Moyes v Redknapp: tactical battle

, 12 March, 31comments  |  Jump to most recent
There are various opposing tactics in football — attacking versus defensive, ball retention versus counter-attack, fluid versus structured, wide versus narrow. Great tactical battles come between two sides evenly balanced in terms of ability, but completely opposing in strategic terms.

A detailed analysis of contrasting styles in The Guardian argues that both Moyes and Redknapp are highly talented, but both still need to diversify in order to establish themselves in the top tier of coaches.

Quotes or other material sourced from The Guardian Sport Blog



Reader Comments (31)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Roger Trenwith
1 Posted 12/03/2012 at 14:45:16
You can't argue with any of that, apart from "broadly speaking (Bale & Coleman) are two similar players". I wish!
Mick Gallagher
2 Posted 12/03/2012 at 15:01:23
Thats what most have been saying about playing lesser teams a bit more flair or invention. A few more points against lesser teams and who knows how further up the table we could be. 10 years on Wednesday lets hope the headlines are about Moyes first win at analfield.
Daniel A Johnson
3 Posted 12/03/2012 at 15:44:47
10 yrs and ZERO wins at Anfield.

Moyes the legend!
Jason Heng
4 Posted 12/03/2012 at 15:44:16
Is that why we can't beat Liverpool regularly... cos they are "weaker opposition"?
Jim Hourigan
5 Posted 12/03/2012 at 16:20:59
A simplistic view of tactics based on the analysis of how Bale plays. Redknapp made a mistake in playing Bale on the right to get away from Coleman and Neville - not just Coleman. He recognised his mistake and changed tactics and in the second half Bale caused far more problems.

That aside the more fundamental aspect of the tactics on show is one mans desire to win the game and anothers to avoid defeat and hope to win. First half we played well had outlets and caused them problems both out wide and with Osman playing short balls to feet. After a short period of pressure Moyes removes Drenthe - our main outlet with pace, puts on a converted defender into midfield and puts Osman out wide. Bale and their LB have pace to burn and Ossie is always chasing shadows. We have no way of getting forward and Moyes is content to defend.

Another centre half is brought on to defend with our only other bit of pace (Coleman) removed - again one man prepared to withdraw attacking players to defend and the other looking to attack. Moyes invited pressure through his negative approach to the second half. We had no way of getting forward with Osman chasing Bale, Rodwell running around trying to catch the pace of the game, Cahill producing his recently typically ineffective and useless performance. Without Fellaini in there trying to keep hold of the ball it would have been even more one sided than it was.

Fabulous result and great determination shown, but hand on heart how many of us were just waiting for the ball to hit the back of our net, hoping it wouldn't happen but getting very nervous.

From afar the result looks very impressive and when viewed alongside City and Chelsea its another feather in Moyes' cap. But for those of us who watch week in week out and think about the game its results by default rather than results by performance. Good luck David if you get the Spurs job, you've done a good job and imo its time to move on, but will you be in for a shock if you think Spurs will accept your tactics on a regular basis !!!
Danny Kewley
6 Posted 12/03/2012 at 17:01:53
As would be the case if ever he went to the Mancs...
Danny Kewley
7 Posted 12/03/2012 at 17:07:09
Also would be the case if ever Man U were to employ him.
Phil Brown
8 Posted 12/03/2012 at 18:14:07
Jim #079 - Couldn't agree more.
Jamie Tulacz
9 Posted 12/03/2012 at 18:54:45
Agree with the general principles the article lays out in terms of the opposing tactics of the two managers and that Moyes needs to be more expansive and confident against the smaller teams.

Don't quite agree with the Coleman/Bale example however, Bale is clearly the better attacking player and a big threat, fair enough to put Coleman on him. Drenthe with the best will, isn't a great defender but his pace can be really dangerous so leave him to attack the opposition. Having said that I agree that we sat back too much in the second half and allowed too much pressure on ourselves.
James Martin
10 Posted 12/03/2012 at 19:02:19
To be honest though, Redknapp reacts first to Moyes by moving Bale away from Phil Neville and Coleman. Drenthe has been starting on the right and with the absence of Pienaar Coleman was always going to come in on that left hand side especially since Bale had moved over there. Everton have great flanks at the moment offering both defensive solidity and attacking intent. Against Baines or Neville, Bale woudln't have done well and that's why Van der Vaart is usually their main threat against us.
Ryan Holroyd
11 Posted 12/03/2012 at 19:41:13
Jim Hourigan in Moyes bashing shock. £2.42 million pound net spend in 10 years. All-in-all, he's done a wonderful job. Only a compete and utter idiot would dispute that.
John Crawley
12 Posted 12/03/2012 at 20:31:03
Ryan I despair when I read cheap shots like you have just made against Jim Hourigan. If you want to disagree then lets hear some actual arguments about the points that Jim makes.
Personally I agree that Moyes has done a good job. Does that mean I can't be critical of the tactics Moyes uses? Of course not, the two are not mutually exclusive.
Michael Cox makes some interesting points about Moyes and he successfully pin points a major weakness that Moyes has, he is unable to adapt his tactics and the style of play to the opposition that he faces in a positive way. Therefore he struggles when we have to take the initiative and attempt to break down teams like QPR.
Jimmy Kelly
13 Posted 12/03/2012 at 21:07:24
Personally, i think that looks like a tactical 'analysis' by a 5 year old. He's got an opinion on both manager's tactics and has seen what he wanted to see to prove himself right.

Jim Hourigan appears to have done exactly the same. Bale only went wide left for about the last 10 minutes but Jim saw his pace causing Osman problems out there throughout the second half. Rodwell is described as a 'converted defender' despite never having played in defence in over 100 senior games, while coleman and drenthe - also converted defenders incidentally - are deemed to be attacking players.

I certainly wasn't expecting them to score Jim, from where I was sat it looked like we were defending resolutely, albeit far more than I would have liked! Spurs are very good side, and they put us under severe pressure, but aside from Saha hitting the post very late on they never actually looked like scoring. The closest other than that was a couple of deflected shots from outside the box.

If we went on a 9 game run without a win and an 'apologist' said that it was nothing to do Moyes and were just losing by default you would (quite rightly) castigate them for their blind faith and stupidity - well i'm afraid the same applies here, you've made Ryan's description look very accurate.
John Crawley
14 Posted 12/03/2012 at 21:46:47
Jimmy, Michael Cox knows what he is talking about. He has a very interesting blog about tactics which is well worth a read, take a look at: http://www.zonalmarking.net/. If you read the full article he was making an interesting comparison between the different approaches that Moyes and Redknapp have to management and tactics. He makes some interesting points about Moyes style. For example he argues that he has a very reactive approach which means that "Everton are well-suited to facing bigger opponents, but picking up wins against weaker opposition is more of a problem, as they look uncomfortable when forced to make the running." Hard to argue against that after watching the way we play. As he concludes Moyes is highly talented but if he wants to be in the top tier of coaches he needs to be able to adopt different approaches and be more creative. Can Moyes improve in this respect? On the recent evidence he doesn't show any signs that he can.
John Ford
15 Posted 12/03/2012 at 22:16:13
Is it coincidence that Arry only got his team above Everton once he'd been given millions to spend. Until them Moyes record was consistently better.

Tactics, really? Given the money anyone can open up.
Adam Luszniak
16 Posted 12/03/2012 at 22:01:07
Have to agree with Jimmy Kelly, in that apart from a few close shaves i don't think that Harry's contention that they 'battered' us in the second half was particularly fair. Shots on target for the whole game was 6 a piece.

Yes they had the lions share of possession in that latter half of the game, but they didn't do particularly well with it. I think Moyes tactics were fair enough, and i disagree with Jim Hourigan when he says " Moyes invited pressure through his negative approach to the second half." I think here the term 'defensive' has been confused with the term 'negative.'

I think Moyes realised that we didn't have the kind of arsenal available to us which would have allowed us to bury the game by scoring more goals, but that we did in fact have a squad of players who where more than capable of preventing Spurs from scoring. The changes he made obviously reflect this, and i'm not sure how playing to your strengths and protecting a well deserved lead is negative?

It is clear however that Moyes has difficulty putting together a squad which can break down teams who are happy to sit back and let us do the work. This is evidenced in the game against QPR and summed up by Drenthe's performance. He showed the spark of creativity which provided us the goal and shortly after caused the foul which allowed them back into the game. I think if Moyes had a couple more Drenthes, or just one very good one, (Say a Bale or a Modric) then his tactics wouldn't look so 'negative'.
Jimmy Kelly
17 Posted 12/03/2012 at 22:13:56
I'm sure he does know his stuff, but that article just seemed lazy to me.

If Moyes had said what Redknapp did after the game - that bale playing on the right pinned baines back - it would have been used as evidence of his 'reactive' style, but Harry saying it doesn't fit with the idea he's trying to put across so it's not mentioned.

The fact that we struggle to break down weaker teams is not only because of Moyes tactics - and before anyone pipes up I said not only - but because we don't have a lot of pace or guile in the side, and have been lacking a natural goalscorer. This is not necessarily because the manager doesn't want that sort of player but because they cost a lot of money.

The point about our average posession stats is pretty pointless aswell, seeing as the likes of Arteta and Pienaar haven't been here all year, the main reasons we used to keep the ball.

Anto Byrne
18 Posted 13/03/2012 at 07:37:08
When Spurs came out to play in the 2nd half, we defended well for 45+5 and rode our luck. It was a tactic to put two defenders on and remove two forwards and to take off the knackered Jelly for the Stracq.

Given our bench, we can't complain, although what if Moyes had put Barkley in for Cahill and replaced the tiring Coleman with Denis? Would this have made any difference to the Spurs onslaught? Most definitely as they would have had to defend against these players and would have been less of a threat going forward.

Moyes is the manager and in 10 years he will always defend what we have and will park the bus, pull down the shutters and run the clock down. THE RESULT IS ALL THAT MATTERS: 3PTS AND ANOTHER SCALP CHALKED UP. It's not pretty but then we are skint, ain't we... and being skint means we can't play decent football for 90 mins and play with an attacking intent.
Danny Broderick
19 Posted 13/03/2012 at 10:36:42
You don't need to be a rocket scientist to see that Moyes is the more cautious of the two coaches, while Harry's teams generally play better football and have a go. Spurs have been the best footballing team in the league this year, and while we have had our moments in the past (thinking back to when Arteta, Pienaar, the Yak etc were in their prime and we were playing in Europe), generally we have tended to play quite negatively under Moyes. Even the year we finished 4th we had a negative goal difference.

Having said this, one approach is not necessarily better than the other. Ideally, both managers could learn a thing or two from each other ? if Moyes is to progress, he could do with taking the handbrake off sometimes, especially against weaker opposition. And Harry could probably learn a thing or two about shutting up shop and seeing a game out... they would have won at the Emirates a couple of weeks ago if they'd been able to protect a 2-goal lead.

The match was a perfect reflection of their strengths and weaknesses, and we came out on top this time.
Robbie Muldoon
20 Posted 13/03/2012 at 13:39:20
BANG! Nail on the head in such a clear and concise article. This is why he frustrates many supporters.
Robbie Muldoon
21 Posted 13/03/2012 at 13:40:33
In that a bit more inventiveness against sides more often would undoubtedly reap a few more points.
Mike Gaynes
22 Posted 13/03/2012 at 15:52:34
"Undoubtedly", Robbie? How do you know? Inventiveness can lose you points as well. We've all seen managers juggle lineups and tactics and have them blow up in their faces.

Moyes is a conservative manager tactically. Whether he'd have been more or less successful if he'd been more adventurous is something we will never know. What he do know is that conservatism has worked for him for ten years, and he's not going to change.
Dave Wilson
23 Posted 13/03/2012 at 16:00:15
I think the prooof of who is the best coach lies in their league finishes and their head-to-heads.

Moyes twats him on both counts.
Aiden Doyle
24 Posted 13/03/2012 at 16:08:20
The thing is though, Moyes' "conservative" approach has actually yielded a greater win percentage (44.01 career percentage) than Harry Redknapp has achieved (40.81%).
John Crawley
25 Posted 13/03/2012 at 16:38:29
Yes but the point he is making is that although Moyes is a good coach if he wants to be one of the very top coaches he needs to be able to change his tactics, be more proactive and positive when needed. Mourinho is a good example, he is basically a defensive manager like Moyes but he is not reactive and can adapt his tactics and style of play in a positive manner when required. That is one of the main things that makes him such a brilliant manager.
Brian Waring
26 Posted 13/03/2012 at 16:45:12
For me, one of Moyes's problems is that he doesn't change tactics etc to suit who we are playing, its the same tactics no matter who.
Wayne Smyth
27 Posted 13/03/2012 at 16:57:03
I agree Brian.

If the players are capable of beating the likes of chelsea, man city and spurs - given a decent slice of luck - what is the reason we dont do nearly as well versus the "lesser" teams?

I think you do need to adjust your style of play for different games and I don't think Moyes does. I think against teams with worse squads, we need to attack a bit more and also keep attacking if we go ahead, not retreat to our own 18 yard line.
John Crawley
28 Posted 13/03/2012 at 18:29:00
Brian & Wayne I agree with you but its not just against lesser teams. To give an example look at the way we play away against Man Utd at Old Trafford. For the last ten years t's like Moyes has been stuck in some footballing equivalent of Groundhog day.
Jon Ferguson
29 Posted 13/03/2012 at 18:50:23
I don't see how anyone can disagree with the points made in the article.

Moyes meticulously plans whilst Redknapp wants players to express themselves.

We have struggled against lesser teams this year as our game plan is the same as against the top temas i.e not attacking enough.

Redknapp has struggled against the bigger teams as he should probably have a slightly more developed game plan.

It was a good idea trying to nullify Bale!

Surely no one can disagree with any of that? I thought it was completely correct. If only we had some decent analysis of games on TV. I hate the phrase 'I've seen them given'.

I do agree with Jim 079 on the fact that we went too defensive in the 2nd half against Spurs. I thought they would score, but they didn't and I left a happy boy!
Jon Ferguson
30 Posted 13/03/2012 at 18:58:51
Plus he says both need to improve to be considered one of the best. Again, surely an undeniable point.
Jim Hourigan
31 Posted 14/03/2012 at 13:12:39
Anyone want to defend Moyes and his tactics after that spinelss performance last night ?

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads