/01/2012 at 16:32:42
81 Posted 22/01/2012 at 16:23:48
"Half a billion" ? hold on, let's say that again, only louder: "HALF A BILLION!!"
I have read some tripe in my time, but this mystical number always makes me cringe.
Let me give you all a number you may understand - £1.24 - that is £ 1.24 MORE than the whole board of EFC have invested of their own personal wealth.
I watched a team yesterday made up of Man U reserves & rejects, too many players over thirty. We are heading for the Championship, and everyone can see it.
We need someone to invest in our club & playing squad now, not in two years, it will be too late. We need investment to stay in the Premier League, forget about new grounds & challenging for the Champions League.
We are now all watching a club crumble before our eyes because of greed & incompetence. This is the result of selling to survive, and you cannot use this model in the Premier League.
We have been extremely lucky with results this season, it's only a matter of time.
82 Posted 22/01/2012 at 16:39:12
83 Posted 22/01/2012 at 16:51:44
I don't think a fairly small parcel of land in one of the most socially deprived areas of Britain would get even a few million quid in the current economic climate (one for the estate agents there).
TrustEverton is a great idea and long, long term I'd love to see us go the German/Barca route. Our club has always been innovators from the time Will Cuff and his mates knocked Goodison up, why shouldn't we do that again and be the first big English club to be part owned by it's fans?
For me that's what will truly ensure the club is still here for future generations.
84 Posted 22/01/2012 at 15:38:23
You both say we should develop the Park End stand. I am no expert in these matters, but was it not the Park End develpoment that recently uncovered the fact that we don't even own the land that the new offices were to be built on? Would that mean that we can't develop that stand as well?
Seems to me that, whichever way we look, we are in the shit.
85 Posted 22/01/2012 at 17:36:11
I don't read the Echo anymore but did you manage to get anything printed in there regarding Trust Everton?
86 Posted 22/01/2012 at 17:42:08
Developing the Park End stand is different in that the club would be the tenants.
How the hell the club thought it could just get a business partner to build on land it had hocked off shows just how amateurishly it is ran, it's like trying to build a house in your neighbour's garden.
87 Posted 23/01/2012 at 00:51:35
88 Posted 23/01/2012 at 01:06:04
Why on earth are people still defending this current board?
When Peter Johnson, who spent money (his own money, I might add, despite being a RedShite) bought top players and won a trophy, was run out of town quicker than a jackrabbit.
But the so-called Blue Bill, who has spent nothing of his own money, lied to fans continuously, cancelled AGMs, ruined the Kings Dock venture, sacked numerous CEOs, alienated fans, sacked off someone who was prepared to put his money in P.Gregg, made a mug out of two managers, sold all the clubs assets, makes an £18M profit on player sales over 12 years, sells all our better players and leaves us with an aging, disillusioned, small squad of players half of which are youth players or loanees.... and people on here and other forums have the crass stupidity to defend or make ridiculous excuses for the current regime, it is unbelievable.
We are in the position we are in because of our failings as fans. For too long we have put up with this shite and are now sadly suffering the consequences. I wrote an article on here entitled "Are the fans to blame" in August 2009; I can't believe nearly 3 years later on we are still discussing our current plight, wake up for christs sakes.
89 Posted 23/01/2012 at 01:34:48
90 Posted 23/01/2012 at 01:45:58
They'd soon have enough to buy Finch Farm then.
91 Posted 23/01/2012 at 01:58:27
How much was Wayne "wouldn't sell him for £50 million" Rooney actually bought for?
And when we've sold all our £10 million players who is going to go out onto the pitch and play?
We would for certain be at the same level as Reading then.
92 Posted 23/01/2012 at 05:16:25
93 Posted 23/01/2012 at 07:31:26
Now your latest 'fact' is "we would be vulnerable to financial predators and not get the long term investment we need." Care to explain how you arrived at this because I find it laughable considering that the current board have never put their hands in their pockets or even had a plan to provide long term development.
94 Posted 23/01/2012 at 09:29:57
We'll have to put this discussion into the 'agree to disagree' category.
You seem to be advocating The Board keeping the price artificially high to protect us from those nasty financiers.
I can't realy argue with that.
95 Posted 23/01/2012 at 10:03:10
You obviously are totally against the BU regardless.
Maybe when we're on the bus travelling through to Barnsley or Port Vale in the future - if we're lucky!! - you may give them a bit of credit for maybe, possibly, being right.
The longer people continue to champion the status quo the more danger the club get in.
96 Posted 23/01/2012 at 10:54:47
Which of these players would not be worth more than £10 million then? We've got Baines, Jags, Fellaini, Rodwell, Barkley etc.
They are the players that I mentioned, and I stand by the opinion that they would all fetch over £10 million, regardless of if we are skint or not.
I am not advocating selling them, but they are still valuable assets to the football club and that needs to be taken into account when valuing us. Our assets (mainly players I agree) need to be weighed up along with the debts, then surely our true value can be calculated using those figures...
97 Posted 23/01/2012 at 23:14:32
I can thoroughly understand why you?re annoyed at being called naive, so I guess you?re going to be completely livid when I explain that you?re not only naive but that you?re totally ignorant of the true situation Evertonians and Everton are actually in.
First of all I don?t ?take every point of view and twist it around to work to my agenda? I have simply taken what you have said and stated that you?re naive possibly on the basis you haven?t a clue what you?re talking about; here?s an example, ?You have to work with, and not against, the current owners if you want change to occur.? On this point I?ve said I agree with you in principle, as I have with others; but the reality this is never going to happen; allow me....
My knowledge of these people comes from personal experience, not what I read on fora or in the media. These are the people who told Evertonians that Everton were going to receive £52m from Tesco towards the cost of a stadium when they knew full well that this wasn?t the case; that?s right, it was a lie and Tesco was never going to give Everton a penny.
They were caught red handed; they were lying to their fans. Tesco admitted where the £52m value was coming from and so did Knowsley Council, it was an uplift in the value of the land which was being transferred to the £78m stadium; however, to this day, Everton employees deny this was the case despite the media and the secretary of state confirming that it was in fact true.
The comments made by Stephen Sauvain QC when cross-examining Knowsley?s CEO were widely reported; he called it, ?a ?miracle of modern economics? and it was further reported, ?Stephen Sauvain was cross- examining Knowsley Council?s chief executive, Sheena Ramsey, about exactly where this additional finance was coming from at the public inquiry into the scheme. Mr Sauvain repeatedly attempted to tie down the link between the profits from the proposed sale of the land in Kirkby and the £52m extra the club needs to build an all-new ground, in addition to its own contribution of £78m. Ms Ramsey said: ?Tesco will fund the £52m through the increase in the value of the land brought about through the development.?
What in fact was happening was that the £52m would have appeared on the Everton balance sheet which the directors would have taken advantage of via a sale. Of course, for a privately owned business to be in receipt of money derived from the public purse is a serious issue, so of course, once again, they had to lie to the Secretary of State and say their shares were not for sale, despite Bill Kenwright, just months earlier, telling shareholders at the September 2008 EGM, ?I?m saying the club is up for sale, My shares have been up for sale since the day I bought the club.?
After Kirkby, in my opinion, Bill Kenwright should have been run out of Goodison. He?d betrayed the fans and the club, but sadly too many people fell for the same old stories and the paid employees know where their salaries come from.
This wasn?t the first time and it won?t be the last of course; let?s not forget about the phony investor paraded in front of the shareholders, the one that Kenwright?s spin doctor later revealed was a means to an end, the one Paul Gregg is on tape saying he?d never heard of the bloke. And let?s not forget about the £3,000 in cash Bill Kenwright gave to the GFE to get rid of Paul Gregg; I could be here all day, I think that lot is enough to be going on with.
The fact is Michael, the fans are treated with contempt, they always have been and still are; look at the plans they were making against legitimate protestors that were highlighted in those leaked emails. All this talk about openness and communication is rubbish. It?s nothing but lip service and only a complete fool would think otherwise. These are the people you want to sit down with and have genuine and meaningful discussions?
You don?t what you?re dealing with here. The only way Bill Kenwright can make peace with the fans is to hold a meeting, record the lot and apologise for everything he has done. That?s not going to happen but I tell you what is, the many people who have phoned and emailed me today saying, after Saturday, ?that?s enough I?m not going until the whole lot have gone?.
You may feel that you have allies in James and Peter; you feel comforted by the fact their ignorance of the situation is on a par with your own. This suggested figure of £500m which you?re so comfortable with, you think that somebody is going to spend a portion of that on players and subsidise their wages do you? You think that anybody is going to pay what Kenwright is asking, pay to rectify his cock-ups and then hope to get a ROI?
You?ve never heard of the financial fair play regulations? The regulations that have been adopted by the Premier League and a version of which is being adopted by the Championship; regulations that are now in force as the 2012 accounts will be scrutinised as part of the three year amnesty. Why do you think City and Liverpool have announced record sponsorship deals, why did the owners of City and Chelsea capitalise their loans for their 2010 accounts?
Alternately, do you think somebody will just spend a major portion on a new stadium? There?s always a first time I suppose, nobody else has just handed over a big wedge to built a new stadium in the Premiership but it is exempt from FFP regulations. What do you think? I think no chance.
Perhaps it could be a magic stadium that you could build anywhere you happen to find 12 acres? Let?s forget the 35 sites Everton has examined and concluded that all were unsuitable, let?s forget about planning regulations and the need to comply with strict and enforceable government targets like modal share requirements, let?s forget about the need to cooperate with the local council who you?ll need on your side; again I could go on but you clearly don?t appreciate the complexity of building a stadium in a location that suits all parties needs.
There is a solution and it will be staring the new owner in the face and, in my humble opinion, it happens to be the best solution, the most cost effective and the only solution at present which complies with all the criteria listed above. I?m not an expert on these things but I do know a man who is; I?m not certain who Peter takes his advice from; maybe he knows somebody who works for Tesco....maybe it?s more likely to be Woolworths or Ritchies ;-)
Now, obviously, I have little or no understanding of finance or business operations, as you put it, but as a person who understands these things, maybe you can propose a more realistic proposition than the text book one.
Perhaps, as you suggest, I may have no finance or business knowledge to speak of, but I will offer you an assessment of the situation which no doubt your superior business knowledge will see the flaw in immediately.
My own view is that there are four elements to consider, Kenwright?s profit, the debt, the money required to address the stadium situation and the money required to address the chronic underinvestment in the squad. Three of these are more essential the other and that one isn?t important for the future wellbeing of the club.
I?d hazard a guess that Bill?s even more livid than you because as Barry Jones said he?s been forced to begin reducing his price.
Have another go.
98 Posted 23/01/2012 at 23:30:20
What on earth are you on about, "long term investment?" what long term investment exactly has this board put in? If this elite league delivers significant earnings and our assets are our players, then we're up shit creek without a paddle! "Protect this club from Financial Predators" Good God almighty.
This club needs protecting from the ego maniac and his masters who killing our club. This man has been in control of this club for what 10years or so. In that time we haver seen a world class site for a stadium go floating off down the Mersey. Why, because in my humble opinion, he knew that Gregg would have him shifted for the useless job he was, and is, making of guiding our club with any vision, any plan or any hope.
We''ve seen any asset, other than this bunch of world class superstars, sold off until we don't have the proverbial pot to piss in.
If an asset stripper wants to come and strip our club, then he/they will have to put some assets in first. This crew should only be selling for what they put into the club less a percentage paid to the fans for the long suffering torment of seeing our club going to the wall, for that's what I fear is happening. The likes of Blue Union are good people who are asking a number of extremely valid questions and calling for a fair way forward, in my view.
Personally, I think it's too late. By the summer we will have an even older and smaller squad, with little chance to build a new team, even if Moyes was capable of doing so, I think he's lost heart.
So I fundamentally disagree with your "facts" as I don't see them as facts. I just see you positing some quasi business speak as though it was the only formula around to do the business of salvaging our club. "Financial Predators" if only!
99 Posted 23/01/2012 at 23:54:21
100 Posted 24/01/2012 at 01:22:27
you?re thinking of the value of players if the current owners were to sell them off one by one but they would not be considered a saleable asset to a new owner because he is not going to asset strip the Club to recover his investment. If he did he would have no players left and therefore no team and no investment.
For any player a new owner sells he has to buy another as a replacement as we have such a bare bones squad, so you have to take the value of the replacement from your valuation of a players worth. Would you like the new owners to buy worse players than we have now or better players? Better players cost more.
Also, you have to take into account the amount of time left on the players contract, remember when their contract expires they are worth nothing. And what happens if one of your £10 million assets gets injured? (Fellaini only spends half a season playing) he?s not like a machine that you could sell for scrap value and recover some money, and you still have to pay him his full salary as well as spend money getting him repaired.
It?s like trying to sell your house fully furnished and adding the new cost of all the furniture you bought 10 years ago to the price, or adding the cost of the new engine to the price of your car. A purchaser isn?t interested in paying over the odds because YOU think that?s what it?s worth.
101 Posted 24/01/2012 at 08:45:04
Without realising it, you're actually arguing the same thing as everyone else.
You see, the debt, the amount that hasn't been invested in the stadium, the amount that is required for the playing squad, all the other things that add up to £500m; these are all things that will be taken into account when calculating the amount someone will want to pay for the shares.
How do you think debt, ageing stadium, under-invested squad, poor commercial revenues etc etc are going to affect purchase price?
Well, it won't make it higher, I can tell you that for free.
102 Posted 24/01/2012 at 10:41:06
103 Posted 24/01/2012 at 10:57:07
104 Posted 24/01/2012 at 11:13:35
105 Posted 24/01/2012 at 11:30:43
Neither of which would cost any new owner anywhere near the sort of figures some people are quoting.
106 Posted 24/01/2012 at 15:55:22
107 Posted 24/01/2012 at 17:00:19
The BU have forced Kenwright onto the back foot.
I truly believe had they not formed this pressure group the inadequacies and lies of the board which were so blatantly highlighted during the Kirkby inquiry and at other times, would have slowly melted into the past.The PR and spin of the club would have seen to that big time.
At this present time and until someone, such as yourself, comes up with alternatives, then we only have the pressure and ideas being exerted by the BU.
The past has shown us that Kenwright and his cronies are not condusive to open debate. If you think I am wrong I would ask you to approach the club and ask the questions that you want answers too.
I really think you are being harsh on the BU. They have come a very long way in a relatively short period of time.
They have to be given time and the opportunity to tweak their proposals to suit changing circumstances.
If there was unlimited time then maybe your criticism of them may be acceptable but lets be honest I don't think we have a lot of time.
I know you have been asked to meet the guys at the BU and I would urge you to accept that offer.
Possibly a bit of a face to face might clear some issues you obviously have.
I have been to a couple of their meetings and I can assure you every person is a true concerned supporter. I am positive that anyone, including yourself, who have ideas that can enhance and move change forward would be more than welcome.
108 Posted 24/01/2012 at 17:33:18
109 Posted 24/01/2012 at 18:25:55
110 Posted 24/01/2012 at 19:39:10
111 Posted 24/01/2012 at 20:12:04
112 Posted 24/01/2012 at 23:12:19
Let?s say Newco is prepared to invest in a phased redevelopment of Goodison Park which the city council is prepared to support and facilitate. [Yes they really are because, unlike the useless incumbents, some fans got off their arses and actually did something to get the club out of the mess they?re in]
Newco is also prepared to pay off £27m of debt, which immediately releases approx £3.5m. They decide it?s not cost effective to pay off the remainder of the £30m prudential loan as the penalty charge would mean the true debt of the club would be in the region of £67m.
To address the chronic underinvestment in the squad, Newco commit to provide a transfer budget over a three year period comprising of at least £30m in the first, £20m in the second and £10m in the third.
Newco bring with them new sponsors, Everton?s new domestic shirt sponsors, Qatar Petroleum, pay £125m for a 5 year deal and European sponsors, Al Jazeera, pay £50m over a similar period.
The first phase of the infrastructure improvement begins; a £35m redevelopment of the Park End which includes a second tier, corporate boxes, a hotel and conference centre all encompassed in an innovative design that allows for 365 a year operation and a unique matchday experience to Evertonians seated in this stand. The prudential don?t object as it is Everton who own the development unlike the proposed Williams Tarr development which was akin to building an extension on a council house.
Outsourcing contracts are dispensed with and professional managers from the retail and catering industries are employed to oversee the increase in profits from a club on its way up.
Better players and evidence that the club is actually going somewhere brings back the crowds and further improves the revenue streams.
Over the next three years the second, third and final stages of the redevelopment are completed through a combination of increased cashflows, debt and equity.
After five years Newco are the proud owners of a high flying Premiership team who not only have a great history but have a great future. They?ve ?invested? £200m in the running of the club, the infrastructure and the squad. They now have a stadium valued at £200m, a competitive squad and a thriving business with a positive balance sheet.
They sell the club for £350m to an Australian plutonium billionaire who decided that he?d buy it after bumping into Peter Fearon in a bar in the outback who convinced him that after St Bill had laid the foundations Newco had come along and finished off his vision.
Of course this is all fantasy, I?m not saying this is going to happen or that this is the best way to rectify the problems but??? http://www.soccerissue.com/2012/01/23/is-the-qatari-money-on-its-way-to-england/
The one thing that will definitely stop things happening is the asking price for the shares Bill represents, £110m. Nobody in their right mind would pay that for the privilege of pumping in even more money to rectify the problems they failed to address in over twelve years of ownership. New owners will need to see a way to obtain a ROI.
The problem for everyone is obvious; it?s the people who have wiped over £55m from the balance sheet of the club whilst the net debt has more than doubled to £47m [?], it?s the people who have disposed of all the assets or mortgaged what is left, it?s the people who have wasted millions on abortive stadium relocation schemes and have presided over accumulative losses of more than £54m which were only limited through the sale of inherited assets such as Rooney, Dunne, Jeffers and Bellefield - and now they want a reward for this incompetence? Laughable.
113 Posted 25/01/2012 at 01:06:20
When you are purchasing a house and you see it is in a poor state, needs a new kitchen, woodwork needs repainting, garden in a mess, then you would consider the cost of rectifying this neglect and knock it off the asking price.
It's the same with selling the Club.
114 Posted 25/01/2012 at 04:11:22
That is why your efforts, laudable though they are in principle, will never succeed because they are informed by hostility and thrive on destruction. At a time when fans need to be united you divide. At a time when we need inspiration you stoke the fires of despair.
Incidentally, if only it was as simple as getting £175M in shirt sponsorship! Currently the entire shirt sponsorship for the whole Premiership is £117.5M. (Excluding Utd's £40M training kit deal) Manchester City's shirt deal is £20M and some say that is economically indefensible. So the chances of a £175M deal over five years seems remote. But hey, why worry about keeping the numbers in the real world? You have your bigotry to keep you warm.
115 Posted 25/01/2012 at 05:31:22
116 Posted 25/01/2012 at 06:13:05
Or maybe he was specifically referring to Dick and not you?
117 Posted 25/01/2012 at 06:15:56
118 Posted 25/01/2012 at 10:56:11
I'll agree that we disagree on a few items, but I bet we'd agree on a whole lot more. It was nice to get the reaction from you though.... Got you back :)
I appreciate that you have had dealings with these guys and have been thoroughly frustrated. Yes you are right I haven't, so I can't talk directly to that,
Finance and also dispute resolution (yes I know strange combination but explains why i have friends who are ceo's of banks and play indoor futsal with my mates who are heads of the trade unions... Never invite them both to your wedding again!) are two of my specialities that make up my normal work day. Therefore, I look at the issue through my eyes. That is : 1. What amount of money is required to execute the strategy, 2. What is the risk of that finance, 3. How do we deal with the parties involved.
From my analysis, this is: 1. A lot, 2. Museum to high, 3. Difficult.
It seems your only disagreement with me is the money? The risk can't be questioned in the industry (enter Portsmouth e ample)! And you are under no illusion about the difficulty in dealing with the people involved.
I can't say I know much about the Kirkby and Tesco or Kings Dock fiasco. From a people point of view I just know that if the BU keep bagging the Evwrton board then they will go further to ground. If the BU want change they have to deal with the board as they hold the cards, and it's a lot of money needed to get us on a level playing field so as to compete.
I see risk in Everton getting a sugar daddy, and would like to see some "outside the box" thinking on how the clubs make money.
If I really analyze your posts I don't see much difference between you, me and many others. More I see general agreement that there has to be a better way, just we can't agree on what it is and what it costs. I hate to use a cliche (thats a lie) the people 'united'....... Etc.
119 Posted 25/01/2012 at 11:50:45
First of all I don't hate Bill Kenwright as you put it. I'm offended that he believes I'll believe all the stories he comes out with; a mild irritation at best I?d say. I'll reserve my hatred for something worthwhile, racism, poverty, hunger; things that everyone really should hate.
I don?t believe my opinion on how the club has ended up in this mess are ?informed by hostility? whatever that means. My opinion has been formed by observation, which, if I choose to present, I attempt to substantiate with facts such as when I earlier responded to Michael and explained what happened when Bill Kenwright attempted to sell the club down the river for £50m the modern equivalent, in my opinion, to thirty pieces of silver because I believe Bill Kenwright is Everton?s Judas Iscariot.
I did say at the end of my post that you refer to that it was a fantasy, but my fantasy has some semblance of truth. I think you need to read this,
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/football/article-1379466/Liverpools-mammoth-25m-year-Warrior-kit-deal-rewrites-record-books.html
Then understand that rather interestingly Spurs identified an opportunity to sell their presence in the Premiership separately to that in cup competitions and then duly announced a deal with Investec . You see that?s the difference, Spurs GET money from Investec whilst we GIVE Investec money.
My premise was that new owners can bring with them potential sponsors; you yourself have mentioned City to which I've added Liverpool, whose recent shirt deal with Boston based Warrior can?t be a coincidence for New England based owners of Liverpool who also own Boston Red Sox whose shirt suppliers are?..
Peter, your obsession with the Blue Union brings you substantial criticism on Toffeeweb. I actually applaud your tenacity and look forward to all your misunderstanding, that you post, as I know for a fact that when people read all the responses they begin to realise that Bill Kenwright is undoubtedly a prime candidate for the worst chairman Everton Football Club has ever had the misfortune to have.
The fans are united Peter, they're united in the belief that there needs to be a change; you, and people of your ilk, cannot understand the reasons behind why this change has not happened so you huff and puff on here and other internet sites; maybe it?s a Freudian demonstration of inadequacy? Who really knows why you feel the need to constantly go against the majority and be ridiculed; maybe a fetish of yours? If you want to make an omelette Peter you need to break a few eggs.
To clear up your obvious confusion I keep asking you to meet at the game, I?ve done so on three or four occasions now but you?ve ignored me. You accuse me of creating a divide but when I attempt integration you ignore my response hence my intimation that you must live in the back of beyond. Whose being divisive again?
At least your posts on here are consistent; consistently wrong. Whilst you obviously read people?s replies to your ramblings you never appear to understand them. Your shirt deal response was a prime example; try to look before you leap would be my advice.
Fulham? City?
120 Posted 25/01/2012 at 12:53:54
No Michael we wouldn?t end up having a scrap at all. I?m a lover not a fighter, in the physical sense at least I couldn?t fight my way out of a wet paper bag, but true to the common Liverpool trait, I don?t mind a good argument!
I could see you?re a bit of a mediator Michael from your posts and there?s nothing wrong with that; you?re looking for some common ground to move the whole mess forward and, as I said before, I agree with you as I did with Alan Williams, but like you said you?re unfamiliar with the Kirkby and Kings Dock fiascos so probably best to read up on them, particularly Kirkby, before you formulate an opinion on whether the board and the fans can make headway.
Everton are great at doing all the fluffy fan engagement stuff but when it comes down to the real issues they?re not interested in what the fans may or may not say. That?s not an opinion that?s a fact. It?s a fact that they stopped the AGM?s when they became too uncomfortable for them and changed the articles of association to make it more difficult to call an EGM. Forced to have a fan forum they hand selected the members, installed an employee as the chair and decide on the agenda of their meetings and produce their own minutes. That?s not what UEFA intended and they know it.
There are some very good people at Everton and I?ve met them, but they all suffer as a consequence of firstly having to work for a club that is now based on deceit and secondly suffer the criticisms from the fans for having to defend the instigators of that deceit. Eventually they follow the path of least resistance and comply with those who pay their wages.
It will be difficult for the board to go deeper underground when they're exposed for what they are. It saddens me that they can't understand that the games up, the bullshit no longer works and that they haven't the decency and dignity to do the right thing after beinging the club to its knees. Who in their right mind could trust this board, with their track record, to sell the club to the right buyer for US. A guy in a one bedroom flat surely killed off any hope of that ever happening.
You?re right when you say that there?s not much difference of opinion amongst many and you?ll know that to solve a problem you need to identify its root cause and not be distracted by its symptoms.
121 Posted 25/01/2012 at 13:32:44
Blue Union have become the itch that Kenwright cannot scratch, the power of the internet and the ability to communicate on forums such as this ensures freedom of speech and the opportunity for the truth to be out.
122 Posted 25/01/2012 at 13:46:00
123 Posted 25/01/2012 at 15:54:28
Not just me but everyone on these threads who deviate from your own authoritarian point of view is excoriated with gratuitous venom and abuse, all with the same affable veneer. Your last effort was very provocative. The irony is that you have more in common with BK than you think. You both have an overwhelming need to be right. You both have a pathological need to be admired. Neither of you can brook any opposition. Neither of you know fact from fantasy. And both of you are damaging Everton. BK more so of course, but then he's had more opportunity. I support the justifiable protests of Evertonians. It's so unfortunate they are so ill led.
124 Posted 25/01/2012 at 17:18:23
You can ask anybody on here who knows me; I never shout in pubs, I?ve never been on a picket line, the only protest I?ve been on are the Blue Union demo?s and I?ve been as quiet as a church mouse and at business meetings I have so far survived by using my wit so I have no need to shout there either. I have like all people many failings, one of them being I do not suffer fools. I guess you know where this is going......
Thanks for the comparison with Bill, as a person I quite admire him; he?s just shite at running Everton.
You?ll never meet me Peter because you?re nothing but an Internet warrior, easily identified by posting shite and constantly ruining threads because you have nothing to say of any value. I have no problem with that, all Internet warriors are spineless and are nothing but a minor irritation.
Have a nice night; I think LFC are on the TV.
125 Posted 25/01/2012 at 17:30:28
You will never know how riduculous your personal attack in your last post was because you have stated that you will never meet Colin. Not confronting the absurdity of such false accusations might be the greatest kindness that you can do for yourself , I suppose - you'll be mortified if/when you ever meet him!
It would appear to be you who has the personality issues. Prove me wrong - meet him at the match - you choose the venue..hey, I'll buy the drinks - perhaps the prospect of a freebie might encourage you to show up?
Peace and Love ;>)
Mark
126 Posted 25/01/2012 at 17:56:18
A totally unnecessary response and completely out of order.
127 Posted 25/01/2012 at 19:31:08
128 Posted 25/01/2012 at 20:38:56
Ah well, if disagreeing with you constitutes a "personal attack" then no doubt I have just committed the same crime. Clearly I'll have to work on some new guidelines as the goalposts are moving on a daily basis!
129 Posted 25/01/2012 at 20:59:06
130 Posted 26/01/2012 at 13:55:36
You certainly are an embarrassment. You?ve been playing the attention seeking victim to perfection for weeks. You post shite to attract attention and then start to cry and plead that you?re being victimised when the inevitable backlash for those posts begins to tell.
I genuinely can?t remember an article or post you?ve made that hasn?t brought the majority of people down upon you. Strangely you appear to revel in it.
You?re not being bullied, you?re being put straight, by the vast majority, over the shite that you post and because you don?t like it you?re screaming like a little girl. You?re not even man enough to meet face to face.
Rather disgracefully, In the 18th century people used to go to Bedlam to stare at the lunatics. For a penny one could peer into their cells, view the freaks of the "show of Bethlehem" and laugh at their antics. Thankfully times have changed; we now have the Internet for that. ;-)
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 20/01/2012 at 23:02:44