Pienaar wants a permanent return

, 30 April, 50comments  |  Jump to most recent
Steven Pienaar has told David Moyes he wants to turn his loan move to Everton into a permanent deal from Spurs.

Pienaar rejoined the club in January after a miserable year at White Hart Lane, he has been back to his best and played a massive part in Everton's turnaround in fortunes since the turn of the year.

It is no surprise that he wants a permanent switch back to Everton but he is under contract at Spurs and they will demand a fee for the 30-year-old which may make the move difficult for David Moyes.

He told the Daily Post: "Steven has made a huge impact for us. I don't know if we can sign him or not, but we will try after the season finishes.

"I'm sure we would all here like to keep Steven Pienaar. He has told me he wants to stay.

"If that's the case, then it gives us a chance to make it happen. Obviously though he is owned by Tottenham Hotspur.

"Steven was terrific against Fulham. He looks like he enjoys his football here where he can be appreciated and what he does is acceptable."

Quotes or other material sourced from Setanta



Reader Comments (50)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Gareth Fieldstead
1 Posted 30/04/2012 at 15:38:57
When you consider that we would get him for around £3 million and there is a chance of getting Moses and Dempsey for around £5 million each, would £13 million really be so difficult to find considering it would give Everton every chance of competing for a European place next season? It goes back to the old adage speculate to accumulate, I suppose, something this board has been unwilling to do.

If a player has to be sold that would provide those sort of funds then I would go for Rodwell and Jagielka. I think Heitinga is simply one of the best centre backs in the country and we would get another season out of Distin, with Duffy in reserve. In midfield, Rodwell simply would not get a place in the starting 11 ahead of a potential Moses, Fellaini, Gibson, Pienaar and Dempsey, we would have plenty of replacements if need be in Osman, Cahill, Neville, Gueye and Barkley.

Just a thought.
Bob Willis
2 Posted 30/04/2012 at 15:48:03
You're right!
Edward Robinson
3 Posted 30/04/2012 at 15:47:15
Gareth, I think you put up some very reasoned arguments, but I fear that we will be lucky if we keep the existing squad together, never mind bringing in fresh! We have now the basics of a great team but can we afford them? We haven't been able to in the past, and it's SO frustrating!

I notice now that Rodwell is going out of favour and Barkley is next on the chopping list... (AND he's hardly played this season!) When the cheque books appear, Kenwright's eyes light up and we lose another star!
Jeremy Benson
4 Posted 30/04/2012 at 16:22:30
I think you'll find in this current climate, finding £13 million is difficult and not as easy as you make it sound.

Banks won't lend to clubs as much as they used to... now they're shutting off their overdraft facilities and want existing debts paid back. Remember, the reason the world is in recession is because banks gave out money too easily to individuals/businesses, who could not pay it back. They learned, they stopped. They're clawing it back, not giving it out.

We don't have rich board members who are prepared to give £13 million of their own money to a transfer pot.

We've already raised money in the past, based on repaying from income in the future.

So where are we going to find £13 million from?
Peter Laing
5 Posted 30/04/2012 at 16:56:14
Depends how you look at the definition of rich board members Jeremy, are we talking about those directors who are on record as holding shares in the Club, or the shady silent men that appear to be lurking in the background.
Phil Martin
6 Posted 30/04/2012 at 16:53:32
£13M?

This is the club which sold McFadden, Pienaar and Arteta ? and gave it all to the banks.

The banks won't lend us anything because they know Bill has run out of friends to borrow from ? and hence pay them back.

We WILL lose a star player or a highly rated youngster in the summer. The question is: What measely % of that fee will find its way back to the transfer kitty?

This is the Everton way until Bill or his associates actively pursue trying to sell their shares for a fair price.
Jim Harrison
7 Posted 30/04/2012 at 16:48:33
Not sure of this, but I think the extra bonus per league place is around £800k. If we finish 7th this year and say 4th next year, the gain would be about £3.2million. By the FA websites figures, winning the FA Cup would give about £3.5million. Carling website states last year's League Cup winners as receiving £100,000. If we could boost gate receipts to 2010 levels, that would add £2plus million.

Very, very rough math I know, but I make it about £9 millionish if we win both cups and finish in the Champions League places. And this money would have to be invested before the team achieve these results. Anyone heard of a team called Leeds?

Sorry, bottom line is we need outside investment to help achieve these goals. In the meantime, we have to hope Moyes can pull another rabbit out of the hat.
Leigh Sadler
8 Posted 30/04/2012 at 17:09:09
We need to sell to buy so I would try and get as much as possible for Rodwell and Jagielka. Rodwell is injury prone and seems to have had his early promise knocked out of him. His stock will remain high for know as he played for England not so long ago but the longer he is injured/not performing his value will start to dip.

We have hardly missed him since he got injured so although it will be disappointing to see another product of our youth system sold it is the best thing to do. If we could raise 10-15 million for him we should sell.

I would also move on Jagielka. Yes he can still fill in and do a job but he has had a serious injury and is not getting any younger, and I don't think he is the same player he was 3-4 years ago. I imagine we could command in the process of £8 million for him, he has been a great servant for the club but to be succesful you have to move the right player on at the right time.

With this money try and buy Pienaar, Moses and a back central defender. We have Duffy coming through so just need somebody to cover Distin, Heitinga and Duffy. Of course it is not as easy as it sounds as it is not football manager on the PC but this is what I would try and do if I was Moyes.
John Daley
9 Posted 30/04/2012 at 17:08:31
"When you consider that we would get him for around £3 million"

Why is it presumed that Spurs would simply look to recoup what they paid for him? Daniel Levy normally seems to screw a good deal for them. Pienaar is only a year into his contract, and there must surely be other interested parties given the form he's shown for us since January.
Jeremy Benson
10 Posted 30/04/2012 at 17:15:11
Peter, it makes no difference.

We have no shareholders nor board members nor any other individual (lurking or otherwise) who want to put £13 million of their own money into a transfer pot.

There aren't many of them around these days, only the uber-rich (numbered in the hundreds on the planet probably), who can afford to toss that kind of money into the ether for entertainment (or other) purposes.

If you don't make money (we don't), and you can't borrow money (we don't appear to be able to, neither can most other people or businesses), and you're not sold (which gains a short period of some investment, in most cases), then you just have to make do. Thats life. Its not specific to EFC or football.
Ben Howard
11 Posted 30/04/2012 at 17:44:15
I think that Moyes has gone on record saying it's something 'he hopes to be able to do' speaks volumes. As a man normally so cagey with the press (for fear of other clubs stealing a headstart on our targets) and his reluctance to speak about other club's players (I never doubt the dignity of the man), there must be something in place already to acquire Pienaar from Spurs. I'd imagine it's a swap deal involving another of our players ? Jagielka perhaps?
Ian Glassey
12 Posted 30/04/2012 at 17:43:14
Pienaar has got to be the number one target but it wont be easy, Spurs wont give him away..
On a different thread all together, just watched a video of Tim Cahill Aussies Abroard on NSNO Cahills twitter site.

The man is a legend watch it...
Mark Pierpoint
13 Posted 30/04/2012 at 17:50:43
Nice idea Gareth! Pienaar, Moses and Dempsey. £13M? It may as well be £130M because we won't have that sort of money to spend unless we sell more than one of our core assets (Baines, Fellaini, Jelavic, Jags, Barkley...)

You quote £3M for Pienaar and I have seen those ultra reliable 'Sportsmail' sources on the DM website suggest this. Given that Levy bought him with only 6 months left on his deal for that amount, and given the hard bargain they always drive (Modric, Berbatov, Carrick), I just don't see it as that straight forward.
Mark Pierpoint
14 Posted 30/04/2012 at 17:57:53
Also Gareth, can we all get away from this idea that Rodwell is our Goose that laid the golden egg! The guy is next to worthless in Premier league terms. He is injured until August and his form has been patchy at best. He doesn't really boss the game in the middle of the pitch, so any pretensions of getting upwards of £5-6M for him are ludicrous.
Jamie Barlow
15 Posted 30/04/2012 at 18:15:29
Mark, I think we've seen the price young English talent goes for.

It's your £5-6 million that's ludicrous.
Barry Rathbone
16 Posted 30/04/2012 at 18:28:37
Jamie

This equation with "young and english" equating to big money is ludicrous.

Being fit with above average ability are the important bits, neither appear descriptive of Rodwell this last year.
Peter Davies
17 Posted 30/04/2012 at 18:29:01
Do you agree that this really will be THE big test for Kenwright? Here is a player who has transformed our style of play since he came back on loan. He wants to stay, Moysie wants him to stay, if we lose out because the board can't stump up the readies or we have to sell big time then I'm afraid it's bye bye Bill.
Jamie Barlow
18 Posted 30/04/2012 at 18:36:41
We're not likely to sell him this year Barry. When he is fit though, he is an English international. Which means we'll get more than £5-6 million if we wanted to sell.
Johnny Rainford
19 Posted 30/04/2012 at 18:39:12
Gareth... fair do's mate. You just said what everyone on here is hoping for... over to you Kenwright.
Phil Martin
20 Posted 30/04/2012 at 18:36:53
Peter,

As far as I can recall Kenwright has failed every major test he's ever faced.

Two stadium moves, multiple investment deals, selling our best player for a generation, selling our "prince among men", the Park End hole in the wall.

What pisses me off is that he'll come out with a story about potential investment or being linked with [insert any exciting player he can think of] at Season Ticket time early in the summer. Then totally fail to provide Moyes with any funds of any worth.

...cue stale, ever decreasing squad, and another slow start.
Ian Glassey
21 Posted 30/04/2012 at 18:39:18
Peter it is a big test for Kenwright, but this is the man who said two seasons ago, "I don't to be here next season and see Moyes with no money to spend." Well, he is still here....
James Flynn
22 Posted 30/04/2012 at 18:33:07
We need Piennar in for sure. Beyond that, why sell anyone? Lets' go into next season with what we have.

How about this way? Moyes did his summer signings, Gibson, Piennar and Jela (still can't believe that one). He just did them 6 months early. Squad's been quite re-freshed with those signings.

I have no problem us going into next season with what we have. If ownership doesn't provide funding (likely), fine. Stand pat. Don't sell anyone.
Mark Pierpoint
23 Posted 30/04/2012 at 18:50:41
True Jamie. English players do command a higher fee, i have worked that into my price. I class him in the Connor Wickham mould, the worries over his long term fitness though would cap what we can call his resale value though.

You say he has played for England, but so have Luke Young, Francis Jeffers, Jordan Henderson! it doesn't really denote someone being International class!

I am not getting on the back of our players, i support them all and would never denigrate them and their talents, but at the moment Rodwell flatters to deceive so he isn't in the same price category as some others.
Paul David
24 Posted 30/04/2012 at 19:00:29
If I was offered £5-6m for Rodwell I'd struggle to keep a straight face as I said I'd grudgingly accept.
Jamie Barlow
25 Posted 30/04/2012 at 19:04:18
Thank fuck you're not in charge then Paul.
Paul David
26 Posted 30/04/2012 at 19:13:20
Face it Jamie, Rodwell looked like being a class act at 18 but is exactly the same player now. The talk was of him being an England regular for years; well, if he carries on progressing at this rate he will get there by the time he's 50.

Sorry you got a bit upset there Jamie, I didn't realise you was related to him.
Keith Glazzard
27 Posted 30/04/2012 at 19:17:27
James - that's exactly how I see it.

Far from being a 'stale' squad we have some of the top players in the league producing great football and should be pretty well ready for next season. Pienaar is now saying he wants the move back, and that alters the negotiating position of the selling club - get what you can as quick as you can.

The finances are a nightmare we know, but not so bad that we couldn't bring in Jelavic. And there can't, surely, be a higher priority on Moyes's list than Pienaar can there?

And if its new signings you want, what about Hibbo? I don't know what they're putting in his feed, but it seems to be working.
Jamie Barlow
28 Posted 30/04/2012 at 19:31:46
No relation Paul.

He was in the England team this season, before he got injured.

Time must be running out though, I mean, what is he now, 21.

Paul David
29 Posted 30/04/2012 at 19:39:11
So was Jordan Henderson.

He might be 21 but I've seen little sign of improvement over the years, he has absolutely no influence on games. Maybe he has still got time to improve but I would be surprised if he ended up anything more than a good Premier League player but I'll stick my neck out and say he will always be average.
Peter Davies
30 Posted 30/04/2012 at 19:25:56
Ian and Phil maybe I should have said 'final straw' rather than 'big test' Talk of stadium moves and new investment are more involved situations where it is easier for Bill to find a scapegoat or excuse. The Pienaar situation will not be so easy for him to wriggle out of, especially as both the player and manager are clear on what they want. If Bill can't make it so, then there are no other excuses left...surely?

However I do like James Flynn's psychological approach to the problem, we've had our summer signings, just 6 months early. How would everyone feel if we keep hold of Peinaar and there are no other incomings over the summer, will this be good enough to be competative for the whole of next season?
Jim Hillier
31 Posted 30/04/2012 at 19:35:51
Paul, I can see your point, but on here we slag our own players off all the time as soon as they are out of form - or injured (Rodwell) only to go into to deep depression at any realistic prospect of them being sold.

Jagielka is a case in point. Unthinkable to sell him, future long term captain, a couple of below par performances later and he is shit and we should ship him out asap and cash in.

I still think Jagielka will be the next Brian Labone, even if he has not come back properly yet. And Rodwell is still a fantastic prospect if he can shake the injury (big if - look at Michael Ball - but if he does not shift the injury he is finished, and there will be no cashing in possible).

Look at the way people turn on Fella at the drop of a hat.

If we haven't got a pot to piss in again next season, so be it. Keep what we've got, bring on the youngsters, and consolidate on what we've just achieved since January.

I can't think of anyone in the current squad who is likely to bring in serious money that we should be off-loading. Bily was the last one in that category.

Moyes: have the courage of your convictions.

Keep Tim for the bench and impact, make Jags fight for his rightful centre half position and captain's armband, protect Jack through the injury, then give him his head, tell Fella he owes us one more season to prove we can make the breakthrough.

Make sure you do not lost Jelavic, and buy Pienaar even if you have to mortgage the club china to make up the fee.

We've already got a top four team to put out, and with the right coaching it will grow in strength even without additions.
Paul David
32 Posted 30/04/2012 at 19:54:53
Jim I hope your right about Jag,he was my favourite player 3 years a go,he still plays well but he hasnt been the same player lately.
Jeremy Benson
33 Posted 30/04/2012 at 20:49:07
I very much doubt we will get a £6 million+ offer for rodwell. He hasn't played much, and I don't remember any man-of-the-match performances that would turn heads for the future either. A decent squad player would be my own summary, at the moment. He needs to get quality game time, and turn in quality peformances over a sustained period (a season+), before clubs would cross our palm with silver.

Personally, I think Ross Barkley's stock is higher.
David Chait
34 Posted 30/04/2012 at 21:09:39
Hear Hear Jim #730!!!! Absolutely spot on!

Excellent post.
James Stewart
35 Posted 30/04/2012 at 22:28:17
Can't see Dempsey going for £5m! You can at least double that!
Mark Pierpoint
36 Posted 30/04/2012 at 22:26:57
Jim, I think there is clearly a divide on this between the fanbase. I think we represent the rational pragmatist arm of the fanbase whilst you see us as disloyal.

I am not disloyal to Jags or anyone else. I think he is a good servant to the club who if the circumstances were different would be here for the rest of his top level career. The reality is that we don't have a benefactor to give us a £10m a year budget, though, so, to improve the squad, decisions like this have to be taken.

You say you would mortgage the club silver to get Pienaar; it already has been! There is no indication that there is going to be any change in the policy the bank shows the club, and we haven't spent any money (net) for years.

If we want Pienaar and realistically either a RB or Right Midfielder, we will have to do something. If it is a straight choice between Jags and Pienaar, I have no problems saying I would choose the latter.
Frank McGregor
37 Posted 30/04/2012 at 23:02:58
One thing that should be considered in getting Pienaar back from Spurs would be for his agent who set up the transfer to Spurs to forgo the fee he no doubt obtained in the original transfer deal in which he wrongly advised Pienaar to advance his career. This would help in getting the finances to complete his return to Everton.
James Flynn
38 Posted 30/04/2012 at 22:45:52
Mark - Well said. I'll disagree on "a RB or Right Midfielder". Not that we couldn't use them.

Stevie back in can be facilitated on loanees other than him sent back and some settlement on Yobo. Spurs didn't splash the cash getting Piennar. They can't now say he's worth so much more after parking his ass on the bench.

I say we sell no one. If I haven't been watching a top side since January, what's a top side look like? Keep everyone. Getting Stevie back in the fold won't send off alarm bells at the bank.

How's this? Other than specific Everton-related discussion in the general soccer press, where are all the articles on "What's next for Steven Piennar"? Nowhere, that's where.
James Flynn
39 Posted 30/04/2012 at 23:17:01
Keith (&25) - "And if its new signings you want, what about Hibbo? I don't know what they're putting in his feed, but it seems to be working".

I say, we have competition for spots. Finally!

I'd add, Straq wants to stay and couldn't cost much. Why? What other EPL team will be in for him? Bull in a China Shop, yes. But a young one still, who took a giant leap from where he was to big league competition.
Phil Martin
40 Posted 01/05/2012 at 07:02:51
Keith & Peter,

I can't agree that our Jan signings are our summer buys 6 months early. In fact that sounds like a Billy Bullshit quote.

The signings in Jan were 6 months late. There is no coincidence that we have slow starts every summer we don't strengthen. So unless we want a rereun of the last 4 seasons. We need to buy in the summer. Or we'll be salvaging yet another campaign next Jan.
Peter Bradshaw
41 Posted 01/05/2012 at 10:02:40
Tigres want £5M for Stracq, if we waste that sort of money on him and not buy Pienaar we need to kick someone up the arse.

Regards Yobo, wasn't this the last year of his contract? Therefore he can leave for free at the end of the season...

Finally, we know we have to sell to buy therefore we will lose one of our crown jewels... be prepared to lose one of the following: Baines, Fellaini, Heitenga or Barkley.

I don't want it to happen as I think he has been our best and most consistant performer over the season but I think we will lose Fellaini.
Wayne Smyth
42 Posted 01/05/2012 at 12:18:47
I think there are a number of players who could and should be moved/not signed on(for a fee if possible) and to save wages.

Straq, Yobo, Neville(moved upstairs or out), Drenthe, McFadden, Jags(if we get a decent offer).

Cahill is borderline. Doesn't contribute enough, but has been and still is a legend and may well still have more in the tank so probably deserves another season just out of loyalty.

Getting rid of those players or moving them on should save us roughly 8 million per year in wages, plus perhaps some fees. Enough to fund pienaar, or perhaps even a younger version of him. Perhaps another loan deal for pienaar might be better for us?

We can't borrow any more money, especially with Moyes inability to get consistent performances out of the team during a full season. To do so would seriously risk us going bust.

Moyes is quite shrewd in the transfer market, we need to sell to buy and I'd also like to see time given to some of the younger players like bidwell, vellios, hope, barkley, McAleny, rather than relying always on players brought in on relatively high wages like McFadden.

That is the only way we can hope to compete with the teams around us in the long term.

As for Rodwell, I still think he has a lot of ability and potential. He looked a different animal when he played for england in a more advanced role and he has shown glimpses of this for us, like his goal against Utd at goodison a few seasons ago.

Maybe we could try him as the centre back he was always touted as, or perhaps he is the long term partner for Gibson, with fellaini pushed on to help Jelavic.
Paul David
43 Posted 01/05/2012 at 12:45:09
Wayne

I have yet to be convinced Rodwell will become the player everyone thought he would be a few years back but the thing I can say with out a doubt is he will never make it as a centre back.

He lacks 3 of the most important attributes to play there.

1 He is shit in the tackle.
2 Shit in the air.
3 Lacks bravery.

He did look good for England but i've hardly ever seen him like that for Everton.Maybe its Moyes stifling him and i've been harsh on Rodwell,maybe with a bit more freedom he can become the player we all hoped he would.
Trevor Lynes
44 Posted 01/05/2012 at 13:08:57
If we do not manage to sign Pienaar its no ones fault but our own.

We had him and let him go for a small fee due to not tieing him to a good contract with a salary that matched our top earner/s.

He was well worth the money and when Arteta was injured for a long time it was Pienaar who stepped up to the plate and starred for us week in and week out.

He was even vilified in some quarters for asking for wage parity.
Now we do not own him and have let Arteta go ?????


This club is penny pinching in the wrong areas and wasting money on bringing back Weir and McFadden and signing players who are not worth a starting place in the first team. Where is the logic in all this stupidity.

Despite the behind the scenes mishmash our players are playing quite well and its no coincidence that Pienaar is back on loan and pulling the strings on the pitch.

His enthusiasm has rubbed off on the others and collectively they are looking a decent team.

Against Liverpool in the cup there was no Pienaar so no inspiration or ambition.....we have totally mishandled the Pienaar situation and if he moves to some other team it will be our own fault !!
Jem Traynor
45 Posted 01/05/2012 at 14:12:41
I concurr with Gareth (#690), all the doom and gloom or the realists are just magpies in my eyes, the negativity is worse than the board and all taking the money from selling players while the fans watch their hopes dwindle as these people cash in.

Sorry I know there are fans who want to dream but all the BKs and J Woods of this world are dithering greedy bastards. Woods was worth when he sold Ocean to Sony £500 mil! There's a lot more to this than is being shown or talked about.

Enough of looking too far back, this board CAN make thing's happen, the banks will let us re-invest via loans but will the board do it? I don't mean to offend any reader's here but this is so frustrating to hear or think this will all happen again with one of our top squads while we wait for this next season to start!
James Flynn
46 Posted 01/05/2012 at 14:55:20
Jem - Well said. Need Piennar in, but where this "sell" stuff is coming from is beyond me.

We have a damn good squad right now. Keep everyone.
Jem Traynor
47 Posted 01/05/2012 at 15:29:10
James, I know we do need to sign Pienaar back and let's hope he says as much to the Spurs backroom staff so they know he's got to go. As for everything else, it is a case of keeping hold of and doing what Newcastle have/are doing in that we just push from the word 'Go' next season. It can be done; we have done it before and can again.

There's a great team at Everton right now, the players are at the right ages with the right amonut of experience in the 'key' positions... changing it around now will only set us back years, again!
Richard Reeves
48 Posted 01/05/2012 at 19:03:27
It's crazy to think that we didn't offer Pienaar that extra £10k a week to make him joint top earner with Arteta. We've got a lot of deadwood on ridiculous money but let one of our best and most creative leave for pittance.

Whenever pundits talk about Pienaar, it's always the old "he wanted Champions League football but it hasn't really worked out" line... or "it was always going to be difficult establishing himself in that team with the players he has to compete against".

If he comes back, this is what we'll be fed with nothing mentioned of the failure to keep him in the first place which would've saved us millions and helped us climb the table.
Ernie Baywood
49 Posted 02/05/2012 at 02:30:16
I'd take the punt with Rodwell. we could sell a 21 year old for 5m-ish or keep him fit for a year and what would he be worth at 22?

And I'm still not writing off his potential. He's potentially a class act... just needs a run of games to aid his development.

Signing Pienaar is just a no brainer. He's worth more to us than he is to Spurs.
Jason Lam
50 Posted 02/05/2012 at 04:51:47
Looking forward to Sept 1 when one of our spine players leaves and we pick up 2-3 loanees as we start from square one all over again. If anything it freshes up the squad with new faces until Captain America saves our sorry arses come January.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads