Jagielka & Osman getting close

, 16 February, 56comments  |  Jump to most recent
But they are still a few weeks away...
Phil Jagielka and Leon Osman are getting closer to a return to full fitness after sidelined by injuries for the past few weeks. Jagielka damaged his medial knee ligaments against Bolton back on January 4th and has not played since, but he is expected to return within the next two to three weeks. That is the same time as midfielder Leon Osman who has had a minor operation to remove some floating bone in his knee and he too is expected to return within the same time scale.

Quotes or other material sourced from Setanta



Reader Comments (56)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Brian Waring
1 Posted 16/02/2012 at 15:44:33
Do they walk straight back into the team as Moyes's favourites?
Mike Gaynes
2 Posted 16/02/2012 at 16:10:56
No, they walk back in as the best choices. Jags is still a better player than Heitinga, and Osman is better than Gibson.
Andrew Ellams
3 Posted 16/02/2012 at 16:13:20
Mike, Heitinga has been awesome over the past few games. To bring Jagielka straight back would be madness and potentially moralising for the rest of the squad. And whilst Gibson is the not the worlds most spectacular player his presence has obviously brought some sort of balance to the team.

If it ain't broke, don't fix it. And also Mr Moyes please do not bring Osman back to fill the gap left by Landon Donavon.
Ben Jones
4 Posted 16/02/2012 at 16:14:43
Mike, based on form, Heitinga over Jags all day for me. Jags hasn't had the best season at all.
David Chait
5 Posted 16/02/2012 at 16:16:34
Yes lets bring Jags back together with Distin and revert to shipping stupid goals game after game... That partnership has me tearing my hair out!

Heitinga for me all day long. For me its Moyes being Moyes that keeps him out.
James Martin
6 Posted 16/02/2012 at 16:16:48
Heitinga deserves his spot because Jagielka's form was terrible before he got injured, indeed he's never really regained his pace or confidence since he did his cruciate. Osman is probably our most creative central midfielder and as we struggle to create chances he has to come back in if he can recapture top form.
David Barks
7 Posted 16/02/2012 at 16:13:47
Jags is better than Heitinga? We've been keeping clean sheets against the likes of City and Chelsea with Heitinga in the team. Heitinga has been playing superbly whether partnered with a 20 year old making his debut or Distin coming back from injury. Heitinga has been acting as a leader on the pitch, both vocally and by the example he has set.

He's taken the chance he's been waiting for, to get a run in the center of defense, and he has been superb. He takes the opportunity to sprint forward and join in the attack, as well as occasionally bring the ball forward himself. Jags was below par this season, he admitted so himself after the transfer rumors over the summer. I hope Heitinga retains his spot and in my opinion if Neville isn't on the pitch Heitinga should be the captain.

As for Osman, when Donovan leaves I'm sure Moyes will put him on the right. I don't want to see this happen, but I'm sure that it will. I'd much rather have him in the middle with Fellaini and Gibson, with Fellaini and Osman taking turns getting forward to support the striker. Osman is much better with the ball at his feet than Cahill and I think he'd actually work quite well up front with Pienaar and Baines getting forward on the left. But he'll be on the right.
Mike Hayes
8 Posted 16/02/2012 at 16:10:11
Like them both play well when they are in the side, but when Jags hoofs the ball up the field its frustrating. I'd say they were guaranteed a starting place unless we remain unbeaten by the time both return.
Andrew Ellams
9 Posted 16/02/2012 at 16:28:09
Mike H, as Blackpool is our last game until 3rd March I hope we will be unbeaten for a couple more weeks yet
Jamie Barlow
10 Posted 16/02/2012 at 16:39:02
I watched an interview with Jags yesterday and he fully accepts he will be kept out of the team by the lads who are in now.
Sam Hoare
11 Posted 16/02/2012 at 17:24:34
Would like to see Osman when fit playing in the Cahill role. Think he offers so much more penetration and guile than Tiny tim.

Jags will have to wait i think. Heitinga has earned a run in the team.

What i fear is Jags going back into CB and then playing Heitinga in CM. Please no.
Bob Willis
12 Posted 16/02/2012 at 17:42:34
Johnny deserves to keep his place and Duffy is the future - sell Jags and run down the bank.
Mike Gaynes
13 Posted 16/02/2012 at 17:38:52
OK, fair enough on Jags. I still think he's a better player, but agreed Heitinga has earned his run.

As to Osman, I don't see him in the Cahill role at all... and I don't think Moyes does either. Coleman should be back in the side or at least on the bench this weekend, and I wouldn't expect Moyes to bump him and/or Drenthe for Osman. That leaves only one spot for Osman -- and that's Gibson's.

I saw one poster say Fellaini is reaching his peak with Gibson beside him, and that's a good point, but Gibson was also inarguably our weakest player against Chelsea. So I still think that if Ozzie is ready to go March 3, Moyes will slot him in for Gibson.
James Stewart
14 Posted 16/02/2012 at 17:47:37
Osman is welcome back. Better than Gibson. There is no way on earth Jags is better than Heitinga though.
Mike Gaynes
15 Posted 16/02/2012 at 17:52:17
Bob, I don't think so. Heitinga has never committed his future to Everton, Distin is 34, and we've only seen Duffy for a couple of games. Remember, Moyes didn't think Duffy was ready for City and transplanted Hibbert to CB instead. I think selling Jags would be premature.
James Morgan
16 Posted 16/02/2012 at 17:44:12
Heitinga all day for me, Jags cant pass a ball shorter than 30 yards. I don't think Moyes will drop Gibson as it seems he does the water carrying that lets Fellaini play. If we see Neville or Heitinga in midfield again with the depth we have then the men in white jackets need to come for Moyes.
To be fair I'd rather Osman and Cahill sit on the bench and have another striker playing instead and Drenthe should be on the right, he just needs to learn how to keep the ball better.
Sam Hoare
17 Posted 16/02/2012 at 17:54:04
I don't think Osman has the positional sense to play Gibson's role in CM. Its no coincidence that since Gibson's arrival we have looked more solid at the back and also seen the best of Fella.

Mike- do you not think Ossie, with his shooting ability, quick feet, good touch and good footballing brain is best suited to the Cahill role. Its was his playing there last season that coincided with our considerable upturn in form.
Bob Willis
18 Posted 16/02/2012 at 17:49:43
Gibson our weakest player - why would you say that? He plays a quiet game yes, but what does he do wrong.?

The team have arguably been 10X better with him than before he arrived.

It's a TEAM game.
Mike Gaynes
19 Posted 16/02/2012 at 17:56:15
James, I'm basing my Jags/Johnny opinion on the past three years, not the past three games.
Andrew Ellams
20 Posted 16/02/2012 at 17:59:20
People seem to have a downer on Gibson because he doesn't go on long mazy runs beating 6 players. He is not Ronaldo or Messi, even they have grafters in their teams that do the quiet donkey work that allows the creative players more attacking freedom.
Steve Guy
21 Posted 16/02/2012 at 17:59:20
Osman in for Cahill. Jags needs to wait; it's no coincidence we've looked better at the back and are unbeaten in the last 6 without him. Gibson should not be dropped, he's the water carrier in the team and does the simple things that allow others to play better (Fellaini in particular).
Mike Gaynes
22 Posted 16/02/2012 at 18:23:41
I'm not down on Gibson at all. I just think Osman does the donkey-water carrier stuff as well as Gibson, and offers far more creativity going forward. I think the Cahill role requires a physical aggression that Osman lacks, and I don't think Osman has been effective in that role when he has played it. So I stand by my prediction.
Keith Glazzard
23 Posted 16/02/2012 at 18:15:43
Johnny and Jags - the point is that we have two of the best central defenders playing in this country, and possibly further abroad. We are blessed - and having Distin plus Duffy makes this by far our strongest position in any depth. We have to keep them all, fit and raring to go.

Leon won't walk straight back in, but he has a lot to offer. He is, as has been said, a skillful, creative player, and he should be able to play in front of a well set-up defence. I hope he will be seen as another option in an increasingly varied attack.
Steven Bennett
24 Posted 16/02/2012 at 19:12:18
shut up mike you haven't got an igloo
Mike Gaynes
25 Posted 16/02/2012 at 19:25:00
"Haven't got an igloo"??

Sorry, need a translation on that one. I assume it's not complimentary. Pretty funny, though.
Ciarán McGlone
26 Posted 16/02/2012 at 19:29:11
Osman in the deep lying midfield role?

Aye, I'm sure that'll work.
Luke O'Farrell
27 Posted 16/02/2012 at 19:36:11
Osman isn't good enough defensively or strong enough on the ball to play CM. His best role is the 'Cahill' position and it always has been.

Gibson, as someone said earlier, does a lot of the donkey work and it allows Fellaini to focus on his own game. Don't understand those who say Gibson can't pass; he's better than the team average in all passing areas.

How many matches have we had, this season, were Fellaini has been alongside Neville or Heitinga and had to do their work; forward and back. He used to look out on his feet, just after half time, due to the work he had to get through.

Heitinga has more than earned his place now. He should be our first choice CB on current form.

Jagielka is a good defender but his distribution means I'd bench him every time. His lack of composure often creates panic and leads to mistakes. He's overrated badly by the clueless media, most of them only rate him due to him being English.
Phil Walling
28 Posted 16/02/2012 at 19:45:06
IMO Osman has had some great games in the Cahill role and this season has been better there than Tim.
Martin Mason
29 Posted 16/02/2012 at 19:52:35
One things that great managers do is never change a winning team. It will be very interesting to see what DM does. If he puts Jags and Leon straight back in it will brand him as incompetent forever. OK, they have to cater for the loss of LD in midfield but it doesn't automatically have to be Osman when we have Barkley and Rodwell too. Surely though only Coleman can replace Donovan on the right?
Keith Glazzard
30 Posted 16/02/2012 at 19:53:15
Luke - the media may be clueless, but 30,000+ Evertonians know what Jags has been doing for us game after game. Yes, his distribution is poor - only Heitinga's is better from the back. But like Heitinga, he is a classy defender who reads the game and covers for everone else, particularly Distin, by far the biggest cause of panic at the back.
Dave Wilson
31 Posted 16/02/2012 at 20:18:35
I wrote an article on here about two years ago suggesting we sell Jags. I still take stick for it now, so I aint saying a word about him,

I will say I welcome Ossies return though, not the strongest player in the world, but he`s the most intelligent we`ve got.
Luke O'Farrell
32 Posted 16/02/2012 at 20:26:16
Keith

He may have been good in the past but this season, he has been abysmal. He had a few better games just before his injury.

Don't buy into the Distin panic nonsense. He's often the one saving the day, he has great recovery pace and is spot on in the air.

Jagielka often appears heroic, however it is often when recovering his own initial error. I rate him defensively but his distribution should relegate him to the bench.

Jagielka and Distin don't work as a partnership either, they always concede soft goals. We've looked at our best, this season, with Heitinga at the back. That leaves a choice between Distin and Jags, it would be Distin for me; every time.

Heitinga and Distin work best together, on that basis alone, they should be first choice.
Tom Bowers
33 Posted 16/02/2012 at 20:46:38
For all you Osman lovers,sorry but no thanks.
Give me Coleman,Barklay or Gibson but please no more of the anemic tackling or challenging that Osman brings. Yes he scores once in a blue moon but so does Cahill these days and that is not enough for a regular place.
Arthur Westhead
34 Posted 16/02/2012 at 20:57:11
It's no coincidence that suddenly with Heitinga and Gibson in the team, in their correct positions (Moyes forced into that by injuries to others!) we beat City and Chelsea.

Only a few weeks earlier, with Jags and Ossie in the team, we were dreadful at the back and non-existent going forward.

Early days yet, but Gibson looks to be the best partner Fellaini has had beside him. And that includes Arteta. Fellaini can now play further forward with Gibson behind, rather than defending. Playing to his strengths.
Ciarán McGlone
35 Posted 16/02/2012 at 21:58:19
Dave,

Totally agreed with your article on Jags then and still agree now.

Although I'd suggest Drenthe is head and shoulders above anyone else in our team in terms of footballing intelligence.
Andy Morden
36 Posted 16/02/2012 at 23:05:28
We don't miss Jagielka. We've kept clean sheets and got some impressive wins without him. Bench warming it is, Why disrupt a team finally showing some form?
Richie Whyte
37 Posted 17/02/2012 at 00:42:16
I think some people on here are forgetting the fact that when we we were churning out muck that jags was the only one who looked as if he believed in the crest when no other f*cker wanted it....thtas right Bob Willis sell jags...my arse..we'd be fools to do it..johnny isnt solid..dont be fooled by a few games of grit
Peter Barry
38 Posted 17/02/2012 at 03:08:27
Jags might be a fairly competent defender but his constant hoofing just gives the ball back to the opposition which allows them to attack again so a more level headed defender such as Heitinga who can pass out to an Everton player is the better option. I am still undecided about Gibson he does go on anonymous walk about in games sometimes you dont even know he is on the pitch.
Russell Buckley
39 Posted 17/02/2012 at 04:52:44
I personally prefer Heitinga and Distin over Jags. Jags hasn't hit the same level he achieved before his knee.

Heitinga and Distin have both out played him this season but we also need to factor in the fact that Distin is not the future.



I'd let Osman share Cahill's duties for now.
Iven Biedermann
40 Posted 17/02/2012 at 06:19:46
Hello mates! I think Jags should be our first CB without a doubt, but who should patner him?

I think JH.
Anto Byrne
41 Posted 17/02/2012 at 08:09:07
Jags back in with Distin; JH to midfield, with Neville in the hole behind the Strac. You know it makes sense. And we need as many defenders behind the ball as possible. 7 points to safety FFS. 7 draws will do it for me. Jags is the right man with his defence-splitting passes on to the head of Fellaini and The Strac.

Nothing more I like to see than a 50/60-yard pinpointed pass from the Jags a simple nod down from the Strac to Fellaini to volley into the top corner from just out side the box. Roy of the Rovers Stuff this. I love David Moyes ? the best fucking manager in the world.
Brian Waring
42 Posted 17/02/2012 at 10:27:36
Find myself agreeing with Dave here on Osman.
James Martin
43 Posted 17/02/2012 at 10:49:11
Tom Bowers 'Osman scores once in a blue moon'? He's probably been our most consisten goal scoring midfielder the last few years when he's been fit. Crucially he tends to score in those period when we are playing absolutely crap and he wins us points. How many would we have now if it wasn't for his form earlier in the season? How many points did he gain for us at the back end of last season?

I'd rather watch Osman's 'anemic' tackling and his skill and vision on the ball rather than Fellaini just running into people, half falling over, giving away constant free kicks, and then when he does appear with the ball, slowing the game down to a standstill before passing backwards.
John Keating
44 Posted 17/02/2012 at 11:07:24
Heitinga or Jags with Distin? Could we not keep the three happy??

Jagielka's courage is indisputable, putting his body in the way every time. Let's be honest, if he was that shit, he wouldn't be an England international.

Heitinga is playing better every week and showing true leadership qualities.

Distin, regardless of his age is commanding in the air and still has terrific pace.

I've always had my doubts about Jags and Heitinga as a combined central pairing being susceptable to high balls from corners, free kicks etc. Would it not be possible to play Jags and Heitinga in central defence and play Distin left back?

Put Baines on the left of midfield. Pienaar moves over to the right of midfield covering Hibbert/Neville/Coleman. Distin's height and power would still be there at all deadball plays and Heitinga and Jags both play in their best and preferred positions.
Stephen Kenny
45 Posted 17/02/2012 at 11:37:26
Find some of the comments directed at Osman quite Bizzare. For almost the second half of last season and a good spell of this he was our only genuine attacking outlet. Him and Baines have until recently carried the burden of creating for lazy forwards and plodding midfielders.

IMO the standard of football will go up tenfold with Leon in Cahill's position. BTW, when was a playmaker required to have 'aggression'? Surely a decent shot, eye for a pass and ability to go past someone all rate higher as requirements than aggression?

Dave,

Like Ciaran, I agreed with the article then and I'd agree if you posted it again tommorow.

Duffy has shown enough promise for me to hope than he will establish himself over the next twelve months as a regular. He doesn't have the experience to simply oust Jags at this point but we're well covered in that area anyway. Jags staying at Everton will IMO hinder his progress.

Gibson's presence has seen Fellaini pressing the ball 10-15 yards further up the pitch than he normally does. This means, when we win it, we are straight on the attack. While I don't rate Gibson at this point, I do rate the change of dimension his presence has brought and I like to think we will carry on in this vein.
Sam Hoare
46 Posted 17/02/2012 at 11:54:04
Stephen, agree with you about Osman. If people want us to play better football then replace Cahill with Osman and watch the difference if the ball gets played into his feet...which with Pienaar back it will.

Peter Warren
47 Posted 17/02/2012 at 11:51:04
Defence not leaking goals, keep it as it is. Only question is whether to play Hibbert or Neville at full back. Please play Jelavic up front with Strac
Roman Sidey
48 Posted 17/02/2012 at 12:34:32
"Let's be honest, if he was that shit, he wouldn't be an England international."

Made me chuckle, John Keating.

Dave Wilson, if I had read Toffeeweb 2 years ago I also would have backed your article regarding Jags. If another offer came in for him this summer for anything north of about 7mil, we'd be crazy not to take it and stuff it in the bank.

Distin is probably going to be able to play for another few years - some players just can. Look at the guy, he's a picture of health and fitness.

As has been said a few times and is gathering pace; make Johhny captain and get him to sign on for another few years. He said he wanted to end his career at Ajax, so, at 29, I'm guessing he's got at least 3-4 years before he needs to head back there.

Osman, use him, but by no means does he need to be in the side every week. Play him against the lower sides in the league and he'll get the job done. Against the top sides, he needs to be watching from the stands, as better teams have always been able to kick him around.

All that aside, everyone knows what will happen when Jags is fit at least. Back to the old pairing of Jags and Distin, with JH either in the midfield, or warming the bench. Sadly, when this does happen, I think we can start getting used to seeing Johnny playing for a very good club that isn't Everton.
Keith Glazzard
49 Posted 17/02/2012 at 19:25:13
In all of this one thing is clear. Johnny Heitinga is world class, and should be kept in his best position. What happens around him is up to the boss. And his problem, as we know, is that he will use good players out of position.

But Heitinga never looks happier than when he is playing well at the back and then coming round the crowd to thank us for the support - he should be a very big player for us for a few years yet.
Joe McMahon
50 Posted 17/02/2012 at 19:42:22
As has been siad, how about no Cahill role, and actually playing 2 strikers. I Don't think one goal since Dec 2010 justifys a Cahill role anymore.
Bob Willis
51 Posted 17/02/2012 at 21:45:59
Anto Byrne 511 - Classic mate, made me laugh! Neville in the hole!! Jags defence-splitting passes!!. FFS.
Bob Willis
52 Posted 17/02/2012 at 23:55:17
RW 490 said - 'sell jags...my arse..we'd be fools to do it..johnny isnt solid..dont be fooled by a few games of grit'

I sit in the stands and hear dozens of opinions every game - your is another - an opinion, just like mine!
Ian Smitham
53 Posted 18/02/2012 at 00:06:04
Luke I agree with you, JH and SD at CB. Roman, I have to agree with you, though I have ben saying it since he "on the job" coached Duffy, JH for Captain.

Mr Wilson, I have also written on here for a while, sell Jags, nothing against what looks to me to be an honest pro, but one we can cash in on as we need to, but for £7mill, no sir, we need double that.

My slight worry is that I have written on here a number of times saying that Fella and jack is the future, and though I am not sure of Gibson, anyone who has seen Fella over the past few games can not have noticed how he has been the player we would have all hoped he would be. So from my MF/JR being the future now I am not so certain, which is why I do what I do and Moyes does what he does




Roberto Birquet
54 Posted 18/02/2012 at 00:24:09
Mr Barks, are you from Ohio?
....the center of defense
Ian Smitham
55 Posted 18/02/2012 at 00:26:26
Bob #653, I guess you do not sit where I do, so what opinions do you hear please?
Bob Willis
56 Posted 18/02/2012 at 08:39:07
Ian 657 - No idea where you sit, nor does it matter.
How about Moyes is shite, Kenwright out,
Neville is shite, Cahill is past it, Howard is shite, Anichebe is shite, Saha was shite, Straqu was shite now brilliant,
Fellini is sometimes shite mainly brilliant,Darren is shite, Osman is shite but has a brain. - Oh yes the pies are overcooked - the Chang is too cold.

Unless you are deaf or pretend to be there are 'experts' all around you mate telling all and sundry what to do and giving their 'opinions'.

I'll be there today listening to yet more 'opinions' most of which I completely disagree with but boy do they make you laugh - just listening to them.

Oh by the way I will not be in my usual seat - it been given to the away lot - so it will be interesting to hear their opinions as well!

Having seen Jags 'hoofing' and Johnny's passing I know which one I'd keep.

I also know that for £12M I'd get rid in the close season. Just opinions mind, not really in a position to influence anything.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads