Manchester United 4 - 4 Everton

, 22 April, 457comments  |  Jump to most recent
Fellaini, Jelavic and Pienaar immense
Everton fought back from 3-1 and 4-2 down to draw an incredible contest at Old Trafford. Wayne Rooney headed in Nani's cross to cancel out Nikica Jelavic's opener. Welbeck and Nani gave United a two-goal cushion before Marouane Fellaini pulled one back with a volley. Rooney appeared to have sealed victory when he slotted home, only for Everton to score twice in three minutes through Jelavic and Steven Pienaar to secure a brilliant comeback score draw.

Match Summary

Everton kicked off and pushed United form the start. Some really neat football down the left saw some great passing among Fellaini and Pienaar, Osman chasing the final bobble ball and heading just wide. Fellaini was back to cut out United's first attack but hoofed clearances were not helping the cause.

Osman then played to a superb run from Jelavic, pulling well wide of his marker but his shot from a golden position was weak and saved too easily by De Gea. Pienaar then picked out a run by Osman who shot was low but wide of the far post rather than going for the nearpost shot.

After totally dominating the first 10 mins, Everton allowed the The Reds to poke a few shots in on Howard, Heitinga losing the ball a little too easily.

Everton were seeing glimpses of light through the middle, with Fellaini and Pienaar exploiting space, Osman and Jelavic running into good positions. Everton put more pressure on the home side with some dangerous crosses, fierce shot from Osman blocked away.

United were pressing on the half-hour the ball getting to see a little more of Haward's gloves but Gibson got up filed and drilled one wide. But some more great work in the middle by Pienaar allowedd Gibson to feed Hibbert for a very deep cross to the far post, where Jelavic headed it perfectly back over De Gea and in off the far post! Another excellent strike.

Howard was very lucky to stop a tripple deflection driven at him through the crowd by Scholes as United looked to respond.

And 5 mins before the break, Nani beat Hibbert with a superb cross that Neville could not jump high enough for and Rooney in behind him had a simple task to complete with an easy header to level things. Advantage lost again by the Blues.

Fellaini again played in Osman for a great little run forward but the final powder-puff shot was poor as Pienaar's run made excellent space for him. Jelavic tried something acrobatic on a difficult cross from Pienaar. Distin was then given a ridiculous yellow card when Valencia lost his balance and fell over Really, the Blues should have made more of their stunning first-half dominance... but what sort of Blue side would appear after the break this week, having surrendered another lead?

Everton came out with good enough intent, Gibson, Fellaini and Pienaar all playing good forward balls, searching out Jelavic, while aat the back, some tenacious defending was required, Neville coming in strongly on Ferdinand, we decided to extract some afters and should have been booked for his reaction.

But increasing United pressure finally paid off, thanks in part to a criminal failure by the Everton defence to clear the ball properly on two occasions, allowing a brilliant piece of skill from Welbeck after Heitinga turned the wrong way, allowing the young striker to curl a brilliant shot past Howard. Moyes will complain that Pienaar was out of the play, down after overstretching, but he had not been fouled.

From a one-nil lead to two-one down... sounds familiar? And United then waltzed far too easily through a static Everton defence, Nani with plenty of time to clip the ball past Howard and make it 3 - 1. More United pressure could have seen more goals as Moyes reacted to the reverse by swapping Osman for McFadden, the Blues in danger of imploding after such a wonderful 40 mins in the first half, where they failed to take the chances created and now looked to have paid the price.

But a neat move involving McFadden and another good cross form Hibbert allowed Fellaini to smack him a difficult hip-high volley to make the score 3 - 2. More good work saw excellent forward play and Pienaar set up for a good strike that was saved by De Gea.

But it didn't take before another far too easy move sliced open the Everton defence, Rooney stroking home from close range and Everton rocked back at 4 - 2 with 20 mins left to play.

Despite the scoreline, Everton did at least try to keep up the forward momentum, although quite what McFadden was doing with one forward pass was anyone's guess. Pienaar was still up for it but just failed to find Fellaini after a great turn in the Utd area.

More good work set up Jelavic but his shot into the side netting was lacking conviction as Everton kept attacking despite the depressing scoreline, McFadden and Fellaini combining nicely but not getting the end result. While at the other end, incredibly Man Utd failed to make it five with another with Nani and Evra combining to hit the post instead.

That seemed to spur the Blues to a slightly higher level as they pressed United back yet again, and Fellaini manged to head the ball into Jelavic's path, the Croatian powering in Everton's third goal as Cahill replaced Distin.

Really confident possession straight down the middle and the inside left channel then built Everton's best goal of the game, a great ball in to Fellaini who turned brilliantly and fed the perfect ball to Pienaar, who smacked it home in fine style!!! 4 - 4!!!

Five mins left, plus five mins of added time, and United desperate to swat aside the annoying Blues who had outplayed them substantially, SAF bringing on Hernandez for the big push, and it was finally Everton who were on the back foot, defending with increasing nervousness.

One clear-cut chance came to Ferdinandbut his shot was saved brilliantly by Howard, tipping over in the 94th minute, and that was it: 4 - 4, and a pretty astounding result. Some excellent attacking football form Everton,always playing positively... why oh why did they not play like this last weekend???

Everton: Howard; Hibbert, Jagielka, Distin (83' Cahill), Neville; Osman (63 McFadden), Heitinga, Gibson, Pienaar; Fellaini; Jelavic.
Subs not used: Mucha, Stracqualursi, Gueye, Barkley, Anichebe.

Quotes or other material sourced from ToffeeWeb Match Report Page



Reader Comments (457)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


John Ford
1 Posted 22/04/2012 at 14:28:20
Fuck me I turned off at 4 - 2. What the fook?

You fucking beauty. Talk about Jekyl and Hyde!.....fookin get in!
Eric Myles
2 Posted 22/04/2012 at 14:30:14
After that performance the tactics in the semi final are even more indefensible.
Jem Traynor
3 Posted 22/04/2012 at 14:31:22
HA HA!!! What a game!!! COYB!!! Very hard to pick a MotM there although I would let Felli edge it in front of Pienaar. Class, everyone was absolutely Class!!!!
Michael Mulholland
4 Posted 22/04/2012 at 14:31:44
Put that in your pipe Fergie
Paul Ferry
5 Posted 22/04/2012 at 14:29:36
Great stuff. Pure bottle, this time. We have to keep Pienaar, have to. Fellaini was immense today, fucking immense. Jelly/Fella/Peanuts, that's three to build around. Truly impressive. Credit Moyes for setting up like that.

Real guts after 4-2. Loved seeing Jelly blowing kisses to the blues. One dank point: centre defence, deary me. Brilliant. That's why when all is said and done, we are blue and damn lucky to be so. Spirit.
Nick Entwistle
6 Posted 22/04/2012 at 14:30:02
I hope this result will remind people that we've been playing brilliantly in the league and that there's no reason to fear anyone. Which is the reason we were hoping to thrash Liverpool. This game is a continuation of the teams ability since the new year and their should be more belief from fans on this site because its tougher going on here than watching the games sometimes. Great game and I hope credit is given to all the right recipients.
Ed Fitzgerald
7 Posted 22/04/2012 at 14:33:31
Great performance a week too late though when it mattered, we bottled it.
Mark Riding
8 Posted 22/04/2012 at 14:34:55
He's got red hair... but we dont care..

What, too soon ?

A tale of two half time team talks ? Or just no real pressure at Old Trafford ?
Stu Gore
9 Posted 22/04/2012 at 14:34:41
Great game. Love that we now have a threat up front. Good interplay for the goals. Felli immense. Some really great crosses from Hibbert. Jags and Heitinga = goals against tho. Wonder why they can't play together?
Kevin Sparke
10 Posted 22/04/2012 at 14:38:36
That makes only 3 losses in 18 - (pity two were against Liverpool) 12 wins in 22...

Great game of football but if you were a defence coach you'd be tearing your hair out

More attacking football please blues... Jelavic is the best natural forward we've had at Everton since Gary Lineker - use him and Fellaini in that role more often.
Derek Williams
11 Posted 22/04/2012 at 14:40:42
The second half no show against the RS now even harder to understand, Man Utd being a far better team than them.

Whats done is done but well done the boys and Moyesy on today's never say die approach.

Dontcha love Jelly?
Jonathan Steinmetz
12 Posted 22/04/2012 at 14:44:02
I wonder if the boys could have squeezed out a 5th if Baines were fit. Fellaini looked terrific in an advanced position.
Jem Traynor
13 Posted 22/04/2012 at 14:41:05
Stu, I think it's a Work in Progress? But I agree, what a comeback though I'm made up they did it like we know they can! After that it makes it harder to believe Liverpool are still in the Cup the way we can play and the way they play!

Oh well, I'm a lot better for seeing a game like that but would like to see us do better now with having a natural finisher in front of goal. Let's get the players we need in, like Pienaar back and get those kids into the mix and push on!
Kevin Sparke
14 Posted 22/04/2012 at 14:45:14
And the ref was an absolute homer...
Ian Riddell
15 Posted 22/04/2012 at 14:46:03
@Eric. Great Toffeeweb post. Every silver lining has a cloud!
James Martin
16 Posted 22/04/2012 at 14:45:30
Great result, once again we had the usual Everton problem when they're down and the pressure is off they play well, when they're ahead or with a chance of winning they freeze and aren't sure how to win, but after last week at least we can go back to reading the newspapers again.
Keith Glazzard
18 Posted 22/04/2012 at 14:44:44
Fellaini fabulous - as good as anyone in the Prem. And Jelovic is a gem.

Very good draw - the ref must have been gutted.
Danny James
19 Posted 22/04/2012 at 14:50:56
One more goal and we have a player in double figures. Jelly baby all the way.
Steve Lowe
20 Posted 22/04/2012 at 14:52:53
Where the fuck was that team last week??? See what we can do if we have a go... Shit or bust for the rest of the season !
Paul David
21 Posted 22/04/2012 at 14:43:50
I am surprised and proud of that performance.I have to admit I feared the worst when I seen the line up but we didnt play for a draw.Thats all we have been asking for,to not be scared of teams and take the game to them.

Our defending could have been a little bit better but lets not worry about that now.There was very few long balls and we proved when get the ball down and play we can be a match for anyone.

The goals we scored were great but what a difference it makes when you have a player you can rely on to put the ball in the back off the net.

It could have been even better if it wasnt for the ref,could not wait to blow his whistle for every fair tackle we made.How he can stop play for Evans yet allow utd to score after Pienaar went down is nothing short of blatent cheating and were did 5 minutes injury time come from.

I'll never forgive Moyes for whats happened this last few weeks and this game showed why.Look what can happen when you try to win a game instead of trying not to get beat.
Peter Laing
22 Posted 22/04/2012 at 14:51:56
Moyes needs to shuffle his pack in the summer, the team needs tobe built around Fellaini and Jelavic with Pienaar signed up permanently. Would be looking for offers on Jags and Rodwell, phase out the likes of Neville and Cahill.
Christine Foster
23 Posted 22/04/2012 at 14:51:02
Its so hard being an Evertonian, from the depths of despair one week to glimmers of hope the next, from no bottle to no giving up.
Cannot take anything away from the lads today, wonderful goals, chased from the off, penned them in and the goals were good ones, 4 no less, away from home.. I would love to know why the same tactics weren't used last week, but I'll take the point and the pride that goes with it.
David Booth
24 Posted 22/04/2012 at 14:53:46
Where the f*ck did FIVE minutes of extra time come from?????????

If ever there was proof that there is some form of conscious, or unconscious, bias in favour of them in every home game, that was it.
Anto Byrne
25 Posted 22/04/2012 at 14:37:20
Other than Rooney's first goal that Neville should have done better with, and not sure what Howard was doing with the cross, it was a great result.

At 4 - 2, I was expecting us to go further behind; as soon as Osman went off, we looked a lot better going forward and patient on the ball.

McFadden can play a bit it would seem.

Not sure why we had to have 3 central defenders getting in eachother's way. Tony Hibbert was outstanding today and that cross to Jelavic was superb.

Fellaini... words fail me what a player, what a volley and good work setting up Pienaar.

Happier than I was a week ago but Moyes ain't off the hook.

Have the wheels come off at Spurs? Will we run them down? All to play for eh?
Paul Mackie
26 Posted 22/04/2012 at 14:52:50
@Eric - #340

Exactly my thoughts. How can Moyes dare justify trying to defend a 1 goal lead against the shite and then let the players of the leash at Old Trafford. Unbelievable.
Neil Pickering
27 Posted 22/04/2012 at 14:55:15
To mr moyes,

See what happens when u just have a go?

Made up, but in a funny sort of way that makes last weeks result even harder to take. If we had gone at the shite like we did utd today the game would have been over after an hour.
Peter Laing
28 Posted 22/04/2012 at 14:58:23
Fellaini was different class today, immense performance from the big fella !
John Nugent
29 Posted 22/04/2012 at 14:58:08
Five min highlights (foreign comms)

http://www.101greatgoals.com/gvideos/manchester-united-4-everton-4/
Jim Hourigan
30 Posted 22/04/2012 at 14:58:57
Great performance and great attitude but why did last week happen? I'll enjoy the moment but it doesn't make up for the last 2 derbies
Paul Ferry
31 Posted 22/04/2012 at 14:57:35
6 goals = 6 x 30 secs. That's three of the five minutes sorted. Couple of injuries = 2mins. 5 mins, sorted.
Dan McKie
32 Posted 22/04/2012 at 14:55:55
Great performance today, and we never looked beaten even when 4-2 down. I wouldn't criticise Moyes half as much as I do if we could at least show that kind of intent each week, regardless of who we are playing. We have good players who can give anybody a game so forget their qualities, and focus on ours, forget respect, we owe nobody anything. Go out and attack and the results will come what may.
Andy Walker
33 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:02:49
Fantastic performance, Pienaar makes such a difference. Moyesy must take massive credit for picking up the players after last week, it would have been easy to wallow in self pity and give up. Positivity, positivity, positivity. Let's carry on.
Robin Hunuki
34 Posted 22/04/2012 at 14:59:50
What a game!

Kept faith whilst being told to give up from my United "band wagon-er" mates at 3-1 and 4-2!!

I'm not defending Moyes at all re: last weeks events but it does make a difference when you've got Pienaar on the pitch. Nonetheless, hats off to the boys today, did us proud! MotM Felli, with Pienaar a close second.

Where that 5mins of extra time came from... who knows, the prick!
Rahman Talib
35 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:07:40
Would anybody agree with me that Jagielka is too soft and the reason why we cannot defend against 3 out of the 4 Manure goals?
James Robinson
36 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:06:17
Several great performances today but one of the key differences to last weeks capitulation is Peinar. He is one of the few, if not only, players we have who you can give the ball too in a tight situation who has the ability to keep it and make something happen, when there seems to be nothing on. LAst week it just kept coming straight back at us after every clearance.
Paul Smith
37 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:03:23
Blindin game, chuffed to fook. Just shows what an attacking mentality can achieve, score 1 and we`ll score more. Even if we would've lost, the effort and spectacle of seeing Everton play positive attacking football is a sight for sore eyes!! No abuse for the team today, just plaudits.
Ed Fitzgerald
38 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:04:31
Lets face it a great result, tremendous attitude, showng opponents little or no respect all great stuff, however it makes no difference that Moyes shit himself last week when we had the chance to beat the RS last week at Wembley and in the league derby.

Hansen et al will be on tonight purring what a great manager he is and how we are holding him back! 65k a week and the 12th best paid manager in the world.
Andy Walker
39 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:10:51
Pienaar makes a big difference as hit fits into our style of play perfectly, wasnt the case a spurs who rely on two fast wingers and quick counter attacking. Hopefully we can find the money to buy him but he wont be cheap now hes on a long contract. If we secure him then we have the making of one of the best blues sides for several years imo. Offloading Rodwell who flatters to deceive, maybe swap deal with Spurs who lets face it always go for style over substance, may work.
Ed Fitzgerald
40 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:12:15
James

If Pienaar is the reason for the transformation explain the 3-0 at Anfield?
David Hallwood
41 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:13:43
One thing that no ones mentioned is how our midfield nullifies Scholes & Carrick, it's a shame Baines wasn't playing as we would've been playing with a settled back 4. BTW lots of respect for Rooney, for the no celebration, great player can you imagine him and Jelli??"!!
Danny James
42 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:14:27
Moyes is a great manager!
Joseph Strumm
43 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:00:46
We can thank Fellaini, Pienaar and Jelavic for that face-saving point.

The end of the season must bring a cull: Osman, Neville, Cahill, Heitinga, Jagielka, Anichebe... uncle Bill cobbly and all. Time for change and a complete rebuild, this inconsistency is too much to take. Back-room staff also need to be culled and a return of the School of Science with the same philosophy of technical excellence running throughout the club from kids to first team. It's time for this sleeping giant to awaken.
Denis Richardson
44 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:11:49
Great game and actually fun to watch as we didn't just roll over and take it as per usual. I will say hats off to the manager and give credit where its due, for changing the formation and especially the attitude and also for not starting Cahill.

Not at all surprised to see that we can actually play football if given some license to do so.

(If i do have a couple of minor gripes (wouldn't be TW without them), I was really disappointed to see Macfadden on the bench, let alone actually coming on. Does not give a great confidence booster to the kids to see someone who wont be at the club in a months time ahead of them in the que.)

Overall a great come back and finally a good advert for the club on the telly.

Ian Glassey
45 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:14:08
Great comeback, were is everyone who was having a go at Felli yesterday. The lad is class and get Peanuts signed up in the summer..
Andy Meighan
46 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:07:42
It just shows what can be done when you go out in a positive frame of mind. I'll bet you even them bastards over there are wondering why we didn't play like that last Saturday...

Yes, we've conceded four but let's be honest here, we've scored four and could have had another two, that striker of ours has got ice running through his veins. I'll bet Dixie is turning slowly in his grave... Given the service, he'll get a shedful for us.

Piennar has got to be kept ? simple as that; pure class... and invaluable to us... and he weighs in with the odd goal as well. But special mention to Fellaini today, he was head and shoulders above anyone on that pitch ? absolutely awesome.

Why, oh why haven't we seen more of that from Moyes's Everton?!? I can never forgive him for March 13th and Wembley and the dross that's been served up this season... but that type of performance will go a long way.
Andy Walker
47 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:15:52
Ed, we didnt play well at Wembley but neither did Liverpool, in fact we were slightly better than them until we gifted them a goal. 1-0 up with less than 30 mins to go, I reckon we would probably have won if Distin had not made an elementary error, thats what lost the game pure and simple. Moyes set up for a tight game which is not unreasonable for 1) a derby 2) an FA Cup semi 3) at Wembley, knowing Liverpool would also set up accordingly. Just the worst individual mistake of the season had to come in the last 30 mins of the semi. Bad luck.
Phil Brown
48 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:12:54
Fantastic performance today, all you need is a positive attitude.

But only highlights what a few have been saying for a long time:

Play with a positive attitude;

Cahill should have been rested 18 months ago;

Still don't think that he gets the subs right.

However, brilliant let's build on that and get Barkley some game time in the support role behind Jely - last 30 mins of each game. i.e. Feli back into centre mid alongside Gibson and Ossie playing off Jely to start.

Feli was a threat in the air today but I think that was mainly down to poor defending by United.

Danny James
49 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:17:26
We have scored 4 goals twice now and both times Baines has not been playing.

Perhaps we rely on him to much as an attacking force? Perhaps with Baines we become too much of a one trick pony. We looked more on an attacking threat down the right and more balanced as a team

Hes played nearly 100 consecutive games. Perhaps this break whilst he is injured will enable the team to develop more and learn to be more creative from all areas of the park
Paul Ferry
50 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:18:06
Easy, Danny James, easy. Let's not get too carried away. Good day at the office today; in fact, a first-rate day at the office. It seems trite, I know, and I'm not pissing on the bonfire, but rolls back time eight days? No need to get overly excited here. Let's keep things in perspective.

This was one of his on days without any shadow of a doubt. Off and on, off an on, however, tends to be his favoured rhythm.
Tom Bowers
51 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:17:34
Funny how when Osman goes off we score 3 goals? Okay just a coincidence as it was who McFadden came on. Doesn't say much for the others on the bench.
Notwithstanding this was a surprising result mainly due to the fact that Moyes finally showed some guts and went for the win from the off. Yes it went pear shaped for a while but it was so refreshing to see Everton attacking so much right from the start against a team like Manure. Of course the question is why have they not done this in so many other games this season.
Andy Walker
52 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:26:33
Cant beleive theres only 50 posts on here in an hour after a brilliant come back. WHY?
Chris Smith
53 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:30:14
What a game. Fellaini, Pienaar and Jelavic were fabulous. Our defending wasn't great at times but I won't worry about that right now. We are much better going forward without Cahill it saddens me to say.
Paul Ferry
54 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:32:37
Coz Andy Walker, Mike and Co are working through a big backlog and/or an unknowable number of blues are walking around in a daze.
Paul Ferry
55 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:34:07
Oh, and Mr Walker, the forum is still buzzing.
James Robinson
56 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:24:58
Ed Fitzgerald- what are you on about? so just cause peinar played that game and we lost, he is no good? Even George Best didn't win every game singlehandedly. Peinar was great today and has made a massive difference since coming back to us. To pick out one game where we got beat and use it to condemn his impact just seems childish, especially when we had below full strengh team starting that game.
Trevor Lynes
57 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:29:31
Felli had his best game since he arrived and everyone showed all the bottle that was missing against Liverpool... I really feared for today's game but I have to say I was proved totally wrong by the most unpredictable side we have produced for yonks.

Man Utd looked shell-shocked and Fergie blamed bad defence from them and did not credit us at all. He said our goals were soft and Utd's goals were all great... what a load of sour grapes!! I hope Mancini beats him to the title.

I still think we need replacements for next season but give DM his due, he picked up the players from last weeks debacle and brought some pride back !!!!!
COYB and FOLLOW THE JELAVIC ROAD !!!!!!
Mike Hughes
58 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:32:15
Was listening to the match on my headphones when out on a 10 mile run. I must have looked like a compete nutcase when we scored the 4th running through Pensby.

A week too late but onwards and upwards.

Now where's my Baggies shirt?
Andy Walker
59 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:34:52
TW come on - just seen your headline STILL NO WINS IN 10.. but an excellent draw.'
How about 'AN EXCELLENT DRAW.. but still no wins in 10.'
Lets be positive!!!!!!!
Phil Rodgers
60 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:35:01
Excellent match. Credit to Moyes for making the right decisions this time. We were fantastic apart form a ten minute spell either side of halftime. Jelavic and fellaini really worked for us today. If we had defended half as good as we are capable we would've won the game.
Robin Hunuki
61 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:36:54
I told my mate who is a Baggies fan to wish his side luck on my behalf...

I then told my other mate who is a Reds fan to fuck off...

Thats fair, right?
Mike Hughes
62 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:39:51
...by the way West Brom have won more away than the RS have at home.

Come on Woy, your boys can do it!
Stephen Kenny
63 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:37:20
Andy,

Most just probably feel like a point at OT, which is all it is, doesn't make up for a season's worth of capitulation against the shite.
Ed Fitzgerald
65 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:38:34
James

Im not blaming Pienaar for the derby result but it was you that claimed his absence last week was partly the reason for the defeat. to the RS. I blame one person for the defeat last week a certain millionaire manager.

Danny James - He is a great manager really, please tell me what he has won at Everton or Preston?
Andy Walker
66 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:42:52
As balanced as it gets Robin. Come on the baggires.
Peter Jansson
67 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:41:40
Absolutely a great game of football today!

I am sick and tired of the negativety of the fans on this website.

Get real Everton has a very limited budget. Still we are ahead of the RS in the league.

It is ridiculous to demand that Everton should win anything as long as 5-10 other teams are spending tons and tons of cash buying players.

Great stuff today! COWB!
Neil Eccles
68 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:43:27
Just can't understand how we got such a result without Drenthe ?
Craig Mills
69 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:42:39
We need to stop bringing up last week's Wembley woes and post comments about a fantastic game today. Best performance of the season for me, we were fearless in our approach and clinical with our finishing.

I'm already looking forward to next season and with Jelavic in from the start we have for the first season in many, a truely class act ? well done, Davey, for taking the chance with him, another brilliant buy
Kevin Tully
70 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:35:21
Jelavic is definitely something to build around next season. He is a predator in the box alright. If we can get the Baines- Pienaar axis working again, imagine the goals they could put on plate for this guy.

We also need to address the right hand side for service into the box. Time for Moyes to clear out Osman, Cahill and possibly Jagielka if he would get the money to re-invest.

A completely different way of playing today - attacking the big boys in their own back yard. More please.
David Hallwood
71 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:46:28
Who cares about the game today......c'mon you baggies!!!!, only jesting gents
John Crossley
72 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:49:09
We attacked away from home! Superb result and performance, well done lads.
Andy Walker
73 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:46:17
Ed, had Moyesy brought himself on at left back and I missed it? It was Distins error, no manager can be held resposnible for a one off error as glaringly bad as that one. It happens, we just have to get on with it and that's exactly what happened today. Moyes deserves massive credit for getting the players into the right frame of mind and totally motivated for today. lesser sides would have rolled over. The players want to play for him, pure and simple and that's the first key skill a manager needs. Moyes has it no question.
David Hallwood
74 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:49:23
How about this for next season Kevin #411
Howard, Coleman, Heitinger, Distin Baines, Donovan, Gibson Fellaini, Pienaar, Dempsey Jelovic. I would love to see Coleman with Donovan in tandem as Donovan can provide cover for Coleman's defensive frailties.

The only drawback would be that Donovan, Dempsey & Pienaar are nudging 30-right put the football manger away
Kevin Sparke
75 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:53:03
Drenthe - who was he again?

Saiful Yusoff
76 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:54:17
Shame on you for those who thought Everton will be battered today. Credit to Moyes, he wants to win it badly and almost achieved that. I never doubt his capability as the Everton Manager. Can anyone share with me when was the last time MU failed to win at Old Trafford after had 2 goal advantages in the last 15 mins.
Eric Myles
77 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:57:47
Baines - who was he again?

Now we can see what we will be like next season when he's sold in the summer.
Mark Riding
78 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:57:46
David #416 -

How about going after Jelavic's Croatia team mate / strike partner Klasnic who is out of contract soon at Bolton ??
Dan Parker
79 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:59:07
Follow the Jelavic road!!
Ed Fitzgerald
80 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:51:41
Andy

People are wetting themselves because we get a point at OT. For a more objective look at his record against the top four teams consider the past ten years. What games have we won away from home against a top four side?

We did beat Chelsea on pens in the cup and beat Man U reserves on pens in the SF against Liverpool, Chelsea, Arsenal - I think the answer is zero. I am happy for any Moyesophile to tell me different or have I been dreaming the last ten years.
Andy Walker
81 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:57:53
David thats 8 attack minded players out of 11!
Steve Brown
82 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:59:33
Let's give the moaning a rest for once and celebrate a superb results. To fight back from 4-2 down at OT was a real achievement.

More importantly the way we played - real guts - never mind the training ground can we all have a whip round to buy Stevie Pienaar?
James Robinson
83 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:59:36
Looks like Drenthe is deffo off in the summer if not already gone foor good. However if we fail to get Peinaar back we will be back to the same old shit, with some decent players but no creativity to make things happen. Just hope Spurs don't take this piss on his valuation, after all he barely played for them all season.
Andy Walker
84 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:00:29
Ed nice to here from you, lets try and kill the postive mood! What you drinking? Is it half empty?
Steve Brown
85 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:02:18
Ed Fitzgerald, you must be a barrel of laughs at parties, cheer up FFS.
Paul Smith
86 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:01:27
Oh I don't think your ready for this jelly.......
Oh I don't think.......
Richard Dodd
87 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:02:16
As someone said in the Freshy-it was a perfect job interview for Moyes.(Fergie`s even going to give him his watch!)
Paul David
88 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:59:58
Ed I want Moyes out myself but we only ever go to OT in hope rather than expectation.

Yes its only a point but it was the manner in which it was earned that was pleasing.If Moyes had adopted this aproach for the last 3 years i'd still be singing his praises every week.

I really hope he has seen the error of his ways and this game wasnt a one off.
Graham Mockford
89 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:57:45
David #416 nice team but that would involve buying three players, one of whom is not available for sale.

I also don't see Seamus Coleman being a Premier League quality right back and I suspect Phil Neville has at least one more season in him. As ever, he is always underated, usually one of the first for the boo boys. But his qualities (and limitations) were there for all to see today. We go 4-2 down and he rattles into a tackle that tells everyone including his own teammates this game ain't over.
Ed Fitzgerald
90 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:03:56
Cheer up! Lets see how cheerful you will feel if Stevie G La is waving the FA Cup at St.Georges Hall in May then think about how it could and should of been us.
Kevin Sparke
91 Posted 22/04/2012 at 15:57:30
If there's been a game this season with 8 better goals then I've not seen it. Everton carried on where they left off before they met Liverpool in the cup and continued the fine attacking, one touch football they're becoming known to play since Jelavic joined the club.

The stats of the game display how we took the match to Manchester United (who were imperious in attack - Rooney really is a wonderful footballer... wonder where he learnt his trade?) - we had marginally less possession and only 3 fewer strikes at goal, but were penalised by a picky ref nearly twice as much as Manchester United.

It's not numbed the pain of last week - not by a long chalk... but I can see that the vast improvement in Everton's style of play and win ethic that started as Jelavic and Pienaar became available for selection.

We're in a win/win situation with Jelavic - I'd love to see him stay and continue this goal a game (almost) score ratio... but even if we have to sell him in the future - £25 million would be my starting price...

Sometimes the Everton supporting lark pays off
Ed Fitzgerald
92 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:06:26
Paul

I admire your optimism mate, I have hoped and prayed for the best part of ten years that David Moyes would realise that attacking football is the best form of defence its never going to happen.

Anyway I will leave you all to your Moyes love in and when we look at the league table tomorrow we will probably be 8th great point or not, when we could have tried to feckin win at Anfield!
James Robinson
93 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:05:54
As ever we finish a season well and 2 or 3 signings away from a really decent team. However as ever we will fail to bring anyone in and will go back to square one. Has been the same for so long now.
Mike Keating
94 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:05:53
Pity we didn't play like that against the RS (ManUre a much better side).
We would be in the Cup Final
I think Hibbert was MOTM
Loved the look an Sir Bacon Face the end not to mention Rio's ugly gob.
COYB
Paul Ferry
95 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:06:51
Re #421: With what we know about Klasnic ? his attitude to women and charge-sheet, he ought to be lined up to join the Shite. That would then be: Bellamy, Carroll, Gerrard, Downing, Klasnic, Suarez, and that frightening looking skinhead in defence. Ah Nessie, Shanks would be turning in his grave,
Andy Gleaves
96 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:08:27
ARGHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!! I probably share this sentiment with the majority of fans, The life of Evertonians is never easy or straight forward is it?? If only today was last Saturday we probably would be in the Final etc etc, but not to be!! Anyway I absolutely slated Moyes last week, probably 40% rightly so and 60% out of anger & frustration!! But Massive credit to MOYES today and the players for going at it and not lying down and giving in!! Well done today, Everton!!
Andy Walker
97 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:07:43
Ed what happens to a room of people when you walk into it?
Paul David
98 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:14:52
Ed I hope Moyes sets his teams up like this every week,I dont think he will though but I want to enjoy Everton yes EVERTON being involved in one of the best games of football i've seen in a long time.
Ed Fitzgerald
99 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:14:44
Andy

I take it you are a season ticket holder and have been for many years have you?
Paul David
100 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:19:05
Ed I am a season ticket holder and have been for many years,this year was the first time I had to think about getting a new one or not.I am sick at the total non football at Goodison so just enjoy this match while you can.
Paul David
101 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:19:05
Ed I am a season ticket holder and have been for many years,this year was the first time I had to think about getting a new one or not.I am sick at the total non football at Goodison so just enjoy this match while you can.
Kevin Sparke
102 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:22:28
Oh stop your fucking moaning Paul - you'd make a glass eye wince.

Non football my fat hairy arse...
James Robinson
104 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:21:34
While I can understand people being critical of Moyes and often rightly so, surely Kenwright is by far the bigger problem here. Lets enjoy this result but not forget that to progress next season we really need Kenwright to go ASAP. Otherwise it will be Fellaini out and not Peinar and Donavan etc in, which is what we all want.
Andy Walker
105 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:19:55
Ed, I watched my first game in 69 and was a season ticket holder from 78-89 then moved away due to work and now only get chance to get to go a few times a season, last game being Spurs. I have managed to convert my wife from the dark side as well. What's this got to do with draining the life out of such a positive day though? Enjoy the result today it was fabulous, if you can't enjoy a performance like today then what's the point.
Paul David
106 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:24:59
Kevin I am telling Ed to stop moaning and enjoy what was a great game but if you want to get into it you tell me when was the last time you was entertained at Goodison?

Not hard fought wins over better teams but actually entertained.
GJ Butler
108 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:30:22
Have to give a shout to McFadden. Thought he played well when he came on.
Ed Fitzgerald
109 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:27:55
Paul

You are wasting your time. I have been a seasonn ticket holder for since 1975 and went to my first game in 1968. Moyes may have you all convinced it has to be his way or we all doomed as the Scottish one out of Dad's Army used to say...

Andy, it's his fear I have an issue with. I don't want to respect Liverpool, I want us to attack them, not build them up before games, saying we are the underdogs etc. I want him to say of course we can beat them. Well done on the wife!
Mark Gittins
110 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:36:58
Did anyone hear Graeme Sourness after the game saying Fellaini could/should play up front.... what do you reckon? Move him upfront with Jelavic?
Paul David
111 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:37:15
Ed I am not fooled by Moyes and I still want him out but today was a really good performances and I cant slate Moyes today for doing what I've wanted him to do for years.

Call him out when he gets its wrong (a lot) but give him credit when its due.
Rahman Talib
112 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:24:23
I like Jamie Mac. He knows how to play with hibbert. He places the ball well for Hibbert to sock into dangerous areas. Hibbert's cross is crucial considering the number of right footed midfielders we have.

We must maintain the Jamie Mac-Hibbert partnership
Brian Denton
113 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:43:12
Credit when due, criticism when due; seems fairly reasonable to me.
David Hallwood
114 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:35:10
Thnanks for the comments about my fantasy football team, just a bit of fun. BTW when was the last time we scored 4 in consecutive league games.

I'm watching the Citteh game and the missus came in and said she couldn't understand why a city has two teams and why isn't there just one team in Manchester, London and Liverpool. After all these years, she still doesn't get it
Eugene Ruane
115 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:12:35
It was a great result and a good performance over all.

Jelli looks a natural, Fellaini continues to impress and we NEED (to sign) Piennar.

However some (ie: Andy Walker - a poster who presumably won't buy batteries because there's a negative on one end) need to get a grip.

Today there was nothing to play for (for us) and (fortunately) they were a little nervy.

I'm more than happy with a 4-4 at United but ffs we NEED to keep questioning everything - if we don't, WE (imo) allow things to slip.

For those (like me) who believe we can achieve just as much (and maybe more) by playing attacking football (or maybe more accurately, not stupidly defensive and dull football, a la City away) this needs to be pointed out...often!

Never understood the need (given this is a discussion forum) for anyone to post what is basically "Oh come on, turn that frown upside down".


James Robinson
116 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:45:44
Agree McFadden did pretty well when he came on. Strange signing but fair play on todays cameo.
Dan Brierley
117 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:20:09
I do not understand why people continually re-live games we have lost? We have lost 5 games, and won 11 this year. Nobody can deny the progress this team has made, since Moyes made his signings in January. Clinging onto losses as though it is the norm seems to be ridiculous. 16 goals in the last 6 matches shows a very different picture. Instead, people want to focus only on the games against Liverpool.

To me, it's ancient history. You sometimes win, and sometimes lose. Regurgitating the same crap about something that has passed seems like such a waste of energy. If Moyes can keep Pienaar in the team and add to the quality this summer, then I see good things for us next season, especially now we have a decent striker.

Truly proud today, some quality performances. Instead of people holding their hands up and saying 'I was wrong before the game to say we will roll over', instead the general consensus moves to the standard position of 'I told you we would play better if we attack!!'.

Against Liverpool, the majority were screaming about the fact that Felli was played up front, this week people are saying 'told you he should play up front!!' It's funny as fuck seeing just how fickle we are sometimes.
Rahman Talib
118 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:44:51
Am also concerned about both our center backs. At least two of those goals are soft goals.
Paul David
119 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:44:44
Mark my view is in most matches we should play with two proper forwards,Jelavic would be a constant treat if he had a patner to help him out and make space for him.Theres no reason why Fellaini still cant get up and support when we're on the attack.
Carl Lee
120 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:47:11
So much better going forward without a certain Mr Tim Cahill.

Back four was poor today, but I think that could be to the reshuffle of players, I will be happy when Distin and Heitinga are back in the middle again.
Rahman Talib
121 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:47:44
To me, Jamie Mac's only value to the team is his partnership with Hibbert. He keeps feeding Hibbert with passes enabling Hibbert to cross the ball more often.

That alone has activated our right side, making our attacking balanced.
Doug Nestor
122 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:49:13
Who gives a shit??.............A week too late for me..........only makes it even more un-defensible.........
Dave White
123 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:36:35
Fabulous that, just fabulous.

I still maintain we give ourselves the best chance to get a result when we work so hard to not allow the opposition time on the ball in midfield. We completely removed Paul Scholes from the game today.

Felli played the game of his life, he is without doubt worthy of being our record signing. Unconventional for certain, but so much of our best play both offensive and defensively went through him.

I am beginning to get very excited about Jelavic. And fair play to Distin, playing out of position. Is it just me or is Tony Hibbert getting better and better? You just watch, the fucker will score next!

After the way we played today I'd be tempted to let the leash off, and I bet that is going through Davey's mind just now....I'd rather draw 4-4 than 0-0 that's for sure!
Andy Walker
124 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:43:31
Ed, do you think Mancini really thought the title race was over, which he said in an interview even though Wigan had just beaten MU? Of course not, its basic reverse physcology to try and take pressure off his team. I'm sure Moyes 100% believed we were favourites to beat the RS last week, thats why he was so down after the game, he couldnt believe it. Like all of us.
Dave White
125 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:51:54
Christ Doug, cheer up mate. There are some phenomenally morose people on this site!
Paul David
126 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:52:52
Dave I agree with you on Hibbert today.Two assits today from quality crosses.Pushing your luck with a goal though.
Dan Brierley
127 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:51:38
Carl Lee, did you not see it was Heitinga who was mostly at fault today? Jagielka played much better than Heitinga, he seemed to always be in the right positions clearing headers and putting blocks in. I don't see why people cannot give Jagielka the credit he deserves.
Andy Walker
128 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:52:21
Eugene, you been opening crackers again for your jokes? Oh, forgot that would imply enjoying yourself. We played brill today, enjoy it!!! Life is to short, please stop trying to bring us all down by putting a downer on such a positive perfromance.
James Robinson
129 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:55:10
i worry that if we started playing Felli up top we would just default to long ball, much better to keep him in his best postition at CM and (wishful thinking) get in a speedy channel running striker to work for Jelavic.
Dave White
130 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:56:32
I think we've got 3 of the best centre backs in the league actually.

But, to end the love-in, I agree that James McFadden is a step back. I can only assume we're paying him fuck all.

And to start the love-in again, I thought Darron Gibson was superb.
Paul David
131 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:56:47
Dan, I noticed Heitinga let players run off him a few times; if we had to lay blame on someone, I'd have to say he should have done a bit better but you have to give credit to Utd. Their movement and short passes in the box were excellent and very hard to defend against.
Mike Keating
132 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:00:25
After the Sunderland game McFadden should have been ahead of Gueye in the semi given that Drenthe was dropped.

Can't believe that we let them off the hook & then play so well at Old Trafford!

Ernie Baywood
133 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:01:51
Cracking game and great to see us prepared to have a go at them.

That McFadden lad looked alright when he came on too. I reckon he could be the Scottish Rooney...
Dan Brierley
134 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:00:52
Paul, it's a fair point, it is harsh to criticise the 3rd or 4th goals. But watch the 2nd goal, he was shocking the way he jumped out of the way.

The 1st goal lies squarely on Neville's shoulders, Jags pointed out Rooney was spare, Neville was just too slow in getting goal side of him. And his reaction shows that he knew it...

Whilst I applaud our forward line today, our back line really has to be better.
Dave White
135 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:59:30
Eugene I agree with you, keep questioning and constructively criticising by all means. For example the 'you mark Rooney, no you mark Rooney' defending for the first goal was dreadful.

I just don't understand the 'well we were shit against Liverpool so fuck today' comments.
Dave White
136 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:05:05
Dan - Spot on.
Paul David
137 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:05:03
You're right, Dan, I don't know what was going through Jonny's mind for that goal, he must have thought Welbeck was going to pass and trying to cut it out meaning he made it easy for him to score.

How fantastic was it though to see our play in their box? It's refreshing to see we can score goals other than from crosses. You know things are going well when Neville starts playing through balls... ha!
James Morgan
138 Posted 22/04/2012 at 16:15:43
Andy Gleaves, your name rings a bell. From Leigh area?

Anyway, can't believe those who were slating Fellaini recently, he was great today like he has been all season.

Jelavic is just plain old awesome, can't find fault really. If we address our right hand side and start the season well, we could make a solid go at top 4 or 6 at least.
John Crawley
139 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:01:05
Good performance (apart from some of the defending) and for once we actually went for it at Old Trafford. I thought Fellainin and Jelavic upfront were a constant threat. In the middle of the park I thought it was Phil Neville who was driving us on and to me he played a lot better than Gibson.

Moyes looked distinctly uncomfortable when asked by Sky about this being a change from his normal practice of sitting and trying to keep it tight. Until he actually admits that he has made mistakes about the way he has approached games then I feel this type of response will remain the exception rather than the norm.

All-in-all, though, a greatly entertaining game and it just shows sometime fortune favours the brave! Interesting to hear the Gary Neville comments after the game I wonder if he has been chatting to Phil?
Terry McLavey
140 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:07:03
I think it was having Pienaar back made a lot of difference. I really didn't think we'd come back though, shame on me, but on past performances?

Fellaini did really well in his role today, playing against a team plus a ref in a red shirt! Let's hope Moyes could see the difference and keep to it! Do you think it's bit bit worrying we're all delighted with a draw?! Perhaps Moyesism is catching!! Great day though!
Mark Riding
141 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:14:38
How did Fellani look such a threat further forward today? And yet, last week when he swapped prominent forward roles with Cahill, he looked totally ineffective? As Fergie once said himself, 'football... bloody hell'.
Brian Waring
142 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:11:00
As my other half said "Thats the first time in ages I've seen you that excited watching Everton"

So all I can say is "Please sir, can I have some more.......?"

For me, today's game sort of rings true what a lot of lads said after the shite semi, that when the pressure is on us, we don't deliver, but when we're not expected to get anything, well........
James Stewart
143 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:11:48
Pienaar, Jelavic and Fellaini were sublime. We were really lucky Rangers were in dire straits and let us have Jelavic for loose change. Quality player and has transformed us.

Pienaar was immense and needs to be top priority to sign him up.

Fellaini was class but I don't agree he should be playing in an advanced role. He should be CM with licence to get forward yes but we really miss him if he isn't in CM breaking up the play too.

Hibbert deserves a mention for his excellent crossing. Sadly the rest of the defence was a shambles. Neville was has bad as I have seen him. 2 goals were directly his fault. Jagielka was poor as were Distin and Heitinga. Distin definitely does not work at left back.
John Audsley
144 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:16:24
Have to say that, with Gibson in the team and Pip in the centre as well, I much prefer Felli behind the striker.

He has done well in the DM slot but as an attacking midfielder he can be a top creative outlet.

Great stuff today, boys, and credit to Moyes for actually giving it ago rather than just saying it.
Andy Walker
145 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:02:03
For me we need a new right back, Donovan signed full time, Pienaar signed, and a new striker, Barkley in squad, Osman used as a squad player. Out: Rodwell, Anichebe, Straq, Vellios, Coleman. Possibly also Jags but that would depend on money and if Duffy has come along enough or a replacement/swap deal could be done with Jags.

I think we really could have a good season next year IF Moyes stays and the right deals are done in the summer. And if we win our last 4 games, I won't be saying it's because it doesn't matter, it's because Moyes is doing what I said they should do, it's because the other teams were crap, it's becasue we were lucky, or why didn't we do this earlier or v RS. I will say fucking brilliant though.
Eugene Ruane
146 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:11:12
Dan Brierly - Jesus, where to start, a whole plateful of wrong.

"I do not understand why people continually re-live games we have lost?"

Well I'm sure there's all kinds of things you don't understand, but I think you'll find even the genius Moyes does this (ever heard 'you learn by your mistakes'?)

"We have lost 5 games, and won 11 this year. Nobody can deny the progress this team has made, since Moyes made his signings in January"

So...just ignore the first half of the season? "Nobody can deny"? Yeah fair enough, nobody can deny we're better now...than the hopeless defensive, clueless dull shite we were for the first half the season - happy?

"Clinging onto losses as though it is the norm seems to be ridiculous".

By clinging, do you mean 'mentioning' or 'discussing'?

Plus it is no more 'ridiculous' than harping on about draws in games that don't mean anything.

"16 goals in the last 6 matches shows a very different picture. Instead, people want to focus only on the games against Liverpool"

Bollocks - What 'picture' are you looking at!? The Liverpool game actually MATTERED - that's the difference.

"To me, its ancient history"

Yeah all of a week ago (by the way, "ignore history and you're doomed to repeat your mistakes" - Stan Ogden).

"You sometimes win, and sometimes lose"

Yes thanks for that Socrates.

"Its funny as fuck seeing just how fickle we are sometimes"

You presumably see as 'fickle' those who (sometimes for years!) question the decisions, selections and motivation tactics of a manager.

Well I'll ignore the obvious better blue-ist nature of that and tell you that I see as fickle those who can watch half a season of dross, three embarrassing defeats by The Victims (possibly their worst side in my 52 years) and THEN...come crowing because we got a point at United.

Actually it's not fickle, just stupid.
Andy Codling
147 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:26:30
A week too late... so sorry if I'm not jizzing in my pants about a .... draw!
Chris James
148 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:23:56
Just checking, these are the same people that were largely slagging Felliani as overrated lazy player we wouldn't miss over the weekend, right?

Great result of course which suggests that Moyes and the players do have some backbone and that the FA Cup Semi-Final had more than an element of bad luck to it ? even the supposedly great teams sometimes can't get the result they want (see el Classico, Champions League semis 1st leg and, well, Utd today).

Our season's still as good as over of course, there's literally nothing to play for, so we need to start giving the youth a run out in the upcoming games.
Mike Hughes
149 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:21:34
YEEESSS ... COME ON YOUR BAGGIES
Mike Hughes
150 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:33:13
That'll wipe the smile of the smug, diving, racist scumbags.

Well done Roy. I've always liked you.

ROY FOR ENGLAND.
Andy Walker
151 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:29:05
Andy Codling, so we should have simply thrown the towel in and lost today? Coming back from 2 goals down at OT deserves a quickie ;)
Andy Walker
152 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:34:48
Ed #435, your 8th place prediction looking a bit dodgy now.
Andy Corrie
153 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:33:40
WTF??? How can we play like utter utter crap last week and like this the next?

Interestingly, Moyes even said post-match that he reckoned we should have won today, albeit for poor biased reffing. We played like a side with nothing to lose; oh hang on, we are a side with nothing to lose, that's alright then.

Roll on our potless, managerless 'little' club, as we enter the frightening abyss of season 2012-13...
Dan Brierley
154 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:30:11
So to summarise your rambling post Eugene, you don't agree?

I am not against anyone questioning things, of course it is healthy and needs to be done. Just like above, I have highlighted our need to improve defensively. Its not all rosy, improvements have to be made. Losing against Liverpool is painful, but it doesn't mean Everton Football Club will collapse and cease to exist. We move on, and try to improve.

And today I felt proud of our performance. I think Moyes has done a good job today, and deserves to be recognised for it. So much for your and many others' opinion that we will get our annual hiding at Old Trafford. But you can keep pointing out the Liverpool performance ad infinitum, as we will surely lose again one day after a poor performance. Then you can scream 'look, I told you I was right!!'
Matt Traynor
155 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:38:00
Chris (#494) he had a great game, credit where it's due. But he has had some shockers. We all know he has ability, we just wish he had a bit more consistency.

But can you explain how we had "more than an element of bad luck" in the semi? I thought we played shite and barely created any chances of note, and on balance, were the worst of two poor teams.

Great result today, and all credit to the team, and yes, the manager. Although some on here argue he's not at fault when we lose "as he can't control what the players do", credit where it's due. Although "only" a draw, I can't think of a more significant result in his tenure.
Brian Waring
156 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:47:57
Dan, you must admit though, this comeback will be used against anyone who is anti-Moyes.
Michael Kenrick
157 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:42:05
I suppose it's understandable that this result and the improved performance will cause confusion amongst the following. It was much better than last week... but not really as fantastic as some are making out.

The positive attacking intent throughout was indeed a breath of fresh air... but how many will connect this with the scoreline and suggest this 'proves' that open attacking football leaves big holes at the back and doesn't give you a win, even though you may be (and I definitely think we were) the more deserving side?

The chances we missed, and a few of their goals where they waltzed far too easily though our defence, mean we failed to win a game that our football and attitude should have had sown up. It was a much better performance than last week by far ? that goes without saying... but we could only secure a draw. We still didn't win; Moyes still hasn't won at Old Trafford.
Andy Walker
158 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:44:10
Matt, you have just posted a quote - "as he can't control what the players do" which doesn't seem to exist on this discussion?
Jim Hillier
159 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:19:34
That result just got even better. Shite lost to WBA. Ha ha ha
Mark Riding
160 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:46:59
Dan / Eugene

You both put up good arguments for your opinions.. could either of you please answer for me:

How the fuck did that shower of shite, who have just been turned over AGAIN by an ale-house team at home.. beat us last week in an bloody FA Cup Semi-final??

Even the Reds I know admit that they are utter shite...
Andy Walker
161 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:51:33
I don't think the attacking play caused gaps, I think Jags, Distin and Heitinga had relatively poor games, certainly Heitinga compared to recent performances.
Ed Fitzgerald
162 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:55:19
Mark

Because when we were one up we should have gone for the throat and we didn't. They (RS) are bleeding awful and they have beaten us three times this season: seven against and one scored by us.

Andy, I am delighted to be wrong about the prediction about being 8th and hope we finish 7th at the end of season.
Paul David
163 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:57:09
Playing attacking football means we can't be as tight at the back, Remember we were playing Man Utd who could just as easily have scored 4 if we sat back but with no reply.
Kunal Desai
164 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:54:37
Michael Kenrick ? I made a similar point on the forum: Why did we not play the same way last week as we did today? And, although my opinions were a little OTT, I got shot down by some, where it was the manner from coming back 2 goals down to draw.

Some fans are easily pleased, as I stated earlier, but that hit a raw nerve with some as well. Let's just say as Evertonians we support one club but we'll agree to disagree on opinions ? that is for sure. I believe when the pressure is off us, we can play and beat anyone but it's when the pressure is on, we choke!
Phil Roberts
165 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:01:40
Stat of the Day?

1st time we have scored 4 in consecutive league games since 1999-2000 season.

And the weekend made even sweeter by Roy Hodgson getting revenge.

Any bets on us being 3rd on MotD given that the Reds lost at home again and Wolves relegated? Or will Kenny be on last so it can be brushed over by the media...
Paul David
166 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:03:27
I forgot just how shit the Shite really are, there's no reason we can't finish above them, that will be the smallest of consolations though.
Brian Denton
167 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:05:28
A good day just got better
Chris James
168 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:03:17
Bah, I really am depressed at the moment. Having been initially annoyed that we could turn on a steely attacking response against Utd (at Old Trafford) but not the cup semi, I'm know even more annoyed that the reds have lost at home to...West Brom and Carroll once again can't hit a bloody barn door.
Eugene Ruane
169 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:57:44
Mark, they are (as I said) the worst Liverpool side in my lifetime, BUT (imo) their manager appears to realise that these games are different and mean a FUCK of a lot to the supporters.

Ours (apparently) is not too arsed about them.

Plus (heard nothing about their game/side/performance avvy) they only have ONE game of any importance left this season.

If Dalglish has any sense, he'll make sure he has his best team for the final.

nb: Us finishing above them means fuck-all, especially if they're in Europe and we're not (as is the case).

Wouldn't surprise me if they play rezzies for the next three games and get fuck all.... then win the final.
Eugene Ruane
170 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:08:21
Dan (500) - did you once meet Steve Martin on a plane?

(you're not a shower-curtain ring salesman by any chance?)

No matter, I'll give you a bit of Steve's advice - have a point!

(me rambling? Fuck that's rich - like being called smug by Simon Cowell)

And by the way..

"So much for your and many others opinion that we will get our annual hiding at Old Trafford"

"Your"?

Well I'll tell you what, why don't you SHOW me where I posted that

If you CAN'T, I expect your next post to begin - "I sincerely apologise for making shit up just to make myself look 'clever'"

The (badly defended) ball is in your court.
Brian Waring
171 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:14:02
Sir Alex Ferguson.

"It was a travesty - the football we played was fantastic"

"Their goals were soft. We created goals by really good football, today, they got their goals easily"

Michael Kenrick
172 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:18:12
My god... that SAF quote is astounding. A travesty?!?!?

Are all these Glaswegians full of shite or what? I mean even Alan fucken Green has just given us massive credit on 606.
Matt Traynor
173 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:16:02
Andy (#504) it wasn't specific to this thread or anyone on it, rather a recurring theme in the post-semi autopsy.
Eugene Ruane
174 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:18:54
Brian, he's off his cake but I am reminded of (American football coach) Vince Lombardi's - "Show me a good loser and I'll show you a loser".
Paul David
175 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:19:22
Fuck off, is that what Ferguson said? I actually thought he would come out and praise us for playing our part in a great match.

Sings our praises when we take a hiding but hasn't a good word to say now, sour-faced prick.
Dave Roberts
176 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:16:42
GGGGRRRRR!!!!

Summary of shites last 10 games.

1. Shite

2. Shite

3. Shite

4. Shite

5. Shite

6. Beat us 3-0

7. Shite

8. Shite

9. Beat us 2-1 at Wembley.

10. Shite

(might not be mathematically accurate but you know what I mean)

The scrawny bastards will probably catch Chelsea on a bad day and win the FA Cup on fucking penalties!!!!

GGGGGRRRRRR!!!
Nicky Styles
177 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:17:52
I was genuinely heartened by Rooney's celebration (or lack there of) when he scored. Well done Wayne, showed great respect for your former club.

And well done our lads. Wonderful, wonderful rocky balboa-like spirit displayed when the game seemed long lost.
Brian Waring
178 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:21:54
The funny thing is though, I wish it would have been Moyes coming out with those quotes.
Andy Codling
179 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:20:05
Andy Walker, just saying why couldn't we show some fight and swagger last week when it actually counted for something!

Oh and Roy Hodgson has just done something Moyes has failed to do in 10 years!!
Tom Bowers
180 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:16:09
There are many positives to come out of today's game. Generally we have played well against the better clubs this season and been crap against the others including Redshite. Today was a first for Moyes in that we had an offensive attitude from the start and could have been 2-0 up in the first five minutes. We still need to weed out the players who are older and those who are past their best before next season.

Personally I think all the loan players should be sent back except Peanuts.
Michael Kenrick
181 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:24:17
Hilarious call on 606 now... "Moyes, the master strategist [sic], next England Manager." ROFL
Mark Riding
182 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:21:19
Eugene.. does the Lombardi quote apply to Dalglish also ?
Or is he just a bitter old tit, bottle went after the 4-4 cup game, who is living off the 80's ??

Ed #508 - Beaten by them 3 times this season.. I was getting over last weekend, and you reminding me of the total meltdown they would now be in without our 6 points and FA Cup final place has just made me wince with pain once again...
Eugene Ruane
183 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:27:27
I AGREE!!!

MOYES FOR ENGLAND!!

Or Spurs!

Or Chelsea!

Boca Juniors?

Grasshoppers?

Anyone?

Hell-OH!!?
Dave Lynch
184 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:19:05
Quote post match by Moyes.

"I dont think I've ever set a team up to sit deep."

????????????????????????
Mark Riding
185 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:27:39
Michael # 528..

I said earlier in the week 'Moyes for England !'

Imagine his job acceptance speech... ' well guys..Taking a small country like England to a Euro Final campaign and being expected to compete with the likes of Spain and Germany.. is just like taking a knife to.....'
Matt Traynor
186 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:28:54
Michael (#528) shame Green never pushed him on who he supported. Methinks he was a Spuds fan trying to keep Hawwy...

(and avoid getting Moyes maybe haha!)
Brian Waring
187 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:28:16
Michael, I just heard someone say Moyes deserves a knighthood for his contribution to football!
Andy Crooks
188 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:23:27
We should have won today, The attitude was positive and we played some really good football. Jelavic was an inspired signing.

Unfortunately I can't forget last week because of today. We are better than Liverpool yet were the poorer of two poor teams. Yes, of course I enjoyed today but it is small consolation.

I agree with the comment that we have three good centre halves at the club probably not the three that were being referred to.
Eugene Ruane
189 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:29:55
Mark - well he IS a bitter old tit and he definitely DID bottle it after the 4-4, however, even with the absolute shite bunch he has there right now (worst I can remember) they've easily beat us THREE times this season, plus he has one trophy in the cabinet and a good shot at a second.

All that just makes me even more depressed about the man we have in charge and our complete lack of success.

(Yes, they've spent millions more than us, but I think most agree, it hasn't been spent all that wisely).
Simon Harris
190 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:21:13
Mark - Because they didn't gift the shite a goal and were able to withstand the onslaught.

Great comeback from the blues today, someone on the live forum predicted a 5-2 Man U victory when they went 4-2 up, and too be honest it looked the more likely result, so to comeback showed great character.

Fair play to David Moyes and the team they could have crumbled again, but they kept going and special praise to Phil Neville. A few of us have been asking for someone to get nasty, and you could tell by his reaction to going behind after that crunching tackle, remonstrations with the ref and rallying of the troops that he truly cared.

Looking forward to MOTD2 after a dismal and depressing week.

Oh, and Kenwright, please sign Pienaar.
Derek Williams
191 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:30:35
Who would have thought, given the respective fixtures, that we would finish the day further ahead of the RS than we were at the start of the day?

Funny old game.
Graham Mockford
192 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:28:12
Eugene #516

You are clearly one of TW 's more articulate and entertaining contributors but can I just ask a question that my logical linear thinking is struggling with: Do you really think Moyes is 'not arsed' about losing to Liverpool?

I think you can accuse him of many things such as negativity, predictability etc. and I really don't want to get into the league game team selection. What I would state with some confidence is he left Wembley last week feeling just a sick as all of us. Maybe I'm missing the subtlety of apparently in parentheses.
Michael Kenrick
193 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:49:09
Dan Brierley, I've just seen some of your comments on the Live Forum. Red card.
Paul David
194 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:47:11
Graham, Moyes might not like losing but he threw the Anfield derby. So, no, it has nowhere near the same effect on him as it does us.
Mark Riding
195 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:54:48
Michael #540 - Why so many Reds on an Everton live matchday forum ??
May explain a few odd posters on the site me thinks ??
Dan Brierley
196 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:55:28
Fair enough Michael, its your website. I personally found it very disrespectful for a fellow fan to celebrate when Rooney scored, and even more annoying when that a fellow fan starts supporting Man United when 4-2 down. I admit I overreacted, but I am tired of being labelled 'you are the reason Moyes and Kenwright are still in charge' like I should be ashamed of supporting my club.
Mike Green
197 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:37:41
Good point today, good performance and great to see the boys fight back and not lie down. Much more than I expected, Fellaini and Pienaar brilliant.

COYB!
Paul Ferry
198 Posted 22/04/2012 at 19:01:33
To be fair to Dan Brierley, who I rarely agree with, he was severely provoked by Kunai Desai, Michael. In my opinion, Desai behaved far more shabbily and rudely than Mr Brierley. You went through the thread Michael: how many people did you see patting Desai on the back and how many did you see rapping him on his knuckles?

In balance, I also hope MK that you publicly rap KD on the knuckes in the same way that you have dished out a red card to DB. I'm sorry, but Desai was a disgrace on the forum, an utter disgrace. That's not enough to justify hideous abuse. I know. But (1) DB was not in that bracket and (2) KD behaved just as badly ? more badly, in fact, and, as I said, he too deserves your rebuke.
Graham Mockford
199 Posted 22/04/2012 at 19:15:56
Michael #540

I think Dan's comments were over the top and he obviously allowed another contributors comments to get the better of him, so I think a red card sounds fair enough.

However just for information what is the penalty for calling another poster 'a fucking imbecile'?
Eugene Ruane
200 Posted 22/04/2012 at 18:58:59
Graham (539) - you ask..

"Do you really think Moyes is 'not arsed' about losing to Liverpool?"

Well a couple of things first.

1) I think all managers want to win all games.

2) We are ultimately judged on what we do rather than what we say.

That in mind, I think Dalglish will consider it more important for The Victims to beat Chelsea in the FA Cup Final than it will be to win their last few games, given they already have the only European place they can get.

Of course he'll WANT to win them, but (I believe) won't be too arsed if they don't win any of them, BUT have a full fit side for Wembley.

BUT (like Jay-Lo, bug butt) if one of those last few games was against US, I DON'T believe he would take it easy and let us have the win.

In other words, I think he understands that losing to Everton means more than losing to West Brom.

Moyes, because of the team he put out at Anfield (ie: by his actions) showed (certainly me) he sees things differently.

'Not arsed' might not be accurate and probably does need defining.

I'd suggest 'not arsed ENOUGH' is fair.
Kevin Tully
201 Posted 22/04/2012 at 19:07:12
With 4 games left to play, Moyes should convince himself we can play attacking football without leaving yourself open to a big loss.

He is really set in his ways and " 4-5-1 works " so why change attitude.

I don't think the top teams are as dominant as they were a few years ago. As the money trickles down from transfers and T.V. rights, even the bottom teams have a decent chance of a result. Look at Swansea & Norwich, both would have been murdered in the P.L. a few years ago.

Most teams have Internationals playing for them as a norm in the P.L. these days. So we can hold up the redshite as a typical example - just spent £114m since K.K.K. has been in charge, and they are on their worst home run since 1948. Proof that money is not everything.

Just to make a few blues happy - they are posting what a bargain Jelavic has been, and they should have signed him !!

If we can get rid of the actor - we may even be on the up with a 20 goal a season man up top. 12 points to play for, let's see what we are capable of Davey.
Eugene Ruane
202 Posted 22/04/2012 at 19:22:39
That is 'big butt' by the way.

(knocks one....)
Kevin Sparke
203 Posted 22/04/2012 at 19:21:13
I think post 3 or 4 on the match thread had 'I hope we get beat today'

A true blue I'm sure - if he said that at the match he'd be collecting his teeth from his next shit.
Kevin Tully
204 Posted 22/04/2012 at 19:30:48
We want names Kevin.
Roman Sidey
205 Posted 22/04/2012 at 19:12:54
Danny James, good point about Baines' absence. I read a similar theory about RVP at Arsenal, in that they rely on him so much that when he plays, he's the only option they try to use. Same can be said for Baines and our left.

Also, I only got to see the first 10 minutes or so, can someone tell me how the defence was set up? Was it four at the back with Nev or Heitinga in midfield, or were we actually using a five man line?
Phil Bellis
206 Posted 22/04/2012 at 19:00:56
Well, what a day this has been, what a rare mood I'm in
I note we are still united on TW by our diversity

I would like to think Moyesey will reflect on the last 2 games and see if he can put his finger on the ingredients of the difference in performances: I'd offer guts, attitude and belief

Ane, yes, I know there wasn't an error of Distinesque proportions today but at times our defence resembled training ground cones and we STILL fought back

Marvellous - c'mon Chelsea, ease the pain
Eugene Ruane
207 Posted 22/04/2012 at 19:34:03
Looks off into distance.

Holds ciggy behind back between thumb and forefinger

Covers mouth.

"Snitches get stitches lad - get me?"
Michael Kenrick
208 Posted 22/04/2012 at 19:38:34
Dan, I don't care about any of that... you're banned for your abuse on there, as are a few others. Zero tolerance.

Graham, don't go there. The imbecile was lying and would not accept the facts when pointed out to him. Zero tolerance of that too.

Kunal, you being a total prick on the Live Forum, and probably the main cause of most of the trouble, so guess what...
Jamie Barlow
209 Posted 22/04/2012 at 19:44:42
Does that mean you've banned Dave Wilson for lying Michael?
Phil Bellis
210 Posted 22/04/2012 at 19:49:44
Streuth Jamie, is lying Michael any worse than waltzing Matilda?
Stephen Kenny
211 Posted 22/04/2012 at 19:42:32
Finishing above them after Wembley will be like winning an arm wrestle with a fella who's just bummed yer wife.
Graham Mockford
212 Posted 22/04/2012 at 19:32:33
Eugene appreciate the clarification, however, I fundamentally disagree. Moyes played a weakened side, gambling on:

A) he might get away with it on the night
B) it might help in the longer term ambition to win a trophy

In the end those mights amounted to fuck all and he will ultimately be judged quite rightly on his results.
But I just don't get the 'not arsed' even if qualified by 'enough'. I just don't see him as that type of individual, in fact if anything I suspect his intensity and desire whilst creating a hard to beat attitude week in week out may on the big occasions create too much pressure on the team. He may be better next time taking a leaf out of Old Big 'ead's book and taking the players out for a pint the night before the game.

I have always had the greatest admiration for him for what he has achieved over 10 years juggling limited resources but I am now questioning whether he has the necessary flexibility of thought to ever do more than make us a competitive PL team. What I won't have, however, is that he doesn't care.
Andy Walker
213 Posted 22/04/2012 at 19:55:43
Stephen Kenny, so presumably on that basis you'd prefer we finished below the RS?
Graham Mockford
214 Posted 22/04/2012 at 19:55:53
My apologies Michael it was a cheap shot! Just couldn't resist!!
Stephen Kenny
215 Posted 22/04/2012 at 19:56:36
Graham,

His comments after the game were "My only regret is I never rested more".

He didn't give a toss we lost that derby game.

He cares when there's an opportunity to boost his reputation IMO.

His comments after todays game were also interesting IMO. He stated we were there to win right from the off today as though that isn't always the case.
Stephen Kenny
216 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:00:45
No Andy,

Unlike some it kills me to lose anything against them.

Let's not kid ourselves it means fuck all though.
Danny James
217 Posted 22/04/2012 at 19:26:51
We moan at Moyes about his negative tactics but I dont see any difference with the way we have played most of the season and the way most of the other clubs have played this season

Are we really implying the likes of Liverpool, Sunderland, Fulham,Stoke,West Brom,Norwich,Villa,QPR,Blackburn,Bolton,Wolves are all playng wonderful free flowing football. Even Chelsea are boring to watch and Wigan were hardly entertaining until about a month ago

The majority of teams play shit boring football. Its hardly a Moyes only trait. Thats just the way football is in the premiership. MOTD is boring as hell these days. The objective of most teams when they play each other is to just cancel each other out. This is why you have a league where six points separates 7th to 14th
Brian Harrison
218 Posted 22/04/2012 at 19:52:59
I thought we played well today, and could have been 2 up before they scored.
Considering we were playing the best team in the league and matched them in effort and skill.

I dont know why Jagielka is getting stick for todays performance. I think despite being in great form this season Heitinga was the poorer of our 2 central defenders. But lets face it Old Trafford is a difficult place to get a result, and I cant think of to many teams who come back from a 2 goal defecit twice.

Jelavic is what we havent had for a long while a natural goal scorer, and Pienaar is playing some great football. Although I see his agent is not saying he would like to stay at Goodison, only that they will asses the situation at the end of the season while reminding everyone that he is a Spurs player on a long contract.

I think irrespective of where we finish in the league, we need to address our perenial poor start to practically every season. Seems like we always have mountains to climb come Christmas.
Andy Walker
219 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:03:43
Thank fuck for that Andy! It will mean something to me if we finish above them though.
Graham Mockford
220 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:03:34
Stephen #576
To paraphrase Johnson ' IMO is the last refuge of the scoundrel'
So go on show me one single shred of evidence ie not opinion that is,that David Moyes only ' cares when there's an opportunity to boost his reputation'
Stephen Kenny
221 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:09:29
Will it mean we're a better side than them to you?

Or something else?
Jim Harrison
222 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:01:21
four goals at old trafford. its got to at least go some way towards giving moyes a break? no? didnt think so!
Paul David
223 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:12:34
Danny 557

I cant think of a single team that only plays with one striker in every single match,imo thats the main reason we have struggled for goals(pre-Jelly) and why our play looks so shit in the final third.

A simple change in formation would make us much more of a threat,more options for a pass and better movement.
Ian Bennett
224 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:05:14
First goal - missed header Neville, to much room to cross hibbert

2nd goal - failed clearance Neville, Heitinga buys dummy

3rd goal - Distin fails to stay with man

4th goal - Heitinga buys dummy and then fails to catch Rooney.

Evra hits bar - Distin fails to close cross

Taggarts comments about our goals was what you would expect from him. Can't stand united and hope they blow it next week. Can't stand united, can't stand Liverpool, love today despite not winning.

Special mention for Gibson, would have loved for him to score. God is great!
Jamie Tulacz
225 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:07:35
Saw the game in a Manc pub today, so doubly satisfying indeed!

Interesting that a couple of Moyes' tactics which have been heavily criticised- ie Neville in midfield, Fellaini further forward, players out of position (Distin) and yet we get a great result?

Jelavic as well- what a signing, one of the bargains of the season, just looks a great all-round player, mobile, good in the air, knows how to hit the onion bag! Anyone care to give any credit for that one?

ps - the person who said that we'd probably have won at Wembley if it hadn't been for Distin's howler, you're quite right. Unfortunately you won't get any credit on here for giving a balanced point of view!
Al Reddish
226 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:17:47
To be honest Paul, I don't blame the fact that we only play one striker for our lack of goals, it's more to do with how creative the person behind the striker is. It ain't Cahill that's for sure, but look at the difference today with Fellaini behind Jelly. He had vision, composure and linked the forward line to a very defensive midfield (on paper, Neville and Gibson), in a way rarely seen at Everton in recent years.
Even Redknapp has said recently he hasn't been playing 4 4 2 because of the gaps it leaves in midfield, and he is meant to be some footballing genius according to some.
Kunal Desai
227 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:21:42
Michael at least I had the decency to hold my hands up and say I went OTT and issued an apology. At least I never resorted to name-calling like some on there... and, like I stated on the forum and previously before, I'm not there to pick bones with fellow Evertonians and start name-calling.....
Paul David
228 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:23:56
Al your right,having a player behind Jelly who can actually contribute as an attacker makes a difference but I would still like to see us play 442 in most of out home games.With two forwards and Fellaini getting up in support as well we would be a handfull for most teams.I'm not suggesting Fellaini should play in the hole behind two strikers but as a box to box midfielder while Gibson is the one who holds his postion further back.
Jamie Tulacz
229 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:23:18
Paul (587)- I'll give you a few- Arsenal, Chelsea, often Spurs, United have done quite a bit in recent seasons, the Shite have done quite often (with just Suarez) and that's just off the top of my head!

ps- another RS defeat in the league- priceless!
Andy Walker
230 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:22:28
I do think we are a better side than them and it was one of those days at Wembley, a once in a 10 season out of the blue error, from a usually reliable player. I am convinced we would have won without that one of error, but thats gone. Next season is looking better for us than them, assuming we both still have the same managers and we get Pienaar signed. It speaks volumes for our manager and the players how they picked themselves up for today and it speaks volumes how the RS are playing. I think Chelsea will easily beat them, problem is I can then see Dalglish getting sacked, I want him there a lot longer.
Mike Keating
231 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:17:55
After the Sunderland game McFadden should have been ahead of Gueye in the semi given that Drenthe was dropped.
Can't believe that we let them off the hook & then play so well at Old Trafford!

David Price
232 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:08:24
As usual we are a different side with Pienaar. So whilst it's maddening comparing today with last week, it wasn't a like for like comparison.
Has Moyes learnt from last week? I hope so, To drop Cahill was bold and overdue. Fellaini was the main support off Jelavic and changed us to a 4 -3-3 formation.
With Cahill, we were never a 4-5-1, more a static 4-4-2.
Pienaar and Osman moved infield when play developed on their flank and either one joined up with Fellaini and Jelavic.
For me it showed a change in tactical nouse from Moyes and more intelligent play from our own players.
Gibson and Neville were the holding players still looking to probe forward as well.
That style of play would have easily won home games against QPR, Bolton, Blackburn, Aston Villa but we didn't have the personnel then,
Next season we will, there are things to look forward to. Agree, Dempsey and Donavon would enhance our side, obviously with Pienaar. Being all at the 30 age mark, means we get three quality years whilst bringing on the promising young lads we have coming through.
Jelavic is the player we've been waiting for years, remember the 4-6-0 formation at City when we won 1-0. He stays fit and we have a great chance of being competitive all season.
Today was impressive and hoe we should play the game, Utd were quality up front today and we stood up and had a go.
Lesson learnt hopefully Mr Moyes on that horrible journey home last week.
Danny James
233 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:18:34
I think though the the role of the 5th midfielder is that of a support striker. He is in essence a second striker. Due to our lack of striking quality the role is usually Cahills or Osmans or even Fellaini.
If we had a player like Suarez (god forbid) then he would essentailly play in the hole instead of Cahill et al
Our 5th midfielder today scored on and had two assists in the box
The reason we looked like an attacking side today wasbecause we played a team that just came out and attacked us constantly allowing us space to attack them back. Usually because all teams play the same its a case of us and the oppostion just stifling each other
Paul David
234 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:31:16
Jamie your wrong,them teams play 433.One main striker with another two either side as inside frwards.
Phil Bellis
235 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:30:49
Jamie Tulacz - bit harsh!
Balanced?
Most of us on here have a chip on both shoulders
Jamie Tulacz
236 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:30:47
Jim (585)- you should know better by now!
Steve Mink
237 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:32:07
Agree with David #599 re Pienaar. He injects urgency into the midfield and they move the ball more quickly when he plays.
Mike Keating
238 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:30:55
Sorryandy
Moyes cost us the game @ Wembley not Distan
Now it doesn't matter we play like champions

I renewed my season ticket but not sure why Aftwr last week they don't deserve fans like us
Paul David
239 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:36:54
Jamie

All the teams you mentioned change their formations depending on who their playing,what players are available,we stick religiously to 451 and its not always the answer
Stephen Kenny
240 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:31:18
Andy,

Why weren't we the better side who were unlucky in that case?

Moyes choked. He's done it before and he'll do it again. That's why I cant just forget it. I forgot it the last time and the time before,

Most were saying we'd roll over again today. I never. We were in the only position he likes to be in, backs to the wall underdogs.

If we're going to progress we cant always be plucky little Everton.
Andy Walker
241 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:37:25
Mike it was Distins back pass not Moyes'. No one thought Distin shouldnt have started, we would have all put him on the pitch I suspect. We all make mistakes, Sylvain unfrotunately made one of his worst, probably worse ever, with 28 mins to go in a semi final. I do not beleive we would have lost had that not happened, but its gone, we must look forward and stop bringing it up, its detracting from a brilliant performance today. We stood head to head with the Champions at their place and with less than 10 mins to go scored twice, no other team has done this. Today is a day to be proud to be a blue.
Jamie Tulacz
242 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:35:10
Paul- for me one mans 451 is another man's 433- just depends which team's playing the formation though. The media tends to show the bigger teams playing 433 just to show their apparent sophistication.

Respect your point of view though, the formations could be seen either way. And I think that often too much is made of formation, just depends how you play the formation instead. I'll agree that Moyes is often too defensive, but fair play, we played 1 up front today and got 4 at Old Trafford, so it does work, just that we generally need a more attacking mindset and belief that we can play some good stuff!
Jamie Tulacz
243 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:44:58
Phil (602)- ha!

All that talk of chips making me very hungry!
Paul David
244 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:42:51
I agree with Stephen but surley Moyes now knows we're not as bad as he makes out and when he allows the team to play we will win more than we lose.

Saying that judging by his post match interview were he said "I dont think we've ever sat back" am not so sure.
Ian Bennett
245 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:47:09
Andy it was least the players could do, they owed the fans the last 10 mins today.
Eugene Ruane
246 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:46:31
Graham (583) you say (to Stephen)..

"To paraphrase Johnson ' IMO is the last refuge of the scoundrel'"

Question: Is that a fact or..your opinion?

Sam Hoare
247 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:31:22
Great day.

In Fellaini and jelavic we have two rather special players i think. Goals on the pitch for the first time in quite a while.

Cahill needs to be out of the starting lineup from now on.
Paul David
248 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:46:40
Jamie

Yeah when I seen the line up with Neville in midfield along side Gibson and Fellaini (who I expected to sit deep as well) I thought it would be 90 minutes of defending on our 18 yeard line.

Just goes to show it is the way you play it,Gibson and Neville held their postion which allowed Fellaini and the wide men to get forward.A far better tactic than everyone defending.
Angela Smyth
249 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:51:29
Jags and Johnny were poor; Neville, for all his critics tremendous; Felli Jelly and Peanuts (sounds like a sarnie) awesome.

Finally don't be fooled by Shrek's non-celebrations, he is still a shithouse.
Graham Mockford
250 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:52:57
Eugene 100% my opinion, but I guess you know that! I could explain the point I was making but IMO I know you know that too.
Phil Bellis
251 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:55:12
EJ...shush, you might stir the ghost of Martin O'Pinion Mason
Well, off out to wind up the loveables
Stephen Kenny
252 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:51:36
City away - Couldn't see a way for us to win so got a bit of damage limitation in beforehand.

United away - "We were her to win right from the 1st minute".

Why no knife to a gunfight bollocks this time?

Because he can sense an opportunity to boost his reputation so lets go out all guns blazing.

I can't show you evidence. It's my interpretation of his actions.

IMO the sale price of the club is far too high. I can't show you any evidence of that either, just my interpretation of Bill's actions.
Peter Warren
253 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:59:06
Please do not play Fellaini as defensive midfielder ? he is so much better than that.
Jamie Tulacz
254 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:46:06
Stephen (609)- fair enough, I do think you've got a point there. Psychologically when the chips are down, there's a lack of belief at our club that we can win on the big occasion, and it's largely the manager who should inspire that belief. And the whole RS thing has become psychological, just don't believe that we think we can beat them, hence why we don't nearly as often as we should.

Still think that Moyes over-achieves big time with the budget he has though, in an era when money is (almost) everything. To those who ask what Moyes has won in 10 years, I'd ask how many other teams outside of the big money boys have won anything, and where are some of those clubs (eg Birmingham, Pompey) now?
Eugene Ruane
255 Posted 22/04/2012 at 17:52:53
Graham, I really DON'T know what you mean

You asked of Stephen

"So go on show me one single shred of evidence ie not opinion that is,that David Moyes only ' cares when there's an opportunity to boost his reputation"

Well I don't want to speak for Stephen, but I'm sure he DOESN'T have any 'evidence'..or certainly not of the type you appear to be hinting at.

(ie: a tape recording of Moyes saying: "Ah dinnae care unless ah can boost mah own reputation").

Everything (repeat EVERYTHING) from everyone, is just..'imo'.

You included.

We put forward a view, throw in whatever is there factually to back it up, argue as stridently as we can (got to be in it to win it) BUT it's imo.

I'll prove it.

You show 'evidence' (not imo!) that PROVES Moyes DOES care - actual proof!


Andy Walker
256 Posted 22/04/2012 at 21:00:27
Stephen, he had Jelevic, Gibson and Pinaar available to play today instead of Rodwell Coleman and Cahill away at City. That says it all.....
Stephen Kenny
257 Posted 22/04/2012 at 21:02:36
Jamie,

I agree he's moved us up a level. I'd like us to move up another level though. That level is challenging for cups. He's proven he hasn't got it in him to do that. I'd have said we overachieved 5 years ago. Not the last five though.

We don't owe him a job for life. We have given him a fantastic opportunity to make a name for himself and to a degree he's took it. It hasn't been pretty for the most part though.
Stephen Kenny
258 Posted 22/04/2012 at 21:09:15
Eugene - feel free to speak for me. You're a fair bit better at it TBH.
John Crawley
259 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:49:34
Michael, you have to love those quotes from SAF ? it's when he comes out with bollocks like that you know you've given them a bloody good game and he's pissed off! Too often his after match quotes are full of praise for Everton that's when you know we've given them an easy game.

Paul, I agree with you ? for me if Moyes is really going to change his approach, the first thing he needs to do is admit he's been wrong. I don't see any sign of that happening though.
Andy Walker
260 Posted 22/04/2012 at 21:07:16
Eugene, thats all getting a bit Zen isnt it? Maybe this is all a big dream and we will wake up in the matrix.
Graham Mockford
261 Posted 22/04/2012 at 21:02:20
Stephen

I genuinely get the frustration at where this club is, it drives me to fucking distraction. I even share some of your concerns about how far DM can move this club forward.

I just believe characterising him as someone who is in it for himself, doesn't care when we lose does an injustice to a genuinely decent honest individual who has if nothing else has always acted with dignity and instilled values into our football club which I for one am proud of.
Stephen Kenny
262 Posted 22/04/2012 at 21:10:30
Andy,

It makes no odd's who plays if you've got no intention of moving out your own half
Tim Locke
263 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:37:44
Great game of football and 8 very good goals. I know a lot of people are now even more confused about what happen last weekend and left asking why. You could say the team was different, but I don't think dropping Baines and playing three centre backs would have helped. Hibbert had a great game a right back, and clearly having Pienner in the side makes a massive difference going forward. I don't think it is fair to ask what happened at Anfield, as Pienner was in a very different team.

So why did we lose the semi, I think factors which need to be considered. It was a derby match and therefore form goes out the window. Liverpool didn't allow us to play and broke up our play. The match was very tight and decided on 3 errors, not one side out playing the other. Everton didn't perform, sadly football is inconsistent and teams lose, barcelona losing to Chelsea is a good example. I know it is disappointing but it is one game and it looks like we have an amazing opportunity to finish above Liverpool.


I don't think anyone on this site would have done what Moyes did today, and it worked so credit due. McFadden sub had a lot of people asking questions, same old Moyes, why is he not bringing on Barkley. If that was not confusion enough Distin then comes off for Cahill. Which was surprising attacking move, but something which seemed to work.


So where to in the future, is this a new more attacking risk taking Moyes or are we going to go to type against Fulham? Are we finally going to get a manager who wants to kill teams, and play attacking football? I guess time will tell, there is no reason why we shouldn't finish the season with 57 points, and no reason why next season we should start how we left off. I am looking forward to next weekend and seeing what happens lets hope that the team and manager don't let us down. COYBs
Stephen Kenny
264 Posted 22/04/2012 at 21:13:06
Graham,

What's your take on the months of sulking that ruined the first few months of the season last time his contract was due?

BTW, I can also see he's got a lot of decent qualities. Most people are inherently selfish(IMO).
Andy Walker
265 Posted 22/04/2012 at 21:16:20
Stephen, you set your team up based on the personell you have available. Moyes now has a better squad so can employ different tactics.
John Daley
266 Posted 22/04/2012 at 20:59:07
Dan Brierley red carded? It's like putting the boot in to Brick Tamlin from Anchorman.
Paul David
267 Posted 22/04/2012 at 21:23:53
But Brick killed a man.
Stephen Kenny
268 Posted 22/04/2012 at 21:22:33
Andy,

QPR gave city the game of their season the week later. We had a much better side than them even then. He was more concerned about how a heavy defeat would reflect on him if we wen't for it and set us up for a low scoring loss.
Stephen Kenny
269 Posted 22/04/2012 at 21:26:12
John,

Any Everton manager should always have that attitude IMO(if that's OK with Graham).
Eugene Ruane
270 Posted 22/04/2012 at 21:12:13
Andy Walker (640) you say..

"Maybe this is all a big dream and we will wake up in the matrix".

Well if we did, it would be fine for me, but awful for you and your positivity.

Basically, from what I remember, it's not the most positive place - everyone wearing black, scowling, guns, war, controllers.

I can just see you giving Laurence Fishburne your let's be positive spiel.

You: "Hey can't we just be pos.."

BLAMBLAMBLAMBLAMBLAMBLAMBALAM!!!!!!!!

Ttinkle of last shell-case hitting deck

Fishburne raises his shades





Silence.
Jamie Tulacz
271 Posted 22/04/2012 at 21:23:00
Graham (641) ? agree entirely, some of the personal attacks Moyes gets on here frankly baffle me. Comes across as a thoroughly decent, moral, straightforward guy in interviews, especially compared to a lot of managers (see Fergie in his post-match interview).

Think a lot of it stems from the amount of money he's being paid. Far be it for me to say that it's in anyway right that anyone should get paid more money in one week than most earn in 3 years, as I don't think that's right for anyone to get that in any way shape or form. But I hardly think he's the worst offender in a game which is awash with indecent amounts of money, there are plenty on wages of £100k + a week who are even more guilty.
John Crawley
272 Posted 22/04/2012 at 21:26:30
Stephen, spot on about THAT Man City game. I have never been so incensed at an Everton display this season (until the recent Liverpool games) as I was about Man City. First of all, we had that "knife to a gun fight" bollocks then, when we had corners, we only had a couple of people in the box. The whole way we approached that game was an absolute disgrace.
Stephen Kenny
273 Posted 22/04/2012 at 21:31:43
Jamie,

I honestly couldn't give a flying fuck what he gets paid. I think he get's what he's worth in his industry.

My gripes are certain aspects of his personality hold our club back at times.
Andy Walker
274 Posted 22/04/2012 at 21:32:39
Matrix was all about the power of positive thought Eugene, that was the fundamental point of the movie, good over coming bad by the power of a positive mind. Obviously this was lost on you! Simply being negative never gets anyone anywhere. So many people accusing Moyes of being negative and they can not see the irony...
Graham Mockford
275 Posted 22/04/2012 at 21:12:52
Eugene
We are in danger of entering quite philosophical areas of which I suspect will get us nowhere.
Let me just say you are right, there is no definite way an assertion can be completely proven, I was asking for evidence not proof however ,a very different thing. Even if I had the tapes you described it would not necessarily be proof. OJ got off after all.
Stephen Kenny
276 Posted 22/04/2012 at 21:44:27
Graham,

I'm not trying to goad you into an argument but I'd be genuinely interested to see how you viewed that episode?
Graham Mockford
277 Posted 22/04/2012 at 21:49:57
Stephen not feeling goaded at all , in fact it's nice to have a debate that is not degenerating into name calling. I was only calling you a scoundrel in a literal sense you understand.

I didn't really get any sense of sulking, I'm guessing that's how you saw it. I think the media need stuff to fill their pages and any contractual negotiations are a good opportunity to write a story. At the end of the day ' manager really happy, chairman really happy, no problems with new contract' is exactly going to sell many papers.
Eugene Ruane
278 Posted 22/04/2012 at 21:29:05
Andy, you say..

"Simply being negative never gets anyone anywhere".

Possibly but then the same goes for 'simply being positive'.

You continue..

"So many people accusing Moyes of being negative and they can not see the irony".

Nonsense as it assumes circumstances are the same for Moyes as everyone else.

They're not.

The 'irony' is neither-here-nor-there because of circumstances.

Which are?

Posters to TW are only responsible to themselves.

Posters to TW are not paid fucking fortunes to give opinions.

Posters to TW are not accountable to thousands around the world.

If we were, THEN it would be ironic.
Ian Smitham
279 Posted 22/04/2012 at 22:02:17
MotD2 ? Enjoy it LARGE!
Paul David
280 Posted 22/04/2012 at 22:04:07
Fuck me, we're first on MotD.
Stephen Kenny
281 Posted 22/04/2012 at 21:59:50
Mourinho is to me the ultimate egotist. He wouldn't ever consider going to a side that wouldn't give he all the things he thinks he needs to win.

He also uses the press to elevate his own mystique. His teams successes are also his. Most manager's are like this to some degree.

Ferguson's every action has what he thinks is best for Man Utd at it's base.

He also has the ultimate will to win and the temperament to gamble to achieve it. To get to the very top we'll need a fella like that.

To get to the next level. (good league finishes and challenging for a cup every other season) we need a bit of that. He lacks in both them area's and he often misjudges a situation too.
Andy Walker
282 Posted 22/04/2012 at 22:03:50
Eugene to be clear are you saying Moyes is negative = bad
Eugene being negative = good
Wayne Smyth
283 Posted 22/04/2012 at 21:56:08
Great result, great performances for the most part. Today showed again that the team that Moyes built IS capable of playing good football against the best in the league and competing. No need to look at the financial gulf and play for a draw/creditable loss.

Still not convinced about Moyes, as it took him far too long to dispense with the ineffectual Cahill/Saha and I suspect he will revert to type and have the team playing no-risk football again soon, but I have to say that he does sign some gems. Jelavic looks a 30 goal a season striker.
Stephen Kenny
284 Posted 22/04/2012 at 22:12:21
Missed the first half today.

What a player Jelavic is. Let's get a side built around him.
Paul David
285 Posted 22/04/2012 at 22:21:48
Not a mention of the ref's blatant cheating on MotD.
Ben Jones
286 Posted 22/04/2012 at 22:25:03
Just bizarre that we are generally considered a defensive team, then we score 4 goals in one of the hardest stadiums in the world, and we defend shockingly.

Really happy with the performance though.
Alex Willett
287 Posted 22/04/2012 at 22:59:16
Excellent display! Lets keep it up........
Ian Smitham
288 Posted 22/04/2012 at 23:03:30
Paul #679, Take a deep breath, you are better than that
Steve Smith
289 Posted 22/04/2012 at 23:10:10
You know we've done well when, according to Ferguson, all their goals were class and ours were put on a plate for us, he didn't even give us his usual patronising "Everton are a great club, great manager great fans etc. etc." that he usually does before patting Moyes gently on the head, and sending him on his way.
Brendan McLaughlin
290 Posted 22/04/2012 at 23:18:59
OK, Moyes just clinched the United job... Who.... What the feck do we do now?
Dave White
292 Posted 22/04/2012 at 23:00:14
Great to read tonight's posts boys, the passion that's out there for this club is inspiring.

I'll admit I'm an eternal optimist but bringing in a creative midfielder (has Mikel got a younger brother?) and a top notch right back to that side would make us a formidable force for next season.

As for getting rid of Moyes, be careful what you wish for.....and be grateful your not a shite fan, despite their cup success they have been a laughing stock this season. I almost feel sorry for them. And despite what they say finishing above them will really, really hurt.

And whoever said that the draw today after last week was like winning an arm wrestle against a bloke who's just bummed your wife, take a bow son, fuckin hilarious!

Right I'm off to bed with Hibbo as after two assists I've agreed to have his babies
Eugene Ruane
293 Posted 22/04/2012 at 23:40:50
Andy (676) you ask..

"Eugene to be clear are you saying Moyes is negative = bad. Eugene being negative = good"

To be CLEAR?

I thought I had spelled out the difference fairly clearly, but it becomes apparent that even if it was tattooed on your ball-bag, by a tattoo-artist with a blunt needle and a bad case of the Hattie Jaques, you still wouldn't see it.

But never let it be said.

Moyes is negative = bad for Evertonians
Eugene being negative = of no consequence to anyone but Eugene.

See the difference?

Awaits post beginning..

"So...do you mean..." etc.
Mark Riding
294 Posted 22/04/2012 at 23:54:12
Ooh,, Matron !
David Moorcroft
295 Posted 22/04/2012 at 23:54:54
I have to say, the reaction of most of you Toffees is bordering on the fucking hysterical. We have drawn a game against probably the worst Man Utd side I have ever seen... You're all shouting as though we have won something. Pienaar was the difference. But that is no excuse for the shit from last week (unforgivable).

We have only had 1 good game every 6 or 7 games and I think that is the problem. A lot of Evertonians nowadays are quite happy to have 1 happy week in fuckin 6 or 7... Well I am fuckin NOT and I want Kenwright and Moyes OUT asap ? and in that order because I have always enjoyed going to Goodison Park... and by the way, I am 55 yrs old and now it's fucking shite.
Lee Hind
296 Posted 22/04/2012 at 23:22:17
Ian Smitham (#688), did you think the referee was even-handed?

He stopped play when we were attacking for a non-head injury, as we broke 3 on 2... Pienaar goes down, play is not stopped and Utd score.

I'm not saying that what happened to Pienaar deserved the game to be stopped, but having set a precedent for stopping play with minor injuries in the first half, the ref should have consistently applied it to both teams. He didn't, it was biased and not in our favour.

Perhaps blatant cheating is a bit of a stretch but even handed? Not today.
David Moorcroft
297 Posted 23/04/2012 at 00:08:56
Eugene, Are you living in a concrete box? Because it seems you cannot get through. I love Everton so much, 46 years solid support.
Michael Mulholland
298 Posted 23/04/2012 at 00:06:49
Eugene, what's with the negative waves... Davey deserves a bit of respect.
James Flynn
299 Posted 23/04/2012 at 01:36:02
Fuck them. We should've won. Who's next?
Andrew Gilbert
300 Posted 23/04/2012 at 01:34:41
Eugene! Don't want any of that Cockney shit on here!
Peter Bourke
301 Posted 23/04/2012 at 02:11:09
David Moorcroft (#701).

Talk about bending the truth. Since Christmas it has been 1 BAD game in every 6 or 7. This current Man Utd team will probably break the record for the highest points tally in a season and has already surpassed their total points tally when they won it last year.

Of course I would rather a win and given the circumstances most of us are happy with the performance. Let them express their happiness at a good performance and they let you have your histerical rant.

It's all good.
Jason Heng
302 Posted 23/04/2012 at 02:23:56
Awful defending! Moyes out!

Heh heh...
Tony Eastwood
303 Posted 23/04/2012 at 02:43:24
@ Terry McLavey ? We must be related. My mum's family name is McLavey and there are still many "Macs" on the Wirral. I was over a month ago for the funeral of my aunt Frances.

Anyway... Great game today and for the Moyes critics out there (and I will not argue the over defensive attitude which leaves us back-peddling in so many games), just look at our league positions since Davie has been in charge. And look at who was in the Premier League back in 2002 and who are not now, or who have been up and down and up.

Given the aftermath of Johnson at the helm, I don't think we can complain about much, other than the style of football on offer... Except for today when we were a true fighting club with not much to fight for except pride... Which we did very well.

Watching a game at 7:30 in the morning on a Sunday (Eastern US) is never an appealing proposition... Coffee and football don't really mix... I nearly grabbed a beer when we scored the third. Onwards but not upwards, unfortunately... but I am a very happy blues fan right now.
Peter Barry
304 Posted 23/04/2012 at 03:06:11
Just as I expected, a half-decent result and a good game against the probable Champions and all the Moyes-loving crew are out-shouting and denigrating everyone.

Forget the THREE surrenders to the RS scum; forget getting dumped out of the cup by them AGAIN; forget all the pathetic surrenders to the Top Four for TEN years; forget the disgusting dross we played for the first half of this and MOST seasons under Dire Davey.

But oh no! one half-decent game and the Moyesiah is back and all the Moyesophiles go beserk. You Moyes lovers just make me laugh. With Moyes We're Bust.
Philip Guy
305 Posted 23/04/2012 at 04:17:29
Fantastic game, unbelievable. I watched it in NZ starting at 11:30 at night. Hey Terry McLavey, can anyone who knows him ask him if he used to live in Durban Road, Wallasey, we were mates way back as kids and he was a true blue then. From Philip Guy.
Peter Thistle
306 Posted 23/04/2012 at 04:21:31
Have to say that was a pretty sweet performance against a good UTD side. Hard to imagine that was the same Everton as the one in the first part of the season when it looked like they forgot how to play.

I guess you have to credit Peanuts and Jelly for turning it around. The passing n movement was excellent, imagine if we played like that every week ?

Sure has been a weird season. From the lack of optimisim before new year to almost believing we have the basis of a good side that can go on and do good things. Adding a couple of players would help iron out some of the inconsistency i think. Our bench needs more depth, good to see Barkley on it even if he didn't get any time on the pitch, step in the right direction.

Please sign pienarr up, we need him....
Peter Barry
307 Posted 23/04/2012 at 04:20:18
What the Moyes boys fail to understand is that it is precisely BECAUSE of games like yesterday's that Moyes must go.

Why? you ask... Well, yesterday's game proves without doubt that Everton have a team which can compete with the best. So why don't they???

There is only one reason: the MANAGER and his bottling of the big IMPORTANT games and his negative DEFENSIVE Tactically Inept approach to so many games which make Everton so boring for neutrals to watch ? and which I am sure annoys the players too.
Mick Davies
308 Posted 23/04/2012 at 05:21:58
I have never despaired of some of my fellow blues as i have after reading through this thread. Anyone would think we'd just won something. Jesus, Blackburn won at OT, and for those on here citing Hibbert as being something wonderful, take a look at the game if you've recorded it. He doesn't stop ONE cross coming in, he hoofs in 2 crosses which we all know, because of terrible defending, led to goals. He is the worst defender we've had at the club since fuckiing Darracott. And what's all this bollocks about Shrek not celebrating his goal (he did the 2nd one)? FFS, what short memories about how he treated our club and kissed the utd badge at us. Yes I think the goldfish syndrome needs addressing before our club will ever improve. As one sensible post above says. .if our players can score 4 goals against the reigning champions/champs elect, then how is it we can only score one and concede seven in 3 matches against the worst reds side in 60 years?
Joe Royle was interviewed on TV and said how he psyched his players when Oldham boss to beat 2nd place Villa to escape relegation. WTF does DM tell his team when we face the KKK? "Go out there lads and try to limit the damage. They won the CL 7 years ago"
Total surrender monkey and the sooner we get a boss with balls the better
Jamie Barlow
309 Posted 23/04/2012 at 07:51:32
Mick, why are Hibberts crosses hoofs?

I bet they'd be fantastic crosses if they came from Baines' left boot.

Give the lad a bit of credit when it's due. It just makes you look silly when you don't.
Shaun Sparke
310 Posted 23/04/2012 at 07:50:25
In the interest of fairness Mick #742 I think your post needs a little analysing. Firstly, I am surprised that you seem in such a churlish mood after a pretty decent performance yesterday. I too despair at some of my fellow Evertonians who seem to have forgotten what it is like to celebrate a good albeit non-match winning performance. Yes, Blackburn did win at Old Trafford but I wouldn't swap their league position with ours. I don't think anybody is saying that Hibbert is wonderful, but he did put in 2 wonderful crosses (not hoofs) that led to 2 great goals. His defending was ok, nothing special but maybe that is why he hasn't been first choice for much of the season.
Rooney is entitled to celebrate as much as he wants in front of his own crowd. Man Utd pay his wages and he is desperately trying to win another winners medal for them. The fact is, despite what has happened in the past the lad is and always will be an Evertonian. How would you react if you had 35.000 people screaming aggressive abuse at you whilst you were at work. He was still an uneducated kid during the badge kissing episode. Get over it, these things will make you bitter if you allow them to fester.

Finally, you talk about Moyes having no balls. That is an easy and lazy accusation to make. Give him £100 million to spend and watch him grow the biggest kahunas you have ever seen.
George McKane
311 Posted 23/04/2012 at 08:11:32
It was a great game to watch yesterday. Real free flowing football, movement and decisive passes and finishing by Everton.
Capped by The Reds getting beat (again). Great.
But makes me think even more about what happened last Saturday and at Anfield a few weeks ago - - the only game they have won at home this year.
Just cannot figure it out.
Adam Baig
312 Posted 23/04/2012 at 08:07:13
Peter 736 - Exactly right. I had the good fortune to go yesterday, and also watched it when everyone had gone to bed last night.

Some great performances out there yesterday, and it is baffling to me why we cant take that approach to every game.

Although, judging by his interview after the game, Mr Moyes seems to think that we do...

I do get the feeling that this will be Moyes last season with us - maybe I'm just hoping - and feel that a manager with a more positive attitude will be able to produce fluent, attacking displays such as yesterday's as the norm, rather than the exception.
Bob Willis
313 Posted 23/04/2012 at 08:19:06
ED!
Lot of banter naturally after the game BUT these boards are being monopolised
by the few. Same ones, Same shite, over and over again.
In fact I would say a lot of it is boring and you should start limiting the number of posts to say six per poster per discussion.
Sorry lads but you do my head in!!
Shaun Sparke
314 Posted 23/04/2012 at 08:41:43
Bob, I can't speak for the editors but if you have something to say then lets hear YOUR point of view. There is no point in criticising other posters as boring. At least they are putting their view forward. I am sure the editors and other contributors would welcome your point of view.
Steve King
315 Posted 23/04/2012 at 09:15:21
Great game and a little pride restored.

I understand the sentiment that it makes last weekend's performance all the more frustrating.

However....those of you who continue to have a go at Moyes and call for a change - I have yet to hear anyone offer up a reasonable alternative??

Who do you want??

Currently on the market are:

Steve Bruce, Peter Reid, Rafael Benitez (haha what a climb down that would be!!), Mick McCarthy, Lawrie Sanchez, Gary Megson, Nigel Pearson, Steve McClaren.......

I dont know about you, but I'd rather stick with the fella that dragged us out of annual relegation battles and into top half security on a ridiculously tight budget!
Alan Clarke
316 Posted 23/04/2012 at 09:17:52
Why did Moyes go to Man City spouting drivel about taking a knife to a gun fight yet goes to Man U with fight in his belly and belief in the team to actually go out there and achieve something?

When Moyes looks at his early season form, I think he needs to look a little bit more at himself and his own bipolar personality.
Steve King
317 Posted 23/04/2012 at 09:41:29
Alan,

maybe its because he didnt have Pienaar and Jelvic then??

We had Saha and Cahill as options up front......Enough said.

I was depressed about the shite we had to choose from....imagine how the manager felt!!
Dave Richman
318 Posted 23/04/2012 at 07:01:26
@Mick Davies #742: I had pretty much expunged the memory of Terry Darracott from my mind, and now you've just brought it all back again........

1977 League Cup Final 2nd replay....... CLEAR THE FUCKING THING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Eugene Ruane
319 Posted 23/04/2012 at 09:54:46
Steve King, you say..

"We had Saha and Cahill as options..Enough said"

Enough said my hole

It's only 'enough said' if you're not prepared to discuss the other options he had (players AND formations).

You add..

"I was depressed about the shite we had to choose from....imagine how the manager felt!!"

Ok LET'S imagine then.

I was depressed so I'm imagining he was depressed BUT with 65,000 nicker in his arse pocket...for that WEEK.

Re managers, you 'inform' is

"Currently on the market are: Steve Bruce, Peter Reid, Rafael Benitez (haha what a climb down that would be!!), Mick McCarthy, Lawrie Sanchez, Gary Megson, Nigel Pearson, Steve McClaren" and dare us to pick one.

Problem is, the premise is bollocks.

Or are you REALLY saying the only manager we can get has to be 'on the market'.

Newsflash: Moyes wasn't 'on the market' when we got him

Sorry but your arguments are imo, piss weak and amateurishly skewed.
Anto Byrne
320 Posted 23/04/2012 at 06:07:11
Chelsea will roll the Shite at least weve got that to look forward to. Looks like 7th is the best we can hope for. There were games this season when Moyes settled for a point and games he just threw away (Anfiled). Still, it was nice to get a result over SAF and do City a favour.
Paul David
321 Posted 23/04/2012 at 10:34:21
I get people saying its only a point why are people going mad over it but a point for any team at OT is a good point.

For me it wasnt about the point we gained,I still would have been relatively happy if we got beat 4-3.It was about the atitude and will to win that impressed me.

There is still no way back for me with Moyes,its too little too late but on the day the got it right.
Steve King
322 Posted 23/04/2012 at 11:39:25
Eugene,

You still haven't offered any alternatives?

Why not suggest some names to back your frankly over-aggressive arguments?
Andy Walker
323 Posted 23/04/2012 at 11:53:55
Eugene 698, so if all the fans turned up at Goodison with, as you acknowledge, your negative attitude it would be of no consequence to the team? Rubbish. Our crowd is our 12th man but wouldnt be if we all had a negative attitude and slagged off the players after every mistake. Being constructively critical is positive, being repeatedly negative has an effect on those around you and those who read this board. If you truely believed your views had no conseqeunce to anyone other than you why would you post? The fact that you post is proof you do want to express your views to other people, quite rightly, so dont try and kid us that you dont want to influence other people or that you do not have your own agenda, that's insulting others intelligence. Would you write a letter addressed to no one and post it to no one? of course not, you publish to be heard in the hope you influence. At the end of the day we are both blues, I get excited when I watch them and they play well and get results, (and pissed off when they don't), but can't understand why you still want to post negative stuff after a great performance.
Eugene Ruane
324 Posted 23/04/2012 at 12:18:03
Steve my arguments may have been 'overly aggressive' but at least they WERE arguments

(nb: arguments you ignored completely by the way)

Sorry but imo you trotted out the same lame "Well give us some alternatives" bollocks we've seen a hundred times (as if to say "Har har - get out of THAT!")

But you know what - fine.

Here's your list.

Joaquín Caparrós.

Quique Flores.

Luis García.

Manuel Pellegrini.

Unai Emery.

Ralf Rangnick

Bruno Labbadia

Edoardo Reja.

REALLY look forward to reading your opinion on each of them, then on why Moyes is a better option than ALL of them.

True they're not all 'on the market', but as I pointed out (nb: and you ignored, preferring to show how offended you were) neither was Moyes when we got him.


Stephen Kenny
325 Posted 23/04/2012 at 12:28:02
Steve King,

Ottmar Hitzfeld. Currently managing the swiss national side and earning half what Moyes gets.

Now can we finally put the "We'd never get anyone better, it'd be Megson or Jones" bollocks to bed for the last fucking time.
Anthony Lamb
326 Posted 23/04/2012 at 12:23:59
People have rightly been naming and congratulating players who put in particularly fine performances in what was a terrific team display and a great game of football. But one name that seems to have escaped well-deserved praise has been Phil Neville who I believe had his finest game yet in an Everton shirt. i have long been exasperated by his limitations in the use of the ball either in passing or crossing, especially for a man of such great experience. It has been a cause of some real frustration for on every other level the man is deserving of genuine admiration. He seems a man of some real character whose attitude on the pitch is invariably honest, competitive and truly professional, captured brilliantly by the incident of his tackle on Ferdinand and his failure to indulge in the usual player histrionics at Ferdinand's pathetic attempt at "retribution". But yesterday I could not believe what I was seeing. He combined all those qualities with a display of controlled, accurate, incisive and creative passing that raises the question as to why if he has this capacity does he fail so often to utilise it??? It beggars belief that a man can appear so limited in technical abilities so often and yet produce such a brilliant all-round display against such strong opposition. The man is indeed an enigma but I just feel he deserves genuine congratulations on a truly outstanding - if unheralded - display. There again, Tony Hibbert managed two crosses that led to goals......at 67 years of age this is all too much!
For me...not Tony!
Anthony Lamb
327 Posted 23/04/2012 at 12:54:40
ps: Just wanted to add what a totally ungracious man "Sir" Alex Ferguson is? A so called knight of the realm...services to "football" (No, simply to Manchester Utd ? and it is not "service" ? it is obscenely well paid remuneration.)

When is this craven, servile media going to take people like him to task and bring them down a peg or two? His behaviour towards the fourth official (what IS the point of these people) was utterly disgraceful with the referee taking no action against him ? was it coincidental that moments later Distin found himself booked and Ferdinand later able to get away scot-free for a clearly retributive tackle on Neville?

Ferguson is the perfect example of today's culture where "I am fine, genial, engaging etc ? until I do not get what I want". As usual it is in precisely those circumstances that one's true character emerges ? thanks for making it perfectly clear yesterday Alex!
Phil Rodgers
328 Posted 23/04/2012 at 12:51:54
I really cannot believe how bitter Ferg face is. We dominated the game for large spells. Yet somehow its a travesty. Our goals were soft? Yet theirs were Barca-esque works of fine art. Ridiculous.
Kev Johnson
329 Posted 23/04/2012 at 13:18:15
Know what you mean, Phil (813), but to be fair pretty much all managers are like that - "We score good goals, theirs were giveaways". Giving credit to the opposition is just not something managers do very often. Moyes is the same.

I suppose you could say every goal is the result of a mistake somewhere along the line.
Ciaran Duff
330 Posted 23/04/2012 at 13:24:19
I don't think that tactically we were very much different than usual. However the spirit and resilience shown were fantastic. That is something that Moyes seems to have instilled into the team.

I thought McFadden did okay when he came on. What he, Pienaar, Felli, Gibson and Jelavic have in common is that they are comfortable on the ball. Even though Felli was pushed up front, our goals were built up through patience and accurate passing not hoofball.
Ray Jacques
331 Posted 23/04/2012 at 13:17:29
Thought MotD was interesting in the way they re ran our goals as a result of Utd's poor defending but their goals were down to quality football. Typical

On Tony Hibbert's cross for the first goal, I must admit to groaning whilst the ball was in flight as I thought it was overhit. Had to quickly back track when Jelavic stuck it in the net.

For all of Hibbert's critics, I know he's not the best player we've ever had but the lad has been in the squad for 11 years now so he must have some qualities.

Wouldn't swap him for Rafael,ha. Now he is crap!!!
Steve King
332 Posted 23/04/2012 at 13:22:58
Eugene,

Joaquín Caparrós - A good CV indeed. But much like Moyes a distinct lack of silverware present (discounting 2nd tier chamionships, which is something we hope not to be competing for)


Quique Flores - Athletico Madrid, Valencia, Benfica - All had money to burn, a luxury he would receive at goodison. Doesnt mean he couldnt do it, just means he hasnt any experience of managing on a budget.

Luis Garcia - No idea who he is?

Manuael Pellegrini - Has done an excellent job at Malaga and appears to be a fine coach. I'm happy to concede that he would be great. But cant help think its a little unrealistic with no eurpoean football or rich foreign owner to offer. Both of which he has at Malaga.

Unai Emry - Dont know him

Ralf Rangnick - Why would he leave Shalke for Everton??

Bruno Labbadia - Dont know anything about him, but would be more than willing to read his CV.

Edoardo Reja - Once again I am more than willing to admit I know very little about him. But cant imagine he'd be willing to leave Lazio for Everton.

You've obviously looked into it and have backed up your views with some examples. I applaud you for it and hope that if Everton did get rid of Moyes that they would approach the subject in the same way.

Just a shame you have to SHOUT about it in capital letters all the time and attack fellow evertonians for having a different opinion.
Andy Walker
333 Posted 23/04/2012 at 13:39:49
Eugene 802.
You have simple put a list out with no reasoning or explanation as to why any of those listed are better than Moyes, then you have the nerve to ask others to say why Moyes is better!!! We just accept your agenda do we? how about taking some of your own advice and putting forward at least some arguments as to why each are better than Moyes? Here's my comments:

Joaquín Caparrós. Has lost more games than he's won as a manager and has a worst record than Moyes.

Quique Flores. Looked to have a promising career then decided to sell out for the money by running off to manage Al Ahli in UAE. Don't tell me that was a career move, he puts money first. No thanks.

Luis García Plaza I assume. Lower league Spanish manager, no thanks.

Manuel Pellegrini. Not a bad record but only won one major trophy back in 2004 and failed to win anything at Real Madrid before being sacked. Not exactly a brilliant record for a manager nearing the end of his career, he's 59 and has never managed in England.

Unai Emery. Of course he's going to leave Valencia!!

Ralf Rangnick Quit Schalke due to 'exhaustion' - couldnt hack it despite earning all that money.

Bruno Labbadia. Young inexperienced German manager, still to prove himself, certainly not a better record than Moyes, although he has potential. Too risky in my book.

Edoardo Reja. He's 67 and never managed in the UK, why put the future of our club in the hands of a manager at the end of their career?
Paul David
334 Posted 23/04/2012 at 13:46:09
I am not one for foreign managers. For it has to be Lambert if there is a change of manager. Not as free flowing as Holloway, Rodgers but defensively sound while committing men forward in attack and won two promotions in two years. Not to mention a Champions League winner as a player.
Eugene Ruane
335 Posted 23/04/2012 at 14:17:22
Andy Walker (801) - you say..

"Eugene 698, so if all the fans turned up at Goodison with, as you acknowledge, your negative attitude it would be of no consequence to the team? Rubbish!"

SFX: Family Fortunes wrong answer noise!

To be fair though I LOVE the 'so' and 'if' attempted sleight-of-hand (to be honest, I remember using it a fair bit myself in my teens).

You invent a situation, immediately assume it's real, then you..run with it.

For example..

Man 1: "I don't really like cheese"

Man 2: "So if you see someone eating cheese you think they're wrong? You think people who do wrong should be punished? You think people who eat cheese should be put in PRISON!!?

Man 1. "Er.....wh...eh....no...i just"

Too late, he's off running with his own hypothetical (FNAAR!)

Andy, if (remember now, that's only 'IF') Edward had a 'minnie-moo' instead of a 'doo-dar', he'd be Edwina (excuse the graphic medical terms)

However (important bit!) he....DOESN'T!

Sorry but you can do all the 'iffing' you want, ALL the fans aren't going to turn up at Goodison and do anything other than what they normally do.

ie: Moan, stare, cheer, swear, drink, or in your case (presumably) sing REM's Smiley Happy People for 90 mins while pulling a thorn out of a puppy's paw.

By the way, I'm not against all hypotheticals, just ones ludicrously contrived to 'win' a point.
Steve King
336 Posted 23/04/2012 at 14:24:09
Eugene

Since you've decided to study the psychology behind some peoples posts on here maybe you should consider the following anonymous statement regarding Freud's theory on the displacement of aggression:

"Displaced aggression and mental imbalance go hand in hand. I think they feed off one another and exacerbate each problem. There is an internal strength to right our negative impulses but, if the mind is already stressed then the possibility of over aggressive behavior becomes more serious.

Lashing out at others is the way of a weak minded person. Obviously a person who is unbalanced has a weak mind in some form.

The idea that all theories are valid for different reasons and for different individuals is probably the best way to deal with any undesirable behaviour. "
Jem Traynor
337 Posted 23/04/2012 at 14:28:58
I have to take back what I said earlier in a post.

I said that Neville wasn't good enough but I've just watched the game again and seen he was great too! He made a couple of mistakes but more than redeemed himself! COYB!!!!!
Steve King
338 Posted 23/04/2012 at 14:37:16
Particular reference should be made to :

The idea that all theories are valid for different reasons and for different individuals is probably the best way to deal with any undesirable behaviour. "
Trevor Lynes
339 Posted 23/04/2012 at 14:29:54
This game has been hailed as a fantastic performance as if we were a lower league side playing away at Old Trafford... before the Premier League, we beat them regularly home and away and the ONLY team that bettered us was unfortunately Liverpool. Even now, when they cannot score against other sides, they score frequently against us!

I'm pretty sure that we have a big complex about Liverpool as it's too often to be just coincidental. Liverpool have battered most teams this season and failed to score, especially at home, BUT if they could play us every week they would be in the top four... I've watched EFC since 1948 and our record since then against Liverpool is really poor. Even when they were in the 2nd Division and we were in the 1st they beat us 4 - 0 in a cup-tie. ALL their best strikers have dined out against us eg; Rush, Hunt and even Aldridge.

The draw against Utd will NEVER make up for the toothless display the previous week. We STILL need to face facts and see that our squad is ageing and needs to be completely refurbished. DM could well bale out on a high and then we will be in Shit Street!!
Eugene Ruane
340 Posted 23/04/2012 at 14:23:03
Steve King (824) you say..

"You've obviously looked into it and have backed up your views with some examples. I applaud you for it and hope that if Everton did get rid of Moyes that they would approach the subject in the same way".

Save your applause, I have no real idea who these people are.

I simply looked at a few teams close to the top of their leagues and googled their managers names.

Took about 4 mins.

My reason for doing so was to show that managers don't have to come from a list of 'on the market managers' (as your list suggested!) or for that matter (again implied) be British.

(or have to be paid 3m a year).

You finish..

"Just a shame you have to SHOUT about it in capital letters all the time and attack fellow evertonians for having a different opinion".

I have NEVER sent an all caps post.

I have (do and will continue to) use caps for emphasis on CERTAIN words.

An entirely legitimate tool when writing, as it is the ONLY way word emphasis is really possible.

By the way 'attack'?

Talk about OTT.

Eugene Ruane
341 Posted 23/04/2012 at 14:48:31
Steve - (839) you say..

"Eugene Since you've decided to study the psychology behind some peoples posts on here maybe you should consider the following anonymous statement regarding Freud's theory on the displacement of aggression"

Freud?

Nar, I'll skip it, the man was dick-happy.

(nb: well googled though!)

You continue..

"Lashing out at others is the way of a weak minded person. Obviously a person who is unbalanced has a weak mind in some form"

Hmmmm...vich in IDZELF iss ein passive-aggressive form of lashing out.

Ziss iss ein most iiiiinderesting case!
Andy Walker
342 Posted 23/04/2012 at 14:49:52
Eugene, you disappoint me, I thought we were going to have a sensible debate on possible alternative managers but seems you tried a bit of BS and got found out. Instead you choose to respond with aggression and a ranting diatribe. Pity thought you may have been man enough to have an ADULT discussion, sometimes I never learn. Thats what forum's are for, putting alternative views to be debated with mutual respect. You have expressed no argument to support your views other than something about cheese.
Andy Walker
343 Posted 23/04/2012 at 15:06:33
If Moyes left then I would want us to look at, in no particular order:
Roy Hodgson
Glen Hoddle
Mick McCarthy
Dave Jones
Roberto Martinez

I dont think any are as good as Moyes, but if we had to look then these would be my starter for 10. Its a realistic list I hope.
Paul David
344 Posted 23/04/2012 at 15:24:59
Mick McCarthy?
Andy Walker
345 Posted 23/04/2012 at 15:22:48
Eugene you wrote:
------------------------------
To be fair though I LOVE the 'so' and 'if' attempted sleight-of-hand (to be honest, I remember using it a fair bit myself in my teens).

You invent a situation, immediately assume it's real, then you..run with it.


For example..

Man 1: "I don't really like cheese"

Man 2: "So if you see someone eating cheese you think they're wrong? You think people who do wrong should be punished? You think people who eat cheese should be put in PRISON!!?
-----------------------------------------

You have just used the 'so and if' yourself!!!! Not that there's anything wrong with it in my view, but obviuosly there is in your mind. Are you now actually arguing with yourself? Chill man or your could loose the plot. Remember we all support the same team
Andy Walker
346 Posted 23/04/2012 at 15:33:11
Paul, just quite like how the guy comes across, straight talking, looks like he'ss take no crap. As I say though he's not in Moyes league, just if the worst happens and we lost him before next season.
Eugene Ruane
347 Posted 23/04/2012 at 15:46:41
Andy (849) - very surprised to hear YOU'RE disappointed.

You..didn't sound like the type.

If it's any help, can I remind you of the words of a very, very, very, VERY wise man (373).

Positivity.


Positivity


Positivity.

Andy Walker
348 Posted 23/04/2012 at 16:04:38
Quite right Eugene, you've seen the light ;) LOL

What do you reckon to the list of alternative managers?
Mark Riding
349 Posted 23/04/2012 at 16:11:22
Andy #853
Thats a pretty scary list.
Hodgson - Did you watch Liverpool last year ? Yeah, I know he is an international man of mystery and is really a dead good coach.. Wants England job..
Hoddle - Quote 'my life feels incomplete without the England job'. And has some bonkers ideas !
Mick McCarthy - scary.. just a scary thought..
Dave Jones - Would be out of his depth at Goodison, his Cardiff side bottled a few play-off finals.
Martinez - Premiership experience, but having seen Wigan play, they aint that clever, and I know the recent results are ok.
Others, Lambert, will struggle next season at Norwich I reckon..
Rogers.. will get more attractive offer..

I still would like to see someone from the club given a go if Moyes does go ( he wont ! )
Wayne Smyth
350 Posted 23/04/2012 at 17:10:17
For all those asking about alternatives to Moyes, and shouting them down as no-no's because they haven't done X Y or Z, I have a simple question.

Who would've agreed that Moyes was the man to take over from wally 10 years ago? He came in a relative unknown and yet he did a fantastic job on a limited budget and stabilised the club.

Unfortunately he's proven himself unable to get the best out of the players at his disposal on a consistent enough basis for me. Far too loyal to underperforming players and far too inflexible.
Jem Traynor
351 Posted 23/04/2012 at 17:38:06
Look it's simple... If he wants to go ? and that's a big IF because there is no way he will be forced out, we all know that ? then sound; bye-bye, mate, thanks for all you tried to do... but we need to get on with finding our new manager.

Brendan Rodgers! He'd be my first priority if I was BK then it would be to find a wealthy investor to really take the club through the league with a new ground to boot! Sorry Davey but if ya want to go, tara! People have had too much of it now.
Ed Fitzgerald
352 Posted 23/04/2012 at 17:32:13
I will be amazed if Moyes decides to go. He will have to find better wages for a start! Only the top clubs will be able to meet that type of demand. Plus a question I would want answered if I was an employing chairman would be what has he won? Not good enough for a top club surely and in my opinion not good enough for us either

Peter Jansson
353 Posted 23/04/2012 at 17:35:30
It is amazing. It seems that some of you in here are going to be angry at what Everton do no matter what. It would have been better to loose 4-0 against Man U.. then you would have nothing to be angry about.. that we played better than we did against the Red Shite in the semis.

Some are angry with moyes saying that he is too defensiv etc. But hello, get real, has he ever had the kind of players to play offensive style like Man C home? Not really. He had a more offensive team earlier last decade when Andrew Johnson played, when we beat Sunderland 7-1.

In the first half of this season Everton simply did not have the squad to play offensive football. That was not Moyes fault.. it was lack of money.

What has happened afterwards?
Moyes has for a strictly limited budget put Everton up to the 7th spot in the league!! He got rid of Saha that did not deliver and bought Jelavic... the best buy for 10 years, he managed to get Pienaar back and he bougt Gibson.

Do you think that was bad management? I expected Everton to be in the relegation struggle after the first 10 games... but I was totally wrong.

Moyes is a good manager - the best thing for Everton is that he stays for a long time.
Paul David
354 Posted 23/04/2012 at 18:08:44
Ok Peter,saying he didnt have the players early in the season but that doesnt explain the past 3 or 4 years of defensive football
Andy Walker
355 Posted 23/04/2012 at 18:03:49
I totally agree with you Peter. Of course no one actually knows what would happen if he left and a new manager was put in place, it could work, it might not. I happen to think it would be a massive mistake, thats my call on it, but to those who think otherwise the one point that is in no doubt is that loosing Moyes would create significant risk to our club, as it results in unavoidable uncertainty (i.e. will the replacemnt manager be any good). Sure you take a view on this inevitable risk and if you feel its a better bet to sack him then you do it. I think the risk/reward balance though is massively in favour of keeping Moyes as opposed to a new appointment. Changing personell in any business is a risk and doing it at Everton is no different. I do not think this risk is considered as seriuosly as it should be by some.
If we were languishing in the lower reaches I would have a different view, but we aren't, so I don't. My view will change if our performance changes.
Andy Walker
356 Posted 23/04/2012 at 18:19:16
To those who want a new manager, what targets would you have in mind ie league position (win, top 4, top 6), cups? Or is it simply a case of lets play more attacking football and not be that bothered where we finish as long as we dont go down? Or is it both ie league position target and always playing attacking football.
Barry Rathbone
357 Posted 23/04/2012 at 18:16:01
Peter

When he had the players he dropped them against some people we don't care for, effectively throwing the game.

At Wembley he failed against the same hob goblins.

WHEN IT MATTERS his judgement isn't very good (could Drenthe have been handled better?) and he's a stroppy drama queen.
Paul David
358 Posted 23/04/2012 at 18:26:23
Andy

For me I would be prepared to drop a couple of places if it meant being entertained every Saturday but I dont believe playing football means we will fall down the league,I can only see it helping us.

Yes change your tactics when playing the top teams but theres no excuse at home not to play the likes of Wolves off the park.
Ben Dyke
359 Posted 23/04/2012 at 17:49:55
Lets face facts that we all have our trains of thought about Moyes and no matter the opinions and perspectives that are aired here we probably wont change!

For the record I find some of the anti Moyes sentiments absolutely incredible! Why? Because I have been following Everton all my life (born in '73) and a season ticket holder for many seasons (up until about 7 yrs ago) and I rate the football served up under Moyes as the best in my life outside of the mid 80s. But I respect the fact that others disagree. And for those who do you will NEVER change my mind!! And I dont expect to change yours either! But I do expect respect towards my opinion when it is aired on Toffeeweb and you deserve respect for yours. I despair when people get shirty towards fellow blues!

As for the Man U game I have been continually gutted about Man U success since they won their first Championship in the 90s and I would love to tonk them every game but I have to recognise that we will not regularly beat them (especially at OT) until we have had years of large NET spending on our squad. In the meantime a draw there feels good. There is resignation to even say that but its the only rational perspective. This isnt about Moyes or no Moyes, it is about our level of support and resources and theirs and whilst Man U keep winning Championships, statistically the majority of other teams in those Championships will more often than not lose or draw against them. Thats just Maths!! Does it piss me off? Yes! But is it realistic? Yes.

Thats the long winded background to saying lets just enjoy the good four goals we scored and recognise we dont have strength in depth defensively to handle the best teams consistently but we do have a good attacking base of players in our first 11.
John Ford
360 Posted 23/04/2012 at 18:24:56
I agree with Peter Jansson. In my view we have a decent squad, which was made into something workable with the addition of Gibson, Jelly and Piennar. Prior to that we were a below average premier team.

This summer is, once again, a crossroads for the blues. If we add to our core we have the best chance, i believe, since 2005 of nudging above one or two of the money teams. Sell Fellaini/Johnny or Baines and we take another step back.

Paul Ferry
361 Posted 23/04/2012 at 18:21:18
Could I just chip in and say that I %100 agree with Bob Willis (754), a fine Evertonian, analyst, and test bowler (who can forget Headingly - IMO Bob was more important than the beached Somerset whale in winning that one): this thread is so boring and is serving as a tit-for-tat for Eugene (whose wit I have always admired), this Steve King fella, Walker, Sparke, and others to boot.

Gotta larf. Sparke (755) asks for the best test bowler we have ever had to give an opinion. Kevin, saying this thread has become boring and a tit-for-tat IS an opinion. It states loud and clear that we have meandered far and wide and that it has now become a soap-box for certain individuals to score points off each other. Perhaps there is some value in what Bob Willis says, that we might need a little more editorial tinkering here.

Anthony Lamb (807). Couldn't agree more mate. I watched the game for a 2nd time here in Chicago last night and watched PN all the way though, as, 1st time round, I thought he played terrific, and then I logged in and people were blasting him. So, my pies were on him and he deserves each one of your praising words. But, my word, how good were Fella, Jelly, and Nuts yesterday? Top-drawer.

Not noticing many, by the way, point out in post mortems on the goals that, in fact, the first two were down to botched clearances by (1) Hibbert and (2) Osman. Not those two again. Deary me.
Mark Riding
362 Posted 23/04/2012 at 18:45:22
Paul #908 - Im sure the 'beached Somerset whale' was born on Merseyside ? Just saying like...
Graham Wingate
363 Posted 23/04/2012 at 19:01:19
If we had played like that last saturday we would be in the FA Cup Final now
Peter Jansson
364 Posted 23/04/2012 at 18:59:45
Ben I agree with you.

If we see this from another perspective. Football has somehow become more boring now than in the 80ies. Now you need money to win. That was not the case earlier when club mentality/heart was more important because there was not much else to play for(salaries were way lower). I mean Gothenburg won the UEFA cup. Wont ever happen again.

Evertons budget is simply to low to win the premiership. Do I hate that? Yes definitely.

What is realistic for everton? I say 5-10 place is realistic. Looking at the league and at the other teams it is pretty unrealistic to believe that Everton should top Man U, Man C, Arsenal, Tottenham and Chelsea. Newcastle has been a the biggest positive surprise in my opinion this year. Maybe the prove Im wrong.

My point is that the sad reality is that Evertons 7th place in the league is rather above realistic expectations than lower.

I think the best thing we could do as Evertonians is to try to be positive when we have the chance rather than beeing angry most of the time :-). If we get angry because we are not winning any trophies we will most likely be angry at least 90 % of all years. That is not life quality.

COYB
Nick Entwistle
365 Posted 23/04/2012 at 19:56:45
Interesting that many are citing it a fault of Everton that we can only win when the pressure is off, yet it is continually thrown at Moyes that he can't get the team playing till January when the pressure to kick on comes about.

Damned if he does... etc etc.
Andy Corrie
366 Posted 23/04/2012 at 20:16:39
You'll love this:

Fellaini and Pienaar are obviously the difference when they play together and they're both on their way out this summer, along with Moyes (not Kenwright), and don't forget Bainesy of course! We're in serious shit street!

Jelavic will be the next one heading for the exit now that he's been universally marked as a definite 'consistent' performer and goal scorer.

Sorry; just wanted everyone to pull their head out of the sand for a moment, too much happiness on here.

Did I miss anyone else deserting the Goodison Titanic any time soon?
Peter Bourke
367 Posted 23/04/2012 at 23:40:19
Andy #960.
Remarkable knowledge of our transfers which are yet to take place. God help you if you swallow everything the press say about impending transfers.
James Flynn
368 Posted 24/04/2012 at 00:50:37
Andy - Did I miss anyone else deserting the Goodison Titanic any time soon?"

Besides you? No one I've seen in here. Supporting with gritted teeth I've seen. Screaming up to the heavens, "WHY is this happening"? Seen that too. But no one abandoning ship until you here.

Boat and provisions for young Andy. On your way and best of luck. May all your weather be fair friend.
Simon Temme
369 Posted 24/04/2012 at 00:43:41
I love TW. My posts are few and far between, however I always seem to manage to see all sides of the debate (Being a Toffee it's a hard thing),

Are we a proud club with amazing history and still the fourth most succesfull league club?

Are we an also-ran that views 7th as the best we can hope for?

Are we limited by lack of funds and ambition?

Do we have a manager that, to the outside world is god and splits fans opinions in his own club down the middle?

Do we have a board and Chairman who is holding the club back?

IMO the only no should be question 2
Dean Adams
370 Posted 24/04/2012 at 01:09:39
Andy Corrie - you would probably be better off going to see your doctor. He can give you some lovely little pills that will make everything in the Goodison garden ever so rosey!!!
Mick Davies
371 Posted 24/04/2012 at 03:46:13
When Moyes came in, he was like a divine wind, sweeping away the negativity that pervaded our club under Walter.

But, after a decade in which he promised to lower the average age of the team, he has now actually taken it back to before he arrived; not won a trophy when other sides have got rid of their bosses in half the time for being unsuccessful; adopted a policy of demoralising his own players before matches by bigging up the opposition; failed to bring through any proven players from the youth system despite having one of the best training facilities in the PL; and failed to win a single league game at Anfield, Old Trafford, Stamford Bridge or The Emirates in about 40 attempts.

I think the time has come for a club of our stature to expect a lot more from a man who is getting a King's ransom but still doesn't know his best team or how to change direction when a game is slipping away.
Peter Barry
372 Posted 24/04/2012 at 07:06:26
Seems like there will be a post becoming available very shortly for that Media darling Dour Davey one where he can finally realize his potential and show the world what Everton have been holding back. I refer of course to King Kenny's imminent abdication (AGAIN) from the RS. What better place for Moyes - to go to a "sleeping Giant' who just need a man with Dire Daveys tactical nous and motivational ability not forgetting of course his 'UNIQUE' knack of finding low grade footballers and turning them in to maestro's. And whats more he won't even have to move house. Sarc off. I had to put that as some on here really just don't get it.
Shaun Sparke
373 Posted 24/04/2012 at 08:35:09
Ferry #908 Thank you for sharing your hilarious and highly original observation regarding Bob Willis. Your intellect pulsates like a beacon through the mist of toffeweb contributions the way you made the connection between his name and that of a former English test bowler. Now why didn't I think of that one? Which reminds me, had anybody asked you to take them across the Mersey recently? Ho ho, I bet you have never heard that one before either.

I was actually suggesting that Bob should give an opinion on football matters and not just on what he perceived to be a boring debate. Maybe I should have articulated this clearer for those who are hard of understanding.
Leung Chi Ho
374 Posted 24/04/2012 at 10:25:33
For those who want Moyes out (surely I am not one of you), what if we bring Big Dunc back (our superhero), or Stubbs(our reserve coach), or Phil Neville (our great caption) as player-manager?! They all True Blues

I am an Evertonian since 1995 (I was 10) when we win the FA Cup, from that 7 years, we are a relegation candidate, we have no hope, no future, no money, no big star...

It is THIS DAVID MOYES bring back hope to us, from relegation candidate to European challenger.
I live in Hong Kong, most football fans a glory hunter, they love Man Utd, Liverpool, Arsenal, Chelsea in the 90s, I always get laughed by my classmate and friends for telling them my favourite club is EVERTON...
But now, Everton is admire by most football fans in Hong Kong, and no one laughed at you if you say you are a EVERTONIAN.
Thank you Moyes to transform this team and please stop to say he is not good enough.
Without him, we are playing in Championship League in 2003 and may well like what Leeds and Nottingham Forest now!!!
Eugene Ruane
375 Posted 24/04/2012 at 10:45:30
Dave we KNOW that's you!
Kevin Tully
376 Posted 24/04/2012 at 11:04:53
Peter Jansson #894,

Your'e right Moyes was only left with a mis-firing Saha at the beginning of this season.

Now - remind me how many goals Yakubu & Beckford have scored this season. it was completely down to Moyes that he sold those two players. He fucked up big time because we were left with a crock & Anichebe to lead our line. Typical Moyes - he didn't like their attitude, so rather than man- manage these players , he got rid.

That's the reson he keeps his yes men for years past their sell by date, Cahil, Osman, Hibbert etc.

" Yes boss, I can run all day and never complain."
Andy Walker
377 Posted 24/04/2012 at 12:32:14
So to those who do not want Moyes who do you want?
Kevin Tully
378 Posted 24/04/2012 at 12:42:45
Andy, can't we have Moyes, but let him show a little imagination and courage ?
Matt Butlin
379 Posted 24/04/2012 at 12:42:19
I sit here at work with a Forrest fan, a Coventry fan, a Cobblers fan and a Villa fan... I told them my tales woe about Everton and they told me to piss off.
Henry Weindling
380 Posted 24/04/2012 at 13:00:39
I believe the fact that we expect more and more as Evertonians these days is down to Moyes himself. What he has achieved has raised the bar and set standards even higher for us. He deserves credit for that. Long gone are the days where we hope/pray for 40 points, we now expect European qualification and trophies, and rightly so. After all, we have an outstanding manager and a squad that is potentially looking very strong. With a couple of good summer additions, we could be in excellent shape.

A lot of people on here are asking for more attractive football. I too would this, but the football David Moyes has served up over his entire reign has not been bad. Admittedly this season has been one of the worst, but even Moyes admitted that expectations had shifted downwards this season due to the departures of Arteta and Pienaar. We played excellent passing football when Arteta, Pienaar, the Yak and Cahill were at their peaks. People seem to conveniently forget about this. I didn?t hear anyone complaining when we enjoyed 4th place, an FA Cup Final and some very enjoyable European adventures.

I also hear people craving wins at Old Trafford, Anfield, The Emirates and Stamford Bridge. Me too. But let?s be realistic, these are not easy places to get results. We shouldn?t judge Moyes on this, or use it as an argument to get rid of him just because the likes of Blackburn, Wigan, West Brom etc have managed a win at some of these grounds, even though they face relegation battles year in year out.

As for replacements, Paul Lambert seems to be the flavour of the month on this site. He is Scottish, young, sets his teams up well, plucky, plays far from exciting/adventurous football. So really, what you are asking for is to replace David Moyes with a younger version of David Moyes, which makes little sense.

We need Moyes more than Moyes needs Everton, and the worry for us should be not how to replace him, but whether Moyes himself starts to wonder whether it?s all worthwhile.
Matt Butlin
381 Posted 24/04/2012 at 13:20:52
Yes Henry, what we need is a bit of money to eliminate the need to sell and a bit more money to eliminate the need to field players that are either declining or never really had it. Although that's been mentioned a few times before...

Stephen Kenny
382 Posted 24/04/2012 at 13:26:56
Henry,

I believe the exact opposite to be true.

There was no such thing as Everton punching above our weight up to maybe 10-15 years ago.

Also, I doubt a journalist had ever typed the words "plucky Everton" until Bill and his sidekick started constantly talking us down to anybody that would listen.

Your we need him more than he needs us comments show you fell for this hook, line and sinker.

BTW, the younger version of Moyes was a much, much better manager than this one.
Andy Walker
383 Posted 24/04/2012 at 13:23:26
Kevin would be nice but does a leopard change his spots?
Henry Weindling
384 Posted 24/04/2012 at 13:39:24
Stephen - we are currently seventh in the league, reached an FA Cup Semi Final, all achieved in a season after we sold our best players and have played shocking football. So if this is what we are achieving in a poor season, who knows what we could achieve with a few additions and a strong start. We are close to European football, despite our huge and well publicised financial contraints?

May I ask what more you realistically expect from Everton at present?
Paul Foster
385 Posted 24/04/2012 at 13:42:35
Stephen Kenny, you're damn right there was no such thing as Everton punching above our weight 10 or 15 years ago.

Far from punching above our weight, we were alternately against the ropes or flat out on the canvas, our heads spinning and blood pouring from every orifice. We were awful, we were becoming a laughing stock and the media barely even talked about us. We were the ignored, perennial losers. We were grouped with the likes of Derby Country, Middlesborough and Sheffield Wednesday - clubs with proud histories but ready for spells outside the Premier League.

It's easy to forget but I went to most home games under Kendall and Smith and we were a joke. Moyes returned pride and the media perception of Everton now is unrecognisable from the late 90s. Don't get me wrong, I think Moyes cocked up against Liverpool and I think he had a huge opportunity to win a trophy this year. But to say Moyes has done anything other than revolutionise the reputation of Everton is simply wrong.
Tony J Williams
386 Posted 24/04/2012 at 13:40:48
"Who would've agreed that Moyes was the man to take over from Wally 10 years ago? He came in a relative unknown and yet he did a fantastic job on a limited budget and stabilised the club."

Your last three words says it all. Moyes was brought in as a gamble, as for all intents and purposes it looked like we were going to get relegated.

We have moved on from that, we are an established top ten team and we derserve a better manager than a "gamble". There was no down side to Moyes, as it looked like we were knackered; now we are half decent so we need a better calibre of manager.
Stephen Kenny
387 Posted 24/04/2012 at 13:49:49
Henry,

we sold an injury prone 30yr old who had stunk the place out for over a season. Plenty were more than happy to see him leave, including me.

The rest who left were subs at best under Moyes.

Your post weren't about what we can reasonably expect.

It was stating Moyes has rasied all expectation at Everton. I don't believe that to be true. It also suggested Everton need Moyes more than he needs us, again untue IMO.

Most of your post's imply that Moyes is one of the all time greats and create excuses for all his failings.

We have won nothing for 10 years and if he stays another 10 we will win nothing. A decent point at a ground we normally get stuffed won't change that. He's as predictable as rain at an outdoor wedding.
Henry Weindling
388 Posted 24/04/2012 at 14:02:20
Stephen - I have nowhere stated that Moyes is one of the all time greats. I stated that he deserves credit for what he has achieved, which is a great deal on a tiny budget.

There is no need to create excuses for his failings, there are none.

You did not answer my question relating to your expectations for Everton so I await your response eagerly on that.

As for predictability, yes it's is fairly predictable that we will achieve a strong top half finish pushing for Europe and have a good cup run on a budget of nil under Moyes. Do you have an issue with that?
Richard Dodd
389 Posted 24/04/2012 at 13:46:21
Moyes deserves to be regarded as a very good manager if only because he has consistently brought his team in ahead of budgeted expectations.

All the figures available to us are speculation but the general impression given by both Elstone and the manager himself is that each season,the Club budgets to achieve a top ten finish. Now that, in itself may not be seen as too onerous but many of his fellow custodians fall very short of their clubs' expectations which, of course, is why so many get the sack.

I know some will say that with a wage bill placed 8th largest in the Prem and a manager carrying probably the 6th highest salary, we are right to expect more. However, we have to factor into the calculation that the net spend afforded to Moyes is but a fraction of all the clubs above us and several below!
We may well DESIRE to be up there in the European places but we have absolutely no right to EXPECT it. Meanwhile, all things considered, our manager continues to do a bloody good job!
Christine Foster
390 Posted 24/04/2012 at 14:28:33
No Richard, David Moyes was a man for a season, that season has come and gone. He has undoubted attributes that have served us well but we do have a right to expect more from a board and the management test ofnthis our club. Our football can be from the sublime to the riduculous but no one can ever say that prominent amongst his attributes are tactics or flair. Too often when there is a need to change are we left shaking our heads.

It was a really good display against Man United, but opportunities lost and the decision compounded further bybhis comments show a disgraceful consideration for what it means to be an Evertonian. They are the two moments that defined our season and defined Moyes as a manager.

There was no going back after those defeats but it was the manner in which they were allowed to happen, the tactics, the disrespect for the supporters and the sheer bloody mindlessness of comments that nailed it for me.

Thank you, but goodnight Mr Moyes.
Andy Walker
391 Posted 24/04/2012 at 14:52:38
Will anyone who wants Moyes gone put forward an alternative? Fair enough if you dont want him but you must have some thoughts on who realistically should be our manager?
Steve Barr
392 Posted 24/04/2012 at 15:17:32
Andy @ # 110,

How about we look at this from the board's point of view, with a little humour added!

Like you I believe the ?Moyes issue? is a recurring thread on TW and seems, more than most, to elicit very strong points of view from both the ?pro and anti Moyes brigades?.
Given the contrasting form displayed by Everton throughout this season, the issue is not likely to go away!

Therefore, this may be an opportune moment to consider a hypothetical scenario where Moyes? either gets the ?Spanish Archer? (al a Huddersfield Town) from Kenwright, or decides he?s had enough and resigns overnight.
Any well run business should have a Plan B for such occasions, so let?s give it a try and put ourselves in the Board?s shoes and assume we are tasked with finding a replacement!
Many have argued who could possibly do better? Well that is moot if the situation is forced and we find he?s gone.
So?. First of all we would likely lay out a JD based on what we want in a manager - to deliver the desired goals and objectives we believe are in Everton?s interest. It may go something like this:
The Role: Manager
A superb opportunity has arisen for a World Class Manager to take the lead in rebuilding Everton into the Premier club in the EPL, responsible for all aspects of running the playing and development side of the club; to include, junior and youth strategy and development, first and second team player appointment, recruitment along with complete autonomy regarding buying and selling of any player associated with the club.
The Club: Everton FC
The greatest club in the history of English football, founder member of the Football League, winner of ?X ? league titles, ?Y? FA Cups, best fans in the world etc. etc. etc.
This should get the interest of any self respecting coach/manager out there!
The Club Vision
To become the Number #1 football team in the EPL, as measured by consistence, flowing style of winning play, youth development, Premier League titles, FA Cup wins and regular qualification for the European Champions League, culminating in European Championship titles.
The Candidate
Key attributes of the Everton Manager to include:-
? A passion for cultured flowing football in the style of the legendry ?School of Science?
? Ability to work with world class players, manage their hopes and desires, in the framework of a good honest family club with a sprinkling of journeymen, young upcoming lads and good honest professionals
? Strong interpersonal skilled, charismatic and articulate
? Significant football club management experience demonstrating an ever improving record of development and achievement
The role will be based at the MECCA, L4, initially a minimum of 7days a week until the goals are accomplished i.e. turning Everton into the leading club in world football.
Assume a maximum salary of 65k (same as Moyes? current package). Assume we find a way to provide the new manager with a transfer fund of say 30m.
We set a timescale to cover a honeymoon period, a rebuilding period and a timeline to deliver the goods. We also set a trapdoor i.e. a minimum level of performance and points required each season while the rebuilding process is undertaken.
I?m sure many of you can come up with more detailed process/structure/objectives/timelines etc. but take it in the spirit it is intended, think about the potential candidates out there and come back with your recommendation, supported by at least a paragraph explaining your decision!
COYBs
Paul David
393 Posted 24/04/2012 at 15:24:32
Moyes done a great job transforming the club but has slowly been undoing his good work the last few seasons.
Peter Jansson
394 Posted 24/04/2012 at 15:46:57
#62
I think Leon Osman is one of the most underrated players in the league. He is one of the best Everton players and have saved Evertons ass a lot of times.

Last year he did not play anything until there were too many players injured. What happened? Everton started to win when he got on the pitch.

This year. He has been one of the few players in Everton that has contrubuted to offensive football and has been brilliant in many matches.

What I think Everton should improve now.
1. Get another quality forward. Jelavic plus another quality forward would be brilliant. Then you could forget Everton scoring few goals.

2. Everton should get one right defender. Even though Hibbert has been playing good lately we need new blood here. We need someone that is more like Baines here. That contribute in the offense.

Well I hope we manage to keep Pienaar and that we do not sell of quality players in the summer.
Stephen Kenny
395 Posted 24/04/2012 at 15:33:42
Henry,

It's also predicatble we will start like a tortoise and be round about the relegation places until Dec/Jan.

Usually we will get a few good hidings off good sides and we will get turned over a couple of times at home by sides full of players who aren't fit to lace our ones boots.

He will also sulk like there's no tommorrow while refusing to trade players, no matter how old or useful.

I expect us to try and play the game the way that has proven successful over the history of football I.e. passing and moving into space with attacking intent.

I expect us try our best in every competition with the aim of wiinning a cup or at the very least reaching a final every 2/3 years.

I expect our history and heritage to be respected by not belittling us at every opportunity just because a few sides have a bit more money than us at this point.

I also expect us to stuff the minnows when we play them, after all they are the ones coming to a "gunfight with a knife".
Tony J Williams
396 Posted 24/04/2012 at 16:04:54
"I expect our history and heritage to be respected by not belittling us at every opportunity just because a few sides have a bit more money than us at this point" - What's our history got to do with playing a Man City side who have droped 2 points at home all season?
Andy Walker
397 Posted 24/04/2012 at 16:06:09
Stephen who would you replace Moyes with then?
Stephen Kenny
398 Posted 24/04/2012 at 16:17:19
Andy,

There are plenty of manager's who I believe would be a better option than Moyes at this point.

I've mentioned one in this thread, Ottmar Hitzfeld.

Tony,

He's done it on more than one occassion. Our history has a lot to do with how we conduct ourselves and the standards we should aspire to.

Before you talk about realism I don't expect us to tonk city because of NSNO. I expect everyone at the club to use it as a yardstick to measure against and a target to aim for whenever we fall short.

He doesn't.
Nick Entwistle
399 Posted 24/04/2012 at 16:36:19
There's no point listing a series of managers if they won't come to a cash strapped club with a sell-to-possibly-buy ethos.

Don't know if it was you Stephen who listed about ten foreign managers on another thread but how many would go to any club under these circumstances. Revise and edit job I reckon.
Stephen Kenny
400 Posted 24/04/2012 at 16:41:18
Nick,

It weren't me.

Also, I accept there is little money for transfers but there is room for manouvre in terms of player trading and we do have a decent wage budget.

Throw in we are well supported and have a lot of exposure and I think you would find we have a lot of pull for foreign coaches and up and comers like Martinez(who would be my choice). I believe an ambtitious man would look at our style of play and poor starts and see potential to upset the established order in the samw way the Geordies have.
Brendan McLaughlin
401 Posted 24/04/2012 at 16:37:29
Stephen @119
You expect us to at least reach a cup final every 2/3 years. Yeah because pre-Moyes thats the level of cup success we were acheiving. I mean other than the big money boys NO-ONE gets anywhere near that level of cup consistency.
Nick Entwistle
402 Posted 24/04/2012 at 16:54:20
I wouldn't have Martinez but I see where you're coming from citing him, but Ottmar is 63 and probably chose international football for that reason.

Stephen Kenny
403 Posted 24/04/2012 at 16:57:20
Perhaps Nick.

I cited him for the reason that some of the more blinkered Moyes supporters won't have it that there is a successful manager out there who earns less than Moyes and couldn't fill his boots.
Nick Entwistle
404 Posted 24/04/2012 at 17:03:58
I think we all know there are, but as said, there's no point saying this that and the other if they wouldn't come.

Ottmar I doubt would come to us, so you then mention Martinez who isn't a success and has proved nothing.

If you're going to replace Moyes, who may not have succeeded at Everton in terms of silverware but certainly hasn't failed overall, you're going to need to trade-up in ability. Why take the risk on trading down? They're still going to have no pot to piss in.
Jeremy Benson
405 Posted 24/04/2012 at 17:01:44
When even managers like Mark Hughes are leaving clubs because they aren't guaranteed transfer funds (and I really don't see what mark hughes has ever done to justify it..), you can see that attracting a good manager to EFC without money would be very difficult indeed.

My own personal view is that we could easily find a better manager (with relative experience) than Moyes if we had cash to splash. Sadly we don't, and I think given the environment to work in, that we would be hard pushed to find a better, proven manager than Moyes.

If we get new investment, I want change, if we dont get investment, I want the same.

So I reckon I stand right in the middle of the pro and anti-moyes camps. Call me fickle if you will...
Stephen Kenny
406 Posted 24/04/2012 at 17:10:14
Nick,

Martinez has achieved the same as Moyes in real terms.

In relative terms I'd say keeping a tiny club up for the amount of time he has, and laying the foundations for Swansea, are similar to Moyes.
Jeremy Benson
407 Posted 24/04/2012 at 17:16:08
Stephen,

martinez has finished 16th 2 seasons in a row (v lucky to escape relegation, had the lowest ever goal difference one year) might go down this time, and has also had 8 and 9 put past them in the last 12 months or so. He's also had relatively decent amount of money to spend (I checked and posted the amounts in a diff thread, can't be bothered doing so again!)

Martinez is unproven.
Stephen Kenny
408 Posted 24/04/2012 at 17:13:07
Jeremy,

Hughes left Fulham because he thought he was a shoe-in for the villa job. Villa are a much bigger club with better scope.

Fulham outspent Villa that summer so I doubt it was money to spend that made him move.
Jeremy Benson
409 Posted 24/04/2012 at 17:18:25
p.s.

and before anyone points to wigan's relative "success" against top 4 teams (if you can call success being perennial relegation fodder but beating a team or two...);

Ever wondered that maybe they get so mullered, that the top 4 teams often use that match as an opportunity to rest their players and don't put a full strength side out?

They dont do that against moyes/efc....
Stephen Kenny
410 Posted 24/04/2012 at 17:19:26
Jeremy,

I don't really believe luck plays too big a part over a 38 game season. If you stay up it's because you deserve to.

He's spent a bit but he's also had his best players sold on a few occassions. I'd be interested to see his net spend.

They also operate one of the lowest wage bills in the league.

You admit yourself you'd want Moyes gone if there was money. I assume you see him as a safe pair of hands?

Martinez has also proven he can keep a side in this division with a different style and without the players Everton can attract.

BTW, Moyes has had more than his share of stuffings over his time.
Stephen Kenny
411 Posted 24/04/2012 at 17:24:51
Man Utd FA cup semi final.

They do.
Nick Entwistle
412 Posted 24/04/2012 at 17:24:45
Sorry Stephen, but you're talking cuckoo bananas.
Stephen Kenny
413 Posted 24/04/2012 at 17:32:22
In what way Nick?
Jeremy Benson
414 Posted 24/04/2012 at 17:37:17
And conversely stephen, if you keep finishing in 16th place (and maybe get relegated this season), it's because you deserve to.

Steve Barr
415 Posted 24/04/2012 at 17:36:18
OK so let's face a certainty.

Sooner or later we will have to replace Moyes. Every club should have a plan B so what's wrong in discussing who that replacement could or should be.

A bit of mental stimulation, make assumptions.

One thing is for sure there will be someone out there who will manage Everton, post Moyes.
Jeremy Benson
416 Posted 24/04/2012 at 17:44:44
Steve,

you're right, sooner or later that situation will happen. You can't plan in advance though; as you simply aren't in control of the timing and situation.

You can draw up a shortlist right now, but in 6-12 months (when they might be needed), they might either

a) not be available (e.g. have signed a new 4 year deal as manager of spurs/man city/liverpool)
b) their stock may have dwindled (e.g. got relegated with team B/made wildly inappropriate reincarnation comments to press/being investigated by HMRC, etc..

When you need a new manager it's all down to whats around at the time.

Paul David
417 Posted 24/04/2012 at 17:44:47
I dont want Martinez because he is foreign but how people can suggest he has achieved nothing is beyond me.All things being equal Wigan should be in league 1 or lower.
Jeremy Benson
418 Posted 24/04/2012 at 17:54:12
Paul,

there are many, many people who might suggest that all things being equal, Everton should be in the championship.

Just playing devils advocate...
Paul David
419 Posted 24/04/2012 at 17:55:29
How you work that out Jeremy,I'd be interested to know how many other clubs below us have players on £70,000 a week.
Jeremy Benson
420 Posted 24/04/2012 at 17:57:48
Paul, I'm just saying what I hear from non-everton fans. But I will go and have a quick look at wage bills to see what the score is in the premiership.

We certainly have bottom 8 transfer funds...
Jeremy Benson
421 Posted 24/04/2012 at 18:02:16
Apparently, everton have the 8th highest wage bill.
Jeremy Benson
422 Posted 24/04/2012 at 18:06:26
p.s. that was a grudging acknowledgement paul that you're right.
Paul David
423 Posted 24/04/2012 at 18:03:43
I had no idea were we was on the wage bill league table but knew not many teams offer the wages we do.

I've said a few times that a few years a go it was obvious Moyes had 2 choices.

1 sell players to keep the wage bill down and raise transfer funds.

2 Keep his squad together by giving them big,long contracts and sacrificing funds for new players.

Yes BK and the board take the bulk of criticism for lack of funds but Moyes isnt blameless either.
Eugene Ruane
424 Posted 24/04/2012 at 18:10:44
Paul David (158) you begin..

"I dont want Martinez because he is foreign.."

Was that serious?
Stephen Kenny
425 Posted 24/04/2012 at 18:07:50
Jeremy,

I think 16th in the top division is brilliant for a club with Wigans standing in the game.

Whether 7th is about right for us at this point I honestly don't know?

The first half of a season says it's brilliant, the second half say's it's an underachievement.

If a club has limited resources you would expect the first half of the season when players are fresh, suspensions and injuries haven't kicked in to be the most productive.

Often a side with limited resources(Swansea this season) will do well for a while then fade as a long season takes it's toll on a small squad, yet we do the opposite.

That makes me think we may be underperforming and it's an issue with the way the squad and players are managed that this happens. Also, we are rarely still in the cup competitions by the time we come into form. This means winning anything even if the manager weren't a bottler is nigh on impossible.

I can't think of a side who have been dumped out of cup competetions by inferior sides so often over the past ten years.
Jeremy Benson
426 Posted 24/04/2012 at 18:19:35
Stephen,

I don't know. Truth is, I'm the other way round. I know the semi has been a focal point for many.

But the first half of the season, I thought we were very poor, languished in the bottom half, and I wanted moyes gone.

The second half, we've crept up to 7th, and had a decent cup run. I want him to stay (if no money).

I guess we all see things differently.
Jeremy Benson
427 Posted 24/04/2012 at 18:23:07
Sorry, think I misread your post, you're saying the same thing...
Stephen Kenny
428 Posted 24/04/2012 at 18:24:59
Jeremy,

I don't have a problem with people who wan't him to stay because they believe he does a good job.

I just find it odd when people state, almost categorically, that nobody could do better or there's no way this squad could play a better style of football when all the evidence is to the contrary.
Jeremy Benson
429 Posted 24/04/2012 at 18:30:10
Stephen,

I think there are quite a few people who could do better, and have a better style of play.

However, I believe that the majority of those people wouldn't come to everton in the current financial climate, and the minority that would, are unproven enough to a degree that I think the outcome would be uncertain and therefore, grudgingly, I recognise that Moyes is the best option at the moment with our resources.

That's my opinion, I don't mind admitting it. I want whats best for efc. I want more success, I think there may be a brighter road out there, but I do think that if we changed manager right now and under-performed for half a season, we'd find ourselves in a very dark place. (bearing in mind we only have 48 points at the moment and its been a good season...).

I recognise that some anti-moyes people might shout that I'm holding the club back...

Stephen Kenny
430 Posted 24/04/2012 at 18:40:03
I personally don't think your holding the club back any more than I'm moving it forward.

In the grand scheme of things the opinions we post on here may have 0.01% influence over the club and the media. I doubt it's even that high.

We're a talking shop that talks about one subject IMO.
Jeremy Benson
431 Posted 24/04/2012 at 18:44:45
Stephen, you're right, there isn't much influence.

I can't imagine kenwright sacking moyes, and I don't think moyes will jump to a more-afloat ship either. I think its highly likely that next season moyes will be in charge once more. At the end of that season? I'm not so sure.

Graham Mockford
432 Posted 24/04/2012 at 18:51:12
Just been away a day so just read the last 24 hours posts....... Fuck me it's groundhog day.
How many times can we contribute to a post that goes along the lines of

Anti Moyes contributor: he's shit, defensive and ruining my life.
Pro Moyes contributor: he's done a great job against all the odds and we would be shagged without him.
Eugene: In the words of Groucho Marks 'a child of five would understand this, send for a child of five'

Everton's new away kit anyone?
Stephen Kenny
433 Posted 24/04/2012 at 19:23:44
Graham,

Don't worry a few games time it'll be the OLD kenwright debate.
Paul David
434 Posted 24/04/2012 at 19:37:06
Sorry for the late post Eugene just been for a birthday dinner.

Yes I would like our manager to be British,we appear to be the only country that thinks the sun shines out of foreigners arses just because there foreign when I doubt there any better than ours yet they never get a mention at the top clubs.

Its not just the manager I would love it if the bulk of our players were British,maybe thats unrealistic but I personnally would take more pride in the team if they were nearly all British/English/Scouse.
Jeremy Benson
435 Posted 24/04/2012 at 20:11:04
Paul, thats a piss-poor excuse.

Don't you take a smart phone/wifi laptop with you when you go out for dinner?

We need answers, damn it.
Andy Walker
436 Posted 24/04/2012 at 20:38:26
Moyes isn't the best manager around... however, we can't attract the best manager around. Pep Guardiola and similar are not going to manage Everton. I think Martinez would be someone to consider should Moyes go (as opposed to being sacked), along with Hoddle, Hodgson, McCarthy and David Jones. It's not a brilliant list in my opinion and I think Moyes is by far a better bet, which is why I don't want him to go at present.
Andy Walker
437 Posted 24/04/2012 at 21:39:39
Think we have just seen an example of how motivated players, playing to a plan, fully committed can over come a far more talented team. Its not always about playing attacking football, its about playing to your strengths, which is exactly what Moyes tries to do.
Attacking football is not all it's made out to be eh?
Eugene Ruane
438 Posted 24/04/2012 at 22:11:46
Paul (191) - Couldn't agree more! The thing I don't like about foreigners is their tails. Plus they talk in some kind of babble (certainly NOT a language!). They eat disgusting oily food and come over here taking all our women. The idea that one of them could be better than a British manager is, quite frankly, ludicrous.



(I fucking despair, I really do).

Paul David
439 Posted 24/04/2012 at 22:29:02
Eugene I think you cant the wrong end of the stick,thats not were i'm coming from at all.
Paul David
440 Posted 24/04/2012 at 22:42:32
And Eugene just to let you know I had not long got back from watching the Chelsea match in my Spanish aunties house,I hated being there having to sit next in the same room as her but what i'm I to do when I dont have sky.
Eugene Ruane
441 Posted 24/04/2012 at 22:35:07
Paul (223) - genuinely curious as to where you ARE 'coming from'.

I mean did I misinterpret your response?

"..we appear to be the only country that thinks the sun shines out of foreigners arses just because there foreign"

Please explain how/why this is NOT just little Englander bollocks?

Plus you say 'we APPEAR to be'

Really?

Do you KNOW how many foreign managers work in other countries leagues?

Paul David
442 Posted 24/04/2012 at 22:54:41
Eugene if i'm honest no I dont know how many forgeign coaches are in charge of clubs in other countries but it seems to me that most of them are not forgeign.

How many forgeign coaches have Chelsea got through that have not delievered,a English coach never seems to even be rumoured with the job.

There might be a point that few English coaches have won anything but thats my point there not given the chance.

I do not think its racist to want Everton to mainly be made up of English/British players.

UEFA used to have a rule about the number of forgeigners allowed to play for a team in Europe.I dont remember anyone kicking up a fuss calling UEFA racist because of it.
Paul David
443 Posted 24/04/2012 at 23:12:51
Eugene

There are only 4 english managers in the premiership,I doubt any other nation compares to that tiny number.
Eugene Ruane
444 Posted 24/04/2012 at 23:08:38
Paul, i never mentioned 'racist'.

I'm simply baffled at how you arrive at "it seems to me that most of them are not forgeign" while admitting "I dont know how many forgeign coaches are in charge of clubs in other countries"

Does that not seem...odd?

Why does it SEEM that way - based on what?



Paul David
445 Posted 24/04/2012 at 23:18:33
Based on the names of the mangers when I see them on the tele,they tend to be German named managers in charge of German clubs,Italian named managers in charge of Italian clubs ect,I could well be wrong but thats how it seems to me.

You never mentioned racist but I think the sarcastic comment about foreign people having tails and barely talking a language is the same thing.
Eugene Ruane
446 Posted 24/04/2012 at 23:18:11
Paul (242) - You say "There are only 4 english managers in the premiership,I doubt any other nation compares to that tiny number"

And?

Seriously, what is your actual point?

Plus now you're counting ENGLISH managers?

British no good?

For the record, no i don't think you're a racist.

You are however (imo) coming across as ludicrously xenophobic.

And (also for the record) I'd take ANY manager from ANYWHERE who could do the business for Everton.
Paul David
447 Posted 24/04/2012 at 23:34:03
Eugene I just think an English/British club should have a strong English/British reprensentation (not sure if thats the right word,ironically English wasnt my strong point at school).
Marcus Kendall
448 Posted 24/04/2012 at 23:42:30
I agree with you, Paul David, I'm saddened with modern day football and the fact clubs generally are losing their national identities by fielding virtual foreign sides. That's why I applaud the likes of Athletic Bilbao and find their approach refreshing.

No doubt the likes of Eugene will accuse me of xenohobia or being a little Englander even though I don't even support the English national side. I liked the old 3 foreigner rule, I'd actually up it to 5 now and the other 6 starting players should be the same nationality as the club they play for.
Andrew Gilbert
449 Posted 24/04/2012 at 23:39:27
Eugene-

You don't half jump to conclusions, almost as much as you jump down peoples throats.

Why not just have a normal conversation without being so up you own arse?

I think it would be really nice to see more English people involved in the English game if only to help our nation be more effective at playing internationals.

Ciarán McGlone
450 Posted 25/04/2012 at 00:18:17
Ah...that classic argument..'if there was more English involved in the English game we'd be beezer'....

Do me a favour, the League would be shit - just like your national team.
Gavin Ramejkis
451 Posted 25/04/2012 at 00:24:41
Paul, I think the British trained managers who hold FA badges are all trained on a system borne from Howard Wilkinson and his mediocre dross play acting at Football coaching. Watching some of that dross in the overhyped EPL is shamefully boring with games drowned in the midfield with little if any true exciting end to end games for the majority of each season.

Foreign coaches bring a very different approach to the game where in many occasions flair and football go hand in hand and provide a much better spectacle. For me thats not a pro or anti xenophobic statement but an observation that British football in general is deull as dishwater in comparison to what is played in Europe and further afield.

A nice blend of British and Foreign coaching skills in the FA coaching badge scheme would be a starter for ten to address this mediocrity.
Jim Knightley
452 Posted 25/04/2012 at 00:34:56
In a multi-cultural society, is there not a probability of having more 'foreign' than British managers? Many of the foreign managers have also played football in England, and any label of 'foreignness' is volatile.

I think that England do not have the best players in the world, as exemplified by our trophy drought. I do not think we have the best managers either. The best rise to the top, and the english game is dominated by foreign coaches simply because they have been more successful. There is no reason for French managers or Italians to have more opportunities than English; there is no foreign conspiracy. The cream rises to the top. Scottish managers have done well, Italianstoo, and a certain portugese manager. If English managers have been less successful, I think it is because of themselves, rather than outside influences.


Mick Davies
453 Posted 25/04/2012 at 03:48:20
Henry Weidling, Everton finished 4th under Bingham and his team eventually reached a League Cup Final, but he was sacked after only 3 years. This illustrates the LOWERING of our expectations as a club.

We are the 4th most successful club in the country and if you can tell me why we arent finishing in the top 4 this season, with the squad we have, then it will probably be because we have given away games with our negativity, to name just one, our first game of the season was a pointer to how we underperformed: QPR, a side just up from the Champship with hardly a change of the previous seasons personell. They were annihilated the week before at their own ground by relegation fodder Bolton.

Sad to say but I predicted the outcome at Goodison and the very predictable Moyes is not good enough to manage our great club. A decade is long enough not to be making the same mistakes every year. He's learned nothing, fallen out with most of his attacking players and brought in a whole backroom of defenders to 'coach' our squad.

I really believe that with the right management this season we could easily have finished in the top 4 and won a trophy. It's just a pity our well paid boss doesn't share my belief.
Eugene Ruane
454 Posted 25/04/2012 at 06:02:31
Andrew Gilbert (255) you say..

"Eugene- You don't half jump to conclusions, almost as much as you jump down peoples throats"

I didn't 'jump' to anything or down anyone's throat.

My first post to Paul was in fact the opposite, I asked him if he was serious (a genuine inquiry).

The OPPOSITE of jumping down someone's throat.

You continue..

"Why not just have a normal conversation without being so up you own arse?"

When someone offers up an opinion so bereft of reason, that unfortunately is as 'normal' as it's going to get'

You finish..

"I think it would be really nice to see more English people involved in the English game if only to help our nation be more effective at playing internationals"

'Nice?'

Sorry but I don't give a fuck what/who is 'nice'.

My interest is ONLY Everton and how well/badly we do.

You make NO sensible point and then suggest it is ME that is being rude.
Paul David
455 Posted 25/04/2012 at 09:25:17
Marcus

Everything you say is how I feel,I have always admired Bilboa and not just because they have done well this season and personally think a limit of 5 foreign players would be good.

I dont have anything at all against foreign players,in the main they have greatly improved the PL.

I really dont see anything wrong in wanting a British club to have mostly British players.If other people think think I have an out dated mindset and label me for it thats upto them.
Henry Weindling
456 Posted 25/04/2012 at 09:18:25
Mick ? lowering expectations is disappointing but completely necessary. Why should Everton be challenging for Champions League places when clubs like United, City, Arsenal, Chelsea, Liverpool, Spurs are all bankrolled to the hilt? Just because we have a proud history and a decent honours list? I believe this is called living in the past.

The reality is though that we ARE challenging for silverware and European football regularly, when quite frankly we have absolutely no right to at all. Why are we able to challenge for European football and trophies? Because we have an outstanding manager in David Moyes who season after season performs well above expectations.

Richard Dodd @ 098 sums it up very well ? ?We may well DESIRE to be up there in the European places but we have absolutely no right to EXPECT it.?
Andrew Gilbert
457 Posted 25/04/2012 at 13:47:08
Eugene...Just a few of your quotes from this thread alone. Not at all rude though.


"However some (ie: Andy Walker - a poster who presumably won't buy batteries because there's a negative on one end) need to get a grip."

"Well I'm sure there's all kinds of things you don't understand, but I think you'll find even the genius Moyes does this (ever heard 'you learn by your mistakes'?)"

"Yes thanks for that Socrates."


"did you once meet Steve Martin on a plane?
(you're not a shower-curtain ring salesman by any chance?)"


"I thought I had spelled out the difference fairly clearly, but it becomes apparent that even if it was tattooed on your ball-bag, by a tattoo-artist with a blunt needle and a bad case of the Hattie Jaques, you still wouldn't see it."


"Sorry but your arguments are imo, piss weak and amateurishly skewed."


"Freud?

Nar, I'll skip it, the man was dick-happy." (Homophobia?)

Who mentioned Paul?

My point is that at times you are an extremely unpleasant poster. (Although I do give credit (for what it's worth, and to you I suspect very little.) that you know the difference between Racism and Xenophobia.
Andrew Gilbert
458 Posted 25/04/2012 at 14:17:52
P.s.

COYB!
Chris Leyland
459 Posted 25/04/2012 at 14:36:05
Just reading the debate on here about the wage bill being 8th highest. I think the reason we have a relatively high wage bill is because we don't spend big on transfers and therefore have to retain our players on relatively high wages in order to retain a squad. So, we develop a player - Rodwell for example (although not necessarily a great example) and we then have to give him a contract on good money to retain him. Or we sign a player, Cahill on the cheap and on low wages then have to renew the contract on big money.

If we were high net spenders and high wage payers then we could compare performance to others but we only spend in one and not the other.
Ciarán McGlone
460 Posted 25/04/2012 at 16:06:32
"My point is that at times you are an extremely unpleasant poster. (Although I do give credit (for what it's worth, and to you I suspect very little.) that you know the difference between Racism and Xenophobia."
--------------

Ha..not this again...get your gear on, Mr Entwistle.
Stephen Kenny
461 Posted 25/04/2012 at 18:38:52
Henry,

You just said he's raising them and now you agree lowering them is neccesary??? Make your mind up.

The reality is we aren't challenging for silverware(We haver challenged for silverware once in his time here) and we cannot qualify for Europe unless we finish 6th, which we won't. That will be our third year without European football.

All the reasons you have put forward in defence of him are false.
Terry McLavey
462 Posted 14/05/2012 at 13:22:07
#731 Philip yes it is me !! I lived at 40 and you at 28 !! My wifes website is www.starthedancer.com you can contact me through her site Hope the powers that be don't mind us using this as a friends reunited !! As we're both true blues hopefully they'll turn a blind eye!!

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads