Blue Union calls off Spurs protest

, 9 March, 105comments  |  Jump to most recent
A protest planned for the Spurs match has been called off by the Blue Union after 'significant fan feedback' via their various constituent member groups. The reason given being that the team is now doing well and now is not the time...

Excerpts from the Blue Union statement

The organisation of Saturday's planned protest began in earnest following The Blue Union's third and most recent public meeting, during which a clear consensus of opinion was reached amongst those in attendance that further positive action was supported, and that the nature of that action needed to be taken to ?the next level?.

Since that meeting however, David Moyes and the players have managed to effect a significant upturn in form that now offers us the outside chance of UEFA Europa League qualification via the Premier League and, perhaps more significantly, has taken us to a very winnable FA Cup quarter-final at home to Sunderland, with the carrot of a mouth-watering return to Wembley that all of us so desperately crave.

With such a significant period of the season now upon us, it would be remiss of us to ignore the wave of feeling that has become apparent over the past few weeks, and indeed the personal feelings of the majority of our officers, all of which together are telling us, very clearly that ?now is the time for unified support, not protest?.

The future of our great football club remains of paramount importance to all involved with The Blue Union and our supporters should be assured that a short-term upturn in results on the field will not in any way divert our attention from the cold hard facts of the precarious situation that Bill Kenwright and his board have put the club in off it.

Quotes or other material sourced from The Blue Union



Reader Comments (105)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Chris Morris
1 Posted 09/03/2012 at 15:16:52

So the Blue Union have cancelled their protest tomorrow because the team is doing well. It doesn?t look good for a protest group to not protest does it? Their motto of putting the team first is admirable, but the change in tack because they fancy a jolly day out at Wembley kind of makes them laughable in people's eyes.

Guess what......... I only shout at the dog when he?s been naughty!!!

Brian Waring
2 Posted 09/03/2012 at 15:20:27
It doesn't look very good them calling it off.

It's like there saying "We'll only protest when we're shit."
Lee Courtliff
3 Posted 09/03/2012 at 15:24:04
This looks very, very bad for them. It's almost embarrassing.

What if we get stuffed by Spurs? Will they protest at the Sunderland game?
Phil McKeown
4 Posted 09/03/2012 at 15:22:53
I was on the marches and I believed in what was trying to be achieved.

I can see the reasoning by trying to eliminate negativity through a vital point in the season.

It's a lose-lose situation; on one hand it will create negative opinion that they are protesting when things have changed (temporarily or not) for the better... and on the other it will get a reaction like already demonstrated above .

Personally I think it's a mistake, the line was crossed and it needed to be pursued if that's what the Blue Union believe in.
Denis Richardson
5 Posted 09/03/2012 at 15:24:41
Agree Brian, the underlying reason to protest was to effect change in ownership. A couple of decent results on the pitch should not in any way change this.

Although it may have seemed a bit odd to protest when the team was playing 'reasonably' well, it would have driven the message home that the protests are independent of what is going on on the pitch.

Anyway, it is what it is. I assume we'll get back to protesting if the results are bad in the next 3-4 games.
Chris Morris
6 Posted 09/03/2012 at 15:36:20
Denis . "I assume we'll get back to protesting if the results are bad in the next 3-4 games."

Why? Why not use your energy to support the team?

The Union isn't united at all.
Paul Hardcastle
7 Posted 09/03/2012 at 15:32:33
So it's a little confusing for someone on the fence about this lot. I could understand it if they acknowledged that the stagnation they oppose has somehow changed... and perhaps a case can be made that indeed it has over the past months ? new players in; Inner Circle Sports...

But to make no reference to that and instead call it off because the team is doing better, and claim that the fundamental problems still exist seems to play into the hands of the Blue Union opponents, who I'm sure will have a field day over this U-turn.
Lee Smith
8 Posted 09/03/2012 at 15:36:57
Pretty gutted about this in all honesty. I hardly ever get to Goodison as it's almost a 600-mile round trip for me, but had chosen to make this game my first home game of the season primarily so I could attend the BU protest. Had a feeling this was going to happen due to the total lack of info coming from the BU. Shame.
Brian Waring
9 Posted 09/03/2012 at 15:39:08
Chris, I think it was a bit of sarcasm from Denis.

By the way, I back the Blue Union 100%, just think this is a bad move.
Chris Morris
10 Posted 09/03/2012 at 15:42:03
Denis I apologise because I read your message literally. Having re-read it I see the sarcasm. Sorry
Mike Rourke
11 Posted 09/03/2012 at 15:41:25
"We'll only protest when we're shit."

Actually, that's a pretty good strapline.
Steve Guy
12 Posted 09/03/2012 at 15:38:18
The BU are saying that (as they always have) we support the Team and the Manager but not the Board. So to say "now is the time for unified support, not protest? is I think an admirable position at the start of a week which will define our season in both the League and Cup. To have done otherwise would have left them open to further criticism and played into the hands of the Board and Billy BS.

The problems won't go away because of a few (hopefully) good results, but further protest needs to be strategically positioned to have maximum inpact on the Board and minimal impact on the Team.
Chris Morris
13 Posted 09/03/2012 at 15:43:47
Lee Smith... you wanted to make this your first home game PRIMARILY to join the BU(llshit) protest?
Brian Waring
14 Posted 09/03/2012 at 15:49:21
Steve, whilst its 'Admirable ' but, as mentioned above, the fans who are against them will have a field day with this. It will just make them look fickle.
Lee Smith
15 Posted 09/03/2012 at 15:49:25
Chris Morris, wrong choice of words there. It was more a case of 'two birds with one stone'. As I said, I get to Goodison very rarely, so wanted to be able to time my trip up there with the protest. I will of course still be in the stadium behind the Blues as much as I would have been, protest or no protest.
Steve Guy
16 Posted 09/03/2012 at 15:52:48
I agree Brian @329, but I think this was the best course for the longer term and helps them keep to the higher ground.

The naysayers on this site and elsewhere tend to have a go regardless and I definitely prefer that the BU don't give the Board any ammo, as opposed to worrying about supporters who haven't yet woken up to what's going on.......I'll get my tin hat and body armour......
Brian Waring
17 Posted 09/03/2012 at 15:57:53
In a way, the BU are in a no-win situation Steve. If they protest, the lads who are against them will have a pop, and with them deciding not to protest, the lads who are against them will still have a pop.
Chris Morris
18 Posted 09/03/2012 at 15:58:46
Steve Guy... You don't need to be a naysayer when the BU have done it themselves. They look ridiculous now.
Steve Guy
19 Posted 09/03/2012 at 16:00:42
Hi Chris, we'll have to disagree I'm afraid and leave it at that.
GJ Butler
20 Posted 09/03/2012 at 15:54:52
Shocking decision. I'd imagine they'll lose a lot of support over this. Either you're unhappy with the current board/ownership or you're not ? the results of the team are ironically irrelevant.
John Keating
21 Posted 09/03/2012 at 16:02:36
Fully support the aims of the BU but think this is a grave mistake. Support for the team has always been a priority; pressure on the Board of Directors should have been maintained until their entrenched position moved.
Denis Richardson
22 Posted 09/03/2012 at 16:11:23
Sorry Chris, was meant to be sarcastic (although even that is a bit unfair admittedly).
Barry Rathbone
23 Posted 09/03/2012 at 16:10:55
I support the BU and in all honesty I'm staggered by the vilification they receive.

I thought putting their head above the parapet rather than whining like every man and his dog would have ignited a fire ? particularly after the Kenwright 'expose'.

Anything but... our fans are not arsed, or they are content; BK must laugh his socks off ? no wonder he says other clubs wish they were like us.

The glee on here, people can't wait to put the boot in.
Mick Gallagher
24 Posted 09/03/2012 at 16:25:48
Let's hope the team do kick on and win the FA Cup, then hopefully someone will buy us from Mr Bullshit himself.

Fully support the Blue Union ? just hope this doesn't backfire.
Jimmy Kelly
25 Posted 09/03/2012 at 16:30:24
Steve, I would have thought this was actually playing into Kenwright's hands.

He can now say, "Look, it's nothing to do with me at all ? they just protest when we lose." If it was me, that's what I'd be saying, and that the march had been cancelled as they knew there would be nobody on it, because people only joined in because they were annoyed with performances.

(I should clarify this isn't necessarily my opinion, but it does look bad.)
Neil Humphreys
26 Posted 09/03/2012 at 16:31:22
I understand their sentiment, but they have just essentially commited hari-kiri.... A single issue group has to be relentless in its objective or it leaves itself open to division and collapse. Much as I agree with their views, I think they should have been more aggressive with bi-weekly marches sooner.

They have just collapsed and allowed Kenwright off the hook yet again. That bloke has more lives than a bloody cat...
Richard Dodd
27 Posted 09/03/2012 at 16:37:09
Never agreed with the marches but it just proves that as long as the TEAM are doing well, nothing else really matters to the fans. It was probably ever thus and it will require a relegation battle ? which we all abhor ? to focus hearts and minds on the Blue Union cause.
Stephen Kenny
28 Posted 09/03/2012 at 16:42:13
Moyes commented a while back the natives will always get restless but a few good wins will sort that.

At the time, I ridiculed him for it and assumed the BU had a greater sense of purpose, which I bought into. It appears he was right and I owe him another apology.

They now look like a fairweather fan group and will look ridiculous should they try to protest again this season. Our season could be in the gutter in the space of 10 days.

Two good wins and a cup quarterfinal has not dulled my anger at a board who are ruining my club.

IMO a terrible decision.
Ciarán McGlone
29 Posted 09/03/2012 at 16:51:59
The team may be doing well, but we're still in financial shitstreet..

Frankly, this is pathetic. Either you have a consistent protest, until the end-game ? or you don't bother.
Jamie Barlow
30 Posted 09/03/2012 at 16:44:15
Steve @326, I agree 100%.
Robby Daniels
31 Posted 09/03/2012 at 16:36:54
The BU have decided not to protest in this defining month for the team, so as not to detract. If the BU protested and we had got beat by Spurs and Sunderland, people would have laid the collapse of our season at their feet.

BU have already effected change since they began, the purchase of the January signings, loan deals, would not have taken place, imo, if there wasn't a protest group putting pressure on the board.

Inner Circle Sports, whom the BU suggested, have now been brought on board, to help search for investment ? would this have happened without BU? (Keith Harris, anyone??)

Even this week, Walter Smith made reference to the state of our clubs finances ? two brushes with administration... News to us all, no doubt. The BU are here to stay until the club is in better hands with a forward plan. But, above all, they are true fans who only want the best for Everton.

There will be plenty of large protests in the future, until Kenwright and Sir Phillip Green, and the other Spurs fan, Planet Earl of Hollywood, have nothing to do with our club. In such a small timescale, the BU have unmasked these rouges, and the club are now aware they are being scrutinised at every dodgy deal.

All hail the Blue Union.... god knows were we would be without them.
Shaun Brennan
32 Posted 09/03/2012 at 16:56:48
Protest is off because the team are doing well.

How fickle can you be?
Chris Morris
33 Posted 09/03/2012 at 16:56:50
What's that in the distance???

It's the BU running away with their tails between their legs and leaving their principles behind...
Anthony Hawkins
34 Posted 09/03/2012 at 16:54:52
Have I missed the point of the protests? I thought they were about the mis-management of the club? I haven't seen anything change other than results on the field, so why cancel the protest???

I initially believed in the cause then some weird decisioning happened and the focus shifted for the group. Now I do not understand what the group is trying to achieve.

Talk about shooting yourselves in the foot!
Paul Jamieson
35 Posted 09/03/2012 at 17:10:27
I'm not speaking on behalf of the Blue Union or anything but I?ve heard they?ve done this for a very good reason which is slightly more important to them than Everton just bringing in the company they suggested last year.

Don?t be so quick to criticise, I?ve met them many times and they?re a bunch of decent blues who aren?t going to jeopardize the change that they?ve campaigned for by doing the wrong thing at the wrong time.
Robby Daniels
36 Posted 09/03/2012 at 17:12:44
Paul,

I've actualy heard the same whisper... and, if the Blue Union fuck it up, they would get slaughtered.....
Robby Daniels
37 Posted 09/03/2012 at 17:16:06
Paul @371

The point of the protest was to get the club to bring in professionals to effect change, the club have listened and done this.
Tom Hughes
38 Posted 09/03/2012 at 16:46:00
The BU never said that they would protest at every game... that does not mean that their stance hasn't been just as relevant and justified at the games when no march was organised, and that remains the case.

At the time of the last meeting there was no real indication that this period and sequence of games would be so pivotal. The BU are conscious of the heightened importance of these games, sensitive to the accusation of negativity and have adjusted their approach accordingly... in the certain knowledge that they will be slated by some either way.

Timing is very important... and no doubt the right opportunity will present itself in the coming weeks and months... as the real issues regain prominence as they inevitably must!
Shaun Brennan
39 Posted 09/03/2012 at 17:18:36
Paul (371)

Would you care to divulge us with this information?

At the moment we can only go with what we have been given.
Robby Daniels
40 Posted 09/03/2012 at 17:18:18
Paul @371,

The club have appointed professionals as the Blue Union demanded and possibly more if the rumours are true?
George McKane
41 Posted 09/03/2012 at 17:19:59
Anyone interested in asking a few questions about Everton fans, seeing matchday atmosphere live and chatting to a few BU members then see my comments on the Bulletin Board - - Overseas fans
Mick Gallagher
42 Posted 09/03/2012 at 17:37:54
Chris #369

Get grip of yourself mate with comments like that are you still in the school yard. What the Blue Union has done in few months is highlight the problems with in the club. Then again you probably think everything is perfect and there is nothing wrong with the club.
Dan Brierley
43 Posted 09/03/2012 at 17:12:54
"BU have already effected change since they began, the purchase of the January signings, loan deals, would not have taken place, imo, if there wasn't a protest group putting pressure on the board."

Funniest thing I have read for a long time. The BU now pull the strings on club transfers? It's statements like this, that really make people laugh at the BU and give them no credibility.

I think there are some good guys representing the BU, with clear views. But there are also a lot of bellends mixed in, tarnishing the overall image with ridiculous statements.
Robby Daniels
44 Posted 09/03/2012 at 18:00:28
Dan,

The BU were campaigning for the club to put the sale of the club in professional hands, and even named Inner Circle Sports as a company they wanted, Kenwright wanted Orville the duck.

They have now took on board the BU opinions and implemented them, with appointing Inner Circle Sports.

Also there are a lot of bellends on here spouting shite...

There is another reason for the protest to not go ahead, as you will no doubt find out a bit later, then you may stop slagging them and realise they did what was right.
Kevin Sparke
45 Posted 09/03/2012 at 18:03:07
Blue Union is the expression of a bunch of concerned Evertonians and as such should be applauded. Personally, I think they'll make no difference whatsoever to any decision making at the club.

However, good luck to them and I welcome their sensible decision to suspend their protests whilst the team has so many important games coming up and it looks like we might have turned a corner.
Liam Appleby
46 Posted 09/03/2012 at 18:13:42
It's a shame the dockers who went on strike fighting for their cause didn't take a similar approach to the Blue Union... "They have changed the biscuits in the canteen and got new toilets, so things are looking better. Let's go back to work." #heroicstuff
Richard Reeves
47 Posted 09/03/2012 at 18:18:15
Don't know if this is the right decision but you can understand the reasoning. Most of the herd in the stadium think the BU are troublemakers so this march would be seen as doom-mongoring.

Richard Dodd ? I think in all the years that I've been on this site that is the only thing you've said that I agree with although I must add that there is another thing that would push some to focus on the BU cause and that's if them lot over the park started winning silverware regularly...

I don't feel well.
Chris Morris
48 Posted 09/03/2012 at 18:45:37
Mick 380... Nonsense, the problems were apparent anyway. The BU have done nothing but prove they are fair weather protesters.
Neil Steele
49 Posted 09/03/2012 at 18:46:06
If half of the people who talk such a good game on these websites were interested in protesting... then it would be happening.

The turnout for the last one was disheartening to say the least, and common sense tells you that the apathy towards a protest at this point would have been far greater than it was then.

How do you have a protest with no people because they can't be bothered to get off their arses and turn up... I've yet to hear anyone answer that one?

All of these fan sites are the same in part, in that they are absolutely riddled with people who can talk for England but, when it comes down to it, are all mouth and no trousers.

The lads who have put their own time and money into organising these things have been let down by thousands of apathetic Blues who claim to want change, but who can't be bothered to attend a meeting on a Wednesday night, or who are too precious to march with them on a Saturday afternoon.

Anyone spitting bile, you stand up and tell me what YOU have done. If bullshit were currency we wouldn't need a sheikh the way some of our fans go on. Makes me sick.
John Crossley
50 Posted 09/03/2012 at 18:51:33
A mature and sensible decision, fair play to the Blue Union, not an easy decision to make, they must have known of the shit they would get in some quarters.
Barry Rathbone
51 Posted 09/03/2012 at 19:03:28
Neil Steele

Well said, it needed saying as well.
Mick Gallagher
52 Posted 09/03/2012 at 19:11:36
Chris #391 Why didn't you tell everyone all this sooner instead of waiting for a group of fair-weather protesters to tell us???

Neil Steele, well said mate. The worse part of the last march were people drinking outside alehouses clapping instead of marching ? sums things up.
Robby Daniels
53 Posted 09/03/2012 at 19:19:37
Neil Steele,

Spot on, nail right on the head,

Well said, sir.
Chris Morris
54 Posted 09/03/2012 at 19:36:01
The only thing it sums up is that people would sooner drink than walk with a group of people that protest when the team is doing badly and can't be bothered protesting when there's a scent of a day out at Wembley!! Hypocrites.
Chris Jones [NZ]
55 Posted 09/03/2012 at 19:52:34
Is there time and enough interest to consider mounting a demonstration against the Blue Union's decision to cancel the demonstration?

I'll get me scarf...
Mike Allison
56 Posted 09/03/2012 at 19:47:49
I don't 'fully' support the Blue Union but am still staggered by the vilification they receive. I see honest blues giving up time and money for a club they love and have supported (financially as much as anything else) for years. I'm not sure they're going the right way about it, and I don't know what the consequences of their actions will be, but I fully respect that they are bothering to do something.

I also agree (Brian Waring, 333) that they are basically in a no-win situation, and that actually, if you're serious about effecting change, then now IS the time to protest, and that it WILL have far more impact as it won't just be a bunch of disgruntled supporters moaning about some bad results. Surely the national media would look into the boardroom more seriously if the protests come when results on the pitch are half decent?

I also think the BU have put pressure on the club, and this MAY have contributed to January's relatively useful transfer window (although its easy enough to argue that it was obvious something had to be done and it would have happened anyway).

All in all though, I think they are right not to protest now, as whatever the logic, perception is everything, and I think they would lose support because it would come across as trying to make trouble at a crucial time, and could therefore harm their long term aims.
Mick Gallagher
57 Posted 09/03/2012 at 20:02:34
Well, Chris... What would you have done to highlight the problems at the club??
Chris Morris
58 Posted 09/03/2012 at 20:09:36
The question should be: What have the BU done to highlight problems that the Liverpool Echo failed to highlight years before?

Answer.................. Nothing
Bob Willis
59 Posted 09/03/2012 at 19:45:49
Now what about organising a BIG march at Wembley - sorted!!

Any takers - we can all march down Wembley Way and sing 'Grand 'ol Club'
'We shall not be moved' and whistle 'Z-cars. Oh aye & Kenwright out! & Moyes Out!

OoRrr - how about looking the other way - and facing reality
Dan Brierley
60 Posted 09/03/2012 at 20:07:20
Mike, this is where I struggle. The BU tell us that they are trying to find a new owner, due to the lack of investment by the current owner, and the poor business management resulting in our difficult financial situation. Which is fine for me.

Yet they shout from the tree tops when the club spends money, that they were responsible. I thought they were telling us, that we were in debt up to our eyeballs? If so, why are they 'forcing' the club to spend money we apparently don't have, thus making our financial woes worse? And even more so, being proud of it!! If we are in financial shit street, where is the logic in pressuring the club to spend money? Surely it should be the opposite?

This is why I struggle to support them, the agenda seems weak at best. 'Let go if you love the club', I need something a bit more substantial than pitch forks and torch type protests.

The money spent in January, was on the back of the sale of Bily and letting Saha go. Hardly rocket science. Are the BU going to claim responsibility for those transfers also?
Robby Daniels
61 Posted 09/03/2012 at 19:58:49
I would like to say that all these fans that are disparaging the Blue Union, and clearly getting off on it, makes me sick.

We all support the same thing: EVERTON, why do people knock honest Evertonians for highlighting and protesting about the state of our club?

If you don't want to protest fine, if you aren't happy that the club is in financial meltdown fine, protest.

But to slag a group of Evertonians off for wanting better and exposing the true state of the club is disgraceful.

Shame on you.
Barry Jones
62 Posted 09/03/2012 at 20:24:57
Think they?ve made a good decision and also think there?s more to it from what I?ve heard from a few places this week. I have a feeling that those quick to have a go at the Blue Union will be regretting their actions in the future as there's proof that their demands for change are being met and not just with the clear admission that Inner Circle Sports have become involved. I wonder why some Evertonians just won?t give credit where credit?s due?
John Keating
63 Posted 09/03/2012 at 20:24:23
Dan.

Didn't know the BU were trying to find a new owner - first I've heard
Didn't know they were shouting from the tree tops about spending money.
Didn't know they forced the club to spend money they didn't have.
Didn't know they were making our financial woes worse and being proud of doing so.
Didn't know one man was capable of talking so much shite!
Mick Gallagher
64 Posted 09/03/2012 at 20:42:56
No Chris, I'm asking what would you do to highlight the problems, as you're quick to slag the lads at Blue Union and anyone who supports them.
Robby Daniels
65 Posted 09/03/2012 at 20:57:06
Chris,

I've never seen the Echo highlight that we don't own the Megastore or the Car park?

What are you drinking?

Gis a bottle....
Andy Crooks
66 Posted 09/03/2012 at 20:56:31
I recently posted that Moyes has saved Kenwright again, Well he certainly has. I fear that the double act are here to stay.

I was wholeheartedly behind the aims of the Blue Union and respected their decision to focus on off field matters. This is a truly baffling and credibility shattering move.
Stephen Kenny
67 Posted 09/03/2012 at 20:57:02
Barry,

I'm not a fan of this decision but the thing I like and will always respect about the BU and KEIOC is that none of them are even seeking credit. They are just doing what they feel needs to be done for the club we all love.
Derek Thomas
68 Posted 09/03/2012 at 21:27:39
What do we want??

KENWRIGHT OUT!

When do we want it??

Furtive looks, mumblings, no go on you say it, no you, lots of iPod calender consultings, I can do Friday week, How are you fixed? looking around, shuffling of feet, trying to not look like you're siddeling away.

From Kenwright Towers can be heard the faint sound, laughter growing slowly louder... ha ha ha ha HA HA HA
Robby Daniels
69 Posted 09/03/2012 at 21:59:42
Not really, Derek.

The laughter you can hear is people laughing at you as the Blue Union have never said Kenwright out, and why would Bill be laughing at someone Everton takes advice from?

Stop putting shite out there when it's not true.
Richard Dodd
70 Posted 09/03/2012 at 22:54:07
Guess the marches will re-start as soon as we lose a couple!

Unless and until there is a realistic alternative to the Kenwright board nothing CAN happen. They control the purse strings and as long as they work within the parameters set out by the banks and pay creditors ? especially the Revenue ? it will remain their train set.

In short, MOYES has seen off the opposition for Kenwright ? which will probably merit a 20% rise ? and, splendid fellow that he is, he will probably forego it!
Mike Allison
71 Posted 09/03/2012 at 23:19:29
Equally, Robby, you might just as well say, "If you slag off people who think the BU are harming the club and say so, then shame on you". It's not shame on anyone; people are allowed to disagree... none of this is personal, it's people differing over what's best for the club.

I defend the Blue Union in trying to do something that they think is for the best, but somebody may passionately believe the club is far better off without protest groups and discord of the like the BU represent, so they can say what they think too.

It's not disgraceful to slag off the BU if you think they're harming the club, clearly from your point of view it's the right thing to do. You might just as well say it's disgraceful to slag off the board in public protests, but it's not if you genuinely believe that's what's best for your club as the BU do.

What we definitely don't need is Blues trying to pick fights with each other and tell each they're disgraceful or shameful. Accept that people may have different strategies to each other but all want the same thing. No-one should be sure their way is right (and if they are then they've lost their position of reason and rational thought) and we should constantly reassess our position with the club in mind, not proving we were right all along.
Eddy Bernard
72 Posted 09/03/2012 at 23:28:43
As someone who is not an active BU member but who has some sympathys with its aims, I think this decision is a big mistake.

If the club is being poorly run in a business and administartive sense by Kenwright and Co then it is being run poorly irrespective of what happens on the pitch.

Rightly or wrongly, it's always been the case that most fans are not interested in how the club's run as long as the team is doing well on the pitch; now unfortunately it looks like the BU are taking the same view.
Robby Daniels
73 Posted 09/03/2012 at 23:33:38
Fair point Mike, I stand corrected, but some of the responses haven't been that fair.

It's okay to agree or disagree, but why be abusive to fans, we all want whats best,

Think Dan said 'bellends', trying to get a rise out of people?

I wasn't slagging anyone off, just think it's a bit off when people don't understand the full facts and think it's okay to disparage honest fans.

Chris Morris is a wind-up, he is obviously getting some sort of sexual satisfaction because there won't be a protest?

There are other factors why the BU aren't protesting, and when the likes of Chris see these he may change his opinion, although I doubt it.

See your point though.
Michael Kenrick
Editorial Team
74 Posted 10/03/2012 at 00:35:30
Yea, Robby, I'm a bit surprised just how personally you've reacted to what are mostly reasonable posts on this topic. You've been one to throw it far and wide yourself in the past, so perhaps a bit of it is coming back to bite you on the arse.

But that doesn't concern me so much as this 'hinted knowledge' bullshit: "There are other factors why the BU aren't protesting." ? What exactly are you on about? It's pretty crass to post that kind of teaser. Either share what you know or belt up about it.
Derek Thomas
75 Posted 10/03/2012 at 00:35:26
Robbie Daniels 440; yes I knew that. But the whole point wouldn't work without the unspoken 4th line NOW! Let's try it your way...

What do we want??

(Bill) Let go if you love the Club and we would like an interim group of expert marketers and businessmen to find and implement new revenue streams, plus some one other than your goodself and Orville to push on with finding a buyer or investors. Oh and we totally support Moyes and the Team.

When do we want it??

"Well, not this week... we've done quiet well recently and there's a few big games coming up, so anytime's good for us, Sur (gives forelock a good knuckling), beggin' your pardon," ? while the rest of them cast their eyes to the ground and pass their hats through their hands in the manner of Mexican peasants from The Magnificent Seven.

Not their finest hour.

Nah doesn't work...and ? if you don't think that BK has not got a smirk on his face at the news ? you maybe a tad innocent.
Robby Daniels
76 Posted 10/03/2012 at 00:55:42
Mike hmmm...

You're surprised how I have reacted?

Mike, people on here are talking about the demise of the Blue Union, as if there taking the decision to not protest is a victory for Kenwright.

Yes I can throw it about with the best of them.... but you dont let me, and full credit to you, for keeping things civil.

As for the hinted knowledge that you hint as bullshit?Are you getting me mixed up with Kenwright?

I only tell the truth, and truth is Mike, there are two parties interested in us. One of which is an American business, and the talks are at a delicate stage. This is what the BU have been led to believe by the people inside Goodison.

This leaves us with a no-win situation; if we protest and it fucks up, we will be hung, drawn and quartered. If we don't protest, and believe me we want to, we are still being slaughtered.

So there you have it and it was requested we didn't mention it, but your response needed address. So it's not Bullshit, that's Kenwright's department.

Just for your information, one of the said companies dealing with Everton at the moment are handling the Rangers receivership... This company also handles finance support to purchasers. Let's hope its with the latter that there viewing Everton.

Cheers Mike, you've probably got me thrown out of the BU, for saying something we had agreed wouldn't be said till a later date......

Bullshit indeed?????
Robby Daniels
77 Posted 10/03/2012 at 01:31:36
Derek ....Dear, Dear, hmmm...

The unspoken fourth line? What do we want!!! When do we want it!!!

Are you at uni? If you cared enough to ever go to a Blue Union meeting, you would know that those words have never been said. But If THEY HAD????

If your auntie had bollocks (yours probably) she would be your uncle.

Grow up son, and stop making things up like the fourth line????

The Blue Union will be here for as long as it takes... Get used to it.

KEIOC Faced the same deadbeats as you and proved they were right. Here we go again...

Fourth line...Haha..classic..
Peter Barry
78 Posted 10/03/2012 at 03:09:20
Yes just look how well we are doing! We have DROPPED to 13th in The Prem thanks to the fabulous run of eight games without a defeat. But a run in which we could not seal the three points against vastly inferior, bottom-of-the-Prem teams which would have secured us a top half position.
Ciarán McGlone
79 Posted 10/03/2012 at 08:30:08
Robbie,

What's the likelihood that this information coming from the club is bullshit?

And do you really think that any serious buyer doesn't know there's disent against the boardroom? I don't understand the logic. How could a genuine protest, which is a matter of public knowledge, fuck anything up?

Please explain.
Steve Jones
80 Posted 10/03/2012 at 10:12:32
So, clearly, this is nothing to do with the BU wanting to avoid disruption when we are playing well and are coming up to a pivotal point in the season.

Its really all about making the club as attractive as possible to potential new owners. Fair enough, but, aren't we all well used to the routine trotting out of prospective new owners at season ticket time? Why is it bollocks when the club says it to us plebs, but, credible when 'club sources' let it slip to the BU?
Eugene Ruane
81 Posted 10/03/2012 at 09:54:55
The BU have my support and for me this move makes perfect sense (ie: you strike while the iron is hot, not cold).

They've obviously (and the gloating here indicates they're spot on) realised that for many (most?) the idea of forward-thinking is a none-starter and as long as there's something shiny and glittering in front of a lot of Blues (ie: 13th and a cup quarter-final), they won't be in the least bit interested or distracted by dull stuff like the future (or not!) of Everton FC.
Richard Dodd
82 Posted 10/03/2012 at 10:31:34
Robby, you stand being accused by Kenwright of betraying a confidence.... again!

Anybody who has ANYTHING to do with Rangers/Craig Whyte will be less welcome at Goodison than even Bill himself.

And as for having to borrow the money to purchase the club ? and no doubt load that onto EFC ? how far forward would that take us?
Jamie Barlow
83 Posted 10/03/2012 at 10:28:52
Peter, a run that also seen us take 6 points off vastly superior teams at the top of the league.

Its like you're on some sort of loop.
Colin Wainwright
84 Posted 10/03/2012 at 11:12:47
Chris Morris #413.

''The question should be: What have the BU done to highlight problems that the Liverpool Echo failed to highlight years before?''

Jesus Christ! Blind idiocy of the highest order. People like you, are the real reason why Bill's laughing like a drain.

Mike McIlroy
85 Posted 10/03/2012 at 11:18:20
Actually I don't think it's a mistake. No-one wants to protest outside the ground ? I think people are protesting because there's nothing else they can do to be heard by this hapless board of ours.

BK was quoted as saying it was they that betrayed the club and yes potential buyers or even potential players will not find a club with ongoing disputes an attractive proposition ? that's a simple cold hard fact. So protest has to be the last resort.

Ultimately we all want the same thing ? of course we do ? we want the team to win things, play attractive football and remain in the top flight of domestic and eventually European football. Those fuckers in the boardroom won't do it and yes have to be removed but if the momentum is with the team at the moment there is not value added in emphasising negativity around the club.

The board need binning, we all know that, but let's not cut our noses off here; let's get behind the team and make this club an attractive sales opportunity so we get rid of the cancer that's at the top of this club at the moment... (but no fucking chicken farmers PLEASE!!) COYB!!!!
Mike Green
86 Posted 10/03/2012 at 11:16:21
Sounds like a pretty responsible move to me by BU. It would probably be much easier to have stubbornly gone ahead with the protest any way regardless of our up turn in performance, hopefully the club will give them lots more reasons not to protest which I'm sure is what we all want.

If BU are going to put pressure on the board it has to be sustainable, so why diminish any momentum they've built up with a badly timed protest? Life's all about timing and they'll have better days to make their point appropriately, and in doing so be taken more seriously.

Some people seem to be saying the BU are bottle jobs, to me this says the complete opposite.
For me, they've done the right thing.
Richard Dodd
87 Posted 10/03/2012 at 11:37:08
Careful, Mike, I was accused of racism for using the 'chicken farmers' phrase re Blackburn's owners but agree with all you say in this post.
Stephen Kenny
88 Posted 10/03/2012 at 11:42:54
Richard,

Your clumsy attempt to get Robby to drop himself in it and reveal more than he can was as see through as Madonna's knickers.

Mike Allison
89 Posted 10/03/2012 at 11:45:33
"Potential buyers or even potential players will not find a club with ongoing disputes an attractive proposition ? that's a simple cold hard fact."

I think we need a definition of the word 'fact' posted as some kind of pop-up on this website.

I could leave it there and I'd still be right, but consider the possibility that a club where the fans want the current board out makes them MORE attractive to potential buyers, as they will be on a 'win' from the off simply for not being the previous lot. Isn't that what happened when Kenwright et al came in in the first place?

It may be a perfectly reasonable and even correct opinion Mike, but it certainly isn't a 'simple, cold hard fact.'
Steve Jones
90 Posted 10/03/2012 at 11:49:41
The principle objective of the BU is to oppose the stagnation that's happened under the current board and do whatever they can to speed their replacement.

IF there are interested parties in contact with the club, demonstrating now can be seen as directly acting against their stated aims. It would be the right thing to do to tone things down and try to show the club in its best light.

Problem with this is, if it is no different than all the previous times that the board have trotted out tales of wonder at season ticket sales time, the BU are going to look like a bunch of prize mugs for swallowing it.
Mark Wilson
91 Posted 10/03/2012 at 00:23:11
As ever when the Blue Union comes to town, the first casualty of any debate is 'balance'. As a sheep / apologist / whatever from a past Toffeenet life, I know what it's like to stay loyal to your viewpoint and however emotive it's not always a fun experience, in fact it can be a very damaging thing to get through.

I cannot understand the way the BU folk are slaughtered for doing something that makes perfect sense. Why would they go ahead with the protest at this time? They do not have the support to carry out the protest and frankly had they done so in the ground they would have rightly been "slaughtered" and I think their support would have reduced still further.

In a way, though, I'm confused by the decision as the BU seem to have accepted that, no matter how dire our finances, and for heaven's sake, they are STILL very poor, the vast majority of us do not want to see protests that impact in ANY way on the team. That's the way it is.

I know it's hard for some of the more vociferous BU members but that is the truth of it. But... I don't understand how the usual (and in my view ineffective) marching etc is impacted by the fact that the team has bucked up, a little, and the January transfer window wasn't quite the disaster we feared... though it was hardly earth-shattering? If the BU haven't changed their position about the club and it's Board etc then sticking to their guns seems okay by me.

I don't agree with a lot of it but I'm not prepared to abuse these Evertonians, it's just wrong, and every bit as wrong as baiting the Chairman through railings or some of the dogs abuse I've seen made by a minority of BU supporters against the rest of us for having a different view.

I have to say, though, that's it naive in the extreme to ignore the realities that impact how much support the BU have. If we are fighting relegation, and come on, it did look very iffy before Christmas, then dissatisfaction is more evident; if the transfer window hadn't produced a just-about reasonable outcome, then many more would have given in to a feeling of despair at any hope for change in on field fortunes.

But the irony is that, within the BU, most want exactly what the rest of us want: Wembley and top six or seven and finish above the Shite. In doing so, they are I guess hoping for their support to reduce. It really is lose-lose for them as others as said here.

The irony is that some of the very real dangers we face as a club have not gone away because things seem a bit brighter on the pitch. If we lose the next four games, which please god doesn't happen, then we will to a degree be back to pre-Christmas, although I don't think we will go down. We will still be losing around £5m pa and, unless I've missed something, will only be able to buy in the summer if we sell. We will still badly need investment and must hope Inner Circle Sports have the magic touch and can find someone who will put a crazy £500m into the club.

It would be great if BU followers and let's face it, what is still the vast majority of non-BU members, could do something amazing, and just debate the issues in a reasonable way and accept we may never really agree on the best way to help Everton become the force that we once were.
Derek Thomas
92 Posted 10/03/2012 at 11:45:58
Robby (466 and 464): two words... no not those two, these two: poetic license.

I support the whole idea of BU 'sticking it to the Man' aka Bill, his shadow backers and the rest of the ghost board members and would march if I could (btw, it's many years since Uni was an option for me).

There may be behind-the-scenes reasons for the want of a better word, 'Climb Down' because, unless otherwise enlightened, that's how it comes across to me. I thought that as a focus group, which is what they are, the pressure should be on all the time, keeping the focus on the problems.

Donovan and three results are no excuse for backing off, nothing has radically changed in the great scheme of things.

So, unless you know different and there is a hidden agenda for backing off, and it's not due to lack of support or the prospect of a trip to Wembley, get off your high horse. We are on the same side here and I feel let down.
Andy Crooks
93 Posted 10/03/2012 at 12:41:22
This site is about debate and, hopefully being open minded. After reading Mike Green @538 I have come round to his point of view.
Dan Brierley
94 Posted 10/03/2012 at 12:01:59
Robby, the 'bellend' comment was pretty harsh, but your comment about the BU being responsible for the January transfers was ludicrous in my opinion.

And given your comments about the club being in 'delicate stages' with some interested parties, are you now suggesting that the interested parties talking with the club are only in discussion because of the pressure from the BU?

Because one of the BU party lines is 'the club is not for sale'. If your information is correct, then why do we keep being told by some BU members that the club is not for sale (as per the Kirkby Documentation), and then yourself saying the club are in discussions?
Robby Daniels
95 Posted 10/03/2012 at 12:58:32
Derek,

I take your point about the high horse and indeed, how you feel let down. We're all frustrated with what's happening off the pitch, but to protest at this time would be a mistake.

I have said too much already regarding interested parties, and there are other people on TW who know just as much as me, so I'll leave it for them to elaborate or not as the case may be.

Glad to see we're on the same side.

COYBS.


Dan.....

The comment I made about the January events being down to the pressure of the Blue Union was only my opinion. I never suggested that the BU were responsible for the interested parties either, you seem keen to put words in my mouth?

The club have recently brought in Inner Circle Sports to enable a sale, I'm not going to knock the club for doing as we asked?

Doddy...haha.

As for borrowing the money to purchase the club, and how far down the road would this get us?

Exactly about this far..... Kenwright/Anita Gregg?
Martin Mason
96 Posted 10/03/2012 at 13:08:29
Dan

There are at least two paragraphs in the DK Inquiry report that state that the club has been for sale for years.

Outwardly the BU has lost credibility by calling off the protest and they may even have been duped by the two interested parties at a delicate stage line? Time will tell.

I'm very worried about the "American Business" and needing finance to make the sale.
Richard Dodd
97 Posted 10/03/2012 at 14:09:44
Perhaps, BU should compromise and only order a protest if we lose tonight!

Rangers fans were delerious when Whyte `bought out` the monster, Sir David Murray, for a quid and payed off the bank, then they found out he`d mortgaged their season ticket income to do so! Any potential `saviour`will struggle to pull that one here, won`t they?
Bobby Thomas
98 Posted 10/03/2012 at 14:48:02
Doddy, yes, and as you may already be aware, unfortunately new owners most certainly would struggle to pull off the mortgaging of future season ticket sales, as its already happened years ago.
Dave Wilson
99 Posted 10/03/2012 at 14:57:30
Mike Green #538

Couldnt agree more
Derek Thomas
100 Posted 10/03/2012 at 17:04:06
Robbie 563; No problem, I await with baited breathe, for the other shoe (or shoes) to drop and I hope they are size 12s and the stamp on Bill's fingers so as he does let go.
Robby Daniels
101 Posted 10/03/2012 at 17:23:26
Derek ..

Haha.. well said, bring on the shoes....
Jack Molloy
102 Posted 10/03/2012 at 20:15:59
I'm surprised Blue Union's outspoken and often gratuitously offensive leadership hasn't already been on here yet explaining why it's a good decision and we're all idiots for not seeing the light.

The fact is that a campaign to force Kenwright to sell the club is either right or it's wrong. It's either relevant or it's not. It either has mass support or it hasn't. It should not be impacted by short-term progress on the field.

I happen to disagree with the Blue Union's three basic proposals but I'm shocked that they are so fickle and mercurial about their own campaign.
Jimmy Sørheim
103 Posted 11/03/2012 at 04:29:15
Hello guys. Why the chopping off at BU for the choice to stop 1 single protest?

This is a long term job, that means you spread your protest towards important dates, such as come summer when Moyes is going to have his "chat" with Kenwright with regards to the future.

In no way is this a "sign" of giving up, or running away from the problem. I support the intent of the BU and I feel they have a long term plan that will give results, in fact it already has in some way.

The January transfers plus the Inner Circle Sports company, these are signs of change.

I think it is a smart choice to wait until the season nears a close; as they say, timing is everything.
Eric Myles
104 Posted 11/03/2012 at 05:53:51
Another piece of mis-information here from our resident WUM. "There are at least two paragraphs in the DK Inquiry report that state that the club has been for sale for years."

As Colin Fitz has pointed out in another thread, it was HE that stated that the club was for sale whereas the Club CEO categorically stated it was not.

The inquiry believed Colin and not the board who were lying in an attempt to fool the inquiry into thinking they would not profit from the development.
Martin Mason
105 Posted 11/03/2012 at 06:18:14
I posted the references and it was in response to somebody saying that the club hadn't been for sale. Please post the references in the report if you are going to make statements like your last paragraph. I can't believe that anybody could possibly take Colin seriously.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads