Season › 2011-12 › News
Cold water poured on Baines reports
Speculation in The Mirror earlier this week, fueled by matching reports in the Daily Mail, claimed that United chief, David Gill, had held talks with Bill Kenwright regarding an initial offer for the England left back.
But Everton have apparently rejected the speculation and sources in Manchester deny that any approach has been made, reinforcing a tweet by BBC Chief Sports Writer, Phil McNulty, to that effect yesterday.
Additionally, it is believed that the Blues have not lodged any inquiry for Kieran Richardson.
Reports had suggested that David Moyes had made his interest in the 27-year-old known with Sunderland.
Quotes or other material sourced from Liverpool Echo
Reader Comments (16)
Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer
2 Posted 24/05/2012 at 22:22:55
And so did we.
Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying supporters believed all the lies and (as in this case) the club didn't let it go without ANY response.
But..is that enough?
I mean imagine the headline tomorrow..
"Ronaldo on his way back to Utd!"
The paper is bought by every Utd supporter in the UK who reads..
"A source close the the Real Madrid star say bollocks wank shite.." etc.
Two days later Utd '(like us) pour cold water' blah
How the fuck is that not fraud?
If we (football supporters and..erm..everyone else) want to see and end to TOTALLY INVENTED SHITE, something (other than tutting and shaking our heads) needs to be done
Personally, I would love Everton to hold a press conference alerting the media with 'this is going to be BIG'.
Then when Sky and the rest assemble, tell them simply..
"We think the world should know that staff at The Daily Mirror Newspaper (Mail, Sun, whoever) have been involved in a paedo ring" etc etc.
Let it explode, then let them scream and carry on for a day or so, then explain..
"Every time a complete, 100% lie is published about our club in this newspaper, we intend to respond in kind".
Every club does that and in two weeks, they're fucked.
4 Posted 25/05/2012 at 07:59:09
5 Posted 25/05/2012 at 09:43:10
6 Posted 25/05/2012 at 10:18:28
It's all bollocks but then the Mail is the biggest-hitting news site in the world. Cue, 'Kim Kardashian's arse set to replace entire Everton backline'.
7 Posted 25/05/2012 at 09:59:13
It's funny, The NOTW was the biggest selling Sunday Paper for 140 years or whatever and certainly for the last 40 of those years, the percentage of invented bullshit contained within it's pages was almost certainly huge.
Yet...people didn't seem to care either way.
As for the legal side of things, I'm not so sure (nb. really, so below is all guesswork)
I actually believe they get away with what they do because they're not pushed.
My guess is, under the law, (using my Utd-Ronaldo example) if there was no (reasonable!) doubt about what the paper was IMPLYING (rather than actually stating), I think they could be in deep shit.
Certainly loads of advertising ends up being pulled because of what is implied rather than actually said.
Plus I think many slander and libel cases stand or fall depending on what it's decided the implication was/is.
The only way we'd know for sure though is for Utd (or anyone) to bring it to court.
The defence could only really say to the Jury..
"My client didn't ACTUALLY say this, it was stated by a source and unfortunately, that source can't be revealed"
The prosecution in reply would simply have to hold up the offending copy, showing the headline "Ronaldo on his way back to Utd!" and ask the jury..
"Both Manchester United and the player refute the notion that anyone had met, or spoken, or even THOUGHT about such a move. All concerned deny it TOTALLY. Given this, and the undoubted money that was made as a result of what we now know to be - and let's call it what it is - pure and TOTAL invention - do you think there is even the SLIGHTEST chance the intention of The Daily Trousers was something OTHER than deception and fraud?"
(be good to have a lawyer give a hint on how it all/actually works)
8 Posted 25/05/2012 at 11:06:26
I might be wrong, but I don't think there is any legaislation specifically for publishing false or misleading stories. Other wise fiction books would be in a tad of bother.
Generally, papers are only held to account under libel laws. In the case mentioned above, I think it would be difficult to argue that anyone has been slighted to any real degree.
Sadly, its not worth the time nor cost in most cases just to make a point. I'd rather EFC were focussing on the pitch rather than trying to take a newspaper to court.
9 Posted 25/05/2012 at 11:16:05
The press construct lies every day...the amount of times I've had my dad ring me saying 'who is this guy we are signing' because the Daily Mail or another similar publication has published some shit. When it comes to what it is believable, it goes -
That Toffeeweb guy with inside information....
Twitter,
Newspapers (Guardian are more reliable...and the telegraph and to a lesser extent, the times, but they still publish lies)
Sky Sports (alot of false rubbish, but they have some good inside info, and often are the first to break news). And then the BBC. believe it if it is on the BBC, doubt it everywhere else.
The Newspaper guess....it is an educated guess, sometimes with authenticity, but nonetheless is often a guess. Man U may want to buy Baines, but as I said on the another thread, consider this -
United Must buy a top CM, and another striker. At LB they have probaly the third best lb in the league, and a very talented young and upcoming player. Why would they spend 15mil (or more) of their budget on a position they have an experienced French international in?
We can all guess....
I will guess that Van Persie will leave Arsenal, Modric will leave Spurs, Kalou will go to Arsenal, Chelsea will buy Hulk...etc etc. I also think we will get a significant offer for one of our top players...but imo it is more likely to be Heitinga(1) or Fellaini (2) than Baines. And I really really hope we get Pienarr back.
And yeah, Gossip is fun. The only annoying thing for an Everton fan, and for us regulars on the generally knowledgable Toffeeweb, we know our financial position as well as or better than any mainstream journalist. So when we are linked with buying Dempsey for 7million, or some random french striker for 10mil, we can't enjoy it because we know it's shit. But we have to sit through all the converse stories, about losing our best players, which are completely believable or maybe completely unbelievable...but nonetheless slightly feared because of our financial situation.
Apart of me wishes the Baines interest was true...not because even a tiny part of me wants him to go...but just so we don't have to sit through the rest of the Summer wondering how we are going to buy Pienarr and who will be sold to appease the bank and buy a creative player.
(Although in my ideal world we sell Jags for 10mil to Spurs or Newcastle...)
10 Posted 25/05/2012 at 11:48:17
I actually wouldnt be surprised if this happened.The whole world can see utd's midfield needs adding to it and i'm sure that will be a priority for them but would a £15m plus (I would want at least £20m) bid for Baines really be out the question?
You have to remember they would recoup a large chuck of what they spent by selling Evra,especially if PSG came in for him.
11 Posted 25/05/2012 at 11:20:49
I also agree that it would be hard to show anyone had been slighted to any degree by the claim.
However there are other reasons besides 'my feelings were hurt' as to why these (ie: slander/libel) cases take place.
Most obviously, for business reasons.
That (for example) because of a lie someone tells ABOUT me, others don't want to do business with me.
Now I don't think this reasoning applies (well..not exactly) in this case, but if I was running Everton, or any other club, I would not want my (often not particularly bright players) reading/believing what are complete lies and then secretly running to their agents saying "well if HE'S going...." etc.
Yes this example IS an exaggeration and not very likely and I absolutely wouldn't expect Everton alone to be fighting the media.
However, If ALL the PL clubs benefited from the absence of invented stories, surely it would not be too hard for them to agree a combined ban on an individual paper for 'blatant 100% lies' against one of their members.
The fact is - "Dimchester Wednesday's 50-goal hotshot striker, Trent Bell, to sign for Althorpe Athletic for 100m!!" could ONLY be interpreted as fiction"
But could - "Bye bye Baines: Man Utd have opened talks with Everton over 12m move for England full-back" be taken as anything other than factual?
Personally I don't mind them printing 'junk', I mean if people want to read about Jordan's wedding or see pictures of Brad Pitt drinking a latté 4 miles away, fine.
For me though, pure invention about REAL people is different and should be subject to.....well.....erm.....some fucking thing.
And one thing I know for sure, if you want change you make change.
12 Posted 25/05/2012 at 12:08:19
I don't neccessarily disagree. Personally I don't read the papers anymore and I feel quite sad sometimes that people do seem to lap it all up. Some of stuff I've read in the papers when I have known the truth to be the complete opposite is quite unbelievable at times.
But as much as the occasional club might be slighted, generally I would imagine the clubs are happy gaining the benefit when the shoe is on the other foot. Whether its the media complaining about a refereeing decision, helping tap up a player, or playing mind games with the opposition.
In some cases, I'm not the newspapers are to blame. It's just as likely to be the agents trying to engineer moves and more fee's.
13 Posted 25/05/2012 at 12:12:36
He had a meeting with the journo, and got paid £2k for this snippet. He told us the day before it was published.
The story was indeed splashed over the back pages the next day. Just goes to prove they will put any load of bollocks in the paper to fill the back pages.
And if you met our kid ? there is evidence they must be more gullible than old grannies!
14 Posted 25/05/2012 at 12:18:30
Now that they can't illegally get news stories from peoples voicemails, they probably have to listen to random sources about potential transfers. Hell, they probably check forums like this, pick up the odd snippet then report it as a rumour.
To be honest, I would imagine that being a journo on a paper is pretty boring, sitting at a desk all day wondering where your next story is going to come from. As I doubt you can phone up Alex ferguson and ask him.
When you look at it, it really isn't so surprising the junk that is out there.
15 Posted 25/05/2012 at 12:24:06
£2k?
Wheres the phone?
16 Posted 25/05/2012 at 12:39:12
God help me, but I'm going to admit this publicly on TW... I'm a journalist. So, I'll try to clear up at least the legal side of the papers' transfer 'stories'.
Yes, the majority are made up. In among them are the occasional true stories, based on off-the-record briefings from the club, player or agent. They are written, as is pretty obvious, because footie fans love the gossip - if you look at the readership both online and offline, a good transfer story will boost readership figures.
Are they legally allowed to do this? Yes. There's actually no law to say that any newspaper need fill its pages with anything other than tripe.
If there were, how do you think the Sunday Sport with its London Bus Found On Moon stories managed to survive for so long?
The reason good journalism survives is because it is based on evidence gained by good journos, and that evidence is published as part of the story.
Transfer stories are bad journalism written by bad journos because they never need to produce any evidence in the story - but they are not illegal.
The only time a sports journo would be in trouble with one of the transfer stories is if the story libelled an individual or club. Saying a player may be moving from one club to another is not libellous - it doesn't damage the reputation of the player (more often than not it enhances it) and usually enhances reputation of buying club. Saying a club may be willing to sell a player is not libellous - it's a natural business transaction for a football club.
Now, if the story read: Leighton Baines may be joining Utd this summer for £12m ... because Blues owner Bill Kenwright is a bit short of holiday cash and wants to embezzle the money so he can treat his wife to a 5-star jaunt around the Caribbean... THAT would be libellous.
Odious as it may be, there is nothing to stop the papers producing made-up transfer tales. You can either choose to believe them or not.
As an aside, in terms of libel, ToffeeWeb consistently has comments and articles about Bill Kenwright and the Everton board that could be argued to be libellous. The only reason TW is not hauled up in front of a judge is that it really wouldn't be in Blue Bill's interests to take such action. But, if he wanted to, he probably could.
17 Posted 25/05/2012 at 18:36:37
Paul, the Baines deal is by no means out of the question...but it is still unlikely imo. If it comes to fruition, these rumours were still clearly constructed and the fee arbitrarily designed. Whilst Man United may replace Baines with Evra, I would expect this to happen next season, as Evra clearly is still playing at a really high level, and United will not receive very much for an ageing Evra. It will also be a risk swapping one for the other, and not a guarantee of improvement considering Evra's superior experience of the big matches and the minor disparity between the players. (I prefer Baines of course though).
Not to say I don't consider it a possibility though...but I reckon they will tie up the more important business of the midfield (and if they get Hazard...and a cm, they wont be left with much in the way of budget)
Add Your Comments
In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.
Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.
1 Posted 24/05/2012 at 22:16:35
Where's Judge Leveson when you need him?