Season › 2011-12 › News
Moyes is not for selling players
Moyes, who has no intention of sacrificing any big names, said: "It will be important that we keep hold of our best players.
"We lost Mikel Arteta last year but I don't want to sell. So I'm not going out there as a salesman to try to sell them. We have had no contact from Chelsea (on Fellaini)."
Quotes or other material sourced from Daily Mail
Reader Comments (47)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 05/05/2012 at 08:16:23
You say Moyes is too much talk and not enough follow through. Yet you keep posting that you don't want him to have any "follow through" on his discipline of Drenthe.
You can't have it both ways.
3 Posted 05/05/2012 at 08:17:25
4 Posted 05/05/2012 at 08:40:09
5 Posted 05/05/2012 at 08:38:11
6 Posted 05/05/2012 at 08:46:26
7 Posted 05/05/2012 at 09:10:51
8 Posted 05/05/2012 at 09:24:22
That doesn't stop Pompus, Precious Peter talking out of his bum.
9 Posted 05/05/2012 at 09:07:37
You can bloody guarantee that Fellaini's old man, should Chelsea get into the CL next term, will be up Abrahamovitchs backside like a rat up a pipe!. He's made no secret of the fact that he believes we do not match his boys calibre.
If this is Moyes going on record to say 'no bargains here' there is realistically little more he can do. For the money we'd get for Fellaini we could do a lot of good in the squad especially with Gibson covering the defensive slot allowing a pure creative midfield replacement to be brought in. That and an answer to the right wing issue with a Weiss or Johnson would go some distance to easing Fellaini's loss.
10 Posted 05/05/2012 at 09:11:01
However I also felt that his quality was such that he deserved to play in the Champions League. After all he was never going to get to play for his country (perhaps the best player ever not to be capped? discuss!)
Anyway after 5 and 1/2 years with the club as a consummate professional I don't see that any toffee could begrudge him the move. I also believe we got value for a 29 year old.
As for blaming Moyes I think he deserves infinitely more credit for the signing of Arteta that he deserves criticism for the sale.
11 Posted 05/05/2012 at 09:40:16
If there is no desire there to sell (ie we have to for the bank) then we need to sit all these players down on May 14 and ask them straight - do you want a move. If they say yes then the transfers must happen quickly and for good money and then we can look forward to spending some of it to hopefully improve us as we have done before. We need to get our business done early not let things drag on to August 31 as usual. This would definitely lead to our annual shit start.
For me I would look at moving on Rodwell, Jags and possibly Barkley if Chelsea are offering stupid money now. We also need to pick up what we can on the likes of Anichebe and Coleman who are just not good enough. If we do all that which I know is unlikely then we could buy Pienaar, Donavan (or the like), another starker, young centre back etc.
However I can see the sky sports breaking news banner at 7.30 on August 31 now ' Everton accept £25m offer from Chelsea ......' I think we should all just fuck off for 4 months !! (if only we could !)
12 Posted 05/05/2012 at 09:26:35
Look at the clubs linked. PSG and United. Champions League Clubs.
You get one go at a career and more than likely the players will want off. Is anyone seriously saying Baines shouldnt be playing Champions League football? He could play for anyone, he's way better than this.
Look at Lescott now. Or should he display some faux loyalty and be covering left back for us which would be the case? Or should he be playing and training with top end players every day?
Remember the bullshit we gave John Collins before we conned him into signing his last big contract and wasting the last 2 years of his career. And, even though he was probably past his best he had his pick of clubs. If i was him id never forgive Everton for the bullshit we ran past him, he ended up covering left back at one stage in a depleted team ran down cos of, guess what? We'd sold all our decent players cos we'd ran out of cash.........again!!
And people were surprised when he didnt re-sign.
He may have said in public he was thinking about it though.
How much of what is said is for the public? How much of what is said is driving a hard bargin?
Moyes drove the Lescott stance to almost self defeating purposes, however the Everton of 10 years previous would have taken 15 mil straight away.
It was actually nice to see someone standing up and saying, no, you do not walk in and fuck with me, my players and my club. What excuses are you talking about? Your talking outright bollocks.
The Lescott situation became unworkable. Mainly as he was virtually on strike.
I think, purely my opinion, if Moyes had been in the job longer the Rooney deal would have been different, we got undercut big time for someone who was obviously, injuries permitting going to be one of the best English footballers ever.
Whilst were on it from the footage of games ive seen i think Bobby Charlton is the possibly best English players ever, mainly as he doesnt play like an English player. I cant tell which foot is his natural one, left/right, range of passing, body swerve, natural 2 footed dribbler, changle of pace, never gives it away, goals, the lot.
He makes Scholes look like Barry Horne.
Also, a small issue but we blatantly need the dollar.
Someone is going to go in the summer, get used to it now. Its the only way we will sign anyone. People on here are dreaming of getting Piennar, adding Dempsey etc. Without a sale forget it. We are virtually bust.
Players come and go im past being attached.
13 Posted 05/05/2012 at 09:49:19
I am sure if he could, Moyes would keep all the players and add to them... but that is in an ideal world.
14 Posted 05/05/2012 at 10:14:09
Histrionics such as those surrounding the sale of Rooney,Lescott and Arteta won`t wash anymore and retention of his full squad may become the key to his signing for another five years.
Kenwright beware!
15 Posted 05/05/2012 at 10:23:34
Yes, he is right, but now we are a top 8 team in the league which means we must demand more for our top players.
Look at Newcastle,and Aston Villa, they demanded above market price for Carrol, Hendorsen and Downing, while we only got 10 million for Arteta, who in fact is way better then any of these 3.
I am just saying that Moyes needs to demand more for his top players, after all we cant afford not to!
Moyes should set a minimu price for all his top players, like 25 million.
When you think of it Carrol went for 35million so why should we be different?
Their sale of Carrol gave them the freedom to buy and the results are there to see.
16 Posted 05/05/2012 at 09:50:00
A far more likely scenario is that after a season of falling attendances with matchday revenue likely to dip again next season, and with the annual borrow from 2014's Sky money to pay the loan on borrowing on 2013's Sky money, it is likely that we'll be forced to sell someone.
Then it's a case of trying to get the best price for the player. Phase 1 is stating you don't want to sell. The fact Fellaini appears to be named could be telling, or could be a smokescreen.
Then it's a game of bluff which will see said player sold at a minute to the close of the transfer window, when we've either got the deal we wanted or have been forced into a last minute compromise.
Throughout all of this though it will be spun as "the player wanted to leave". Worked out well for Modric to Chelsea last season.
17 Posted 05/05/2012 at 10:41:09
Ultimately it comes down to the players attitude and personality if they want off.
Off the top of my head as i type i can only think of Gareth Barry when at Villa and Ronaldo at United as a players that were made to stay.
Barry was made to stay and to be fair to him got on with it, they got another season out of him and the took a drop on the fee when he went. Ronaldo by season end was acting the twat. The fee trousered is freakish and not the norm as were talking Ronaldo, one of the worlds best players.
An unhappy player is a dressing room cancer. You need that unity.
Man Citys dressing room must be a horrible place and its an aspect of Mancini's job thats overlooked, he has his hands very full there. But without the Tevez situation, if Tevez had kept i lid on it till season end, or they could have just got rid (this is where the transfer window can compromise a manager and the deals he makes) i personally think its very likely they would have comfortablty won the league by now. Theres a couple of examples of player power compromising the manager. One of them being Ferguson, who has had to completely change his man management to deal with modern players.
There are also other factors like we aint got to pot to piss in. In recent history we have painted black both Richard Dunne and outrageously Michael Ball, who had the club crest on his fucking house, cos we needed the cash. Completely unnecessary, just front it, i would have respected the club more.
Moyes just saying someone aint going and expecting that to be the law is one dimensional and, apologies for the use of an aggressive term i dont mean it in that fashion, naive.
18 Posted 05/05/2012 at 12:07:39
19 Posted 05/05/2012 at 11:49:08
And unfortunately Felli could be in that category! When he signed his new deal last year, when being interviewed, he said that he believed Everton would match his ambitions and sign players... so obviously Kenwright, Elstone and Moyes have fed him such stuff so he'll be expecting something to happen this summer (hence why he recently told Kenwright to loosen the purse strings) and if or when it doesn't happen, we could have a situation like the Shite had with Torres, and he'll want to fuck off cos of broken promises?!
Maybe he'll give us another season as he's still young and seems to have a wise head on those young shoulders; then, when we haven't progressed and matched his ambitions, then maybe he'll decide to leave as he thinks he needs to to match his own ambitions?
I mean, how many times have we all said it after a season of "if onlys" after a second-half surge or a good season, "if we get it right in the summer and sign quality, we'll be right up there, possibly Champions League?!" ? and then we've all been left disappointed? This summer is possibly only going to be the same!
It's a shame cos IMO were only 3 signings for the first team away from possibly being up there challenging for Europe and Champions League spots after the good January we had.
I look at Newcastle as the new yardstick; yeah, selling Carroll for as much as they did helped... but they went out and bought well for the first team. Yes, they have had luck with injuries and not so many suspensions... but, if you look at them, their first team is good and they haven't really got any good fringe players to come in. With a few signings for our first team, we could be in the same boat as we have already got some quality first teamers already!
Yes, I understand teams above and around us will strengthen but if we could add the neccesary quality to a squad that as done really well this second half of the season and performed up there alongside the best of them, then I think we could easily go do a Newcastle next season, I really do.
20 Posted 05/05/2012 at 12:15:44
21 Posted 05/05/2012 at 12:25:59
I thought the way we treated Michael Ball was out of order though, no need, really sly and underhand.
22 Posted 05/05/2012 at 12:33:16
Could probably put an XI together of Blues who played for, and fell out with the club.
23 Posted 05/05/2012 at 12:48:15
Seemed more natural at centre half, may have been a size issue there, but would have had a great career left back or centre half.
Walter Smith used to like playing the 3 centre halfs with Gough central, Weir right side and Ball left when all fit. Erickson came to Goodison to watch us in a 2-2 draw against Leeds, all the back 3 were excellent, Gough came back after something like 6 weeks out and played like a 25 year old, i have massive respect for that fella he was unbelievable first season for us, 37 years old as well. Model professional.
Ball was in great form, was fantastic that night and was called up for England. I dont think it would have been a flash in the pan call up like Unsy either. Im not saying he would have got a shit loads of caps only handfuls of players do, but i think he would have had a fantastic career, but, its all conjecture.
He was classier than Unsy put it that way. Unsy was a Premier League plodder, not that im running him down, id have given anything to be a pro.
We shipped 2 but the back 3 got us the result as Leeds very, very good midifeld destroyed us that night.
Apparantly word was we fucked his knee with jabs to keep him playing as the squad was so light. We did Joe Parkinson and John Ebbrell that way as well. Something was going on at Everton then, basically taking advantage of lads good nature, their desire to play.
Out of order and we did 3 lads careers. I heard John Ebbrell was still on crutches a year after when he broke down soon after his Sheff Utd move? I know you can always say no but apparantly there was pressure to play, and as a player you want to play. There aint nothing like playing.
So when he turned up at Rangers Balls knee was already fucked. And before sending him off we attempted to blacken his reputation. Awful stuff.
24 Posted 05/05/2012 at 12:59:22
I think the Ferguson transfer was completed from speculation to deal done in under 8 hours ? reading between the lines, that was one which was done to stave off administration.
Re the Michael Ball transfer, he was very poorly treated by the club and rumours (which have never been substantiated) were circulated that him and Richard Dunne were dressing room rabble rousers and, in Dunne's case, a piss-head.
I also read in Bobby Robson's autobiography (I think) that Duncan Ferguson didn't want to return to Everton, though it was sold by the club he was desperate to return.
With football transfers, you're never quite sure what to believe ? even after the players' careers are over and ancient history, they often don't want to upset the fans who will be buying their books and attending their dinners by telling the truth.
25 Posted 05/05/2012 at 13:11:38
IMO DM is a good manager who has an excellent transfer record. Not perfect but tell me who's is.
26 Posted 05/05/2012 at 13:13:58
27 Posted 05/05/2012 at 13:26:30
On Michael Ball i remember Smith saying in the press, "he can go....if he wants to.....".
How would it benefit Everton to let go 2 excellent young defenders? We were on our arse, again.
Young players need discipline and guidance, plenty step out of line. I think it was used as a convenient excuse.
There seemed to be a personality issue with Smith and the Hutch. I think we legitimately wanted rid of him. He was in great form for us as well. We got undercut on that although maybe we were happy to offload. Did we get roughly £2 mil?
I couldnt believe it and he was then great for Reidy for 2 years before they pocketed £6 for him. A bad knee injury, i think, did the Hutch at West Ham. Cracking player for me, pity he only did 3/4 years of what he was capable of cos he lost his way early doors.
28 Posted 05/05/2012 at 13:12:03
If Chelsea offered £25m for Fellaini, I can see Moyes rejecting it; no-one wants to see our best players leave but we're not in a position to turn that type of money down and we need to think about what's best in the long term. If we carry on resisting to sell while loosing millions, sooner or later we'll be in administration. Then the likes of Fellaini will be sold by the banks for £10m, the same way we got Jelavic so cheap.
If Moyes really is to resist any players leaving, then I agree with Mike (#885); it might be a bit naive but sit the players down and ask them what their plans are and to tell him early so we're not stuck with another Arteta situation.
While people are talking about Michael Ball, I thought he was a fantasic player... gutted when he left, and could not be more surprised the way his career turned out. I still wanted him back a couple of years ago just as cover for Baines.
29 Posted 05/05/2012 at 13:36:41
A club will never admit they sold for the cash, I understand that. But instead of blackening a player's name, they could trot out the "in the interests of all parties" line.
People are fed spin in all walks of their lives now. Where you work, who (if) you vote for, and now it permeates the one bit of escapism ? your football team.
30 Posted 05/05/2012 at 13:43:20
If a really big dog starts sniffing after them they sometimes forgo that bonus as they perceive the move to the big time will offset it. If they all had them Rooney, Lescott and Arteta all blew off their bonuses on that basis.
Without such a golden future in the offing though why are players going to turn around and admit, to the boss, they'd be off first twitch of a CL clubs skirts? They are just flushing their bonus down the toilet if the clubs they would want to move to dont come through with the right offer. Would be nice to see such principled honesty from players... but I wouldn't hold my breath waiting to see it!.
31 Posted 05/05/2012 at 13:48:41
I was 11 and sitting in my dad's car pretending to drive it whilst my dad was in the bookies putting on his sixpence Yankee on the horses... when he came out I told him that Everton had sold Ball, he never believed me ? thought I must have made a mistake. When he had it confirmed he said, "£220,000 ? he was worth double that'. My mate in school Billy Rogers painted his white boots black in protest (with Airfix enamel!).
32 Posted 05/05/2012 at 14:07:52
Rooney, Lescott and Arteta will have got a signing on fee so doubt they cared about missing out on a loyalty fee.
Like I say it might be naive to expect honesty from players regarding their future let's say if Fellaini said to Moyes, "Boss, I'm happy here and I'm happy to stay so I won't be forcing a move but, if a CL club come in for me, I would be intersted because I believe I'm good enough to play at that level."
I doubt Moyes would hold that against him and at least he would know where he stood with the player if Chelsea did come knocking.
33 Posted 05/05/2012 at 14:27:20
We sold Arteta for £10m and only saw enough of it to sign Gibbo and Pienaar on loan in January, possibly some of it went on getting Drenthe and Stracq on loan as well?
We signed Jelavic with the Bily money.
So if we sell our best players, like some say, by snapping clubs' hands off when they bid the likes of £25m for our players, is it really worth selling them if Moyesy isn't going to see enough of it to replace the quality he's sold?
I think that's why he's making this stance to Kenwright and clubs that are interested cos he knows he won't get enough of what he brings in to replace them so he'd rather keep them and go with what he's got!.
Hopefully he can sell off fringe players and appease the banks and be able to sign a player or two to improve the squad?!
34 Posted 05/05/2012 at 14:41:30
I think everyone knows Moyes would not see all the money but, if we don't sort the debt out, we will end up in serious trouble.
As it stands now, I think Moyes still has control but, if the banks don't start getting paid off, they will start making the decisions and they won't hold out for top dollor for players; they will sell below market value just to ensure they get their money now.
35 Posted 05/05/2012 at 14:29:50
36 Posted 05/05/2012 at 14:57:34
What got worse was he was given permission to miss a game away at West Ham to talk to Newcastle, then the club put out the story that he'd refused to travel. He absolutely hadn't.
So yes, in the end he wanted to go but there was no way he could stay. He was still a Blue to the end.
37 Posted 05/05/2012 at 15:12:32
As you say, he was a blue to the end and felt at any time he could have came out and discredited Everton but he took a dignified silence.
True gentleman and fantastic player.
38 Posted 05/05/2012 at 15:25:29
But if we sell and don't get enough money to spend to replace what we've sold, nevermind add and improve on what we've got, then cherish these top 8 finishes cos we won't be challenging up at the top for long.
But I do understand the club comes first and if we need to reduce the debt to survive then, regardless of how good we are, I'll be glad there's still an Everton FC!
39 Posted 05/05/2012 at 16:02:16
As for sales of players, there's no player he sold out of force, that didn't bang his door down to leave, or play so crap that we lose by 5 goals or more ? *cough, cough* Lescott. If they don't wanna be at Everton, then goodbye. I certainly don't want them, no matter how good they are, so then it's play it cool and get as much as you can. Arteta was a last-minute deal and he wanted out; yes, Mr Everton wanted out... so that was the last-ditch amount we could muster out of Arsenal. Rooney was a good price at the time. Lescott was excellent business. It's just a shame the rat has won at least one medal up to now.
Moyes will know if he has got to sell, and he will know who he will sacrifice if so. There will be people he really hopes don't get interest... and, if they do, he will say NO, but agents hear of this and the rats phone their 'assets', because they see the money, and they feed them the crap that causes them to knock on the door; that then becomes a problem he has to deal with, and he will.
All we do is speculate; I still trust Everton in Moyes's hands, we just need the other leaches gone!
40 Posted 05/05/2012 at 16:35:18
You don't think these deals are worked out well in advance of that?
I remember explaining to a deluded shite fan that Mereiles didn't suddenly demand a transfer at 10:30pm that day (as reported on SSN) and it was wrapped up within 90 minutes, meaning miraculously Benayoun could suddenly go to Arsenal on loan.
41 Posted 05/05/2012 at 16:43:43
Lawrence should know he's supposed to be a mate of Moyes'.
42 Posted 05/05/2012 at 16:52:40
Whatever he said, he was still banging down the door for a move. We then accepted the last offer that Arsenal made, due to it being last-minute, that probably only took 90 mins, which was the conclusion of days of negotiating.
43 Posted 05/05/2012 at 16:49:22
The story transpired that as this was a culmination of a few boozy incidents with HK, Speed had a very urgent and frank 1-2-1 with said manager later that week and he implored him to sort himself out for the good of the team - a week or so later Speed was on his way and worked out to Newcastle in a very devious fashion by making it seem he was the one pressing for a move, when it was anything but that.
Speed on being asked why he was moving on said (and I paraphrase) that it was common knowledge why he was going but he didn't want to darken the name of EFC.
It didn't stop the boo boys calling him a shithouse on his return, when the real shithouse tricks were perpetrated by those sat in the dugout and in the directors box.
44 Posted 05/05/2012 at 19:40:40
45 Posted 05/05/2012 at 21:32:13
In the quote he says he's not actively selling his players, but that's different from not entertaining bids. If top clubs want Fellaini and are prepared to pay a good fee (£25M+), then let him go and reinvest.
There are many criticisms of Moyes - from me as well as others - but one thing we can probably all agree on is that he does have a very good eye for a bargain, so the idea of one expensive player out and 3-4 young players in would be a positive step.
As a club going forward, I'd like to see Moyes really focus on youth, potential and players with good resale value as it's the only way we're likely to be able to compete with those with rich owners.
46 Posted 06/05/2012 at 11:49:18
Let be reasonable here, if say Chelsea or PSG offer 25m for Fellaini, are we really going to turn that down? I seriously dont thnk so!
The speech from Moyes is just the usual 'if you want anyone of my players, you're going to have to bring a big wad of cash'. Nothing wrong in saying that. However, if a player wants to go or the offer is too much, we will be selling.
47 Posted 06/05/2012 at 16:42:21
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 05/05/2012 at 07:02:06
Knowing both Moyes and Kenwright, all Chelsea need to do is persist and then submit a bid lower then the market price, just as Arsenal did with Arteta.
I am not at all persuaded Moyes will not sell if pushed. He needs to toughen up, he tried with Lesott, but he did not persist long enough. Same thing with Rooney in a way, though with Lescott we at least got the right market price; with Rooney and Arteta we did not.
Are anyone else really persuaded that Moyes will not sell no matter what?
If so, then I will advise you to look at the past, most recently last summers transfer window.
Though it is nice to hear Moyes say it, what we really need is for him to be TRUE to his word. This seems like a cheap ploy to build up the price of his players.
After 10 years, I hope Moyes will DO and not just SAY. Sometimes I find Moyes to be a politician: too much talk and not enough follow through.