Moyes is not for quitting

, 16 April, 239comments  |  Jump to most recent
Neville believes Moyes is in it for the long term
Phil Neville has dismissed fears David Moyes may consider his Everton future after the heartbreak of the FA Cup semi-final derby defeat. Moyes cut a despondent figure after the match, prompting questions over his desire to continue working within the tight financial restraints of the club. But Neville insisted: ?The way he has managed us in the last month or two suggests to me that he is in it for the long-term."

?He has been fantastic and rotated the team, something this club hasn't been able to do before. The lads have really embraced that.

?He is ambitious and he wants to get to the top. He wants to do that with Everton. We've just got to make sure we stop slipping up at this stage of games.?

Neville added: ?It's going to be difficult to lift ourselves. Back in October, everyone had written us off. Everyone thought the club was on its knees and we were finished as a team. But we bounced back.

?It's going to be a test of our mettle now but we've got five games left and if we can finish seventh that might give us European football. That is something to hang on to.?

Quotes or other material sourced from Liverpool Daily Post



Reader Comments (239)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Dave Stewart
1 Posted 16/04/2012 at 13:04:57
There are quite a few articles like this going around in today's papers that it's time for Moyes to move on to reach his full potential... please god, let them be true. This is as good as Moyes gets: he's an average manager and he's perfectly at home at an average club.

No club with ambition will touch Moyes. The papers are saying Moyes for Villa... well, that about sums it up; out of the frying pan, into the fire.

Here's my prediction (stick it on your fridge and look at it when the seasons over): If Harry leaves Spurs, no way will they look at Moyes, they know he's the emperor with no clothes, and I know Spurs got walloped yesterday but they will regroup and aim for success. Moyes ain' t gonna give that; he's a mid-table manager suitable for mid-table clubs and, as time goes on, more and more Evertonians are becoming mid-table fans.

Mark Murphy
2 Posted 16/04/2012 at 14:10:58
I almost replied to one of those Moyes should move on for his own good articles until I realised I had to log in to the Daily fucking Mail to do so and I draw the line at that!

After the Anfield derby, I wanted Moyes out. After the Sunderland draw, I resolved to give him another chance. After the Sunderland replay, I was back on side.

If we had played the Shite like we did either of those Sunderland games, I would still be on side. 10 minutes before kick off, I was writing my apology to David Moyes for ever doubting him. But we didn't go for it as we did v Sunderland. We blew it again and I've had enough!

If he is such a good manager that he needs to move on to fulfil his destiny, then so be it. But I bet a virtual mortgage his destiny will be trophyless!
Aidy Dews
3 Posted 16/04/2012 at 14:10:35
I just wish Moyes would show confidence and trust in the team to have a go at such sides like Liverpool but I don't know if it's in his make up anymore, it used to be in the early days!.

He needs to show that he believes in the team and that he believes that they're capable of having a real good go at beating the likes of Liverpool and the top four sides.

The way we've performed against Liverpool at least two out of the three times we've played them now this season suggests he thinks they're a superior team to us and tries to sit and contain them and hope to nick a goal at some point and try and defend it, similar to how we were against Man City and Spurs at home!

It's nice if we see it through but horrible viewing, and absolutely disgusting and hard to take if we don't get anything out of the games.

To me, we have the basis of a good side. We have a good spine to the team now we've got Jelavic on board. With Howard, Jags, Heitinga, Gibson, Felli, Jelavic and the likes of Baines and Pienaar around those, we do have the makings of a good side and just need to add the neccesities to make us better but as always, money determines that.

If we could add to those players with better quality somehow, we could be a good side seriously challenging the European spots again IMO but, if Moyes was able to add to the squad with better quality, would he be more positive in big games and allow the side to go out and have a go instead of feeling inferior and try and defend against em and nick things on the break and defend what we've got??? I'm really not so sure?!
James Morgan
4 Posted 16/04/2012 at 14:07:58
If Moyes were to resign tomorrow, I think a whole host of clubs would love to have him at the helm, but none of the so called big boys. All those above us in the table would want somebody who has trophies on their CV, something I think we should look for in our next boss, although they don't always come cheap. Then again, I'd also be happy to gamble on a Lambert, Rodgers and maybe even a Martinez.

Everything comes to and end at some point and I believe it's Moyes's time now. Don't be afraid of change, Blues!
Andy Callan
5 Posted 16/04/2012 at 14:45:30
Everton ARE a mid-table club though, Dave.

We've got no cash and it doesn't fuckin' matter who we get we can't afford the best players.

If we can't get the best players we'll be stuck with mid-table players and a mid-table manager....

I don't know what people expect.

I have to say though, we still should have beaten them the other day, even if we'd of got twatted in the final....... That's the 'orrible part.........
Joe McMahon
6 Posted 16/04/2012 at 15:10:01
Another shit thing is most of these mid-table clubs have new or well maintained stadiums, we don't even have that!
Jamie Barlow
7 Posted 16/04/2012 at 15:12:45
You have no idea whether Moyes could be a sucess at another club because you haven't seen him go out and spend money without having to get rid of his better players.

He could very well be a success at a club willing to give him the money to do as he pleases.
David Stewart
8 Posted 16/04/2012 at 14:59:24
Andy, I accept that without mega bucks you ain't going to win the league but, as Kenwright isn't going anywhere, then surely we have to look at other options. I believe that the present day Everton in the present day league can still be relatively successful, even Cardiff pushed Liverpool to the wire.

The whole mindset of Moyes is not to go out and win but to go out and not lose and it saddens me to say too many Evertonians are now thinking the same way. We took a gamble on Moyes and I now believe it's time for another gamble... don't worry, we won't go down ? there's a lot lot worse below us ? but I'd prefer to be looking upwards than down.

If I'm in a minority and most fans accept the status quo then that saddens me too. All I can do is hope that one day all of us ? fans, manager, owners and players ? aspire to do a lot better. COYB
Matt Traynor
9 Posted 16/04/2012 at 15:26:13
James (#244) the next manager may not come cheap, but this one is already one of the highest paid in the world ? a recent report had him at #12.

Moyes is too comfortable. BK won't sack him: keep us in the Prem and the heat is off Bill. Like when he was offered the chance to better himself at Arsenal as a player, he chose the comfort of regular games for Cambridge.

He won't leave us yet as he wants to build up his pension a bit more before taking a 2/3 cut to go see out a career at Celtic.

I used to think I'd like to see him given a chance with new owners. In the unlikely event that materialises, I doubt he'd stay as they might decide to set some targets ? I expect he'd ride off with his Chairman and a bag full of cash.

As others have said, Everton is as good as it will ever get for him in the Premier League. With Bill pulling the wool over fans' eyes by lowering our ambition, we're stuck with him a while yet.
Mick Wrende
10 Posted 16/04/2012 at 15:24:10
Evertonians have a simple choice.

1) We won't be relegated under Moyes but he is not a winner so if he stays another 10 years, we will never have a trophy in the cabinet. So fans will never know the triumphant, heart thumping moment when the final whistle goes and the cup is ours. We will never know the victory parade in the open top bus with the cup held aloft as we chant at the tops of our voices.

2) We can 'risk' appointing one of the up and coming young managers who will get us playing attacking, goal scoring football, so we actually look forward to going to games and where we wont have the horror of the abject capitulation we saw on Saturday.

I have felt the thrills and the glory of league title wins and cup successes so I know which I would choose. My dad did too and so did his dad. My sons haven't ever experienced those feelings, so go now Moyes and give them a chance of glory. After 10 years of misery they have earned it.
David Stewart
11 Posted 16/04/2012 at 15:26:14
Jamie, this is my last reply cos it's late over here and I've gotta be up soon for work. Mate, I firmly believe Moyes will never be a succes anywhere; regardless of how much money he has, it would be one huge quantam leap.

Of course you need money to win the league but it's not necessary for the League Cup or FA Cup. What you do need though is a belief that you can do it and I don't believe Moyes has that belief.

Fellow blues, wherever you are in the world, sweet dreams.
Gary Heywood
12 Posted 16/04/2012 at 15:48:46
Moyes could well go to Spurs. They have no chance of ever winning a major trophy, ie, Premier League, Champions League or Europa Cup, and a very limited chance in domestic cups.
Tom Winek
13 Posted 16/04/2012 at 15:55:23
'This is as good as Moyes gets: he's an average manager and he's perfectly at home at an average club.'

Most fans think their teams are special and Everton fans are no different. However, truth be told, we are a very average club, certainly over the last 25 years.

There are so many deluded fans who think, should Moyes resign, we're going to be inundated with interest from world class managers who are going to step in and change our fortunes. Or a one-season wonder like Holloway, who, let's not forget, led his team to The Championship after one year in the top flight.

I don't think Moyes is the problem. I think it's the whole club. We do have a small club mentality. How many of us really thought we'd win the semi-final? Not many if you read ToffeeWeb last week. I am as guilty as anyone.
Anto Byrne
14 Posted 16/04/2012 at 16:04:24
He's not gonna leave when they pay him three million quid a year now. It makes losing that much more bearable. Winning and playing attractive football and regularly beating the top teams is not in his contract.
Joe McMahon
15 Posted 16/04/2012 at 16:14:36
For Crying Out Loud! This is not want I want to hear. I haven't seen us in 3 years, I'm desperate to see a New Dawn at Everton. I vowed I would never watch us again, until he leaves. I'm sticking to it, but it's hard. How many years can a top flight club stick with a manager who never actually achieves anything but Mediocrity??? Please no one say top 6 finish, LMA awards etc... he's had 10 bloody years!!!
Dan McKie
16 Posted 16/04/2012 at 16:19:12
Tom, Holloway did get relegated, but it was on the last day after going out and attacking every single side they played, without fear. They eventually went down because of the fact that most of their players had been playing league 1 and 2 football a couple of years earlier. Like I have said before, if Holloway had a back 5 of Howard, Neville, Baines, Johnny and Distin, they wouldnt have gone down. Also, he took Blackpool to Anfield once, and won once!!
Mike Hayes
17 Posted 16/04/2012 at 16:23:42
If he was a decent a bloke as he makes out he would walk out now. Sick to death of his negativity and unwillingness to give youth a go. How do Barkley and Vellios feel?

Got nothing against Faddy but taking him to Wembley instead of Drenthe or Barkley smacks of defeatism which he has well acomplished here.

Go now and let someone in with attacking vision and not dire defensive dross.
James Stewart
18 Posted 16/04/2012 at 16:28:14
If Moyes leaves at the end of the Season, I will be more elated than had we won the FA Cup. Here's hoping!
Billy Fisher
19 Posted 16/04/2012 at 16:01:52
There's no truth in saying we'll never know if he would be better with money to spend. There have been a number of starts to seasons, where a very good squad has been available and injury free.

Moyes was still clueless, infuriating and baffling with his tactics and substitutions, then we get to see the players we're all screaming for only through injuries to his preferred team, and then we start to look exciting as a team.

He's good in the transfer market but then kills any heart, spirit and creativity in those players; he doesn't instill confidence or fight in the players, he's no tactical nous and can't change a game to combat the tactics of his opponents. He's done his best and it's nowhere near good enough for Everton.

Ideally Kenwright should go first, but that fucker's going nowhere, is he?
Joe Bibb
20 Posted 16/04/2012 at 16:30:02
Moyes might not be for quitting but I am. After 50 years watching the Blues, I can't take any more of this man, The School of Science is no more. He had McFadden on the bench, Hibbert ready to come... Where was Drenthe, Barkley, Stracqualursi, Vellios???

Only empty seats will get this man out. Kenwright might love him but he loves money more. A half-empty ground and he will be gone.

I have seen Walter, Walker, Gordon Lee but I honestly think they tried to win although they were not good enough; this bloke tries to draw. He is killing EFC.

Eight of the all time worst Everton records and no one complains? Look at the other lot, they had forwards that attacked direct. We had players passing the ball until the sponsors name wore off.
Dan McKie
21 Posted 16/04/2012 at 16:34:53
Also Holloway had a wage cap of 5k a week imposed when Blackpool were in the Premier League, although they did extend it to 10k to get Charlie Adam to saty until the end of the season. He's still managed to convince players like Kevin Phillips and Barry Ferguson to play for them this year, and he is a massive reason why they are again looking a decent shout for the playoffs. Blackpool should have been out of sight relegated by christmas last year, but werent because of the way Holloway got them playing, and more importantly, get them believing. When was the last time we said that about Moyes?

P.s Blackpool are my second team, as I live there, hence why I talk them and their manager up. Wish I could do the same with Everton right now.
Jim Knightley
23 Posted 16/04/2012 at 16:38:09
Yeah, Let's sack the man who has taken a relegation squad on the brink of demotion to a top 8 club, on a low prem/upper champ transfer budget (under 2 million a year net). Oo yeah he is shit because we haven't won a trophy...but Spurs, City, United, Liverpool and Arsenal have... (let's ignore their spending) (although Wenger is a miracle worker).

Any of you whingers could an actual factual reason why Moyes should be sacked? apart from the pathetic ideals born of success in the 80's, and a belief that we should be fighting higher up the league, when in reality, we have the means of Bolton/Wigan or Blackburn?

And as for saying even Cardiff pushed Liverpool to the wire...how benign and stupid a reference to show ideas. Answer me this, who are the most successful cup team in England this season? Liverpool. Who knocked City and United out? Liverpool. There is a difference between Cup and League football, but that is easily forgotten when it wants to be.
Jim Knightley
24 Posted 16/04/2012 at 16:43:29
Billy, if Moyes is so tactically naive, then why do we consistently finish above where we should with regards to wages and transfer monies spent?

Looking forward to this one.

We must have fluked wins against Chelski, City and Spurs recently.
Jim Knightley
25 Posted 16/04/2012 at 16:45:44
One more thing...'good enough for Everton': this is the key problem. Fans need to realise Everton have the means of a lower Prem football club. We have the history of a top one, but history means nought.
Dan McKie
26 Posted 16/04/2012 at 16:48:26
Jim, did you watch the Spurs game? Yes, we did fluke it. We scored our 1 half chance against City, and we caught Chelsea in the worst form they have been in for years. Who spends more on wages that are below us? Liverpool are 1, but who else?
Nick Entwistle
27 Posted 16/04/2012 at 16:52:41
How is it possible to get Europe in 7th???
Nick Entwistle
28 Posted 16/04/2012 at 16:54:44
That's right Dan, Moyes' fault when we lose, someone elses when we win.
Tony J Williams
29 Posted 16/04/2012 at 16:52:46
You tell 'em Jim....crikey!
Mark Riding
30 Posted 16/04/2012 at 16:52:14
Jim #301.. whilst I admire your support, I do believe enough is now enough.
This season:
QPR - Goodison league game
Bolton - Goodison league game
Liverpool - Anfield league game
Sunderland - Goodison Cup game (after resting players)
Liverpool - Wembley - Biggest game in 15 years.
Bilyaletdinov.
Van De Meyde.
Fucking Drenthe.
Yakubu.
Yeah.. he is a genius in the low end of the transfer market..
Yep - you will throw Cahill etc back at me..
Lescott fiasco.
Rooney going for 'top dollar'

Christ, I wasnt even totally anti-Moyes.. but I have convinced myself....
Dan McKie
31 Posted 16/04/2012 at 16:56:51
Not at all, Nick, but it is Moyes's fault when we roll over with shithouse tactics like Saturday. From the moment we scored, that was it for attacking.
Dan McKie
32 Posted 16/04/2012 at 16:58:12
I'd bet none of the teams below us, bar Liverpool, who let's face it, will be above us after this weekend, when we are going and get our annual tummy tickling off Fergies boys, spend more than us on wages.
Peter Foy
33 Posted 16/04/2012 at 16:52:29
Jim, here's a reason.

The longer Moyes works his wanders at keeping us forever medium, he is inadvertantly keeping Kenwright at the club.

We really need to be in the shit before the fans will finally accept who the problem at Everton is.
Clive Lewis
34 Posted 16/04/2012 at 17:02:26
Re Nick (#306): If Chelsea win the Champions League and finish 5th, and if Spurs finished 4th they go into Europa League, suggesting Newcastle qualify for Europa League and that will open up to 7th for Europa League. Of course this is unlikely to happen but interesting reading all the same:

http://www.leazesterrace.com/the-complicated-road-to-europe/

Tony J Williams
35 Posted 16/04/2012 at 16:57:40
Usual story, lose because of him but win despite of him....fantastic logic
Michael Kenrick
36 Posted 16/04/2012 at 17:04:13
Whereas in your world, Tony, it's never the manager's fault when we lose: always the players' fault.
Barry Rathbone
37 Posted 16/04/2012 at 16:56:29
Thought when he and Kenwright were doing their matinee performance on SKY there were enough hints Moyes was ready to go.

Moyes endorsement of anyone getting the chance to work for bill - should!!

Bill doing his "Dave is the boss" routine adding "if he goes..."

Plus the mere fact they were on that show - it's like a job centre advertising board for managers putting themselves in the shop window.

After 10 years it ain't gonna change, time to go - simple as....
Michael Kenrick
38 Posted 16/04/2012 at 17:09:21
Oh, and Jim Knightley, I didn't see you responding to this counter-argument posted on a different thread:

From Football 365 today "While it should be acknowledged that Everton's team cost substantially less than Liverpool's, there is something of a fallacy about claims that the Toffees team was bought with pennies. Indeed, the total expense was near enough the same as the Newcastle team currently punching above their weight in fifth, with sizeable fees paid for Nikica Jelavic, Marouane Fellaini, John Heitinga, Phil Jagielka and Leighton Baines. There are many other clubs in the Premier League whose teams were cheaper to assemble than Everton's and yet would have been able to overcome Liverpool at Wembley."
Tony J Williams
39 Posted 16/04/2012 at 17:09:03
You must have missed my posts then Michael, as I have blamed them all.

I just refuse to blame one person, when the rest of them get away scot free.

Is your world any different to mine Michael?....oh I get it, I must be in some cloud cuckoo land because I don't agree with your view of Moyes...brilliant.
Wayne Smyth
40 Posted 16/04/2012 at 17:02:34
Mick Wrende (264) is right.

Moyes is doing a decent job with the resources he has, but I for one am fairly convinced that we'll never win anything with him in charge and he certainly appears to have hit a glass ceiling.

I've always been quite a risk taker in my day to day life and we also took a risk as a club bringing in an unproven manager to take over from Smith. Personally I'd get rid and try again. Might be better, might be worse, but I've no desire to watch a good team of players playing within themselves because the manager has no belief or confidence.

Also doesn't the following line worry anyone?

"The way he has managed us in the last month or two suggests to me that he is in it for the long-term."

what about the previous fucking 6 months?? Why do we have to wait until january every single season for him and his team to start playing to their potential? How about we start paying him from january too? That would save us about £1.5M per season.
Thomas Windsor
41 Posted 16/04/2012 at 16:56:28
I think it time for Moyes to go 10 years is a long time at one club in my time watching Everton only Harry Catterick has been here longer,

If he does decide to move on he has left us with a decent squard and maybe a new younger manager with fresh ideas could move us up to challenge more and not be afraid of the bigger teams which Moyes does 3 defeats against one of the worst Liverpool teams in years proves that.

We as Evertonians know the champions league is well out of reach until we have more money to spend on better players but to lay down and get spanked like that is not acceptable.
Nick Entwistle
42 Posted 16/04/2012 at 17:04:10
Clive, there are only 3 EL places. 1 to Liverpool, 1 for finishing 5th and possibly and probably to 6th with either Chelsea or Liverpool winning the cup.

The only way I see 7th is possible is if Liverpool finish 6th and we too overhaul one of the teams 10 points above us. That's not going to happen at all. Ol' Pip is talking crap.
Jim Knightley
43 Posted 16/04/2012 at 17:12:35
Michael...We have a net spend of under 2 million a year since Moyes took over. The only team who have been more successful than us with a comparable transfer record are Arsenal, and they have paid far higher wages. The facts are there in black and white. I think the last part of the comment, which you have strangely glorified through an ostensible reposting, the funniest:

There are many other clubs in the Premier League whose teams were cheaper to assemble than Everton's and yet would have been able to overcome Liverpool at Wembley.

The statement is firstly predicated on inane supposition. But apart from that, let me ask you a question: Who has beaten Liverpool in cup competition this season?

Last time I checked it was no one, including Manchester United and City.



Try again Michael.
Peter Thistle
44 Posted 16/04/2012 at 17:23:02
I'd be happy to see a new manager at the club but we don't exactly have the finances to attract a top quality replacement. Would the likes of Paul Lambert and Brendan Rodgers want to leave clubs with lower expectations to come here and be under pressure from the start ? I doubt many would want the job to be honest....
Tommy Coleman
45 Posted 16/04/2012 at 17:26:14
Jim Knightley - I guess you'd take 10 more years of the same then eh ? Funny, Liverpool supporters are saying just the same.
If money is everything explain Ath Bilboa outclassing Man Utd ?
Explain Apoel reaching the Champs League Quaters ?
You're saying it's all impossible without money, well history says otherwise.
I think you'd just rather look for little facts to back up your Moyes support rather than admit that Moyes just isn't good enough.
Mark Riding
46 Posted 16/04/2012 at 17:30:15
Jim #328
Arsenal higher wages ?

Arteta took a pay cut to go there....
John Crawley
47 Posted 16/04/2012 at 17:26:13
Just out of interest can anyone tell me someone who has managed a team for 10 years and not won a single trophy?
Kevin Tully
48 Posted 16/04/2012 at 17:26:34
Jim, after Fergie sold Ronaldo, Man U won the title with a negative net spend. The fact is, we had a £9m player on the bench for three seasons, we have two England defenders, a World Cup finalist, a £15m midfielder and spent over £11m on Yakubu. We have just purchased Jelavic for £7m.

So if you want to compare like for like, please stop quoting the likes of Swansea & Norwich, as in the same League as Everton. I can go into net spends all day - Moyes has had big money to spend on players, and he is on £3m a year. He is not a miracle worker.
Tommy Coleman
49 Posted 16/04/2012 at 17:41:51
John Crawley - David Moyes :)
Brian Waring
50 Posted 16/04/2012 at 17:40:33
Jamie (#261) The same arguement could be made when we have lads saying no one could do a better job than Moyes at the club with the funds available.

Jim Knightley
51 Posted 16/04/2012 at 17:34:46
Tommy, how are they little facts? every season we finish above where we should based on transfer budget and wages. These are not little facts, these are financial fundamentals. And I am not saying it is impossible without money; I am saying money dictates football. Who are the top two in Spain Tommy? Where are Bilboa there? Barca and Real are the top two because they spend so much more money than the rest. Why are City and United the top two? money. Those that follow, have all spent alot of money. Some buck the trend occasionally, but ultimately success is dictated by money. Some teams outside the top 4 have won cup competitions, but it has often come at a price. Where are Middlesborough, Pompey and Birmingham now?

Kevin, why the inane fact? are you attempting to be stupid? we are talking about extended periods, not one season.

And Mark...are you actually serious? you do know that Arsenal operate with wages completely out of sync with ours dont you? As way of an example, after a quick search:

In 2007/8 - Arsenal paid out 101 million and finished 3rd. We paid out 44 million and finished 5th. Arsenal's wages will almost be 75%-100% higher than ours.

And Tommy, taking the word of Liverpool supporters, great argument. Wouldnt we take 10 more years of Dalglish? Wouldnt Liverpool Kill for a manager who could get value for money? they have poured money down the toilet with little to no improvement, and in recent times, regression.
John Crawley
52 Posted 16/04/2012 at 17:48:33
Tommy I walked into that one! Meant to say other than David Moyes
Dan McKie
53 Posted 16/04/2012 at 17:47:01
Jim, if Dalglish keeps delivering trophies and cup finals for Liverpool, then no, I doubt many Everton supporters will want him there.
Mark Riding
54 Posted 16/04/2012 at 17:46:34
Jim , I am being serious about you saying Arsenal pay higher wages than us. You are quoting 2007 figures. The Emirates is whats keeping their wages down ( for now ) once the stadium is paid for they will be on a different level completely. Our Kings Dock if you like...
Jim Knightley
55 Posted 16/04/2012 at 17:56:39
Change almost for always.

I think you all need to realise something; this club is not the club it was. We are not the team of the 80s. We have the means of a lower prem team. You can say we spent money on some players, but so do our rivals. Stoke wasted 10million on an ageing crouch, Sunderland made a silly amount for some of their players in recent times, Villa paid over 20million for Bent etc etc etc. But these figures are irrelevant, because they are singular examples. The important facts reside in the net and gross spends, and the wages paid, and we consistently punch above our weight for money spent.

Now someone please give me an example of someone in the Premierleague who have consistently achieved success with our financial capacity. Because from where I sit, the most successful teams in the league in the last 10 years: United, Arsenal (although no lately, because of money), Chelski, Spurs and Liverpool (kind of) are the only teams to have done so, and they have all spent alot of money. In the last 10 years of the FA Cup, only Pompey have won outside the top four. They did by spending beyond the means and have been subsequently relegated. In the last 10 years of the Carling cup, only Blackburn, Middlesborough and Birmingham have won it outside the top teams. We don't need to talk about their situations.

So why should we, a team with lower to mid-table means, be doing so much better? someone please tell me.
Mike Oxlong
56 Posted 16/04/2012 at 17:51:42
Some of the "average team" comments here are truly laughable....it seems a lot of Evertonians have the same mentally as the club.
We now have a team with one of the best back fives in the premiership, a goalscorer of genuine quality and two or three midfielders the envy of most clubs in the premiership. When on form this team can blow any team in the league away.....and that's the problem.
Moyes has shown time and time again that when it really matters he completely disregards the football we have previously played successfully (i.e. Sunderland) and goes all negative...that second half on Saturday was as bad a surrender as I have seen in thirty years of supporting Everton.

This team, with a brave bold manager could be challenging for top 4 I am convinced of that. Part of me hopes Moyes throws caution to the wind and goes for it himself though more realistically I think its time to says thanks and move on.
Kevin Tully
57 Posted 16/04/2012 at 17:46:06
O.k Jim, explain why Man U have the fifth highest net spend OVER THE LAST TEN YEARS and Arsenal have the ninth highest net spend OVER THE LAST TEN YEARS why we should judge Moyes on his net spend figures - because it fits your defence of the clueless one ?

What a tit.
John Crawley
58 Posted 16/04/2012 at 17:56:00
Did a bit of checking myself to see if there were any managers who had been in the job for 10 years without winning a trophy. Could not find any current managers (other than Moyes) who had been manager for 10 years without winning a trophy. The only one that I can think of within the last 40 years is Dario Gradi who didn't win a trophy but he did win promotion several times.
Tommy Coleman
59 Posted 16/04/2012 at 17:49:03
OK Jim - Barcelona is a very bad example, the 11 players that won the Champs League a few ago cost less than Everton's. They are the best team in the World but cost less than Man Cty / Real Madrid etc. Bilboa cost far less than Everton's or Man Utd' teams but still outclassed Man Utd at Old Trafford, something we have never done.

You say "some buck the trend occansionally, but ultimately success is dictated by money" and I agree with you here, I don't think anybody can deny this but the problem I have and I think the problem others are arguing is that Moyes has never bucked the trend as he's never won a trophy.
Is 4th, a FA Final, and a semi over 10 years with a club like Everton really bucking the trend ? I don't think it is at all.
Tommy Coleman
60 Posted 16/04/2012 at 18:02:27
Jim - As for the Liverpool argument, I'm with Dan McKie. I'd rather have a wasteful manager who wins trophies than a resourceful manager that doesn't.
Jim Knightley
61 Posted 16/04/2012 at 17:57:26
Mark, I am aware of Arsenal's financial situation. They are the best run club in this country and will dominate the British game in 10 years for some time. However, your comments concerning their wages are misplaced. They spend less than Chelksi, City and United, but millions and millions more than us. Please present me with some figures to argue otherwise? You wont be able to, because they don't exist.

Check this out btw

- Arsenal's 110million...ours? 54million.
Dan Brierley
62 Posted 16/04/2012 at 17:54:00
Mark Riding, you are talking rubbish:

http://abehnisch.com/arsenal-wage-bill-history/
Dan McKie
63 Posted 16/04/2012 at 17:57:38
Jim, we should be playing better, braver football. That would be enough for most fans, the knowledge that we go into every game for the win. Over the last few weeks we have managed that. I remember watching the Norwich game and we only came away with a draw, but we attacked, we went out to get goals and you could tell we were after the 3 points. To me, it happens too often where it doesnt look that way. We have had 3 full games of football this season where we haven't managed a single shot on goal. Is that good enough to you? You keep saying we are punching above our weight on wages, I dont think we are, look at the teams below us and try and think of how many of thier players will be on 50, 60, even 70k a week like some Everton players are. I think we are probably in a fair league position, but cant stand to see us capitulate so often. Once we scored on saturday, that was it, we stopped attacking and tried to hold on to 1 goal, with over an hour left to play, and once they equalised, there was only ever going to be 1 winner, because by then we had fully reverted to defense only and it is a very hard mindset to change during a game. That is where Moyes fails. I would rather him send the team out at Old Trafford next week to fully go at them, and yeah, we would probably get caught at the back and lose, but who knows, we might go and score 2 or 3, which is something we wont do if we approach the game like every year and limp to a 2-0 defeat that was never in doubt from the kickoff.
John Crawley
64 Posted 16/04/2012 at 18:05:33
Tommy 354 couldn't agree more and I think that is the point. 10 years is one hell of a long time, I think it is reasonable to expect to have won a cup in that time.
If some people still don't think Moyes should go I think they need to say exactly how long are they prepared to give him without winning a trophy?
Mark Stone
65 Posted 16/04/2012 at 18:06:16
Mark Riding, Arsenal pay much higher wages than us.

Tommy, to have a wasteful manager you need to have the resources to be wasted. No matter what you think of Andy Carroll, Jordan Henderson, and Stewart Downing they represent ~ £75m worth of spending. Incidentally I think all three of them are very good players and I know a hell of a lot about two of them. That is not even including players like Charlie Adam. If David Moyes was given £75m that kind of money in one transfer window, I would very much expect him to win something. £15m over ten years and I'm less critical.
Mark Riding
66 Posted 16/04/2012 at 18:06:27
Tommy #354, you mention Barcelona, well in 2008 I had the unfortunate pleasure of being in hospital in Spain for a good while..
Guardiola lost the first game of the season, I watched it on tv, the press were calling for his head immediately. He then drew his second game at home, Messi scored a pen if I remember correctly, but the knives were then well and truly out.
Barca then had a 'fuck it' mentality.. thats when they started to have no fear and just played football.
They started to batter teams, it was fantastic to see the confidence grow.. and as they say, the rest is history..

My point being... If we had the 'fuck it' attitude and just went for it on Saturday.. we would all be looking forward to a Final. Liverpool would not have know what to do if we attacked them in the second half.
Pep went for it.. Davie hopes for it..
Jim Knightley
67 Posted 16/04/2012 at 18:07:10
Tommy, we cannot have a wasteful manager that wins trophies, because we dont have money to waste. Tell me please, who has won a trophy recently and survived as a club outside the elite teams? and I do not measure success on only trophies, I consider it based on league performance. For me, a manager who takes a relegation squad and transforms them with a minimal net spend into a top 8 club, good enough according to some on here to push for the top 4, is a successful manager.

Kevin, you twit, what is your point? We have the 14th. The top 5 net spends are: Chelsea, City, Liverpool, Spurs and United...Arsenal aside, as I have already referred to(who have not won a trophy since 05), the top 5 spenders and the top 5 most successful in this league. Below those 5 you mention come Villa, Bolton, Stoke, Sunderland, Wolves, Fulham, QPR, West Brom and then us. Which of those have out performed us?

Kevin Sparke
68 Posted 16/04/2012 at 17:59:36
Net spend is a bollocks statistical argument...

If a person sells a house for £1 Million then buys one for a million and a penny they have a net spend of - 1p

If another person sells a house for £50 and buys one for £500 they have a net spend of £450.

But the first person with the smaller net spend is still living in luxury and the other person who is spending 'big money' is living on Pluckington Park estate... (I can say that as I lived there once).

As a matter of interest - when was the last time Everton bought a £35 million player?... or a £20 million player.... or even a £15 million player?
Matt Traynor
69 Posted 16/04/2012 at 18:11:28
Okay, as I've already said, Moyes is 12th highest paid manager in the world. I've now found a link to it.

So, with that nugget of info, those who say who could we attract, would you care to suggest why we couldn't attract someone of the required calibre/experience?

Also, those banging out this £2m net argument, it's sobering to bear in mind that much of the income was due to two forced sales - Rooney (£27m) and Lescott (£24m). I agree with those who say the Chairman is the real problem, but try to think laterally for a second - why if we are so skint do we pay a manager the 12th highest salary in world football? Because his achievements (coupled with the dumbing down of expectations) keep the Chairman where he sits until he can figure out a way of conning someone into paying upwards of £150m club for a financial basket case.
John Crawley
70 Posted 16/04/2012 at 18:14:30
Yeah Barcelona the other day played 1-2-3-4. Can you imagine Moyes playing like that even if he had the same players - no chance.
Kevin Tully
71 Posted 16/04/2012 at 18:14:56
Nice shot in the foot there Jim, you posted a link where we are 8th in the wage league, now, guess where our average finish is under Moyes ?

Great manager my arse.
Mark Riding
72 Posted 16/04/2012 at 18:13:44
Mark#361, Dan#358..
I just had the fact that Arteta said he took a pay cut to join Arsenal in my head.. I dont confess to researching my knowledge of Arsenal salaries.
I trust you are more clued up on this than me.
Kevin Sparke
73 Posted 16/04/2012 at 18:15:48
That should be Pluckington 'Farm' BTW
John Crossley
74 Posted 16/04/2012 at 18:17:30
Moyes so negative when it comes to the big game, The Shite have beaten us so many times since his reign he has'nt a clue
Kevin Tully
75 Posted 16/04/2012 at 18:17:19
So you are disregarding Arsenal winning the League with the 9th highest net spend Jim ? Ditto Man Utd.

You cannot point to figures and cherry pick which ones you want to quote to suit your argument Jim, glad you are not my bank manager.

Dan McKie
76 Posted 16/04/2012 at 18:18:31
Jim, is 55k a week on Tim Cahill, who has been inneffective for the last 2 years at least, not being wasteful? One of my biggest gripes with Moyes is that he doesnt know when to let go. When there was talk of Arsenal coming in for Jags a couple of years back for a fee reported to be around £15 million, we should have sold, and got 2 or 3 players in with the money (if he is so good in the transfer market, this would be no problem), however, Moyes would see this as a weakness, so digs his heels in and gets Jags a massive payrise on a longer contract until he is worth jack shit in the market. Our players are getting older, and they will need replacing. Moyes doesnt know how to work the market, and on £3 million a year, he should do.
Henry Weindling
77 Posted 16/04/2012 at 18:26:38
Dan @ 376 - I understand your logic, but I don't agree. If we sell Jags when he is at his peak for £10-15m, then we are seen as a selling club who lack ambition, and merely a feeder for the so called big 4. If we don't sell him, and give him a massive contract, it is seen as bad business from the club. In reality we should applaud the club and manager for showing big ambition.

Would you apply the same logic to Leighton Baines if Arsenal bid £10m this summer, or the same with Jelavic/Felliani/Heitinga? I don't think so, as these are key players to the future of Everton. We need to keep hold of our best players if we are to get anywhere surely.
Paul Holden
78 Posted 16/04/2012 at 18:34:54
Moyes will be off this summer. What's the odds on Neville and Stubbsy taking over? I reckon they'd do a good job!
Tom Bowers
79 Posted 16/04/2012 at 18:30:59
Moyes won't quit , Kenwright won't sell. These 2 statements alone tell you that next season will be more of the same. Only season ticket sales will change things and as long as the same number of people keep buying them then Kenwright will hardly raise a sweat to change anything. He is after all a businessman and he is happy as long as he is not losing money.
Mark Riding
80 Posted 16/04/2012 at 18:31:57
As Im already talking rubbish, apparantly.. why not fantasy football ? A well run Everton could have had the following available on saturday ( all recent/current players)
Howard
Neville
Lescott
Heitinga
Baines
Pienaar
Donavon
Arteta
Fellani
Rooney
Jelavic
And we would be top of the league, playing in the Kings Dock, and we could all go and watch U2 play a gig at our ground in the summer..
Thanks Bill..
Paul Holmes
81 Posted 16/04/2012 at 18:37:54
Let all these people who back Moyes after the two derby-game fuck-ups go to the games next season while the rest of us wait for CHANGE before we spend our hard-earned money on that £60,000 a week useless twat!

There will be plenty of seats to sit on if you're not happy with the view!
Paul David
82 Posted 16/04/2012 at 18:38:56
Jim Knightley,
let's forget about transfer spend and wages for a minute and look at it in terms of ability.

For the last few seasons we have finished exactly were I expected us to, the teams with better players above us, the teams with lesser players below us.

From that point of view I don't believe Moyes has worked miracles,neither has he under-achieved.

What I would like to ask you is are you happy with the way he has achieved this?

I for one I'm sick to death of the horrible, negative way he has his teams playing.Yes, it's a results business but also an entertainment business and that's were he fails miserably.
Andy Crooks
83 Posted 16/04/2012 at 18:40:37
Jim, I admire your defence of your point of view and I believe you make some pertinent points. However, whatever our net spend I believe,and give him full credit for it, that Moyes has assembled a good squad on a shoestring. He just doesn't get those good players to turn up when it really matters.

Can you not see that Moyes does well to take us to a certain point and then just doesn't have what it takes. In my view we have few options:

Kenwright isn't going so our option is to make the best of what we have got. Moyes will keep us safe and I can see the merit in supporting that. To me ,though, it seems that a better option is to take a chance and go for someone who will freshen things up and revitalise the attitude of players and supporters.

You disagree, fair enough, but we must move on and i believe that we must do it without David Moyes.

Dan McKie
84 Posted 16/04/2012 at 18:47:45
Henry, there are certain players we could have got cash for that could be scarificed with no immidiate detriment to the squad. In my opinion at that time, Jags was one of them. Baines for £10mil, never, but if anyone came in with double that, then id say as much as id hate to see him go, that money could be used elsewhere, get a new left back, and one or two other players as well. So we never sell a player through fear of looking like a selling club? Even though it may be better in the long term.

The key to our future are the players in the early 20's, or even younger, the Fellaini's, the Barkleys. We basically cant afford to let too many more players hit 30 on big money in the near future, so yes, I do include the likes of Baines, Heitinga. We need a strategy, we are in the shit. Who do we buy when Neville and Distin call it a day? And with what? A couple of years after that it will be Cahill, Jags, Heitinga, Baines all reaching 30+, where and how do we replace these? It ain't like we are winning anything with these players neither.

I believe that the next player to go will be Fellaini, in 2 years he will be at a top club, and with the money we make, we will probably give Baines an 80k a week 5 year contract. Thats how Everton seem to work under Moyes, sell the young to keep the old happy.
Edward Robinson
85 Posted 16/04/2012 at 19:12:47
I would rather the team had gone down like Spurs - at least they "had a go". We just sat back and let them walk all over us! with the only vestige of an attack the long ie 50 -50 ball.There was no attempt to have a real go like we did at Sunderland. Absolutely gutted!
Paul Andrews
86 Posted 16/04/2012 at 19:16:54
To the posters quoting the lack of money argument.

It doesn't make any difference how much money a manager has to spend when you have a manager with a distinct lack of bottle in attempting to win a match.

This man's philosophy of football tactics is to defend what we start with, nick a goal, and drop deeper every time we happen to get that goal,; 10 men behind the ball.

We can't win semi-finals or finals with this man in charge.
Henry Weindling
87 Posted 16/04/2012 at 19:05:35
Dan, based on your attitude, yes the long term future of the club would be secure, but our ambitions would be similar to the of Fulham, Sunderland etc. Admittedly we are not achieving a great deal at the moment, but the club has to aim high, which is the one thing I feel they are doing right.

You are basically saying that each time a player has a very good season and starts to get noticed, we should sell them. I believe the club are of the opinion that if a player has a very good season, we tie them to the club so they can go on to have another few hopefully great seasons, which is completely correct in my view. Admittedly it?s always a gamble, but at least it shows ambition. It?s a very different level of player but look at Arsenal for example. Cesc Fabregas has the season of his life, Barca bid £50m, which Arsenal reject as they want to keep hold of their prize asset. The following season he is injury hit and half the player he was. Arsenal then do decide to sell him but for only £30m. No doubt the same saga will ensure with Robin Van Persie this summer. You could use the same argument with Moyes ? at the time he was the right man for the job, and we tied him down and convinced him Everton was the place to be. Maybe that was wrong, but that?s a whole other argument. At least the ambition was there.

My point is that Arsenal didn?t sell Fabregas because they believed he was a crucial player to lead the club to potential Premier/Champions league glory. Now we could easily sell Baines and Felliani for £12 and £18m respectively (which I believe is the absolute maximum we would get for these players), but then again these might, just might be the players to lead us to 4th place, FA Cup/League Cup glory over the next few seasons.
Thomas Keating
88 Posted 16/04/2012 at 18:59:40
The amount of calls for Moyes's head and claims we would not miss him on this link are ridiculous! Many Everton 'fans' will do well to remember the kind of season we were looking at at the end of the 0-2 stuffing at Goodison this year and compare it to what we have achieved since.

Our problem still lies at the beginning of every season, the inevitable snail start we've come to expect means we can no longer aim for Europe. But to turn around after another strong cup run and show Moyes the door would be foolish.

We have establshed one of, if not, the best defences in the league, a fighting and improving midfield, and now at long last an awkward looking striker who knows where the goal is. We are a team on the up, looking for an invester.

My gut instinct, however, is that this lack of funding will mean Moysey leaves sooner rather than later. Most likely when one of the big clubs decide to take a chance on him and see if he really is a ginger jock or just a mid table nobhead.

If the fans continue to focus on getting the best man for the job axed from our club then it will be the biggest mistake since Alex Nyarko. Pressure the board for investment instead and dont push my main man moysie before he jumps!
Kunal Desai
89 Posted 16/04/2012 at 19:11:11
In 10 years how many times has Moyes made master substitutions and changed tactics to turn around a losing side?
Dan McKie
90 Posted 16/04/2012 at 19:27:05
Henry, I didnt say sell Fellaini, he is one player who I do believe we can build around, but he will force his way out, they must have spun him some bollocks to make him think it was worth signing a new deal with us. The problem is the older players and hanging on to them. Look at Cahill, in his 30's, not played well for a couple of years, but is on a big fat contract and will continue to keep the likes of Barkley out of the side. We have to look to the future, what is the alternative? Keep Baines, Jags, Heitinga etc. forever? We aren't Chelsea, when Lampard claps out, they will go and get a Luca Modric, but us? What do we do?
Jim Knightley
91 Posted 16/04/2012 at 19:30:39
Kevin, I'm not explaining anything else to you, as you seem incapable of digesting information. I've shown, purely and simply, that the top 5 net spending teams over the past 10 years have been the most successful. The only team to have bucked the trend consistently is Arsenal, and their gross spend and wages completely outstrip ours.

They also haven't won a league title in a long time, and a cup since 2005, and maybe fans want Wenger to leave. I disagree with this sentiment, as you might extrapolate from my generally pro-Moyes view, and I think Wenger is one of the greatest managers in the history of the British game. He though, like us, has suffered from an incapacity to match the spending of his rivals.

Andy I take your points, and unlike too many of them on here, they are well reasoned. My issue is that the risk is not worth the reward imo. Moyes has made some mistakes in the big games, and yesterday we should not have gone so deep as we did. But I think his mistakes, and the teams, are partly the result of money.

We don't have alot of big game experience (although we have some) because we haven?t been able to fund consistent success and procure the kind of players FA cup winners and top 4 teams have. I think the mindset of the team can only change with funded success and patient. I think that, despite Moyes's salary, we will not beable to attract a manager that can improve us.

We have poor prospects, no money and ownership issues; being able to pay £3 million is irrelevant. We will be able to attract managers with experience similar to Moyes, who I believe are far more likely to cause our regression. If we had a £20-30million transfer budget, I believe we could attract a manager to effect positive change (although I also believe Moyes would bring the success we wanted with such money, and if he didn?t, then a change would be necessitated).

I would love, as much as anyone, for a manager to come in and prove me wrong. But the finances suggest that Moyes has overachieved, and Wenger aside, I have not seen a Premier League manager in recent history consistently do it in the league as well as Moyes has with limited means.
Dan McKie
92 Posted 16/04/2012 at 19:50:54
"Moyes has made some mistakes in the big games, and yesterday we should not have gone so deep as we did. But I think his mistakes, and the teams, are partly the result of money" What, Jim?

So we were 1 nil up against a team who have been awful, but the reason we then sat back and defended is because we have no money? I can just imagine Gibson thinking 'I could play this to Jellys feet to run on and have a pop, but we're skint, so i'll just hoof it aimlessley instead'
John Crawley
93 Posted 16/04/2012 at 19:53:33
Jim if Moyes kept achieving top half finishes in the league and the club remains in the same financial situation would you ever get rid of him?

Mark Riding
94 Posted 16/04/2012 at 19:58:00
Dan, are they scared of making a mistake ? ( Barkley QPR - Hardly seen since ) scared of looking for the forward pass ? ( Distin's mistake )
John Nugent
96 Posted 16/04/2012 at 20:04:35
Kevin-
Plucky farm estate (my birthplace)
The jewel of the north!
Howard Don
97 Posted 16/04/2012 at 19:54:11
Jim Knightly (412) spot on. I despair of the whingers and knee jerk experts, none of them ever say exactly what their alternative to Moyes' over achieving tenure would be. There is no money, the guy has worked miracles on what he's had and that is his major problem. By taking us from the depths we were at when he arrived to being on the fringe of the top clubs, with a fraction of their resources he has created unrealistic expectations. The spoilt whingers now berate him constantly for not achieving the near impossible of winning major trophies in the face of totally unequal odds.

Of course he doesn't get everything right - guess what, no manager ever does - but the job he has done over the last ten years, with next to no resources, has been nothing short of phenomenal.

I really hope he stays, and his great loyalty to the club suggests he might, but I wouldn't blame him for leaving to be honest. However if and when he does and the almost inevitable decline sets in (assuming no major investment), I'll be around to say "I told you so" to the whingers. Not that I would expect them to accept they were wrong of course - no doubt there will be some knee jerk, cliche ridden theories as to why it was all Moyes fault even after he's gone.

Dan McKie
98 Posted 16/04/2012 at 20:16:29
Mark, if they still have fear when going onto a football pitch, then they either need dropping, or the manager needs sacking for putting that fear into them. Also, would it really be scary? Ross Barkley has been playing pressure free under 18 games and swanning off to the USA since the QPR game, all whilst picking up 20k a week. Frightening times for the boy!
Phil Roberts
99 Posted 16/04/2012 at 20:12:43
Not seen the highlights, too depressed, only seen the goals.

But all the complaints on here is Moyes not going for it and therefore he should go.

But if Distin had not screwed up the back pass and we would therefore have got to the last 5 minutes 1-0 up. Bit more holding on to what we have and scraped through 1-0 then Moyes was a hero. Remember, we were battered by United, got lucky with a pen and then won on penalties last time. Then he was a hero for getting us to Wembley.
Dan McKie
100 Posted 16/04/2012 at 20:19:54
Howard, I have felt the way I do about Moyes for a few years, it's hardly knee jerk. Also, how is your claim of an inevitable decline any better than those that claim somebody could do better? Moyes is not a miracle worker, he is a very well paid football manager whose cowardly approach to certain games has grated on fans for years.
Mark Riding
101 Posted 16/04/2012 at 20:24:43
Dan, Ross had the swagger that Rooney had.. a swagger only a scally has.. Im sure its been taken out of him by now though...
Paul Johnson
102 Posted 16/04/2012 at 20:18:30
Howard you are a sad excuse of an Evertonian. You are happy towallow in mid table mediocrity for the rest of you life but I will tell you know we will not improve under Moyes from were we are now. You openly admit he is doing the best he can.

So what are the options. Rafa Benitez is out of work. Sorry he has won a trophies consistently were ever he has gone... So who else, to be honest I don't give a flying as long as we go out to win games.

Sorry that doesn't turn you on but I can just imagine you putting your feet up after another dismal Saturday and getting all excited when strictly ball room comes on.

I am fed up of people defending mediocrity because they are frightened of change.
Mark Riding
103 Posted 16/04/2012 at 20:29:25
Wigan are actually having a go at the highly paid Arsenal boys... Probably end up getting beat.. but having a go !!
Dan McKie
104 Posted 16/04/2012 at 20:36:37
Can you Imagine Everton going to old Trafford on Sunday and being 2 up after 8 minutes? Nah, me neither.
Howard Don
105 Posted 16/04/2012 at 20:32:45
Paul 438. You shoot yourself in the foot. If childish abuse is the best counter you can come up with, rather than reasoned argument, then keep it to yourself> I am NOT a sad excuse of an Evertonian, I had my first season ticket at 12 years old for the 1962/63 Championship year, since then I've supported this club through thick and then, glory and despair. How dare you abuse me for having an opinion, you are just so typical of many of the knockers, so full of anger you can't see the big picture, you witter on about change, but you never ever come up with anything coherent to say on what would improve the situation. Oh and no, I don't watch strictly whatever it is, or any of the other reality crap you seem so well informed about.
Dean Adams
106 Posted 16/04/2012 at 20:46:41
Why do so many of our fans fear a change of manager? Simple, they do not believe that anyone can do better than Moyes. That is, for me the legacy that BK is leaving us with. Fear, afraid to go out and play, just incase we lose a few. They have no faith in anyone else.
Gavin Ramejkis
107 Posted 16/04/2012 at 20:46:26
Phil #431 you must have watched pretty short highlights, we were played off the park for the majority of the second half and but for the RS having Mr Ed up front doing his best Steven Seagall impersonation missing absolute sitters we would have been behind well before Klux Klux Swearez scored. we were holding on for dear life up to the last five mins and the only thing misery had on the bench to offer was Anichebe who managed one of his trade mark tantrums in the box towards the end of the game and fuck all else.
Paul Johnson
108 Posted 16/04/2012 at 20:44:51
So tell me Howard if you are such a lifelong staunch blue. Why do you have this acceptance that this is the best we are going to get.

Fact 1, we are wallowing in mid table mediocrity and you don't want change.

Fact 2, we have never won a trophy under Moyes.

How have I shot myself in the foot. In my opinion Howard there are a number of sad excuses on this site, just as I have no doubt people think I am a total arsehole.

One thing you cannot escape from though Howard are the 2 facts stated above. Or do you dispute them.
Paul Johnson
109 Posted 16/04/2012 at 20:53:08
And Howard in my opinion you have got one thing right. I am angry..... In fact I am raging.
Danny James
110 Posted 16/04/2012 at 20:37:43
We are a mediocre club. There are 5 or 6 big clubs and then there is the rest. We are one of the rest. Moyes has constantly made us finish as best of the rest

What do you people expect could happen with another manager? 9 titles means fuck all in the here and now

Its stupid to hear people saying we should be achieving more than we are. Moyes is getting as much out of a club like Everton that can be got out of it.

Take at look at Villa., a club similar in size,stature and history. Look at where O'neill took them in the league and look at where Mcleish has taken them. That is the difference between what having a good manager and a shit manager does to a club our size

People who dont see finishing 7th or 8th in the league every season as a good achievement are living in a fantasy world . Understanding this is not accepting mediocrity, its being realistic and understanding where we sit as a premier league club in this current climate
Jack Molloy
111 Posted 16/04/2012 at 20:55:41
I'd be reinvigorated if Moyes left and so would the team. First, he will never prove he is a top flight manager because he is NOT a top flight manager. The reason why we were beaten Saturday is because Liverpool took the field in the second half determined to win and we took the field terrified of losing. You don't have to look further than the substitutions to see the difference. Two attacking creative goal-bound players came on for Liverpool. Moyes was busy placing more defenders on the field. If I was Kenwright I'd be asking Nik Jelavic for Slaven Bilic's mobile. If it's really true that Drenthe wasn't included because he was late for the team bus then Moyes should say so. Drenthe for Gueye could have made the difference and for him not to be allowed to play for some trivial infraction is a disgrace. What would Moyes do if he was handling the likes of Balotelli or Tevez or Rooney? Top flight manager? Bollocks!
Tim Locke
112 Posted 16/04/2012 at 20:06:42
It is nice to see that some things never change. Find an article about Moyes and him leaving and you be sure to find a load of Toffeeweb supporters who consider themselves more through though than any football pundit, player or manager.

Like or not getting rid of Moye is like changing your wet sock when you have a hole in your shoe. Moyes is not the problem. When Andy Callan 253 - points out the main problem and the mistake in the cunning plan, we have no money, people think life will still be better with someone else in charge.

Mick Wrende 268 gives us two options, and David Stewart 270 - states you don't need money to win a cup. Mick's two options: the first one unprovable, we have to wait 10 years. The second, not well considered at all. If he could name one up-and-coming manager who is currently above us in the league or has gone further in the FA Cup this year, then I would be interested.

With the excpetion of one team, ALL the teams who won the FA Cup since we won in 95 have had money, the exception: Portsmouth. Well, I don't think they are an example we should be following.

Well maybe you will make you point with the league cup, a lesser competition so maybe. Last ten years, all big spenders but a few more exceptions: Birmingham City, Middlesbrough and Blackburn Rovers, I would hardly be holding any of those teams up as ones we would want to follow either.

Then add in we have never won the League Cup and only been in the final twice, during the time it has been running, we have had some quality sides, I think we can forget about winning the League Cup.

If you really think the solution lies with a new manager, then you look carefully at our history and the great Mike Walker at Norwich: finished 3rd in the Perm, his one great season, and then it all went wrong.

Moyes has brought stability to the club, the last manager to win something with Everton hardly cover himself in glory the following season finishing with 42 points, 2 points of relegation. We have a side under Moyes which is consistent in finishing and slowly becoming better and I have great confidence we will win something soon.

Finally thank you to Kevin Sparke 366 - what a great post, if I exchange something worth 1p more my net spend is 1p. Brilliant. I would only ask where did that first million come from? Net expenditure is what matters because that is what has to be financed by the club. Less net spend equals less need to find money.

All the big clubs in the Prem have spent money, ie, had large net expenditure. They might not have large net expenditure each year, like Tottenham for example this year, but they have in the past spent a lot. We don't have the money to spend, so change the manager will make little difference, in fact I would argue would probably only do harm.
Paul Smith
113 Posted 16/04/2012 at 20:50:05
When the pain of staying the same is worse than the possibility of the unknown and change, then change might happen . The question must be have we had enough pain yet ?
Tommy Gibbons
114 Posted 16/04/2012 at 21:01:16
We weren't outplayed because they haven't the players to outplay us, we were outhought by a better tactics set by a better manager and a better captain who know how to motivate their team on the pitch...

Moyes is finished and if he had any feeling for the club (which isn't hard at £3m a year)!! he'd resign now or at least at the end of the season..the taxi for Moyes is long overdue!
Mike Oxlong
115 Posted 16/04/2012 at 21:06:11
Wigan (a team far inferior to Everton) and with the threat of relegation hovering over them are away from home to Arsenal (a team far superior to Liverpool) and having a real go....so much so they are 2-1 up.

Does anyone here seriously have confidence that Moyes would ever do this??

As for the alternatives someone is bleating on about. Given the wage we pay to Moyes I would suggest more managers would be interested than we give credit for...so; Martinez, Jol, Rodgers, Lambert, Pearce as well as foreign options. Personally I like Martinez's brand of football and Jol's ability to set up a team with attacking options.
Mike Oxlong
116 Posted 16/04/2012 at 21:13:17
That said ^^^^^^^

I would still prefer Moyes to have a brainwave and decide to set Everton up to attack teams - I just don't think that's ever gonna happen.
Danny James
117 Posted 16/04/2012 at 21:14:11
Perhaps we should take a leaf out of Wigans book and be hovering around the relegation zones every season. Wigan are having a go because they are in a desperate situation. What have they been doing for the previous 28 games?
Ian Bennett
118 Posted 16/04/2012 at 21:08:40
Sick of everton choking when it matters. Villarreal, Chelsea, Saturday. When the pressure is on against quality teams we fold and this is nothing new.

We lack belief and perhaps explains the poor starts at the start of nearly every season and strong finishes when we have nothing to play for. We have some decent players but too many that go missing when it really really matters.

Pistone got sent a heart one Christmas and I think after this the butcher could be busy again. Blame the manager, blame the players.
Ian Bennett
119 Posted 16/04/2012 at 21:08:40
Sick of everton choking when it matters. Villarreal, Chelsea, Saturday. When the pressure is on against quality teams we fold and this is nothing new.

We lack belief and perhaps explains the poor starts at the start of nearly every season and strong finishes when we have nothing to play for. We have some decent players but too many that go missing when it really really matters.

Pistone got sent a heart one Christmas and I think after this the butcher could be busy again. Blame the manager, blame the players.
Tim Locke
120 Posted 16/04/2012 at 21:16:40
Mike hardly a classic example. Wigan week in week out lose more games and without some amazing keeping this evening would be 3-2 down. I don't think you can take a model of one team and say this would have won us Saturday, we made mistakes, played poorly, end of. Take a good look at Tot, same players, and they can't buy a win, Ars a couple of months back same thing, clubs seem to go through phases, are seems to be after a break, and the longer the break the longer we play poorly for.
James Stewart
121 Posted 16/04/2012 at 21:12:15
Slight arrogance there Jim. I couldn't give a shit what Moyes's net spend is. I simply find the man intolerable. His failings and defensive to the extreme style have been done to death on here so I can't be bothered to list them again. I don't like his ethos or his whole footballing philosophy.

And here is my KEY Point. Even at "his" best I do not enjoy watching us play. That includes the 4th place finish. The recent wins over City, Spurs etc We were still shite to watch during all of these and yes we beat spurs etc but we could quite easily have lost by 4! I do not like Moyes and no matter how long anyone bangs on about finances or points per pound will not change that.
Kevin Tully
122 Posted 16/04/2012 at 21:21:33
To all posters who insist Moyes is a " miracle worker " who constantly " punches above his weight " and is doing a " phenominal " job.

Answer this.

There are possibly 4 major managerial posts available shortly. The Spurs job, Chelsea, England and Man U when Fergie retires.

Surely Moyes will be offered one of these posts if he is as good as you lot say he is ?
Peter Foy
123 Posted 16/04/2012 at 21:23:10
I would like to see Moyes leave.

Then I would like to see us finishing 17th until Kenwright is forced from the club.

This is the only way we will ever progress. As much as I hate to say it.
Kevin Sparke
124 Posted 16/04/2012 at 21:27:11
Yes but Tim - if you've a club with £300 million pound total cash turnover re players over 2 years with a net spend of £5 million per year - and you've a club with £30 million worth of total turn over in two years with a £6 million net spend per year... which club is likely to have the better players on sale and the ability to buy better replacements?

Sure - money doesn't mean everything; I mean look at Manchester City... they were totally shit 5 years ago and they're still... oh, hang on... they've players of the calibre of Aguero, Silva, Tevez, Kompany etc... and they're currently second in the league - but money means nothing - they're where they are because of that Shakespeare of managerial excellence Mancini... the best players money can buy mean nothing, absolutely nothing.

BTW - I'm not using this paucity of resources as an excuse for Saturday as despite Liverpool being able to waste over a £100 million on the shite they bought last year, we had by far the better form going into that debacle...

Bottlers - both on the bench with red hair and on the pitch...
Tim Locke
125 Posted 16/04/2012 at 21:40:04
James Stewart 465 - Great post. I have to respect where you are coming from. To me it is about winning, sure it is great watching attractive football but I would choose winning poorly over playing well and losing. A lot of fans on toffeeweb want their cake and eat it, annoyed with Moyes that he lost the Semi but hardly thankful he got us their in the first place. James who would you like to see us managed by? And what changes would you make to the team, players sold brought in etc?
Paul Holden
126 Posted 16/04/2012 at 21:45:57
I remember Thomas hitting the byline and banging in the crosses for Latchford. Will we ever see anything like it again? Fcuk, I'm not getting any younger and I can't afford to wait another ten years!!
Tim Locke
127 Posted 16/04/2012 at 21:50:19
Kevin Sparke 473 - I get the idea. The problem where do you get the £300, squad from? We need investment if we are going to become champions again.
Kevin Tully
128 Posted 16/04/2012 at 21:58:04
Martinez has just beat Arsenal & Liverpool on their own turf in the past three weeks. Good job he had all that money to achieve what Moyes has failed to do in 10 fucking years.
Ray Jacques
129 Posted 16/04/2012 at 21:06:16
Having read all the threads, all i can add is that the whole set up of the club is stagnant and stale.

Same level of performance each season, ie poor start to the season which lasts until Xmas and then an improvement from January.

Same league position each year (within a few places)

Same tactics, predictable pattern of play and problems of scoring goals

Same disappointment in the derby each season.

Same let down in the big cup games and missed opportunities

Same problems /issues every transfer window (although Moyes pulled some out of the bag this January)

Same media coverage. We should change our motto to' everton the club with no money who overachieve'

Same stadium with no chance of development.

Same manager with no trophy for 10 years.

Same old everything really, we are a steady mid table club showing no signs of future progress.

Lastly and the biggest problem....

Same chairman who cannot or will not relinquish control or change the manager as its all so cosy and comfortable .

Until the ownership of the club changes as supporters we are in limbo knowing that each season will be similar to the last.

Unfortunately things will only alter if Moyes gets a better offer from another club or Kenwright sells .Only then can we speculate over managers or will we find out whether Moyes really is the great manager the press have us believe.

PS just watched Wigan beat Arsenal. restored a little of my faith in football . Oh and proves that on any given day in a one off game such as Saturday money, net spend etc means nothing. We had our chance and blew it big time.
Eddy Bernard
130 Posted 16/04/2012 at 20:59:19
Just seen the result from the emirates,

Only for a dodgy ref and the cheating Chelski, Wigan would have beaten the once called top 4 all in the last 4 weeks, they say Fortune favours the brave and i think Martinez has proved the point here.

Move over Moyes!
Dan McKie
131 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:02:18
I can only assume that Wigan must have received a massive injection of cash before kick off, or maybe they just have some balls.
Tim Locke
132 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:00:51
Kevin Tully 480 - Where are they in the league?
Kevin Sparke
133 Posted 16/04/2012 at 21:58:34
Tim - nail on the head... but if we did get that investment (which I doubt) would you still want Moyes managing the team - because I'm not sure I would.

But whilst we're skin't, I don't think we can do better than Moyes - (sad to say) nobody has consistently matched his record with similar resources at his disposal.

If they have - I can't remember them.
Mick Gallagher
134 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:04:09
5 Games left, were not going down so for fuck sake try and cheer us up by playing some decent fucking football. Fuck sake lets have a go at the manc's for once at there place. You never know Davie we might just win for once.

Renewed the 2 season tickets this morning fuck knows why, but its done.
Danny James
135 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:03:34
Stop comparing what Wigan are doing now. If Martinez is so good how come he has never won the title for them?

If they can beat Arsenal, Liverpool and Man Utd surely they should be beating everybody and be champions.

If he is doing so great how come they are close to being relegated?

Moyes beat Chelsea, Man City and Spurs and only a dodgy ref sending off Rodwell stopped us beating Liverpool
Tom Bowers
136 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:01:45
When all said and done Moyes has his opinion albiet distorted about some of his players who he thinks are good enough.
Most of us know they are not and it's time for Moyes, no, Kenwright to do something about it.
The same picture will evolve next season unless we have a change.
Moyes is not a Messiah,far from it.There are other good coaches out there who could do what Moyes is doing which we all know isn't very much. Yes,Moyes has made some astute buys but I could too given 10 years at it.
Everton need new blood and fresh ideas. It has to start with the Manager's position.
Kevin Tully
137 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:07:32
Tim, I think they are 16th, didn't Moyes finish 17th one year?
James Stewart
138 Posted 16/04/2012 at 21:53:15
Tim, I think after Walter Smith, we were just all pleased not to be a laughing stock bringing in the likes of Gazza, Ginola etc. So winning ugly was accepted. I thought Moyes might then be the man to change style and envole but I see the same tactics now as I did when he had the likes of Naysmith, Kilbane, Bent et al. We are now a team very much in his image despite having better players now. I called for his head many times after the 4th place finish and european embarrassments so it is nothing new, me hoping for his exit.

I would like to see someone come in who would have a plan and football first ethos. That would need to be implemented root to branch from the youth team up. It would definitely not have the likes of Stubbs coaching our Barkleys. I would like to see the average age of the team brought down and initially we would sell to buy quite heavily. I would keep the likes of Baines, Heitinga, Fellaini, Osman, Jelavic listen to offers for any others. They are the best passers in the team and I would like a team built around possession. Neville, Cahill, Jags, Coleman etc would have no place in a side like that.

I would look abroad for the man to spearhead it all. The likes of Benfica, Basel, Standard Liege were all built around this model. If I had to choose someone from the epl it would be Rogers by a long way. He has been praised by the likes of Mourinho , Lampard etc. I think he will achieve a lot more once he has better players than those at Swansea.
Kunal Desai
139 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:12:13
Danny - I don't remember us being in a winning position against liverpool before Rodwell got sent off. How do you know we were going to beat them?
Dan McKie
140 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:11:32
Mick, It is too big a game for Man U. Moyes wouldn't dare go there and risk rocking the boat with Sir Alex by trying to get a result. We will see Everton roll over on Sunday as per usual.
Mick Gallagher
141 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:13:38
Danny #488 read your last line and think about it. It was 0.0 when he was sent off how do know we would have won. Saturday we were 1.0 up with over 60 minutes on the clock and still fucking lost.
Dan McKie
142 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:14:40
What stopped us beating Liverpool in the other 2 games, Danny? Moyes.
Danny James
143 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:13:30
James 491
Keep Baines, Heitinga , Fellaini, Jelavic. Thats everybody worth anything then.
Paul David
144 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:05:28
For people to suggest, if we had a go like Wigan, it would automatically mean we would struggle against relegation, is a joke.

We have far superior players than Wigan so by playing football and taking the game to the opposition like Wigan would bring us even greater success.
Mick Gallagher
145 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:18:53
I agree Dan but for once we can just dream about it.
Paul David
146 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:20:23
Even if playing football means sacrificing a few league places,so fucking be it.
You get nothing for finishing 7th anyway so might as well finish 10th and be entertained.
Tim Locke
147 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:13:03
Kevin Tully 490 - correct 2003/4 season following year bagged 4th. Wigan have the same points at the moment as they did this time last year, and last year they managed 16th and 42 points. I don't see Wigan getting 4th.
James Stewart
148 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:19:44
Danny, I wouldn't keep them if good money were offered. I ment more that they would be capable of playing in a different style. You could probably include Gibson in that group too.

I don't think any of our players are worth fighting tooth and nail to keep.
Kevin Tully
149 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:27:06
Kevin Sparke # 486

Bolton reached the League Cup final in 2004, but lost to Middlesbrough. Nevertheless, Bolton finished eighth in the league, at the time their highest finish in their Premiership history. In 2005 Bolton finished sixth in the league, thus earning qualification for the UEFA Cup for the first time in their history. The following season, they reached the last 32 but were eliminated by French team Marseille as they lost 2?1 on aggregate. In April 2007, towards the end of 2006?07 season, manager Allardyce resigned.[18] In his final four seasons at Bolton, Allardyce had recorded consecutive top ten finishes, a record of consistency bettered only by the big four of Chelsea, Manchester United, Liverpool and Arsenal.

Tim, that's just the problem, you are comparing Everton to Wigan - that's what you have to quote defend Moyes ?
Nick Waters
150 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:26:22
It wasn't just the result tonight ? or that at Anfield ? that shows Martinez and others can succeed at these clubs' own grounds it was the WAY they played: composed, on the deck, break with pace and with numbers.

As for trying to use Wigan's league positon as proof that Moyes is a better manager ? you are desperately clutching at straws. Everton not out of the top flight for nearly 60 years and Wigan only in for the last half dozen. How are they comparable?

Martinez has transformed both Swansea and Wigan, and even Gary Neville (who was born with most of his brother's brains as well as his own) is waxing lyrical over Martinez's formation and coaching. He's a coach on the up while Moyes is a busted flush.
Mark Riding
151 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:35:18
Roberto Martinez...

We have got a gun-fight at the weekend...

Can we lend your knife ????
James Stewart
152 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:35:43
I would also make Pienaar top priority. I would make him Captain and the focal point of the team.
Play him centrally as a number 10 of a new footballing team.

To weigh in on the Wigan debate. I want moyes gone as much as any but Martinez is not a fit replacement. There would be no point to that at all. Consistent relegation fodder.
Nick Waters
153 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:26:22
It wasn't just the result tonight - or that at Anfield - that shows Martinez and others can succeed at these clubs' own grounds it was the WAY they played - composed, on the deck, break with pace and with numbers. As for trying to use Wigan's league positon as proof that Moyes is a better manager - you are desperately clutching at straws. Everton not out of the top flight for nearly 60 years and Wigan only in for the last half dozen. How are they comparable? Martinez has transformed both Swansea and Wigan, and even Gary Neville (who was born with most of his brother's brains as well as his own) is waxing lyrical over Martinez' formation and coaching. He's a coach on the up while Moyes is a busted flush.
Kevin Sparke
154 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:31:35
Kevin Tully - what did Allardyce do at Newcastle United with far more resources at his disposal?... what did he do at Blackburn? Why do the West Ham fans hate him so much?

BTW - Moyes has finished 6th, 5th, 5th, 8th, 7th - qualified for Europe 3 times...

Sam Allardyce - as Moyes's replacement - surely you jest?
Mick Gallagher
155 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:34:46
Paul #500 I agree mate go out and try and put a few smiles back on are faces with a bit of attacking football. So we lose a few quid in place money we will lose a lot more if more fans dont turn up next season.

I seen enough young toffee faces coming out of Wembley that would have brought tears to a glass eye. There the future and we need to keep them and put smiles back on there faces. I bet they fucking hated school today.
Kevin Tully
156 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:42:19
Kevin ~ 513,

I was attempting to answer your question of achievement vs resources, I think fat Sam's record compares to Moyes, because of the size of club Bolton were at the time, and cash he had for players.

I wouldn't want Allardyce near Everton. Why would you think that ?
Tim Locke
157 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:24:26
James Stewart 491 - Thanks have copied the comments as think worth coming back to that. Osman is an interesting choice, and no Gibson. I would presume the current crop of youth you would keep rodwell, barkley and Gueye, and you have kept the choice to outfield players. Do you think Pienaar should be signed? What about Drenthe?

Rogers does stand out, and as you said his time as Chelsea was praised, but would you not be concerned about what happened at Reading. I am not saying he is a bad manager, but like players (although less so) maybe some manager just don't fit and therefore he could come and it might not work out. It was interesting that both Moyes and Rogers went for Rory Donnelly.
Kevin Tully
158 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:46:16
And why miss out his 17th & 11th place finishes ?

Another cherry picker in our midst.
Kevin Sparke
159 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:48:28
Kevin - (I missed out 4th as well) I was going from 2007- onwards...

Subtle form of argument you've got there- have you ever considered a career at the bar?
Kevin Tully
160 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:52:40
Not really Kevin, how could anyone hope to compete with the intellectual brilliance you possess ?
Barry Rathbone
161 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:41:42
My support of Martinez is long standing he is the only modern manager I've seen with a vision and confidence to see it through. He is a completely different manager to the frauds that sing the same song like Moyes and infect english football.

I saw his reconstruction of Swansea and knew then he was what I wanted at Everton.

Annoying he's getting these results I was hoping he'd stay under the radar, likely he'll get snaffled as the media will get behind him now.....shit.
Howard Don
162 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:42:20
Paul 446 & 448 You're comments and "facts" are cmpletely inaccurate.

1) I have never said I am content with the current situation, what I am saying that it is not Moyes fault that we are lacking in the investment necessary to compete at a higher level on a consistent basis. That resposibility lies with the board and neither Moyes nor any other manager could achieve what both you and I want without that investment. What I am saying is that Moyes superlative job in keeping us on the fringe of contention has raised expectations to such an extent that you and others blame him for not being able to do the impossible and take us on to another level. We need money man!

Regarding your "facts" :-

1) Where on earth did I say I was happy "wallowing in mid table obscurity" I hate it just as I hate the easy knee jerk tactic of blaming the manager for what is a much more complex issue.

2) Moyes has won nothing is meaningless. Neither have most other PL managers outside of clubs with megabucks, which brings us back to investment.

Once again you have not said anything about how this miraculous change you set so much store by would come about. What is your theory and great stategic plane to improve things? You witter on about change but give precious little info about how it is to be achieved. Oh yes I forgot - sack the manager just about everyone in football thinks is exceptional - well thought through mate.
Kevin Sparke
163 Posted 16/04/2012 at 23:06:11
I'll call that a score draw Kevin...
John Crawley
164 Posted 16/04/2012 at 23:06:10
Howard I will ask you the same question I asked Jim. Given the club's financial situation staying the same how long would you carry on with Moyes as manager if he keeps on getting top half of the table finishes but doesn't win a cup?
Jamie Tulacz
165 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:59:05
So Martinez is the new flavour of the month then... Not sure many were saying that a few weeks ago when Wigan were bottom of the league, amazing that 3 or 4 good results can make you the best thing since a sliced granary loaf..
Stephen Sullivan
166 Posted 16/04/2012 at 22:31:19
There's a rumour going around that things are so bad that the obstructed view seats are going to cost more next season than those with a clear view?
Paul David
168 Posted 17/04/2012 at 00:52:43
Jamie 532
I cant speak for anyone else but I am not using Martinez as an example of someone who can bring us success or that I even want him as our manager.
The fact is we cant compete without money,the best we can hope for is maybe a cup but what there is no excuse for is the brand of football under Moyes.
At least Martinez would give us a team with a bit of pride and confidence in their own ability to go out and play.
Richard Harris
169 Posted 17/04/2012 at 01:25:18
Wigan had some terrible results in the first half of the season but Martinez stuck to trying to get (for the most part) average players to use the ball more creatively and develop a team who could pass the ball. At times some of the defending was naive and the lack of a quality striker was telling in games where Wigan played well but couldn't get the result. In the last few months they haven't played like a team in the relegation zone and if you follow Martinez's positive philosophy first with Swansea and then with Wigan what could he achieve with better players at a better resourced club ?
Jason Lam
171 Posted 17/04/2012 at 02:25:27
"Phil Neville has dismissed fears David Moyes may consider his Everton future "

Who's fears is Neville referring to? Certainly not mine!

It is corruption that Moyes can control his own destiny as my club's manager. Where is the justice?
Anto Byrne
172 Posted 17/04/2012 at 03:17:27
Give Phil Neville the job, I think you would see a different approach, must have learned a bit from SAF and has won stuff. Player manager as in Daglish and Kendall.

You think Neville would have sat back on saturday given his experience. It can only be instructions from Moyes to defend deep and hang on much as we did v spurs chelsea(until the 2nd goal) and city all of those teams had chances and with better finishing it may well have been a different story. He finally sets the team up for Sunderland Swansea and WBA and to some degree v Norwich and then reverts to utter shite v the shite.

He has a chance to redeem himself by having at go at United this weekend but it will be the normal 4-5-1 defensive shite to hang on for a point and end up with a 1-0 loss that he will no doubt claim he was happy with. Moyes is a loser and until he goes we will always be mid table mediocre.
Alex Willett
173 Posted 17/04/2012 at 07:57:20
Moyes is like being with the same bird for 10 years. Its stale and boring. No sex life, no enjoyment, just hassle and grief! going nowhere, time for some fresh meat, a new model. Get out! And dont come back!!! Get Martinez in. Now!
Howard Don
174 Posted 17/04/2012 at 08:18:19
Alex 579 - You're doing something wrong mate!
Joe Clarke
175 Posted 17/04/2012 at 08:43:45
Distin has apologised, what about the rest of them, including Moyes?
Jem Traynor
176 Posted 17/04/2012 at 10:02:02
Dan McKie, comments spot on! I can't believe that there's people defending Kenwright and Moyes. Them two are the biggest problem Everton have.

There has been a stabilising effect on the Club (in a way) but it's only a quick fix. There's no way or plan been worked out on What To Do Next! all the posts that appeared after the Semi's said it all.

What Next??? I'll bet it's back to the same old shit.
George McKane
178 Posted 17/04/2012 at 10:12:03
I will be 63 in November. I have been watching Everton since 1959/60 initially from The Boys Pen and now with Season Tickets for myself and grandkids. My daughter in 41 and has been going since she was a child and my grandson of 20 has been a ST Holder with me for about 15 years.

We were at Wembley at the weekend.

I have seen other games where I felt let down and disgusted but I have to say not as many as under Mr. Moyes.

This is just my opinion and I expect some people to say how much they think he is doing a good job.

On Saturday evening I said I would finish my Season Ticket off and not get one next year because I couldn't stand any more disappointment. Not just disappointment but sheer dullness.

I have witnessed bad games under previous managers including Kendall Catterick and Royle but I have never witnessed such a lack of any real drive, passion, such a feeling of dullness on the pitch over such a long period.

I am critical of Moyes and the so called senior players for playing such dull boring and lack lustre football. I excuse the younger and newer players in some ways.

The players are like robots, the seem to freeze and lack any individual decision making and drive.

I love going to the game. I have made 1000's of friends through football/Everton, I love going to the pub (The Dark House - you can see our photos on FB - The Dark House Blues)), having a drink, talking football,having a laugh and telling old stories about our past. But actually watching Everton for the past 4-5 years, apart from a very few games, has been overwhelmingly dull.

I will most probably re-new my ST and my grandsons but until things change I almost accept that it is the going to the match today that is more exciting than watching the match.

I lay the blame for this situation at The Board, The Manager and the Senior Players for accepting and playing such flat, tepid, and in my opinion cowardly football.

Yet again we are told by a Senior Player, "we will make it up to the fans" - - didn't someone say something like that just a few weeks ago after the debacle of Anfield. Fed up hearing that they will make it up - - as time goes on we, of course,realise they don't make it up - hardly ever.

A pretty disgusted Blue - - but as always a Blue Forever.
Barry Rathbone
179 Posted 17/04/2012 at 10:34:17
George McKane

Well said mate, true blues the lot of you.

I won't be going till Moyes goes but I respect fans like you who go come what may.
Paul Holmes
180 Posted 17/04/2012 at 11:53:19
Well done to the poster who found the link to say MOYES is the 8th HIGHEST paid manager in world football ? FFS! I CAN'T BELIEVE IT!!! NO WONDER WE CAN'T GET RID, UNBELIEVABLE,GOBSMACKED!!!

Look at the quality of managers around the globe, with our wages WE COULD GET SOMEONE DECENT!
Tony J Williams
181 Posted 17/04/2012 at 11:51:21
Martinez has been a manager for 6 years, what has he won? Apparently longevity is linked to success....why hasn't he won anything yet?
Daniel A Johnson
182 Posted 17/04/2012 at 12:08:42
The point lost here is compare Cardiff City to Everton.

A lower division club who pulled their sleeves it and wanted to FUCKING WIN they went for it big time. Lower league players all playing with one ambition to beat Liverpool at wembley.

Compare them to us. A cowardly fearful side so scared of upsetting Moyes and his tactical game plan. A side looking like they had just shit themselves. Nota single meaningful effort on target to test their 3rd choice keeper. Fucking disgrace.

If i was manager i would have made them watch a video momntage of liverpool getting twated numerous times this season and then ended teh video saying now go and fucking destroy them.

I fucking despise Dalglish but he is a winner he understands what it means to play for Liverpool. Does Moyes understand what it emans to play for Everton? He's the cowardly 60k a week manager who rests players for a derby at Anfield. Would Dalglish ever rest players for a derby?

Jesus christ you telling me somone out there couldn't do better with this group of players than Moyes.

anybody who claims no one can do any better than Moyes is a fucking liverpool fan as far as I'm concerned, just like the other red shite TV pundits who "love" Moyes.
Tony J Williams
183 Posted 17/04/2012 at 12:35:07
Daniel, they lost didn't they? The main striker bottled it near the end, their players all bottled it in the penalty shootout.

Just like us, our players bottled it and if Distin would have decided to use his good foot, who knows what may have happened?
Howard Don
184 Posted 17/04/2012 at 12:18:50
George (642) I'm only a couple of years younger than you mate and am also ex boys pen and long term season ticket holder. Whilst I wouldn't agree with all you say, I respect your right to say it and the loyalty you show. For holding my views I have, on this thread, been called "a sad excuse for an Evertonian" - sad times we live in when we can't agree to disagree.
Peter Laing
185 Posted 17/04/2012 at 12:37:51
So fucking what Tony that's stating the bleeding obvious as you always do with a spin, what Daniel's saying is Cardiff had a 'go' and took a crap Liverpool side very close, winning as the always do on penalties. We bottled out and opted to try to keep it tight and it backfired big time as it did in the previous derby.
Danny Kewley
186 Posted 17/04/2012 at 12:20:25
I have been an Everton supporter about as long as George but i am lucky in a way cause i dont have the agonizing decision of whether or not to renew a season ticket. However if i was back home i`d go a long with Barry.

I can`t for the life of me see Moyes changing now--I honestly thought he had come to his senses for the games before the semi----
but NO he had to revert to text against THEM
The gates will no doubt reflect the disappointment felt by a lot of Blues fans.
Jem Traynor
187 Posted 17/04/2012 at 12:37:15
Martinez doesn't run a team like Moyes does, nothing like... he goes for it with his team tactics and gets good results from average players at big grounds. Moyes isn't far off the mark but is off the mark; after ten years of top wages, how much longer will we just 'Get on With' winning nothing and worse ? shitting a brick when we see the silverware or play a derby!
Chris Rudd
188 Posted 17/04/2012 at 12:42:28
When are you going to stop trying to defend the indefensible Tony? Cardiff, a Championship side, who will more than likely be a Championship side again next season pushed the RS all the way to extra time and penalties and looked at all times like they were trying to win the game.

Compare that with what we witnessed on Saturday.

I find it embarrassing not to mention heart breaking...can you honestly say it doesn't bother you? And can you honestly say anymore that there's no better way than the Moyes way?

A lot of people are sick of pitiful capitulation - I'm one of them.
Tony J Williams
189 Posted 17/04/2012 at 12:48:54
So fucking what Peter, they lost - same end result so it means fuck all.
Peter Laing
190 Posted 17/04/2012 at 12:49:56
It's called pride Tony, that's why I opted to go to Wembley and you opted to stay away
Chris Rudd
191 Posted 17/04/2012 at 12:50:17
"So fucking what Peter, they lost - same end result so it means fuck all."

Do you watch football on teletext Tony? Does what happens between minute one and minute 90 or 120 or whatever, not matter.

It's not just about winning or losing, it's about looking like you're trying to win while you're out on the pitch for god's sake. It's about intent!
Tony J Williams
192 Posted 17/04/2012 at 12:50:09
Chris, I am not defending anyone, they all bottled it, the manager and the players.

I and others are getting stick because we refuse to just blame Moyes.

Of course it bothers me, I was fuming on Saturday, nearly involved in a few kick offs because of it.

When have I or any others said there is no way better than Moyes, of course there are managers out there who can do a whole of a lot better than him but chopping and changing to the flavour of the month like so many on here isn't the way to go.
Simon Harris
193 Posted 17/04/2012 at 12:31:29
Daniel - you can blame Moyes til the cows come home, but we had 2 decent free kicks in the 1st half.

The 1st from Baines, a good effort but just over. The 2nd was a woeful attempt from Jelavic that was well wide.

Before both, I was yelling for them to try and make the keeper work.

Moyes was probably thinking and shouting something similar, but ultimately he was let down by his players, as they bottled it and his bench, unlike the shites, was piss poor and cost peanuts.

Saturday hurt and is still hurting, (I'm still sulking like my 5yr old) but the players have to share a large part of the responsibility for that 2nd half display. Moyes is not without fault and I can't believe he wasted a sub in Mcfadden when a local youngster with some fight and spirit could have added value in place of the useless and anonymous 2nd half Darron Gibson.

But too many of the team that bullied and played Sunderland off the park in the quarters like men vs boys choked on the big stage when it mattered.

Is that really all Moyes fault.
Dan McKie
194 Posted 17/04/2012 at 12:58:08
The buck stops with the manager, Tony. When has that ever been any different?
Tony J Williams
195 Posted 17/04/2012 at 12:56:11
Pride? I opted to stay away because I am getting married in 3 months and couldn't justify paying £200 for a day out to the missus.

Pride, do me a fucking favour!
Daniel A Johnson
196 Posted 17/04/2012 at 12:57:41
Flavour of the fucking month chopping and changing Moyes HAS BEEN HERE FUCKING 10 YEARS
Peter Laing
197 Posted 17/04/2012 at 13:02:24
Fuck me says it all under the thumb before you even get married !
Tony J Williams
198 Posted 17/04/2012 at 13:00:20
"It's not just about winning or losing" - ultimately, yes it is.
Lee Baines
199 Posted 17/04/2012 at 12:46:34
I think, sometimes, that people forget where we've come from. OK, ten years is a long time...but coming from this----->
http://www.toffeeweb.com/season/02-03/squad.asp

To this ----->
http://www.toffeeweb.com/players/current/

Is an achievement, trophy or not.

Make no mistake, I'm as distraught as anyone about the debacle of Saturday, but I think saying Moyes had 'done nothing' for Everton, is a bit too far.
Tony J Williams
200 Posted 17/04/2012 at 13:03:47
Under the thumb or sensible? £200 to watch that shite or £40 in the pub? I know which one I preferred
Chris Rudd
201 Posted 17/04/2012 at 13:04:45
Well okay Tony - here's one for you...

40 odd away games at the 'Sky4' over 10 years...

Wins... err none!
Dave Wilson
202 Posted 17/04/2012 at 12:51:37
"I almost accept that going to the match today is more exciting than watching the match"

I couldnt agree more.

Your spot in identifying ALL the culprits George.


John Daley
203 Posted 17/04/2012 at 13:18:42
".. like being with the same bird for 10 years. Its stale and boring"

"I almost accept that it is the going to the match today that is more exciting than watching the match."

The sad part is it's much easier to bin the first one off. If my missus put me through as much shit as Everton, her severed head would be stuffed in a cardboard box and I'd be on the run trying to blame it all on a mythical one-armed man.
Scott Hamilton
204 Posted 17/04/2012 at 13:22:14
There are currently two threads, this one and the one about Martinez, which are basically addressing the same thing. I'll paste my comments from the other thread below:

What is obvious here, and to a degree understandable, is that many see our performance against the RS as an overall barometer of Everton as a club. Three humiliating defeats = Everton being in dire straits.

As much as I am sick to the stomach of not beating them and listening to their shit, I see it slightly differently. If we had gone out of the FA Cup in an earlier round and to lesser opposition (lesser even than the RS) and were now sat where we are in the league I think, ironically, many would be far less vitriolic towards Moyes. So what are we saying: that he has the audacity to get us to an FA Cup semi-final and then lose? How dare he!

Martinez et al may have been mentioned on TW for quite a while. That doesn't make them the right choice for our club. What about solvency? If bringing them in risks finishing lower in the league of even relegation then doesn't that reduce our revenue and put us under financial pressure? Who's to say that the club's creditors have not insisted on tying Moyes into a long-term contract as they see it as the only guarantee of some moderate level of financial stability. All ifs, buts and maybes but so is the conjecture normally offered on TW.

The time to change managers is likely to be at the point where investment and/or a change of ownership take place.

Going back to Martinez; I rate him very highly but I guarantee that if you rang Wigan and offered to swap him for Moyes then they would do it in a heartbeat.
Tony J Williams
205 Posted 17/04/2012 at 13:23:59
"Well okay Tony - here's one for you...

40 odd away games at the 'Sky4' over 10 years...

Wins... err none!"

Man City finished in the top 4 last year, we did the double over them.

Also, as stated in another thread, do we get more points if we beat them away than at home? Which we have done all 4/6 (including Spurs)
Paul David
206 Posted 17/04/2012 at 13:07:52
Tony J williams1
I have to say your attitude astounds me.
I would rather die on my feet fighting than live on my knees.
Paul David
207 Posted 17/04/2012 at 13:29:04
Scott 731
I feel your right about feelings towards Moyes not being as strong if we were knocked out in an earlier round but your missing the point.
People are upset because of the way the team rolled over and died again in the face of the worst Liverpool side in living memory.
Scott Hamilton
208 Posted 17/04/2012 at 13:36:28
Paul (743) - The point isn't lost on me. My point is that you are therefore using the games against the RS as a barometer of the club's performance rather than the performance over the season as a whole.

Obviously if we choke in every game from here til the end of the saeson then that is something else all together and is symptomatic of something far more serious
Chris Rudd
209 Posted 17/04/2012 at 13:31:19
Y'know Tony, the instant I pressed 'submit' I kind of knew you'd come back with a City comment. You know who we're talking about here.

Let's face it we're wasting our time. All you're interested in is knocking the 'argumental ball back over the net'.

Seems to me you'd rather accept mediocrity and dull, soulless football than risk, as you appear to think it is, a change.

Me, I'd rather have some excitement on a Saturday afternoon, or whenever Sky allow my team to play.

What's that phrase about 'having nothing to fear but fear itself'?
Kevin Tully
210 Posted 17/04/2012 at 13:48:16
There is absolutely no pressure on the team to win at Man U on Sunday.

We are still 8/1 to win with our phenomenal over-achieving miracle worker in charge.

Oh, my aching sides.
Richard Dodd
211 Posted 17/04/2012 at 13:36:50
Only this morning, I read in The Daily Telegraph that David Moyes has been nominated as one of the BEST FIVE EVER managers in the Premier League's 20-year history. Now, I acknowledge that he is very much the junior member of a club which numbers SAF, Mourinho, Redknapp and Wenger as its other members but it re-inforces my view that only on ToffeeWeb are his achievents with Everton not acknowledged.

OK, in 10 years we`ve won no silverware but season after season after season he has won us great respectability ? and for a club in our dire straits that is mega achievement! Of course, we would like to be vying with the top dogs for honours but you need money for that and that`s a comodity destined to be in short supply.... even after our chairman`s current stint in Corri!
Dan McKie
212 Posted 17/04/2012 at 13:51:48
The bookies know Moyes wont send his team out to win against his best and most non patronising pal Sir Alex. They will be too bust discussing 'longevity', or thrashing out the Barkley deal. We have already had Gibson, so 500k, and he'll lob in Johnny Evans when Vidic gets back.
Dan McKie
214 Posted 17/04/2012 at 13:54:56
Cant wait to see the open top bus with the team parading that respectability, Doddy.
Paul David
215 Posted 17/04/2012 at 13:50:48
Scott 747
I get what you are saying and I have no arguments about our final league postions under Moyes.
What i can not stomach is the way he goes about it.The standard of play has got less and less over the years.
He sends his teams out not to get beat rather than to win.
These are his tactics against champions and relegation fodder alike but obviously doing it against Liverpool in a Wembley semi was the last straw for some people.
John Crawley
216 Posted 17/04/2012 at 13:51:50
I've asked this question of Howard & Jim but haven't received an answer. I'll throw it out to anyone who still thinks Moyes should be in charge next season.

Given the club's financial situation staying the same how long would you carry on with Moyes as manager if he keeps on getting top half of the table finishes but doesn't win a cup?
Scott Hamilton
217 Posted 17/04/2012 at 13:56:04
Dan - I hope you are being ironic because otherwise that is just bollocks!

Now, I'm not saying that Moyes and the team won't lose the game, most realists on here would accept that that's likely against the likely champions. To suggest that Moyes won't do his best to win the game though... Is this all part of the vast conspiacy that now incldes SAF?!
Daniel A Johnson
219 Posted 17/04/2012 at 13:53:33
iT not about being beat its the manner of the defeat.

It was Chelsea Deja-Vu again and Moyes has learnt nothing.

His stock has fallen in the eyes of everyone even the media after that defeat.
Paul David
220 Posted 17/04/2012 at 14:04:13
Scott 767
Moyes is more scared of defeat than the rewards victory can bring.
So yeah I do think Moyes won't do his best to win the game.
Jem Traynor
221 Posted 17/04/2012 at 14:04:31
Daniel A Johnson 770 ? that's never going to happen with the utter drivelings of the MotD morons back-slapping one another, but you are right to anyone who says it as it is and how he is a far cry from being a top manger.

Paul 764 ? that about sums it up in my eyes, it's the manner we handed it over on both occasions after the Rodwell sending off! Are we not MEN! Should we not be proud, this guy is one of them in charge! That's it!
Dan McKie
222 Posted 17/04/2012 at 14:06:47
Scott, did that look like a serious post to you? I do however believe we will go there and defend, which is the same as not sending the team out to win in my book. We always roll over at Old Trafford. It wont stop Sir Alex coming out with 'best Everton side he has ever seen' or 'Moyes for United' though.
Richard Dodd
223 Posted 17/04/2012 at 13:59:01
John, my feeling is that we `will only keep on getting top ten finishes` if Moyes IS the manager for the foreseeable future.

We have heard from the Chairman that the two of them will sit down shortly to plot the future. With great reservations about BK, I suspect that future will continue to involve both of them. Not ideal, I know but the thought of Kenwright having to find a successor to Davey frightens me to death!
Scott Hamilton
224 Posted 17/04/2012 at 14:14:58
Dan (774) - On TW you never know!

Remember Keegan's Newcastle, Ardilles' Spurs and Holloway's Blackpool? All entertained the socks off us but didn't win anything. One even threw away a league title that looked impossible to lose, partly by bringing in a flair player (Asprilla).

Look at our team compared to Utd's. We have nowhere near the quality. We are also playing away from home. Of course we'll keep it tight and try to nick one, or do you want to lose 6-1? That is the reality of this squad if we play attacking, expansive football against the top teams.

Yes, I want to be entertained but I also want to avoid us being humiliated every other week. Utd desperately need to beat us on Sunday and will go all out. Unless we set ourselves out to weather the storm and hopefully generate a few moments which get us goals, we will be destroyed. It might hurt to admit that but it is the way things are.

Last night's Wigan result was one of those anomalies that occurs a couple of times a season. The fact that there were only 10 men on the pitch for Arsenal at the time may have helped too!
Howard Don
226 Posted 17/04/2012 at 14:21:26
John Crawley (766) Sorry John I missed your first post as I was a bit preoccupied with being called a "sad excuse for an Evertonian" after 40 years of non-stop support.

The answer to your point is that there isn't a definitive one. In the current climate - yes I would continue with Moyes unless I thought his appetite for the job had gone and he's not given any indication that is the case so far. Quite simply his talent for getting something out of very little is indispensible at the moment. Given substantial investment, then again I'd give him a shot as I feel he deserves the chance to show what he can do. If he then fails to move us forward then obviously it's time for a re-think.

However none of that would be down to what you or I think. If some major investor came out of the woodwork, then the chances are they'd want results fairly quickly and may decide immediate change is the way forward and i could live with that.
Dan McKie
227 Posted 17/04/2012 at 14:30:45
Scott, ever heard the saying 'attack is the best form of defence'? If we did go out and attack, is the 6-1 a guarantee? No it isnt. I remember Blackburn went to Old Trafford and attacked them, was that 6-1? We have decent attacking players who Utd would have to worry about if we went at them. Im not saying we would win, but it would make me feel better than if we go out with 11 behind the ball, every time we get it, we hoof it to De gea, who is playing mostly outside his own box, ready to knock it to Scholes for another attack. Then once they get a couple up they knock it from side to side for the rest of the game.

Also, are you saying you wouldnt rather be like Keegans Newcastle, or Holloways Blackpool and winning nothing? And dont come back with 'Blackpool got relegated'. They gave it a good go with League 1 and 2 players, won at Anfield, and would have been out of sight down by christmas if he had them playing like Moyes.
Paul David
228 Posted 17/04/2012 at 14:35:27
Scott 785
I agree going away to OT should be about keeping it tight but the problem with Moyes is once we go 1 nil down the gameplan becomes about keeping the score down rather than attempting to get back into the game.
We can't go away from home and expect to play teams off the park and win.
For me away matches are about doing whats best to get results but at home entertaining the crowd should be just as much a priority
Tony J Williams
229 Posted 17/04/2012 at 14:46:55
Same old fucking stupid comments about me being happy with our lot because I won't call the manager a coward etc

I'll say it again for the cheap seats. Me not going all Breivik doesn't mean I'm not as pissed off as the next person as to how low we have sunk since the 80's and again, me not going nuts has absolutely no fucking effect on how Everton play, none whatsoever. Same as a mindless rant about this or that has absolutely no effect on how the team is lined up to take it up the arse at Old Trafford on Sunday.
John Ford
231 Posted 17/04/2012 at 14:23:39
I'm firmly in the pro-Moyes camp and taking his overall contribution, particularly regards Premier League positions, his impact has been very impressive. No-one on similar resources can touch him.

In contrast, his ability to flunk on the big occasion is a consistent problem, although granted we have some good results against the big boys. It's the nature of defeat rather than the defeats themselves which can really disappoint.

On balance, it is unlikely that any manager we appointed would do as well as Moyes. This is based on the simple observation that many have tried and have all pretty much failed. So we take a risk? It might change our approach and it may be that Holloway, Rodgers or Martinez would do better at Everton as we (theoretically) have greater resources than their present clubs.

Moyes gets more for his buck than anyone, but do we risk relative success (consistently positive league results) for a punt at something better? Maybe, but winning anything more than a very occasional League Cup has proven impossible for everyone.
Jem Traynor
232 Posted 17/04/2012 at 15:13:40
Tony Williams you right 100% but it's all too easy to agree with how the pundits see it and how it is and we aren't them but we are the same as in we support Everton and are too pissed off knowing it could be worse! but finishing above Liverpool will make things a little better, to me anyway.
Scott Hamilton
233 Posted 17/04/2012 at 16:49:35
Dan (791) - I'd love us to be like Keegan's Newcastle but he had pots of money and we don't. I certainly don't want us to be like Blackpool. Entertaining football is no consolation for being relegated and losing your best players. What's worse than losing 3 derbies? Er, not playing them because you are in a different league.

"Defence is the best form of attack" is a bumper-sticker of philosophy! A good manager will adapt the playing style to suit the opposition and get the best result. That also means adapting mid-way through a game which is undoubtedly a weakness of Moyes's.

Paul (793) - I think my comment above touches on yours.
Paul David
234 Posted 17/04/2012 at 17:00:51
Scott 854
Why does playing entertaining football automatically mean relegation?

As you point out we both think theres a time and a place to play football but everyone thought Blackpool would do a Swindon and be down by March before a ball was kicked.

So to only go down on the last day with mostly second rate players is'nt bad.

If Moyes were to approach the game like Holloway theres no way we would be relegated.

However I believe the best way to go is somewhere between the two strategies (closer to Holloway's).
Scott Hamilton
235 Posted 17/04/2012 at 17:16:57
Paul (863) - I think we are on a similar wavelength!

My comments, and most of my postings today, are a reaction to those that are saying things like "bring in Martinez/Rogers" or "play attacking football like Blackpool". As you say, the reality lies somewhere in between and Moyes conservatism can be frustrating. Not that many of us complained after the vistories over Man City and Chelsea. That doesn't mean ditching him for somebody that's just had a purple-patch, nor does it mean a wholesale change to the manner in which we play.

Whether Moyes has now got it in him to organically change as a manager is something else all together and, as I said in an earlier post, if the run-in to the end of the season produces performances like the derby then I would be more convinced of the requirement for a change of manager.

As it stands, at 7th in the league and with some winnable games ahead (ignoring the next one for the sake of my health) I am prepared to see what unfolds first
James Stewart
236 Posted 17/04/2012 at 17:17:10
Late reply to Tim Locke if your still checking this thread as I was enjoying our debate.

Osman is a cracking little player. Yes he has his faults but he has great feet and can spot a pass. He would be exactly the type of player who would play better in more "footballing" side. You could possibly include Gibson in that group too yes.

I do not have much faith in the current crop of youth sadly. I thought not selling Rodwell when his stock was highest was a mistake. Gueye doesn't impress me at all. Barkley did look promising before he was banished.

I would go all out to sign Pienaar. In fact I would go further than that I would make him captain. I would also play him in the central No 10 role and build the side around him. I wouldn't sign Drenthe. I initially like his pace and directness but I don't think he would be worth the high wages he would cost. Nor would he fit into a short passing one/two touch side.

As for Rogers I wouldn't be too concerned with his spell at Reading he was only there for 20 games. Hardly enough to change a team's style that radically. He is probably a moot point to be honest though as I think he is a shoe in for the Spurs job if Renknapp leaves. And I think that in itself will be a big shun for Moyes and his style of football if you can call it that.

Where do you stand on these points anyway, Tim? I think you mentioned you would prefer to win at all costs? Do you think Moyes achieves this still?
Paul David
237 Posted 17/04/2012 at 17:43:41
Scott 870
Maybe we are on a similar wavelength but I suspect you have more patience.

I have got to the point were I expect some sort of entertainment value for my money and don't believe Moyes will ever deliver that.

With just a few days left on the early bird offer I have some serious thinking to do.
Paul David
238 Posted 17/04/2012 at 17:50:27
Who am I kidding?

The pain, stress and constant disappointment is what makes us Blues,. I am gunna fill the form out now.
Howard Don
239 Posted 17/04/2012 at 18:25:03
Go for it Paul, you know you want to.
Eddy Bernard
240 Posted 17/04/2012 at 20:27:58
Tony @690

He led Swansea to win the League one title in 2008.

Same number of trophies Moyes has won
Tim Locke
241 Posted 17/04/2012 at 20:19:38
James Stewart 881 - Thanks for getting back to me. I have always been a big fan of Moyes, I think he has given Everton stability and consistency and at the same time not bankrupted the club. A lot of fans were angry about Saturday and I understand why, but I am not a fan of knee jerk reactions, in any one off game any team can win, and on from we should have won, with the players we had we should have won, but then again Man U shouldn't have lost to Blackburn earlier or Ars to Wigan. So I came into this thread defending Moyes along with a lot of others. But your post made me think and I have been thinking it though last night and today.

Conclusion is, Moyes is a good manager and has done a good job at Everton. Most professional acknowledge that and his recent selection into the top 20 prem leg awards adds further weight. So that leaves the question why do so many Toffeeweb supports dislike Moyes? I think it lies in the definition of good. When it comes to football management good is relative term, doing a good job at Man U would not be avoiding relegation, which might be considered a good job at Wolves. So given Everton's position relative to their spend, and recent history people consider Moyes to have done a good job. O'Neill, Villa, Leicester and now Sunderland Allardyce Bolton and Coyle Burnley are all in the same boat, all considered to have done a good job. People often point to how those teams have fallen since the manager left thus adding more weight to their stock of greatness. So good is not playing good football, or having good players, good is out performing expectations. A slight side note is the more often you exceed exceptions the most those expectations grow, how fair that is I don't know. So in the footballing world most people consider Everton to be an ok side, and when Moyes gets them into the top 8 people say he has done well, I felt Moyes is helped by a poor start and selling of good players on transfer deadline day, as expectations are lowered and it become easier for Moyes to become seen as good again. I am therefore concluding that the people on Toffeeweb who don't like Moyes because they know what will happen and would rather finish 10th playing attacking passing football than 7th having seen out a 1-0. Getting and keeping a reputation as a team that disrupts other teams, who can't pass their way out of trouble and likes the long ball is not good or attractive to watch, and I have to respect those people who have been around longer than I have on this thread who have had enough of defensive football.

So where does this leave me, well as I said at the start I would have said keep Moyes at whatever cost, but now I would say if he wants to go let him. I use to think the problem was money, Moyes was a man with the wrong tools being asked to make the impossible. Give the man a chisel and he would be fine, but how can we expect him to craft anything with a hammer. But then I was reading Gibsons comments and how different it was playing at Everton than Man U, yes we have different players but we should be aiming to play the same way. That is a concern, and I have concluded that Moyes approach to most games is like a Champ or Div 1 teams approach to a cup match against a prem league side, close them down, force mistakes and nick a goal. History tells us that will work more often than not, and we will do alright in the league etc. So I think we could buy Moyes a chisel and he would still use it has a hammer, which is sad. So I wouldn't push him unless we had someone else line up but I have concluded that the football I want to see will not be played under Moyes.

If we did bring Rogers in, nothing is impossible, then I don't think he has a magic wand and there would be a lot of unpleasant times ahead before it got better. My only concerns with Rogers, like any manager, would firstly could we get him. I remember us trying to get Bobby Rob and New bagged him, so managers, especially those in demand, are hard to get. Second would he fit the club, I think with managers like Rogers there is more a club fit than say an O'Neill, Coyle is a good example of someone who is struggling at Bolton but was being praised at Burnley. So I would be a little nervous about think Rogers or whoever will be a magic wand. So you have a choice stick with Moyes, knowing you have signed away exciting football but have a top 8 finish and maybe a cup win or take a risk. Personally I would give Moyes one more season and then move him on.

The next question is how do you attract money and players, winning is normally the way forward, a winning team which you can be part of. This normally attracts TV rights as well as players into the club, but do you have to win in a certain way to get those things? Probably yes, even when we have played well we sit at the bottom end of viewing on MOTD, so to raise our value we might need to win more but also play well.

Finally players the ones I would keep in the current squad would be Howard, Baines, Heitinga, Distin, Duffy, Gibson, Barkley, Osman, Pienaar, Fellaini, Rodwell, Baxter, Jelavić, Vellios, Gueye, I think Gueye will become a good player. As for Drenthe there is no question he is good, but he is not a team player, it is all about him, which means when it is going well he is great to watch but when it is bad he will lose you a game. A player I would like to see us take a closer look at is Jamie Vardy at Fleetwood, I watched him play on Friday and this guy is quick and can finish, 24 years old and banging them in for fun, I know there is a massive gap in quality but one on one finishing is similar whatever division and his pace will mean he gets chances.
John Crawley
242 Posted 17/04/2012 at 22:32:19
Tim a good, thoughtful and interesting post. For me personally this season has confirmed a lot of the thoughts I had about David Moyes as a manager. So here are the things that this season has confirmed for me:-

1) Moyes is a negative coach who tactically hasn't developed for a number of years. He was innovative when he first played 4-5-1 but 10 years later he is still playing the same type of football and there is little sign of this changing. In the meantime we have seen how football has developed with the more successful teams playing an attacking pressing game with quick passing and keeping possession.

2) Moyes doesn't learn from his mistakes. We have bottled it in every big game that we have played (exception being we didn't bottle the penalty shoot out against Man Utd). The worst examples of this for me would be the semi-final against Chelsea in the Carling Cup and the semi-final against Liverpool. The Chelsea game we had arguably our best team under David Moyes. We were drawing 1-1 and Chelsea went down to 10 men but we made no attempt to capitalise and the result being they knicked a goal at the end to win the game 2-1. I remember the utter frustration that we made no effort to try and kill the tie off but instead we were content to keep it tight and get a draw. I won't comment further about the Liverpool Semi-Final because I think its pretty clear what happened there. This has led me to believe that Moyes will never win a cup competition at Everton.

3) Moyes's overall approach this season has been, for the most part an absolute disgrace. The way we played against Man City away was a particular low point with his refusal to even send the normal players forward when we got a corner. I remember one corner when we only had 4 players in the box.

4) His handling of young players. The treatment of Barkley, Vellios and Duffy this season has been very poor. His comments about those players and young players in general has made it clear that he will always go with the more experienced professional players, no matter how well the young player has played or how badly the experienced players are playing.

I was interested to hear what Howard and Richard said about keeping Moyes as manager for the foreseeable future on the basis that he carries on as he has done. To me, this is pointless, football is about glory and entertainment. Under David Moyes I remain convinced that we will never get any glory and the entertainment is surely very limited.

The only football I have enjoyed this season has been the away performances against Swansea (second half) & Sunderland in the cup and the home performance against Sunderland (second half). I am fed up with the type of football that we are playing and it isn't good enough for Everton football club.

In all of my years watching Everton (over 30 years now) I can't think of a single top flight manager who has had 10 years in the job and not won a single trophy. If you stick with Moyes then to me you are settling for mediocrity.
James Stewart
243 Posted 18/04/2012 at 02:07:02
Very interesting posts Tim and John. Certainly the best Moyes for and against debate I have had on here.

I started following Everton in the early 90's Tim so by no means can I ever remember seeing an attractive football playing Everton side. The only Highlight being the 1995 FA Cup win under Royle which wasn't exactly pretty (Spurs game aside).
I too like John do not believe we will ever win a cup competition under Moyes. There have been better chances than the Liverpool debacle but on the big occasions Moyes always comes up short and this is mainly down to style and fear. No risk no reward and Moyes NEVER takes a risk. The Chelsea game John takes about was a perfect example. Then there was the European embarrassments which I have still not got over.
So yes Tim I can totally understand where you are coming from with a lot of your points. I do not think we would be any worst off with a fresh approach though. Hell it might even be fun to watch us play again sometimes! A lot of Success is relative and subjective though as you say. For me Royle is the most "successful" Everton manager in my time not Moyes, who I will forever remember as just damn frustrating.
Peter Laing
245 Posted 18/04/2012 at 15:42:50
Look at it this way, we may end up with our very own version of Dario Gradi at Crewe with David Moyes. He could be here for the next twenty years, never win a trophy and we meander along. There are no expectations from the board other than survival, top-ten finish and possibly a Cup run. That's the business model for Everton these days and as unpalatable as it is the Kenwright-Moyes axis is built upon this strategy.
Tim Locke
246 Posted 18/04/2012 at 18:51:32
James, thanks for coming back and John great to have your contribution.

I started following Everton in 85, and have slowly watched a club which was historically greater and better than Liverpool fall under their shadow, and now the shadow of more clubs. To me some of the worse times where the 90s, a side which performed badly, should have been relegated and when they did win something were labelled the Dogs of War ? something a local pub team might aspire to but not a Premier League club.

Everton have always been one of the front runners in football: the first club to have a purpose built-stadium; the first club with dugouts and under-soil heating; and the first club the be on the television, an honour shared with Aston Villa. So it is disappointing as John said that have stagnated as we have, and there is a slow realisation that Moyes is not the man to carry the team forward, which is very sad; but then, as I went to sleep, this happened?.

I got myself in a right pickle last night with my thinking; I believe that Moyes will out-perform most other managers without money, and history does back that statement up. So Swansea play better football than us but we are more than likely to out-perform them in the league and cups. Now is that down to us having better players? Does that mean that Moyes is better with resources?

I don?t have an answer on that, but I wouldn?t mind if a long-term plan was forged by Everton and players were sold, eg, Jags etc for decent money and we built up a decent transfer fund... although short term we might drop a few places in the league, but that is another debate.

Back to my thinking last night: so, although Swansea are playing the right type of football to take them into the top four, they don?t have the players to do it, so would changing the manager make any difference? Using the logic that Moyes gets the best league position out of all those managers without money, then you would have to conclude that changing the manager might change the style of play but we would still be top 6 at best.

One could go further with the argument and say if Moyes can assemble a team which out-performs those with no money, if you give him money, he will out perform them too. However, as James has pointed out, this will not be a great brand of football. The conclusion with my thinking was: give Moyes money and he would get you a trophy-winning side. In fact, I would go as far as to say it would consistently win... but the football would be poor and there might be a lot of 1-0 victories. If we got Rogers in and gave him money, then we would be less consistent in winning but we would always be in the mixing pot and playing better football.

The question then comes: is it about watching good football or having a reputation as a team which is hard, if not impossible, to beat? As I sat and watched Bayern v Real, I thought it would be great to watching entertaining football, However, it was interesting that the panel afterwards, when speaking about Chelsea v Barcelona, all agreed that Barcelona had a better side and therefore Chelsea?s best chance was disruption and grabbing a goal ? a far cry from the attacking flowing football they displayed on Sunday.

So is that why the pundits love Moyes? He has beaten Man City, Chelsea, Tottenham... the underdog can win. How often is the phrase 'playing poorly but winning' used on MotD?

So is football about entertainment or winning? Those teams which have come up and ?played? their game but gone back down have only every got an afterthought of praise; might as well say thanks for giving it a try... but clubs which stay up get praise, even when winning ugly. However, fans don?t want to just win ? they want to win with style, which creates a problem because, to win with style means good players... and good players means money.

I think, for too many fans, it has become all about the winning and who cares what the football looks like. They cite what Moyes has done and say, as I have outlined above, out of all the managers with no money, who is out-performing him?

The other fans sit there saying, "We want entertainment, we are paying money week-in & week-out to watch players play well..." but, as well as a team plays, surely the elation comes from winning? I don?t think I have ever left a game thinking, "Well, we played well but got whipped 3-0, so I am happy."

Walking to the office on a Monday, I don?t think I have ever thought, "Who cares, we lost; I have bragging rights over the way we played." If anything, hitting the post twice, crossbar, playing amazing football and losing to a long throw or set-piece because the opposition decided to ?park the bus?, I go home deflated and annoyed; I feel cheated by football.

So are the fans who say "It's all about winning" right? I think the answer lies in the middle: having a team which can adapt is key, thus play flowing attacking football when you are playing rubbish (Wolves at home) and a more defensive and counter-attacking style when up against it, like playing Barcelona and the like.

No fan is going to begrudge a team getting the odd ugly win but, when that number starts creeping above 10 games, fans start to think "Is this really worth the money?" So some of what Moyes has taught Everton ? pressing, good defending ? does have it?s place, but when playing 10-man Chelsea, we should be attacking and pushing like Bayern did last night and, more often than not, we will get our reward; Arsenal and Man U are two teams who do this consistently.

So, could the answer lie in different backroom staff at Everton? Would Moyes consider being a Number 2? I don?t think either of those two options are great possibilities but players like Gibson with their experience at good clubs should be used to make the team more rounded.
Joe Bibb
247 Posted 18/04/2012 at 21:12:37
To all of you who quote no money etc, Martinez at Wigan has done in the last fortnight what Moyes hasn't done in ten years and that is to win at Arsenal and Liverpool.
Howard Don
248 Posted 18/04/2012 at 23:43:09
Ridiculous Joe (313) Wigan are constantly flirting with relegation, which is exactly what we used to do in the years before Moyes arrived.
James Stewart
249 Posted 19/04/2012 at 00:48:43
Tim, I think Moyes's biggest weakness is his complete inability to evolve or improve. Like you said if he were handed 100m we would still be set up the exact same way. The biggest problem however for me is that I just cannot see how he will ever leave. He is the 12th highest paid football manager in the world! He is highly unlikely to ever willingly leave a contract like that despite how ever many of us are sick of his antifootball

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads