Hillsborough tribute at semi-finals

, 10 April, 139comments  |  Jump to most recent
A minute's silence to mark the 23rd anniversary of the Hillsborough disaster will be held before this weekend's FA Cup semi-finals at Wembley. Players from all teams involved will also wear black armbands in memory of the 96 Liverpool fans who died on April 15, 1989 at the semi-final with Nottingham Forest.

Saturday will be a particularly poignant affair with the Reds taking on Everton in a Merseyside derby at Wembley.

Rival captains Steven Gerrard and Phil Neville will present members of the Hillsborough Family Support Group with flowers prior to kick-off and also lay floral tributes to the Hillsborough victims at the side of the pitch.

Liverpool paid their own tribute with a minute's silence prior to Saturday's game at home to Aston Villa and Anfield will host the annual memorial service on Sunday afternoon.

"We are very respectful to Liverpool FC in regards of this weekend," FA spokesman Scott Field said.

"We understand the significance and the importance to the club, the fans, the staff and of course, the wider significance of our game."

Quotes or other material sourced from Football 365



Reader Comments (139)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Stephen Sullivan
1 Posted 10/04/2012 at 14:45:05
A minutes silence in honour of Hillsborough victims to take place before the semi final plus black armbands. We should honour this with due respect. However, we need to make sure we are not sidetracked by the emotion of the occasion.

I feel Kenny is bound to mention "winning it in memory" and try and use it as an inspirational/motivatiional factor for Liverpool. I'm not sure he is right to do that as loss of life in my opinion should never be used to inspire victory over another, especially if the opposition were connected through friendship and in many case the blood relatives of those who died?

Maybe Kenny will not use Hillsborough like I suspect he will?
Andrew Fair
2 Posted 10/04/2012 at 15:21:02
Stephen #903 I think its a great point about Hillsborough. It was of course awful and we will all (I hope) respect the minutes silence but .............. The media is going to make a huge huge deal of it all, the build up will be all about Hillsborough and LFC and Kenny especially will use it to spur on the reds (although what the anniversary means to most of their players nowadays is minimal).

Our lads need to respect it before the start, I believe Neville is too put a wreath down before the game. Then however we need to completely ignore the anniversary for 90 mins! We are the better footballing team and should win comfortably. It's getting very exciting!
Steven Connor
3 Posted 10/04/2012 at 16:06:03
So it was announced this afternoon that there will be a minutes silence prior to both semi finals at the weekend to commemorate those who died at Hillsborough.


This was almost inevitable I suppose from the moment the possibility of a Merseyside Derby was thrown up in the draw and with it also being the Hillsborough anniversary.


It does, however, raise a number of thorny issues.
Let me state first off, that I think it right and proper that the anniversary of the disaster be marked in some way. Like all scouse thirty-somethings, what unfolded on 15 April 1989 had a profound impact on me at the time and has continued to do so since. And I, like thousands of other Evertonians, will show the utmost respect on Saturday... but I am not without some real reservations about this.

You only have to read some of the comments on the Echo website beneath the article to see that there are reds and blues spoiling for this to go wrong. From our perspective it only takes a few to disrupt, get shouted down and before you know it there's murmurings that turn into shouts that will be audible ...all in front of a watching global audience. We would be stupid and naive to think that this might not happen. I'm afraid some of our younger support, who do not remember the tragedy first hand and have been drinking since 4 am in the morning, will be ripe for this.

Also, there's the fact that, whilst it's only a football match after all, one can't help but feel it's being 'hijacked' again and turned into some maudlin "self-pity city" event. You won't be able to pick up any of the papers this week without articles relating directly to it... and ? despite the fact that as many scouse Evertonians of a ceratin age will have had just as many friends and relatives suffer or perish at Hillsbrorough as scouse Liverpudlians ? it always seems like we are the 'poor relation' invited along to share in the grief. They call the shots on how it should all be remembered, down to the minutes silence, day and time of the game, the flags, the songs ....our role is to turn up, show respect and get beaten.

And as mentioned earlier, there are a lot of reds who would love for a vocal minority to disrupt the silence as it would give them a further stick to beat the 'bitters' with. Should it be disrupted, it will turn what is likely to be an already nasty atmosphere downright dangerous and would likely poison relations for evermore.

I can't help thinking that a minutes applause or a simple laying of flowers would have avoided this potential nastiness before the game even starts. There will after all be the annual ceremony of remembrance at Anfield the following day (always at Anfield of course, not the city's cathedrals but thats another point).

Like I say, I will stand and remember the people I knew who lost their lives, reflect and then move on to the game. I hope that's what all of our support and players do and don't get caught up in the sentimentality / hostility of the occasion....

Thoughts on this?

Kevin Tully
4 Posted 10/04/2012 at 16:07:08
I see Alan Davies has had death threats issued today for questioning why L'pool cannot play on the 15th April.

I can see this going wrong, and agree a minutes applause would have been more appropriate on the day.
Peter Davies
5 Posted 10/04/2012 at 16:34:09
Why don't we do our own bit of hijacking and put the word about to all Evertonians that we will remember the event with a minutes applause regardless of what is planned. We can't then be accused of being disrespectful, we are just showing respect in our own way and it will hopefully drown out any ill mannered disruption. Is there anyone with the clout at Toffeeweb who could maybe put this forward to the Club management?
Paul Joy
6 Posted 10/04/2012 at 16:34:21
In the immediate aftermath of Hillsborough and ever since our fans have behaved impeccably and with the utmost respect. Quite rightly too.

Personally I will respect the minutes silence on saturday however silence is just too easy to disrupt and I can only hope that all of our fans respect the silence - then boo when that song is played.
Danny Broderick
7 Posted 10/04/2012 at 16:44:19
Let's just hope everyone can be responsible enough to respect the minute's silence, and then we can have a right good go at them once the whistle blows. Even though they are our biggest rivals, we can hopefully conduct ourselves with dignity and then beat them fair and square.
Paul Joy
8 Posted 10/04/2012 at 16:46:00
Oh and I forgot to state the obvious fact that The FA are giving them a clear and distinct advantage over us.
James Morgan
9 Posted 10/04/2012 at 16:52:55
They will obviously get their god awful song played on the day, but will we hear Z Cars ring out? I can't remember from '09 semi.
Scott Hamilton
10 Posted 10/04/2012 at 17:02:31
James (951) - If not then every blue at the ground should sing it!

Altogether now "der der der, de-der der der der. Der der der, de-der der der.."
Stephen Kenny
11 Posted 10/04/2012 at 16:56:28
I just hope that our club, players and fans don't allow them arrogant bastards to make the day all about them.

It's not the anniversary and it's not their day. Were Everton FC and FA cup semi finals at Wembley should be about us.

I will respect the silence but why does our captain have to lay wreaths or anything else the day before an official ceremony is held?

We always do our club proud on that day and will probably continue to do so forever.

We don't need all the other bollocks distracting us and getting referee's on their side. Were there to knock them out the cup not play a part in their no account ceremony.
Peter Thistle
12 Posted 10/04/2012 at 17:04:17
Wish they would just do their respect thing at a Anfield and not bring down the atmosphere ahead of an important game. I don't see how this can help the players to be up for it.
Mark Riding
13 Posted 10/04/2012 at 17:07:32
Whether I agree with such an act at Wembley or not, I always feel silence is better than applause for rememberence.
Although I had tears in my eyes when we held a minutes applause for young Rhys Jones at Goodison.
I hope the obvious shouts dont arrive if it is silence, but it wouldnt surprise me.
Neville laying a wreath is a little too much for me personally.
King Kenny moaning about Refs ( how effective was Moyes' moan before the United semi a few years back ! ) and now this... Its started already.
John Keating
14 Posted 10/04/2012 at 17:13:13
Fully agree with the fact there should be some sort of rememberance, however, the eyes of the world will be there.
Recently it has become more fashionable to have applause.
Maybe they should have used this instead of silence.
It only takes one arsehole from either persuassion and believe me regardless it will go down as being a Blue
Lorcan Walsh
15 Posted 10/04/2012 at 17:13:05
Agreeing with Paul Joy re. the advantage being handed to the RS.

It drives me nuts the way they always grab the focus and the attention and it's all about them.... It will require an immense effort to overcome this om Saturday.

To add insult of course KK has already begun putting pressure on the referees about how hard done by they have been... Expect a dodgy penno or an offside goal....
God I hope we tank them!
Tony Dove
16 Posted 10/04/2012 at 17:26:05
Like most people I cant post what I really think
Phil Bellis
17 Posted 10/04/2012 at 17:29:08
Lorcan

They're welcome to one; a consolation in a 3-1 defeat; that'll do nicely
John Crossley
18 Posted 10/04/2012 at 17:36:34
S Kenny( 955) an excellent response could not have said it better
Shaun Sparke
19 Posted 10/04/2012 at 17:42:38
As much as I despise that club I can remember the respect everybody at Anfield showed to the parents of Rhys Jones when they stood respectfully and allowed the playing of Z cars. Lets not mix what happens before the match to what happens during the 90 mins. If anybody has a problem with keeping their gobs shut for a mere 60 seconds then I hope you get thrown out.
Nothing is going to distract us from teaching those across the park that we know how to be dignified both on and off the pitch.
Jon Cox
20 Posted 10/04/2012 at 17:32:55
Jeez I was in a fairly good mood till reading this thread.

Dogleash, you are a little twat and a fuckin cheat (refs). No wonder you like that little shit Suarez. All you need really is that other little scab Ashley Young, then you'll have the set.

I hope we screw you into the ground on Saturday and you resign AGAIN.

A vexed Blue.
Alan Williams
21 Posted 10/04/2012 at 17:53:32
I shall not take my seat until it?s over, I will stay quiet underneath and keep out of the way. I don?t agree with the silence and I?m angry this is going ahead but I will respect it because I?m an adult. I hate the fact they don?t respect the 39 dead like they do for their own it?s a disgrace and we should hold up a banner saying what about the justice for the 39 but stand in silence when doing so. Hillsborough was a terrible day for football that never changes but I have no respect for LFC when they chose to ignore 1985, they hide behind such anniversary?s all the time and we are all muted if we question them at any point, I think Evertonians no longer want to stand aside Reds so I will understand why this will not be honoured by some fans but I cant bring myself ever to disrespect it, I hate being put in such a predicament especially on occasions like this they always spoil the party, I hate them always calculated in everything the do!!!
Tim Locke
23 Posted 10/04/2012 at 18:04:15
It is right to remember events like this. Sadly Hillsborough was on the cards for many years and action should have been taken in 71 after Ibrox. The fact it was Forest and Liverpool means many of us have a connection to those that died, and like all football fans, we too should remember and pay respect to those that lost their lives. But the semi and the what happened are not the same event, we don't owe Liverpool a day in the sun because they are having a hard time of it now or what happened in the past. So on Saturday we stand united as a city remembering what happened, but when that minute is up and the whistle goes they are the RS and they are there for the taking. COYB
Steve Sweeney
24 Posted 10/04/2012 at 18:26:43
They asked for silence rather than applause.
As much as I hate the gobshites we are EFC and bigger and better than them.
60 seconds of silence please and then let's outshout them,outsing them and silence them for the rest of the season.
COYB
Bobby Thomas
25 Posted 10/04/2012 at 18:39:13
Anyone else got a bad feeling about this?
Jon Cox
26 Posted 10/04/2012 at 18:44:01
Perhaps before Saturday we will really see the bias the media has between us and the shite.

Especially one Alan Brazil. He couldn't be further up KK's backside if he tried.
Mark Riding
27 Posted 10/04/2012 at 18:45:51
#988 Alan, just asking... not critising.
You mention not taking your seat. Could empty seats be seen as a sign of dis-respect / protest?
I will be there on Saturday, and if I'm honest, I'm not keen to go through a silence either, especially if it goes tits up, but I would want to shout the lads onto the pitch?!
John Ford
28 Posted 10/04/2012 at 19:03:19
Amen to that Tim Locke.

This might be seen as unecessary - silence being the wrong way to go, but i'll be deeply ashamed if any blues create a problem.
Thomas Williams
29 Posted 10/04/2012 at 18:59:08
Steven Connor wrote this an i agree
Also, there's the fact that, whilst it's only a football match after all, one can't help but feel it's being 'hijacked' again and turned into some maudlin "self-pity city" event. You won't be able to pick up any of the papers this week without articles relating directly to it... and ? despite the fact that as many scouse Evertonians of a ceratin age will have had just as many friends and relatives suffer or perish at Hillsbrorough as scouse Liverpudlians ? it always seems like we are the 'poor relation' invited along to share in the grief. They call the shots on how it should all be remembered, down to the minutes silence, day and time of the game, the flags, the songs ....our role is to turn up, show respect and get beaten.

This is what irks our fans more than most, is that every special occasion we have we somehow end up having to pay our respcts to them if it is not Hillsborough it is the merseyside nonsense, it is almost like we have no identity.

We have all paid our respects many times over, but this now is rubbing our noses in it, and I think most fans privately feel the same, you only have to look at the comments in the mail following the alan davies article, to see that the rest of the country is sick of it being rammed in their faces.
Jack Molloy
30 Posted 10/04/2012 at 18:58:17
I am absolutely 100% against this. It is a naked, cynical and despicable attempt to make Liverpool's winning this game a matter of honouring those lost at Hillsborough. It's using the dead, not respecting them. It gives Liverpool a psychological advantage, however slight. It's not like this is a landmark anniversary like the 25th anniversary, or like Liverpool are playing Forest. It's the 23rd and it happens to be a derby game. The FA wouldn't be trying to give Liverpool a psychological advantage if Spurs or Man Utd were playing them. Sunday's memorial is appropriate - and enough and Evertonians who want to express their respect should go and do that. If this is really about respecting the anniversary and the loss of life, let there be a minute's silence at every match this weekend. They aren't doing that because that's not what this is really about. However, now that the FA has fallen for this we as Everton fans have to respect it. We have no other option.
Brian Harrison
31 Posted 10/04/2012 at 18:43:03
I well remember that day, obviously I was at our semi final at Villas ground against Luton. During our game guys with radios were saying that at the other semi final that the players had been taken off the pitch. Then we heard that the match had been abandoned, obviously there were no mobile phones then so anybody who had a radio was telling everyone what was happening.

At this point we heard that 3 or 4 people had been killed in a crush, well watching our game after the first lot of news was weird to say the least. Then you had half an eye on the game while listening to what rumours were circulating. Then we heard that as many as 15 Liverpool fans had died in the crush. Now our City unlike any other has blue and red in many families, so people who had family members and friends at that game were very concerned.

Just before the final whistle went in our game the news was filtering through that over 20 people had lost their lives and many more injured. The referee blew his whistle which meant we were going to Wembley, after coming back from a goal down. Normally there would have been a lot of singing and laughter, but apart from a cheer at the final whistle there was no singing or cheering.

Most Evertonians were gathering round radios to get the latest updates as to what was happening at Hillsborough. Queues were forming outside every public phone boxes. We drove about an hour away to have a drink on the way home listening to everything through the radio. Didnt feel like football was of any importance to any of our fans that day, and all the talk in the pub we called into was about the tragedy that had happened at Hillsborough. Hardly anybody talked about our game, and the queues to use the pub phone was huge.

So I think for us to stand quietly for 1 minute to remember that day is no big deal. I recently relayed this story to a friend who was at Hillsborough and he hadnt heard about the muted celebration to us winning the semi, so be proud Evertonians again on Saturday, and fully respect the minutes silence.
Brian Denton
32 Posted 10/04/2012 at 19:29:30
Brian, it was against Norwich not Luton (1985)
Brian Harrison
33 Posted 10/04/2012 at 19:37:30
Brian 25

Yes sorry of course it was Norwich, dont know why I thought it was luton. I guess you will have to put it down to a senior moment
Mark Riding
34 Posted 10/04/2012 at 19:37:57
Brian # 024 - I was also at the semi at Villa Park.
You give you own account and its a very emotional one.
Now, in hindsight, the original reaction I saw / heard was in-accurate, but it was one of ' they have done it again '....
Ed Fitzgerald
35 Posted 10/04/2012 at 19:33:02
Anyone who was at Villa that day will remember the fear that spread around the ground and the concern we had for family and friends who follow Liverpool. I know all about Heysel and the damage it did to our club but we have to be better than that. The silence on the way home said it all that day and we conducted ourselves with dignity in the following months.

A minutes silence to remember the dead is appropriate and correct and any Blue that disrupts that is a disgrace. We dont have to descend into mawkish sentimentality we just have to show some respect. We know the meda will hype it up and how liverpool are destined to win but we just have to put it up with it and then proceed to show them who are the best team and supporters on Merseyside.

It is our date with destiny if David Moyes just for once shows some belief we can beat them and get some revenge for 71,77, 84, 86, and 89. Come on Blues
Brian Harrison
36 Posted 10/04/2012 at 19:44:56
Mark 29

I agree that when we first heard that there was trouble at he Hillsborough game some did say oh its that lot again.
But once we heard that people had lost the lives the mood quickly changed.
Brian Denton
37 Posted 10/04/2012 at 19:47:13
Echo the above. We all know how the media are going to play it, but we just have to 'suck it up' to use that horrible Americanism.
Stephen Sullivan
38 Posted 10/04/2012 at 20:04:35
If your not happy with biased coverage by BBC or anyone else then write to them and demand balanced reporting etc
http://www.bbc.co.uk/complaints/complain-online/
The more people express their concerns the more likelihood LFC lose the advantage their whinging and self pitying fans/managers demand
Paul Johnson
39 Posted 10/04/2012 at 20:01:52
I Rosas at villa park that day and the walk back to the car was one of the worst experiences of my life. The death toll Rose at every passing car radio and the drive home was silent and I am not exaggerating.

I had friends and family at hillsborough that day and I know people who lost family.

The whole city went into mourning and it is not an experience anyone should have to go through again. Unfortunately I will not be at wembley ( I now live in Nairobi) but if I was I would respect that minutes silence with all my heart and maybe even shed a tear.

Let's get one thing straight that minutes silence is for the people who died on that horrible day and not for Gerrard or Dogleash or any other gobshite at Liverpool FC.

So let's be grown up and do the right thing then twat the shower of shit who have no morales whatsoever.

Fuck them and fuck Dogleash but let us never forget 96 people, friends and family.

COYB.
Stephen Kenny
40 Posted 10/04/2012 at 20:10:10
One thing I can't get my head around is this;

They had a minutes silence against Villa. They will also have a minutes silence against us. Then they will also have a silence at the memorial service, why?

I cant imagine the hurt they must carry but surely that's not an appropriate way to express it.

It appears the FA have tried to jump on their bandwagon for some reason???

I'm firmly of the opinion that whatever happens beforehand we will go out and absolutely fuck them.

COYB!!!
Graham Mockford
41 Posted 10/04/2012 at 20:04:46
If there is one thing that should never be forgotten is that Hillsborough taught us that in the end football is just a game. On that fateful day 96 people left home on a Saturday morning just like those who will this Saturday however they never returned. For that reason it is appropriate it is remembered and fitting our club shows a due mark of respect.
What happens afterwards during the game will not affect the result in the slightest. To talk about some FA conspiracy against us or Liverpool using it as a psychological ploy is complete nonsense.
If they want a minute of silence that's their prerogative. Let's observe it respectfully then spend the next 90 minutes knocking ten tons of shite out of them.
Jon Cox
42 Posted 10/04/2012 at 19:38:15
The good news. Doni sent off the shite only have one goalie for wembley.

The bad news, the Yak misses a penalty and the shite are still two up.

Sorry OT but hey, news is news.
James Royston
43 Posted 10/04/2012 at 19:40:52
It should not surprise anyone that something like this has come up . Like most others I totally respect the memory of Hillsborough and have no problem with the annual rememberance, it could so easily have been Everton playing there that day ... " But the memorial day is Sunday " is that not why this game quite correctly HAD to be played on Sat...... Couldn't LFC & supporters at least try to be honorable (for once) and instead allowing themselves to be accused of appearing to milk the sympathy vote, suggest something both sets of decent supporters could join in without feeling compromised &/or used. Perhaps with an announcment in advance a unanimous " Merseyside Merseyside " chant could be ideal and an enormousley respectful & lasting memorial to all concerned.....
Andrew Flanagan
44 Posted 10/04/2012 at 20:34:54
I can see this Brad Jones going on and having a blinder now...

Saying that the Yak has just scored!
Andrew Flanagan
45 Posted 10/04/2012 at 20:38:50
If anyone deserves some luck its Jones after the year he has had (his six year old son passed away). However, why do I detect a Hollywood conclusion to Saturday?

I hope all this doesn't conspire against us.
Mark Riding
46 Posted 10/04/2012 at 21:20:26
yep.. brad jones having a blinder...
Mark Riding
47 Posted 10/04/2012 at 21:21:23
(2-2)
Jon Cox
48 Posted 10/04/2012 at 21:18:16
2-2 Jones should have been sent off but the Yak scores. Dalglish does not look a happy bunny.
Jon Cox
49 Posted 10/04/2012 at 21:22:53
Hey Mark, dont you think this is a strange evening. Moyes is at the match. God knows what he must be thinking.
Mark Riding
50 Posted 10/04/2012 at 21:26:16
Jon, I gave up on guessing what Moyes was thinking when he re-signed Mcfadden..
Im not anti-moyes either, but, he should walk out of the Blackburn game now, and give a shady 'quip' to a journo and just say 'I've seen enough here.. bring it on ! '
Mike Hughes
51 Posted 10/04/2012 at 21:29:55
Just checked on Paddy Power.
The most popular bet is Everton who are now down to 15/8 to win in 90 mins.
Jon Cox
52 Posted 10/04/2012 at 21:36:50
Yeah, and he tells a journo Faddy for a hat- trick..
Barry Rathbone
53 Posted 10/04/2012 at 21:32:35
The memorial is something we'll just have to endure.

The irksome aspect of hilsborough is the same songs, flags etc used to laud it for years raise their ugly head in sanctimonious display for the cameras.

Sorry if I upset some but they don't fool me, it is a rallying call for their hypocritical narrow minded little club.

If they sang "abide with me" instead I'd heartily join in as a genuine tribute to the memories of innocent souls.

Well this time there is a difference we have the strength in the team and defiance in support.

Remain silent let the anger build then unleash the wrath o against what is the shame of english football.

Not one step back.
Jon Cox
54 Posted 10/04/2012 at 21:49:56
2-3 what a miserable bunch Blackburn are. Andy bloody Carol.
Tony Twist
55 Posted 10/04/2012 at 22:02:20
Let's hope Liverpool are now thinking everything is business as usual and then we take advantage of that. Saturday's match will be the most difficult of the season, form means nothing at the start it's up to us to punish and make them lose all hope of winning by being clinical, professional, taking our chances. I remember the gunners going to anfield having to win by 2 clear goals to take the championship off Liverpool. It was a similar situation, they were respectful but as soon as the match started got on with the task in hand. it's our turn to do the same. Over to you Moyes.
Colin Gee
56 Posted 10/04/2012 at 22:40:39
I was at Villa Park that day, never been on a coach so quiet on the way home after any match win lose or draw.
The radio was on and we all just sat there listening to the reports, the coach driver pulled in at some services on the M6 so everyone could ring home to try and find out what had happened.

As for the minutes silence on Saturday, I think like me 99.9% of Evertonians will observe it, BUT my own opinion is don't think it is the right thing to have one.
We are having it forced down our throats again, it only takes one idiot to start shouting and we will be the bad guys in the eyes of the world.
If we start shouting and singing during it then we will have done Daglish's teamtalk for him.
Let's hope we can stand quietly for 60 seconds, then lift the roof off Wembley when we stuff the RS.
James Royston
57 Posted 10/04/2012 at 22:56:37
If we have to have it and it looks like we do. Colin Gee at 115 is spot on. Don't give them the slightest chance to take advantage..Listen quiet for the 60secs, while you fill your lungs then give them a blast .....EVERTON EVERTON...
Steve Green
58 Posted 10/04/2012 at 23:08:21
Had a brother in law and nephew at Hillsborough on the day, didn't know for some while that they were safe. Knew someone who tragically lost their life that day, RIP. Was at Villa Park and can never, ever talk or think about that day without the 'could have been us' scenario coming to mind. Travelled to Hillsborough with my red girl to pay homage and respect to the occasion, stood in the Bullens Road to pay silence and respect at the derby game immediately after the tragedy.
But hold on a minute.
LFC requested not to play on Sunday 15th as it was the anniversary date they wanted to mark. The FA licked their arse and Chelsea were hugely disadvantaged as a result. Now LFC want the 14th to be marked with a minute's silence when 'THEY', repeat 'THEY' regard the landmark as the 15th and fuck everybody else.
Smacks of wanting it all ways, but hey, why should I be surprised or affronted.
Fuckin hate them..................... always have... always will. Print me a tee-shirt.
Carl Peters
59 Posted 10/04/2012 at 23:20:46
I'm with that, James> The older Evertonians all knew this this was coming. Yeah, sure... give them their minutes silence; at one second over, we raise the fucking roof off Wembley Stadium so the fuckers have to put new hinges on it for the next game ? and don't give them the chance to let that fucking shite song they sing be heard.
COYB
Jack Molloy
60 Posted 10/04/2012 at 23:57:44
"To talk about Liverpool using it as a psychological ploy is complete nonsense." Were there similar expressions of "respect" during previous semi-finals involving Liverpool? In 2006 against Chelsea for example or 2001? I don't recall but I doubt it. If there wasn't a benefit to them they wouldn't be ding it, believe me. Cynical bastards.
Ste Traverse
61 Posted 11/04/2012 at 00:01:09
If we win and there is anykind of noise during the minutes silence,you can bet the Liverpool fans and their apologists in the media will go out of their way to blow it all propertion.

I'm there on Saturday and was at the 1989 Cup Final and hope the 60 seconds can be as respectfully observed as it was nearly 23 years ago.
Paul McAllister
63 Posted 11/04/2012 at 00:09:05
They better not get some nobhead to come and sing You'll Never Walk Alone on the pitch before kick off and expect us to join in with it. A minute's silence is fine but I categorically refuse to sing that song or agree to keep quiet whist they sing it. If it comes on I'll boo until I lose my voice.
Ian Linn
64 Posted 11/04/2012 at 00:49:40
There was a similar thing a couple of years back where the Manchester derby was played on the aniversary of Munich. The City fans observed the minutes silence impeccably and I think on Saturday we should do the same.

Remember, it's not about Hillsborough, it's the semi final; when the whistle blows we will kick the shit out of them and their 3rd chioce keeper and book a ticket to the final.
Kevin Sparke
65 Posted 11/04/2012 at 00:32:38
Hillsborough was an awful time for the City of Liverpool and for football supporters in general. We were lied about in the Murdoch press and generally kicked whilst we were down by the establishment. The truth has never been told, justice has never been done for the 96 who died and it probably never will be.

I never lost any family or mates, but I felt that awful sense of loss in the city that went on for a long time. I was at Villa Park with my mates - 10 of us went up there in a transit... another transit from the same alehouse went to Hillsborough... with other mates and mates brothers on it ? they all came home. They went to a football match ? not on a commando raid or over the top at the Somme... a fucking football match ? that's all.

I still remember the anxious faces of the lads I went the game with ? queuing at phones in Birmingham and at every stop on the M6. Phoning home for news of brothers, uncles... sons.

So, let's observe the silence with the quiet dignity that befits the occasion, even if we feel it's nothing to do with us and let's not give the world the chance to drag us down again and mark the blue half of the city as more Scouse Scum to be mocked as self-pitying head-the-balls...

And then when the 60 seconds for sober reflection is over, let's shout our lungs out for Everton and cream the red hoards on the pitch and make them wish they'd been knocked out a round earlier... let's hit them so hard that their ancestors can feel it.
Ed Fitzgerald
66 Posted 11/04/2012 at 00:36:56
We must respect the minutes silence for the right reasons, 96 people lost their lives watching a football match they were from our city thats reason enough. Let's leave the paranoia to Daglish and get on with the job of beating them. If we disrupt the silence it will be the best team talk for them they have ever had. I know how 'blind' they can be when Heysel is mentioned even the best of them deny any culpability or the impact the ban had on other English teams.

It's our moment to right some wrongs of our own against the red shite and they know it. We will never have a better chance to do it
Danny O'Neill
67 Posted 11/04/2012 at 01:00:58
If that has what has been decided then we must respect it. We must not let it become a distraction, but let's not forget how it felt at the time.

I wasn't fortunate enough to have a ticket at the Semi-Final in 2009 (same weekend coincidentally) and watched in a pub near Wembley with a mixed Everton / Utd contingent. We held banners in support of the 96 then and, when the United fans in the pub made derogatory comments, I took pride in the way the Evertonians turned on them ? they backed down quickly.

I despise Liverpool's current mentality but let us not lower ourselves and be dragged down to that mentality. We are Evertonians, the most knowledgable football fans in the country and must respect our fellow supporters; more importantly, our fellow citizens (in many cases, family). 60 seconds to remember the dead, then we unleash the Blue tide on the deluded victims!
Danny O'Neill
68 Posted 11/04/2012 at 01:11:24
Deluded as in they are deluded, victims as in the current popular chant, which I assume refers to every claim they make other than Hillsborough.
Anthony Jones
69 Posted 11/04/2012 at 01:08:02
I don't see why a tragic accident on the 15th April 1989 would be commemorated at Wembley before our match.

If they want to pay respect by having a tribute event at Anfield on the 15th I wouldn't question their motives, but this smacks of using grief as both a marketing tool and a morale booster.
Ed Fitzgerald
70 Posted 11/04/2012 at 01:27:17
Anthony when we protest about a minutes silence it makes us look mean spirited at best, we are better than that its only a minute. How many minutes silences, rounds of applause have we observed over recent years,loads!

You have questioned their motives I think to call it a marketing tool is a little strong perhaps they are just trying to show respect to the families who lost people

Lets not forget all though it was 23 years ago there has still been an on going battle to get papers released about the governments response to the disaster going on this year.
John Atkins
71 Posted 11/04/2012 at 00:33:24
As a lifelong Evertonian of almost 40 years it might surprise most to hear I was in fact at Hillsborough that fateful day instead of Villa Park due to work commitments for the then club sponsor, I was gutted to have to go to Hillsborough and not Villa Park that day but I had to adhere to my job. It's seems so long ago now and the pain and the nightmares don't ever go away (there for the grace of God go I) and especially when I lost one of my mates (RIP Brad) so I reckon I understand more than most blues ever will and proper RS for that matter what this day means.

I will never forget and I will pay my own tribute / respect to those poor souls come Sunday

It's time to move on, any fans under the age of 30 simply cannot relate to the events of 89 and therefore I fear for the future of an already delicate relationship which will be un repairable ? absolutely crazy to have a minute silence with so many pissed up fans and surely an applause is the only sane option.

Would we be vilified if we started an applause? Surely not? I seem to remember previous requested minute silences have been overturned by fans into an applause ? a fitting tribute to all those who never came home that day

How fucking naive are these so-called officials who make these decisions, have they consulted both sets of fans?

Why is there nobody at our club to challenge these decisions??? You can be assured WE will come out of this as the bad guys should the unthinkable happen!

If we don't go for the applause then I just pray to God we can keep our dignity and observe the minutes silence then go out and fuck them, we owe them, this is our time.
COYB
Paul Johnson
72 Posted 11/04/2012 at 05:28:34
For fuck's sake I don't get it.

These were people, friends and family who just happen to support Liverpool.

Let's do the right thing as human beings, respect the minute then twat the gobshites on the park.

But please don't lower ourselves to scumbag levels, remember the guy or girl stood next to you could have lost someone dear to them on that day.
Ernie Baywood
73 Posted 11/04/2012 at 06:38:41
Can't believe some of the posts on here. Respect the minute's silence.

Most blues must know someone who was at that game.

Will really disappoint me if our support do anything but stay quiet.
Gareth Fieldstead
74 Posted 11/04/2012 at 02:35:44
Spot on Colin, for our own respect, image and dignity we do it for the minute and prevent the likes of Gerrard and Dalgliesh having any additional determination to win. If you don't agree with it make a point of vacating your seat just before the referee blows for the silence to commence and stay under the concourse until it's over. Personally I cannot get my head around not wanting to pay tribute. Justice for the 96
Alan Williams
75 Posted 11/04/2012 at 08:11:33
Mark 004, great point and its something that does bother me, as much as 1989 hit everybody (my brother?s friend, brother died that day) I wont no part of it and no part of what I think will be the silence being ruined by EFC fans. If you look at the Mirror paper today it?s all started again this wave of sympathy and I just don?t fall for it anymore. I have no respect for LFC whilst it has no respect for the 39 dead, and LFC not recognising that day is disrespectful to the Hillsborough families too. At some point they need to be told because we play on all other days like 11th November which is more important, this is just the 23rd and has no significance other than it being another painful anniversary for the families. In my opinion part of grieving is moving on and doing this all the time holds back the process the difficult and moral thing we have is all fans have moved on apart from LFC. The more they continue this enforced compliance the less sympathy they will have across the football world and that is evident with the people I speak too, we are all fed up with this.
Mark Murphy
76 Posted 11/04/2012 at 09:10:37
Please God everybody respect the minutes silence.
This is about more than just a game of football and local rivalry. its about mates and family who happened to follow a different club to a different ground who through no fault of their own didnt come back.
Please pay your respects as will I.

And a minutes applause is not apt here. Its a minute thinking of the ones who lost their lives. A minutes applause is used to celebrate a life, ie with Gary Speed it was in recognition of his skills. Whilst many of those who died may well have been remarkable people they were, in the end, unfortunate victims. And that should be contemplated with respect, not applauded.

Justice, and respect, for the 96.
Eugene Ruane
77 Posted 11/04/2012 at 09:35:53
Any noise, 'applause', shouting, bellowing, chanting etc from us, DURING the minutes silence, could have the same effect on them that spinach has on Popeye.

Whatever your thoughts, I'd suggest the best thing for EVERTON is all hands keeping it firmly shut for 60 seconds.

Then whup them!
Mike Hughes
78 Posted 11/04/2012 at 09:54:23
While I can't stand kopites, I have to agree with the comments here regarding compliance with the minutes silence.

Personally I will respect it.

If you don't respect them then consider keeping your trap shut for the sake of Everton's good reputation if nothing else.
Liam Reilly
79 Posted 11/04/2012 at 09:47:19
Pay our respects to the people who died, not the football club.

Let the papers do what the papers do and sensationalise the event

Let them and the FA sympathise with LFC

Let the media proclaim that it?s LFCs divine right to win the trophy this year in remembrance of the dead

Let them talk about the LPL-Chelsea or Tottenham final like this Saturday is just an exhibition

....Then let them watch as we pummel them just like we did in 95 when we humbled Spurs, the Media darlings and ruined their showcase final.

COYBs
John Atkins
80 Posted 11/04/2012 at 09:50:54
Fair point Mark #189 over applause I'm just worried that whilst 99% of us will behave with dignity come Saturday as we always have done it will only take a handful of idiots to cause the slitest bit of noise and it will spread into something very unsavory.

The media and cynics wiould just love this to happen especially morons like Kelvin MacKenzie


Emotions will indeed be running high come 1230, I'm shaking and nervous now!

I was hoping for something to avoid this but let's just hope and pray it is observed then we can hold our heads up high then go out and stuff them COYB
Sam Morrison
81 Posted 11/04/2012 at 10:07:33
I suppose I shouldn't be, but I'm shocked there is any talk of not honouring the minute's silence. There is no club I want us to beat more than Liverpool ( though Chelsea come close) - but for fuck's sake, this is football and we are ALL remembering people who lost their lives. In light of which the club they supported is hardly relevant.

Bobby Thomas
82 Posted 11/04/2012 at 10:38:18
Remember that bank holiday derby years ago when they had to cut short the silence?

Clearly, theres an undercurrent of discontent about this silence, wreath laying etc. Theres gonna be 31,600 blues there, many under 30 and some will have been drinking since 6am.

The decision has been made. I view it as a little bizarre, its the day before, its the 23rd anniversary etc etc, and theres all kinds of reasons why the silence should be respected....the cover up being one.

But i am getting a very bad feeling about it. It could be a watershed day for relations between the fans of both clubs and the atmosphere could turn very sour.

If we break the silence, we will look very bad indeed. And yes, their team talk will be done. If we break the silence its gonna go off after the match. Can you inmagine whats its going to be like? It will be horrendous.

All we want is to turn up there and have the day unaffected, any emotion and extra uplift they an draw from it. You just want to get there and benefit from it, enjoy it and let Everton and their fan enjoy theexposure of the day.

You can already feel I feel it does make it less likely and skewers the day. The dutiful coisens of Liverpol FC are to turn up, play the game and do one. On a football level, it is getting toward the stage where i have completely had enough of them. I can understand it and am fankly pissed off with it myself.

But we have to respect the silence. Do i think it will happen. Honestly, no.


Scott Hamilton
83 Posted 11/04/2012 at 11:31:33
This really is a powder keg situation. In all seriousness, it only takes one tourettes sufferer in the crowd to shout something and world war 3 will follow
Anto Byrne
84 Posted 11/04/2012 at 11:09:55
Let's just remember those who lost their lives quite unnecessarily. Let's be thankful we are Evertonians and the greatest supporters in the world. Let's get the job done and get to the final. The tide has turned and we are the better side. coyb.
Stephen Sullivan
85 Posted 11/04/2012 at 11:34:50
I have many of the same concerns and have voiced mine through proper channels and urge as many Evertonians to do the same

I'm concerned about four aspects of this tribute
1, Everton agreed to bring the game forward to accommodate Liverpool and now they also want to honour it the day before too
2, The emotion and media coverage surrounding the Hillsborough tragedy takes attention away from what is after all a major football match. Both sets of players deserve equal attention and recognition for getting this far so why can't we just focus on football and not be sidetracked?
3, The focus on Hillsborough and Liverpool FC in particular tends to exclude the fact Evertonians lost family/friends etc and this should be honoured too.
4, The minutes silence can be disrupted by just a couple of mindless idiots from either side. Why take the risk? Relationships between Everton and Liverpool are at an all time low so why risk further problems which could easily escalate? A round of applause is more appropriate.

I suggest Everton fans start singing "Merseyside, Merseywide....." immediatly after the minutes tribute so as to deflect attention away from Liverpool FC and back to an event being played by two teams not just one.

http://www.thefa.com

http://www.bbc.co.uk/complaints
03700 100 222
James Kelly
86 Posted 11/04/2012 at 12:05:43
Same old RS trying to manipulate whenever they can into trying to make us feel we're there to just make up the numbers...

I for one will be at the bar while that "silence" is on.
Peter Davies
87 Posted 11/04/2012 at 12:23:01
After the minutes silence, if we do have to endure THAT song we should drown it out with a long and rousing chorus of 'Justice for the 39'
Alex Willett
88 Posted 11/04/2012 at 12:37:06
Liverpoolwill be made up with this! everyone arguing and getting upset before a ball has even been kicked. Maybe the anouncer could make the silence in hounor of the hillsborough victims AND in rememerance of Gary Speed, and Gary Abblet, who of course played for both clubs. I bet then you wouldnt hear a pin drop.
Chez Hutton
89 Posted 11/04/2012 at 12:50:37
Wow! Is this really how some of our 'fellow supporters' feel?

Not in my name, thanks all the same.
Phil Bellis
90 Posted 11/04/2012 at 13:04:25
The day of remembrance should have been held in dignity and isolation, away from a major football match and the circus it is becoming.

Why could the game not be put back a week, in the first place?
All the Blues I've spoken to and, I suspect, many on here, feel it will only take one
I hope the deludes don't bring that bloody Steaua Bucharest flag
Colin Wainwright
91 Posted 11/04/2012 at 13:22:41
Fair enough Chez. That's why your name accompanies your post. Don't know what your 'fellow supporters' comment is all about though. IMO, no-one has been particularly out of order on this thread, just that some are concerned that the match is being innapropriately highjacked and fear the consequences.

I agree with Phil (246).

Declan Brown
92 Posted 11/04/2012 at 13:35:53
Liam Reilly #196 love the reference to the dream final but there's a big difference here - Joe Royle (unbeaten as an Everton manager in derbies by the way) was managing us then.

Can't see Davey having the same tactical and motivational impact on the players as Joe did that day / season.

But i would love to hear Moyes / Captain Phil or another Everton player coming out and saying that we have heard enough of Kenny's whining about referee's and that we hope Howard Webb won't bow under the pressure Kenny is putting him under and that we are above such gamesmanship and don't want to resort to such underhanded desperate tactics.

Really nervous already, the worst Liverpool in my 26 years as an Evertonian, they're down to their 3rd choice keeper, they're below us in the league, i'd rather go into this as the underdogs with them under all the expectation and pressure (some of my red friends do genuinely believe they have it wrapped up already and want the Spurs dream final).

Please don't let us down again Davey, if ever was your time this is it, much belatedly but we are where we are right now, let the players go out and do what they do best, let them play with freedom and discipline, let them express themselves, and please God Davey, deliver the mother of all motivational pre match speeches, if you're in doubt watch Braveheart again for some inspiration!!!

One (Evertonian) for all (Evertonians) and all (Evertonians) for one. Do us proud.
Chez Hutton
93 Posted 11/04/2012 at 13:41:49
Colin (249) 'some are concerned that the match is being innapropriately highjacked' - 96 football supporters lost their lives at an FA Cup Semi Final - IMO this is one of the most appropriate events to pay tribute to them, at an FA Cup Semi Final on virtually the same date.

'and fear the consequences' - I hear you 100% on this - assuming you mean that a mindless few may try to spoil it. If however you mean that it may give LFC the upper hand (as per a few comments above) then I disagree - the issue of the minutes silence and the match are separate.
Matt Traynor
94 Posted 11/04/2012 at 13:50:03
Declan (#254), that's exactly why we ARE underdogs. The reds I know like yours are already planning for 2 trips to Wembley.

It's easy to see why, with Moyes abysmal record against big teams away from Goodison. This isn't the first time we've been favourites in some quarters to get the result.

It actually goes back further in my mind, to the 70s. No matter how well we were doing, they seemed to do a bit better - like we were the push they needed. The dodgy decisions, mind games and all the other bollocks just add to the burgeoning sense of inferiority a lot of Evertonians feel.

Of course we'd love to be proved wrong!
Declan Brown
95 Posted 11/04/2012 at 13:46:35
Forgot to add this to my original point guys, if one eejot does ruin it and it all kicks off and World War 3 erupts, I would have preferred Joe's Dogs of Wars going into a battle on this occasion than most of our lot.

We don't bully, overpower and physically dominate Liverpool any more since the days of the Dogs of War.

I will respect the silence, I hope everyone else does, but if we have to listen to that stomach churning dirge as well then yes, boo like hell, let it all kick off, then when it quietens down we should start singing "There's only one Alan Davies". He's got death threats for saying most of what has been said on this thread!!! Says it all.
Phil Bellis
96 Posted 11/04/2012 at 14:01:25
I dont agree, Chez
The remembrance should be divorced from the game - it's personal to the bereaved and their grief
My great great uncle was one those who who died on the Titanic - will we have a minute's silence on Saturday for all those poor souls, including the 90 Scousers
Chez Hutton
97 Posted 11/04/2012 at 14:11:47
Phil (260) last time I checked the Titanic didn't crash into an iceberg inside the ground during an FA Cup Semi Final.
Colin Wainwright
98 Posted 11/04/2012 at 14:13:12
Of course it's virtually the same date, Chez. Semi finals are always played at this time of year. I know 96 people died mate. I was at our semi at Villa that day and it was a tragedy that affected the whole city.

My point is that an alcohol fuelled semi final meeting, on what is the most important match of the season for both clubs, is not the right place for sedate and respectful contemplation of what happened at Hillsborough, 23 years ago, the day after.
Chez Hutton
99 Posted 11/04/2012 at 14:19:02
Colin (264) personally I'd like to think that both sets of fans will treat the minutes silence with complete respect - but I understand your concerns.
Phil Bellis
100 Posted 11/04/2012 at 14:24:42
Watch it Chez - gross lack of respect, a la Alan Davies, for those who died on the Titanic

Do you see how easy it is to give offence?
Colin Wainwright
101 Posted 11/04/2012 at 14:26:26
So would I Chez (265), and I hope everyone does.
Stephen Sullivan
102 Posted 11/04/2012 at 14:20:24
Chez 262
So the tribute to the Titanic victims is to be held on an iceberg? Following your logic it would have to be?

Emotional and sensitive tributes such as Hillsborough deserve space away from the tribal and emotionally charged atmosphere of an Everton v Liverpool FA cup semi final. Fans on these occasions are very tense, anxious, fearful, excited and the adrenaline is firing full on. That is not the place for quiet reflection. People can act irrationally and out of character when these emotions run so high.

Why risk anything that might damage relations between the clubs when they are strained enough? In fact, I strongly believe that Moyes and Dalglish should avoid any mind game crap for this match as it stokes up the fans even further. Maybe they should agree to act with dignity and respect at all times for this potentially explosive match and ask the fans to do the same?
Chez Hutton
103 Posted 11/04/2012 at 14:38:35
Phil (271) please do not try to drag me into a pissing match - my point is clearly that the Titanic has nothing to do with football, whereas Hillsborough does - however if it were to be commemorated on Saturday, I would again like to think both sets of fans would give it the respect it deserves.
Chez Hutton
104 Posted 11/04/2012 at 14:46:29
Stephen (277) as per my note to Phil
Andrew Ellams
105 Posted 11/04/2012 at 14:49:27
Problem with a situation like this is that we are 23 years on and the majority of blues in the stadium on Saturday probably aren't old enough to remember that horrible day like some of us. Because of that it hasn't had the same effect on them and that in turn will change the feelings towards it.

I'm not suggesting that they won't pay the situation the respect it deserves, they just won't see things the same as some of us do.
Colin Gee
106 Posted 11/04/2012 at 14:55:02
Declan #259 I'm the same, quiet for the 60seconds, but if that song is played i'll be booing and whistling like everyone else. I think we all know that it will kick off between us and them at some stage during the day. Let's not give them any moral higher ground.

As for Alan Davies, he must read ToffeeWeb, as I said pretty much the same thing as he's said in another thread on here about a fortnight ago...
Kieran Kinsella
107 Posted 11/04/2012 at 15:00:30
In 1989 I almost felt as if we had to let Liverpool win aft HB. However, this is 23 years later and it says a lot about our own small mindedness and inferiority complex if we cannot have a minute's silence before a game without feeling that somehow it will enable big bad Kenny to get one over on us.

Half the players were not even born when HB happened so I do not think for one minute (pardon the pun) that the minute's silence or the song will have any impact on how Fellaini, Heitinga or Jelavic play on the big day.

We do not need to make excuses for ourselves ahead of time. We are ahead of them in thee league and we are in better form than them. If we lose it is because of our own psychological problems and not because someone decided to have a minute's silence.
Phil Bellis
108 Posted 11/04/2012 at 15:01:39
That wasn't my intention, Chez - we simply disagree about keeping the commemoration away from the stomach-churning intensity of the most important derby match for decades
So, `nuff said

As for things kicking off: as usual, if they win, we'll behave; if WE win - watch how they react
Chez Hutton
109 Posted 11/04/2012 at 15:11:40
Phil (298) fair play!
Tom Fazal
110 Posted 11/04/2012 at 14:34:17
I too, am fed up with the way they play ?victim? card whenever it suits them (something that is increasing in frequency) and ignoring their own responsibilities for things they have done, but I hope we can separate the issues here.

We should honour the minute?s silence out of respect for the ordinary fans ? like many of you lucky people that have tickets for Saturday, who will travel full of hope and anticipation, filled with excitement, looking forward to returning home with bragging rights - who went to a football match and never came back.

I am a lifelong Blue but it touched me, as one of those who was killed through others incompetence, was my friends? 19-year-old son, Colin.

The silence is not about respecting Liverpool FC; it is not supporting the bandwagon they roll out whenever it suits them.

However, it is about remembering people like Colin (and his family) and many others, mostly young people (look at the list of names, the vast majority were young people) ? they were the real victims ? and our silence adds support for justice for them.

Drown out that dirge when they play it; be silent for a minute to show the world we respect the dead and then drown them out for the rest of the day.

COYB
Simon Harris
111 Posted 11/04/2012 at 14:58:01
I believe, any decent human being should be able to respect the sadly passed for 60 seconds. I hope it's observed with dignity.

But please no 'Merseyside' chants, it's patronising,cringeworthy and insincere.

And, as for 'that song' - ....words and common sense fail me.
Jack Molloy
112 Posted 11/04/2012 at 15:21:50
Of course we have to respect the minute's silence, no matter how cynical the proposal or how it twists the occasion into something it isn't or shouldn't be. Just pretend it's for Gary Speed. Don't let anyone be in any doubt, however, that this quasi-religious ritual before the game gives Liverpool a psychological head start.
Eugene Ruane
113 Posted 11/04/2012 at 15:26:34
Alan Davies?

About as funny as getting a paper-cut on your bell-end, then dipping it in salt.

Oh and he can't act a fucking lick either

(he makes Dean 'Jimmy Corkhill' Sullivan look like Lee Strasberg).

One smug twat.

Just..saying.
Stephen Sullivan
114 Posted 11/04/2012 at 15:38:31
Kieran 296

"If we lose it is because of our own psychological problems and not because someone decided to have a minute's silence."

The minutes silence can have a psychological affect and therefore influence the result?

Liverpool won the final after the Hillsborough tragedy. Where there any psychological factors relating to Hillsborough influencing things? I believe so as we were a better side at that time.

Liverpool lost the game against Juventus following the Heysel tragedy. Where there and psychological factors influencing things? I believe there may well have been; at the time, Liverpool were seen as invincible.

I know there are other factors influencing outcomes of matches like this but don't under-estimate the psychology of the minutes silence. The referee and linesmen have family, may have suffered bereavements etc. They may be unconsciously biased towards Liverpool given the emotion of the occasion. Everton's players may be "softened up" a bit in their resolve following the tributes whereas Liverpool's player may feel that little extra determination and steely resolve.

Most people, including you, understand the importance of psychology in sport.

We need to ensure we are not manipulated into a position of disadvantage, that's all.

Regarding Saturday:
I believe Moyes should say absolutely nothing about the game at all to the press other than the minimal he may have to. The players should keep their mouths shut too. Let Kenny spout off his team's strengths and their players do the same. Then, don't respond. They will be waiting for a reaction. As the days and hours go by whey will slowly become aware that Everton are saying nothing. Give nothing away. The silence will get to them. Silence can be the most powerful tool of all.

Small things can make such a difference.
Thomas Windsor
115 Posted 11/04/2012 at 15:47:59
Each person to his own view on this. Liverpool had a minutes silence on Saturday, I think that was enough. This is a semi-final at Wembley, played at a stupid time on a Saturday because Liverpool wont play on that date.

As somebody said on here before, this is not 1989 ? the younger followers of Everton will have been drinking all night and I can see the odd nasty chant. A minutes applause sounded a better idea to me or not even at all as Liverpool fans could have done that at Anfield Sunday at a mass there. I personally on the day will observe the minutes silence but I don't have to agree with it.
Barry Rathbone
116 Posted 11/04/2012 at 15:55:55
If it's so much about "Merseyside" how come they don't play YNWA then Z-Cars straight after?

Each tribe shouting "fuck off" non stop through the others tune would let the world see how "we're all muckers" really.

In one fell stroke you wouldn't see the FA promote such an ill-thought-out idea again.
David Barks
117 Posted 11/04/2012 at 16:20:25
At some point, when do you move on. Seriously, it sounds insensitive, but people die in tragic accidents all the time. This need to "mourn" in public constantly does nothing for the people who are dead, or their families. This happened decades ago, move on. I'll observe this memorial when Liverpool agree to hold a memorial each year on the date of the Heysel killings.
Mike Brown
118 Posted 11/04/2012 at 15:56:58
The decision has been made: there WILL be a minute's silence at Wembley on Saturday. It's now about how WE conduct ourselves on the day.

One comment to Jack (308) is that we don't have to pretend anything here. The minute's silence is to remember 96 people who went to watch their team play a football match and deserved to get home safely after it. We are remembering THEM.

I am old enough to remember. I was at Villa Park that day and was as bewildered as the next Blue as we tried to make sense of the news that slowly filtered through from the tragedy at Hillsborough.

In the days that followed, the accounts I heard of people dying doing what I love to do had a profound effect on me. I could relate to it but couldn't understand it. I was 35 years old at the time and had already introduced my own young family to the match. The effects on the families of the deceased is unfathomable.

Let me now relate one of the proudest moments in my life as an Evertonian. I was in the away corner of Old Trafford the day they held a minute's silence to respect the passing of Sir Matt Busby. We showed the class, dignity and sportsmanship that we're renowned for that day when observing the silence impeccably. As soon as the referee's whistle blew to signal the end of the minute we raised the roof in our support of Everton. No psychological advantage was handed to United.

May I appeal to all Evertonians to display the same class and dignity on Saturday. Anyone thinking of doing otherwise, I promise that you'll feel good if you do it properly and show the respect that the minute's remembrance calls for. Then go mental in a unified support for OUR team.

COYB
Tom Jones
119 Posted 11/04/2012 at 16:09:44
Yes, it is playing into their hands and can I ask if anyone knows was there a minutes silence when Liverpool played an FA Cup semi in 2006 or 2001 (I think)?

I just can't get excited as, come kick-off, I will be crying in my non-alcoholic Budweiser.

I remember the last derby and refuse to be disappointed again when Moyes announces his team ? which will of course feature Anichebe! I expect nothing but another rollover and more of Moyes's shithouse tactics (TM), he has let me down too many times for me to expect anything else.

I have now learned how if Rodwell wasn't injured (sorry, Jack), he would somehow be squeezed into the midfield with neville...

COYB! (See, even I cant help it!)
Bobby Thomas
120 Posted 11/04/2012 at 16:15:19
Stephen 319: There is no way we were a better side than Liverpool in 1989. They were a much, much better side than us.

We were awful in that final and didn't really deserve to take it to extra time.

Harvey's signing were poor. Cottee McCall, Nevin, Mike Milligan(!) was soon to arrive. In fact, most of Colin's signings, Keown and Hinchcliffe aside, were terrible. And Harvey didn't even see the best of them. We didn't even see the best of Keown. Sacrificed for £2 million, straight to the bank. See how long this decline has been ongoing?

It's well documented team spirit was very ropey with factions within the squad coupled with the remaining players from the glory days in terminal decline, such as Sharp, Van den Hauwe, post injury Ratcliffe was a poor imitation of the player he was.

Liverpool's was the Barnes, Beardsley, Aldridge side. John Barnes was the best player in the country at the time. They were streets ahead of us and most sides and it showed in that final.

Now, the '86 cup final, that was a completely different thing, we blew that and should've won it, after blowing the league as well.

I could handle '89, I just didn't think we were all that good. '86 was much more difficult.
Dan McKie
121 Posted 11/04/2012 at 16:20:10
I dont think there should be a minutes silence, that's my view.

If Liverpool fans or any affected Everton fans want to respect the dead on the 15th in a service then thats fine, but I think the rest of football should be allowed to move on. Would it be the same the other way around if Liverpool fans were expected every year to stand silent for the Munich air disaster? No.

Let people remember for as long as they want to, but the Sunday semi, how many Spurs and Chelsea fans still give the 96 a second thought, be it 15 April or any other day?

Also, what after 23 years will be considered justice for the 96? There may be time for quiet remembrance, but not with the world's media watching every second, probably hoping that it kicks off.
Chris Butler
122 Posted 11/04/2012 at 16:36:57
My problem is that Liverpool fans obviously don't respect the importance of the disaster, just look at Athens 2007. Read Nicky Alt's 2007 book Boys From The Mersey, in which he glorifies bunking into games, yet doesn't accept that he and his gang could have caused a disaster themselves.

Also, the fact that they constantly call United Munich hardly is going to stop United fans getting revenge and singing about their disaster.

Also, they mocked the 39 dead Italians in 2010 by their ridiculous banner.

Also, their fans and the club have never shown Everton any respect over the years ? remember Benitez's 'small club' comments. They had their minutes silence last week.

Also, take a look at their forums; they don't respect us. They also sing about Phil Nevilles disabled child and they spat at him in 2008.

As it wasn't 96 Everton fans nor anybody I knew that died at Hillsbrough, I think it would be wrong of me to speak about the disaster or the fans who died. What I do know is that Liverpool FC and Liverpool fans regard Everton FC as just a small club and our fans as bitters so it's no surprise there will be Everton fans who interrupt this on Saturday.
Ciarán McGlone
123 Posted 11/04/2012 at 16:30:03
Sad that there isn't universal agreement on such an issue...

What's even sadder, is that the predictions above will most likely materialise.

That some club-footed ingrate, with a lamentable understanding of life ? and unfortunately covered in blue....will open their mouths and piss all over this tragedy.

Unfortunately, Evertonians are NOT cut from the same cloth ? despite the cliches.
Declan Brown
124 Posted 11/04/2012 at 17:05:55
Lads just got a text from Queen Kenny.

I'm a goalkeeper myself admittedly with my best days well past me now. He wants to know if i can do nets on Saturday, he told me not to worry about red cards as Stevie Me Me Me is refereeing this one.

And they say sarcasm is the lowest from of wit...
Stephen Sullivan
125 Posted 11/04/2012 at 17:04:28
Bobby 339
Yes you are correct they did have the edge on paper at that time.
Don't know what I was thinking?
I'm not myself at the moment with all the talk of Hillsborough and Wembley. The minutes silence has influenced my already so god help the players?
Jon Cox
126 Posted 11/04/2012 at 15:17:13
I think the minutes silence most of us can handle. It's fair, it's respectful and it's the right thing to do.

But if I have to be quiet while some numpty sings their song on the pitch in the space of that minute then no,

I wont.
Stephen Sullivan
127 Posted 11/04/2012 at 17:17:40
An interesting article that unfortunately tars us all with the same brush.
http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/news/brendanoneill2/100150255/alan-davies-has-committed-a-thought-crime-against-the-post-hillsborough-cult-of-emotional-correctness/#disqus_thread
Steve Sweeney
128 Posted 11/04/2012 at 17:10:41
Every Evertonion should urge the guy next to him or her at Wembley on Saturday to respect the minutes silence.
Don't let those murdering bastards get one over on us.
Lets show the whole world that we are EVERTON, the best football club in the world.
With the best supporters.
Please don't let the club and ourselves down,
they are not worth it.
The only reason they have done this is to wind us up
rise above it- we will do them Saturday if only for my DAD.
Paul Andrews
129 Posted 11/04/2012 at 19:27:19
Respect should be a two way thing.

I am told they will unfurl a banner congratulating Steua Bucharest winning the European Cup in 1986.
The year after they got us banned,and the year when we had a chance of winning the cup.

Pay your respect with applause during the minute.
David King
130 Posted 11/04/2012 at 19:18:52
i agree with chris Butler (341)...I was listening to 2 middle-aged redshite at work last week laughing and joking about seeing a large mob of ticketless redshite trying to 'strom' the gates at the League Cup final recently.
They said that they heard them planning how to do it, then watched them trying to fight their way in.......
They thought that it was really funny and were pleased that some of them managed to get inside.....
I asked them if anyone was hurt during the incident.....they both just looked at me with blank expressions............

While Hillsborough was a terrible tragedy and the 96 should be remembered at the appropriate time and place, I do not believe that the semi on Saturday should have a minutes silence as I fear major trouble if it is not observed properly.

Dogleash will undoubtably refer to it at every oppurtunity before the game in an effort to influence the officials.

I hope we absolutely twat them on the pitch.....horrible,cheating bastards.
David King
131 Posted 11/04/2012 at 19:49:14
'storm'
Danny Broderick
132 Posted 11/04/2012 at 22:39:13
Any Blues who are thinking about disrupting the minute's silence would be doing our club a massive disservice. Can you imagine the headlines the next day if such a thing happened? It would also spur the Liverpool team on massively. Surely the rivalry can be put to side for 1 minute? Hillsborough caused a lot of grief to the whole of Merseyside, not just LFC fans. Let's pay our respects, & then beat them fair & square. Let's not do anything that could possibly detract from one of the best opportunities we will ever have to beat them & more importantly win something. 17 years is far too long without silverware. COYB!
Steve Barr
133 Posted 11/04/2012 at 23:33:33
I'm surprised there is any debate here.

We're decent human beings, honour the minutes silence as that is the only thing to do.

No argument can defend any other kind of behaviour.

After the minute's silence then we focus on the match.

Kev Johnson
134 Posted 11/04/2012 at 23:58:22
Well said, Steve Barr! I'm in total agreement with you.
Anthony Jones
135 Posted 12/04/2012 at 02:18:25
We absolutely have to play the game and honour the ritual. Very few are arguing this point, but to not question the reasoning behind it is just plain ignorrant. This smacks of "our pain is worse than your pain" sentiment. Tell me, why is there no ceremony for those dying in syria, or everton fans who have recently passed away? Are we only to publically mourn lfc fans from now on? If it were simply a remembrance ceremony I could stomach it, but there will no doubt be more "justice for the 96" rhetoric that stinks of victimhood.
Steve Smith
136 Posted 12/04/2012 at 06:01:56
The clubs have announced today that a period of silence will be observed before kick-off in memory of the 96 souls who died at Hillsborough.

Surely a minutes applause would be the better option? It worries me that a few knobheads on the day will leave us all tarred with the same brush.

Eugene Ruane
137 Posted 12/04/2012 at 06:17:21
I repeat, any Evertonian breaking the minute's silence, will be increasing LIVERPOOL"S chances of winning this game.

Want to get their Adrenalin REALLY pumping?

Boo or applaud.

If you don"t want to give them ANY advantage on the day, keep it shut for 60 seconds.
Gareth Humphreys
138 Posted 12/04/2012 at 09:58:17
For all those younger Evertonians out there, Hillsborough affected the whole city. There was the mile of scarfes between Goodison and Anfield and the match that LFC most comfortable returning to football in after the event was a derby. At Goodison.

If you don't want to pay your respects on Saturday by observing the minutes silence than that is your prerogative. Stay away. But don't besmirch the name of EFC at the same time as you don't have the right to make that choice.
Phil Bellis
139 Posted 12/04/2012 at 10:29:40
I will feel for the bereaved and pay my respects to those who died at Hillsborough as I do on Remembrance Day for those who gave everything so that my generation and those that follow can lead decent lives. But I don't attend a public wake every 11 November, 9 September or 29 May.

What should be a respectful time of reflection and compassion is being turned into a circus hosted by the media. Keep the silence if you're there but I refuse to keep quiet if they start that funeral dirge from South Pacific or wherever it's from ? if it's NOT just about Liverpool Football Club but those that died, football and the City, how about the traditional football hymn, Abide With Me? Thought not!

I've still got my `66 songsheet, though
Dave Wilson
140 Posted 12/04/2012 at 11:03:23
Families are still divided, but it was much more commonplace back in the eighties. The Hillsborough disaster had a profound effect on both sets of fans. Many Evertonians lost loved ones too.

The blue half of the stadium will observe and respect the minutes silence.

We know how to conduct ourselves and when the teams peel away to their respective ends, the kopites will make incredible noise .That`ll be our cue to bring the fucken house down.


Howard Don
141 Posted 12/04/2012 at 23:24:48
Whether you agree or not with this, let's all show some class and respect the minutes silence. We can only lose respect by not doing so.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads