Moyes faces up to financial reality

, 11 May, 55comments  |  Jump to most recent
Everton still on a sell-to-buy footing

The tight nature of Everton's financial situation is well documented and in admitting that the Club may have to "start trading players more than we would like to," David Moyes has set expectations for the summer as he tries to build on his team's impressive recovery from an awful first half of of the 2011-12 season.

Though he didn't explicitly mention that he might have to cash in on one of the Blues' more valuable assets like Leighton Baines and Marouane Fellaini, the Blues' boss did draw a parallel between Everton's sale of Wayne Rooney in 2004 and Newcastle's ability to make key additions after selling Andy Carroll to Liverpool for a mind-boggling £35m.

"They got a big buy off Andy Carroll which gave them some cash to go and spend and it changed things around.

"I don't think you need to break the bank but you have to do things within your means and that is what we have done.

"There is a bit of similarity with how we did it in the early days when we sold Wayne Rooney and had to go out and purchase some players and bring them on.

"I think you do need to have that lump some to go and start your work and that can kickstart things."

Whether it's a big-money sale or offloading some of his fringe players, Moyes indicated that he will have to sell players before he is able to add others as he bids to build a team around hot-shot striker, Nikica Jelavic.

"You never want to lose the players you have got, they are vitally important.

"We've brought them here, nurtured them, brought a lot of them on and we hope we are able to keep them.

"We might now be in a situation where we have to start trading players more than we would like to - but that is the way things go.

"In the last window we bought well and showed we didn't need a great deal of cash to turn things around."

Indeed, Moyes expressed his pleasure at the improvement in both his side's results and their standard of play since he was abl to make those targeted additions in January.

"I have really enjoyed the way we have played since January, it has given me a great thrill.

"And more so because I feel I have been able to give the supporters something back.

"At the start of the year I don't think I would have come and watched - there was nothing to excite me.

"People were saying we were dull, but there is nobody that wants to see attacking play and goals more than me."

Quotes or other material sourced from The Telegraph



Reader Comments (55)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Ian Bennett
1 Posted 11/05/2012 at 22:12:36
2 + 2 = Felli out?

He never mentioned him on another interview recently, in the same way Arteta wasn't mentioned by Bill in a similar style last year. Biggest earner, win win.

My prediction is United £20m. Let's see if I am right.
Wayne Smyth
2 Posted 11/05/2012 at 22:14:29
Sounds eminently sensible.

Should've been doing this more the last 5 years to balance the books, rather than mortgaging our future with shady 3rd parties at high interest rates.

Paul David
3 Posted 11/05/2012 at 22:17:07
Ian I would want more than £20m for Fellaini, Utd paid £18m for Carrick. I can see Utd coming in for him though and Carrick coming the other way.
Ian Bennett
4 Posted 11/05/2012 at 22:22:24
He's not a typical united player granted. The fee may be higher, but they need new players and he will of impressed in the 4-4.

Carrick - hope to god not.

He would be a huge luxury, but berbatov and jelly would be a classy pairing.
Paul David
5 Posted 11/05/2012 at 22:27:52
Ian

I think Fellaini is exactly what utd need and I would like Carrick depending on his wages. He is an excellent passer especially long range. He would put an end to our slow build up play, he always looks to cut out the middle man with balls over the top into space.
Shaun Brennan
6 Posted 11/05/2012 at 22:36:37
Paul #414,

you forget Jagielka does one better he misses both middle men out with his balls over the top.
Ian Bennett
7 Posted 11/05/2012 at 22:33:16
He has no legs for me, and will earn a boat load.

In theory you would put Gibson in with Rodwell., and use the money elsewhere, or look to bring players like cabaye.
Paul David
8 Posted 11/05/2012 at 22:38:53
Haha, I know, Shaun, maybe Moyes should consider putting him back in midfield with his passing range.
Graham Haines
9 Posted 11/05/2012 at 22:43:22
Shaun #415

Brilliant mate, absolutely cracked me up after a very long day!
Paul David
10 Posted 11/05/2012 at 22:41:21
Ian

Yeah, he isn't the most athletic of players. If Moyes is true to his word about looking to build a more creative side, then a partnership of Carrick and Gibson who naturally sit deep would allow the wingers to focus more on getting forward and not have to worry as much about defending. Tell you who I would like is Whittingham from Cardif; everytime I've seen him, he is always looking to get forward and play forward passes.
Tony Twist
11 Posted 11/05/2012 at 22:54:52
Carrick?! God help us. He is well past his sell by date. It's lots of cash, it's time for utd to dig deep not get on the cheap. Fellaini is our prize asset and worth £25M.
Paul David
12 Posted 11/05/2012 at 22:59:33
Tony

I wasnt suggesting that I wanted Carrick as part of a Fellaini deal even though I can see him doing a job for us.I think Moyes would want someone as a ready made replacement.
Barry Rathbone
13 Posted 11/05/2012 at 23:09:57
Carrick? No thank you.

Carrick is a midfield version of John o'shea and the other chump they off loaded to Sunderland - great buys they've turned out ? not.

Get the money and back your judgement with some pace and creativity LIKE YOU SAID, Mr Moyes.
Tony Twist
14 Posted 11/05/2012 at 23:19:47
Let's hope the club stays strong, if we need money then take the full market value not a reduced amount of money and some cast off player. If only there was interest in rodwell instead, I can't see him coping with the demand to play game after game after game playing for Everton. I hope I am wrong. Maybe playing in defence will be better for him.
James Martin
15 Posted 11/05/2012 at 23:28:22
Carrick's rubbish isn't he, how many league titles has he won again? He's only been the mdifield mainstay of United's recent title winning sides, then again what does Ferguson know about football, after all he thinks Moyes is a good manager, clearly deluded. Why would Ferguson want Fellaini? When have United ever played with a big slow donk either in midfield or upfront? He had Berbatov, twice the player Fellaini is upfront and couldn't fit him in his team.

The same reason we got Gibson is the same reason Ferguson won't take Fellaini, because top teams who want to win things don't buy slow players. Ferguson will be taking his pick from Europe's top table of midfielders: Hazard, Modric, Sneijder, Gaitan, Javi Martinez.

He's not going to go for Fellaini; no-one is, because outside of this website no-one rates him. I hope someone is stupid enough to buy him for big money then we get rid of a slow player who adds to our turgid footballer and might instead be able to buy 2 or 3 fast players with a goal threat who can pass forward.
Paul David
16 Posted 11/05/2012 at 23:42:47
James

Carrick is slow.
Andrew James
17 Posted 11/05/2012 at 23:32:08
If we sell anybody to Man Utd, we must get full cash back like we did with City, not some dodgy deal where we get their rejects every few years as part payment. I don't follow the whole thing whereby average Utd players are good enough for us. No, they are good enough for Bolton or Sunderland but we are better.

Carrick would be no better than Rodwell for us and certainly inferior to Fellaini by a mile.

No...we should get the Manc coin and spend it wisely on hungry players not guys who will always think they haven't quite made it because Man Utd got rid.

That said, if we could sign up Pienaar and let go of perhaps the Straq and Jimmy Mac (I like both but I am being a realist) and get through the summer with the squad intact, I'll be happy.

Sam Hoare
18 Posted 12/05/2012 at 00:21:58
Think I would rather sell Baines than Fellaini...

How about we sell Baines for £20M to Utd, Jags for £12M to Arsenal and Rodwell to Spurs for £15M (they love injury-prone English central midfielders).

Chuck £15M to the bank, get Daniel Pranjic on a freebie to play left back, and have £32M to spend on Pienaar another playmaker, another striker to play with Jelavic and a young Lescott-esque centre-back from the Championship.

I'll put Football Manager down now.
Shaun Brennan
19 Posted 12/05/2012 at 01:22:09
Seeing as some of you have decided Fellaini is off with Man U as a possible destination. I'd fancy Carrick and perhaps Wellbeck on loan as part of the deal.
James Stewart
20 Posted 12/05/2012 at 01:47:28
Carrick is complete shite, we don't want to go there. We need someone more mobile and creative than him.
Shaun Brennan
21 Posted 12/05/2012 at 02:31:54
I actually didn't realize Carrick was 30, so swerve that.
James Flynn
22 Posted 12/05/2012 at 02:59:18
I like how Moyes has been going at ownership. Subtle. Nice. The constant references, "Knife to a gunfight" on the extreme end (And the best. Loved that one). But, these quotes today and how he wants to do business early in this transfer window, the need to build around Jela, etc.

He's in negotiation for a new contract and letting them know where he stands without breaking balls.

Well done Davy. Keep it up.
Richard Styles
23 Posted 12/05/2012 at 03:50:10
David Moyes will do the same as he has done for the last 10 years: wait until Deadline Day to get loan players or even couple of Bosman players... sell one or more of our prized assets in order to please our so-called investors, and the bank that we have been paying £44 million to for the last 5 years!....

No transfer money from Bill because you people are sheep and buy your season tickets before the end of the season every year instead of waiting it out until we actually buy a few players then pay an extra £10-20 for your season tickets, which I would gladly do if we actually looked like we were planning ahead instead of taking what we can get at the very last minute...

Mark my words: this is Moyes's last year! Rumour has it Slaven Bilic is on his way here...
Roman Sidey
24 Posted 12/05/2012 at 04:49:08
This article I just read is about artists, but the first story can be well related to Moyes and Kenwright.

http://www.cracked.com/blog/4-artists-who-should-probably-just-take-break-while/?wa_user1=2&wa_user2=Movies+%26+TV&wa_user3=blog&wa_user4=feature_module
Ged Simpson
25 Posted 12/05/2012 at 06:50:04
"Rumour has it Slaven Bilic is on his way here..."

....and what is the source of these rumours?
Chris Morris
26 Posted 12/05/2012 at 07:10:03
There's more chance of Hibbert scoring a goal than there is of Everton having more than £5m to spend this Summer. That includes us selling Baines, Felli, Jags and Rodwell "to get funds".
Chris Morris
27 Posted 12/05/2012 at 07:12:31
If I was in charge of the team (and I'm not honestly, don't believe the rumours) I would probably be on the lookout for a new Goalkeeper.

Howard is good, one of the best in the league some would argue, but for me he does a lot of silly things. The worst one is punching the ball when he could catch it......oh and he's awful at punching the ball out!!
Jimmy Sørheim
28 Posted 12/05/2012 at 08:16:39
You have a good point Chris!

To predict Moyes in the transfer market is unrealistic, given what he did last summer I would say we stand in great danger of losing Fellaini or Baines, Fellaini before Baines since Baines is a local player.

Beyond that we already know Moyes likes to have defensive cover, so it is unlikely that Jagielka will be sold, unless Jags wants out.

Moyes has a very hard job this summer, if he sells to early then we will get below the market price for that player.

Normally each summer is a quiet one until the deadline lapses, only then will we be able to sell to buy.

That is how I see it, and given earlier transfer windows then I fear a repeat of this or earlier summers.
Mike Allison
29 Posted 12/05/2012 at 09:34:20
James Martin I really enjoyed your sarcy opening, but then it all went wrong.

You seem to think Fellaini would play up front for United. He's a holding midfielder, and one of the best around. The fact that we can shove him into the wrong position and he still affects the game in a positive way just shows his class. If United had Fellaini they'd be massively improved. It still amazes me how many people don't seem to notice all the times he just wins the ball and keeps it. Half our possession seems to come from him when he plays in front of the back four.

And as for "He's not going to go for Fellaini; no-one is, because outside of this website no-one rates him" ? By God, I hope you're right.
John Shaw
30 Posted 12/05/2012 at 09:47:47
Where has this notion come from that Moyes has a say in how and when he does his deals in the transfer market?

He doesn't, it is dictated by the incompetent Board we have in charge. Moyes can only move on players when the fools upstairs let him, which is invariably after the Sky money has arrived, which is August.

I think the only time I recall Moyes having funds early was the summer we signed A Johnson.

So don't hold your collective breaths chaps!!!!!!
Chris Morris
31 Posted 12/05/2012 at 10:10:17
It doesn't matter anyway because the top players will go to the top clubs and we'll be fighting to pick up what's left of the rest.
Wayne Smyth
32 Posted 12/05/2012 at 10:04:54
I can't believe some of you seriously think that Carrick would be a decent signing.

We paid £15M for Fellaini, developed him into probably one of the finest defensive central midfield players in Europe and people think we should be happy for a few quid and an over-the-hill Carrick? Wow.

Fellaini's on a long contract, if teams want him they can stump up £25M or more. Personally I'd guess Chelsea or City might be more interested than Utd.

As for who he should buy with the money, we have on our books a few players who can play a holding role. What we need most is some pace and trickery on the wings. I would say another forward, but we all know Moyes only plays with one 99% of the time, so it would be money wasted.

I'd personally like to see a bid for Adam Johnson, or similar types of players. There must be more Ben-Arfa's out there available for relatively little, but who need a fresh start.

I'd also like to see a real leader brought in, someone like Phil Neville, but younger and with enough footballing ability that the other players don't take the piss out of him.
Ian Bennett
33 Posted 12/05/2012 at 10:34:40
Carrick = poor man's Butch Wilkins.
James Martin
34 Posted 12/05/2012 at 10:28:20
Mike,

I have no doubt that Fellaini is good at winning the ball back, and with his size he should be. I don't agree that he never gives the ball away, though, because, in my opinion, he always takes the risk-free approach. He'll debate playing a forward pass for so long until someone's on top of him at which point he'll drop it off slowly to one of the full backs who can then do nothing with it but curl it down the line, giving the ball away. He may not have lost the ball directly but the slow pace and negative angles off his passes cause others to lose it.

Fortunately for Fellaini, Pienaar actually likes receiving the ball behind him and then cutting infield but other wide players like Gueye don't/can't. The one time Fellaini gave it to Gueye on the run, he crossed in for Jelavic versus Sunderland, but all too often it's the familiar sight of wide players having to check back to pick up balls that are barely rolling by the time they get to them.

We improve immeasurabely when Gibson plays; on paper, he doesn't have many attributes like height, skill or pace but he can pass. His balls are quick, forward and to feet, and he plays the riskier balls that get us moving forward; a few may go astray but in the main its more reward than risk.

That's why, when you get Rodwell and Fellaini together, it's like watching paint dry as both of them only ever face one way in the game... and, in attempts to look classy, end up playing lethargically; all our players filter back looking for the ball and the opposition gets on top of us, meaning an Osman or Pienaar has to take that ball with his back to goal, and beat two men just to get anywhere near the penalty area.
Ian Bennett
35 Posted 12/05/2012 at 10:41:39
James I don't disagree with some of that.

What I will say is that both the City (home) and United (away) game, both opposition teams would go nowhere near him.
Denis Richardson
36 Posted 12/05/2012 at 10:21:37
Moyes is saying all the right things and it's not exactly rocket science that we need to offload one of our better players every now and then to bring cash in and refresh the squad. Other teams have been looking to do that for years, as we also should have been. Our problem has been hanging onto players for far too long.

I am happy to take one or two players off United's hands as well (in the 20s, that is). Reserve players for United ARE currently good enough for Everton. Howard, Saha, Neville, Gibson have all been decent signings for us (we're just making the mistake of hanging onto some of them for too long).

I cannot criticise what Moyes is saying... but, until actions back up these statements, its just cheap talk. However, judging by what all the papers are saying, this looks like a set up for Baines to go to United ? although the rumoured £10M would only make sense if we got a couple of players going the other way. I seriously hope we don't accept just £10M for England's next long-term left-back!! (Never know what was agreed in the Gibson transfer).

To be honest, I would be happy to swap Baines for a pacey right winger, decent 2nd striker and replacement left back. Due to homesickness I think the only place he's going to go is Utd as a long-term replacement for Evra. (I don't think any big club will be interested in Fellaini.) Baines is good enough for the CL so I would let him step up a notch. He's given excellent service for the last 4 years.
Oliver Molloy
37 Posted 12/05/2012 at 11:00:12
It doesn't matter what Moyes or Kenwright say to any club that makes enquiries for the likes of Fellaini, Heitinga, Baines, Jagielka, Jelavic.... If a Champions League club come knocking and the player gets to hear about it (and they will), the ball will be in that player's court.

It's the players who have the power and if they want a move they will get it ? simple... and nothing can be done.

I would expect us to sell two of the above and a couple of fringe players also before the start of next season ? unless we suddenly get investment!!
Peter Barry
38 Posted 12/05/2012 at 11:08:03
For my "tuppenerth' we will sell TWO big names late in the day and bring in some dodgy OTH loaners at the start of the season and then play like shit until January. McRooney of course will be retained ? how could we do without him.
Chris Morris
39 Posted 12/05/2012 at 11:20:26
For what we need, I fear it'll be more than one top player going...
Jim Knightley
40 Posted 12/05/2012 at 11:10:39
Read this on the Guardian blog yesterday:

Sky has named the 16 players heading out of QPR in the summer. They are: Patrick Agyemang, Radek Cerny, Lee Cook, Kieron Dyer, Danny Gabbidon, Fitz Hall, Peter Ramage and Danny Shittu who are all out of contract. And Angelo Balanta, Matt Connolly, Troy Hewitt, Rob Hulse and Brian Murphy will be sold, while Jay Bothroyd, Clint Hill and Heidar Helguson...

They are essentially letting go almost as many senior players as we have in our squad... bizzare mismanagement by themselves of course, like a poor man's Manchester City, but disconcerting that a team who may be relegated have bigger wage/spending capacity than us.

Personally I think Fellaini has been world class over the past few months. But how many of you would have resisted £20M in the first few months of the season? For me, Fellaini can look like the best man on the pitch, whoever we play, and the worst. If we need to sell, and could get £25M, I would take it. It would make us weaker in his position, we would lose someone who is going to be potentially one of the most defensive midfielders around (he is not yet... that statement is too reactionary imo) but for his position, and for a player who has consistency issues (and £70k wages), it would be good business.

We could give £10M to the bank, spend £2-2.5M on Pienaar and then use £12.5M on the squad. Off-loading Yobo, McFadden, the loan wages of Denis and Drenthe, (Cahill?), Mucha and maybe one or two I've missed would give us some wage potential, and there will be a few good free transfers available this season.
Chris Morris
41 Posted 12/05/2012 at 11:31:20
Don't get rid of Denis Stracq. I seen him in Morrisons in Belle Vale yesterday and he tucks his ears into his cap. Anyone with that kind of fashion sense is worth having surely???
Brian Harrison
42 Posted 12/05/2012 at 15:37:53
I dont want anybody sold, as that means we sell our best players, and get in second rate players. Yes I know Moyes track record in picking up bargains is first class. but I think there is only so many times you can do this and be succesful.

Rather interesting to hear Moyes mention what Newcastle did, do you think he plans to sell off 5 of his best players as they did. Mind if we did use the Newcastle template then think of the advantages, if we could get around £50 million in transfer fees. We could wipe off the debt and buy Finch Farm, now the short term might look decidedly dodgy but if they could survive and stay in the Premiership. This would make us much more appealing for a takeover, and failing that we could then give Moyes money for the next 4/5 transfer windows.
Liam Reilly
43 Posted 12/05/2012 at 20:45:26
Brian
if we sold 5 of our best players, there's only one place we're going fast and that's the championship.

We'll lose maybe 2 of our better players in the summer and replace them with bargain basement footballers and to appease the supporters, we'll get Nuts back permanently.
Nigel Tufnell
44 Posted 13/05/2012 at 05:26:05
Maybe we could use a striker who can get 15+ goal a season.

I hear Blackburn will be selling theirs.....

David - we have a reunion gig next week, can you give Ian a call and see if SIr Denis Eaton-Hogg will be showing up - I was wondering with his connections if he can get me some Euro 2012 tickets.
Conn Prosser
45 Posted 13/05/2012 at 09:35:30
I'd be happy to see the back of Fellaini. He's not impressed enough for his wage ? I just don't think anyone would have him. The big worry is Pienaar, I just don't see Harry letting him go. They can sell Bale for £25m+ and not need to replace him if Pienaar goes back down south.

As for Baines, it would be a shame to see him go but it could be good business post-euros if he has a good tournament.

We could take Jason Roberts for fuck all...
Thomas Windsor
46 Posted 13/05/2012 at 10:02:09
If we have to sell Fellaini, Baines & Jagielka, so be it... but give the manager the money to spend or what's the point of us going?

And get it all done early; if Spurs want too much for Pienaar, don't buy him, look elsewhere.
Dave White
47 Posted 13/05/2012 at 10:12:05
I don't think we should underestimate how much it will cost to get Piennar back.

'Arry will be quite aware how desperate we are to re-sign him. The money that Spurs payed was hugely influenced by the fact he only had 6 months left on his contract. According to Wikipedia, he's on a 4.5-year deal with Spurs and I would imagine with the form he's shown since he's been back we won't see any change from £5m.

Unfortunately I can see our only big signing this summer being a player who's already here. I hope I'm wrong!
John Ford
48 Posted 13/05/2012 at 10:29:03
Agree Dave, and the flip side will be Baines Fellaini or Johnny disappearing.

How any manager is expected to produce a side capable of challenging for trophies when their best players are regularly recycled out of the club is beyond me....lets be honest.....it never actually happens.

We're all just breeding grounds for the money clubs. How depressing.
Jim Knightley
49 Posted 13/05/2012 at 10:49:12
Pienaar won't cost the earth... he is ageing and wants to leave. More important may be, potential rumours of outgoings aside, Spurs' need for money. They don't have the financial pull of previous seasons, and Harry has made it clear he wants Hazard, Vertonghen (they desperately need a cb), and they will have to buy a striker to replace the departing Ade. I think maybe we will appear desperate....but then maybe Harry will too. Hopefully they will sign up Hoilett (assuming we can't/don't of course) and then a Pienaar deal will be far more viable.
James Morgan
50 Posted 13/05/2012 at 10:40:54
As much as I'd hate to see Baines go I think if we could find an ample replacement and get in a pacy right winger who can cross and hit a dead ball like him then we wouldn't miss him quite as much.
Bottom line is we will have to sell somebody and if we get over £20m for Baines from United, I wouldn't blame him for going.
Mick Gallagher
51 Posted 14/05/2012 at 12:20:45
Think it might be Baines to one of the mancs hopefully for about 25m
Daniel A Johnson
52 Posted 14/05/2012 at 12:13:45
Players to sell are Baines, Jagielka and Rodwell.

We need to Keep Fellaini at all costs and keep our spine of Howrad-heitinga-Fellaini-Jelavic and build around that.

As always the foundations are there.

.....................over to you Billy Bullshit in your London fantasy land.

We need money.
Daniel A Johnson
53 Posted 14/05/2012 at 12:25:16
Actually wtaching the Man City all-stars nearly bottle it yesterday, made me realise how far away we are.

I'm in my 30s and will say with confidence that I will NEVER see Everton win the premier league.

Were a selling to survive club, we are just incapable of challenging for anything and as the years go by we just fall further and furher away.

Pass me the fucking prozac
Kieran Fitzgerald
54 Posted 14/05/2012 at 14:01:36
I think that we might have the answer is selling big and buying small. Moyes has shown in January that he has gotten some of his mojo back with purchases. I think that he will know this summer that he will have a limited budget again and that he will need to squeeze at least two players out of what money he is given. I think that he is also in a good position that thee are a couple of players we could get decent money for, plus a couple of fringe players so he can afford to be a bit choosy with who he lets go. The only thing is though, it wil depend on how much of a push the bank puts on us.
Ian Bennett
55 Posted 15/05/2012 at 19:24:12
Here's an interesting for one that has been thrown on the boards over the last couple of years.

The Villarreal model for Everton to follow. They have just been relegated this season. Pretty surprising.


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads