The shirt off your back

, 3 June, 34comments  |  Jump to most recent
This article by KEIOC asks some serious questions about the impact of outsourcing the Kitbag deal, the terms of which severely limit the availability of Everton mechandise and act as a throttle on one of the club's primary revenue streams.

Quotes or other material sourced from Keeping Everton in Our City



Reader Comments (34)

Note: the following content is not moderated or vetted by the site owners at the time of submission. Comments are the responsibility of the poster. Disclaimer


Kieran Fitzgerald
1 Posted 03/06/2012 at 08:52:52
You really do have to wonder if we actually employ people such as accountants, marketing directors, people with business degrees and such like at all? I know it's true to a large extent that the Board isn't up to the task but surely there are properly qualified heads of department and senior officials at the club who are employed to professionally run the club on a day to day basis. You would think that there would be weekly staff meetings or such like where they sit down and discuss all the figures and facts and business strategies that KEIOC and Blue Union can spell out in such obvious detail. Why can't they see what everyone else can see? Does anyone running the club actually raise these issues or come up with a better plan. It just seems to me that the club's complete administration is made up of kids on their gap year and fans like me who can just about manage to keep the balance on his credit card to under a grand.
Steve Cotton
2 Posted 03/06/2012 at 08:57:27
Absolutely disgraceful if these figures are even close to the mark. LFC are boosted each season by £25M towards their players fund while we get just £650k ? this means we can never ever compete in the commercial world while we are being handcuffed to this appalling arrangement.

Let's say we were able to bring in the average of £6M a year then there is the basis for team improvement without BB having to put his hands in is pockets at all.

Small club mentality with small club leadership will get us nowhere. Someone needs to get this sorted out or the person who put it in place should be sacked for gross incompetence... or both!

Kieran Fitzgerald
3 Posted 03/06/2012 at 09:08:18
When you see what we could be making, we would be giving ourselves so much more in terms of financial options. We wouldn't be operating at a loss. We wouldn't be under such pressure to sell our best players, we would be keeping the banks a little bit further away. It really is amazing how short sighted and amatuerishly the club is being ran.
Dan San
4 Posted 03/06/2012 at 09:18:17
Nike Everton Kit ? tick!!

End of the day, the reality is that 80% of the world's population probably wear copies of football kits and it's fair to say the the old 'Coq' hasn't got much further east than its native France... Everton is massively under-represented in Asia despite Li Tie, Chang and all our youth projects out there, while other clubs that have Nike shirts are everywhere.

Personally, I think an extra tenner for a Nike kit I will pay, though I would hope it goes to the club. I definitely feel that on the whole, and especially bearing in mind the search for a new owner, a Nike kit will pay more dividends in marketing opportunities than the Le Coq ever could, despite their impressive efforts at the recent launches etc. Every cool Kid, Player and Dude wants to wear Nike, this will matter a lot in places where you choose your team on whether they're cool or not... We all know Everton are the coolest but try explaining that to somebody in Outer Mongolia, I reckon that with the tick it will now be an easier task.

I don't think we've gone for the most lucrative offer on the table ? more the one that gives the club a good profile; I have no complaints about that.

Denis Richardson
5 Posted 03/06/2012 at 09:45:19
Kieran, thats why most people simply want the current board and management replaced with competant people, as opposed to necessarily having a sale of the club (although unfortunately the two are interlinked). We don't necessarily need a sugar daddy (would be nice), a more professional set up, board and management would make an immediate difference.

Our relatively low commercial revenues have been known for a long while and go deeper than the kitbag deal. For example, not too long ago we had the captain of South Africa as we were approaching the world cup....in South Africa. Add to that the captain of Austrailia and Howard. We dont seem to have really made any use of these marketing opportunities.

Many people say that we can't do much as the stadium is a big problem, lack of corporate facilities etc. Whilst this may be true in parts, there seem to be so many basic things that could be done better and reading an article like this just makes you shake your head in wonder (again) as to how the people running the club ever got to that position in the first place.

I know someone who used to worked for Kenwright in his theatre business and they said that he was an absolute control freak who rarely let anyone else make any decisions. Given this, I lay the blame 100% at his door step for every lost opportunity and f'ck up at the club. Unfortunately, as long as he 'controls' 50+% of the voting rights, there is not much we can do and until the team on the pitch performs really poorly, the majority of Everton fans will remain apathetic and/or ignorant to these kind of things.

There is no idiot out there who is either going to pay a stupid price to buy the club or provide 'investment' without getting control. Therefore we're stuck where we are for the foreseeable future. Kenwright simply isn't going anywhere soon and as long as we continue finishing in the top 10, most fans don't seem to really care.

Bob Willis
6 Posted 03/06/2012 at 10:14:06
Very sad reading.

I was under the impression that this new Nike deal was to be a defining moment in our marketing opportunities notably in the USA, when Donovan returns to these shores and dons on the Everton kit.

Seems that all we are going to benefit by is a paltry sum which at best will go towards a few months of his wages.

Matt Traynor
7 Posted 03/06/2012 at 10:23:42
This is a thought provoking piece, although I don't necessarily agree with all the sentiments expressed.

A point I've been hammering home about one of the reasons why EFC is an attractive proposition to buyers (at the right price, so end of that discussion) is that the piss poor commercial exploitation (ha!) is one of many un-tapped revenue streams.

But given that most of the tapped revenue streams have been borrowed against, we're stuck with Kim Jong Bill.

Joey Brown
8 Posted 03/06/2012 at 10:40:21
Here I was in my happy disillusion that we'd get a few players in, have a go at Europe and a Cup run and maybe the money would sort itself out. It really is upsetting that the people that run the club we all love so much, probably can't pay their own bills.

The issues with this club lie the secretive nature in which the club is run and the fact that the current owners literally do not give a crap about the fans. If this article is accurate, that is reason alone to fire up the protests again, and try to make a difference. When I buy a kit I want to think I am helping my team. It's one of the few contributions I can make...

Why can't these imbeciles do anything right?

Derek Thomas
9 Posted 03/06/2012 at 11:04:02
Only three words need be said...Board Out... Kenwright Out; is that actually 3 or 4...whatever, the message is there. Lions led by donkeys. It fitted at the Somme, it fits now in this case.
Paul David
10 Posted 03/06/2012 at 11:04:21
I dont normally comment on financial matters as I simply dont understand them most of the time,the size of the debt is about all I understand.Yet if that article is correct its obvious even to me that Everton's kit deal is shockingly low.Its depressing to think that even if we were getting paid an average amount it would be enough to stop us losing money each year but as it stands we're losing £5m a year which will have to be made back up by selling a player we dont want to sell.
Colin Fitzpatrick
11 Posted 03/06/2012 at 11:11:03
The defence will be that before we outsourced our retail operation we were losing money hand over fist due to inefficient stock control and shops that simply weren't selling enough. Now we?re receiving a pure profit payment from Kitbag said to be £3m a year. The line in the accounts that show this is sponsorship, advertising and merchandising. In last year?s accounts this line was £6.8m so that would be approximately £4m from the well reported three year £12m Chang deal and approximately £3m from the equally well reported ten year £30m Kitbag deal.

That?s all very well but the piece isn?t about outsourcing effectiveness so let?s not be distracted, it?s about why every other club is benefitting from these kit supply deals at an unprecedented level whilst it appears we?re not. We received nothing from Nike, yet they and their competitors, are paying everyone . I googled these deals and found this:

http://www.theenginegroup.com/opinions/sponsorship/major-premier-league-transfer-news

It does beg the question, are Kitbag more than just our partner in a retail agreement and where?s the money Nike are paying everyone else?

?New marketing opportunities? is jam tomorrow talk for me, I?d just like to know, in plain English, why all these other clubs are receiving vast amounts of money from kit manufacturers and we?re not.

Paul Gladwell
12 Posted 03/06/2012 at 11:23:17
I came home for a weekend break fro Amsterdam with my Mississippi last week,as we came through arrivals straight ahead was a shop riddled with redshite stuff and not a carrot of blue "where is rh Everton stuff" she commented shaking her head, I was too embarrassed to try and explain.
The club is run by imbeciles who cannot even perform big standard busibess practices and still people back them.
We will sink one day unless this clown goes.
For all my stick at Moyes I shout in frustration, when the anger dies down you do realise he is the reason we have not sunk already.
Paul Gladwell
13 Posted 03/06/2012 at 11:32:47
That was meant to be Missus just fast text of my phone.
Barry Jones
14 Posted 03/06/2012 at 11:50:46
Joey Brown, ?If this article is accurate, that is reason alone to fire up the protests again, and try to make a difference.? First of all its from KEIOC, they?re always right as far as I?m concerned, they?re always very accurate, but getting Evertonians to protest is a waste of time when they?re handing out awards to Kenwright and clapping him as he?s having them over. They?re like the fag telling Flashman, ?Oh do it to me again Harry? The press need to get hold of this, Kitbag handled Sunderland change of kit supplier to Adidas and no money was reported, what's going on?
Gavin Ramejkis
15 Posted 03/06/2012 at 11:59:52
Kieran the fatal flaw with requiring the staff with the acumen and business savvy to make all of these rudimentary changes is that they are recruited and employed by what has to be the most incompetent and negligent board in the history of the club. Without accepting their own faults they will never succeed and thus continue to take the club in a symbiotic sham of a business under their abysmal guidance.

The market place is full of people with more going for them than the current incumbents

Matt Traynor
16 Posted 03/06/2012 at 12:09:38
Colin #031 long-term deals look good on paper. Arsenal when they signed a 10 year £150m stadium naming rights were rejoicing at the time. Now they are counting down the days to the end of that deal. Yes it's money up front, but we live in a football world that is fast evolving, both in costs and revenues.

The merch was losing around £750k a year when it was in house. So a £30m, ten year deal looks good on paper, but it's shockingly bad when you analyse it.

However, if you're an out-of-your-league owner, borrowing from whoever will lend you, having that on the balance sheet helps (borrow more).

Richard Jones
17 Posted 03/06/2012 at 12:21:49
It would be intersting to know who the directors of Kitbag are to be the beneficiaries of such a generous deal from our board of Directors. Shis smells rather like the Finch Farm deal to me!!! Come on Evertonians wake up!!
Colin Fitzpatrick
18 Posted 03/06/2012 at 12:17:05
Matt #041

I?d agree with you that the world of football, particularly financing, is fast evolving. Who would have believed just a few years ago that these incredible sums are being demanded, offered and received by clubs in the premiership for wearing a particular brand of shirt but here we are and this is how the clubs are financing their business activities, well not all obviously!!!

Funny you should mention Arsenal, yes no doubt they are counting the days but they did put that deal and indeed their long-term deal with Nike to good use, they used it to finance a new stadium which in turn has generated more money for the club ? investing in infrastructure, it?s the future!

David Hallwood
19 Posted 03/06/2012 at 12:51:34
Thanks for the correction Paul#036; reminds me of the old joke ? I like my wife in something long and flowing...
Paul Gladwell
20 Posted 03/06/2012 at 13:04:03
Dave she was more than long and flowing after a coffee shop visit, more like long and jellylike.
Barry Jones
21 Posted 03/06/2012 at 11:55:04
KEIOC must be onto something here, hence why they?ve called their article KITBLAG. I?ve just read this on another forum:
?Don't mean to burst anyone's bubble here, but Kitbag brokered the deal with Nike. Know a lad who works with them & he says it's simply because they're delighted with how Everton work, so want to prolong the deal, whilst Nike are their main sports partner & they wanted to put us together. Our deal has paved the way for the likes of City (who we outsell shirts currently nearly 3 to 2- expect that'll change soon) who are now with Kitbag on the same terms as us & will be Nike season after next?
City aren?t on the same deal as they?ll be receiving £12m a season directly from Nike. Are KEIOC suggesting that Kitbag are fully responsible for this sector of our business, negotiate on our behalf, receive a payment from whichever kit manufacturer offers them the best deal and then hand over £3m to a grateful Everton and then keep all the proceeds from the sale of merchandise?

There certainly appears to be an important element missing in Everton?s revenue compared to other clubs, namely the money from the kit manufacturer. We must be worth at least the same as Villa to a manufacturer, which when you think about it adds up to what we get off Kitbag. Could this be the real deal? Surely not.
Mark Riding
22 Posted 03/06/2012 at 13:36:12
"Hi Sir Terry, Bill here... I'm not into all this retail lark... any chance of telling me how we could make a few bob by selling some stuff in the shop and on-line? You seemed to do ok with that supermarket... I realise you are a busy man, so if you can't, could you point me in the direction of someone who could help us out? Cheers!"

That phone call is all it would take, surely!

Mike Allison
23 Posted 03/06/2012 at 14:03:54
This article seems to suggest that our c.£5M operating deficit would be effectively wiped out (and turned into a tiny profit) by simply getting what we're worth from selling our kit.

Can it be that simple?

Steve Sweeney
24 Posted 03/06/2012 at 15:10:44
Maybe not all the money goes to the club,
Perhaps there could be payments to off shore companies
Who act as advisors?.

Our club is rotton to the core.

Jay Harris
25 Posted 03/06/2012 at 15:45:13
Step forward one Bill Kenwright who, when questioned why EFC's merchandising income was so poor, famously said "Only Newcastle supporters buy shirts".

With that level of thinking, is it any surprise we do so badly?

He doesn't even know why "unexplained" operating costs have risen to £24 million a year from £1 million a year when he took over ? or at least he pretends not to know.

Jimmy Sørheim
26 Posted 03/06/2012 at 16:08:58
Where is the BU when you need them?
This should be their cause this summer!
John Waugh
27 Posted 03/06/2012 at 17:45:41
Regardless of the apparently shambolic (as ever) basis of the Kitbag deal, what really gripes me is that you cannot buy an Everton shirt anywhere outside of the club stores / website. This really struck home when on holiday last year in the US where the family went into a "Soccer" store. Every club from the UK had a presence in there to varying degrees - except us! Impulse buys at JJB etc for kids especially are a thing of the past and surely this will affect our future fanbase.
James Cadwaladr
28 Posted 03/06/2012 at 18:02:59
Sadly when the board and executives are as inept as our have been for too long the knock on effect is shambolic.

The clubs call in debt, the club needs to realise guaranteed money in the short term and are not able to consider or be in a position to look at long term opportunity and therefore taken guarantee payments such as this deal.

"£650k a year, guaranteed, we need to service the banks so we'll take it".

To effectively sell its own merchandise the club needs to invest quite heavily in a successful operation. Put simply the club simply can not afford and does not have the cashflow to sign off these costs, such as marketing, staffing, legals etc etc etc.

I've said before this board have failed the club. There is no getting away from that.

James Cadwaladr
29 Posted 03/06/2012 at 18:02:59
Sadly when the board and executives are as inept as our have been for too long the knock on effect is shambolic.

The clubs call in debt, the club needs to realise guaranteed money in the short term and are not able to consider or be in a position to look at long term opportunity and therefore taken guarantee payments such as this deal.

"£650k a year, guaranteed, we need to service the banks so we'll take it".

To effectively sell its own merchandise the club needs to invest quite heavily in a successful operation. Put simply the club simply can not afford and does not have the cashflow to sign off these costs, such as marketing, staffing, legals etc etc etc.

I've said before this board have failed the club. There is no getting away from that.

Iain Love
30 Posted 03/06/2012 at 23:04:51
Put something similar a few years ago.

I was looking at the O/S to buy EFC related clothes to wear on holiday and the ms saw the pink ladies kit and said, "Oh that's nice, I'd wear that, get me one." Could I? No chance.

That to me sums up our retail expertise, we find something that will increase our revenue yet fail to exploit it. Many many companies are like this [I worked in retail for over 30 years] so I know it happens. Why oh why, when we have two of the best retailers in Archie and Green involved in the club does this happen????
Jem Traynor
31 Posted 04/06/2012 at 06:14:00
Steve Sweeney #061, basic but correct in essence.
there Something very dodgy at work, I would like to say naive... but people and that much money going astray! It doesn't work that way; never does and never will. It'll be going offshore to keep it on the low as with a lot of the high flying lawyer types who are in-the-know.
Chris Williamson
32 Posted 04/06/2012 at 06:30:34
I've collected dozens of shirts over the years - most of them Everton - as they're my club. I've been frustrated for years that sports shops don't seem to stock anything apart from the 'big 4' plus spurs and incomprehensively newcastle (even when they were "div 2" last year.

I won't buy a damn thing from kitbag though - always premium price, minimal overheads, only source (outside liverpool) - strikes me as a monopoly. I choose not to play that game.
I'm not keen on giving Nike my cash to encourage their far east sweat shops, nor the pointess middlemen of kitbag, and since only a pittance goes to the club, I no longer see buying a s hirt as supporting them.

I'll follow BB's example and keep hold of me cash.

Paul Jamieson
34 Posted 04/06/2012 at 14:59:49
Dragged away for a few days, bored out of my skull, I found the local internet cafe helped with the time on my hands. I found this article a great thought provoking read from KEIOC, back to getting at the truth that's buried under an avalanche of spin like it was over Kirkby and the Park End.

For me this isn't about where you can buy a shirt or whether the outsourcing deal is better than selling the shirt ourselves, it's much deeper than that, it's about exposing poor performance that's tolerated by owners who are equally inept and spurious.

Have we really surrendered our negotiation position on whose kit we wear and the riches that other clubs enjoy? I find what KEIOC are suggesting deeply disturbing as it consigns us as a club to being in a position that has nothing but mediocrity.

I don't know about others but for me fans must be now told the extent of this Kitbag deal, not the confidential details, but whether it includes the forfeiting of the right to choose kit supplier and the right to sell that choice to the highest bidder, in other words obtaining a separate payment from the kit supplier in addition to the retail outsourcing agreement, because if we have signed that over to Kitbag the much heralded record £32m 10-year deal with them is a disgrace and the person responsible needs showing the door.

Jack Molloy
35 Posted 05/06/2012 at 14:40:40
Three years ago, when the kitbag deal was made, it was said to be worth 32 million pounds over the next ten years:


http://www.evertonfc.com/news/archive/-32m-deal-for-blues.html


Pork pies anyone?


Add Your Comments

In order to post a comment, you need to be logged in as a registered user of the site.

» Log in now

Or Sign up as a ToffeeWeb Member — it's free, takes just a few minutes and will allow you to post your comments on articles and Talking Points submissions across the site.


About these ads