Moyes calls for a 20% Pay Cut!

, 4 March, 32comments  |  Jump to most recent
David Moyes has a bold and radical vision for improving the national sport: ?Everyone in the Premier League takes a 20 per cent pay cut to put football finances back on an even keel and allow a significant reduction in ticket prices to make football more affordable for the ordinary fan.?

?Perhaps the 20 per cent suggestion would cause some mayhem,? says Moyes, ?but I think we need to do something serious. People might say it would be harder to attract players to the Premier League, but we have to take responsibility for the long-term health of football.

?Clubs have to control their money properly and only pay what they can actually afford. People have to be held responsible when things go wrong.

?Every family in the country at the moment has to finance correctly. They can't overspend. Why is football different?

?I'd like to see lower ticket prices so that everybody can afford football. We should be filling all the grounds all the time. If people in football took that 20 per cent pay cut, then lower ticket prices could be one direct result. Football's been around for 150 years and it has come a long way, but we have to make sure we don't take it away from its roots. We must not get too far away from people.

?Look at the kids — we've moved too far away from the roots there. I would advocate allowing top young footballers to go back to playing for their school teams. Taking kids out of school, and just playing with other elite youngsters, has affected discipline.

?I think we need to get back to kids growing up normally, not being banned by football clubs from playing other sports, like cricket, at the age of 14. I think that's terrible. Just let kids play.

?We used to talk about ?over-use' injuries in youngsters because they played too much. Now the danger is that they are nearly not playing enough and not playing just for the fun of it.?

Quotes or other material sourced from Sunday Express



Reader Comments (32)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Declan Brown
1 Posted 04/03/2012 at 17:44:52
Give the man credit where it is due.

Good call Davey. Football's finances are on a cliff edge, the sooner the players wages are capped and we get rid of agents in the game the better.

If all clubs could get their wages down by at least 20% it could go a long way to reducing their debts.

Good call Davey, but it's the white elephant in the room and the self serving leeches in the game will be having none of it. But fair play to you for bringing it up.
Matt Traynor
2 Posted 04/03/2012 at 18:04:33
I spotted this article when the BBC featured it. It's stuff like this that makes me realise that Moyes is a man of principles and ethics - he'd no doubt be willing to take that 20% cut himself.

I can actually see something like this happening. Paying exorbitant wages to players takes money out of the game. It's wrong on so many levels that an un-proven 18 year old can be driving around in a Bentley.

I honestly think Financial Fair Play will be watered down and clubs like Man City will use ludicrous sponsorship deals to boost up their income. Chelsea must've spent £50m since Mourihno just hiring and firing managers.

For clubs like Everton, that last season lost £5m without even signing a player, they have to reduce the wage bill. I'd even say go full circle and put a portion of a players wages on bonuses. If half of your salary was dependent on appearances and wins, it might turn some of those draws or defeats to teams we would expect to beat into wins...
Lee Chambers
3 Posted 04/03/2012 at 18:18:28
Top article this Moysey! If only this would happen it would be great for all levels of football. If UEFA & FIFA had any balls they would make these financial fair play rules binding and implement these. It has gone past a joke seeing how many clubs are on the brink of financial ruin. Portsmouth with Trevor Birch as administrator (remember him?!) stating they are paying Premiership wages to a player, Villa reporting a massive loss, Chelski continuing to hire and fire managers and paying out fortunes. It needs some big clubs to be taken to the cleaners, start with Rangers and then what it needs is a Premiership club to go, pity it was not the Red Shite a yer or so ago!
Richard Dodd
4 Posted 04/03/2012 at 19:08:20
As Moyes's self-proclaimed No 1 supporter,I am sure he includes himself in this proposal. But........ If he is REALLY serious then he should announce forthwith that his soon to be signed new contract reflects this gesture.

Talk is cheap but then the football world and its money-crazed inhabitants just MIGHT sit up and take notice. I love you to bits, mate, but talk is cheap ? show them the way!
Tommy Gibbons
5 Posted 04/03/2012 at 19:41:34
I think EFC should go the whole 'hog' with this and renegotiate all the players' contracts so money can be saved, especially as it seems we're not going to get any investment anytime soon! The players do not have any loyalty to the club, they only have loyalty to the money, and before anyone starts to bleat on about losing players, we lose them anyway ? and I'd rather lose them than the club!
Mark Riding
6 Posted 04/03/2012 at 19:50:25
How much is Moyes on then? I'm sure the 20% saving on his weekly salary will go a long way in securing the clubs future...

Nice one, Davey... well done!
Joe McMahon
7 Posted 04/03/2012 at 20:04:12
"We must not get too far away from people"- Too right David, hand back some of your £65,000 a week back to the club then.
Bobby Mallon
8 Posted 04/03/2012 at 20:06:26
Great article, he's changed my view of him, top bloke and speaks lots of sense. Great read.
Ciarán McGlone
9 Posted 04/03/2012 at 20:11:04
Why didn't he put this cunning plan in motion when he negotiated his £70k-a-week pay packet???

Hollow words.
Danny Kewley
10 Posted 04/03/2012 at 20:26:34
Judging by the man's comments, I reckon if he did kick start a fairly revolutionary concept to modern football, he would include himself. The way things are now in this "man-made recession" is going to kill off a lot of clubs! So fair play to D Moyes for thinking outside the box!
Ray Robinson
11 Posted 04/03/2012 at 21:12:53
I agree with Moyes... but this comes at a time when the club has increased season ticket prices by 3%!
Brian Waring
12 Posted 04/03/2012 at 21:16:08
When I win the lottery, I'm going to give half of it to charity.
Tony Cheek
13 Posted 04/03/2012 at 21:35:14
Lead the way then Davey!!! Someone has to be first, show us what you are made of!
Roman Sidey
14 Posted 04/03/2012 at 22:51:38
Very well said, Doddy.

Whoa. I just said that! Since Moyes will probably be signing a new contract soon, it would only be right for him now to be signing for something more like £50k a week.

Credit where it is due. This is a good thing for Moyes to come out and say, but those responses saying that it proves that he is man of integrity and are changing their view of him, I guess you believe that Billy Clinton didn't nail Monica Lewinsky either...
Barry Rathbone
15 Posted 04/03/2012 at 23:01:05
Percentage cuts don't deal with the level playing field problem and whilst applauding entrance fee reduction it does nothing to resolve the "financial league" defining the "Premier league Table".

Y'know when everyone knows who the top 6 is before a ball is kicked ..... or am I in a parallel universe again where 5 quid less to watch the same old shite is just fuckin' fine ?

I'm going to bed.

Matt Traynor
16 Posted 04/03/2012 at 23:27:14
Ciarán (337) - he did, he was offered £85k a week, but only took £70k!
Andy Crooks
17 Posted 05/03/2012 at 00:17:53
What utter nonsense. First of all, I don't begrudge Premier League players their money. They are working class blokes living the dream and paying their taxes. Why are they the only occupation who have their salary quoted in terms of how much per week? It is simply to make other working class folk resent them.

Do we ever hear that a prancing mime such as ,say, Tom Cruise earns £100k per week or that George Gideon Osborne earns zillions per week outside parliament. A pay cap would be unworkable. So Mr Moyes how about a voluntary reduction?

Dave Wilson, tongue in cheek, I'm sure, suggested paying Moyes for the half of the year he is adequate. So cut out the empty sound bites, Mr Moyes, and lead by example.
Michael Coville
18 Posted 05/03/2012 at 02:04:13
Andy Crooks #374.
Tom Cruise is not part of an industry which is going bankrupt so why bring him into the picture. We have old clubs like Portsmouth and Rangers possibly going out of business, and many other clubs have financial problems. Something has to be done otherwise the future looks bleak. How long do you think the Arabs or Russian will stay around if there teams have a restricted fixture list. At least Moyes is making a reasonable suggestion, it might not be the answer but the authorities need to come up with some plan.
Jordan Beagle
19 Posted 05/03/2012 at 06:36:18
Perhaps all the players and staff at Everton should be encouraged to set up a Staff Trust and contribute 20% of their salaries. The trust could then join with Trust Everton in buying Finch Farm or even BK's shares.
Peter Barry
20 Posted 05/03/2012 at 07:43:25
Talk is cheap so let's see you put it in to action, Davey Boy.
Phil Roberts
21 Posted 05/03/2012 at 08:05:52
The person who will lose out the most is us.

Remember, the only money the government have is what they get in taxes. It is ours. And if salaries are reduced by 20%, then 50% of that will be tax so the tax will be 50% lower.

But what the article proves is what I have said for a number of years - David Moyes is a very honest, morally sound guy and someone I would be proud to have as a friend.
Andy Crooks
22 Posted 05/03/2012 at 09:15:43
Michael, I brought Tom Cruise into as an example of someone who doesn't have what he earns described in terms of per week. Bankers are the same. It seems to be exclusively for footballers and is patronising to players and supporters alike.
Ciarãn McGlone
23 Posted 05/03/2012 at 09:25:53
"Tom Cruise is not part of an industry which is going bankrupt so why bring him into the picture."
------------------

Tell that to Wesley Snipes.

The industry isn't going bankrupt. That's pure myth. In fact the industry is growing despite the biggest recession since the start of the century. I expect the next Sky deal to be bigger than the current one..
Brian Harrison
24 Posted 05/03/2012 at 09:28:50
So many great points in what he says, not least youngsters not being allowed to play for their school teams.

I think unless something is done quickly, more and more clubs will be going into administration. I think there are only 10 clubs out of the 92 in league football that arent in debt. That has got to be a worrying statistic, and the major reason for this is undoubtedly players wages.
I see there was a suggestion that to avoid player redundancies at Rangers the players take a 75% pay cut till the season ends.

I was listening to a debate the other day about agents, another group sucking the life blood out of football. I believe that Joey Bartons agent got £800,000 for arranging his transfer to QPR, and this money was paid by QPR surely it should have been Barton who paid him. After all his agent is there working on his behalf so why do QPR have to pay him. I have no qualms about players employing agents, although the PFA are willing to negotiate with clubs on the players behalf for nothing.

Dave Rice
25 Posted 05/03/2012 at 11:47:03
Andy Crooks - perhaps footballers pay is quoted at a weekly rate because the numbers are so big - several million a year is more difficult to relate to a reasonable annual salary.
Paul Ellam
26 Posted 05/03/2012 at 11:53:17
Whether you like him or not, the man is talking sense. I'm glad someone in the football circle has said what most other people think.

And regarding him taking a pay cut ? of course he would, he's not an idiot who puts forward an idea and then does the exact opposite to it!
Steve King
27 Posted 05/03/2012 at 13:20:43
Call me cynical but I'm quite sure that players agents would find a way of re-negotiating contracts so that players would get the 20% back elsewhere.

Good to see we have a manager brave enough to challenge the establishment though.

I agree with Jordan:
"Perhaps all the players and staff at Everton should be encouraged to set up a Staff Trust and contribute 20% of their salaries."

Sadly I believe if Everton were to lead the way....not many would follow.
James Flynn
28 Posted 05/03/2012 at 13:39:34
Players can only earn what a club will pay them. As long as numbskull owners drop ridiculous amounts of cash on no-better-than-average players, soccer will have a problem.

You pay the Messis, Ronaldos, and, even, Rooneys of the world top dollar because they help generate revenue. Why shouldn't they get their cut?

It's all the lesser lights (which is most) paid exhorbitant sums that's causing the problem. And it's one created by the owners, not the players.

I have a great job with the best kind of people. Good pay and "Quality of Life" couldn't be better. But if a company 6 miles down the road offers to double my pay for doing the exact same thing? "Hey guys, I'll stay in touch" and I'm off.

Not my fault someone's overpaying for what I do. And it's not my fault for taking the money. The owners need to be reined in. That happens, the wages will go down as a natural result.
Roman Sidey
29 Posted 05/03/2012 at 15:05:55
If anyone wants to know what is going to happen if they start capping and reducing the amount allowed to pay players, read up on the Australian Rugby League vs Super League war.

We can kiss Merseyside derbies goodbye. No more pushing for European places. We'll end up playing in a league somewhere between Championship and Premier League.
Richard Dodd
30 Posted 05/03/2012 at 15:29:34
But if clubs insist on paying players more than the money they bring in, there can only be one end to it. Bankruptcy!

It`s not the politics of envy for whilst virtually every player in the game must earn more in a week than I do in a year or two.... or three etc, my pay only centres on my ability to find holes to dump rubbish or ships in which to export it. Can`t imagine many of you would pay me to watch me doing that!
.
Jack Molloy
31 Posted 05/03/2012 at 19:47:29
This idea sounds good in a newspaper headline but it is doesn't survive even the most basic analysis. If everyone took a 20% pay cut and the savings were passed on to the consumer in lower ticket prices, the clubs who need money most would benefit the least. The savings would need to be used to pay down debts. Gates would not necessarily increase anyway. Dull, unentertaining football is more responsible for low gates than are high ticket prices. A significant across the board financial overhaul of the whole business is necessary or many clubs will not survive the next decade.
Peter Mills
33 Posted 05/03/2012 at 21:10:29
Roman, you shouldn't introduce Bill and Monica into the debate. Did you never read that the infamous stain on the dress was eventually analysed to be soup? (Cock a leakie...)

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads