Elstone rules out redevelopment

, 16 March, 43comments  |  Jump to most recent
Despite evidence to the contrary provided by various groups over the years, Everton CEO Robert Elstone maintains that Goodison Park cannot be redeveloped — it would be too expensive — and he reiterates the failed business model of Destination Kirkby as the way forward.

?Chelsea recently did some work about the challenge of redeveloping and staying at Stamford Bridge, and it said their capacity would go down.?

He said the London club had been told it would be hugely complex and also cost £600m.

?There are similar problems to rebuilding Goodison. The only sensible option is land acquisition. I genuinely believe that the redevelopment of Goodison is not a realistic option.?

He said ideas to redevelop the Park End would still leave the other three sides of the stadium in desperate need of updating.

?We have to look for a new site and use the Kirkby funding model which involved 40% to 45% of the capital cost coming from retail uplift subsidy.

?I don't think there are a shortage of sites, I believe there is a shortage of funding.

?I think our optimum capacity is around 50,000, which generates an extra £5m [a year]. That means it's tight, it needs a great naming rights deal or subsidy, or probably both.?

Quotes or other material sourced from Liverpool Echo



Reader Comments (43)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Ray Said
1 Posted 17/03/2012 at 11:19:46
Did Elstone really say it would cost £600 million to redevelop Goodison?
Jay Harris
2 Posted 17/03/2012 at 17:26:09
It totally sums Elstone and the board up when he claims "he is not myopic" but EFC's only chance of more income is finding a retail-led development that might generate an extra £5 million a year.

Destination Kirkby 2, anyone? Or is Green still writing the scripts for him???

The club has been told 1000 times that GP can be developed economically and everyone knows Father Xmas doesn't exist so come on, Bill and "Friends of Everton".... fuck off and let somebody with brains take over the running of the club.
Mark Riding
3 Posted 17/03/2012 at 20:40:16
Now is the time to develop Goodison.
We aint getting relegated this year..
Plenty of bum teams next year in the league..
Even just one stand....

Ray Said
4 Posted 17/03/2012 at 21:06:48
Mark 883
Elstone recent quote re Chelsea ' the London club had been told it would be hugely complex and also cost £600m. ?There are similar problems to rebuilding Goodison',
With that attitude the ground wont event get a coat of paint this summer.
Gavin Ramejkis
5 Posted 17/03/2012 at 23:04:27
Bobby Bullshitter now spouting the same shite Kenshite did and Bobby had to admit at the DK hearings - this mythical "coming from retail uplift subsidy" also known and shown as a profit route for the shareholders and fuck all to do with being funded.

The toxic patch at Kirkby would have risen in value with the cowshed on it, as would another piece of barren scrubland if they find one somewhere else. As far as the £600m to rebuild the stadium, I'd expect the northern version of The Emirates for that money ? right on the waterfront.
Lyndon Lloyd
6 Posted 17/03/2012 at 23:32:06
It wasn't so much the Destination Kirkby business model that failed as the scale of the project (in terms of its impact on the rest of the region) and the fact that none of the financing that Everton claimed was holding up their end of the bargain ever really existed.

If you can get a development partner to foot the majority of the bill and provide you with a first-class stadium in the right location with the right transport infrastructure, then the model works fine.

Unfortunately, it's all a bit pie-in-the-sky; you don't get brand-new, world-class stadia (or even anything approaching it) without hundreds of millions of pounds. Which retail partner is going to be willing and/or able to offer that?

The Kings Dock was the once-in-a-generation opportunity and the for want of the equivalent of couple of Fellainis, we screwed it up.

Mark Riding
7 Posted 17/03/2012 at 23:34:17
Elstone.. your boss had the chance of a lifetime and totally fucked it up... Why should we believe you about Goodison when your boss couldn't even come good on the 'ring-fenced' money for the perfect Kings Dock??

I don't believe a word anymore. Wolves are developing their ground during a period of recession (builders needing contracts) and you're still living in fantasy land.

Your plan of moving makes an extra £5m a year, does it?? Try investing in the team and gaining some Premier League places and extra sponsorship / TV deals first...

The Nike kit deal next year may help... but I doubt it!
Tom Hughes
8 Posted 17/03/2012 at 23:43:50
The man is a complete charlatan.... £600m to redevelop GP? Yes, that is the inference. Despite the fact that the professionals have shown that redevelopment can cost a tiny tiny fraction of this. The continued insistence that only a retail-led scheme can deliver tells you all you need to know about the competence of those in charge of our club. A complete farce!
Derek Thomas
9 Posted 18/03/2012 at 00:40:10
Not can't - Won't. He's right about the funding being the major stumbling block. BoD want someone else to pay for it coz they won't
Gavin Ramejkis
10 Posted 18/03/2012 at 01:01:54
By the way, The Emirates only cost £470m so, in a recession, with builders' and materials' costs available for a song in a buyers' market, the £600m must be taken as it is: utter fabrication ? even in London, that would be an outlandish cost.

The £16m for the new Wolves stand is a far more indicative cost, which both Trevor and Tom have shown with documentary precision is down to sight lines and cost per seat and corporate / box provision.
Trevor Skempton
11 Posted 18/03/2012 at 08:19:02
We have to keep saying it, for those who are new to the arguments: there are three ways forward, one of which is more sensible than the others.

1. Wait for a fairy godparent to buy us a new ground [and, while we're at it, a team to compete with Barcelona].

2. Share with LFC - Many of us have taken a good hard look at this, but it seems like a flawed business proposition because it would damage key unique selling points [of both clubs] as well as upsetting many supporters.

3. Develop Goodison in affordable stages, starting with an expansion of the Park End, linked with a new hotel and 7-days a week hospitality overlooking the park. This would allow for the retention of much of Goodison's historic structure and atmosphere, retaining its place at the heart of the community, and placing it as a key element in a new World-class Football Quarter. It's not about the overall final cost, it's about what can be self-financing at each stage - producing extra revenue to support of the club's first priority - team development.

Barry Rathbone
12 Posted 18/03/2012 at 09:08:15
I've said it before and I'll keep at it: where has a new stadium transformed a club's fortunes?

Derby, Coventry, Southampton, Middlesbrough, Sunderland, Man City, Arsenal?

Man City rumoured to be taken over must be spurrious else why are they talking about building a new one?

Arsenal ? not won a bean since moving. Much is made of Wenger not spending the apparent increase in transfer funds from The Emirates ? is that the case or is the build cost absorbing it?

Shifty bugger that Elstone, isn't he.
Barry Rathbone
13 Posted 18/03/2012 at 09:34:40
Oh, and Bolton.
Phil Martin
14 Posted 18/03/2012 at 10:16:07
Small time CEO for a small time outfit. At least we aren't owned by lazy, incompetent foreigners, eh?
Bobby Thomas
15 Posted 18/03/2012 at 10:03:50
New stadium effect and a good team go hand in hand, Barry, no-one is sugggesting that building a new ground gives you cutting edge up front, for example.

The Emirates does not mean that Wenger's recent signing record isn't poor. But it does mean that they have safeguarded the future of the club for generations.

A new stadium on its own does not guarrentee progress on the pitch. But it would give us modern facilities and increase our chances of generating more revenue/make us a more attractive proposition to new investment, for example.

Or we could keep trying to progress / stand still / manage our decline by doing nothing. Our ground is the equivalent of a wooden tennis racket.

Ever attempted to buy anything in the Bullens Road at half time, it's a joke... it's difficult giving Everton your money!!

Goodison is a timewarp. It's one of the main reasons we are viewed as an irrelevance in modern football.

This was the great thing about the Kings Dock. It would have transformed the way Everton are perceived locally, nationally and internationally. There is virtually no chance of getting a similar scheme that would give the club the adrenaline shot it desperately needs.

But it doesn't mean we shouldn't try, or look to re-develop Goodison. We do nothing and we are toast as a top flight club at some point, soon.
Paul Watson
16 Posted 18/03/2012 at 10:07:49
The Emirates is certainly the role model for many football clubs ? but take a closer look at the actual detail and who has benefitted.

The stadium and infrastructure cost an initial £390m. Asenal heavily discounted the naming rights and sponsorship and so had to borrow £260m from the markets in order to see the project through. It took 2 years of planning and a plethora of enquiries and contracts before they got the first JCB in.

To help fund the deal, Arsenal got planning permission to build 711 flats at the Highbury site ? Highbury is a Grade 2 listed building and had to be accommodated. They also managed an agreement with Islington Council for a further 3,000 homes in the Borough by what is known as'planning gain'.

Arsenal are one of the biggest property players in North London. The increased capacity and corporate facilities have allowed Arsenal to comfortably pay the accrued debt and post a very healthy profit, BUT this does not appear to have found its way into the playing pool.

Arsenal was for years a family run club - it has never been quoted on the stock exchange. However, since the Emirates arrived it has been the subject of a bitter battle to control the club by amongst others, a Russian Billionaire and an American billionaire. The club is valued by Forbes at over £1 billion. It generates very big profits ? in excess of £60m.

A modern stadium with associated retail/housing/corporate facilities would appear to be good for the overall value of the club, but there is no real evidence that this will filter through to playing staff.
Phil Walling
17 Posted 18/03/2012 at 10:25:52
I gave my tickets away for yesterday`s game which I think is the beginning of the end of my lifetime love affair with EFC. This administration and one-eyed manager has just about done for me and when the twat Elstone comes out with this crap it just goes to confirm there is no fucking hope!

Steady decline now until we reach a `Rangers situation`. Depressed... you bet.
Derek Thomas
18 Posted 18/03/2012 at 10:43:34
Until the revolution all we are is Leeds in slow motion, we can't even go bankrupt properly.
Paul Watson
19 Posted 18/03/2012 at 10:54:10
Beware Greeks bearing gifts. A new stadium ? anyone remember John Hall at Newcastle? King of the Geordies, "NUFC's saviour". Well, he had a very grand plan to move Newcastle out of St James Park.

SJP was old, in need of massive renovation, in an old part of the city... sounds familiar. Hall wanted to build an 80,000-seat stadium. He even had the site ? near Sunderland! Yes, they were going to Gateshead and they would share with their biggest rivals, along with two rugby clubs and an ice hockey team. There would also be a shopping centre, posh houses, golf course and park.

A large part of the cost would be picked up from grants, loans and bond issues. None would come from him. For one reason and another it never happened ? they redeveloped SJP, and a magnificient stadium it is.

Hall eventually sold his interest to Mike Ashley, who to his horror found the extent of Newcastle's debts too big even for a billionaire ? relegation ensued.

If we are talking about a ground for football, Goodison has potential ? as the American owners have discovered about Anfield. If you are talking about shareholders making a handsome profit, throw in a retail park and new housing and take the tax breaks associated with a 'community venture' and Bob's your uncle..
Barry Rathbone
20 Posted 18/03/2012 at 11:24:04
Bobby

"New stadium effect and a good team go hand"

"A new stadium on its own does not guarrentee progress on the pitch."

Not sure you're consistent there and the first statement seems without basis given the clubs I've mentioned.

If we had the beans to do it and do it properly fair enough - but we haven't.

Has to be a phased redeveloped GP - no realistic alternative.
Peter Foy
21 Posted 18/03/2012 at 12:46:00
This is why the club is simply not for sale. Phillip Green wants his retail Park. End of.
Bobby Thomas
22 Posted 18/03/2012 at 12:05:03
Barry, to progress a club, ideally the new stadium effect/redevelopment will go hand in hand with being well managed on the pitch to get the optimum effect.

So, therefore, no, a new stadium itself doesn't guarentee success on the pitch.

I'm not being consistent?

To drive a club forward, you need to be well managed on and off the pitch, that's obvious. Suppose the best example of that is United in the 90s. Celtic is another decent example. They were in a similar position to us 20 or so years ago. But they got it done and progressed the club.

A club can do the right thing in getting infrastructure boxed off and completely balls up managerial appointments: Southampton, Newcastle etc. Countless examples of ego, personality clashes, outright cluelessness from chairman on football matters, hurting a club.

Conversely, we are an example of a club that has benefitted from stability and progression on the pitch; up until a couple of years ago we were progressing on the pitch, and that has been derailed by our board's inability to progress off it. As I say, you need board and pitch working in harmony to achieve optimum effect.

A new stadium will not stop a manager buying shit players, as is the case with the majority of clubs you have mentioned.

Someone has rightly highlighted the murky ownership issue at Arsenal, and also there are questions about profit being fed into team building, we shall see what Wenger does in the summer, I guess.

Money was tight at Arsenal when the ground move was on, but it still doesn't mean that his recent signing record isn't patchy. That's the main reason they have declined on the pitch.

However, so far, they still qualify for the Champions League every year. Wenger has won the league 3 times at Arsenal. Other than that the main hallmark of his tenure is Champions League qualification, every year.

They are in a very strong position as a club and turn huge cash profit. They have a new infrastructure for generations, boxed off. They have stalled slightly because, putting it bluntly, he has been signing players that aren't as good as previous ones.

I just think your point is a bit one-dimensional.
Mark Riding
23 Posted 18/03/2012 at 12:56:47
To take two of the clubs mentioned above, Newcastle & Southampton... the thing is, their 'bad' owners have gone ? ours shows no sign of going anywhere.

I personally can't stand Newcastle, but they are now breaking even and will make a profit next season. Southampton will be back in the Premier League next season and St Marys is a very tidy stadium indeed (just think of the players they have had to sell as well.. Bale, Walcott. Chamberlain etc).

As I said earlier, we need to do something now about the ground issue, as we could end up being Sheffield Wednesday quite quickly!
Bobby Thomas
24 Posted 18/03/2012 at 12:53:00
Barry, I know what you're saying about my initial "hand in hand" comment. It sounded like I believe a new stadium will automatically mean a good team.

I don't think that, but it may have come across that way.

Think I've subsequently justified my train of thought now my hangover is receding!!

Just to clarify, main point is that, to get the full benefit, new infrastructure and good team will be achieved in unison.

That's where I was coming from with the "hand in hand " comment.
Robbie Riddal
25 Posted 18/03/2012 at 13:09:09
"He said Chelsea had been told it would be hugely complex and also cost £600m."

Sigh. No doubt those instructed to carry out a feasibility report on the redevelopment of Stamford Bridge were told to come back with the most expensive price, just like Desperate Dan & Corky the Cat were told to do when Everton asked them to do the same with Goodison. It's common knowledge that Chelsea are also looking to move away from Stamford Bridge, amidst much fan resistance, and as such any club-sponsored feasibility report cannot be taken seriously.

I am sick to death of Elstone's complete lack of transparency, he is treating supporters of this football club with such disrespect it's sickening. Half-truths, lies, spin, all to pursue an agenda. Get these rats out of our club, before they put the final nail in the coffin.
Steve Abraham
27 Posted 18/03/2012 at 13:21:12
Is there a problem with Goodison redevelopment? What happened with that 3 storey building that was supposed to go on the Park End car park? Are the same problems preventing redevelopment?
David Hallwood
28 Posted 18/03/2012 at 13:33:04
Mmmmmmmmm... Same old, same old. I wish when anyone from the club talked about possible sites, they would name them. I know the city really well and I am struggling to name more than three sites that are suitable and wouldn't have to overcome years of planning objections.

I was pro DK, but now that's dead in the water, IMHO the only way forward is to redevelop the old girl in phases.
Peter Davies
29 Posted 18/03/2012 at 15:39:00
TREVOR SKEMPTON!
The obvious choice is option 1...that's the one most likely to happen for us!
Gavin Ramejkis
30 Posted 18/03/2012 at 16:16:56
Peter, I think whilst we are stuck with Calamity Kenwrong we have option 4 which is sod all.
Kevin Tully
31 Posted 18/03/2012 at 16:41:28
Now just waiting on the the new figures to be spouted by the fools: "You would need a billion to purchase Everton ? £600m to redevlop Goodison, £150m to buy the club, and £250m to buy a League winning squad.

I knew we would reach the £1bn mark sooner or later. Why do people fall for this shit?

The current board have no ideas and no money, so anyone with a few bob would be an improvement on these liars.
Barry Rathbone
32 Posted 18/03/2012 at 16:50:40
Bobby

No probs, mate ? at least you had a hangover to blame. I put my trackie bottoms on the wrong way round this morning after scrupulously checking where the label was ? hadn't touched a drop.

Honestly reckon I'm losing it these days.
Ciarán McGlone
33 Posted 18/03/2012 at 17:11:11
This doesn't sound like the words of a man who expects the impending sale of the club.

Fishy...

The club's for sale? My arse.
Eric Myles
34 Posted 19/03/2012 at 01:32:07
Paul 005, "He even had the site ? near Sunderland! Yes, they were going to Gateshead."

Sorry but Sunderland is nowhere near Gateshead mate.
Steve Carter
35 Posted 19/03/2012 at 02:22:03
As an outsider, I express my regret in advance for offending those of you who regularly attend matches and want to stay at Goodison. (I am an Australian who has keenly followed Everton since 1972. I have only been to Goodison three times: 2004 Everton 1 Middlesbrough 0; 2005 Everton 0 Bolton 4; 2011 Everton 2 Aston Villa 2). However, again with the outsider and Australian caveats, I cannot understand (other than for historical/sentimental reasons) why people want us to stay at Goodison any longer than is necessary.

It is, let's face it, out there in a pretty downmarket area that people only go to when Everton is playing, arrive a bit before the game to down a pint or two (in the Winslow... good grief... is there a more grimy, uninviting waterhole?) and then bugger off straight away after the match. Put up a spanking new stadium with a hotel and convention centre, etc., as much as you like, and people still won't want to hang around out there. It'll just be a shining white elephant amongst all that decaying red brick Victorian terrace. Walton or Kirby, it doesn't matter: both are, I'm sorry, uncool, unsexy suburbia.

Comparisons with Arsenal, Chelsea or anywhere else in London are not apt. Yes, they're not in the City, but there's stuff happening around afterwards, and if you don't want to hang around you just walk a few minutes to the tube and in 10 mins you're where you want to be next (unlike hanging around for a bus or taxi in the freezing cold on Walton Lane, and then meandering your way back into Liverpool). To state the obvious, we blew it big time with Kings Dock. Is it not possible to find a site around the City area?
Martin Mason
36 Posted 19/03/2012 at 03:41:00
The depressing problem is that any option for redevelopment of Goodison or moving to a new ground is that EFC has to put up some money and this effectively rules out any option. I would say that the board probably realises now that they aren't going to sell the club so I see nothing but black clouds everywhere for the club and a future at best reaching financial equilibrium as a Championship / League One team and at worst in receivership.

What is even more concerning now is that perhaps £40M of potential sales revenue in Rodwell and Barkley is looking like a pipe dream. I agree with Steve above that we shouldn't be tied to Goodison but this is a minor detail if we can't afford a move or redevelopment under any circumstances.
Martin Mason
37 Posted 19/03/2012 at 03:55:28
Just an off topic comment but I watched United put 5 past Wolves last night and I realised that they aren't massively better than other squads. What they are though is well organised and they play very simple football and work incredibly hard in terms of movement. They don't do hoofball but they attack the area on the ground and they have players in the box to take the final ball and score.

They are on a different planet compared to us but with our squad we should be a lot closer to them than we are. Hoofball isn't football and until our coaches learn the simple basics, as practiced by United, we will be doomed to footballing mediocrity and the embarrassing spectacles we witnessed this week.
Richard Dodd
38 Posted 19/03/2012 at 08:51:19
Just to deny Phil Walling`s claim that `me and me mates` make up most of the phantom bidders reputed to be ready to buy our Club. But we might just as well be as only a Russian gangster or a misguided shiek has enough money to solve Everton`s problems if the re-deveopment of Goodison would cost £600M. Total bullshit, methinks!
Tom Hughes
39 Posted 19/03/2012 at 08:32:07
Steve,
3 visits to Goodison hardly qualifies you as an expert on Walton.... and the Winslow is only one of dozens of pubs in the area. There are many very good ones amongst them.

The city-centre is only minutes away by train, bus or taxi. The high density Victorian streets and pub-laden high streets are an Evertonian hotbed and in many ways an asset. The fabric is a bit tatty in places (mainly the non-Victorian additions of the 70s) but it has massive potential.

I've got nothing against a city-centre move but this will require substantial enabling or financial assistance. GP does not require 4 new stands right now and therefore in both practical and emotional terms it is a very safe bet in the absence of a grand masterplan to move dowtown.

The club's sustained insistence that a retail-led scheme is the only option illustrates in one go their grip on the key issues. It was made abundently clear at the inquiry that no such scheme will be allowed in the region for overwhelmingly obvious reasons. In anycase, the tiny amount of enabling that would've been realised by the whole DK project wouldn't have paid for half of one stand.

The retail development would've need to be approx the size of 5 Trafford centres to have come close to covering the build costs. City-centre schemes are different but I think it would require far greater vision than anything remotely demonstrated by the current custodians.
Tom Hughes
40 Posted 19/03/2012 at 09:13:53
I also meant to say that is isn't about being tied to anything.... it is about looking at all the options and seeing the value in what you've got. GP is real.... it is a solid foundation to build on. It won't appear on any spreadsheet but there is great value in tradition and heritage and we are as rich as any in this respect.

In practical terms there is also value in continuity and the tried and tested. Moving is always a bit of a gamble in these respects. Even a slightly different street layout can greatly affect access and egress dynamics perhaps even changing the feelings and perceptions for the club and the matchday experience. DK would've been potentially catastrphic in this respect.

Yes, city-centre could be great, but unfortunately I've a feeling that we've missed that boat.
Steve Carter
41 Posted 19/03/2012 at 10:04:36
I accept that, Tom. I have really only blown in and out, and better take a proper look next time at the Walton area (hopefully later this year). We were impressed with the City area when we there for the Villa game earlier this season. It's a shame that it doesn't look promising there for Everton.
James Flynn
42 Posted 19/03/2012 at 15:14:05
Said before and am saying again, The Shite's ownership had a similar situation to Goodison with Fenway Park in Boston for their Red Sox.

Here's a quote from an article discussing their current ownership's outlay over 9 years of $140 Million. Dollars not pounds.

"This American icon that once was cramped and congested now has more seats and spaces, wide open concourses, new and improved facilities and many more food and beverage options for our fans. Leading up to its 100th anniversary in 2012, our focus has been always to improve and expand the physical structure without disturbing the warmth, charm and authenticity that surrounds this ballpark,"

At $140 million over 9 years... £600 million? What an insult to intelligence.
Tom Hughes
43 Posted 19/03/2012 at 15:59:29
James.... you're absolutely right. GP can be all that Fenway and Wriggley field are.... and more besides. Being 4 sided GP can match all their charm and intimacy and still have extensive modernity too. £600m is indeed an insult to our intelligence, timed and designed to plant seeds of doubt regarding the Football Quarter.
James Flynn
44 Posted 19/03/2012 at 18:00:48
Tom - I wonder often just what it is this group intends? Players the only assets left to sell. Two failed attempts at a new stadium. Really, I'm not even taking shots at them. What exactly are their plans? They have to have SOME idea. Yet, we just keep dripping and drabbing along.

At this stage, I can't see interested parties swooping in without a significant drop in asking price which seems is only coming along if relegation does.

And we're not even asking some new financial wheel be invented. Between American and European professional sport, many simple revenue streams have been well-established. We're not even copying some of them.

There's really no plan at all? None?

What the Fuck?

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads