Jelavic a massive piece of the puzzle

, 10 May, 73comments  |  Jump to most recent
Moyes hints at teambuilding going forward
Talking positively about the task of team-building David Moyes faces as he heads into his 11th year at Goodison Park, he sees Nikica Jelavic a key piece in the puzzle.

He says: ?We're now looking at what goes with Jelavic, what would be good to put with him, what type of player we can buy in the future.

?In your mind, you are building a team because you have a piece in the jigsaw.

?We have had pieces in the jigsaw in the past such as, in the main, having good centre-halves, we have an excellent left-back, we have good midfield players.

?Where we have often been short is in terms of creativity.

?We lost Steven Pienaar, we lost Mikel Arteta and we didn't have a forward who could score lots of goals.

?Suddenly we have a forward who can score but we are maybe still lacking a wee bit of creativity.

?Steven's brought us some more creativity since he's been back. Steven is undoubtedly one of the bits of business we need to do.

?I can see in my head pictures and directions of where I think we should be going and what players we need to get, which players can help us progress again,? he said.

?Jelavic is a massive piece. For a decent value, how else could you get a striker who might get you 20 goals a season in the Premier League? Normally, for that piece you are looking at £15-20m.

?There are bits of building blocks now. At the end of the season, I'll have a chat with Bill and see where we should go.?

Quotes or other material sourced from Liverpool Echo



Reader Comments (73)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Barry Rathbone
1 Posted 10/05/2012 at 16:48:07
Stop trying to impersonate me Moyes it won't wash.

"Creativity", pah!! I have the copyright on moaning about that.
Steve King
2 Posted 10/05/2012 at 16:51:51
This looks like a clear message to the board.

Lets see how they respond this summer.
James Newcombe
3 Posted 10/05/2012 at 17:07:14
Lets hope we can hang onto him for a while!
James Morgan
4 Posted 10/05/2012 at 17:11:31
He will be great for City next season!

Moyes knows what he wants (probably 8 more centre halves) so lets see if the clowns at the top can provide. Most likely not. In the words of Bananarama, It's a cruel, cruel summer.
Peter Laing
5 Posted 10/05/2012 at 17:28:25
I cant believe I've just read that from David Moyes and therefore I cannot be cynical regarding his opinions and hopefully his intentions. The ball now is well and truly in the court of The Everton Board of Directors ? which is where it should be.
John Malone
6 Posted 10/05/2012 at 17:36:22
It's either going to be the pressure needed for Bill to get investment and sign some players, or the the straw that broke the camel's back and a way out for Moyes.

It's about time Moyes started talking about wanting to sign players publicly and put the pressure back on Bill and the Board to do their job and support the manager and improve the team. I'm not holding my breath....
Paul Ellam
7 Posted 10/05/2012 at 17:47:21
I hope this puts a few fans' minds at rest ? it seems like the boss DOES actually want to play attacking soccer after all!

Maybe he actually sees something he can be positive about now with the squad and realises that scraping victories is not the only way to play. It is certainly nice to hear him talk of creativity anyway!!

It is now up to the board to match these ambitions (gulp!)
Barry Rathbone
8 Posted 10/05/2012 at 17:54:41
James 131

"In the words of Bananarama, It's a cruel, cruel summer."

Just brilliant mate, so off the wall I nearly pissed meself.
Richard Reeves
9 Posted 10/05/2012 at 17:50:55
How can you get optimistic about something that suggests David Moyes will be here beyond next season?

I would be happy if he was talking to Kenwright about who his successor would be after his contract expires, and about one or two aditions for next season, but we all know he'll be looking for a new contract. If he signs another contract, I will loose all respect for him.

That coment from Jeff Shreaves in the Sky interview is spot-on, "Have you ever heard the phrase, 'knowing the best time to leave a party'?".
Wayne Smyth
10 Posted 10/05/2012 at 18:09:42
For all the moaning at Kenwright ? much of which is justified ? Moyes has still had 10 years and a £60M wage budget, plus transfer fees that he can generate from player sales in order to bring new, creative blood in.

If he has chosen to spend the vast majority of that money on players who are not creative or let players like Pienaar go for want of a few quid, and he's happy to pay McFadden or Straq, then that is his fault, not Kenwright's.

He should be offloading the deadwood out of the squad or accepting bids for the likes of Jags and bringing in players who can add that bit of spark to our play.

Kenwright should be selling up to get some investment into the team but, that aside, it doesn't excuse Moyes for crying poverty when he has quite a healthy budget to work with. Need to do some selling and buying!
Ged Simpson
11 Posted 10/05/2012 at 19:13:18
Barry - you'd piss yourself if we got relegated.

Reality check.

Look at our income / expenditure.

Now find me where £20m or whatever dream figure comes from ?

I dislike BK but economics are what they are - harsh and unforgiving.

But hey - Toffeeweb is a place to vent frustration if not logic.
Dan Brierley
12 Posted 10/05/2012 at 19:19:16
Wayne 145#, when you say 'healthy budget', can you please let us know what that is measured against? To our household budgets, it is indeed quite healthy.

But if we are gauging it against Premier League standards, 60 million over ten years is nothing. Most top teams spend that over 2 or 3 years.

Moyes has played a blinder with Pienaar. Sold him for a profit when he could have left for nothing, then brought him back paying only a percentage of his wages. Your view is so one sided its ridiculous. For want of a few quid? Since when is Steven Pienaar worth 70K a week? You honestly believe he is worth more than Luka Modric???
Aidy Dews
13 Posted 10/05/2012 at 19:44:38
I agree with you Pete 134#. It beats hearing him being negative and down beat like he was at the begining of this season!.

Im just glad to hear that he wants creativity in the side and wants players to play and fit around Jelavic.

We all know we need a right winger who's quick, direct and gives us the option of countering teams and stretching em, like Donovan did. If we could find a younger version of him then we'll be sorted out wide on the right.

But we also need a technically good player with skill and brilliant vision and a quick footballing brain who can spot Jelavic's runs and pick him out more often than not and isnt affraid to keep on looking for him inbehind.

A young, all round RB wouldnt go a miss either!.

But everyone will say 'well these types with quality cost alot of money!', but we originally got Pienaar on loan with a view to a permenant 2.5 - 3 million signing, Arteta before him, Jelavic recently, all players that werent getting a look in at there respective clubs or at clubs in a sticky financial position and we might have to look down that route again, players not getting a look in, players at clubs in lumber financially, relegated clubs that need to reduce the wage bill?!.

Hopefully the board can club together and give Moyesy the money he needs to strengthen cos were, IMO, 3 good players from having a very good first team that can go do a Newcastle or replicate what we did in 2004 even, i do believe that?!.
Wayne Smyth
14 Posted 10/05/2012 at 20:13:22
Dan, £60M is about the current annual wage bill. Which should be enough to purchase a little creativity.

Are you so sure Moyes' paid a blinder with Pienaar? I'm not. Any references for your assertion that we're only paying a portion of his wages...and what portion would that be?

I assume there is a loan fee - as there normally is - and I would have expected us to cover the vast majority - if not all - of Pienaars wages....but I have nothing to back that up than opinion, so I'd be interested if anyone does indeed know the exact situation.

On the flip side, we've only had him back for half the season and I expect we'll need to find at least what we got for him in a transfer fee if we want him again. I suspect we'll be financially worse off if we manage to get him back next season than we would've been had Moyes given him parity with Arteta.

As for whether he's worth £70k / week, I'd happily pay him £70k, rather than pay the scottish rooney £20k, or straq £10k, if that is what they're on. Fellaini is on £70k / week, I believe and Heitinga is on over 50k / week, when we've got Yobo loaned out and the excellent duffy unable to get a game.

I've stated before that as much as I think Felliaini is a fantastic player we need to keep our massive wages for our creative types and goalscorers. We can pick up decent defensive centre mids like Gibson for relatively little. Rodwell, Heitinga, Cahill or any number of players can play that role too.

Personally I think if Moyes is such a great coach that some people say he is - and given he's paid bloody well too - then he should be able to work within the budget he's been given and purchase accordingly. Not have a squad lopsided with too many centre halves and rely on 2 players for any kind of creativity after 10 years of a no-pressure job.
Jem Traynor
15 Posted 10/05/2012 at 22:35:41
It's good to know he is looking to bring in player's that will have Jelavic in mind because he is just a Natural attacker with a massive bag of finesse to boot, So I am happy to be reading that type of Interview with the Manager, all good.
James Stewart
16 Posted 10/05/2012 at 23:28:17
Wayne @ 174 ? Hear, Hear.
Dick Fearon
17 Posted 10/05/2012 at 22:27:36
Because we cannot afford ready-made improvements it places huge emphasis on development from within. In that regard, we should be a leading club. We have magnificent training facilities, top-notch medical and other resources, a coaching panel of hand-picked ex-stars, and the steadying influence of Moyes who is embarking on his third 5-year plan.

Most good young players come under notice of professional clubs in their pre-teen years And by 20, they would have had 10 years of training under the above-mentioned hand-picked panel. Why then do all PL clubs except Everton and City boast quality first team regulars that came through their own ranks?

It appears that Moyes has so little confidence in the current crop of wannabees, they are not worth a mention in his dream time plans. That very sad state of affairs demands a clear out or at least a rethink at all levels of coaching.
Ciarán McGlone
18 Posted 10/05/2012 at 23:45:45
Balls.

Heard it all before. Mark my words. Him and Kenwright will be holding hands on the MotD sofa in August after another shambolic summer.
James Flynn
19 Posted 11/05/2012 at 03:00:54
Ciaran ? Take out Moyes holding hands and replace him with anyone you like.

If whomever is holding hands with Kenwright, he and we remain fucked.

No such thing as lousy ownership and great clubs. Incompatible. Any sport.
Jem Traynor
20 Posted 11/05/2012 at 04:06:24
On hearing Wayne Stewart (#174), I find it hard to disagree; it seems at least backward to prioritise players and their wages that way ? especially with young talent waiting in the wings? I have to say it's baffling me...
Tom Dodds
21 Posted 10/05/2012 at 23:53:06
Totally agree with Dick 213;

What IS going on with the reserve/youth? It's the opposite of the old quoted phrase 'seen and not heard'... We hear but never or damn rarely see them.

Curious bordering on suspicious, yet the scouts and moyes are continually running round looking at loads of young players all over the place, Why? ... It's like their hunting for butterflies in a strange way to add to the 'collection'!

Joking aside, why the hell ? and this includes the rest of the way Everton conducts its business and management of the club ? are we fans forever being left in the dark???

It's OUR club! Without us turning up every game, they'd be fuck all.

Time the Blue Union or someone with a better organising grip got organised properly next season, the reds wouldn't take all this constant secretive shit chairmanship & board crap lying down... SO WHY ARE WE???
Jason Lam
22 Posted 11/05/2012 at 06:16:56
What's the point in youth development if we don't play them. Those that show a slight bit of promise are thrown back in the youth team.
Terry Downes
23 Posted 11/05/2012 at 06:42:33
I'm sure all these posts and messages were the same about this time last year... and the year before... come to think of it, about the last 5 years. And I'm sure we'll be saying the same next year.

Do we never learn with Moyes and Kenwright?
Peter Barry
24 Posted 11/05/2012 at 06:55:08
With Moyes We're Bust. 10 years of mediocrity from the Dire Dour Defensive one and now he is promising a bright creative attacking future. Anyone foolish enough to believe him - 'cos I don't.
Matthew Lovekin
25 Posted 11/05/2012 at 07:09:52
Sounds like Moyes is already trying to sell Jelavic for £20m!

He obviously doesn't track back enough for corners!
Jimmy Sørheim
26 Posted 11/05/2012 at 07:05:43
Good points Jason and Peter!
There is a lot to be corrected, even after 10 years with Moyes we seem to have drifted backwards the last few years.

Moyes has to take some blaim for this.
But he hides behind lack of investment, I do not see Lambert and Rodgers complain and put out negative comments about our club like Moyes did during the first half of the season.

Some remember the bad things, but too many overlook it!
Nick Entwistle
27 Posted 11/05/2012 at 07:52:47
Wayne... 'Dan, £60M is about the current annual wage bill. Which should be enough to purchase a little creativity.'

Erm, care to point out where you made a tit of yourself there?
Steve Pugh
28 Posted 11/05/2012 at 08:08:21
Peter 245, you embarrass yourself with comments like that. No matter what Moyes is now he took us from being relegation scrappers to being European challengers so slagging off his entire tenure is just childish.
Stephen Kenny
29 Posted 11/05/2012 at 08:16:19
Moyes biggest plus is his eye for a player.

I think we will sign Pienaar and if he doesn't think Ross is ready he may try for a creative type if there's cash to do so. I think he'd get us a player for relative peanuts.

His biggest drawback is his loyalty to certain players.

I can see him giving Cahill another season of starting before he's ousted. The impact this has on our play is obvious. If he's serious this cannot happen.

It appears his attitude has changed. I welcome it. Hopefully we will be going out to win games from the off and we will see more of this talking us and our players up.

I believe his attitude to be a factor in our poor starts. This changes and we may get out the blocks quicker and make an impression on the league.

But, as Ciaran says we have seen this all before and it will need a big change in a man who appears ridiculously stuuborn for us to come out next season as a different side.
Peter Barry
30 Posted 11/05/2012 at 09:01:44
@ Steve Pugh # 252 . Moyes is on record as saying 'Top ten' is an achievement for him and he expresses 'SATISFACTION' with bore draws and was 'PLEASED" to get three points from winning one game and losing to the RS because he only thought the BEST he could get from the two games was two draws so getting THREE points was an ACHIEVEMENT even though we lost AGAIN to the RS in the process. If you that this is the kind of man that is in touch with the feelings of Evertonians then good luck to you.
Matt Traynor
31 Posted 11/05/2012 at 09:07:30
Stephen #255, Moyes has had many road to Damascus moments down the years. This year, his attitude post Anfield Derby and Semi Final, in defending his selection and tactics against criticism from supports and some sections of the media showed for me he's started believing his own publicity.

Ultimately it will come down to what funds he's given. I think most would agree if he had the money his favourites would be relegated to bit parts, but it's all moot as we know he won't have a pot as usual.

Jelavic may be a piece of this jigsaw puzzle he talks about, but he's 26, and in 12 months if he has a good season will be at the peak of his value and will be sold.
Tony J Williams
32 Posted 11/05/2012 at 09:53:33
So the manager says something a little bit positive and the MOB go all negative on his ass....just love the irrony of this.

"But he hides behind lack of investment" - because it is true, in the last 3 years, we haven't spent any money on players until January and they were paid for by selling our most creative player.....and Bily
Wayne Smyth
33 Posted 11/05/2012 at 10:22:26
Nick (#250), I understand that the basics of finance when running a company - in our case a football club - may be a bit above your head, so here's a little lesson in basic economics.

I'll try to keep it simple, since you're probably fuelled up on meds or alcohol trying to stop believing/forget that our magnificent coach will conspire to have us finish behind the RS this season.

1) Money comes in through gate receipts, sponsorship, TV deals and other income streams.

2) Money is spent on overpaid coaches, players, maintenance, interest and other outgoings.

What you save in wages - or any part of your expenses - can be used to finance other areas of the business such as transfer/loan fees or pantomimes.

Thus in a completely hypothetical situation which bears no relation to our current predicament, if your company turns over £80M and you spend £60M on wages then that's £60M you can't spend on transfer fees.

Furthermore, for example, if you were to get rid of expensive liabilities that contribute very little to your business:

Hannhemann £10k / week
McScottishRooney £20k / week
Straq £10k / week

That means over the course of a season, you'd be better off to the tune of approximately £2M, which can then be funnelled into transfer fees. See how it works?

We're not even going near biting peoples hands off when they offer £10M for overrated, jittery, error prone centre halves, or £8M for injury prone, elderly forwards. This cash can also be used to rejuvenate the squad by promoting youth players in or bringing in unpolished youngsters with potential. Buying talent in where you need to.

Because we're owned by Shakin' Kenwright rather than Sheik Mansour, we're reliant on the manager to MANAGE with the budget he's given, because while I'd be more than happy to see Kenwright replaced with a more wealthy and commercially astute owner, in premiership terms Moyes has still been allocated a reasonable financial pot to work with.

Now, if all that is still over your head, there is the outside possibility that I can draw some pictures for you. ;-)

P.S. Its also funny to read Moyes stating that you normally need to spend £15-£20M to get a forward who'll score 20 goals a season. I thought we had one of those who we got rid of for £1.5M?

In all seriousness, although Moyes sounds positive and wants us to be getting better players in, I'm actually quite worried for the future of the club when we have an owner like Kenwright who doesn't have money to put in, and Moyes demanding cash to work with when he could and should be managing us more effectively by using our youth system, trading players and getting rid of deadwood.

One likely outcome is that Kenwright in his desire to keep his train ends up mortgaging us up with more debt from shady 3rd parties and we end up doing a Rangers in 2 or 3 years time.

I'd much rather be comfortably mid-table but solvent than bust.
Tony J Williams
34 Posted 11/05/2012 at 11:24:29
"Moyes demanding cash to work with when he could and should be managing us more effectively by using our youth system, trading players and getting rid of deadwood" - Youth system, you can only utilise it if they are good enough. The only player this year I have seen come in and look comfortable enough in a Premier League team is Duffy...and he made a few mistakes too.

Barkley, hoping he comes on but he doesn't look good enough yet and the hysterical clamouring for his inclusion is just quite odd.

rading players, we don't have enough of them to do this, we bring in loans and frees so who will buy them from us.

getting rid of deadwood, again, who will buy them and to cancel their contracts means paying them out, so may aswell have them doing something for their money instead of just giving them a wedge and saying ta ra
Paul Mackie
35 Posted 11/05/2012 at 11:25:53
Whislt it's nice to once again see Moyes making all the usualy noises about business being done early, talking with the chairman and wanting to play attacking football, I'll believe it when I actually see it.

I don't hate Moyes. I think he's a good manager who has worked well within the constraints of our current financial and ownership situation, but he has a lot of faults too. One of which is his reluctance to phase out players like Cahill who has quite frankly been terrible this season. He also needs to realise that there'll be no funds made available by the board. If he wants to get more players in he either needs to look to our youth setup or will have to sell existing talent. Selling one player to fund many more replacements is not a bad thing in my opinion and is frankly the most likely way we'll see anyone new at the club. Providing of course that any money raised goes into the transfer budget and not straight to the banks. Which of course it won't.

Kenwright out etc...

Denis Richardson
36 Posted 11/05/2012 at 12:29:55
?I can see in my head pictures and directions of where I think we should be going and what players we need to get, which players can help us progress again,?

Can someone reconcile the above statement from Moyes with the fact that we haven't had a decent recognised right winger in the squad for a number of years. Given the impact the short loan spells of Donovan had (a decent but not exactly world class player), its a bit strange that we've never sorted this position out.

Its not like its a new problem...
Tony J Williams
37 Posted 11/05/2012 at 12:43:05
Denis, he has tried to buy right wingers but either been outbid/not been able to bid or they have ended up being drunken Dutch men.

If every fan in the league know we need a good right winger, I am guessing our manager knows...hence the Donovan deals, Drenthe playing there, Simon Davies etc
Wayne Smyth
38 Posted 11/05/2012 at 12:35:27
Tony, Duffy looked the better of the two centre halves when he played earlier this season. Can't recall which of heitinga/distin/jags he played with, but I do remember being very, very impressed.

If I recall correctly, he was dropped for the next game when hibbert was placed at centre half and to be fair hibbo played an absolute blinder and we got a result.....but Duffy should've been restored to the 1st 11 at least for some games after that.

I don't recall Duffy making any (significant) errors, but that didn't stop Moyes playing jags at the start of the season when he was having a shocking time and got bailed out time and again by Distin.

Why do we need 3 experienced keepers? We've got no-one in the youth system that can play 3rd fiddle? We're so flush with cash we can pay someone to sit on their arse all season? These players don't just turn up and get given a contract, the manager decides to give them one. Same for McFadden, same for Straq.

Our youth team may or may not contain premiership standard players, but they're a damn sight cheaper than bringing in has-beens, will sweat for the cause and if only one or two make it, then it saves the club millions of pounds.

Remember Jeffers? Crap player, played well for a short period of time, conned arsenal into paying £10M. We're not going to get anything for our (good or crap)youth players with them stuck in the ressies.

Whats so wrong about blooding these youngsters for 10 or 15 minutes at the end of a game and seeing if they can cope? McAleny didn't look really out of place when he came on at the Emirates, made more of an impact than the waste of space Saha that he replaced if my memory serves me correctly and at least created some chances.
Stephen Kenny
39 Posted 11/05/2012 at 12:47:31
Matt,

I can see a real top drawer spine in this group and Pienaar, Baines on the left is also class. We don't have quality for every position but most sides don't. A Rodwell move to RB and I think we'd be a force.

I just hope he's realised that playing to this group's strengths means playing quick passing football on the floor.

I don't think he'll ever lose his cautious nature when the heat is on but he doesn't need to do that for us to finish in the European places, IMO.
Denis Richardson
40 Posted 11/05/2012 at 12:45:36
Tony, sorry but trying and failing for one summer is one thing, not being able to fill this obvious hole for multiple years is quite another. And I am not just talking about the last 2-3 years, this has been an obvious issue for at least 5+ years now.

This is also not a lack of transfer money issue ? granted, if we were loaded we could buy anyone but there are a number of Prem players on free transfers every single year (100+!) before we even start on Europe. He and the scouts have had ample time and opportunity to solve this. I just don't think this has ever been made a priority to be honest and he's been happy playing Osman, Arteta, Rodwell, Anichebe ? Anyone in that role.

Please don't use the likes of Simon Davies as an example, he was at the club about 7 years ago! May as well include Shandy Andy as well. They both turned out to be top buys and really worth the millions we splashed out there!! This actually just highlights our inability to bring in a decent right winger and that there is something very wrong with the whole scouting set-up.
James Martin
41 Posted 11/05/2012 at 13:04:30
Why are some people of the opinion the Stracq contributes nothing and is a waste of wages? If Jelavic gets injured tomorrow, who starts upfront for us? If we ever played 4-4-2, who would partner Jelavic? Everyone might say Vellios but clearly Moyes doesn't think so and considering Anichebe's injuries it appears that Stracq is our only viable option behind Jelavic.
Nick Entwistle
42 Posted 11/05/2012 at 13:00:40
Wayne, if McRooney isn't on a pay as you play deal I'd be surprised. The 20k pw wages are no more I believe than TW rumour mongering.

As for what I pulled you up on, yes ok, wages can be reduced to offset transfer spending. But £60m to play with gives no room for maneuver.

The £2m you conjure up is to what? Spend £2m on a player? Where are his wages coming from? All of a sudden we're spending more.
Or just give a free signing £2m a year in wages... but then what's for the transfer fund?
For fees and wages the £60m offers nothing at all to work with.

You can't compete at the top with a squad full of Gibsons in terms of fees and effect. They're few on the ground. We only got the best striker we've had since... take your pick... for a pittance because of Rangers' imploding... anyway, I'm getting back on the gin and meds. Happy Friday.
Wayne Smyth
43 Posted 11/05/2012 at 13:23:10
Nick, you might be right about the pay as you play, as I think McFadden didn't exactly have a lot of suitors, but I'm not sure anyone actually here knows. If I had to guess I'd imagine he'd at least have a 10k basic salary, plus a pay as you play.

Our budget of £60M is just about mid-level when it comes to premier league salaries, so we're finishing roughly where we'd expect to based on our expenditure.

As for what £2M buys you, well it doesn't (always)get you a lot, but its still £2M. It might pay for a Darron Gibson, or a George Green, or perhaps even the wages of someone with talent brought on a free.

Heaven forbid, but running a tight ship might also mean that youth players with potential get the occasional game and get to see what its like at the top level. Are we really saying that Straq contributes more than Vellios? I would've loved to see Vellios used as a second striker.

I think Blackpool last season had a wage bill of just £13M, and although they went down, they still played some decent footie, so you say £60M doesn't give you scope, but I don't think Moyes is so hamstrung as he likes to have people believe.
Nick Entwistle
44 Posted 11/05/2012 at 13:41:13
Good points, Wayne, but look, we're into the last game of the season and we could drop two places which could cost us from varying reports somewhere between £1.6m and £3m. So effective players that will put points on the table will always be placed above trying out youth for their benefit alone. The stakes are too high.

The wage budget may well indicate that we are finishing where we should, although the other thread detailing these expenses were before Arteta, Saha and Yakubu left. But, if you don't have a transfer budget to cherry pick the players to then pay a percentage of that £60m, then you are scraping the barrel.

Mixing metaphors here, but it does put us at a disadvantage from those with the same wage budget but have transfer clout in fees.
Paul David
45 Posted 11/05/2012 at 13:52:51
Yeah Nick, but when those senior players are not effective you have nothing to lose by playing younger players.

If Vellios had played instead of Saha and Cahill, I'm pretty sure we would've had more points on the board by now.
John Ford
46 Posted 11/05/2012 at 14:03:11
Nick, in my view the wages budget is a bit of a red herring. It shows we are able to compete, kind of, with other teams as far as salaries go.

Player purchase power to a level where a club can buy a decent number of the very best players around is the single biggest determinant of success. NET spend of the top clubs is consistently high for a reason.
Nick Entwistle
47 Posted 11/05/2012 at 14:00:29
That's a definitely maybe, Paul.

But an on-song Saha would have the team flying. Moyes gave him every chance which he didn't take. But I don't blame Moyes for trying to play him into form.

As for say Duffy or Barkley its a different matter. Saha was there to score goals and didn't. A very specific requirement, yet with CBs and MCs its more difficult to justify an exclusion of the seniors for a youth's development.
Paul David
48 Posted 11/05/2012 at 14:09:20
Nick, how long do you give a player to re-discover past form?Moyes is far too loyal and certain players know they will be starting games if they play crap or not, that cannot be good for the team.

I agree, young players cannot be given an extended run in the team for the sake of it but the same goes for senior players and Moyes has certainly done that.
Ian Bennett
49 Posted 11/05/2012 at 14:13:13
I would love to know if we were really offered big money for Saha a couple of years back.
Paul David
50 Posted 11/05/2012 at 14:21:33
Ian I'm sure a Turkish side offered £6-8m for Saha. Brilliant on his day but far too inconsistent; I cannot believe he wasn't sold.
Stephen Kenny
51 Posted 11/05/2012 at 14:23:49
Nick if he was just out of form he'd still be here as Jela's understudy.

Moyes knew he was finished and so did everybody else. So is Cahill and he's still first name on the sheet. He's had two seasons to play his way back to form when other like Vellios have far more pressing claims to play.
Nick Entwistle
52 Posted 11/05/2012 at 14:34:24
Not too loyal Paul, he got shot of him in January.

I don't know if he was/ is finished, his Spurs debut and subsequent form showed that he can still play at his best. Even if he's down the pecking order.

An ageing striker on big wages playing understudy to Jely? I think Moyes had enough of that with Campbell and Ferguson sapping £4m a year from the coffers.
Paul David
53 Posted 11/05/2012 at 14:43:24
Nick

I meant in general, Saha, Cahill, Arteta, Jagielka, Osman have all gone through extended periods of poor form yet their place in the team was never under threat.

If it wasn't for Pienaar coming in the opposite direction, I'm sure Moyes would still be persisting with Saha now.
Ian Bennett
54 Posted 11/05/2012 at 14:43:40
It was money we should've never turned down. I think Yak was being sniffed at by Hawy Wedknapp.

Hindsight is a wonderful thing, something like £23m was turned down on 2 players that left for £1.5m. Only the club will know if that is true ? but it's not the best if it is.
Wayne Smyth
55 Posted 11/05/2012 at 15:10:28
Nick we're not playing youth players for their benefit. Its entirely for our(club's) benefit because ultimately we hope to find a baines, osman or rooney from our youth system who is good enough, or could be good enough to either play for us and/or be sold on for a profit.

Hanhemann, McFadden, Cahill, Saha, Straq are all players who have contributed little or nothing to our current position in the league despite being given games. I don't see the issue with moving them on allowing us to save the many millions in wages and giving room for our youngsters like Duffy, Barkley and Vellios to see if they can step up.

Unfortunately we don't have the cash to compete with the likes of Spurs, RS, or a few other clubs. We just can't afford to be carrying passengers if we are to realise our potential as a club.
Joe Clitherow
56 Posted 11/05/2012 at 15:08:09
Paul 334

I don't believe a serious bid of 6-8M from a Turkish side ever came in for Saha. If it did I don't believe it was ever more than two bob down and a 'gentleman's' agreement to pay the rest later on from the most disreputable group of operators in world football (see Yobo and any number of stories about non-payment of wages).

Similarly reports of 6m+ for Yakubu from West Ham are completely unsubstantiated paper talk. The only genuine comment I remember was that they bid 1m for him as that was what they valued him at, a comment which came from their pompous porn peddling vertically challenged owner. This was stated with a kind of 'how dare you turn that offer down' attitude. Then West Ham were relegated that season (hooray!) - and an extra few million for the Yak's goals may have kept them up. Yakubu wanted to leave as he always has done throughout his career. Started like a train and then got relegated in an awful side and last few times I have watched him he looked like a player nearing the end of his time. So I don't think the pot of gold at the end of that rainbow was really ever there.

Ian 339 it wasn't money we should never have turned down; it was money that never existed. If you genuinely, seriously think Everton turned down £23m for two players who then left for £1.5m, well then I don't know what to say, really! I think it's the same mentality as replying to those ads cable tied on traffic lights for £500+ an hour for working at home not doing much.

If it sounds too good to be true, it probably isn't.
Nick Entwistle
57 Posted 11/05/2012 at 15:35:16
I think we've now gone full circle Wayne. We'd be starting from the top about points on the table etc.
Ian Bennett
58 Posted 11/05/2012 at 16:14:34
Joe - I was talking about Harry red knapp at spurs rather than west ham (avram grant was the manager with them). Harry hasn't been at west ham for about a decade. So unless he has a delorean how was he going to sign him? I know he was subject of West ham bid, congratulations, I was talking before hand.

If you read on, I stated only the club will know what was really offered. At the time yak was a 15m+ player and we haven't a clue what the deal for Saha was, if one indeed existed, I suspect it was Moyes talking him up.

Joe Clitherow
59 Posted 11/05/2012 at 18:15:26
Ian

When? When and who was ever supposedly bidding upwards of 15m for Yakubu??

I think we paid top dollar for him at the peak of his power and that was 11.25m. 15m+ seems to be either your or a tabloid journalist's made up number.

Either way the point stands that - given that yes only the club knows for sure - 23m 'worth' sold for 1.5m is just made up completely...in my opinion.

But believe what you want to.
Ian Bennett
60 Posted 11/05/2012 at 18:48:23
Joe - what do you mean who. I have bloody said Spurs didn't I.

Yes, we signed him for £11m, he scored 21 goals in his first season, so why not expect more (he was 24 at the time not 30).

Spurs supposedly bid £15m for him, he was miffed and then did his achiles in a little later.

I have already said i haven't a clue if Saha deal was real or not. If it was, it would have around £23m for 2 players that walked out for next to nought.
Joe Clitherow
61 Posted 11/05/2012 at 19:04:15
Yes Ian I know you did, I just don't believe a single word of it was my point.

You'd find Harry walking round today with no hand after it had been snapped off. It wouldn't be Mr Levy's style to throw money about to cash strapped clubs either.

Yakubu by the way was never 24 when Harry was in charge of Spurs either even if you believe his official birthday of November 1982.

You can believe that or not as well.
Jamie Barlow
62 Posted 11/05/2012 at 19:19:34
McFadden is on £2000 a week.
Ian Bennett
63 Posted 11/05/2012 at 19:25:35
Joe - Feel free to question everything including player ages.

For the record, Yak got injured in the November I think actually at Spurs. The said Mr Levy then paid £15.75m for Defoe from Portsmouth (a cash strapped club).



So yes I think it had substance, but injury blew the chance of putting that to the test.
Tom Bowers
64 Posted 11/05/2012 at 19:31:07
Moyes is the manager of a business and BK is the chairman of the board.
In a sense Moyes has done well in that aspect as the club has not lost money but on the other hand has not made money due to the lack of success over 10 years.
Moyes is sitting pretty as long as BK accepts the lack of success without it costing him and the shareholders.
Obviously it is we the fans who suffer as long as the team remains a mid-table proposition.
We always seem to pick up in the second half of the season which seems to warrant Moyes being kept on for yet another.
Defensively very few teams have a better record this season and Jelavic has made the scoring numbers better since January.
The big question is who is going to help him and who is going to bolster a somewhat average midfield outfit.
It would appear that the likes of Cahill,Straqs,Velios and Anichebe no longer have the skills nor werewithal to have an impact at the top level. Cahill has become a back number now and Velios seems unrated by Moyes.
There has to be some off-loading and if not everything will be deja-vu next season.
Joe Clitherow
65 Posted 11/05/2012 at 19:48:59
OK Ian I'll give it one last go and then I'll quit.

Yakubu - born 22 November 1982 (cough!)

Harry Redknapp - managed Spurs from October 2008, so Yakubu was nearly 26 (cough!) when he took over.

Yakubu ruptured his Achilles at end of November 2008 so an overlap of less than two months of Harry's tenure, unless you are saying a bid was made after Yak suffering one of the worst 3 football injuries along with medial and cruciate damage.

I don't think you are so then we get to the fact that you can't actually make a bid for any player who is not a free agent at that time of year - you have to bid within the transfer window. Sure you can tap a player up illiegally but you wouldn't mention any figures, and if you did you would want the fee to be as small as possible to the club so you could negotiate "sign-on" bonuses and such like directly to the player and his agent out of the budget set by the buying club.

You can though, if you're a hack trying to sell tabloid rags make up any old shite you want with no basis in fact on the premise that no-one remembers it a week later and so what if it's bollocks anyway?

Then we get to the fee. Everton paying 11.25m is done via a small down payment with the rest on the drip, so a large part of that was not paid out at that time either and would go to the previous club. Suddenly your 23m looks a lot less. Based on the fact that an immediate 3.75m profit on a down payment would be hard (I'd say impossible) for Everton's financiers to turn down and you can see where I'm going.

I'll go out on a limb here and state that no genuine tangible bid (as opposed to tabloid rubbish) has ever been turned down by Everton in recent times and you can see where I'm coming from.

I could go on about the transfer from Portsmouth to Middlesbrough which was very murky but the whole point is that all of these quoted figures are very suspicious.

In any case, the club never turned down 15m+ for Yakubu because it was impossible for a bid to have been made, even if Spurs would offer that amount outside the window (which they wouldn't since an illiegal agreement cannot be enforced and QED would not be made).

So yeah I'll believe what I want but it will have to make some kind of logical sense and stand up to scrutiny and not just because someone says it or because it's in the Sun/Mirror/Star etc
Ian Bennett
66 Posted 11/05/2012 at 20:22:25
Joe - We are talking Harry Redknapp, do you really think he waits to the transfer window and then phones up to bid for a player?

Everton had only just signed him. What makes you think that the same financers would demand a sale for such a small profit? I think we just sold Johnson as well, so funds had rolled in/signed Fellaini for cash/future cashflows. Doesn't point to fire selling then.

The fact is we dont know. Yakubu had scored a boat load before,got injured and never really recovered to the player he was. Saha knocked in some goals for a freebie. At the time it should have been goals galore, but sadly it went down hill from then despite the cup run.
Paul David
67 Posted 11/05/2012 at 20:40:11
Joe

I have no idea if Spurs put a bid in for Yakubu but if they did offer £15m plus I bet Moyes would have knocked it back,the man is stubborn.Moyes only accepted £25m for Lescott because the player was pushing for a move so I could easily see him knocking back £15m for Yakubu.
Ben Jones
68 Posted 11/05/2012 at 20:57:15
Here we see Moyes opening up more to the media than usual, and give a spot on account on what we want next season, and people still slate him?

Why arnt people saying that Moyes hasnt done this earlier? Its not his fault, its the boards!! Moyes buys players at bargain prices, typified by one of the leagues form players at the moment in Jelavic, and the board still dont back him up.

People who criticise his squad, look at a comparison to his good and bad players, look at the net spend, and look at our internationals. Yeah, we are short on creativity, but no squad is perfect.

Rather these problems to the dark, dark days of Walter Smith I'm telling ya
Ian Bennett
69 Posted 11/05/2012 at 20:55:22
For the record he had scored19,17,19,16 and 21 goals for rank teams prior to that injury, so he pretty decent. I think only Henry had a better record at the time.

I would think Moyes would of turned down, but the everton fans wouldn't have been happy to lose a new gary lineker either. Hindsight is a wonderful thing.
Paul David
70 Posted 11/05/2012 at 21:03:50
Ben

I hope Moyes has changed his ways and is genuinely looking to build a more creative attacking minded team (I will still want him out though) but part of me thinks he is just saying the right things to keep the likes of me quiet untill he signs his new 5 year £75k a week contract.
Joe Clitherow
71 Posted 11/05/2012 at 20:46:33
Ian I know I said I'd quit but...

..yeah Harry has to wait to bid, because, well he has to.

He can say he wants Yakubu for 15m, sure, to a journo, and that rumour can go around. But your original post that I disagreed with (339) stated that "It was money we should never have turned down" and that the club is somehow cuplable for turning down 23m.

My point is that the club could not possibly have turned it down because it could not have been offered.

Or, alternatively, it was offered and accepted (both illegally) outside the transfer window but then withdrawn because of injury, But then that's not turned down either is it? Nor does it make any kind of sense to negotiate figures then.

Any "gentleman's" (or in this case "non-gentleman's" agreement) at that time of the season does not make any sense because a) the selling club does not know if a bidding war will start in the three months to the window and b) the buying club may have other better options by then (e.g. Defoe) so any bid/agreement/whatever is pointless.

I agree with you that, since Defoe was signed in the next window, it is quite possible that an attempt could have been made to sign Yakubu (and I believe would have been accepted by Everton) but that is quite different to being turned down isn't it?

it's also quite a different argument that both you and I are in apparent agreement that such a bid should be accepted in those circumstances. That's clearly a difference between head and heart because just prior to Yakubu's (and Arteta's) injury Everton were really a very very genuine force with powerful and effective players and you wouldn't have had much support for such a sale then. We haven't been at that level since then in terms of quality of player.

You'd have had murder on here if he'd been sold in the January and I don't think my (business) head would have won over my (Everton) heart either.

As an aside my favourite Yakubu moment was the 2-0 away win at an upcoming heavily spending Man City when he and Lescott scored and we dismantled them really in a comprehensive win while I was the only Evertonian in a pub full of City fans.

That and a "see you later" dummy in a Europa League game when he scored.

Best goalscorer in a blue shirt since Lineker.... until Jelly came along!!
Joe Clitherow
72 Posted 11/05/2012 at 21:12:42
Bizarre Ian! I wrote my post while you submitted yours and we said very much the same thing, even naming Lineker!
Ian Bennett
73 Posted 11/05/2012 at 21:19:31
Joe - we'll leave at that.

Yak and Saha looked a sure bet. Moyes had signed Fellaini, had arteta, Cahill, pienaar, baines,lescott, jags, howard, Neville.

Christ that wasn't a bad side.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads