Premier League Finances laid bare

, 10 May, 26comments  |  Jump to most recent
This survey in The Telegraph presents the 20 Premier League teams (from 2010-11) with their finances 'laid bare' in a nice web app that allows you to reorder the pack based on: Season position, Debt, Income, Wages Net transfer value, and Cash flow.
Unlike other surveys, this focuses on the true cash income and expenditure of top flight clubs, giving a far more accurate portrait of their strength than the operating profit or loss figures which have been used previously. The key figures here are a club's turnover, what it pays in wages and "other" running costs (comprising heating, lighting, travel expenses etc).

The working capital movements also demonstrate a number of cash items — money spent on buying stock for retail outlets for example.

Amortisation and depreciation are simply accounting charges and do not affect cash flow, but do need to be presented to show how a club's operating profits or losses are calculated.

When all the elements have been added up, it gives sight of a club's operating cash flow, the cash left over from revenues after their day-to-day expenses have been paid. After interest bills have been paid, a club's disposable income available to spend on transfers, or paying down debts, is revealed.

Quotes or other material sourced from The Telegraph



Reader Comments (26)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Alex Kociuba
2 Posted 10/05/2012 at 14:41:29
The only thing which surprised me was Villa's wage bill is 40% higher than ours. Apart from that...
Dave Roberts
3 Posted 10/05/2012 at 14:52:49
The comment about Everton having to sell a player every season to survive (is making finding a buyer difficult) is a bit of a generalization. Firstly, it's not strictly true, and secondly, other clubs have found buyers while being a 'selling club' ? most notably Chelsea and City (to name but two)!

Reading the notes about Liverpool makes it apparent that the contract with the Devil was certainly working at the time of their latest sale. They're like a 'kept woman'!
Shane Corcoran
4 Posted 10/05/2012 at 14:57:21
I agree Alex although Villa have offloaded Young and Downing since that. It looks like Sunderland might be in a spot of bother unless they've a sugar daddy behind them that I'm not aware of. Also if Bolton go down they could be royally fucked. I guess what it doesn't show is what the owners are willing to put into the clubs to get them out of their respective messes.
James Martin
5 Posted 10/05/2012 at 15:01:47
I'm not sure all is as rosy in the Liverpool garden as they like to make out. I notice that aside from the initial £30 million the American owners ploughed into the club (which has gone on transfers) they haven't put any in and in fact have borrowed £120 million from the banks, all the while there seems no sign of a new stadium (where have we seen this before).

Everton are 9th in income, 9th in wages, 9th in cashflow, and towards the bottom in net transfers. Hardly a surpirse we're finishing 7th is it, when everyone above us can buy whoever they want, pay whatever wages they want and have more money coming in and less debt to repay thanks to their own sugar daddies.
Andy Mack
6 Posted 10/05/2012 at 15:14:24
Having a brief glimpse through that I'd have thought Felli, Baines, Jags would pretty much clear our debt.

If only we had competent owners and board to not be in the same mess two years later, I'd be for those sales and a couple of seasons restructuring with Moyes managing to keep us midtable.
Chris Matheson
7 Posted 10/05/2012 at 15:31:43
Andy Mack, you're spot on:

"If only we had competent owners and board to not be in the same mess two years later "

The problem is not Everton's debt, but the reason for that debt in the first place. The root cause is mismanagment from a clueless. visionless, strategy-less board.

Did I say strategyless? Well, no... they have a strategy: sell off assets, keep fingers crossed and hope Moyesy can keep us in the Premier League.
Kevin Tully
8 Posted 10/05/2012 at 16:00:00
Can anyone shed any light if the wages are the players only, or the entire wage-roll for the clubs listed?
Kevin Tully
9 Posted 10/05/2012 at 16:07:15
Just scrolled down the page - it does say wages are for players and other staff.

Here's where the figures become a little skewed. If your commercial operation is turning over a much as our entire revenue, you will obviously require many more staff than our lousy operation.

I would like to see the figures compared against other teams for our starting eleven, plus manager's salary - then we can compare apples with apples.
Jon Gorman
10 Posted 10/05/2012 at 16:13:40
I'm not suggesting that Chris (112) has formed part of the rabble calling for more spending to capitalise on the bare bones of a decent squad which we currently have. He might be big on austerity and fiscal responsibility. But it seems as though BK can't win. Comments like:

"The problem is not Everton's debt, but the reason for that debt in the first place. The root cause is mismanagment from a clueless, visionless, strategy-less board."

So which is it, people? Borrow and spend or live within our means? I think that the link provided sums up exactly why investment hasn't been forthcoming; there's no big blue conspiracy.
Chris Matheson
11 Posted 10/05/2012 at 16:29:45
Hi there Jon. I am in neither group actually, not spend what we haven't got and not don't spend even in my limits.

The group I am in is the one that views Kenwright as a failure, whose only financial strategy is to sell assets (eg Bellefield) , mortagage land (eg the Park End) and take out dodgy, expensive short term loans from the BVI and other finance havens where secrecy is paramount, secured on the tv money from the season after next, to pay off the interest on bank loans for this comign quarter.

He failed catastrophically at two ground moves (although I confess that I am relieved he failed with Kirkby) and seems to have no other strategy for getting us out of the mire.

Jon you pose a fair question : borrow to invest or live within means, but I want blues to think about another possibility which is to bring in a board which knows how to successfully run a business. This one does not, as twelve years of failure atest.
Jon Gorman
12 Posted 10/05/2012 at 16:57:08
Fair enough. However, I doubt that even the most astute of businessmen could turn a profit at Everton.

In terms of operating income we fare well, safely in the second tier of clubs. And there in lies our predicament: we need a benefactor in order to compete. No amount of business excellence would result in a significant increase in our income.

Asset stripping is a worry though.
Kevin Tully
13 Posted 10/05/2012 at 17:43:57
Jon#129,



" In terms of operating income we fare well."

No we don't. Our commercial income is a pittance considering the size of the club. The corporate hospitality income suffers from only having 11 exec boxes. We only " fare well " because T.V. revenues are shared evenly compared to other leagues.

I could go on but can't be arsed.
Ged Simpson
14 Posted 10/05/2012 at 18:53:32
The corporate hospitality income suffers from only having 11 exec boxes

Yeah and how do we get them - now?

I am a brill corner shop and could match Tesco if I could borrow the money to expand.

Yeah but you can't coz Tesco are a better bet for us at the banks.

Basic economics
Paul David
15 Posted 10/05/2012 at 19:06:22
Jon 129

Were told we lose about £5m a year on average.I'm no business man but that amount is the same as Neville and Cahill's wages,get rid of them 2 and we've already broke even.
Matt Traynor
16 Posted 10/05/2012 at 19:15:29
The figures don't show the whole picture. It doesn't show cash-at-hand, for instance. I know that's as rare as hens teeth in the Premier League, but Arsenal, for instance, have £115m in reserves (bank, not their second team).

Also, Everton's debt is rumoured to be more than £45m, due to off-balance sheet debt and rumoured loans from other backers. Therefore it is too simplistic to say sell Felli, Baines and Jags and we're good to go.

As others have pointed out, it's not the debt that's the problem, it's cash flow. (See my point re Arsenal's cash at hand versus debt). In Everton's case it's compounded as portions of the ticket and broadcasting revenue have been borrowed against. Effectively permanent payday loans! We should be sponsored by Blackpool's sponsors, Wonga.
Dave Roberts
17 Posted 10/05/2012 at 20:03:49
Sell Felli, Baines and Jags and we're good to go?

Go where for fucks sake?

The Championship?

Christ, this is a football club and if we ever have to sell players it should be with the utmost reluctance.... not as a way of keeping the bank balance acceptable.

I'd rather we go tits-up while trying to be as good on the pitch as we can rather than selling the family silver just to balance the books, temporarily, and dying a slow and tortuous death of a thousand cuts.

If the club were suggesting we were going to sell all our best players to pay of some debt and keep Elstone et al in a job there would be fucking uproar. But it's ok for for Toffeewebbers to suggest it it seems!
Matt Traynor
18 Posted 10/05/2012 at 20:28:28
Dave, I never said it but was debunking the suggestion made earlier in the thread by Andy Mack that he'd happily sell them if we had a responsible board...

He's got half the solution worked out.
Ian Bennett
19 Posted 10/05/2012 at 20:41:11
James Martin - how dare you come on this website and try link finishing places/trophies with financial budgets.

Moyes has been here 10 years, earns 65k a week etc etc etc etc.
David Hallwood
20 Posted 11/05/2012 at 00:09:03
A good report that once again highlights the barmy economics of the EPL, a number of people have been forecasting meltdown, and when you look at the figures it seems to be a matter of when not if

To people who say it'll never happen, remember there were people predicting financial meltdown 15 years before it happened. Personally, I think that it will be a necessary enema...
Eric Myles
21 Posted 11/05/2012 at 02:01:19
Paul, we only lost £5 million last year because we sold Bellefiled for £10 million.

Without the sale of that fixed asset the loss would have been £15 million.

Now we have no more fixed assets to sell so we have to sell players (Arteta) to pay off the banks.
Eric Myles
22 Posted 11/05/2012 at 05:23:20
At least that table explains what "other operating costs" are.

Other costs: Other general running costs, eg: lighting, heating, food, travel, auditing, legal and agents' fees etc.

Somebody should send the link to Bill so he knows when he's asked again.
Peter Barry
23 Posted 11/05/2012 at 09:33:18
James Martin # 105 Should all tally up nicely then when we finish 9th too behind Fulham and the Red Shite.
Ian Bennett
24 Posted 11/05/2012 at 09:42:39
Its a really clever piece of analysis.

What is incredible is the income to wages for the whole of the top flight and the cashflow.

Sugar said years ago that football clubs have diarrhoea. Nothing has changed only its leveraged diarrhoea.


Christine Foster
25 Posted 11/05/2012 at 13:28:39
Ian, yes and every EPL owner is crapping themselves at the thought that the bubble will burst.

It will at some point, thats inevitabe, to be replaced by god knows what..

Its an over inflated bubble, unsustainable financial models that are based on continuous growth and demand. Based on customers ability to pay...based on disposable income, based on jobs, based on....the economy.

Toilet economics indeed

Getting the pic?
Jeremy Benson
26 Posted 11/05/2012 at 13:45:28
Re: David Hallwood @217,

To be fair you don't have to be Nostradmus to make the very vague prophecy that there will be a "financial meltdown within 15 years". Even a broken watch is right twice a day.

John Ford
27 Posted 11/05/2012 at 13:47:28
It should be said that the accounts of the high spending clubs are really nothing more than a business admin requirement. If you're propped up by a squillionaire your accounts can basically show what you want them too, based on how and when a benefactor decides to throw another chunk of money in, and there are varying ways to account for this..

I agree teams like Everton suffer because we try to balance books in the traditional way, whilst our opponents net spend goes up the roof on the back of personal/historical wealth (market spending remains the key financial transaction in terms of success).

So how do we compete with that? Well our salary level is one way, as this is reasonably competitive. We still suffer as a result of not being able to deal equitably in the transfer market. Clubs accept the highest bidder regardless of what is/isnt offered to the player.

One more thing, if the bubble does burst there will still be the haves and the have nots as clearly individual wealth wont be affected by a general slump in PL finances. Theoretically the divergence will be even greater.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads