Season › 2011-12 › News
McNulty hints at Moyes's tactical blunder
Excerpts relating to Everton (The rest of his blog is about Liverpool):
For Everton, and manager David Moyes, there was only obvious desolation at yet another defeat to Liverpool when stakes were high, an opportunity missed in a timid tactical fashion that will frustrate them for a very long time.
Everton manager Moyes cut a dejected figure in his post-match briefing, perhaps knowing he and his team had squandered one of the best opportunities they will ever have to pay back the misery they have suffered at their neighbour's hands on big Wembley occasions in the past.
And for Moyes himself, there was the painful knowledge that even in this troubled Liverpool season, he has failed to fashion a derby victory in three attempts.
This was a scenario Everton's fans have witnessed before, a team — and maybe its manager — simply not having the confidence and belief that Liverpool could be beaten.
After Everton took the lead when Nikica Jelavic, a striker of finesse and threat with an ice-cold mind in front of goal, profited from a calamitous lack of communication between Jamie Carragher and Daniel Agger to score, they seemed happy to contain.
With a lead to encourage them, Everton failed to get the job done and recent results suggest they struggle psychologically to convince themselves they can overcome Liverpool.
Moyes now completes a decade at Everton without a trophy and, for all his widely acknowledged work in that time, it is still a statistic that will wound him. He has said he will discuss Everton's future direction with chairman Bill Kenwright at the end of the season - it promises to be an interesting, and potentially pivotal, meeting.
Quotes or other material sourced from BBC Sport
Reader Comments (54)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 15/04/2012 at 20:47:21
Think that's the responsibility of both the manager and the players- the manager's job is to motivate the team to beat them, the players should be experienced enough to cope with the pressure now
3 Posted 15/04/2012 at 20:38:34
In the games building upto the semi, we played our best stuff and were more solid when we pressed high up the pitch. We would have men forward and pressing and, when we would nick the ball, we would have plenty of men forward to do damage and score. Defensively, because we were pressing higher, we were giving less chances to the opposition and that's why we were not conceeding or conceeding very little!
First half in the semi, we grew into the game and took the lead but second half we expected them to come out fighting and they did... but we chose to keep on sitting and containing and giving the Shite the initiative! The mistakes didn't help either but Moyesy should learn from teams like Cardiff and the likes of Wigan who had goes against the Shite and gave them good games, with Wigan even going on to win at Anfield!
He's got to be braver when going up against Liverpool and stop treating them with too much respect as if they're shit hot and one of the best! Only difference between them and us IMO is Gerrard; without him, I think they'd be like us or worse even?!!
4 Posted 15/04/2012 at 20:55:47
5 Posted 15/04/2012 at 21:23:01
6 Posted 15/04/2012 at 21:05:09
The Drenthe debacle is an example of weak journalism. By accepting without question the club silence on the matter the fans were denied their right to know.
It should be remembered that it is the fans that keep the press and club afloat.
8 Posted 15/04/2012 at 21:39:22
First off though, met 3 great Evertonians on the tube who had just arrived from Lime street, heading to Wembley so joined them at the Green Man Pub for the pre-match bevvy. Great atmosphere, heaving with blues and no trouble whatsoever. Police where in great form, joining in the banter and keeping things cool.
Then onto Wembley, just in time for the minute silence which silence was immaculatly observed and then kick off.
Mediocre first half, neither team seemed up for it, but Everton deservedly went in ahead. We discussed the half time talk and as layman. The consensus was we have to come out on fire, stop them playing down the wings and ram home our superiority with a quick second goal.
Surprise surprise, we sit back, deer in the headlight, and then the inevitable!
Sorry but once again I'm sad to say Moyes proved me right. He is finished as far as I'm concerned, can't produce the win that was just waiting for us to grasp. If ever we should have beaten Liverpool then yesterday was it.
I expect there will be excuses but Moyes should put his handS up, as Distin did, admit his failings and get the hell out of it.
Brilliant day notwithstanding and well worth the flying visit from the USA. But what a hollow feeling now that I'm back.
Unfortunately
9 Posted 15/04/2012 at 21:52:49
Under Moyes, we've gone back to the early 80's of just hoping for a draw or a low scoring defeat.
10 Posted 15/04/2012 at 22:09:49
Not so with Moyes they know they'll probably win or draw at worst. His record against the top sides away from Goodison is shameful and as previous respondents have said needs airing by the media.
11 Posted 15/04/2012 at 22:33:59
12 Posted 15/04/2012 at 22:20:16
The usual form is:
Unmitigated disaster
internet meltdown for 2 days
Moyes boys get the all clear and slide out with "punching above weight" mantras.
then everyone goes back to sleep.
13 Posted 15/04/2012 at 22:49:04
14 Posted 15/04/2012 at 22:48:34
It's down to the manager and players who let the supporters down in every meaningful match: Champions League, Europa League, FA Cup, League Cup etc..
We need a change; it's okay beating Sunderland, West Brom etc but, when the pressure is on, they 'bottle it' and that comes from the management.
15 Posted 15/04/2012 at 23:09:06
16 Posted 15/04/2012 at 23:54:20
Agree totally.
Maybe if Moyes doesn't go we could coax Colin Harvey out of retirement to take round's place.
Then crack on from the early eighties you talk about because what was just around the corner wasn't half bad!
17 Posted 15/04/2012 at 23:56:57
18 Posted 16/04/2012 at 00:33:25
One (theirs) had the gumption to introduce Bellamy as soon as he realised that Baines was injured. He recently got huge flak for supporting a racist and a low life. The results, the racist scored a goal, got MOM and Bellamy injected fresh pace into their attack at a time our defence was in meltdown.
Our manager stood on the touchline and went back to the only tactic that he knows after 10 years in the job. Try to defend a one goal lead, with 66 odd minutes left. One of our centre-backs was on a yellow card so he had to back off Carroll, while Jags sat on the bench. Result? Carroll destroyed us. Meanwhile, Drente was elsewhere after a breach of club discipline, allegedly for being late for a training session. Now, while I don?t condone this type of behaviour, surely Moyes could have swallowed his pride for once and dealt with the matter differently. Perhaps a heavy fine? Drente, in my opinion would have wrecked havoc with their defence with his runs and shooting.
Conclusion: A massive opportunity to win a trophy has been squandered while the RS and their manager go on to play in the final against a team with a manager who has been in a job a few weeks. In the interim, we can look forward to more abject failure for as long as Moyes is in charge
19 Posted 16/04/2012 at 00:50:36
20 Posted 16/04/2012 at 00:50:35
What goes wrong is the execution. There were times we can hit them with a counter, but somehow the communication between Jelavic and the mids went wrong. And of course Distin's blunder had an effect on the team's confidence.
It would be a complete different story if Pienaar had played...
21 Posted 16/04/2012 at 01:40:19
22 Posted 16/04/2012 at 01:58:48
23 Posted 16/04/2012 at 03:44:57
For all the clever arses out there, tell me what these numbers are
13 17 15 6 15 17 14 13 16.
24 Posted 16/04/2012 at 05:14:08
25 Posted 16/04/2012 at 05:22:07
26 Posted 16/04/2012 at 06:32:57
27 Posted 16/04/2012 at 07:00:26
We'll get the usual toss pot players coming out in the Echo telling us how bad they fee, how much they're hurting.
They were in so much pain that they just had to go out on Sunday and buy another Bentley to cheer themselves up, oh yes and a BMW for the wife cos she was upset cos the dog groomer couldn't shampoo the Shitz zu this week.
We'll get the usual toss pot correspondants Prentice and O'Keeffe telling us absolutely nothing - as usual - but then again they'll be too busy worrying about the lack of freebies they got at Wembley.
We'll get Davie on telling us that him and Steve and the backroom staff will be spending this week motivating the players to tighten up at the back and concentrate on only losing to Man Utd 1-0 which will, of course, be a resounding success.
Greg and Dave and all the players will be right up for Utd, Greg and Dave cos the freebies are brill there and the players cos they'll be made up to see top players and might get their autographs.
Fucking tossers every last one !
29 Posted 16/04/2012 at 08:18:42
Almost to a man our fans were confident of victory. Player like Fellaini, Heitinga, Jelavic and Gibson don't fear anyone, they've shown it often enough.
Only the manager who is lackinbg the belief. He could turn a lion into a mouse.
Surely he will go now.
30 Posted 16/04/2012 at 08:46:44
We have now gone 17 years without a trophy. So we are close to breaking that adjusted record.
We are settling nicely into the situation of plucky Everton. Good old Everton who are a well run family club and will always have a good try. Once again on Saturday night's 606 on BBC I heard them talking about how David Moyes should move to a big club for his own sake.
All standards are set at the top. The Chairman sets the standard, he puts down what is acceptable. He has demonstrated in 12 years at the helm that he is satisfied with mediocrity and that he has no clue as to how to move us on from that stage - or more likely that he has no desire to move us on from that stage.
There needs to be a new standard at the club, one of professionalism rather than benevolent amateurism. One that sets up the business side to succeed rather than rely on asset sales. One that demands the team try to win, rather than try not to lose. One that recognises that 17 years without a trophy is simply not good enough. One that instills in the playing staff the demands of supporters that it is better to go down fighting than stagger on to another capitulation.
So we come back once again to the same problem. We need to force this Chairman out and get in someone who has a single clue about driving Everton forward in every area we operate, whose yardstick is success rather than how much longer he can hold on to his trainset.
31 Posted 16/04/2012 at 08:56:04
32 Posted 16/04/2012 at 09:32:09
33 Posted 16/04/2012 at 09:33:58
What about Man U next week at OT? I predict 11 men behind the ball, a promise that we wont have a shot on goal, providing they dont put more than 2 past us, Moyes gets his belly tickled by Sir Alex, and he then recommends Moyes for the Utd job to the media.
34 Posted 16/04/2012 at 08:34:38
Why are you bringing in our league finishes before Moyes' arrival? That has nothing to do with this article, which is primarily a discussion on Moyes' tactical choices against Liverpool, the 'Sky 4', his inability to change his stubborn defensive ways against them, and his horrendous record against them and in big games.
I knew our record against these teams since Moyes' arrival in March 2002 was bad, but your post pushed me to find out exactly how bad, and it was even worse than I thought....
In all competions, Home and Away :
P 97 W 12 D 26 L59
In all competitions, Away only :
P 47 W 0 D 16 L 31
Cups, Home, Away and Neutral :
P 16 W 2 D 3 L 11
In the words of Mr Willian Kenwright, I looked at that list, and I just said "Wow!".
35 Posted 16/04/2012 at 10:09:04
Pffft... and some people say he's negative hey!
36 Posted 16/04/2012 at 10:17:47
37 Posted 16/04/2012 at 10:47:51
I don't think Moyes wanted to play so deep, Liverpool just pushed too hard, too many players weren't up to their usual standard.
38 Posted 16/04/2012 at 11:00:58
Seriously you are pissing in the wind. These guys love being mid table fodder. I know Lyndon put a mail out about respecting each other but they really get on my tits as to what length they will go to defend Moyes.
Surely these guys realise that THEY have to DEFEND this guy because of the shite his team has dished up this year.
But what hurts more than poor standards and I will not dispute the lack of money has a bearing on who he can sign. Is the lack of heart we have shown against our biggest rivals. That is why he should go now. Fuck me, Wigan played them off the park a week earlier at their so-called fortress. I despair and I despair for the poor souls who actually support Moyes.
39 Posted 16/04/2012 at 11:40:12
Joe Royle, as a player, before kick off in derby games he was playing in, would calmly ask the ref..
"Are we playing the rules today ref or the LIVERPOOL rules?"
Not Bill Hicks I'll grant you, but a good-humoured, little psychological dig that may, or may not, have done him/us any good on the day.
The point is, it showed a little wit and a little imagination.
Joe was imo (is) cool.
Whether he was actually smarter than most other managers I've no idea but he certainly SEEMED smarter.
He had that kind of 'quiet knowing scouse cool' that you used to find in dockers and merchant seamen in the 60s and 70s.
Fairly quiet, a mouth-full of Juicy Fruit on the go at all imes and a very smart cutting response when required.
When we won the cup in 95 we were not supposed to win the semi and we CERTAINLY weren't supposed to win the final.
We did because Joe Royle wasn't for accepting that anyone was better than Everton, or that anyone was a smarter manager than him
And (more importantly), he had the ability to get this over to the team.
For me, this is all part of what is wrong right now.
Our present leader insists on showing his fucking hand to the whole world BEFORE anyone has bet.
He can't change himself or anyine else
His lack of wit, imagination, 'smarts', ability to change etc, is there for all to see.
And those in the media (or on TW) who can't see it now, surely never will.
40 Posted 16/04/2012 at 12:28:52
Magaye and Gibson strolled around the pitch not looking arsed and if anyone can tell me how Shite-Fadden can get on the bench before Barkley then I do not know football.
41 Posted 16/04/2012 at 12:34:32
42 Posted 16/04/2012 at 12:39:19
I never thought he was the greatest manager but he knew how to beat the RS. If Moyes hasn't got it in him why doesn't he bring someone in who has, before Derbies etc to talk to the players.
And talk about 'cutting off your nose to spite your face' - leaving Drenthe behind! Christ! Our only game changer from the bench and he leaves him behind for apparently being late! (Admittedly I haven't got the full story here, but what I do know is bloody McFadden was on the bench not Drenthe!)
A wise manager once said that football is about 'moments in a game' - recognising them and reacting. We had 'a moment' the ten minutes before half time and we needed to press home our advantage and get a second goal not wait to sit back and hope for the best... as usual.
Unbelievably painful Wembley trip yet again. Sick of it. And this week I have to renew my season ticket!
43 Posted 16/04/2012 at 12:56:00
Simple answer would have been to keep Felli and Gibson going as they had done in first half and subbed Tim for either Victor or Straq to keep their back four occupied.
44 Posted 16/04/2012 at 14:21:36
That's such a sad and sorry indictment against Moyes and his tactics against those teams. ZERO wins away from home after 10 years really says it all.
Peter#202: Completely agree. I thought Fellaini did a great job winning the midfield battle. In contrast, Cahill looked lost and was nowhere near as effective, either up front or in defensive mid. I could see it, my gf (who's football illiterate) could see it, and I'm guess Kenny Dalglish could see it. Pity the one person who mattered on that day couldn't.
45 Posted 16/04/2012 at 15:52:51
Magaye and Gibson strolled around the pitch not looking arsed and if anyone can tell me how Shite-Fadden can get on the bench before Barkley then I do not know football."
Keith Knowles @ 188, what are you trying to say? Gibson and Gueye should be sold, Cahill kept as a sub and McFadden shouldn't have been sitting on the bench with no danger of coming on? Have you any thoughts on the man who chose to buy or play these players, who hasn't produced a single decent young lad through the ranks in ten years of negative bungling? Do you accept a decade of shite as long as we change the players about a bit more? Titanic deck chairs come to mind, and just like the 100 year old tragedy, we are in danger of sinking even further next season if we don't change the short sighted man at the wheel
46 Posted 16/04/2012 at 16:10:06
I went to day-release college with Joe and you couldn't have met a more likeable teenager, no side on him, no swank, he was just after more O levels in case he didn't make it
My favourite Joe story...
he was called in to Harry's office where Harry commenced to give him a lecture on toughening up, using his physique to bully defenders, "throw yourself about a bit, get meaner, son"
"Any questions, Joe?"
"Would you like a sweetie, Boss?"
47 Posted 16/04/2012 at 17:21:28
The same arguments also apply to Bill Kenwright - who is another failure.
48 Posted 16/04/2012 at 19:02:18
A kind of cool that comes from not trying to be cool.
Polite, calm, engaging but with a bit of inner steel.
Still think he got fucked by Everton but don't remember him whining or 'telling his story'.
Despite his age and time out of the game, I'd have him today if it meant getting rid of our current, devoid of imagination, wit and psychology, miserable Presbyterian 'leader'.
Not saying we'd be winning trophies, but I do believe the football would be better and do believe we'd go into derbies not beaten before we started.
He's younger than Fergie too.
49 Posted 16/04/2012 at 19:19:16
He is an Evertonian and he managed Duncan fantastically well..
50 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:25:30
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
to save you the bother of checking them out, they are the years in which Moyes has never admitted to a single mistake.
51 Posted 17/04/2012 at 03:13:50
52 Posted 17/04/2012 at 05:39:51
53 Posted 17/04/2012 at 06:20:34
54 Posted 17/04/2012 at 08:12:47
Moyes tells his team to keep it tight at ManUre. Ashley Young dives to win a penalty to lead 1:0. Moyes waits until the 70th minute to have a go at them. ManUre score two goals more to make it 3:0 at full time.
The Shite win their next game to overtake Everton in the league table.
More of the same shite from Moyes apologists on Toffeeweb.
55 Posted 17/04/2012 at 09:26:41
I also commented on Gibson recently that he is no more than a Carsley clone with a long range shot.
Well excuse me I didn't see no long range shooting from our 'we have not lost a game with Gibson', 'he's the perfect foil for Fellaini', 'he's not good enough at Man Utd but that does not mean he's shite' at the semi did we?!
Oh wait a minute, you mean we haven't lost with Gibson in the PREM? Oh dear me I hope Moyes does not play Gibson against man utd we might get a point! What a thought eh!!!
56 Posted 18/04/2012 at 19:15:15
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 15/04/2012 at 20:28:43
This was an absolutely disastrous decision by Moyes (yet again) to try and hold onto a one-nil lead. He should hang his head in shame. Why didn't they at least go down fighting??
It reminds me so much of the Cup Final against Chelsea ? one-nil lead and then... nothing but defend. Stupid way to lose any game, never mind a semi against Liverpool.