David Weir returns to Everton

, 21 February, 67comments  |  Jump to most recent
Defender joins coaching staff
David Weir has returned to Everton as a coach five years after leaving the club for Rangers. Weir, who made 269 appearances during eight years at Goodison Park, will work with the youth and reserve teams. The defender, who turns 42 in May, will also be eligible to play for Everton's reserve side.

"He'll help out Alan Stubbs with the reserves and will play in the occasional reserve game," said manager David Moyes.

Weir left Everton in January 2007 to link up with Walter Smith at Rangers, where he won the Scottish Premier League title three times and the Scottish Cup twice. But he left Ibrox last month having seen his first-team opportunities limited this season. Weir had been hoping to continue playing first-team football and had been training with Sheffield United since departing Ibrox.

"David did great for us when he was a player here and we are looking forward to being able to work with him again as he starts out in his coaching career," Moyes told the club website. "It will be good to have him around the place. He is a great professional and someone all the players at the club can look up to."

Weir said it had not been a difficult decision to leave Rangers. "I'm not sad about it, I'm happy that I got the opportunity to play for such a great club," he said. "I have so many memories to look back on and I am very proud of that. I wouldn't change it for the world.

Quotes or other material sourced from BBC Sport



Reader Comments (67)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Tom Fazal
1 Posted 21/02/2012 at 16:01:52
Just read that David Weir has returned to the club as a reserve team coach and may also play in some reserve games. Whilst he was a model professional and served the club well, how many defensive coaches do we need?
James Morgan
2 Posted 21/02/2012 at 16:02:27
Would it really hurt to have an attacking coach on the books? Jeez.
Glen Anderson
3 Posted 21/02/2012 at 16:23:53
James Morgan - We do: Duncan Ferguson came back a couple of months ago to work with the strikers I believe.
Gerry Quinn
4 Posted 21/02/2012 at 16:30:07
Davey Weir played in the 1-1 draw against the Shite reserves today
Paul English
5 Posted 21/02/2012 at 16:22:04
Just watched Weir play for the reserves v RS ? one for the future. Jobs for the boys, make easy money out of EFC... Any more Scotsmen out of work. Mcadden's doing the interviews.
Andrew Laird
6 Posted 21/02/2012 at 16:34:05
What a kick in the balls for any young centre back on the books.
Brian Hill
7 Posted 21/02/2012 at 16:55:13
What can David Weir teach our current playing staff that has not already been drummed in to them ad nauseam by Moyes et al? Give me strength.
Jay Wilson
8 Posted 21/02/2012 at 16:55:30
Andrew, did you not read Moyes comments about using him in the reserves to help the development of our young defenders? They should learn a lot from playing alongside him. He hasn't been brought in to play for the first team. Also, I think Ferguson has been brought in on a more long term basis to work with the Academy, so there's someone on the coaching staff with a more attacking mindset.
Alex Robinson
9 Posted 21/02/2012 at 17:01:39
Davie only played today apparently due to a few of the younger defenders being injured. Agree with some of the sentiment on this thread though. The defensive-minded coaches severely outnumber the attack-minded ones at the club. How about getting Andy Gray back? He's only doing radio these days :P
Richard Dodd
10 Posted 21/02/2012 at 17:16:31
Whither Stubbsy?
Chris Leyland
11 Posted 21/02/2012 at 17:28:13
Everton today announced the signing of Lionel Messi, Cristiano Ronaldo, Xavi and Inniesta. A spokesperson for the MOB sais "for fuck's sake what the fuck does the dour, dooless, dire Davey think he's playing at blah blah blah"
Stephen Kenny
12 Posted 21/02/2012 at 17:41:14
Everton today announced the signing of Lionel Messi, Cristiano Ronaldo, Xavi and Iniesta. Moyes has stated he expects all four to be ready to challenge for a 1st team place before the season ends.

Greg O'keefe at the Liverpool Echo comments "A goodison insider has suggested the four were well off the pace and will need to work a lot harder to displace model pro's like Neville, Cahill and Seamus"
Stephen Kenny
13 Posted 21/02/2012 at 17:51:14
To play at any level up to the age Weir has shows what a tremendous professional he is. As his legs went a decade ago he must also have a fair bit of nous.

If he passes some of this on to our younger players he will be well worth his relatively low coaches wages.

I like that we are building a coaching staff that know what it means to play at the top level for Everton.

One that includes Big Dunc and Sheedy, both potential future managers.
John Daley
14 Posted 21/02/2012 at 17:48:54
"Everton today announced the signing of Lionel Messi, Cristiano Ronaldo, Xavi and Inniesta. A spokesperson for the MOB sais "for fuck's sake .."

Steve Round today spoke about what it will take for the fantastic four to force their way into the starting line up: "What the new lads have got to learn is that it's not all about going on scintillating runs, scoring screamers and setting up goal scoring chances for others. They've got to close down the opposition, track back, learn how to defend set pieces and hold the ball up until Tim can get in the box."
Dan Brierley
16 Posted 21/02/2012 at 18:05:18
John Daley, you yet again demonstrate how little you know about football. When you are playing wing backs (as we do), your midfielders MUST track back to cover.

You keep repeating the same shite, as though wide midfielders do not need to cover overlapping full backs and track back when not in possession. You know nothing about the modern game.

You fail to even recognise, that since Moyes has had the right playing staff available, our results have 'miraculously' improved. We are also leaking less goals, as our midfield are back there helping out of defence to win back the ball, and giving outlets for the defence to play the ball to.

And the last point about set pieces, is basic maths. if they opposition have 8 or 9 players attacking the ball, and you have only 4 defenders in there, who do you think is most likely to win the ball, or any loose balls? Its not rocket science is it?
Gavin Ramejkis
17 Posted 21/02/2012 at 18:34:59
Dan if you are going to play the smart arse card, care to name our wing backs (plural) as the only player remotely resembling one is maybe Baines, or are you honestly claiming Hibbert or Neville are really a wing back is disguise?
Barry Rathbone
18 Posted 21/02/2012 at 18:32:59
Right, that's the recent "feel good" factor dealt with nothing like another centre half on the coaching staff to rally the troops.

Cruyff schooled Barca to produce what happens today, in 10 years we'll be able to head the ball further than any team in the championship.

Mouthwatering.
Stephen Kenny
19 Posted 21/02/2012 at 18:50:08
Mouthwatering - That's just cracked me up!!
James Carroll
20 Posted 21/02/2012 at 18:49:45
Be nice - he was a great servant to the club - and will be again in this new role.
Welcome home, David.
Dan Brierley
21 Posted 21/02/2012 at 18:46:58
Gav, I am not really interested in debating what you want to call a 'defender' that chooses to go forward when we are in possession. Personally, EVERY GAME I see Baines, Hibbert/Neville getting down the 'wing' and putting crosses into the box, or passing the ball inside if needed. I certainly don't classify any of them as traditional 'full backs' (clues in the title).

Semiwingfull back ok for you? But my point was, if 'insert correct player position here' go forward, the midfielder needs to cover them to prevent getting smashed on a counter attack.
John Daley
22 Posted 21/02/2012 at 18:39:54
Dan,

Did that read like a serious post to you? It was a light hearted response to an earlier humorous post.

The only time I've mentioned about wide midfielders tracking back previously was when discussing Drenthe. Not like it's one of my favourite topics or anything and I just can't refrain from repeating it. Anyway I didn't realise I had to ask your permission first o' oracle of fucking football wisdom.


Fuck me, you're right. If you seriously consider either Tony Hibbert or Phil Neville to be wing backs then our understanding of football is completely different and I bow to your superior knowledge of the subject matter.

"You fail to even recognise, that since Moyes has had the right playing staff available, our results have 'miraculously' improved."

Err, do I? Where and when? Our results have improved recently. Not exactly difficult for me to say. Am I now supposed to be some kind of major Moyes critic? News to me.

Who are 'the right playing staff' Dan? Moyes has got a bit of an injury crisis going on at the moment so his hands are pretty much tied in regards to the personnel he can pick and choose from. Would he still be picking 'the right playing staff' if Jagielka, Osman, Rodwell, Anichebe et al were all available or has he simply lucked into the current line up because of the unavailability of his tried and trusted?

I feel like I've just been started on by fucking Scrappy Doo.
Jeremy Benson
23 Posted 21/02/2012 at 19:05:23
Surely, if some of our reserve defenders were not available, it should be under 18 or youth defenders who step up and fill in, in order to aid development?
Sam Hoare
24 Posted 21/02/2012 at 19:08:47
Watched a little of the reserve game online. Weir was being absolutely skinned for pace! Let in their strikers 2 times in the space of about 10 minutes just because he couldn't get anywhere near them.

In the half I watched, I thought Vellios looked lazy, Coleman rusty, Baxter gave the ball away alot and looked like a young Leon Osman, Barkley was very uninspirational and looked no better than any of the others. Our best player looked like Gueye who tried to bring the ball down and showed some neat touches.

I wonder if everyone watched all the reserve games they would still be calling for the likes of Barkley and Vellios to start.
Kiern Moran
25 Posted 21/02/2012 at 19:12:12
I think it is a smart move. The kids need to learn early not to mind being shouted at by a very angry Glaswegian Centre defender, if they want to get anywhere at the club.
John Daley
26 Posted 21/02/2012 at 19:18:05
Sam,

Do you watch the reserves often? I posted this question on another thread but maybe you can answer it?

'What do those who watch the reserves regularly make of Eric Dier? I know when he first arrived he was supposed to be really highly rated by Sporting and the portugese media. He was also chosen by Umbro to feature in an England kit launch campaign as one of the future faces of English football alongside Rooney, Joe Hart etc.

'His whole loan situation at Everton has always seemed a bit of an oddity to me when there appears to be no possibility of actually keeping him. What's the point of him being here? Why play him in the reserves ahead of one of our own young defenders?'
Dan Brierley
27 Posted 21/02/2012 at 19:16:46
Wide midfielder? Not a winger John? We could keep this up all day!

My reference was more to your post on the 'Drenthe - Stracqularsi' thread. But it seems you have nothing else to debate, so decide to bring it up again on a thread about Davie Weir coming back?

I see the old 'forced into changes' chestnut is being played whenever our team starts doing well. Whats your view on bringing in Pienaar and Donovan? You think Moyes would have still played Anichebe and Osman on the wings with both those players fit?
Rob Sawyer
28 Posted 21/02/2012 at 19:45:15
Welcome back Davie, I would imagine this is a first step on the managerial/coaching ladder for Weir and won't involve heft wages. He is a class act and will be a decent example to young pros and academy kids. By chance I started reading his biography yesterday. It's nothing special but there were some interesting insights into Smith and Moyes. I was also surprised to learn how close he came to a move from Hearts to Liverpool (he came down for a couple of days trial but in the end Liverpool purchased Phil Babb!). It's clear that he retains a great fondness for the Blues.
Richard Dodd
29 Posted 21/02/2012 at 19:37:02
Talk in the Freshy this tea-time was that Weir could well be `the chosen one` should Moyes decide to take one of the flood of offers for his services as his contract rolls down to its final year. Given that our ex-skipper is about to graduate from the famed Scottish School of Coaching which gave us Davey, Weir would seem to have the march on Phil Neville who many at Goodison have seen as the likely successor.

The prospect of so many ex- skippers in Weir, Ferguson, Stubbs and Neville working in unison is mouth-watering but could the club afford them?
John Daley
30 Posted 21/02/2012 at 19:43:43
"My reference was more to your post on the 'Drenthe - Stracqularsi' thread"

Dan,

Have you heard the one about the dyslexic guy who walks into a bra?

The only point I was trying to make in the other thread was that, in my opinion, Moyes would not attempt to keep Drenthe on a permanent basis because he doesn't do the NECESSARY defensive work consistently enough. You've obviously read it and taken something else from it.




"Whats your view on bringing in Pienaar and Donovan? You think Moyes would have still played Anichebe and Osman on the wings with both those players fit?"

No, because I think he trusts both those players. I wouldn't bet against him starting one of the two ahead of Drenthe when they become available though.
Mark Riding
31 Posted 21/02/2012 at 20:12:12
John Daley #496...
Scrappy Doo... brilliant mate..
Gavin Ramejkis
32 Posted 21/02/2012 at 20:37:11
Doddy, your "flood of offers" for Moyes' services which seem only to exist in the head of a club mouthpiece that can't count and yourself and is almost as funny as John's "if it wasn't for you meddling Dan Brierleys"
Andy Crooks
34 Posted 21/02/2012 at 21:17:53
I don't see any downside to bringing David Weir back to coach. He has played against the very best and I'll be happy to see Duffy learn from him.
Roman Sidey
35 Posted 21/02/2012 at 20:54:29
Of all the club insiders, he's instantly more believable as a manager than Stubbs, Ferguson or Neville. Wouldn't be surprised if he was our next manager.

Sam, cheers for the input about the reserves games. Do they stream them on the same sites that they stream normal games? If they aren't performing in the reserves then that is fair enough, but there is that case in sport where a lot of players play better the higher the level they play. Once they've played top flight, some might find it hard to adapt back to having less qualified team mates. I know rugby is a different sport all together, but most of my team mates all agree that you don't play as well in 2nds as you do in 1sts for that reason.
Barry Rathbone
36 Posted 21/02/2012 at 21:17:57
Is the "freshy" an asylum?
Paul Andrews
37 Posted 21/02/2012 at 21:47:40
Dan,

I don't normally get in the middle of arguments, but wingbacks are used in a 3-5-2 formation, not something we play, so you're wrong there.
Mike Green
38 Posted 21/02/2012 at 21:52:01
Andy! Will you shut the fuck up about Duffy please!!!! Enough!
Tommy Gibbons
39 Posted 21/02/2012 at 22:14:03
Not being a fan of Mr Moyes's style of play, I am though intrigued by the recent return of former players as coaches. Is he building our version of the old Liverpool bootroom? (I believe they had a modicum of success...) If his intention is to build the Everton bootroom, then I applaud it as it's the only legacy we're going to get out of him. May well turn out to be the best thing he does for the club.
David Cooper
40 Posted 21/02/2012 at 22:15:22
I was just reading that Davie Weir has returned to Goodison to help his old pal Stubbsy with coaching the reserves. With no footy to keep my mind occupied for the next 2 weeks, in a moment of weakness I thought what sort of team would DM put out if he could pick anyone of the past Blues.

In goal it would have to be Jags.

Across the back 4: Stubbsy, Labby, Davey Moyes (would back him to pick himself even though has never worn the shirt), and Pat van den Hauwe.

In midfield he would pick the ball players: Jonny H, Davie Weir, Dave Mountfield and Ratty... which would leave two up front.

Lescott, as he scored more goals than our strikers, and Rhino.

On the bench he would have Dave Watson, Stubbsy and Sandy Brown... A formidable team.

Barry Rathbone
41 Posted 21/02/2012 at 22:17:33
David Cooper

Thanks a lot mate, I'm off to bed soon I'll have nightmares now.

I'm damn sure Moyes reads these pages - a team of centre halves!! - he'll have your post printed out in his cellar like some kind of frankestein project.

'kinell
Dick Fearon
42 Posted 21/02/2012 at 23:04:11
It goes to show that Moyes who is a know all about defence and lectures at the FA academy on that subject will not allow himself to be upstaged by an attacking coach.
Big Dunc is only in the early stages of getting his coaching levels. I have no doubt that by time he has earned his badge Moyes would have rid him of any foolish ideas about what happens across the half way line.
Derek Thomas
43 Posted 21/02/2012 at 23:38:58
At first glance it would seem that we don't need yet another CB for a coach,BUT...The position he played, his skill levels or lack of are no judge as to how he will set out a team if given the job of doing so. It could also be argued that having been matched against many dozens of strikers up close he might have an inkling of what is required by a striker.

Take George Graham, there weren't many silkier inside forwards than him. Don Revie was a inovative deep lying centre forward more versed in making the bullets for others to fire. But except for a few times their teams were horrible and nasty to watch and by all accounts even worse to play against.

Busby, Paisley, Shankly, Stein, Mercer, Docherty, Kendall, who were in old money, halfbacks, who could and did put themselves about a bit. No one can deny that they put out some nice teams to watch.

But I still go with my initial reaction...not another 'kin centre half, until proved otherwise.
Mark Riding
44 Posted 21/02/2012 at 23:57:13
Toe to toe.. last minute in the FA Cup semi final at Wembley 2012.. Downing pings in the corner towards Carrolls head... Jags.. or Weir to mug the lanky prick off ?? Still pick Weir all day...
Maybe 42.. but one solid player is Davey Weir.. and if he wants to coach the young lads thats fine with me.
Sam Hoare
45 Posted 21/02/2012 at 23:50:41
John Daley- no, just watch them sometimes when online. Dier was solid, not really sure if we have an option to sign him, would imagine so.

Roman- was a link I found online, think it was on Liverpool tv. Fair point about players upping their game, difficult to guess who is capable of it.
Eric Myles
46 Posted 22/02/2012 at 00:46:13
It's just like having an old signing!!!
Jamie Crowley
47 Posted 22/02/2012 at 02:20:21
"Won the Scottish Premier League three times"

By writing hot checks?

HRMC

Sorry, couldn't resist....
Mick Davies
48 Posted 22/02/2012 at 02:59:16
Dave Weir was an outstanding servant to our club. But does that merit him a job coaching here, when we already have dour, defensive coaches like Stubbs, Round, Moyes and Holden. Lumsden was a defensive midfielder. These are the five most senior coaches at Everton FC and the lack of balance i.e. an attack minded coach possibly with a personality to offset the miserable mob above. It's no wonder so many strikers have come and gone, usually falling out with the management, and you can be sure that in the near future, there's a job for Phil Neville as a . . wait for it. . yes, a defensive coach
Anto Byrne
49 Posted 22/02/2012 at 03:13:19
Weir & Stubbs ? the new management team for 2012-13 season when Moyes fucks off to who gives a shit... Maybe Howie Kendall to come back as midfield coach and, hey, what's Bob Latchford up to these days?

Sometimes you can just over-coach players and then they become robotic and the natural talent is stifled. Drenthe back defending corners FFS limits the quick counter-attack. Do we really need all eleven players back defending corners?
Peter Barry
50 Posted 22/02/2012 at 04:00:57
First McFadden and now Weir - So what are we a Football Club or a Charitable Rest Home for clapped out footballers as long as they are SCOTTISH. Yet ANOTHER defensive coach to add to the long list of ex-Defenders already brainwashing the players .
Robin Cannon
51 Posted 22/02/2012 at 06:03:11
I've rarely seen the appointment of an assistant reserve team coach cause such a furore. Whether because he's a defender, or because he's eligible to play for the reserves (like, say, a certain Howard Kendall, who kept his playing registration when he first became manager, with the express intent of playing in the reserves to keep an eye on developing players).

As Derek(535) points out, where managers and coaches played in their professional career isn't actually a great guide to what kind of teams they manage. He points out the George Graham/Don Revie examples; attacking players putting together notably dour teams. Looking at it the other way round, of current managers you might look at Arsene Wenger (defender) and his assistant manager Pat Rice (defender), Paul Lambert (defensive midfielder) and his assistant coach Ian Culverhouse (defender), Harry Redknapp (defensive midfielder) and his assistant Kevin Bond (defender). None of them responsible for particularly dour and defensive teams.

It's one thing to make the legitimate criticism that Moyes is an overly conservative manager. The next step, which looks at every decision and uses a negative interpretation as "proof" of that negativity, regardless of real evidence, is getting a little silly.
Phil Walling
52 Posted 22/02/2012 at 08:55:32
Naive question, perhaps... and nothing against Weir and Big Dunc, but do all these Scottish mates (including Faddy here) come back to work without pay?

I just had a glimmer that the bank were cutting out the wasteful expenditure and with so many coaches already in place did we need more?

Probably means a clean out of the old guard come summer, don't you think?
Andrew Laird
53 Posted 22/02/2012 at 09:06:13
Jay Wilson, that's alright then the young centre backs can learn one at a time in the game while the others sit and watch waiting for their chance to play with a 41 year old.

What matters is his experience of playing football and unfortunately it was in a position we are more than covered for throughout our unbalanced coaching staff.

Everton are in a financial mess and yet more money is spunked on staff who are not needed ie McFadden, Hahneman, Weir. (how much to the 3 of them pa?)

What can he teach or SHOW the reserves about shooting, through balls, attacking wing play, attacking set pieces, crossing, dribbling? It's a good thing that none of these aspects need working on at Everton for the last 10 years.
Brian Waring
54 Posted 22/02/2012 at 11:36:39
I haven't got a problem with the appointment of Weir, the thing I can't understand, is the reserves have already got a coach who was a great defender and servant to the club, so why bring in another defensive coach, when you already have one in place who was a top defender? Seems like a waste of a wage to me.
Daniel A Johnson
55 Posted 22/02/2012 at 12:08:08
Previosus service should mean nothing.

We have a whole host of good honest pros over the years do we have to give all them jobs too.

Exactly what is David Weir bringing to the table?

It scares me to think that our youth team is having any form of creativity and individuality beaten out of 'em by yet another dour Scottish defender.
Thomas Windsor
56 Posted 22/02/2012 at 13:11:28
I liked David Weir as a player but the reserve team is to keep the squad players or younger players match-fit for when they will be called to the first team.

How much defensive work does our whole club need? I thought the whole point of playing football was to score more goals than the opposition ? but not under David "put me to sleep" Moyes.
Steavey Buckley
57 Posted 22/02/2012 at 13:45:13
Putting together a good background coaching staff of experienced former players, who know each other very well (Ferguson, Weir, Stubbs and Irvine) and have played for the same club, is the forward.
Andrew Fair
58 Posted 22/02/2012 at 13:45:57
Surely having a successful pro who has a lot of knowledge teaching our kids is a good thing. The fact he is a defender won't have much bearing on matters. He will be great for Duffy, Dier et al. But his professionalism will hopefully rub off on Barkley, Baxter, Wallace, Gueye, Vellios, McAleny and others.

One thing everyone seems to naively mention is "blah blah he is a defender etc". Well Wenger, Alf Ramsey were defenders I think Shankly also?? They didn't do too bad with attacking teams did they? Added to that Guardiola and Kendall who were defensive midfielder. It just shows you don't have to be an attacker to manage /coach attacking teams.
Anthony Jones
59 Posted 22/02/2012 at 14:11:08
Class thread. Loving the many tangents
Andy Crooks
60 Posted 22/02/2012 at 15:28:18
Mike Green, fair enough. Enough is probably enough. I'll do my best.
Mike Green
61 Posted 22/02/2012 at 18:20:17
Fair play Andy, you're a very reasonable man. Thank you. And apologies for the bad language earlier. : )
Joe McMahon
62 Posted 22/02/2012 at 20:53:11
This is great news, we may as well carry on the Scottish theme and bring back Richard Gough & Stuart McCall. Although McCalls not an ex defender, so he may not fit in, although he can train the Scottish Rooney is still bloody here. Guys it's pitiful isn't it. We all knew this was gonna happen last year.

To make matters worse everytime I log on I see the frightening picture of the woman for Mature Dating on the top right of the screen. Is she your type Doddy? Yer mate Kenwright may be able to fix you up!
Roman Sidey
63 Posted 22/02/2012 at 21:46:01
Even though I said earlier I wasn't too concerned with Weir returning, the arguments people are making about good managers being defensive players (Wenger, Redknapp etc) and attacking players making dour managers (Revie etc) is a bit blinded. Not positive, but do these guys have an entire coaching staff of defensive players as well?

As I said, Weir returning doesn't concern me, but the coaching staff should be a bit more balanced.
Mick Davies
64 Posted 23/02/2012 at 03:25:57
To answer one of the above comments about Redknapp being a defensive midfielder, yes, but he has Joe Jordan, an up and at 'em centre forward alongside him and you can bet the younger man does most of the coaching and training sessions, especially while Dirty Harry's in court. We have a host of coaches in the dugout but not one of them a former striker, or even attack-minded midfielder or winger since Irvine left and returned in charge of the kids.
Peter Barry
65 Posted 23/02/2012 at 03:48:22
Another point of some concern is was the job Weir has been given a published post and if so who were the OTHER contenders for this 'VACANCY?????". Or is it as I and many others more than suspect just ANOTHER 'Job for the SCOTTISH' boys.
John Barnes
66 Posted 23/02/2012 at 06:08:16
Harry Redknapp was a right winger, an old fashioned, out and out winger who got twatted in the first minute by hairy arsed full backs. Took corners and swung crosses in ( either from the by line or halfway line depending how hard that 1st minute tackle was !) He's doing OK as a manager considering his playing position dosen' t exist anymore
Jimmy Sørheim
67 Posted 23/02/2012 at 06:41:16
Sam Hoare. You mention watching the reserve games and forming a conclusion based on that.

I think playing for the reserves today is a boring task for most first team players.

One of the reasons for that is players like Saha refused to play there, and Cahill, Neville and Osman are never seen near the reserves. That to me is part of the problem, Moyes does not use the reserve games the way he should.
Also playing Weir is not a good idea, you have to give youth a chance at that level.

Now, on the performance level, this was a mini derby and sometimes that happens, but in all the other games we do see the quality of Barkley, Vellios, Gueye and a few others.

I think that the substitutes need to play in the reserves if they do not play more than 15 minutes during the last Premier League game. No matter what their names are.

I hope there will be a change in the reserves now that Weir has arrived, but it is up to Moyes to let the players on the bench play in the reserves.
Sam Hoare
68 Posted 23/02/2012 at 07:24:15
Jimmy I would never form a conclusion based on one game. It just reminded me how much better the staff know the players form and development than we do.

The trouble about playing senior pros in the reserves is the increased risk of injury I suppose. Seems there's an increased desire to get the 'older' kids out on loan this season, which I think is much better training than playing in the reserves.
James Stewart
69 Posted 23/02/2012 at 15:25:08
It's true in his prime Weir was a class act but he stayed well past his sell by date and became a liability and an embarrassment.

Why on earth do we need more ex defenders on our coaching books! Bring back Kanchelskis!

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads