James McFadden, Scotland & Everton

, 26 February, 28comments  |  Jump to most recent
What is going on with him now?
James McFadden, Scotland and Everton striker.
What's going on with him now? Well, he's trying to get fit, trying to learn the game again, he says. His mind knows what he wants to do but his body hasn't been allowing him to do it. He's at Everton until the summer and who knows after that. Nothing's ruled in and nothing's ruled out. He'd just like to get some game-time before the end of the season.
That's part of a feature in today's Scotsman entitled "James McFadden, Scotland and Everton striker". At least it sheds some light through the mist of silence from official channels that has shrouded the months since he strangely re-joined Everton, ostensibly to provide some much-needed sharp-shooting in Everton's goal-shy strikeforce... or what was left of it after Yakubu, Beckford and Arteta departed last August. More realistically, to occupy the treatment room?

It turns out that McFadden has been on a long and tentative recovery path from a career-threatening knee injury, and last-ditch surgery to repair it back in April of last year. The knee did improve ...

A month passed and the news was better. He'd play again right enough but, when the knee healed, the hamstring went and, when the hamstring was fixed, it was the groin that was the problem. That was a month ago. Felt a twinge in training with Everton and pulled up as a precaution. He was hoping it was nothing but, when your luck is out, it always ends up being something. A tear. Momentum checked. And now here he is on this Thursday afternoon on Merseyside talking about his wretched 18 months, a period that has seen him start the sum total of one game (for Everton against Tamworth in the FA Cup last month) with just two more appearances off the bench. Eighteen months and 77 minutes of football.
The rest of the interview wallows in introspection over more of Scotland's seemingly perennial failures on the football field, but one more paragraph stands out:
"I was definitely trying too hard and it got the better of me. It's not often I can say that, but it definitely did. I wouldn't say I never tracked back [as Levein alleged], but my reaction wasn't great at times when I lost the ball, but it was a reaction of sheer frustration at myself. It wasn't because I was lazy. If you look at my time at Birmingham, that's all I done. Running up and down the line. My football was suffering because all I done was work hard for the team. I would have wanted to talk about it face to face [with Levein], but then I got injured. The frustrating thing for me is that I haven't had a chance to prove everybody wrong.?
To read the full article, click the link below:

Quotes or other material sourced from The Scotsman



Reader Comments (28)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Derek Thomas
1 Posted 26/02/2012 at 07:20:19
When we re-signed him it was mostly wtf but, as ever, there is more behind the scenes than we know about. I hope the Scottish Rooney can make it back to being at least the Scottish Osman, hang on to the cash he's made over the years and keep playing for as long as Weir. Because once you stop...
Peter Barry
2 Posted 26/02/2012 at 10:20:30
So McFadden was injured when Davey recruited him and we also learn that Jelavic was also injured when he signed. So what part of our current crisis lack of strikers and midfield maestros can these two possibly be the solution to?
Nick Entwistle
3 Posted 26/02/2012 at 10:31:07
Crisis?
Gavin Ramejkis
4 Posted 26/02/2012 at 10:31:39
A pointless signing when we made it... and cemented with this article. Since when do Everton, a potless club, need to act on behalf of former players as a medical insurance provider? ? wtf doesn't he pay for his own medical bills? Not like he hasn't earned more money than most on here already.
Dennis Stevens
5 Posted 26/02/2012 at 11:02:27
It sounds as though he's lucky not to be out of the game already.
Arthur Westhead
6 Posted 26/02/2012 at 11:26:08
Bringing McFadden back was a low point for us. I thought it was a joke when I first heard about it.

Disgraceful lack of judgement by Moyes. We have no money, but we must be paying Faddy something, whether it's £1k a week, or £10k. Unless he is here for nothing? Does anyone know?

The amount matters, whatever it is, because we can't afford to waste a pound. He should be paying us. The thought that my ticket money is going into his pocket disgusts me.

Or perhaps Moyes is paying him from his own £3m salary? If he isn't, he should be.
Jimmy Hacking
7 Posted 26/02/2012 at 11:45:16
The problem I have with us re-signing McFadden is that even if he fully recovers, he is barely good enough to play for our reserves.
Amit Vithlani
8 Posted 26/02/2012 at 13:26:01
I watched him a few times for Scotland and us when he played upfront and he was a decent player, but no more. In this day and age you can't be a top striker without pace. Moyes deserves some credit for off-loading him at a healthy profit.

I sense he is coming to the end of the road and would not be surprised if he hangs up his boots at the end of the season.

Mick Davies
9 Posted 26/02/2012 at 16:08:07
"Bringing McFadden back was a low point for us. I thought it was a joke when I first heard about it"
"a pointless signing when we made it . .wtf doesn't he pay for his own medical bills not like he hasn't earned more money than most on here already"?

"The problem I have with us re-signing McFadden is that even if he fully recovers, he is barely good enough to play for our reserves."

Are these comments made by Alzheimer sufferers? The lad has earned this club millions with his transfer and even more with his priceless goals getting us into Europe, goals at Boro, Blackburn and home to Charlton come to mind. 11 goals and almost always played out of position and mostly sub apps.

He's only 28 and yes, he does have problems with motivation and can often be accused of laziness but his talent is beyond doubt. Who else at Everton could have scored that goal v Charlton in such circumstances? Where it gets hypocritical is that all these Moyesites who praise everything he does are questioning his reasoning in bringing a player of his ability on a free! The only problem I see is that the lad is seriously injured and has been for over a year. That is Moyesie's mistake.
Mick Davies
10 Posted 26/02/2012 at 16:23:42
Anyone remember the goal that turned the tie around in Europe, I think it was Metalist Kharkov?
Eugene Ruane
11 Posted 26/02/2012 at 16:40:10
Nothing against him personally, but he's cack.

Mick Davies (224) you say..

"He's only 28 and yes, he does have problems with motivation and can often be accused of laziness but his talent is beyond doubt".

As far as I'm concerned, if his motivation is a problem, I don't give a fuck if he can keepy-uppy a boiled egg the length of Priory road, he's a waste of time imo.

I also think (and this is not just aimed at him) any player getting more than two grand a week to play a game, who is lazy or can't get motivated, needs a fucking good 'talking to'.
Marc Williams
12 Posted 26/02/2012 at 16:46:31
"His mind knows what he wants to do but his body hasn't been allowing him to do it."

I know that feeling!
Thomas Windsor
13 Posted 26/02/2012 at 18:14:37
He would be better off either back in Scotland or the lower leagues here... his days in the Premier League are over. At 28, if he can get fit, and look after himself, he can still earn plenty of cash... but not here.
Arthur Westhead
14 Posted 26/02/2012 at 18:05:17
Mick Davies (224): So, because we sold him at a profit and he scored a few goals for us, we should sign him again, pay his wages (whatever they are?) and give him the best medical treatment?

By that judgement I would rather have Michael Ball and Franny Jeffers back.

If we were Man City with cash to throw away, we could afford to be a charity, but we aren't... and we can't. We sold him four years ago because he wasn't good enough for us (Moyes's decision) and he is certainly no better now.

Signing him is the strangest of all Moyes's signings as he just doesn't fit the profile (fit, motivated, chase all over etc). I just wonder if we pay him only if he plays.

I say again, the thought of my ticket money going in to his pocket disgusts me! If we really needed him, how low we have fallen?
Bob Willis
15 Posted 26/02/2012 at 19:54:17
''The frustrating thing for me is that I haven't had a chance to prove everybody wrong.?

Prove me wrong, Jimmy... just fuck off somewhere else ? you sponger!
Mick Davies
16 Posted 26/02/2012 at 21:57:18
Bob Willis, the biggest sponger at Everton FC is Steve Round. The club has gone downhill since he took over Irvine's job, but I don't hear anyone calling for his head. McFadden gave a lot of us Evertonians some great memories and he is one of ours, he even turned down Celtic to come here again. If he is beyond repair and hasn't grown up yet then the man to blame for bringing him back is the manager.
Andrew Ellams
17 Posted 26/02/2012 at 22:11:24
Mick Davies, not sure if you are new to this site but "Round Out" has been quite a popular opinion for some time now...
Joe McParland
18 Posted 26/02/2012 at 22:11:01
Not my favourite player, but I'm convinced some of the posters on here haven't read the full article. It's like they have read the parts posted above and have finally got the chance to snipe about McFadden that they have waited 6 or so months for!!!
Gavin Ramejkis
19 Posted 26/02/2012 at 22:54:38
Mick, are you for real? He did a job for the club and got a fucking wage for it, there and then... what is this a fucking retirement village? Maybe your use of Alzheimer's was a little close to your home.

I've spent fucking thousands over the years supporting Everton; maybe I should roll up looking for a handout with the nonsense argument I was one of those thousand souls there week-in, week-out, home and away ? and in Europe.

The "one of ours" reads like a sponsored Clinton's Cards message ? save the sentiment for greetings cards and who is blaming McFadden for coming back? If someone is stupid enough to offer you a wage when you are finished, you'd be daft not to take it.
Mike Green
20 Posted 26/02/2012 at 23:10:20
McFadden was one of those players who now and again would do something verging on great and you'd think "This is it... This is it! He's arrived!" ... Then he would revert to type for the next ten games.

If you we're attending your first match you'd be forgiven for thinking his Christian name was For Fuck's Sake rather than James. Having him back feels a bit like a recurrence of genital herpes: embarrassing... fairly painful... but thankfully kept well out of sight. [No offence intended.]
Mark Stone
21 Posted 26/02/2012 at 23:55:00
Haha nicely put Mike! Hope your ok, any gamesfor us to watch in HW coming up?
Roman Sidey
22 Posted 27/02/2012 at 07:46:56
There is one reason, and one reason alone that McFadden was given a spot in our squad this season. Most don't need me to say what that reason is.
Eric Myles
23 Posted 27/02/2012 at 09:03:00
Peter #190, we had to get something for our physios to do with Saha departing.
Mike Green
24 Posted 27/02/2012 at 09:19:01
Hi Mark - nothing that I know of. Have got one eye on West Brom game at Goodison next month, thinking of taking my lad to his first game. Then there's also the possibility of a trip to Wembley..... Once he's got an EFC game under his belt I'll start taking him down the road. Let us know how you're getting on!
Rob Sawyer
25 Posted 27/02/2012 at 13:10:48
Some harsh words posted by some about someone who hasn't dumped on the club. He was OK with us first time round and scored some crackers ? although you got the feeling he was not fulfilling his considerable potential. A lack of pace did not help but also poor decision making on the ball would let him down. Becoming a bit of a target for fan's stick later on did not help either as he was a "confidence player".

Ironically as he reaches what should be his peak years in terms of maturity etc his body has let him down big time. I suspect Moyes was doing a former player a favour by bringing him back to get himself fit again (for probably minimal wages ? structured based on appearances). I wish the guy well and hope that he can get hilmself back to being able to compete at a good standard in England or Scotland.
Trevor Lynes
26 Posted 27/02/2012 at 13:10:49
The whole point is WHY did we bring him back when his money would have kept Pienaar and it smacks of jobs for the boys. Its like Yozzer Hughes "giz a job," I can do that rubbish! We supposedly have very little money for the manager to use to strengthen the squad, yet we provide jobs for Hahnemann, McFadden, Weir etc etc... it's a bloody joke.

We let Ruddy go and he has proved his worth at Norwich while we have Hahnemann and Mucha on the payroll and neither are worth their salaries.

We let Gosling go for free and Pienaar because he was not given pay parity with others at the club... now we sign McFadden et al and they don't play a game hardly.

I suppose we can expect Weir and McFadden on the bench preventing youngsters from getting a look in next. I cannot believe the way this once great club is now being run.
Stephen Kenny
27 Posted 27/02/2012 at 21:36:36
I wish him well but it doesn't change how consistently poor he was.

Blind alleys, poor passing, lack of vision and an appalling injury record first time round.

I hope he is just here to get fit and isn't being paid!
Tom Dodds
28 Posted 28/02/2012 at 00:21:47
Just referring to above posts re Round out (Irvine In), defensive angle yet again.

I keep saying this time and time again on this site, that Moyes should have another 'head' with him, in either Alan Irvine or even Phil Neville (which of course helps with one of his problems!). Otherwise, he will constantly keep placating the stuck-too favourites.

Barkley by the way, was only injured recently. I'll stand by (to the bitter end) my view that the forward progression of the team/tactics and all the future peripheral players would be projected/propelled further to a quicker progression forward, if David Moyes had another tactically yang-minded attacking head to the yin of his defensive nature. Which is why, if you think about it, we are consistently neither quite here nor there, season after season.

Steve Round methinks is a yes-man.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads