Moyes holds Everton dream

, 12 February, 176comments  |  Jump to most recent
He wants to see Spurs' Investment
David Moyes insists he has not taken Everton as far as he can and hopes to still be the club's manager when new investment is finally found. He has been mooted as a contender to take charge at Tottenham Hotspur, if Harry Redknapp leaves White Hart Lane at the end of the season to become England coach. However, rather than jump ship to North London, Moyes wants the Toffees to emulate the progress Tottenham have made in recent years, providing chairman Bill Kenwright can secure fresh investment.

"I take pride in the fact that it's only in the last 10 years that Everton have really come back to life," Moyes told The People.

"The history of Everton has been great but I think in the decade I've been here I have established us as a top 10 Premier League club.

"I don't want to leave this club then see someone else come in and get the chance to do all the things I've dreamed I could do here with the right investment."

"It's been an incredible 10 years and I wouldn't swap them for all the difficulties we have had. Over most of those years we have been consistently competing against Tottenham but the last couple of years that has changed because of the investment they've made at Spurs.

"So it's my belief and hope that I will still be in the building when our time comes to make the same change Spurs have done.

"My chairman Bill Kenwright will need investment to make that happen and he is out there looking for it. But that prospect keeps me going here. Because I want the chance to be able to take Everton where Tottenham have gone.

"I don't want to leave this club then see someone else come in and get the chance to do all the things I've dreamed I could do here with the right investment."

He added: "I will know when I have taken the club as far as I can and I would hate to think I would overstay my welcome here at Everton. I hope I'd never be hanging around like a bad smell.

"I don't think it's quite that yet. The supporters can see what we are trying to do, even though we are in a bit of a transitional period."

Quotes or other material sourced from Sky Sports News



Reader Comments (176)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Alex Mullan
1 Posted 12/02/2012 at 15:33:17
"The supporters can see what we are trying to do, even though we are in a bit of a transitional period."

I would not say we are in a transitional period at all ? it's the same team as it was years ago to some extent. Not only are the players basically the same, but some of the better ones from days gone by are now back on loan, ie, Pienaar, so in a way its the same, but not even as good. Howard, Hibbert, Jags, Neville, Baines, Felliani, Cahill, Big Vic, Osman 'Pienaar' ? to name the majority ? have all been at Everton for ages, growing old. Even Donovan is back. Hell, even McFadden is back!

No Davey, it is not a transitional period, it's a Groundhog Day-esque bad dream. SAME players, SAME football, SAME tactics, SAME shite start, SAME 'late' recovery.

You have become the bad smell you were worried about. Get some fucking Lynx, or go to Spurs.

(And yes, we have done great in the last couple of weeks (barring Wigan), but it's the SAME old shite. See you back here next year when we have the traditional dire start and end well.)
Rob Teo
2 Posted 12/02/2012 at 15:38:46
Often, I can't stand the fact that we play such defensive, negative football, and place the blame largely on Moyes' shoulders.

However, when it comes to acting with dignity and pride and recognising the privilege he has of being Everton's manager, he has my respect.
Kevin Sparke
3 Posted 12/02/2012 at 15:37:19
Get Straq, Pienaar and, if possible, Drenthe and Donovan under contract. Everton's recent revival has been built on effective, genuine width and a Centre Forward who is not afraid to graft and put himself about. (He reminds me of Duncan Ferguson - without the chip on his shoulder).

I'd argue (probably in the minority on here) that if Moyes, infuriating as he can be some times, would have had half the money that Spurs, City and Liverpool have had chucked at them we'd be regular top four - given the hand he has had to play over the years, we've punched well above our spending weight.
Ian Edwards
4 Posted 12/02/2012 at 15:49:25
What a cheeky git. Everton are one of the biggest clubs in the country. He can shove his top ten finishes up his arse.

If he had more testicular ambition in his tactics and formations we would have finished consisently higher in each of his ten tortuous and painful seasons.

If Spurs are stupid enough to want to have him managing them and playing with Saha up front with someone like Huddlestone just behind then good luck to them. We will be well out of it.
Alex Mullan
5 Posted 12/02/2012 at 15:51:34
Kevin Sparke,

I really like Strac too, but I don't know if he is really the answer in the long run to a transition.

Does anyone really think he is genuinely good? I know the world loves a trier and I love watching him, but he does appear pretty heavy, slow and unskilled. Sort of like watching a bull in high heels batter his way around goodison park. Still love the guy though!

To be fair, I did enjoy his pass to Drenthe vs Chelsea that nearly came off. He has shown glimpses of flair and technique.
Mark Stone
6 Posted 12/02/2012 at 15:42:33
I think it is a transitional phase. I wrote exactly that a few days ago on another thread. The players who have been a staple of David Moyes' Everton in recent years have either left (eg Arteta, Pienaar) or are coming to the end of their shelf life (eg Neville, Cahill, Distin). Meanwhile younger players with fantastic potential are coming through the ranks to replace them (eg Rodwell, Barkley, Duffy). However, the former seems to have happened/be happening 12 to 24 months before the latter (Rodwell, to an extent, accepted) are considered fully ready to take their place.
Dennis Stevens
7 Posted 12/02/2012 at 15:47:02
He has my respect as well, Rob - but he's not the man I want to see in charge when the necessary changes have happened in the Boardroom, if that means the purse-strings are to be loosened somewhat. Moyes is effective at what he does, but I have no expectation that we would ever win anything whilst he is Everton manager.
Stephen Kenny
8 Posted 12/02/2012 at 15:54:58
He's earned a small amount of respect back from me with those comments.

Still could do without his 'knife to a gunfight' bollocks and his piss poor starts. But it's nice to see some of the passion he once had for being the manager of one of the biggest and most decorated sporting institutions in British football is intact.
Joe McMahon
9 Posted 12/02/2012 at 15:58:40
"My chairman Bill Kenwright will need investment to make that happen and he is out there looking for it."

We really are stuck with these two aren't we. Investment, Investment, never a look for a new buyer is there! Why on earth would Moyes think Spurs would want him ? in the past 10 years, no-one else has. If he (Moyes) signs another contract, I think I may throw in the towel and give up my support.
Phil Walling
10 Posted 12/02/2012 at 16:04:50
Joined at the fucking hip. We`re stuck with him and his tosser of a chairman until we go bust. What a jolly prospect!
Stephen Leary
11 Posted 12/02/2012 at 16:08:04
I have said on these pages that Moyes has done my head in with his negative tactics etc but the man conducts himself well with dignity, and I do truly think that he has a great love for our great club and does care. I would give him a year when we get investment and see how he gets on with that.
Phil Walling
12 Posted 12/02/2012 at 16:11:46
......and when`s that likely to arrive,Stephen?
Not in my lifetime,I suspect and I ain`t drawing my pension yet!
Kevin Sparke
13 Posted 12/02/2012 at 16:13:32
Alex - I think Straq's a strong physical, old fashioned style 'English' Centre forward with a very good football brain - look how often he finds a man when he's in possession and under pressure. That said, he's not a flair player nor a poacher. However, I'd love to see him play with a smaller more agile striker/attacking midfielder playing just behind him - Someone like Nicika Jelavic for example!
Mark Riding
14 Posted 12/02/2012 at 16:24:50
Transitional period ? We played Chelsea yesterday.. 5 years ago, 2007, we also played Chelsea in November...
Out of the 16 man squad named in the 2007 game... 11 are still on Evertons books today.. Transitional period.. dont make me fucking laugh..
Declan Brown
15 Posted 12/02/2012 at 16:28:25
This is an interesting article.

It'll split the fanbase in terms of opinions again.

The Moyes Believers will see this as a positive statement and a vision for Moyes' future and were he wants us to go, meanwhile at the other end of the spectrum the Moyes Disbelievers will have a field day taking it apart.

I think it's not just about money at Tottenham, their manager, his motivational skills, their attacking flair etc, there's more to it than just money!!!

Sorry Davey, as much as I like and respect you, you and Spurs would be a bad fit, like chalk and cheese but that's my take on it. Could you see 4-6-0 being used at White Hart Lane?

As for the Kenwright and Everton have only come back to life in the last 10 years comments ? what planet are you on Davey?
James Martin
16 Posted 12/02/2012 at 16:29:58
Transitional period doesn't mean he has to have a whole new team does it? Otherwise you'd no longer be in transition would you? Relying on the older players whilst new and youth players come through is what transition is all about. Doean't matter how good Barkley and co. will be if in the meantime we go down because we played a team of kids all season rather than players who can get results.

Some people have been claiming for ages that they wanted Moyes's fire back and were fed up with his defeatist attitude and now that he comes out with a statement of intent and ambition he gets derided for it. I hope Moyes is still here if/when the investment comes so he can show everyone what a damn good manager he is.
Mark Stone
17 Posted 12/02/2012 at 16:00:22
'If he had more testicular ambition in his tactics and formations we would have finished consisently higher in each of his ten tortuous and painful seasons.'

Rarely a less true word spoken. The team that finished 7th in 2002-03 was widely recognised as a team that over achieved, and their 17th place finish of 2003-04 was probably s more realistic representation of the quality in the squad. Answer this: Which of the three teams that finished above us in 2004-05 should we have finished above? And which of the five teams that finished above us in 2006-07 should we have finished above? Which of the four teams that finished above us in 2007-08 and 2008-09 should we have had any chance of finishing above? Which of the seven teams that have finished above us in 2009-10 should we have had any chance of finishing above? Which of the six teams that finished above us last season should we have had any chance of finishing above?

The answer is none. The Villa team who have finished above us once or twice was expensively assembled and their wage bill was/is about 150% of ours. With that in mind, the only season where we might have done any better since David Moyes has been in charge, was 2005-06. And at that time, it was still nice, as an Everton fan, to not be biting our nails in April/May.
Mark Stone
18 Posted 12/02/2012 at 16:38:28
Declan do you not think Everton were fucking shite for a decade before Moyes came?
Mark Stone
19 Posted 12/02/2012 at 16:39:52
Mark Riding, 'Out of the 16 man squad named in the 2007 game... 11 are still on Evertons books today.. Transitional period.. dont make me fucking laugh..'

But they were in their prime then, now they are hanging on by the skin of their teeth. They need to be replaced ... as is often stated on here. That is exactly what is meant by transition. Remains to be seen if this transition will be successful.
Mark Stone
20 Posted 12/02/2012 at 16:43:49
Exactly James Martin
Mark Riding
21 Posted 12/02/2012 at 16:45:24
Mark Stone.. The 'transition period' I mentioned.. I feel I didn't express what I meant very well.

The players who have made the difference to our recent results / performances are not ours! They are on loan... take them away, and the squad is paper thin. Any chance of the 'transition' has been spunked up the wall by the chairman.

I find the timing of Moyes's comments interesting, and I'm glad he has come out and at least said something.
Mark Stone
22 Posted 12/02/2012 at 16:50:47
That's the point though Mark. The transition is a lull, no-one is saying we have made the transition, they are saying we are smack bang in the middle of it!
Mark Riding
23 Posted 12/02/2012 at 16:54:14
You cannot create any transition with players who are on loan though Mark... it's a stop-gap.. just do whatever it takes to stay in the league!

Totally understand that... but, once safe, we must play any potential 'prospects' and give them a run in the team. If we get dicked a few times and they turn out to be not up to standard, then we can get rid and try again.

Baxter, Duffy, even Barkley ? play them... what's to lose? And at least the element of doubt in fans minds will be gone.
Danny James
24 Posted 12/02/2012 at 16:46:19
I can understand people moaning about negative defensive style of play. Maybe a different manager could take us to 7th 8th or 9th whilst playing more exciting football. However, I don't believe we could have had another manager who could have taken us to higher up the league than we have finished each season with Moyesy.

We may not be too exciting to watch but it has been effective: 7th, 4th, 6th, 5th, 5th, 8th, 7th since 2001-02. What manager out there would have taken us beyond that?
Colin Southern
25 Posted 12/02/2012 at 16:55:44
Mark Riding (400) I have to disagree with that comment ? it's ludicrous. Let's have look at the squad from that Nov 2007 game.

? Howard - yep 1
? Hibbert - yep 2
? Valente - nope
? Yobo - nope
? Lescott - nope
? Carsley - nope
? Neville - just about 3
? Osman - yep 4
? Pienaar - yep 5
? Cahill - yep 6
? Yakubu - nope
? Anichebe - yep 7
? McFadden - yep 8
? Gravesen - nope

My maths count 8 players in all with 2 on-loan and Pip on his way out of the squad (I hope). You could break this down further and add in when these existing players signed for EFC and their ages to see that the squad really is in transition.
Wayne Smyth
26 Posted 12/02/2012 at 16:53:23
Mark Stone, I'm not one of Moyes fans, but you make some very good points in his defence. He certainly did some sterling work in his first years with us.

Where I'd draw the line is to state that in the last few years he really hasn't got the best out of the team he has available, even accepting that he's had bugger all transfer money in recent years.

Results against Chelsea and Man City in comparison to the game against Wigan really highlight Moyes's limitations in terms of flexibility of tactics/formation and also motivational ability.

Against teams better than us, Moyes's backs to the wall tactics seem to work quite well, enough of the time. Against teams who are worse than us, like Wigan ? or Tamworth ? we really need to be a bit more positive in so many respects, yet Moyes seems to play the same way in every game.

There was a comment by SAF after their game vs the RS this weekend. He said that he thought his team at 2-0 up made a mistake by not going for the 3rd or 4th goal and seemed happy to soak up the pressure, which he thought was a very dangerous tactic and a mistake.

Yet, hanging onto a 1-0 (or 0-0) is something Moyes teams always seem to do. Even this weekend with us 1-0 up when Pienaar broke away, he had a right go at Donovan and others when he realised that he was the only one making any attempt to go forward. It's a mindset thing and it seems to be something that is instilled into the players.
Mark Stone
27 Posted 12/02/2012 at 17:01:45
I agree Mark, the point I made at #383 is that the older players seem to be coming to the end of their shelf life 12-24 months before the youngsters are considered ready to step in and take their place. I'd hope over the next two seasons we gradually see more of players like Barkley and Duffy, and gradually less of players like Neville and Cahill. Transition.
Mark Stone
28 Posted 12/02/2012 at 17:08:14
Wayne, regardless of the style of play, Everton have always finished as high (or higher) in the premier league table than can be realistically have been expected. With perhaps the exception of 2005/6. There are genuine criticisms of Moyes, and when I read them I don't argue with them. However, 'If he had more testicular ambition in his tactics and formations we would have finished consisently higher in each of his ten tortuous and painful seasons.' is not one of them.
Dave Wilson
29 Posted 12/02/2012 at 17:10:30
Go and win us the cup Moysie lad.

Jim Knightley
30 Posted 12/02/2012 at 17:06:24
Ian, re. your comments:

"What a cheeky git. Everton are one of the biggest clubs in the country. He can shove his top ten finishes up his arse.

"If he had more testicular ambition in his tactics and formations we would have finished consisently higher in each of his ten tortuous and painful seasons.

"If Spurs are stupid enough to want to have him managing them and playing with Saha up front with someone like Huddlestone just behind then good luck to them. We will be well out of it."

Utterly bizzare. Do you have any hold on reality? Do you understand that we are not the team of the 1980s? Do you understand that history doesn't buy points, players do? (Players who are bought with money.) Moyes took us from a relegation team to regular top six finishes on a low budget.

You represent the type of deluded fan, living in the past, with completely out-of-sync realities. Our squad is a mid-table quality at best; our spending ability is that of a championship team. We have over-achieved in pretty much every season of Moyes reign, and if we finish in the top half this season, we would have done it again.

Moyes could play better football (which we did a few seasons ago) but his finishing positions cannot be argued with. If we had money, I think he could have re-consolidated us as a top top club, but without a fair budget, we are simply drifting away. That is not Moyes's fault, it is the Chairman's.

I don't believe we are in a transitional phrase, however; I believe we are merely getting worse as players age and leave, and we cannot replace them. I think the new manager of this club will oversee our relegation if we do not balance our finances in the next three seasons.
David Johnson
31 Posted 12/02/2012 at 17:17:51
"I take pride in the fact that it's only in the last 10 years that Everton have really come back to life," Moyes told The People.

All hope has been lost in the last ten years. I couldn't be arsed anymore and have even given up going until Kenwright has gone. Moyes too as I've lost all respect since he gagged himself after he took the Kenwright shilling.
Brian Waring
32 Posted 12/02/2012 at 17:18:57
The problem for Moyes, unlike Spurs who don't have to sell players to appease the banks, Moyes will have to keep selling, so without investment, he is always going to be in a transitional phase.
Jamie Tulacz
33 Posted 12/02/2012 at 17:28:25
David (426) ? can you name me a manager that does come out and slates his chairman in public? Just interested... Doesn't seem a great way to keep your job to me.
David Johnson
34 Posted 12/02/2012 at 17:26:17
His comments prove he hasn't got a scooby about Everton like some of the young kids his only perception of what it is to be a blue is tainted by the brainwashing and bullshit of the Kenwright regime. I'm far to old and wise to fall for any of it.
Mark Stone
35 Posted 12/02/2012 at 17:20:58
Jim, there are people on here who truly believe that four Latin words sewn into a crest have more value than £200m. I love our motto, I love our history, but in the Premier League era they mean very little.
Barry Rathbone
37 Posted 12/02/2012 at 17:24:14
Jim Knightley

"You represent the type of deluded fan, living in the past, with completely out-of-sync realities."

Possibly the most arrogant sentiment written on here for some time, if it wasn't for people of this mindset GP would be empty.
Mark Stone
38 Posted 12/02/2012 at 17:34:32
'All hope has been lost in the last ten years'

You old enough to remember the previous ten, though?
David Johnson
39 Posted 12/02/2012 at 17:35:37
Jamie 431 He goes beyond just trying to keep his job and appears to even back the fucker. Maybe it's all in his contract.
Chris Verghoden
40 Posted 12/02/2012 at 17:34:39
Seems that Villa fans want Lerner out now. I Remember when he was held as a beacon of everything that is good about football ownership by many blues. I don't see a great deal changing at Everton for a good while so it will be interesting to see what the future holds for Moyes.
Dave Wilson
41 Posted 12/02/2012 at 17:36:28
Ah Jim Knightley

The voice of reason.
Paul Hardcastle
42 Posted 12/02/2012 at 17:41:06
At least in the previous decade, in the Premier League era, a very alive Everton actually WON a trophy. Something Moyes seems to conveniently forget... and seems incapable of emulating.
Ian Smitham
43 Posted 12/02/2012 at 17:33:29
Mark, A touch of reality thank you. That phrase can be used to hang anyone not living up to our standards of the past. In case I forget, when were we "Nil satis...."? And those that were that myth, what were they doing to protect it for the future of the ones Mr Johnson so values?

So much for the "supporter" ethic of "through thick and thin". Easy to type about Mr Moyes's care for the club from behind a computer. Fora all his short-comings, I doubt a lack of commitment and care are charges that he could be regarded as guilty of... especially from those who choose to "support" the club when things are going to be so much better when BK goes.
Chris Verghoden
44 Posted 12/02/2012 at 17:44:18
Paul Hardcastle.. I think it's more Mark Stone forgetting we actually won something in that previous decade. It also gets conveniently forgotten that for two years Joe Royle had a very decent team.
Mark Stone
45 Posted 12/02/2012 at 17:46:12
'at least in the previous decade, in the Premier League era, a very alive Everton actually WON a trophy'

A very alive Everton that finished 15th in the league that season and 17th the year before that. Fifteenth again 2 seasons later, stayed up on goal difference (17th) the year after that, Then 14th, 13th and 16th before looking dead certain for the drop before Moyes took over in 2002? .

Not taking anything away from the FA Cup win in 1995, but the the cup is a lottery. Anyone can beat anyone on their day. But the league table doesn't lie. Joe Royle's biggest achievement was finishing 6th in 1996 - he says so himself.
Mark Stone
46 Posted 12/02/2012 at 18:05:37
I don't forget the FA Cup in 1995 at all, Chris. And the team was only good for one season after that. Would I give up going into May in, or within touching distance of the relegation zone pretty much every season up for pretty much a decade of 4th-7th finishes? You betcha.
Mark Stone
47 Posted 12/02/2012 at 18:10:12
If anyone thinks being an Everton fan between 1992-2002 was better than 2002-2012 then they need their head testing. The FA Cup was one of the best days of my football supporting life. Pretty much other 36499 were fucking terrible.
Brian Denton
48 Posted 12/02/2012 at 17:35:36
Actually, I am going to be brutally honest here. I've been going to Everton games regularly since1966, and for most of the seasons from 1970 onwards we've been pretty crap, apart from the brilliance of 1984-87 and to a lesser extent 1987-90.

I've seen brilliant, exciting football and I've seen dreck. The one thing I have never seen is relegation, And I don't want to, although there is a school of thought which asserts that all experiences are good, even hurtful ones!

I couldn't be arsed doing the research, but I'd be surprised if there is any ten year period in our history which has delivered sustained top ten finishes. As Aussies say, we are a 'Sydney or the Bush' club, like it or lump it.
Sam Hoare
49 Posted 12/02/2012 at 18:16:51
Anyone who thinks moyes has not pushed this club forward in his ten years here is either lying or daft. Just look at the league finishes in his ten years here and the ten years before.
Ian Black
50 Posted 12/02/2012 at 18:24:30
For all those who are keen to see the back of Moyes, have you ever considered who would replace him? No, not who YOU would replace him with, but who Kenwright would replace him with? He'd want someone young, ambitious, entrenched in the Everton way with a respect for their history; someone aware of the clubs finances and willing to back his chairman to the hilt; someone willing to carry on all the great work Moyes has done for the club (kenwrights thoughts, remember). In my mind that would be a shortlist of one, a certain Mr P Neville and that scares the shit out of me.
Paul Holmes
51 Posted 12/02/2012 at 18:24:34
He is on £60,000 a week,he will never be sacked by the current chairman no matter how bad we become. He has 'THE BEST JOB' in football! He is saying he would turn down a job at a Champions League team to stay at Everton, which proves he has no ambition and is happy to just keep taking the money!
Mark Stone
52 Posted 12/02/2012 at 18:38:31
Sam Hoare, I've listed them at #447 and #404

There are a lot of posters who must be either <10 years old, or spent the 90's in a coma.
Colin Southern
53 Posted 12/02/2012 at 18:09:28
That's true, Joe Royle and Big Nev have always said anyone can win the cup, the league is completely different. If you look at the league since the Premier League started, it's the teams who have spent the most or pay the most who are at the top.
Dennis Stevens
54 Posted 12/02/2012 at 18:40:03
Seing as we can't afford to buy out any currently employed manager's contract out then it'd have to be someone who's readily available, Ian : David Jones?
Mark Riding
55 Posted 12/02/2012 at 18:46:38
Colin Southern #418..
I apologise.. It was 10 - not 11
You said I was 'ludicrous' bit harsh, but I hope you see my point..
Howard - yes
Hibbert - yes
Yobo - still only on loan.. so yes.
Lescott - no
Cahill - yes
Neville - yes
Valente - no
Pienaar - short term loan - yes.
Osman - yes
Yakubu - no
Carsley - no
SUBS...
Wessels - no
Gravesen - no
McFadden - yes
Jagielka - yes
Anichebe - yes
Chris Leyland
56 Posted 12/02/2012 at 18:45:31
One thing we can be thankful of is that he is not like the prick managing across the park. I used to respect Dalglish until his recent dispicable behaviour over the Suarez incident. Yesterday's interview post match was a pathetic and shaming embarrassment. He and Suarez have been made to apologise by the hierarchy today. Moyes may have his faults but he isn't ever gonna bring shame and scorn on the club to the extent Dalglish has with the shite over the Suarez debacle.
Ian Smitham
57 Posted 12/02/2012 at 18:56:14
Dennis "In my heart of hearts my blood is blue, I am an Evertonian" chilled me and since the day he said it, call me melodramatic, but if we want an Everton related Manager, then yes, alas I support Everton but that does not mean I would be a good Manager. (Though obviously I would be)
Jim Knightley
58 Posted 12/02/2012 at 18:32:56
Jim Knightley

"You represent the type of deluded fan, living in the past, with completely out-of-sync realities."

Possibly the most arrogant sentiment written on here for some time, if it wasn't for people of this mindset GP would be empty.

- Barry I'm confused...you are suggesting that those with out of sync realities, and those who live in the past, fill the ground?! And with that argument, you are implicitly suggesting those with grips on reality don't? Amazing.

I can't speak for every supporter who fills the ground. However I would suggest it is those who expect more than reality, who are the first to leave when reality bites. Football too often suffers from the unrealistic mindset of fans, who believe that past acclaim, should be repeated in the present, irrespective of circumstance. Look at the Arsenal fans who complain at Wenger, despite his resurrection of that team. In 10 years, Arsenal's economic backbone, will make them the most self-sufficient club in world football. Wenger is constantly outspent, but clings onto a top four position whilst playing some of the best football in the world. Yet the fans expect the manager to risk economic security, by spending at high levels to bring trophies now. The very same fans who criticised Wenger (along with the media) so avidly for buying Chamberlain, and who then criticise the manager for bringing him off.
On record, I watch Everton in person, or on television, because they are my team. I am use to watching us struggle, I am use to us being without money, but that matters not at all to my support. I realise that under Moyes, I have seen my club move from a relegation team, to a team that played in Europe, and who consistently outperformed those teams who should have been our come above us. If we go down, I will still watch as before. I don?t need to cling onto the past, to demand we come in the top four, to keep watching Everton. I watch them because they are my team.
Football cannot subsist, like anything, on success for all. From an objective point of view, I would say any position from 12th upwards, is success for us. I believe this based on the following factors:
-When wage details are released for this season, we will have the 12th-13th lowest wages in the division.
-Our spending has for the last few seasons, been either the lowest, or around the lowest in the division.
-The players which were so impressive for us in the past, have grown old. We cannot afford to replace them.
-We have suffered the morale effects of constant off the field problems, and a hopeless financial situation.
-We have suffered from the continued effects of decreased competition and a lack of signings (rectified in part this window).
I stand by my comments re. Ian?s post. The past has nothing to do with now. The biggest clubs in the country are those with the most money and we have now divine right to success. I will stand by Moyes onto I believe he is underachieving, and the club will benefit with a replacement. At the moment, given our position and financial capability, I believe the time of manager we could attract is unlikely to improve on Moyes.
Ian Black
59 Posted 12/02/2012 at 18:55:56
I like Dave Jones, have a lot of time and respect for the man, but could he do a better job than Moyes with no money? I personally think Kenwright has locked himself away in his bolt-hole and would be more keen to bring someone in who won't challenge him and won't speak out after (another) one of his appalling gaffs. As Neville knows exactly how Kenwright works and it'd be a new job with his entire managerial reputation on the line he would be much more malleable, with the added bonus of being able to spout off endless claptrap to the press.
Mark Stone
60 Posted 12/02/2012 at 19:08:27
I find it amazing, but not entirely surprising, that Jim had to spell that out.
Ben Dyke
61 Posted 12/02/2012 at 18:53:15
I find all the extreme anti Moyes sentiment absolutely devoid of any reality! I have been a season ticket holder from way back in the end of the 80s (the start of our decline) and I have to say under Moyes I have seen more attractive solid football overall than at any period since the mid 80s. And all this with a budget far far less than our main rivals, unlike then when we were relatively rich (but still badly managed off pitch in my eyes).

Yes Moyes is relatively defensive minded but I can tell you he only does that because he thinks its the best way with our resources to establish a regular top ten side. He does not do it because he hates flair football. You can tell that from the purchases he has made. And I for one 100% agree with his approach. In fact, strangely enough so do pundits, fellow managers, other teams fans, his chairman and lastly but not least FACTS and FIGURES and STATS!!

But forgive me fellow fans because I forgot just by being a Blue who plays FIFA and watches football u think you know better than Moyes.

Now before u rant at me, I am criticising the unthinking extreme anti Moyes bias, not the thinking, balanced realistic criticism.

And yes, believe it or not some matches the Ginger Scot has absolutely done my head in with his approach because I would rather we attacked and lost 4-0 to a better team sometimes than some of our narrow losses to them. BUT I couldnt take too many big losses and neither could u lot, and that would have happened a lot more often if we had tried to be expansive.

If u want, compare Tottenham because they play the football we 'want'. But I can categorically say they are like that because they have had money to buy the quality above us, or have attracted people because its London.
Colin Southern
62 Posted 12/02/2012 at 18:59:13
Fair enough Mark (466) was a bit harsh there. But lets back it up with some facts as well.

I missed Jags, didn't see him the subs list I will give you that one.

You're stretching the Yobo one; he's on loan with no chance of coming back and when was the last time he played for us ? not counted.

McFadden was only 23/24 in 2007 and he's not 29 until April 2012.

Victor Anichebe is only 23 now.

Jagielka joined team Everton aged 24, in 2007.

Howard went out on loan to Everton to play more first-team football and eventually signed permanently with us in February 2007 aged 27.

Pienaar joined Everton on loan for 2007-08 aged 25.
Not exactly an aging squad of has-beens is it?
Dennis Stevens
63 Posted 12/02/2012 at 19:12:08
"I like Dave Jones, have a lot of time and respect for the man, but could he do a better job than Moyes with no money?" - not too sure of the relevance of that comment, Ian. You were speculating as to who Kenwright may choose as a replacement for Moyes if he should vacate the Managers position & suggesting Neville as a likely candidate, I'm merely pointing out someone who I think would be another likely candidate. Peter Reid would also perhaps fit the bill, from a Board perspective.
Chris Verghoden
64 Posted 12/02/2012 at 19:17:43
Well I suppose Ben, Ian and Jim that the anti Kenwright are devoid of the same reality. As is often quoted on here, all Moyesy is missing is an owner that will provide him with funds.

As I said earlier Villa are calling for Lerner ad MCCLeish Lerner was allegedly the type if owner we should aspire to and allegedly was turned away . Now 'reality' bites for them.

That just leaves the billionaire type. The irony is though, for all the moaning that Kenwright only wants a donor and not a buyer, that is exactly what most Evertonians want. Someone who will use his own money to buy the club, write off debt, build a stadium and get us into the CL annually whilst operating at a profit. So really it is not just the anti Moyes brigade who are devoid of reality is it?
Dennis Stevens
65 Posted 12/02/2012 at 19:24:19
Ian [Smitham], don't really know what you're getting at, but if you are ever appointed rest assured you'll have my support - at least for the first 45 mins!
Colin Southern
66 Posted 12/02/2012 at 19:24:09
Jim (473), I wish people wouldn't throw Wenger into the argument. They still pay higher wages than us. Remember Sol Campbell when he joined them 2001? He was on 80 grand a week then. Recently Moyes said he wanted to sign one of their youth/reserves and he said he was on more money than our first teamers. They also don't bring many of their own players through; they poach a lot of talent from other teams and consistently pay top 4 wages.
Tom Owen
67 Posted 12/02/2012 at 19:19:02
Moyes has done a magnificent job with Everton. He has saved Everton Football Club, no doubt about it. But at this present time, I find it's gone stale. It's stagnating and we do need change, from top to bottom.

He sets his team out not to lose, because that is the safe option. I don't like how we go away to the 'top 6' and completely surrender and just park the bus. His record away to the bigger teams is abysmal. His continuous negative out look has cost us a lot of points this season. That is my only concern. I just believe that if we had a more attacking tactical manager like Martinez, Rodgers or Lambert then we might of been challenging Chelsea for 4th. But then football is all ifs and puts.

However the longer the wait for investment goes, the more we need Moyes to stay. In five or six years time, when Distin, Neville, Hibbert, Osman, Cahill have all left for nothing, and Baines, Heitinga, Jagielka reaching the end of their careers. Where going to be in a really bad position if we don't have the funds to re-build the team to regain top 10 status. And for me there's only one man I would want at the crown to manage us in those difficult times, and that is David Moyes.

The City and Chelsea results were great. I was worried that we had lost our belief and spirit. But it was all evident that we hadn't. Moyes' spark was back and the spirit and determination was a joy to watch.

Colin Southern
68 Posted 12/02/2012 at 19:36:05
Ben Dyke (480), I agree with most of that except the bit where you said you would rather we attacked and lost 4-0 to a better team sometimes than some of our narrow losses to them. Ok you back-tracked a bit but have you ever been to the match when we've been battered by a big score ? it's sickening!
Mark Stone
69 Posted 12/02/2012 at 19:39:39
But if the Rodgers/Martinez/Lambert style gets you more points, why would you rather keep Moyes? Surely if we were in the mire we'd have an even more urgent need for points? Not my opinion by the way, it's just your philosophy doesn't make sense to me.
Andrew Ellams
70 Posted 12/02/2012 at 19:49:27
Moyes has stood still and other clubs have overtaken us. Whilst I don't expect to be looking up at the likes of Norwich or Swansea this time next year, the days of top 6 finishes are gone for good and if the likes of Newcastle and Sunderland keep improving we are going to start looking at 9th or 10th place finishes as genuine achievements.
Mark Stone
71 Posted 12/02/2012 at 19:54:02
Of course Sunderland should have been finishing above us for several seasons, given that they pay ~ £20m more p.a. than we do in wages, and that they actually buy players in the transfer window. I'm amazed at what NUFC have done this season. Whether it will be sustained, we'll see.
Colin Southern
72 Posted 12/02/2012 at 19:57:33
Andrew Ellams (493)

No, I disagree Moyes: has not stood still ? it's our club that's stood still and other clubs have overtaken us. You can only move forward with investment.

The likes of Newcastle and Sunderland keep improving because they invest in their squads and pay higher wages than us.

You can't keep slating the man if he hasn't been able to sign quality players, and then expect him to have his team playing like Man Utd or Barca.
Ian Edwards
73 Posted 12/02/2012 at 19:57:08
Mark Stone

You are blind to Moyes's many failings.

He has spnet money and on occasions big money-and squandered it. How much has he lost On Bily?- Millions and Millions.

Moyes said last season he had the best squad in his time at the club. Shouldnt he therefore have finished at least 4th?.

He also said he was responsible for transfers. If he let Arteta go and Pienaar and Yak and Beckford then that was his fault.

Give him more money to squander? I wouldnt send him to buy a bag of chips.

I could go through virtually every season in his managership and point to many games where his negativity especially at home has failed to beat relegation fodder. Must be at least 12-15 points a season.

This season we have failed to beat a considerable number of teams at home that are fighting relegation. If he had shown a bit more bottle we could have won those games. If we had another ten points not only would we be above the RS but more than in with a chance of top four.

For every point gained against the likes of chelseas and City there is the tactical shambles and cowardice like last week at Wigan.

See what a decent Manager can do with Saha???

When is he going to go to Anfield or Old Trafford and try and win? The answer is he wont.

If Spurs want him I'll send him a route map.... and Davey ... don't look back because we won't be waving.

Goodison is full of deluded fans like you Mr Stone and it has kept Moyes in a job for at least 4 or 5 years too long. You get what you deserve and I hope you enjoy your one up front with a player just behind who has scored the same number of goals as Tim Howard in the last 15 months.
John Ford
74 Posted 12/02/2012 at 20:01:06
Tom O, there are lots of examples where teams play more attacking expansive football than us, do well for a time, and then drop like a stone. Trouble is everyone forgets this.

Last season Blackpool West Ham Sunderland and even Bolton went all out up front. They all had some noteable victories which made for great highlights on MOTD etc. Jeezus was Holloway the new Clough or what! For the first half of last season these were the teams the anti moyes posse picked as examples of what we should be doing. The common denominator is that they all dropped, like a stone (no pun Mark!). All of them. They were found out over a long season and failed because their managers didnt deal with the basics. Teams just rolled them over. Pretty stylish players, but clueless about proper teamwork

This happens so often. Moyes may be cautious, but he is so because he knows how to get the best results with the resources he has. Nobody but nobody does this better. This season he has had less than ever to play with, Now we have the bit of flair to go with our strong defence and were looking better once more.

The only teams who look consistently creative are the money teams, they can afford the very best creative players, and the very best defenders to do the basic boring stuff.

Moyes with a few bob would be an interesting proposition. He may not actually be the man for us if we had the cash, but i'd love to find out.
Gavin Fennessy
75 Posted 12/02/2012 at 20:10:12
Spot on Chris #472.
Bob Willis
76 Posted 12/02/2012 at 20:14:32
Correct me if I'm wrong 'cos I haven't read all the above comments.

But from reading the Moyes statement
I get the impression that he is talking about the 'Club' being in transition, not just the team.

As a club we are facing severe restrictions - whoever is to blame - and it is becos' of those restrictions that Everton
HAS to be in transition. These loan deals are part of that transition or if you prefer the quest for financial stability.

A 'financial' transition must take place and it is becos' of this that I think that both Jags and Rodwell will be sold in the Summer. Jags 'cos we have better and Rodwell can't cut the mustard. Should get the books back in line with how they should be.

Further 'investment' would be great but until the present regime have sorted out the transition and the good ship EvertonFC is back on an even keel there will be no investment.

The 'Club' got itself into this mess and its the 'Club' that have to sort it out.

There are no fairies!!
Simon Harris
77 Posted 12/02/2012 at 20:25:17
John Ford #500 - I couldn't agree more.
John Ford
78 Posted 12/02/2012 at 20:24:58
Why do some Moyes detractors just open themselves up to be knocked down?

Premier league points per £ spent? ....Moyes comes out on top. Hardly a revelation. Our net spend is a relative pittance.

There are reasonable criticisms of Moyes but accusing him of wastfullness in the market isnt one of them. If he is then so is just about every premier manager who shook a chairmans hand.

Mark Stone
79 Posted 12/02/2012 at 20:40:18
Ian Edwards #498, do you think before you type?

Firstly, what makes you think I am blind to any of Moyes failings? The very specific point that I am arguing here relates to league position only.

'He has spnet money and on occasions big money-and squandered it. How much has he lost On Bily?- Millions and Millions'

'He also said he was responsible for transfers. If he let Arteta go and Pienaar and Yak and Beckford then that was his fault'

Here is you new challenge. Find anything I have ever written on this website where I have challenged these facts.
Mark Boulle
80 Posted 12/02/2012 at 20:38:07
I just can't make my mind up. I am trying not to be blinded by two excellent home wins vs Citeh and Chelski, but at the same time it is hard to summon up the same levels of vitriol I was feeling after the Blackburn draw a few weeks back. Right now, as an Everton fan, I'm reasonably happy with moving into the top 10 and the chance, if we beat Blackpool, of an FA Cup 1/4 final. But then, back in the dark days of draws at home to Norwich and dreadful defeats at home to Bolton, I was firmly into the 'Moyes out' camp.

It does seem that, whenever we reach our lowest ebb, Moyes somehow summons a performance of fire, grit, determination and no little skill from these players. I don't know how he does it, and I wish he'd do it all of the time. I also fervently wish he would set out in a more attacking vein. But then, perhaps there is just something in dour Glaswegians. Villa fans were phoning 606 in their scores just now and their complaints about McCleish and his playing style could have been drawn straight from these pages.

At times like this, my true ire once again turns on our silent, inactive Board, sitting there doing nothing and making no obvious progress towards selling the club.

Yours, a confused Evertonian.

ps - Chris Leyland at 467. Spot on. Not to turn this into a thread about Liverpool, but what a tosser 'King' Kenny showed himself to be yesterday. He seriously expects people to believe he had no idea that Suarez didn't shake Evra's hand?! And he, along with many equally deluded Shite fans, still see Suarez as a victim of some kind of FA stitch up. What a joke!
Mark Stone
81 Posted 12/02/2012 at 20:45:16
'I could go through virtually every season in his managership and point to many games where his negativity especially at home has failed to beat relegation fodder. Must be at least 12-15 points a season.

This season we have failed to beat a considerable number of teams at home that are fighting relegation. If he had shown a bit more bottle we could have won those games. If we had another ten points not only would we be above the RS but more than in with a chance of top four'

Of course, this is ignorant to the very nature of a league, isn't it? You say we dropped points to relegation fodder and if we hadn't we'd be challenging top four. But at the same you ignore the fact that the teams above us have also dropped points to 'relegation fodder'. Off the top of my head, how did Liverpool and Chelsea get on at Wigan? How did Man Utd get on at Blackburn? And at the same time, Man City shouldn't be dropping points to teams like us, so if we are changing results against teams we shouldn't have dropped points to, are we changing the results against teams we shouldn't have beaten, too? Nature of football, Ian.
James Martin
82 Posted 12/02/2012 at 20:40:49
Why does everyone go on about Martinez, Lambert or Rogers? Martinez has some decent players at Wigan yet ploughs them into a relegation battle each season. Everyone goes on about them playing good football but where is it? Very easy just to pass it around the back 4 for ages pretending your amazing then having every move break down and losing most games.

We're having one of our worst seasons (apparently, which tells you everything you need to know about how Moyes has raised our expectation levels with high league finishes) yet look at the league table, anyone realistically think either Swansea or Norwich will finish ahead of us?

This is the same Swansea who just surrendered all attacking instinct against our terrible side at Goodison. They'll both stay up which for them and their managers will be miracle seasons. Wigan will probably go down and one of Swansea or Norwich will next season as second season syndrome bites.

Rogers will have probably switched clubs as he always does the second the pressure gets too much. What have either of these three managers done compared to Moyes? Absolutely nothing.
Mark Stone
83 Posted 12/02/2012 at 20:52:01
If teams always beat those below them, and always got beat by those above them, the bookies wouldn't last very long would they? Fans of any team can look at individual games and think what could have been. Individual games don't shape the league table. That is the beauty of it. The league doesn't lie. The Cup, of course, is a different kettle of fish.
Mark Stone
84 Posted 12/02/2012 at 21:00:34
Anyway Ian, answer the questions I asked at 404. Which of the teams who have finished above us in those seasons SHOULD we have finished above? And why?
Mark Stone
85 Posted 12/02/2012 at 21:08:26
Finally:

'See what a decent Manager can do with Saha???'

One good game, Ian. And that, a home debut. He had loads of good games for us. As I've said on the thread which is dedicated to Saha, I'll reserve my judgement on him till the end of the season.
Mick Gallagher
86 Posted 12/02/2012 at 21:17:28
Give me a FA Cup win and a mid table finish anytime if your not going to win the League then FA Cup is the next best thing. Winning cups and leagues thats what make great managers not top 10 finshes.

Im not Moyes biggest fan mainly because he his to negative a times and yes he has improved us since he took over but maybe a fresh challenge his needed. Glad to see him enjoying the last 2 games makes a refreshing change.

I would love it if he's walking up the stairs at wembley in May but this time to get a winners medal. I would take a bottom half finish and a FA Cup win right now.
Ian Smitham
87 Posted 12/02/2012 at 21:24:24
Ian Edwards, you have a go at the "deluded fans"

Before I explore the comments that you make, please may ask you to let me know if you go to the game and if not how you "suuport" the club. Then also, Sir, just tell me how I am deluded supporting the club I have for a number of years, thick and thin, then, just to finish off, then let me know where we can discuss this face to face how I am "deluded" because I find that offensive. Time to stand up or shut up, you choose.
Jim Knightley
88 Posted 12/02/2012 at 21:29:07
Ian Edwards... Seriously... one of the most stupid posts I've read on here, although tbh I am not suprised after your first post.

Re. the transfers... How reductive is it to refer to just poor transfers? And name one long-serving manager in the football, Ferguson (who has wasted a lot more than us) and Wenger included, who haven't mis-spent. But as you've gone there... What profit did we make on Lescott? What profit did we make on Arteta? How much did we buy Baines, Jags, Arteta, Lescott, Howard, Coleman, Pienaar for? Moyes has made a few bad buys, but I would say some of his transfer dealings have been the best in the league. Please, let me hear you disagree with this? As credence for this, I would refer to the above list. But beyond this, I want you to explain this:
Moyes took over when we were 17th; with very little relative spending money he secured several top six finishes, including some decent cup runs. Now you maintain Moyes is tactically poor and can't buy... Can I ask therefore, how he managed with less money than his rivals, to achieve what he has?

And how he created a squad, which according to you in one of the most idiotic comments I've ever been privy too, should have recieved 12-15 more points a season (and therefore be regular top four finishes).

You Ian are priceless, and not in a good way.
Mark Stone
89 Posted 12/02/2012 at 21:29:26
'Give me a FA Cup win and a mid table finish anytime'

Mick, that's one thing, but the story of the nineties wasn't really 'mid table' finishes, was it? It was barely staying up!

'If you're not going to win the League then FA Cup is the next best thing. Winning cups and leagues thats what make great managers not top 10 finishes.'

Well that is your opinion so it's neither right nor wrong. I can see why feel that way. For the record, I tend to disagree (again, just my opinion). For example, I'd take Wenger over McLeish anyway, even though on current form (ie over the past 5 years) the latter has won more trophies.
Ian Edwards
90 Posted 12/02/2012 at 21:39:02
Ian Smitham

Yes.. I go to the games and in fact was there when there was 9000 against Coventry. I feel that entitles me to comment and the football played by the club then was infinitely better than it is now. Even if we were losing more than we won.

I stand by my comment about Moyes supporters being deluded... and if that really offends you Mr Smitham then you need to get a life and get out more.
Mick Gallagher
91 Posted 12/02/2012 at 21:45:00
Mark ever one has there own opinions and we are all entitled to them but I cant agree with you classing Wenger and Mcleish and saying but only over 5 years. Look what Wenger has won as a manager and yes Mcleish won plenty in Scotland.
James Martin
92 Posted 12/02/2012 at 22:02:24
The football of the late 90s was 'infinitely better' than it is now? Are you joking? Those teams were terrible.

All those records that stood before Moyes swept them all away, how many years was it without a win at Elland Road, White Hart Lane, St James' Park. I can remember praying for a point whenever midtable sides like Newcastle, Villa, Leeds, Boro or Spurs came to Goodison. They wer evastly superior to us whilst the top sides were a mile out of our league.

Nowadays, we look down on the majority of those teams and up at teams like the RS and Spurs who have spent £100s of millions more than us. A whole decade of long balls to Ferguson's head, how was that any better than the football played by the Moyes team of Arteta, Pienaar, Baines, Yakubu, Lescott and Osman?
Mark Stone
93 Posted 12/02/2012 at 22:14:28
McLeish won the League Cup with Brum last season (or was it the season before???) Wenger has won nothing since 2005 (7 years). Bit harsh to judge Moyes for not winning a trophy when you compare what Wenger has had at his disposal in that time, compared to what Moyes has had. Can you judge a manager on what they achieved 7-10 years ago?
Ian Smitham
94 Posted 12/02/2012 at 22:18:40
I take it that you still go to the game and are a supporter and in this regard, just tto be clear to all the readers, let me know where you sit now and then also let me know how we can discuss how I am deluded. Ready to go for it whenever you are ready to call me face to face "deluded".
David Sheen
95 Posted 12/02/2012 at 22:19:28
The years before Moyes......

1992 - 12th
1993 - 13th
1994 - 17th
1995 - 15th
1996 - 6th
1997 - 15th
1998 - 17th
1999 - 14th
2000 - 13th
2001 - 16th
2002 - 15th

Moyes comes in. With hardly any investment compared to other clubs and makes Everton a top 8 club.

Yet you still get deluded fans talking about "Yeah but we are the 4th most successful.". Our club declined in the 90s.



Martin Mason
96 Posted 12/02/2012 at 21:55:13
Not only does Moyes handle himself with dignity but he is also correct. The team and club are both in transition and the fact that there are players here who were here 5 years ago is an irrelevancy.

Our future now is far more in the youngsters who are coming through rather than the has-been hacks who were brought in pre-Moyes and current players who are patently past their best. Given what we have spent under Moyes we have done exceptionally well and being a top ten club with our spend is, as Moyes says, a very good achievement. Is anybody really so naive to suggest that we should expect to be a lot higher or, laughably, to win things given our spending power?

Moyes does things that we punters see as crazy but he knows more about soccer and coaching than our combined knowledge and he sees the players constantly in training. If I could see a point where his craziness kicked in it was when we took on Steve Round as AM, Moyes had done a brilliant job without an AM but could Round have so much negative influence on the Manager?

Wigan beat Bolton (who easily beat us earlier) away yesterday and they were unlucky to lose to City and Chelsea so why should we expect to roll them over? In that light, our recent run has been pretty amazing and, apart from Donovan going, I believe that Moyes is assembling a very good squad with Heitinga in his correct position like having a new player.

We could sell Jags if needed to fund a decent right sided midfielder and hopefully Stevie Pienaar back again and with Barkley, Rodwell, Duffy, Coleman we have the basis of a side with a good mixture of youth and experience.

I refuse to share the buttock clenching, unconstructively negative criticism of Moyes and the club shared by many posters here who are beginning to sound like a cracked record. Criticism for the sake of it is the ultimate in negativity when what the club needs is very large doses of positivity and support which is what good fans should provide and we have until recently been the best of all fans.

I for one give my full backing to Moyes and the board and sincerely hope they can pull a rabbit out of the hat even without the resources that clubs like Spurs are blessed with. I desperately hope we get some investment or sell up but this is unlikely.

I do not believe that we should expect the board to put their own money in unless there is return and so there is absolutely no alternative way to run the club than how it is being run now, within its means. I hope that Trust Everton gets off the ground such that real Evertonians can make a real contribution to the club and be a genuine focal point that is both positive and non-threatening.

I'm extremely happy to see how well Blackburn are begining to play under Steve Kean after the "protests" there and hope that they continue to meet their potential which like ours will be limited by how much they can spend.

It looks as though Moyes is the favourite to take the Tottenham job and I for one will be very sorry to see him go. I believe that he will do well and that there is a very high probability that we won't do well when he has gone. I believe what he says about wanting to see his job through at Everton and he seems positive that investment will come.

FFS get behind the team and club, they are doing well and could have turned the corner; even at their best in the past there have been games like Wigan where we have ground out draws and even won championships by doing it. This obsession with negativity, ceaseless criticism and in some cases a genuine wish for the team to lose to precipitate the crisis is like a cancer and the prophesies of doom will be self-fulfilling the more it takes hold.
David Sheen
97 Posted 12/02/2012 at 22:33:28
QUOTE = "A whole decade of long balls to Ferguson's head"


HAHAH! It made me laugh, but that's sadly true.
Mark Stone
98 Posted 12/02/2012 at 22:33:18
Ian I wouldn't get too offended mate, just read the posts and you can tell he's not all there. Sure he doesn't mean anything by it.
Barry Rathbone
99 Posted 12/02/2012 at 22:28:25
Ian Smitham

What are you some kind of troublemaker?

I'm not entirely sure what excuses football fans going half way to offering fisticuffs to fellow supporters but claiming someone's views are deluded don't seem to fit the bill.

Lighten up, remember one of the Moyes brigade called critics of Moyes "cunts" and his mate followed up with "fuck off to analfield"

There was no problem......

they've never been heard of since mind!!!!
(cue Jaws music)
Mark Stone
100 Posted 12/02/2012 at 22:41:40
Both been banned, Barry
Barry Rathbone
101 Posted 12/02/2012 at 22:47:37
Mark

I heard they sleep with the fishes.

(@ Goodfellas - De Niro)
Colin Southern
102 Posted 12/02/2012 at 22:39:09
Ian Smitham ? chillout, the other Ian (525) is either winding you up or talking bollocks. I mean, come on ? who in their right minds would say "I feel that entitles me to comment and the football played by the club then was infinitely better than it is now. Even if we were losing more than we won."

Another Ian (Snowden) said in his book that we we a poor side. Apart from about 2 seasons, Everton were a bad joke. I used to live down south for a while and whenever we were mentioned people used to laugh out load about how bad we were.

They don't do that now!
Derek Thomas
103 Posted 12/02/2012 at 23:02:11
I see this as a polite word to BK: "Find me some money, before I have to commit to the Spurs job, do that and all is forgiven. I have an option. You don't."
Ian Smitham
104 Posted 12/02/2012 at 23:25:58
Barry, I take it you have read the thread. The "deluded" word is not mine.

The other Ian, if I may say that, mentioned he was one of the 9,000 Good. So many were.

But I would like to talk about now.

Step forward, Ian.
Roman Sidey
105 Posted 12/02/2012 at 22:40:10
"I don't want to leave this club then see someone else come in and get the chance to do all the things I've dreamed I could do here with the right investment."

Sounds to me like he thinks his achievements are more important than the team.

Sounds like he's getting ready to sign a new contract. Counting down my remaining days giving a fuck.
Christine Foster
106 Posted 12/02/2012 at 23:29:59
Facts speak for themselves. Moyes has stabilised the decline that was the 90s, no doubt about that. Absolutely none.

To do it Everton FC had to sell the family silver when they should have seen the writing on the wall.

Short term fixes, a credit card mentality and a reality check when the bank said no more meant that instead of transitioning the team, we stopped. Reliance on loans cannot continue.

The club is in transition away from the appalling financial management by the board. Except of course the team that got us there in the first place is still in charge.

Neither bodes well for the immediate future of the team, the club and our ability to compete. Surely those who refuse to look beyond next week (or the last game) can see that.

The search for investment goes on.. note the term investment.. rather than sale, is there anyone who can explain to me just HOW that will work? Given that the directors have no intention of diluting their share base!!

A sale is a sale. It's not an investment.

I think Moyes believes he can do better, but I also think he is paving a path of keeping his integrity intact if (and when) he leaves because of the "lack of investment" No one would blame him would they?

The question of how good a manager he is, is another story, he is conservative at best, negative at worst, obstinate and often gets caught in the headlights.

He is a rock, immovable at times. inflexible and his strengths are also his weaknesses.

But time is running out, players aging, more loan deals, selling more than buying, somewhere something is going to break.

When we run out of players to sell we have run out of time.
Ian Edwards
107 Posted 12/02/2012 at 23:41:44
Just been away from the net and returned to see more ramblings from Messrs Stone and Smitham.

Mr Stone ... I am all there...and I think you will find more posters on Toffeeweb are anti rather than pro Dreary Dave.

Mr Smitham... you obviously want a fight which speaks volumes for your neanderthal mentality.
Ciarán McGlone
108 Posted 12/02/2012 at 23:57:39
Ian Smitham,

That's several times now you've indicated that only those who go to games can be considered supporters.

Any chance of knocking this bollocks on the head?
Mark Stone
109 Posted 13/02/2012 at 00:01:04
'Mr Stone ... I am all there...and I think you will find more posters on Toffeeweb are anti rather than pro Dreary Dave'

First, you don't have to be anti- or pro. And second, that doesn't make them right, does it? I will listen to any genuine criticism of Moyes and take them on board. I will readily criticise Moyes myself, when I think it is appropriate.

I readily admit that there are things he does that frustrate me. But the specific criticism you make of him at #380 is absurd. I bet there are not many on here, or in the world for that matter, who consider our fourth, fifth and sixth placed finishes to be underachievement. You might say ramblings, but you can't answer the simple questions I have put to you. Which of those teams, in those seasons, SHOULD we have finished ahead of?
Cathal Naughton
110 Posted 12/02/2012 at 23:24:08
To all those who say Moyes has squandered money if you take a look at the the http://www.transferleague.co.uk/ website. It states Evertons net spend over the last 9 years sitting 14th in the table of current PL teams, this pretty much incompaces Moyes reign states a net spend of £2 million each year.

Irregardless of the mistakes made when selling on players such as Bily and Yakubu there have been good deals to offset this such as Lescott and McFadden to give just 2.

Take a look at the likes of Bolton and Wolves squads and Everton's, the amounts of money they have pissed have just produced at best two yo-yo teams. I think he has done a great job and it will be a sad day when he leaves.
Mark Stone
111 Posted 13/02/2012 at 00:18:59
PS it's Dr Stone, thanks
Tommy Coleman
112 Posted 13/02/2012 at 00:08:01
Damn, missed a good one.

Mark Stone ? I see you've been busy! I'll ask you though, whats the difference between averaging around 8th to averaging around 13th ? Nothing for me really. The footy has been terrible for both decades apart from some good stuff from Joe's team. I never liked our 'dogs of war' tag though.

You've got to go with the FA Cup win Mark, that's making history, it's what footy is all about, not finishing in the top 10. Moyes sounds too proud of that for me, too content.
Mark Stone
113 Posted 13/02/2012 at 00:40:04
Been on a train since lunchtime Tommy, just got here! Not much else to than Toffeeweb on my iPhone. It's all very well saying average 8th versus average 13th but that doesn't really tell the full story, does it? In nine seasons under Moyes we've finished 4th, 5th (twice), 6th and 7th (twice). So only three times have we finished 8th or lower, and two of those times were very early days.

One major difference there, is reaching Europe several times through league position. But the big thing for me, Tommy, is wondering whether we will qualify for Europe rather than shitting myself about relegation. From a financial perspective, I think there is about £800k per place, so the difference between 13th and 8th would be ~ £4M. For a club losing £5M a year I reckon that is a pretty big deal.

As for the FA Cup 1995, I wouldn't change a thing in hindsight, but it doesn't work like that, does it! The point I was making, FA Cup or not, Everton were better between 2002-2012 than they were 1992-2002.
John Brereton
114 Posted 13/02/2012 at 01:10:34
Jim Knightly = reason. Moyes knows.
Roman Sidey
115 Posted 13/02/2012 at 01:09:02
There it is again! Net fucking spend!

It makes no difference where Moyes gets the money that he squandered. It's still squandered.

Oh, spend £9-10m on an attacking midfielder and never play him in his position to the point that he becomes useless and we have to sell him for half. Doesn't matter, because that was Lescott money so it doesn't count as a transfer. What the hell? It's still £9-10m pound on a player that should have been used a lot more wisely.

I'm not absolving the board, as I've stated that I agree they're the biggest hindrance to the team, but that does not excuse Moyes from bottling it when he's had the opportunity to go on with the job.

For me, the 10-11 season should have been the year that we stepped up, despite only getting Beckford and Gueye in. We showed in the second half of the season what we were capable of. Moyes biggest flaw being that he now struggles to start a campaign let us down.

For those that support Moyes, this season looks to be taking the same route, and if next season repeats this trend, how can you continue to not call for a change?
John Brereton
116 Posted 13/02/2012 at 01:28:41
Roman, every manager in the PL has had bad buys. Look at the results with the resources Moyes gas had - there are very few other managers that would achieve that. From where I am sitting I'll stick with what I know. Any alternative would have a high risk of not doing as well = relegation. I would not be prepared to take that risk.
Roman Sidey
117 Posted 13/02/2012 at 01:33:27
John, I think that is the biggest issue in the separation of the fans. Those that want Moyes to stay, in my view apologies if I'm missing the point), are not prepared to accept the risk of a new manager. Those of us that would rather Moyes do one are fully prepared to risk our status for the possibility of greater success. That is what it all boils down to.

Honestly, I don't think Moyes would win the Premier League if he managed Manchester United. I just don't see it in him. So, gun to your head, if Everton got the investment that Moyes says we may eventually get (how long is his window of acceptance), can you see him taking Everton to the top? I can't, which is why I don't see the point in persisting with him.
Peter Barry
118 Posted 13/02/2012 at 03:25:24
The key word in Delusional Davey's interview was 'investment' and that one word exposes Billy Liar as a well........LIAR. He is not trying to SELL he is searching for the impossible a deluded fool to give HIM lots of money to buy players and a new ground and to leave Billy Liar in charge. That in a nutshell is why Billy's 365/24/7 search has not and will not turn up any solutions.
Mick Davies
119 Posted 13/02/2012 at 03:36:36
Wow! Moyes has made a statement so we should all jump up and wave our rattles around thanking the Lord almighty for bestowing on us such a wonderful strategist.

He said in 2003 "We have to improve every year" and I don't think this has happened. He also said, "The Board back me 100%. If I need a player, they will always come up with the money for me. It's just that there aren't many players available who are better than what we've got" What like Ba, Rodellega, Odemwingie, Graham, N'Zogbia etc.

I for one am sick of his negativity and lack of ambition. He used to be able to motivate players but judging by the Wigan, Bolton, QPR and other crap games against lower sides, it seems he can only do this against the top teams. Which goes to prove the players have the ability, just lack of direction from the likes of Round, Lumsden etc.
Anto Byrne
120 Posted 13/02/2012 at 03:59:06
For the last 10 years, we have played a brand of football that is mostly bland. Creative players are stifled or not played or played out of position.

He had Arteta playing deep a mid role and now he is unrecogonisable playing for Arsenal.

Class players such as Louis Saha who when fit and firing and playing with an attacking partner, ie, Beckford he scores 4 against Blackpool. When asked to lead the line alone and isolated due to Cahill mopping up at the back (and we all saw what a mess he made of a simple clearance off the goalline a few weeks back).

My point is that we should be trying to play attractive football much like Utd Spurs Arsenal and even Man City.

We play a dour unattractive brand of blood sweat and more sweat.

More Moyes, more of the same.

I watched Chelsea tear us apart for a good 35 mins and for some woeful finishing they could have been out of sight by half-time or leading 2-1.

As an Evertonian, I dream of the days when we can have an elegant style of football and compete with the top 6-7 teams who seem to want to play football as opposed to the dire dross we have been served up since Moyes took over 10 years ago.

Everton from 84--89 played classy football since then it's gone down hill. Even Joe Royle's team was called the Dogs of War.
Art Jones
121 Posted 13/02/2012 at 07:12:40
Everton, since Moyes's appointment, have amassed the 6th highest points total in the Premier League, the nett spend of the club is the 14th highest and if you only consider the amount spent, there are 11 teams who have spent more. On every count, over a sustained period of 10 years, he has performed better than he should have.

If you consider that the rug has been pulled from under his feet for the last 2½ years then this is even more remarkable. The 2009 squad, if you include the long-term injured Yakubu, Jagielka and Arteta, only needed to have had a little adjustment and we would now be where Spurs are, challenging for CL football.

The fact that he identified that bringing in Donovan and Pienaar would completely transform the team shows that he knows where the weaknesses are but is unable to afford them. Using the purchase of Bily to beat him up with is just clutching at straws, every manager has bought players that just don't fit: Shevchenko, Veron, Carroll, Torres ? four players whos combined cost would be enough to buy our club, all worthless crabs.

Sadly, the Premier League is more about results than performances nowadays, and Moyes gets results, and has done for 10 years on a meagre budget.
Bob Parrington
122 Posted 13/02/2012 at 07:19:47
Christine Foster #550

Trust the female to tell it as it is! Well done! But I luv this Toffeeweb. It's great that people can give their own views. keep on keepin' on!
COYB
Mark Stone
123 Posted 13/02/2012 at 07:57:11
Roman, the point is if you have to sell to buy you can't build your squad, can you?
Sam Hoare
124 Posted 13/02/2012 at 08:05:50
Roman, you may have a point about Moyes not being the best man if investment did miraculously come in but do you not think he at least would deserve a shot?

Also Ian Edwards, I commend your ability to ignore all the flaws in your arguments that have been pointed out to you, perhaps you didn't want to stay logged on for long in case Ian Smitham tracked you down!
Martin Mason
125 Posted 13/02/2012 at 08:56:25
If EFC were the only club living beyond its means then I'd really criticise EFC. The credit crunch has bought all clubs back to reality though and reality will be a better future for EFC.
Richard Dodd
126 Posted 13/02/2012 at 08:02:17
The best news we could all hear now is that David Moyes has committed to another few years with Everton FC. I know there are those who abhor his `safety-first` approach but only a dreamer would believe that any manager could have done better with the resources at his command.

Sadly, I have come to accept that under the Kenwright regime the Club is going nowhere. Talk of `investment` coming in is a pipe-dream and whilst there may well be a dozen would-be purchasers in Bill`s waiting room, I suspect they may be more of the Venky variety rather than the mega rich Arabs/Russians who have so transformed Man City and Chelsea.

Which brings us back to Moyes. He MAY NOT be the best manager in the Prem... or even the most adventurous... but he has worked miracles to keep Everton amongst the best dozen teams in the land. Given the frustrations he must suffer working within the creeking structure, his rapport, understanding and empathy with Kenwright has done as much to keep the club in business as his ability as a coach has kept his team ultra competitive.

Like many other Evertonians, I fear the day Moyes moves on to leave the present `non-Board` to its own devices. No doubt, Peter Risdale would be on hand to advise and usher another `great Evertonian` like Peter Reid into the hot seat or we might see the better option of seeking continuity with Phil Neville. But the sound judgement and great authority of the Scotsman would be lost to our chairman and I fear the consequences greatly were he left to his own devices.

Get Davey signed up now, Bill!
Derek Thomas
127 Posted 13/02/2012 at 09:53:23
Doddy; An Immensely Freudian slip / Damning with faint praise ramble. Mitigation for the guilty, not defence. Still you're consistant.
Jim Knightley
128 Posted 13/02/2012 at 09:51:55
Roman, yet another one of your posts that ignore the positive spending (we've had this discussion before). Look at my reply to Ian re.his loopsided representation of spending, which he like the previous reply, still ignores. Moyes has spent better than he has made mistakes. EVERY manager makes bad choices, and the best of Russia has failed in this league with respect to Billy. Let me ask you, where do you get the idea that Billy was just a second striker who Moyes put on the left? for me it is the great toffeeweb myth. Billy has played more games on the left than the did in the second striker position.
Roman Sidey
129 Posted 13/02/2012 at 11:00:07
Jim, who said anything about Bily being a second striker? If Doddy hadn't just said what he just said, I'd say that's the craziest post I've seen on Toffeeweb in a while. I'll humour you a little bit though. If a player comes into a new club and says explicitly, "I've never really been a left winger," wouldn't it be a bit idiotic to only ever play them in that position. Don't know what you do for a living, but as a history/English teacher, I'd be pretty cut if a principal hired me, then told me I had to teach senior physics.

Yes, DM has had some success in the transfer market, but when he's had funds (from selling or from the bank), he's proven on two very significant occasions to bugger it up (05 and 09). Occasions that could have seen us kick on to become a regular top four side.

Sam, thanks for actually committing to actually dialoguing with me rather than what some on here do. I don't think "deserves a shot" should be a criteria for a manager though.
Roman Sidey
130 Posted 13/02/2012 at 11:11:26
Also, Jim, using the "lopsided" argument is very hypocritical on this site. Everyone does it, even you. It's how you get through debate, mate. If you can't accept that people with other opinions to you use it too, you shouldn't be on a debating forum.
Alan Clarke
131 Posted 13/02/2012 at 13:17:04
Christine, you're always very good at hitting the nail on the head. I suppose Bill's hope is we don't run out of players to sell because we have some good youth prospects.

I don't think he can claim to be building anything at Everton anymore, not after the way his squad was decimated over the past 3 years. Our best players this year are all loanees so any post-Christmas upturn in form will be undone again in the summer when they're sent back to their clubs and our best players are sold again.

As long as Kenwright is in charge, the future is bleak.

Phil Walling
132 Posted 13/02/2012 at 13:52:15
Doddy: With all the wrong reasoning,you reach the right conclusion.Neither could survive without the other! Kenwright would not know where to turn without his Davey and Moyes realises that only Kenwright would pay him that wedge and ask so little for it!
But `Kenwright Out`is the easy part. Who the hell would want to take on the basket case he`s made of our club?
Jim Knightley
133 Posted 13/02/2012 at 14:20:24
Roman...I don't just lay out arguments whilst ignoring facts. To suggest everyone does it, does not negate a poor arguing style. If I did that as you claim, I would suggest Moyes was a genius, never gets anything wrong etc etc. My support however, as is evident throughout my posts, is based on the belief that Moyes gets more out of us than he should (a belief I take from financial figures). Not that he plays fantastic football, or never makes mistakes.

If you are teacher, then I'm assuming you'd have some knowledge of how to construct an argument? If I write a lopsided paper or submit an article that ignores half the facts, I will suffer for it. Just because people debate on a forum, does not mean they should ignore reality, as you often seem to love to do. If I follow your style of Argument, could I not claim Ferguson was terrible in the transfer market, because he wasted money on Veron, Djemba Djemba, Kleberson, Miller etc...?

Re. Bily, I said second striker, when I meant attacking midfield, ie, the Cahill role (also referred to sometimes as the second striker position, but I should have used CAM). No re. Bily....you are talking bullocks. Bily has played substantially on the left-hand side in his carear, both at club level and for the national team! Now please tell me, where did you get the idea he has never played Left wing? Because I have seen games where he has played for Russia there (and even at left back) so I'm finding your assertions pretty funny.

Thanks for your posts though Roman, they are always good for a laugh.
Jay Harris
134 Posted 13/02/2012 at 14:32:39
May I remind all those that say that history is best forgotten and we should live in the present day and feel lucky to be in the top ten that in 1990 we had more championships than United.

When the Preniership was set up led by Sir Philip Carter EFC was considered one of the big 5!!!

Do not accept less than NSNO.

Leeds were never at our level for more than a few brief years, similarly Nottingham Forest and as for Prtsmouth dont make me laugh.

Similarly both Sheffield clubs.

So all the comparisons with "failed" big clubs is nonsense.

Everton belong in the top four and we as fans should expect and demand that and if Kenwright cant give it to us he needs to pass the baton on.

We do not need an oligarch or billionaire Arab we just need a board with sound business sense which is all Spurs have had for the last few years.

I would urge all fans not to accept the mediocrity that is top 10 because it is better than what we have had in the recent past.

We need to demand top 4 and chances of winning trophies and only the expulsion of Kenwright and cronies will bring that about.
Nate Allen
136 Posted 13/02/2012 at 15:10:48
Moyes is a blessing.
Mark Riding
137 Posted 13/02/2012 at 17:00:55
Mick McCarthy is available now guys !!!

Be afraid... be very afraid.
Andy Hunt
138 Posted 13/02/2012 at 17:16:14
Gutted to see so much anti Moyes sentiment floating about. Yes it is frustrating to see us playing such a negative game so often, but would you rather do a Blackpool - cracking team to watch all the way to relegation.

Moyes has brought stability and created a platform to build upon. I'm sure he is as gutted as anyone that the funds needed to do that building have never been made available to him.

If we lose Moyes we will lose the one thing that has allowed us to come close to competing in the Premier League in recent years. I just can;t see that group of mostly average players performing at the level they have and do now with anyone else at the helm (or at least with the sort of manager we would be likely to attract).
Stephen Kenny
139 Posted 13/02/2012 at 17:23:35
Andy,

What makes you think Everton Football Club who have been in the top flight of English football for well over half a century consecutively would be relegated just because the manager put two forwards on from the start or the midfield were told to pass the ball forward quickly on the fucking floor?

Tottenham also play like Blackpool. Are they looking at relegation? No, they have the player's to play that system and get results. Have we? Maybe, it's impossible to say because we have never really played that way under Moyes.

Stability's great and no-one bar the most myopic will say he's done fuck all for Everton, But the game is about winning trophies. We haven't really had a sniff in a decade. It looked like we may not this decade up to a few weeks ago. Plenty point to European capitulations and defeats at the hands of lowly sides due to Moyes cautious nature as a valid reason. I believe we have under performed in a big way in the cups over Moyes reign.

If Moyes is here for another decade then we will most likely stay in a similar position to the one where in now. A change may be god for us and if that change brings a better style of football the club may benefit through increased gates, sponsors, a cup win and TV time.
Brian Waring
140 Posted 13/02/2012 at 18:07:46
" If Moyes is here for another decade "

Stop it Stephen, your scaring me now, I'll have to sleep with the lights on tonight.
Phil Martin
141 Posted 13/02/2012 at 18:58:31
@720, "Tottenham also play like Blackpool. Are they looking at relegation?"

Err no, but isn't the entire point of this fucking thread is that Tottenham have backed their man big time but Everton havent. Which is why after being close to top 4 and ahead of Spurs, we are now left way back in the distance and it fucking stinks.



Or shall we just enjoy another Moyes bashing session and forget about any semblence of reality.
Mark Riding
142 Posted 13/02/2012 at 19:08:57
#746 Phil.. I hope Blackpool dont play like Spurs in the cup though !
Got me worried now..
Jamie Tulacz
143 Posted 13/02/2012 at 19:15:44
Jay (682)- spot on. It's Kenwright we should be looking at as the problem not Moyes
Danny James
144 Posted 13/02/2012 at 19:20:13
up until the end of 2006-07 season moyes was our 9th most successful manager in terms of win percentage. By end of 2009-10 season he was the 6th . If he were to stay another 5 years i honestly believe that only kendall and catterick will have a greater win percentage than him. Sure he hasnt won a trophy yet but with all the financial restrictions he has had to deal with it seems ludicrous that so many people view him so negatively

it may be that is style is negative and defensive but maybe thats what i takes to ensure so many victories. we didnt complain when it took us to 4th. We didnt complain when it took us to the cup final. We complained when we lost the final

It seems to me that those who appreciate what moyes have done tend to be more consistant than those who object to moyes

If this season we were to win the FA cup with a heroic defensive display it would be interesting to hear people still slate moyes for winning the cup without style. To confirm they would rather see us lose 5-3 with flair than win 1-0 with grit.

I thank god we got moyes when we did because god knows where we would have been without him. He may get it wrong sometimes but he gets it right more often
Joe McMahon
145 Posted 13/02/2012 at 19:39:03
Please everyone stop moaning about Blackpool. Their wage bill was nothing like ours! Ian Holloway got them promoted to the premiership when they were favourites to be relegated. David Moyes would not have achieved this. It is unfair to compare the 2 clubs.
John Crawley
146 Posted 13/02/2012 at 19:37:37
Given the squad at his disposal Holloway did amazingly well to even be in contention to survive on the last day of the season. The style of football he played was the main reason why they were still in contention to survive on the last day. It wasn't the reason they got relegated!!

If Charlie Adam hadn't thrown a strop about not going to Liverpool in the January transfer window they would have survived.

Moyes is a good manager but he is very negative in his play. I don't think you can argue otherwise. The main problem is the board and the way the club is run but I would still like to see a change in the manager. I hope I am wrong but I think David Moyes is simply too negative to win a cup competition.
Dave Wilson
147 Posted 13/02/2012 at 19:26:37
Ian Edwards

What are you talking about lad ?

"I think you`ll find more posters on TW are anti rather than pro Moyes" . . who told you that ?
I bet even Lyndon or Micheal could call than one with any degree of certainty.

Your post 498 was just about the most idiotic I have ever read
"Goodison is full of deluded deluded fans like you Mr Stone and it has kept Moyes in a job for at least 4-5 years"

Now you may have GUESSED right about the number of anti Moyes posters on here, but I`m guessing you are the only one dim enough not to realise that without the fans you call "deluded" you wouldnt even have a club to moan about.

Even More stupid than the post you submitted labling the guys at BU as "Moyes apologist"
Martin Mason
148 Posted 13/02/2012 at 20:15:56
Many forget that we have at times played exceptional football under Moyes but now we now have to survive far more importantly than we have to entertain. Look at Rangers and you will see where EFC could very easily end up.

We beat City the other night, did we do it by waves of attacks with a 4-4-2 formation? No, we did it pragmatically and avoided the hidings that sides have taken attacking them unconditionally (Spurs and United for example)

It is easy to say that we are doing badly as a club. It's just as easy and far more rational to be positive sometimes about how well we actually do. Moyes is rebuilding the side with shrewd loans and purchases and I believe that he is doing a brilliant job. I believe that he will do it too using in the main cheap buys and Everton academy produce. I live on the South coast and am on short leave from working abroad but I'm going to the game on Saturday to give my financial and vocal support to the team that I have supported now for over 50 years. I will not kick them when they are down or support any organisation that will.

COYB
Stephen Kenny
149 Posted 13/02/2012 at 21:16:15
Phil,

That point was in response to an assertion that playing an attacking game means delegation a la Blackpool. With better players it doesn't.
Clive Lewis
150 Posted 13/02/2012 at 21:44:48
Why Moyes will not leave......

Money for nothing
He is I am right in thinking the 3rd or 4th highest paid manager in Prem league.

No really expectations.
If we finish mid table every year until investment he will still keep his job

Big House
erm he is probably got house in Cheshire area.... slippers little furry critters around the house......big garden anyway.

Chaz and Dave
He hates them

People with pointy beards
Tottenham have loads and not many are ginger, he just would not fit in.
Joe Bibb
151 Posted 13/02/2012 at 21:47:52
Just looking at some of the posters on here, took you some time to get here after the Bolton, Stoke, Qpr & Blackburn games... Just Saying.

Ten Years of this boring sod is enough, look around you at Goodison ? there are empty seats everywhere. Yes, the Man City & Chelsea games were good but the rest has been dross: two out of 13 is not a good average.
Ian Edwards
152 Posted 13/02/2012 at 22:04:08
Dave Wilson

I don't think you're in a position to criticise my posts. I think you will find that most people on this site think you are a pro Moyes clown.
Steve Moore
153 Posted 13/02/2012 at 21:56:08
I have to admit I'm a Moyes fan. Here's a couple of questions for those of you who constantly moan, moan, moan.

Why do most pundits say that Moyes is a great manager and constantly praise the job he is doing, if like you, why don't they think he is so bad? We have just beaten Chelsea and City and still you moan, why?

Moyes makes a passionate speech about his undying love and commitment for Everton FC, and you moan, why?

When Moyes finally gets a small amount of money, he brings Donovan on loan, buys Gibson for a steal, buys Jelavic, a prolific goalscorer and brings Pienaar back on loan, A great job, but you moan, why?

We have played some great football in the last 10 years (admittedly some crap also), and have constantly finished in the top 7, and you still moan why?

We have no money, I will repeat this cause some on this site seem never to understand this, WE HAVE NO MONEY, we cannot go out and spend £20 million on a player, get over it move on.

It is widely understood and accepted that with the money available to Moyes he has done an amazing job, but still you guys must be right to moan (forget these football experts, ex-players, people in the know, who disagree with you). If Moyes was to go and we still had no investment we would be fucked, plain and simple.

We are not in the same level as Man Utd, Man City so stop fooling yourselves. We used to be a big club but not anymore but we are still a great club. Hopefully Moyes will get his chance to spend, spend, spend, and we win something, but if he doesn't and if we don't he will still go down as one of the best Everton managers of all time.
Peter Bourke
154 Posted 13/02/2012 at 22:10:56
Ian, Dave is in as good a position as anyone to criticise your posts. I wouldn't be so quick to make broad statements assuming what most people think.
Let us hear your opinion which you are entitled to and let others have theirs.
Ian Smitham
155 Posted 13/02/2012 at 22:19:46
Jay #682, Nottingham Forest ? As I recall it, there was a period when they and Liverpool dominated not only the league in England, but also Europe.

I know we have had a short period in the Mid eighties when we were good, and I started going to Goodison in 1969 when we were good, as I recall for a short period.

Some will recall other periods we have enjoyed but most will have suffered many years of great disappointment, more of those years than the good ones, sadly.

So, my point, a Nottingham Forest supporter browsing on here may make the same point about Everton not being "at our level" as they did win the European Cup twice on the run.

Just a thought, but I am not sure we have a right to think we are the best though I for one will support us in the hope that one day we will be.
John Brereton
156 Posted 13/02/2012 at 22:01:12
I have been logging on to toffee web for I don't know how long. It is a joy to realise I am not alone. There are other realists out there. COYB!
Ian Smitham
157 Posted 13/02/2012 at 22:57:43
Mr Edwards, I quote you "I stand by my comment about Moyes supporters being deluded... and if that really offends you Mr Smitham then you need to get a life and get out more", and I stand by my comments . These were "Before I explore the comments that you make, please may ask you to let me know if you go to the game and if not how you "suuport" the club. Then also, Sir, just tell me how I am deluded supporting the club I have for a number of years, thick and thin,"

Not satisfied with being so offensive, you have added "Mr Smitham... you obviously want a fight which speaks volumes for your neanderthal mentality"

Thank you for that further insult.

I have noted your attitude to others, most recently,
"I don't think you're in a position to criticise my posts. I think you will find that most people on this site think you are a pro Moyes clown"..

I am sure that many agree with me (obviously!!!) and also disagree with me, but I try to conduct my discussions on here in a positive and constructive manner. Namecalling is not for me.

My enquiries regarding your attending the games remains unsloved, I do not believe that you have responded aside from the 9,000 comment (was the attendance at that game 90,000 or 9,000 as so many claim they were there?) (I was not).

I believe that you have evaded answers, as you appear to do to most that query your ramblings, and in making your "neanderthal" comment. As I said, for someone with so many opinions, posted with such passion, I have assumed that you actually go to the game (Sorry Ciaron) and I have simply challenged you to discuss your passionate views with me, including the "delusion" remark. Now extended to the other vitriol.

In conclusion, I will be at the games and in the Winslow before them. I will even get the first beer in, so, as i put it earlier, "Time to stand up or shut up, you choose." from post 520.

For those reading this, please remeber Ian made the "delusioned" comments about me and others that go to the game and all I have done is challenge him to discuss his proposition.

Once again sorry to ramble, but some on here need thier views and insults challenging and Ii propose that Mr Ian Edwards is one that fits that category well

If this gets past the censor then may I add that I thank you all for reading it
Ste Traverse
158 Posted 13/02/2012 at 23:51:17
"My chairman Bill Kenwright will need investment to make that happen and he is out there looking for it".


FFS how many more times do we have to hear Kenshite is looking for investment? We've been hearing this same soundbite over and over and over for the last 12 fucking years!!

The fact no-one has come forward to fund Kenwright's regime 12 years down the line speaks volumes.

It's not going to happen and never will so keep dreaming Moyes.
Roman Sidey
161 Posted 14/02/2012 at 03:51:21
Steve Moore, you asked questions, so you deserve answers. These are by no way shape or form meant to be antagonistic or aggressive, but just the opinions of one fan who is sick of Moyes.

1. Most pundits aren?t emotionally invested like the fans are, and the only time they have anything at length to say about Everton is when we happen to beat a good side. Where are they when we lose to Bolton, QPR, Stoke?

2. Since holding the club to ransom in 2008, his love for the club is questionable. We moan about his commitment because we no longer want him here.

3. For all the good work he?s done, he wastes, valuable money bringing charity cases in such as McFadden and Hahnemann. Why?

4. We have played a lot of shite football as well. We moan that we?ve finished in the top 7 so many times yet we have nothing to show for it. We?ve had at least two clear cut opportunities to kick on as a team and push for Champions League football, and poor management has been to blame for missing both.

5. Moyes has known that we?ve been a selling club for a long time. Sell to buy, yet he has passed up offers from other clubs to sell players that have been on the slide. Some of these players he?s then sold for a nominal fee after they?ve contributed nothing to the team for too long. He cries poor, yet he knew the situation and did nothing about it.

6. We might not be fucked if someone else was manager.

7. We certainly aren?t as big as the Manchesters, and playing it safe against the bottom sides in the league is the best way to ram that one home.
Dave Wilson
162 Posted 14/02/2012 at 10:06:25
Ian Edwards

And I think YOU`LL find that the matchgoers will view you as some sort ot idiot.

You and the rest of the " I wont watch this shite" Brigade make me laugh.
You listen to the result on Radio Merseyside and then come on here spouting your "expert" opinion.

People all over the world would give their right arm to be able to get to the match, but cant, YOU on the other hand wont.

Your right though, Everton dont need any more deluded fans going to Goodison.
What they REALLY need is a few more thousand of you none contributing malcontents . .that`ll get them into the Champions league.

Dont suppose you`ll be turning up at the next BU meeting and telling them all their just a bunch of apologist ? . .Na peeople who want to induldge in childish namecalling from anonymity of their Keyboard ALWAYS turn out to be two bob
Carl Sanderson
164 Posted 14/02/2012 at 12:19:47
Without Moyes we would have been relegated a long time ago. If he does go to Spurs or anywhere else I will genuinely fear for Everton's future. (Rarely do I post on here but some of the stuff in this thread drew me out of lurkdom.)
Ste Traverse
165 Posted 14/02/2012 at 12:34:08
How do you actually know without Moyes we'd have been relegated a long time ago Carl?

Got a crystal ball?
Colin Southern
166 Posted 14/02/2012 at 12:39:06
Roman, thats conjecture about Moyes holding out for more money. Both Kenwright and Moyes have said it was about control over team affairs and players being brought in.

The last thing you want is the Board or Chairman pissing about with team selection. Look at Chelsea, they have had some of the best managers in the world and then Abramovich starts to interfere and it all goes tits up.
Carl Sanderson
167 Posted 14/02/2012 at 14:23:58
Ste #923 I wish I was as funny as you. Idiot.
Brian Waring
168 Posted 14/02/2012 at 14:29:09
Carl, but Ste is right, how do you know we would have been relegated a long time ago without Moyes?

Carl Sanderson
169 Posted 14/02/2012 at 15:30:15
Brian, Ste is not right and neither are you. Neither am I for that matter, or not necessarily. This is a forum for debate, an arena for the expression of opinion. We are not testifying under oath. Post 916 was my opinion, nothing more. Ste's unnecessary rejoinder was about as humorous as a cold-sore, yet it serves to remind me why I lurked for so many years.
Stephen Kenny
170 Posted 14/02/2012 at 17:21:34
Carl,

Probably best to go back to it if your calling people idiots just because they disagree with you.
Ian Smitham
171 Posted 14/02/2012 at 20:11:55
Mr Dave Wilson, I know that there are a few on here who disagree with you about various matters, and Ciaron, I am not banging a drum this time, honest, but I note your input to this thread with interest and also that Mr Edwards has not answered recently to my comments.

Ian, I take it that you will respond.

Dave, your comments are a bit more direct than mine, albeit in the same direction, care needs to be exercised as next minute you may well be called a "neandethal".

Enough for now, tick tock tick tock Ian
Dave Wilson
172 Posted 14/02/2012 at 20:24:21
Ian.

I wasnt for one minute suggesting anyone from Blue
Union would be violent towards Mr Edwards if he turned up at the next meeting accusing them all of being apologists.

I think one or two may have a little chuckle at his expense though.
Martin Mason
173 Posted 14/02/2012 at 20:30:58
Remember guys, as soon as you insult somebody you've shown one of two things; you've either lost the argument or you don't have the intelligence to be in it anyway or both. This is a board where opinion is expressed and as long as there's some justification for the opinion then it's as good as anybody's. We have to remember though that despite what some think, opinion isn't fact.
David Johnson
174 Posted 14/02/2012 at 20:38:11
Moyes is an extremely good manager but his backing of Kenwright is unforgivable and for that reason and that reason alone I want to see the back of him too. Kenwright has been on the board since 1989 ?
Phil Walling
175 Posted 14/02/2012 at 20:49:44
.....and what would he list as his greatest achievement?
Richard Dodd
176 Posted 14/02/2012 at 20:56:07
Securing and retaining the services of David Moyes!!!
Nick Entwistle
177 Posted 14/02/2012 at 21:05:25
David, do you really expect him to criticise the one man who can take away his 10 years of toil and effort at the club?

Phil, tell me which of his fellow managers he's come up against have proven themselves better and you realise the list is very small.

Forget the Sky 4 and City for a moment, the only managers to 'achieve' during Moyes' tenure are Redknapp, McClaren, McLeish, Ramos, and Souness. Take your pick.
Ian Smitham
178 Posted 14/02/2012 at 21:15:36
Dave, I meant the three paragraphs starting with the one you started with "Yo and the" were the ones I agreed with.

Mr Martin Mason, I agree entirely which is why I object to an individual calling me "deluded" and then later a "neanderthal". I support the club in the way I do and I believe it to be right. (Imay be wrong) but I am not going to stand for someone making those comments and stand aside without response.

I will challenge objectively those i do not agree with, and expect to be challenged in the same way, but not in the way that a certain individual has done.

A simple retraction or even apology will do but till then....
Gavin Ramejkis
179 Posted 14/02/2012 at 20:39:20
Steve #803 a little melodramatic getting Gibson for a "steal" as I didn't realise Everton were in competition for his signature from any other team. If he works out then fair play but he hasn't won me over yet.

Carl #916 if you want to make a statement then counter later saying its your opinion then before you post it worded like fact add the "I personally believe" or "I think" or "we may have" that will remove any retort you are lining yourself up for asking about your crystal ball.
Carl Sanderson
180 Posted 14/02/2012 at 23:51:35
Steven (985):

Read the posts again, please. It was not for disagreeing with me. It was for the smart-arse reply to my first post in years. Anyway, it's back to lurk-mode for me.
Steve Moore
181 Posted 15/02/2012 at 00:41:11
Thanks for the answer Roman, I disagree but hey that's the point of this question/questions. I for one worry for the day we lose Moyes and I rate him very highly, like most football commentators and so called experts.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads