Big clubs will come sniffing for Moyes

, 19 February, 90comments  |  Jump to most recent
Fans Liaison Officer, Graeme Sharp has told TalkSport it is only a matter of time until a big club comes sniffing for Everton boss David Moyes. Speculation surrounding Moyes's future is something the Blues will have to become used to, due to Moyes's relative success at Goodison.

?David has been at Everton ten years now and while some people may look at him and think he hasn't won anything, what he has achieved has been fantastic,? Sharp told The Weekend Sports Breakfast.

?You look at the finishes he has had in the Premier League and he has given us an FA Cup final. He has been punching above his weight. ?Obviously there is the Harry Redknapp situation at Tottenham. David has been mentioned there and that is always a worry.

?Everton can't compete with the big boys financially nowadays so there may be a possibility that he could be lured to a top-six club but it is something we just have to get on with.

?We just want to enjoy what he is doing at Everton at the moment but we can't put away the fact that the big boys will come sniffing eventually.?

Quotes or other material sourced from TalkSport



Reader Comments (90)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Kevin Elliott
1 Posted 19/02/2012 at 18:00:05
God ,i hope you're right Sharpy.
In my humble opinion i honestly think that with a bit of positive thinking by a positive thinking manager(not dour Davey) and we would be at least nine points better off than we are today.
OK so we made some good signings in the transfer window .But was that nothing to do with our scouts?
Getting Pienar back is farcical ,Why did we sell him for peanuts(no pun intended) in the first place.If we buy him back for say five million then that is one of the worst pieces of buisness that i have ever witnessed.Moyes is shit. The sooner he goes the better.Even if we win the cup.
Yusuf Bobat
2 Posted 19/02/2012 at 18:30:08
What succesfull management style?
Eric Myles
3 Posted 19/02/2012 at 18:30:26
We had to sell Pienaar because he would have walked for free 6 months later.
Ian McDowell
4 Posted 19/02/2012 at 18:32:51
Redknapp to England? Moyes to Spurs? Who for Everton???
Kevin Elliott
5 Posted 19/02/2012 at 18:40:26
Eric.
not if we had given him the raise in pay that he requested.And that we will have to pay if we keep him.
Ian . Paul Lambert.
Colin Southern
6 Posted 19/02/2012 at 18:22:40
Only a fool can't see how this club has progressed since Moyes took over. And before you say it, yes he can fuck up just like everyone other manager in the league ? Wenger anyone?

Beforehand we were heading down and out each season as we were shite. We still are a basket-case Premier League club but at least we have got our pride back which was in short supply as I used to be ashamed to say I supported us as we were an absolute laughing stock.

I've supported this club for 40 years and have seen the good sides and the bad sides... The side that Walter put together was the worst side I've ever seen in a blue shirt. I was at the cup game when Tranmere tanked us 3 - 0 and that was such a low, we had Campbell and Ferguson upfront... god we were so bad, I just knew it wasn't long before our derby days would be playing THEM in the Championship.

Give credit where its due, Moyes has put Everton back on the map, listen to the other teams saying they hate playing us, it's only down to money that we can't make the next level. This great club of ours is goosed and is teetering on the brink but I think Moyes has single handedley kept our heads up. People accuse Moyes of being defensive but has anyone considered that even the top 4 Prem teams play that way and with the same formation.
Martin Mason
7 Posted 19/02/2012 at 18:48:44
It's easy for people who know little about team coaching to criticise Moyes for some of the apparently bizarre tactical and selection moves Moyes makes. Look though at the team he has quietly put together now which is doing so well and who are a rag bag of loanees, cheap purchases, Everton academy output and players who are undoubtedly past their sell by date. He drives me mad sometimes with what I see as his bizarre tactics but he has forgotten more about managing a side than I'll ever know and sometimes I recognise that as a selector of good buys and getting the most from a weak squad he has few equals. The early season form thing is baffling.
Phil Walling
8 Posted 19/02/2012 at 18:52:29
Expect Kenwright to leak that negotiations are ongoing over new £4M contract for the Moyestro ere long!
He`d be a gonner without his soulmate!
Barry Rathbone
9 Posted 19/02/2012 at 18:38:38
The one thing about Moyes is he's not damaged goods, he doesn't cause trouble and according to some he's a miracle worker.

Management talent at the top is getting thinner, particularly young talent, after Mourinho and Guardiola where do you go?

As Wolves are finding the domestic managerial carousel is full of the same tired old Steve Bruces, under such circumstances I could easily see a chairman making a case for him.

Be a 6 month wonder IMO.
Andy Crooks
10 Posted 19/02/2012 at 18:56:35
Man U, Man C, Spurs, Arsenal and Chelsea could all be looking for a new manager soon. I very much doubt that any of them will come looking for Moyes. He has proven himself as a safe pair of hands and maybe having loads of money to spend might lead to us seeing a different side to him. Personally, though I don't see it. I believe that he is in the best job he will ever have.

He has been given plenty of time at Everton but instant success is more the norm in the expectations of Premier League club owners. Rightly or wrongly, a season without a trophy or Champions League qualification at one of the clubs I mentioned would be viewed as abject failure.

David Moyes has a secure, well paid job that comes with less pressure than most Premier League jobs. He has the respect of the media, the admiration of his peers and probably the support of most Evertonians. Our dreadful start to this and most seasons is forgiven once a good run starts. He keeps Kenwright safe while at the same time making him look like a model, loyal, chairman. If we win the FA Cup he'll have a job for life.

My views on David Moyes are well known but ? should a "big" club come calling ? for his own sake, he'd do well to ignore them.
Dean Adams
11 Posted 19/02/2012 at 19:16:50
Kevin Elliott - we saved half a years salary, so that would mean about £1million difference. He wanted to go, now he knows that no other club is a patch on EFC
Phil Walling
12 Posted 19/02/2012 at 19:21:42
Dean,you kidding! His brother who negotiates for him,had the contract back-dated to the commencement of negotiations.Believe me!
Anthony Flack
13 Posted 19/02/2012 at 19:33:30
Paul Lambert = Mike Walker, remember that bloody canary
Kevin Elliott
14 Posted 19/02/2012 at 19:43:07
Dean. If we re-sign him, we will be (taking into account the one million pounds saving on his wages) about two million pounds down. We shouldn't have sold him in the first place.

Anthony. Comparing Paul Lambert with Mike Walker is nonsense. It's like compering Mike Walker with Howard Kendall. Both managed the same teams.
Dean Adams
15 Posted 19/02/2012 at 20:00:22
Kevin - agree that we should not have sold him, but at least he knows that being here is the better option and it may reflect in his new wage demands! Wishful thinking I suppose.
MIchael Williams
16 Posted 19/02/2012 at 19:56:52
If Moyesie left it would more than likely be pretty much the end for us. I would be surprised if another manager would be able to keep us in the Premier League with the finances at his disposal.

We all hate the phrase 'punching above your weight' but that pretty well sums it up. A net average transfer spend of roughly £1.5 million a year is nowhere near enough for a Premier League team. What Moyesie has achieved has actually been incredible.
Amit Vithlani
17 Posted 19/02/2012 at 20:06:34
If Moyes leaves for me it would be between Lambert (but could we afford him) or an Alan Stubbs / Alan Irvine combo.

Lambert is in no way another Walker. He has played at the top level (Champions League winner) and spent time taking his coaching badges. Walker spent more time on the sun lounge and got found out.

I have always liked Stubbsy as a man. Here is a true Evertonian who has been through a lot in life. From the looks of it, his reserve team do like to attack and get plenty of goals and he knows most of the younger squad members. Maybe someone to get the best out of Barkley and Rodwell.
Chris Verghoden
18 Posted 19/02/2012 at 20:15:49
£3m a year, a loyal chairman, £68m a year wage bill and some of the game's brightest young players... Not a bad package to offer a new manager despite what some say. Everton started in 1878 not 2002!!!
Mick Gallagher
19 Posted 19/02/2012 at 20:27:07
Why the fuck do we always hear punching above are weight, so fucking negative.
James Morgan
20 Posted 19/02/2012 at 20:55:48
I'd have Holloway or Hughton. Two managers who have worked wonders on a tight budget yet are more adept at producing entertaining attacking football. I would also have Stubbs and Ferguson along side them. Moyes has done ok and for us put some pride back in the shirt, but I think he has took us as far as he can.
Peter Laing
21 Posted 19/02/2012 at 21:00:09
My sentiment too Mick Gallagher, I was listening to the commentator today at the Stevenage v Spurs game and he was mentioning that some of the big clubs had been knocked out of the competition and was raving about how big Sunderland have become under that leprechaun Martin O'Neill, FFS not even a cursory mention of Everton
Tim Locke
22 Posted 19/02/2012 at 20:44:40
Kevin (Elliott) what are you going on about, clearly you don't like Moyes but who would you put in place?

I have never understood why people think Moyes has done a bad job. As other has pointed out Moyes has done a good job. He has won two manager of the season awards, and if we look outside Everton most people with no emotional contact with the club speak about how great he is as a manager. I know he is defensive but as I have pointed out on other threads a defender costs a fraction of the cost a forward and therefore it is not surprising he has not been out spending millions of forwards. His history in the transfer market exceeds that of most other managers.

Peanuts was a great signing and if you remember Moyes said he has been a great servant to the club and if he wanted to move on, and he did, then fair enough, Moyes has managed to get him back, so Peanuts clearly thinks he is a good manager and got the club some money in. Your point that we might end up paying more that we sold him for is stupid. He has a two year contract left, if he only had 6 months we would be getting him for free. We sold him when he only had 6 months left, and we only sold him because he wouldn't sign a new contact. This is not Moyes, Peanuts like Moyes, hence he came back, he wanted the chance to player Cham league and who could blame him. Who knows we might get him back from free and then it would be a good deal. Lets see what the summer brings
Derek Thomas
23 Posted 19/02/2012 at 21:30:21
All Sharpy is doing is preparing the ground for a) So the fans get used to the idea of Moyes going. b) Covering Bill's arse for not keeping him. He left us, not my fault we offered him xxxxx.
Wayne Smyth
24 Posted 19/02/2012 at 21:18:36
Moyes would never be poached by a "big" team. The teams with more money than us simply wouldn't put up with his shit brand of football.

He certainly did well in the first half of his tenure and I was very pleased to have him. But as time wore on and the money ran out he started to wave the white flag, with all the defeatest talk of "knives and gunfights" which I'm sure has got into his players minds.

We've also a habit of consistently starting the season shit and I have a theory: the first half of the season Moyes talks down his side, aims for 40pts, plays the players he's most comfortable with(i.e. as many defenders as he can). Any creative types that don't conform get sidelined. Remember how long it took him to use Drenthe? How he treated Barkley when he played barely a game? How he continually plays his misfiring favourites(cahill/saha), and sidelines those who might offer something fresh(vellios/straq).

As the season wears on and our position becomes more desperate he's forced into changes he wouldn't normally make(e.g. dropping saha & giving straq a decent chance).

Moyes is a natural backs to the wall manager. He thrives on that. No pressure, no-one thinks he(or his team) can do it and he galvanises the players. His one and only style of "defend and nick one" is suited perfectly to a team that no-one thinks can win, opposition attack us, we defend and grab a winner sometimes. This is also possibly why we're capable of beating Man City and Chelsea one week and putting in an inept performance against bottom of the table Wigan the next.

As a final note, recall the game at the weekend. Remember the crossfield pass that Drenthe attempted and the ball went out for a throw. Recall how Moyes bawled and ranted at Drenthe. Now remember all the times Neville has given away possession or played hospital balls. When you've digested this, imagine Moyes at Chelsea or Arsenal trying to deal with players with skill and flair.

No, Moyes will never leave EFC for a "bigger" club. But it would certainly be fun to see him try to manage one!
Tony McNulty
25 Posted 19/02/2012 at 21:31:35
We need a list of banned phrases on here. My immediate candidates would be:

Peanuts
Punching above our weight
Careful what you wish for
Brian Waring
26 Posted 19/02/2012 at 21:31:17
"Your point that we might end up paying more than we sold him for is stupid. He has a two-year contract left, if he only had 6 months left, we would be getting him for free."

How is Kevin's point stupid, Tim? As you say, he has a two-year contract left, so if Spurs decide to sell in the summer, they will dictate what price he goes for, and if he keeps performing for us till the end of the season, there will be plenty of takers for him. Also, if he only had 6 months left, what makes you think we would be getting him for free?
Brian Harrison
27 Posted 19/02/2012 at 21:49:56
I am a fan of David Moyes, but I accept that there are people with differing views. But don't listen to fans for or against ? his fellow Premier League managers to a man say he has done a fantastic job.

Now some might say well all the Premier League managers pat one another on the back. But listen to ex-players who know the game all say what a terrific job he does.

So I think I would take note of people who coach or have actually played the game for a fair and honest opinion.
Keith Edmunds
28 Posted 19/02/2012 at 22:02:50
One more banned phrase.

Big Clubs.
Jem Traynor
29 Posted 19/02/2012 at 21:44:52
I completely agree with "Wayne Smyth" ? when Moyes came to Everton, we were in 'Rag Order', there was only relegation on the horizon and everyone knew it! Now the time has changed and, if Moyes moves on, he has done a good job for us but he is going into unknown territory. At Everton the history is well known and there are managers out there who can do a good job, Hughton for one! On a tight budget with passionate fans!!

Don't get me wrong here: I want Moyes to stay and so he can grow with Everton! It's a symbiosis! I can't stand all these brow-slapping pundits who love the opportunity to mention what Moyes has done for lowly little Everton... Piss Off!!! It's divisive and they know it!

I don't know why Sharpy put this interview out there... but it too is the same as. If he wants to go the tara, Everton is more than that and should be to him... if not, more of the same.
Gavin Ramejkis
30 Posted 19/02/2012 at 22:08:08
Moyes has done what he has at Everton for a decade and not once has he been sniffed at by bigger clubs and there have been plenty of vacancies in that ten years.

Don't forget this is the same Sharpy that claimed one of the BU marches was just one bloke and his dog, a club puppet greasing the lemmings ready for another bumper deal for Moyes to head off all those big bad clubs lining up to steal him away.

BK wouldn't last two minutes with a manager who said how things were behind closed doors at GP and all the broken promises, lies and bullshit Black Bill has spewed over his tenure.

Finally there will be a day when Moyes has gone and the club will not cease to exist because he isn't there any more in exactly the same way it will carry on without BK and any one of the players when they are sold or retire, don't be fooled by the twaddle about definite relegation etc etc as its all just speculation, similarly to Sharpy's line of we cant compete which again speculatively admits BK and his board aren't pissing off any time soon.
Tim Locke
31 Posted 19/02/2012 at 22:27:44
Brian 092


The point is stupid because it implies the sale in the first place was a bad decision, I think there is little or no evidence to support that. A club in general sells a player for 3 reasons, the club don't want the player. The player does not want the club. The club gets an offer it can't afford.

In the case of pienaar he wanted to leave the club and his contract was running out. So the manager has two choices presuming the player is needed by the club. Play the player and let him
go when his contract runs out, so makes nothing. Sells the player the when an offer comes in. At the end of Jan pienaar could have been signed for free. Moyes tried to keep him, but pienaar wanted a better opportunity and wanted to leave. Given Moyes had run out of time he had two choices sell and get some money or give the player away and get the rest of the season out of him. He decided to sell.

So given he had two options sell or give away selling was 'less stupid' that given away. I don't see how anyone can say it's stupid, we might lost out but let's see, there's a good chance Tot will give us him.
Ian Edwards
32 Posted 19/02/2012 at 22:33:06
Let them sniff..... Let them breathe him in....Let them have him.
Chris Leyland
33 Posted 19/02/2012 at 22:49:58
I see the nurses have let the MOB arrears the computer room again
Roman Sidey
34 Posted 19/02/2012 at 22:25:28
My opinion of the man is known, but this statement by Sharp should be worrying for all Everton supporters.

- For the Moyes fans, it could be the ominous sign of him leaving for another club.

- For the MOB, it could be exactly what Gavin has just said - justification for an improved deal.

The latter is alarming regardless of whether you want Moyes to stay or go, as you could only see him staying for a similar or better deal than he is on now. One thing is for sure, the club cannot afford to keep paying these wages unless something changes dramatically in the next six months.
Peter Warren
35 Posted 19/02/2012 at 23:01:42
Tim 100 - Pienaar was bad management because Moyes let time run out. We knew for a year before how much money he wanted and wouldn't give him it, so why not flog him earlier ? especially in our perilous state .

I think Moyes didn't let him go and others such as Arteta, Jags who we were offered big money for because he felt we had a great chance of getting Champions League football. He made a judgment and got it wrong, fair enough. The board is the biggest problem by mile but what is unacceptable is the defeatist attitude he's publicly displayed at the beginning of the season. He did it once before when he wasn't sure whether or not to sign a new contract .

I understand why he's frustrated... down... pissed-off... but it is totally unacceptable . His job is to get a team to play football and thank goodness he's changed his demeanour now.

I'd love to see Moyes with loads of money and see how he gets on with us as I find it difficult to criticise him too much because his hands are tied . I don't see any top club offering him a job as I don't think he's good enough . A loyal hardworking passionate Evertonian he is... but a great manager? As much as I would love that to be true, as I like the guy, I think he's okay and that's it.
Tim Locke
36 Posted 19/02/2012 at 23:22:15
Peter 108 - Your comment at face value is fair enough. But football fans have to accept managers are human. Most football fans speak with hindsight and speak of the perfect decision. This is crazy everyone makes non-perfect decisions, and everyone can make a perfect ones with hindsight, lottery, horse racing and football results would be easy to predict.

So you have to go back to before the decision was made and ask was it a good decision. Then ask what can we learn from it. So the decision, Moyes said Pienaar had been a great servant to the club and he didn't want to let him leave or sell him. So Moyes kept him, and then when it became clear Everton were not going to make the Champions League that year and Pienaar was going to leave, he got some money it.

Yep, selling for £10m+ would have been great but who is going to pay that when you can have him for free? So should he have sold him in July, maybe, but then fans would say he has no ambition, club swallow the money and we get no replacement? I don't think Moyes decision was bad, and we have another impossible question to answer, if we had sold him in July with a year left would we have got £10m? I am not sure.

If you then look at how it has worked out. We sold a player, took him off our wage bill, got some money for him, and then got him back a year later, rested and playing well, for nothing. Looking at that, it looks like an amazing decision. I know people will point to we only have him on loan, but let's see what the summer brings.

All-in-all, looking back at the time I don't think it was a bad decision; at the moment it, looks like a very good decision.... time will tell how good.

Richard Jones
37 Posted 20/02/2012 at 00:03:32
Sharpy pre-empting the possibility... the club's PR machine working in advance here, guys... let's see what happens in the summer.
Dennis Stevens
38 Posted 20/02/2012 at 00:27:48
"Big clubs will come sniffing for Moyes" - When?
James Stewart
39 Posted 20/02/2012 at 00:51:48
Is there no end to the shit this guy spouts!
Bob Parrington
40 Posted 20/02/2012 at 01:22:03
OK. Moyes is the manager and the responsibility starts and ends at the top. But, there seems no discussion about who is pissing in his ear. If we have only "defence" ex-players etc ... "mind sets".... in the first team management/coaching group, isn't this likely to mean we play a defensive style?

Derek Thomas
42 Posted 20/02/2012 at 07:24:48
Next time'll be the first.
Noel Lynam
43 Posted 20/02/2012 at 08:04:15
"As a final note, recall the game at the weekend. Remember the crossfield pass that Drenthe attempted and the ball went out for a throw. Recall how Moyes bawled and ranted at Drenthe. Now remember all the times Neville has given away possession or played hospital balls."

Wayne, I was thinking the very same thing but with Jagielka and Hibbo too.

I wonder just how Sharpy views the club if he is worried about Moyes being poached by a "top six" club - top eight? Top ten? Top division?
Stephen Kenny
44 Posted 20/02/2012 at 08:03:41
Everton will not be seen as a basket case by most outside the club. A large part of that, no in fact that is completely down to David Moyes.

The integrity everybody associated with the club displays (bar the board) is a credit to us and means a lot to the wider football world. That also came from him.

The training ground has his stamp all over it and is up there with the best in this country as is the youth set-up and we will bear the fruit of it in time.

But, the style of play and the set-up of the side has also got his name written through it. He's a safety first, risk averse guy. He's also prone to a major sulk and I believe this may be the reason we start so poorly. He's seems to brrod his way through the summer when he see's other clubs spending.

He's got some brilliant players to work with and players coming through with unbelievable potential. If he's the best man to take advantage of that for the good of Everton then I can't see it.

He compares favourably with most managers in this league and I believe he is better than most. That said having time to build counts for a lot and most managers don't get the time he's had.

A club Everton's size finishing 17th would not be tolerated by most chairmen. This is usually brushed aside by his fans when they compare him to his peers.

Another comparison with managers who have been in their post for a similar amount of time shows him much worse off. That said, that's not really a fair comparison either.

The first half of our season's compared to the second shows there is room for improvement. The second shows that Moyes is capable of getting us results to do serious damage in this league.

After 5 years of poor starts I'm happy for someone maybe more adventurous to have a go.

Footballing history is littered with situations where a manager puts most of the building blocks in place and another comes in and finishes the job. If that fella goes on to win things or achieve more I'd still recognise the part Moyes played.

I think his knife to a gunfight comments showed this last leap is a leap too far for Moyes. You would need to be a great manager to win things at Everton. A great manager wouldn't say that.
Steve Guy
45 Posted 20/02/2012 at 09:07:27
When he goes, he goes. It will be a moment of his choosing and unlikely to be one of BK's. This Summer will be a window of "opportunity" in this regard as the managerial merry go round will be at full speed. Awwy departing Spurs will be but one possibility for DM.

If we were to win the Cup (and it's opening up in front of us now as I don't think we need to fear any of the teams left in it), this would give him an ideal opportunity to leave on a high; having fulfilled what he would see as his commitment to win a trophy for the Club.

The Club still has enough quality players that another intelligent manager can work with and build on and maintain our EPL status; maybe even play football that fills the ground every week.

Graham Sharp was asked a question and gave the obvious answer, even I'm not so paranoid as to believe it was preparing the ground for either DM's departure or his signing a new contract.
Ernie Baywood
46 Posted 20/02/2012 at 09:44:23
Excellent post, Stephen Kenny. I'd be surprised if either the Moyes Fanatics or the MOB (if these groups exist) disagreed entirely with it.
Tommy Coleman
47 Posted 20/02/2012 at 10:10:08
Stephen Kenny - Well said and agreed.
Jimmy Sørheim
48 Posted 20/02/2012 at 09:45:13
The problem with a new manager is the lack of player knowledge.
I think we need to look inside the club for a replacement for Moyes.
I think Phil Neville is a good candidate, as is Alan Irvine.
Maybe Duncan can be our assistant manager.
A lot of clubs find that it is sometimes easier to give the job to somebody who already knows all about the players and the club.
It is a cheap option too, and in my mind it would be the safest one, at least until we can find that right manager.

I do not want to see Steve Bruce or Gary Megson come and take over.
I would sooner give the job to Phil Neville.
Steve Smith
49 Posted 20/02/2012 at 10:28:49
I think Ian Holloway put his c v in at the weekend didn't he ? all those nice things he was saying about us, Kenwright will be creaming himself.
Jon Cox
50 Posted 20/02/2012 at 10:59:51
What? Talksport chatted about something else other than Chelsea Spurs or Arsenal.

What is the world comming to?
Steve Guy
51 Posted 20/02/2012 at 11:30:31
Jon Cox, No, they were steering the conversation round to where Moyes would go:ie Spurs :-)
Kevin Elliott
52 Posted 20/02/2012 at 11:53:31
Tim Locke 86.Read Wayne Smyth 89.
Thanks Wayne.
You saved me a lot of explaining.
Tim Locke
53 Posted 20/02/2012 at 12:46:43
Kevin Elliott (193) Did Wayne type in white? Or did I just miss it, but the open question is still not answered who do you want in his place?

Wayne's post I am not sure helps you, his 'theory' does not stand up. Moyes in public speaks of wanted to win and having a good start, so be must be a very different man behind close doors. Hardly agree with the creative argument Moyes has started with creative players, pienaar and Arteta have started seasons.
Kevin Elliott
54 Posted 20/02/2012 at 13:02:10
Tim, The answer you require lies in the second part of post 35 which you obviousely have not read.
Kevin Tully
55 Posted 20/02/2012 at 13:13:56
Tried and failed 42 times to beat the old " top four " away.

If any one statistic gives you an insight into how he sets up a team - then this is it.

A decent manager who is capable in the Premier League, but no more.

Thomas Windsor
56 Posted 20/02/2012 at 13:15:02
I can see a lot of good jobs coming up in May: England, Spurs, maybe even Man Utd, Chelsea, Arsenal... if Moyes is as good as all these TV pundits say he is, let's see if he gets any of these jobs.

The last two seasons, the football at Everton has been rubbish to watch, he continued to pick Saha who never looked bothered and Cahill who had lost form.

Moyes is a safety-first manager that's okay if you dont have a lot of money to spend but, if you take any one of the above jobs, you have a maximum of a few years to deliver a trophy or bye-bye... thats why he will stay at Everton ? a cushy job and a good pay packet,
Gareth Humphreys
57 Posted 20/02/2012 at 13:46:00
Kevin Elliot - 020 - A lot of supposition and opinion in your comment with absolutley nothing to back it up. Well done.
Gareth Humphreys
58 Posted 20/02/2012 at 13:47:40
There isn't a bigger club than Everton.
Anto Byrne
59 Posted 20/02/2012 at 13:52:50
Drenthe made a diagonal run across the park before feeding the ball to the advanced Nevile who then passed it to Gibson and then on to Johnny who played it back to Howard. This was greeted with warm applause by Moyes as we retained possession and prevented any threat from Blackpool. Superb stuff well worth the money. Not sure the likes of City Arsenal Chelsea Man U or Spurs would appreciate such tactical genius (snore zzzzzzz)....
Bobby Thomas
60 Posted 20/02/2012 at 14:23:14
If Moyes went, it would be Phil Neville, who has 'manager' written all over him.
Jack Molloy
61 Posted 20/02/2012 at 14:16:44
If any of the "big" teams were going to come after David Moyes, they would have done so by now. They would have done so after the fourth place finish, or they would have done so after reaching the Cup Final. They are hardly likely to do so after he has failed to live up to the expectations created by those achievements.

The knock on David Moyes is not just that his football is too negative but that he cannot deal with the egos that grow on major stars. That may or may not be justifiable but teams like Chelsea, Manchester Utd, Arsenal, etc are not going to take a risk that their major stars are going to ankle after a going over from DM.

Also, Moyes knows that if he were to go to a club with big money they would expect big things in return. At Goodison, virtually nothing is expected of him which is part of our problem, not his. Few managers who had the starts to so many seasons he has had would have survived this long at most Premier League clubs.
Brian Waring
62 Posted 20/02/2012 at 14:33:53
Tim, Pienaar went because we weren't prepared to offer him the wages he was after. If we would have give him what he wanted, he would have stayed.
Ben Howard
63 Posted 20/02/2012 at 14:42:49
Here's a question for you to ponder. If Moyes was English, do you think he'd be the frontrunner ahead of Redknapp for the vacant England job? I think he would.

Redknapp won an FA Cup with Portsmouth (which is more than Moyes has done admittedly) but aside from the sexy, attacking football Spurs are playing at the moment, are his credentials any better? I'd say over the years Moyes has come out on top when they've met in the Premier League.

Whether this is a legitimate way to measure how good a manager DM is or, for that matter, how good a manager he is for Everton is another question but it may go someway towards analysing him objectively.

John Daley
64 Posted 20/02/2012 at 14:51:46
"Here's a question for you to ponder. If Moyes was English, do you think he'd be the frontrunner ahead of Redknapp for the vacant England job? I think he would."

Seen as though you asked....no.
Mark Stone
65 Posted 20/02/2012 at 15:15:39
Well, Ben, as I've just said on another thread until Redknapp took over the third biggest spenders in the transfer market (consistently for about a decade, of not longer) and a squad which are paid a salary of almost double that of Evertons, Moyes had finished above him in the league something like 4 out of 5 times. And yes, Redknapp did win the Cup. Take nothing away from them but how many premier league teams did they play in that competition? One! In Man Utd the QF (I think). Compare that to our run in 2009 and the 'Moyes shit out' argument doesn't really sit too well. If we'd played a championship club in the Final I'd have been pissed off at him if he'd have not won. As it stands, I'm not. Just like Spurs fans aren't that pissed of that HR lost the Carling Cup final to Man Utd in 2009. PS If Everton had drawn against Stevenage yesterday Moyes name would definately be getting dragged through the mud!
Andy Crooks
66 Posted 20/02/2012 at 18:16:20
Mark Stone, you make a very pertinent point If we had drawn with Stevenage I would indeed have been on here at 5.00 giving Moyes a good going over.

Frankly, Moyes's ability to turn us round season after season is the main cause of the division among Evertonians. For four months he is sackable and for four months he is the toast of football.

Luke O'Farrell, your a bloke with a bit of talent and ambition. Run your eyes over this conundrum. Shite starts,negative football and the season wasted then saved by March. Write an article on it and let's have a proper no name calling football debate.
Brian Waring
67 Posted 20/02/2012 at 18:32:37
Thats the problem Andy, beating Man City, Chelsea and progressing in the cup seems to have some people thinking Moyes has turned the season round.

The thing is though, the season started the 20th August against Q,P,R, not the 31st Jan against Man City.
Steve Barr
68 Posted 20/02/2012 at 18:27:41
I've posted before that no one is irreplaceable and that Moyes has had more than a fair chance at turning us into regular championship contenders and silverware acquirers!

The dichotomy seems to be:

1. He's doing a great job in the face of our dire financial situation by keeping us in the Premiership and occasionally contending for titular honours, and almost picking up a piece of silverware.
2. He's destroying the club with his dour, negative tactics and strategy based on a total inability to know when to make substitutions to effect a positive outcome and to ever set up the team in an attack minded format.

Some will argue at that the first part of the case has been at the expense of decent attacking, joined up football that a lot of Evertonians have been brought up on.

Others will argue that given the financial constraints, no one else would have done any better.

While agreeing with both positions to a certain extent, I'd rather take the chance and move on. Set out the criteria desired of a new manager, focus efforts on getting that person and...you never know!

What I can't accept is stagnation, acceptance of the mediocre and this negative assumption that no one else on earth could do any better.

Luddites comes to mind.

COYBs let's move on and take our chances.
Jamie Barlow
69 Posted 20/02/2012 at 18:54:00
I wouldn't say Moyes has had a 'fair' chance. I'd say he's been shafted quite a bit actually.
Wayne Smyth
70 Posted 20/02/2012 at 20:14:28
Mark(240): If Moyes had drawn at stevenage then I'd also be here with Andy berating Moyes and perhaps the players too. However, that is only in the context of the many years of consistently dire football and lack of results against teams with worse quality players than us.

If we'd been playing like spurs every week and getting the kind of results our squad is capable of then I'd probably just put it down to a one-off and move on.

Jamie(293): I kind of agree with you about Moyes being shafted. The money tap has been turned off by Kenwright several seasons ago and there has not been the money to replace players who have left.

However, Moyes job by definition is to "Manage" and he basically failed to do so and spend the first half of the season sulking and talking the team down and talked our chances down rather than biting Wengers hand off and taking £10M for jags and perhaps giving a game to Duffy and/or mending his bridges with Yobo.

We could've also kept Yak if Moyes was willing to accomodate his goalscoring style of play and wouldn't have needed to shell out on wages for players like Hanneman/McFadden or bring in Jelavic whose wages I'm sure are more expensive than Yak.

Personally I also think we should've given Pienaar another £10k over what he was offered and kept him. Perhaps then Donovans loan would've been unnecessary and we'd still have a £5M player on our books.

As usual though its not quite cut and dry since Moyes has done some very good business with Gibson, but overall I think I'd like to see another more positive manager given the opportunity to take us on and improve us.
Mark Stone
71 Posted 20/02/2012 at 20:30:57
Mark(240): If Moyes had drawn at stevenage then I'd also be here with Andy berating Moyes and perhaps the players too. However, that is only in the context of the many years of consistently dire football and lack of results against teams with worse quality players than us.'

For the record Wayne, I would have as well. I was merely pointing out that not only Everton and David Moyes are guilty of underperforming against cup 'minnows' every now and then ? something Moyes has routinely been slated for. Given the nature of this thread and some of the recent unfavourable comparisons DM has had to HR on this site in the last few days, I'm sure you can see how the reference to the Spurs result was a pertinent one.

"If we'd been playing like Spurs every week and getting the kind of results our squad is capable of then I'd probably just put it down to a one-off and move on."

Really? Just what is out squad capable of Wayne, relative to our competitors? Champions League? You're having a laugh!

Over the last DECADE under Moyes, barring the admittedly disappointing seasons of 2003-04 and 2005-06 (although many will argue that they were actually more representative of the quality of our squad) give me one example of a team who we had a better squad than, that finished a season in a higher position than us. If you can't find one it's because they don't exist. On the other hand, there ARE teams with better squads than ours who we finish above... consistently.
Wayne Smyth
72 Posted 20/02/2012 at 21:01:09
Mark, if we're capable of beating the likes of chelsea and city occasionally then how can we play so badly so consistently against teams near the foot of the table or lower league opposition? Why are our first half season performances consistently dire?

I'll grant you that I dont expect us to beat city or chelsea or utd regularly, but the fact that we do should be a bonus on top of results against the Wigans and QPR's of the league.

The money tap may have been turned off by Kenwright, but we still probably spend more on players(salaries, transfers & other fees) than most of the teams in the league, so on that basis I'd still probably expect us to finish 7th or 8th, perhaps higher given that Moyes has had 10+ years of stability to reshape the club in his image and no pressure whatsoever. He probably has the safest job in world football while Bill Kenwright is in charge.

I don't think he's doing a bad job overall, but I think we could and should take a chance on someone with energy and fresh ideas. More than his dull brand of football, the thing that worries me the most is the defeatest talk. I dont think anyone who manages our club should talk like that and the David Moyes who walked into Everton 10 years ago certainly did not.
Mark Stone
73 Posted 20/02/2012 at 21:17:36
'but we still probably spend more on players(salaries, transfers & other fees) than most of the teams in the league'

We absolutely don't. Our salary expenditure is similar to Bolton's and Fulhams in recent years and markedly less than teams like Sunderland and Villa. Pound for pound, transfers + wages we are 12th/13th.
Mark Stone
74 Posted 20/02/2012 at 21:22:15
'on that basis I'd still probably expect us to finish 7th or 8th'

Ok. How many times in the last decade have your expectations not been met then? And how many times have they been exceeded?
Mark Stone
75 Posted 20/02/2012 at 21:24:23
'I'll grant you that I dont expect us to beat city or chelsea or utd regularly, but the fact that we do should be a bonus on top of results against the Wigans and QPR's of the league.'

As I've posted on several threads now, this argument makes no sense at all. How did Liverpool and Chelsea get on at Wigan away? This is what I posted on this topic on a previous thread. It more than answers your question. A question which, to me shows no understanding about the uniqueness of a 'league'.

'All too often I read 'if only we hadn't drawn away to Wigan we'd have ...'. Its bollocks! The league is a marathon not a sprint (apologies for the cliche) and is not shaped by individual results. In the premier league any team can beat any other on their day. Even a bottom of the league Blackburn can tonk Man Utd 3-0! If it didn't work like that the league would be a pretty dull affair and the bookies wouldnt have such a lucrative business!

Also if we are taking back the points we 'dropped' against Wigan, are Chelsea and Man City (etc) picking up the points they dropped against us? Are Liverpool picking up the points they 'dropped' against teams like Wigan and West Brom, too? The beauty of the league is that it's the cumulative number of points collected over a season and without fail, the best teams win and the worst ones go down'
Wayne Smyth
76 Posted 20/02/2012 at 21:31:34
Mark, my expectations in terms of league places have been met and sometimes exceeded, but then I'd expect that from an "average" manager with the resources the club has provided.

Throw in rock-solid job stability - which should not be underestimated - and perhaps the odd finish above our expected position should be achieved. Sometimes our league placing hasn't been great and that is to be expected too.

So, given the football on offer is dull as dishwater and league placings are as expected, am I content to risk that average performance for something a bit better? Maybe we'll get a Wally, maybe we'll get a Wenger, who knows.....but I don't see why people are convinced this man is some kind of world class god manager who we should all be eternally grateful manages our club and scared shitless to replace.

If you gave me a choice now of keeping moyes and finishing 7th for the rest of eternity and never winning a thing, or perhaps getting a Joe Royal who had us playing decent footie and occasionally winning stuff I'll take Royal every time. A day lived as a lion et al.
Guy Hastings
77 Posted 20/02/2012 at 21:40:58
Redknapp is just putting pressure on Levy for a pay rise. He'll stay put at Spurs and no-one will be going anywhere. Same old, same old at the start of next season.
Mark Stone
78 Posted 20/02/2012 at 21:42:48
Well that is obviously where we differ Wayne. I can't see any justification in sacking any employee of any organisation who admittedly routinely 'meets, and occasionally exceeds' expectations. In fact it seems completely irrational and somewhat bizarre!
Daniel Russell
79 Posted 20/02/2012 at 22:28:42
I just can't wait till Moyesy leaves and we get Steve Bruce and Gary Megson knocking our door down for a job...
Steve Barr
80 Posted 20/02/2012 at 22:36:48
Mark,

Sort of agree with your sentiments about being fired for doing your job.

I bet Lee Clark, ex Huddersfield, is wondering what just happened to him!

Despite lying fourth in the division and prior to defeat by leaders Charlton in November, Clark presided over a club-record run of 43 league games unbeaten.

However, football seems to be a little peculiar. In the real world I wouldn't expect someone who has just been sacked would then walk into another job the next week.

Football managers routinely sign term contracts and get paid out in full if their contract is terminated early. They then routinely walk into a job the next week.

Apparently Grayson who was recently sacked by Leeds just got appointed to the Huddersfield job. Probably with a large payoff in his back pocket to boot.

I wouldn't be too concerned, it's not the same as being laid off/sacked in the real world!
Graham Mockford
81 Posted 20/02/2012 at 22:50:09
Steve
Agreed that's why we should be grateful in the words of Ian Holloway we support a 'proper club'.
Mark Stone
82 Posted 20/02/2012 at 23:24:55
Well I'm an exercise physiologist and do consultancy at more than 1 premier league club and I do get to know the managers quite well. During my time there I've seen 5 managers sacked. And believe me, it is the real world. And I'll also tell you there isn't a manager in the premier league who thinks he could do more with Everton than Moyes has done. One thing I'd want, is for at least the incoming manager to think he could make an improvement. The sacking of Lee Clarke was a good example. Sheer lunacy.
Peter Roberts
83 Posted 21/02/2012 at 00:00:10
Moyes's contract extension I think runs until the end of next season doesn't it? I thought the 5-year deal he signed in 2008 runs out at the end of the 2012-13 season?

Which may mean we won't get as much compensation because Spurs will only have to pay £3.5m compensation to buy out his contract.

Get him signed up, Bill!
Brian Waring
84 Posted 21/02/2012 at 00:00:24
Daniel, I don't think there will be anyone knocking our door down for a job if Moyes leaves, because like some on here, I reckon our next manager in waiting is Phil Neville.
Roman Sidey
85 Posted 21/02/2012 at 05:52:49
Stephen Kenny, your post should have ended this thread. Truly stirring stuff, mate. Could not have said it any better.

Jimmy, I agree about the knowledge of players being an advantage. However, in our case where we've put up with "Moyes' favourites" for so long, don't you reckon that there could be a positive to come from a manager who knows little about our squad?

Ben Howard, a sidetrack to your question is, if Moyes became England manager, it would be a massive 360 by the press within about 10 minutes of him signing. He'd go from being the "manager who gets the most out of what he's got" to public enemy number one.
Daniel A Johnson
86 Posted 21/02/2012 at 12:23:47
It comes down to this would you prefer,

David Moyes

Or

Phil neville
Nick Entwistle
87 Posted 21/02/2012 at 12:46:27
Daniel, the moment Moyes leaves I'm putting £20 on Neville. Hopefully they won't even have him listed and they have to phone in for the odds... presumably Ol' Pip has his licences?
Michael Sloan
88 Posted 21/02/2012 at 13:11:23
Type or paste your comment here. No txt-speak, please try to use proper grammar, all-lowercase posts are likely to be deleted
Nathan O'Hagan
89 Posted 21/02/2012 at 16:21:00
I guarantee, if Moyes leaves, not one manager will be able to do as good a job as he has done on these resources. Yes, he makes utterly baffling decisions at times (Heitinger and Neville in centre mid against Bolton, ludicrous) and makes subs too late, but all these people saying he just plays dour fottball forget the way we were playing a few seasons back, when we had Arteta, Cahill, Piennar and Osman all at the top of their games, and a solid defence, we were playing some stunning stuff at times, and tearing some teams apart. Since then, Arteat lost form and has left. Piennar left, and is now back, Cahill is past it, and Osman is injured. DM has been unable to replace them (but he must take full blame and responsibility for signing Bily for that much money, £10 to us is huge, and should onl be spent if 100% certan they ill work in our team/this league).

We're going through a tough transition and struggling to reach the heights of a few seasons back, an DM is trying to keep the squad together and add t it when he can. Yes, there are some managers wo play nicer football, Rodgers at Swansea for one, but i'm not convinced he could take us to the next level. Who else? Martinez? Nice footballing philosophy, but his side is bottom. Who else could realistically take us forward at present?

At some point, Moys will leave, and we will have to answer these questions, or the board will, but for now, we absolutely hve the bst man for the job. Yes, he's pretty fuckin far from perfect, yes h frustrates me at times, yes he has a questionable record with strikers, but cast your minds back to the Smith days. Remember how fucking depressing that was?

Moyes came in and has restored pride. He's strugglig now, but i believe he wll bring yet more pride back. If he can be given a bit spend each year (not even tens of millions, just a net spend of about £5-10m each season, while being allowed to keep the players he wants) he will win us a cup soon.

I wont say IN MOYES WE TRUST, as that shows blind, unquestioning faith, and i dont have that in anyone, but Moyes is a skilled, talented but imperfect manager, who has done a great job for us, and will continue to do so.
Thomas Windsor
90 Posted 22/02/2012 at 09:18:08
Moyes won't leave Everton, the big clubs wont touch him with a barge pole. his tactics are too boring.

As for Neville managing Everton ? no chance! Even Kenwright is not that stupid.
Paul Mackie
91 Posted 22/02/2012 at 13:08:21
Just heard an BBC 5 Live interview with Alex Ferguson where he was talking about potential succesors and managers in the PL:

"Some are doing great jobs with the resources they have and David Moyes has been unbelievable. I put him in the top six because what he?s done at Everton has been quite miraculous"

When you get praise from one the club managements all time greats (and whatever you think of Man U, you can't deny that they've won quite a bit...) you're obviously doing something right.

Moyes has a lot of faults. He's overly defensive at times, relies on out of form favourites and is overly cautious withs subs. It would be very interesting to see what he can do with a board willing to back him. We're certainly not going to find out definitively whilst he's at Everton that's for sure.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads