Moyes: Everton is for me

, 11 March, 102comments  |  Jump to most recent
David Moyes says that he plans to sit down with Bill Kenwright this summer to discuss the next five years at Everton. The Scot is frequently mentioned in discussions regarding the hot seats at Chelsea and Tottenham but he insists he isn't looking to leave Goodison any time soon.

"The next five years will be for me to talk with Bill about at the end of the season.

"Nothing at the moment will turn my head, Everton's for me, I'm a loyal kind a guy most of the time and I try to do the right things as often as I can and I certainly will be doing that at Everton."

Quotes or other material sourced from Sky Sports



Reader Comments (102)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Peter Bourke
1 Posted 11/03/2012 at 07:47:07
Well I will start this off and for me this is great news. Yes he has his faults and shortcomings but tell me a manager out there that doesn't. There isn't a manager in the premier league i would have over Moysie and he has red hair and I don't care.
Honest, decent manager.
Terry Riley
2 Posted 11/03/2012 at 08:18:55
DITTO....if this post is allowed
Ged Simpson
3 Posted 11/03/2012 at 08:38:32
ditto
Phil Roberts
4 Posted 11/03/2012 at 08:40:37
I agree.

Good Manager - kept us in the Premiership and always in the top half after the first couple of years but

Great Guy - honest, loyal, hardworking and trustworthy. Also stops players from being obnoxious
Nick Waters
5 Posted 11/03/2012 at 08:48:04
I'm not totally convinced by Moyes and it's mostly down to all the poor starts to the season we have. Why, given our 'new year' form every season, do we have the same players turning out miserable performances from September to December? If he could turn that around next season as well as keeping it up (as we did in 04-05) then he would FULLY deserve all the plaudits and testimonials he receives from the media and his peers - most of whom seem to think Everton are lucky to be in the Premier League!
Paul Dewhurst
6 Posted 11/03/2012 at 08:47:05
I moan about negative tactics, go mad when he plays 1 up front at home against weaker teams. Get really frustrated by him when making mechanical substations, and see us start each season poorly. BUT could I think of anyone to replace him, no. Can I offer suggestions to who would do a better job under the circumstances, no. Am I a whinging, fickle I know better than you football fan YES!

He's done a great job, considering the whole situation, but I will still moan when we do any of the above. Thats football
Phil Brown
7 Posted 11/03/2012 at 08:58:11
I,m one of the supporters who think that he's done a good job but has taken us as far as he can and it's time for him to move on (with our respect and thanks).

His strengths are in stabilising and rebuilding clubs but he's not up to managing a top club.

I think that he's tailor made for either the Wigan or Wolves job once they've been relegated - and I'd swap him for Martinez.

Football is changing and we'll need a manager to innovate in terms of training (poor starts to the season), team selections and substitutions and bringing on our very good youth players. These are all Moyes weaknesses.

The future - for clubs like ours - was on display on Thursday in the shape of Athletic Bilbao.

Billy holds the key to our future in his hands, is he up to it?
Do you really believe that Moyes come come up with football like that from locally grown players?

Brendan O'Neill
8 Posted 11/03/2012 at 08:58:20
I've been visiting TW for a number of years and rarely make a post. Just a quick one regarding this poor 1st half followed by a good 2nd half of the season.

Back in 2004-05, many people on this site were bemoaning the fact that the 2nd half of that season was poor and trying to work out why we ran out of steam as the same thing happened in 2002-03, Moyes's first season.

We also tailed off in 2007-08 having been in 4th position until around March/April time with performances relatively poor in the 2nd half of the season. 2005-06 was a very poor start and didn't really get an awful lot better though we did end up 11th I think.

It's been since 2008-09 that we've had this poor start/good finish thing but it hasn't always been the case and I do remember a lot of posts on here 3 or 4 years ago bemoaning the poor finishes to the season rather than the poor start.

If only we could maintain our very best form throughout the entire season then we would be competing for CL every season. IMWT
Ray Roche
9 Posted 11/03/2012 at 09:13:28
If anyone is interested there is an excellent article on Moyes in todays Sunday Times.

Moyes irritates me on occasions with his negative outlook and his baffling substitutions, but after reading that article his loyalty and love for the club are beyond question.

As is his distaste of The Fat Spanish Waiter who showed a "lack of class" over his Small Club remark. And this in a week when we were discussing the managerial love fest following Sir Alex and his glowing admiration for Moyes.
(Oh, and any other manager his team have just played, providing that Utd have beaten them, that is.)
Dave Burnett
10 Posted 11/03/2012 at 09:21:15
I agree with many of the comments regarding his loyalty and who could we get to replace him... No doubt the big issue he will have in the discussions he has with Kenwright and the next 5 years, is how can he take us to the next level. That requires money to buy quality players; if, as we all expect, no money is available, then that loyalty may cease, understandbly. The big issue that has been hanging over the club and our ability to be in the top 4 is investment and it will never go away.
Colin Potter
11 Posted 11/03/2012 at 09:37:55
Please please please not another 5 years of his dour ,dire defensive negativity
Carl Sanderson
12 Posted 11/03/2012 at 09:37:48
I would rather have David Moyes in charge than anyone else. He is superb. It is also my opinion that he is a human shield for the Board - on the sad day that he leaves they will be sitting ducks.
Derek Dolan
13 Posted 11/03/2012 at 09:42:37
Here's to 10 more years. DM is the man. Our day will come. COYB.
Chris Morris
14 Posted 11/03/2012 at 09:41:53
I don't think he'll leave and certainly hope he doesn't. People nag about his tactics and sometimes he does get them wrong..... just like every other manager. But more often than not he gets them spot on, just like yesterday with Coleman and Bale.

Some people have short memories and this whole business of "he's taken us as far as he can" or "he's incapable of managing a top club" is pathetic. He's done wonders with basically, pennies to spend. And can someone tell me a top manager that would even consider the job at EFC????
Billy Bradshaw
15 Posted 11/03/2012 at 09:42:44
Moyes is a good manager who has gone a little negative over the last few seasons. I like his honesty but you can't get away from his negative tactics of late. Look at yesterday's substitions, taking Drenthe off and putting Osman right mid was a very, very poor decision.
Jimmy Sørheim
16 Posted 11/03/2012 at 09:31:23

I think we must decline to hand Moyes a longer contract, at the very least his wages has to take a 25% cut.
Overall it is a mistake not to try something new, and with regards to investment it could not hurt to have a more impartial manager.

Part of the reason I think Moyes has stayed too long is that Kenwright now actively use Moyes as a buffer for angry fans.
Moyes is his strongest supporter and to me that is the biggest mistake regarding Moyes.

A manager to me has to stay impartial to the chairman, no matter what, for the best of the club.
This simply has not happened with Moyes and the failure of Kings Dock should have made Moyes even more demanding of his chairman, but he has stayed loyal to a fault.

I agree with Phil.nr740.

Moyes handling of Barkley and Vellios has been poor , I think that a manager like Ferguson sees a youngster and then either sticks with him or leaves him out.

The way our best youngsters have been rotting on the bench or in the reserve team this season just goes to show that Moyes lacks faith in youngsters in general, unless he is absolutely forced to use them because of injuries.
Chris Morris
17 Posted 11/03/2012 at 09:51:25
DM also gets stick for playing his favourites, but dropping Cahill is a big decision. Personally, I think he's ineffective because we very rarely get wide and cross in the ball this season. Now Pienaar is back that will/has changed, but still, if Cahill isn't running towards goal then there's no point in playing him. He's also the reason we play 4-5-1

Neville is our captain and in season's gone by, when he's been injured it's been glaringly obvious that we needed his leadership on the pitch.

Osman, I think, should play behind the striker every time because EFC play better "football" when he plays. If you watch his movement off the ball its excellent and he rarely gives the ball away.

Hibbert, top defender, shite attacker, but top defender. Simple



Chris Morris
18 Posted 11/03/2012 at 10:00:09
Jimmy.. He plays his youngsters when they're ready. It's proven and also a big draw to young players look for prospective clubs. Rooney played. Rodwell plays. Vaughan played. Anichebe plays.Everyone screamed for him to play Gueye and when he does play you can see he's not good enough. Barkley played but was getting over ran and will probably play more next season when he's ready. Vellios played, scored a couple of goals but lost his place to Stracq!!!! Stracq is terrible (100% committed though) so that tells me that Vellios is doing something very wrong, either in training or behind the scenes
Ciarán McGlone
19 Posted 11/03/2012 at 10:03:54
Chris Morris,

"We miss Neville and Osman rarely gives the ball away"???

Sarcasm? Irony?
Colin Southern
20 Posted 11/03/2012 at 10:08:15
Our poor starts to the season are not down to the manager, they are down to the board not stumping up the cash to bring new players in. Likewise, when we've tailed off, like in 2004 that's when we've lost players in the January and not really replaced them.
Graham Mockford
21 Posted 11/03/2012 at 10:04:13
Here we go again just when I thought after nine unbeaten including City, Chelsea and now Spurs we might have some respite from the Moyes haters.
Jimmy Sorheim you really are a special individual, what world do you inhabit were negotiating a new contract would involve a pay cut. And when DM is asked by the media about his chairman ,would you expect him to be anything but supportive, as the guy pays his wages he can do nothing else. That doesn't mean he can't be challenging or demanding behind closed doors which is exactly how it should be.
Phil Walling
22 Posted 11/03/2012 at 10:15:13
Yesterday`s performance must have had Moyes in ecstacy.His lads` nicked one and then managed to keep it tight-see section 6,clause 43 (iii) Scottish FA Coaching Manual-How to win by staying in your own half!
If only he had lived 170 years ago Davey Crockett would have been fired and Texas would have won the Battle of the Alamo!
But `he keeps us safe`and saves his mentor`s arse so who are we to complain if there ain`t no fun in it ,anymore?
Simon Harris
23 Posted 11/03/2012 at 10:06:51
I imagine his 5 year conversation with Bill will be pretty predictable.

"I'm working 24/7 to find you investment Davey, but the reality is that I'm a goon, and therefore you'll have to sell a big player each season. I'll try and give you 85p in every £1 of each sale but the reality will be more like 6p to re-invest and save my bacon again again"

I'm delighted that David Moyes is considering 5 more years at Everton. There is no one else (IMO) who could have over achieved on such a consistent basis, working with the financial constraints imposed over the last 10 years.

The only thing BK has got right, was signing and retaining David Moyes.
Graham Mockford
24 Posted 11/03/2012 at 10:27:48
Phil #767 if you didn't have fun and enjoy yesterday there really is no hope for you. Yes it was hairy in the second half but the stadium was rocking at the final whistle and from where I was sat there seemed to be about 30,000 + having fun.
Carl Sanderson
25 Posted 11/03/2012 at 10:46:30
Phil #767

We have put to the sword three out of the top five, we're still in the Cup and the atmosphere at Goodison is excellent atm. On the pitch, what more do you want?
Steven Bennett
26 Posted 11/03/2012 at 10:43:14
Moyes has done well, but to say no other manager could do a better job is a bit ridiculous.

I have said this before, but it seems we have a generation who have grown up in the years of walter smith etc..Who quite understandably see this as success. And another who don't remember anything previous .
Chris Morris
27 Posted 11/03/2012 at 10:52:10
Question: If DM leaves on Monday morning, who is going to take the job and do it better than DM?
Richard Lloyd
28 Posted 11/03/2012 at 10:54:46
Spot on, Graham; first half we were the better side; second half, Spurs showed what a good side they are. If you didn't enjoy the feeling of belting out "Its a Grand Old Team" at the end of that game, there really is no hope for you.
Barry Rathbone
29 Posted 11/03/2012 at 10:59:03
me
Barry Rathbone
30 Posted 11/03/2012 at 11:00:12
if you ask a stupid question
Chris Morris
31 Posted 11/03/2012 at 11:05:24
Stupid people answer?
Barry Rathbone
32 Posted 11/03/2012 at 11:07:56
and you have
Chris Morris
33 Posted 11/03/2012 at 11:11:31
Check again Bazza. I clearly had ? at the end, which denotes a question. You, my friend, answered. DOH
Phil Walling
34 Posted 11/03/2012 at 10:59:06
Moyes is about to prove his lifelong theory that you can garner more than enough points to finish halfway up the table by scoring just one goal a game. Of course, it helps if you can score first and then you can focus everything on the real purpose of football ? not to concede. That, some of you are saying, is what gets you off! God help us.

The glory days of this ? and every other club ? are based on teams with attacking flair WHO WENT OUT TO SCORE GOALS (in the plural).

Moyes's KITAHTNO theory may preserve Everton's Premier League status but it will be at the expense of falling crowds and the loss of a whole generation of fans. Just you see!
Graham Mockford
35 Posted 11/03/2012 at 11:08:13
Chris as you can probably surmise I am a DM fan but it is impossible to state someone couldn't do a better job. It's just a gamble I wouldn't want to take.

And your question just opens the floodgates for the Lambert/ Martinez/Holloway/Rodgers/ anyone else who has won a game or two who is flavour of the month brigade who would be prepared to gamble our future on a punt.
Chris Morris
36 Posted 11/03/2012 at 11:14:16
Phil... Expensive tickets and football matches widely available on TV or illegal streaming are showing now that less and less people are going to the game.
Dave Wilson
37 Posted 11/03/2012 at 11:13:06
Anyone listening to TalkShite?

Spurs fan after Spurs fan is coming on to slaughter 'Arry.

Apparently he tries to put square pegs in round holes and ... wait for it ... he was too negative by starting with two defensive midfield players.
Chris Morris
38 Posted 11/03/2012 at 11:16:05
Graham... that was exactly my point. He's done very well in charge of EFC and mostly gets things right. But who would take the job and do it better? Answer nobody, because those people ? Martinez, Holloway, Hodgson etc ? aren't better than what we've got now. The top managers wouldn't even consider the job.
Graham Mockford
39 Posted 11/03/2012 at 11:15:08
Phil why don't you see if you can buy a ticket for next Saturday? Oh sorry it's a sell out, funny that!
Graham Mockford
40 Posted 11/03/2012 at 11:18:51
Chris all I was trying to say as it appears we are like minded is that no one can state with certainty someone could not do a better job. It's just opinion and in our opinion we are better sticking with what we got.
Richard Dodd
41 Posted 11/03/2012 at 11:16:13
Phil, I`m beginning to think you`re my old man in disguise! To save you suffering as you seem to do, I`ll borrow his copy of `The Golden Vision` and set it up on an endless loop for you. Then, like him, you won't need to go to matches!
Phil Brown
42 Posted 11/03/2012 at 11:13:09
Chris #776 How much did you know about David Moyes when he took over 10 years ago?

And at #753 ? Was he considered a top manager?
Barry Rathbone
43 Posted 11/03/2012 at 11:18:04
Chris

Sorry, thought you were answering my post (which of course you were) but go on bore the arse of everyone saying "no, I wasn't". Inane question, ccompletely unanswerable unless you're a fortune teller - are you?

Stall at Blackpool reading palms?.. cheap clothes pegs, lucky heather?
Chris Morris
44 Posted 11/03/2012 at 11:21:02
Graham... Absolutely. It bugs me when people moan about tactics. Everyone is entitled to their opinion of course but some people don't watch what happens off the ball. Example was last night when, AGAIN, Bale was non-existent against Everton. Of course he gets some things wrong but we're in a far better position with him.
Chris Morris
45 Posted 11/03/2012 at 11:23:37
Phil Brown... I, like most, only knew what was touted around at the time. Most people had heard of the manager of Preston due to the play-off final and the surrounding hype.
Dave Wilson
46 Posted 11/03/2012 at 11:28:30
Ha Ha...

TalkShite`s getting better by the minute.

An Evertonian has just come on and slaughtered the Spurs fans for getting above themselves.

All I want now is for the gobshites to come on moaning about KD and me few pints will go down a treat this avy.
Chris Morris
47 Posted 11/03/2012 at 11:32:46
Dave Wilson.. I wonder if any of them will mention the fact that KD's PL record is worse the Hodgson's was???
Dave Wilson
48 Posted 11/03/2012 at 11:37:38
Is that right, Chris? Ha Ha, this day just gets better.
Jon Tollitt
49 Posted 11/03/2012 at 11:11:08
Success in the PL is mostly about money and DM isn't given close to what those in and around the top six have.

When he has splashed a bit of cash, the football has been better than now (ie, when Pienaar, Arteta, Yakubu were playing and Cahill was on form).

He isn't perfect, and I'm not sure about 'miracles', but he's been gritty when things were tough and bought some decent players when times were better.

Seriously, just look at what Redknapp, Dalglish, Bruce, AVB and others spend for limited reward.

I'd like to see him stay and money to be invested in the club for the long term. Perhaps he won't be the one to bring much success, but I believe he would be the one to build a platform for it.
Chris Morris
50 Posted 11/03/2012 at 11:46:28
Dave... I honestly didn't believe it when I got told. Only 4 wins at Anfield this season and 11 draws. Don't tell them KD is crap though, because they might spontaneously combust and start singing King Kenny songs.
Jim Knightley
51 Posted 11/03/2012 at 11:39:17
Phil Walling - if Football fans only supported team's based on attacking flair, everyone would support Barcelona, Arsenal and Manchester United. Give Moyes hundreds of Millions, and I will complain if his team bores me. Give him one of the consistently smallest budgets in this league, and a rapidly falling wage bill, and I will take his football anyday. At the moment, despite spending around 5% of what Liverpool have in the last 14months, we are 2 points behind them in the league, and will in all likelyhood finish above several teams with higher wage budgets and spending power. We need to keep Moyes, because it will be near impossible to find a replacement we can afford who will match his feats with us.

Also Phil, I can't wait for a new generation of fans. Because they wont remember the '80's' and will come to realise Everton consistently fight above their means. And Jimmy...re. Ferguson's handling of youngsters...He played his great young players, precisely because they were great and Barkley isnt there yet. There are plenty of examples of him withdrawing players and of them going through periods in and out of the team because they are not ready. (See the twins, Anderson, De Gea, Nani to an extent, etc etc)
Kevin Naylor
52 Posted 11/03/2012 at 12:05:16
It just shows the fickleness of a lot of fans because, if we lose to the shite on Tuesday and Sunderland knock us out of the cup Saturday, we'll be right back to where we were at the end of last year. Be interesting to see opinions then should the unthinkable happen...
Phil Walling
53 Posted 11/03/2012 at 12:11:07
I guess we`ve already got a new generation of fans, Jim. Richard Dodd`s! And they put up with all the shit that`s thrown at them on and off the pitch.

Heard on Sky this morning amongst all the 'Moyes is a genius' crap that "Everton have reached the heady heights of NINTH!".

NSNO re-written for the Dodd era, eh?
Graham Mockford
54 Posted 11/03/2012 at 12:20:56
Kevin you make a good point, at least the Moyes haters are consistent. It's just they are consistently wrong!
Chris Morris
55 Posted 11/03/2012 at 12:26:48
Kevin... if that happens then I'm sure the Blue Union will be rubbing their hands with glee and all heading to the wardrobe to get their clown costumes out!! If it doesn't, then the Blue Union can enjoy their jolly day out at Wembley and continue to cancel protests because people don't want to protest.
Kevin Naylor
56 Posted 11/03/2012 at 12:30:07
Chris, you are probably right; my only beef with Moyes is his inability to change to the play on the pitch. This stuck out yesterday in the second half where he had his goal and sat on it and but for the post would have come unstuck. You can't be that lucky every game. Taking Drenthe off signaled we were shutting up shop and giving the green light to the onslaught.
Chris Morris
57 Posted 11/03/2012 at 12:34:02
Kevin... I agree with that yesterday and I think it''s becoming more difficult each week to justify Cahill's selection. Arguably DM's best signing and has been great for us since day 1 but if we're not crossing balls in the box then there's no point in having him.
Richard Reeves
58 Posted 11/03/2012 at 12:30:28
You just couldn't make it up. Forget about loyalty, it's about the size of your balls, no wonder why thoses tracky bottoms are so high.

Five more years of ready made excuses. Thanks for the first five, Mr Moyes but now it is time to stop hiding and prove all these lazy journalists right at a club with money and ambition.
Ray Roche
59 Posted 11/03/2012 at 12:50:36
While we're talking about managers, and thanks to Dave Wilson for pointing out the Spurs fans' unhappiness wiv 'Arry, did anyone else get as angry as I did watching that porridge faced, ungracious, horrible little fat twat on MotD last night? He mentioned the "second 'alf " battering they gave us six times. I'd have given a King's (Dock) ransom to have been the interviewer and asked him about the first half battering we gave his side.

And a great bit of tactical nous from Moyes in neutering Bale. Again.
Richard Tarleton
60 Posted 11/03/2012 at 13:14:47
Is there a better manager at setting up his team to negate an attacking team, or a top four club? Possibly no. If I was a chairman and was facing a relegation dog-fight, I'd choose Moyes before anyone else.

But ? and it's one hell of a 'but' ? he is negative through and through. He hates the idea of two players upfront. Against poor teams and I think of the Blackburn game, he will not set out to destroy the opposition. He starts with the mindset of "what we have, we hold and if we can nick a goal that's the job done".

As for youngsters, he doesn't trust them: Rooney was frustrated and left a season before he had to; Rodwell went backwards after his debut season because he was rarely used; and Barkley was outstanding in the opening match and has disappeared from view. Cahill, Neville and to a lesser extent Distin are played after their best. Carsley and Weir were kept on too long.

Under Moyes, we'll remain hard to beat, but we won't be entertained in any broader sense. And that seems to be what most fans want and expect.
John Ford
61 Posted 11/03/2012 at 13:19:53
I hope Moyes sticks around despite possible summer distractions.

He's done us proud when success in English football is related almost exclusively to club budget. He's more consistent than any other manager in his attampts to break the glass ceiling to compete with the moneyed elite.

I can understand the cries for more attacking football cos it's better to watch when things go for you. But there isn't a team in the last ten years which has been able to challenge the top places by doing this. It always ends up in failure: West Ham, Blackpool, Bolton, Sunderland ? all did well initially then dropped without trace. There are loads more examples when you look back.

Our first half display yesterday was typical of a Moyes teams at their best. First and foremost outworking the opposition and earning the right to play your football, with good passing and movement.

Happy anniversary, David.
James Morgan
63 Posted 11/03/2012 at 13:27:41
If he is such a great manager then why can't he set the team up to beat the shit teams? A couple of good results against the media darlings hides the fact that he obviously can't motivate or tactically set the boys up to beat teams like QPR, Wigan and Blackburn.

It's funny how all the pundits crawl up his arse when we win against the big boys but don't question or pick him apart when we can't beat the relegation fodder. And the fact that we can never start a season well is purely down to him.

I appreciate what he has done to improve us but I think a new manager (a good one) could maybe take us to the next step.
John Ford
64 Posted 11/03/2012 at 13:47:22
If we can't beat the 'shit teams', why do we end up higher than all of them, basically higher than anyone except the rich bastards?

It's the same over the seasons, we beat the 'shit teams' more than anyone except the top six. No-one actually wins football matches regularly except the rich bastards, and that's what they pay for. It's shit but it's a shit fact of footy life.
Dean Adams
65 Posted 11/03/2012 at 13:52:08
James Morgan

Or down to the next level if he fails!!

Moyes is the best ? that is why if you look at his record, nobody comes close on a consistent run. With the better players fit and ready for action I feel that he makes some poor decisions. That apart, he has worked miracles here.
Graham Mockford
66 Posted 11/03/2012 at 14:14:15
James Morgan #845. Utter nonsense. By media darlings you actually mean the teams lying 1st, 3rd and 5th who have spent hundreds of millions of pounds assembling squads of players we could only dream of.

As for the results you mention, disappointing, yes... but that's what happens on occasions. QPR beat Chelsea, Wigan drew at Liverpool and Chelsea, Blackburn drew at Liverpool and beat Arsenal and Man U. Was that because the opposition were tactically inept or unmotivated. Of course not; football is not a perfect science or we wouldn't have bookies.
Stephen Kenny
67 Posted 11/03/2012 at 14:33:37
He's a difficult man to dislike, Moyes.

His 20% cut comments show a fella who understands what's good for the game and cares about the average fan.

His various interviews this week have also changed my view of him to a degree. When asked about being linked to other jobs he point blank refused to discuss it out of respect for Everton, not the "their a great side but nothings come up" bollocks that some would happily use as an invite to poach them, but that just makes his gunfight comments all the stranger.

Eugene Ruane
68 Posted 11/03/2012 at 14:12:32
Graham Mockford (765).

Just to be clear - is a 'Moyes hater', anyone with an opinion that is not 'I think Moyes is doing a great job and should stay forever'?

Phil Roberts (727) believes Moyes to be a "Great Guy - honest, loyal, hardworking and trustworthy".

So do I, wouldn't disagree with any of it.

(nb: so hardly hatred on my part - agreed?)

However as these qualities guarantee you nothing in football, I would happily see Moyes gone and replaced by someone (anyone) who lacked these qualities BUT had imagination.

A simple philosophical difference (possibly an age thing)

My belief is Moyes can take Everton no further and that he will get staler and staler and that other sides (as certainly happened in the first part of the season) found us easy to 'suss'.

Simply my opinion - one no more or less valid than yours.

But...Hater?

Thinking Moyes is negative is not hatred.

Believing Moyes lacks imagination is not hatred.

Believing he should go is NOT hatred.

Threads like this are pure opinion and nobody 'wins'. So fight your corner by all means, but stop acting like a soft twat and throwing about fucking stupid phrases like Moyes hater.

Dean Adams (851). You and I obviously have a VERY different idea as to what constitutes a 'miracle'
Graham Mockford
69 Posted 11/03/2012 at 14:59:34
Eugene I wouldn't class you as a Moyes hater, you provide reasoned and erudite arguments (if I ignore your penultimate paragraph that is) which as you quite rightly point out are your opinions which as long as they are well argued are fine with me.

No, my definition of the Moyes haters are the Peter Barrys (strangely quiet today!) and the Jimmy Sorheims of this world. They place the difficulties of our team squarely at Moyes's door when in my opinion they lie with our ownership structure and business model which, unless they change, consign us to a lot more of the same.
Graham Mockford
70 Posted 11/03/2012 at 15:12:05
Oh and Eugene not sure how old you think I am but my first season ticket was 1969 if that helps.
Danny James
71 Posted 11/03/2012 at 14:53:34
We cannot know what the effect of having a new manager would have on our team and future as a club.

Those who would rather have a new manager hope they could turn out to be even better than the one we presently have and the club will go on to bigger and better things but are prepared to take the risk of us lapsing back into the 90s, fighting relegation and chopping and changing managers when things arent going our way.

Those who want Moyes to stay don't wont to take that risk and would rather have Moyesy keep us in the top ten in the hope that he can build a new generation team that will lead us on to bigger and better things.

I would take Moyes anyday. I hated all but two seasons of the 90s. I don't feel any manager can do better with our club than he is doing with the restraints that are on us. I am not saying another manager might not do as well as Moyes but why risk change when the new guy could only either achieve the same or take the club down?
Joe McMahon
72 Posted 11/03/2012 at 17:08:41
He's a good manager, and a very well paid manager.

I would like to see him move on, an dsee how he copes with a budget with (some) expectations.
I would like to see a manager with adventure, a manager who would drop Tim Cahill, as one league goal in 15 months is not worthy of automatic selection. Our goal tally is embarrasing, I think 10 years has been long enough.
The kenwright/Moyes partnership currently has us stagnated. We as a club need fresh ideas, Moyes needs a challenge.
Scott Ellis
73 Posted 11/03/2012 at 17:51:37
Re post 733:

I completely agree with you, Paul. I get so angry with his caution when he makes his 60-min sub and brings on another central defender for a midfielder. Or leaves Neville and takes off our most creative player to hold on for the rest of the game.

But we are fans and this is his job so we are not supposed to agree with his decision-making.

We have to step back and be thankful that we have a manager who gets results with fuck all. And if you look about, I don't think you will find many more men capable of maintaining our league status with £0.

Nothing is perfect in life. Let's keep the faith a little while longer...
Dan Roy
74 Posted 11/03/2012 at 17:57:54
Before Moyes's arrival, the club's average Premier League finish was 14.1. Since his first full season, it's been 7.8. Pre-Moyes, we had one top 10 finish. During the Moyes era, we've had seven of them. It's not to say that we've not had disappointments, but I expect the "change" we'd see if the manager left would be in the wrong direction. In Moyes I Trust.
Roberto Birquet
75 Posted 11/03/2012 at 18:02:14
I'm one of the supporters who think that he's done a good job but has taken us as far as he can and it's time for him to move on (with our respect and thanks).
---------------------------
I hear echoes of Charlton fans and Curbishley. They were probably right: he'd taken them as far as he could.

But no-one else would've even taken them that far. Bye bye, Charlton.

We need to find a way to make money. I would be very happy if Moyes could get us back to where we were 3-4 years ago. But it'll be difficult. Our season tickets are not even half the price of Spurs' (never mind competing with the likes of Manchester clubs, Arse, Chelski, or the Shite), we are increasingly dependent on Sky money, and the Merseyside region does not look likely to have a big economic boom anytime soon.

We need corporate money, a modern ground, some bloody luck; not a new manager.
Roberto Birquet
76 Posted 11/03/2012 at 18:14:45
Before Moyes's arrival, the club's average Premier League finish was 14.1. Since his first full season, it's been 7.8. Pre-Moyes, we had one top 10 finish. During the Moyes era, we've had seven of them.
----------------------
And that is seven out of just nine full seasons, and at the mo we are on target for eight out of ten. And of the two in which we finished outside the top ten, the last (2005-06), we finished 11th.

It's true that sometime the football is not a high enough standard; I think we need to get European football again. Our best Moyes era football was in the post-Uefa Cup seasons from 2006-09. Although I enjoyed the first full season, too. Since when it has been half-season poor, half-season good.
Eugene Ruane
77 Posted 11/03/2012 at 19:30:44
Graham Mockford (862) - You say...

"No, my definition of the Moyes haters are the Peter Barrys (strangely quiet today!) and the Jimmy Sorheims of this world. They place the difficulties of our team squarely at Moyes's door when in my opinion they lie with our ownership structure and business model which, unless they change, consign us to a lot more of the same".

I'd like to pick four words out of that.

"..when in my opinion.."

So if I'm not mistaken, basically a case of they think one thing and..you think another.

Isn't that what that paragraph says?

Isn't that simply THEIR opinion and (nb: as you agreed) aren't they entitled to it without being given your silly 'Moyes hater' label?

Sorry but it sounds EXACTLY like you not being prepared to entertain a different point of view, so resort to calling names.

And do you honestly think those who (like me) would like to see Moyes gone, believe our (fucking useless) board are absolutely blameless?

Or do you think it might simply be a case of when a post is about Moyes, people...er..talk about Moyes?

By the way, I read Jimmy's post (757) and whatever my opinions on it, for or against, there is no 'hate' in it, just his opinions (but if I'm wrong, feel free to point out any particularly hateful sentences paragraphs).

As for my penultimate paragraph, well if it quacks like a duck and it walks like a duck..
Graham Mockford
78 Posted 11/03/2012 at 19:50:09
Eugene, I was attempting to be conciliatory but you sound like you want a row. If I want to use a phrase, I don't need your approval and will use it as I see fit. It's my opinion you see so to quote your eloquent quacking back to you, stop being a soft twat.
Jamie Barlow
79 Posted 11/03/2012 at 19:58:30
You sound a little bored Eugene. There's plenty of "Moyes haters" on here and you know it.
James Martin
80 Posted 11/03/2012 at 19:55:14
Football fans are generally growing more fickle, Spurs get one sniff of the Champions League and suddenly they expect it every season now. I hate Redknapp but am not blind to what he's done there this season yet the first bit of bad form they're in and some fans are calling for him to go and they're third in the league! The same for Wenger, even some Man U fans were caling for Ferguson after the Newcastle and Blackburn losses. The only ones who haven't are the moronic RS over the park, incapable of objective thought but even the orcs there are starting to whip up a bit of discontent that Dalglish has swilled £100 million down the toilet.

Every manager has faults. Whoever we get in after Moyes will have faults of his own as equally as infuriating as Moyes's. It is not a guarantee that a change of personnel will yield better football (not that Moyes's style over his reign has been bad) or will magically take us to the next level (without any money?).

Jimmy, if Ferguson puts so much faith in his kids, why do Scholes and Giggs play most games alongside Carrick, Ferdinand and Evra? Where's Pogba, Morrison, Macheda? ? That's right, they're not playing bcause they weren't ready... the same way Barkley and Vellios won't be ready for whole seasons of football; the odd game they can do well but not consistently. We give youth more of a chance than most teams in the Prem but that's still not enough for some is it?
Iain Love
81 Posted 11/03/2012 at 20:27:34
Some people on here must be dreaming, considering what Moyes had to start with, what he's had to spend, what he's had to sell, and the league positions he's achieved, I don't think there's a manager out there who could have done better.

Given our DESPARATE financial plight if Moyes did go we are seriously fucked. Can any anti-Moyes posters on here name another manager who's done what Moyes has over a 10-year period.
Graham Mockford
82 Posted 11/03/2012 at 20:44:40
Iain good intentions but you only encourage the Moyes haters!
Eugene Ruane
83 Posted 11/03/2012 at 20:09:19
Graham Mockford (894) - Yes..er..thank you Clarence Darrow.

Nice to see you pathetically avoid all my questions.

Jamie (895), you say - "You sound a little bored Eugene. There's plenty of "Moyes haters" on here and you know it".

'And you know it'?

That's the level of debate?

What are you, seven?

Not far off the Pee Wee Herman comeback - "I know you are, but what am I?"

Yes there are many who hate Moyes TACTICS, see him as dour and without imagination and or flair and believe he's gone stale (ie: me) but to describe those who see things this way as 'Moyes haters' is fucking plain dumb.

And if you don't want to look like a prick, don't (like a soft kid) say 'there's loads and you know there is', - provide evidence.

Personally I might have seen two or three posts at most (ever!) that have actually said "I fucking hate David Moyes' but..maybe you can think of many more (love to see a few of them)

Soft-lad (above) who has been using the childish phrase, when pressed, couldn't point to ONE sentence in Jimmy's piece above, yet named him as a Moyes hater (If it was a court case it'd be thrown out on day one and he'd be looking at a libel case)

If you're going to make claims like 'there's plenty of Moyes haters on here (and you actually mean people who hate David Moyes), then back up what you have to say with something approaching facts.

If not, wind your neck in.

And by the way, I might be bored (I'm in Hamburg, I'm entitled) but obviously no more bored than you.
Dean Adams
84 Posted 11/03/2012 at 19:57:50
Eugene Ruane 860

Clearly! But I have never known you to agree with anything I post, so no suprises. You have your opinions based on your view of things, I have mine. You are happy with yours (I assume) and I am happy with mine. It does not mean either is right or wrong. We just come from different backgrounds and have different ideas.

The EFC of the 10 years before Moyes was, in my opinion, doomed to the drop. Moyes has turned it around and with a bit of luck, I believe the youth system will soon bear fruit enabling us to make further steps forward.

I live in hope, more than expectation... perhaps you don't!!
Barry Rathbone
85 Posted 11/03/2012 at 20:46:26
Iain

Forgetting all the caveats and accepting it's a ploy to keep out Wenger and SAF I'll simply list those who have been given 10 yrs and you can work it out, here's the first 3:

Moyes
Moyes
Moyes

Because you barged in with capitals, it's;

DESPERATE with an "e"
Graham Mockford
86 Posted 11/03/2012 at 20:53:47
Ok Eugene I'll answer your questions only to try and calm you down a bit, I'm getting worried for your blood pressure.
Thanks for comparing me to Clarence Darrow by the way, high praise indeed but I suspect you may have been trying to be ironic.
Reading your post again you asked four questions, so in order

1. Yes

2. Yes it is their opinion but no they are not entitled to anything. It is my prerogative to label them as I see fit. They could always try to sue me for libel of course.

3. No I don't. In fact I think I may struggle to find anyone who would like to see Moyes gone who is a staunch supporter of the Board. If you can find one let me know.

4. No. I think you cannot discuss Moyes without the context of the economic environment in which he operates therefore it is inevitable the subject will involve discussions about our Board.



I may have to change my opinion on you as a Moyes hater because you seem to be catching Peter Barry's UPPER CASE syndrome.
Stephen Kenny
87 Posted 11/03/2012 at 21:06:10
Ian,

It's impossible to say one way or the other. We can't know for sure.

On the balance of probability there's not many that could have done much better but there may be a few who would have done equally well given that level of time to build. They may favour a more pleasing, yet equally effective style of football too. To most of the MOB the style of football and approach to games is the main factor in wanting him gone.
Eugene Ruane
88 Posted 11/03/2012 at 21:57:44
Oh dear Graham - the old calm down 'blood pressure' barb to kick off with.

Maybe the most desperate distraction any poster can begin a response with.

(raised the roof at Stonehenge when first used I believe).

Well, I'll keep it short as your answer to number four says it all.

"No. I think you cannot discuss Moyes without the context of the economic environment in which he operates therefore it is inevitable the subject will involve discussions about our Board".

So there we have it.

All discussions on Moyes tactics, Moyes team selections, Moyes training methods, Moyes substitutions?

"You cannot discuss Moyes without the context of the economic environment in which he operates...." etc blah.

You know, one of these days you're going to think an argument through, instead of just throwing yourself at it

I guarantee when you do, it'll feel great.

Until that happens, you'll continue to remind me of the Viz character with the Christian name Terry.

Last word to you.

Goodnight.
Graham Mockford
89 Posted 11/03/2012 at 22:21:57
Well thanks for the last word very gracious of you. I think I preferred the Clarence Darrow comparison as opposed to Terry Fuckwitt but I have to say for someone who accused me of name calling you are doing a pretty good job yourself, in fact you seem incapable of constructing an argument without personal insults or smart arsed references which I assume you think makes you sound clever.

You seem happy enough with my first three answers but not my fourth. Quite patently you can discuss elements of Moyes performance without reference to economics, however on a thread of lots of opinions it is impossible that it is not relevant the financial conditions are a topic for discussion. Quite rightly whether Moyes selects Neville over Barkley has fuck all to do with finances but whether he is doing a good job in the round it is absolutely relevant.
So don't worry about my ability to think an argument through I feel great most of the time.
Gute nacht
Jamie Barlow
90 Posted 11/03/2012 at 22:21:36
"Yes there are many who hate Moyes TACTICS, see him as dour and without imagination and or flair and believe he's gone stale (ie: me) but to describe those who see things this way as 'Moyes haters' is fucking plain dumb."

When did I describe any of those people as Moyes haters?

You said yourself that you might have seen two or three posts at most (ever!) that have actually said "I fucking hate David Moyes. My comment ( which I don't think justified me being called plain dumb, a soft kid or a prick) was aimed at certain posts where Moyes has been called a ginger twat, cunt, prick (take your pick) and should just fuck off.

Or, off the top of my head, the person who said he "couldn't give a fuck if Moyes won every game from now until the end of the season, I still want him gone".

Maybe hate is too strong a word but there are posters on here who clearly don't like the bloke.

I could trawl back through all the posts and i'm certain i'd find some more but I really can't be arsed.

I'm sorry if my off the cuff remark upset you.
Colin Southern
91 Posted 11/03/2012 at 22:52:00
I can't think of any manager with less resources than Moyes who has done better than him for more than a one-off season.

There have always been managers out there who play better football than Everton with less resources. They usually come up from the Championship and surprise everyone for a year. Then reality sets in and they can't compete during the next season ? they end up sacked or hovering near the bottom of the league or relegated.

That's why I think the majority of us are quite rightly thinking to know that we'll be goosed the day Moyes goes.
Mark Murphy
92 Posted 12/03/2012 at 10:37:30
I'm obviously a thicko cos I havent a clue who Clarence Darrow is but whilst I think Moyes has done a decent job I am not getting carried away with the odd "fighting above our weight" result and genuinly think that even witht he limited funds he has available he has the players to do better. I look at other line ups against us and even given that I look at our abilities through biased eyes I still struggle to fit many opposition players from the top five down into our team.
What confuses my view of Moyes is that he assembled this squad but isnt utilising it as best he should?
Roman Sidey
93 Posted 12/03/2012 at 11:24:48
Got in a bit late on this one. Really, Moyes's decisions on Tuesday night against the Shite will tell us more about the man than almost any game since the FA Cup Final. Liverpool are absolutely dreadful at the moment, and we seem only to perform acceptably against teams above us. No room for defenders coming on for attackers unless we're up by a couple, and certainly not the time to be breaking up the centre halves. Also, Drenthe HAS to start.

For me, a win is the only result that will keep me happy.

Additionally, with all this chat about Moyes talking to that fuckwit thespian we have as a chairman, Moyes's true character could be found out. If he signs for anything that isn't 20%+ less than his current deal, he's a fucking hypocrite. Also, if he actually signs another deal, and we don't get significant investment/a buyer within a couple of years, then he's nothing but a no mark who knows he couldn't cut it at a top club.
Matt Traynor
94 Posted 12/03/2012 at 12:04:13
Roman (002), if you cast your mind back to last January, I think it was Dalglish's first game in charge at Anfield. They were truly dreadful then, and we were 2-1 having been 1-0 down. That was the time for Moyes to get his first league win away at one of the original Sky 4.

Although they're dogshit again, particularly at Anfield, I can't see an Everton side being set up to go for a win. He just doesn't do that.
Daniel A Johnson
95 Posted 12/03/2012 at 12:08:33
Let's face it, Kenny Dalglish has spent over £65 Millon on new players and yet they are only 2 points ahead of us; David Moyes has spent fuck all. Imagine what Moyes could do with £65 million.

I would fucking love to see King Kenny's fucking face after we hammer them and move above them in the league.

The treatment of Roy Hodgson was shocking, yet King Kenny has been even more shite, but because it's King Kenny they shut the fuck up.

Judgement day is coming for the reds. Dalglish is a football managing relic and so out of touch with life outside of his LFC pyjamas, he doesn't even know what day of the week it is.
Tony J Williams
96 Posted 12/03/2012 at 12:32:41
"If he signs for anything that isn't 20%+ less than his current deal, he's a fucking hypocrite" ? No, he's not, he is going along with the norm of the whole game. If everyone else was taking a pay cut and he haggled for a pay rise, then he is a hypocrite.

The 4-5-1 against Spurs, Chelsea and Man City worked well enough for us in the last few games, so why should he change a winning formation again the Shite.... just because it's the Shite?
Gerard Carroll
97 Posted 12/03/2012 at 11:49:59
Mr Moyes has been here ten years, we have remained in the Premier League but with no silverware! I would describe him as an average manager. EFC have been very loyal to Moyes, they say familiarity breeds contempt!. Moyes is stuck in a very comfortable rut (a big fat salary rut!)
Danny Kewley
98 Posted 12/03/2012 at 12:22:15
The first time I saw Dalglish playing for Celtic, I thought he was fantastic. When he joined the dark side of Stanley Park, my opinion, though obviously lessened, in private hadn't changed a lot. HOW TIMES CHANGE !!!!

Never in all the derby games have I wanted us to win so much. I want to see Dalglish`s gob pouring out the excuses! By some considerable irony, not only did Moyes and Dalglish both play for Celtic, they are both Rangers fans!
Danny Kewley
99 Posted 12/03/2012 at 13:15:47
Forgot to add COYB !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Roman Sidey
100 Posted 12/03/2012 at 13:22:49
Tony, I agree that Moyes isn't the only one that is overpaid, and that all players are now earning more than they're worth to society, but if Moyes is going to come out with that pay cut stuff just before his negotiations start, then it is not unreasonable for us to expect him to take the cut. Regardless of what others are doing, it would still be pretty hard to understand if he didn't.
Stephen Kenny
101 Posted 12/03/2012 at 13:39:11
He should be paid what somebody feels he's worth in his industry. People aren't paid just on their value to society.

If clubs are getting themselves in a mess by living beyond their means they will have to face the consequences at some point. But they shouldn't blame anybosdy but themselves.
Richard Dodd
102 Posted 12/03/2012 at 14:05:14
I have good reason to suspect Davey has already sewn up an `in principle` deal with Blue Bill at 20% less than last time. Good business on Bill`s part and great bargaining card for Davey when he sits down with the `out of contract` players this summer. What a shrewd operator!
Roman Sidey
103 Posted 12/03/2012 at 21:59:17
Not that I want him to sign a new contract, Doddy, but knowing that he probably will, I hope you're right.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads