Season › 2011-12 › News
Football Quarter may get special status
Council bosses have discussed the feasibility of unveiling a designated Business Improvement District for the proposed 40-acre zone in Stanley Park between the two stadiums.
While talks are currently in the ?ideas? stage, indications are that town hall chiefs believe an approved business district award could help the initiative's cause.
Under the scheme, clustered firms pay up to 2% of their rates to a specially-created group that spends the cash on improvement projects in their areas that can include safety, events, marketing or green issues.
Also suggested was the possibility of a Football Quarter becoming part of a Mayoral Development Zone after the May election.
Council leader Joe Anderson — the favourite for Mayor — has backed the scheme, which includes a ?fanzone? venue, football museum, hotels, bars, restaurants, and pedestrian links between Anfield and Goodison Park.
Colin Fitzpatrick, from KEIOC, said: ?We have been having meetings since we launched the project just after Christmas. The council, Liverpool Vision and Mersey Partnership appear to be solidly behind what we are suggesting. We would welcome any ideas of how funding could be attracted to the Football Quarter and backing from agencies in the region.?
The quarter plans, set out in a 28-page prospectus, include a possible park-and-ride link between Walton and the city centre.
Crucial to the idea is investment from private companies and support from city agencies to give it financial backiing. So far, Liverpool and Everton football clubs have remained non-committal.
A Liverpool council spokesman said: ?This is still in the very early stages, but there is a possibility we could look at the Football Quarter being a Business Improvement District. We are looking at a number of options.?
A Mersey Partnership spokesman added: ?Football is a massive part of the city visitor economy, particularly with Scandinavians and Europeans.
?Home matches at Anfield and Goodison are lucrative dates for the region, as they have a knock-on benefit with hotel occupancy.?
Ian McCarthy, director of programmes of Liverpool Vision, welcomed the ?supporters-led? initiative.
He said: ?We met the groups who have developed the proposal and are supportive of the concept. It has been accepted for many years that the economic and employment potential of the two football clubs in such close proximity, is not being exploited.
?The wider city and particularly the local area would benefit from an improved environment, better accessibility and extended visitor offer, both on match days and during the week when considerable numbers visit the stadiums.?
Quotes or other material sourced from Liverpool Echo
Reader Comments (20)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 05/04/2012 at 19:05:57
3 Posted 05/04/2012 at 20:09:40
4 Posted 06/04/2012 at 02:39:53
The initiative is based on the fact that both clubs are operating within a mile of each other and will continue to do so, for without that commitment the Football Quarter is a no go business initiative.
Stepping back LFC want to increase their match day capacity to increase revenue and are debating if this can be done in house at Anfield or elsewhere, financial, growth and income related objectives.
EFC, as demonstrated with Kirkby have no such objective, with similar capacities being seen as acceptable. The driver for EFC is not so much ot increase match day revenue than increase worth of the club to current owners ( as confirmed in the last inquiry)
Without the commitment of both clubs to make a statement such as "A commitment to find a solution to redevelop what we have or stay in the immediate vicinity" business investors will not commit to the quarter ewither. Chicken and egg time.
The one obvious solution is obtaining grants to build a single stadium. But that would take away the large pay day prize for EFC directors (shared stadium, shared / lesser value) plus of course it hasn't got the full support of the fans.
But honestly, if a single stadium made financial sense to both clubs do you really thing either would actually consider the fans??
Our best scenario for the football quarter to happen would be:
1. Liverpool redevelop Anfield.
2. Everton are sold.
If both of the above happen I think a new owner of Everton would follow LFC lead and redevelop Goodison.
THEN a football quarter would happen AND be successful.
A great initiative now sits ons the alter of the great god of money and greed.
5 Posted 06/04/2012 at 04:40:37
I think the more PR this idea gets, the bigger chance both clubs will follow and at least take a serious look at it.
6 Posted 06/04/2012 at 07:11:08
7 Posted 06/04/2012 at 09:56:00
8 Posted 06/04/2012 at 11:15:40
http://soccernet.espn.go.com/news/story/_/id/1042232/uefa-representative-defends-milan-pitch-after-barcelona-complaint?cc=5739#
...its a bad idea from every aspect. Unless you go down the absurd dual retractable pitch notion.
The other point Steve is that the whole purpose of the Football Quarter is to provide some hope that there may be enough trade to make KEIOC's Park End hotel concept a viable revenue generator for EFC when there is no match on. Shared stadium doesnt fit the agenda.
9 Posted 06/04/2012 at 14:03:04
But on the subject of grounds it's my view that the only way forward for both clubs is one stadium. It's just a sign of the times; this recession will be a fact of life for many years to come. I just can' t ever see public funding awarded for two similar projects in the same location or even area and where is the private funding going to come from??
10 Posted 06/04/2012 at 15:12:43
11 Posted 06/04/2012 at 16:29:08
Perhaps EFC and LFC could cooperate better in other ways too in such a situation. Probably not financially, as the dark side are in a far better situation there at the moment.
On the other hand, a shared stadium does work in some European cities such as Munich and Milan, although how the fans feel about them is open to discussion.
I often wonder what Liverpool and Everton supporters think of the present domination of Manchester in the Premier League. Is it due to luck or something else?
12 Posted 06/04/2012 at 16:49:11
I think the issue is what to do with the hotel on those days when there is no football being played. Like weekdays and the whole off season!. Enter the Football Quarter concept and the hope and prayer that its not just attractive to locals but also to out-of-towners who might need a hotel and not notice the dozens in the city centre that are also usually not full on non-matchdays!.
Did you read the article from the link I put up above regarding Barca's bitter complaints to UEFA over the state of the shared pitch at Milan?.
Thats a recurring theme for the state of a pitch in a shared stadium when two top flight clubs try and use it. There are solutions, as mentioned, one is to have dual retractable pitches.
The question has to come though about the costs for such an edifice and at what point would we have to contribute so much, to the shared stadium, that we could actually have built a more modest ground for ourselves with our 'contribution' anyway!.
13 Posted 06/04/2012 at 18:26:24
Sorry if I gave the impression that the issue is more about two stadiums than a shared one. I should have probably written the contribution in a different way....
Where I live, in Bern Switzerland., Novotel built a big hotel very close to the new stadium the " Stade de Suisse", . This was built for the European Championships when they shared the event with Austria. It holds 32K spectators, has excellent facilities and also a big VIP area with restaurants etc. Sponsors were mainly the Swiss Coop who opened a large supermarket, underground parking and a shopping mall below the stadium itself.
The Hotel mentioned above is also just across the road from the Bern Ice Hockey stadium which has the largest capacity in Europe. At the moment it's invariably full (17k) as it's been fully renovated.and the team is "top 4"
Having worked in Swiss Hotels for 10 years, one can say town Hotels are mostly empty at weekends because they're mostly catering for business people during the week. You then have to try to put bums in beds on Fridays and Saturdays
If you apply the above formula to a FOOTBALL town hotel then the capacity improves, so the Park End idea has merit
The Novotel does well but also because Bern needed more visitors beds and in spite of another large new Hotel which was built quite close by.
I take your point about the state of the pitch in Milan. In fact, I could envisage a movable pitch too, as in the Schalke facility in Germany.
In sum, there are all sorts of factors and possibilites concerning this whole subject and comparing similar situations in other countries could perhaps show what can or even should be undertaken.
14 Posted 06/04/2012 at 19:14:36
I'm neutral on the stadium or stadiums issue.
like the Swiss on other matters!
Personally, I WOULD prefer each team had their own new or rebuilt ones.
The alternative to a movable pitch by the way is an artifical one but they cause other problems.
Harry Redknapp railed against the artificial one which was intially laid at the "Stade de Suisse" after the European Championships.
Tottenham were 3 down within 25 minutes on that surface during a championship qualifier against Young Boys Bern. When Spurs got used to the surface, they scored 2 in reply in the second half and won the replay easily at White hart Lane!
15 Posted 06/04/2012 at 19:33:04
16 Posted 06/04/2012 at 19:35:14
Please put John with (number) when making references to other contributions. I know I should have noticed which John you meant
but the numbering system prevents confusion
17 Posted 06/04/2012 at 23:38:09
Indeed on the numbering...my apologies.
I know what you are saying on the hotels profile usually being light at weekends. That doesnt seem applicable to Liverpool though. If you check midweek next week in the city for example you'll see that 78 out of 87 hotels showing on the Active Hotels site (one I've used a lot) have availability.
Its weekends when its hard to get a hotel bed here...especially if the red side are playing. Very different from that you describe. An incidental point though and not on topic so I'll tip my cap to you mate and leave it there.
18 Posted 07/04/2012 at 01:23:16
I think if you check most city's room availability, you will find that on most occasions there is availability.... However, the stats also show that Liverpool has had one of, if not the highest occupancy rates in the UK over the last few years Hence the reason for the continual additions, with more to come.
The attraction for any prospective hotel chain might be the rooms with a view aspect, with exec boxes that convert into rooms.... this combined with on-site exhibition/conference and catering facilities may form a potent mix.
Then there is the Gwladys Street School redevelopment combined with Bullens Rd-Walton Lane Triangle forming a potential residential/community/education-based development to help fund stadium development on that side of the stadium.
The whole point being that there is a lot already in place, and a lot to build upon..... this aswell as the shared infrastructure has massive value.
19 Posted 08/04/2012 at 16:06:55
Good idea that about hotel rooms overlooking the pitch.
Basle's new stadium, in Switzerland, includes an old people's home and they have a special room which has an excellent view of pitch. It's very popular with the senior citizens!
20 Posted 10/04/2012 at 01:09:09
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 05/04/2012 at 18:35:03
I just find it sad that supporters groups have had to come up and promote the idea, which will have massive benefits for the local area and the city, and neither club has shown much interest in the proposals as they are both too tied up in their own agendas regarding relocation.