Tony I'Anson's vision for Trust Everton

, 8 February, 182comments  |  Jump to most recent
Survey of Fans' interest in Finch Farm purchase
In a broadly targeted follow-up to the initiative we headlined some weeks ago, Tony I'Anson is featured in today's Echo, talking about Trust Everton and the vision of one day having the fans owning Everton's state-of-the-art training facility at Finch Farm. The venture is receiving a lot of support, including a strong endorsement from Andy Burham, MP and we would encourage fans who have not already completed the online survey to do so now.

Quotes or other material sourced from Liverpool Echo



Reader Comments (182)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Nate Allen
1 Posted 08/02/2012 at 18:32:09
I think Finch Farm is more of an asset than some realize. It would be fantastic if it was purchased by the fans.
Gavin Ramejkis
2 Posted 08/02/2012 at 18:46:50
It's a very valuable asset too Nate as the club found out after buying it and selling it only to pay exorbitant rent from then on.
Kevin Tully
3 Posted 08/02/2012 at 19:42:14
Fantastic news. What an embarrassment to the club this must be. Anyone who reads the article must be pissing themselves about this latest short - term thinking by BK and his cronies.

When will his supporters wake up and realise how he has to sell the family silver to keep hold of this club?
Graham Mockford
4 Posted 08/02/2012 at 20:01:19
Gavin, can you please explain how you know it's an exorbitant rent? How much did the club receive, how much is the rent? What do you think the yield on investment was for the property investor?

Or is this just another lazy anti-establishment comment with no foundation whatsoever? Please feel free to prove me wrong but please provide some evidence not just supposition.
Thomas James
5 Posted 08/02/2012 at 20:26:51
I think this is a great step. Having been to the survey site I would say to Tony that you might get more response if you hosted the survey on a site where you, the user, didn't have to create a profile first...put me off.

Surveymonkey.com for example.
Tony I'Anson
6 Posted 08/02/2012 at 20:30:06
Many thanks to Michael and Lyndon for the ongoing exposure on Toffeeweb for the Trust Everton project. I would also like to Echo their call for all Evertonians to complete the survey to demonstrate there is a will amongst the fan base.

Also, credit must be given to the small team of talented professionals who are continuing to work behind the scenes on the project.
Denis Richardson
7 Posted 08/02/2012 at 20:39:51
Graham, if you want to know more about the deal that the club made re the sale of Finch Farm, you can get some fact some the thread below. The facts are also public, Gavin is not posting a 'lazy anti-establishment comment with no foundation whatsoever'.....

http://www.toffeeweb.com/season/11-12/news/19390.html
Nick Waters
8 Posted 08/02/2012 at 20:38:14
Graham I think everyone knows how you support the Moyes/Kenwright partnership all the time but your ignorant and sneering post at 414 does you no credit.
Peter Laing
9 Posted 08/02/2012 at 20:32:21
Graham the widely quoted payable to ROM capital (Houston securities) is £1.1 million.
The terms of repayment is apparently 50 years.

The Club purchased the land at Finch Farm in 2006 for approximately £2 million and then sold the land to ROM who developed the complex at a reported £9 million cost

The complex is now valued at between £15-17 million by ROM

Fantastic return on that £11 million investment by ROm considering the current economic climate

We sold an asset in the form of Bellefield for £9 million to repay the banks, a complete disgrace since the previous training ground was a legacy from Sir John Moores

Do the maths Graham and realise that Everton are being shafted, word has it that Alex Ferguson is also a major shareholder in Houston securities.
Jack Molloy
10 Posted 08/02/2012 at 20:26:47
Gavin, we didn't buy it only to sell it only to pay exorbitant rent on it. We bought the land then sold it to ROM Capital (now Hudson Capital Properties) who spent £9million developing it with some first class facilities. We then took a 50-year lease on it with an option every five years to buy at about £15 million.

If we had built it ourselves, we probably would have taken out a 30-year mortgage but then we would be stuck with management costs, upkeep etc. It's just another form of outsourcing.

I do not see what we gain by re-acquiring it right now. If Trust Everton or anyone else has access to £15 million, buy a striker. That we can use.
Gavin Ramejkis
11 Posted 08/02/2012 at 20:34:45
Graham, are you serious?

Finch Farm original purchase costs ? not available in public domain?

Everton sold the property for £2.1m to ROM Capital and gave a contract worth £9m to AFL architects to build the training facilities

The finished site value was £17m but don't forget we don't own this - ROM Captial now have a £17m facility.

The for sale document shows the rent for the property is £1,259,163 and that the fixed rental increases provide increases every five years so 2017 the rent will rise 8.77%,

2022 - 9.92%,
2027 - 11.23%,
2032 - 12.70%,
2037 - 14.37%,
2042 - 16.26%

I'll let you do the maths on that Graham, but for an initial outlay unknown, sale of £2.1m, contract outlay of £9m to build the facilities, which you simply can't just lift and take with you should you leave, add the rents and fixed rental increases over the 30 year-lease I'm on rock solid ground to piss all over your revisionist bullshit of "lazy anti-establishment" label

You want the for sale document with those figures?

http://www.scribd.com/doc/69456072/Everton-Training-Complex

Feel free to provide a response to these if you have any evidence to the contrary.
Graham Mockford
12 Posted 08/02/2012 at 20:48:33
I take your point; however, there are a few words in your post that would concern me as far as proving to me it was a bad commercial deal, namely 'widely quoted' 'apparently' 'approximately' 'reported' 'between' word has it'...

The point I'm making is not that I think it was a good deal one way or the other, we just don't know unless someone can prove it evidentially. My gripe is that there is a propensity to lazily report opinion as fact.
Martin Paice
13 Posted 08/02/2012 at 21:01:11
Great idea to buy Finch Farm, just worry that in practice at £15m we don't have the fanbase?

£15m @ £30 per person = 500,000 people

£15m @ £100 per person = 150,000 people

We barely got 30k for City at home last week.

Fantasic proposal and I for one would support and pay towards it, but just worry the numbers are too large.
Gavin Ramejkis
14 Posted 08/02/2012 at 21:14:58
Graham, Nothing in my response is supposition, it's in black and white from the vendor of the property. The ROM Capital deal and the AFL architects deal are all public domain information.
Graham Mockford
15 Posted 08/02/2012 at 21:08:01
Thanks Gavin for your detailed response. I am very interested. Just a couple of questions because I'm struggling here to do the maths.

Are you suggesting we sold an asset for £2.1M, got a £9M development at a rent of £1.3M pa with built-in increases in rent for a term of 35 years?

So my questions: Are the figures you are quoting factual based on stated accounts which can be proved or assumptions based on offer documents that you provided a link to?

I'm genuinely not trying to score points but trying to understand the facts.
Graham Mockford
16 Posted 08/02/2012 at 21:28:43
Gavin, thanks for detailed response but as you state I'm really struggling with the maths. Couple of questions, are the figures you quote ie sale proceeds, rent, kickers etc taken from publicly available accounts or assumptions from the documents you provided a link to?

If the £2.1m is a figure that can be absolutely proven, what price should we have got assuming it was better to leverage property assets as opposed to selling more players. Genuinely not trying to score points here just trying to inform myself.
Mark Riding
17 Posted 08/02/2012 at 21:41:16
Gavin.. have a few bevvies mate, and you can read it easy.. I can even hear Z-Cars playing if I read it backwards.
Graham Mockford
21 Posted 08/02/2012 at 21:58:55
Nick #421 you have me wrong. I have grave reservations about the current administration, you couldn't be in any other position given the parlous financial state we find ourselves. However, I don't just assume it is maladministration but do consider that the whole PL financial model could be at the root of our problems, ie, we don't have a rich owner and we are not particularly attractive to investors... but I do accept without new ownership we are going nowhere.

As for David Moyes, I'm in the minority on this site in that I think he is a great manager for us, especially in our current financial position. Given a fighting budget, who knows; let's hope we find out. What I struggle with and what seems very prevalent on this site is there only seem to be two positions: pro or anti, whether that be Kenwright or Moyes. I'm neither.
Gavin Ramejkis
22 Posted 08/02/2012 at 22:44:18
Graham I think the club has employed cowboys who were well out of their depths in positions of power. The old outsourcing and balance sheet tricks of selling property and renting to get that year's annual return looking clean, but not bothering to see how it looks over a ten-year period, appear to be more aligned to what appears to have happened.

The land parcel Finch Farm is on was bought by the club some time ago, despite protests about it being green belt and I don't believe the price paid was made public. It was sold for £2.1m which appeared in the annual returns. The contract for the design and fit of the facilities for £9m is also public domain information but, as I said earlier, gave no one other than ROM Capital a healthy return.

The club rent back the land and facilities on a very long lease which has a window every five years with an opportunity for the club to buy it back. The annual rent and initial purchase and build costs negated several years worth of ability to buy back the site and, unless the club literally found another two Rooneys, it would never have the ability to buy back Finch Farm as it has other debts like the mortgages on Goodison Park, and the Bear Stearns season ticket future sales loan (now held by JP Morgan). Other loans such as the Park End via the Prudential, the Vibrac loan, the future EPL membership rights for the next few years means the opportunity to buy Finch Farm has gotten further and further from reach.

The rental increases are fixed into the terms of the long lease with a guaranteed income and very healthy profit for it's owners.

Working on a figure of £1.1m rent since October 2007 when they officially moved in and currently £1.2m rent and rising in rent alone the club have paid over £4m in rent together with £9m to develop the facility plus the unknown original purchase cost which at a guess would be less than £2.1m it was sold on for then remove the £2.1m and its already a loss maker in excess of £10m and rising.
Graham Mockford
23 Posted 08/02/2012 at 23:12:38
Gavin I appreciate your reply but I'm still sensing assumptions in your reply. eg 'working on a figure' etc. What I'm trying to say is you have an opinion, and a well argued one, but let's agree we can't be sure.

I'm sure if you asked the question of the current administration, they would either refuse to comment or say they struck a good commercial deal. I just struggle with certainty based on unproven assumptions. As ever I am open to being proved wrong.
Ciarán McGlone
24 Posted 08/02/2012 at 23:24:32
You're not open to being proven wrong, Graham. Nor are you simply being inquisitorial. The tone of your opening post tells me as much.

The information that Gavin has provided is available as accounts and financial statements of the parties concerned.

If you're not willing to accept the bona fides of there reproduction ? then go find, read and ruminate on them yourself.

It always astounds me whenever Evertonians queue up to have a go at anyone criticising the club's finances, without having bothered to educate themselves on the issue.
Anthony Jones
25 Posted 09/02/2012 at 00:00:27
Graham, #464, you're on the wrong site Sir if you want fact only debates.

Assumption and conjecture are rife. You have to try to distil your own truth from the biased masses!
Ian Smitham
26 Posted 09/02/2012 at 00:02:18
Gavin, for my two penny worth, I respect your views can you let us have a detailed insight in to the terms of the other "facilities" the club enjoys, term, interest rates, security provided so that we can compare like with like, cheers. I ask as it seems obvious to me looking at your postings, that you are close to the numbers.
Jimmy Sørheim
27 Posted 09/02/2012 at 02:05:07
At first I thought it was a good idea.

But now I feel that if I and others were to put in a substantial amount on this then that will serve to protect and excuse the mistakes Bill has done, and Bill and his board gets away without having to take responsibility.
Eric Myles
28 Posted 09/02/2012 at 02:28:52
Jimmy, look at it this way, either the money goes out of the Club to some company that makes millions and contributes nothing, or the money goes to the Trust who use it to put back into the Club.
John Keating
29 Posted 09/02/2012 at 02:49:38
Anthony. I assume when you talk of "truth in the biased masses" you put BK and the Board at the head of this??

FSF, KD, DK etc etc spring to mind.
Mick Davies
30 Posted 09/02/2012 at 03:08:03
Why, even if it were possible, should loyal fans feel obliged to use their hard earned cash, possibly leaving them financially vulnerable, just to ensure that a multi million pound business with it's millionaire employees get pampered in plush, state-of-the-art facilities and offices?

Why don't the players put their huge profits towards securing this expensive drain on the club's already mis-managed finances. From the fans point of view, let them train in Walton Hall Park or Formby beach.

The cosy Finch Farm regime has coincided with a deterioration in the team's performances, so fuck them and the board. Let them sort it out
Eric Myles
31 Posted 09/02/2012 at 06:55:00
Anthony #468, it's fans like Gavin that DO provide facts on this discussion, unlike others that only mock and deride those that are making an attempt to make a difference.
Steavey Buckley
32 Posted 09/02/2012 at 06:56:17
The £1.2 million pa rent does not add up. If Finch Farm cost £9 million to develop, a rent of 5% would be a more realistic figure of £450,000. The £1.2 million represents a nearly a 15% rip-off figure. A mortgage would have been the best way to proceed to buy the training facility outright in the first place.
John Keating
33 Posted 09/02/2012 at 08:45:49
Graham. Can I ask if you actually read Gavins replies to you??

If so I cannot believe your #464. Obviously you're not stupid, so why reply with that??
Derek Thomas
34 Posted 09/02/2012 at 09:29:57
Martin Paice # 432; I'm sure Tony will correct me but I don't think it will work like that. Contributors sign up to pay in (according to their means) over a period of time, just like you promise to pay off your house or car.

M x VA x T = FF

Many (relatively) X varying amounts X time in years = Finch Farm.
Tony Waring
35 Posted 09/02/2012 at 09:48:23
I don't get it. I tried to sign up for information and the possibility of subscribing but the site informed me that I needed another email addres because the current (only) one is already registered. How the hell do they expect to attract support if they turn down people at the first stage? Another Everton saga or what?
Richard Larnder
36 Posted 09/02/2012 at 09:39:39
Steve #485,

The rental yield on the property should be compared to the market value of the premises, rather than it's historical build-cost.

i.e., It's more like £1.1m on a £17m property, yielding 6.5% which is much more commercial. Actually it looks pretty weak given the investor is exposed to Everton credit risk and it has limited security in the event of default i.e., who would you rent the complex to if Everton went bust?

I think the key points here in the debate are: what is a market rate for renting a similar size premises? and, what are the ongoing costs of maintenance/who pays for them?

The rent/buy debate is a lot more complex than marvelling at the expense of property. Not saying that renting is a good deal for Everton in this instance but the analysis is complex.

Those suggesting a commercial mortgage are probably wide of the mark. A bank would probably not provide a senior facility for this type of property given the issues with security I've noted above. Which might be the reason ROM are selling. They can't get a leveraged return and 6.5% is probably well below their target IRR.

Fair play to the organisers of this Trust. I think it will be a difficult sell but would be made easier by making it commercial for the fans, rather than being a donation. There would presumably be headroom for a modest, inflation-linked, return and some residual profits to fund future costs and possible expansion.
Eric Myles
37 Posted 09/02/2012 at 10:06:01
Richard, I don't think that under the terms of the Trust they can pay dividends to the subscribers so it will be a donation from the fans.
Mark Wilson
38 Posted 09/02/2012 at 09:42:22
I need to go back and re read the Trust proposal because, put simply, it feels like this :

150,000 bluenoses each put in £100 which they never get a return on, in fact never get back at all, though they do technically "own" a brick or two of a clearly top class Premier League football club training complex. The club still pays rent at a relatively high rate, but not to JP Morgan but to Trust Everton. Then, instead of the greedy capitalists going away and adding to their already overflowing coffers, the Trust uses the money, somehow, to benefit EFC.

Quite how we use the £1.2m pa received, probably more like £1m after fees and costs etc, is a real question. Does the Trust save up and every five years buy a championship winger or even a striker? Do we use the money to develop young players, help ex payers, improve disabled facilities at Goodison?

Genuinely, I love the direction of travel, far prefer this approach to marches and protests, but just cannot see how it can ever work? Where are the 150k fans willing to hand over £100 in the financial climate we live in now or in the next 3 to 5 years? It will more likely end up with a few relatively rich individuals providing the vast bulk of the capital needed and lots of small investors or shareholders, which sounds spookily close to what we have now!

I really really want to be wrong here. I so respect the effort and the incredible drive that has got Tony and colleagues this far. But I just don't understand how it is realistic, how it really changes things for EFC in a "make the difference" kind of way and crucially, even if these visionary fans pull it off, how it can happen inside of the time we have left to turn things round at the club before the dire financial state we are in finally catches up with us?
Steavey Buckley
39 Posted 09/02/2012 at 10:06:12
Richard #498. I don't believe Everton are for one minute going to default on a world class facility, that has an academy which assists the first team in providing young and exciting new players.

As far as finances go as a whole, £40- £50 million debt can be cleared away by a new rights issue if the existing board agreed. The reason they may object, it may dilute their share and investment in the club. Basically, if you need more money, you find new investors.

At this stage of Everton's finances, £70 million a year may not be a lot of income per year compared to the likes of Man Utd, but it can deal with the debt, even if it means selling one or two of the better players or prospects. And that is the type of security a bank would need to carry on with the debt.
Eric Myles
40 Posted 09/02/2012 at 10:23:39
Mark, there will be no small investors and shareholders, there will only be the Trust which is not owned by anyone.

The aim of the Trust is to buy fixed assets for the benefit of the club, not players
Richard Larnder
41 Posted 09/02/2012 at 10:48:06
Steve #502,

I've no doubt that Everton don't want to default on the rental payments but this is quite different from actually defaulting. Especially given that so much of Everton's revenue is Premier League dependent.

My point is that you wouldn't want to be exposed to the credit risk of a football club and the training complex offers limited security to a provider of finance.

The above would be reflected in the return an investor would demand on the complex.

Rights Issue has been floated before (if you pardon the pun). Who do you think would subscribe and who do you think would underwrite it?
Paul Wharton
42 Posted 09/02/2012 at 10:54:33
The money should be going to a new Bullens Road stand so we as Evertonians have one objective and that's to redevelope the ground.

We could get rights that the Chelsea pitch owners have if we go down this route.

Roberto Birquet
43 Posted 09/02/2012 at 12:29:34
My answer to the online survey:
The questions on this survey are dreadful.
Should a fans group buy Finch Farm? Answer: it depends on the price. Where is that in your question. Are you simply going to accept the asking price? Then count me out. The club sells for £2 million at the height of the credit bubble, and what we buy back for seven times that price after national land values have fallen by 20% (and that ignores the fact that property sales volumes have collapsed by more than half since 2007, which always indicates that real prices - ie those that can be realised by a seller are even lower). On top of that, even ignoring the collapse in volumes, Liverpool land prices have fallen by more than the national average ? ie by more than 20%.

I want to see the reasons for why this purchase would be value for money, And I do not accept that "renting is a waste of money", so is throwing away £13 million, and more so.
I am an Evertonian, not a moron. And this survey does not inspire me with any confidence at all.
Roberto Birquet
44 Posted 09/02/2012 at 12:29:59
Peter Laing
The complex is now valued at between £15-17 million by ROM

Fantastic return on that £11 million investment by ROm considering the current economic climate
-------------------
That is nonsense, Peter. Just because someone puts a property for sale and quotes an asking price does not mean that is the true value.

If it were, we would all become millionarires. We just buy a property for say £100k, and then put it up for sale at £200k. Do it ten times, I'm a millionaire. Nothing simpler. Nor more stupid.

This country was run like this for the best part of a decade by the banks... Result: The biggest financial crisis and recession since World War I, the banking sector bust, and kept alive by Mr and Mrs Taxpayer.

Despite all the bonuses, this remains the case. Banking only survives because of government guarantees on their business, and the Bank of England printing money and simply giving it to the banks as IOUs... or, as many believe, simply giving them it for free ? it will never be seen again.

Has no-one yet realised that means this type of thinking is redundant?
Steavey Buckley
45 Posted 09/02/2012 at 13:10:47
Richard #508

An underwriter is only necessary if the rights issue of a certain amount of new shares are not taken up to raise a certain amount of cash. Then an underwriter would then have to sell the remaining shares to a financial institution, bank, a company or something similar.

Tom Hughes
46 Posted 09/02/2012 at 13:01:07
I would tend to agree with Paul Wharton in that I would probably prefer funds to be directed at stadium redevelopment too.

Indeed, an initial (relatively modest) outlay could be put towards commissioning a proper design competition whereby all redevelopment options could be explored fully, and presented to the trust/club.

This could be done quite quickly and give great direction to the trust and IMO help generate more interest, and therefore greater funding from the fanbase and/or interested investors.

I can understand the attraction towards the training facility as an affordable target for this type of intervention, as a slightly separate entity which is modern, complete and functioning, but seen by some as a drain. However I'm not yet convinced that it would yield the greatest benefit nor interest. I believe the stadium itself is a more pressing issue, and I think more fans would identify with that and be more readily enthused by images of say a new Bullens Rd stand, or expanded Park end stand, which could be equally affordable over the lifespan of a trust.

That said, I'm not averse to the prospect of targeting Finch farm, but would only see it as a stepping stone towards a greater objective.
Richard Larnder
47 Posted 09/02/2012 at 14:32:32
Steve #521

I am familiar with the rights issue process. My point is that you're not going to embark on the process without an underwriter in place given the costs involved with raising the funds.

Who in their right mind would subscribe to or underwrite a capital raising at Everton, other than a few thousand fans wanting to own a share? Especially given that 70% of your hard-earned will find its way into David Moyes and his merry-men's back pockets, along with the rest of the Club's equity.
Colin Fitzpatrick
48 Posted 09/02/2012 at 14:36:59
Roberto, #519

I think you?re being a little harsh on Peter and the guys at Trust Everton.

You?re mocking Peter with your comment, ?just buy a property for say £100K, and then put it up for sale at £200K. Do it ten times, I'm a millionaire. Nothing simpler. Nor more stupid.? Unlike others I could mention, ROM Capital [Academy] Ltd haven?t just bought something for £2m and are now attempting to sell it for £15m; they invested £9m to redevelop the land into a state of the art training facility AND they have a 50 year legal agreement with a Premiership club for annual payments that are now £1.4m with five year rent reviews built in. This is what the prospective purchaser will be looking at, this is what they?ll be purchasing; it?s not just a field that ROM purchased and have done nothing with.

Of course there are associated risks, you?d be liable for repairs and maintenance of the site but I?m assured by a construction professional that with modern construction methods, materials and regulations this would be minimal.

Like life, business is a risk and it?s about managing that risk. Low risks give you low returns, high risks the opposite. What?s the risk here? Everton may go out of business? For what it?s worth I can?t see any evidence that Everton are going out of business; there?s no evidence for this whatsoever. They could be relegated but they?d still need a training groung and historically it would appear that they are extremely dexterous at remaining in the top flight so for the prospective purchaser I think the risk/return on offer is an acceptable one. If risks weren?t taken in life we?d still all be living in caves.

I also fail to see any evidence that anybody from Trust Everton is about to simply buy at an asking price. ROM Capital [Academy] Ltd has essentially initiated an auction with a reserve of £15.3m, if more than one party show a genuine interest then DTZ, the professionals that the current owners have employed to conduct the sale, will probably sell the complex for more, if no potential buyers are forthcoming then the price will fall. It looks to me that Trust Everton, who on the face of it are Evertonians and don?t appear to be morons, are keeping a watching brief on developments.

It also appears to be a big ask to find enough Evertonians to come up with the £15m, no trust has managed to do it this way to my knowledge so I guess the clue must be in when they say, ?using subscription-based memberships and OTHER SOURCES OF FINANCE.?

If it was me I?d phone up Philip Green, ask him to ?negotiate? a £13m loan from VIBRAC for less than the £1.4m guaranteed payment and then make DTZ a cash offer??..

My own opinion is that it looks like the Trust Everton guys are taking their time and they?re looking into everything in fine detail. The more obvious route for some would have been to look into redeveloping the ground to bring more revenue into the club; but the current owners don?t want to redevelop the ground and look at the problems Everton faced when they wanted Williams Tarr to build a new office and retail centre which they?d then lease to Everton who had Sodexo and Kitbag lined up to pay the lease payments. On paper it appeared a great deal for Everton but the reality was Williams Tarr was building an extension on a council house. Everton simply can?t learn the lesson that there?s no such thing as a free lunch and with the owners we have that is all they?ve ever attempted to obtain. To redevelop in the name of someone other than Everton the securitisation loan with Prudential would need to be addressed and there's no way they'd simply accept what is on the balance sheet as the outstanding amount, about £24m; they'd want substantially more than that.

Like anybody that actually gets off their arse and attempts to make a difference Tony and his colleagues should be applauded and supported every inch of the way.
Steavey Buckley
49 Posted 09/02/2012 at 14:48:20
Richard #552 The existing chairman and directors can take up new shares being issued. And there must some Evertonians somewhere if given the opportunity would like to buy some. Not necessarily to make money, but to help the club stay solvent.
Richard Larnder
50 Posted 09/02/2012 at 14:54:30
Steavey #563,

So the current Board will be underwriting the process in your example?

Not going to happen mate.
Steavey Buckley
51 Posted 09/02/2012 at 16:41:38
Richard Larnder 565 The only realistic way of bringing new capital into the club, without having to resort to selling the best players or prospects, is a rights issue. That's if the board agree to one. That is something that has not really been pursued, but should be. A rights issue to raise J60 million would clear the debts and pay for Finch farm outright. That would create an air of optimism and hope for a better future.
Colin Fitzpatrick
52 Posted 09/02/2012 at 18:16:43
Steavey #585

I applaud your optimism but I think Richard #565 is speaking from experience rather than just offering an opinion.

The board have never invested a penny into the club; TBH merely paid Johnson for his shares and that has been their sole investment; it?s been nothing less than a personal investment.

Bill Kenwright, the only one of them prepared to speak, has said he?s not interested in a rights issue; his only plan is to sell.

Hypothetically if a rights issue were to be launched I think that it would be inadvisable to use the proceeds to pay off debt and purchase Finch Farm as we can comfortably meet all our commitments at the moment and such an action would only release £4-5m a year at most. The thing to do, the thing that this board is guilty of not doing over the last twelve years , would be invest in the club?s infrastructure to generate even better revenue streams from football and non-football events.

Sadly it?s never going to happen. We have a board that are incapable and incompetent and they employ people who are happy to take their money to cover up what?s been going on for years.

It will be interesting to see the accounts for year ending May 2012; interesting to see if after all the asset sales the debt has decreased. Exactly what to do if you're selling a business and are intent on maximising your return.
Richard Larnder
53 Posted 09/02/2012 at 20:52:33
Colin, I couldn't have put it better myself mate.
Eric Myles
54 Posted 10/02/2012 at 01:58:05
Roberto, you also have to consider the return on investment when valuing Finch Farm for sale.

There is, I think, 35 years remaining on the lease to EFC and at the current rate of £1.4m per year that gives a potential total return of £49million for the purchaser.
Justin Coward
55 Posted 10/02/2012 at 13:12:08
I have a question.

Forgetting the business plan (there are issues and there are good points), if you go ahaead and raise the funds to buy the facility, how are you going to fund running the development as figures show 23 full-time staff with a yearly salary of £575k, power, water bills etc on £300k pa.

Forgetting PT staff etc, the MAIN bills are between £800k and £900k per year which the club don't pay. In rough calculations, the Finch Farm make the owners around £300k profit per year. This is probaly why they are selling due to getting a larger profit margin in a shorter term. If the lease and prices have not changed then, over the 40 years that equals £12 million. So, even if you purchase the facility, how are you going to process this?

I am not trying to be negative but thinking logically.
Steavey Buckley
56 Posted 10/02/2012 at 14:45:23
Colin #605 The £1.2/1.4 million rent/lease agreement for Finch farm represents a government PFI agreement at it's worst. The only real alternative is to have the annual rip off reduced or have it bought outright.

The sad situation with the board not agreeing to a rights issue is very bad in the present environment of Everton not being attractive enough to buy at the asking price of £140 million plus debts. And that I am afraid will leave Everton in a struggling financial situation for the foreseeable future.

As for buying a new stadium, forget it. That is not going to happen with this present board of directors. Liverpool council can buy one if they want to. The only good offer on the table was Tesco's (proposed by a staunch Everton supporter and former CEO of Tesco UK) but the good people of Knowsley in their wisdom opposed it.
Colin Fitzpatrick
57 Posted 10/02/2012 at 16:39:33
Steavey #792
Finch Farm is what it is Steavey. It?s not the best deal because our directors are the most unsuitable bunch in the history of the club, and believe me they have some strong competition; they?re unwilling / unable to invest or provide a suitable mechanism for the club to move forward and yes that would include your suggestion of a rights issue but not perhaps at the level you suggest, but as I and Richard have pointed out it simply isn?t going to happen.

The way forward is new ownership; most fans and the hierarchy of the club are in agreement with this, it?s just the process surrounding how this is achieved which is causing great animosity.

Bill Kenwright believes he is the best salesman for the club whilst many fans, me included, believe that the best interests of the club will be served if the sale process is outsourced to professionals who have a track record of selling major sports businesses.

The logic behind this is simple; Bill Kenwright and this board are synonymous with failure and it has been proven in the public arena that when it comes to acting in the best interests of the club they are not to be trusted.

Your last paragraph is nicely linked to what I?ve just said. I?m not sure if you don?t live in Liverpool, been asleep for five years or simply don?t know what has been going on but to describe Kirkby as a good offer is somewhat curious.

Kirkby?s demise wasn?t due to opposition from the people of Kirkby; it failed because it was based on the sheer greed and arrogance of Tesco, Knowsley and a grossly ill advised Everton who believed they could flout by a figure of 400% the local, regional and national planning regulations that were in force. The Government ended this folly with the outcome of their lengthy and detailed planning inquiry.

Kirkby is the perfect illustration of why Bill Kenwright and the rest of the charlatans should have been run out of the club years ago, because unlike all their other lies, lies that have been inflicted on the Everton fanbase, all of Kirkby was well documented and is there for all to see.

The board are fully responsible for telling the fans that Everton were receiving £52m from Tesco towards the cost of a stadium when the reality was the £52m was simply a value that would have later appeared on the Everton balance sheet to be realised when the club was sold so that the ?investors? could get their money back.

The only losers in this scam were Everton. Tesco have now obtained planning permission for a development that is now only 200% greater than what is allowable under planning regulations and Knowsley have managed to find a developer who will upgrade Kirkby town centre for nothing more than handing over the land.

Everton were used as a decoy, as a Trojan horse to deliver what Tesco and the most corrupt local council in Merseyside wanted and Kenwright and his cohorts were willing participants. For me that is unforgivable as is the willingness of Evertonians to turn a blind eye to these bullshitters. As for Leahy I'd include him with the directors as an official advisor who advised that Everton would be better off in a cheap stadium, built on a rubbish tip, nine miles from the city centre.

It?s great that someone like Tony is willing to investigate a different concept than relying on a bunch of self-serving conmen.
Colin Fitzpatrick
58 Posted 10/02/2012 at 18:17:38
Justin #761

Are you on drugs?
Tony I'Anson
59 Posted 10/02/2012 at 20:28:43
Hello all,

It's been a busy week. And the response has been really positive, with a number of questions raised that we will clarify soon. The questions show you are really taking the time to think about the proposal, which we are really pleased about.

Apologies, if after reading the press articles and reading the website, that you?ve been left under the impression that Trust Everton are proposing to buy Finch Farm and run it for Everton FC. This is not the plan. This is a business proposal and Everton FC would still be paying rent to Trust Everton.

Any Investments by Trust Everton will only involve commercial fixed assets. It will NOT be buying players, paying their wages, or be involved in the costs involved in the day-to-day running of the Club. We cannot stress this point enough.

Many thanks and enjoy the weekend. Sorry I cannot be there. But I will be lurking on the ToffeeWeb live matchday forum.
Paul Wharton
60 Posted 10/02/2012 at 22:57:46
Tony

Well done, you have put a lot of effort and time into this and has had a great platform for Evertonians to air there views.

I hope you will be able to tell us all how many of us have filled in the survey.
Steavey Buckley
61 Posted 10/02/2012 at 23:04:22
Richard #498 As far as I know, Andy Burnham MP, a great Everton fan, supported the Knowsley project, put forward by another Evertonian Sir Tony Leahy (once a CEO of Tesco) who I don't believe wanted to undermine his own football team.

There was going to be a 50,000 stadium (with sufficient corporate entertainment and executive boxes thrown in, and maybe a hotel as well) going to be built, near the M57 and not far from East Lancs Rd and M62, with rail links to Mersey rail.

So far you have not stated how much the proposed stadium was going to cost Everton. I was under the impression the figure was derisory or minimal, which ever way you look at the cancelled project.

But certainly there is not one going to be built in the near future at a proposed cost of £300 million. That means Everton's income is going to be limited for quite a few years until..........
Colin Fitzpatrick
62 Posted 11/02/2012 at 00:30:09
Steavey #874

I can 100% assure you that Andy Burnham didn?t support the ?Kirkby Project? as you call it and that Terry Leahy certainly did use Everton to obtain the best deal possible for his then employers.

You?re embarrassing yourself now about the transport facilities surrounding destination Kirkby; you?re either completely oblivious as to what happened or you?re yet another wind-up that has got past Lyndon and Michael.

The stadium was going to cost Everton £78m, a figure which they failed to convince the planning inspectors that they could actually raise as was outlined in the secretary of state? report. As Tesco and Knowsley Council both admitted that the additional £52m was merely a value it must be concluded that Everton were paying for the lot and one look at the thing tells me that they were getting robbed!

The stadium was a low cost, barely Championship grade, structure which was little more than a glorified Rugby League ground.

You seem oblivious, as I must say the majority of the people employed to defend the board are at Goodison, to the fact that we have no need to leave Goodison as the local council and the leader are more than willing to accommodate any future owners plans to redevelop as you can read here: http://www.guardian.co.uk/local-government-network/2012/jan/26/regeneration-practice-liverpool-football-quarter.

This makes your guesstimation of £300m as accurate as your claim Andy Burnham supported Kirkby; but he is wholeheartedly supporting Trust Everton and has even commented that it would be good to investigate ways of redeveloping the ground as I?m certain he understands that if there is a political will it would be advisable to take advantage.

This would be particularly prudent as Everton have already conducted an extensive study into possible stadium sites around Liverpool which concluded that of the 35 available non were suitable ? they could of course be lying!
Mark Stone
63 Posted 11/02/2012 at 00:36:25
Can I just ask how this would work? The survey mentions regular monthly payments, which I'd be more than happy to make, but which also are not guaranteed. So let's say I sign up for, for arguments sake, £10 a month. By the end of one year, a load of fans were up for this at the start but by now have changed their tune and stopped their payments. We're desperately short of the money required to buy FF and the rate at which it is coming in, we're never going to get there. What then? Or have I massively got the wrong end the stick? Apologies if this is a stupid question but I've not read any paperwork on this, I just filled out the survey and these.
Eric Myles
64 Posted 11/02/2012 at 00:54:20
Steavey #874, what's limiting Everton's income is average gates of less than 30,000 in a 40,000 seater stadium.

What's never been explained is where were the boarrd going to get the £78m needed to build Desperation Kirkby? and why aren't they willin to use that £78m to redevelop Goodison?
Mark Stone
65 Posted 11/02/2012 at 01:13:24
I'd imagine it was from naming rights and the sale of Goodison etc, and some would have probably been a mortgage against projected increased earnings associated with the new stadium facilities. If so that money doesn't exist to be spent on redeveloping goodison.
Mark Stone
66 Posted 11/02/2012 at 01:19:02
They could sell the naming rights to Goodison Park. Any takers? The Pukka Pies Stadium, perhaps?
John Keating
67 Posted 11/02/2012 at 05:00:10
Steavey 874. Sorry mate you must have been out the country during the Kirkby inquiry and have never bothered to read up on the outcome. If you had, you would not have written that post.

Evertonians I know who were initially for the move now don't speak about it. Not because the inquiry found against the proposal, simply because they realised during the course of the inquiry, how much they'd been mislead and lied to by the pricks who run our club.
Tony I'Anson
68 Posted 11/02/2012 at 12:11:21
Tony Waring (496) can you please email enquiries@trusteverton.com with details of this for us to investigate.

hello Paul (867), it's several thousand and rising steadily. We just need to keep spreading the word.
Steavey Buckley
69 Posted 11/02/2012 at 14:36:00
Eric (#884) ? £78 million mortgage spread over 20 years + all the regional and EU funding thrown in, for the creation of new jobs in the Knowsley area, a deprived area. Then there is extra income generated through corporate hospitality and executive boxes. That's where a lot of money is generated in this day and age.

It is very difficult to develop the old lady, since it is surrounded by old Victorian or Edwardian housing stock. Everton are not alone with this situation. Clubs around London have the same problem developing their grounds, when housing encroached their stadiums in the late 1800s and early 1900s.
Colin Fitzpatrick
70 Posted 11/02/2012 at 19:08:36
Steavey #967

Thought you may have been oblivious but clearly in that last post you've proven that you're a wind-up merchant.

Pity you've chosen to do it in a thread which is on a serious subject.

A six million pound per annum mortgage ffs! I know that I criticise Bill for being sly, underhanded and disingenuous but he's no fuckwit.
Steavey Buckley
71 Posted 11/02/2012 at 22:11:25
Steavey #967

"Thought you may have been oblivious but clearly in that last post you've proven that you're a wind-up merchant."

That's not true. I just ''see'' things different from you.

"Pity you've chosen to do it in a thread which is on a serious subject."

It is a serious subject. But nobody is going to come in and give Everton £300 million pounds to build a much needed brand new stadium. And the idea that GP can be redeveloped is way off the mark. Recent history shows that grounds hemmed in by Victorian and Edwardian housing stock have had to move to new grounds, such as Roker park to stadium of Light and Ayresome Park to Riverside. Burden Park to Reebok.

"A six million pound per annum mortgage ffs! I know that I criticise Bill for being sly, underhanded and disingenuous but he's no fuckwit."

The 6 million pound figure would depend who is footing the bill. A new owner could be tempted to buy Everton with a brand new stadium with only a mortgage of 6 million than having to fork out £300 million. £300 million invested could easily return £15 million pounds per year.
Colin Fitzpatrick
72 Posted 11/02/2012 at 23:05:42
Steavey,

You're not seeing anything different than me you're just talking absolute shite and you know it. Just about everything you've spoken about is complete bollocks, rights issues, Andy Burnham, Kirkby's viability due to its location in relation to a motorway and a train station, £78m mortgages, the topography of Walton, imaginary regional and European funding, a hotel, the list is endless; if I'm honest it's been like listening to someone with the brain cell of Ian Ross.

Nobody is going to build Everton a £300m stadium because, notwithstanding the fact that nobody has built a stadium for any premiership club, it would be impossible to obtain a return from a club of Everton's size. You've suggested a return of £15m per annum; have you calculated what the percentage interest rate that is? That is why I know you're a wind-up, nobody is that thick.
Steavey Buckley
73 Posted 12/02/2012 at 14:46:35
Colin Fitzpatrick
#193 ""Nobody is going to build Everton a £300m stadium because, notwithstanding the fact that nobody has built a stadium for any premiership club, it would be impossible to obtain a return from a club of Everton's size. """'

So you can believe GP can be redeveloped, then?. Basically to have extras to bring extra income, like corporate hospitality and executive suites (which I am familiar with) on a greater scale than at present, GP is in the wrong location.

""You've suggested a return of £15m per annum; """.

I just made the point about 300 million being worth a least 15 million a year to who ever had that money. And who ever had that money, could use 7 million of that return to fund a mortgage and still have 8 million with the 300 million still intact. Than having to buy a stadium outright.

Colin Fitzpatrick
74 Posted 12/02/2012 at 15:22:43
Steavey I don't believe it, I know it; I've been in Goodison with a firm of highly respected stadia architects and I've sat down on many occasions with the council leader, on one occasion taking him into Goodison for a meeting with the management team.

Of course it can be redeveloped and it can be redeveloped at a fraction of the ludicrous figures both you and current club officials like to imagine; officials who have proven themselves to be not up to the job on numerous occasions, hence the desperate need to being professionals into the club to start the process of rectifying the mess.

As for your picked out of the air £300m figure, you do realise that you could put that in any account and receive that figure, so can you explain why you would build a stadium?

A tatty £78M, 50,000 seat stadium with a significant increase in the corporate hospitality offer, a 47,000 average attendance and six additional events attended by 180,000 people would have produced an additional contribution of just £6M according to Everton. This was for the stadium in Kirkby, a stadium you clearly have no true knowledge of.

Now you're talking about a £300M mortgage - Jesus wept, give it a rest; it's like kicking a cripple.
Steavey Buckley
75 Posted 12/02/2012 at 16:39:00
Colin Fitzpatrick
"As for your picked out of the air £300m figure, you do realise that you could put that in any account and receive that figure, so can you explain why you would build a stadium?"

Most teams, who have built new stadiums, because they had little or no choice, because of proximity, got a lift in attendances and revenues. And attracted wealthy backers i.e Man City and Sunderland. Also, since quite a few supporters arrive in cars, new stadiums provide more accessible car facilities.

Finally, you may not like to be told this, judging by previous posts, football is in the leisure industry. And anything that will attract new supporters, returning supporters and financial investment should be done.
Colin Fitzpatrick
76 Posted 12/02/2012 at 17:05:03
Steavey, please. like I said it's like kicking a cripple. "Supporters arrive in cars" you don't understand about Government transport targets on how people travel to stadia and modal share comparisons; failure to comply with would mean capping the available attendance, hence the reason Kirkby had NO general parking facilities, in fact there was a complete no parking zone of two miles around the stadium. You sound increasingly like someone who Everton employed over Kirkby - they didn't have a clue either.

You're wrong again with your ridiculous statement that ANYTHING that will attract new supporters should be done; the only things that should be done are those things which are achievable and provide real advantage to the club and at this moment in time nobody is going to pay for a £300M stadium with a mortgage or anything else, there isn't a suitable site within Liverpool, both LFC and EFC have concluded this and for ALL the reasons I've stated the most logical approach to solving Everton's stadium issue is the phased redevelopment of Goodison Park..

Discussing anything with you on here reminds me of this... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W2Rdf0n_Lsg
Barry Jones
77 Posted 12/02/2012 at 18:37:06
It?s a shame that a decent thread on a scheme that could play a part in the future of Everton and Evertonians has been hijacked by somebody who hasn?t a clue what they?re talking about.

Steavey haven?t you heard of KEIOC? People like Tom Hughes and Trevor Skempton who were part of this along with who you?re arguing with must be some of the best informed Evertonians around when it comes to the stadium. They know more than the likes of Flymo Bob who has to tow the line of the owners who can?t provide a penny to improve Everton?s income.

I?m just reading another interesting proposal on fan ownership at Everton, think I?ll write an article on the two proposals as they stand. There seems to be a lot of interest in these supporters trusts at Everton and other clubs but to succeed they?re going to have to be professional and appealing.
Steavey Buckley
78 Posted 12/02/2012 at 20:39:00
Colin Fitzpatrick #427 Barry Jones
#459

It should be recognised, that everyone has opinions about Everton Football Club. Some are the same, but others quite different. I probably fit into the latter. I don't believe GP can be transformed into the state-of-art-modern stadium, fit for the 21st century. For the first half of the last, yes.

Stadiums have to be more than people siting down and having a pie and cup of tea. I noticed Sylvester Stallone was a aghast when he drank his first cup of tea at Goodison some years ago.

And as I have stated earlier, there are other Premier Leaague teams who had to leave their famous stadiums to have to go somewhere, for the same reasons that I have given. Football is very much connected to commercialism because of the huge sums involved that have to go to towards players.

Before the mid 1960s, revenues from matches seemed to have gone in Directors' pockets, with players paid a pittance compared to today.
Colin Fitzpatrick
79 Posted 12/02/2012 at 21:00:27
Steavey, some people believe the earth is flat, that's not an opinion, that's just bollocks.

Stallone ffs, TW used to have some standards.
Dean Adams
80 Posted 12/02/2012 at 20:57:45
Colin
I dont think you are doing your public relations any good with the way you are treating Steavey. He may, or may not be as well educated in the stadium debate, but your tone is just condescending. You have a great deal of knowledge in this area, why not just make it clear to others if they get it wrong.

Whilst on the subject of the stadium, do you know who it was that put the fantastic stadium development plans up on this site some time ago (last few years). They were so detailed and were a real revelation to those of us who have an interest in the "old lady" being developed.
Dennis Stevens
81 Posted 12/02/2012 at 21:17:42
Dean, I have to disagree with you somewhat. Until a couple of Colin's more recent rather pointed responses, I was impressed at his patience in trying to explain so much that Steavey seems unwilling to accept or make the effort to find out about for himself. It's not as though there's a shortage of sources of material to enlighten the interested in issues such as KD, DK, GFE, FQ etc. Even a trawl through TW would be a good starting point.
Dean Adams
82 Posted 12/02/2012 at 21:33:02
Dennis - agree he showed patience, however, the reference to the YouTube clip was not a good direction to take.

The fact that Toffeeweb has so many people who have a wealth of knowledge is what makes it such a good forum, but never is it a wise choice to lower oneself to the base elements!

As you point out, so much info is readily available, not always easy to access all what you would like, hence my question about the stadium development piece.
Derek Turnbull
83 Posted 12/02/2012 at 21:53:08
Finch Farm isn't tangible enough to invest in so I think this will struggle.

A new stand, then I'll raid my piggy bank for it.
Michael Kenrick
84 Posted 12/02/2012 at 21:54:32
I can sympathize with Colin's frustrations to an extent. It's as if this guy Steavey totally has his blinkers on and will not accept what most hopefully now understand to be the truth about Destination Kirkby. To keep raising such nonsense with Colin of all people is maddening.

And to maintain that Goodison Park cannot be redeveloped is equally frustrating, given that was the filpside of the Club's mantra as to why we must up sticks and move to Kirkby. The whole sorry scam has been exposed for what it was...

Then to believe that there is any chance of a rights issue is simply crazy. There is no other word for it. The current majority shareholders are never going to go for that. If they would, they would have already done it during far more favourable times but it was never going to happen.

Rather than seeking to ban him, however, I think it is important to understand that if one fan out there still believes this nonsense, then many more of the silent majority may do so as well. That might justify going over the same ground yet again, as each time there might be new readers who will be willing or open-minded to learn something they did not know, and have that change their preconceptions...

Dean: I think we still have the old GFE designs on the website... Is that what you recall?
Dean Adams
85 Posted 12/02/2012 at 22:11:56
Michael

Thanks. Yes this was the article that I refered to. When I read it the first time, I just could not believe the club was stalling on making in roads into this option.

As I said, thanks.
Steavey Buckley
86 Posted 12/02/2012 at 23:04:44
Michael Kenrick #529

Everton need to attract commercial sponsorship and support. And putting it mildly, the area surrounding GP is not very attractive. And in parts, obstructive. At the moment, Everton get most of their money through Sky and at the turnstile, which is not enough to match other teams other incomes.
Tom Hughes
87 Posted 12/02/2012 at 23:28:23
Steavey,
Liverpool are content to stay in the area (which is far more derelict), and will attract major commercial sponsorship and support. Build the facilities, produce on the pitch and the commercial stuff will follow.

Walton might not be Beverley Hills, but so what? The emergence of a stadium out of the Victorian streetscapes is quite precious to many people. It shouts history and tradition on every corner and in every pub, shop and chippy..... and there is much of quality in the area that is prime for redevelopment, with a large and functioning High Street still intact, and very high density local population.

The area is fed by many times greater public transport capacity than Kirkby (and this will never change, as Kirkby will always be the end of the line and peripheral). Walton also has multiple routes serving the area in all directions creating a far greater number of traffic lanes than any edge of city site (motorway or not, the routes back into Liverpool are very limited).

It is also much closer to the city centre, all its major national and local transport hubs and the city's growing commercial districts (i.e. the people were supposed to be trying to attract).... and of course the important connections with the Wirral and its substantial Evertonian population.

The Scheme at Kirkby did not only violate planning legislation on multiple levels, it also contradicted all current stadium planning theory. The out-of-town option has been tried, and for the most part failed miserably..... prompting the biggest stadium building boom in generations in the US and elsewhere in recent times, where by far the majority have been relocations downtown.

The transport strategy for Kirkby went through several revisions and ultimately was laughed out of the inquiry.... with the so-called experts discredited. Even Knowsley themselves recognised this, and were forced to add the last minute capacity-capping clause to cover the arses, when it became obvious that the plan could never deliver (or even come close). It rarely can with the out-of-town option, and the model certainly doesn't fit the traditional British football stadium senario.... with large localised walk-up support.

In any case the Kirkby stadium only offered minimal Exec box and corporate provision (well below most in the Prem). To the extent that just one new stand at GP could readily eclipse it in terms of exec boxes and lounges etc. This has all been demonstrated several times by many different people..... which only further illustrates the fact that Kirkby was always underpinned by falsehoods, and was fundamentally flawed.

There are no major obstructions to redeveloping GP..... there are several options to create the capacity and facilities required.... and these needn't cost anything like the mystical £300m as shown by several companies involved in stadium design.
Colin Fitzpatrick
88 Posted 12/02/2012 at 23:46:24
Dean, there's only so much patience a person can have and I'm related to a Saint so I must have some tolerance, somewhere!

What I never do is suffer fools and as Michael has pointed out this fella is crazy. Steavey is either the most ignorant person on the TW or a complete WUM.

Look at his last post; Everton can't redevelop because the area surrounding the ground isn't, "very attractive" yet Liverpool are redeveloping or building a new stadium a few yards away in a significantly worse area!

That's not to say I don't want to hear what he has to say; just like Michael I also welcome people with an opposing view because it's a great platform to highlight what's going / has been going on, but honestly, at times it's been like talking to Ian Ross; the lights are on but nobody's home.

TW has a reputation, quite rightly, for having a reasonable standard of debate, there are some great posters; they're not all of the same opinion but they fight their corner with a passion which I for one respect.

This guy is acting just like that donkey; in fact I'll apologise to the donkey..... for comparing it to Steavey!
Colin Fitzpatrick
89 Posted 13/02/2012 at 00:15:08
Great post Tom, one thing you missed was that it was claimed that moving to Kirkby was meant to inject £13M into the local economy due to visitors to the stadium; or to put it another way, take out £13M from the local economy of Walton, a constituency that, whilst housing two of the most successful football teams in the country, is also one of the most deprived in the country, far worse than the deprivation described by Tesco at Kirkby.

The belief that these clubs could be used to regenerate an area is anathema to some, as much as the though that football clubs should be community assets rather than existing simply for parasitic individuals to make a profit from.

The MP for Walton is lobbying the house for the plan to use football as an anchor for redevelopment; the city council leader has championed the concept which is mention in Lord Heseltine's and Sir Terry Leahy's report, Rebranding Britain, which will form the plan to attract funding and developers to the city.

We need somebody with the resources and the plan to induce a renaissance at Everton in place of the embarrassing free lunch failures that have become endemic during the Kenwright era. If this includes the Burnham backed Trust Everton all the better; hopefully with fans involved, fans that aren't simply worried about their pockets, the mistakes of the past is where they'll stay in the future.
Michael Kenrick
90 Posted 13/02/2012 at 05:55:15
Steavey (#544) ? Whatever you might believe about the suitability of Walton, Liverpool L4 as home for Everton Football Club, the fact is we're not going anywhere.

If you're going to have any kind of debate about Everton making progress, you need to address this reality. But, just like the club, you seem to be holding out for the mythical sugar daddy who is going to ride into town, build us a new stadium somewhere (where exactly?) and save us into perpetuity.

Just how many "interested parties" are there this week, eh, Steavey?
Steavey Buckley
92 Posted 13/02/2012 at 15:36:10
Tom Hughes #557

"Liverpool are content to stay in the area (which is far more derelict), and will attract major commercial sponsorship and support. Build the facilities, produce on the pitch and the commercial stuff will follow."

Liverpool are in the planning process of moving to a green field site called Stanley Park, with acres of land to develop. Yet, you are wanting Everton to be redeveloped hemmed in by old Victorian and Edwardian housing stock. But without greater finances from executive boxes, corporate hospitality and a new hotel, there can't be new and more exciting additions to the squad.
Steavey Buckley
93 Posted 13/02/2012 at 15:56:18
Michael Kenrick
#579 "Just how many "interested parties" are there this week, eh, Steavey?"

Since the Knowsley project was shelved, even though the Reebok stadium is, relatively, doing well, although built outside Bolton, the next alternative is building two stadiums, one for LFC and the other for Everton, in Stanley Park. And if all parties can agree, there maybe stimulation for someone to buy Everton, in a brief window of opportunity before the readies have to be made available.
Mark Riding
94 Posted 13/02/2012 at 16:14:27
Everton would have absolutley no chance of getting permission to build on Stanley Park..
I am not surprised by what Liverpool get away with anymore, but its staggering that they were given the go-ahead for their plans for Stanley Park... It's a protected site.
Steavey Buckley
95 Posted 13/02/2012 at 16:42:38
Mark Riding #701 If Liverpool can get permission, why can't Everton as well?
Mark Riding
96 Posted 13/02/2012 at 16:57:06
#707 Steavey... As far as Liverpool City Council are concerned, there is only one football club in Liverpool. They have the global fanbase... they have the trophy laden history... they have Gerry and the fucking Pacemakers... Need I go on??
Colin Fitzpatrick
97 Posted 13/02/2012 at 17:06:40
I sorry Michael but this guy's a fucking idiot he's reduced the site to something approaching a kindergarten.

Bolton? A club whose hotel turnover is more than its stadium, Stanley Park FFS? I get more sensible conversation out of my dog.

Tom Hughes has just taken the time to post an eloquent and informative post; someone who this whole site knows has an intimate knowledge of stadia and Liverpool and I've posted link after link on what the Council and the leader are attempting to do and have you seen his response to Tom?

Come on Michael, you must know who this is, he's a total WUM. Opinions are one thing but posting absolute uneducated bollocks is another.
Steavey Buckley
98 Posted 13/02/2012 at 17:19:12
Mark Riding: So there are no Evertonians in the Liverpool council chambers, just Liverpool fans? Or could it be, the Everton city councillors are the ones who just want to develop Goodison park?
Steavey Buckley
99 Posted 13/02/2012 at 17:26:55
31 Oct 2011 ? The 2010/2011 campaign saw Bolton Wanderers Football Club complete ... Turnover increased by 10% to £67.7m (2010: £61.7m) and retained ... Everton's turnover was not much more than Bolton's for the same period, with a bigger fan base.
Gavin Ramejkis
100 Posted 13/02/2012 at 17:21:09
This guy has to be a fucking wind up or completely clueless - "a green field site called Stanley Park with acres to develop" FFS you bell end have a look at google maps and look where the site is right next to Mordor and Goodison Park not even a different post code and the planning permission was on the former coach park not the acres of public park.
Steavey Buckley
101 Posted 13/02/2012 at 17:44:31
http://www.liverpooldailypost.co.uk/sport/everton-fc/everton-fc-news/2010/05/10/new-siamese-stadium-plan-for-liverpool-and-everton-football-clubs-unveiled-92534-26411613/

The proposal for a twinned stadium and a 300 bed hotel, which was rejected, not because of extra required land, which would have required more land than the former car park.
Mark Riding
102 Posted 13/02/2012 at 17:57:42
Steavey... it may well have been rejected because it's a shit idea?
Tom Hughes
103 Posted 13/02/2012 at 17:25:04
Steavey,
I have to agree with Colin, you appear to be talking in riddles which suggests a wind up. Unfortunately some of that mud can stick so I'll respond to some of your points: You said the area itself was unsuitable for execs/corporate etc, yet this is not the case for Liverpool building only a few hundred yards away? (who until very recently were also open to the redevelopment of their existing stadium, and may still return to that yet, as they have already done in Boston's Fenway ballpark)

Goodison Park does not necessarily NEED to be redeveloped on all four sides to easily exceed the exec and corporate offer of the Kirkby stadium. Many existing stadia have expanded to accommodate all such facilities and this can apply here also. The area adjacent to Bullens Rd is already earmarked for major redevelopment, and the Park end is a blank canvas that can quite simply accommodate any size stand. This can then be achieved without the additional expense of having to build 2-3 whole new stands. Indeed, it can be shown that adding new tiers to existing stands can create the capacity and quality to match anything proposed elsewhere (as achieved at Ibrox, Hillsborough, Old Trafford, St James and many others).... and this cost could be minimal in comparison to the whole new build model. I have a feeling you knew all this anyway.....
Steavey Buckley
104 Posted 13/02/2012 at 18:13:47
Both Old Trafford and Sports Direct on line football grounds are not hemmed in by houses. That was one of the reasons why BK did not want to redevelop Goodison Park. And the majority of Everton fans agreed. The higher GP goes with stands, there will be the inevitable planning appeal by local residents, something LFC experienced when they tried to redevelop Anfield. The increase in size of the stands would have to happen to accommodate more executive boxes, to match something in number that Old Trafford and the emirates have, which are about 150 each club.
Gavin Ramejkis
105 Posted 13/02/2012 at 18:38:50
Poor try Steavey, how would a second Tier on the Park End with an additional 5000+ seats alter any residents sight line with it backing onto open ground? Look up the previously posted drawings on reworked stands removing pillars and you'll see again no immediate need to build upwards to any massive extent again negating the argument of local residents who are only found on two sides of the stadium. A second tier on the Park End and a reworked Bullens Road would have no impact on residents. Too easy to dismiss again
Colin Fitzpatrick
106 Posted 13/02/2012 at 18:14:07
Steavey

Bolton -

http://www.bwfc.co.uk/staticFiles/5c/92/0,,1004~168540,00.pdf

Read it and weep you WUM, page 21, their gate receipts were £6.2m, their hotel receipts were £7m. Our gate receipts were 280% higher, sorry I don't have the figures for our hotel as we don't have the foresight to own one, our overall turnover is 22% greater than their whole group. I have no idea what your point is because you're coming out with that much shite. I know some people like to play fair and give some people the benefit of the doubt but this is turning into a turkey shoot.

The so called Siamese stadium wasn't rejected as it wasn't even considered. It was a design exercise by a few people, nothing more nothing less.

The leader of the council is a matchgoing Evertonian, as was the last leader. Once again this is what he and the council are backing:

http://www.guardian.co.uk/local-government-network/2012/jan/26/regeneration-practice-liverpool-football-quarter

This is what could happen, because the council who hold the key land are supportive; what you are descibing will never happen.

Like I said WUM.
Mark Riding
107 Posted 13/02/2012 at 18:47:08
I always felt the re-development of the Park End was a missed opportunity. In my opinion, two tiers is always the prefferred design. It also creates the chance to sell more tickets to away fans and put some more cash in the bank for 'less attractive' games.

I bet we still have the wooden crowd knocking about somewhere from the last development...
Mark Riding
108 Posted 13/02/2012 at 18:56:01
#738 Colin.. Thanks for the link to the local government article.. I may have to back track a bit on my clearly mis-informed slating of Liverpool City Council earlier on this thread !
Tom Hughes
109 Posted 13/02/2012 at 18:52:32
Steavey,

You obviously haven't been to St James park otherwise you would know that it's right on top of the city centre, and is completely lopsided because of the row of listed Georgian houses on one side.

There would be little or no overshadowing at GP since only 2 streets abutt the Bullens side, and remodelling may be taking place there in anycase. Villa Park was expanded across a fully occupied street. WHL may be too. Both have over 100 boxes within the footprint of their existing stadia. Kirkby had only 22 boxes if I remember right.... 30 less than 2nd division Leeds and more than 20 less than mighty Coventry. There are numerous other examples of similar expansions on similarly constricted sites. It was this constriction that prompted the building of this country's finest stadium in Walton. It can still be the case.... potentially generating something completely unique too.
Mark Riding
110 Posted 13/02/2012 at 19:19:46
Just read this link..
It was back in April 2003 that Everton finally shelved plans to move from Goodison Park to a 55,000 capacity stadium at King?s Dock. The new development had the backing of most Evertonians, it was walking distance from the city centre and it was much more than just a football stadium ? King?s Dock was an impressive project in terms of its scale and ambition.

The site would have been home to a ?housing and leisure complex? as well as a conference centre, all for an estimated cost of £300m. It also drew a few envious glances from the red half of Merseyside whilst they were struggling ? and still struggle ? to get plans to leave Anfield off the drawing board.

Mark Riding
111 Posted 13/02/2012 at 19:22:11
That one was the big one. Every time I drive past that place I think of what may have been

Kevin Ratcliffe, former Everton skipper
Richard Dodd
112 Posted 13/02/2012 at 19:23:36
But,Tom,we all know that if Bill announced he was ringfencing £10M to kick-start the revamp,he`d get pelters for srarving Moyes of funds!
No win situation!
Mark Riding
113 Posted 13/02/2012 at 19:30:29
Richard.. he would 'get pelters' as his ringfencing promises are not worth a wank !
Phil Walling
114 Posted 13/02/2012 at 19:36:42
And if Kenwright had been the perfect chairman in every other way,his failure to deliver King`s Dock would still mark his years at the helm as a disaster!
`The chairman who put personal pride before the interests of EFC.`will be his epitaph.
Tom Hughes
115 Posted 13/02/2012 at 20:29:57
Richard,

"But,Tom,we all know that if Bill announced he was ringfencing £10M to kick-start the revamp,he`d get pelters for srarving Moyes of funds!
No win situation!"

The point is.... ALL other clubs have found ways to juggle their finances to create the infrastructure and build teams at the same time. Many haven't had a fanbase the size of ours, or a manager who can fashion a side on a shoestring.... but they have essentially made the most of what they are and what they can be. Some of these clubs have now enjoyed the biggest average attendances in their history. We haven't delivered anything!! Many Clubs in lower divisions have completely rebuilt their stadia.... they have found new revenue sources, innovated or speculated, shown imagination to create new facilities either through phased redevelopment or new builds. They have shown foresight and imagination.... we have not!

The bottom line is: if you haven't got that level of ambition, determination and expertise you shouldn't be in charge. That's where we're at! Rudderless and potless, and totally reliant on Moyes working miracles with loanies and relative unknowns. Goodison could've had all these facilities several times over, but instead they squandered opportunity, and wasted years and millions chasing a fundamentally flawed white elephant!!

As stated the Kings Dock debacle illustrated the defficiencies.... that should've been a WIN-WIN situation, with DK the complete opposite end of the spectrum. This board has failed repeatedly!
Gavin Ramejkis
116 Posted 13/02/2012 at 20:59:38
Doddy the only way Black Bill would make £10m appear for redeveloping Goodison would be if he sold another player or took another loan from his "no friend of the club" or from the BVI (no difference there then) and got hit on the head, suffered complete amnesia and forgotten his complete unwillingness to spend a single penny on the place as per his last decade in control of the place.

An investment into the stadium over the last decade would have already generated income back into the club, it hasn't been and the reciprocated income has obviously not appeared accordingly.
Ray Said
117 Posted 13/02/2012 at 21:12:59
On an associated point, will the move to an elected Mayor with a Mayoral fund and the power to create 'Enterprise Zones' move the Football Quarter idea forward?
Steavey Buckley
118 Posted 13/02/2012 at 21:49:28
Colin Fitzpatrick
#738 In your efforts to make out that I am some kind of WUM, I can point your mind completely at rest, I would not bother.

The point that I was trying to make about Bolton, because they developed a new ground, they could add a hotel to their income stream. Something that can't be done around GP. Unless you want to turn the houses around GP into bed and breakfasts. And that won't bring in much.
Colin Fitzpatrick
119 Posted 13/02/2012 at 22:06:32
Would you care for a gentleman's wager over your last claim regarding a hotel at Goodison Steavey?
Tom Hughes
120 Posted 13/02/2012 at 22:04:04
Steavey,

City planners have already agreed that a hotel is a very viable proposition, and could be easily incorporated into a redeveloped Park end. It would have the benefit of being only 2 miles from a city-centre already boasting the highest hotel occupancy rates in the country (just over 1 mile from the proposed Liverpool waters development).... and of course close to another major prem club with a vast out of town support desperate for accommodation. Boxes can also be coverted to hotel rooms in minutes, and lounges into restaurants and conference facilities etc (as at Bolton and elsewhere).... all of which would dwarf that at Bolton for obvious reasons. Plans have already been generated to illustrate this.
Steavey Buckley
121 Posted 13/02/2012 at 22:01:16
Colin Fitzpatrick
738 & Tom Hughes 747: First, it is all about developing GP, which was shelved, when a majority supporters accepted, when they voted, they would be better off with a new stadium. Now it is to a football quarter, but nobody has said where it is going to be, and where the money is coming from. Then someone said around Anfield is the most deprived area in the UK. So where is the football quarter going to be exactly? Back to Stanley park? But someone said, that only the former car park is available. So that's it? And I have no doubt I will be answered with a WUM signature, when I, also, have no doubt, most supporters are like me, who are just as confused about the future direction of EFC.
Alan McGuffog
122 Posted 13/02/2012 at 22:22:32
I've missed a trick here, obviously. I gathered that Liverpool had opted, more or less, to shelve their Stanley Park plans in favour of tarting up Castle Greyskull ?
Is this not the case ?
Tom Hughes
123 Posted 13/02/2012 at 22:33:02
Steavey,

Your ignorance is either contrived or quite simply astonishing. You really haven't bothered to research any of this..... with stuff that is really old ground on here..... making statements that even Rossy would be too embarrassed to put his name to nowadays.... mind you that would be a novel concept in itself.

Where was the redevelopment option in your ballot literature? It wasn't an option, so how was it ever "shelved"? Why? because the club knew that if any alternative had been included, Kirkby would never have got past the vote..... only in the ensuing months did the club finally issue any documentation indicating ANY consideration of the redevelopment option as the clamour for its inclusion grew as all the lies were exposed.... and these were blatently biased and a mere after-thought. They even had the cheek to reproduce my drawings in them haha. Proving that no genuine attempt was ever made to study that option fully..... after-all, they knew no such option could ever include a massive retail development to reward our silent partners.

The club has never approached the issues with an effective process..... they nearly fluked it with the Kings Dock option, then blew it because the internal politics of the dysfunctional board and its complex ownership issues..... They then attempted to fit someone else's solution to our problem.... with the biggest square peg in a round hole that was DK.
Steavey Buckley
124 Posted 13/02/2012 at 23:21:36
Tom Hughes
#812 The fact remains, most Everton supporters are like me, confused. Where as you and others are giving the impression have already decided on where Everton's long term future is, when that decision can only be taken by BK and the majority of shareholders. The only decisions that can be taken here are to express each others opinions in the hope they can be taken serious by those who can make the decisions.
Tom Hughes
125 Posted 13/02/2012 at 23:32:23
Actually Steavey I think the fact that we have already had 3 votes would suggest that BK and the previous owners believe that the fans should have the decision.... Unfortunately, the last ballot illustrated how voters can be misled and falsely influenced.

Personally, I am very open-minded about the options. Always have been.... but the only realistic one at this moment is the redevelopment one. The site exists and functions already, and space is available on at least 2 sides to add further capacity and quality facilities. There is much that is salvageable in the existing structures, and that could be enhanced (as with Ibrox's mainstand). The transport issues are readily resolved and tried and tested.... the duopoly aspect holds potentially multiple opportunities..... not to mention all the potential benefits of preserving history/tradition and continuity generally.

Relocation to a more central site is an attractive option, but will require major enabling developments and/or a serious benefactor. If these particular planets align then perhaps it will become a contender.... but at this point we only have the opportunities and things to build on that is GP, and all it represents!
Dennis Stevens
126 Posted 14/02/2012 at 00:30:05
Steavey, you have twice asserted in this thread that a majority of Evertonians voted for DK - this is inaccurate. Even with all 'misinformation' & with only one option to vote for the result was only that the largest minority of the electorate selected by the club voted in favour. More people either voted against or abstained.
Mark Riding
127 Posted 14/02/2012 at 00:52:25
Tony l'Anson...

Just an idea, but the 'Trust Everton' crest, as seen on the top of your thread above, would make a cracking little badge / car sticker. I really do think you could sell literally thousands of them if marketed / sold correctly worldwide (eBay etc). Fiver a pop as a recommended price / donation...

As Sir Terry says 'Every little helps'... and it would raise funds quickly and get a bit of awareness out there. A spin on "The People's Club" phrase would be good... "The People Want Their Club Back".
Eric Myles
128 Posted 14/02/2012 at 01:22:47
I'm afraid Steavey is right, there are a lot of fans like him out there, fans that just don't want to listen to the facts put before them and only believe the misinformation coming out of the Club.

That much is obvious from reading this website where there are people prepared to debate the issues but my bet is that there are a lot of fans out there, maybe even a majority, that are not interested in the inner workings of the Club and only care about the match day experience.

It's those hearts and minds that have to be won over, not the members of this website.
Steavey Buckley
129 Posted 14/02/2012 at 10:54:46
Dennis Stevens #830

Trades unions backed by law follow the same voting proceedures, which Everton did, when they had the intention of moving to a new staduim. All perfectly legal.
Steavey Buckley
130 Posted 14/02/2012 at 11:00:36
Tom Hughes #820

The problem of not building 2 stadiums, for Everton and Liverpool FCs is also a political problem. Liverpool has to find ways of regenerating run down areas, so should not block where the clubs want to build. Yet, Liverpol council are also perceived as treating Liverpol FC unequally, which is not how most Evertonians see it.

Then there is a question of finances, how much are the council prepared to raise to help with the building of 2 stadiums, with cash-strapped Everton needing more money than cash-rich Liverpool FC.
John Keating
131 Posted 14/02/2012 at 11:30:21
Steavey. I would suggest you ask those Evertonians who initially voted for DK, how they would vote today, after learning of the lies and deceit that emanated out of their own football club during the inquiry.

Many people voted for DK, however, they were misled and lied to by the PR spin of the club. This all came tumbling down during the inquiry.

You talk about Trade Union officials, well they are elected by the members and can be voted out, if they are caught lying. Unfortunately we are and were unable to oust the Board after they were caught out in their catalogue of lies.

It is no good you just ignoring the fact that the Kirkby inquiry highlighted the incompetence of the present Everton management. You really just can't gloss over this and talk the shite you are talking.
Steavey Buckley
132 Posted 14/02/2012 at 11:50:17
John Keating #909

I was wanting to discuss strike ballots, sometimes only 40% of those eligible actually voted. More Everton supporters voted in their ground move, for or against.
Colin Fitzpatrick
133 Posted 14/02/2012 at 11:43:39
John #909

It's been very nostalgic reading the responses from Steavey; clueless, totally ignorant of both reality and how local government works, he could have earned a nice living from Everton four years ago as his belief in the veracity of the rigged vote and the perceived inability of redeveloping Goodison would earn a pat on the back from Bill at the very least.

Poster after poster has pointed out the error of his ways, link after link has been given to him but he bounces back like a rubber ball.

It's going to kill him looking at these two images of a redeveloped Park End which includes a hotel and conference centre, all of which can be achieved for a figure of £16m. Forming one element of a phased redevelopment, a board with resources and vision could, with the offer from the council, transform the area in which it exists.

http://www.toffeeweb.com/images/club/goodison/wcec-parkend.jpg

http://www.toffeeweb.com/images/club/goodison/wcec-interior.jpg
Steavey Buckley
136 Posted 14/02/2012 at 16:25:54
Colin Fitzpatrick #913

One of the reasons BK was against redeveloping Goodison park was the need to knock down properties adjacent to GP. Then there is the noise and disruption for local people, who may block any development with appeals.
Colin Fitzpatrick
137 Posted 14/02/2012 at 16:32:23
Steavey,

Do you take Lithium by any chance?

You appear to simply make things up as you go along, for example, Bill doesn't want to redevelop Goodison because of the need to knock down properties and that he was worried about noise and disruption; any chance of a link to that information?

Your grip on reality is concerning me. I've just posted some architects drawings on what you claim can't be done and this is your response.

Before you show yourself up any further I suggest you research Goodison; find out what Gwladys St looked like prior to 1939, find out about Goodison Avenue.

The only reason Bill Kenwright hasn't done anything with Goodison is that he has nether the money not the means to facilitate the money for any development which would increase the revenue streams for the club. He relies on the free lunch theory which has brought about abysmal failure at Kirkby and Goodison Place.

You're finished.
Steve Jones
138 Posted 14/02/2012 at 16:31:15
Colin,.

The images of the £16M hotel are very pretty, but, can you tell us what the projected occupancy rate is for it?

In short... with Evertonians predominantely local, who stays in the hotel? On non-matchdays especially, who stays in the hotel? Have any commercial studies been undertaken that prove conference facilities in Walton, several miles away from the more conveniently located facilities in the City Centre, are in demand?

I understand that the driving force behind the Football Quarter, from the BU/KEIOC standpoint, is to try and find something/anything to put tourists in the area to justify the building of that Park End hotel (that Walton just won't support any other way) but what happens if the Football Quarter doesn't happen?

Worse still, what happens if the FQ does get built and, like the National Football Museum, no-one comes spending money? We suddenly have £16M hotel and conference facilities that no-one uses, generates nothing for us and we are locked in to Walton by our philanthropic promises to be one half of the duopoly that heralds regeneration of the local community. This improves our lot financially, does it?

I've asked these questions on this site before, Colin, and been met with stunning silence so I'm not holding my breath this time either. Do feel free to denigrate my intelligence, experience and loyalty to the club though... as you appear to do anyone else who questions you.

Do me one favour though.... after you have called me naieve and witless, don't be shocked and stunned if I don't want to drink with you, okay?
Danny Harris
140 Posted 14/02/2012 at 17:41:29
Redeveloping Goodison? I would say you would be looking at least ten years to complete. All four stands need replacing. Say you did a stand every 2-3 years you would lose all the cash from them seats for the lengh of the project. Stadium only three-quarters full for 10 years must be very expensive.

All four stands must be of the size to adequatly hold all modern day facilities from co-operate boxes to bars, restaurants, fast-food outlets without ridiculous cues that we have now.

People need to realise the "match" will not be the only reason people will carry on going to the footy.In the long term they will look foward to the whole experience. The Emirates and Wembley type experience. This in the long term is how to make the stadia more profitable by been able to get the fans drinking in the stadia before the game instead of pubs and also eating there as well with great facilities. A great example of this is the Yankees stadium! The Americans know how to do facilities.

The point I'm trying to get to is can anyone see Goodison transformed into this type of vision with the land thats there and by doing it stand by stand. Not without demoliting the lot and starting again or finding new land to build. If say, we had one decent stand at least it would be a start point for the others but we don't! So surely a new stadium would be the only option for the future.
Mark Stone
141 Posted 14/02/2012 at 19:16:49
Colin, architects drawings are not evidence of feasibility. Just because something technically fits, doesn't mean you can put it there. Steavey doesn't know that it isn't feasible, just as you don't know that it is.

Not having a go at you, and haven't read the thread so I'm not commenting on anything but that specific post. I have nothing but praise for those of you who are pushing ideas like the Goodison redevelopment, and purchase of Finch Farm and both are things that I would commit to financially as much as I could. I shouldn't have to clarify those points, but to some of the vultures on here any question over the efficacy of these ideas is seen as bumming the board.
Tom Hughes
142 Posted 14/02/2012 at 20:17:43
Mark,
WCEC are specialists in designing extensions to existing stadium architecture, and associated facilities such as hotels etc.

They were absolutely overwhelmed by the potential at GP when they visited to carry out their assessment..... to the extent that they couldn't believe that full feasibility studies of this option had not been done already. In their experience this option was a relative formality, and ? given the value of the existing structures, their history, character and their potential ? that this option merited much greater consideration as a priority.

The City planners are also in agreement about the potential for expansion, and its viability..... as are several other bodies who have been consulted during the FQ initial studies...... and even long before that.
Stephen Kenny
143 Posted 14/02/2012 at 20:33:28
Tom,

You must agree that demand for hotels in Walton, which doesn't have particulary good transport links, is not likely to be that high. At least for 13 days a fornight anyway?
Tom Hughes
144 Posted 14/02/2012 at 20:28:14
Steve,

Liverpool has amongst the highest hotel occupancy rates in the UK (I think it was the highest rates last time I looked). This is why many new major hotels are being built continuously even through the current climate..... with several more to come (and not all in the city centre). The city planners agree that both within the FQ concept, and as stand-alone projects, a hotel development would be viable. This has formed part of the initial studies too, I believe.

Being in a prominent landmark location, on a major arterial road and just 2 miles to the city centre is a further attraction. There are many similar arrangements at a multitude of other stadia. Hotels are attracted by the prospect of association with prestigious clubs... sharing lounge, exhibition, conference, & catering areas overlooking world famous stadia is very enticing.... as proven elsewhere.

The FQ concept has the additional attraction of another massive Prem club next door. LFC's international fanbase have no localised bias regarding where they stay, and if anything would probably enjoy the opportunity to take in both stadia in one visit..... LFC fans already use EFC carparks, and wanted the tent too.

Evertonians are also based far and wide.... and in crowds of 35k+ a few thousand will have travelled substantial distances, and will be attracted too. Exiled blues visiting relatives will also be attracted to this opportunity..... Even Bolton's hotel has been a success, and that's in the middle of nowhere at a relative minnow of a club.

The football museum analogy is a bit off the mark since it was a one-trick pony in a one-horse town. The FQ is an entirely different prospect, on a far grander scale and in a much bigger city.

BTW, Colin is only reacting to ignorance persisting despite most of these issues having been resolved emphatically years ago. Even the club would not dare post the content of some of the stuff on this thread. In the past he has also had to contend with club stooges posting under several aliases.... not surprisingly when asked to show their faces, the same characters soon vanished behind excuses.
Colin Wainwright
145 Posted 14/02/2012 at 21:06:29
Steve (#979).

TBH, I can distinctly remember a couple of occasions, when you have posed your questions and received full and complete answers from both Tom and Colin, so I can't understand the tone of your post.

Steavey may or may not be a wind-up. He may be delusional, but his highjacking of a thread about Trust Everton, so as to spout this discredited shite regarding Kirby, seems to suggest he is.
Steavey Buckley
146 Posted 14/02/2012 at 21:42:57
Colin Wainwright #032

You appear to overlook one very important point, Everton is owned by the shareholders. You may not like that, but that's a fact. And what ever ideas you may have, that might fly, the shareholders are in a position to reject them.

It was the same with Manchester United supporters with the Glaziers. But the Glaziers are still there as owners, while those who wanted them out, are not as vocal these days. Because Ferguson (like Moyes) supports the owners.
Mark Stone
147 Posted 14/02/2012 at 21:44:56
Tom, wasn't the same thing said about the East Stand at St James Park though? But when it came to planning it was knocked back.
Colin Wainwright
148 Posted 14/02/2012 at 22:00:50
Steavey. You cannot compare the Glazers with Bill. Finch Farm is not Everton's asset, but a drain on finances and a black hole on the balance sheet, with all the cash going to a third party.

Trust Everton and the current Everton board bear no resemblance to anything that has occured at Utd over the past ten years.
Steve Jones
149 Posted 15/02/2012 at 10:30:12
Tom (#030)

Thank you for the response... meant sincerely.

Liverpool may have high rates of hotel occupancy, but how does that breakdown to Walton? It's flippant to say it but I've never seen crowds of Japanese tourists wandering about the 'historic cemetery' or snapping roll after roll of film of the significant local architecture etc. If there is a major tourist presence in Walton then they're bloody discrete... arterial road a couple of miles out of town or not.

Hotels are enticed by occupancy rates... if the stadium is somewhere where there is a draw then a hotel capitalising on the niche of association with a recognisable brand is going to be attractive. That doesn't fit Walton though, does it? On non-matchdays, people are going to be drawn 2 miles out of town, away from all that is on offer there, just because their room overlooks an empty football stadium? I'm not in marketing but I think you'd find that a tough sell to be honest.

I appreciate what you say about LFC fans potentially being willing to stay at an EFC hotel, but, why are LFC going to sit still and let that revenue escape again? This is the outfit that want to split out of the Prems agreement with Sky so they get more TV money at the expense of the leagues smaller clubs? If they see revenue from their fans going into our coffers every other week, why are they not going to build their own hotel and pocket that? Do we lose nearly 50% of our hotel revenue when that happens?

You've mentioned 'city planners' a few times, Tom; would I be right in saying that there have been reports prepared that indicate the viability of a hotel in Walton such as that described? If so, is that published and available anywhere?

The National Football Museum is a clear indicator of the state of football tourism in this country. If it really was a case of 'one-trick pony' then why did it get 40,000 visitors the year after they made it free to enter?

People will go and look at football memorabilia etc but, unless it's their team or they have some personal connection, they won't pay for it. Is that a great surprise though? Spurs, Arsenal, United etc have had some legendary players and hugely contributed to the development of the English game... but would you pay to go around a museum of their history? I wouldn't.

Without that Football Museum (presumably a joint enterprise from the clubs themselves?) income it is hard to see where the Football Quarter puts revenue back into the clubs in any direct form? Unless the only value to Everton is the hope that visitors to the museum might stay in the notional Park End hotel?

If memory serves, the majority of the 40,000 visiting the 'free' National Football Museum were locals taking advantage of a free local day out. Putting a hotel next to that institution, before it was shut down and moved to a conference venue in Manchester, would not have been a recipe for success would it?

As for your spirited defence of Colin, that's fine, but he branded one guy an 'Internet Warrior' because he didn't want to drink with him or meet him at the match! Come on, how arrogant is that?! I take my kids to the match and, personally, it's special time for me... last thing I want is that ruined having a slanging match with someone who brands me a mug because he's met the board more times than I have!

If someone can't debate without condescension in a nice sterile environment like this, close physical proximity rarely makes things better!.
Tom Hughes
150 Posted 15/02/2012 at 12:06:24
Mark,
I'm not overly familiar with St James East stand project but I know Trevor Skempton was involved in looking at how to expand it.... and other planning issues with the stadium generally.

The obvious difference there being that this row of Georgian Terraces are listed. The end Terraces abutting the Bullens (or anywhere around the stadium) are not. Newcastle eventually chose the route of least resistance.... and have further planning consent to finish the Gallowgate..... The current owner has decided to shelve that idea for now.... but it is still an option.
Tom Hughes
151 Posted 15/02/2012 at 12:16:16
Steve,

There are several hotels outside the city centre.... There are even some in Kirkby, Queens Drive, Speke, Croxteth, Huyton and elsewhere. This is a landmark site on a major road (the extension of the East Lancs) with a destination status.... and it's a short taxi ride from the city-centre too. It would also be linked to all the other facilities and developments planned... hence my referral to a one trick pony.

It is not just about football tourism (but that is also immeasureably greater here than it is in Preston), but major developoments that will bring greater footfall and demand for accommodation. All that said, have you ever been to the Reebok.... it is miles away from anything, and the Hotel works well.

Given the city's high occupancy, the planners had little hesitation in confirming its viability in principle (several years ago)..... LFC will probably have their own hotel planned (I think one appeared in at least one of their schemes). However, if you have ever tried booking a hotel room in Liverpool on matchdays, you'll know this alone will not meet full demand (and there are thousands of rooms in the centre).

As far as reports are concerned, I was only involved when discussing my original plans..... The FQ scheme is at a more advanced stage, and you would have to ask Colin, KEIOC or the city-planners involved.

I have no need to defend Colin..... he has had to suffer many fools and some poisonous stooges on these pages over the years..... he's less inclined to do so now, so long after his initial concerns were fully vindicated, and the lies were put to bed. To hear some of the same crap spouted now is not reasoned nor reasonable debate.... it's quite frankly unbelievable, and has all the trademarks of a few "old friends" making an appearance (so needless to say they'll never agree to meet).

He is however a very approachable and affable character. He's a straight talker.... but there you go: you can take the lad out of Everton, but you can't take Everton out of Col..... as they might say!
Phil Bellis
152 Posted 15/02/2012 at 13:07:14
Jesus, what a brilliant performance from young Buckley. Must be half-term...

As a great man once said "here's a pound son, go and buy some sweeties"
Steve Jones
153 Posted 15/02/2012 at 13:35:08
Tom,

So what, it's a landmark site? It's still 'a short taxi ride' away from all the attractions in the City centre that are not a short taxi ride away if you stay in a hotel in the city centre. Without the football element what is left to attract tourists to the FQ?

Bars, restaurants etc, etc are plentiful in the city centre. Are people going to come all the way out to Walton just to have a nice meal in the shadow of an empty Goodison? Seriously, has any market research been done that says this is a goer?

I don't doubt that on matchdays a hotel would get full occupancy, and be able to charge way above the odds doing so, but in the week where is the trade coming from?

The Reebok hotel fills in this gap by being sat less than a mile off the M61 junction and gets passing trade from that, just like all the motorway services Travelodges do. If you accept that passing trade is going to be harder to come by in Walton then you see it's not a like-for-like comparison.

Fair enough on what you say the city planners described to you. Hopefully Colin can flesh that one out that some evidence exists to support the business case for a hotel at Goodison.
Steve Jones
154 Posted 15/02/2012 at 14:05:43
Err....

"Its still 'a short taxi ride' away from all the attractions in the City centre that are not a short taxi ride away"

should read....

"Its still 'a short taxi ride' away from all the attractions in the City centre that are not a short taxi ride away if you stay in a hotel in the city centre"

bloody cut/paste
Steavey Buckley
155 Posted 15/02/2012 at 16:18:44
Colin Wainwright #050

I came into this thread to comment on the Finch Farm deal, which I believe was too high at 15% rent or lease per year. Then I got embroiled in other aspects of the club, then I was accused of hijacking the thread. Who do those, who accused me, think I am, from the PLO?
Michael Kenrick
156 Posted 15/02/2012 at 16:28:11
Steavey,

I imagine most people would hopefully confirm that they think their viewpoints are based on a perception of reality that is communicated to them from the world outside.

The problem comes when you ignore or arbitrarily dismiss external information that shows your perceptions to be flawed.

It's hard to come on an internet forum like this and admit you are wrong about anything, that you are clinging to perceptions spun to you by the club that have been proven beyond all doubt to be not only wrong but deliberately deceptive.

I don't think you've even acknowledged any of the rebuttals, instead coming back with counter-points that continually deflect the discussion, rather than addressing the flaws in your position. That in itself is annoying to those who've taken the considerable time and trouble to reply to your posts.

You say you are confused about the future direction of EFC, yet it's your confusion about the past of EFC that causes the most concern. If you won't accept the truth about what went on in the past, what hope is there for any rational discussion about the future?
Colin Fitzpatrick
157 Posted 15/02/2012 at 19:08:38
Steve, [Jones]

You haven?t been left with stunned silence whatsoever, and well you know it, as your rather pathetic parting shot implies. When you asked questions about the Quarter the thread fell off the front page before I could answer, just as this one has. I replied to you in another thread, I answered;

Steve, 93.
Off topic but the other week you asked me a few questions about the proposed FQ; unfortunately I have been unable to respond until now. Michael will let you have my email address I?ll respond to you directly, or if you?re really interested we could meet up at the Bolton or Stoke games?

You subsequently ignored this yet continued to post. Tom Hughes, answering you in the same thread, even gave you a gentle reminder;

Steve,
So you'll be volunteering your services then, and accepting Colin's invitation? Or are you all talk and hot air....? I can't see anything you say that hasn't already been tried thus far.

After this apparent snub, I was surprised that when there was a lively TW debate on the very well attended launch of Football Quarter prospectus in December, you were somewhat conspicuous by your absence.

Surprised is of course a little disingenuous; after making a twat of yourself having wrote in October , ?Dangling the 'Football Quarter' carrot in the Times now? How long will it be until the realisation dawns that no-one is interested, commercially, in the Football Quarter for a reason!? is more like it or being ashamed to show your face would be a far more accurate explanation for your absence.

Making a twat of yourself is something you have carefully honed to perfection. Another prime example was when you wrote in the thread about the Blue Union?s meeting in Zeligs,

?Comparing us to Spurs in financial terms... are you kidding??

On and on you droned, paragraph after paragraph about how it was a ridiculous commercial comparison; except it wasn't a commercial comparison between the clubs at all.

If you had taken the time to actually attend the meeting and listen to the presentation or read the newsletter that was produced afterwards, you would have discovered that it was a comparison between the performances of our respective directors and nothing to do with what had you jumping up and down like a child.

It was a 12-year comparison explaining how Spurs directors have taken a business with net assets of £41M and developed it into one with net assets of £70M whilst Everton?s directors have taken a business with net assets of £20M and have repressed it into one with net LIABILITIES OF £35M.

It explained how Spurs are paying for their new £30M Bulls Cross training facility and how they have plans in place for their much needed Northumberland development in WHL which will accommodate the 33,000 people on the paid for season ticket waiting list, whilst Everton?s directors have delivered a facility that appears to be inexplicably draining an additional £11M out of the business every year and have no further plans whatsoever as their only strategy is an exit strategy.

Look before you leap would be an adage that you should embrace because, frankly, I could be here all day highlighting the failings of your observations which appear to me to be motivated by a need to discredit and smear any fans who show the slightest amount of initiative, the Blue Union and KEIOC being prime examples of your incessant, unwarranted and highly ignorant criticism.

You have been very critical / sceptical of the Football Quarter on this site, like I said, you?ve been very critical of any fan initiative; your eagerness to criticise leaves you looking rather foolish at times, a condition which you appear completely oblivious to. Prior to the publication of the prospectus and your subsequent disappearance, you stated that it was a non-starter; you asked questions, you still do, but these aren?t designed to advance your knowledge or the knowledge of anyone else, you just think you?re being clever and that you?re highlighting ill-perceived weaknesses in the concept that will somehow devalue its worth; I think your eagerness to criticise at all costs makes you look a twat, but there you go.

Your previous questions on the Football Quarter included asking "What interest if any had the Football Quarter received from the private sector?" Well, the publication of the prospectus and the partners involved in its production, answered that one.

Your next question involved the feasibility study; once again, the publication answered this, as did the published pre-feasibility study carried out by Liverpool University's Dr Alan Southern.

Your next concerned the question which both club?s obviously asked, ?What?s in it for me?? ? the answer to which lies in persuading the council to make available land for both redevelopment and development, which if you?ve listened to the leader of the council is exactly what has happened ? over 40 acres ? which nobody from our club has ever managed to achieve.

Now you?re asking what the projected occupancy rate is for a hotel at Goodison and the simple answer is, I have no idea. I?m told by the operators and designers [architects] of hotels attached to football stadia that they have occupancy rates of over 70%. I also have no idea how many football industry degrees will be bestowed through the involvement and presence of Liverpool University, or another, and I have no idea what fees will be charged, but I do know, like the hotel operators, that they?re interested.

You wouldn?t have the effrontery to ask Peel Holdings what the projected occupancy rates for the hotels planned for Liverpool Waters were; they couldn?t tell you either, but you feel confident to ask mere football supporters because you feel their ideas aren?t worthy of consideration. To me, you come across as TW version of Philip Carter. Good God what is the world coming to, these people will be wanting to live in Wirral next... ;-)

Your questions and criticism merely betray your complete and demonstrable inability to understand what is being put before you. You believe the Football Quarter is nothing but a ridiculous tourist destination, which it isn?t, hence your waffle about who?s going to stay in the hotels and visit football museums on non-match days.

Like most, you?re fully aware of the commercial failings of Everton Football Club; we simply don?t generate sufficient revenue to compete with our perceived peers. It?s a no-brainer. The ideal solution to this is a new stadium. In an ideal world, the best solution for Everton would be to say good-bye to Goodison one Saturday night and walk into a brand new state-of-the-art stadium the following Monday. I know it, you know it, Robert Elstone knows it; I?ve agreed with him on many occasions.

That would be in an ideal world; unfortunately we don?t live in an ideal world, we live in the real world and the reality is someone is going to have to finance this stadium and find a suitable location that meets the specific needs of Everton. Perhaps you can show me a Premier League Club whose owner has paid for their stadium? Perhaps you can show me a suitable site in Liverpool where the new owner of Everton can build a new stadium. Neither Everton nor Liverpool can; they have examined 35 potential sites and have both agreed that they all fail to meet the criteria for building a Premier League grade stadium.

That is the background to the Football Quarter. It?s an attempt to solve a problem and make the most of what we have. The technical constraints on redeveloping Goodison to a stadium that maximises the potential of both matchday and non-matchday revenue, isn?t unachievable; in fact it isn?t even that taxing.

The phased redevelopment is obviously the most cost-effective solution and requires little thought to ensure attendances don?t fall below economic levels during construction. It?s not as though these problems haven?t been solved elsewhere.

With all Premier League clubs now being in the FFP era, clubs now must look to maximising their ability to generate revenue; some clubs have massive fan bases to exploit, Everton will need to look elsewhere.

To encourage the potential for increased non-matchday income, the area around the stadium and facilities including leisure, retail, educational and cultural on offer, along with transport facilities, all need improving, drastically improving in some cases, and this is what a small group of fans have attempted to do, they?ve attempted to make a difference, an achievable difference, one that meets with the proposals outlined in the three elements of the North Liverpool Strategic Regeneration Framework which are, Economy & Employment, People & Communities and Neighbourhood and Places.

The concept was also included in the report ?Rebranding Britain? after a presentation to Lord Heseltine by the City Council. This report will influence Government funding of projects in the city over the next two decades. These things don?t just happen by accident, they happen as a consequence of the work Evertonians are conducting, not for financial benefit but for the potential of Everton as a club.

Whilst Evertonians at KEIOC and Trust Everton are attempting to make a change the board are sitting there waiting for Keith Harris to come up with something. Keith Harris whose productivity is equal to the square root of nothing.

You choose to criticise these Evertonians because you think you understand but you don?t. Even when your ramblings are explained to you, you still don?t have the good grace to admit your failings; I have no doubt whatsoever that you'll still attempt to wriggle out of your Spurs comparison fiasco.

It?s a personal irritation of mine that people who predominately do nothing, save sit behind a keyboard, deem it necessary to react negatively to ordinary fans attempting to make a difference. You of course do not enter that category as you have made several suggestions on what the Blue Union should be concentrating.

Last year you suggested that rather than demonstrating, and handing out leaflets, their time would be better served by large-scale fundraising towards producing a professional promotional campaign for the club to enhance its appeal, thereby enabling it to be sold.

You put forward several suggestions which included a ?'Buy us a Pint? matchday campaign whereby fans would give up their pint of Chang and donate £5 to the Blue Union?s campaign to enhance and promote the sale of the club and hit the club where it hurts; in the bottom line. You also said that you were emailing the Race for Life people to find out how they organised their runs that attracted 24,000 people on the basis that you believed, with a lot of local support living close to the stadium, you?d get a turnout approaching 6,000. Simple question, how did you get on?

My own view is that I?d find the idea of fans contributing their hard-earned cash to the quest of a group of multi-millionaires to obtain a return on the money they used to secure a club that they have systematically bled dry abhorrent and pretty much close to ridiculous, as I believe the majority of matchgoing Evertonians would be of the same opinion.

Your notion that this would damage the club is also flawed; we?ve sold off the catering along with just about everything else so this act wouldn?t affect the outsourcing payment.

Having said all that, I?ll support you; it may come as a surprise but I don?t agree with demonstrations or leaflets either, but democracy rules and I?ll support any idea that proves to be efficient and all the demonstrations have been very efficient at what they were designed for; attracting publicity from the media.

You?re a shareholder, why don?t you join the Shareholders Association and shake them up a little bit, at least if you could persuade them to fund such a campaign at least they?d see something for their endeavours!

It takes a big man to admit that they were wrong ? I won't hold my breath.
Tom Hughes
158 Posted 15/02/2012 at 19:23:01
Steve,
What market research do you really need when the model has been a success at most football clubs in the country? How many examples do you need?

Walton Lane is a major arterial road into a major city. GP sits right on it.... not half a mile away, this has massive passing trade literally on its doorstep. This is a site serving not one, but two Prem clubs with a combined fanbase the size of both Manchester clubs.... it dwarfs Bolton many times over. Bolton in comparison is a relative backwater..... there are many more besides, and even more planned from Newcastle to Burnley and everywhere in between. Newcastle alone have a £300m scheme with planning consent... to deliver similar facilities such is the pull of Prem clubs etc.

The intention is to build in new demand for conferences and exhibitions as well as new educational institutions spread between the clubs.... on top of the already substantial footfall that currently has to stay elsewhere. We are not Preston nor Bolton, and Liverpool city centre can compete with anywhere in the UK.... literally! The proposed new developments at Liverpool Waters will be closer still, and the potential is almost limitless.
Steve Jones
159 Posted 15/02/2012 at 22:46:20
Simple, Tom ? I need the market research that says a hotel is viable in Walton a) now, and b) after FQ is built ? if ever it does get built.

Walton Lane is not a major motorway like the M61 and doesn't have the same useage. It isn't even the way most out-of-towners get to the city... that's the M62 to the Rocket and down Edge Lane.

If you want to stick a new stadium on Edge Lane with a hotel, then maybe that's a flyer, but let's not pretend there is any comparison between the M61 and a local route like Walton Lane!

As for passing trade, why do locals, the predominant users of Walton Lane, need a hotel? Hotels are built on motorway services because the passing trade is there in non-locals ? case in point: the M61 which is a primary route between Manchester and points east through to the M6 and up to Scotland. The customer base is people transitting through the area... if they are travelling to Liverpool, odds are by the time they get to Walton they are nearly at their destination, so why stop at a hotel just a couple of miles short of where they are going? Far from plentiful, the passing trade at Goodison is going to be near non-existent.

What does it matter if Newcastle or anyone else is doing it, Tom? You used Bolton as your initial example and I've had to show you how flawed it is because the commercial backdrop is completely different between the two places. So what works at one site has no bearing on what works at another. What's important, to us, is the commercial environment in Walton ? not that next to Leazes Park.

You say the intent is to 'build in demand'? How do you build in demand when you are in direct competition with world class venues that have far better surrounding facilities and are closer to national and international transport links in the city centre? You have to recognise the serious handicap you are starting from.

The substantial footfall you are talking of is matchday only. There has still been no explanation as to where the substantial footfall is for the days when there aren't thousands of fans milling about? I just did a quick check on Active Hotels website and there is availability tomorrow night at 70 out of 86 hotels listed in Liverpool ? and that's on school holidays!

You see why I'm keen on seeing the specific evidence that backs up the faith you guys seem to have in this Park End hotel? It's not an unreasonable request surely seeing you are asking the wider Evertonian community to share your vision?
Dennis Stevens
160 Posted 16/02/2012 at 00:53:39
Steavey, I'm chuffed to bits to hear the Trade Unions are complying with the relevant laws. Not too sure of the relevance though, as I'm not aware of having suggested that Everton had breached either Trade Union or any other legislation. I merely pointed out that even within the electorate selected by the club, the majority did not vote in favour of DK & therefore it is inaccurate for you to state otherwise.
Eric Myles
161 Posted 16/02/2012 at 01:38:03
Steve Jones "Bars, restaurants etc, etc are plentiful in the city centre. Are people going to come all the way out to Walton just to have a nice meal in the shadow of an empty Goodison? Seriously, has any market research been done that says this is a goer?"

Could be Desperation Kirkby you're describing there mate.

But don't foget there are actually people that live in Walton, quite a lot of them in fact. Where do they go for a night out now?
Tom Fazal
162 Posted 16/02/2012 at 02:27:35
Tom and Colin,

Thank you both so much for taking the time to provide such detailed and informative responses in this thread, I have learned a lot. Please keep up the good work, those who attempt to create possibility are always easy targets, but without such people nothing ever changes.

I am open to change, I would have been very happy to have gone to Kings Dock, not to DK, but I am sick of either silence or lies from those allegedly in control of events at Goodison. My club is at risk and I support those who are willing to stand up and offer ideas, if we cannot move then phased redevelopment is required.

Michael, Lyndon there are a number of informative links in this thread, might it make sense/be possible to have a spot on the site where they and any others relevant could be made available so others can educate themselves?

Steve Jones
163 Posted 16/02/2012 at 09:23:14
Colin,

So you did answer me just not on the same thread and at some later point?. OK...how much of a twat I am not to have caught that?!. Toms gentle reminder would have been great had I read it...I'll have to check the archives of the site but I recall neither it or any invite you made. Generally, if I don't get answers to questions after a while, I take it they are not going to be forthcoming and move on. I'm not exactly a prolific poster on this site and that's not going to change much.

As for my absence from the FQ launch, I read the prospectus. It said very little of note in nice fancy wrapping... the basic tune hadn't changed. No commercial backing. No publically acknowledged club interest. No feasibility study. What was there to discuss? The quality of the graphics?

The Spurs thing was all about the Directors? The directors naturally being able to operate fully independently and without constraint by the commercial environment their clubs are in, eh? Of course, again, what a twat I am not to grasp this simple principle. The landlord of a pub in Walton, with a customer base of lads on the dole, should be absolutely capable of generating exactly the same revenue as the owner of a bar in London with lots of nice rich patrons... and if he doesn't then, by god, he's just not trying hard enough, is he? Colin said so... For pity's sake, man.

I've been and am very critical of something that seems solely intended to lock Everton into Walton with nothing better to be said for it other than 'its the best we've got'. Lots of the vocal BU-ites wave the 'nil satis nisi optimum' banner as indictment of the board or the manager or the current player who's not up to the mark, but, let's face it, the FQ isn't following the principles either, is it?

To me, it's pissing around the fringes of the problem and it's sketchy as a solution at best. If you can't convince me it's any more than that, why do you expect me to support you? You're advocating a gamble with the future of the club which, even it it pays off, isn't likely to be wholly adequate to give us the extra revenue we need to compete at the top! Which is the bottom line.

The rank and file, Colin, believe that the FQ represents massive new revenue stream opportunities that will save us and give the manager millions for a transfer pot every season. The truth is somewhere short of that, isn't it... but you don't seem to be in a hurry to point that out?

This is why I feel the need to ask the questions that you claim are solely intended to discredit you and KEIOC. Like the board you oppose, you always seem to stop short of being completely frank and open. Either that or you are genuinely ignorant of the matters you are professing knowledge of... which I find more scary to tell you the truth.

You are throwing your full weight of support behind this Park End hotel and you've not seen if there is even a robust business case for it? Seriously? You have hotel chains interested, but, no market research has been done? These really are not unreasonable questions, Colin.

"Your previous questions on the Football Quarter included asking what interest if any had the Football Quarter received from the private sector, well the publication of the prospectus and the partners involved in its production, answered that one."

No, I missed that, perhaps too subtle for me... who was providing commercial backing for the project again? Pre-feasibility study by an interested academic is not a commercial feasibility study is it?

Congratulations on getting the council to donate 40 acres of land though... that catch of you having to get someone to do the regeneration for them on the land, at zero cost to them, is a bit of a doozy though! Must have been criminally difficult for you to get them to agree to let you handle part of their regeneration scheme for them on someone else's coin.

"You feel confident to ask mere football supporters because you feel their ideas aren't worthy of consideration."

No. I ask mere football supporters because it's THEIR plan that will impact the future of the club I love! FFS, Colin if the market research exists showing that this fucking hotel is viable and will pump £15-20M in extra turnover into the club per year, just put it up somewhere.

You know what? Do that and I'll apologise to everyone here ? you first and foremost ? and I'll shut up and go away! If you can't have the damned grace to realise that asking reasonable questions you should be able to answer about YOUR plan doesn't mean you're being subject to the bastard Spanish inquisition!

"Neither Everton nor Liverpool can; they have examined 35 potential sites and have both agreed that they all fail to meet the criteria for building a premiership grade stadium."

Liverpool's requirements are different to ours as point one. Everton thought that Kirkby was viable as point two... they were wrong then, but, now you trust them that they are right on this? OK.

I'm not doubting the phased upgrade of Goodison could deliver a bigger stadium, I think 'not taxing' glosses over some issues with planning permission, but, it should be deliverable as you say. I dont think it will bring in enough revenue to do anymore than see us tread water though. I think a serious commercial investor would see we aren't going anywhere commercially, even with a revamped Goodison, to get to the next level and, because of it, we are more likely to be stuck with the present halfwits in the boardroom, or another bunch like them, for an extended period.

You don't need to go into the full campaign speech for the FQ... I get it. You know Walton offers no prospects for competing with the city centre conference venues as is so, rather than move the stadium, you are trying to rally support to make Walton as popular as the city centre... all under the guise of this regeneration bollocks. Those with their own vested interests are onboard for their own purposes. It's all fairly transparent. Bottom line is though, Colin, what does it look to make for the club?

"You also said that you were emailing the Race for Life people to find out how they organised their runs that attracted 24,000 people on the basis that you believed, with a lot of local support living close to the stadium, you'd get a turnout approaching 6,000. Simple question, how did you get on?"

Didn't amount to a lot in the end. With the BU, the mechanism I was expecting to use to advertise the effort, marginalising itself and the support more modest than expected there didn't seem much point in carrying it on.

"They have systematically bled dry abhorrent and pretty much close to ridiculous as I believe the majority of matchgoing Evertonians would be of the same opinion."

Can't argue with that. I want them gone though and, if that means they walk off with a profit, they are still walking off... which beats them still being in charge. There is a place for 'do first, question later' and this is it. Let's have the 'who deserved what' conversation after they are gone and we have better owners in place.

"It takes a big man to admit that they were wrong ? I won't hold my breath."

We agree on two things finally then.


Eric Myles,

Hope you are still reading this far down. If you are I agree that the FQ would be great news for Walton residents. Property prices should get a nice little nudge upwards as well. If you have a house in the immediate area, there is no shadow of doubt that you want this to happen!

Problem for the club is that locals going to the bars and eateries doesn't put any money in their coffers. The only benefit EFC are likely to see is from the hotel and you need out-of-towners to fill that as locals will just toddle back off home at the end of their evening. So, while you are right, that's not really the point of the exercise.
Brian Harrison
164 Posted 16/02/2012 at 10:05:56
Steve Jones

Completely agree with all the points you make. I would doubt a hotel in Walton would have any real draw except on match days. I would also suggest that it would predominantly be used by visiting Liverpool fans on match days, as there fans come from far and wide.

Regarding the issue of upgrading Goodison, while I am sure this could be done. I would ask how do we make up the shortfall in money from the reduced attendances while the reconstruction takes place.

Finally I would like to congratulate Tony I'Anson on looking at trying to start something positive. I think it's a pity that now the asking price is £15 million ? it seems an immense amount to raise via our fan base. But I wish him all the very best for his initiative.
Colin Fitzpatrick
165 Posted 16/02/2012 at 13:30:05
Steve,

I've merely glanced at your post, another load of shite by the looks of it. I know you'd love me to read the straw -lutching excuses in full and be annoyed enough to answer you, but after reading your responses to Tom, I realised that your opinions are both nonsense and redundant.

You're nothing more than a literate version of Steavey; like him, you simply ignore facts, professional opinion means little to you as you drone on and on and zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz.

You have little understanding of the development process, a process explained to me by those who delivered Liverpool One; your experience is?

Professionals in the public AND PRIVATE sector must be re-evaluating their position at the news that Steve Jones doesn't think a hotel or redevelopment of Anfield, Walton and Goodison is commercially viable ? along with declaring that Walton Lane and County Road aren't major thoroughfares.

The fact that Brian Harrison supports you speaks volumes; his post is an illustration of the fact that, no matter what is put in front of people, some people are unable to read, understand or process it and in this state of oblivion they're not embarrassed to exhibit it; my dog would be embarrassed by that last post but I have the feeling he's as pleased as punch.
Steve Jones
166 Posted 16/02/2012 at 14:45:17
Colin,

You accuse me of ignoring facts. Chance would be a fine thing! Can you please supply some for me to ignore?

I appreciate you are trying to use the very hackneyed "can't kill the message so kill the messenger" routine. I've no idea why are you bothering though...

I'm not interested in disrupting your sermons from the mount on here; I am asking very simple questions about the viability of your plans for the club. OK?

I'll trim it down to just three if that makes things clearer and less turgid to have to wade through:

a) Have there been ANY studies undertaken, by KEIOC, or an interested commercial party, that proves the business case for a hotel on the Park End of the ground?

b) Who is the commercial partner funding the feasibility study into the Football Quarter?

c) Is there an expectation that the Football Quarter will add direct revenue into the club in routine operation?
Colin Fitzpatrick
167 Posted 16/02/2012 at 16:04:52
Steve, you're making a fool... sorry, a greater fool of yourself. You're finished.
Tony I'Anson
168 Posted 16/02/2012 at 16:09:15
People have asked who is behind Trust Everton, so my head has been placed above the parapet:

http://www.youtube.com/​watch?v=oQ16Rb0bjBU&feature=plc​p&context=C38febeaUDOEgsToPDsk​JCFUazhFcquLy-Ds2oW71P

This short video clip was recorded when invited to speak to EFC Shareholders Association earlier in the week. We hope this approach encourages more Evertonians to fill in the survey and enable us to progress to the next stage.

(ps: Tony insists that the camera adds 20lbs.)
Tony I'Anson
169 Posted 16/02/2012 at 16:11:10
Sorry, link never worked. Try this one. http://www.youtube.com/trusteverton
Steve Jones
170 Posted 16/02/2012 at 16:14:49
Answers, Colin?

Apologies, Tony.
Tom Hughes
171 Posted 16/02/2012 at 20:11:35
Steve,

If this scheme had not been so well received and backed by professionals in this field, and local officials, then you might have a point. However, we have gone way past that stage...

When city planners who have been involved in multi-billion pound developments say that a Hotel at GP is a viable prospect, I'd tend to believe them... It doesn't mean that it would have to be the size of the Adelphi (but it doesn't have to be).

When the hotel/conference/exhibition centre idea was first discussed with officials several years ago, they were fully aware of its potential and all in agreement. These were people sitting on planning applications for numerous new hotels all over our city. Many national chains recorded their best results at their Liverpool hotels and were desperate to expand. We can now see the results with duplicate hotels of every variety... and there are still more being built and others in the pipeline, if you wish to view new planning applications.

Liverpool has bucked the national trend. Their overwhelming opinion was that there would be no shortage of takers. This, combined with the fact that so many other stadia have hotels or are planning them too, adds to that argument. Of course the added incentive for GP is that there will be not one but two large Prem stadia, and other developments feeding it.

If what you say is true, then there wouldn't be any hotels at any football grounds... nevermind any other peripheral sites. They are all over most cities nowadays.... and not just next to motorways... which when you enter cities are only 6 lane dual carriageways in anycase.

I would also say that a hotel half a mile away from a motorway is no more inclined to attract passing trade than one with a major road just 4 yards away... especially if that major road is as busy as the one that leads directly on to the East Lancs..... which incidentally already has several hotels along its length (which rather refutes your argument too).

The East Lancs Road has had to have several costly upgrades to absorb increased traffic... it's not the minor local road you're trying to suggest...... BTW, I have worked on the design team for several local transport projects and can tell you that this road supports as much traffic as many sections of actual motorway.... as do many other A-roads.

Then there are the other potential developments along the Bullens side. The school and residential development aligns quite nicely with the successful Everton in the Community programme ? literally taking it to another level ? by potentially incorporating community and education-based facilities directly into any new structures, be that the stadium itself or any adjacent new buildings.

These are potentially direct enabling schemes....... they may form either part of the superstructure for new stands, and/or form adjacent buildings, helping to release funding for new facilities and capacity...... it's a tried and tested model.
Barry Jones
172 Posted 16/02/2012 at 21:58:23
Steve Jones

I?ve watch this thread develop from an interesting thread on Trust Everton to a fascinating thread on the abilities and knowledge of Evertonians during debate.

But now Steve, I have to tell you, I?m embarrassed for you; you?ve been slaughtered, you are having the piss taken out of you, and you can?t see it. What is it that you actually do for a living?

I have no idea what is behind your aggressive attitude towards Colin or your steamrollering (if that?s a word) of just about everything Tom has said. These are two well respected Evertonians who have well earned reputations and I find myself agreeing with Colin in that you are now making a complete fool of yourself.

You?re childishly repeating the same question because you don?t like the answer and, when that tactic fails, you dismiss their argument and begin all over again.

You say that you?ve read the Football Quarter document (so have I), so my question is, if that is true, how come you don?t know who the private sector developer is? I know and probably everyone who has read it knows its Capita Symonds. It?s there in black and white, it?s been all over Twitter.

I have no idea how Colin and Tom have managed to attract them, even less how they have developed this idea, but I do know one thing: this is what our club should be doing instead of doing nothing and your criticism reeks of bitterness (the root of which only you know).

You also repeatedly ask about studies that have been undertaken and once again Colin has answered you by saying that if you?ve read the document you would know the answer. I?ve looked and there is a chapter titled next steps and there are two sections, Business Investment By and Technical Delivery By, which would appear to answer your question.

If Colin and Tom are being advised by Capita Symonds and the city council, then these advisors must know what represents an effective timeline? Perhaps you know better than these people who earn their living from developing or working with developers? Again, what is it you do that makes you so sure that what all these people are taking about isn't feasible?

Your final question concerning the club earning money from the proposition: I do know the answer to this as I?ve heard Joe Anderson say it. The Football Quarter is there to enhance the surrounding area with commercial opportunities and improved transportation that provides the right environment for the clubs to prosper. But it is the clubs responsibility to take advantage, it is their responsibility to invest in their own infrastructure which the council make clear will assist in all ways possible. I think that?s pretty clear. It?s all very well suggesting the impossible but it is the possible that real people have to work with.

It?s weird that you can?t admit that you?re wrong, you?ve been helped to find the answers to your questions but you want to be spoon-fed and the explanation over misunderstanding the Spurs thing is cringeworthy to be honest; you made an error, you misunderstood something, have the courage and good grace to admit it and move on. Don't create pathetic excuses ? it devalues the other posts that you make.


Tom repeatedly described why a Hotel attached to a conference centre attached to Goodison would be an important move as it would open up the opportunity of making money that wasn?t football based. You think you know all the reasons why it can?t, but offer not one of how it can. I?ve stayed at the Holiday Inn at Norwich City, it?s down a street on an industrial estate but they market it as a conference venue ten minutes away from the city centre, Everton?s ten minutes away from our city centre. Sheffield is another one, Bramhall Lane isn?t a major route but the hotel changed the area and brought in business and jobs. There?s a hotel at Kirkby called Suites, been there for years, there?s another on dunnings bridge call the Park. Why do these contine to be in business? You think people aren?t employed with a plan to fill them?

Tom and Colin came up with the Football Quarter, so far you?ve come up with some soft 'buy us a pint' thing. You?re looking increasing foolish with each post. Time to cash your chips in and leave with what little dignity you have left mate.
Steve Jones
173 Posted 16/02/2012 at 21:40:57
Tom,

I'm sure local officials have backed this. I'm sorry, but, if someone is offering to deliver their regeneration targets for the cost of land that it'll stand on they'll trumpet it from the rooftops. Especially as the risk is so tiny against the potential rewards...for the community if not the clubs.

I worked in the local government sector as a highways engineer for 5 years. I used to design roads and surveyed I dont know how many square miles with dumpy level and EDM's. You say it yourself Walton Rd goes to the East Lancs and ultimately to Manchester. Its a heavily trafficed route for predominantly local traffic sourced from one destined for the other. Now, unless you do the journey on a push bike, thats an hour and a half journey in traffic. You dont need a hotel stay for that trip.

Very few journeys use the East Lancs or M57 feeding in to Walton Rd as a through route. Southport to North Wales maybe....if you want to use the Wallasey tunnel as a cut through. Even that is too short a journey to need a hotel in Walton though.

Hotels on the East Lancs by the way are clustered, one by the M57 serving the business park, and pretty much the rest at the Haydock junction...the hotel trade doesnt come from the East Lancs itself.

The traffic profile on a motorway is completely different....its all transient...its being used as through route for traffic sourced almost anywhere from Glasgow to Nottingham and back the other way. On a motorway there IS passing trade by the nature of that traffic. Thats why a hotel half a mile off a junction like Boltons works. The distance off the motorway in Bolton is scarcely different than some dedicated motorway service areas!.

Walton Rd is a heavily trafficed road and a major local thoroughfare...but its not providing the same traffic as the M61 does at Bolton.

I'm seeing what your writing Tom about City planners etc. If that is the case and, as Colin says, there are hotel chains interested why is it so much of a bizarre request to ask if a business case has been compiled so we can all see that those planners were right however many years ago and were really focused on Walton?. Non-matchday without a local tourist environment or occupancy draw is a very clear concern for anyone talking about a hotel....that cant come as a surprise?.
Steve Jones
174 Posted 16/02/2012 at 23:00:51
Barry,

I'm not interested if I am having the piss taken out of me by anyone here. I'm asking very basic questions and they are being dodged, skipped and 'answered' by vague references and unsupported tails of wonder.

The FQ documentation....in Chapter 11 said that the next step was to get funding for a feasibility study. Unless I'm reading that wrong too?. By implication then the feasibility study is unfunded. If that has changed its important....and is the reason I asked the question?.

The comment from Joe Anderson I take to mean that the FQ does absolutely stuff all to provide direct revenue to either football club. I'm beginning to see that he was at least being forthright. That was as close to a straight answer as I've had on this thread so I'll thank you for that at least.

As for the hotels thing Norwich doesnt have the conference facilities Liverpool city centre does and is certainly not as accessible as Liverpool. Suites I've stayed at after a function and serves the business park just over the roundabout. Its the same as Tom's Bolton example....its not like for like.

The desperation with which you are trying to find the slightest possible angle that makes the hotel viable....when clearly no business model exists....is very telling though.

Why am I doing nothing to make it work?. Simple....because it wont work and I dont believe in flogging dead horses. The solution is to build a new stadium where we can compete for business or exploit new revenue streams. NOT build facilities and take a huge gamble on business coming to us.

We get a new stadium we will attract genuine new owners. If we have to sell players short term to raise funds, in conjunction with share offerings, Goodison disposal and all the usual other sources to build a new ground then so be it.

We have to break the cycle of building up the squad to challenge for honours and then see it fall apart for lack of turnover to take us that final step. Were on the downswing from that peak now. If Moyes does get us built back up again we will hit the same ceiling as before....its pointless...before we rebuild again we have to have the revenue in place to support us as we step up. That is not going to come about with us still in Walton.
Colin Fitzpatrick
175 Posted 17/02/2012 at 09:33:48
Barry,

I wouldn?t suggest that the FQ was just the work of two people Barry, many have been involved and many more will become involved if it ever comes to fruition.

Bereft of ideas; Everton are unable to offer a solution to their own problem, yet they look upon the FQ with disdain because firstly, they were unable to formulate a solution that unites the situation, circumstances and the people who can enable it, the council, and secondly they?re unable to communicate with the fans who have adequately displayed that the Everton hierarchy are simply not up to the job, which they clearly and perhaps understandably, resent.

Without any shadow of doubt it?s an audacious move; it?s clearly anathema to some to suggest that the communities that has served these clubs well for 134 and 120 years respectively could benefit from their presence in a symbiotic relationship rather than a parasitic one that we have now.

With regard to Steve, it appears to be all coming out now. His rather strange logic, which he likes to portray as sound business practice, now appears to be based on nothing but his experience as a glorified boy from the blackstuff!

It all makes sense now. It's clear why he believes hotels only get business from passing trade, from people making journeys along roads. I did those road surveys, I did them in junior school lol.

I bet you never knew that Liverpool One was built because they did a footfall survey of the existing retail offer and discovered hundreds of thousands of people just couldn?t get into the shops so they built a billion pound retail complex. There was no business plan or marketing plan to create a destination, all they did was take advantage of passing trade! Lol, you couldn?t make it up.

Now he?s suggesting hotels only operate on the Conrad Hilton principle due to road proximity and nothing else; the business model, tried and tested btw,that he so eagerly seeks, is staring him in the face but because it doesn?t suit his argument he ignores it, it really is laughable.

Steve?s what some people call a know all. I call them know fuck all. He once tried to tell me I?d suggested Jon Woods should be chairman, when I pulled him up he cut and pasted what I originally said, which was nothing of the kind, and still wouldn?t admit he was wrong!

I?ve now read the Spurs explanation, it?s pathetic but what would you expect from a navvy ;-)
Steve Jones
176 Posted 17/02/2012 at 09:51:37
Coiln,

I tell you what I'll stop shovelling bitmac into potholes for a few minutes if you can clarify what you mean by the 'business model staring me in the face'? You see you stopped short of actually explaining what you are talking about while, cleverly, hinting that you do. A great way to hide ignorance in plain sight I'd expect.

The Jon Woods thing were you suggested Jon Woods as the only credible board member.... but weren't saying he should be chairman? Well versed in selling snake oil, Colin?

Got to say you have the full arsenal of spin control at your fingertips, don't you mate. You'll have to be more careful with Barry in future though.... he answered a direct question honestly.
Colin Fitzpatrick
177 Posted 17/02/2012 at 12:02:52
Steve, you really do have a problem. Every time you make a mistake you can't accept that you're wrong. To err is to human....
Steve Jones
178 Posted 17/02/2012 at 12:37:06
Colin, the way this works is that when you consider yourself right an the other guy wrong you use your facts (note: fact i.e piece of information supported by factual evidence) to show the other guy why he is wrong. You dont just tell him he's wrong and leave it there.

So far on this thread I've directly asked for you to provide the supportable facts that prove me wrong. Several times and justified the reasons why. I've, clearly, stated the conditions on which you can, if its so important to you, stump me down, shut me up and put me back in my box.

You show me some kind of objective proof, something that isnt just a comment from someone you've spoken to who's emminently credible, that this hotel will have decent occupancy rates on non-matchdays without the FQ and I'll ask the site admins here to delete my account and you'll never hear from me again. How's that?

Otherwise you have to understand that you are asking people to take on your word, which is clearly not objective, that a scheme, that hasn't survived a full feasibility study yet, is going to support a hotel, that doesnt have a clearly structured business case, to provide the major new revenue stream to support the future development of Everton Football Club!.

Maybe I am two steps removed from banging the flint rocks together mate, but, you dont have to be Alan Sugar to see thats ropey at best!. The fact that you are surprised that someone is asking to see this sort of detail before jumping on the bandwagon is sad testimony as well.
Barry Jones
179 Posted 17/02/2012 at 15:02:58
Steve,

I?m not surprised by your response, your self- belief is admirable, if not grossly misplaced, I think Colin has a point when he calls you a know all, but for me it?s your inability to consider the possibility that others could be better advised and more knowledgeable than you on certain subjects which gives cause for concern. Stating that you?re not worried looking foolish is a classic symptom of superiority complex which I understand is treatable, but of course you know this to.

You refuse to yield to anyone no matter what. You?re still going on about dodging questions when in reality nobody has dodged your questions, saying they are is your method of continuing your argument.

You wanted to know who the commercial partners were and you were told who they were, Capita, re- reading the report there appears to be another called 3D Reid, who I have not heard of but appear to be the real deal going by their website. You then wanted to know if a study had been done to see if a business case could be made for a hotel, the brochure detailed the next steps which are clearly defined (their steps, advised by experts, not your steps) and do not include a study as you?ve said it yourself. You incredibly state than no business model exists but we all know and Tom has told you that there is a widely accepted model for hotels attached to all kinds of sports facilities, football, rugby, racing, it is well proven, you just won?t recognise it because it doesn?t fit your agenda which is rapidly becoming unfathomable from a logical perspective but seems all too apparent that it is one against anything ordinary fans propose.

The truth is all your questions have been answered but you still persist with your belief that the only solution is a new stadium and not one in Walton, which I can only assume is because you feel that it?s a place that is economically unviable as a location for a modern football stadium.

Whilst you are unyielding in your opinion, Tom and Colin at least acknowledge the possibility of moving to another stadium, Colin even agreed that it is the best solution.

If I went to the bank to discuss my finances because my bank manager wanted me to explain how I was going to reduce my overdraft, what do you think the bank manager would say if I gave him two options, win the lottery and pay it off in one go or reduce my monthly outgoings to a more appropriate level and use the excess to address my overdraft? One is sought-after yet highly unlikely whilst the other is more challenging but far more realistic and ultimately deliverable and that?s the key to all these discussions what is the more deliverable option.

You indicate that a new stadium would attract new owners but where exactly is this new stadium going to be built? How much is it going to cost, who is going to pay for it and how are they going to pay for it? Land values in Walton are less than £800k per acre. You advocate selling players to build a stadium? Who, how much would this raise and will it be detrimental to our standing as a premiership club? The current owners will not offer a rights issue and we have no assets left. How are the current owners going to pay for a premiership stadium? What are these usual other sources to pay for a stadium, can you quantify them? Of course a new owner may be attracted at the possibility of a new stadium that had been designed and had planning permission, again it comes down to where and I think its already been pointed out that no fabulously rich owner of a premiership club has ever financed a stadium. Robert Elstone identified that we need to follow a facilities led model, in place of the billionaire model which uefa rules are designed to suppress. We need to be in a location where we can take advantage of government funding and any other advantages such as transport improvements, isn?t this what these guys are attempting to achieve through their vision whilst you are pursuing you lottery win fantasy?



To me it seems to come down to this, you believe in a new stadium and pour copious amounts of cold water on anything that challenges that belief, may I ask, were you in favour of the relocation to the proposed new stadium at Kirkby? Did this fulfil your criteria when you say, ?The solution is to build a new stadium where we can compete for business or exploit new revenue streams. NOT build facilities and take a huge gamble on business coming to us.??



Steve Jones
180 Posted 17/02/2012 at 17:06:29
Barry,

"but for me it?s your inability to consider the possibility that others could be better advised and more knowledgeable than you on certain subjects which gives cause for concern."

You see the issue I have with this is that I've asked to be proved wrong with something more tangible than a second-hand report of someones interpretation of what someone else said. I dont know Colin or Tom and, naturally, I dont trust their objectivity on this issue. Its their baby why would they be objective....no fault no foul there, but, a commercial entity coming back with a documented review of the FQ saying yep this is economically viable is an objective validation isn't it?. Once again thats all I'm asking for and the FQ doesnt answer it.

Colin does indeed talk of a general business model for hotels attached to football grounds and similar facilities. Tom mentioned twice the model that sees a business attached to a landmark site. These models dont fit the immediate Goodison area though. You cant build a hotel to that model where there is no ancilliary market to take-up non matchday. If you know enough to talk about the generic model I was sort of assuming that was obvious. I will apologise if I haven't made that clear.

"Whilst you are unyielding in your opinion, Tom and Colin at least acknowledge the possibility of moving to another stadium, Colin even agreed that it is the best solution."

Barry if I think, as I have expressed, that the whole FQ concept represents a massive gamble with the future of our club and one, if it succeeds, that will lock us into the same cycle of inadequacy we are experiencing now why am I going to suddenly decide its a really great thing for the future of Everton?. To massage Colin's ego?. To give my personal thumbs up to Tom?. I wouldnt expect them to be in the slightest bit bothered.

"One is sought-after yet highly unlikely whilst the other is more challenging but far more realistic and ultimately deliverable and that?s the key to all these discussions what is the more deliverable option."

Unfortunately thats not the end of the analogy is it Barry. You have missed off the clamouring wife and dependents who demand you, while paying down your overdraft, also deliver a new car and a nice holiday every year and you can do one if you dont!. There is something very sensible in what you say about reducing costs, but, in direct terms for Everton the major component of the outgoings is playing staff wages. We need to increase that if we want to compete, as the fans demand, for honours....not reduce it.

"You advocate selling players to build a stadium? Who, how much would this raise and will it be detrimental to our standing as a premiership club?"

Simple the first silly offer we get for Barkley....sell him, Rodwell....sell him, Fellaini....sell him. Essentially whoever we get £20+ mn offers for we sell and put that into the stadium. With the right offers you could see half the cost of an Eastlands-sized and appointed ground from those three players. Do we take a hit if we lose some players and have to use free agents, kids or loans...yes we will. We are doing this for the long term future of the club though. We've been piss poor all season so far WITH the players we have...maybe it will be easier to motivate the remainder if they see we have a future roadmapped to a new stadium, with new earning potential and the promise of better things to come.

A rights issue with the intent of supporting a major infrastructure project may be more attractive than one that is not going to add value to the business. Wasnt Earl quoted as saying he'd not stump up any more until there was a new stadium.

"isn?t this what these guys are attempting to achieve through their vision whilst you are pursuing you lottery win fantasy?"

Yes, but, as before the gamble with their vision is that people dont come....then what...there is no failsafe in the plan. If the FQ doesnt work out we're condemned to a future as bereft of hope as we are now. You site the stadium properly and give it peer facilities with whats around and you can guarantee people will come and with new revenue we will be attractive to prospective new owners of the right calibre. Exactly those people who arent interested in us now.

"Did this fulfil your criteria when you say, ?The solution is to build a new stadium where we can compete for business or exploit new revenue streams. NOT build facilities and take a huge gamble on business coming to us.??"

Kirkby?. I'm evangelical about us being on the river in an iconic location that puts in the frame for tourism footfall. I thought the council rolled over too easily for Peel Group and still think there is potential in the sections of the Festival Gardens site that Langtree arent going to build their residential development on now. Given how opposed to Walton, for a sustainable future, I am what do you think my views on Kirkby were?!.
Tom Hughes
181 Posted 17/02/2012 at 17:16:16
Steve,
There are several hotels around Sefton Park..... how is this possible, there is no passing trade, and no motorway for miles? There are several others in other suburbs..... and even along the east Lancs (and not near the motorway). Build attractive facilities, offer rooms and lounges overlooking the pitch (convertible to exec boxes as at several stadia).... and the attraction is there....

If the East Lancs is just a local people mover.... how is it still congested far beyond the city boundaries.... which necessitated the whole lane and junction remodelling beyond the M57 junctions?

I've attended several courses and conferences at stadia from Aberdeen to Pride park. We can have similar and better. There is conference facilities in Liverpool but there is still a defficiency.... hence the scheduled expansion of several established facilities in the city centre. At the end of the day.... if Hotel chains like the idea they'll take it up..... if not, they wont. The city planners seem to think they would have no problems in selling the idea.... even in the current climate. This could offer the leg up to address some of the issues at that end of the stadium.... ie. increased high and medium quality capacity, and corporate facilities..... both of which we are short of. It's an attainable target. 4 new stands might not be, with major investment and certainly a change of ownership.

I have to stress FQ is not my baby at all.... I was involved in discussion regards the expansion of GP long before FQ came out of a series of brainstorms. I have no aversion to moving to a more central stadium at all!!!! In another economic climate and with another boardroom it would be an attractive option.... However, the practicality you profess to have says its less likely
Tom Hughes
182 Posted 17/02/2012 at 20:06:38
Steve,

The FQ was formulated after months of meetings with professional planners and other interested parties..... it isn't the work of one or two unqualified people as you intimate...... I certainly cannot claim any credit. My only involvement has been with regards the nuts and bolts of stadium redevelopment.... and the continued untapped potential of the existing site. You talk about gambling, yet redevelopment is in many ways the safest bet. Hence the reason why the vast majority have chosen that route. GP and Walton are not the dead duck you are trying to portray.

You accuse the FQ of unsubstantiated evidence, then wildly suggest the site near the garden festival as a better option than GP..........? One single carriageway in, one out.... next to no public transport.....! Much lower local Evertonian population, and lower density population. Parking?

The reason why you were asked how you voted regarding Kirkby, is that some of the more myopic were still unable to demonstrate any objectivity towards KEIOC long after that particularly flawed non-option sank without trace. They were stuck in their good (BK) versus bad (KEIOC) mode long after it was shown that they were deceived and sold a dud..... Long after the shareholders were gagged for openly challenging the club's lies even.

These types made disingenuous arguments against anything remotely connected to KEIOC..... saying the garden festival site is better than GP in ANY WAY is one such argument. Saying that hotels just 2 miles away from the city centre cannot work (when several far more isolated already exist without a stadium or conference anchor)), and that the east lancs is a quiet cul de sac that no-one outside of merseyside uses is another....; Completely ignoring the combined critical mass of two major prem clubs, and the two local area redevelopment schemes (which will have to happen no matter what), and other supporting developments that can be centred around a listed park that has already changed beyond recognition in recent times...... is your hatrick. You can stretch one strained point to make a plausible argument....but 2 or 3 or 4?

As regards central stadia.... KEIOC were also instrumental in bringing the Loop site to the attention of the club..... only for farcical rejection on the grounds that it wasn't big enough... so you can't say they haven't looked at or advocated alternatives.

BTW, where is your business plan to support Otterspool prom over L4? More to the point.... where's the common sense?

Steve Jones
183 Posted 17/02/2012 at 23:19:35
I said there was potential in the site at Otterspool....nothing more.

Far from no public transport the rail line past the site, with a station much closer than Kirkdale is to Goodison, connects in to the City centre direct to the loop and through South Parkway to the east on the mainline back into Lime Street. That means rail access is pretty much doubled over that serving Goodison. Plus away fans dont have to come all the way in to Lime Street congesting the city centre at all on the way in. They can shift from the intercity to Merseyrail at South Parkway. Football trains carrying fans from the loop to St Michaels can go on to terminate at Parkway and carry full loads back again. Merseyrail are going to go for that!

Then there is the river. An obvious natural attraction in itself to someone visiting Liverpool and, with the site halfway between the city centre and the airport, its an appealing location for a tourist aimed hotel. Not enough by itself possibly as its a bit far south for real convenience...unless you put in a landing stage on the site as was there in 1982.

What you get there is the potential to run a river taxi/ferry service into the Albert Dock/Pier Head directly for tourists/conference goers as another attraction. On matchday...with three ferries tasked you have the capability to move about 3000 people an hour direct to the stadium doorstep from the Pier Head or the sites on the Wirral. You could even put park and rides in on the Wirral side bussing fans to the ferry terminals further offloading the city centre transport hubs. Offer 3000 passengers an hour to Mersey Ferries 20 times a season and they'll likely come onboard with the landing stage and boat handling costs....it will put a major hike in their yearly carriage numbers.

Finally the land is cheap and extensive. Langtree bought into the McClean Festival Gardens scheme for just £500k and picked up the rest when McCleans folded. They have a residential scheme "Phase 2" penned in for a parcel of land in the wider development area.

That residential scheme has been stalled since 2007 as the domestic market in the city has no demand for it. They were trying to talk up interest last summer, but, were still trying to find a development partner. Langtrees residential section of the total 90 acre plot was about 25 acres...plenty of space for stadium, hotel and bars/restaurants. It was going to support more than 1300 residential units so access is hardly going to be an issue.

Thats potential. A hotel will work there as it has inherent attractiveness to the tourist market irrespective of the stadium. That means IF your contention that people will travel out of their way to sleep next to an empty football stadium doesnt quite hold up....and I for one have never chosen a hotel based on proximity to a stadium when I didnt plan to watch a match in it.... then there are genuine alternate draws for business.

The loop site works on the same principle....if we can get in a stadium design that properly fits in the available space, as you have said in the past does exist, then its proximity to the city centre that is the safety net. The risks from both of these, of the scheme not generating new revenue for the club, are far lower than for the redevelopment option. That is, after all, the whole point of going through this whole process isnt it?.

Going back to Walton Rd you are still confusing traffic volume with traffic profile. Simplifying further the users of the road live in Liverpool or Manchester predominantly as the road doesnt form a component in any other through route that doesnt have a better option. If you are going to Liverpool from the north you come down the M6 and go down the 58. If you come up from the south its M6/62/Edge lane or M6/M56/Runcorn Bridge. The East Lancs isnt going to give you a customer base to sustain a hotel on like a motorway supplied place does.

There are isolated hotels in Liverpool, but, comparable to those in the city centre which we would be competing with?. The biggest 'around' Sefton Park is 40 rooms and the other one Stuart Sutcliffe apparently used to live in!. Are you planning a hotel, that will actually bring in decent money, at Goodison or a Bed and Breakfast?!. I still dont see an empty football stadium (or even two of them) being a reason for people to travel the 3 miles from the City out to Walton past dozens of closer hotels, but, then again that is why I've been asking if there is any objective source evidence that supports your view that it will.

Eric Myles
184 Posted 18/02/2012 at 01:14:33
Steve, forget about a new shares issue, I agree it's the best solution to raise some cash for the Club but it's never going to happen with the current board.

Kenwright will not give up the controls of the train set and he hasn't got the money to buy more shares to maintain his control. Likewise his 'friends' are not going to put their hands in their pocket to maintain control.

They're all only looking for a pay day in selling the Club, not investing into it. It's a non-starter.

As for selling players worth £20+ mn, that's as big a dream as a shares issue. We've only ever had 1 player worth that much and he's now playing at United. (Lescott was a mistake by Mark Hughes and I doubt any other manager is going to make the same mistake.)
John Keating
185 Posted 18/02/2012 at 02:10:04
Steve. Just following the thread, it seems you are doing what you accuse Colin and Tom of doing: stating a case based on assumptions, what someone said to someone, etc.

You said Otterspool had "potential". Well, you could say that about hunderds of locations in and around the City... Then, from " potential " you attempt to make a case on your assumptions.

One of the problems with DK was rail access. Have you got proof the present access is sustainable to commute X number of supporters safely? Let's see the proof.

Regarding the ferries, you assume Merseytravel will allow the 3 ferries to operate at certain times regardless of existing schedules and hire for private functions. How can Merseytravel accommodate the games? How many games per season are played at 3pm on a Saturday? Are you sure Merseytravel will go to the enormous expense of building a landing stage for ferries to operate for a couple of trips on a few days per year? If you have done a study and have the support of Mersytravel, let's see it.

Are Langtrees prepared to sell the land? Have you asked them? Wheres the proof?? More important, who is going to buy their land? The club??? Possibly Trust Everton? Who is going to build the stadium? The club?? Trust Everton??

You say a hotel will work there. Maybe it will, maybe it won't. Can you prove it? Have you done a study?

You say access isn't a problem. How do you know? Have you done a feasibility study on it?

So, Steve, to repeat: you said Otterspool has potential and then "assumed" a catalogue of points to back up your assumption. I ask you what you asked Colin and Tom. Show me objective source evidence that supports your view.

It's very easy to criticise without having an alternative answer. You seem to be making an art of it.
Steve Smith
186 Posted 18/02/2012 at 01:24:52
Just read through quite a lot of this thread {I don't sleep much}, and will re-visit it on Sunday night to have a proper read, but you know what I love about this site? It's the passion of peoples opinions, and their love for the club.

It would be nice if we could stop calling each other twats, but that's up to you lot.... you bunch of cunts!!!
Colin Fitzpatrick
187 Posted 18/02/2012 at 10:04:53
George Mallone

If you think for one moment that I would want you to delete your account then you?re more insane than the box of frogs you already resemble; you provide the best entertainment on here by a country mile, and long may it continue.

As ever, when you?re wrong, you want to move the goal posts; you began by wanting to know what the projected blah blah blah blah and with Evertonians being predominantly local who was going to stay in the hotel; I answered you but now you want me to justify, what was it again ?that this hotel will have decent occupancy rates on non-matchdays without the FQ? why would I wish to do that? The FQ is designed to enhance the locale, its part of the solution to the problem; why would I leave part of it out? Would you also want me to leave out the C&B facilities to make your argument about the hotel a little stronger?

You believe the constituency of Walton is an unsuitable place for a modern premiership stadium, I don?t, neither does Liverpool; if you left it there that would be fine, but you can?t; you can?t bear the fact that some Evertonians have suggested a Goodison solution to Everton?s problems and people who influence these things, not navvies, are listening. It annoys you as much as it annoys the amateurs inside Goodison and your comments are becoming increasingly more and more bizarre as you dig the hole you?re in deeper and deeper with every paragraph; it?s that deep now you?ve developed an Australian twang??sport.

Your understanding of the importance of location is bizarre; the comment that Suites serves the local industrial estate is a prime example; the limit of your understanding appears to be that hotels are occupied by people travelling past on a journey to a destination; have you ever considered that Goodison may be their destination? It?s as if you have never heard of a business plan with a marketing strategy through which you position your business or product in the marketplace. The FQ is about creating a destination, creating a location; hence the C&B facilities and the additional proposals to enhance them making it a location almost separate from the council backed FQ if necessary. Here?s an extract from a 2007 PWC report:

?In an age when space is at a premium, hotel companies are now turning to sports venues to help attract new clientele and extend the brand into new areas. Research released today by PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP indicates that the number of hotel rooms attached to sports stadiums has been growing by 13 percent per year since 1998, totalling eleven hotels with a 1314 rooms and this number will triple over the next nine years. Julie Clark, sports and leisure leader at PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP, believes the growth potential for this niche hotel market is worth serious consideration by operators. ?We have seen significant growth in the past decade, but the greatest opportunity is yet to come as penetration levels remain low and more sporting venues announce plans to redevelop their venues. ?Currently only about eight percent of football stadia and 16 percent of racecourse venues have hotels attached so the scope for growth is enormous.? However, Clark warns that this product is not for every business and it does attract some risks. ?Merely opening a hotel at a sporting venue will not automatically guarantee additional revenues. Location is paramount and the hotel needs strong demand base to ensure a viable business model. ?The right hotel at the right venue can provide benefits for the operator and venue alike ? the secret of success is to pursue mutually beneficial goals and opportunities.? Some venues have developed innovative products such as Coventry FC where executive boxes convert to bedrooms to provide the ultimate room with a view. But creating a powerful synergy between the hotel operator and the venue operator is even more important than having a glitzy product. Liz Hall, head of hospitality research at PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP, said: ?The sports venue hotel is an unusual niche in the lodging market. Nevertheless it can provide a serious business opportunity - enabling the sports venue to leverage its integrated corporate offer, while providing the hotel operator with a foothold into a strategic location? Existing hotels and planned developments by sport include: Football?

The FQ concept meets this evaluation of the market. There are C&B facilities in the city centre but a strategy targeting a specific market sector is more than achievable, in my opinion. The hotel demand across the city continues as you can see from this article in last night?s Echo,

http://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/liverpool-news/local-news/2012/02/17/liverpool-s-hotel-boom-continues-to-gather-pace-with-opening-of-travelodge-on-waterfront-100252-30346566/

Everton could be offering much more than a place to stay the night as there undoubtedly is a gap in the market that they could exploit.

For those thinking that the limit to what Everton could offer the market is a place to rest your head for the night on the way to somewhere else I suggest you look at something like this http://vimeo.com/27809407

My position is clear; I believe a redeveloped Goodison, in an aesthetically and economically improved Walton, is the best and most cost effective solution for Everton Football Club at this moment in time. I acknowledge the possibility that a new owner could have unlimited funds with which to build a new stadium, which will always be the best solution, if positioned in the right location, but I UNDERSTAND that this remains a somewhat remote possibility, an event that has only occurred twice in the Premiership and excludes both of the largest clubs, MUFC and LFC, who have been taken over by businesses.

Sites for a stadium are pretty much non-existent; Barry Jones asked you a series of questions about location, cost, funding. Your answers speak volumes. You have no idea of cost, you persist in the notion that a rights issue is viable when the current board has rejected it out of hand, and if a new board were to emerge, through new owners, you think they?d be chomping at the bit to organise a proposal that, due to the amount of money involved, could reduce them to minority shareholders unless they did a Johnson and were prepared to underwrite the issue which would then get us back to the fact that no premiership club owner has financed a stadium, through cash, equity, anything you like.

Your next stab at financing a stadium involves selling off our players, Rodwell, Barkley, Fellaini and you talk about gambles? You?d risk the clubs Premiership status to raise how much exactly? Your suggestions on financing a stadium are comparable with Everton?s own back of a fag packet economics, their description not mine. I think it?s best to file these alongside your ideas to ask fans to fund a promotion campaign to help sell the club and your buy us a pint fundraising suggestion; think we?ll label the file ?fucking ridiculous?.

Joking apart, your suggested location is an interesting one; it was a site looked at by KEIOC as you can see here:

http://www.scribd.com/doc/18590098/KEIOC-Proof-of-Evidence-alternative-sites-design?in_collection=2864070

You have the advantage here as I was unaware that Langtree were no longer planning to develop almost 1400 houses which they have planning permission for; do you have a link to this or is it privileged information that you have?

The last I heard was that they had started to sell the plots off to builders and if this is not the case I wonder where they stand over the £4M of RDA money they received as developers of the site or was that just specifically for the festival site. No matter, its location looks to me like prime residential with the river, woods and park in close proximity.

I?m aware of the problems which have caused delays in the past, their main contractor going to the wall and, only a few weeks ago, the land trust which they were handing the finished development over to manage, suffered the same fate. But as I said I was unaware of this news, which if true could be interesting.
Langtree are an interesting company, they?re responsible for St Helens new stadium; well they were the developers for the site.

Their MD John Downes said something very interesting a few months ago, he said,

?For all successful sports clubs, whether they are in football, rugby or cricket, there comes a time when stadium development becomes nothing less than a commercial necessity, if they are to achieve their long-term ambitions. Whereas some are able to expand the capacity or footprint of their existing ground, for others a move away from their traditional home is the only solution. The regeneration potential, that such a project can afford an area, should not be underestimated. Potential can only be fully realised by making the stadium a destination within the city itself. Non- match day visitors are vital to attract the private sector investment needed to create the homes, jobs, community facilities and programmes for urban regeneration.?

I had made a note of that as I think it describes the FQ perfectly.

The access around the Discovery Park site is poor and not designed for matchday visitors but no doubt the roads could be improved unlike the access from and to St Michaels which is a small station surrounded by Victorian properties. Like Kirkby a strictly enforced no parking zone would be implemented and government targets on modal share would need to be met; noncompliance would lead to compulsory capping by the council. The Langtree development faced spirited opposition from the many local residents and other groups on the issue of loss of green space and no doubt local residents, particularly those adjacent to Riverside Drive, will view the potential prospect of 50,000 people descending on their neighbourhood with understandable resentment as they moved to these homes in the knowledge that a football stadium wasn?t on their doorstep unlike residents living in Walton.

The question of funding is paramount. Let?s not even suggest that the Kirkby stadium at £78m is the kind of money we?re talking about. That stadium, full for every game and projections of additional events attracting 180,000 people, only produced £6m of additional contribution. Once actual attendance and interest payments of finance were taken into account personally I didn?t believe it would have generated anything.

Any stadium would need to maximise the potential of non-matchday income; this is a vital area for Everton due to the decades of neglect of their stadium facilities, which transfers to income, and a limited outlook on matchday income due to the size of its fanbase.

Being 3 miles from the city, like Goodison, there would be nothing stopping Everton developing a stadium that maximised the potential of the hotel, C&B market and other events, but to build this in one hit requires much more money than the alternative and, as I keep repeating, the current owners can?t fund it, and aren?t interested in finding it, and no owner of a premiership club has financed the construction of a brand new stadium. Combined with the purchase cost of the club it would be difficult to obtain a return on that level of investment; it would be more cost effective to leave your money in a nice BVI account.

There?s another potential fly in the ointment; you?re unlikely to get any assistance from the council, the only game in town at the moment is the redevelopment of the North end. Liverpool Waters, Project Jennifer and I know that you?re going to hate it but yes, The Football Quarter as outlined by the man himself, http://www.guardian.co.uk/local-government-network/2012/jan/26/regeneration-practice-liverpool-football-quarter

That?s why I believe a phased redevelopment of Goodison is not only the most cost effective solution but, under the circumstances, it?s the best solution.

If I need my drive doing I?ll give you a shout.
Steve Jones
188 Posted 18/02/2012 at 08:43:44
John,

The difference is that I'm very clearly going off 'back of fag packet' and until I did put flesh on the bones of such a scheme I would not publically promote something like Otterspool because it is just potential.

I'm not asking you or anyone else to 'share my vision' because I cant back it up with hard fact - that differs from where Colin is with the FQ doesnt it?.

I was asked whether I supported Kirkby and I explained my views on where we need to be. Tom took exception to one part of it so I explained how I arrived at that point. No more no less.

Just to go on record, before I get crucified further for doing a 'slipshod design for Otterspool' in the pitchfork and torch manner that some of you lot seem to go after heretics on here. There are distinct unknowns on that site from an engineering standpoint stemming from the origins of the ground itself. Drainage considerations impacted the Langtree residential scheme and you'd need to see an engineering analysis of the load bearing capacities there to see if it would be an easy (cheap) or hard (bloody expensive) engineering task to put a 46-48k seater ground there in the first place. There would also be dredging issues on the river side, but, neither daunting or insoluable ones and an overnight 30% increase in their passenger figures isnt something Mersey Ferries could easily ignore.

Anyway, like you said John, there is clearly not going to anything tangible that results from this whole saga and the answers that I hoped for arent there. I imagine, as Tom says, time will tell whether an empty football stadium can attract paying visitors 3 miles away from a vibrant city centre already replete with hotels.

For now I have to start the process of getting 2 primary school aged kids ready to go the match. A task much more fearsome and onerous than any bout of literary combat on here.
Tom Hughes
189 Posted 18/02/2012 at 20:59:19
Steve,
I don't think anyone expects you to back any suggestion with that level of detail.... however, you should at least subject your counter ideas to the same level of scrutiny you like to apply to the FQ. Don't you think some of the people that have been in discussions with KEIOC have considered this site.... and several others?

You've tried to shoot down the idea of a hotel at GP because its Walton, because its 2-3 miles from town and because Walton Lane isn't a motorway..... Yet, as shown there are numerous hotels around the city that satisfy none of YOUR disingenuous criteria. There is high demand for hotel space in the city.... full capacity has not been reached yet.... check out the planning applications. As shown elsewhere the stadium variant can offer a whole new angle, a whole new attraction.... as well as the value of the multi-functional room/exec box as an incentive to any chain.

TBH, Otterspool probably ceases to be a serious discussion with the "one road in, one road out" factor.... but there are several others too. St Michaels is marginally closer than Kirkdale, but Kirkdale has more trains and serves more stations. Sandhills (via soccerbus) more again (including S.Parkway). The number of roads and bus services serving Walton, including the confluence of inner ring roads and multiple dual carriageways serving directly to Merseytunnels, City centre, northwards and eastwards demonstrates instantly why GP has one of the fastest dispersal rates of any major stadium in the UK...... again tried and tested, and not the gamble you're stating..... they are knowns, not unknowns. Otterspool has none of that infrastructure, and is a complete unknown. There is also far more on and off road parking capacity in Walton..... as there is far more road space generally (look at any street map).... and parking has evolved over decades. Not perfect, but where is? And, at the end of the day, the point of the combined effort is to avoid the wasteful duplication of infrastructure that 2 stadia in 2 seperate locations would inevitably bring. One road in and one road out would render any onsite parking a complete none starter. Then on top of everything else you throw a highly speculative and improbable new Ferry terminal into it.... for a fortnightly event venue? Apparently a third ferry and crew can be mobilised.... just for the occasion...... and a 30% increase to boot?

Who said it was literary combat.... is that your real motive for engaging?

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads