Third Blue Union Public Meeting Tonight

, 25 January, 34comments  |  Jump to most recent
Strategy Meeting at The Casa, 7pm
Following a successful series of planned demonstrations and meetings, The Blue Union, a consortium of like minded Everton fan groups, are now holding a strategy meeting that will allow their supporters the opportunity to express their concerns over the current plight of Everton Football Club and participate in deciding the future strategy of The Blue Union in the coming months. It's at The Casa, 29 Hope St, Liverpool. L1 9BQ. 7pm on Wednesday 25th January 2012.

There will be a live blog during the meeting — fans can pose questions to davekelly@goodisonpark.com until 18:00 today and blueunion@goodisonpark.com during the meeting, or follow along live at SOS1878.co.uk.

Invited speakers are Everton's Fan Liaison Officer, Graeme Sharp and Echo Sports Editor, John Thompson.

The Blue Union's last meeting saw 700 fans listen to a financial presentation that outlined the current situation and gave a highly accurate forecast of the next accounts which were subsequently released almost three months later.

The Blue Union's proposal is simple; they believe that the sale process of the club should be outsourced to professionals who can exhibit a successful track record in selling major sporting organisations, a quality which will enable them to identify and deliver the prospective buyer who can best demonstrate the resources, ability and a genuine desire to take the club forward on both a commercial and footballing level.  



Reader Comments (34)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Dave Lynch
1 Posted 25/01/2012 at 08:59:37
Now the detractors have an opportunity to go along and have their say on why the BU is wrong.
Peter Laing
2 Posted 25/01/2012 at 09:18:50
Fair comments Dave, an open and transparent meeting which can be scrutinized by those detractors who question their motives. Recall that I have seen on another website that the meeting is going to be available via a podcast, can anyone confirm this ?
Michael Parrington
3 Posted 25/01/2012 at 09:53:42
Great idea. I'm glad to see the BU is looking for some diverse opinion.

For someone who nowadays is living a fair old plane trip away, it would be great if there was some way of including people outside Liverpool. Perhaps next time.

I made some points about finding a way to work with the current directors, even if you dislike (or worse) them. Unfortunately the BU has to deal with the current board. Perhaps the BU can find a way to find common ground, a d work on that first.
Paul Jamieson
4 Posted 25/01/2012 at 11:38:23
There will be a live feed later on from the meeting, it will probably be done by Twitter. Follow @theblueunion for details.
Joe Jennings
5 Posted 25/01/2012 at 11:52:14
For all the Evertonians that can't be at the Casa tonight for whatever reason there will be a live blog, which can be found here:

http://www.sos1878.co.uk/everton-news/blue-union-strategy-meeting-live/
James Ryan
6 Posted 25/01/2012 at 11:44:59
Really want to wish the Blue Union all the best and support what they're doing 100%. It's time to take the fight inside the stadium in my opinion, support the team fully during the match and then have a sit-in or something. I'm sick of the dross on and ? more to the point ? off the field. Keep it going, lads!
Brian Harrison
7 Posted 25/01/2012 at 12:00:34
I am not a supporter of the BU, but like all Evertonians I am concerned in how our club can turn its fortunes around.

As far as outsourcing to find a buyer, that seems like a plausible route to take. But BU want this Company to sell the club for whatever price and then demand the present board accept the offer. Now with the best will in the world they are not going to agree to that.

I know Colin Fitzpatrick has suggested Barclays Capital or another alternative company well maybe Kenwright could employ these people to look for new investors. I know BU supporters would say that Kenwright would still demand to high a price for the club to be sold.

But Elstone has said that he doesnt believe the asking price is the stumbling block to the sale. So maybe at their meeting tonight they could ask Barclays or an alternative what they would charge Everton for finding potential buyers, would that not be a workable compromise?
Daniel A Johnson
8 Posted 25/01/2012 at 12:30:16
If it wasn't for the Blue Union what eactly would be happening to put pressure on Kenwright.................Nothing.

So come on support them if you can, any form of change is better than just sitting on your hands and waiting for relegation.
Peter Laing
9 Posted 25/01/2012 at 12:44:53
Great to see you are entering into constructive dialogue Brian regarding ways in which we can move the club forward. The Blue Union are not the anti-christ, they are a diverse group of Evertonians from all walks of life who have one purpose and common goal : improving the fortunes of Everton Football Club.

The recent comments by Christopher Samuelson would appear to be heaping even more pressure on Bill Kenwright as all of his chickens appear to be coming home to roost. Let's have the transparency Bill - we are Evertonians and deserve better.
Tony J Williams
10 Posted 25/01/2012 at 12:52:16
"If it wasn't for the Blue Union what eactly would be happening to put pressure on Kenwright.................Nothing."

I applaud them for what they are trying to do, but what actual pressure have they put on Kenwrong? His 24/7 search remains the same and is as inefffective as it has always been.

We are no closer to getting the fecker out than we were before the Union was formed.

As I say, well done for getting off their arses and doing "something" but ultimately it is doomed to fail because it's water off a ducks back to that Charlatan in charge.
Tim Marchant
11 Posted 25/01/2012 at 13:02:12
"Highly successful series of planned demonstrations and meetings" - What success has actually been achieved? No new buyer, no new chariman and no new investment. No success there then.

They have raised the profile of the financial plight, granted, but what else have they actually achieved?

By what means have they actually put any pressure on Kenwright? Media articles seem to be recycling the same story.

The only thing I can see they have achieved is dividing Evertonians either for or against them.

I live 400 miles from Goodison so there may be things I cannot see, and if so I stand corrected, but I just cannot see any substantial success.

To me it looks like bickering and name calling from some people on this and other forums, but I doubt BK gives a toss what people write on here anyway...
Colin George
12 Posted 25/01/2012 at 13:32:30
I don't agree with the BU tactics, and judging by the poor turn out for the protest (maybe 2,000 fans if I'm generous out of a 30,000 crowd) I'm not on my own.

I agree the football we are seeing is poor and I would like to see more investment, but not at any cost!

We are currently sitting mid table; when we get our injured players back we will push on I'm sure.

The bottom line is there are few genuine investors but plenty of profiteers ? I do not want my club to end up like Portsmouth.

THE GRASS ISN'T ALWAYS GREENER!
Colin Fitzpatrick
13 Posted 25/01/2012 at 14:17:06
Tim #688

Tim, the paragraph that appears to have you so excited obviously needs to be explained to you. Both of the meetings that The Blue Union have arranged have been well attended and received by those who attended them, therefore they were, in that respect, successful, hence the statement.

Demonstration marches aren?t designed to achieve their planner?s objective in one fell swoop. They?re designed to attract the attention of others to their cause and, in that respect, both of The Blue Union?s demonstrations have been very successful as they attracted attention from local and national press, radio and TV.

It amazes me that Everton fans have sat and watched Bill Iscariot lead OUR club into oblivion over twelve years but now expect a bunch of drunken knobheads to solve the problem in a few months!

Colin #699

I wish people wouldn?t revel in their own ignorance and they could stop living in the surreal opinion that the misfortunes suffered by other clubs such as Portsmouth are a comfort; they?re not, we already have those owners, look at the state of the club, listen to our chairman when he says ?I pleaded with the bank not to kill us this year and took around a document which prevented them for stopping us trading?

Look at the squad, look at the results, look at the table and look at the fixtures. We?re in trouble; I appreciate your glass maybe over flowing but the rest of us are looking on with great concern.

Btw, enjoyed you're pun at the end, "greener" lol
Richard Jones
14 Posted 25/01/2012 at 14:13:22
Colin, I was at the first meeting and there were 5 of us So the momentum is growing if you estimate 2000.

I think we are watching a Leeds / Portsmouth scenario before our very eyes... I'm sorry but have you considered the 'cost' of you doing nothing?
Colin George
15 Posted 25/01/2012 at 14:32:34
Colin 688
We need investment like every club bar the regular top 6.
The Portsmouth scenario is not a comfort bit a reality.
Change at any cost is suicide, and will not get my support.
Steve Brown
16 Posted 25/01/2012 at 14:54:22
Think BU need to concentrate on the stadium solution before the club becomes a viable investment opportunity for a buyer.

Otherwise the proposal is for a buyer to pay BK 150million (if figures are to be believed), invest a further 150million in a stadium, clear a 40m overdraft and finance rebuilding a squad that has had no money spent on it for 3 year (30m?).

That is before putting a business model in place that generates an operating profit rather than a 5m loss per year. Who would invest in that?

A new stadium is the key to everything.
Steve Brown
17 Posted 25/01/2012 at 15:04:38
On the stadium where are Liverpool City Council? Vocal in challenging Destination Kirby but have done SFA to put a viable alternative on the table.

Steavey Buckley
18 Posted 25/01/2012 at 15:02:01
Until BK and the board start using their own money for transfers and excessive salaries paid to players, then Evertonians, everywhere, will have to start donating their own money, ring fenced for transfers etc. If they are unable to, Everton's better prospects, such as Rodwell, will be sold. Then Everton will take one step forward, then one step back. Borrowing more money is not an option.
Brian Harrison
19 Posted 25/01/2012 at 15:27:20
I see UEFA have just stated that the top clubs in Europe lost £1.33 billion between them. They also say that 56% lost money last year, and 13 clubs which included English clubs would have failed UEFA break even test.

So not only Everton in financial straits, which says a lot about the game overall.
The problem is that most clubs are run uneconomically, but are unwilling to face the hard steps that need to be taken.

There is more money flowing into football clubs than at any other time, but unless they stop paying the greedy mercenaries, by that I mean players and agents then things will only get worse.

This UEFA report highlights the problem,and unless clubs like Everton address this problem, then administration or relegation or both is the eventual outcome.

I know Colin Fitzpatrick suggested we dont need a billionaire backer just a man with a plan. Well with no extra finance I would suggest his plan would have to be to unload players who will fetch top dollar in the transfer market, to enable us to reduce our debt. Because are wage bill for players is killing this club.
Shaun Brennan
20 Posted 25/01/2012 at 15:37:48
Steve Brown (717) Everton are not looking for a alternative site, thereform LCC can not help them.

However the council is in dialogue of the football quarter proposal.

Speaking of a site though, Peel Holdings, Liverpool waters development. Ideal new site for a stadium if we ever had the cash and that development went through.
Ray Robinson
21 Posted 25/01/2012 at 15:57:05
Brian #723, I don't doubt that 13 clubs would fail the break even test that UEFA are about to intoduce but how many of them are in danger of actually going under I wonder? I'm sure Man City are one of those clubs but I don't think their future imminent existence is at stake because of it.

I hate to say it but I'm not certain there are many clubs in a worse financial state than ourselves. As long as you're being bankrolled by someone, you may not comply with the forthcoming rules but you're not about to go under.
Brian Harrison
22 Posted 25/01/2012 at 16:10:54
Ray 727

I am sure City and Chelsea are fairly safe while their owners continue to bankroll them. But not all clubs have such billionaire backers, and as the report said 56% of top clubs around Europe lost money last year.

Bye the way Ray Boltons debt is twice the size of our debt.
Ray Robinson
23 Posted 25/01/2012 at 16:30:50
Brian, Bolton will hit the shit sooner or later but my point is that currently they are being bankrolled by a guy in the Isle of Man who owns a betting chain (forget his name), so as long as he "subsidises" the club, they won't go under. We have no benefactor.

But don't want to be picky as I actually agree with you - they are in dire straits. Look what is happening at Preston because Hemmings is reducing his support.

Sorry, all I was saying is some of those clubs, despite their debt, are not in as immediate trouble as we appear to be. They'll get there eventually!
Colin Wainwright
24 Posted 25/01/2012 at 16:32:48
Thank christ! Bolton are more fecked than us.

These endless comparisons to other teams, mean nothing. No matter what these clubs finances look like, no matter what the state of the economy or any of the other reasons given for the dire condition of Everton Football Club, there can be no denying that the actions of Kenwright and his board have massively exacerbated the problem.

Over ten years of lies and failure. Stop making fucking excuses for them.
Steve Guy
25 Posted 25/01/2012 at 16:48:07
Meanwhile over on BlueKipper, the notice for tonight's meeting has been published to howls of protest (apart from the obligatory naysayer to provide "balance"). One joker has even blamed the failure of Kirkby ( a free stadium apparently) on the BU; which is pretty spectacular.
Peter Laing
26 Posted 25/01/2012 at 16:57:01
Steve #744 Do you actually expect anything other from Bluekipper who are in my opinion an unofficial mouthpiece for the Club with its childish content and questionable motives. Dont forget Michael Durkin (AKA MBE) was on the leaked e-mail list from Ian Ross as a Club sympathiser.
Colin Wainwright
27 Posted 25/01/2012 at 17:10:48
Colin (699). If you don't want your club to end up like Portsmouth, stop backing Bill and support the BU, because if this board remains in control for much longer, that is exactly where we're heading.
Mick Davies
28 Posted 25/01/2012 at 17:00:52
To be fair to BK, he was conned as we all were by the initial good fortune Moyes had in lifting the club, and the players that emerged just at that time. Rooney lifted the club's profile and his fee helped Moyes break the transfer record more seasons running than any other manager in our history (it's just a pity he never had the know how to keep the lad happy and build a successful team around him).
Alas the gamble didn't pay off and just like O'Leary at Leeds, the architect wasted the funds on a flawed project: you can't be successful unless you have the drive, vision and ability. Now we are in shit street it seems the problem is Bill's only, but wasn't he just trying to get his beloved club back to where he believes it should be. and with his limited finances, he gambled on David Moyes and it hasn't worked. So why is BK getting all the flak off the BU yet Moyes is still revered while he sits on his throne getting ridiculous wages for nothing?
Dave Street
29 Posted 25/01/2012 at 17:34:58
Noticed that neither of the "invited" guest speakers are attending! They both have prior arrangements apparently! Interesting......
Colin George
30 Posted 25/01/2012 at 17:31:49
Can some one explain to me why BK would hold on to a club that's about to go out of business, it makes no sense.
Peter Evand
31 Posted 25/01/2012 at 17:38:50
I love the simplicity in the thought process of BU.

We need a buyer who can invest upwards of £350m - much of it ringfenced at the outset (not sure of any business that does it that way) - willing to take on a loss-making business and keep it going whatever the cost. Now, don't get me wrong, if such a creature exists I'll support it but the reslity is that they don't.

The alternative is somone like the Glazers or Gillette and Hicks who rasie money through debt. Hence the comparisons with Portsmouth, Bolton, Blackburn and the like are justified.

Try this as an alternative. BK sets out his price then every Everton fan - man, woman, child or concession - who attends the match pays £5 after they enter the ground and that money goes to a fund to progressively buy shares at a pre-determined price. the same with shirt purchases or other merchandise. How will fans react? I suspect they will be mortified and refuse at the prospect of 'risking' their own money to own the club but many of those fans are supporting the BU in expecting someone else to do just thaton a much larger scale.

See, you can't accuse me of saying do nothing but many of the alternatives are simply unworkable, unachievable or unpalatable. To almost every investor in the world other than a rich oligarch or major criminal the BU proposal will engender the same response.

If BU members still think their proposal has got legs, I can offer you a number of alternative loss making investments other than EFC and I am only asking for £2500 with a further £3500 ringfenced for development and, probably a further £3000 per month in losses (I need a salary after all). Any takers? Thought not!

Now, drop the obsession with BK and try to reach a deal for sensible alternative achieveable with modest investment and some likelihood of an operating profit.....but being realistic, profit may come at a cost: increasing seat prices and continuing the frugal policy on player acquisition.

Colin George
32 Posted 25/01/2012 at 18:19:35
Colin Wainwright, can you answer Peter Evand for me? I would like to read your response.

Thanks.
Richard Jones
33 Posted 25/01/2012 at 20:24:40
Or Bill could just lower his asking price Peter!!
Michael Kenrick
Editorial Team
34 Posted 25/01/2012 at 20:50:25
Some good discussion on this thread, thank you. We're closing it at this point as the Blue Union meeting is now ongoing at The Casa. Please add any comments you may have on the meeting, and the issues raised, over at the new thread behind the lead story on our homepage.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads