McFadden and Hahnemann released

, 18 May, 127comments  |  Jump to most recent
Drenthe and Stracqualursi loans to expire 30 June
Everton have released James McFadden and Marcus Hahnemann after their one-year contracts expired.

Season-long loan players Royston Drenthe and Denis Stracqualursi will also officially leave Everton when their terms are up on 30th June.

They all join Academy and Reserve players Adam Davies, Connor Roberts, and Femi Orenuga in departing the Club and becoming free agents this close season.

Aristote Nsiala was also released this week and has joined Accrington Stanley on a one-year contract after spending the latter half of the season on loan there.

Stracqualursi will return to Tigre in Argentina after failing to make the grade in the Premier League while Drenthe, who scored four times for the Blues, will be a free agent now that his Real Madrid contract is up.

Quotes or other material sourced from Everton



Reader Comments (127)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Jon O'Dell
1 Posted 18/05/2012 at 16:29:31
I might be reading into this a bit too much but interest how this article mentions Stracq and Drenthe both being released back to their clubs on the 30th June - but not Pienaar?
Gavin Ramejkis
2 Posted 18/05/2012 at 16:29:04
Can't say I'm surprised about Hahnemann as it was money wasted, even in cameo appearances McFadden was as average as he was when he left, Drenthe is a dead cert to be off and Denis was only ever a stop gap but not a peep on the missing Velios now for weeks add in the two kids and the payroll is already looking lighter.
Luke O'Farrell
3 Posted 18/05/2012 at 16:41:56
I'd imagine that Pienaar isn't mentioned because we're going to try and sign him. The other two are mentioned because they are going and won't be coming back.
Kevin Ruscoe
4 Posted 18/05/2012 at 16:46:18
It does seen strange that Pienaar wasn't mentioned when the other two loanees were. Gavin, I thought Vellios signed a 4-year deal with us?
Paul Ellam
5 Posted 18/05/2012 at 16:52:52
I have to say that this news makes me happy. It is about time we got rid of some dead wages. I would like to see Mucha, Yobo and Anichebe go too.
Sam Hoare
6 Posted 18/05/2012 at 17:08:34
Really don't understand the point in bringing Hahnemann in? Even if he was only on 15k per week thats still around 250k that we wasted.

If Denis was a freebie then worth bringing back but don't see him being worth more than 1m. Would prefer to pay 2m for Naismith i think.

Hopefully with this lots plus Yobo, Yak, Saha, Billy and Arteta gone there's some room on the wage bill to bring in some hungry new players. Plenty of freebies and players on the move this summer...
Wayne Smyth
7 Posted 18/05/2012 at 17:16:49
Yep, I agree sam.

If we were that desperate to play McFadden, Hahnemann or straq, then I'd have much rather seen our younger players like Barkley, McAleny, Vellios etc get a run-out and save a few million in salary.

Drenthe was never going to work out in hindsight, but was worth a look as he is obviously very talented. Shame about his professionalism and attitude.

Hopefully we'll be 50k lighter per week which gives some scope for a few freebies or maybe someone on a low fee.
Kevin Sparke
8 Posted 18/05/2012 at 17:18:04
Best of luck Dennis - you never gave less than 100% and always did your very best for the team. You were limited in skill - but never in heart and I wish you well.

Drenthe - fuck off you waste of talent
Tony J Williams
9 Posted 18/05/2012 at 17:21:18
What fecking loon agreed the loan deals until June 30th? The season always ends in May, so we have a month of the feckers being on their hols yet we are still paying them?
Eugene Ruane
10 Posted 18/05/2012 at 17:23:34
Just thinking the same thing Tony.

Would have thought it would be a case of, when the whistle goes after the last game, that's that.

Mind you, I get the impression that for your average shifty, greedy agent, screwing Everton out of a few bob isn't exactly a challenge.
Paul David
11 Posted 18/05/2012 at 17:35:48
I think it probably has more to do with the parent club not wanting to pay the wages.
Kevin Sparke
12 Posted 18/05/2012 at 17:40:04
Re June 30th - just as the tax year goes from April to April the following year; most player contracts go from whenever they sign to the end of june at the end of the season.

Don't ask me why but agents insist upon it. I suspect it's something to do with the 'official' end of the season and the beginning of a new one.
Jeremy Benson
13 Posted 18/05/2012 at 17:52:28
The press release states that pienaar, straq and drenthe loan deals finish on 30th June. Which is just stating facts.

Doesn't say we won't be trying to sign any of them permanently...
James Flynn
14 Posted 18/05/2012 at 17:49:35
Only glad Jimmy Sorheim wasn't alive to hear this shocking news.
James Flynn
15 Posted 18/05/2012 at 17:53:42
And best of luck to Straq. Loved you brother.
Dean Adams
16 Posted 18/05/2012 at 17:48:52
Straq, you made me laugh and you made me cry, for some reason I thought you were great. Not good enough to be a top premier player, but you had the ability to keep trying, which is missing from many players in this day and age. Anyway, best of luck to you.
Paul David
17 Posted 18/05/2012 at 17:56:49
McRooney was a joke signing but if Moyes thought he needed him because we were short on numbers then fair enough but what was the need for a third keeper?For a skint club that makes no sense.
Stephen Davies
18 Posted 18/05/2012 at 17:57:04
Loved the way Straq kept on trying, can show a lot of others how to keep going. That is what we need players that keep on playing for the full game and he never gave less than that
Kevin Sparke
19 Posted 18/05/2012 at 18:03:44
Paul David - it made every sense; using Liverpool as an example they were down to their 3rd choice keeper. Before the Hahnemann signing our 3rd choice was a 17 year old.

Re McFadden - he was a punt and an experienced Premier League player... unfortunately it never worked out, but he put in at least one good shift.

Of course, Moyes isn't blessed with your uncanny foresight and judgement.

Ever thought of applying for the job as head coach? chief scout?... or you might choose to start at the bottom and sell some burgers in the Main Stand
Paul David
20 Posted 18/05/2012 at 18:10:52
Kevin

Unlike Liverpool we dont have money to spunk up the wall and what are the odds of a third choice keeper being needed.Normally the chances of the second choice keeper being needed are slim so Hahnenmann was pointless.

You dont need any foresight to know McFadden is shit because he has been here before and guess what,he was shit then even before all the injuries.I did say fair enough if Moyes felt he needed bodies ( if thats all that was available).
Sam Hoare
21 Posted 18/05/2012 at 18:21:03
Also Kevin, I believe that if two keepers get injured you are allowed to bring in an emergency loan outside the window... didn't we do that once with someone?

Liverpool was different as obviously they had two keepers sent off in a row... the odds of which must be astronomical.
Nick Barnes
22 Posted 18/05/2012 at 18:32:38
As Jeremy (12) stated, it doesn't mean that we won't try and sign Straq, Pienaar or Drenthe in the summer. Granted, we won't be signing Drenthe. Nowhere does the official announcement state that we have/will release these three players, it only says that their loan deals will come to an end on 30th June which we knew anyway...
Matt Traynor
23 Posted 18/05/2012 at 18:47:47
Sam #022, that was Espen Baardsen, and please don't remind us. His one game was his former club Tottenham, away. Damn it, you've gone and reminded me. 3-4 and it felt like he was at fault for all the goals, even ours.
Mark Stone
24 Posted 18/05/2012 at 18:30:47
Sam, that shit happens. Imagine this scenario. Whilst your first choice keeper is out injured your second choice keeper injures himself by falling over a board (telling him not to warm up in that goal) whilst warming up before a match. Your third choice keeper therefore steps in, making his debut, but gets sent off within ten minutes leaving your fourth choice keeper (who six years later would go on to go to a major tournament with the senior England team) to come in.
Mark Stone
25 Posted 18/05/2012 at 19:00:50
Matt, and Sander Westerveld a few years later.
Declan Burke
26 Posted 18/05/2012 at 19:18:09
Might as well release Mucha as well. Moyes musn't have much confidence in him. Howard appeared to be struggling with an injury last Sunday. We were 3 up, but no indicitation that be would ever come on.
Kevin Sparke
27 Posted 18/05/2012 at 19:21:36
Richard Wright (((shudder)))

Almost as bad as Seamus Mcdonagh
Mike Allison
28 Posted 18/05/2012 at 19:26:30
Mark don't be ridiculous, that would never happen.

By the way, Iain Turner is now without a club...
Timothy Blanshard
29 Posted 18/05/2012 at 19:32:11
I was hoping we would keep the count, as for Royston, it has been said many times before if only he had a brain to equal his God given skill he would be one heck of a player. So funny to hear his car was parked around the corner (when he said it was broken down), as if he could blag DM that easy, no chance.


Can't say I really care about the others released obviously they are not needed.
Mark Stone
30 Posted 18/05/2012 at 19:45:28
As is Richard Wright, Mike!
Steve Pugh
31 Posted 18/05/2012 at 20:04:12
Pienaar thing is interesting, OS does mention him as one of the season long loanees, but the subheading says "Six released and two loan players to leave at end of June."

So which two are leaving and which one isn't?
Richard Dodd
32 Posted 18/05/2012 at 20:15:48
I am neither qualified nor inclined to query the judgement of David Moyes but I would love to know the thinking behind his preference throughout the season towards the likes of no marks like Stracq and Faddy rather than giving valuable game experience to the likes of Barkley, Vellios and Baxter.

It's as though, if they played for any other club, they MUST be better than our 'own grown'!
Shaun Brennan
33 Posted 18/05/2012 at 20:52:17
bloody hell Doddy we don't live in North Korea...
Kevin Elliott
34 Posted 18/05/2012 at 20:52:14
Farewell Strach.
I hope that your memories of us are as happy as our memories of you.
Good luck.
Nick Entwistle
35 Posted 18/05/2012 at 20:33:06
When he scored he was like Marco Tardelli each and every time. The turn around in form wasn't all about the skills of Pienaar, Landon and Jely arriving. All others were letting us down weakly and weekly, but his gut busting effort showed a lot of players true commitment when we needed it the most.

Against City and Chelsea he dragged the players and the Goodison crowd along with him for the best results and memories of the season. If Stracq walks out at Goodison in fifty years he'd get a standing ovation and yet he's on a plane while Anichebe picks up a gold plated crutch and sulks from the stands. Shock Bollocks.

Good luck Stracq, but I don't think you need it.
Paul David
36 Posted 18/05/2012 at 20:59:03
I really like Straq,he wasnt good enough thought but like its been mentioned if theres a place for Anichebe in the squad then on that basis Straq should be starting every game.
Richard Dodd
37 Posted 18/05/2012 at 21:04:52
I agree,Paul,and I bet Straq was not on a fifth of Anichebe`s money.
But still not good enough!
Gavin Ramejkis
38 Posted 18/05/2012 at 21:11:21
We always had a third choice emergency keeper in Jagielka who has played as an emergency keeper before - when Paddy Kenny got in jured for Sheff Utd and Jags spent over 30 mins in goal against Arsenal including a fine save against Van Persie to ensure they won the game.
Tom Bowers
39 Posted 18/05/2012 at 21:55:55
Stracqs was an honest hardworking player but alas lacking in certain skills needed in the Prem.but would do well in the Championship if someone wants him. Drenthe an exciting player but so much like Fernandes ? inconsistent over 90 minutes.

McFadden had his best days several years ago and lacked that turn of foot that could have made him something special.

Hopefully new and better loan players will become available especially if Pienaar isn't.
Jay Harris
40 Posted 18/05/2012 at 21:53:53
We have to be ruthless... and Stracq for all his loveable qualities was not the answer even as sub.

There again McFadden wasn't even the question. Really dont know what DM was thinking of except giving a fellow Scot a leg up at EFC expense.

As for GK cover in the good old days one of the outfield players could take the jersey but I guess it's more specialised now.
Ian Smitham
41 Posted 18/05/2012 at 22:47:50
Blim ey, one of the saddest
Dave White
42 Posted 18/05/2012 at 22:49:49
I still never quite understood how the Count was top scorer in the Argentinian league...I can't imagine him being top scorer in the Lower Briantspuddle Amateur & Social League (Veterans Divison)! I will miss him though, and wish him all the best.

Just like to say well done to John Ruddy on his international call up. He's been superb this year. Kudos to Chris Woods too.
Michael Summers
43 Posted 18/05/2012 at 23:06:28
Best of luck! Big Den might not of been Prem standard but gave us some great moments and grafted his bollocks off for us. Cheers, big man. COYB.
James Martin
44 Posted 19/05/2012 at 00:01:00
If Howard had got injured at any point then Mucha would have been keeper and Hahnemann would have been on the bench rather than some seventeen year old. It's only seen as dead wages in retrospect because the situation never came about. If it had and we'd ended up with some kid in goal for a big game then that would have been Moyes's fault naturally.

From what I remember of Stracq, he got in the team, looked 10 times more effective than Saha had done all season, scored 3 goals in 4 games (had another one off the line) before being dropped for Jelavic and barely being seen again all season, but now suddenly he was rubbish, not good enough for the Premier League.

It's a different argument if people want to say he's not worth any of our transfer budget, I'd probably agree with that, but don't try and pretend the Fulham, Chelsea, Man City and Blackpool games didn't happen. You could trawl back through the records of this website to all those posts of everyone fawning over him saying how he's just the sort of centre forward we've been looking for and perfect for Moyes's teams. He held the ball up better than a lot of Goodison's recent strikers (Jelavic and Yakubu aside), and had a physical presence that we haven't had up there for a long time, plus he performed well against top defences like Man City's and Chelsea's.

Frankly it's just another player to replace now, Jelavic and sicknote Anichebe will be our senior striking resources for the entirety of next year unless someone comes in.
Paul David
45 Posted 19/05/2012 at 01:08:49
James

It's not only dead wages in retrospect at all, how often does it happen that a team has both first and second choice keepers unavailable? And has it has already been said if that situation did happen your allowed to bring a keeper in even if the window is shut.
Nigel Tufnell
46 Posted 19/05/2012 at 03:01:04
I'd be quite happy to see Straq stay.

Kind of reminds me of Derek Smalls - daft as a brush but a hell of a trier.
Jim Harrison
47 Posted 19/05/2012 at 05:47:26
Paul, Its not common but does happen. It happen to us, It happened to chelsea when 2 keepers were injured in one game, Liverpool this season. Its just a good safety net. And getting emergency cover means picking up a keeper that cant get a game anywhere else, bringing a new player in and putting them straight into the first team.

Have more of an issue that Mcfadden was being paid to hang around as it meant young players were not given a chance.
Mathew McKay
48 Posted 19/05/2012 at 07:24:49
IMO it looks like we're freeing up wages for someone else!
Brian Cleveland
49 Posted 19/05/2012 at 07:23:46
Can't we just kind of merge Drenthe and Straq into one player? Drenthe's skill and Straqs commitment... that would be one hell of a player.... but knowing our luck we'd get the wrong half of each!
Wayne Smyth
50 Posted 19/05/2012 at 07:41:56
Jame(083) - Why not have 15 experienced keepers on the books just incase the 13 of them get injured and you don't want to have a youngster on the bench?

Here's a bit of news: WE'RE SKINT.

because of this we do actually have to make use of our younger players, which Moyes seems to have an aversion to unless he's really backed into a corner.

Duffy, for example, has shown himself to be plenty good enough when he played, but couldn't get a game.

Barkley/Vellios not given any playing time at the end of the season, despite giving McFadden and straq playing time with the full knowledge that he was likely to release both of them a few weeks later.

In some of the games where we've been 2 and 3 nil up are ideal games to be giving the young players some pressure-free experience in a team that is playing well....but no, lets give that experience to players who will no longer be part of the club.
Carl Sanderson
51 Posted 19/05/2012 at 07:47:20
Willing though he was, Denis was never more than a stop-gap. His first touch improved under Moyes but it remained poor. Jelavic is so much the better player it's embarrassing. I know Lurch is a different type, but it's like watching a selling-plater next to a thoroughbred yearling.
Derek Thomas
52 Posted 19/05/2012 at 08:03:47
We keep Anichebe at 30K and get rid of The Strac???
Steve Pugh
53 Posted 19/05/2012 at 09:31:12
1. Have to pay for Straq, already have Vic
2. Who knows what wage Straq would ask for
3. Who says Straq wants to stay.
Mark Cheetham
54 Posted 19/05/2012 at 09:40:40
Sam #997

I can't see Hahnemann being on anything like £15k a week. 3rd Choice keeper of his age that didn't have a club. No chance. £3 or 4k tops. Still not bad for messing about with Woodsy for a couple of hours a day.
Gavin Ramejkis
55 Posted 19/05/2012 at 10:18:03
Jim #095 "getting emergency cover means picking up a keeper that cant get a game anywhere else" what like Hahnemann was but instead cost a weekly wage?

Moyes didn't even substitute Howard during the Newcastle game when it was blatantly obvious he had some sort of groin strain from taking a goal kick which meant he could even take a goal kick from then on or was able to change direction and gather the Hibbert headed backpass/own goal.
Kev Johnson
56 Posted 19/05/2012 at 11:12:27
I noticed that Drenthe and Straq have already been deleted from the "player profile" page on the O/S - but Pienaar is still there. Surely significant?
Paul David
57 Posted 19/05/2012 at 11:54:41
Jim

Hahnenmann couldnt get a game anywhere else either and as for throwing an emergency keeper straight into the team,I dont think a keeper needs to know his defence intimately to be able to do his job.

Agree with you over McFadden though.
Ryan Holroyd
58 Posted 19/05/2012 at 12:08:20
"I don't think a keeper needs to know his defence intimately to be able to do his job."

Totally disagree with that. A defence and a keeper need total trust in each other.

Most top flight teams have three goalkeepers so it's hardly uncommon.
Steve Brown
59 Posted 19/05/2012 at 12:31:36
God love's a trier (and Everton fans especially), but Straq just didnt cut it. Neither did McFadden and Drenthe is a talented waster. Which begs the question of how badly do Neville, Osman and Cahill have to play before they're shown the door?

There can be no more excuses, we need to bring some of the younger players through.
Steve Brown
60 Posted 19/05/2012 at 12:40:59
McAleny, Barkley, Duffy, Gueye, Baxter... even Rodwell is still young.
Paul David
61 Posted 19/05/2012 at 12:41:41
Steve

Moyes does give young players a go but in his eyes 24 is young,Anichebe is 24 and he still talks about his potential.
Trevor Lynes
62 Posted 19/05/2012 at 12:40:59
The main reason for the Count having to go is because he could not play in sunshine, he would need to be used only in evening games...

McFadden was a total waste of money, as was Hahnemann. The money saved on the above two would have kept Pienaar instead of letting him go. Ironically Arteta left too so all the reasons for letting Pienaar go became irrelevant.

Drenthe is a shame as he was talented and upset opposition defences by running at men and he could change a game. Basically we could not control him off the field and neither could any other club he played for.

I still do not understand the business logic of letting Pienaar go ? and Ruddy too for that matter. Ruddy could have been sold if he wanted first team football. Our board seem to be a shambles as far as running a football club.
Eugene Ruane
63 Posted 19/05/2012 at 12:44:07
Kevin (018) You ask Paul David..

"Ever thought of applying for the job as head coach? chief scout?... or you might choose to start at the bottom and sell some burgers in the Main Stand"

Well personally speaking, first half of the season, I'd have taken the coaching of a main stand Joseph over the shite we were subjected to from Moyes.

Yeah we KNOW he's not 'blessed with uncanny foresight and judgement' but that's not what anyone was asking for.

A bit of passing and movement would have done.

You say McFadden was a punt?

Well...you're close.
Thomas Windsor
64 Posted 19/05/2012 at 13:27:08
I think Moyes will try to get Pienaar but it all depends on the price; if there is younger and cheaper talent out out there, have a look. Don't forget, Pienaar left us in the shit when he left for more money at Spurs.
Jon Beck
65 Posted 19/05/2012 at 13:40:24
Really pleased you're not choosing the Manager then Eugene as I fear the Main Stander might take us down! As for the implied insult to McFadden, shameful.

Thanks for the effort Denis and all but Royston, albeit you did entertain at times during a grim period (I certainly enjoyed your early strike and the win at Fulham). As for the argument over 3rd choice keepers, who cares?
Eugene Ruane
66 Posted 19/05/2012 at 14:05:22
Yes thank you Jon 'Private Godfrey' Beck (161)

(always wanted to taste one of your sister Dolly's upside down cakes).

If you want to know what is GENUINELY shameful, it is staggeringly average players like McFadden picking up thousands a week for under-performing, while supporters (earning fuck-all) try and cobble the money together to watch them.

Imo, your post shows you wouldn't recognise GENUINELY shameful if it bit your ball bag.



Richard Harris
67 Posted 19/05/2012 at 14:48:43
Eugene Ruane "You say McFadden was a punt? Well...you're close".
I always thought that McFadden had that punk attitude that was missing from the squad....
Eugene Ruane
68 Posted 19/05/2012 at 15:39:00
Richard if he had a 'punk attitude', it was sadly more Plastic Bertrand than Johnny Rotten.
Ian Edwards
69 Posted 19/05/2012 at 17:14:55
Best of luck Royston

I hope you go on to play for a club where the manager has man management skills and doesnt base team selection in big games on petty time keeping stubborn selfish reasons to the detriment of the team.
Stuart Mitchell
70 Posted 19/05/2012 at 18:12:00
Was sad to see Orenuga leave, always seemed like a good prospect out on the wing!
Jim Harrison
71 Posted 19/05/2012 at 18:21:50
Paul, my point is that having a 3rd choice keeper train with the team mean s that, in the not so very likely event that the first choice 2 are injured, the 3rd choice keeper isnt a complete stranger to the rest of the team. It is also pretty standard practice in most squads.
John McLoughlin
72 Posted 19/05/2012 at 18:32:37
Stracq is not good enough, it's as simple as that. He did well for 4 games and that's it, if that's the level of player we are happy to have at the club, don't start moaning when we never achieve anything. Work hard but very little threat on goal it saddens me that so many prefer hard work over goals or creativity. If he's half as good as some believe he'll have no problem getting another PL side to pick him up... Let's see if anybody else goes for him.

As for Hahnemann, I'll bet he was on buttons; less than £5k a week.
Steve Green
73 Posted 19/05/2012 at 21:29:11
We can argue all day long about whether Stracq was good enough or not but...
he came on against West Brom (A) - before the January signings arrived - on a day that we were playing shite, ran his bollocks off, put himself about, got the team actually interested and we won with a late goal.
That was the turning point of our season, we went onwards and upwards from that point on, yes due to the capture of 3 quality players but also because we had the momentum thanks to one man putting a bit of (hitherto non-seen) effort in.
Always get a warm Goodison welcome from me in future years Denis lad. Thanks for that.
Alex Kociuba
74 Posted 19/05/2012 at 22:09:53
Hahnneman on 15k a week? I would say more like it was £1400 a week tops.
Jim Knightley
75 Posted 19/05/2012 at 22:35:09
Can't understand the Hahnemann moaning; are you familiar with the practice of other teams? United, Chelski, Arsenal and Liverpool all have used third choice goalkeepers in recent times, and they are there for a reason.

And Ian...you and Jimmy should get a room along with Royston.
Paul David
76 Posted 19/05/2012 at 22:39:13
Jim what do all them clubs have in commom?
Jim Knightley
77 Posted 19/05/2012 at 22:50:14
Your right Paul...only the top teams have third choice senior goalies....hang on, no they don't.

I was picking out high profile clubs because the use of third choice goalies was more memorable.
Gavin Ramejkis
78 Posted 19/05/2012 at 22:53:34
Jim from the 30th June how many Keepers do Everton have? I'll give you a clue, Hahnemann is going as is the kid from the youth team, so your point about hang on, well hang on which is it to be then?
Paul David
79 Posted 19/05/2012 at 22:52:40
Jim I just been on the premier league website and checked all the keepers registered and 3 is the most common number each team has (some have more,a couple only had 2).Other than the top 5 i've never heard of the 3rd choice keeper at all the other clubs,I think its safe to assume thats because their kids.
Jim Knightley
80 Posted 19/05/2012 at 23:05:50
Ok Paul, without researching, I'll go with Sunderland straight away: Mignolet, Gordon and Westwood all competed this season. All well known goalies, all good goalies (unlike ours) and a team of our level.
Jim Knightley
81 Posted 19/05/2012 at 23:05:50
Ok Paul, without researching, I'll go with Sunderland straight away: Mignolet, Gordon and Westwood all competed this season. All well known goalies, all good goalies (unlike ours) and a team of our level.
Jim Knightley
82 Posted 19/05/2012 at 23:07:06
Gavin, are you actually for real? are you attempting to disregard an argument about teams generally having three senior goalkeepers by pointing to pre-season prior to the opening of the transfer window? Brilliant
Paul David
83 Posted 19/05/2012 at 23:08:34
Jim go on the website yourself,I wouldnt try to prove a point and give you the imformation to see for yourself if I was lying.Yes I might have forgot to mention Sunderland as well but I think they will be the only other team other than the ones at the very top.Do Sunderland count really because Gordon has spent most of his time in England injured,therefore thats why Sunderland needed another decent keeper,his contract runs out this season and I bet they dont replace him.
Jim Knightley
84 Posted 19/05/2012 at 23:15:42
Btw, you need to learn how to research. I've checked 3 other clubs around us (I'll stop at three).
Stoke had Begovic, Sorensen and Nash (and a fourth, and im assuming you've heard of the above three).
Villa had Given, Guzan and Marshall (again as above)
Fulham have Stockdale, the main Aussie guy I can't remember and some 22 year old.

I think it's safe to assume you are talking bullocks.
Jim Knightley
85 Posted 19/05/2012 at 23:16:16
I don't believe you are lying, but if you go on Skysports you can check out the squads and you will see that teams of our stature have 3 senior goalies. This is a nonsense point being used to question managerial practice. A third experienced goalkeeper is essential, not only because of the potential for the injury of the first two, but to provide competition for a covering goalie who might turn out to be poor. Of course now with retrospect we can all moan about it, but the basis for having three senior goalies is sound. If it wasn't, other teams would not do it.
Paul David
86 Posted 19/05/2012 at 23:21:30
Yeah because saying some 22 year old that you have never heard of means he's a senior keeper.If the info the premier league site is wrong then fair enough i'll back down.
Jim Knightley
87 Posted 19/05/2012 at 23:27:50
Well Paul, 22 is not a kid is it? and have you heard of the Stoke, Sunderland and Villa goalies?

And do you think lots of non-Everton fans have heard of Mucha?

Jim Knightley
88 Posted 19/05/2012 at 23:29:45
Just go through teams on Skysports. Just did it with WBA now, they had 2 seniors I've heard of playing, and a 24 year old reserve...the pattern goes on.

Mcfadden was a strange additon, a third goalie was not.
Paul David
89 Posted 19/05/2012 at 23:32:54
Jim if sky sports shows more keepers at clubs then the premier site does then fair enough but I wouldnt class players as senior by age more by experience.
Kieran Kinsella
90 Posted 20/05/2012 at 04:22:36
There was no mention of Nyarko. Has his 500 year contract expired yet?
Jim Harrison
91 Posted 20/05/2012 at 05:54:53
Too be fair, Paul, I would rather have a 24-year-old 3rd keeper, as it would be a better long-term option. But the club did have that policy before with Turner and Ruddy, but couldn't keep them as reserves for their whole careers.

Now it seems the policy is to keep 2 experienced keepers as back up just in case. As long as their wages are not too high I think it is a reasonable policy.
Jem Traynor
92 Posted 20/05/2012 at 06:26:39
I just thought I'd post to say that I appreciated Denis Stracqualursi's tireless running and effort to do better ? something that has been missing at Goodison from forwards of late. But tara to McFadden, it was never going to work out with the memories of his attitude from before and now an injury too.
Gavin Ramejkis
93 Posted 20/05/2012 at 06:29:34
Jim I am for real but given the highly unlikely chance of losing Howard and Mucha (Moyes wouldn't even sub Howard against Newcastle - remember him not subbing Gosling and that injury crippling him because Moyes left him on?) and the fact I've already pointed out Jagielka is a reasonable keeper as witnessed by none other than Robin Van Persie then we already have a capable third choice who knows the squad.

As far as your argument on the rest of the EPL squads having a third keeper, its like comparing apples to oranges, how often do Everton buy a player in comparison with our peers over the last four to five years and how do the squads compare Jim? Take a look at the senior squad on the OS and of the 28 work out how many have kicked a ball for the seniors and up to the end of the season how many were actually here and not on loan?

Its all well and good claiming we should have three keepers but you may as well say we should have a reasonable squad depth, we should have a reasonable annual transfer kitty, we should have a chairman and board worth a balloon - all of which we havent.
Kevin Sparke
94 Posted 20/05/2012 at 08:31:51
Picture the scene - Everton are beating Fulham 3-0, Howard goes up for a high ball and comes down hard on his ankle; he struggles on manfully for 10 minutes but then signals to the bench he needs to come off. On comes Mucha and a minute later he's on a one-on-one with Dempsey and brings him down in the box, penalty and the goalie has to go - he takes exception to that he sees as a dive and sticks the head on Dempsey.

Howard has a stress fracture and is out for 10 weeks; Mucha receives a 4 match ban - 3 for the original offence and 1 for the appeal.

Everton are left to face Manchester City, Arsenal, Aston Villa and Chelsea with... well... with who?

Okay, so they bring in an emergency goalkeeper - an Italian from the Albanian Third division who no fucker has ever heard of... after the first tonking it's clear the team have no confidence in the new keeper and we take another three severe beatings

I switch on Toffeeweb Monday morning...

Paul David - 'Moyes is at fault - we should have cover, every other team does'

Gavin Ramejkis - 'This is down the the deadly duo Black Bill and Moyes - if Moyes hadn't have put up with Bill's penny pinching we'd have had an experienced third choice keeper; every other team has a third choice, but not Everton

Eugene Ruane - 'When the seagulls follow the trawler... Moyes out'

As a manager you just can't win at times...



Ray Robinson
95 Posted 20/05/2012 at 09:07:58
Everton simply cannot afford to have a third string keeper for the remote possibility that the first two keepers are out injured / suspended - unless they are paying them buttons.

In the game when we beat Blackburn 1-0 we ended up with Turner starting and Ruddy on the bench. That is the answer for us - to have a promising keeper as the third string.

On other occasions, I have known Everton to employ Baardsen and Westerweld as emergency keepers - in other words we used the loan system.

These two approaches have got to be a more sensible approach for a cash-strapped club like Everton, surely?
Jim Knightley
96 Posted 20/05/2012 at 11:12:05
Gavin...you are actually implying Jags should be a third choice now...this gets worse and worse.

Goalkeeper is an excluded position; an outfield player cannot replace a goalie. We might have less cb's than some teams...but Rodwell, Neville or Hibbert could cover. We might have less strikers, but we could stick Cahill or Fellaini up front. If we lose a couple of goalies, we CANNOT put an outfield player in goal. It would be beyond stupid, and I can only assume your comment about Jag is some form of satire, rather than the musings of idiocy.

Ray, how is using the loan system different from getting Hahneemann on a free? we only pay wages, minimal at that; there is no difference.
And we would like a promising goalie..but we can't buy anyone, and can't always produce them, hence the situation. Maybe in a couple of seasons our best youth gk will be promising and have loan experience, but he doesn't yet.

Seriously guys, cant believe the shit spouted as a means to suggest we shouldnt have a third choice senior goalkeeper. Maybe Moyes should train Fellaini up in his spare time, as he is big and good in the air?
Gavin Ramejkis
97 Posted 20/05/2012 at 11:33:47
Jim are you for real? Who took the goal kicks for the remainder of the Newcastle game and which of Everton's current outfield squad has previously played in goal in the EPL?

Is it really so hard to realise the club is potless and should be cutting its cloth accordingly or are you genuinely so blinkered to maintain a club with fuck all money should be pissing it away when they have a solution already on the books? Or do you want to go all risk averse and say what if Howard and Mucha and Jagielka (or either of the two centre halves of Heitinga and Distin got injured) ignoring Duffy and Hibbert have also played at centre half for Everton this last season gone?

How many spare million do you think the club has? If you find any do us all a favour and let Moyes know where it is.
Gavin Ramejkis
98 Posted 20/05/2012 at 11:39:46
In case your myopia still doesn't believe it after your claim of not being able to put an outfield player in goal - http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/football/eng_prem/6205685.stm

Kevin, what if an asetroid hit Goodison Park and wiped out the entire team? As likely as the scaremongering scenario you described
Eugene Ruane
99 Posted 20/05/2012 at 11:18:01
Kevin (322) - Wow, all that for the philosophical gem, 'sometimes you can't win'.

But..fair enough, there's no 'no waffle' rule.

And as you're keen to point out what you see as the weakness of other's arguments, only fair to point out (for the hard of thinking) your own 'strategy'.

Kevin Sparke - "Ok imagine this, then picture that IF the other happened. Then picture the other, if that happened WITHOUT that picture. Now if all THAT happened..er..I'd be right and you'd look a right twat"

(Question: When you go on holiday, are you received by a dwarf wearing a white suit, who has a face like a smashed crab and fingers like cocktails sausages?)

Mark Stone
100 Posted 20/05/2012 at 11:51:19
"Kevin, what if an asetroid hit Goodison Park and wiped out the entire team? As likely as the scaremongering scenario you described"

I don't think that scenario is any more unlikely than those which have seen us sign the truly shite Espen Baardsen and Sander Westerveld in the past nine years.
Ray Robinson
101 Posted 20/05/2012 at 12:04:05
Jim #341, the difference is that signing a goalie on emergency loan is that you only have to pay his salary for (say) 1 month (and if the emergency doesn't happen, you pay NOTHING), whereas we have paid Hahnemann for 5 to 6 months for effectively doing nothing.

Good God, we started some seasons with barely a forward and yet some would have us sign 3 goalies. Some managers omit a goalie from the subs bench (not something that I would advocate) but it's all about balancing the budget and the odds catastrophic happening to two goalies simultaneously.
Terry McLavey
102 Posted 20/05/2012 at 12:47:41
Tony j #001 Probably sharp practice by the agent to pay them 'till June, fuckin' parasites, who the fuck is Hahnemann?!!!
Paul David
103 Posted 20/05/2012 at 13:00:28
Kevin 332

I hardly think the emergency keeper would be some novice from the third tier.More likely Everton would pay a reasonable fee (about the same as a third keepers wages over a season) to another skint club like Bolton for their reserve keeper for a month.
Mark Riding
104 Posted 20/05/2012 at 13:19:05
Kevin #322.

Dinamo Tirana have 3 goalies in their squad, and 1 out on loan. They are in the Albanian first division, so if your scenario does come about, Im sure we could loan one of theirs.
Kevin Sparke
105 Posted 20/05/2012 at 13:25:19
Well to cut to the mustard Eugene, Paul, Gavin etc...

You're whinging now that we shouldn't have had a third choice goalie - and I can see some logic in that, what with money being so tight.

But I'd have bet dollars to doughnuts that in the unlikely scenario of needing a third choice goalie (which has happened at least a dozen times since I've been watching us from 1968 onwards - I can list them if you like) you'd be the first three to get your whinges in that Moyes and Kenwright had fucked up by not having cover...

So - Moyes has cover in depth at goalkeeper - he's fucked up for not spreading his resources

Moyes doesn't have cover at goalkeeper and there's a couple of injuries... he's fucked up.

Do you get it now? It's a no win situation...

BTW Eugene explain the Dwarf comment... you've lost me with that one laa
Paul David
106 Posted 20/05/2012 at 13:45:18
Kevin

No I wouldnt moan if we needed a third keeper because as it has been pointed out,keepers can be signed outside the window.
Kevin Sparke
107 Posted 20/05/2012 at 13:51:29
Paul - I'll bet you would have done - and I base that speculation on reading your comments over the last few months.

Can you point to any when you've not been whinging about something or other?

How come you've never once praised the team, the manager... or even the club?

I'm not having a pop - just curious...
Paul David
108 Posted 20/05/2012 at 13:55:32
Kevin

After each match I give credit were its due and have a go if I think we havent done enough.

When commenting on threads that are not about the match then yeah I will usually moan.Thats not because I love moaning,if someone has wrote an article that I agree with then theres no need for me to comment.If something has been written I dont agree with then i'll say something and hopefully point out why I do.

I suppose the fact I dont want Moyes in the job either means i'll disagree with a lot of his decisions,if I liked the manager I would have less to moan about.
Kevin Sparke
109 Posted 20/05/2012 at 14:14:41
Fair enough Paul- we all call it as we see it, (apart from Eugene who's too busy chasing dragons and communing with aliens to see anything further than his crack pipe)

Philosophical question - was the word 'pipe' necessary in the above sentence?
Paul David
110 Posted 20/05/2012 at 14:19:14
Kevin

Seeing as you've switched your attentions elsewhere i'm looking forward to Eugene's responce now.Should be interesting.
Simon Harris
111 Posted 20/05/2012 at 14:59:34
It must be the close season.

When else would you seriously debate the need for a "3rd" choice goalie. Unless of course Howard was injured, and Mucha was involved in freak hunting accident with Jags..... oh bollocks, I'm off to watch the cricket.
Dave Wilson
112 Posted 20/05/2012 at 15:26:28
I think we take Howard`s fitness for granted. He hasnt been out injured for about . .fuck knows, has he ever been injured ?

Having a third choice goalie is not just an insurance policy against injuries.what about poor form ? I dont rate Howard that highly but having winessed Mucha throw the ball in when he was selected for a cup game, I`d have panicked if he was our last line of defence for any length of time - particularly given the form he was in.

Chances are your first choice Goalie will get injured, what if your second choice is going through a bit of a weston at the time ?

Luxury maybe, but one we have to have, its better to have a regular third choice keeper who trains with the team than to have to pin your hopes on a lone stand in who`s only available because nobody else wants him.
Paul David
113 Posted 20/05/2012 at 15:49:05
Dave

You miss the point. Any third choice keeper we have would only be with us because no-one else wants them as their number 1.

Except for the exception of a few clubs the standard of a number 2 or 3 will not be anywhere near as good as the number 1.

If we were in the situation of needing to bring in an emergency keeper, chances are they would not be inferior to any third choice keeper that was permanently on our books.

I've had enough of this one now and that's the last from me on this subject.
Eugene Ruane
114 Posted 20/05/2012 at 15:09:01
Kevin, I'M smoking crack?

Presumably you meant..

'Picture Eugene smoking crack - SEE he's smoking crack!'

Ok, to the chase, I'll PROVE your schtick is basically make up any old shite, pretend it's real, take it from there.

But hold on, can I REALLY prove this?

Well..I'm happy to let others decide.

So...

You (nb: YOU, not someone you've 'pictured') wrote...

"Well to cut to the mustard Eugene, Paul, Gavin etc...You're whinging now that we shouldn't have had a third choice goalie"

Right so far?

Ok - two things.

1) On this post I have not MENTIONED goalies/keepers.

2) On this post I have not COMMENTED on goalies/keepers.

Coaching..McFadden..you inventing bollocks, but NOTHING on whether we should have 2, 5 or 10 keepers.

- Allows time for you to read back, realise (AGAIN!) you've invented it -

Now imo, you have three choices.

1) Show me a post where I AM "whinging now that we shouldn't have had a third choice goalie"- thus proving I AM on crack

2) Do your usual an invent some shite justification that makes you right.

3) Accept that in trying to score 'points', you took your eye off the ball and fucked up.

Odds

1) 10,000/1

2) Evens

3) 10.000/1

By the way, the dwarf?

He (also) lives on Fantasy Island.
Dave Wilson
115 Posted 20/05/2012 at 16:00:54
Paul

Any emergency goalkeeper would only be available when nobody else wanted them, full stop.
Kevin Sparke
116 Posted 20/05/2012 at 16:12:03
Re Eugene's comment - can someone from the same planet explain what he's saying - because I've not got a scooby about what he's on about?

Tut tut Eugene - and to think you told a first time poster on another thread to treble his medication just because he had a different opinion than you - methinks you also need to up yours.

'Up yours' - fair comment methinks.
Eugene Ruane
117 Posted 20/05/2012 at 16:19:04
Wow Kevin, looking desperate (you are aware it's not just me and you reading this?)

And REALLY desperate - trying to muddy the waters with unrelated talk of first time posters (nb: who said they were 'proud we had Kenwright as chairman')

Stick to the point.

1, 2 or 3?



Ray Robinson
118 Posted 20/05/2012 at 17:16:06
Kevin #367, I'm already suffering withdrawal symptoms, so go on amuse me. Apart from Jennings (un-used), Baardsen, Westerveld and Turner/Ruddy (same match), when else have we employed a third string goalie? I've followed the Blues since 1961 but I can't remember any other examples. Don't mention Mick Lyons or Sandy Brown as they both donned the goalie's shirt due to there being no substitutes allowed.
Andy Walker
119 Posted 20/05/2012 at 17:05:30
Eugene do you think we should have 3 goalies or 2 in the squad?
Andy Walker
120 Posted 20/05/2012 at 17:25:14
should have said, I'd go with 3 on the basis that we're a top PL side regualarly challenging for Europe.
Eugene Ruane
121 Posted 20/05/2012 at 17:29:23
Andy - (sharp intake).

Hmmm...tricky question.

2 keepers or 3?

Twoooo or threeeeeee.

Hmmmmm...tough one, VERY tough.

I think if you PUSHED me...I mean If I was pushed into a corner so to speak, I would have to say..all things being equal....not to put too fine a point on it.....all things being considered.....not showing favour either way....to be COMPLETELY frank........and ernest.....TWO!

Or....three's fine as well.

Seriously If I gave a fuck either way, I'd have commented, as you can see, (despite what 'bright' Sparke lied) I didn't.

If we could afford three great, if not, I wouldn't lose a minute's kip.
Andy Walker
122 Posted 20/05/2012 at 18:34:11
Thats cleared that up then Eugene! Its a tough one isnt it, a call that a manager has to make. As some have said - I dont mean you - it is all so easy to make an argument for 2 or 3 after the event. Simply a judgement call that could be right or wrong.
Ian Bennett
123 Posted 20/05/2012 at 18:47:57
Ray - plenty should have been 3rd choice - Richard wright and Paul Gerard for starters.
Ray Robinson
124 Posted 20/05/2012 at 18:56:14
Ian - agreed, but that's not the point! They weren't. If a goalie is that bad, you'd hope to shift him, not keep the duffer and get another one in!

Kevin still hasn't responded re the multiple occasions when we actually NEEDED 3 goalies. If we needed 3 keepers (and there is an argument if the club is in Europe and/or if the club has oodles of money), why didn't we start the season with 3?

If Hahemann was deemed to be better than Mucha (again, this is possibly a valid argument), why wasn't he on the bench every week?

Whichever way I look at it, he was a waste of valuable money - as was McFadden.
Mick Davies
125 Posted 21/05/2012 at 05:07:45
McFadden being played kept younger players out of the side???? WTF, I think he played about an hour in all. He done more in his time at Everton, with match turning goals like away at Kharkov and at home to Charlton than that fucking waste of space Anichebe ever could.

If Moyes is keeping young players out of the side it's because he doesn't know what to do with them. round pegs don't go into round holes at our club. Long live Tony Hibbert, the only Walter Smithy left, and the reason why we'll never have a right side to match our left
Jason Lam
126 Posted 21/05/2012 at 06:45:36
Just place Jags in goal and you've got a bonus rushing sweeper. Plus all 3 centerbacks with first team appearances that can only be win-win for all. Howard up front he's got a goal in him.
Jim Harrison
127 Posted 21/05/2012 at 18:34:00
If you think Everton are the only team making shit signings, check the BBC. QPR have just given Kieran Dyer a one year extension.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads