Cahill red card appeal turned down

, 15 May, 47comments  |  Jump to most recent
Everton's appeal against Tim Cahill's sending off at the end of the Newcastle game has been rejected by the Football Association.

The decision is not a surprising one — the Australian grabbed Yohan Cabaye around the throat at the final whistle of the Blues' 3-1 win and whatever compelled him to do it, the authorities couldn't be seen to be condoning such conduct.

The decision means that Cahill will be suspended for the first three matches of next season.

The 31 year-old issued a statement through his management company accepting the suspension but explained that he was disgusted by comments made by Cabaye.

"My reaction at the end of the game was out of character but I was disgusted at comments made to me by Cabaye.

"I don't wish to elaborate on the exact detail of what was said - but his words have no place either on or off the football pitch.

"Cabaye has apologised via his club's website and as far as I am concerned the matter is now closed."

Quotes or other material sourced from Evertonfc.com



Reader Comments (47)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Nick Millington
1 Posted 15/05/2012 at 15:59:16
Not surprising, Cahill deserved to go. However, referee Marriner seemed to encourage Cabaye to roam around all afternoon picking fights with whoever he liked. This is the same referee who tried to screw us over in the cup against Sunderland. To me, that puts him in the same club as Riley, Webb, Clattenburg, Atkinson. Moyes should send off a dossier to the FA with video proof that all these referees are nowhere near fit to referee Everton games.
Ben Howard
2 Posted 15/05/2012 at 16:52:45
Of course it was rejected. I can't for the life of me understand why they appealed. It should have been dealt with internally and brushed under the carpet, not given extra attention by the media due to the appeal. I love Cahill as a player and a ambassador of our club but he was silly here and I'm sure he knows it.
Eugene Ruane
3 Posted 15/05/2012 at 16:55:33
On a slightly different tack, anyone want to see a pissed Steve Kean calling Big Sam a crook?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-ndBfPWZ0Eo&feature=related
Paul David
4 Posted 15/05/2012 at 17:13:36
Eugene how do you find this shit?

So that is the now world famous "dignity" in action.
Eugene Ruane
5 Posted 15/05/2012 at 17:20:50
Paul - It's all over the (sports) news, Allardyce is taking legal action against Kean and (apparently) Blackburn.
Ben Howard
6 Posted 15/05/2012 at 17:22:18
Oh dear. I feel really sorry for him though. He's drunk and is taking the time to talk with some fans and the bastards tape him and put it on YouTube. Funny though.
Jeff Beaumont
7 Posted 15/05/2012 at 17:13:26
Can't understand the Club condoning his action by appealing ? lucky not to have the ban increased for wasting the FA's time.

Still waiting for him to publicly apologise to the fans & the Club for his behaviour.
Paul David
8 Posted 15/05/2012 at 17:22:57
How have I not heard it before?

The phone was nearly in his face at the beginning so how did he not notice?
David O'Keefe
9 Posted 15/05/2012 at 17:24:19
He wanted to be filmed and it's blown up in his face. No sympathy for him.
Keith Glazzard
10 Posted 15/05/2012 at 17:29:03
Nick ? totally agree about Marriner on Sunday. I expect nothing from prem refs and usually get less, but his display was as close to as bad as it gets.

Newky were a niggly, deliberately fouling side ? only to be expected I suppose, and it possibly explains some of their successes this season given that we have shite refs.
Jeremy Benson
11 Posted 15/05/2012 at 17:36:14
I'm not sure he "wanted" or "allowed" it.

He was pissed wasn't he? Or are you all going to tell me that when rat-faced you're completely and utterly in control of everything!
Paul David
12 Posted 15/05/2012 at 17:37:43
Jeremy we all do stupid things when drunk but he's not falling down drunk is he and every Scot I've ever drank with might as well talk a different language after about 5 pints yet I can clearly understand Keen so I dont think he's that bad.
Jamie Barlow
13 Posted 15/05/2012 at 17:40:21
Why is he taking legal action against Blackburn?

Who said he wanted to be filmed?
Eugene Ruane
14 Posted 15/05/2012 at 17:49:54
Thinks.

Take mobile to Bill's fave bar, buy him champagne all night.

Bladdered BK: "Hic....Moyes is a shit-house right....I fuggin bark and he...HIC!....fuggin jumps...MORE CHAMPAGNE!...I says to 'im, 'hey bollocks, you're signed for five years, you're goin' fuggin NO-HIC! WHERE..yer gingerfugguntwasssnyttwatfu....." - slump

Youtube, result!
Dennis Stevens
15 Posted 15/05/2012 at 18:00:12
What a bunch of tossers - hope they don't come back up.
David O'Keefe
16 Posted 15/05/2012 at 17:57:28
He was secretly filmed....doubt it. Judging by the camera angle he must have know that he was being filmed.
John Ford
17 Posted 15/05/2012 at 18:05:03
I can't see anyone knowingly doing this. It was naive of Kean, but you have to have sympathy with the bloke. It's shitty that the fans would do such a thing.
John Daley
18 Posted 15/05/2012 at 18:19:18
Why's it disgraceful of the fans to film him? They want him gone and have done for a long time. The guy is clearly a deluded, self aggrandising bell.

Anyway, it's not like he's sat in a corner, whispering conspiratorially is it? He's stood in a boozer, gobbling it and giving it the 'big I am'.
Andrew Clare
19 Posted 15/05/2012 at 18:21:51
Over here in Italy the football pundits/commentators often remark about how bad the refereeing is in the EPL. Most of the English, Spanish and German matches are shown on Sky here.

I can't believe that Tiote wasn't given his marching orders on Saturday. He was fouling persistently for much of the game.

On another note. What great ambassadors for the game are Kean, Tevez and Barton! Not too clever I think!
Mike Allison
20 Posted 15/05/2012 at 18:49:02
Back to Cahill, so will Andy Carroll get the same suspension then?
Mike Rourke
21 Posted 15/05/2012 at 18:39:54
The Steve Kean defence.

"What I meant by 'fucking crook' was that thing shepherds use on sheep, you know sheep like chickens, I was crooked by the owners, best possible sense, chicken crooking a sheep, am I mixing my metaphors, maybe, I love chickens, by the way we'll definitely be in Champions League next year I'll be shocked if we aren't, in that dressing room the boys are all behind me, eating lovely delicious Venkey's chicken, did I ever mention anything about the iniquities of the fucking East India Company and the British Raj, fucking crooks as in the criminal kind, not like Big Sam, great mate of mine, we're thinking of taking the families over to Goa, can I just add we're in the process of signing Iniesta loves Blackburn he does, have I even mentioned the nutritional value of chicke..." *keeps talking utter bollocks until everyone stops listening*

I quite like him.

Blue Bill v Steve Kean in the Who's The Greatest Verbal Diarrhoeaist would be quite a close run thing I reckon.
Eugene Ruane
22 Posted 15/05/2012 at 19:42:00
Mike 238.

Bill wins.

(in boxing terms, KO 1 - AND he can do it sober)
Kevin Sparke
23 Posted 15/05/2012 at 21:20:17
Reading between the lines on Cabaye's swift apology and Cahill's 'disgust' I'd suggest that there was an element beyond the usual needle in Cabaye's comments ? and to Tim's credit, he's called the matter closed after his appeal was knocked back.
Colin Wainwright
24 Posted 15/05/2012 at 21:29:56
Totally agree Kevin.
Michael Kenrick
25 Posted 15/05/2012 at 21:27:05
So the reaction gets punished while the perpetrator effectively walks free, with a yellow card that is meaningless at this stage of the season? I just wonder if this really sends the right message?

Yes, retaliation must never be condoned... and this decision says there is no justification for retaliation, no matter how bad the provocation. Or perhaps there are comparisons to the infamous Suarez business...??? The key there being that Evra did not retaliate (as I recall) but did report the matter off the field.

We will never know, but at least in that case, the buck-teethed perpetrator was well punished.
Jamie Crowley
26 Posted 15/05/2012 at 22:13:03
This is the one thing that drives me up the wall and back down with soccer.

Let's say Cabaye said something awful...

Cahill grabs him by the throat. Doesn't clock him, kick his knee, toss him to the ground and pop him a few times...

he grabbed his neck - and it was harmless frankly.

but Cahill gets tossed out.

The sport I grew up playing... they'd a dropped gloves and settled it right then and there. Sit down for 5 minutes, catch your breath and your wits, get back out on the ice and play hard.

Hockey figured it out. If you pop off a la Cabaye, Terry, Suarez - expect to get hurt - quickly, with extreme malice, and don't open your freakin mouth unless you understand what's about to happen to you.

Players can police themselves. Unfortunately, soccer doesn't allow fighting and doesn't have a penalty box.

It's just silly. He grabbed his neck like a girl and he's out for 3 games! Why not just haul off and hit him - sit for 6 games and send the dude a message: talk like that again, I'll hurt ya.

I'll switch to decaf tomorrow morning...


Cultural difference clearly. One that confounds me.
Jamie Barlow
27 Posted 15/05/2012 at 22:44:50
Fantastic post Jamie.

It's something I'd love to see.

Is it right that they only stop them once one of them falls?
Paul David
28 Posted 15/05/2012 at 22:40:45
Jamie

You used to be able to tackle round the neck and "let a player know you're there" by nearly breaking his leg. Obviously this had to be stopped but the FA and Fifa have taken it to the other extreme and it's becoming a non-contact sport (which I hate). Legitimate tackles are clamped down on and even warranting red cards while blatant cheating is encouraged by letting it go on.
Ciarán McGlone
29 Posted 15/05/2012 at 22:49:30
Fuck me, Jamie,

One of my favourite films is Slapshot....

But come on. Be serious.
Jamie Crowley
30 Posted 15/05/2012 at 23:05:18
Jamie - nice name btw

There's this "unwritten law" in hockey and it's simple: take a shot, receive a shot. Either way, take it like a man. And back down to no one.

The linesman (2 officials in hockey, kind of like your ARs) let the two fighters square off. They grapple, punch, et al until they tire out, or until one hits the ice. When someone's in a position of authority over the other guy, there's usually one for good measure, and then the linesman jump in and separate the two.

So yes, they almost 100% of the time wait until one falls. But the real reason they wait is so they don't get hit themselves. If they jumped in right away, they'd get smacked.

Also, when a much larger guy has a smaller fella down, he won't pummel the crap out of him. OFTEN a winner fighter is over a guy totally helpless ? but doesn't throw a punch. It's a respect thing.

I fought a few times ? I weigh about 160 lbs dripping wet. I usually lost frankly as I'm not a big guy. But I would never, ever back down. If some dude said something to me that I suspect Cabaye said to Cahill, I'd have no reservations whatsoever ? I'd just hit him. I knew I'd take more than a few... and that dimes to doughnuts I'd lose in the end ? but ya gotta do what ya gotta do.

And Cahill shoulda clocked that piece of garbage immediately.

But he can't....

Mind you, I have 4 fake teeth ? knocked out of my cranium. So these things can get ugly which is why I suppose the gentlemen's rule is in place.

And maybe I'm compensating.... who knows.

But I still wish, possibly more like Paul's answer of strong (ferocious?) tackles, that men in this sport could retaliate if they are "wronged".
Paul David
31 Posted 15/05/2012 at 23:56:05
I just realised that if Moyes had plans to move out Cahill in the summer the club would not have bothered to appeal his red card. To me, this is a sign that Moyes still thinks the sun shines out of Cahill's arse so look forward to another season of nothingness from Cahill while being paid £50k a week.
James Flynn
32 Posted 16/05/2012 at 00:47:17
Jamie (286) - C'mon brother. They can't allow that anymore baseball can.

Had to laugh though. But no. Liked Cahill pointing ala "Let's go outside"! Jesus, imagine Cahill growing up playing hockey in North America?
Jason Lam
33 Posted 16/05/2012 at 07:26:20
Firstly, Cahill shouldn't have grabbed him by the neck after the whistle. Stupid.

Secondly, Cahill didn't follow through his threat. All I saw was Cahill backing away after the grabbing. If you're going start a fight you better follow through and stand your ground. So what's the point?
James Stewart
34 Posted 16/05/2012 at 10:08:05
I have to agree more with Jamie above. If you are going to get sent off and a 3 match ban for violent conduct you might as well do a Big Dunc. The butting heads or throat grabbing or, even slapping happens now, is just pathetic.

Caybaye is a tosser and was lucky to be on the pitch. Tiote should have seen red and how he wasn't sent off for persistent fouling I don't know.

No idea why we appealed it, stupid. Cahill out is probably a good thing anyway though.
Eugene Ruane
35 Posted 16/05/2012 at 10:26:25
Anyone (old enough to) remember this - Franny Lee adopting what you might call Big Dunc logic?

In a game against Leeds (Lee was at Derby by this time) Norman Hunter was giving him a good kicking.

At one point, Lee had had enough and gave him a mouthful.

Hunter gave him a smack.

Incredibly, the ref decided to send them BOTH off.

Lee then applied what was a very sound bit of logic.

He figured as he had done nothing, and yet he'd been sent off as well, he had nothing to lose by twatting Hunter.

So, as they were walking off, Lee went for Hunter, who (in true bully style) almost shat himself.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jPZnXgKl70I
Dennis Stevens
36 Posted 16/05/2012 at 11:42:50
Excellent Eugene - sad to admit I recall the incident as if it were yesterday! If I remember correctly Hunter came out of Lancaster Gate looking like a pimp, as tended to be the fashion.
Neat finishes from Duncan McKenzie & Roger Davies - signed by County from my home town team Worcester City, who famously knocked RS out of the Cup back in the 50's.
Jamie Barlow
37 Posted 16/05/2012 at 12:10:47
Great stuff Jamie. I can just see Ossie trading blows with Yaya Toure.

Maybe not.
Robert Workman
38 Posted 16/05/2012 at 12:04:51
Alternatively, if you have been badly injured get one of your mates to sort it out. I will never forget that after Brian Marwood badly injured Adrian Heath at Goodison (he was never the same player again), his mate Peter Reid exacted retribution on Marwood just before half-time with a tackle that almost put Marwood into the Paddock/Lower Bullens!
Tony J Williams
39 Posted 16/05/2012 at 12:27:03
As with Duncan, if you are going to get sent off (like Barton) make it worth your while.

Nut the fucker and walk off with a wave to the Lower Gwladys, or a fist salute like Dunc's
Eugene Ruane
40 Posted 16/05/2012 at 13:45:58
Robert (397), as I remember, he only got a booking.

(but my memory is shite)
Jamie Crowley
41 Posted 16/05/2012 at 14:19:19
Robert -

last comment on this. In hockey the "mates" that do something about it are called "goons".

Every team needs a good goon. An enforcer.

Wayne Gretsky had Marty McSorely. If you looked funny at Gretsky, never mind cross check him in the back, slash him, run him.... McSorely would come racing across the ice to put the hurt on the poormbastardcthat exercised either very poor judgement or a massive amount of bravery. He would just stop playing and race over, dropping the gloves 20 feet away, and prepare to pound the living shit out of the man brave enough to breath on Gretsky.

He was paid millions to play this role...

Imagine if every opposing player knew that if they dared to cheap shot Jelavic, Heitinga was allowed to beat the shit out of him...

Soccer has surpassed hockey as "favorite sport" in my feeble little world. But there's some things you just love - and hockey will always be on the radar for ALL of the reasons I described above.
Mike Gwyer
42 Posted 16/05/2012 at 16:50:54

Robert #397.

Reidy - Everton's walking hitman. However, both Reidy and Inchy were both of the same persuasion and by all accounts, very close.

Marwood was fucked the moment he left his boot mark on Inchy.



Keith Bailey
43 Posted 16/05/2012 at 19:06:23
Any ideas what Cabaye said to Timmy? Racist stuff? Something about his missus? Never seen Tim react like that
Graham Mockford
44 Posted 17/05/2012 at 14:57:34
Paul David #307 you obsessive dislike of Cahill is getting nearly as boring as Jimmy's man love for Drenthe.
We get the point, give it a rest why don't you.
Jim Knightley
45 Posted 17/05/2012 at 15:07:15
Paul, you could also argue that a team buying Cahill would prefer if he could start the first three games of the season. Ultimately it means nothing, as it makes sense to appeal the ban, whether Cahill stays or go. You could also argue, that Moyes omission of Cahill for a very significant game (financially, only a win in the semi-final would have been worth more), is a statement of sorts. But great work manipulating a scenario to suit your theory.
Paul David
46 Posted 17/05/2012 at 19:07:55
Jim

How does it make sense to appeal the ban when the whole world could see his hands round his neck,he was never going to get away with it.It could go against us in the future if there is a genuine red card to appeal and the FA think there not going to give us the benefit of the doubt because we appeal for everthing.

As for manipulating a scenario,how many games hasnt Cahill been involved in this season,2 maybe 3?
Jamie Crowley
47 Posted 17/05/2012 at 23:38:41
I said earlier last post... I lied. And probably no one's gonna read this as it's bottom of news trawl on the home page... but just in case:

Eugene -

That's EXACTLY what I'm talking about. Good for Lee. Shoulda cracked him. I say well done Mr. Lee, well done.

If you're gonna get sent off for some mambi-pambi bullshit, just go out in style and stand up for yourself. In short, don't go off wearing a skirt - especially if you've done nothing.

Excellent link. TY


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads