Moyes calls for retrospective action for divers

, 20 April, 19comments  |  Jump to most recent
David Moyes says that players who feign fouls or injury by diving should face retrospective disciplinary action and has vowed to fine any of his players who try to con referees in this manner.

?There is one thing I would do with football," said the Everton manager. "I would have retrospective punishment on diving the same way they look back to see if somebody has elbowed someone.

?If it was me, the best way to make our referees' job easier would be to have retrospective punishment on diving because the players are so good at it, but if you check afterwards to see if they have done it and you find they did then you ban them.

?If the referee says he didn't see an incident and the Football Association panel looks in to it to see if somebody punched someone off the ball then why could they not doing it for diving? It would make the referee's job much easier.

?I've said to [my] players I don't want them diving. Of course people will go down but I don't like it and if I think they are going down outrageously cheaply I will say it to them and I think all managers will. I think in the end it comes back to haunt you."

Quotes or other material sourced from The Telegraph



Reader Comments (19)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Lyndon Lloyd
1 Posted 21/04/2012 at 00:44:52
I'm in complete agreement and tweeted the same thing last Sunday after Ashley Young's latest piece of theatrics.

It would be the easiest thing to do as well for the most obvious of cases.
Nick Entwistle
2 Posted 21/04/2012 at 01:20:06
The FA don't want their players officially branded cheats. Bad for the image. They much prefer gray areas where pundits talk of having the right to go down and my new pet hate 'genuine contact'.
Paul David
3 Posted 21/04/2012 at 01:21:03
Blatant diving should be a 5-match ban as standard.

In F1, when two cars come together, it is referred to a panel of ex-drivers to decide if someone is to blame or just a racing incident; football should do something similar for dives that are not obvious.

Also, it is easy to stop players who feign injury. Do what happens in rugby: the game carries on while the physio treats the player.

Cheating really needs to be clamped down on ? it's ruining our game. It's the reason I now enjoy watching rugby which is an honest sport.
Paul David
4 Posted 21/04/2012 at 01:33:54
Nick, I can't stand that either. That gormless twat Shearer is always saying it's a penalty because there has been contact, even though the contact isn't enough to knock over a 5-year-old girl.

Can't remember who it was but the commentator said about Young's dive against QPR that the ref had no choice, like it is now an acceptable part of the game.
Brian Waring
5 Posted 21/04/2012 at 10:32:54
There is never going to be any action taken, because there would be that many bans being handed out, it would be a bad image for the so-called best league in the world.

Also, I feel sorry for the refs at times, because if there is the slightest contact, it's a pen, because there has been contact, but the diving just makes it look a bad call by the ref.

I remember all the free kicks Arteta used to get, because of going to ground at the slightest touch, he was defended for doing it, and the defence was, it doesn't matter how much contact there was, there was still contact.
Phil McKeown
6 Posted 21/04/2012 at 10:57:46
Moyes's comments have again annoyed me.

Leading up to the FA Cup semi-final, Moyes had nothing but positive things to say about the Shite whilst Dogshit concentrated on themselves. Yet again, he is emphasising dignity at Everton Football Club. Yes, we can hold our heads up high with this outlook but ? when every other bastard is diving, feigning and getting in the refs minds and face ? who is losing out?

It almost seems like respect from his peers is more important than winning. Do the Red Shite give a fuck that Suarez and Dalglish are two of the most cheating obnoxious people in football? No, do they fuck.

Grow a set Moyes, it's no coincidence other managers and pundits praise you. It's cos you're not seen as a threat.
Dean Adams
7 Posted 21/04/2012 at 11:17:02
Personally I would be glad to see new rules that penalize players for diving. It is not acceptable and has no place in football. The sky 4/5 are the worst for it. When you challenge the fans of these clubs they always use the old "everyone does it" or "bad decisions even out over a season". The facts of course are that they dont. Clubs get relegated because decisions went against them, it happens every year. It just does not affect the top clubs because they get the media fawning over everything they do.

Five matches for cheating would be a start. Thet even try to use " its sportsmanship" as an excuse. Golfers dont cheat, so why should we tollerate it.

If a player dives for a second time in a season, the five match ban should be accompanied by a months wages as his fine. Maybe it could be paid to charities for ex pros or some other useful good cause!!
Kevin Sparke
8 Posted 21/04/2012 at 11:57:05
Good idea but will be impossible to police fairly.

EG Scenario One: - Player X - well known diver, has penalty after penalty refused him after league managers label him a well known diver who 'goes to ground easy.

Player X is Andy Johnson and had at least 8 legitimate penalties denied him and it cost his club dear - should he also have had a suspension for diving if the evidence is not clear on review whether he has dived or not? Or does his reputation as a 'well known diver, who goes to ground easy' and who doesn't play in next week's Champion's League quarter final sway the FA panel... remember - this is the FA we're talking about - that bastion of common sense and fairness.

Dean Adams
9 Posted 21/04/2012 at 12:25:06
Kevin - I know your point, but that scenario had our manager sending the FA video footage that clearly showed AJ was fouled, repeatedly. If he had played for Manure, Chesea or maybe the Arse, he would have had penalty after penalty and the media would have analysed the living daylights out of it until they had brainwashed the moronic masses that they cater to.
Jeff Beaumont
10 Posted 21/04/2012 at 12:03:58
Earlier in the season, I remember Osman accidentally tripping himself up & we were awarded a penalty. Should he have received a retrospective ban?

If the debate is basically about cheating, why not retrospectively punish all cheating ? grabbing opponent's shirt at corners; pinching 10 yards at throw-ins; stopping opponents taking a quick free-kick etc, etc, etc?

Or are we saying that some forms of cheating are acceptable?

Sadly in today's "win at all costs" mentality, I think maybe it is ? providing the decision is in our favour.
Ian Hams
11 Posted 21/04/2012 at 15:51:59
Hmm... maybe this would convince Jelavic to try a little harder to stay on his feet. I am beginning to realise the real reason my Rangers friends call him 'Jelly Fish'.
Nick Entwistle
12 Posted 21/04/2012 at 15:50:57
Because Jeff, none of those in their execution are to con the referee into believing something has happened that has not. And neither is it possible that a cheeky throw in means a straight red and penalty.
Eugene Ruane
13 Posted 21/04/2012 at 15:56:53
Jeff (068) - You ask..

"Earlier in the season, I remember Osman accidentally tripping himself up & we were awarded a penalty. Should he have received a retrospective ban?"

For tripping himself?

No.

But for sitting on the deck waving his arms about while pulling a dead narked grid and trying to fool everyone he had been clipped?

Absolutely!
Kev Jones
14 Posted 21/04/2012 at 16:53:29
If the EPL made a stand against it, half the more 'talented' players would bugger off back to the continent, leaving the EPL in a position where it's no longer the greatest division in the world, killing sponsorship & TV right potential worldwide. After all, Asia won't want to tune into see circa 1970 kicking-ten-bells-kick-and-rush whilst they can watch talented players play non-contact in leagues sympathetic to theatrics and cheating.

It's a case of 'we couldn't beat them, so now we've joined them'.

It's too late anyway, British kids are now getting coached from an early age to invite contact take a dive. We'd better get used to it.
Anthony Lamb
15 Posted 21/04/2012 at 17:30:41
Perhaps some of the comments in this thread sum up precisely why football in fact is simply unfit for purpose in its present state. David Moyes is absolutely right full stop - at least to those who believe that somehow the rules and their application have to wrested back from the players and the vested interests of clubs and the money men of the media etc. The erosion of respect for the rules of the game is catastrophic. The pulling and dragging in the penalty box from corners and free kicks; the ludicrous diving and cheating (personified perfectly by that abomination of a cheat Didier Drogba recently against Barcelona and going unpunished); the gradual "elimination' of the rule once known as obstruction; the obscenities mouthed at referees and linesmen; the current pushing of the limits viz a viz placing the ball in the quadrant at corners etc etc is seemingly endorsed by some here along lines such as "everyone else is doing it why shouldn't we? So in last year's riots we should simply go and help ourselves because everyone else is doing it should we? In the end it comes down to self-respect at the individual and collective levels and to authorities taking their responsibilities seriously. It is beyond the powers of referees at present to restore "ethics" to the game without first of all the raising of their own standards and a thorough appraisal and application of all the tools necessary to help them put players and their clubs - and their supporters -in their place. And that "place" is if you are playing the game then you are subject to the rules and laws of the game. I for one do not want to "get used" to any grandson of mine being coached to dive etc. David Moyes is spot on and if he IS making efforts to address it we should all be behind him - whatever we may think of his tactical acumen after the semi-final etc!!
Paul David
16 Posted 21/04/2012 at 18:35:13
Kev 116

If it means we get to see an honest game of football I could not give a fuck if talented cheats fuck off to play in other leagues were they can get away with it.

The thing is that clamping down should be done by all governing bodies from fifa down so there is no where these players can hide.
David Stewart
17 Posted 22/04/2012 at 10:52:28
After the debacle that's just happened in today's Australian A-League final, I'm afraid retrospective action ain't gonna achieve anything unless the penalty (if scored) is cancelled and by then it's all too late.

Today's game, Brisbane v Perth, 1 - 1 in the 94th minute when a Brisbane player takes a dive that would have made Tarzan proud. Ref fucks up big time and gives the penalty, Brisbane win 2 - 1, so it's no good having a retrospective talkfest unless we are willing to cancel the goal and replay the game ? and we all know that ain't gonna happen.

Maybe if we want to get serious and clean out the cheats, it's time for video replays when the incident happens; otherwise, we have to accept that players will cheat and continue to be a blight on the game.
Colin Grierson
18 Posted 22/04/2012 at 22:49:39
Well said Moyes. Spot on.

I might not always agree with the ginger one but I'm right behind him with this.
Nick Waters
19 Posted 23/04/2012 at 19:16:56
What about retrospective action against managers who simulate trying to win semi-finals?

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads