Moyes keen to keep hold of Cahill

, 23 May, 46comments  |  Jump to most recent
David Moyes sees Tim Cahill as a key component in his team and if his comments prior to the win over Newcastle are any indication, he won't be in any hurry to let the Australian go amid speculation that Saudi club Al Nassr could make a bid for his services.

For the first time since joining the Blues from Millwall in 2004, Cahill struggled for form and goals at times this season, leading some to wonder if he would either seek a new challenge elsewhere.

Press speculation this week suggests that uber-wealthy Al Nassr are keen to capitalise on the 32-year-old's profile in Asia by tempting him with big money to play in the Middle East but prising him away from Moyes won't be easy.

?He's fit, he's athletic, he can do several jobs for us,? said Moyes earlier this month.

?There'll be a time when we have to move on and that will evolve, but not at the moment.

?I think he's still got a two or three-year contract and he'll still be a big part of what we do.?

Quotes or other material sourced from Liverpool Echo



Reader Comments (46)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Mathew McKay
1 Posted 23/05/2012 at 18:11:00
?There'll be a time when we have to move on and that will evolve, but not at the moment."

Errr... I don't think there's any better time for our time to move on and evolve, than now.
Tom Dodds
2 Posted 23/05/2012 at 18:16:09
Still a big part ??Take it Pienaar`s a done deal then ?
Denis Richardson
3 Posted 23/05/2012 at 18:12:05
I really dont understand this. The guy has been a great servant to the club in the past but has been lacking any sort of form since the end of 2010!

He's one of the top earners at the club and will turn 33 later this year. For a club that has little money and needs to lower the wage bill as well as the average age, this is just a ridiculous (and frankfly depressing)statement to read.

If (however it may happen) we do actually add to the squad in the summer, Cahill will not be a regular starter so we're going to have a really expensive player simply warming the bench most games. Surely Cahills wages could help pay for Pienaar, if we manage to sign him.

I really hope Cahill takes a bumber pay cheque if offered and leaves with the fans blessing, rather than milking 2.5m from the club sat on the bench most of the year.

I fear one of Moyes failings is knowing when to let go of players. Then again, with the likes of Macfadden and Hahnemann last season, I guess we've got money to burn when it comes to wages!
Wayne Smyth
4 Posted 23/05/2012 at 18:13:44
Although cahill gives 100% effort in every game, you don't win games through just effort. Cahill hasn't contributed enough in this last season in goals, assists or general play to deserve his spot in the 11.

On that basis and because he's only getting older, if a decent offer does come in we should definitely take it. We can't afford to have a player earning £50k / week - or whatever he's paid - and have that player not making a big contribution.

...and Moyes can't complain about lack of funds, while doggedly keeping hold of his loyal, but ageing and underperforming players in the face of external interest.
James Stewart
5 Posted 23/05/2012 at 18:41:23
That time is now. We are not a club that can afford to have benchwarmers earning what he does.
Aayush Jain
6 Posted 23/05/2012 at 18:51:58
Agree with all your comments but he does have a great profile in Asia...is probably our only Player garnering support from overseas(apart frm Donovan of course)....i dunno...maybe we could profit from keeping him if only for his image
Richard Reeves
7 Posted 23/05/2012 at 18:55:46
If Moyes isn't carefull he could ruin the relationship between fan and player.The time is now but as i've said before the chance of Moyes seeing this is non-existant.
Jon Beck
8 Posted 23/05/2012 at 19:16:14
Whether there are genuine offers for his services and whether he stays or goes, Moyes is surely right to ensure he doesn't go cheaply is he not? Given this, I'd hardly expect him to say "he's finished, come and get him", would you?
Brian Williams
9 Posted 23/05/2012 at 19:22:29
John Beck you beat me to it!

Moyes states he's an integral part of our set-up, which sends the message that we don't want to sell (even if we do) and the Saudi's have to think about coughing up!

What else was he supposed to say?
Edward Robinson
10 Posted 23/05/2012 at 19:29:34
Moyes is praising up Cahill, saying he doesn't want him to go simply because the Saudis want him for nothing on a free when he still has a couple of years left on his contract.
I'm sure if they came waving the cheque book (or CASH!) with maybe £5million, his feet wouldn't touch the ground!
Anthony Flack
11 Posted 23/05/2012 at 19:46:20
Spot on nothing else Moyes can say. On a lighter note reminds me of when some numpties paid £3m to us for Marcus Bent, quite a few wondered if they had the right Bent.... - maybe the Arabs have the wrong Cahill.....personally I think he is great, but would chop off the hand that has a wedge of cash if it ever comes off
Joe McMahon
12 Posted 23/05/2012 at 19:45:54
He's had his day, including him in the starting 11 limits us too much. He's a massive earner (by our standards).
We have to move on 4 - 5 - 1 and 2004 was a long time ago.
Aidy Dews
13 Posted 23/05/2012 at 19:40:58
I get what your saying Jon #302, Brian #308 & Edward #310 but i do think that Moyes genuinely still sees Cahill as an important player to Everton and doesnt want to sell, i really do.

Even when he's been dog shit and not contributed with goals Moyes as always kept on saying how important he is and that he'll find his form etc, etc but he never did, he had spells where he played well and got a goal or 2 but he never hit great heights and unfortunately Cahill is on the decline.

He's been a brilliant signing for us but there always comes a time when you part ways and look to move forward and if the Saudi's are daft enough to bid silly money for him then i do think we need to seriously consider selling Cahill.

But i do genuinely feel that Moyes sees Cahill as still an important player for us and isnt ready to drop him, let alone sell him.
Edward Robinson
14 Posted 23/05/2012 at 20:28:21
On a "lighter" (or maybe not ?) note, I wish that someone would come for Victor!
I do feel sorry for him but he is not what we want!
Peter Healing
15 Posted 23/05/2012 at 20:51:21
In Allah's name, go. Get someone in who will contribute
John Daley
17 Posted 23/05/2012 at 21:35:04
"Moyes is praising up Cahill, saying he doesn't want him to go simply because the Saudis want him for nothing on a free when he still has a couple of years left on his contract. "

No, he isn't. The comments from Moyes were made at the beginning of this month, before any rumoured interest in Cahill.

Moyes truly believes in Cahill and will continue to do so despite all evidence pointing to his increasing innefectiveness and despite what anyone else says. His loyalty to his stalwarts is only strengthened by his stubbornness.

The qoute from Moyes used above actually began with the telling line "Tim's been the mainstay of the way we?ve played." and then continues, "There?ll be a time when we have to move on and that will evolve, but not at the moment."

So, key man for the manager once again next season it seems.

Bobby Thomas
19 Posted 23/05/2012 at 21:37:45
I wouldn't underestimate how much Moyes may value having Cahill around the place, in the dressing room etc. I'm not saying it's the only reason to keep him, but it may be consideration when he says hes a big part of what we do.

Like when Phil Neville was brought in, I think one of the main factors was to raise standards, professionalism and work ethic at the club. He's part of the fabric and the way Moyes does things. To be fair, he does seem very, very good with the other players and would be very good in the dressing room.

Can only guess obviously, but I'd imagine he is fantastic with the younger players as well. He has a great attitude to the game, great to play with, horrible to play against. When he was at his best anyway. Lately he's turned into a serial free-kick conceding liability!! He's also loyal, genuine and will play anywhere. He was probably too genuine at the start of this season for example.

He's the finish however, no doubt. This is a very, very big season for Cahill. Moyes could do with playing him less so, when he plays him, he's sharp and can get some of that fizz back. Very much a sharpness, aggression and energy player is Cahill. Without that, there ain't much. We need to, have to, change.

Larry Bird
20 Posted 23/05/2012 at 21:55:53
Cahill has been an absolute legend for Everton for 8 years now. Some of the "fans" on here are the most fickle I have ever seen. If Cahill goes best of luck to him, he owes us absolutely nothing. If he stays then I for one will back him 110%. He's a blue through and through.
Mike Green
21 Posted 23/05/2012 at 22:07:51
You're right Larry, he's been a credit to himself and the club and put his heart and soul into it. At some point his usefulness will wane and I think now the balance has tipped. Happy to see him as a squad player, involved, but if he gets a better offer then he can go with an ovation. Hall of Famer for me.
Ciarán McGlone
22 Posted 23/05/2012 at 22:11:25
John Daley.

Spot on. Moyes can't tell when a player's time is up.

Paul Brannan
23 Posted 23/05/2012 at 22:31:18
You moan about loyalty from players but when it suits you want to drop them like hot snot.
John Tyrrell
24 Posted 23/05/2012 at 23:25:34
Larry, Mike I agree with you both. Cahill has been brilliant for us. I now think he is more a squad player than the first 11 he was. So if someone came in with a good offer I would let him go, but would also be happy to see him stay.
Kase Chow
25 Posted 23/05/2012 at 23:43:55
Just a thought: is it possible that to get the best outta Cahill now, given his age, is to use him sparingly e.g. Like Scholes/Giggs?

If so, maybe he can return to his best form for say 20-25 games rather than poor form for 40-45 games?

We still need a replacement tho. Perhaps Moyes sees the ability to push Fellaini up as a similar tactic to what Citeh do with Yaya Toure?

Like I said, just a thought...

Ernie Baywood
26 Posted 24/05/2012 at 01:07:07
Is this journalism? A potential bid surfaces and they rebuff it by dragging out some quotes from before the Newcastle game.

What did they think he'd say before a game? "Och, Tim's had a fucking shocker this year".

James Wilson
27 Posted 24/05/2012 at 01:48:55
Okay, all you people saying "let him go," he has been good for us since he has been there, he is having a rough patch and you wanna let him go.

Real loyal!

Anto Byrne
28 Posted 24/05/2012 at 01:58:16
Moyes, true to form, wants his favorites (yes-men). Moyes and Cahill should GO! This group of players can play football as witnessed in the last weeks of the season but could not beat Wolves nor Stoke when they were there for the taking.

Let's not forget the dirge of dire dross served up for seven months of the season. Let's not forget the negative, crab football, let's not forget the unwillingness to have a go and the six straight losses we endured at season start that saw us nailed to fourth bottom.

When it was patently obvious that Saha and Cahill were no longer cutting it with one goal between them in 30 odd games, he just persisted and persisted while he kept Drenthe on the bench and Stracq in cotton wool. His demeanor, attitude was negative and for me he had run his race.

Just as Moyes took a punt on Cahill in 2004 he took a punt on Jelavic (I don't remember there being this mad rush for this guy by all the top teams). An unproven Premier League player? Well, not now... and now worth five times what we paid for him.

Gibson on a free (or reportedly £500k) was another punt, and one wonders why SAF preferred Scoles over him?

We knew what we were getting with Donovan but second time around seemed like an act of desperation and of course we all know how good Pienaar is linking with up with Baines. That was a gamble but one worth taking; it's just a pity we sold him in the first place.

Selling Arteta and the Yak was good business and fully justified, while bringing in McFadden and Hahnemann to warm the bench and exile young players like Vellios and Barkey to youth sides makes no sense. Vellios was the leading scorer at one stage and given his ability and flair (from what I saw any way) should have been playing with Jelavic even off the bench. Never happened as the rigid 4-5-1 does not allow two natural strikers on the pitch at the same time.

Big Vic looks the goods as an out-and-out centre forward and can score but is not a winger or wide player and is another round peg in a square hole. Hoof-ball has its place as a tactic all teams use it even City and Utd... not sure where I'm going with this so I will stop this ramble here.
Tim Brashar
29 Posted 24/05/2012 at 04:39:25
James #385 makes a good point.

It's probably already been discussed on other threads in the past, but it seems that loyalty has no place in the modern era of professional football.

Moyes loyalty to players (Cahill, Osman, Hibbert, Neville), the chairman and the club is constantly portayed as heinous by many.

Re: Cahill, I absolutely love him, love his absolute and unrelenting passion for the club, and have him on the back of almost all of my jerseys. But I agree that his best days for Everton are behind him. I think he should leave the club when he wants to though and on his terms.

With loyalty and fans, my view is that fans fall into 3 categoreis:

1) Fans who understand the professional nature of the game and are ok with players leaving the club to chase money or trophies.

2) Fans who value loyalty greatly and hate when players leave for other clubs for money or trophies. These fans however stick by their players during tough patches and do not cry out about how sh*t the former legend is and how the sooner we get rid of their nuisance the better.

3) Fans who crucify players leaving our club for lack of loyalty but in the same breath want to hastily turf out players who have given their all for the club over many years coz they are having a bad trot.

I know you can't pigeon hole every fan into one of those 3 categories, but I consider myself to be in category one. I won't begrudge a player leaving the club to chase money or trophies, and always wish them well when they have given 100% of themselves to Everton during their time here.

And although I love TC and always will (it feels like I'm giving away my beloved first car again) I think it's time he made way for the next generation of great blues coming through.

Peter Bourke
30 Posted 24/05/2012 at 07:26:23
Tim #388.
Interesting post and hard to disagree with your logic. I suppose I would be somewhere between 1 and 2. I have seen plenty of catagory 3 on these pages but I suppose everyone supports in their own way.
What you say about Tim is true and in the modern game he has conducted himself in an exemplery manner and deserves the highest praise. Even though there are some sensible discussions regarding Tim, it does hurt to see him slagged of by some. Thankfully they are in the minority.
Jason Heng
31 Posted 24/05/2012 at 07:34:03
Moyes is saying to the Saudis - "Buy the club if you want Cahill".
Matt Traynor
32 Posted 24/05/2012 at 07:44:33
Jason, the true value of the club is probably less than Cahill's.
Thomas Windsor
33 Posted 24/05/2012 at 08:20:16
Always enjoyed Cahill at Everton but his time as a first teamer has ended a good move away better for Tim and Everton
Jelaviv needs a good forward to play alongside so all the money ha ha - we will get to spend this summer must go on a forward
Andy Meighan
34 Posted 24/05/2012 at 08:27:48
Larry #343,

I wouldn't go as far to say Cahill has been a legend. He's been a great servant and a good player but that's as far as it goes. Moyes says he could do several jobs for us ? I'd like to know what they are because he couldn't play wide (no pace); couldn't play centre-midfield (no creativity, can't tackle)... so I'm baffled to know what roles these are he's talking about.

People say there's no loyalty in football... There is if you play for Everton and are one of Moyes's babes because you'll have a job for life ? Moyes's words, not mine. And as for being Blue through and through, not true; he's never actually paid to see an Everton game in his life, and probably never will.

No Larry, it's us mugs that are Blue through and through.
Eric Myles
35 Posted 24/05/2012 at 10:56:36
Think of the player Moyes.

Let him go and get a bumper pay day that you can't give him and use the saved wages to make sure we secure Pienaar.

Jim Knightley
36 Posted 24/05/2012 at 11:31:28
Firstly, don't assume Moyes means what he says. I cant believe how often people on Toffeeweb take statements at face value, when football talk is as much smoke and mirrors as anything else. There is no way that Moyes is going to come out and say: Cahill is no longer of use, we are willing to let him go. He still has a long contract and might not attract any offers and as has been pointed out on multiple occasions, he has been a loyal servant.

If Cahll does stay, he will benefit from a summer's rest. Clearly he has played too many games over the past couple of years, and at his age, needs to be used more sparingly. I think that, with a good summer's rest, we could see a Cahill who will score 8/9 Premierleague goals for us next season, and once more be a vital player, both for the first 11 and squad. If we got an offer, I would reluctantly let him go; if he doesnt leave, he will still be a valuable player.

Please stop all this 'Moyes favorites' crap. Don't assume that was Moyes says and does will be the same thing. Do his comments re. safety and seventh as not good enough reconcile? no, because the private and public are, and will always be, different things.

Tony J Williams
37 Posted 24/05/2012 at 11:51:03
If you listen really carefully, somewhere in the world Dave Wilson's head is exploding after reading the title of this thread.
Denis Richardson
38 Posted 24/05/2012 at 12:01:39
Jim - if we're not supposed to comment on public statements then wtf else do we have to talk about? Obviously a lot of it is bollocks, especially from the Mail, Mirror, Sun, [add any other tabloid] but there is no other information available to us and its the silly season so why can't we comment?

Re Cahill you can't have it both ways, either we're poor and need to maximise our money and try to lower the average age (i.e. not pay an ageing player 50k a week who has had no form for 1.5 years and take a complete punt that he finds his form again approaching his 33rd b'day), or we're not and we happily keep the Everton family together and let the likes of Neville, Cahill, Distin etc carry on playing until they decide its time to ride into the sunset.

Am all for allowing a top servant of the club to decide when they should/can go but the cost has to be realistic. Fact is, for 50k a week we can get a player that is going to be better than Cahill and possibly have some resale value.

It cuts both ways, Cahill owes the club nothing as he's given a great long service to it. However, on the other hand the club owes him nothing as its made him a multi millionaire over the years and given him the platform to reach the level he has. I think that you can say that for practically every footballer - no prem league club owes any player anything. They are being given an opportunity to literally live their dream and be made extremely wealthy at the same time. (Not saying that in a bitter sense, simply that the fact). So I have no issue with letting him go if the saved cash can be put to better use. Every player has a use by date.

James Wilson
39 Posted 24/05/2012 at 12:46:49
Tim Brashar #388

If loyalty has no place in the game, then why do players stay? I'm pretty sure that even you would have had a problem with Gosling and Pienaar not signing and leaving for much less than we deserved for them, so shouldn't it go both ways?

Yeah, okay, Moyes might have favourites but there isn't too many options left for him; Neville and Hibbert are the only two right backs and Osman is really the only option for right wing... Yeah, okay, everyone saying to play Vellios and Barkley, we don't see them at training, we don't know everything. We came 7th so how about we have a little more faith in Moyes?

Jimmy Sørheim
40 Posted 24/05/2012 at 12:58:46
I have been a fan of Cahill for a long time.
Now, he is 32 and he is still playing for Austrailia.
To me it is simple, if Cahill can start by only playing for us, then I would keep him.

The problem is Cahill is being destroyed by these stupid friendlies.
Moyes said it last summer, Cahill needs to quit his Aisia tours or he needs to be sold.

Cahill has been poor for a long time, so unless Cahill leaves Austrailia then he is no good to us.

Moyes should force Cahill to choose, it is the only way forward.
Moyes neeeds to play hardball.

Jimmy Kelly
41 Posted 24/05/2012 at 13:31:45
So, when Moyes makes negative noises about players ability - 'knives to a gunfight' etc - he gets castigated but when he makes positive noises about them - 'cahill isn't finished' - he... also gets castigated.

He really can't win can he?

Jim Knightley
42 Posted 24/05/2012 at 15:27:50
Agreed, Cahill needs to stop playing for his country ideally...It is hard, but playing in the Premier league and for Australia at 32 is a big ask.

Denis, when did I say don't comment on them? don't misread me, I am merely pointing our how benign it is to take comments at face value, and then use them to launch attacks on the management. Throughout the summer we get comments such as these, outlining the use of a player before letting him leave.

Ciarán McGlone
43 Posted 24/05/2012 at 16:37:00
"I cant believe how often people on ToffeeWeb take statements at face value"


Followed swifly by...


"Don't misread me"


That's a cracker...as dear old Frank would've said.

Denis Richardson
44 Posted 24/05/2012 at 17:47:15
Sorry Jim - jumped the gun there.....to be honest I've never been a massive Cahill fan. I appreciiate the effort he puts in when he's picked but let be fair, as far as footballing ability is concerned he was always pretty average.

I think that our style of play would hav

Denis Richardson
45 Posted 24/05/2012 at 17:50:49
e been a lot different had we mixed it up a bit with other (more creative) players playing in the number 10 role. So if another club come calling, I would say thanks for the effort but time for new blood...
Wayne Smyth
46 Posted 24/05/2012 at 20:17:15
How does anyone know the people talking about "lack of player loyalty" are the same people asking for Cahill to be sold?

Can't speak for anyone else, but my position is quite clear:

We are skint.
We can't afford to pay any player £50k / week without getting a decent return on the pitch.

Its all well and good saying that he should be played sparingly to keep him fresh, but we'll still be paying him every week regardless.

Anyone who defends keeping someone who consistently underpeforms at the club on high wages need never complain that Kenwright isn't putting money in or finding investment. If I was Chairman and that was how my cash was being spent, I'd not put any in either.

It would be great to keep Cahill on till he was 40 and pay him £50k / week just because he's a top bloke, but sadly we have short arms and deep pockets.

Tim Brashar
47 Posted 25/05/2012 at 04:51:20
James Wilson #437

I think players stay with clubs because they are on a good wicket.

During contract periods, small differentials on pay offers from other clubs might be turned down because a player & his family are settled in a city/club.

But when it comes time for contract renewal, I think most players will happily switch clubs for more moola. And so they should. Again if the moola is only slightly different I think they might stay at a club - that is the modern era display of loyalty.

Yes I was disappointed when Pienaar & Gosling left Everton, but I didn't hold it against either player and wished them well.

My personal opinion is that you can't have it both ways with your position on loyalty. Either you:

1) Consider players as the commodities they are in the modern game and happily buy/let them go when it suits you without begrudging the players; or

2) You despise players who cut and run to other clubs, but at the same time you stick by players going through a bad trot or nearing the end of their careers.

But again, I don't think it is as black and white as that because emotion inevitably gets invloved, and to be in category 1) (which I consider myself) and not be passionate or emotional over players would be sad.

Peter Barry
48 Posted 25/05/2012 at 05:26:52
@ Larry Bird # 343 Larry there have hundreds of players who have been Everton Legends and given service to Everton longer and greater than that of Tim Cahill. So is your contention that just because a player is 'Legend' and has been here a LONG TIME that we must ignore the fact that for TWO SEASONS he has not performed and continue paying him the high wages that we do? That is the logic of RELEGATION.

Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads