Samuelson coy over FSF collapse

, 24 January, 19comments  |  Jump to most recent

Seven years after the proposed Fortress Sports Fund investment in Everton fell through, its proprietor, Chris Samuelson, is on the verge of brokering the takeover of an English club... ironically on behalf of Anton Zingarovich, another supposed investor in the Club trumpeted by Bill Kenwright but whose interest was denied almost as quickly as it had apparently developed.

Samuelson facilitated Thames Sports Investment's 51% takeover of Reading FC on behalf of Zingarovich, the wealthy son of Russian paper magnate Boris, which is expected to be concluded shortly after Sir John Madejski agreed the sale this past weekend.

The Geneva-based financier looked all set to purchase a 29.9% stake in Everton in December 2004 via the Brunei-based FSF, with Bill Kenwright promising at one point that the funds would be "in the club's bank account within 48 hours". The transaction was never completed, however, and, despite being pressed on the matter, no official explanation was ever provided by the Everton hierarchy.

Former Communications Director, Ian Ross, is reputed to have admitted to a shareholder at an Annual General Meeting a couple of years ago, however, that the FSF had been a "means to an end" to force then director, Paul Gregg, off the Goodison Board.

Whatever the reason, Samuelson was not prepared to provide it when asked today about his failed investment in Everton.

"There was a very good reason why we withdrew from the transaction with Everton," Samuelson says. "I'm not going to go into it here. It's confidential between me and Bill Kenwright."

Quotes or other material sourced from Via SOS1878.co.uk



Reader Comments (19)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


John Roberts
1 Posted 24/01/2012 at 20:08:04
Another one Bill and his muppets have paid for his silence!!
Stephen Leary
2 Posted 24/01/2012 at 20:23:29
Prob didint have 160 mill
Phil Martin
3 Posted 24/01/2012 at 20:23:26
"There was a very good reason why we withdrew from the transaction with Everton."

Because Bill was being a twat?
Peter Laing
4 Posted 24/01/2012 at 20:34:02
Because Kenwright used the FSF as a front to head off his arch enemy and old friend Paul Gregg. What amazes me is that a guy who name-drops his friends including Philip Green, Amanda Staveley et al is still seeking a buyer more than 10 years on. The whole chronicle of the Kenwright years needs to be told, the pages of lies, deceit and spin would turn into chapter after chapter. Insight from the likes of Gregg, Wyness, Birch and most recently Ross would make for interesting reading. The Blue Union need to keep the momentum going that has built in recent months, Kenwright out !
Steve Guy
5 Posted 24/01/2012 at 20:52:53
You have to wonder don't you ? Samuelson took a lot of stick then and since for being what appeared to be a "charlatan" and time waster. Blue Bill came out of that one lily white and with his repuation as a True Blue enhanced by what was seen as his being let down by others. BU do need to keep the momentum (meeting tomorrow ?) but I'm not expecting the truth to ever come out. I just wish he was gone.
Aodhan O'Faolain
6 Posted 24/01/2012 at 21:06:26
Its hard to know who has what. All I can say is if a Carson Yeung or Venkys type investor came in everyone would be singing for joy and talking about great days to come.
I am not a huge fan of Bk and his constant excuses but rather the devil you know that a ex hairdresser whose cash came from money laundering or some indian firm whose wealth is based only on artifican property prices in downtown Mumbai. Maybe Paul McCartney will buy Everton!
Chris Wright
7 Posted 24/01/2012 at 21:28:27
Aodhan-We have our Venky's, Carson Yeung, Peter Ridsdale, Portsmouth or hearts type owners. No money invested, debts built up, assets sold, poor business plan. The difference is our's is supposed to be one of our own. Or maybe he's just a puppet having his strings pulled? If Kenwright was not an Everton 'fan' and played on that (misplaced) loyalty he would have been run out of town a longtime ago.
Phil Martin
8 Posted 24/01/2012 at 21:28:38
Aodhan,

on the contrary...if "a Carston Yeung or Venkys type investor" bought Everton and sold all our assets, increased our net liabilities to an all time high, reduced our transfer warchest to one first team purchase every 3 years, fucked up 2 stadium moves, lied about Goodison being condemed, would we still be using phrases like "better the devil you know"?
Steve Pugh
9 Posted 24/01/2012 at 21:46:24
The only difference with Kenwright is that he has shafted the club slowly so that it wasn't as noticeable until it was to late.
Paddy Howlin
10 Posted 24/01/2012 at 22:06:05
Probably because Bill insisted on keeping overall control and would not allow anyone (regardless of how much money they were prepared to 'invest') have a say in how the club should be run or reap the rewards of his £160m pension plan at a later date.

The whole Fortress Sports Fund fiasco sums up Kenwright's reign in a nutshell. A potential opportunity to bring investment in to the club at a time we could have pushed on from 4th place and challenged for honours, lost. Probably due to a personal agenda and a reluctance to have an ?outsider? have a say on how the club could be run. Thanks to a strong league position at the time, nobody decided to press the chairman on the 'money will be in the account in 48 hours' promise. One in a long catalogue of broken promises/naïve statements or lies - depending on what your stand point is with BK and his motley crew. I suppose such sound-bites are ok, when everything on the pitch is looking rosy?

Overall since 1999, Kenwright has been a very fortunate chairman. Fortunate that Liverpool have failed to be as dominant as they once were. Fortunate to obtain the services of a manager who has bailed him out time and again for the majority of his ten year tenure. Where Kenwright has been most fortunate however, has been mainly down to the fact that our supporter base is in the main lethargic and seems prepared to swallow the broken promises and gross mismanagement of the club. As a result the majority of our fan base has had its ambition or expectation of challenging for trophies or just expecting to see good, entertaining football knocked out of them. The silence after the end of the Blackburn game demonstrated to me how beaten our fan base has become. 20-30 years ago, do you think Kenwright or Moyes would have been allowed to leave the ground after a season of rank home performances or signs of signing new players to overcome the problem without visible or audible displeasure from those in attendance? It is sad to see how fragmented our supporter base has become, to the point where we don?t know how to air our displeasure at the gross mismanagement of OUR club.

The one bright side in an otherwise dismal season is that Kenwright's luck is quickly running out. From the incoherent interview with BU in August to his senior executive team having their ?dirty laundry? e-mails leaked from an alleged internal source, momentum is growing that Kenwright is not fit to stay in control of the club. His main defence, the one thing that has stopped the majority of the fan base turning on him, David Moyes, has now clearly ran out of ideas and looks defeated and tactically limited with the resources he has at has left to his disposal. As the results and performances continue to disappoint, the pressure and tipping point will finally come. Sooner or later (probably when Everton fall in to the bottom three at the end of March) the media will start to question why the club have been allowed to stagnate in to such a precarious position. Sadly I fear it will be too late by then, and I wonder how many of those who inexplicably clapped BK on the Jumbotron against Villa, will be protesting in vain?

The ?be careful what you wish for? argument is now starting to wear very thin now, as under the current regime we are closer to the abyss than ever before. If we survive this year (a big if on current form) but nothing changes in the summer, then next year an aging Everton squad will face the biggest battle for survival since 1998. Something has to change, plain and simple. For me it starts with the Chairman, but is looking increasingly like after ten years, it?s time for Moyes to move on too.
Matt Garen
11 Posted 24/01/2012 at 23:27:40
I'm a Moyes supporter but to be honest, Paddy Howlin, you my friend are spot on there!
Gary Shaw
12 Posted 24/01/2012 at 23:18:44
The FSF saga would have even enough to finish most chairmen at any other club. The Kings Dock would have been another situation that most other club owners would have trouble getting out of. Not to mention Kirkby and the subsequent enquiry, AGMs or lack thereof! We can all reel off our infamous list of failures and fuck-ups perpetrated by our "True Blue" chairman and his cronies!

Every single one of these incidents will certainly have contributed to our downward spiral from European hopefuls to relegation fodder in less than 3 years. Admittedly, not directly, but in some 6 degrees of Kevin Bacon way, they have not helped our cause of trying to compete at the business end of the Premier League.

David Moyes battled well for 8 or so years until the Cup Final defeat to Chelsea and then the sale of Lescott to City at the start of the 2009-10 Season.
Gareth Fieldstead
13 Posted 24/01/2012 at 22:28:14
Superb, Paddy... I only wish I had your optimism that the end is nigh for our Blue Chairman. I just don't think it is just him that is demanding the inflated price that has been rumoured. Even if he resigned, you still have the other 3 or 4 still wanting their profit. We could easily end up with the same scenario as we had in 98 with Johnson when they were hardly queuing up to buy us then either.

I also would like to see Moyes leave to be honest, I just think the guy has ran out of ideas and again, if rumours are true and we are looking at a loss of around 6 million on Bily, then quite frankly I wouldn't trust him with what little we do have.

He has made a decent profit on just four players since he has been at the club: Lescott, Beckford (for the fact we got him on a free), Arteta and McFadden. I don't include Rooney simply because he was already at the club and Moyes had little role in his development before his acrimonious departure.

Then compare to the players he has lost money on Radzinski, Davies, Yakubu, Wright, Krøldrup, Bily, Beattie, Yobo and Valente, £36 million that we could ill-afford to waste. Sadly it will take a genuine relegation fight for anything to change and I don't think this group of players have the fight to get us out of it.

I honestly hope Moyes walks as surely the press will genuinely then take notice. Good luck Blue Union.
Russell Buckley
14 Posted 25/01/2012 at 03:02:16
Everton would be headline news again if Moyes walked.

The thing is from every impression he has ever given me I think he would only step aside if we went down. If we were relegated I think Bill would still have faith in Moyes but sack him to appease the fan base.

I don't see us going down this year. I don't see Moyes walking in the near future and I don't see Kenwright sacking his favourite lap dog.

Even if Kenwright did sack Moyes the call on who relaces him is still Bill's to make. He may have found a manager who kept us battling well last time but considering his track record as chairman who here would have any confidence in him making a new appointment.
Peter Barry
15 Posted 25/01/2012 at 03:53:35
He's not called Billy Liar for nothing.
Tim Marchant
16 Posted 25/01/2012 at 14:11:20
He feeds the current hysteria by dropping a few veiled references that this could be BK's fault then stands back and watches the fireworks.
Chris Matheson
17 Posted 25/01/2012 at 17:15:10
Paddy that was a good comment. Spot on, son.

However none of this makes any clearer WHY FSF pulled out. Maybe there are confidentiality deals but wouldn't he be better saying nothing than telling us all he's got this great secret but he can't tell us what it is?



We have two chief Execs walking away in mysterious circumstances saying nothing. We have this possible back walking away saying nothing. There are those emails, briefly published on this site, saying how difficult the club are to deal with. None of this is a smoking gun but the circumstantial evidence really has built up.

Apropos of nothing much else, that picture at the top looks like the baddie out of Robocop.
David Israel
18 Posted 25/01/2012 at 18:13:47
To be honest, and having been a great fan of David Moyes, I'm also getting fed up. One thing is not being able to challenge for a top League spot or one of the cups; quite another is being incapable of beating just about every relegation-fighting side at Goodison Park.

Still, and as pointed out above, the decision to replace him would fall to BK and the mind boggles as to whom he would be able to convince to join his Costa Concordia.
Marc Williams
19 Posted 25/01/2012 at 20:58:08
Bill Kenwright productions brings you ....
"SECRETS & LIES" a new tale of intrigue & self interest set in 2004.

What the critic's say about this new production, effectivly Fortress Sports Fund, the musical....

" I was on the edge of my seat waiting to see if the cheque really would be banked in the morning"

"A story of hope, dashed on the rocks of deceit...heartrending"

"You'll laugh at the studitity of it all & the songs weren't bad either"

"The most emotional final scene since BLOOD BROTHERS. I cried tears of despair as the dream finally died"

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads