Cabaye apologises for Cahill flare-up

, 14 May, 79comments  |  Jump to most recent
Yohan Cabaye has issued an apology for his role in the altercation that saw Tim Cahill sent off at the final whistle of Everton's 3-1 win over Newcastle.

The Australian received a red card from referee Andre Marriner for grabbing the Frenchman by the neck, apparently in response to something Cayabe said.

Cabaye said that he was sorry for the exchange with Cahill:

"I would like to apologise for the cross words I exchanged with Tim Cahill which resulted in his red card and my booking on the final whistle.

"It was unnecessary and, regrettably, the result of frustration and disappointment, all in the heat of the moment. It is out of character and for that I am sorry."

Cabaye was also involved in an incident with a Goodison ballboy in the first half which may or may not have something to do with Cahill's reaction. The Frenchman apologised to the ballboy too at half-time.

Quotes or other material sourced from Sky Sports



Reader Comments (79)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Keith Glazzard
1 Posted 14/05/2012 at 01:13:16
This may or may not have been a correct decision by the referee. I didn't see enough to judge. But from what I saw of his handling of the rest of the game, he was probably 7/10 wrong.
Craig Harrison
2 Posted 14/05/2012 at 01:22:54
Interesting that Cabaye has immediatly come out and appologised for what he said.... sounds like Cabaye realises he might be in a bit of trouble if this comes out.
Robin Hunuki
3 Posted 14/05/2012 at 01:38:50
Don't know what the ref was thinking... altercation happened 2 hours after the final whistle and his produces a red card.

Yes, it may have been wrong to do what he supposedly did but we've all made mistakes in the heat of frustration. The fact that Cabaye apologised after the game is commendable.

With 'old mate' Suarez, he'd be rolling around as if he broke a leg way before Cahill had put a hand on him, lol.
Chris Cook
4 Posted 14/05/2012 at 01:56:22
Dunno if I'm missing something but how did it happen 2 hours after the final whistle? He was sent off at the end of the match.
Bryan Wendell
5 Posted 14/05/2012 at 02:02:05
I agree with Craig (800). Must have been really bad and/or had pressure from management.

Not sure how this works, but can red cards in the last game harm a player next season?
Eric Myles
6 Posted 14/05/2012 at 02:09:34
Who was that idiot commentator on the game that was stirring up trouble saying Cahill "tried to put the nut on someone"?

Cabaye had him by the back of the neck and Cahill ducked to get out of his grip.

If Cahill really had tried to nut him I'm sure Cabaye would still be in hospital.
Chris Cook
7 Posted 14/05/2012 at 02:36:32
Probably the same guy who started the Cahill to Cabaye altercation rumour as him saying "You like beating up 11-year-olds, meet me outside the ground and see what you can do."

Though I would probably pay to see that...
Robin Hunuki
8 Posted 14/05/2012 at 02:42:27
You stitching me up Chris?

Surely you didn't take that seriously, understandably slight bias / exaggeration on my behalf... it seemed like ages after the final whistle when the ref decided to get a bit more camera time and give the red lol!

Apparently Cabaye had knocked over a ball boy where Cahill had confronted him... Will have to see if Timmy will explain his actions or leave it on the field.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8_5eEJyoH6g
Kieran Kinsella
9 Posted 14/05/2012 at 04:50:23
The commentator was ex-Spurs Gary Stevens. He isn't the sharpest knife in the drawer.
Peter Thistle
10 Posted 14/05/2012 at 05:40:27
Nah it was Gary Birtles, if you were watching Sky Sports. He's always a twat btw.

I think Cahill was infuriated by the ball boy situation and carried it onto the pitch. Semi stupid and kinda ruined the vibe at the end of the game but to be fair, fuck Cabaye and good on ya Tim for standing up to a tosser.
Andrew Fair
11 Posted 14/05/2012 at 07:38:17
Cahill is a legend and fair play for getting Cabaye back. Good thing is he will be suspended for start of season so won't be playing behind Jelavic. Leaving Fellaini to be support player! Which hopefully will carry our good end to the season into a good start.

Cahill is now a bench player for us, not good enough for our starting 11.
Michael Brien
12 Posted 14/05/2012 at 07:36:49
I thought Carroll's actions at Swansea were worse - I was waiting of for Alan Hansen to comment " he was lucky you can't raise your hands to an opponent" ....funny though he didn't say anything about that!! Nor did he comment about his remarks when he claimed man City were out of the title race a few weeks ago!!!
Adam Baig
13 Posted 14/05/2012 at 09:09:36
I think yesterday highlighted the need for retrospective cards/bans etc. The inconsistency of refereeing will only be eradicated when this happens.

Carroll did exactly the same as Cahill, but saw yellow not red. Tevez landed the first blow on Barton (we dodged a bullet not buying that prick, by the way) and nobody says anything.

Until players stop getting away with things because of 'common sense' refereeing, the more media friendly teams will keep getting away with things
Mick Wrende
14 Posted 14/05/2012 at 12:14:18
Cahill deserved to go off - what an idiot after the final whistle. You cant get someone round the neck and expect to go unpunished.
Chris Davies
15 Posted 14/05/2012 at 12:26:54
Praying the ban carries over because we might actually win our 1st three games if that's the case.
Shaun Sparke
16 Posted 14/05/2012 at 12:37:50
Chris whether that is true or not is a mute point. Your comment is disrespectful to a player who has represented Everton with pride and courage throughout his tenure at the club. We all know that the writing is on the wall for Cahill, but the man never gives less than 100% effort. A true blue and a fine ambassador for this club, lets not forget that.
Mike Hargreaves
17 Posted 14/05/2012 at 12:46:14
My thoughts exactly Chris
Shaun Sparke
18 Posted 14/05/2012 at 12:57:10
Incredulous comments on here sometimes
Paul David
19 Posted 14/05/2012 at 12:56:06
The man has been awfull for 18 months.How long does it take for a player to be shite before it affects his reputation in some fans eyes.

Pick any fan out the crowd and they will give 100% as well,for £50k a week I expect a bit more than that.
Trevor Lynes
20 Posted 14/05/2012 at 13:22:44
Lets face it boys... it almost spoiled the lap of appreciation for the players at the end of the game! Moysie should have hooked Cahill and told him to shut up! If Cahill had been playing for Newcastle, we would have slated him!
Cabaye apologised to the ballboy at half-time so it could not have been about that. God knows what goes on inside footballers' heads sometimes... I repeat, Cahill's outburst almost spoiled the celebrations at the end of the game and in that light, HE should make an apology to the fans!
Robin Hunuki
21 Posted 14/05/2012 at 13:13:16
Are the above comments serious... I believe Cahill deserves every recognition he gets.

Paul, yeah you could put a fan who would put in 200% effort (put me in there, maybe even yourself!), yet we'd get done over again and again and again; sorry mate, no weight behind that comment.

Chris you're a gee up son! So you're saying that we start poorly because Cahills in the first 11, what about the other 10 on the field, what about the cohesion between the D, midfield and strikers? What about the hoofing every time we get the ball, what about the poor display by the midfield against QPR... one of your best mate.
Paul David
22 Posted 14/05/2012 at 13:31:04
Robin

Yes me and you would get done over and over again but thats my point,so has Cahill all season.Yes we all want hard working players but not hard working players with no ability.
Tony J Williams
23 Posted 14/05/2012 at 13:36:28
"but not hard working players with no ability" - Feck me!

"it almost spoiled the lap of appreciation for the players at the end of the game" - No it didn't, it was forgotten about when they started going around.

A passionate footballer with fight, yes please.
Paul David
24 Posted 14/05/2012 at 13:42:12
I'd rather have a passionate footballer with fight and ability. Other than being a good header of the ball, can someone tell me what other footballing abilities Cahill has?
Shaun Sparke
25 Posted 14/05/2012 at 13:38:35
Yeah, I have changed my mind, why don't we boo him the next time he plays. It happened to Peter Reid so Cahill shouldn't expect anything better from such loyal supporters!

Cahill's form does not warrant a starting berth, I don't think you will find a single supporter arguing against that point, but the man deserves more respect than he has been given on here. Moyes will probably use him less and less next season, but I wouldn't blame the bloke for wanting to leave before the booboys turn on him.

Forget your goals against Liverpool Tim, forget your overhead kick against Chelsea, forget the times when you were the only player who seemed to care, forget the amount of times you have stated your passion and love for this club. You're getting older and because of that you are shit!

As I said earlier, there are some incredulous comments on here.
Ray Roche
26 Posted 14/05/2012 at 13:53:26
Paul David



"I'd rather have a passonate footballer with fight and ability"
Which is something that Cahill has had in spades since he became one of the best signings we've had for years. OK, so his form has dipped considerably since his best days but he still gets picked and still does his best. He doesn't pick himself. Why not level your vitriol against the man who picks him? What would you do if YOU were Cahill? Say "Sorry Boss, can't be arsed playing today, find someone else. I'll sit in the stands and trouser my £35k a week and listen to my i pod".

"Pick any fan out the crowd and they will give 100% as well"
And they'd take "shite" to another level.
It's pretty obvious that you don't like Cahill going from your previous efforts on other threads. Are you the sort of supporter who slagged off Ball, Reid, Young etc when their star began to fade?
Paul David
27 Posted 14/05/2012 at 13:51:59
Shaun, I am not saying he should be booed or we should forget what he has done, just that if he is shit then people have the right to say so and not have other people say they're wrong for doing so.

If it was a one-off poor performance in an otherwise excellent season, I could understand you finding it incredulous but poor performances is the norm now from Cahill.

History should be taken into account but players should be mainly judged on form.
Mick Gallagher
28 Posted 14/05/2012 at 13:53:17
Shaun 900

100% right mate but that never stops the booboys.
Shaun Sparke
29 Posted 14/05/2012 at 14:01:44
Paul, I am not saying you're wrong in voicing your opinion. What I am saying is that there are some disrespectful posts on here directed towards a player who has always given 100% everytime he plays.
Paul David
30 Posted 14/05/2012 at 14:01:35
Ray, you're right, I don't like Cahill and it is Moyes's fault for picking him but I stick by what I said: Cahill has no other footballing ability than being good in the air and now the goals have dried up he is being exposed for what he really is, a player with limited talent but a big heart.

I am too young to have seen them players, Ray.
Paul David
31 Posted 14/05/2012 at 14:08:07
Shaun would you rather people expressed their dis-pleasure of a player on here or at the match.This is the whole point of the site.If a player is poor he is poor whether he has given 100% or not,the fact he is still getting stick despite being a fans favourite and always giving his all shows how poor he really has been.
Ray Roche
32 Posted 14/05/2012 at 14:09:42
That's right, Paul, rub it in. I've just had a golfing weekend where my playing partners were not slow in pointing out my rapidly approaching pension and fading memory...which was why I agreed to go without checking the fixture list first and consequently missed Saturdays match.

There are some players in our squad who are paid great money and have yet to do much for the club, like Anichebe, and you could argue that he is one who might be seen as a target for terrace abuse, but Cahill has been a terrific player for us, and not just because he's a good header of the ball. Just ask any opposition fans who they feared most and the answer was invariably Cahill.
Paul David
33 Posted 14/05/2012 at 14:17:39
Ray dont get me started on Anichebe.

Me and you have had this before about Cahill and the reason other teams fans fear Cahill is the same as why Evertionians think he has scored more than he has.Over the years we've been a low scoring side and we won most of our games 1 nil and it was usually Cahill who scored so everyones overriding memory of Cahill is of him constantly scoring winners even though he averages 7 league goals a year.Not a bad record but its hardly Frank Lampard is it.
Jay Harris
34 Posted 14/05/2012 at 14:16:36
Let's be honest about this.

Tim Cahill is a very honest pro and respected by so many of his fellow professionals for his sportsmanship and never "trying" to get another player sent off.

Cabaye must have said something pretty inflammatory to kick him off like that.

Noone can question Tim Cahill's allegiance or commitment to the club and while that doesnt make him a great player you can be sure he has put a shift in whenever he has played.

He has contributed some of the most important goals (particularly in our 1-) period) and is still a great "defensive" header of the ball.

Tim is in the Duncan Ferguson mould for me and should be treated with respect not damnation.
Mark Murphy
35 Posted 14/05/2012 at 14:23:34
Ray,
you should have checked the fixture list again when you got home from golf - the match was on sunday!
You could have made it after all!



Was Peter Reid really booed? Shameful!
Mark Stone
36 Posted 14/05/2012 at 14:18:49
I actually think Tim has done alright since Saha left. He's not a flair player, clearly, but still does a job. He's got great movement off the ball and seems to have a good understanding with Jelavic, who is reaping the rewards.
Ernie Baywood
37 Posted 14/05/2012 at 14:31:38
Someone might be able to support what I saw. Cahill lunged a bit in the last few minutes and the barcode threw himself to the ground and rolled around for no reason.

I saw it that Cahill took exception to someone trying to get him sent off with the game all but finished and at walking pace by then.

Cahill then had a little altercation with Cabaye (was it him that dived? I couldn't make it out) and pretty clearly was incensed and, to me, it looked like he was offering him out after the game.

Whistle blows and surprise surprise Cahillplatings near Cabaye and gets him by the throat.

While he was getting dragged away he was still pointing off the pitch and indicating he wanted him off the ground.

Sunday league stuff but haven't seen Cahill like that before. Wasn't the usual football handbags, he was ready to go!

Would love to know the full story but suspect Cahill will keep his mouth shut.
Robin Hunuki
38 Posted 14/05/2012 at 14:30:34
Shaun 900 / Ray 903, spot on the money, couldn't have said it any better myself.

Paul, yes he may not be the man in form and unfortunately looks as if he's on the inevitable decline but surely you'd have the respect to gee him on and admire his push as opposed to saying mate, even though you've picked up a knock, even though youve ran your heart out and upset a couple defenders during this shift - get off, you can only run and have limited skills, you've had your time...

As Ray rightly put it, he's not going to go to Moyes, "mate, have you seen my form lately... Can't hit one in to save me life! What do you reckon I put my feet up this round... Oh look there's another 5k for todays shift".

Stunned with the comments here re: Cahill. I'd back a workhorse that understands the club, it's history and its fans - not a gee up of a player that has all the skills in the world yet has no interest in this grand old club (hate to reference him but Drenthe).
Eugene Ruane
39 Posted 14/05/2012 at 14:30:46
Robin (mate, son, pal, dude, etc).

I take it (like David Cameron), you're using 'lol' as an acronym for 'lots of love'.

Admittedly (in your posts), this wouldn't make much sense, but would definitely make more sense than if 'laugh out loud' is what was meant.

Example: "it seemed like ages after the final whistle when the ref decided to get a bit more camera time and give the red lol!"

Er...Eh?

SACS!!












(snarls at computer screen).
Paul David
40 Posted 14/05/2012 at 14:56:51
Robin you would pick the team out of sentiment?

Yes I would drop a player if his only contribution is to run around all day and no effect on the game.
Ray Roche
41 Posted 14/05/2012 at 15:03:48
Paul, The fact that a 1-0 win is down to Cahill's goals only underlines the importance of his contribution.

Mark.
I was away Saturday and Sunday near Blackpool, finishing our round just in time for the second half of the City and Utd matches which we watched in a very boisterous club house.!
Paul David
42 Posted 14/05/2012 at 15:09:16
Ray I agree with you he was important to us but he is now a liability and has been for some time.I would suggest you take time to check out his goals a season youself and you will see its not as impressive as you would imagine.
Tony J Williams
43 Posted 14/05/2012 at 15:26:37
"but he is now a liability and has been for some time" - How so? How many goals has he given away?

I would rather have him in centre mid than Neville, rather have him behind Jelavic than Vic.

He is a good footballer and his passing is neat and crisp and sometimes his first time passes are impressive, I remember particularly the 40 yard hooked first time pass to Rodwell on the right wing this season.

A lot of posters want to call him limited because he doesn't dribble passed players, he doesn't need to, he lets the ball do the work for him.
Paul David
44 Posted 14/05/2012 at 15:37:00
Tony

He cost us a goal against Stoke but that not my argument because its almost impossible to give the ball away if you never do anything more adventurous than a 10 yard sideways pass.I really do disagree with you about his passing,theres nothing crisp about it,its basic and predictable.

I'm with you on playing him in midfield ahead of Neville or in the hole ahead of Anichebe but thats not saying much.
Ciarán McGlone
45 Posted 14/05/2012 at 15:21:12
"respect"???

...he's not old father time, a sage provider of wisdom.

If he's shit we're entitled to say it. The kind of sanctimonious 'faux incredulity' that the 'respect crew' exhibit whenever someone points out that he's shit...is quite frankly toe curling.

He's not your Da. Get over it...
Dave Wilson
46 Posted 14/05/2012 at 15:27:57
Yes he`s always given everything and scored some goals against the top boys.

But he`s always been extremely limited, he`s choked in his three wembley appearances and he`s on nearer 70k a week than the 35k claimed here.

Cahill was/is a favourite ( I cringe when people call him legend) but when he left us struggling in the bottom half in the middle of an injury crisis to go and play for Australia in a tournament eighteen months ago, two things happened.

A) He showed us where is loyalties really lie (which would be fine if he wasnt picking up 70k a week when he came back injured)

B) We found out that we were actually a better team without him.

Lets not pretend his form has suffered a mini dip. He has been garbage for the best part of two seasons.

Ray Roche is right, its not his fault. He is simply answering the call from a manager who refuses to believe/see he is on the wane, but lets not make some sort of Martyr out of him, or put him above criticism, as long as he takes the 70k people are entitled and will, criticise his performances.

Steve Hopkins
47 Posted 14/05/2012 at 16:15:10
This incident has at least cleared up what Big Dunc's role at the club is.......he must be providing classes on conflict resolution.
Mark Riding
48 Posted 14/05/2012 at 17:50:34
Ray Roche
49 Posted 14/05/2012 at 18:00:16
Dave Wilson.

I'd be astonished if Cahills on £70k a week.
And Cahill, like Ferguson, is not quite in the "Legend" category. Although they may be to some who haven't witnessed truly great players from sucessfull eras.
Ray Roche
50 Posted 14/05/2012 at 18:22:29
"successful" before the spelling/grammar police descend.
Jason Heng
51 Posted 14/05/2012 at 18:44:45
How did Suarez get away unpunished with a rugby tackle on Heitinga during a match in Wembley?
Shaun Sparke
52 Posted 14/05/2012 at 18:38:44
Ciarán (wtf) 953 'faux incredulity! If the cap fits.
Why does everybody have to belong to a crew if they hold a different opinion to you? Moyes out crew, respect crew, etc..If an individual has the same opinion as another individual does that automatically make them a crew member or is there a given mythical number that constitutes a crew?
Ciarán McGlone
53 Posted 14/05/2012 at 19:20:16
I think that's the first time I've used the word 'crew' as a description of a collective.

Dave Wilson
54 Posted 14/05/2012 at 19:39:30
Ray Roche

I can't find anything concrete on Cahill's wages, but I seem to remember Pienaar was reputedly offered £60k pw and his agent said he wasn't signing because he wanted parity with Arteta and Cahill.

Cant find any links just now... but I would bet an awful lot of my own wages that my estimation of £70k is an awful lot closer than the £35k you claim he earns.

Eugene Ruane
55 Posted 14/05/2012 at 20:05:53
I'm worried Ciaran.

It starts with 'crew', next thing it's..

"Cahill though blood, I mean he's WELL past it innit man, you know wha' am sayin' though - totally Mexico".
Shaun Sparke
56 Posted 14/05/2012 at 20:52:38
Eugene, you continue to make me smile on here. I am not sure why though as I think you are a few bricks short of a wall. That makes two of us then, does that make us a crew?

Except my apology Ciarán, I wasn't really having a go at you. You are normally one of the more rational posters on here.
Sean McCarthy
57 Posted 14/05/2012 at 21:21:54
Having read the above comments, I feel I have to ask how many TW contributors actually go the match and don't just jump on each and every passing bandwagon??? The latest appears to be that Tim Cahill is past it so let's slag him off at every opportunity. Previous to that weve had the Tony Hibbert/Phil Neville/Leon Osman threads all saying pretty much the same thing or the other type who go all gooey eyed at the thought of Seamus Coleman playing RB (even tho he clearly cant defend!!)

Yes, Cahill has not played to the levels he reached in seasons gone by but is he finished? I don't think so and those of you who do go the game should at least recognise that. Even the RS will tell you that Steven Gerrard isn't the player he was 2 seasons ago... are they filling their forums calling for him to be dropped or blaming him for their shit season??? I doubt it.

My view is that Cahill had a much improved 2nd half to the season once Jelavic arrived pretty much like most of the team. Does he warrant a 1st IX place next season?? Maybe not. Does he warrant some of the abuse he recieves on this site?? Definitely not.
Drew O'Neall
58 Posted 14/05/2012 at 21:39:50
He might not get into the 1st IX but could end up behind the striker or on the left wing!
Paul David
59 Posted 14/05/2012 at 22:26:35
Sean I go the game and see Cahill offering nothing every week.Unlike others I dont think its down to age either,he does just as much running now as he always has so its not his legs.I dont see much difference in Cahill's performances now than to 4 years a go,he has stopped scoring thats whats different.
Roman Sidey
60 Posted 14/05/2012 at 22:33:01
Have to agree with Dave Wilson here.

Everyone is making the right points, but mis- reading what others are saying. Cahill's loyal, and has been good for us in the past, but really hasn't been valuable to the team since about 2008.

The positive that this red brings is that now Moyes is short one of his favourites and, let's be honest here, a sure starter for the first few games next season.

Down here in Australia, the general sport watching public is very superficial when it comes to football. Some people still think Cahill would be top value if we sold him. Perhaps the A-League is where he needs to be soon, where form doesn't dictate reputation.
Ray Roche
61 Posted 14/05/2012 at 22:57:30
Dave Wilson
Dave, I would be surprised if anyone on here has an accurate insight into a plyers wages, we only have what we read in the newspapers. My £35k comment may well be as wide of the mark as your £70k.
Whatever it is, Sean McCarthy is right with his comment that Cahill, despite his dip in form, does not deserve some of the abuse he gets on here.

Roman.
2008? Do me a favour.
Paul David
62 Posted 14/05/2012 at 23:08:46
Ray come on,18 months is not a dip in form.
Mike Green
63 Posted 14/05/2012 at 23:07:02
Shaun - for the uninitiated - two's company, three's a crowd. So four must be a crew. Yes, four's a crew. Definitely.
Ciarán McGlone
64 Posted 14/05/2012 at 23:17:47
Ray,

What abuse?
Ray Roche
65 Posted 14/05/2012 at 23:24:58
Paul, he has been playing better since we had a striker in Jelavic. So, for the last few months I would say his form has actually improved. Anyway, I'm off to my pit now, goodnight all.
Paul David
66 Posted 14/05/2012 at 23:28:13
He has been better but still not good enough.
Shaun Sparke
67 Posted 14/05/2012 at 23:44:05
Thanks Mike, but I always thought that four people made up a gang! If you don't agree with me then my gang will take on your crew anyday. Or to put it in Cahill parlance, "you and me outside the Winslow later and dont bring your crew with you".
Robin Hunuki
68 Posted 14/05/2012 at 23:18:07
Eugene (oldmate, legend, elder!),

I feel honoured, you commenting on a post of mine. I assume / hope it wouldn't be the last.

Are you referencing your PM re: using lol to express his love for the lady at some new firm? If so, then I actually did/still "laugh out loud"; poor bloke.

How does "lots of love" make any sense? My comment was more in humor therefore (what I believed) needed an LOL. Please explain? (as Pauline Hanson would say).

Didn't think you'd comment on my youth / colloquialism (if you can say that) using acronyms to express my thoughts. Is that not permitted on the infamous TW?

Paul, that's the thing mate I don't pick the team so I can't comment. If I did, (like in football manager 2012) I would try and work with him, off the bench, work him back into CM and have someone like Ossie sit in the pocket... Again id approach it differently however just to reiterate I am not DM..

Sean 052,

Mate if I were in England I would 100% try and attend the matches however because I'm in Sydney I do the next best thing and watch every game I can live (if Fox show it). I have the option to IQ it, yet I still stay up till 1-2am, with my Everton jersey and Facebook ready to comment on their performance / give it to my mates who support the otherside.
Derek Thomas
69 Posted 15/05/2012 at 01:08:28
So how many is a Posse then and is a Cabal more or less than a Posse. How many before a Cult becomes a Minority.
Sean McCarthy
70 Posted 15/05/2012 at 01:15:32
Robin, even I don't expect those living in places like Sydney to be at the old ground every other week!! However, my gripe is that a lot of bandwagon jumpers have probably never set foot inside the place!!!

It seems if someone shouts loud enough or repeats the same point over and over again, soon enough the usual suspects will tag along for the ride. Cahill is still worth a place in the first team SQUAD and no number of bandwagon jumpers will tell me otherwise.
So... Coleman for RB?? Discuss!!
David Ellis
71 Posted 15/05/2012 at 03:18:16
The number of people in a crew depends on the size of the boat.
Ken Morgan
72 Posted 15/05/2012 at 03:19:59
Tim seems like a nice enough chap to me.
Roman Sidey
73 Posted 15/05/2012 at 06:09:50
Ray, until Cahill started playing decent football since Jelavic came in, it was December 2008 since he's had a decent run of goals. A few at the start of 2010 aside, he's been in low single figures for a long time.

Moyes said a few seasons ago (thinking 05-06 perhaps) that Cahill's goals were a big part of his selection, and if they dried up, he would look at not selecting him. Well, they dried up, and he still got selected.

Sean McCarthy, you didn't mention me personally, but what bandwagon is there to jump on? We've fuck SFA, and play dreadful football.
Eugene Ruane
74 Posted 15/05/2012 at 06:57:04
Robin (086). You say..

"My comment was more in humor therefore (what I believed) needed an LOL. Please explain?".

I will try.

Since the written word was first..erm..written, there have been many writers with the ability to make us 'laugh out loud'.

And of course many lacking the gift.

However they all had one thing in common.

They all understood that as humour is subjective and laughter an involuntary action, no instruction as to how one should react to their work was/is necessary.

"Ah!" you might say "It's NOT an instruction, it is letting you know what MY reaction was".

This for me is worse.

Rather like someone elbowing you in the ribs and saying "Come on laugh you miserable get".

As I say, subjectivity is the key.

I mean imagine if Thatcher died and someone posted "Margaret Thatcher passed away - CLF" (cried like fuck).

Many (like me) would NOT cry.

Come to think of it, if there's one time lol WOULD be acceptable...






Paul David
75 Posted 15/05/2012 at 10:37:46
Robin

Well if its football manager your talking about dont even bother teaching an old dog new tricks.Just do what I do,sell Tim Cahill as soon as possible and replace him with Sigurdsson.A much younger,far more talented player on half the wages who will also consistently outperform Cahill.

By the way this would work in real life as well.
Robin Hunuki
76 Posted 15/05/2012 at 12:16:20
Eugene,

I didn't realize I'd get an English lesson from you. Sorry if I'd upset you (absolutely nothing to do with the OP) let's get back to it yea?

David,

Would be but he's popping goals and we're sitting a comfortable 4th (in front of Liverpool!) in Football Manager and I smash anyone on FIFA 12 with the Toffees?!? Would be strange to transfer aye?

Ultimately to top off this post I do not see why Cahill should have to defend himself on an Everton website.

Some say he may have overreacted during Sundays game however how many times have we seen him go off like that?

Is he a repeat offender like Barton? Is he a bad sportsman? Does he get yellows / reds once every month? Yet he gets a bashing on an "Everton fan base website" from a minority of supporters! Surely something must have been said to have upset him and go off like that?!?!

At the end of the day if Cahill is on the pitch (if he started or off the bench) I'd cheer him and the other 10 players in blue on!
Paul David
77 Posted 15/05/2012 at 12:46:19
Robin

I think most people are slating Cahill over his performances not the sending off.I have not mentioned it because i'm happy he got sent off,its 3 games were he can not be selected,a plus in my book.

You say a minorty of fans but I think nearly everyone is in agreement that Cahill has been poor this season and should not be starting as many games.The only argument is peoples opinion about Cahill's treatment by fans on here and whether its warranted or not.
Paul David
78 Posted 15/05/2012 at 12:56:24
By the way Robin try out Sigurdsson he will be winning you the league after a couple of years.
John Daley
79 Posted 15/05/2012 at 13:10:13
Since when does criticising a players performances and questioning their contribution to the team constitute 'abuse'?

"Yes, Cahill has not played to the levels he reached in seasons gone by but is he finished? I don't think so and those of you who do go the game should at least recognise that"

Why should we recognise that when the only evidence that counts (i.e. actual performances on the pitch) points to the contrary? It's not just the fact that Cahill has gradually become less and less effective over the years that leads people to hope he is no longer selected as often. It's also due to the fact that for the last seven years the whole system Moyes plays has been built around getting the best out of Cahill. His diminishing, flatlining, goal return no longer warrants this being the case. When Cahill starts, our play is much more predictable. It's basically spread it out wide, wait for Tim to get forward and whip it in the box. Rinse and repeat. Fellaini is no attacking midfielder/ deep lying forward but he's looked much more of a handful than Cahill in that position and our attacking play has displayed much more fluidity with him, Pienaar and Jelavic in tandem.

I never thought I'd say it but I agree with every word of Dave Wilson's post #954. If Cahill is as committed to the Everton cause as he seems he should really consider calling time on his international career. For a player who has apparantly suffered with repeated niggling injuries over the years, flying halfway round the world to play in meaningless friendlies can't be doing him any good at all and will only serve to hasten his demise as a Premier League player.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads