Mini-derby ends goaless at Goodison

, 6 March, 37comments  |  Jump to most recent
Plenty of returning talent on display
A pretty strong and experienced Everton Reserves side featured a number of the recovering players David Moyes is hoping to have back fit and ready to face the "terrible" sequence of upcoming first team fixtures in the next couple of weeks. Jagielka, Rodwell, Osman, Coleman and Anichebe all featured along with Barkley, Duffy and McFadden but no-one could break the deadlock against a determined Liverpool side at Goodison Parkin a game that that ended 0-0.

Match Report by Luke O'Farrell

The two team's reserve sides met on Tuesday, although to call Everton's side a reserve team would be stretching the truth somewhat. Nine players in the Everton side boast Premier League experience with the Liverpool team made up entirely of reserve players. Based on the 90 minutes that followed, it was hard to tell which team had the Premier League players in it.

Everton's first and only opening came within the opening minute. Good work by McFadden and Anichebe presented Osman with a chance. The midfielder used his feet well to draw a sharp stop from Brad Jones, with Seamus Coleman's rebound going harmlessly wide. Liverpool's Raheem Sterling showed his potential throughout and was a constant threat to the Everton defence. His first sight of goal came after a driving run with his shot curling just wide.

Seamus Coleman got into some promising situations down the Everton right. Unfortunately, misdirected passes or over hit crosses let the young full back down. His decision-making and final ball was poor throughout the match. Coleman's performance suggests he is still more suited to a full back role. Jagielka showed his defensive class with a great last-ditch tackle preventing a chance for the visitors. Suso had another effort for Liverpool as they began to see more of the ball.

Everton grew into the half with Osman and Barkley looking bright in the final third. Osman produced a smart turn but the Liverpool defence were quick to block his shot. Sterling remained Liverpool's biggest threat and Mucha had to be alert to make a low save from the winger. Sterling forced an even better save from the Slovakian keeper just minutes later as Liverpool began to dominate.

At the other end, Anichebe had a penalty appeal waved away with the forward going to ground too easily. Suso had a low effort for the visitors, which Mucha gathered well. Everton were struggling to keep possession due to Liverpool's pressing game and the poor distribution of Jagielka and Duffy. Liverpool almost took the lead from an Everton corner, as a rapid break found Sterling on the left. His curling effort finally evaded Mucha's grasp but the frame of the goal came to Everton's rescue, this time.

Coleman's ball found McFadden, on the stroke of half-time, but the Scot's header found its way over the bar. The half-time whistle went with Liverpool much happier, due to their inexperienced line-up. Osman had been bright for Everton with Barkley showing slight glimpses of his ability. Sterling and Krisztian Adorjan showed their potential for the visitors with Adorjan looking very assured in possession.

Nathan Eccleston was on hand to fire an effort narrowly wide after cutting in from left. Around the hour mark, Everton's most composed performer, Leon Osman made way for young midfield prospect Francisco Junior. The Portuguese midfielder's cameo proved to be the highlight of the Everton performance. The youngster constantly looked to get on the ball and displayed a good range of passing off either foot. Despite only playing a third of the match, Junior impressed more than the highly rated pair of Rodwell and Barkley.

Eccleston tested Mucha with the Slovakian producing another save, whilst at the other end; Touray's over hit cross almost embarrassed the Liverpool keeper. The Liverpool right back, McLaughlin, produced a fine cross into the Everton area as Liverpool still looked the most likely to score. Thankfully, for the home side, Adorjan missed the ball and Sterling put his effort wide.

Rodwell and Barkley efforts from distance and a Duffy header were all Everton had to show for their second half endeavours. Michael Roberts fired an effort over for Liverpool, from 25-yards, with Mucha beaten. That was the last effort of note as the game fizzled out to its goalless conclusion.

Jagielka and Duffy showed their class defensively but, even at reserve level, their distribution simply isn't good enough. Rodwell remained anonymous throughout and failed to stake his claim for Tottenham on Saturday. McFadden appeared lost on the left of midfield; his second stint at Everton may prove to be a short one. The two young full backs, Browning and Touray, showed signs of promise with Browning tackling well and Touray looking a threat going forward.

Barkley appeared easily frustrated at times, often due to the defence's willingness to bypass the midfield. The youngster will have to learn to go about his business, even if the team is not playing well. The midfield prospect remains a work in progress although there were several flashes of his undoubted potential. Francisco Junior's bright cameo suggests his stay at reserve level could be a short one.

The game time will help the first team players but a bright and purposeful Liverpool side easily outplayed their experienced opponents. Osman aside, Everton's first team players wasted their chance to impress the watching David Moyes.

Player Ratings:

Mucha 8*; Browning 6, Jagielka 6, Duffy 6, Touray 6; Coleman 5, Barkley 5, Rodwell 4, McFadden 4; Osman 7; Anichebe 6.

Subs: Francisco 7, McAleny 6.

Unused Subs: Adam Davies, Joao Silva, Eric Dier.

Quotes or other material sourced from Match Report by Luke O'Farrell



Reader Comments (37)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Yusuf Bobat
1 Posted 06/03/2012 at 14:50:27
Just watched the 1st half on LFC TV & we are being outplayed.
Yusuf Bobat
2 Posted 06/03/2012 at 15:45:12
Absolute garbage from our reserves. Their keeper only had to make 1 save & that was inside the 1st minute. Mucha was our MOM which says it all really. Only the sub Francisco junior impressed me the rest were garbage.
Nick Entwistle
3 Posted 06/03/2012 at 16:04:41
Does it matter?
Sam Hoare
4 Posted 06/03/2012 at 16:07:12
Found a link to watch the second half. Was pretty dissapointed to be honest.

Liverpool dominated and Suso and Sterling looked a class above anyone in blue.

Rodwell and Barkley were pretty quiet in midfield. Jack to be fair is coming back from injury but if Barkley is to deserve the starting place that many on here think he is entitled to then he must surely be dominating at this level. Jags and Duffy looked relatively solid though Liverpool were really only denied the win by Jan Mucha who made a few top notch saves.

Anichebe looked his usual lumbering self, McFadden lost plenty of possesion, Coleman looked ropey defensively when employed at RB though his pace got him out of a scrape or two.

Probably the brightest note was Francisco Junior who I thought looked very composed, picked some good passes and almost scored from range. He reminded me a lot of Manny Fernandes, able to receive the ball in tight space and retain possesion before moving play forward.

On the 45 mins I saw he looks like he deserves to take Neville's place in CM before Rodwell or Barkley.
Yusuf Bobat
5 Posted 06/03/2012 at 16:12:24
Yes every game that everton play whether it 1st team, reserves or youth matters. If we suffer terrible injuries or suspensions it's these players who will have to step up.
Kevin Sparke
6 Posted 06/03/2012 at 16:29:53
It was very clear to me that most Everton first team players were playing at 60% in that game - Rodwell, Osman and Jagielka in particular; probably Barkley also.

I liked the look of Fransisco Junior - looks like he's got plenty of skill and a great first touch.

Mucha looks an adequate replacement for Howard on that showing - he was my Everton Man of the Match.
Thomas Windsor
7 Posted 06/03/2012 at 17:24:57
Just back from the match, I thought Liverpool played some good football at times but, as Kevin says, some Everton players were just having a warm up.

The thing for me though is: Why is McFadden at Everton? He will no longer play again for any Premier League team... he was bad at times, no pace, first touch gone. I hope we are not paying this lad any wages. It does not add up.
Jamie Barlow
8 Posted 06/03/2012 at 17:30:19
Yusuf, what if one of the lads coming back from injury suffers a terrible injury because he was running around and jumping into tackles like it was a first team game?

Playing in the reserves is all about getting your fitness and touch back.
Peter Mills
9 Posted 06/03/2012 at 17:26:10
It was a very poor performance from Everton, with no movement or guile and one man up front for most of the match. Barkley and Rodwell were anonymous, Anichibe was his normal self, McFadden ran up blind alleys. Very tedious display from a team that had 9 players who have appeared for the first team this season.

Sterling was very dangerous for Liverpool, who as team moved quite well, kicked the ball away at free kicks and spoke to the referee to ask for one of our players to be booked. A pretty predictable afternoon all told.
Yusuf Bobat
10 Posted 06/03/2012 at 17:56:53
Point taken Jamie 728 but we didn't do the basics right.
Noel Lynam
11 Posted 06/03/2012 at 18:28:12
To add to Kevin's (702) point, Junior was probably the only one who felt like he had something to prove, which would explain why he stood out.
Graham Mockford
12 Posted 06/03/2012 at 19:22:11
For all the 'Ross Barkley is the answer to all our prayers and should be starting every week' posters, do me a favour and watch the highlights of this game.

I hope he develops into the player we all want but he needs time and proper development and would currently be destroyed playing in the Premier League week-in, week-out.
John Crawley
13 Posted 06/03/2012 at 20:06:03
Graham I haven't read anyone saying that Barkley should be starting every week. Plenty of people saying he should get some game time as a sub, start the occasional game or go on loan.
Graham Mockford
14 Posted 06/03/2012 at 20:15:37
John please you haven't read anyone. Just go and read a few threads or read today's article which clearly points out the club's strategy to Ross's development.
There is a number of people on here always looking for the magic answer normally on unproven players. Sam Hoare #708 is a classic, let's replace a 6 times Prem , CL winner , 59 England caps 250 games for Man U, 200+ games for Everton with a player who for 45 mins in a reserve game showed some promise..... absolutely priceless.
James Stewart
15 Posted 06/03/2012 at 20:31:16
not excited by any of those "first team" players returning at all.
Paul Thompson
16 Posted 06/03/2012 at 20:44:08
Only watched the first 60 minutes as I was at work. But during that time we were mostly outplayed. Suso (Spanish by the way) in midfield for Liverpool was so far ahead of Barkley and Rodwell it was embarassing. Sterling looked so much more acccomplished than Anichebe (not very difficult admittedly). Coleman's qualities and (mostly) limitations looked exactly the same as when he plays for the first team.

Now it may be that playing a 'strong' team in which half the players were getting their fitness back isn't a a fair test of normal reserve capabilities. And some of the younger players did ok. But I'd hoped for better (and it seems I missed a good performance from Junior).
Sam Hoare
17 Posted 06/03/2012 at 20:57:56
Graham mockford, did you actually read my post? I said he deserved it before Rodwell and Barkley. Not the same as saying he should be played.

If you're gonna bother with your patronising laying out of stats at least do it against someone who actually disagrees with you...
Andy Crooks
18 Posted 06/03/2012 at 21:06:37
Graham, what is the relevance of Phil Neville's past record to Sam's post?. His best days are well and truly behind him, we haven't the money to spend big ; therefore at some stage he's going to be replaced by a young player. In my view that time has come, he is emergency cover at full back at best.
Graham Mockford
19 Posted 06/03/2012 at 21:10:44
Sam so when you said he deserved it before Rodwell and Barkley what you really meant was he doesn't deserve to replace Phil Neville but he deserves something he doesn't deserve more than Rodwell and Barkley?
Yusuf Bobat
20 Posted 06/03/2012 at 21:16:34
Problem with having Neville in midfield is he provides no attacking threat which then puts more pressure on fellaini to be the spark.
Graham Mockford
21 Posted 06/03/2012 at 21:16:51
Andy correct at some stage yes but the reason for quoting his record versus a complete and utter unknown quantity is the PL is a tough place and I would contend he still has the required nous and ability to do a job. It's just that he does one of those jobs that mainly goes unappreciated by most and provides leadership to those around him. Fortunately DM completely gets it, as for that matter did Harry Redknapp who only a year ago wanted to buy him.
Paddy Gillen
22 Posted 06/03/2012 at 21:27:41
Is this Junior lad left footed? I want to know more about him, he is just a central midfielder?
Yusuf Bobat
23 Posted 06/03/2012 at 21:29:18
Junior looked right footed & is regarded as a defensive midfielder but he has something about him that I liked. Looked very comfy on ball and had an eye for a pass.
Paddy Gillen
24 Posted 06/03/2012 at 21:34:25
Cheers Yusuf. My initial thought is how has an Everton reserve team that strong not managed to beat that lot?
Yusuf Bobat
25 Posted 06/03/2012 at 21:39:02
Liverpool lads looked a lot better on the ball, had pace & good movement plus they looked up for it unlike our lot who seemed to be going through motions.
Graham Mockford
26 Posted 06/03/2012 at 21:34:25
Just thought for fun I'd pick my favourite TW Dream Team based on some of the more outlandish posts I read around here

Mucha
Coleman
Duffy
Distin
Baines
Drenthe
Barkley
Junior
Baxter
Velios
Staquerlersi

Manager Ian Holloway
Chairman anyone other than Bill

Apologies to Sylvan and Leighton even on here you don't get any stick!
Stephen Kenny
27 Posted 06/03/2012 at 21:43:46
Distins shite and Baines can't defend!!!
Andy Crooks
28 Posted 06/03/2012 at 21:51:08
Bloody good side, Graham. Glad you see it at last.
James Martin
29 Posted 06/03/2012 at 22:16:13
Funy that Suso or Sterling (their academy products that they bought off other teams) have barely been in Liverpool's first team. They've struggled for goals yet haven't had a sniff, not even a substitute performance, and they'v ehad their bacsides handed to them by just about every team in that next gen tournament but have somehow survived thanks to the format of tournament football and a special dispensation. Rodwell on the othe rhand ha sbeen regularly playing in the premier league against far superior players and had his form recognised by an England cap. Barkley's also been in our first team and ha starred for England often being the best player in the age group above him. But yes, I'm sure on the evidence of this one reserve game Sterling and Suso are miles ahead of Rodwell and Barkley.
Graham Mockford
30 Posted 06/03/2012 at 22:26:16
James it is traditional to press the space bar in between words but I think I understan dwhat you ar esaying
Graham Mockford
31 Posted 06/03/2012 at 22:26:16
James it is traditional to press the space bar in between words but I think I understan dwhat you ar esaying
Jason Chew
32 Posted 07/03/2012 at 00:44:24
The ref for the game is obviously a red. A few dangerous tackles from behind, including 1 2-footed studds up lunge at Faddy went unpunished, whereas Junior was booked for a 50-50 (and he made contact with his trailing leg only because of his momentum). Granted it took Sterling at the knee of his standing foot but it was a knee to knee clash, and if a 2-footed tackle deserves just a firm word, then why should he get a yellow? Blatant handball in their box towards the end right in front of the ref also was waved off.

Yes it is a reserves game, but it is also a derby, and for the reserves, this is their derby, so there is no reason for looking so disinterested. The game was played at GP, how often will the reserves get to play there this season? With so many first-teamers watching, the only players who really showed up were the returning regulars (Jags and Osman). Faddy might have lost the ball more often than the rest, but only because he wanted the ball in the first place! Our left back Touray was mediocre, to put it nicely, and Ty Browning left Seamus with nowhere to go often, by passing the ball to him when he's right on the line and tightly marked by a Red. We really need cover for Baines, and fast.
Eric Myles
33 Posted 07/03/2012 at 01:18:37
So a team consisting of 7 of our experienced first team regulars were outplayed by a bunch of schoolkids?
Sam Hoare
34 Posted 07/03/2012 at 08:02:11
Graham I think you are pretending to be stupid when you are not.

Let me explain. What I wrote is called a comparison. It's when you compare two or more things to another. In my case it was Barkley, Rodwell and junior.

In the same way as I might say that on the basis of this season that hodgson would deserve to replace moyes above Coyle and Martinez, I do not necessarily believe that moyes should be replaced it is simply a comparison of three candidates.
Billy Bradshaw
35 Posted 07/03/2012 at 08:46:01
Just got back from the match and Liverpool were much the better team.

Unfortunately the stiffs play exactly the system as the first team which leaves centre forwards isolated and fighting for scraps. Coleman and McFadden did little to get you excited with the latter overwieght and slow, centre-halves who regularly hump it forward because the players are coached to do so.

Barkley was poor giving the ball away in bad areas and didn't look as if he has the energy to chase back or close down, only came to life when he had the ball at his feet.

The new signing little junior looks very lightweight but has a nice touch, can't see how Moyes would ever play a player of this stature in the middle of the park, it takes him all his time to play Osman there.

Overall a disapointing performance with so many first team players on show, Rodwell, Jagielka and Osman look ready to step up to the first team.
Roman Sidey
36 Posted 08/03/2012 at 12:50:32
Graham, because a few people have said that Francisco looks good in the reserve games they've seen him in, that means that some outlandish posters on here think he should be starting for the first team? I may have missed something, but I don't recall ever reading someone saying they thought the lad should be in our first 11.
Graham Mockford
37 Posted 10/03/2012 at 05:55:44
Roman last sentence # 708

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads