Moyes wants early summer business

, 24 April, 156comments  |  Jump to most recent
...but will it be loans and sell-to-buy once more?
David Moyes has sent a message to Everton's Board of Directors that he wants to hit the ground running when the summer transfer window opens.

The manager lost Mikel Arteta to Arsenal once the current season was already underway and wasn't able to spend any money on incoming players, relying instead on the loan market. Royston Drenthe and Denis Stracqualursi were picked up on August's transfer deadline day but it wasn't until Moyes added Darron Gibson, Steven Pienaar and Nikica Jelavic in January that the Blues' season finally took off.

The Scot, who celebrated 10 years in charge at Goodison last month, is keen to add players to his squad but wants to avoid a repeat of that undesirable scenario next season.

?If you can add a couple of players every year it enhances your squad," he says, "it keeps you moving in the right direction and the idea would be to do something similar.

?And that would be the way to keep going forward.

?Ideally you do two or three players in the summer if you can and move a few people out. It's always better if you can do it in the summer.

?If you can do your recruitment early it makes a big difference to your group and gives them a chance to bed in and you get better results sooner.?

It's not clear, though, whether Moyes will have any transfer funds made available to him this summer or whether he will have to either sell in order to buy or scour the loan and Bosman market once more.

With so few senior players compared to most Premier League clubs, it's hard to see how he can add strength in depth in his squad if he has to offload his more saleable assets first.

Certainly his fringe or aging players will not provide a source of funds for significant squad improvement and with Drenthe almost certainly heading out the door when his loan period ends, the team will be short on flair and pace on the flanks from the outset.

Moyes has hinted that he is keen to bring Steven Pienaar back on a permanent basis but with Marouane Fellaini having already stated his desire to see the squad strengthened significantly this summer, there is pressure on the Board to find money from somewhere to make that happen, something they have been unable or unwilling to do over the past two or three years.

Moyes's January business was executed within the confines of a very tight budget, with Gibson secured for an initial outlay of just £250,000 and Jelavic's fee offset by the sale of Diniyar Bilyaletdinov to Lokomotiv Moscow.

Quotes or other material sourced from Liverpool Daily Post



Reader Comments (156)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Simon Atkins
1 Posted 24/04/2012 at 22:49:29
At last Moyes challenging the board to back him publicly with serious cash.

Over to you Mr Kenwright...
Tim Locke
2 Posted 24/04/2012 at 22:57:17
This is going one of two ways either we have money in the pipeline or Moyes is doing the ground work for leaving in the summer.
James Martin
3 Posted 24/04/2012 at 23:04:00
Every team has to sell to buy, why do we place such a stigma to it? Look at newcastle's success, sold all their best players and brought in more high quality ones. We haven't even sold that much compared to toher teams. Liverpool sold Mascherano, Alonso and Torres yet you don't hear all their fans moan about them being a selling club.
Nick Entwistle
4 Posted 24/04/2012 at 23:03:28
'Back me or sack me'. Good on him. Over to you Bill.

Nick Entwistle
5 Posted 24/04/2012 at 23:06:33
Because James, we're a sell-to-possibly-buy-if-we're-lucky club. Big difference.
Paul David
6 Posted 24/04/2012 at 23:08:27
Tim thats what I was thinking but seeing as I dont like Moyes its what i'm hoping.
Simon Harris
7 Posted 24/04/2012 at 23:12:58
Didn't he say something similar to this last year?
Andrew James
8 Posted 24/04/2012 at 23:16:08
Fellaini is right. We must buy Pienaar back. We need another flair midfielder because Osman is not up to a whole season anymore and, unless McFadden is suddenly going to prove me wrong or Barkley steps up, we need someone.

The defence should survive another season as hopefully Duffy will develop for when Distin retires. That leaves us needing a striker. Jelavic is wonderful but without him we are toothless again.

The real investment needs to go on the midfielder.
Nick Entwistle
9 Posted 24/04/2012 at 23:23:27
Midfield is sorted with Fallaini and Gibson with Rodders and Ossie, Cahill, JH and Neville covering, and the guy Silva.

We need wing players. Pienaar please, I'd still take Drenthe, and here's hopeful wishing for Donovan.

Someone young and hungry to go up front too because after Jelly we have nothing.

Oh but wait, there's no money... so Moyes to Spurs then.
Dennis Stevens
10 Posted 24/04/2012 at 23:39:06
same old same old ...
Tom Bowers
11 Posted 24/04/2012 at 23:42:11
The number one priority should be Pienaar at the right price of course and then it remains what other money is left for other players.

I believe some players should be let go and will be but opinions will differ on that point. We have aging defenders such as Distin, Neville, Hibbert... Baines we have to keep as we don't appear to have anyone in reserve for his spot?

Up front we have Jelavic but really nobody who has proven to be a worthy partner save Fellaini on Sunday and I cannot see that being a permanent ploy by Moyes.

Of the others Straqs is a strong runner but lacking something needed to make him a regular. Anichebe and Cahill have very little left to offer and Vellios doesn't seem to be popular with Moyes anymore.
Midfield has improved with Gibson and Pienaar so it remains if Rodwell and Barklay can force their way back to link up with Fellaini and I suppose Osman.
Paul David
12 Posted 24/04/2012 at 23:54:31
Ilike Albrighton at Aston Villa for the right wing spot,he been warming the bench a lot this season so might be available.I also think Leeds's Snodgrass would be cheap as he is coming up to the final year on his contract,can play on either flank as well.
Marcus Kendall
13 Posted 25/04/2012 at 00:05:44
Albrighton isn't much good, I live near Birmingham and Villa fans don't rate him much.

Snodgrass looks useful though but I don't know much about him except some decent highlights I've seen of him.
Jim Knightley
14 Posted 25/04/2012 at 00:47:51
I like both players Paul, but I dont see the point in buying them. We need to improve, and if there is money, we should look to spend it on players who will benefit the team, instead of the squad.

I think we will at most be able to fund one free transfer. We will need to sell to buy in all likelyhood, and unfortunately because Rodwell has been injured, the guy I was hoping we sell wont be going...which leaves the one I hope we don't...Fellaini.

If we do have the funds to go for a free, I'd bid for Hoilett all day long. Superb player, young, and can play wing, second striker and through the middle. Pienarr as a permanent goes without saying too of course.

Who will we sell to make funds? Jags is a possibility, but his value will have dropped this season, and it will leave us short as Distin is getting on. Heitinga and Baines: let's hope not. I can't really see much sale value in the squad, aside from the truly core players whose lost would effect us considerably.

What I (and we'd all give) to be able to compete. The gobshites across the park will likely be wasting 10s of millions again, and we will be searching the bargain buckets.
Andrew James
15 Posted 25/04/2012 at 01:16:59
@ Paul David

Snodgrass could be a good shout. He's 25 so still could come up and develop.
Keith Edmunds
16 Posted 25/04/2012 at 01:52:53
Nothing new here. Says it every year then goes moody when it doesn't happen.
Jimmy Sørheim
17 Posted 25/04/2012 at 01:48:52
I would agree that it seems as Moyes is clearing the road for him to leave, I think Moyes should leave even if he gets some money to play with.

He has grown tired of this club, and it seems he no longer knows what is best for the club, or that he does not care.

Leaving Drenthe out in the semi, fielding a reserve team against the red shites at Anfield also he has not used Barkley or Vellios the way they should be used in order for them to develop.

In the last few seasons Moyes has resisted trying out and using our best youngsters, instead he brings in crap like Mcfaaden and Straq.

We need to develop as many youngsters as possible, as we do not have the money to buy what we want.

Now both Vellios and Barkley have sat in the reserves rotting away during most of this season, they need match practice if they are to become good enough,

At the very least Moyes should start using these youngsters in the last 4 matches so that they can start looking forward to the next season and more first team play.

If Moyes does not dare to use what he has then he should LEAVE, and let someone else who can take over!

Moyes is no longer the perfect fit for Everton, he has changed for the worse, and after 10 years it is time for a new face!
Eric Myles
18 Posted 25/04/2012 at 02:43:32
James #236 "Every team has to sell to buy, why do we place such a stigma to it?"

Because of the way we go about it. We sell on the last hour of the last day of the summer transfer window so there's no chance to get replacements, then do the same again in the winter transfer window but bring in loaners, if Donovan wants to spend his winters in sunny Liverpool.

We all know that we won't get any new signings early doors as we will have to pay their wages over the summer. Same as every previous season bar one.
Peter Barry
19 Posted 25/04/2012 at 04:21:36
Quite right Tim Locke I am sure thats the ploy. After all the sycophantic lick spittle lame Stream EneMedia keep telling us that it is only Everton who are holding back the mercurial brilliant Dour Davey from stardom and it seems Davey himself has fallen for their flattery.
James Stewart
20 Posted 25/04/2012 at 04:23:31
Groundhog day starting early this year.

This was the exact same rhetoric that was being said end of last season. Nothing happened. Same old.
Peter Barry
21 Posted 25/04/2012 at 04:27:03
If we pay more for Pienarr than we sold him for then the sublime stupidity of letting him go in the first place will shine out brightly.
Jeremy Benson
22 Posted 25/04/2012 at 05:29:43
He says the same stuff every year.

How on earth have some of you jumped to the conclusion its "back me or sack me"?. Do you work for the daily mail?!
Tony Cheek
23 Posted 25/04/2012 at 05:30:05
This doesn't sound like a manager ready to quit this summer, sounds like one who has already got a new 5 year deal waiting.

Unlike him to already be talking about next season. There are still important games to play. I want us to finish above the RS. But does Davey think that is important? He bloody should do!!
Jim Harrison
24 Posted 25/04/2012 at 05:59:26
Peter, 278, He wanted to leave, and wouldnt sign a contract extension. I think the error was his! Leaving a club where he was guaranteed first team football and adulation, moving to a team with arguably better players already in his position. Chased the money. Hopefully Harry is feeling benevolent or a little pissed and does us a favor on the price.
Brian Roberts
25 Posted 25/04/2012 at 06:57:07
Losing to the lot across the park once a year is a craw in the gut...Losing twice to the underperforming lot is intolerable...waving a white flag at wembley is utter disgusting...please board dont give a penny I for one want him to piss off..
Andy Codling
26 Posted 25/04/2012 at 07:19:55
Didnt he say the same last year and as usual evertonian drones believed him them as well. This once great club is finished, unless of course you base success on a top ten finish and a day out at Wembley every couple of years.
Matt Traynor
27 Posted 25/04/2012 at 08:22:06
Andy ('#287) you're right, I think Moyes has come out with this or similar at least 3 times during his tenure, about getting the business done early.

However that cuts both ways, and if players are to be sold, wouldn't it be good if they were gone early as well? (Hell it would even save wages), but of course that would mean that money was received which the fans would demand was spent, so we see late sales, a la Rooney, Lescott and Arteta - better pay out a couple of million in wages than spend on players.

Those who think Moyes is issuing a "back me or sack me" call. We can't afford to sack him. Those who think he's paving the way for his departure, don't hold your breath. Everton is the best he'll ever get in the Premier League. As our star fades, so does his. He'll piss off to Glasgow once he's taken another £10m or so out of the club so he can survive on the £20k a week they'll pay him at Celtic. With that league becoming a one horse race, he might even win something, although I wonder if he'd gift Rangers 12 points a season?
Eugene Ruane
28 Posted 25/04/2012 at 08:48:29
Tony Cheek (281) - Sounds like that to me too.

Brian Roberts (284) - Agree completely.
Paul Mackie
29 Posted 25/04/2012 at 08:57:04
Nick #249

"Midfield is sorted with Fallaini and Gibson with Rodders and Ossie, Cahill, JH and Neville covering, and the guy Silva."

This is the funniest thing I've read on here in a while. Do you really think 5 midfield players, of which one is injury prone and the other is an over-the-hill liability in midfield is sufficient depth with 2 defenders as cover is "sorted"?

Of those 5 you mentioned only Gibson, Fellaini and Osman deserve to be starters. Heitinga and Neville have no business going near the midfield positions.

Gueye is a good prospect potentially, as is Barkley. But that still leaves us woefully short.

In my opinion we need 2 midfielders, one of which should be Pienaar and the other someone who can give us some balance down the right hand side.

Christ knows how we're going to get anyone of quality without cashing in on Fellaini (who is already making noises about wanting to play in the CL) or Baines.
Peter Barry
31 Posted 25/04/2012 at 09:49:42
Jim Harrison # 282 I think you will find he wanted pay parity with Arteta and only when Everton would not play ball did he want to leave. So my point still stands that if we buy him for millions more than we sold him for Davey's stupidity will shine out.
Dave Roberts
32 Posted 25/04/2012 at 09:42:58
Selling Baines and Fellaini in order to fund inferior players would be stupid. I'd rather we stayed as we were rather than take ten steps backward in order to take one step forward.

As we only have one left back out of nappies who would we buy to replace the best left back in the Premiership? Any club with any kind of ambition should sell a player only if it is to help fund a better one...unless the player himself wants to go of course....which is a wholly different ball game.
James Morgan
33 Posted 25/04/2012 at 09:48:14
Heard it all before. We need a right back, left back, right winger, creative centre mid and another striker, not to mention tying up Pienaar.
Anyone got a spare £30 million or so?
Richard Dodd
34 Posted 25/04/2012 at 10:29:47
With all due respect to Davey,this is a speech we hear every year-and it usually falls on deaf ears due to the cash flow situation and late receipt of Sky income etc.
Another brake on early signings is usually the need to sell first and,of course,the added burden any newcomers bring to the already stretched wage bill.
I don`t think we should spend the summer bemoaning the lack of signings and accusing the manager for a lack of activity.With the Euro championship in full swing,most managers will want to see how their prime targets perform and it could well result in a very`slow market, indeed..
Having said that Moyes is unlikely to be targeting` mega stars`and may well be more interested in persuading BK to pay the summer wages of Pienaar and Straq.
Hence the little nudge in via the piece above.
Peter Laing
35 Posted 25/04/2012 at 10:49:59
Richard there is an article on Kipper quoting Alan Stubbs saying that without investment Moyes may decide to walk as he is at the crossroads, although I cannot find any other information on the net to substanciate the claim.
Matt Traynor
36 Posted 25/04/2012 at 10:57:24
Peter (#318), how do the BK luvvers on Kipper deal with that conundrum? Or do they think that Bill's friends will magic up more cash on the basis of a new retail-led deal with TJ Hughes?
Nelly Verdonghan
37 Posted 25/04/2012 at 10:57:17
talk talk talk.....havent we hard this all before....EVERY year

Tony J Williams
38 Posted 25/04/2012 at 11:09:34
Nelly, he says it every year, and every year Bill fails to stump up the cash....I would have walked a couple of seasons ago if I were him.
Paul David
39 Posted 25/04/2012 at 11:18:40
Besides any transfer funds that might or might not be given to Moyes he could always sell players he doesnt like to buy other players.

If no players leave in the couple of weeks after the window opens I think its fair to assume Moyes is happy with what he has and only wants to add to it.

My view is there are a couple of players simply not good enough and need to be sold as soon as possible.
Richard Dodd
40 Posted 25/04/2012 at 11:25:19
I bet Subbsy`s in trouble for that outpouring unless,of course,Davey`s put him up to it!
The reality of our situation is that there is NO MONEY for signings until/unless sales are made but who can we afford to let go without actually weakening the squad?
By the way,whose likely to be going for nothing-or next to it- from Old Trafford this summer?
Andy Codling
41 Posted 25/04/2012 at 11:31:55
or Tony , you could stay with the club whilst earning 3 million pounds a year without the slightest bit of pressure from your chairman to achieve anything other than a middtable finish and the odd cup run, then spend your spare time investing in racehorses whilst feeding your ego with soundbites from pundits who think that you are next in line for the old trafford throne.
Chris James
42 Posted 25/04/2012 at 11:11:04
We need to get Pienaar clearly (and I think we have a chance there) and then someone who can play on the right. Of the suggestions above I really like the Albrighton shout (especially if Villa go down - a distinct possibility on current form), Hoillett's good too.

However, with the best will in the world that's going to cost somewhere between £7-8M I'd have thought. Maybe we have £1-2M we can squeeze out from sales vs purchases over summer but more is going to need a sale or investment. So in reality I think we'll maybe find just enough for Pienaar and anything else will be free transfers (with Moyes bringing in 1 or 2 but these won't happen till late in the window)


In terms of outs:


Drenthe's on the way out clearly (and good riddance the guy's a trouble maker)
McFadden too (a pay-as-you-play deal might make sense I suppose)
Probably Straq too (although I'd like to see him given a chance alongside Jelly for the next few games and if we could get him free and low wages, then I think his sheer effort could be an asset, certainly fitting the way we play)
On top of this a clutch of prospects who didn't breakthrough make it will likely move on (Baxter, Forshaw, maybe Wallace).

Of course, all the above will open up some wage money, but not transfer cash. In terms of sales, it's really not clear who we'd be able to release that would generate much cash.
I think it'd be safe to lose the following:
Cahill (a great servant, but time is up - let him get a final payday somewhere) - £1.5-3M?
Anichebe (Young with potential and scored goals, but not shown enough to command a big fee) - £3-4M?


Yobo: (We were supposed to sell last summer, maybe we can get something this year?) - £2-3M

Silva (Seems to be doing okay in Portugal, but not impressed Moyes) - £500K-1M?

Other than that, the clear way forward is to give youth a chance and I think we have some good prospects, especially in Duffy, Barkley, McAleny, Coleman, Vellios, Coleman and Rodwell. But these guys all need to be given game time to play and learn, preferably at Everton (if not, loaning out at as at present is smart move). Indeed focusing on a policy of promoting within and giving youth it's chance seems like the most sustainable way ahead for this club.
Paul David
43 Posted 25/04/2012 at 11:40:39
I think one top player will leave in the summer as selling the dead wood is not going to raise much money.We desperately need pacey wingers also another forward.

There is a lad on loan at Feynoord from City,John Guidetti who at 20 has scored 20 goals in 23 games and has said he has no interest in returning to City if he is not going to be in the first team.
Pete Bibby
44 Posted 25/04/2012 at 11:53:04
I think Rodwell could go.

I personally think if we can move on some of the old guard i.e. neville, cahill, jags it wouldnt be a bad thing.

Would love to see Pienaar in but can not see it tbh.
Daniel A Johnson
45 Posted 25/04/2012 at 11:57:40
Bill Kenwright is on the phone to Quick Quid right now.

£30 Million pay day loan with an intesret rate of 2819.7%
Daniel A Johnson
46 Posted 25/04/2012 at 12:04:16
Cahill and Rodwell need to be sold.
Jeremy Benson
47 Posted 25/04/2012 at 12:02:55
It's a bit of a lottery as inevitably there will be some players out-going. If I had to guess I'd say any of:

Heitinga
Velios
McFadden

Which won't be much of a pay day. Can't see anyone coming in for rodwell, and can't see moyes letting cahill/jags go. So as a bit of a curved ball, I can see one of the homegrown seniors such as hibbo or ossie moving on.

I think we'll end up with piennar, but I think not straq (which is a pity).

Neil Pickering
48 Posted 25/04/2012 at 12:13:45

Take whatever anyone is stupid enough to give us for Rodwell, and ship out sweetpants McFadden.

Buy Jarvis and Doyle from Wolves for a knockdown price, keep peanuts, and maybe get Donovan on loan again.

It wont happen though,and we will be scratchin around at 9pm on deadline day for people u aint heard of.
Greg Lambden
49 Posted 25/04/2012 at 12:23:54
He said exactly the same last year and nothing happened. Elstone has already revealed at the end of season bash that we have NO money to spend & we will need to 'trade' players. Also their are currently NO talks ongoing with buyers / investors.

Expect a big money player leaving and very little coming in. Now where have I seen this before.......
Matt Traynor
50 Posted 25/04/2012 at 12:24:52
Chris (#332) Yobo is gone. He was in the last year of his contract, and whilst I'm not sure whether Bosman applies to Turkey (not in EU, but in UEFA), any tribunal fee wouldn't be worth the legal costs. We got around EUR 800k loan fee for this season.

Other posters are right. It'll be maybe Pienaar (planned for) in, with a couple of loans. If BK really needs to raise some cash then watch as on deadline day Baines suddenly demands a move to Man U, or Fellaini to Chelsea and the deal is rushed through at 5 to midnight, no time to re-invest.

Of course like Arteta, they don't really want to go, but it will be spun that way with the usual bullshit of "he took a pay cut", or "we can't offer CL", and the majority of the fanbase will fall for it.
Paul David
51 Posted 25/04/2012 at 12:33:22
Matt

Yobo still has a couple of years or at least one left on his contract with Everton.He had not long signed a 5 year deal before falling out with Moyes.
George Blundell
52 Posted 25/04/2012 at 12:19:41
I agree with the concept that the midfield is the area wich requires the most strengthening, and like most on here I think Pienaar is key. But I think that we will be lucky to get him in especially without a few sales first!

Basically if we manage to pull off the Pienaar deal, I fear the budget will be spent. Wonder if we could blag Spurs with a Pienaar + £8m for Rodwell?

Drenthe is gone, so any wages paid will be saved. Straq in my opinion is a worthy squad player, but would hate to pay much more than a few hundred thousand for him.

McFadden is out of contract, Silva will leave (But don't expect a fee). Anichebe deserves to stay, people may not rate him, but not a bad back up player, I dont really see us needing a striker, with Jelavic, Anichebe, Cahill (Who Moyes won't sell) and Vellios.

The defence is fine, Duffy will eventually pave the way for Distin to retire (Has Distin signed a new contract yet?). Whilst we would all like to see a new RB, truth is its not priority, Hibbert and Neville (just) can do a job, and I'm still hoping Coleman will get his chance.

We should make a serious attempt to sign Hoillet, rarely do player of his potential come available, let alone on free transfers, we need to show that ambition, want and determination, that not long ago had players wanting to join Everton, despite of the finances. Another free worth a mention is Danijel Pranjić, who we nearly signed at the end of Jan, who is going to be out of contract with Bayern Munich in the summer.
Tom Bowers
53 Posted 25/04/2012 at 12:42:30
Hoilett may be a target after Moyes was seen at the Blackburn game last weekend.
He would be a replacement for the inept Osman who is so often easily pushed off the ball as he was on Sunday.
However Hoilett may become too expensive now as bigger money clubs have become alerted.
Albrighton has speed but there has to be an end product and he needs better coaching.
Kevin Tully
54 Posted 25/04/2012 at 12:37:43
How many people will be fooled into thinking we have to sell the club to a billionaire, who will invest 500-600m to see an improvement on the frauds we have in charge ?

Just not having to go overseas to fund operations would be an improvement. Not being charged ludicrous amounts of interest would help the club. Not having to mortgage future revenue would put us in a healthier financial position. If we hadn't sold all our assets, or owned our training complex, we would be more attractive as an investment. If we had improved the facilities at Goodison and removed the obstructed views, we would sell more tickets.

Apart from the above, our business plan is working a treat, so stay a few more years Bill & Co.
Matt Traynor
55 Posted 25/04/2012 at 12:43:36
Paul (#344) I see from TW player files the saga that it was - hadn't realised he'd signed on for effectively the rest of his top flight career. Either way I can't see us getting more than £1m for him, possibly another loan fee.

The problem we face as a club now, which is the real point, is we have fewer and fewer big price players we can take a risk on doing without. Cahill now won't fetch a big fee - and I'm pretty sure he'll hang on to see out his UK career here.

Jagielka and Rodwell would now be valued much lower than last seasons suitors were rumoured to be willing to pay.

That leaves Baines, Fellaini and Jelavic as players who would command upwards of £10m.
Danny Jones
56 Posted 25/04/2012 at 12:41:51
Keith Edmunds (267)
?Nothing new here. Says it every year then goes moody when it doesn't happen.?
Spot on.
This is not a ?back me or sack me?, it is just a rehash of a previous story. Possibly the same story reprinted by the lazy media.
Paul David
57 Posted 25/04/2012 at 12:39:27
Players out

Not good enough-Mucha Neville Yobo McFadden Cahill Anichebe

Sell to raise funds-Jagielka Rodwell (also not good enough) Howard (if we can sign Hennessey)

Willing to let go for big fee's-Heitinga Fellaini

Targets Hennessey,Stearman,O'Hara,Jarvis,Fletcher (Wolves) Snodrass (leeds) Allen,Graham (Swansea) Sigurdsson (Hoffenheim) Whittingham (Cardiff) Rodriguez (Burnley) McCarthy,Moses (Wigan) Brunt (West Brom) Albrighton (Villa) Badelj (Dinamo) Hooper,Ledley (Celtic) Rhodes (Hudderfield) Johnson,Guidetti (City) Tomkins (West Ham) Hanley (Blackburn)
John Ford
58 Posted 25/04/2012 at 13:04:03
'Deep depression from the man on the window ledge'

.....'sell to buy' in our case means sell our best players to be replaced by lesser players we hope will then improve and keep us competitive.

Sell Baines Fellaini or Jelavic and we're moving backwards again....and expecting Moyes to magic another star for a modest wedge. We just cant keep doing this!

Our net spend is amongst the lowest in the league.......fine, but this cant be the case season after season.
Mark Tanton
59 Posted 25/04/2012 at 13:22:59
I know you can do business from anywhere in the world now, quite easily, with technology - but I'd like to see Moyes decide against fucking off to the USA and stay at home this summer. We should re-organise our summer camp; it clearly hasn't worked.
Matt Traynor
60 Posted 25/04/2012 at 13:18:25
John (#351) but it is the case until BK sells the club, or administration creeps up and finally knocks on the door.

Moyes has done remarkably well with moving his players on and bringing others in (forgetting signings that don't work, as every manager has). I'd contend that in his time only 2 players were sold "reluctantly" - Rooney and Lescott, and both for sizeable sums. Other players that moved on he wanted rid of, either as they weren't good enough, weren't what we needed, or brought in much needed money.

Within that Moyes has to balance the overall size of the squad to cover for the injuries/suspensions that affect everyone, as well as the opportunity to just "switch it up" when individual/team form demands.

The danger is he's walking on a tightrope - bring in 2-3 players that don't work, or lose a key player reluctantly, and he's back to trying to make do.

I'm sure even Moyes now realises that he is not developing the squad any more, he's merely shuffling the cards each season to try to keep us in the Premier League. That's why I'm slightly perplexed at his reluctance to use younger players more often - Barkley, Velios and Duffy spring to mind. Developing players has to be increasingly the way we will depend.

Just like Crewe.
Matt Traynor
61 Posted 25/04/2012 at 13:27:10
Mark (#352) I think he'll be at the Euros, doing some punditry on the side to top up his meagre earnings.

On a serious note, of all the pre-seasons he's had, he always said the US trips were the best in terms of overall fitness objectives, and the squad relaxing and developing that "legendary" team spirit.

The only one I ever saw up close was Thailand in 2005, and that was terrible for us. Bolton and City were also there - can't recall how they did though in 05/06.
Richard Reeves
62 Posted 25/04/2012 at 13:40:08
And so the nightmare continues.
Richard Reeves
63 Posted 25/04/2012 at 13:45:18
I think we need another striker as cover. I think we should sell Baines for £30 mill. I think we need to sign Pienaar. I think Howard needs to wear a wig.......Aaaaarrrrrrrrgh!

Just go away, Moyes, please, just go away.
Dan McKie
64 Posted 25/04/2012 at 14:06:17
If we are sell to buy then we are sell to buy. We were sell to buy in January, and that worked out ok. It would be an improvement on last season where we were just sell, sell, sell! The problem is though, is that we are running out of players that could generate decent funds, but would detriment the team too much. In January we had Bily, but who now? Rodwell's stock has fallen too much, maybe Jags if he goes to the euros and plays? Also, we have to look at the ages of the players to sell. For a team with no cash, we cant afford to let players devalue through age like we have done already with Cahill for example. 28-29 years old with a decent transfer value, and we may have to sell, which would mean the likes of Heitinga or Baines, but if we could sell one and get maybe 3 younger replacements then it could work out. I would rather that than sell Fellaini, Coleman or Barkley.
Alex Bonnar
65 Posted 25/04/2012 at 13:56:06
I think it's wonderful that supporters are prepared to share their in-depth knowledge and experience of running a Premiership club and big business with DM and BK by advising them what to do in future. My own suggestion is that 30,000 supporters all give DM £1000 each allowing him a £30 Million transfer kitty - on which there will be no return. Easy.
Adam Bennett
66 Posted 25/04/2012 at 14:13:52
Alex 369;

This £1000 each to put in, would the £560 I gave the club 2 weeks ago count towards this?
Drew O'Neall
67 Posted 25/04/2012 at 14:21:21
Don't hold your breath for a war chest - we lose £5m a year under normal circumstances necessitating the sale of one player.

With the dramatic fall in season ticket sales this / next year, I suspect we will be well down on that figure and may have to flog two or three just to maintain the status quo.
Alex Bonnar
68 Posted 25/04/2012 at 14:30:10
Good point Adam, but that money has already been spent. Maybe £1560 for a season ticket would do it - in line with the Arsenal/Chelsea millionaire supporters.
Just being serious for a minute it would be interesting to know how much they do pay for a season ticket.
Richard Dodd
69 Posted 25/04/2012 at 14:27:29
I do so hope that this time round BK and DM can seperate the renewal of the latter`s contract from the attention needing to be given to close season signings and preparation for the new campaign.
Three years ago it certainly got in the way with both of them behaving like pantomime dames.
Just get the deal done (at 20% discount of course!)and get on with the really important stuff,PLEASE!
Graham Holliday
70 Posted 25/04/2012 at 14:33:07
Of those mentioned, my records show (I've been trying to keep records since there are none on the OS and TW's can be a touch out of date) that:

Yobo is contracted to 2014
Distin is contracted to 2013

I'd be suprised to see Moyes walk this summer, given that after 10 years he's finally got someone in that can stick the ball in the back of the bleeding net!!!
Denis Richardson
71 Posted 25/04/2012 at 14:46:23
First reaction to this for me was 'oh shit - that does not sound like a guy who thinks he's off soon' as already mentioned above.
Then after initial depression, it dawned on me that this is the same shite spouted practically every year towards the end of the season so nothing new.

For all the talk about needing funds for transfers, there are 100+ premiership players on a free at the end of this season. Not to mention the ones that will become available from the 3 teams that eventually go down. We dont need to necessarily sell to buy, we just need to make room in the wage bill.

Players like Cahill and Neville offer very little today and even less tomorrow to the team so why not start to move them to a coaching role or out of the club all together. Those two alone cost the club somewhere around 100k a week! Thats enough to fund at least 2-3 young hungry players on a 'free'. Add to that, getting rid of Drenthe, Macfadden and Straq must surely free up some wages for a permanent signing.

Should have sold Jags last summer for around 12-14m, if the opportunity arises again, get rid.

Also the article seems to forget that it was the Donovan loan that kick started the revival, more thant any of the other players who came in in Jan!
Colin Potter
72 Posted 25/04/2012 at 15:34:05
The earliest bit of business I would like to see, is moyes quitting this once great club of ours,along with that half baked bastard kenwright!
Andy Walker
73 Posted 25/04/2012 at 16:13:02
Fair enough Colin, but who would you put in his place, you've only givin half of your solution.
Peter Thistle
74 Posted 25/04/2012 at 18:51:17
Maybe we could trade the Toffee Lady for Pienaar?
Phill Redmond
75 Posted 25/04/2012 at 19:00:11
Didn't the same thing get said this time last year?
Danny Kewley
76 Posted 25/04/2012 at 18:40:22
Sometimes it really is about the devil you know and as much as Moyes has pissed a lot of us off this season---
to say the least!---derby capitulation(x3) aside---
Surely to fuck he has been taught some lessons this term , namely, attacking football gets results!!!

Now we have the not so wobbly Jelly, smacking them in from all sides, DM has realised at last! we need to start early--problem -- who do we sell to get the dosh for some new players?

Sam Hoare
77 Posted 25/04/2012 at 19:26:49
Have been a vocal advocate of Moyes on here and totally disbelieving of some of the moronic abuse he receives but would be interested to see a managerial change.

Realistically though Kenwright would be the man picking the replacement, could you see him persuading the likes of Brendan Rogers or Paul lambert? More likely we end up with someone of the Steve Bruce/Mick Mcarthy variety...which could go very badly for us.
Sean Patton
78 Posted 25/04/2012 at 19:24:11
Why are the board getting away with murder again. If Jelavic was paid for by selling Bilyaletdinov where has the Arteta,Beckford,Yakubu,Vaughan,Pienaar money gone if you include the sale of Bellefield that is 30M just vanished into the ether.

There should already be funds available it is outrageous that this has been brushed under the carpet.
Phill Redmond
79 Posted 25/04/2012 at 19:46:50
That must be a big carpet.......
Andy Walker
80 Posted 25/04/2012 at 19:38:36
Sean to pay off the debt so they do not breach banking covenants which if they did would be potentially disastorous.
Sean Patton
81 Posted 25/04/2012 at 19:49:53
Andy

If that is true then the next set of accounts should show a dramatic reduction in the debt, call me cynical but i will believe it when i see it.
Andy Walker
82 Posted 25/04/2012 at 19:55:25
Yes we will see Sean, will be intersting. To be clear I'm talking debt interest as well as capital debt and I probably should have said 'mostly' as no doubt there will have been exs as well. But thats my basic understanding.
Denis Richardson
83 Posted 25/04/2012 at 20:05:12
Not just bank debt Andy, we still owed some payments for transfers from past years I believe.......
Peter Askins
84 Posted 25/04/2012 at 20:34:30
From what I've heard, Warnock has persuaded Robert Snodgrass to have one more season at Leeds, in the hope of securing promotion. So, he's not likely to come, and Ken Bates would be very reluctant to do business with us again, after the Beckford and Garbutt episodes.

Moyes clearly has Scottish connections, and it wouldn't surprise me if he re-visited Rangers for the "Closing Down Sale" in the summer. He's already bought one nugget recently, and there may be others - Sone Aluko really stood out in the recent Old Firm game, playing just off the main striker.
Sam Hoare
85 Posted 25/04/2012 at 21:14:51
Hoilett would be an incredible signing but will most likely go to a richer club i would have thought.

Pranjic is another decent freebie as are Diame and rodallega from Wigan.

I would say a playmaker forward type to replace Cahill (maybe Fellaini or Barkley) a right back and a pacy (but obviously hardworking too) winger are the priorities.
Wayne Smyth
86 Posted 25/04/2012 at 21:23:05
We don't have a lot of money, so we need to be smart.

We need to get rid of/move upstairs those past their best or unlikely to play for the club. Cahill, Neville, Yobo should be moved up or out, Straq and Drenthe should not be renewed. McFadden should be let go unless he's cheap. That should free up a considerable amount in wages and perhaps even some transfer fees.

Coleman should be rotated with Hibbert at right back, Pienaar brought back in permenantly, and we should be on the lookout for cheap/young quick wingers. We also need cover for baines so I hope one of our youth players(e.g. bidwell) will be given a chance.

Any silly offers for our players should be accepted, especially those who are really not that good(£10M for jags for example). Duffy needs to get some game time next year as he has shown he's ready.

Moyes will have to make best use of free transfers, our youth system and if all else fails some loan signings. But to my mind he doesn't give youth enough opportunity. Journeymen and/or players past their best on much higher wages tend to keep the likes of Barkley, Vellios, Duffy etc from getting the first team experience they need to develop.
Steve Mink
87 Posted 25/04/2012 at 21:49:46
Since we playing Fantasy Football

Out - Mucha, Yobo, McFadden, Cahill, Anichebe

Sell if get offered good money - Jagielka Rodwell

Targets
Pienaar (obv)
Lennon (would be great for us)
Mark Noble (if Hammers don't come up)
Junior Hollett (out of our range now I suspect)
Kevin Doyle
Siggurdsson

Myachi (sp)
Joe Bibb
88 Posted 25/04/2012 at 22:28:41
it will take three months for Moyes just to sort out his new contract and it won't be at 20% less as he asked the players to take to make football more accessible.

Let's just get a new manager. Even Harry at Spurs is only on £3million. Moyes is too expensive for Everton and he hasn't been worth the expense.

The team showed at Old Trafford what we can achieve Moyes has failed in 40 games against the top clubs on their ground in the League, Time to ship him out.
Ian Bennett
89 Posted 25/04/2012 at 22:17:36
Big issue for us is not only sell to buy, but releasing wage funds.

Cant see anyone coming in for jags, so it's Coleman or Heitinga for me. The ones we would want to go are worth jot. Would expect tim and Neville to still be here next season.


Predictions:-
Out
Keeper, McFadden, yobo, drenthe, straq,Heitinga

In
Keeper, pienaar, Doyle, random right sided midfielder on loan from foreign club down on luck, random left back, unknown kid.
Ian Edwards
90 Posted 25/04/2012 at 22:56:43
Hopefully his early summer business will be a new job at another club.
Ian Smitham
91 Posted 25/04/2012 at 23:10:31
Mr Edwards, not seen or heard from you for a while, hope you are well.
Ian Edwards
92 Posted 25/04/2012 at 23:22:35
I'm fine Mr Smitham --thanks for asking. Hope you are well too. I'm utterly depressed at our club at present... especially the fact that everyone is so delighted at getting a draw and conceding 4 goals.
Gavin Ramejkis
93 Posted 25/04/2012 at 23:47:41
Steve #500

Of those you mention:

Pienaar agreed but got to be the right price
Lennon cant see it happening myself
Mark Noble not a bad shout cant see him leaving West Ham though
Junior Hollett not a cat in hell's chance of getting him
Kevin Doyle a poor man's Beattie no thanks
Siggurdsson out of our price range
John Daley
94 Posted 25/04/2012 at 23:57:19
There's probably more chance of Madonna magically regrowing her hymen than there is of Bill conjuring up some cash this summer. If I had to chuck a name into the mix then I'd say Nathaniel Clyne (RB) from Crystal Palace. He's out of contract this summer, still young with scope to improve, comfortable on the ball, pretty speedy and not afraid to get forward. On the downside, he's another short arse.
Eric Myles
95 Posted 26/04/2012 at 02:21:08
Kevin #347, there are already a lot of people on this site that have been fooled into thinking we need investment of 500-600m otherwise Bill is the best we can hope for.
Anto Byrne
96 Posted 26/04/2012 at 05:03:06
The 4-4 draw is a distraction from the real issues. Real investment in quality palyers, a tired and often clueless manager persisting with the same old tactics week in week out, playing favourites who are not performing namely Saha and Cahill who couldnt muster a shot on goal between them. Restricting oppurtunties for promising kids Duffy and Barkley, Velios Baxter and Wallace. Negative tactics ie defenders on for forwards and crab predictable football to keep it tight and nick one.

So here we are and some pundits would say 7th and a Semi is a good season. Three losses to the shite in one season is just not good enough, we should be at Wembley next month, the abject capitulation and tactical errors to allow the shite the freedom of the park and to sit back on a 1-0 lead and try to defend is not down to Distin or Coleman. Had Distin been switched on to go forward and press we would not have seen that stupid back pass. No more Moyes time for a change and that is now. Thanks for what you have done but change is needed with a ruthless hardnosed in your face manager who pays no respect to the shite the utds and the mega rich citeh and chelskis. No more mr nice guy.
Roman Sidey
97 Posted 26/04/2012 at 06:29:46
Came in late on this one and haven't read many of the posts, so apologies if I'm repeating anyone's points.

The only way we're going to get Pienaar in is if Redknapp remains the manager of Spurs. With all the humdrum in the papers this week about them having a mare of a January window, any new manager is going to recall those loaned players and use them.

If Moyes wantes early business, then he needs to learn from his past mistakes (fat chance). The summer of Lescott was an attrocious piece of transfer management. If he doesn't want to repeat it, he needs to talk to Kenwright as soon as the season is over, or as soon our place in the league is secure, about how much money he will have.

If Kenwright says none, then Moyes needs to either leave, or pimp out Fellaini, Rodwell or Jagielka to get some funds in to spend. This needs to be done by June 30th though. No more arrogant holding out and refusing to give in like he did with Roger.
Andy Walker
98 Posted 26/04/2012 at 08:20:42
Anto Byne - so who would you put in place of Moyes? Theres lots of people who seem to want him out, fair enough, and like the vast majority you make no suggestion as to who should replace him. If you sack him you need to replace him, thats the issue, who is a better manager who will want to manage Everton?
Its easy to ask for his sacking, the difficult bit is figuring out who to replace him with. Over to you or any other of the folks who want Moyes to go. I keep asking in hope rather than expectation.....
Colin Potter
99 Posted 26/04/2012 at 09:25:55
Andy Walker 405

At £65k a week, I would think there would be any number of applicants for moyess job.
Andy Walker
100 Posted 26/04/2012 at 09:40:53
Colin, yea I would apply but would you what me to manage them? Are we that desperate that we'd take anyone who will come on the cheap? Name names!!!

101 Posted 26/04/2012 at 09:41:52
On the other hand Roman, Harry might learn from his mistake and keep hold of Pienaar in case of future injuries or loss of form of his so called stars.

http://hereisthecity.com/2012/04/23/was-allowing-steven-pienaar-to-leave-tottenham-hotspur-harry-red/?
Andrew Fair
102 Posted 26/04/2012 at 09:45:25
Think this shows a lot for next season:

http://www.eplindex.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/04/Jel4.jpg

People slag off Anichebe and I admit he is a lazy so and so but he scores goals from the bench. I would have Jelavic, Anichebe and Vellios who all convert over a third of their chances this season as 3 of 4 strikers, one more (Dempsey) to add to that. In addition you then have Baxter and Hope.

I would not renew Stracq's or McFadden's contracts although Moyes probably will with the latter. It's then only a case of a replacement for Drenthe's flair and pace! Jarvis on the cheap? There is also a kid at Northampton called Jacobs, I watch him week-in & week-out as I got a couple of free season tickets this year and he looks like he could make it to the top league ? he would probably need to go out on loan to a Championship team first but with the right coaching he could make it!

Getting Pienaar signed up ASAP is a must. And getting rid of Cahill (or at least a bench player). If possible a RB. Looking at that, I would be happy with 2/3 players this year. And they wouldn't have to cost a fortune initially either. Dempsey, Jarvis, Pienaar all for £8 million?
John Whalley
103 Posted 26/04/2012 at 09:41:13
Get Glenn Hoddle. He plays exciting football and has been generally successful wherever he has been,
Dennis Stevens
104 Posted 26/04/2012 at 09:52:04
Andy, I think we can be confident that any manager won't be 'cheap', although there's plenty of scope to save on the current level of remuneration & still offer avery attractive deal. The ridiculous 'Name names!!!' call is just an attempt to deflect genuine criticism of Moyes by starting a hypothetical argument about possible replacements. As none of us can predict the future, none of us know how any new manager would fare, same as when Moyes was recruited. Given a choice between Mourhino, Martinez or Megson, for example, we would have widely varying expectations as to how each candidate might perform in the role. For all we know, Megson might lead the club to one triumph after another whilst Mourhino may get the club relegated - you don't always get what you expect. However, we do know what we've got & some people no longer fear change in the hope of improving on what we have. I suspect those that matter though, ie the Board, are quite happy with more of the same so we won't see any change unless Moyes walks. That scenario seems unlikely as I can't see that he'll have anywhere better to go to.
Barry Rathbone
105 Posted 26/04/2012 at 09:55:52
Andy Walker

You say this:
"like the vast majority you make no suggestion as to who should replace him."

Surely you're not serious.

Names are rattled off non-stop, whether you agree with the nominees is another matter.

The suggestion no-one offers alternatives or there aren't alternatives is dead and buried along with "name me someone, pound for pound over 10 yrs etc etc" baloney.

Martinez.
Andrew Fair
106 Posted 26/04/2012 at 10:13:47
Load of rubbish anti-Moyes again, surely this was meant to be about who we sign/want to sign! All any discussion turns into on this site is a "bitchfest" at Moyes. No one will have got EFC to the positions that Moyes has got us into and with the small amounts of money that he has had at his disposal. It's not just pro-Moyes fans who think this ? it's the rest of the football world, they are constantly heaping praise on the job that Moyes has done at EFC. They cant all be wrong!!!

Most TW's forget what he has done because he is a defensive coach and we can't beat the shite, but I for one would not swap him for anyone. It's not down to blind faith either but it's down to looking at the stats and the quality 11 we have on the pitch most weeks and looking at the issue with my head and not just jumping on Moyes's back when things go wrong.

I firmly believe that the majority of "haters" are also those that have seen the good times, the league wins, the cup wins etc. Well we are now in modern football it's very rare for any other to win these competitions outside the usual suspects, and until there is significant investment then our best option will be Moyes's current approach.
Denis Richardson
107 Posted 26/04/2012 at 10:06:33
Andy 550, the whole 'who would you have instead of Moyes' is really a pointless question. The person coming in does not necessarily need to be another current prem or ex prem manager.

The characteristics of the new manager are key not the name, i.e. a manager with;

-drive
-energy
-POSITIVITY
-picks players on form not loyalty
-isn't afraid to give youth a chance
-knows when to ship out the deadwood (Neville, Cahill, Billy etc)
-isnt afraid to stand up to the chariman/ board
-plays players in their proper position on a consistent basis
-does not blame specific players for mistakes in public
-willing to accept the blame when its his fault
-has a go at home against 'lesser' oposition
-is willing to be flexible with his tactics
-isnt afraid of having ago playing against the 'top' sides etc.
-doesn't cost us 3.65m a year!!

If the guy has most or all of the above charactersitics, he can come from Uranus for all I care.

Before going back to the usual 'name someone else instead' mantra - ask youself one simple question. When everyone was shouting for a new manager in 2002, had you ever heard of one David Moyes?

Do you really think there isn't a young hungry manager out there (rest of Europe included) that couldn't do a better (or at least equal) job? Yes the guy could be worse, there is always that risk, but my belief is that any half decent manager could achive our annual 'target' of a top 10 finish - but at least we would play a hell of a lot better and not be some damn predictable and boring. We may also stop the regular embarrasments of going out to non league sides in cup competitions...
Denis Richardson
108 Posted 26/04/2012 at 10:29:41
Why are so many people afraid of change and happy to stick with the turgid boredom we currently have.

A couple of decent months and its as if the period August '11 - Jan '12 never happened.

Trevor Lynes
109 Posted 26/04/2012 at 10:20:25
We have saved a lot of money on wages in the past couple of seasons, what with Arteta, Yak, Vaughan and Beckford going, but I'm still trying to get my head around the logic in denying Pienaar parity with Arteta in wages and then paying wages to Weir, Hahnemann and McFadden... it makes no sense to me at all.

The situation now is that we may have to BUY back Pienaar and pay him as much as he originally held out for... where the hell is the business sense in all that bullshit?

We must have money available from saved wages and the loaning out of lots of players every season?? We have again finished higher in the league than most other clubs so that brings revenue above the amount that all the clubs below us get. So how the hell can this club whose motto is Nothing But The Best carry on bleating about no money??

Think about it: almost every other club (plus some Championship clubs) are active in trying to strengthen and freshen up their squads every season whilst we just sit and dither. Facts are that Cahill, Neville, Distin etc are all well past their sell-buy date and plans must be made to replace them with younger players. DM was supposedly committed to lowering the age of the team... are the board similarly committed? The future of our great club is in the hands of our present board and they MUST support DM in his quest to better our squad and lower the average age.

Fans want to see new players brought in to supplement and improve what we already have and if our youngsters are not deemed good enough we must rely on decent coaches and scouts who to my mind are being paid for doing nothing! By this time, Baxter and Duffy should already be pushing for first team places. How is it that the likes of WIGAN can find unknown great players and we cannot??? Our scouting system seems bankrupt.
Richard Dodd
110 Posted 26/04/2012 at 10:39:31
`Change for change sake`and boredom with Premier mid table finishes is what saw Charlton sack Curbishley and `progress` to Division One!
Moyes has done a splendid job at Everton albeit being very well paid to do so!
Anto Byrne
111 Posted 26/04/2012 at 10:20:26
Andy Walker.

We need look no further than what we have with people like Phil Neville, Kevin Sheedy and even Duncan Ferguson. I'm sure these guys have learned from Moyes ? and don't get me wrong ? DM has done a terrific job over the last 10 years but you only have to look at Phil Neville on Sunday driving those guys forward with a never-say-die attitude. How many medals did he win with Utd and what attributes do you think he would bring from working with SAF?

The difference between the two is Neville is a winner, a very good pro footballer with a footballing brain. Yes, age has caught up with him but for me it's a no-brainer bringing in someone like this. Everton is a big job and not many will be up to it.

I hear "Who will replace Moyes?" but, at the end of the day, it's a case of time being up and him proving he can do it with a wealthier club or so-called bigger club. We are a big club and demand success; I'm not sure DM can provide it.
Denis Richardson
112 Posted 26/04/2012 at 10:46:23
Ah the Dodd is back.....

Am not asking for change simply for changes sake Doddy. Am asking for change as I am sick and tired of having Moyes as the manager due to his faults, one of which is that he bores me to the point of wrist slashing.

The main reaons however is simply that I believe another manager would be able to get this squad to play better and more entertaining football. He will also not be afraid to get rid of the deadwood and infuse some youth, pace and creativity into the team - things you dont tend to find in defender!

Would also be nice of practically our entire coaching staff were not ex defenders!
Dan McKie
113 Posted 26/04/2012 at 10:53:49
Denis, I havent forgotten those months, and I agree there should be change. I also haven't forgotten August '10 - January '11 or August '09 - January '10. People still make excuses for Moyes. He will never learn from his mistakes. We will sign nobody in the summer, probably sell someone on deadline day, they will say the cash is availabe in January but then blame the fans for when it isn't, just like last year! Moyes will sulk again and we will be taking our fists to gunfights next season.
Dennis Stevens
114 Posted 26/04/2012 at 10:58:24
Nice one, Richard! Always easier to disagree with something if you misrepresent it as something else so that you can then claim it to be a nonsense. There are plenty of reasons why some people are eager for change - at least disagree with the actual reasons put forward!
Dan McKie
115 Posted 26/04/2012 at 11:10:53
Yeah thats it Richard, give us a scenario that backs up your opinion, because that is now exactly what will happen to everyone else doing something similar. We dont want a rich investor neither because didnt Portsmouth get one of those? Eeek!!
Richard Dodd
116 Posted 26/04/2012 at 12:43:38
I know we could improve greatly on Blue Bill as chairman but didn`t Villa fans think their troubles were over when Lerner replaced Ellis and O`Neill took over from O`Leary?
Just look at them now!
Denis Richardson
117 Posted 26/04/2012 at 12:51:22
Richard, its not really complicated. If you're happy for Moyes to remain and we have similar experiences for another 5 years, your entirely at liberty to have that opinion. (BK or no BK).

For me I feel a new manager would instill some fresh impetus and ideas into the club and playing squad (and fans) and allow us to blow away some of the cobwebs so we can agree to disagree.

I don't see BK going anytime soon but I want both him and Moyes gone, preferably BK first but as long as both go am not arsed in which order it is. If Moyes is serious about his 'ambitions' and also believes the hype, then presumably he will be offered a job at a 'bigger' club this summer. (If Chelsea win the CL then Di Mateo would presumably keep his job so that leaves just Spurs).

Personally I believe when he sees the lack of offers coming from those clubs he will realise he will never have it as good as at GP and BK will stupidly offer him another 5 year contract paying 3.65m a year. If that happens, I might seriously think about supporting my second team (Reading) as I cannot even begin to contemplate another 5 years under Moyes.

Time will tell - he only has one year left so we'll see what happens in the summer
James Martin
118 Posted 26/04/2012 at 13:00:00
How many other managers would get Jelavic for 5.5 million? Arteta for 2 million, Pienaar for 2 million, Lescott for 5 million, Baines for 6, if people are going to list all the qualities that a new manager needs and claim that they would do more with this squad then they need to recognise Moyes's talents for putting this squad together on limited resources. Can every other manager who could replace Moyes do this consistently without investment? How many other team in the premer league of our level of resources have a back line consisting of Heitinga, Distin, Jagielka and Baines. So many teams in the league would kill for that. yes Moyes has his faults but if you are going to argue that a new manager would make up for all of Moyes failings ( which is not a cetainty) then it also needs to be recognised that by the same token it is not certain they would possess all of Moyes's strengths.
Denis Richardson
119 Posted 26/04/2012 at 13:08:23
James, 6m for Baines at the time was not cheap, 5m for Lescott at the time was not cheap, the price for Jelavic was due to Rangers being in receivership, Arteta was on his way out at the time, Pienaar was on his way out at the time etc etc. Am not having a go at Moyes for signing these players, all very good signnings, but its not exactly as if he signed them all for nothing!

If you want to go one, we also paid 6m for Distin, 6m for Heitinga, 4m for Jags etc - I have no problem with any of these, all good players.

However, you seem to only include the good players we currently have, why have you not mentioned Billy? Remember Shandy Andy? How could you leave out Koldrup? Davies was f'cking awseome for us as well wasnt he? We signed the Yak for 11m and sold him for 1.5m etc etc.

Listing Moyes good transfers is a bit pointless and one sided. He's had some very good ones and he's have some very bad ones - what exactly is your point?
Paul David
120 Posted 26/04/2012 at 13:20:47
James 630

Wright-£3.5m Beattie-£6.5m Davis-£3.5m Kroldrup-£5m Johnson-£8.5m Yakubu-£11.25m Distin-£5m (good player but far too high a fee) Billy-£9m

There is no doubting Moyes done well getting the players you mentioned but for everyone of them theres an equally poor signing made by Moyes.Worryingly Moyes seem particularly bad when spending big (by our standards).
Richard Dodd
121 Posted 26/04/2012 at 13:11:45
Your choice entirely, Denis, and Reading and their manager ARE the flavour of the month!

But it remains to be seen whether they can play the scintillating football you demand or whether or not their excursion into the Premier League will be any more successful than the last one.

And with Chris Samuelson calling the shots, who knows what might happen there?
Richard Dodd
122 Posted 26/04/2012 at 13:37:14
Paul, that`s true of all managers. Even SAF has signed some real turkeys in his time!
Paul David
123 Posted 26/04/2012 at 13:39:24
Richard

Yes, I know that's true and no manager can get every signing right but, if someone brings up Moyes's successfull cheap signings as proof of his ability in the transfer market, it's only fair to point out his failures as well.
Jim Knightley
124 Posted 26/04/2012 at 13:47:26
Denis what is your point re. prices? it goes without saying that they have worked out cheap retrospectively...whilst obviously there are reasons we got them cheap...any good buy is always predicated on some circumstance, or the player would not be going for little money in the first place.
Re. Moyes' transfer record, it is undoubtedly one of the most impressive in the league. We can pick out good and bad ones, but the proof is in under 2millon net spend every season, with which he has utterly transformed the squad.

A few other things...the wages we could potentially offer a manager is irrelevant; no top manager would come to us, given our financial situation. It will be near impossible to improve on Moyes' record, purely because we can't spend or generate money. If Moyes stays for the next 5 years, we will get worse. If anyone eelse comes in, bar maybe a select few of the very best, we will get worse.

Re. Martinez...I love the excessively reactionary way he is the answer to our troubles all of a sudden. Some results against the top 4, which are admittedly almost unbelievable and brilliant, has completely plastered over the rest of Wigan's season. They have consistently failed against teams around them, despite a talented squad and are still in a relegation battle. Don't get me wrong, I like Martinez and his brand of football, and if Moyes did leave, he would be one of the very very few I would like to see come in. However, don't paper over the cracks; Wigan have had an unsuccessful season.



Ian Edwards...what stupidity. Why do you think we are happy about drawing 4-4 with Manchester United? I suppose coming back from 3-1 down and 4-2 down against Champions at Old Trafford (hadnt they won every other home this year in the league?) is not a worthy achievement. We know you don't like Moyes, and from the regularity of your posts its looking like a rather disconcerting obsession.
Matt Traynor
125 Posted 26/04/2012 at 13:37:42
Richard (#636) please don't rewrite history like your Idol has to paint the whole Fortress/Samuelson/Zingarivich episode as anything other than what it was - all at the hand of BK, at the time to sideline Paul Gregg.

The fact that BK made a joke about it a year or two later in an AGM (remember them?) just serves to show his duplicity.
John Ford
126 Posted 26/04/2012 at 14:27:11
Excellent post Jim K..

Moyes's record given the financial position is very strong. The likelihood of good managers being interested in coming to Everton... or being as effective as Moyes at a club as skint as Everton is open to question.

A simple comparison with any other club without large spending power shows Moyes has done well. I'm not suggesting others couldn't, and maybe a risk is worth a punt, but there are no examples where anyone has done better than our man.
Thomas Windsor
127 Posted 26/04/2012 at 14:45:11
Time for a change but our chairman likes Moyes so no change in the summer then.
Paul David
128 Posted 26/04/2012 at 14:44:38
When are people going to realise that part of the reason we have no transfer funds is down to Moyes? He decided to sacrifice funds to tie down players on very big long-term contracts. Yes teams below us spend more on players but we by far pay more out on wages.

If Moyes was to get rid of Mucha, Neville, Cahill, McFadden, Rodwell and Anichebe (all we could easy do without) that would save the club well over £9m a year.
Dan McKie
129 Posted 26/04/2012 at 14:48:48
John, I suppose it depends on what you view as a comparison. I would say:

Curbishley at Charlton
Allardyce at Bolton
Holloway at Blackpool
Poyet at Brighton
Ferguson at Peterborough

To name just a few who did or are doing very well with very limited finances. Or are we just specifically looking between 4th and 8th in the Premier League as our barometer?
Kevin Tully
130 Posted 26/04/2012 at 14:47:55
Jim # 643,

You always quote Moyes's net spend whenever you want to defend him - fair enough.

When we received i.r.o £24m for Lescott, in one lump I believe, he went out and purchased three players from memory. Bily, Heitinga and Distin.

So he let one player go - and bought three internationals - all on top end wages. So according to your net spend defence, we spent nothing that season.

I don't think the net spend argument paints a realistic picture of transfers or funds made available or wages.
Dan McKie
131 Posted 26/04/2012 at 15:02:35
Dalglish defenders use the same arguement, Kevin. He didnt waste over £100m on players cos he got £50m for Torres which somehow cancels most of it out.
Mike Allison
132 Posted 26/04/2012 at 16:56:27
Kevin does he get no credit for signing a player for £5M and selling him for £24? Effectively he generated the money himself, and wasn't 'given it' by the board the way Chelsea and Man City do.

So I say yes, we spent nothing that season, and that is a realistic portrait of what happened and the only way to measure a managers' dealings in the transfer market. If only he'd bought someone good instead of Bilylatedinov he'd have had an absolute blinder.
John Ford
133 Posted 26/04/2012 at 18:12:00
Dan, I m really comparing premier league managers though obviously some you name would come into that category - Holloway started like a train then faded, and Allardyce was very short lived in terms of his success.

4 - 8th is realistically the best we could hope for, and is still the biggest single indicator of success simply because most games played are in the league.

It would be possible to take a lower league manager and match or even better Moyes record, but based on what we know from the premier league in recent years, it is highly unlikely. Its a question of whether its right to take a risk to achieve something noone else has done - noone has broken the glass ceiling without massive investment. Its a very bland reality.

I think Moyes will go this summer. If Villa or Spurs offer a big transfer pot he might decide its worth a punt.
Denis Richardson
134 Posted 26/04/2012 at 18:44:50
Doddy 636, Reading is my 2nd team because I grew up around there and used to go to Elm park when I was at school, not because they are doing well this season. Just fyi.

Jim 643, in answer to your first question, my point was that James 630 was listing some decent buys by Moyes as evidence of how good a manager he is but conveniently ignoring the dud buys we've had. I.e. pointless as for every good buy you can point out a shit one. Moyes nothing special in the transfer market IMO.

You then say it would be near impossible to inprove on Moyes' record - how on earth can you justify that? Thats basically saying there is no manager out there that can do better than Moyes! Last time I looked, I can remember seeing Moyes wearing a superman outfit and flying through the sky!

You hold Moyes in high regard and that is an opinion you're entitled to. However, to say that the managers wages dont matter and that no one could do better than Moyes in my opinion is bollocks.

I presume your Martinez comment was in answer to someone else. I've already said I dont care who the next manager is as long as he has the right characteristics and qualities - he does not need to have a World Cup winnning medal on his CV.
Richard Dodd
135 Posted 26/04/2012 at 19:13:10
I think it was David Hall who used to tell us that Joe Mercer always held that a manager needed to move on every 5/6 years as his players were tired of hearing the same old same old and the fans always felt somebody else could do better-regardless of results.
I guess the majority of Toffeewebbers would go along with that sentiment.
I don`t choose to.
Paul David
136 Posted 26/04/2012 at 19:42:04
Richard you seem to think Everton fans want change for the sake of it,i'd like to think we're a bit better than that.
Moyes did a fantastic job his first few years but if you judge him on the last 3 or 4 years I dont believe thats the case no more.
Richard Dodd
137 Posted 26/04/2012 at 19:51:50
Perhaps Joe had it right then!
John Ford
138 Posted 26/04/2012 at 21:42:35
Paul, the only difference I see over the past few years is that two more teams have joined the money elite, making Moyes's job more difficult.
Paul David
139 Posted 26/04/2012 at 21:48:10
John yes they have and our league finishes have dropped accordingly.Moyes has the team finishing exactly were we expect them to be but thats not my problem with him.

He plays the same formation home and away,against top or bottom.Stifles any creavitity with his negative,dont get beat rather than try and win attitude.His refusal to drop players out of form,to be honest theres lots more but would take me all night to list the things that pisses me off about Moyes.
Derek Thomas
140 Posted 26/04/2012 at 22:02:21
Blue socks or white socks- poll, this is the burning topic of the day??? taking the p*ss is what it is.
Dennis Stevens
141 Posted 26/04/2012 at 22:10:04
What about blue & white hooped socks?
Dennis Stevens
142 Posted 26/04/2012 at 22:11:08
Joe Mercer - football with a smile. I even liked England whilst he was in charge!
Roman Sidey
143 Posted 26/04/2012 at 22:21:28
Andy Walker, "Are we that desperate that we'd take anyone who will come on the cheap?"

If it's okay for Moyes to use that philosophy with bringing in players, why isn't it okay for the club to do that regarding the manager?
Jim Knightley
144 Posted 27/04/2012 at 11:57:29
Denis, you cannot misread a post and then create a position based on an argument that did not exist.

How does my comment:
'A few other things...the wages we could potentially offer a manager is irrelevant; no top manager would come to us, given our financial situation. It will be near impossible to improve on Moyes' record, purely because we can't spend or generate money. If Moyes stays for the next 5 years, we will get worse. If anyone eelse comes in, bar maybe a select few of the very best, we will get worse'
transform in your mind to this statement: However, to say that the managers wages dont matter and that no one could do better than Moyes in my opinion is bollocks.


I dont need to go into the clearly erraneous misreading. It will be near impossible to improve on Moyes' record because we have no money (i.e even less than when Moyes took over). You can't buy people without money, so therefore how are we to improve on the squad? Moyes has worked on a shoestring, but as we are now, we can only regress, because our squad is slowly eroding. What manager will come in, who will want to come, and improve us, given such a hopeless situation and Moyes record, which some Everton fans aside, is universally praised by the neutral (and some of us). Wages are irrelevant, because the person coming in as a near impossible task unless Bill shits out some money. It will be like replacing Harry at Portsmouth. We have a middle table squad with the means of a lower-bottom half prem side.

Re. wages; the comments concerning us having higher wages than many others is a fallacy. Our wages this season will be around the 12th in the division; they have been slowly slipping from around a decade high relative of 8th in the division 3-4 years ago. I provided figures concerning our wages before and then was told it was irrelevant because we paid Fellaini alot... Of those below us, Liverpool, Sunderland, Villa (insanely over-spend), Fulham and potentially now, QPR, will all be paying higher wages. Paul, your comment:

'If Moyes was to get rid of Mucha, Neville, Cahill, McFadden, Rodwell and Anichebe (all we could easy do without) that would save the club well over £9m a year'

On what planet did that come from? Apart from a clearly bizzare position (Neville, Anichebe and Cahill to a lesser degree have clearly been important to us at points this season) how exactly are we suppose to function without a squad? Let's get rid of everyone, and just keep 11...that would be a real money saver. The 6 players you mention...would save us 9million? To replace them we'd have to bring in at the very least 4 players...even on minimal wages, they would be on at least 20-25,000 each, costing over 5million in wages annually. If we wanted better players, we could have to pay more...how exactly would it save us money and benefit the team? And why wouldnt Moyes tie people down to longer contracts...in doing so, we keep a useful player for longer, prevent the loss of frees which could kill us given our position, and guarantee higher transfer fees. To go through our squad, and claim we should sell everyone who in your subjective view is unbeneficial, is bizzare.
Jim Knightley
145 Posted 27/04/2012 at 12:24:21
And Roman..the dig re. transfers is pointless. Clearly as been pointed out on here, there are two sides to Moyes' record, as there is for every manager in the world, but Moyes' is better than most in this division. We brought in Macfadden, which was annoying(and I disagreed with along with the majority), but may have been necessary if injuries mounted up as they sometimes do. We also brought in Drenthe, Denis, Donovan, Pienarr and Jelavic, who I would suggest have/had all been positive inclusions to various degrees. In this regard, despite spending very little, I would say that Moyes transfers/loans this season have been highly effective,.
Tony J Williams
146 Posted 27/04/2012 at 12:31:06
"If it's okay for Moyes to use that philosophy with bringing in players, why isn't it okay for the club to do that regarding the manager?" - because if the cheap manager fucks up big time we will be looking at relegation but if a cheap player fucks him he will be bench/dropped.

Bit of a different situation really

ps. have you paid your mate out yet for the bet about 40 goals?
Denis Richardson
147 Posted 27/04/2012 at 13:04:17
Jim - as I've said many times already, with 100+ prem players on a free at the end of this season and god knows how many in Europe, we don't need a vast transfer kitty to build a better squad - see Newcastle as an example.

We do have some players of value that could be sold and the proceeds used to get new players in (e.g. Jags, being English, would presumably fetch a high price - should have sold him to Arsenal last year anyway). Also if we clear some of the deadwood we would have space in the wage bill for younger, fresher legs (e.g Neville, Cahill, Straq, Macfadden etc).

Other managers need to sell to buy, we seem to believe that that is somehow beneath us as we're not a 'selling club' whatever that is actually supposed to mean. Moyes knows he won't get much (if any) cash so needs to start to deal with it and get rid of his over the hill favourites - which he has never been good at doing.

A better manager would do this better so yes, IMO someone else could do his job better, even with our financial contraints, and play better football to boot.

(Time will tell though, with the Barca job now also up for grabs, maybe Moyes will try his hand in La Liga - don't thing Messi tracked back enough against Chelsea - thats a joke by the way).
Paul David
148 Posted 27/04/2012 at 12:26:29
Jim

No them players have been usefull to Moyes,I doubt many would have Cahill,Neville or Anichebe in their starting 11 or they at least would not be as important to the team as Moyes believes they are.

Obviously I am not suggesting these players are to go and not be replaced,I am pointing out how much these players cost the club and hows it their wages dragging the club down.

Compare what we pay Rodwell (£30,000),a player yet to deliever anything to what West Brom pay their captain Brunt (£35,000) who would walk into our team.We over pay a large number of our players.

You say any player replacing them would be on £20-25k (I doubt this is a starting point for wages) but so what,bringing in a bog standard player (thats all it would take) to replace Cahill on £20k would save the club over £1.5m a year or are you suggesting its acceptable for a club in our financial situation to pay a player £50k who barely deserves a place on the bench.

I will again use Cahill as an example why it is rediculous to give players approaching their 30's 5 year deals (most clubs give 1 or 2).His level of performances has dropped dramatically so we're stuck with a player no longer good enough on top wages.Cahill would probably rather see out the final years of his contract out at the club bacause no other club would be foolish enough to pay him the same wages.
Roger Sunde
149 Posted 27/04/2012 at 13:28:43
Stracq has a £5m buyout which will never happen as a back-up player.
Ray Roche
150 Posted 27/04/2012 at 13:40:34
Paul

I think Rodwell was given a good contract because, at that time, he was seen as a "hot property" and we wanted to tie him down before old baconface waddled along the East Lancs with bag full of small change he'd found in his trouser turnups over the years. The fact that his career has stalled due to injury or tactics is just one of those things.
Danny James
151 Posted 27/04/2012 at 13:54:43
I for one would be happy to see Moyes sign a new 5-year contract. Replacing him would be too much of a risk in my view.

It's very easy to look at where we are now, achieving 7th or 8th place every year and reaching the semi-final of a cup competion once every 3 years on average. Then look at where we were in the 80s with trophies galore and as a result be disappointed as fans. As disappointing as it is, it is an achievement for a club in our current state to be hitting these positions regularly

Martin Jol said this week that we are a yardstick for them to aim at. West Brom, Sunderland etc have said the same thing... Which basically means they see us as a similar sized club and if we can achieve what we are achieving year-in, year-out then they are aiming to be doing the same. Their opinion of us hasn't shrunk because Moyes is a crap manager, it's to do with finances etc. We are on a more similar footing to these clubs than we are to Man Utd and Arsenal now.
Paul David
152 Posted 27/04/2012 at 15:15:00
Ray

I disagree, I have hardly seen any improvement over the years in Rodwell and believe it was a mistake not to have sold him last summer when as you say he was somehow seen as hot property.
Jim Knightley
153 Posted 27/04/2012 at 15:30:14
Firstly, re. Rodwell, don't believe the papers. Did we recieve any official offers? In my opinion, his links with Spurs (given their financial situation over the summer) were rubbish, as were the links with Chelski who have a plethora of players in his position and who could do better.

I was hoping Rodwell would play very well this second half of the season, so we could sell, but that is not the case. I think it very strange to blame Moyes though, and in this day and age, Rodwell's wages are hardly excessive, esp given his ostensible potential a couple of seasons ago (as yet unrealised). To retrospectively suggest his deal was unwise is bizarre; pretty much everton fan would have been happy at the time when he signed his deal and looked like a potential worldbeater.

Re. Cahill, I agree that his contract was too lengthy but, when he signed it, he was an invaluable player for us. Some clubs give one or two, some give more. The act of only giving older players short deals is also risky; how many top players have Arsenal lost because of a refusal to give them better contracts? There are two sides to every potential.

Denis ? that is a bizarre statement about the free transfer situation. 100s of players could not aid this team, and the top ones, such as the Hoiletts of the world, will be subject to intense competition. If we buy the poorer ones, we will just be loading our team with McFaddens.

Re Newcastle, what free transfers? Only Ba of their current top players came on in a free, and he was wanted by Moyes, and likely commanded a large signing-on fee. What other frees have Newcastle managed? Cabaye, Arfa, Tiote, Cisse, Santon all cost money.

Re Jags, Most of us would like to sell him, but who is offering? A £10 million bid last summer looks ok now with retrospect, but for an emerging England international at the time, we understandably demanded more.
Matt Traynor
154 Posted 27/04/2012 at 15:54:47
Jim (#028) raises a good point, free transfers are never free. As part of the ever increasing leaking of money from the game, agents negotiate hefty signing on fees for players on free transfers - higher if they are in demand. Even extending a players contract now comes with a "singing on fee". Arsenal are reputed to be offering van Persia a £5m fee just for extending his contract.
Paul David
155 Posted 27/04/2012 at 15:51:09
I don't think it's bizarre at all, a lot of blues before the start of the season were saying to get rid of him, some were saying the has potential so keep him. I doubt anyone thought he had fulfilled his potential and as you said there was no contact from other clubs so shouldn't Everton have been in the driving seat regarding his contract negotiations?

A 3-year deal would have been enough and on less wages, with a clause that means his wages go up and increases the length of his contract once he has proved his worth by making a certain number of appearances.

The reason I think Moyes should take some responsibility for players' contracts is because he will have a say on how long they are and will be telling BK how important or not players are to his plans. Moyes, along with a players agent, will be the biggest influence on what wages are offered.
Jim Knightley
156 Posted 27/04/2012 at 18:05:43
Paul, I think the issue is that your chronology is out of sync. Rodwell was offered and signed his contract in 2010, not in 2011. When he signed in 2010 he looked like a world beater with great potential (which whilst at the moment wholly unfufilled, could still transpire). When he signed a contract in 2010, most of us were very happy because it meant we could hold onto him for longer or command a bigger fee when selling.

Your comments re. offering him lower wages is also unrealistic. 30,000 for a top prospect, as he was in 2010, was a reasonable amount. I think we should all remember that the average premiership wage is £22,500 a week (insane isnt it?), and there are more squad players than starting players in most teams.
Paul David
157 Posted 27/04/2012 at 21:05:44
Jim

I thought it was last season he signed,sorry.I still dont understand why we give out 5 year deals to other players who never attrached interest from other clubs.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads